Emergency Application — Talen Montana, LLC, et al., Applicants v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al.
Supreme Court briefAug 20, 2024
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. _______
In the Supreme Court of the United States
Talen Montana, LLC and NorthWestern Corporation,
Applicants,
v.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and
Michael S. Regan, Administrator, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,
Respondents.
ON EMERGENCY APPLICATION FOR STAY TO THE HONORABLE JOHN G. ROBERTS, JR.,
CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE UNITED STATES
AND CIRCUIT JUSTICE FOR THE U.S. COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE D.C. CIRCUIT
APPENDIX TO APPLICATION FOR AN IMMEDIATE STAY OF FINAL
AGENCY ACTION PENDING DISPOSITION OF PETITION FOR REVIEW
Michael Drysdale
DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP
50 South Sixth Street, Suite 1500
Minneapolis, MN 55402
Creighton R. Magid
DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP
1401 New York Avenue NW, Suite 900
Washington, DC 20005
Counsel for NorthWestern Corporation
d/b/a NorthWestern Energy
Joshua B. Frank
Counsel of Record
C. Joshua Lee
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
700 K Street NW
Washington, DC 20001
(202) 639-7748
joshua.frank@bakerbotts.com
Counsel for Talen Montana, LLC
TABLE OF APPENDICES
Page
APPENDIX A - DECISIONS BELOW
Final Rule, National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants:
Coal- and Oil-Fired Electric Utility Steam Generating Units Review of
the Residual Risk and Technology Review, 89 Fed. Reg. 38508
(May 7, 2024) ......................................................................................................................... 2a
Order Denying Motions to Stay (D.C. Cir. Aug. 8, 2024) ............................................. 88a
APPENDIX B - STATUTORY PROVISION INVOLVED
42 U.S.C. § 7412 .................................................................................................................. 91a
APPENDIX C - SELECT RULEMAKING DOCUMENTS FOR THE FINAL RULE
(Select Excerpts) Talen Montana Comments (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR2018-0794-5987)................................................................................................................. 119a
(Select Excerpts) NorthWestern Comments (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR2018-0794-5980)................................................................................................................. 159a
EPA’s Response to Comments (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR-2018-07946922) ................................................................................................................................... 184a
EPA, Resource Adequacy Analysis: Vehicle Rules, Final 111 EGU Rules,
ELG and MATS RTR: Technical Memo (Apr. 2024) (Docket ID EPA-HQOAR-2023-0072-8915) ...................................................................................................... 360a
(Select Excerpts) EPA, Residual Risk Assessment for the Coal- and OilFired EGU Source Category in Support of the 2020 Risk and Technology
Review Final Rule (Sept. 2019) (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR-2018-07944553) ................................................................................................................................... 400a
APPENDIX D - COMMENTS SUBMITTED IN THE GREENHOUSE GAS RULE
Talen Montana Comments on the Proposed Greenhouse Gas Rule (Docket
ID EPA-HQ-OAR-2023-0072-0806) .............................................................................. 474a
(Select Excerpts) NorthWestern Comments on the Proposed Greenhouse
Gas Rule (EPA-HQ-OAR-2023-0072-0747) .................................................................. 506a
i
APPENDIX E - SELECT STAY MOTION PAPERS FILED IN THE D.C. CIRCUIT CASE
Talen Montana and NorthWestern’s Joint Motion for Stay (ECF No.
2062093) ............................................................................................................................. 530a
America’s Power and Electric Generators MATS Coalition’s Motion for
Stay (ECF No. 2063557) ................................................................................................. 572a
Talen Montana and NorthWestern’s Joint 28(j) Letter (ECF No. 2065246) .......... 618a
EPA’s Opposition to Motions to Stay (ECF No. 2065849) ........................................ 622a
Talen Montana and NorthWestern’s Joint Reply (ECF No. 2067227) .................... 688a
America’s Power and Electric Generators MATS Coalition’s Reply (ECF
No. 2067255) ...................................................................................................................... 708a
APPENDIX F - SELECT DECLARATIONS FILED IN THE D.C. CIRCUIT CASE
Declaration of Dale E. Lebsack Jr. (ECF No. 2062093 Exhibit 1) ........................... 731a
(Select Excerpts) Declaration of John D. Hines (ECF No. 2062093
Exhibit 2)........................................................................................................................... 822a
Declaration of Serena K. Wetherelt (ECF No. 2065869 Exhibit 5) ......................... 851a
ii
APPENDIX A
DECISIONS BELOW
1a
38508
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
CEMS particulatemattercontinuous
ConstitutionAve.NW,Washington,DC. PMemi
ssionmonitoringsystems
ThePublicReadingRoom hoursof
referenceexposurelevel
operationare8:30a.m.to4:30p.m. REL
RFA
RegulatoryFlexibilityAct
EasternStandardTime(EST),Monday RIA Re
gulatoryImpactAnalysis
t
hr
o
ug
h
Fr
i
da
y
.
The
t
e
l
e
pho
ne
numb
e
r
[EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794;FRL–6716.3– forthePublicReadingRoom is(202) RIN RegulatoryInformationNumber
02–OAR]
RTR residualriskandtechnologyreview
5
6
6
–
1
7
4
4
,
a
nd
t
he
t
e
l
e
pho
ne
numb
e
r
f
o
r
SC–
alcostofcarbon
2 soci
RIN2060–AV53
theEPADocketCenteris(202)566– SO2COsul
furdioxide
TBtu trillionBritishthermalunitsofheat
1742.
NationalEmissionStandardsfor
input
NFORMATIONCONTACT:For tpy
HazardousAirPollutants:Coal-and FORFURTHERI
peryear
questionsaboutthisfinalactioncontact UMRAtonsUnf
Oil-FiredElectricUtilitySteam
undedMandatesReform Act
SarahBenish,SectorPoliciesand
GeneratingUnitsReviewofthe
We
b
FI
RE
We
ProgramsDivision(D243–01),Officeof System bFactorInformationRetrieval
ResidualRiskandTechnologyReview Ai
rQualityPlanningandStandards,
ckgroundinformation.OnApril24,
AGENCY:EnvironmentalProtection
U.
S.
EnvironmentalProtectionAgency, 20Ba
2
3
,theEPAproposedrevisionstothe
Agency(EPA).
P.
O.
Bo
x
1
2
0
5
5
,
Re
s
e
a
r
c
h
Tr
i
a
ng
l
e
Pa
r
k
,
Co
a
l
andOil-FiredEGUNESHAPbased
ACTION:Finalrule.
NorthCarolina27711;telephone
o
n
o
ur
eview ofthe2020RTR.Inthis
number:(919)541–5620;andemail action,rwe
SUMMARY:Thisactionfinalizes
arefinalizingrevisionstothe
ddress:benish.sarah@epa.gov.
amendmentstothenationalemission aSUPPLEMENTARYI
r
ul
e
,
c
o
mmo
nlyknownastheMercury
NFORMATION:
standardsforhazardousairpollutants Preambleacrony
a
nd
Ai
r
To
x
i
csStandards(MATS).We
msand
(NESHAP)fortheCoal-andOil-Fired abbreviations.Weus
s
umma
r
i
z
e
s
o
meofthemoresignificant
tiple
ElectricUtilitySteam GeneratingUnits acronymsandtermsienmul
c
o
mme
nt
s
r
e
g
ngtheproposedrule
spreamble. thatwerereceaivrdi
(EGUs)sourcecategory.Thesefinal Whilethislistmaynotbthi
e
d
duringthepublic
eexhaustive,to commentperiodand
amendmentsaretheresultoftheEPA’s easethereadingofthispr
ovideour
eambleandfor responsesinthispreapr
review ofthe2020ResidualRiskand referencepurposes,theEPA
mb
.Asummary
definesthe ofallotherpubliccommelent
TechnologyReview (RTR).Thechanges, followingtermsandacronyms
sonthe
here: proposalandtheEPA’srespo
whichwereproposedunderthe
nsesto
APH airpreheater
technologyreview inApril2023,
t
ho
s
e
c
o
mme
nt
s
i
s
a
v
a
i
l
a
b
l
e
i
n
National
Btu BritishThermalUnits
includeamendingthefilterable
Emi
s
s
i
o
n
St
a
nda
r
ds
f
o
r
Ha
z
a
r
do
usAir
CAA CleanAirAct
particulatematter(fPM)surrogate
Po
l
l
ut
a
nt
s
:
Co
a
l
a
nd
Oi
l
F
i
r
e
d
El
ric
CEMS continuousemissionmonitoring UtilitySteam GeneratingUnitsReevcit
emissionstandardfornon-mercury
ew
s
y
s
t
e
m
metalhazardousairpollutants(HAP)for EGU electricutilitysteam generatingunit oftheResidualRiskandTechnology
existingcoal-firedEGUs,thefPM
ReviewProposedRuleResponseto
EIA EnergyInformationAdministration Co
emissionstandardcompliance
mments,DocketIDNo.EPA–HQ–
ESP electrostaticprecipitator
demonstrationrequirements,andthe FF fabricfilter
OAR–2018–0794.A‘‘trackchanges’’
fluegasdesulfurization
mercury(Hg)emissionstandardfor fFGD
versionoftheregulatorylanguagethat
PM filterableparticulatematter
lignite-firedEGUs.Additionally,the GWh
i
ncorporatesthechangesinthisaction
gigawatt-hour
EPAisfinalizingachangetothe
i
savailableinthedocket.
hazardousairpollutant(s)
Organizationofthisdocument.The
definitionof‘‘startup.’’TheEPAdidnot HAP
HCl
hy
dr
o
g
e
n
c
hl
o
r
i
de
i
nf
ormationinthispreambleis
propose,andisnotfinalizing,any
HF hydrogenfluoride
o
r
g
anizedasfollows:
changestothe2020ResidualRisk
Hg0 mercury
Review.
Hg2+ elementalHgvapor
I.GeneralInformation
Hg divalentHg
A.ExecutiveSummary
DATES:ThisfinalruleiseffectiveonJuly Hg
Cl2 mercuricchloride
B.Doesthisactionapplytome?
8,2024.Theincorporationbyreference Hg
particulateboundHg
C.WherecanIgetacopyofthisdocument
ofcertainmateriallistedintherulewas HQp ha
dquotient
andotherrelatedinformation?
approvedbytheDirectoroftheFederal ICR Infzoarrma
t
i
o
n
Co
l
l
e
c
t
i
o
n
Re
q
ue
s
t
D.
JudicialReview andAdministrative
RegisterasofApril16,2012.
IGCC integratedgasificationcombined
Reconsideration
ADDRESSES:TheU.S.Environmental
II.Background
ProtectionAgency(EPA)hasestablished IPMcyclIentegratedPlanningModel
A.Whatistheauthorityforthisaction?
InflationReductionAct
B.WhatistheCoal-andOil-FiredEGU
adocketforthisactionunderDocketID IlRA
b pounds
sourcecategoryandhow doesthe
No.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794.All LEE
ttingEGU
NESHAPregulateHAPemissionsfrom
documentsinthedocketarelistedon MACTlowmaemi
ximum achievablecontrol
thesourcecategory?
thehttps://www.regulations.gov
t
e
c
hno
l
o
g
y
C.
Summaryofthe2020ResidualRisk
website.Althoughlisted,some
MATS
Me
r
c
ur
y
a
nd
Ai
r
To
x
i
c
s
St
a
nda
r
ds
Re
view
informationisnotpubliclyavailable, MMacf millionactualcubicfeet
D.
Summa
ryofthe2020Technology
e.g.,ConfidentialBusinessInformation MMBtu millionBritishthermalunitsof
Re
v
i
e
w
orotherinformationwhosedisclosureis heatinput
E.SummaryoftheEPA’sReview ofthe
restrictedbystatute.Certainother
MW megawatt
2020RTRandthe2023Proposed
CS NorthAmericanIndustry
RevisionstotheNESHAP
material,suchascopyrightedmaterial, NAI
ClassificationSystem
III.Whatisincludedinthisfinalrule?
isnotplacedontheinternetandwillbe NESHAP
nationalemissionstandardsfor A.Whatarethefinalruleamendments
publiclyavailableonlyinhardcopy
ha
z
a
r
do
us
airpollutants
basedonthetechnologyreview forthe
form.Publiclyavailabledocket
NOX nitrogenoxides
Coal-andOil-FiredEGUsource
materialsareavailableeither
NRECA
Na
t
i
o
na
l
Rur
a
l
El
e
c
t
r
i
c
Co
o
pe
r
a
t
i
v
e
category?
electronicallythroughhttps://
As
s
o
c
i
a
t
i
o
n
B.
Whatotherchangeshavebeenmadeto
www.regulations.gov,orinhardcopyat OMB OfficeofManagementandBudget
t
heNESHAP?
theEPADocketCenter,WJCWest
PM particulatematter
C.Whataretheeffectiveandcompliance
Building,Room Number3334,1301 PM2.5 fineparticulatematter
datesofthestandards?
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION
AGENCY
40CFRPart63
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00002 Fmt4702a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38509
A.ExecutiveOrder12866:Regulatory
IV.Whatistherationaleforourfinal
revise’’thosestandardsevery8years
PlanningandReview andExecutive
decisionsandamendmentstothe
‘asnecessary(takingintoaccount
Order14094:ModernizingRegulatory ‘
filterablePM (asasurrogatefornon-Hg
de
velopmentsinpractices,processes,
Review
HAPmetals)standardandcompliance
a
nd
controltechnologies).’’Id.
B.PaperworkReductionAct(PRA)
optionsfrom the2020Technology
7412(d)(6).
C.RegulatoryFlexibilityAct(RFA)
Review?
OnJanuary20,2021,PresidentBiden
A.WhatdidweproposepursuanttoCAA D.UnfundedMandatesReform Act
s
i
g
nedExecutiveOrder13990,
(UMRA)
Section112(d)(6)fortheCoal-andOil‘‘ProtectingPublicHealthandthe
E.ExecutiveOrder13132:Federalism
FiredEGUsourcecategory?
B.How didthetechnologyreview change F.ExecutiveOrder13175:Consultation EnvironmentandRestoringScienceto
andCoordinationWithIndianTribal TackletheClimateCrisis’’(86FR7037;
fortheCoal-andOil-FiredEGUsource
Governments
category?
anuary25,2021).Theexecutiveorder,
C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon G.ExecutiveOrder13045:Protectionof J
a
ngotherthings,instructedtheEPA
ChildrenFrom EnvironmentalHealth tomo
thefilterablePM andcompliance
r
e
view the2020finalruletitled
RisksandSafetyRisks
options,andwhatareourresponses?
NationalEmissionStandardsfor
H.ExecutiveOrder13211:Actions
D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal
HazardousAirPollutants:Coal-and
ConcerningRegulationsThat
approachanddecisionsforthefilterable
Oil-FiredElectricUtilitySteam
SignificantlyAffectEnergySupply,
PM (asasurrogatefornon-HgHAP
GeneratingUnits—Reconsiderationof
Distribution,orUse
metals)standardandcompliance
SupplementalFindingandResidual
I.NationalTechnologyTransferand
demonstrationoptions?
AdvancementAct(NTTAA)and1CFR RiskandTechnologyReview(85FR
V.Whatistherationaleforourfinal
Part51
decisionsandamendmentstotheHg
1286;May22,2020)(2020Final
emissionstandardforlignite-firedEGUs J.ExecutiveOrder12898:FederalActions 3
Ac
tion)andtoconsiderpublishinga
ToAddressEnvironmentalJusticein not
from review ofthe2020Technology
iceofproposedrulemaking
MinorityPopulationsandLow-Income suspe
Review?
nding,revising,orrescindingthat
PopulationsandExecutiveOrder14096: ction.
A.WhatdidweproposepursuanttoCAA
The2020FinalActionincluded
RevitalizingOurNation’sCommitment a
section112(d)(6)forthelignite-fired
twoparts:(1)afindingthatitisnot
toEnvironmentalJusticeforAll
EGUsubcategory?
appropriateandnecessarytoregulate
B.How didthetechnologyreview change K.CongressionalReview Act(CRA)
coal-andoil-firedEGUsunderCAA
forthelignite-firedEGUsubcategory? I.GeneralInformation
section112;and(2)theRTRforthe
C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon
theHgemissionstandardforlignite-fired A.ExecutiveSummary
2012MATSFinalRule.
EGUs,andwhatareourresponses?
TheEPAreviewedbothpartsofthe
1.BackgroundandPurposeofthe
D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal
2
0
20FinalAction.Theresultsofthe
approachanddecisionsforthelignite- RegulatoryAction
EPA’
sreview ofthefirstpart,findingit
firedEGUHgstandard?
sappropriateandnecessarytoregulate
Exposuretohazardousairpollutants iEGUs
VI.Whatistherationaleforourotherfinal (‘‘HAP,
rCAAsection112,were
sometimesknownastoxicair oposunde
decisionsandamendmentsfrom review pollutio’’
edonFebruary9,2022(87FR
n,includingHg,chromium, pr
ofthe2020TechnologyReview?
624)(2022Proposal)andfinalizedon
A.WhatdidweproposepursuanttoCAA arsenic,andlead)cancausearangeof 7
March6,2023(88FR13956).Inthe
section112(d)(6)fortheotherNESHAP adversehealtheffectsincluding
2022Proposal,theEPAalsosolicited
requirements?
harmingpeople’scentralnervous
B.How didthetechnologyreview change system;damagetotheirkidneys;and informationontheperformanceand
fortheotherNESHAPrequirements?
ostofnew orimprovedtechnologies
ancer.Theseadverseeffectscanbe ctha
C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon c
tcontrolHAPemissions,improved
pa
r
t
i
c
ul
a
r
l
y
a
c
ut
e
f
o
r
c
o
mmuni
t
i
e
s
theotherNESHAPrequirements,and livingnearsourcesofHAP.Recognizing met
hodsofoperation,andrisk-related
whatareourresponses?
i
nf
o
rmationtofurtherinform theEPA’s
t
he
da
ng
e
r
s
po
s
e
d
b
y
HAP,
Co
ng
r
e
s
s
D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal
eview ofthesecondpart,the2020
nactedCleanAirAct(CAA)section rMATS
approachanddecisionsregardingthe e
RTR.TheEPAproposed
112.UnderCAAsection112,theEPA mendme
otherNESHAPrequirements?
ntstotheRTRonApril24,
VII.StartupDefinitionfortheCoal-andOil- isrequiredtosetstandardsbasedon a
2023(88FR24854)(2023Proposal)and
FiredEGUSourceCategory
ma
x
i
mum
a
c
hi
e
v
a
b
l
e
c
o
nt
r
o
l
thisactionfinalizesthoseamendments
A.WhatdidweproposefortheCoal-and technology(knownas‘‘MACT’’
Oil-FiredEGUsourcecategory?
a
ndpresentsthefinalresultsofthe
1ofHAP
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
)
f
o
r
ma
j
o
r
s
o
ur
c
e
s
B.How didthestartupprovisionschange that‘‘requirethemaximum degreeof EPA’sreview oftheMATSRTR.
fortheCoal-andOil-FiredEGUsource reductioninemissionsofthehazardous 2.SummaryofMajorProvisionsofthe
category?
irpollutants...(includinga
gulatoryAction
C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon a
prohibitiononsuchemissions,where ReCo
thestartupprovisions,andwhatareour a
al-andoil-firedEGUsremainone
chievable)thattheAdministrator,
responses?
fthelargestdomesticemittersofHg
takingintoconsiderationthecostof oand
D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal
manyotherHAP,includingmanyof
approachandfinaldecisionsforthe
achievingsuchemissionreduction,and theno
n-HgHAPmetals—including
startupprovisions?
a
ny
no
na
i
r
q
ua
l
i
t
y
he
a
l
t
h
a
nd
l
e
a
d,
a
rsenic,chromium,nickel,and
VIII.Whatotherkeycommentsdidwe
environmentalimpactsandenergy
cadmium—andhydrogenchloride
receiveontheproposal?
r
e
q
ui
r
e
me
nt
s
,
de
t
e
r
mi
ne
s
i
s
IX.SummaryofCost,Environmental,and achievable.’’42U.S.C.7412(d)(2).The (HCl).ExposuretotheseHAP,atcertain
EconomicImpactsandAdditional
ation,isassociatedwith
EPAisfurtherrequiredto‘‘review,and laevvaerliseatyndofdur
AnalysesConducted
a
dv
ersehealtheffects.Inthe
A.Whataretheaffectedfacilities?
2
0
1
2
MATS
Fi
na
lRule,theEPA
1
The
t
e
r
m
‘
‘
ma
j
o
r
s
o
ur
c
e
’
’
me
a
ns
a
ny
s
t
a
t
i
o
na
r
y
B.Whataretheairqualityimpacts?
e
s
t
a
b
l
i
s
he
d
nume
ricalstandardsforHg,
s
o
ur
c
e
o
r
g
r
o
up
o
f
s
t
a
t
i
o
na
r
y
s
o
ur
c
e
s
l
o
c
a
t
e
d
wi
t
hi
n
C.Whatarethecostimpacts?
acontiguousareaandundercommoncontrolthat non-HgHAPmetals,andacidgasHAP
D.Whataretheeconomicimpacts?
emitsorhasthepotentialtoemitconsidering
sionsfrom coal-andoil-firedEGUs.
E.Whatarethebenefits?
rols,intheaggregate,10tonsperyearormore emisEPA
alsoestablishedworkpractice
F.Whatanalysisofenvironmentaljustice ocofnt
anyhazardousairpollutantor25tonsperyear The
standardsforemissionsoforganicHAP.
didweconduct?
ormoreofanycombinationofhazardousair
X.StatutoryandExecutiveOrderReviews pollutants.42U.S.C.7412(a)(1).
Toaddressemissionsofnon-HgHAP
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00003 Fmt4703a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38510
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
metals,theEPAestablishedindividual thesurroundingcommunities;andreal- sulfurdioxide(SO2)emissionstandard),
emissionlimits2foreachofthe10non- timeidentificationofwhencontrol whichservesasasurrogateforallacid
HgHAPmetals emittedfrom coal-and technologiesarenotperformingas
gasHAP(HCl,hydrogenfluoride(HF),
oil-firedEGUs.Alternatively,affected expected,allowingforquickerrepairs. selenium dioxide(SeO2))forexisting
Afterconsideringupdatedinformation coal-firedEGUs.TheEPAproposedto
sourcescouldmeetanemission
standardfor‘‘totalnon-HgHAPmetals’’ onthecostsforquarterlyperformance requirePM CEMSforexistingintegrated
bysummingtheemissionratesofeach testingcomparedtothecostsofPM
asificationcombinedcycle(IGCC)
ofthenon-HgHAPmetalsormeetafPM CEMSandthemeasurementcapabilities gEGUs
butisnotfinalizingthis
emissionstandardasasurrogateforthe ofPM CEMS,aswellasthemany
r
e
q
ui
r
e
ntduetotechnicalissues
non-HgHAPmetals.Forexistingcoal- benefitsofusingPM CEMS,theEPAis calibratme
i
ng
CEMSonthesetypesof
finalizing,asproposed,arequirement EGUsandthe
firedEGUs,almosteveryunithas
relatedfactthatfPM
chosentodemonstratecompliancewith thatallcoal-andoil-firedEGUs
e
mi
s
s
i
o
ns
f
r
o
m
IGCCsareverylow.
thenon-HgHAPmetalssurrogatefPM demonstratecompliancewiththe
finalstandards,as
I
n
e
s
t
a
b
l
i
s
hi
ng
emissionstandardof0.030pounds(lb) revisedfPM emissionstandardbyusing discussedindetaitlhe
i
n
ctionsIV.,V.,
offPM permillionBritishthermalunits PM CEMS.AstheEPAexplainedinthe VI.,andVII.ofthispresaemb
EPA
2023Proposal,byrequiringfacilitiesto consideredthestatutorydirleec,ttihe
ofheatinput(lb/MMBtu).
o
n
and
PursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), usePM CEMS,thecurrentcompliance
utbyCongressinCAA
theEPArevieweddevelopmentsinthe methodfortheLEEprogram becomes sfaeccttoiorsnl1a1id2.oSe
rately,pursuantto
costsofcontroltechnologies,andthe superfluoussinceLEEisanoptional ExecutiveOrdepa
r12866andExecutive
effectivenessofthosetechnologies,as program inwhichstacktestingoccurs Order14904,the
preparedan
wellasthecostsofmeetingafPM
infrequently,andtherevisedfPM limit lysisofthepoEPA
tentialcostsand
emissionstandardthatismorestringent isbelow thecurrentfPM LEEprogram abna
enefitsassociatedwiththisaction.
than0.030lb/MMBtuandtheother limit.Therefore,theEPAisfinalizing, Thi
lysis,RegulatoryImpact
statutoryfactors.Basedonthatreview, asproposed,theremovalofthefPM LEE Anaslyasna
isfortheFinalNationalEmission
theEPAisfinalizing,asproposed,a program.
rdsforHazardousAirPollutants:
Basedoncommentsreceivedduring Staanda
revisednon-HgHAPmetalsurrogate
l-andOil-FiredElectricUtility
fPM emissionstandardforallexisting thepubliccommentperiod,theEPAis Co
coal-firedEGUsof0.010lb/MMBtu. notremoving,butinsteadrevisingthe Steam GeneratingUnitsReviewofthe
ResidualRiskandTechnologyReview
Thisstrengthenedstandardwillensure alternativeemissionlimitsforthe
thattheentirefleetofcoal-firedEGUs individualnon-HgHAPmetalssuchas (Ref.EPA–452/R–24–005),isavailable
lead,arsenic,chromium,nickel,and inthedocket,andisbrieflysummarized
isperformingatthefPM pollution
controllevelscurrentlyachievedbythe cadmium andforthetotalnon-HgHAP insectionsI.A.3.andIX.ofthis
vastmajorityofregulatedunits.The metalsproportionaltothefinalized4fPM preamble.
emissionlimitof0.010lb/MMBtu.
