Emergency Application — Talen Montana, LLC, et al., Applicants v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al.

Supreme Court briefAug 20, 2024

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No. _______

In the Supreme Court of the United States

Talen Montana, LLC and NorthWestern Corporation,

Applicants,

v.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and

Michael S. Regan, Administrator, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,

Respondents.

ON EMERGENCY APPLICATION FOR STAY TO THE HONORABLE JOHN G. ROBERTS, JR.,

CHIEF JUSTICE OF THE UNITED STATES

AND CIRCUIT JUSTICE FOR THE U.S. COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE D.C. CIRCUIT

APPENDIX TO APPLICATION FOR AN IMMEDIATE STAY OF FINAL

AGENCY ACTION PENDING DISPOSITION OF PETITION FOR REVIEW

Michael Drysdale

DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP

50 South Sixth Street, Suite 1500

Minneapolis, MN 55402

Creighton R. Magid

DORSEY & WHITNEY LLP

1401 New York Avenue NW, Suite 900

Washington, DC 20005

Counsel for NorthWestern Corporation

d/b/a NorthWestern Energy

Joshua B. Frank

Counsel of Record

C. Joshua Lee

BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.

700 K Street NW

Washington, DC 20001

(202) 639-7748

joshua.frank@bakerbotts.com

Counsel for Talen Montana, LLC

TABLE OF APPENDICES

Page

APPENDIX A - DECISIONS BELOW

Final Rule, National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants:

Coal- and Oil-Fired Electric Utility Steam Generating Units Review of

the Residual Risk and Technology Review, 89 Fed. Reg. 38508

(May 7, 2024) ......................................................................................................................... 2a

Order Denying Motions to Stay (D.C. Cir. Aug. 8, 2024) ............................................. 88a

APPENDIX B - STATUTORY PROVISION INVOLVED

42 U.S.C. § 7412 .................................................................................................................. 91a

APPENDIX C - SELECT RULEMAKING DOCUMENTS FOR THE FINAL RULE

(Select Excerpts) Talen Montana Comments (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR2018-0794-5987)................................................................................................................. 119a

(Select Excerpts) NorthWestern Comments (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR2018-0794-5980)................................................................................................................. 159a

EPA’s Response to Comments (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR-2018-07946922) ................................................................................................................................... 184a

EPA, Resource Adequacy Analysis: Vehicle Rules, Final 111 EGU Rules,

ELG and MATS RTR: Technical Memo (Apr. 2024) (Docket ID EPA-HQOAR-2023-0072-8915) ...................................................................................................... 360a

(Select Excerpts) EPA, Residual Risk Assessment for the Coal- and OilFired EGU Source Category in Support of the 2020 Risk and Technology

Review Final Rule (Sept. 2019) (Docket ID EPA-HQ-OAR-2018-07944553) ................................................................................................................................... 400a

APPENDIX D - COMMENTS SUBMITTED IN THE GREENHOUSE GAS RULE

Talen Montana Comments on the Proposed Greenhouse Gas Rule (Docket

ID EPA-HQ-OAR-2023-0072-0806) .............................................................................. 474a

(Select Excerpts) NorthWestern Comments on the Proposed Greenhouse

Gas Rule (EPA-HQ-OAR-2023-0072-0747) .................................................................. 506a

i

APPENDIX E - SELECT STAY MOTION PAPERS FILED IN THE D.C. CIRCUIT CASE

Talen Montana and NorthWestern’s Joint Motion for Stay (ECF No.

2062093) ............................................................................................................................. 530a

America’s Power and Electric Generators MATS Coalition’s Motion for

Stay (ECF No. 2063557) ................................................................................................. 572a

Talen Montana and NorthWestern’s Joint 28(j) Letter (ECF No. 2065246) .......... 618a

EPA’s Opposition to Motions to Stay (ECF No. 2065849) ........................................ 622a

Talen Montana and NorthWestern’s Joint Reply (ECF No. 2067227) .................... 688a

America’s Power and Electric Generators MATS Coalition’s Reply (ECF

No. 2067255) ...................................................................................................................... 708a

APPENDIX F - SELECT DECLARATIONS FILED IN THE D.C. CIRCUIT CASE

Declaration of Dale E. Lebsack Jr. (ECF No. 2062093 Exhibit 1) ........................... 731a

(Select Excerpts) Declaration of John D. Hines (ECF No. 2062093

Exhibit 2)........................................................................................................................... 822a

Declaration of Serena K. Wetherelt (ECF No. 2065869 Exhibit 5) ......................... 851a

ii

APPENDIX A

DECISIONS BELOW

1a

38508

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

CEMS particulatemattercontinuous

ConstitutionAve.NW,Washington,DC. PMemi

ssionmonitoringsystems

ThePublicReadingRoom hoursof

referenceexposurelevel

operationare8:30a.m.to4:30p.m. REL

RFA

RegulatoryFlexibilityAct

EasternStandardTime(EST),Monday RIA Re

gulatoryImpactAnalysis

t

hr

o

ug

h

Fr

i

da

y

.