EPAfurtherconcludesthatitisthe
lowestlevelcurrentlycompatiblewith OwnersandoperatorsofEGUsseeking 3.CostsandBenefits
theuseofPM CEMSfordemonstrating tousethesealternativestandardsmust InaccordancewithExecutiveOrder
compliance.
requestandreceiveapprovaltousea 12866and14094,theEPAprepareda
Relatedly,theEPAisalsofinalizinga HAPmetalcontinuousmonitoring
RegulatoryImpactAnalysis(RIA).The
revisiontotherequirementsfor
system (CMS)asanalternativetest
RIApresentsestimatesoftheemission,
demonstratingcompliancewiththe methodunder40CFR63.7(f).
cost,andbenefitimpactsofthisfinal
revisedfPM emissionstandard.
TheEPAisalsofinalizing,as
rulemakingforthe2028to2037period;
Currently,affectedEGUsthatdonot proposed,amoreprotectiveHg
seestimatesaresummarizedinthis
qualifyforthelow3 emittingEGU(LEE) emissionstandardforexistinglignite- tsho
e
c
t
program forfPM candemonstrate
firedEGUs,requiringthatsuchlignite- ion.
firedEGUsmeetthesameHgemission Thepowerindustry’scompliance
compliancewiththefPM standard
standardasEGUsfiringothertypesof costsarerepresentedintheRIAasthe
eitherbyconductingquarterly
projectedchangeinelectricpower
performancetesting(i.e.,quarterlystack coal(i.e.,bituminousand
testing)orbyusingparticulatematter subbituminous),whichis1.2lbofHg generationcostsbetweenthebaseline
(PM)continuousemissionmonitoring pertrillionBritishthermalunitsofheat andfinalrulescenarios.Thequantified
systems(PM CEMS).PM CEMSconfer input(lb/TBtu)oranalternativeoutput- emissionestimatespresentedintheRIA
significantbenefits,includingincreased basedstandardof0.013lbpergigawatt- includechangesinpollutantsdirectly
coveredbythisrule,suchasHgand
hour(lb/GWh).Finally,theEPAis
transparencyregardingemissions
performanceforsources,regulators,and finalizing,asproposed,theremovalof non-HgHAPmetals,andchangesin
thesecondoptionfordefiningthe
otherpollutantsemittedfrom thepower
2Thet
ennon-HgHAPmetalsareantimony,
up
pe
r
i
o
d
f
o
r
MATSa
f
f
e
c
t
e
d
EGUs
.
s
t
a
r
t
sectorduetothecomplianceactions
arsenic,beryllium,cadmium,chromium,cobalt,
TheEPAdidnotproposeandisnot projectedunderthisfinalrule.The
lead,manganese,nickel,andselenium.
inalizingmodificationstotheHCl
cumulativeprojectednational-level
3I
nordertoqualifyforfPM LEEstatus,anEGU f
emissionstandard(northealternative emissionsreductionsoverthe2028to
mustdemonstratethatitsfPM emissionrateis
2037periodunderthefinalized
below 50percentofstandard(or0.015lb/MMBtu) 4
Theemissionlimitsfortheindividualnon-Hg requirementsarepresentedintable1.
from quarterlystacktestsfor3consecutiveyears.
HAPmetalsandthetotalnon-HgHAPmetalshave
OnceasourceachievesLEEstatusforfPM,the
supportingdetailsforthese
sourcemustconductstacktestingevery3yearsto beenreducedbytwo-thirds,consistentwiththe The
demonstratethatitsemissionrateremainsbelow 50 revisionofthefPM emissionlimitfrom 0.030lb/ estimatescanbefoundintheRIA.
percentofthestandard.
MMBtuto0.010lb/MMBtu.
BILLING CODE 6560–50–P
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00004 Fmt4704a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38511
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00005 Fmt4705a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
ER07MY24.065</GPH>
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
benefitsareunmonetizedandarethus limitations,theEPAisalsounableto
TheEPAexpectsthatemission
reductionsunderthefinalrulemaking notdirectlyreflectedinthequantified quantifypotentialemissionsimpactsor
willresultinreducedexposuretoHg netbenefitestimates(seesectionIX.B. monetizepotentialbenefitsfrom
andnon-HgHAPmetals.TheEPAalso inthispreambleandsection4ofthe continuousmonitoringrequirements.
projectshealthbenefitsdueto
RIAformoredetails).Inparticular,
Thepresentvalue(PV)andequivalent
improvementsinparticulatematterwith estimatingtheeconomicbenefitsof annua
ue(EAV)ofcosts,benefits,
adiameterof2.5micrometersorless reducedexposuretoHAPgenerallyhas andneltvbaelne
fitsofthisrulemakingover
(PM2.5)andozoneandclimatebenefits pr
o
v
e
n
di
f
f
i
c
ul
t
f
o
r
a
numb
e
r
o
f
r
e
a
s
o
ns
:
t
he
2
0
2
8
t
o
2
riodin2019dollars
from reductionsincarbondioxide(CO2) itisdifficulttoundertakeepidemiologic areshownin0t3ab7lpe
e2.Inthistable,
emissions.TheEPAalsoanticipates studiesthathavesufficientpowerto resultsarepresent
edusinga2percent
benefitsfrom theincreasedtransparency quantifytherisksassociatedwithHAP discountrate.Resul
tsunderother
tothepublic,theassurancethat
exposuresexperiencedbyU.S.
discountratesandsupportingdetailsfor
standardsarebeingmetcontinuously, po
pul
a
t
i
o
ns
o
n
a
da
i
l
y
b
a
s
i
s
;
da
t
a
us
e
d
theestimatescanbefoundintheRIA.
andtheacceleratedidentificationof oestimateexposuresincritical
anomalousemissionsduetorequiring tmi
croenvironmentsarelimited;and
PM CEMSinthisfinalrule.
t
he
reremainsinsufficienteconomic di
HAPemissionsfrom coal-andoil-firedEGUsand
TheEPAestimatesnegativenet
scussiononthelimitationstomonetizingand
t
i
o
n
o
f
HAP
r
e
s
e
a
r
c
h
t
o
s
uppo
r
t
v
a
l
ua
quantifyingbenefitsfrom HAPreductions.Seealso
monetizedbenefitsofthisrule(seetable benefitsmadeevenmorechallengingby Na
onalEmissionStandardsforHazardousAir
2below).However,thebenefitestimates thewidearrayofHAPandpossible Poltliut
nts:Coal-andOil-FiredElectricUtility
informingthisresultrepresentonlya HAPeffects.5Inaddition,duetodata SteamaGe
neratingUnits—Revocationofthe2020
partialaccountingofthepotential
Re
c
o
ns
i
de
rationandAffirmationoftheAppropriate
5Seesect
benefitsofthisfinalrule.Several
ionII.B.2.fordiscussionofthepublic andNecessarySupplementalFinding,88FR13956,
categoriesofhumanwelfareandclimate healthandenvironmentalhazardsassociatedwith 13970–73(March6,2023).
38512
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
Court)byJuly8,2024.UnderCAA
C.WherecanIgetacopyofthis
TheEPAnotesthatanalysisofsuch documentandotherrelated
section307(b)(2),therequirements
impactsisdistinctfrom the
information?
establishedbythisfinalrulemaynotbe
determinationsfinalizedinthisaction Inadditiontobeingavailableinthe challengedseparatelyinanycivilor
underCAAsection112,whichare
riminalproceedingsbroughtbythe
cket,anelectroniccopyofthisfinal cEPA
basedonthestatutoryfactorstheEPA do
toenforcetherequirements.
a
c
t
i
o
n
wi
l
l
a
l
s
o
b
e
a
v
a
i
l
a
b
l
e
o
n
t
he
discussesinsectionII.A.andsections internet.Followingsignaturebythe
Section307(d)(7)(B)oftheCAA
IV.throughVII.below.
therprovidesthatonlyanobjection
EPAAdministrator,theEPAwillposta ftur
oaruleorprocedurethatwasraised
copyofthisfinalactionat:https://
B.Doesthisactionapplytome?
withreasonablespecificityduringthe
www.epa.gov/stationary-sources-air- pe
riodforpubliccomment(including
Regulatedentities.Thesource
po
l
l
ut
i
o
n/
me
r
c
ur
y
a
nda
i
r
t
o
x
i
c
s
categorythatisthesubjectofthisaction standards.Followingpublicationinthe anypublichearing)mayberaised
iscoal-andoil-firedEGUsregulatedby deralRegister,theEPAwillpostthe duringjudicialreview.Thissectionalso
providesamechanism fortheEPAto
NESHAPunder40CFRpart63,subpart Fe
deralRegisterversionandkey
reconsidertheruleifthepersonraising
UUUUU,commonlyknownasMATS. Fe
t
e
c
hni
c
a
l
do
c
ume
nt
s
a
t
t
hi
s
s
a
me
anobjectioncandemonstratetothe
TheNorthAmericanIndustry
bsite.
Administratorthatitwasimpracticable
ClassificationSystem (NAICS)codesfor weAddi
t
i
o
na
l
i
nf
o
r
ma
t
i
o
n
i
s
a
v
a
i
l
a
b
l
e
o
n
toraisesuchobjectionwithintheperiod
thecoal-andoil-firedEGUsource
t
he
RTR
we
b
s
i
t
e
a
t
ht
t
ps
:
/
/
forpubliccommentorifthegroundsfor
categoryare221112,221122,and
www.
e
pa
.
g
o
v
/
s
t
a
t
i
o
na
r
y
s
o
ur
c
e
s
a
i
r
921150.ThislistofNAICScodesisnot pollution/risk-and-technology-review- suchobjectionaroseaftertheperiodfor
publiccomment(butwithinthetime
intendedtobeexhaustive,butratherto tional-emissions-standardsspecifiedforjudicialreview)andifsuch
provideaguideforreadersregarding na
ha
z
a
r
do
us
.
Thi
s
i
nf
o
r
ma
t
i
o
n
i
nc
l
ude
s
entitieslikelytobeaffectedbythefinal anoverview oftheRTRprogram and objectionisofcentralrelevancetothe
actionforthesourcecategorylisted.To linkstoprojectwebsitesfortheRTR outcomeoftherule.Anypersonseeking
tomakesuchademonstrationshould
determinewhetheryourfacilityis
sourcecategories.
ubmitaPetitionforReconsiderationto
affected,youshouldexaminethe
D.JudicialReviewandAdministrative tshe
OfficeoftheAdministrator,U.S.
applicabilitycriteriaintheappropriate Re
consideration
EPA,Room 3000,WJCSouthBuilding,
NESHAP.Ifyouhaveanyquestions
regardingtheapplicabilityofanyaspect UnderCAAsection307(b)(1),judicial 1200PennsylvaniaAve.,NW,
review ofthisfinalactionisavailable Washington,DC20460,withacopyto
ofthisNESHAP,pleasecontactthe
onlybyfilingapetitionforreview in boththeperson(s)listedinthe
appropriatepersonlistedinthe
precedingFORFURTHERINFORMATION theUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfor precedingFORFURTHERINFORMATION
theDistrictofColumbiaCircuit(the CONTACTsection,andtheAssociate
CONTACTsectionofthispreamble.
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00006 Fmt4706a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
ER07MY24.066</GPH>
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
BILLING CODE 6560–50–C
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38513
NESHAPmustreflect‘‘themaximum 1084(D.C.Cir.2008);Associationof
GeneralCounselfortheAirand
RadiationLaw Office,OfficeofGeneral degreeofreductioninemissionsofthe BatteryRecyclers,Inc.v.EPA,716F.3d
Counsel(MailCode2344A),U.S.EPA, [HAP]subjecttothissection(including 667(D.C.Cir.2013).TheEPAmay
aprohibitiononsuchemissions,where considercostindecidingwhetherto
1200PennsylvaniaAve.NW,
achievable)thattheAdministrator, revisethestandardspursuanttoCAA
Washington,DC20460.
t
akingintoconsiderationthecostof section112(d)(6).Seee.g.,Nat’lAss’n
II.Background
achievingsuchemissionreduction,and forSurfaceFinishing,v.EPA,795F.3d
A.Whatisthestatutoryauthorityfor anynonairqualityhealthand
1,11(D.C.Cir.2015).TheEPAis
thisaction?
environmentalimpactsandenergy
requiredtoaddressregulatorygaps,
requirements,determinesis
suchasmissingMACTstandardsfor
1.StatutoryLanguage
a
c
hi
e
v
a
b
l
e
.
’
’
(
e
mpha
s
i
s
a
dde
d)
.
The
s
e
airtoxicsknowntobeemitted
Thestatutoryauthorityforthisaction standardsarecommonlyreferredtoas lfirsotmedthe
sourcecategory.Louisiana
isprovidedbysections112and301of MACTstandards.CAAsection112(d)(3) Environme
alActionNetwork(LEAN)
theCAA,asamended(42U.S.C.7401et establishesaminimum controllevelfor v.EPA,955nt
F.
3d1088(D.C.Cir.2020).
seq.).Section112oftheCAA
MACT
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
,
k
no
wn
a
s
t
he
MACT
The
r
e
s
i
dua
l
r
i
skreview andthe
6I
establishesamulti-stageregulatory
f
l
o
o
r
.
’
’
‘
‘
n
c
e
r
t
a
i
n
i
ns
t
a
nc
e
s
,
a
s
t
e
c
hno
l
o
g
y
r
e
v
iew aredistinct
processtodevelopstandardsfor
pr
o
v
i
de
d
i
n
CAA
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
1
1
2
(
h)
,
t
he
r
e
q
ui
r
e
me
nt
s
a
ndarebothmandatory.
emissionsofHAPfrom stationary
I
n
t
hi
s
a
c
t
i
o
n,
theEPAisfinalizing
EPA
ma
y
s
e
t
wo
r
k
pr
a
c
t
i
c
e
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
i
n
sources.Generally,duringthefirst
a
me
ndme
nt
s
t
o
t
heMACTstandards
l
i
e
u
o
f
nume
r
i
c
a
l
e
mi
s
s
i
o
n
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
.
stage,CongressdirectedtheEPAto
b
a
s
e
d
o
n
t
wo
i
nde
ndentsourcesof
The
EPA
mus
t
a
l
s
o
c
o
ns
i
de
r
c
o
nt
r
o
l
establishtechnology-basedstandardsto optionsthataremorestringentthanthe authority:(1)itsrepe
v
i
e
the2020
ensurethatallmajorsourcescontrol floor.Standardsmorestringentthanthe FinalAction’sriskandwtoecfhno
logy
HAPemissionsatthelevelachievedby floorarecommonlyreferredtoas
r
e
v
i
e
w
pur
s
ua
nt
t
o
t
he
EPA’
s
s
ory
thebest-performingsources,referredto ‘‘beyond-the-floor’’standards.Forarea authorityunderCAAsection1t1a2t,ut
a
nd
astheMACT.Afterthefirststage,
(
2
)
t
he
EPA’
s
i
nhe
r
e
nt
a
ut
ho
r
i
t
y
t
o
s
o
ur
c
e
s
,
CAA
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
1
1
2
(
d)
(
5
)
a
l
l
o
ws
CongressdirectedtheEPAtoreview theEPAtosetstandardsbasedon
reconsiderpreviousdecisionsandto
thosestandardsperiodicallyto
r
evise,replace,orrepealadecisionto
g
e
ne
r
a
l
l
y
a
v
a
i
l
a
b
l
e
c
o
nt
r
o
l
t
e
c
hno
l
o
g
i
e
s
determinewhethertheyshouldbe
t
he
extentpermittedbylaw and
o
r
ma
na
g
e
me
nt
pr
a
c
t
i
c
e
s
(
GACT
7 support
strengthened.Within8yearsafter
yareasonedexplanation.
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
)
i
n
l
i
e
u
o
f
MACT
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
.
promulgationofthestandards,theEPA Forcategoriesofmajorsourcesand FCCv.FeodxbTe
ations,Inc.,556
mustevaluatetheMACTstandardsto anyareasourcecategoriessubjectto U.S.502,515(l2ev0i0s9io);nseSt
e
alsoMotor
determinewhethertheemission
MACT
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
,
t
he
ne
x
t
s
t
a
g
e
i
n
Ve
hi
c
l
e
Mf
r
s
.
As
s
’
n
v
.
St
a
Farm
standardsshouldberevisedtoaddress standard-settingfocusesonidentifying MutualAuto.Ins.Co.,463teU.
S.29,42
anyremainingriskassociatedwithHAP andaddressinganyremaining(i.e., (1983).
emissions.Thissecondstageis
l’’)riskpursuanttoCAA
2.StatutoryStructureandLegislative
commonlyreferredtoasthe‘‘residual ‘s‘ercetsiiodua
n
1
1
2
(
f
)
(
2
)
.
The
r
e
s
i
dua
l
r
i
s
k
History
riskreview.’’Inaddition,theCAAalso iew requirestheEPAtoupdate
Inadditiontothetextofthespecific
requirestheEPAtoreview standardsset rsetavnda
ifneededtoprovideanample sub
sectionsofCAAsection112
underCAAsection112onanongoing marginrds
o
f
s
a
f
e
t
y
t
o
pr
o
t
e
c
t
pub
l
i
c
he
a
l
t
h.
scussedabove,thestatutorystructure
basisnolessthanevery8yearsand
Concurrentwiththatreview,andthen di
revisethestandardsasnecessarytaking atleastevery8yearsthereafter,CAA andlegislativehistoryofCAAsection
thersupporttheEPA’sauthority
intoaccountany‘‘developmentsin
section112(d)(6)requirestheEPAto t1o12tafkur
saction.ThroughoutCAA
practices,processes,andcontrol
review standardspromulgatedunder sectioent1hi
12anditslegislativehistory,
technologies.’’Thisreview iscommonly CAAsection112andrevisethem ‘‘as
Congressmadeclearitsintenttoquickly
referredtoasthe‘‘technologyreview,’’ necessary(takingintoaccount
andistheprimarysubjectofthisfinal developmentsinpractices,processes, securelargereductionsinthevolumeof
rule.Thediscussionthatfollows
andcontroltechnologies).’’SeePortland HAPemissionsfrom stationarysources
identifiesthemostrelevantstatutory CementAss’nv.EPA,665F.3d177,189 basedontechnologicaldevelopmentsin
sectionsandbrieflyexplainsthe
(D.C.Cir.2011)(‘‘ThoughEPAmust controltechnologiesbecauseofits
contoursofthemethodologyusedto review andrevisestandards‘noless recognitionofthehazardstopublic
implementthesestatutoryrequirements. oftenthaneveryeightyears,’42U.S.C. healthandtheenvironmentthatresult
InthefirststageoftheCAAsection
(6),nothingprohibitsEPAfrom from exposuretosuchemissions.CAA
112standard-settingprocess,theEPA r7e4a1s2s(ed)
s
s
ingitsstandardsmoreoften.’’). section112anditslegislativehistory
promulgatestechnology-basedstandards Inconduc
thisreview,whichwe alsorevealCongress’sunderstanding
underCAAsection112(d)forcategories callthe‘‘teticng
hno
eview,’’theEPAis thatfullycharacterizingtherisksposed
ofsourcesidentifiedasemittingoneor notrequiredtorleocgaylcrul
tetheMACT byHAPemissionswasexceedingly
moreoftheHAPlistedinCAAsection floorsthatwereestablisahe
rlier difficult.Thus,Congresspurposefully
112(b).SourcesofHAPemissionsare rulemakings.NaturalResoduricneesaDe
fense replacedaregimethatrequiredtheEPA
eithermajorsourcesorareasources,and Council(NRDC)v.EPA,529F.3d1077, tomakeanassessmentofriskinthefirst
CAAsection112establishesdifferent 6
instance,withoneinwhichCongress
requirementsformajorsourcestandards ‘‘floSpe
cifically,forexistingsources,theMACT
determinedriskexistedanddirectedthe
or’’shallnotbelessstringentthantheaverage EPA tomakeswiftandsubstantial
andareasourcestandards.‘‘Major
ssionreductionachievedbythebestperforming reductionsbaseduponthemost
sources’’arethosethatemitorhavethe 1emi
2
pe
ofexistingsources.42U.S.C.7412(d)(3).
potentialtoemit10tonsperyear(tpy) Fornercwent
sourcesMACTshallnotbelessstringent stringentstandardstechnologycould
rolthatisachievedin
ormoreofasingleHAPor25tpyor thantheemissiobnesctocnt
eve.
ontrolledsimilarsource.Id. achi
moreofanycombinationofHAP.All pra7cFoticrecabtyegthe
Spe
ifically,in1990,Congress
fareasourcessubjecttoGACT radicac
othersourcesare‘‘areasources.’’For standards,theorrieesisono
llytransformedsection112ofthe
r
e
q
ui
r
e
me
nt
t
o
a
ddr
e
s
s
majorsources,CAAsection112(d)(2) residualrisk,but,similartothemajorsource
CAAanditstreatmentofHAPthrough
categories,thetechnologyreview isrequired.
providesthatthetechnology-based
theCleanAirActAmendments,by
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00007 Fmt4707a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38514
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
practicebythebestperformingsources evaluateeveryNESHAPnolessoften
amendingCAAsection112tobea
inthecategoryorsubcategorybasedon thanevery8yearstodeterminewhether
technology-drivenstandardsetting
provisionasopposedtotherisk-based emissionsdataavailabletotheEPAat additionalcontrolisnecessaryafter
onethatCongressinitiallypromulgated thetimeofpromulgation.This
takingintoconsideration
inthe1970CAA.Thelegislativehistory technology-basedapproachenabledthe ‘‘developmentsinpractices,processes,
EPAtoswiftlysetstandardsforsource andcontroltechnologies,’’separatefrom
ofthe1990Amendmentsindicates
categorieswithoutdeterminingtherisk itsobligationtoreview residualrisk.
Congress’sdissatisfactionwiththe
EPA’sslow paceaddressingHAPunder orcostineachspecificcase,astheEPA CAAsection112(f)requirestheEPAto
the1970CAA:‘‘Intheory,[hazardous haddonepriortothe1990
ensurewithin8yearsofpromulgatinga
airpollutants]weretobestringently Amendments.Inotherwords,this
NESHAPthattherisksareacceptable
controlledundertheexistingCleanAir approachtoregulationquicklyrequired andthattheMACTstandardsprovide
Actsection112.However,...only7 thatallmajorsourcesandmanyarea anamplemarginofsafety.
sourcesofHAPmeetanemission
ofthehundredsofpotentially
Thestatutoryrequirementtoestablish
standardconsistentwiththetop
hazardousairpollutantshavebeen
technology-basedstandardsunderCAA
regulatedbyEPAsincesection112was performersineachcategory,whichhad section112eliminatedtherequirement
enactedin1970.’’H.R.Rep.No.101– theeffectofobtainingimmediate
fortheEPAtoidentifyhazardstopublic
490,at315(1990);seealsoid.at151 reductionsinthevolumeofHAP
healthandtheenvironmentinorderto
emissionsfrom stationarysources.The justifyregulationofHAPemissions
(notingthatin20years,theEPA’s
statutoryrequirementthatsources
establishmentofstandardsforonly
rom stationarysources,reflecting
sevenHAPcovered‘‘asmallfractionof obtainlevelsofemissionlimitationthat fCo
ngress’sjudgmentthatsuch
themanysubstancesassociated... haveactuallybeenachievedbyexisting emi
ssionsareinherentlydangerous.See
withcancer,birthdefects,neurological sources,insteadoflevelsthatcould S.Re
p.No.101–228,at148(‘‘The
theoreticallybeachieved,inherently8 MACT
damage,orotherserioushealth
standardsarebasedonthe
reflectsabuilt-incostconsideration. performa
impacts.’’).
nceoftechnology,andnoton
Further,afterdeterminingthe
Inenactingthe1990Amendments
t
he
he
a
l
t
h
environmentaleffectsof
withrespecttothecontrolofHAP, minimum stringencylevelofcontrol,or the[HAP].’a’nd
)
.
The
logyreview
MACTfloor,CAAsection112(d)(2) requiredinCAAsetecctihno
Congressnotedthat‘‘[p]ollutants
o
n
1
12(d)(6)
controlledunder[section112]tendto directstheEPAto‘‘requirethe
f
ur
t
he
r
ma
nda
t
e
s
t
ha
t
t
he
EPA
belesswidespreadthanthoseregulated maximum degreeofreductionin
continuallyreassessstandardsto
[underothersectionsoftheCAA],but emissionsofthehazardousair
determineifadditionalreductionscan
areoftenassociatedwithmoreserious pollutantssubjecttothissection
b
eobtained,withoutevaluatingthe
(includingaprohibitiononsuch
healthimpacts,suchascancer,
s
pe
riskassociatedwiththeHAP
emissions,whereachievable)’’thatthe emicsisfiiocns
neurologicaldisorders,and
thatwouldbereduced.
reproductivedysfunctions.’’Id.at315. EPAdeterminesareachievableafter Notably,Co
ressrequiredtheEPAto
Initssubstantial1990Amendments, consideringthecostofachievingsuch conducttheng
CAA
section112(d)(6)
Congressitselflisted189HAP(CAA standardsandanynon-air-quality
r
e
v
i
e
w
o
f
wha
t
a
ddi
lreductions
section112(b))andsetforthastatutory healthandenvironmentalimpactsand maybeobtainedbasteiodna
o
n
new
energyrequirementsofadditional
structurethatwouldensureswift
t
e
c
hno
l
o
g
y
e
v
e
n
a
f
t
e
r
t
he
EPA
s
regulationofasignificantmajorityof control.Indoingso,thestatutefurther conductedtheone-timeCAAsha
e
c
t
ion
theseHAPemissionsfrom stationary specifiesinCAAsection112(d)(2)that 112(f)(2)riskreview anddetermine
d
theEPAshouldconsiderrequiring
sources.Specifically,afterdefining
t
ha
t
t
he
e
x
i
s
t
i
ng
s
t
a
nda
r
d
wi
l
l
pr
o
t
e
majorandareasourcesandrequiring sourcestoapplymeasuresthat,among thepublicwithanamplemarginofct
theEPAtolistallmajorsourcesand otherthings,‘‘reducethevolumeof,or safety.Thetworequirementsare
eliminateemissionsof,suchpollutants distinct,andbotharemandatory.
manyareasourcesofthelisted
pollutants(CAAsection112(c)),the ...’’(CAAsection112(d)(2)(A)),
B.WhatistheCoal-andOil-FiredEGU
new CAAsection112requiredtheEPA ‘‘enclosesystemsorprocessesto
sourcecategoryandhowdoesthe
toestablishtechnology-basedemission eliminateemissions’’(CAAsection
standardsforlistedsourcecategorieson 112(d)(2)(B)),and‘‘collect,capture,or NESHAPregulateHAPemissionsfrom
apromptscheduleandtorevisitthose treatsuchpollutantswhenreleased... thesourcecategory?
technology-basedstandardsevery8 ’’(CAAsection112(d)(2)(C)).The1990 1.SummaryofCoal-andOil-FiredEGU
yearsonanongoingbasis(CAAsection Amendmentsalsobuiltinaregular SourceCategoryandNESHAP
review ofnew technologiesandaone- gulations
112(d)(emissionstandards);CAA
section112(e)(scheduleforstandards timereview ofrisksthatremainafter ReThe
EPApromulgatedtheCoal-and
andreview)).The1990Amendments impositionofMACTstandards.CAA
l-FiredEGUNESHAP(commonly
alsoobligatedtheEPAtoconductaone- section112(d)(6)requirestheEPAto Oi
referredtoasMATS)onFebruary16,
timeevaluationoftheresidualrisk
8Congressrecogni
2012(77FR9304)(2012MATSFinal
zedasmuch:‘‘The
within8yearsofpromulgationof
Administratormaytakethecostofachievingthe Rule).Thestandardsarecodifiedat40
technology-basedstandards.CAA
maximum emissionreductionandanynon-air
CFRpart63,subpartUUUUU.Thecoalsection112(f)(2).
ualityhealthandenvironmentalimpactsand
andoil-firedelectricutilityindustry
Insettingthestandards,CAAsection eqne
rgyrequirementsintoaccountwhen
consistsoffacilitiesthatburncoaloroil
112(d)requirestheEPAtoestablish de
terminingtheemissionslimitationwhichis
chievableforthesourcesinthecategoryor
l
atedatbothmajorandareasources
technology-basedstandardsthatachieve asub
stconsiderationsarereflectedinthe oofcHAP
emissions.Anexistingaffected
the‘‘maximum degreeofreduction,’’ seleccattieognooryf.eCo
mi
s
s
i
o
ns
l
i
mi
t
a
t
i
o
ns
whi
c
h
ha
v
e
b
e
e
n
‘‘includingaprohibitiononsuch
achievedinpractice(ratherthanthosewhichare sourceisthecollectionofcoal-oroilemissionswhereachievable.’’CAA
merelytheoretical)bysourcesofasimilartypeor firedEGUsinasubcategorywithina
acter.’’ALegislativeHistoryoftheCleanAir singlecontiguousareaandunder
section112(d)(2).Congressspecified cAchatrAme
ntsof1990(CAALegislative
thatthemaximum degreeofreduction History),ndme
Vo
l
5
,pp.8508–8509(CAAAmendments commoncontrol.A new affectedsource
mustbeatleastasstringentasthe
of1989;p.168–169;ReportoftheCommitteeon iseachcoal-oroil-firedEGU forwhich
constructionorreconstructionbegan
EnvironmentandPublicWorksS.1630).
averagelevelofcontrolachievedin
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00008 Fmt4708a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38515
afterMay3,2011.AnEGUisafossil oil-firedEGUswithanannualcapacity dietaryandnutritionalriskfactorsare
oftenparticularlypronouncedin
fuel-firedcombustionunitofmorethan factoroflessthan8percentofits
25megawatts(MW)thatservesa
maximum ornameplateheatinputare vulnerablecommunitieswithpeopleof
generatorthatproduceselectricityfor alsosubjecttoaworkpracticestandard colorandlow-incomepopulationsthat
havehistoricallyfacedeconomicand
sale.Aunitthatcogeneratessteam and consistingofperiodiccombustion
electricityandsuppliesmorethanone- processtune-upsbutarenotsubjectto environmentalinjusticeandare
thirdofitspotentialelectricoutput anynumericemissionlimits.Emission overburdenedbycumulativelevelsof
capacityandmorethan25MW electric limitsforexistingEGUsandadditional pollution.Inadditiontoadverse
outputtoanyutilitypowerdistribution informationofthehistoryandother neurodevelopmentaleffects,thereis
system forsaleisalsoconsideredan requirementsofthe2012MATSFinal evidencethatexposureto
thylmercuryinhumansandanimals
EGU.The2012MATSFinalRule
eareavailableinthe2023Proposal me
canhaveadverseeffectsonboththe
definesadditionaltermsfordetermining Rul
pr
e
a
mb
l
e
(
8
8
FR
2
4
8
5
4
)
.
ruleapplicability,including,butnot 2.PublicHealthandEnvironmental developingandadultcardiovascular
limitedto,definitionsfor‘‘coal-fired HazardsAssociatedWithEmissions system.
Alongwiththehumanhealthhazards
electricutilitysteam generatingunit,’’ From Coal-andOil-FiredEGUs
associatedwithmethylmercury,itis
‘‘oil-firedelectricutilitysteam
well-establishedthatbirdsand
generatingunit,’’and‘‘fossilfuel-fired.’’ Coal-andoil-firedEGUsarea
In2028,theEPAexpectsthesource significantsourceofnumerousHAPthat mammalsarealsoexposedto
categorycoveredbythisMACT
areassociatedwithadverseeffectsto methylmercurythroughfish
standardtoinclude314coal-firedsteam humanhealthandtheenvironment, consumption(MercuryStudy).At
higherlevelsofexposure,theharmful
generatingunits(140GW at157
ludingHg,HF,HCl,selenium,
effectsofmethylmercuryincludeslower
facilities),58oil-firedsteam generating ianc
r
s
e
ni
c
,
c
hr
o
mi
um,
c
o
b
a
l
t
,
ni
c
k
e
l
,
growthanddevelopment,reduced
units(23GW at35facilities),and5
hydrogencyanide,beryllium,and
reproduction,andprematuremortality.
IGCCunits(0.8GW at2facilities).
c
a
dmi
um
e
mi
s
s
i
o
ns
.
Hg
i
s
a
pe
r
s
i
s
t
e
nt
effectsofmethylmercuryon
Forcoal-firedEGUs,the2012MATS
bioaccumulativetoxicmetalthat, The
wildlifearevariableacrossspeciesbut
FinalRuleestablishedstandardstolimit aond
nc
e
r
e
l
e
a
s
e
d
f
r
o
m
po
we
r
pl
a
nt
s
i
nt
o
havebeenobservedintheenvironment
emissionsofHg,acidgasHAP(e.g.,
ambientair,canbereadily
fornumerousavianspeciesand
HCl,HF),non-HgHAPmetals(e.g., tthe
r
a
ns
po
r
t
e
d
a
nd
de
po
s
i
t
e
d
t
o
s
o
i
l
a
nd
mammalsincludingpolarbears,river
nickel,lead,chromium),andorganic aquaticenvironmentswhereitis
HAP(e.g.,formaldehyde,dioxin/furan). transformedbymicrobialactioninto otters,andpanthers.
EGUsarealsothelargestsourceof
EmissionstandardsforHClserveasa methylmercury.9Methylmercury
surrogatefortheacidgasHAP,withan bioaccumulatesintheaquaticfoodweb HCl,HF,andselenium emissions,and
areamajorsourceofmetallicHAP
alternatestandardforSO2thatmaybe eventuallyresultinginhighly
usedasasurrogateforacidgasHAPfor concentratedlevelsofmethylmercury emissionsincludingarsenic,chromium,
ckel,cobalt,andothers.Exposureto
thosecoal-firedEGUswithfluegas
thinthelargerandlonger-livingfish ni
theseHAP,dependingonexposure
desulfurization(FGD)systemsandSO2 (wi
e
.
g
.
,
c
a
r
p,
c
a
t
f
i
s
h,
t
r
o
ut
,
a
nd
pe
r
c
h)
,
durationandlevelsofexposures,is
CEMSinstalledandoperational.
chcanthenbeconsumedby
associatedwithavarietyofadverse
StandardsforfPM serveasasurrogate whi
huma
ns
.
healtheffects.Theseadversehealth
forthenon-HgHAPmetals.Work
particularconcernischronic
effectsmayincludechronichealth
practicestandardslimitformationand preOf
na
t
a
l
e
x
po
s
ur
e
v
i
a
ma
t
e
r
na
l
disorders(e.g.,pneumonitis,decreased
emissionsoforganicHAP.
onsumptionoffoodscontaining
pulmonaryfunction,pneumonia,or
Foroil-firedEGUs,the2012MATS cme
t
hy
l
me
r
c
ur
y
.
El
e
v
a
t
e
d
e
x
po
s
ur
e
ha
s
FinalRuleestablishedstandardstolimit beenassociatedwithdevelopmental lungdamage;detrimentaleffectsonthe
emissionsofHClandHF,totalHAP neurotoxicityandmanifestsaspoor centralnervoussystem;damagetothe
kidneys)andalimentaryeffects(suchas
metals(e.g.,Hg,nickel,lead),and
performanceonneurobehavioraltests, na
useaandvomiting).Asof2021,three
organicHAP(e.g.,formaldehyde,
pa
r
t
i
c
ul
a
r
l
y
o
n
t
e
s
t
s
o
f
a
t
t
e
nt
i
o
n,
f
i
ne
ofthekeymetalHAPemittedbyEGUs
dioxin/furan).StandardsforfPM also motorfunction,language,verbal
c,chromium,andnickel)have
serveasasurrogatefortotalHAP
memory,andvisual-spatialability. (baeresneni
c
l
assifiedashumancarcinogens,
metals,withstandardsfortotaland
idencealsosuggestspotentialfor whilethr
eeothers(cadmium,selenium,
individualHAPmetalsprovidedas Ev
a
dv
e
r
s
e
e
f
f
e
c
t
s
o
n
t
he
c
a
r
di
o
v
a
s
c
ul
a
r
andlead)areclassifiedasprobable
alternativeequivalentstandards.Work system,adultnervoussystem,and
practicestandardslimitformationand immunesystem,aswellaspotentialfor humancarcinogens.Overall(metaland
nmetal),theEPAhasclassifiedfour
emissionsoforganicHAP.
ausingcancer.Becausetheimpactsof ono
MATSincludesstandardsforexisting tche
ftheHAPemittedbyEGUsashuman
ne
ur
o
de
v
e
l
o
pme
nt
a
l
e
f
f
e
c
t
s
o
f
andnew EGUsforeightsubcategories: methylmercuryaregreatestduring
carcinogensandfiveasprobablehuman
threeforcoal-firedEGUs,oneforIGCC periodsofrapidbraindevelopment, carcinogens.
EGUs,oneforsolidoil-derivedfuel- developingfetuses,infants,andyoung WhileexposuretoHAPisassociated
firedEGUs(i.e.,petroleum coke-fired), childrenareparticularlyvulnerable. withavarietyofadverseeffects,
uantifyingtheeconomicvalueofthese
andthreeforliquidoil-firedEGUs.
ldrenborntopopulationswithhigh qimpa
ctsremainschallenging.
EGUsinsevenofthesubcategoriesare fChi
hconsumption(e.g.,people
Epi
de
ologicstudies,whichreporta
subjecttonumericemissionlimitsfor ciosns
umingfishasadietarystaple)or centrami
l
e
stimateofpopulation-levelrisk,
allthepollutantsdescribedabove
irednutritionalstatusmaybe
a
r
e
g
e
ne
r
allyusedinanairpollution
exceptfororganicHAP(limited-use eimpa
speciallysusceptibletoadverse
b
e
ne
f
i
t
s
a
ssessmenttoestimatethe
liquidoil-firedEGUsarenotsubjectto ne
numericemissionlimits).Emissionsof urodevelopmentaloutcomes.These numberofattributablecasesofevents.
ExposuretoHAPistypicallymore
organicHAPareregulatedbyawork
EPA.1997,MercuryStudyReportto
unevenandmorehighlyconcentrated
practicestandardthatrequiresperiodic Co9ngU.rS.
e
s
s
,
EPA–
4
5
2
/
R–
9
7
–
0
0
3
(
De
c
e
mb
e
r
1
9
9
7
)
;
s
e
e
amongasmallernumberofindividuals
combustionprocesstune-ups.EGUsin also76FR24976(May3,2011);80FR75029
thanexposuretocriteriapollutants.
thesubcategoryoflimited-useliquid (December1,2015).
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00009 Fmt4709a
1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
38516
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
Hence,conductinganepidemiologic analysesbutareoftenlackingforHAP, Action.Theresultsoftherisk
madeevenmorechallengingbythe assessmentarepresentedbrieflyintable
studyforHAPisinherentlymore
widearrayofHAPandpossible
challenging;forstarters,thesmall
3ofthisdocument,andinmoredetail
populationsizemeanssuchstudies noncancerHAPeffects.
i
nthedocumenttitledResidualRisk
oftenlacksufficientstatisticalpowerto Finally,estimatingtheeconomic
As
sessmentfortheCoal-andOil-Fired
detecteffects(particularlyoutcomeslike valueofHAPismadechallengingbythe EGU
urceCategoryinSupportofthe
humanhealthendpointsaffected.For 2020So
cancer,forwhichtherecanexista
Ri
s
andTechnologyReviewFinal
multi-yeartimelagbetweenexposure example,thoughEPAcanquantifythe Rule(riskkdo
umentforthefinalrule),
numberandeconomicvalueofHAP- availableintche
andtheonsetofthedisease).By
docket(DocumentID
attributabledeathsresultingfrom
contrast,sufficientpowergenerally
No
.
EPA–
HQ–
OAR–
8–0794–4553).
cancer,itisdifficulttomonetizethe TheEPAsummarize2d0t1he
existstodetecteffectsforcriteria
resultsand
valueofreducinganindividual’s
pollutantsbecauseexposuresare
f
i
ndi
ng
s
o
f
t
he
2
0
2
0
Re
s
i
dua
lRisk
ubiquitousandavarietyofmethods potentialcancerriskattributabletoa Review inthepreambleofthe
2023
existtocharacterizethisexposureover lifetimeofHAPexposure.An
Pr
o
po
s
a
l
(
8
8
FR
2
4
8
5
4
)
,
a
nd
a
ddi
tional
spaceandtime.
alternativeapproachofconducting
i
nf
o
r
ma
t
i
o
n
c
o
nc
e
r
ni
ng
t
he
r
e
s
i
dua
Forthereasonsnotedabove,
willingnesstopaystudiesspecifically review canbefoundinourNationall-risk
epidemiologicstudiesdonotgenerally onriskreductionmaybepossible,but ScaleMercuryRiskEstimatesfor
existforHAP.Instead,theEPAtendsto suchstudieshavenotyetbeenpursued. Cardiovascularand
relyonexperimentalanimalstudiesto C.Summaryofthe2020ResidualRisk NeurodevelopmentalOutcomesforthe
identifytherangeofeffectswhichmay Re
view
NationalEmissionStandardsfor
beassociatedwithaparticularHAP
zardousAirPollutants:Coal-and
AsrequiredbyCAAsection112(f)(2), Ha
exposure.Humancontrolledclinical
l-FiredElectricUtilitySteam
studiesareoftenlimitedduetoethical theEPAconductedtheresidualrisk Oi
ratingUnits—Revocationofthe
review (2020ResidualRiskReview)in Gene
barriers(e.g.,knowinglyexposing
0Reconsideration,andAffirmation
someonetoacarcinogen).Generally, 2020,8yearsafterpromulgatingthe 2o0f2the
AppropriateandNecessary
robustdataareneededtoquantifythe 2012MATSFinalRule,andpresented
magnitudeofexpectedadverseimpacts theresultsofthereview,alongwithour Finding;NoticeofProposedRulemaking
from varyingexposurestoaHAP.These decisionsregardingriskacceptability, memorandum (DocumentIDNo.EPA–
amplemarginofsafety,andadverse HQ–OAR–2018–0794–4605).
dataarenecessarytoprovidea
foundationforquantitativebenefits environmentaleffects,inthe2020Final BILLING CODE 6560–50–P
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00010 Fmt4710a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38517
thattheexistingairpollutioncontrol furans,areregulatedbyaworkpractice
logiesthatwereinusewerewell- standardthatrequiresperiodicburner
D.Summaryofthe2020Technology teesctahno
blishedandprovidedthecapture tune-upstoensuregoodcombustion.
Review
nciesnecessaryforcompliance TheEPAfoundthatthisworkpractice
PursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), effitchiethe
MATSemissionlimits.Based continuedtobeapracticalapproachto
theEPAconductedatechnologyreview wi
ensuringthatcombustionequipment
o
n
t
he
e
f
f
enessandproven
(2020TechnologyReview)inthe2020 reliabilityeoctfitvhe
secontroltechnologies, wasmaintainedandoptimizedtorunto
FinalAction,whichfocusedon
andtherelativelyshortperiodoftime reduceemissionsoforganicHAPand
identifyingandevaluating
continuedtobemoreeffectivethan
incethepromulgationofthe2012
developmentsinpractices,processes, sMATS
e
stablishinganumericstandardthat
Fi
na
l
Rul
e
,
t
he
EPA
di
d
no
t
andcontroltechnologiesforthe
annotreliablybemeasuredor
dentifyanydevelopmentsinpractices, cmo
emissionsourcesinthesourcecategory ipr
tored.Basedontheeffectiveness
ocesses,orcontroltechnologies,nor ndni
thatoccurredsincethe2012MATS
provenreliabilityofthework
nynew technologiesorpractices,for apr
FinalRulewaspromulgated.Control athe
acticestandard,andtherelatively
controlofnon-HgHAPmetals,acid sho
technologiestypicallyusedtominimize gasHAP,
rtamountoftimesincethe
orHg.However,inthe2020 promul
emissionsofpollutantsthathave
gationofthe2012MATSFinal
Te
c
hno
l
o
g
y
Re
v
i
e
w,
t
he
EPA
di
d
no
t
numericemissionlimitsunderthe2012 iderdevelopmentsinthecostand Rule,the
EPAdidnotidentifyany
MATSFinalRuleincludeelectrostatic ceoffns
de
v
e
l
o
pme
ntsinworkpracticesnorany
e
c
t
i
v
e
ne
s
s
o
f
t
he
s
e
pr
o
v
e
n
precipitators(ESPs)andfabricfilters technologies,nordidtheEPAevaluate new workpr
cesoroperational
(FFs)forcontroloffPM asasurrogate thecurrentperformanceofemission proceduresfoarcttihi
ssourcecategory
fornon-HgHAPmetals;wetscrubbers,
regardingtheadditionalcontrolof
dryscrubbers,anddrysorbentinjection reductioncontrolequipmentand
forcontrolofacidgases(SO2,HCl,and strategiesatexistingMATS-affected organicHAP.
EGUs,todeterminewhetherrevisingthe Afterconductingthe2020Technology
HF);andactivatedcarboninj
ection
(ACI)andotherHg-specifictechnologies standardswaswarranted.OrganicHAP, Review,theEPAdidnotidentify
developmentsinpractices,processes,or
forcontrolofHg.TheEPAdetermined includingemissionsofdioxinsand
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00011 Fmt4711a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
ER07MY24.067</GPH>
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
BILLING CODE 6560–50–C
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38518
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
controltechnologiesand,thus,didnot thelevelofthefinalfPM standard), includeschangestothe2023Proposal
shouldtheAgencynotfinalizethe
afterconsiderationofcomments
proposechangestoanyemission
receivedduringthepubliccomment
standardsorotherrequirements.More removalofthenon-HgHAPmetals
perioddescribedinsectionsIV.,V.,VI.,
informationconcerningthattechnology limits.
TheAgencyalsoproposedtolower andVII.ofthispreamble.
review isinthememorandum titled
TechnologyReview fortheCoal-and theHgemissionstandardforlignite- A.Whatarethefinalruleamendments
firedEGUsfrom 4.0lb/TBtuto1.2lb/ asedonthetechnologyreviewforthe
Oil-FiredEGUSourceCategory,
availableinthedocket(DocumentID TBtuandsolicitedcommentonthe bCo
Oil-FiredEGUsource
No.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794–0015), performanceofHgcontrolsandoncost cataelg-oarnd
y
?
a
nd
e
f
f
e
c
t
i
v
e
ne
s
s
o
f
c
o
nt
r
o
l
s
t
r
a
t
e
g
i
e
s
t
o
andintheFebruary7,2019,proposed
Wedeterminedthatthereare
rule.84FR2700.OnMay20,2020,the meetmorestringentHgstandards.
velopmentsinpractices,processes,
Lastly,theEPAdidnotidentifynew de
EPAfinalizedthefirsttechnology
controltechnologiesthatwarrant
developmentsincontroltechnologiesor raend
review requiredbyCAAsection
isionstotheMACTstandardsforthis
112(d)(6)forthecoal-andoil-firedEGU improvedmethodsofoperationthat sovur
cecategory.Therefore,tosatisfythe
sourcecategoryregulatedunderMATS. wouldwarrantrevisionstotheHg
requirementsofCAAsection112(d)(6),
Basedontheresultsofthattechnology emissionstandardsfornon-lignite
wearerevisingtheMACTstandardsby
review,theEPAfoundthatnorevisions EGUs,fortheorganicHAPwork
revisingthefPM limitforexistingcoaltoMATSwerewarranted.See85FR practicestandards,fortheacidgas
from 0.030lb/MMBtuto
standards,orforstandardsforoil-fired f0i.r0e1d0EGUs
31314(May22,2020).
l
b
/
MMBt
requiringtheuse
EGUs
.
The
r
e
f
o
r
e
,
t
he
Ag
e
nc
y
di
d
no
t
E.SummaryoftheEPA’sReviewofthe proposechangestothesestandardsin ofPM CEMSfourcaond
a
l
a
ndoil-firedEGUs
2020RTRandthe2023Proposed
t
o
de
mo
ns
t
r
a
t
e
c
o
mpl
i
ancewiththe
t
he
2
0
2
3
Pr
o
po
s
a
l
b
ut
di
d
s
o
l
i
c
i
t
RevisionstotheNESHAP
revisedfPM standard,asproposed.We
c
o
mme
nt
o
n
t
he
EPA’
s
pr
o
po
s
e
d
arealsofinalizing,asproposed,aHg
PursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), indingsthatnorevisionswere
limitforlignite-firedEGUsof1.2lb/
theEPAconductedareview ofthe2020 fwa
r
r
a
nt
e
d
a
nd
o
n
t
he
a
ppr
o
pr
i
a
t
e
ne
s
s
o
f
TBtu,whichalignswiththeexistingHg
TechnologyReview andpresentedthe theexistingstandards.
limitthathasbeenineffectforother
resultsofthisreview,alongwithour
Addi
t
i
o
na
l
l
y
,
t
he
EPA
pr
o
po
s
e
d
t
o
coal-firedEGUssince2012.Thisrevised
proposeddecisions,inthe2023
removeoneofthetwooptionsfor
Hglimitforlignite-firedEGUsismore
Proposal.Theresultsofthetechnology de
f
i
ni
ng
t
he
s
t
a
r
t
up
pe
r
i
o
d
f
o
r
MATSstringentthanthelimitof4.0lb/TBtu
review arepresentedbrieflybelow in affectedEGUs.
thatwasfinalizedforsuchunitsinthe
thispreamble.Moredetailonthe
I
n
t
he
2
0
2
3
Pr
o
po
s
a
l
,
t
he
EPA
2012MATSFinalRule.Therationale
proposedtechnologyreview isinthe determinednottoreopenthe2020
forthesechangesisdiscussedinmore
memorandum 2023TechnologyReview Re
s
i
dua
l
Ri
s
k
Re
v
i
e
w,
a
nd
a
c
c
o
r
di
ng
l
y
fortheCoal-andOil-FiredEGUSource didnotproposeanyrevisionstothat detailinsectionsIV.andV.below.