The

t

e

l

e

pho

ne

numb

e

r

[EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794;FRL–6716.3– forthePublicReadingRoom is(202) RIN RegulatoryInformationNumber

02–OAR]

RTR residualriskandtechnologyreview

5

6

6

–

1

7

4

4

,

a

nd

t

he

t

e

l

e

pho

ne

numb

e

r

f

o

r

SC–

alcostofcarbon

2 soci

RIN2060–AV53

theEPADocketCenteris(202)566– SO2COsul

furdioxide

TBtu trillionBritishthermalunitsofheat

1742.

NationalEmissionStandardsfor

input

NFORMATIONCONTACT:For tpy

HazardousAirPollutants:Coal-and FORFURTHERI

peryear

questionsaboutthisfinalactioncontact UMRAtonsUnf

Oil-FiredElectricUtilitySteam

undedMandatesReform Act

SarahBenish,SectorPoliciesand

GeneratingUnitsReviewofthe

We

b

FI

RE

We

ProgramsDivision(D243–01),Officeof System bFactorInformationRetrieval

ResidualRiskandTechnologyReview Ai

rQualityPlanningandStandards,

ckgroundinformation.OnApril24,

AGENCY:EnvironmentalProtection

U.

S.

EnvironmentalProtectionAgency, 20Ba

2

3

,theEPAproposedrevisionstothe

Agency(EPA).

P.

O.

Bo

x

1

2

0

5

5

,

Re

s

e

a

r

c

h

Tr

i

a

ng

l

e

Pa

r

k

,

Co

a

l

andOil-FiredEGUNESHAPbased

ACTION:Finalrule.

NorthCarolina27711;telephone

o

n

o

ur

eview ofthe2020RTR.Inthis

number:(919)541–5620;andemail action,rwe

SUMMARY:Thisactionfinalizes

arefinalizingrevisionstothe

ddress:benish.sarah@epa.gov.

amendmentstothenationalemission aSUPPLEMENTARYI

r

ul

e

,

c

o

mmo

nlyknownastheMercury

NFORMATION:

standardsforhazardousairpollutants Preambleacrony

a

nd

Ai

r

To

x

i

csStandards(MATS).We

msand

(NESHAP)fortheCoal-andOil-Fired abbreviations.Weus

s

umma

r

i

z

e

s

o

meofthemoresignificant

tiple

ElectricUtilitySteam GeneratingUnits acronymsandtermsienmul

c

o

mme

nt

s

r

e

g

ngtheproposedrule

spreamble. thatwerereceaivrdi

(EGUs)sourcecategory.Thesefinal Whilethislistmaynotbthi

e

d

duringthepublic

eexhaustive,to commentperiodand

amendmentsaretheresultoftheEPA’s easethereadingofthispr

ovideour

eambleandfor responsesinthispreapr

review ofthe2020ResidualRiskand referencepurposes,theEPA

mb

.Asummary

definesthe ofallotherpubliccommelent

TechnologyReview (RTR).Thechanges, followingtermsandacronyms

sonthe

here: proposalandtheEPA’srespo

whichwereproposedunderthe

nsesto

APH airpreheater

technologyreview inApril2023,

t

ho

s

e

c

o

mme

nt

s

i

s

a

v

a

i

l

a

b

l

e

i

n

National

Btu BritishThermalUnits

includeamendingthefilterable

Emi

s

s

i

o

n

St

a

nda

r

ds

f

o

r

Ha

z

a

r

do

usAir

CAA CleanAirAct

particulatematter(fPM)surrogate

Po

l

l

ut

a

nt

s

:

Co

a

l

a

nd

Oi

l

F

i

r

e

d

El

ric

CEMS continuousemissionmonitoring UtilitySteam GeneratingUnitsReevcit

emissionstandardfornon-mercury

ew

s

y

s

t

e

m

metalhazardousairpollutants(HAP)for EGU electricutilitysteam generatingunit oftheResidualRiskandTechnology

existingcoal-firedEGUs,thefPM

ReviewProposedRuleResponseto

EIA EnergyInformationAdministration Co

emissionstandardcompliance

mments,DocketIDNo.EPA–HQ–

ESP electrostaticprecipitator

demonstrationrequirements,andthe FF fabricfilter

OAR–2018–0794.A‘‘trackchanges’’

fluegasdesulfurization

mercury(Hg)emissionstandardfor fFGD

versionoftheregulatorylanguagethat

PM filterableparticulatematter

lignite-firedEGUs.Additionally,the GWh

i

ncorporatesthechangesinthisaction

gigawatt-hour

EPAisfinalizingachangetothe

i

savailableinthedocket.

hazardousairpollutant(s)

Organizationofthisdocument.The

definitionof‘‘startup.’’TheEPAdidnot HAP

HCl

hy

dr

o

g

e

n

c

hl

o

r

i

de

i

nf

ormationinthispreambleis

propose,andisnotfinalizing,any

HF hydrogenfluoride

o

r

g

anizedasfollows:

changestothe2020ResidualRisk

Hg0 mercury

Review.