Basedoncommentsreceivedduring
Category(‘‘2023TechnicalMemo’’) review.AstheEPAexplainedinthe
thepubliccommentperiod,theEPAis
(DocumentIDNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–
pr
o
po
s
a
l
,
t
he
EPA
f
o
und
i
n
t
he
2
0
2
0
tfinalizingtheproposedremovalof
2018–0794–5789).
thatrisksfrom theCoal-andOil- no
thenon-HgHAPmetalslimitsfor
Basedontheresultsofthetechnology RTR
Fi
r
e
d
EGU
s
o
ur
c
e
c
a
t
e
g
o
r
y
due
t
o
xistingcoal-firedEGUs(seesectionV.).
review,theEPAproposedtolowerthe
ssionsofairtoxicsareacceptable eAddi
tionally,thisfinalruleisrequiring
fPM standard,thesurrogatefornon-Hg eami
nd
t
ha
t
t
he
e
x
i
s
t
i
ng
NESHAP
pr
o
v
i
de
s
HAPmetals,forcoal-firedEGUsfrom anamplemarginofsafetytoprotect theuseofPM CEMSforcompliance
0.030lb/MMBtuto0.010lb/MMBtu. publichealth.Asnotedintheproposal, demonstrationforcoal-andoil-fired
EGUs(excludingEGUsinthelimitedTheAgencysolicitedcommentonthe theEPAalsoacknowledgesthatit
controltechnologyeffectivenessand receivedapetitionforreconsideration useliquidoil-firedsubcategory),butnot
IGCCEGUs(seesectionVI.).
costassumptionsusedintheproposed
ironmentalorganizationsthat, forBe
causethisfinalruleincludes
rule,aswellasonamorestringentfPM firnormeleevnv
a
nt
pa
r
t
,
s
o
ug
ht
t
he
EPA’
s
revisionstotheemissionsstandardsfor
limitof0.006lb/MMBtuorlower.
r
e
c
o
ns
i
de
r
a
t
i
o
n
o
f
c
e
r
t
a
i
n
a
s
pe
c
t
s
o
f
t
he
Additionally,theAgencyproposedto 2020ResidualRiskReview.TheEPA fPM asasurrogatefornon-HgHAP
metalsforexistingcoal-firedEGUs,the
requiretheuseofPM CEMSforallcoal- grantedinparttheenvironmental
PM emissionstandardcompliance
fired,oil-fired,andIGCCEGUsfor
rganizations’petitionwhichsoughtthe fde
monstrationrequirements,theHg
demonstratingcompliancewiththefPM oEPA’
s
r
e
v
i
e
w
o
f
s
t
a
r
t
up
a
nd
s
hut
do
wn
standard.AstheAgencyproposedto provisionsinthe2023Proposal,88FR emissionstandardforlignite-fired
,andthedefinitionof‘‘startup,’’
requirePM CEMSforcompliance
4885,andtheEPAcontinuestoreview tEGUs
he
EPA
endseachportionofthis
demonstration,wealsoproposedto a2nd
llrespondtootheraspe
ctsofthe ruletobeint
severablefrom eachotheras
removetheLEEoption,aprogram based petitwi
10
i
o
n
i
n
a
s
e
pa
r
a
t
e
a
c
t
i
o
n.
itismultifacetedandaddressesseveral
oninfrequentstacktesting,forfPM and
non-HgHAPmetals.AsEGUswouldbe III.Whatisincludedinthisfinalrule? distinctaspectsofMATSfor
independentreasons.Thisincludesthe
requiredtodemonstratecompliance
ThisactionfinalizestheEPA’s
revisedemissionstandardforfPM asa
withPM CEMS,theAgencyalso
de
t
e
r
mi
na
t
i
o
ns
pur
s
ua
nt
t
o
t
he
RTR
urrogatefornon-HgHAPmetalsand
proposedtoremovethealternate
provisionsofCAAsection112forthe sthe
fPM compliancedemonstration
emissionstandardsfornon-HgHAP Co
a
l
a
nd
Oi
l
Fi
r
e
d
EGU
s
o
ur
c
e
c
a
t
e
g
o
r
y
metalsandtotalHAPmetals,because andamendstheCoal-andOil-Fired requirementtoutilizePM CEMS.While
theEPAconsideredthetechnical
almostallregulatedsourceshave
EGUNESHAPbasedonthose
feasibilityofPM CEMSinestablishing
chosentodemonstratecompliancewith de
t
e
r
mi
na
t
i
o
ns
.
Thi
s
a
c
t
i
o
n
a
l
s
o
thenon-HgHAPmetalstandardsby finalizeschangestothedefinitionof therevisedfPM standard,theEPAfinds
thereareindependentreasonsfor
demonstratingcompliancewiththe startupforthisrule.Thisfinalrule
adoptingeachrevisiontothestandards,
surrogatefPM standard,andsolicited
commentonproratedmetallimits
10SeeDocumentI
DNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018– andthateachwouldcontinuetobe
workablewithouttheotherintheplace.
(adjustedproportionallyaccordingto 0794–4565athttps://www.regulations.gov.
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00012 Fmt4712a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38519
TheEPAintendsthatthevarious reflecttheAgency’sjudgmentthatthe UUUUU,untiltheapplicable
piecesofthispackagebeconsidered elementisindependentlyjustifiedand compliancedateoftheamendedrule.
independentofeachother.Forexample, appropriate,andthateachelementcan TheEPAhasconsideredtheconcerns
functionindependentlyevenifoneor sedbycommentersthatthese
theEPAnotesthatourjudgments
regardingdevelopmentsinfPM control moreotherpartsoftherulehasbeenset rcaoimpl
iancedeadlinescouldaffect
technologyfortherevisedfPM standard aside.
reliabilityandconcludedthat
e
l
e
c
t
r
i
c
asasurrogatefornon-HgHAPmetals B.Whatotherchangeshavebeenmade giventhe
flexibilitiesdetailedfurtherin
largelyreflectthatthefleetwas
t
o
t
he
NESHAP?
t
hi
s
s
e
c
t
i
o
therequirementsofthe
reportingfPM emissionrateswellbelow TheEPAisfinalizing,asproposed, finalrulefn,
o
r
existingsourcescanbemet
thecurrentstandardandwithlower theremovaloftheworkpractice
wi
t
ho
ut
a
dv
e
rselyimpactingelectric
coststhanestimatedduring
reliability.Inparticular,theEPAnotes
tandardsofparagraph(2)ofthe
promulgationofthe2012MATSFinal sde
theflexibilityofpermittingauthorities
tionof‘‘startup’’in40CFR
Rule;whileourjudgmentsregardingthe 3f.1ini
allow,ifwarranted,afourthyearfor
0042.Underthefirstoption,startup ctoompl
abilityforlignite-firedEGUstomeetthe 6ends
eunderCAAsection
nanyofthesteam from the 112(i)(i3a)nc
samestandardforHgemissionsasother boilerwhe
(B).Thisflexibility,ifneeded,
isusedtogenerateelectricityfor
coal-andoil-firedEGUsrestona
wouldaddressmanyoftheconcerns
aleoverthegridorforanyother
separateanalysisspecifictolignite-fired spur
se(includingon-siteuse).Under thatcommentersraised.Furthermore,in
units.Thus,therevisedfPM surrogate thepo
secondoption,startupends4hours theeventthatanisolated,localized
emissionsstandardisfeasibleand
EGUgenerateselectricitythat concernweretoemergethatcouldnot
appropriateevenabsenttherevisedHg aisftseorltdhe
orusedforanyotherpurpose beaddressedsolelythroughthe1-year
standardforlignite-firedunits,andvice (includi
on-siteuse),or4hoursafter extensionunderCAAsection112(i)(3),
versa.Similarly,theEPAisfinalizing theEGUng
makesusefulthermalenergy theCAAprovidesadditional
changestothefPM compliance
hasheatorsteam)forindustrial, flexibilitiestobringsourcesinto
demonstrationrequirementbasedonthe (souc
mmercial,heating,orcooling
iancewhilemaintaining
technology’sabilitytoprovideincreased cpur
ses,whicheverisearlier.Thefinal creolmpl
transparencyforownersandoperators, rulepo
i
a
b
i
ity.
resthatallEGUsusethework ThelEPA
regulators,andthepublic;andtheEPA practriecqeui
testhatsimilarconcerns
standardsinparagraph(1)of regardingreno
isfinalizingchangestothestartup
l
i
a
litywereraisedabout
thedefinitionof‘‘startup,’’whichis the2012MATSbiFi
definitionbasedonconsiderations
lRule—arulethat
alreadybeingusedbythemajorityof projectedtheneedna
raisedbyenvironmentalgroupsin
f
o
rsignificantly
EGUs
.
petitionsforreconsideration.Bothof
g
r
e
a
t
e
r
i
ns
t
a
l
l
a
t
i
o
n
o
f
controlsandother
theseactionsareindependentfrom the C.Whataretheeffectiveand
talinvestmentsthanthiscurrent
EPA’srevisionstothefPM surrogate compliancedatesofthestandards? rceavpi
ision.Inthe2012MATSFinalRule,
standard,andtheHgstandardfor
revisionstotheMACTstandards theEPAemphasizedthatmostunits
lignite-firedunits.Accordingly,theEPA beThe
ingpromulgatedinthisactionare shouldbeabletocomplywiththe
findsthateachsetofstandardsis
requirementsofthefinalrulewithin3
effectiveonJuly8,2024.The
severablefrom eachothersetof
y
ears.However,theEPAalsomadeit
c
o
mpl
i
a
nc
e
da
t
e
f
o
r
a
f
f
e
c
t
e
d
c
o
a
l
f
i
r
e
d
standards.
sourcestocomplywiththerevisedfPM clearthatpermittingauthoritieshave
Finally,theEPAfindsthat
tof0.010lb/MMBtuandforlignite- theauthoritytogranta1-year
implementationofeachsetofstandards, fliirmi
edsourcestomeetthelowerHglimit complianceextensionwherenecessary,
compliancedemonstration
of1.2lb/TBtuis3yearsafterthe
inarangeofsituationsdescribed1in1the
requirements,andrevisionstothe
effectivedateofthefinalrule.The
2
012MATSFinalRulepreamble. The
startupdefinitionareindependent.That Ag
encybelievesthistimelineisas
EPA’
sOfficeofEnforcementand
is,asourcecanabidebyanyoneof expe
ditiousaspracticableconsidering Compl
nceAssurance(OECA)also
theseindividualrequirementswithout thepo
tentialneedforsomesourcesto issueditahe
Enfo1r2cementResponse
abidingbyanyothers.Thus,theEPA’s upgrade
acepollutioncontrols. policy(DecMATS
.
1
6
,
2
0
11) which
overallapproachtothissourcecategory Asdiscusosrerdepl
reinthis
de
s
c
r
i
b
e
d
t
he
a
ppr
o
continuestobefullyimplementable preamble,weealrseewhe
addingarequirement issueofCAAsectionac1h13re(ag)ardingthe
evenintheabsenceofanyoneormore thatcompliancewi
fPM limitbe administrativeorderswithrespecttothe
oftheelementsincludedinthisfinal demonstratedusingthPMtheCEMS.
Based sourcesthatmustoperatein
rule.
commentsreceivedduringthe
Thus,theEPAhasindependently oconmme
ncompliancewiththeMATSrulefor
ntperiodandourunderstanding no
consideredandadoptedeachportionof ofsuppl
up
o1yeartoaddressspecific
iersofPM CEMS,theEPAis doctume
thisfinalrule(includingtherevised finalizing
edreliabilityconcerns.While
requirementthataffected severalant
fPM emissionstandardasasurrogatefor sourcesustehe
f
f
requestedand
PM CEMSforcompliance weregranteecdtead1EGUs
non-HgHAPmetals,thefPM
y
e
a
r
CAA
section
monstrationby3yearsafterthe
compliancedemonstrationrequirement, de
1
1
2
(
i
)
(
3
)
(
B)
c
o
mpl
i
a
nc
e
e
x
t
e
nsionby
therevisedHgemissionstandardfor effectivedateofthefinalrule.The
t
he
i
r
pe
r
mi
t
t
i
ng
a
ut
ho
r
i
t
y
,
OECA
compliancedateforexistingaffected issuedfiveadministrativeordersionnly
lignite-firedunits,andtherevised
startupdefinition)andeachisseverable sourcestocomplywithamendments onnectionwiththeEnforcement
shouldtherebejudicialreview.Ifa pertainingtothestartupdefinitionis cRe
sponsepolicy.The2012MATSFinal
courtweretoinvalidateanyoneofthese 180daysaftertheeffectivedateofthe Rul
sultimatelyimplementedover
finalrule,asfew EGUsareaffected,and thee20wa
elementsofthefinalrule,theEPA
1
5
—2016timeframewithout
intendstheremainderofthisactionto changesneededtocomplywith
c
ha
l
l
e
ng
e
stogridreliability.
remaineffective.Importantly,theEPA paragraph(1)ofstartupareachievable
designedthedifferentelementsofthis byallEGUsatlittletonoadditional
1177FR9406.
expenditures.Allaffectedfacilities
finalruletofunctionsensiblyand
12ht
tps://www.epa.gov/enforcement/
independently.Further,thesupporting remainsubjecttothecurrent
enforcement-response-policy-mercury-and-airbasesforeachelementofthefinalrule requirementsof40CFRpart63,subpart toxics-standard-mats.
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00013 Fmt4713a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38520
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
IV.Whatistherationaleforourfinal preparedthatwilleasedataediting, rate.Afterconsiderationofpublic
importing,andexportingandis
comments,theAgencyisfinalizing
decisionsandamendmentstothe
filterablePM (asasurrogatefornon-Hg expectedtobeavailablepriortothedate updatedlimitsfornon-HgHAPmetals
HAPmetals)standardandcompliance bywhichEGUsarerequiredtousePM andtotalnon-HgHAPmetalsthathave
CEMS.
optionsfrom the2020Technology
beenreducedproportionaltothe
Review?
tionofthefPM emissionlimit
A.Whatdidweproposepursuantto frreoduc
m 0.030lb/MMBtutothenew final
Inthissection,theEPAprovides
CAA
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
1
1
2
(
d)
(
6
)
f
o
r
t
he
Co
a
l
a
nd
fPM emissionlimitof0.010lb/MMBtu.
descriptionsofwhatweproposed,what l-FiredEGUsourcecategory?
EGUownersoroperatorswhowould
wearefinalizing,ourrationaleforthe Oi
1.ProposedChangestotheFilterable choosetocomplywiththenon-HgHAP
finaldecisionsandamendments,anda PM
Standard
metalsemissionlimitsinsteadofthe
summaryofkeycommentsand
limitmustrequestandreceive
TheEPAproposedtolowerthefPM faPM
responsesrelatedtotheemission
ovalofanon-HgHAPmetalCMS
standardforfPM,non-HgHAPmetals, limit,asurrogatefortotalnon-HgHAP appr
lternativetestmethod(e.g.,
metals,forcoal-firedEGUsfrom 0.030 santi-ame
andthecompliancedemonstration
talCMS)undertheprovisions
options.Forallcommentsnotdiscussed lb/MMBtuto0.010lb/MMBtu.TheEPA omul
f40CFR63.7(f).
inthispreamble,commentsummaries furthersolicitedcommentonan
andtheEPA’sresponsescanbefound emissionstandardof0.006lb/MMBtuor 2.ComplianceDemonstrationOptions
inthecommentsummaryandresponse lower.TheEPAdidnotproposeany
ntsreceivedonthe
documentNationalEmissionStandards changestothefPM emissionstandard Comme
iancedemonstrationoptionsfor
forHazardousAirPollutants:Coal-and foroil-firedEGUsorforIGCCunits.The ccooampl
l-andoil-firedEGUsalsodidnot
EPAalsoproposedtoremovethetotal
Oil-FiredElectricUtilitySteam
ngetheresultsofthetechnology
GeneratingUnitsReviewoftheResidual andindividualnon-HgHAPmetals creha
v
i
thereforetheAgencyis
RiskandTechnologyReviewProposed emissionlimits.TheEPAalsosolicited finaleiw,
zingtheuseofPM CEMSfor
RuleResponsetoComments,available commentonadjustingthetotaland
ompliancedemonstrationpurposes
individualnon-HgHAPmetalsemission acnd
inthedocket.
vingthefPM andnon-HgHAP
limitsproportionallytotherevisedfPM metarlesmo
Basedonitsreview,theEPAis
LEE
ionsforallcoal-fired
finalizingarevisednon-HgHAPmetal limitratherthaneliminatingthelimits EGUsandfoorpt
oil-firedEGUs(except
surrogatefPM emissionstandardforall altogether.
thoseinthelimiteduseliquidoil-fired
existingcoal-firedEGUsof0.010lb/ 2.ProposedChangestothe
EGUsubcategory).TheAgencyreceived
MMBtuandisrequiringthatallcoal- RequirementsforCompliance
commentsthatsomePM CEMSthatare
andoil-firedEGUsdemonstrate
Demonstration
currentlycorrelatedforthe0.030lb/
compliancewiththerevisedfPM
ufPM emissionlimitmay
EPAproposedtorequirethatall MMBt
emissionstandardbyusingPM CEMS. coThe
riencesomedifficultiesshouldreal-andoil-firedEGUs(IGCCunitsare ceoxrpe
TherevisedfPM standardwillensure di
relationbenecessaryatalowerfPM
cussedinsectionVI.)usePM CEMS standa
thattheentirefleetofcoal-firedEGUs tosde
rd.Basedonthesecommentsand
nstratecompliancewiththe onaddi
achievesperformancelevelsthatare fPM emo
tionalreview ofPM CEMStest
mi
s
s
i
o
n
l
i
mi
t
.
The
EPA
a
l
s
o
consistentwiththoseofthevast
reports,asmentionedinsectionsIV.C.2.
oposedtoremovetheoptionof
majorityofregulatedunitsoperating pr
andIV.D.2.,theAgencyhasmademinor
monstratingcomplianceusing
today—i.e.,thatthesmallminorityof ide
calrevisionstoshiftthebasisof
nfrequentstacktestingandtheLEE tceocrhni
unitsthatcurrentlyemitsignificantly pr
r
e
l
a
tiontestingfrom samplinga
o
g
r
a
m
(
whe
r
e
s
t
a
c
k
t
e
s
t
i
ng
o
c
c
ur
s
higherlevelsofHAPthantheirpeers quarterlyfor3years,theneverythird minimum
lumeperruntocollecting
useproventechnologiestoreducetheir yearthereafter)forbothPM andnon-Hg aminimumvoma
ssorminimum sample
HAPtothelevelsachievedbytherest HAPmetals.
volumeperrunandhasadjustedthe
ofthefleet.Further,theEPAfindsthat
qualityassurance(QA)criterion
a0.010lb/MMBtufPM emission
Howdidthetechnologyreview
otherwiseassociatedwiththenew
standardisthelowestlevelcurrently cB.
ha
ng
e
f
o
r
t
he
Co
a
l
a
nd
Oi
l
F
i
r
e
d
EGU
emissionlimit.Thesechangeswill
compatiblewithPM CEMSfor
cecategory?
enablePM CEMStobeproperly
demonstratingcompliance,whichthe s1o.ur
certifiedforuseindemonstrating
EPAfindsprovidessignificantbenefits FilterablePM EmissionStandard
compliancewiththelowerfPM
includingincreasedtransparency
Commentersprovidedboth
andardwithahighdegreeofaccuracy
regardingemissionsperformancefor supportiveandopposingargumentsfor satnd
sources,regulators,andthesurrounding issuesregardingthefPM limitthatwere reliability.
communities;andreal-time
presentedintheproposedreview ofthe C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceive
identificationofwhencontrol
2020TechnologyReview.Comments onthefilterablePM andcompliance
technologiesarenotperformingas
receivedontheproposedfPM limitfor ions,andwhatareourresponses?
expected,allowingforquickerrepairs. coal-firedEGUs,alongwithadditional 1o.pt
Inaddition,therule’scurrent
analyses,didnotchangetheAgency’s CommentsontheFilterablePM
requirementtoshiftelectronicreporting conclusionsthatwerepresentedinthe EmissionStandard
Comment:Somecommenters
ofPM CEMSdatatotheEmissions
2023Proposal,and,therefore,the
supportedtheproposedfPM limitof
CollectionandMonitoringPlanSystem Agencyisfinalizingthe0.010lb/
(ECMPS)willenableregulatory
MMBtufPM emissionlimitforexisting 0.010lb/MMBtuasreasonableand
achievable,notingthatthislimitis
authorities,nearbycitizens,andothers, coal-firedEGUs,asproposed.
Additionally,commentersurgedthe slightlygreaterthanthefPM emission
includingmembersofthepublicand
limitrequiredfornew and
media,toquicklyandeasilylocate, Agencytoretaintheoptionof
review,anddownloadfPM emissions complyingwithindividualnon-HgHAP reconstructedunits.Additionally,
usingsimple,user-directedinquiries. metal(e.g.,lead,arsenic,chromium, commentersstatedCAAsection112was
Anenhanced,web-basedversionof nickel,andcadmium)emissionratesor intendedtoimprovetheperformanceof
ECMPS(ECMPS2.0)iscurrentlybeing withatotalnon-HgHAPmetalemission laggingindustrialsourcesandthata
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00014 Fmt4714a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38521
standardthatfallsfarbehindwhatthe sectionandinsectionIV.D.1.ofthis substantialactiontocomplywiththe
vastmajorityofsourceshavealready preamble,theEPAfindscaselaw and proposedlimit.
achieved,asthecurrentstandarddoes, substantialadministrativeprecedent
sponse:TheEPAagreesthatmost
supporttheEPA’sdecisiontoupdate facRe
isinadequate.Othercommenters
i
l
i
tyoperatorsnormallytargetan
thefPM limitbaseduponthese
opposedtheproposedfPM limitof
e
mi
s
s
ionlevelbelow theemissionlimit
velopments.
0.010lb/MMBtuastoostringent.For deCo
b
y
i
nc
orporatingacompliancemargin
mment:Manycommenters
instance,somecommentersstatedthat recomme
o
r
ma
r
ginoferrorincaseofequipment
ndedthattheEPAadda
theEPAdidnotprovideadequate
ma
l
f
unc
tionsorfailures.Asthe
iancemargininitsachievability comment
supportfortheproposedlimit.Other caossmpl
ersnoted,theAgencyhas
umptions.Thesecommenters
commentersstatedthatthefactthatthe conv
pr
e
v
i
o
us
l
yrecognizedthatsome
eyedthatmostEGUstypically
vastmajorityofunitsareachieving
o
pe
r
a
t
o
r
s
emissionlevel20to
ratewellbelow thelimittoallow for 50percenttabregleotwanthe
emissionratesbelow thecurrentlimit oape
mit.However,no
ompliancemarginintheeventofan commentersprovidedlida
doesnotconstitute‘‘developmentsin eqcui
tatosuggest
pmentmalfunctionorfailure,
practices,processes,andcontrol
t
ha
t
ESPs
o
r
FF
a
r
e
una
b
l
etoachievea
whichtheyencouragedtheEPAto
technologies.’’
l
o
we
r
f
PM
l
i
mi
t
.
Fur
t
he
r
mo
e,the
iderwhensettingnew limits.These Agencydoesnotprescribesrpe
Response:TheEPAdisagreesthatthe ccoons
cifically
ntersclaimedthatwitha
Agencyhasnotadequatelysupported promme
ho
w
a
n
EGU
c
o
nt
r
o
l
s
i
t
s
e
mi
s
s
or
sedfPM limitof0.010lb/MMBtu, how theunitoperates.Thechoiiocns
theproposedfPM limit.Asdescribedin anapo
e
t
o
ppropriatedesignmarginof20
theproposalpreamble,theAgency
targetalower-levelemissionratefora
percentnecessitatesthatcontrol
conductedareview ofthe2020
iancemarginisthesoledecision
chnologiesmustbeabletoachievea ocofmpl
TechnologyReview pursuanttoCAA tleimi
o
wne
operators.Forfacilities
008lb/MMBtuorlowerin withmorrseatnd
section112(d)(6),whichfocusedon practtiocfe0..The
ha
n
oneEGUinthesame
yalsoexpressedconcerns subcategory,owne
identifyingandevaluating
operatorsmay
ttheEPAdidnottakedesignmargin findemissionsaverrsagoirng
developmentsinpractices,processes, tiha
(40CFR
nt
o
c
o
ns
i
de
r
a
t
i
o
n
i
n
t
he
c
o
s
t
a
na
l
y
s
i
s
.
andcontroltechnologiesforthe
6
3
.
1
0
0
0
9
)
,
c
o
upl
e
d
wi
t
h
o
withouta
Theystatedthatbynotincludingthe compliancemargin,couldrhe
emissionsourcesinthesourcecategory ne
lpthe
e
d
f
o
r
a
de
s
i
g
n
ma
r
g
i
n,
whi
c
h
t
he
thatoccurredsincepromulgationofthe EPAhasacknowledgedtheneedforin facilityattainandmaintainemission
2012MATSFinalRule.Basedonthat tleasttwooftheAgency’spublications limitsasaneffective,low-cost
review,theEPAfoundthatamajorityof a(NESHAP
approach.Additionally,nocommenters
lysisofControl
sourceswerenotonlyreportingfPM TechnologAna
provideddatatoindicatethatevery
y
Ne
e
ds
f
o
r
Re
v
i
s
e
d
Pr
o
po
s
e
d
emissionssignificantlybelow the
o
wneroroperatoraimstocomplywith
EmissionStandardsforNewSource the
currentemissionlimit,butalsothatthe Co
fPM limitwiththesamecompliance
a
l
f
i
r
e
d
EGUs
,
Do
c
ume
nt
I
D
No
.
fleetachievedlowerfPM ratesatlower EPA–HQ–OAR–2009–0234–20223and margin.Becausesomeoperatorsmight
coststhantheEPAestimatedwhenit
argercompliancemarginthan
CEMSCapabilitiesSummaryfor aoitmhefros,riatlwo
promulgatedthe2012MATSFinalRule. PM
dbedifficulttoselecta
PerformanceSpecification11,NSPS, particularasul
TheEPAexplainsthesefindingsin
sumptionaboutcompliance
a
nd
MACT
Rul
e
s
,
Do
c
ume
nt
I
D
No
.
moredetailinsectionIV.D.1.ofthis EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794–5828),the marginforthecostanalysis.Every
preambleandelsewhereintherecord. EPAunderpredictedthenumberof operatorplansforcompliance
Further,theEPAfindsthatthereare unitsthatwouldrequireretrofits.These differentlyandtheEPAcannotknow
technologicaldevelopmentsand
veryoperator’splansforacompliance
commentersstatedthatthecombination ema
improvementsinPM control
in.EveniftheEPAweretoassume
erylow fPM limitandhavingto a20rgpe
technology,whichalsocontrolsnon-Hg oacfcaovunt
rcentcompliancemargininits
f
o
r
t
he
me
a
s
ur
e
me
nt
HAPmetals,sincethe2012MATSFinal uncertaintyandcorrelation
evaluationofPM controls,theresultsof
Rulethatinformedthe2023Proposal methodologyofPM CEMSwouldlikely theanalysiswouldnotchangetheEPA’s
andthisaction,asdiscussedfurtherin cessitatean‘‘operationaltargetlimit’’ decisiontoadoptalowerfPM limit.
sectionIV.D.1.below.Forexample, one
Specifically,a20percentcompliance
f50percentoftheapplicablelimit. ma
industryhasimplemented‘‘best
rginassumptiontoafPM limitof
So
me
c
o
mme
nt
e
r
s
r
e
f
e
r
e
nc
e
d
t
he
practices’’formonitoringESPoperation NationalRuralElectricCooperative 0.010lb/MMBtuwouldincreasethe
morecarefully,andmoredurable
numberofaffectedEGUsfrom 33to53
sociation(NRECA)technical
materialshavebeenadoptedforFFs eAs
(14.1to23.9GW affectedcapacity)and
v
a
l
ua
t
i
o
n
f
o
r
t
he
2
0
2
3
Pr
o
po
s
a
l
t
i
t
l
e
d
sincethe2012MATSFinalRule.The
theannualcompliancecostsfrom
chnicalCommentsonNational
EPAalsofindsthatthesearecognizable Te
$87.2M to$147.7M.Thenumberof
Emi
s
s
i
o
ns
St
a
nda
r
d
f
o
r
Ha
z
a
r
do
us
Ai
r
developmentsforpurposesofCAA
EGUsthatdemonstratedanabilityto
Po
l
l
ut
a
nt
s
:
Co
a
l
a
nd
Oi
l
f
i
r
e
d
El
e
c
t
r
i
c
section112(d)(6).Asothercommenters UtilitySteam GeneratingUnitsReview meetthelowerfPM limit,butdonotdo
noted,inNationalAssociationfor
soonaverageandthereforewould
ofResidualRiskandTechnology.13
SurfaceFinishingv.EPA,795F.3d1,11 The
requireO&M,wouldincreasefrom 17to
y
s
a
i
d
t
ha
t
,
e
v
e
n
us
i
ng
t
he
EPA’
s
(D.C.Cir.2015),theD.C.Circuitfound unrealistic‘‘baselinefPM rates’’andthe 27(includingthecompliancemargin).
thattheEPA‘‘permissiblyidentified lowestpossiblecompliancemarginof Similarly,thenumberofESPupgrades
andtookintoaccountcognizable
(previously11)andbagupgrades
20percent,theNRECAtechnical
developments’’basedontheEPA’s
(previously3)wouldalsoincrease(to20
e
v
a
l
ua
t
i
o
n
e
s
t
i
ma
t
e
d
t
ha
t
3
7
uni
t
s
—
interpretationoftheterm as‘‘notonly almosttwiceasmanyastheEPA’s
and4,respectively).Therewouldbeno
whollynew methods,butalso
hangeinthenumberofnew FF
estimate—wouldberequiredtotake icns
technologicalimprovements.’’
talls.Therefore,cost-effectiveness
Similarly,heretheEPAidentifieda Sta13nda
TechnicalCommentsonNationalEmission valuesforfPM andindividualandtotal
zardousAirPollutants:Coal-and
cleartrendincontrolefficiency,costs, Oil-firedrdsElfeocrtrHa
n-HgHAPmetalswouldonly
icUtilitySteam GeneratingUnits no
andtechnologicalimprovements,which ReviewofResidua
increaseslightly.Moreover,the30l
Ri
s
k
a
nd
Te
c
hno
l
o
g
y
.
theEPAisaccountingforinthisaction. Cichanowicz,etal.June19,2023.AttachmentAto boileroperatingdayaveragingperiod
cumentIDNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794–5994. usingPM CEMSforcompliance
Further,asdiscussedelsewhereinthis Do
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00015 Fmt4715a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38522
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
demonstrationprovidesflexibilityfor alreadydemonstratedtheabilitytomeet reduced,soitshouldnotbeconsidered
ownersandoperatorstoaccountfor thelimit,butdonotdosoonaverage. either.
mment:Somecommentersstated Thecommentersprovidedthe
equipmentmalfunctions,operational Co
tcosteffectivenessisanimportant followingexamplesofprevious
variability,andotherissues.Lastly,as tcha
onsiderationintechnologyreviews rulemakingswhereEPAfoundcontrols
describedinthe2023Proposal,and
tonotbecost-effective:
rCAAsection112(d)(6)and
updatedhere,thevastmajorityofcoal- unde
RefinerySector
wledgedthattheEPAundertook •InthePetroleum
firedEGUsarereportingfPM emissions accokstno
ctivenessanalysesforthethree technologyreview,15theEPAdeclined
wellbelow therevisedfPM limit.For fPM-setfafenda
rdsonwhichtheAgency torevisethefPM emissionlimitfor
instance,themedianfPM rateofthe296 htcomme
existingfluidcatalyticcrackingunits
nt.However,the
coal-firedEGUsassessedinthe202414 csooug
afterfindingthatitwouldcost$10
ntersstated,theNRECA
TechnicalMemois0.004lb/MMBtu, tecmme
hnicalevaluationfoundmeaningful millionpertonoftotalnon-HgHAP
or60percentbelow therevisedfPM
metalsreduced(inthatcase,equivalent
rrorsintheEPA’scostanalysis,
limitof0.010lb/MMBtu.Themedian ienc
ludingunreasonablylow capitalcost to$23,000pertonoffPM reduced),
fPM rateofaquarterofthebest
snotcost-effective.
tesforESPrebuildsandafailure whichnwa
performingsources(N=74)is0.002lb/ etostcima
theIronOre1Pr
ocessing
onsiderthevariabilityoffPM dueto tec•I
MMBtu,about80percentbelow the chang
logyreview,6theEPAdeclined
sinoperationorfacilitydesign, torhno
revisedfPM limitof0.010lb/MMBtu. bynoteut
ethenon-HgHAPmetalslimit
acompliancemargin. afteervfiisndi
Therefore,forthesereasons,theEPA Theyasseilritzeidngtha
thatinstallingwet
ttheseerrorsresulted scrubbersng
disagreeswithcommentersthata
wo
uldcost$16millionper
i
n
s
i
z
e
a
b
l
e
c
o
s
t
e
f
f
e
c
t
i
v
e
ne
s
s
compliancemarginneedstobe
onofnon-HgHAPmetalsreduced,
underestimatesthaterodedtheEPA’s twhi
consideredinthecostanalysis.
chwasnotcost-effective.
ldeterminationthattheproposed •I
TheupdatedPM analysis,detailedin overalilmi
ntheIntegratedIronandSteel
tiscost-effective.These
thememorandum 2024Updatetothe fcPM
Ma
nuf
a1c7turingFacilitiestechnology
o
mme
nt
e
r
s
a
l
s
o
a
s
s
e
r
t
e
d
t
ha
t
t
he
EPA’
s
2023ProposedTechnologyReviewfor rationalewasarbitraryonitsface
r
e
v
i
e
w,
theEPAdeclinedtorevisethe
theCoal-andOil-FiredEGUSource becauseitreversed,without
no
nHg
HAP
metalslimitafterfinding
Category(‘‘2024TechnicalMemo’’) explanation,theEPA’sprior
t
ha
t
upg
r
a
di
ng
allfume/flame
availableinthedocket,estimatesthat acknowledgementsthatacosts
uppr
e
s
s
a
nt
s
a
t
nacesto
thenumberofEGUsthatwillneedto effectivenessanalysisshouldaccount baghouseswoulbdlacsotstfur
$
7
millionperton
improvetheirfPM emissionrateto
o
f
no
nHg
HAP
me
t
a
l
s
r
e
duc
ed,which
f
o
r
t
he
c
o
s
t
e
f
f
e
c
t
i
v
e
ne
s
s
o
f
c
o
nt
r
o
l
s
a
t
achievea0.010lb/MMBtulimithas eachaffectedfacilityandnotsimplyon wasnotcost-effective.TheAg
y
increasedfrom the20EGUsassumedin anaggregatenationwidebasis.They madeasimilarfindingforapreonc
po
d
the2023Proposalto33EGUs,whichis statedthatfacility-specificcostsshould limitthatwouldhavecost$14,000sepe
r
moreconsistentwiththeNRECA
t
o
n
o
f
v
o
l
a
t
i
l
e
HAP
r
e
duc
e
d.
f
a
c
t
o
r
i
nt
o
t
he
EPA’
s
a
s
s
e
s
s
me
nt
o
f
wha
t
technicalevaluationestimateof37
•InthePortlandCement
is‘‘necessary’’pursuanttothe
EGUs.Thisincreaseisaresultof
Ma
nufact1ur
ingbeyond-the-floor
pr
o
v
i
s
i
o
ns
o
f
CAA
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
1
1
2
(
d)
(
6
)
a
nd
updatedmethodologythatutilizesboth CAAsection112(f)(2).
8t
a
na
l
y
s
i
s
,
heEPAdeclinedtoimpose
thelowestachievedfPM rate(i.e.,the Somecommentersassertedthat,even amorestring
entnon-HgHAPmetals
lowestquarter’s99thpercentile)andthe usingtheEPA’scost-effectiveness
l
i
mi
t
b
e
c
a
us
e
tresultedin
averagefPM rateacrossallquarterly figures,theproposed0.010lb/MMBtu ‘‘significantlyihi
ghercosteffectiveness
datawhenassessingPM upgradeand limitisnotcost-effective.These
f
o
r
PM
t
ha
n
EPA
hasacceptedinother
costsassumptionsfortheevaluated commentersstatedthattheEPA’s
NESHAP.
’
’
The
EPA
tedinthat
limits.TheAgencydisagreeswiththe proposaltorevisethefPM standardto rulemakingthatithadnopr
eviously
commenters,however,thatthe37EGUs 0.010lb/MMBtubasedonacost‘
‘
r
e
j
e
c
t
[
e
d]
$
4
8
,
5
0
1
pe
r
t
o
nofPM asnot
intheNRECAtechnicalevaluation
c
o
s
t
e
f
f
e
c
t
i
v
e
f
o
r
PM,
’
’
a
nd
notedprior
e
f
f
e
c
t
i
v
e
ne
s
s
e
s
t
i
ma
t
e
o
f
up
t
o
$
1
4
.
7
wouldrequire‘‘substantialactionto millionpertonoftotalnon-HgHAP EPAstatementsinasubseque
complywiththeproposedstandard.’’In metalsremoved(equivalentto$44,900 rulemakingprovidingthat$26nt
8,000per
theAgency’srevisedanalysis,only13 pertonoffPM removed)isinconsistent tonofHAPremovedwasahighe
rcostEGUswouldrequirecapitalinvestments withtheEPA’sprioractionsbecausethe effectivenessestimatethantheEPA
had
tomeetafPM limitof0.010lb/MMBtu. cost-effectivenessestimateis
a
c
c
e
pt
e
d
i
n
o
t
he
r
NESHAP
r
ul
e
ma
k
i
ngs.
Ofthese,onlytwoEGUsatonefacility substantiallyhigherthanestimatesthe Incontrast,othercommentersfocus
(Colstrip)currentlywithoutthemost Agencyhaspreviouslyfoundtobenot ontheEPA’sestimatedcost-effectiveed
effectivePM controlsareprojectedto cost-effective.Theyfurthersaidthat,in estimatesforfPM (whichisasurrogate
requireinstallationofaFF,thecostliest thepast,theEPAhasdecidedagainst fornon-HgHAPmetals)andarguedthat
PM controlupgradeoption,tomeet
fPM standardsbasedoncost- 15Petroleum RefinerySectorRiskandTechnology
0.010lb/MMBtu.Theremainingnine reeffveicstiing
v
e
ne
tessubstantially ReviewandNewSourcePerformanceStandards,80
EGUsprojectedbytheEPAtorequire lowerthanstsheesctoima
s
t
e
eness
FR75178,75201(December1,2015).
capitalinvestmentsareestimatedto estimateshere.Theyfsfaeicdtitvha
t
t
he
EPA
NationalEmissionStandardsforHazardous
requirevariouslevelsofESPupgrades. shouldfollow theseprecedentsand Ai1r6Po
ants:TaconiteIronOreProcessing
TheEPAestimatesthatmorethanhalf acknowledgethat$12.2to$14.7million Residuallut
lRiskandTechnologyReview,85FR
6,45483(July28,2020).
(20EGUs)wouldbeabletocomply
rtonofnon-HgHAPmetalsreduced 451477Na
tionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous
withoutanycapitalinvestmentsand ipe
s
no
t
c
o
s
t
e
f
f
e
c
t
i
v
e
.
The
y
a
r
g
ue
d
t
ha
t
AirPollutants:IntegratedIronandSteel
wouldinsteadrequireimprovementsto theAgencyshouldnotfinalizethe
nufacturingFacilitiesResidualRiskand
theirexistingFForESPastheyhave proposedstandardof0.010lb/MMBtu Ma
TechnologyReview,85FR42074,42088(July13,
2020).
forthatreason.Further,these
14Fort
herevisedfPM analysis,theEPAusestwo commentersarguedthatthealternative, 18NationalEmissionStandardsforHazardous
methodstoassesstheperformanceofthefleet:
AirPollutantsforthePortlandCement
morestringentlimitof0.006lb/MMBtu Ma
averageandthe99thpercentileofthelowest
nufacturingIndustryandStandardsof
isevenlesscost-effectiveat$25.6
quarterofdata.Valuesreportedhereusethe
PerformanceforPortlandCementPlants,78FR
averagefPM rateforeachEGU.
millionpertonofnon-HgHAPmetals 10006,10021(February12,2013).
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00016 Fmt4716a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38523
Labadie,werenotthecostsassociated
thoseestimatesweresubstantiallylower pollutionatlow costtothepower
thanestimatesthattheEPAhas
sector.Theyconcludedthatallthese withanESPrebuild,butinsteadwere
consideredtobecost-effectiveinother metricsandapproachestoconsidering
costsassociatedwiththefull
technologyreviews.Therefore,these costsshow thatafPM limitof0.006lb/ trhe
e
pl
mentofanESP.Thecommenter
commentersconcludedthattheEPA MMBtuwouldrequirecost-effective stateadcetha
renretrofittedthe
shouldstrengthenthelimittoatleast reductionsandcanbeachievedata entireESPt,t‘r‘aAme
i
ns
o
ntwounitsin2014/
0.010lb/MMBtu.Thesecommenters reasonablecostthatwouldnot
2
0
1
5
.
On
e
a
c
h
o
f
t
he
seunitstwoofthe
alsopointedtoa2023reportb1y9
jeopardizethepowersector’sfunction. threeoriginalexisting
hadtobe
Additionally,somecommenterscited abandonedandoneofESPs
AndoverTechnologyPartners that
t
he
e
x
istingESPs
foundthatthecosttocomplywithan SierraClubv.Costle,657F.2d298,330 wasretrofittedwithnew powe
rsupplies
emissionlimitof0.006lb/MMBtuona (D.C.Cir.1981),andsaidthecase
fluegasflow modifications.Anew
fleetwidebasiswassignificantlyless supportstheEPA’sdiscretiontoweigh astnd
ate-of-the-artESPwasaddedtoeach
thanthecostsestimatedbytheEPA. cost,energy,andenvironmental
unittosupplementtheretrofitted
AndoverTechnologyPartnersattributed impacts,recognizingtheAgency’s
ESPs.’’AnESPreplacementisdifferent
thisdifference‘‘totheassumptionsEPA authoritytotakethesefactorsinto
rebuild,andthereforethe
maderegardingthepotentialemission account‘‘inthebroadestsenseatthe fcroosmtsaonfaESP
nESPreplacementdonot
reductionsfrom ESPupgrades,which nationalandregionallevelsandover inform the
costsofanESPrebuild.The
timeasopposedtosimplyattheplant
resultinamuchhigherestimateof
baghouseretrofitsinEPA’sanalysisfor levelintheimmediatepresent.’’These ESPrebuildcostprovidedfortheother
anemissionrateof0.006lb/MMBtu.’’ commenterssaidthattheEPAhasthe facility,Petersburg,waslessthanthe
EPA’sfinalassumptionregardingthe
Thesecommentersstatedthatmeeting authoritytorequirecoststhatare
theloweremissionlimitof0.006lb/ reasonablefortheindustryevenifthey typicalcostofanESPrebuildona
MMBtuistechnologicallyfeasibleusing arenotreasonableforeveryfacility. capacity-weightedaveragebasis.Neither
currentlyavailablecontrols,andthey Thesecommentersacknowledgedthat oftheseexamplesprovidedbythe
urgedtheEPAtoadoptthislimit.They theEPAhasdiscretiontoconsidercost commenterdemonstratethattheEPA
statedthatalthoughcosteffectivenessis effectivenessunderCAAsection
restimatedcosts.Forthesereasons,
lessrelevantintheCAAsection112 112(d)(2),citingNRDCv.EPA,749F.3d unde
t
he
EPA
sagreeswiththese
contextthanforotherCAAprovisions, 1055,1060–61(D.C.Cir.2014),but commentdi
e
r
s.Additionally,theEPA
arguedthatthedollar-per-toncostthe$103,000pertonoffPM and
di
s
a
g
r
e
e
s
wi
ththesecommentersthat
$209,000pertonoffilterablefinePM2.5 effectivenessmetricislessrelevant theAgencymus
taddacompliance
estimatesthattheEPAcalculatedforthe underCAAsection112thanunder
ma
r
g
i
n
i
n
i
t
s
c
o
s
tassumptions.As
0.006lb/MMBtulimitwerereasonable otherCAAprovisionsbecausethe
describedabove,theAgencydoesnot
Agencyisnotchargedwithequitably pr
andcomparabletopastpracticein
escribespecificallyhow anEGUmust
technologyreviewsunderCAAsection distributingthecostsofemission
becontrolledorhow itmustbe
112(d)(6).TheynotedthattheEPAhas reductionsthroughauniform
rated,andthechoiceof
previouslyfoundacontrolmeasurethat compliancestrategy,astheEPAhas oope
vercomplianceisatthesolediscretion
resultedinaninflation-adjustedcostof doneinitstransportrules.The
$185,000pertonofPM2.5reducedtobe commentersconcludedthattheAgency oftheownersandoperators.
shouldrequiremaximum reductionsof
cost-effectivefortheferroall2o0ys
nerally,theEPAagreeswith
HAPemissionsfrom eachregulated coGe
productionsourcecategory and
mme
ersthatcosteffectiveness,i.e.,
sourcecategoryandhasnoauthorityto thecostnt
proposedalimitforsecondarylead
s
pe
runitofemissions
smeltingsourcesthatcostaninflation- balancecosteffectivenessacross
r
e
duc
t
i
o
n,
i
s
ametricthattheEPA
industries.
adjusted2$1114,000pertonoffPM
c
o
ns
i
s
t
e
nt
l
y
c
iders,oftenalongside
sponse:Inthisaction,theEPAis othercostmetorins
reduced. Theyarguedthat,usingthe actRe
c
s
,inCAAsection112
ingunderitsauthorityinCAA
AndoverTechnologyPartnerscost
r
ul
e
ma
k
i
ng
s
whe
r
eitcanconsidercosts,
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
1
1
2
(
d)
(
6
)
t
o
‘
‘
r
e
v
i
e
w,
a
nd
r
e
v
i
s
e
estimates,the0.006lb/MMBtulimithas asnecessary(takingintoaccount
e
.
g
.
,
b
e
y
o
ndt
he
f
l
ooranalysesand
evenbettercost-effectivenessestimates developmentsinpractices,processes, technologyreviews
agreeswith
atabout$72,000pertonoffPM reduced andcontroltechnologies),emission commenterswhore,caond
g
ni
ethatthe
and$146,000pertonoffilterablePM2.5 standards’’promulgatedunderCAA Agencyhasdiscretioninzho
w it
reduced.Thesecommentersnotedthat section112.AstheEPAexplainedin considersstatutoryfactorsunde
rCAA
theEPAalsocalculatedcost
section112(d)(6),includingcosts.See
the2023Proposal,thistechnology
effectivenessbasedonallowable
e.g.,AssociationofBatteryRecyclers,
review isseparateanddistinctfrom
emissions(i.e.,assumingemission
otherstandard-settingprovisionsunder Inc.v.EPA,716F.3d667,673–74(D.C.
reductionsachievedifallevaluated CAA
section112,suchasestablishing Cir.2013)(allowingthattheEPAmay
EGUsemitatthemaximum allowable
floors,conductingthebeyond- considercostsinconductingtechnology
amountoffPM,or0.030lb/MMBtu)at MACT
-flooranalysis,andreviewing
reviewsunderCAAsection112(d)(6));
$1,610,000perton,showingthatalimit trhe
esidualrisk.
of0.006lb/MMBtuallowsfarless
s
ealsoNat’lAss’nforSurface
RegardingthecommentsthattheEPA Feini
ngv.EPA,795F.3d1,11(D.C.
19AssessmentofPot
underestimatedcoststoanextentthat Cir.s2hi
entialRevisionstothe
0
1
EPAacknowledgesthat
MercuryandAirToxicsStandards.Andover
underminestheEPA’soverallcost- thecost-5e)f.fThe
ectivenessvaluesforthese
TechnologyPartners.June15,2023.DocketIDNo. effectivenessassumptions,theEPA
standardsarehigherthancostEPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794.Alsoavailableat
https://www.andovertechnology.com/wp-content/ disagreesthattheAgency
e
ffectivenessvaluesthattheEPA
unde
r
e
s
t
i
ma
t
e
d
t
he
t
y
pi
c
a
l
c
o
s
t
s
o
f
ESP
upl
o
a
ds
/
2
0
2
3
/
0
6
/
C_
2
3
_
CAEL
P_
F
i
na
l
.
.
c
oncludedwerenotcost-effectiveand
20Nat
ionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous rebuilds.Thecommentersprovidedcost we
ighedagainstimplementingmore
AirPollutants:FerroalloysProduction,80FR37381 examplesfrom onlytwofacilitiesto
(June30,2015).
s
t
r
i
ngentstandardsforsomepriorrules.
s
uppo
r
t
t
he
i
r
a
s
s
e
r
t
i
o
ns
r
e
g
a
r
di
ng
t
he
21Nat
ionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous costsofESPrebuilds.Thecosts
The
EPAdisagrees,however,thatthere
AirPollutants:SecondaryLeadSmelting,76FR
29032(May19,2011).
providedforoneofthosefacilities, isanyparticularthresholdthatrenders
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00017 Fmt4717a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38524
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
Therearealsouniqueattributesofthe
arulecost-effectiveornot.22TheEPA’s twofacilitiestodecidewhetherto
powersectorthattheEPAfindssupport
priorfindingsaboutcosteffectivenessin deployastanda2r4dacrossthemuch
widerindustry. Hereincontrast,the thefinalizationofrevisedstandardsfor
otherruleswerespecifictothose
rulemakingsandtheindustriesatissue EPAisbasingupdatestofPM standards fPM andnon-HgHAPmetalsdespitethe
inthoserules.Ascommentershave forcoal-firedEGUsondevelopments relativelyhighcost-effectivenessvalues
acrossthemajorityoftheindustryand ofthisrulemakingascomparedtoother
pointedout,inconsideringcost
theperformanceofthefleetasawhole, CAAsection112rulemakings.Asthe
effectiveness,theEPAwilloften
EPAhasdemonstratedthroughoutthis
considerwhatestimatesithasdeemed whichhasdemonstratedthe
record,therearehundredsofEGUs
cost-effectiveinpriorrulemakings. achievabilityofamorestringent
regulatedunderMATSwithwellHowever,theEPAroutinelyviewscost standard.Additionally,thereare
rentdifferencesbetweenthepower performingcontrolequipmentthatare
effectivenessinlightofotherfactors, inhe
alreadyreportingemissionratesbelow
ctorandotherindustriesthat
suchasotherrelevantcostsmetrics sseimi
rlydistinguishprioractionsfrom therevisedstandards,whereasonlya
(e.g.,totalcosts,annualcosts,andcosts thisrlaul
king.Forexample,because handfuloffacilitieswithlargely
comparedtorevenues),impactstothe ofthesiezma
eofthepowersector(314coal- outdatedorunderperformingcontrols
regulatedindustry,andindustryareemittingsignificantlymorethan
EGUsat157facilities),and
specificdynamicstodeterminewhether fierecdaus
ethissourcecategoryisoneof theirpeers.Thatmeansthatthe
thereare‘‘developmentsinpractices, bthe
ststationarysourceemittersof communitieslocatednearthesehandful
processes,andcontroltechnologies’’ Hg,laarrsgeeni
c,andHClandisoneofthe offacilitiesmayexperienceexposureto
thatwarrantupdatestoemissions
higherlevelsoftoxicmetalemissions
largestregulatedstatio2na
rysource
standardspursuanttoCAAsection
ttersoftotalHAP,5even
thancommunitieslocatednearsimilarly
112(d)(6).Somecommenters,pointing ecmi
ideringthatthisruleaffectsonlya sizedwell-controlledplants.Thisis
topriorCAAsection112rulemakings froans
ctionofthesector,theestimatedHAP whattherevisedstandardsseekto
wheretheEPAchosenottoadoptmore reduc
nsinthisfinalrule(8.3tpy)are remedy,andasdiscussedthroughout
stringentcontrols,mischaracterizedcost highertitoha
nthoseintheprior
thisrecord,thisgoalisconsistentwith
effectivenessasthesolecriterionin rulemaking
tedbythecommenters theEPA’sauthorityunderCAAsection
thosedecisions.Thesecommenters (asaretheesstciima
reductions 112(d)(6)andthepurposeofCAA
omittedanydiscussionofotherrelevant 2,537tpy)usedatsedasPM
urrogatefornon- section112moregenerally.
factorsfrom thoserulemakingsthat,in (Hg
metals).Incontrast,inthe2020 U.S.EGUsareamajorsourceofHAP
additiontocosteffectiveness,counseled InteHAP
ratedIronandSteelManufacturing metalsemissionsincludingarsenic,
theEPAagainstadoptingmorestringent rulegma
,thesourcecategorycovered beryllium,cadmium,chromium,cobalt,
standards.Forexample,inthe2014 includekding
y11facilities,andthe
lead,nickel,manganese,andselenium.
Ferroalloysrulemakingthatcommenters estimatedornl
ductionstheEPA
SomeHAPmetalsemittedbyU.S.EGUs
citedto,theEPArejectedapotential consideredewo
remo
v
e
d
3
t
py
areknowntobepersistentand
controloptionduetoquestionsabout ofHAPand120ultdpyhaovfePM.
26Li
kewise, bioaccumulativeandothershavethe
technicalfeasibilityandsignificant inthe2013PortlandCement
tentialtocausecancer.Exposureto
economicimpactstheoptionwould rulemaking,theEPAdeterminednotto po
theseHAPmetals,dependingon
createfortheindustry,including
suemorestringentcontrolsforthe exposuredurationandlevelsof
potentialfacilityclosuresthatwould pur
ctorafterfindingthestandardwould exposures,isassociatedwithavariety
impactsigni2f3icantportionsofindustry osenl
yresultin138tpyofnationwidePM ofadversehealtheffects.Theseadverse
production. Incontrasthere,the
tionsandthattherewasahi
gh healtheffectsmayincludechronic
controlsatissuearetechnicallyfeasible rceoduc
2
7
s
t
f
o
r
s
uc
h
mo
de
s
t
r
e
duc
t
i
o
ns
.
re, healthdisorders(e.g.,irritationofthe
(theyareusedatfacilitiesthroughout theEPAestimatessignificantlygreaHe
ter lung,skin,andmucusmembranes;
thecountry)andwillnothave
HAPemissionreductions,andfPM
decreasedpulmonaryfunction,
significanteffectsontheindustry.
emissionreductionsthatareordersof pneumonia,orlungdamage;
Indeed,theEPAdoesnotprojectthat ma
nitudegr2e8aterthanbothprior
detrimentaleffectsonthecentral
thefinalrevisionstoMATSwillresult rulegma
kings.
nervoussystem;damagetothekidneys;
inincrementalchangesinoperational
andalimentaryeffectssuchasnausea
coal-firedcapacity.
finerySectorRiskandTechnology andvomiting).Theemissions
Similarly,intheotherrulemakings Re2v4iePewtraondleumNewReSo
ePerformanceStandards,80 reductionsprojectedunderthisfinal
thesecommenterspointedto,wherethe FR75178,75201(Deurcecmb
er1,2015).
ulefrom theuseofPM controlsare
52020Nat
EPAfoundsimilarcost-effectiveness htt2ps
ionalEmissionsInventory(NEI)Data; r
//www.epa.gov/air-emissions-inventories/ expectedtoreduceexposureof
valuestothosethattheEPAidentified 2020-:na
-emissions-inventory-nei-data.
individualsresidingnearthesefacilities
fortherevisedfPM standardhere,there 26NatitoionanallEmi
andardsforHazardous tonon-HgHAPmetals,including
aredistinctaspectsofthoserulemakings AirPollutants:IntsesgiroanteSt
IronandSteel
carcinogenicHAP.
andindustriesthatdistinguishthose ManufacturingFacilitiesdRe
sidualRiskand
EGUsprojectedtobeimpactedbythe
chnologyReview,85FR42074,42088(July13, rev
prioractionsfrom thisrulemaking.In Te
isedfPM standardsrepresentasmall
2020).
the2015Petroleum Refineries
27Nat
f
r
a
c
tionofthetotalnumberofthecoali
o
na
l
Emi
s
s
i
o
n
St
a
nda
r
ds
f
o
r
Ha
z
a
r
do
us
rulemaking,theEPAconsideredthecost AirPollutantsforthePortlandCement
f
i
r
e
d
EGUs(11percentforthe0.010lb/
effectivenessofdevelopmentsatonly Ma
nufacturingIndustryandStandardsof
MMBt
ufPM limit).Inaddition,many
PerformanceforPortlandCementPlants,78FR
regulatedfacilitiesareelectingtoretire
22Seee.
g.,NationalEmissionsStandardsfor
10006,10020–10021(February12,2013).
HazardousAirPollutants:FerroalloysProduction,
80FR37366,37381(June30,2015)(‘‘[I]tis
importanttonotethatthereisnobrightlinefor
determiningacceptablecosteffectivenessforHAP
metals.Eachrulemakingisdifferentandvarious
factorsmustbeconsidered.’’).
23Nat
ionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous
AirPollutants:FerroalloysProduction,79FR
60238,60273(October6,2014).
28I
naddition,whilecommentersarecorrectthat
theEPAdeterminednottoadoptmorestringent basedontheinstallationofwetESPsinaddition
controlsundertheironoreprocessingtechnology towetscrubbers,basedontheEPA’sdetermination
thatsuchimprovementswerenotnecessaryto
review,theaspectsoftherulemakingthatthe
commenterscitetoconcernedwhetheradditional provideanamplemarginofsafetytoprotectpublic
controlswerenecessarytoprovideanamplemargin health.SeeNationalEmissionStandardsfor
HazardousAirPollutants:TaconiteIronOre
ofsafetyunderaresidualriskreview.Inthat
instance,theEPAdeterminednottoimplement ProcessingResidualRiskandTechnologyReview,
84FR45476,45483(July28,2020).
morestringentstandardsundertheriskreview
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00018 Fmt4718a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38525
duetofactorsindependentoftheEPA’s underCAAsection112(d)(6),suchas 112(d)(6).’’30WhiletheEPAhas
regulations,andtheEPAtypicallyhas costs.TheyconcludedthatCAAsection consideredrisksasafactorin3s1ome
moreinformationonplantretirements 112(d)(6)requirestheEPAto
previoustechnologyreviews, that
doesnotcompeltheAgencytodosoin
forthissectorthanothersectors
promulgatethemaximum HAP
regulatedunderCAAsection112.Both reductionspossiblewhereachievableat thisrulemaking.Indeed,inother
ofthesefactorscontributetorelatively reasonablecostandisseparatefrom the instances,theEPAhasadoptedthe
highercost-effectivenessestimatesin EPA’sresidualriskanalysis.
samestandardsunderbothCAA
thisrulemakingascomparedtoother Response:TheEPAhasan
sections112(f)(2)and112(d)(6)basedon
sectorswheretheEPAisnotableto independentstatutoryauthorityand independentrationaleswherenecessary
accountforfacilityretirementsand
anamplemarginofsafety
toconductthetechnology taondprboevciade
factorinshorteramortizationperiods orebvliigeawtisoenpa
useitistechnicallyappropriate
r
a
t
e
f
r
o
m
t
he
EPA’
s
forthepriceofcontrols.
andnecessarytodoso,emphasizingthe
horitytoconductaresidualrisk
Whilesomecommentersstatedthat raeut
i
pendentauthorit3y2ofthetwo
iew,andtheAgencyagreeswith snde
meetinganevenloweremissionlimitof covmme
t
a
t
ut
oryprovisions.
ntersthatrecognizedthatthe
The
languageandstructureofCAA
0.006lb/MMBtuistechnologically
EPAisnotrequiredtoaccountfor
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
2,alongwithitslegislative
feasibleusingcurrentlyavailable
ormationobtainedduringaresidual history,1f1ur
therunderscoresthe
controls,theAgencydeclinestofinalize rinf
iskreview inconductingatechnology independent
tureofthesetwo
thislimitprimarilyduetothe
w.TheEPA’sfindingthatthereis provisions.33na
technologicallimitationsofPM CEMSat raenvaiempl
Whi
EPAisonly
rginofsafetyunderthe requiredtoundertlaektehe
thisloweremissionlimit(asdiscussed residualerima
t
he
skreview innowayinterferes once(8yearsafterpromulrgiastkiornevoifewthe
inmoredetailinsectionsIV.C.2.and withtheEPA’
igationtorequire originalMACTstandards),itisrequired
IV.D.2.below).Additionally,theEPA morestringentssotbalnda
rdsunderthe
consideredthehighercostsassociated technologyreview whe
toundertakethetechnologyreview
redevelopments mul
withamorestringentstandardas
tipletimes(atleastevery8years
warrantsuchstandards.TheD.C.
comparedtothefinalstandard
a
f
t
e
r
promulgationoftheoriginalMACT
CircuithasrecognizedtheCAAsection standa
presentedinsectionIV.D.1.
rd).ThatCongresschargedthe
Finally,asmentionedintheResponse 112(d)(6)technologyreview and
EPA
t
o
ensureanamplemarginofsafety
toCommentsdocument,theEPAfinds 112(f)(2)residualreview are‘‘distinct, throughtheriskreview,yetstill
thatuseofPM CEMS,whichprovide parallelanalyses’’thattheEPA
requiredthetechnologyreview tobe
continuousfeedbackwithrespectto undertakes‘‘[s]eparately.’’Nat’lAss’n conductedonaperiodicbasis,
fPM variability,inlieuofquarterlyfPM forSurfaceFinishingv.EPA,795F.3d demonstratesthatCongressanticipated
emissionstesting,willrendermootthe 1,5(D.C.Cir.2015).Inotherrecent thattheEPAwouldstrengthen
commenter’ssuggestionthatmarginof residualriskandtechnologyreviews, standardsbasedontechnological
compliancehasnotbeentakeninto theEPAdeterminedadditionalcontrols developmentsevenafterithad
account.
concludedtherewasanamplemarginof
rewarrantedundertechnology
Comment:Somecommentersargued rwe
safety.CAAsection112’soverarching
e
v
i
e
ws
pur
s
ua
nt
t
o
CAA
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
thatthelow residualriskstheEPA
c
hargetotheEPAto‘‘requirethe
1
1
2
(
d)
(
6
)
a
l
t
ho
ug
h
t
he
Ag
e
nc
y
foundinitsreview ofthe2020Residual determinedadditionalstandardswere ma
degreeofreductionin
RiskReview obviatetheneedforthe notnecessarytomaintainanample emixsismum
i
o
ns
o
thehazardousair
EPAtorevisethestandardsunderthe marginofsafetyunderCAAsection pollutantssfub
ttothissection
separatetechnologyreview,andthat 112(f)(2).29TheEPAhasalsomadeclear (includingaprjoechi
tiononsuch
residualriskshouldbearelevantaspect thattheAgency‘‘disagree[s]withthe emissions)’’furthebride
monstratesthat
oftheEPA’stechnologyreview ofcoal- view thatadeterminationunderCAA Congresssoughttomini
zethe
andoil-firedEGUs.Thesecommenters section112(f)ofanamplemarginof emissionofhazardousaimi
r
po
lution
arguedthatitisarbitraryandcapricious safetyandnoadverseenvironmental whereverfeasibleindependelnt
a
fortheEPAtoimposehighcostson effectsalonewill,inallcases,causeus findingofrisk.Moreover,asdisocfus
sed
facilities,whichtheyclaimedwillonly todeterminethatarevisionisnot
s
upr
a
,
i
n
e
na
c
t
i
ng
t
he
1
9
9
0
CAA
resultinmarginalemissionreductions,
Amendments,Congresspurposefully
whentheEPAdeterminedthereisnot necessaryunderCAAsection
r
placedthepreviousrisk-based
anunreasonablerisktotheenvironment 29See,e.g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor aeppr
oachtoestablishingstandardsfor
orpublichealth.
HAP
thatechnology-driven
Ha
z
a
r
do
us
Ai
r
Po
l
l
ut
a
nt
s
:
Re
f
r
a
c
t
o
r
y
Pr
o
duc
t
s
Othercommentersagreedwiththe ManufacturingResidualRiskandTechnology approwi
a
c
h.Thistechnology-driven
view,86FR66045(November19,2021);National
EPA’s‘‘two-pronged’’interpretationthat Re
Emi
s
s
i
o
n
St
a
nda
r
ds
f
o
r
Ha
z
a
r
do
us
Ai
r
Po
l
l
ut
a
nt
s
:
CAAsection112(d)(6)provides
NationalEmissionStandardsforHazardous
SiteRemediationResidualRiskandTechnology Ai3r0Po
authoritiestotheEPAthataredistinct Re
llutantEmissions:GroupIPolymersand
v
i
e
w,
8
5
FR
4
1
6
8
0
(
J
ul
y
1
0
,
2
0
2
0
)
;
Na
t
i
o
na
l
sins;MarineTankVesselLoadingOperations;
from theEPA’srisk-basedauthorities EmissionStandardsforHazardousAirPollutants: Re
PharmaceuticalsProduction;andthePrintingand
OrganicLiquidsDistribution(Non-Gasoline)
underCAAsection112(f)(2).These Re
PublishingIndustry,76FR22566,22577(April21,
s
i
dua
l
Ri
s
k
a
nd
Te
c
hno
l
o
g
y
Re
v
i
e
w,
8
5
FR
commenterssaidthatifthecriteria
2011).
4
0
7
4
0
,
4
0
7
4
5
(
J
ul
y
7
,
2
0
2
0
)
;
Na
t
i
o
na
l
Emi
s
s
i
o
n
underCAAsection112(d)(6)aremet, andardsforHazardousAirPollutants:Generic 31See,e.g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor
OrganicHazardousAirPollutantsFrom the
theEPAmustupdatethestandardsto St
Maximum AchievableControlTechnology
ntheticOrganicChemicalManufacturing
andardsResidualRiskandTechnologyReview ISy
reflectnew developmentsindependent St
try,71FR76603,76606(December21,2006);
hyleneProduction,85FR40386,40389(July sndus
oftheriskassessmentprocessunder f6o,r2Et
eealsoProposedRules:NationalEmission
NationalEmissionStandardsfor
CAAsection112(f)(2).Theysaidthe Haz0a2r0do);us
andardsforHalogenatedSolventCleaning,73FR
PollutantsforChemicalRecovery St
4,62404(October20,2008).
technology-basedreview conducted CombustionAiSorur
cesatKraft,Soda,Sulfite,and 623328Na
ionalEmissionsStandardsforHazardous
AloneSemichemicalPulpMills,82FR47328 AirPolltut
underCAAsection112(d)(6)neednot (StOcands:SecondaryLeadSmelting,77FR
tober11,2017);NationalEmissionStandards 556,564(aJant
accountforanyinformationlearned forHa
nuary5,2012).
usAirPollutants:GenericMaximum
duringtheresidualriskreview under Achievzaabrldo
33Seesect
ionII.A.2.aboveforfurtherdiscussion
eControlTechnologyStandards;and
CAAsection112(f)(2)unlessthat
ofthestatutorystructureandlegislativehistoryof
ManufactureofAmino/PhenolicResins,79FR
CAAsection112.
informationpertainstostatutoryfactors 60898,60901(October8,2014).
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00019 Fmt4719a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38526
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
approachrecognizestheabilityforthe notanticipatethisrulewillhaveany priorCAArulemakingshavenotbeen
EPAtoachievesubstantialreductionsin implicationsforresourceadequacy. borneoutinreality.Forexample,inthe
Nevertheless,itispossiblethatsome staylitigationovertheCross-StateAir
HAPbasedontechnological
ownersmayconcludethatretiring PollutionRule(CSAPR),claimswere
improvementswithouttheinherent aEGU
rticularEGUandreplacingitwith madethatallowingtheruletogointo
difficultyinquantifyingriskassociated nepa
pacityisamoreeconomicoption effectwouldcompromisereliability.Yet
withHAPemissionexposuregiventhe owmctahe
perspectiveoftheunit’s
inthe2012ozoneseasonstartingjust
complexitiesofthepathwaysthrough fcrus
rsand/orownersthanmaking over4monthsaftertherulewasstayed,
whichHAPcauseharm andinsufficient invetostme
ntsinnew emissionscontrols EGUscoveredbyCSAPRcollectively
availabilityofdatatoquantifytheir attheme
unit.TheEPAunderstandsthat emittedbelow theoverallprogram
effectsdiscussedinsectionII.B.2.
beforeimplementingsucharetirement budgetsthattherulewouldhave
Independentofrisks,itwouldbe
cision,theunit’sownerwillfollow imposedinthatyeariftherulehadbeen
inconsistentwiththetext,structure,and de
theprocessesputinplacebythe
allowedtotakeeffect,withmost
legislativehistoryfortheEPAto
antregionaltransmission
vidualstatesemittingbelow their
concludethatCongressintendedthe roerlgeavni
n(RTO),balancingauthority, rindi
e
s
pe
ctivestatebudgets.Similarly,in
statute’stechnology-basedapproachto orstatezarteigoul
atortoprotectelectric
t
he
l
i
t
igationoverthe2015CleanPower
besidelinedaftertheEPAhad
system reliability.Theseprocesses
Pl
a
n,
a
ssertionsthattherulewould
concludedtheriskreview.
typicallyincludeanalysisofthe
t
hr
e
a
t
e
ctricsystem reliabilitywere
Comment:Somecommenters
tentialimpactsoftheproposedEGU madebnyesloeme
utilitiesortheir
expressedconcernthatsomeportionof po
retirementonelectricalsystem
r
e
pr
e
s
e
nt
a
t
i
v
e
s
ughthe
affectedunitscouldsimplyretire
eliability,identificationofoptionsfor SupremeCourt,sytaeyteedvetnhetho
r
ul
ein2016,
insteadofcomingintocompliancewith rmi
tigatinganyidentifiedadverse
t
he
i
ndus
t
r
y
a
c
hi
e
v
e
d
t
he
r
ul
e
new requirements,potentiallyoccurring impa
insomecases,temporary emissionreductiontargetsyea’rssahead
beforenew generationcouldbebuiltto provicstiso,nand,
ofadditionalrevenuesto
fschedulewithouttheruleevergoing
replacethelostgeneration.Duringthis supportthe
scontinuedoperation oint
effect.SeeWestVirginiav.EPA,
period,alackofdispatchablegeneration untillonger-EGU’
term mitigationmeasures 142oS.
Ct.2587,2638(2022)(Kagan,J.,
couldsignificantlyincreasethe
canbeputinplace.Nocommenter
di
s
s
e
nt
)(‘‘[T]heindustrydidn’tfall
likelihoodofoutages,particularly
atedthatthisrulewouldsomehow shortofing
t
he
[CleanPower]Plan’sgoal;
duringperiodsofsevereweather.In astut
rizeanyEGUownertounilaterally rather,theindus
tryexceededthattarget,
addition,somecommentersarguedthat retiho
twithoutfollowingthese allonitsown....
Atthetimeofthe
revisingthefPM limitwasunnecessary prorceesaseuni
mecommenters
r
e
pe
a
l
...
‘
t
he
r
e
[
wa
s]likelytobeno
asthereisacontinuingdownwardtrend neverthesle,syseatsssoume
withoutany
di
f
f
e
r
e
nc
e
b
e
t
we
e
n
a
wo
rldwherethe
inHAPemissionsfrom early
tionalethatishow multipleEGU
[
Cl
e
a
n
Po
we
r
Pl
a
n
wa
s
]
i
emented
retirementsofcoal-firedEGUs,whereas roawne
rswouldproceed,inviolationof andonewhereit[was]nompl
t
.
’
’
’
quoting
acceleratingthistrendcouldhave
irobligationstoRTOs,balancing 84FR32561).Inotherwords,)t(he
claims
potentialadverseeffectsonreliability. tahe
uthorities,orstateregulatorsrelatingto thattheseruleswouldhavehadadv
Somecommentersalsostatedthatas the
ovisionofreliableelectricservice. reliabilityimpactsprovedtobe erse
morecapacityandgenerationisshifted Inpr
a
tion,theAgencyhasgranted groundless.
awayfrom coal-firedEGUsduetothe themaddi
x
i
mum
timeallowedfor
EPAnotesthatsimilarconcerns
InflationReductionAct(IRA)andother complianceunde
rCAAsection112(i)(3) regThe
a
r
di
reliabilitywereraisedabout
regulatoryandeconomicfactors,the of3years,andindi
lfacilitiesmay the201ng
2
MATS
nalRule—arulethat
totalannualfPM andHAPemissions seek,ifwarranted,avnidua
additional1-year projectedtheneeFi
d
nificantly
from industrywilldecline,regardlessof extensionofthecompl
edatefrom greaterinstallationfoofrcsoignt
rolsandother
whetherthefPM limitismademore theirpermittingauthoriiatyncpur
suantto capitalinvestmentsthanthi
scurrent
stringent.
CAA
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
1
1
2
(
i
)
(
3
)
(
B)
.
The
3
4
r
e
v
i
s
i
o
n.
As
wi
t
h
t
he
c
ur
r
e
rule,the
Response:TheEPAdisagreesthatthis nstructionofanyadditionalpollution flexibilityofpermittingauthont
r
i
tiesto
rulewouldthreatenresourceadequacy ccoont
r
o
l
t
e
c
hno
l
o
g
y
t
ha
t
EGUs
mi
g
ht
a
l
l
o
w
a
f
o
ur
t
h
y
e
a
r
f
o
r
c
o
mpl
i
a
nc
s
orotherwisedegradeelectricsystem installforcompliancewiththisrulecan availableinabroadrangeofsituaetiowa
reliability.Commentersprovidedno becompletedwithinthistimeandwill andintheeventthatanisolated, ns,
credibleinformationsupportingthe notrequiresignificantoutagesbeyond localizedconcernweretoemergethat
argumentthatthisfinalrulewould
whatisregularlyscheduledfortypical couldnotbeaddressedsolelythrough
resultinasignificantnumberof
maintenance.Facilitiesmayalsoobtain, the1-yearextensionunderCAAsection
retirementsoralargeramountof
fwarranted,anemergencyorderfrom 112(i)(3),theCAAprovidesflexibilities
capacityneedingcontrols.TheAgency tihe
DepartmentofEnergypursuantto tobringsourcesintocompliancewhile
estimatesthatthisrulewillrequire
s
e
c
t
ion202(c)oftheFederalPowerAct maintainingreliability.Wehaveseenno
additionalfPM controlatlessthan12 (16U.
824a(c))thatwouldallow the evidenceinthelastdecadetosuggest
GW ofoperablecapacityin2028,which facilityS.tC.
otemporarilyoperate
isabout11percentofthetotalcoal-fired notwithstandingenvironmentallimits 34TheEPAprojectedthatthe2012MATSFinal
EGUcapacityprojectedtooperatein whentheSecretaryofEnergy
Rulewoulddrivetheinstallationofanadditional
thatyear.Theunitsrequiringadditional determinesdoingsoisnecessaryto
20GW ofdryFGD(dryscrubbers),44GW ofDSI,
GW ofadditionalACI,102GW ofadditionalFFs,
fPM controlsareprojectedtogenerate addressashortageofelectricenergyor 6939GW
crubberupgrades,and34GW ofESP
lessthan1.5percentoftotalgeneration otherelectricreliabilityemergency. upgradeosf.sWhi
leasubsequentanalysisfoundthat
Further,despitethecomments
in2028.Moreover,theEPAdoesnot
t
he
i
ndus
t
r
y
ul
telyinstalledfewercontrols
assertingconcernsoverelectricsystem thanwasprojectitma
projectthatanyEGUswillretirein
ed,thecontrolinstallationsthat
ccurredfollowingthepromulgationofthe2012
responsetothestandardspromulgated reliability,nocommentercitedasingle oMATS
lRulewerestillsignificantlygreater
instancewhereimplementationofan thantheFiina
inthisfinalrule.BecausetheEPA
nstallationsthatareestimatedtooccuras
EPAprogram causedanadverse
projectsnoincrementalchangesin
aresultofthisfinalrule(where,forexample,the
existingoperationalcapacitytooccurin reliabilityimpact.Indeed,similar
estimatesthatlessthan2GW ofcapacity
wouldinstallFFtechnologyforcompliance).
responsetothefinalrule,theEPAdoes claimsmadeinthecontextoftheEPA’s EPA
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00020 Fmt4720a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38527
viabletoconstructsignificantcontrol foundthat,basedonitsownassessment
thattheimplementationofMATS
upgradesforarevisedstandardthat andthatofcommenters,onlyafew
causedpowersectoradequacyand
reliabilityproblems,andonlyahandful wouldbecomeeffectiveinmid-2027, facilitieswouldlikelybeeligiblefora
only5yearsbeforetheunit’spermanent near-term retirementsubcategoryand
ofsourcesobtainedadministrative
ordersundertheenforcementpolicy retirement.Commentersfurthernotedif thatitwouldnotsignificantlyreduce
issuedwithMATStoprovidereliefto theEPAdoesnotestablishsucha
thecostsoftherevisedstandards.
reliabilitycriticalunitsthatcouldnot subcategoryortakeotheractionto
AccordingtotheEPA’sas3s7essment,67
ensuretheseunitsarenotnegatively ofthe296EGUsassessed have
complywiththeruleby2016.
Comment:Commenterssuggestedthat impactedbytherulemaking,the
announcedretirementsbetween2029
theEPAuseitsauthoritytocreate
retirementofsomeunitscouldbe
2032—lessthanone-quarterofthe
subcategoriesofaffectedfacilitiesthat acceleratedduetothecostsofinstalling aflnd
e
e
t
—andallbutthreeofthoseEGUs
electtopermanentlyretirebythe
aPM CEMSandtheneedtorebuildor (attwo
s)havealready
compliancedateastheAgencyhas
upgradeanexistingESPorinstallaFF demonsftarcaitleidtiethe
abilitytocomplywith
takeninsimilarproposedrulemakings tosupplementanexistingESP.
t
he
0
.
0
1
0
l
b
/
MMBt
standardon
affectingcoal-andoil-firedEGUs.
CommentersstatedthattheEPAcannot average.AdditionaullyfPM
,
t
he
sethreeEGUs
CommentersstatedtheEPAshould
ignoretheneedforacoordinated
a
l
r
e
a
dy
us
e
PM
CEMS
t
o
de
monstrate
subcategorizethosesourcesthathave retirementofthermalgenerating
c
o
mpl
i
a
nc
e
,
t
he
r
e
f
o
r
e
t
he
c
o
mment
adoptedenforceableretirementdates capacitywhilenew generationsources requestingawaiverofPM CEMS
andnotsubjectthosesourcestoany comeonlinetoavoiddetrimental
installationsforEGUswithnear-term
finalrulerequirements.Theyindicated impactstogridreliability.
r
etirementsisnotrelevant.Becausethe
CommenterssuggestedthatiftheEPA EPA’
thattheEPAisfullyauthorizedto
analysisledtheAgencyto
subcategorizetheseunitsunderCAA decidestoproceedwithfinalizingthe conclsude
ttherewouldbelittle
section112(d)(1).Commentersasked revisedstandardsinthe2023Proposal, utilitytoatha
ne
r-term retirement
theAgencyshouldcreateasubcategory subcategoryaand
thattheEPAconsiderother
uldnotchangethe
simultaneousrulemakings,suchasthe forcoal-firedEGUsthatelectbythe costsoftheruleiintwo
a
me
aningfulway,
proposedGreenhouseGasStandards compliancedateoftherevised
t
he
EPA
de
t
e
r
mi
ne
d
no
t
reatea
andGui
delinesforFossilFuelPower standards(i.e.,mid-2027)toretirethe retirementsubcategoryfotortche
PM
3
5
Plants, wheretheEPAproposedthat unitsbyDecember31,2032,orJanuary standard.Inaddition,theEPAfno
tes
EGUsthatelecttoshutdownbyJanuary 1,2032,iftheEPApreferstotiethe thatallowingunitstooperatewitho
1,2032,mustmaintaintheirrecent 2023ProposaltotheproposedEmission thebestperformingcontrolsforan ut
historicalcarbondioxide(CO2)emission GuidelinesinsteadoftheEffluent
tionalnumberofyearswouldlead
LimitationGuidelines,andmaintainthe atoddi
rateviaroutinemaintenanceand
hi
gherlevelsofnon-HgHAPmetals
currentMATSstandardsforthis
operatingprocedures(i.e.,no
e
mi
s
sionsandcontinuedexposureto
subcategoryofunits.Commenters
degradationofperformance).
t
ho
s
e
ssionsinthecommunities
requestedthattheEPAcoordinatethe aroundemi
Commentersalsoreferencedthe
t
he
eunitsduringthat
retirementdateofDecember31,2032,in requiredretirementdateforthe2023 timeframe.sRe
gardingafPM compliance
Proposalwithotherrulessothatall requirementsub
theEPAOfficeofWater’spropo3s6ed
categoryforEGUswith
retirementdatesalign.Commenters near-term retireme
EffluentLimitationGuidelines.
nts,theAgency
Commentersclaimedthatcreatinga reiteratedthattheEPAhasmultiple estimates26of67EGUs
arealready
subcategoryforunitsfacingnear-term authoritieswithoverlappingstatutory us
i
ng
PM
CEMS
f
o
r
c
o
mpl
iance
retirementsthatharmonizesthe
timelinesthataffectcommenters’plans monstrationandfindstha
tthecosts
retirementdateswithotherrulemakings regardingtheorderlyretirementofcoal- de
t
o
i
ns
t
a
l
l
PM
CEMS
f
o
r
f
a
c
i
l
i
swith
wouldgreatlyassistcompanieswith firedEGUsandtheirabilitytocontinue near-term retirementsarereatsioena
ble.
movingforwardonretirementplans theindustry’scleanenergy
The
Ag
e
nc
y
f
i
nds
t
ha
t
t
he
t
r
a
ns
pa
rency
withoutrunningtheriskofbeingforced transformationwhileprovidingthe
ovidedbyPM CEMSandthe
toretireearly,whichcouldcreate
reliabilityandaffordabilitythattheir pr
increasedabilitytoquicklydetectand
reliabilityconcernsor,inthe
customersdemand.Commenters
orrectpotentialcontroloroperational
alternative,forcedtodeliberatewhether suggestedthatEGUsthatplantoretire cpr
blemsusingPM CEMSfurthers
toinstallcontrolsanddelaying
by2032shouldhavetheopportunityto Coong
ress’sgoaltoensurethatemission
retirementtorecoupinvestmentsinthe seekawaiverfrom PM CEMS
r
e
duc
tionsareconsistentlymaintained
controls.Commentersalsosuggested installationaltogetherandcontinue andma
kesPM CEMSthebestchoicefor
thatEGUswithlimitedcontinued
quarterlystacktestingduringthe
t
hi
s
r
ul
e
operationbeallowedtocontinueto remaininglifeoftheunit.Theyalso EGUs. ’scompliancemonitoringforall
perform quarterlystacktestingto
suggestedthatifaunitdoesnotretire
demonstratecompliancewiththefPM bythespecifieddate,itshouldbe
mmentsontheProposedChanges
limitations(ratherthanhavingtoinstall requiredtoimmediatelyceaseoperation t2o.Co
t
he
ComplianceDemonstration
PM CEMS).Commenterssuggestedthat ormeetthestandardsoftherule.
Opt
i
o
ns
imposingdifferentstandardsonthese Commentersstatedthatunderthis
Comment:TheAgencyreceivedboth
subcategoriesshouldcontinuethestatus recommendationanEGU’sfailureto suppo
tiveandopposingcomments
quofortheseunitsuntilretirement. complywouldthenbeaviolationofthe requirirng
useofPM CEMSfor
Commentersclaimedthatitwouldmake 2023Proposal’sfinalrulesubjectto compliancthe
e
de
monstration.Supportive
orcement.
nosensefortheEPAtorequireanEGU enf
c
o
mme
nt
e
r
s
s
t
a
tedtheEPAmust
Re
s
po
ns
e
:
I
n
r
e
s
po
ns
e
t
o
c
o
mme
nt
e
r
s
’
slatedtoretireinthenearterm to
r
e
q
ui
r
e
t
he
us
e
o
fPM CEMStomonitor
concerns,theEPAevaluatedthe
expendsubstantialresourceson
t
he
i
r
e
mi
s
s
i
o
ns
o
fnon-HgHAPmetals
f
e
a
s
i
b
i
l
i
t
y
o
f
c
r
e
a
t
i
ng
a
s
ub
c
a
t
e
g
o
r
y
f
o
r
controlsintheinterim sincethese
facilitieswithnear-term retirementsbut 7Inthisfinalrule,theEPAreviewedfPM
sourcesareveryunlikelytofindit
disagreeswithcommentersthatsucha co3mpl
iancedatafor296coal-firedEGUsexpected
3588FR33245(
s
ub
c
a
t
e
g
o
r
y
i
s
a
ppr
o
pr
i
a
t
e
f
o
r
t
hi
s
May23,2023).
t
o
b
e
o
perationalonJanuary1,2029.Thisreview
3688FR18824,18837(
March29,2023).
isexplainedindetailinthe2024TechnicalMemo.
rulemaking.Inparticular,theEPA
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00021 Fmt4721a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38528
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
demonstratingcompliancewiththe allowingalargercriterionorby
asPM CEMSarenow morewidely
deployedthanwhenMATSwasfirst revisedfPM standard,statingthatthe modifyingthecalculationandallowing
alessstringentnumberinthe
promulgated,andexperiencewithPM requirementsofPerformance
CEMShasenabledoperatorstomore Specification11of40CFRpart60, denominator.Withthesechangestothe
QAcriteriaandcorrelationprocedures,
promptlydetectandcorrectproblems appendixB(PS–11)willbecome
theEPAbelievesEGUswillbeableto
withpollutioncontrolsascomparedto extremelyhardtosatisfyatthelow
othermonitoringandtestingoptions emissionlimitsproposed.ForPS–11, usePM CEMStodemonstrate
allowedunderMATS(i.e.,periodic relativecorrelationaudit(RCA),and complianceattherevisedlevelofthe
fPM standard.
stacktestingandparametricmonitoring relativeresponseaudit(RRA),the
Comment:Somecommentersasserted
toleranceintervalandconfidence
forPM),therebyloweringHAP
tiftheEPAfinalizestherequirement
emissions.Theysaidthatthefactthat intervalrequirementsareexpressedin ttha
odemonstratecomplianceusingPM
termsoftheemissionstandardthat CEMS,
PM CEMShavebeenusedto
willnotbeabletocomply
demonstratecomplianceinamajorityof appliestothesource.Thecommenters withalEGUs
owerfPM limitonacontinuous
reviewedtestdatafrom operatingunits basisand
unitsin38theeightbestperforming
hataccompanyingalower
deciles providesstrongevidencethat andfoundsignificantlyhigherPS–11 limitwithtmo
restrictivemonitoring
PM CEMScanbeusedeffectivelyto failure(>80percent),RCAfailure(>80 requirementsraedds
theregulatory
measurelow levelsofPM emissions. percent),andRRAfailure(60percent) burdenofaffectedstoour
OpposingcommentersurgedtheEPA ratesatthemorestringentproposed permittingauthorities.cesand
toretainallcurrentoptionsfor
emissionlimits.Theystatedthatthe
sponse:TheEPAdisagreeswith
demonstratingcompliancewithnon-Hg cost,complexity,andfailurerateof coRe
nters’claim thatthatEGUswill
HAPmetalstandards,including
equipmentcalibrationremainsoneof nomme
tbeabletodemonstratecompliance
quarterlyPM andmetalstesting,LEE, thebiggestchallengeswiththeuseof cont
inuouslywithafPM limitof0.010
andPM CPMS.Thesecommenterssaid PM CEMSandthereforeother
u.TheEPAbelievesthatCEMS
removingthesecomplianceflexibility compliancedemonstrationmethods ilnb/gMMBt
ralandPM CEMSinparticular
optionsgoesbeyondthescopeofthe shouldberetained.Commentersalso enabelne
rsandoperatorstodetect
RTRanddoesnotaddresswhythe
notedthatrepeatedtestsduetofailure ndqeuiocwne
klycorrectcontroldeviceor
reasonstheseoptionswereoriginally couldresultinhighertotalemissions apr
ocessissuesinmanycasesbeforethe
includedinMATSarenolongervalid. from theunits.
ssuesbecomecomplianceproblems.
Commenterssaidtheyhavepreviously Response:TheAgencyisawareof iCo
rarytothecommenter’sassertion
raisedconcernsaboutPM CEMSthat oncernsbysomecommentersthatPM thant
t
EGUs
llnotbeabletocomply
theEPAhasavoidedbystatingthat cCEMS
currentlycorrelatedforthe0.030 withalowewi
rfPM limitonacontinuous
CEMSarenottheonlycompliance
l
b
/
MMBt
u
f
PM
e
mi
s
s
i
o
n
l
i
mi
t
ma
y
basis,asmentionedintheJune2023
methodforPM.Theystatedthat
riencedifficultiesshouldreAndover3Te
chnologyPartners
previously,theEPAhasdetermined ecxope
r
r
e
l
a
t
i
o
n
b
e
ne
c
e
s
s
a
r
y
;
a
nd
t
ho
s
e
nalysis,9over80percentofEGUs
thesecompliancemethodswereboth concernsarealsoascribedtoyet-to-be aus
ingPM CEMSforcompliance
adequateandfrequentenoughto
installedPM CEMS.Inresponsetothose pur
seshavealreadybeenableto
demonstratecompliance.
erns,theAgencyhasshiftedthe achipo
eveandarereportingandcertifying
Response:TheAgencydisagreeswith cboanc
s
i
s
o
f
c
o
r
r
e
l
a
t
i
o
n
t
e
s
t
i
ng
f
r
o
m
consistentachievementoffPM rates
commenterswhosuggeststhattherule equiringonlythecollectionofa
below 0.010lb/MMBtu.40TheEPAis
shouldretainallpreviousoptionsfor rmi
ni
mum
v
o
l
ume
pe
r
r
un
t
o
a
l
s
o
wareofanyadditionalburden
demonstratingcompliancewitheither allowingthecollectionofaminimum una
periencedbythoseEGUownersor
theindividualmetals,totalmetals,or massperrunandhasadjustedtheQA oexpe
irregulatoryauthorities
fPM limits.CongressintendedforCAA criterionotherwiseassociatedwiththe withrarteograsrodrttohe
PM CEMSuseatthese
section112toachievesignificant
ne
w
e
mi
s
s
i
o
n
l
i
mi
t
.
The
s
e
c
ha
ng
e
s
wi
l
l
remissionlevels,anddoesnot
reductionsofHAP,andtheEPAagrees easethetransitionforcoal-andoil-fired leoxwe
pectadditionalburdentobeplaced
withothercommentersthattheuseof EGUsusingonlyPM CEMSfor
EGUownersoroperatorswithregard
CEMSingeneralandPM CEMSin
compliancedemonstrationpurposes. otonPM
CEMSfrom applicationofthe
particularenablesownersoroperators The
f
i
r
s
t
c
ha
ng
e
,
a
l
l
o
wi
ng
t
he
f
a
c
i
l
i
t
y
t
o
revisedemissionlimit.However,this
todetectandquicklycorrectcontrol chooseeitherthecollectionofa
lruleincorporatesapproaches,such
deviceorprocessissuesinmanycases nimum massperrunoraminimum afisna
s
wi
tchingfrom aminimum sample
beforetheissuesbecomecompliance mi
volumeperrun,shouldreducehigh- volume
perruntocollectionofa
problems.Consistentwiththe
l
e
v
e
l
c
o
r
r
e
l
a
t
i
o
n
t
e
s
t
i
ng
dur
a
t
i
o
n,
discussioncontainedinthe2023
essingotherconcernsabout
39AssessmentofPot
entialRevisionstothe
Proposal(88FR24872),theAgency aeddr
x
t
e
nde
druntimeswithdegraded
MercuryandAirToxicsStandards.Andover
findsthetransparencyandabilityto emissions
ntrolorincreased
TechnologyPartners.June15,2023.DocketIDNo.
quicklydetectandcorrectpotential emissions,caond
EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794.June2023.Also
s
ho
ul
d
r
e
duc
e
vailableathttps://www.andovertechnology.com/
controloroperationalproblemsfurthers correlationtestingcosts.Thesecond awpntent/uploads/2023/06/C_23_CAELP_
Congress’sgoaltoensurethatemission change,adjustingtheQAcriteria,is Finaclo.pdf
.
reductionsareconsistentlymaintained consistentwithotherapproachesthe
40Seef
orexamplethePM CEMSThirtyBoiler
andmakesPM CEMSthebestchoicefor Agencyhasusedwhenlowerrangesof Ope
ratingDayRollingAverageReportsforDuke’s
thisrule’scompliancemonitoring.
RoxboroSteam ElectricPlantinNorthCarolinaand
trumentationormethodsare
atMinnesotaPower’sBoswellEnergyCenterin
Comment:Somecommentersobjected eins
mpl
o
y
e
d.
Fo
r
e
x
a
mpl
e
,
i
n
s
e
c
t
i
o
n
1
3
.
2
nnesota.Thesereportsandthosefrom other
totheEPA’sproposaltorequiretheuse ofPerformanceSpecification2(40CFR Mi
EGUsreportingemissionlevelsatorlowerthan
ofPM CEMSforpurposesof
uareavailableelectronicallyby
part60,appendixB)theQAcriteriafor 0se.0a1rc0hilbng/MMBt
i
n
t
he
EPA’sWebFactorInformation
t
he
r
e
l
a
t
i
v
e
a
c
c
ur
a
c
y
t
e
s
t
a
udi
t
f
o
r
SO
2
38Anal
ysisofPM andHgEmissionsandControls andNitrogenOxideCEMSarerelaxed RetrievalSystem (WebFIRE)ReportSearchand
from Coal-FiredPowerPlants.AndoverTechnology
RetrievalportionoftheAgency’sWebFIREinternet
Partners.August19,2021.DocumentIDNo.EPA– astheemissionlimitdecreases.Thisis websiteathttps://cfpub.epa.gov/webfire/reports/
HQ–OAR–2018–0794–4583.
accomplishedatloweremissionsby esearch.cfm.
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00022 Fmt4722a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38529
Moreover,theAgencyanticipatesthat
minimum masssampleormassvolume isrequiredtoselectthemostcostthenew fPM limitwillincreasedemand
perrunandadjustingthePM CEMSQA effectiveapproachforcompliance
monitoring.Rather,theAgencyselects for,andperhapsspurincreased
acceptabilitycriteria,toreducethe
productionof,betagaugePM CEMS.
theapproachthatbestprovides
challengeswithusingPM CEMS.
Moreover,the30-boiler-operating-day assurancethatemissionlimitsaremet. D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal
averagingperiodofthelimitprovides PM CEMSannualcostsrepresentavery pproachanddecisionsforthefilterable
flexibilityforownersandoperatorsto smallfractionofatypicalcoal-fired aPM
rogatefornon-HgHAP
accountforequipmentmalfunctions EGU’soperatingcostsandrevenues.As meta(alss)astsaur
nda
rdandcompliance
andotherissues.Consistentwith41the describedintheRatioofRevised
de
mo
ns
t
r
a
t
i
o
n
options?
discussioninthe2023Proposal, the EstimatedNon-BetaGaugePM CEMS
TheEPAisfinalizingalowerfPM
AgencyfindsthatPM CEMSarethebest EUACto2022AverageCoal-FiredEGU emi
rdof0.010lb/MMBtu
GrossProfitmemorandum,availablein forcsosaiol-nfisrteadnda
choiceforthisrule’scompliance
EGUs,asasurrogatefor
monitoringastheyprovideincreased thedocket,ifallcoal-firedEGUswere non-HgHAPme
tals,andtheuseofPM
emissionstransparency,abilityforEGU topurchaseandinstallnew PM CEMS,
forcompliancedemonstration
owner/operatorstoquicklydetectand theEquivalentUniform AnnualCost CEMS
posesforcoal-andoil-firedEGUs
correctpotentialcontroloroperational (EUAC)wouldrepresentlessthanfour pur
ththeexceptionoflimited-useliquid
hundredthsofapercentoftheaverage (owi
problems,andgreaterassuranceof
firedEGUs)basedondevelopments
annualoperatingexpensesfrom coal- inilt-he
continuouscompliance.WhilePM
performanceofsourceswithinthe
firedEGUs.
CEMScanproducevaluesatlower
ategorysincetheEPAfinalizedMATS
Further,asdescribedintheRevised acnd
levelsprovidedcorrelationsare
theadvantagesconferredbyusing
developedappropriately,theAgency EstimatedNon-BetaGaugePM CEMS CEMS
forcompliance.Asdescribedin
establishedthefinalfPM limitof0.010 andFilterablePM TestingCosts
2023Proposal,non-HgHAPmetals
lb/MMBtuafterconsideringfactorssuch technicalmemorandum,availableinthe athe
epredominatelyacomponentoffPM,
rulemakingdocket,theEPAcalculated arnd
asruntimesnecessarytodevelop
controloffPM resultsin
correlations,potentialrandom error averagecostsforPM CEMSand
concomitantreductionofnon-HgHAP
quarterlytestingfrom valuessubmitted me
effects,andcosts.
tals(withtheexceptionofSe,which
Comment:Commentersstatedthatthe bycommentersinresponsetothe
maybepresentinthefilterablefraction
proposal’ssolicitation,whichare
EPA’scostestimatescontradictthe
orinthecondensablefractionasthe
Agency’ssuggestionthattheuseofPM discussedinsectionIV.D.ofthe
idgas,SeO2).TheEPAobservesthat
preamble.Basedonthecommenters’ saicnc
CEMSisamorecost-effective
monitoringapproachthanquarterly suggestions,theserevisedcostsinclude eMATSwasfinalized,thevast
testing,especiallyforunitsthatqualify thecostsofintermittentstacktesting majorityofcoveredunitshave
asLEE.TheysaidthattheEPAused associatedwiththePS–11correlations significantlyoutperformedthestandard,
estimatesfrom theInstituteofCleanAir andongoingcostsofRCAsandRRAs. withasmallnumberofunitslagging
WhiletheaverageEUACforPM CEMS behindandemittingsignificantlyhigher
Companies(ICAC)orEnvea/Altech
levelsoftheseHAPincommunities
whichdonotincludenumerouscosts exceedstheaverageannualcostof
associatedwithPM CEMSthatmake quarterlystackemissiontesting,thecost surroundingthoseunits.TheEPA
deemsitappropriatetorequirethese
them notcost-effective,suchasthecost forPM CEMSdoesnotinclude
ofintermittentstacktestingassociated importantadditionalbenefitsassociated laggingunitstobringtheirpollutant
withthePS–11correlationsandthe withprovidingcontinuousemissions controlperformanceuptothatoftheir
peers.Moreover,theEPAconcludesthat
ongoingcostsofRCAsandRRA,which datatoEGUownersoroperators,
arealargepartofthecostsassociated regulators,nearbycommunitymembers, requiringuseofPM CEMSfor
orthegeneralpublic.Asareminder,the complianceyieldsmanifoldbenefits,
withPM CEMSandwouldrise
substantiallyinconjunctionwiththe EPAisnotobligatedtochoosethemost includingincreasedemissions
inexpensiveapproachforcompliance transparencyanddataavailabilityfor
proposednew PM limits.The
demonstrations,particularlywhenall ownersandoperatorsandfornearby
commenterssaidthattheICAC
benefitsarenotmonetized,eventhough communities.
estimatedrangeofPM CEMS
costscanbeanimportantconsideration. TheEPA’sconclusionswithregardto
installationcostsareparticularly
thefPM standardandrequirementto
understatedandoutdatedandshouldbe Consistentwiththediscussion
ignoredbytheAgency.Theysaidthat containedinthe2023Proposalat88FR usePM CEMSforcompliance
theEPAestimatesmayalsounderstate 24872,theAgencyfindstheincreased demonstrationarecloselyrelated,both
PM CEMScostbyassumingthemost transparencyofEGUfPM emissionsand intermsofCAAsection112(d)(6)’s
commonlyusedlightscatteringbased theabilitytoquicklydetectandcorrect directionfortheEPAtoreduceHAP
potentialcontroloroperational
PM CEMSwillbeusedforall
emissionsbasedondevelopmentsin
applications.Thecommenterssaidthat problems,alongwithgreaterassurance practices,processes,andcontrol
whilemoreexpensive,asignificant ofcontinuouscompliancemakesPM technologies,a4nd
intermsoftechnical
numberofbetagaugePM CEMSare CEMSthebestchoiceforthisrule’s compatibility.2TheEPAfindsthatthe
usedforMATScompliance,especially compliancemonitoring.
manifoldbenefitsofPM CEMSrenderit
TheAgencyacknowledgesthe
wherePM spikingisusedforPS–11
a
ppropriatetopromulgateanupdated
correlationandRCAtestingandthat commenters’suggestionsthatEGU
f
PM
emissionstandardasasurrogatefor
thishigherdegreeofaccuracyfrom beta ownersoroperatorsmayfindthatusing non-Hg
HAPmetalsforwhichPM
gaugePM CEMSmaybeneededfor betagaugePM CEMSismost
CEMS
c
a
nbeusedtomonitor
opriateforthelowerfPM emission
sourceswithoutamarginofcompliance alippr
tintherule;suchsuggestionsare 42 notedinsectionIII.A.above,thereare
underthenew,morestringentemission comi
thelessindependentreasonsforadoptingboth
nsistentwiththeAgency’sview,as tnohenerAs
limit.
evisiontothefPM standardandthePM CEMS
Response:TheEPAdisagreeswiththe expressedin88FR24872.However,the compl
iancedemonstrationrequirementandeachof
commenters’suggestionthattheAgency Agencybelievesotherapproaches,
t
he
s
e
c
hangeswouldcontinuetobeworkable
i
nc
l
udi
ng
s
pi
k
i
ng
,
c
a
n
a
l
s
o
e
a
s
e
wi
t
ho
ut
theotherineffect,suchthattheEPAfinds
41See88FR24872.
thetworevisionsareseverablefrom eachother.
correlationtestingforPM CEMS.
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00023 Fmt4723a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
38530
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
demonstrationpurposes.First,thislevel
compliance.However,asthefPM limit Rule.Second,therearetechnical
islowered,operatorsmayencounter developmentsandimprovementsinPM ofcontrolensuresthatthehighest
emittersbringtheirperformancetoa
difficultiesestablishingandmaintaining controltechnologysincethe2012
levelwherethevastmajorityofthefleet
e
t
ha
t
i
nf
o
r
me
d
t
he
existingcorrelationsforthePM CEMS MATSFinalRul
andmaythereforebeunabletoprovide 2023Proposal.44Forexample,while isalreadyperforming.Forexample,as
describedabove,themajorityofthe
accuratevaluesnecessaryfor
ESPtechnologyhasnotundergone
existingcoal-firedfleetsubjecttothis
compliance.TheEPAhasdetermined, fundamentalchangessince2011,
basedoncommentsandonthe
industryhaslearnedandadopted‘‘best finalrulehaspreviouslydemonstrated
additionalanalysisdescribedbelow, practices’’associatedwithmonitoring anabilitytocomplywiththelower
thatthelowestpossiblefPM limit
ESPoperationmorecarefullysincethe 0.010lb/MMBtufPM limitatleast99
consideringthesechallengesatthistime 2012MATSFinalRule.ForFFs,more percentofthetimeduringonequarter,
is0.010lb/MMBtuwithadjustedQA durablematerialshavebeendeveloped inadditiontomeetingthelowerfPM
criteria.Therefore,theEPAdetermined sincethe2012MATSFinalRule,which limitonaverageacrossallquarters
thatthistwo-prongedapproach—
arelesslikelytofailduetochemical, assessed.TheAgencyestimatesthat
requiringPM CEMSinadditiontoa thermal,orabrasionfailureandcreate only33EGUsarecurrentlyoperating
abovethisrevisedlimit.Comparedto
lowerfPM limit—isthemoststringent risksofhighPM emissions.For
someofthebestperformingEGUs,the
optionthatbalancesthebenefitsof instance,fiberglass(oncethemost
usingPM CEMSwiththeemission
widelyusedmaterial)haslargelybeen 33EGUsrequiringadditionalPM
reductionsassociatedwiththetightened replacedbymorereliableandeasierto controlupgradesormaintenanceare
fPM emissionstandard.Further,the cleanmaterials,whicharemorecostly. morelikelytohaveanESPinsteadofa
EPAfindsthatthemorestringentlimit Coatedfabrics,suchasTeflonorP84 FFandtodemonstratecompliance
of0.006lb/MMBtufPM cannotbe
felt,alsocleaneasierthanotherfabrics, usingintermittentstacktesting.In
addition,mostoftheseEGUshave
adequatelymonitoredwithPM CEMSat whichcanresultinlessfrequent
thistime,becausetherandom error cleaning,reducingthewearthatcould operatedatahigherlevelofutilization
thanthecoal-firedfleetonaverage.
componentofmeasurementuncertainty damagefilterbagsandreducethe
from correlationstacktestingistoolarge effectivenessofPM capture.
cond,asdiscussedinsectionII.A.2.
andtheQAcriteriapassingrateforPM Toexaminepotentialrevisions,the abSe
o
v
ngressupdatedCAAsection
CEMSistoosmalltoprovideaccurate EPAevaluatedfPM compliancedatafor 112ien,tCo
he
1990CleanAirAct
(andthereforeenforceable)compliance thecoal-firedfleetandevaluatedthe Amendment
stoachievesignificant
values.Below,wefurtherdescribeour controlefficiencyandcostsofPM
r
e
duc
t
i
o
ns
i
n
HAPemissions,whichit
controlstoachievealowerfPM
rationaleforeachchange.
r
e
c
o
g
ni
z
e
d
a
r
e
rticularlyharmful
rd.Basedoncommentsreceived pollutants,andpa
i
mpl
ntedaregime
1.RationalefortheFinalFilterablePM sotnanda
the2023Proposal,theEPAreviewed underwhichCongreessme
di
rectedtheEPA
EmissionStandard
additionalfPM compliancedatafor62 tomakeswiftandsubstant
tions
Inthe2023Proposal,theAgency
EGUsat33facilities(see2024Technical toHAPbaseduponthemoisatlsrteriduc
ng
e
nt
proposedalowerfPM emission
Memoandattachmentsfordetailed
s
t
a
nda
r
ds
t
e
c
hno
l
o
g
y
c
o
ul
d
a
c
hi
e
v
e
.
standardforcoal-firedEGUsasa
information).Thereview ofadditional sisevidencedbyCongress’scharge
surrogatefornon-HgHAPmetalsbased fPM compliancedatashowedthatmore Thi
totheEPAto‘‘requirethemaximum
ondevelopmentsinpractices,
EGUshadpreviouslydemonstratedan de
greeofreductioninemissionsof
processes,andcontroltechnologies abilitytomeetalowerfPM rate,as
ha
z
ardousairpollutants(includinga
pursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), showninfigure4ofthe2024Technical prohi
uchemissions),’’thatis
includingtheEPA’sassessmentofthe Memo.Comparedtothe2023Proposal achievbaitbiolenaocncosunt
for‘‘thecostof
differingperformanceofsourceswithin where91percentofexistingcapacity achievingsuchemiisng
s
i
o
tion,and
thecategoryandupdatedinformation demonstratedanabilitytomeet0.010 anynon-airqualityheanlthreaduc
nd
aboutthecostofcontrols.Asdescribed lb/MMBtu,theupdatedanalysisshowed environmentalimpactsandenergy
inthe2023Proposal,non-HgHAP
that93percentaredemonstratingthe
rements....’’CAAsection
metalsarepredominatelyacomponent abilitytomeet0.010lb/MMBtuwith r1e1q2ui
(
d)
.Further,bycreatingseparate
offPM,andcontroloffPM resultsin existingcontrols.TheEPAreceived anddis(2ti)nc
trequirementsfortheEPAto
reductionofnon-HgHAPmetals(with commentsonthecostassumptionsfor considerupda
CAAsection112
theexceptionofSe,whichmaybe
upgradingPM controlsandfoundthat pursuanttobottehstteochno
ogyreview
presentinthefilterablefractionorin thecostsestimatedatproposalwerenot underCAAsection112(ld)
(6)and
thecondensablefractionastheacidgas, onlytoohigh,butthatthecost
r
e
s
i
dua
l
r
i
s
k
r
e
v
i
e
w
unde
r
section
SeO2).
effectivenessofPM upgradeswasalso 112(f)(2),CongressanticipaCAA
t
e
d
t
ha
Inconductingthistechnologyreview, underestimated(i.e.,thestandardis EPAwouldstrengthenstandards tthe
theEPAfoundimportantdevelopments morecost-effectivethantheEPA
pursuanttotechnologyreviews‘‘as
thatinformeditsproposal.First,from believedatproposal).
necessary(takingintoaccount
TheEPAisfinalizingthefPM
reviewinghistoricalinf4o3rmation
velopmentsinpractices,processes,
emissionlimitof0.010lb/MMBtuwith de
containedinWebFIRE, theEPA
a
nd
controltechnologies),’’CAAsection
observedthatmostEGUswerereporting adjustedQAcriteria,basedon
1
1
2
(
d)(6),evenaftertheEPAconcluded
fPM emissionrateswellbelow the0.030 developmentssince2012,forthe
t
he
r
e
sanamplemarginofsafety
reasonsdescribedinthisfinalruleand basedwa
lb/MMBtustandard.Thefleetwas
o
n
therisksthattheEPAcan
achievingtheseperformancelevelsat inthe2023Proposalasthelowest
45Ast
q
ua
nt
i
f
y
.
heEPAexplainedinthe
achievablefPM limitthatallowsforthe
lowercoststhanestimatedduring
promulgationofthe2012MATSFinal useofPM CEMSforcompliance
45EPA’
sCAAsection112(f)(2)quantitativerisk
assessmentsevaluatecancerriskassociatedwitha
lifetimeofexposuretoHAPemissionsfrom each
from theElectronicReportingTool(ERT)andis from Coal-FiredPowerPlants.AndoverTechnology sourceinthesourcecategory,thepotentialforHAP
searchableathttps://cfpub.epa.gov/webfire/reports/ Partners.August19,2021.DocumentIDNo.EPA– exposuretocauseadversechronic(orlong-term)
esearch.cfm.
HQ–OAR–2018–0794–4583.
noncancerhealtheffects,andthepotentialforHAP
43WebFI
REincludesdatasubmittedtotheEPA
44Anal
ysisofPM andHgEmissionsandControls
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00024 Fmt4724a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
38531
TheNorthernCheyenneReservation
proposal,theEPAdoesconsidercosts, duetotheveryhighPM control
technicalfeasibility,andotherfactors effectivenessofwell-performingESPs is20milesfrom theColstripfacilityand
whenevaluatingwhetheritisnecessary andFFs,oftenexceeding99.9percent. theTribeexerciseditsauthorityin1977
toreviseexistingemissionstandards Buttheperformanceofaminorityof
requireadditionalairpollution
underCAAsection112(d)(6)toensure unitslagswellbehindthevastmajority tcoont
rolsonthenew Colstripunits
thestandards‘‘requirethemaximum ofthefleet.Asindi
t
wo
c
a
t
e
d
b
y
t
he
(
Co
l
s
p3and4,thesameEGUsstill
degreeofemissionsreductions... highestfPM rates,47EGUswithoutthe operattriing
y),recognizingtheareaas
achievable.’’CAAsection112(d)(2).The mosteffectivePM controlshavenot aClassIaitrosda
he
dundertheCAA.
text,structure,andhistoryofthis
b
e
e
n
a
b
l
e
t
o
de
mo
ns
t
r
a
t
e
f
PM
r
a
t
e
s
Ac
c
o
r
di
ng
t
o
c
o
mmentssubmittedby
provisiondemonstrateCongress’s
c
o
mpa
r
a
b
l
e
t
o
t
he
r
e
s
t
o
f
t
he
f
l
e
e
t
.
t
he
No
r
t
he
r
n
Che
yenneTribe,their
directiontotheEPAtorequire
cifically,theColstripfacility,a
t
r
i
b
a
l
me
mb
e
r
s
—b
oththoselivingon
reductioninHAPwheretechnologyis Spe
1
,
5
0
0
MW
s
ub
b
i
t
umi
no
us
f
i
r
e
d
po
we
r
t
he
Re
s
e
r
v
a
t
i
o
n
a
nd
selivinginthe
availabletodosoandtheEPAaccounts plantlocatedinColstrip,Montana, nearbycommunityotfho
Co
lstrip—have
fortheotherstatutoryfactors.
o
pe
r
a
t
e
s
t
he
o
nl
y
t
wo
c
o
a
l
f
i
r
e
d
EGUs
i
n
b
e
e
n
di
s
pr
o
po
r
t
i
o
na
l
l
y
i
mpa
y
Accordingly,theEPAfindsthat
thecountrywithoutthemostmodern exposuretoHAPemissionsfcrotemdtbhe
bringingthissmallnumberofunitsto PM
rols(i.e.,ESPorFF).Instead, Colstripfacility.51
theperformancelevelsoftherestofthe thiscfaocnt
i
l
ilizesventuriwet
fleetservesCongress’smandatetothe scrubbersityasut
TheEPAbelievesafPM emission
i
t
sprimaryPM control limi
EPAinCAAsection112(d)(6)to
f0.010lb/MMBtuappropriately
c
hno
l
o
g
y
a
nd
ha
s
s
t
r
ug
g
l
e
d
t
o
me
e
t
t
e
continuallyconsiderdevelopments theoriginal0.030lb/MMBtufPM limit, taketsoint
oconsiderationthecostsof
‘‘thatcreateopportunitiestodoeven evenwhileemployingemissions
c
o
nt
r
o
l
s
.
EPAevaluatedthecoststo
better.’’SeeLEAN,955F.3dat1093.As averagingacrosstheoperatingEGUsat improvecThe
ur
r
e
PM controlsystems
such,theEPAhasanumberoftimesin thefacility.Colstripisalsotheonly andthecosttont
i
ns
llbetterperforming
thepastupdateditsMACTstandardsto cilitywheretheEPAestimatesthe PM controls(i.e.,atane
w FF)toachieve
reflectdevelopmentswherethemajority cfaur
r
e
nt
c
o
nt
r
o
l
s
wo
ul
d
b
e
una
b
l
e
t
o
a
mo
r
e
s
t
r
i
ng
e
nt
e
mi
s
s
limit.Costsof
ofsourceswerealreadyoutpe4r6forming meetalowerfPM limit.Specifically,the PM upgradesaremuchiolonwe
thanthe
theoriginalMACTstandards. Indeed, 2018secondquartercompliancestack EPAestimatedin2012,andtrhe
thisfinalruleisconsistentwiththe testsshowedaveragefPM emissionrates reviseditscostsassumptionsasAgency
EPA’sauthoritypursuanttoCAA
0.030lb/MMBtufPM limit,in scribedinthe2024TechnicalMemo,
section112(d)(6)totakedevelopments avbioolvaetitohe
nofitsAirPermit.TalenEnergy, ade
vailableinthedocket.Table4ofthis
inpractices,processes,andcontrol oneofthe
rsofthefacility,agreed do
cumentsummarizestheupdatedcost
technologiesintoaccounttodetermine topay$450o,wne
000to4s8ettletheseair
e
f
f
e
ssofthethreefPM emission
ifmorestringentstandardsare
qualityviolations. Asaresult,the limicttsivceone
ns
redinthe2023Proposal
achievablethanthoseinitiallysetbythe pl
wasofflineforapproximately2.5 fortheexisitde
i
ng
coal-firedfleet.Forthe
EPAinestablishingMACTfloors,based moant
hswhiletheplant’soperator
ondevelopmentsthatoccurredinthe wornt
pur
po
s
e
o
f
e
s
t
i
ma
tingcosteffectiveness,
kedtocorrecttheproblem.
interim.SeeLEANv.EPA,955F.3d Comme
t
he
a
na
l
y
s
i
s
pr
e
s
e
nt
edinthistable,
sfrom Colstrip’smajority
1088,1097–98(D.C.Cir.2020).The ownersnt
de
s
c
r
i
b
e
d
i
n
de
t
a
i
l
i
2023and2024
discusstheeffortsthisfacility TechnicalMemos,isnbtahe
technologicalstandardapproachofCAA hasunde
s
e
onetoimprovetheirwetPM observedemissionratesodfaolnletxhe
section112isbasedonthepremisethat, scrubbersr,gwhi
ting
ystateremove99.7 coal-firedEGUsexceptforthoseitsha
totheextenttherearecontrolsavailable percentofthefclhyathe
t
particulatebut haveannouncedplanstoretirebythe
toreduceHAPemissions,andthose agreewiththeEPAshtha
t
a
ddi
t
i
o
na
l
controlsareofreasonablecost,sources controlswouldbeneededtomeeta endof2028.Theanalysispresentedin
shouldberequiredtousethem.
4estimatedthecostsassociatedfor
0.010lb/MMBtulimit.However,as etaabclheuni
Thefleethasbeenableto‘‘over
upgradetheirexistingPM
tatedinNorthWesternEnergy’sAnnual controlsttotome
comply’’withtheexistingfPM standard sPCCAM
etalowerfPM standard.
F4i9lingandApplicationofTariff Inthecaseswhe
xistingPM controls
Changes, ‘‘Colstriphasahistoryof wouldnotachievreeethe
exposuretocauseadverseacute(orshort-term)
necessary
noncancerhealtheffects.
o
pe
r
a
t
i
ng
v
e
r
y
c
l
o
s
e
t
o
t
he
uppe
r
e
nd
46See,e.
g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor
r
e
duc
t
i
o
ns
,
uni
t
s
pe
c
i
f
i
cFFinstallcosts
l
i
mi
t
:
f
o
r
4
3
pe
r
c
e
nt
o
f
t
he
6
5
1
da
y
s
o
f
HazardousAirPollutants:SiteRemediation
complianceprecedingtheforcedoutage wereestimated.Unlikethecostand
ResidualRiskandTechnologyReview,85FR
its[WeightedAverageEmissionRateo50r] benefitprojectionspresentedintheRIA,
41680,41698(July10,2020)(proposed84FR
46138,46161;September3,2019))(requiring
WAERwaswithin0.03lb/dekatherm theestimatesinthistabledonot
compliancewithmorestringentequipmentleak ofthelimit[...tocomplywiththeAir accountforanyfuturechangesinthe
definitionsunderatechnologyreview,whichwere PermitandMATS,Colstrip’sWAER
sitionoftheoperationalcoalwidelyadoptedbyindustry);NationalEmissions mus
tbeequaltoorlessthan0.03lb/ cfiorempo
d
EGU
fleetthatarelikelytooccur
StandardsforMineralWoolProductionand
FiberglassManufacturing,80FR45280,45307(July dekatherm].’’
b
y
2
0
2
8
a
s
aresultofotherfactors
29,2015)(adoptingmorestringentlimitsforglassaffectingthepowersector,suchasthe
meltingfurnacesunderatechnologyreview where 47Seefigure4ofthe2024TechnicalMemo.
theEPAfoundthat‘‘allglass-meltingfurnaceswere 48SeeDocumentCLT–1TTestimony,CLT–11, IRA,futureregulatoryactions,or
achievingemissionreductionsthatwerewellbelow and
hangesineconomicconditions.For
CL–12inDocket190882athttps://www.utc. c
theexistingMACTstandardsregardlessofthe
example,ofthemorethan14GW of
ov/documents-and-proceedings/dockets.
controltechnologyinuse’’);NationalEmissions wa4.9gSe
coal-firedcapacitythattheEPA
eNorthWesternEnergy’sAnnualPCCAM
StandardsforHazardousAirPollutantsFrom
FilingandApplicationforApprovalofTariff
SecondaryLeadSmelting,77FR556,564(January Cha
stimateswouldrequirecontrol
nges,DocketNo.2019.09.058,FinalOrder7708f e
5,2012)(adoptingmorestringentstacklead
i
mpr
ovementstoachievethefinalfPM
ragraph21(November18,2020)(notingthat
emissionlimitunderatechnologyreview ‘‘basedon pa
‘‘Colstriphasahistoryofoperatingveryclosetothe rate,lessthan12GW isprojectedtobe
emissionsdatacollectedfrom industry,which
upperendlimit’’),availableathttps://reddi.mt.gov/ 51
indicatedthatwell-performingbaghousescurrently pr
SeeDocumentIDNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–
web.
usedbymuchoftheindustryarecapableof
50Forref
erence,adekatherm isequivalenttoone 5984athttps://www.regulations.gov.
achievingoutletleadconcentrationssignificantly
millionBtus(MMBtu).
lowerthanthe[current]limit.’’).
VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00025 Fmt4725a
01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4
38532
FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations
operationalin2028(seesection3ofthe
RIAforthisfinalrule).
BILLING CODE 6560–50–P
maintenancecosting$100,000/year utilityboilersweremuchlowerthanthe
TheEPAhasupdateditscosts
(2022$).Thisadditionalcostrepresents EPAwasawareofatproposal.These
analysesforthisfinalrulebasedon
i
ncreasedvigilanceinmaintainingESP updates,aswellasimprovingour
commentsreceivedandadditionaldata pe
rformanceandincludestechnician methodologywhichincreasesthe
review,whichisdescribedinmore
l
a
b
ortomonitorperformanceoftheESP numberofEGUsestimatedtoneedPM
detailinthe2024TechnicalMemo
a
nd
riodicallymaketypicalrepairs upgrades,slightlylowerthedollarper
availableinthedocket.Inresponseto (e.g.,torepe
pl
ntoffailedinsulators, tonestimatesfrom whatwaspresented
commentersstatingthattheuseofthe damagedaecleecme
t
r
o
desorotherinternals inthe2023Proposal.
lowestquarter’s99thpercentile,orthe thatmayfail,repa
iringleaksintheESP TheEPAconsiderscostsinvarious
lowestachievablefPM rate,isnot
c
a
s
i
ng
,
duc
t
wo
r
k
,
orexpansionjoints, ways,dependingontheruleand
indicativeofoverallEGUoperationand andperiodictesting
ofESPflow balance affectedsector.Forexample,theEPA
emissionperformance,theEPAaddeda andanyneededadjustments).
hasconsidered,inpreviousCAA
review ofaveragefPM rates.Inthese
Additionally,theAgencyreceived section112rulemakings,cost
commentsthatthePM upgradecosts effectiveness,thetotalcapitalcostsof
updatedanalyses,boththelowest
quarter’s99thpercentileandtheaverage estimatedatproposalweretoohighon proposedmeasures,annualcosts,and
fPM ratemustbebelow thepotential adollarpertonbasisandthesecosts costscomparedtototal52revenues(e.g.,
havebeenupdatedandareprovidedin costtorevenueratios). Asmuchofthe
fPM limitfortheEPAtoassumeno
additionalupgradesareneededtomeet the2024TechnicalMemo.Specifically, 52
See,e.g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor
arevisedlimit.IfanEGUhaspreviously commentersdemonstratedthatthe
HazardousAirPollutants:MercuryCellChlorobservedpercentreductionsinfPM
demonstratedanabilitytomeeta
Al
k
a
liPlantsResidualRiskandTechnologyReview,
attributabletoESPupgradeswere
potentiallowerfPM limit,butthe
87FR27002,27008(May6,2022)(considered
significantlygreaterthanthepercent annualcolsotgsyand
averagefPM rateisgreaterthanthe
averagecapitalcostsperfacili
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.