Hg2+ elementalHgvapor

I.GeneralInformation

Hg divalentHg

A.ExecutiveSummary

DATES:ThisfinalruleiseffectiveonJuly Hg

Cl2 mercuricchloride

B.Doesthisactionapplytome?

8,2024.Theincorporationbyreference Hg

particulateboundHg

C.WherecanIgetacopyofthisdocument

ofcertainmateriallistedintherulewas HQp ha

dquotient

andotherrelatedinformation?

approvedbytheDirectoroftheFederal ICR Infzoarrma

t

i

o

n

Co

l

l

e

c

t

i

o

n

Re

q

ue

s

t

D.

JudicialReview andAdministrative

RegisterasofApril16,2012.

IGCC integratedgasificationcombined

Reconsideration

ADDRESSES:TheU.S.Environmental

II.Background

ProtectionAgency(EPA)hasestablished IPMcyclIentegratedPlanningModel

A.Whatistheauthorityforthisaction?

InflationReductionAct

B.WhatistheCoal-andOil-FiredEGU

adocketforthisactionunderDocketID IlRA

b pounds

sourcecategoryandhow doesthe

No.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794.All LEE

ttingEGU

NESHAPregulateHAPemissionsfrom

documentsinthedocketarelistedon MACTlowmaemi

ximum achievablecontrol

thesourcecategory?

thehttps://www.regulations.gov

t

e

c

hno

l

o

g

y

C.

Summaryofthe2020ResidualRisk

website.Althoughlisted,some

MATS

Me

r

c

ur

y

a

nd

Ai

r

To

x

i

c

s

St

a

nda

r

ds

Re

view

informationisnotpubliclyavailable, MMacf millionactualcubicfeet

D.

Summa

ryofthe2020Technology

e.g.,ConfidentialBusinessInformation MMBtu millionBritishthermalunitsof

Re

v

i

e

w

orotherinformationwhosedisclosureis heatinput

E.SummaryoftheEPA’sReview ofthe

restrictedbystatute.Certainother

MW megawatt

2020RTRandthe2023Proposed

CS NorthAmericanIndustry

RevisionstotheNESHAP

material,suchascopyrightedmaterial, NAI

ClassificationSystem

III.Whatisincludedinthisfinalrule?

isnotplacedontheinternetandwillbe NESHAP

nationalemissionstandardsfor A.Whatarethefinalruleamendments

publiclyavailableonlyinhardcopy

ha

z

a

r

do

us

airpollutants

basedonthetechnologyreview forthe

form.Publiclyavailabledocket

NOX nitrogenoxides

Coal-andOil-FiredEGUsource

materialsareavailableeither

NRECA

Na

t

i

o

na

l

Rur

a

l

El

e

c

t

r

i

c

Co

o

pe

r

a

t

i

v

e

category?

electronicallythroughhttps://

As

s

o

c

i

a

t

i

o

n

B.

Whatotherchangeshavebeenmadeto

www.regulations.gov,orinhardcopyat OMB OfficeofManagementandBudget

t

heNESHAP?

theEPADocketCenter,WJCWest

PM particulatematter

C.Whataretheeffectiveandcompliance

Building,Room Number3334,1301 PM2.5 fineparticulatematter

datesofthestandards?

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTION

AGENCY

40CFRPart63

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00002 Fmt4702a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38509

A.ExecutiveOrder12866:Regulatory

IV.Whatistherationaleforourfinal

revise’’thosestandardsevery8years

PlanningandReview andExecutive

decisionsandamendmentstothe

‘asnecessary(takingintoaccount

Order14094:ModernizingRegulatory ‘

filterablePM (asasurrogatefornon-Hg

de

velopmentsinpractices,processes,

Review

HAPmetals)standardandcompliance

a

nd

controltechnologies).’’Id.

B.PaperworkReductionAct(PRA)

optionsfrom the2020Technology

7412(d)(6).

C.RegulatoryFlexibilityAct(RFA)

Review?

OnJanuary20,2021,PresidentBiden

A.WhatdidweproposepursuanttoCAA D.UnfundedMandatesReform Act

s

i

g

nedExecutiveOrder13990,

(UMRA)

Section112(d)(6)fortheCoal-andOil‘‘ProtectingPublicHealthandthe

E.ExecutiveOrder13132:Federalism

FiredEGUsourcecategory?

B.How didthetechnologyreview change F.ExecutiveOrder13175:Consultation EnvironmentandRestoringScienceto

andCoordinationWithIndianTribal TackletheClimateCrisis’’(86FR7037;

fortheCoal-andOil-FiredEGUsource

Governments

category?

anuary25,2021).Theexecutiveorder,

C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon G.ExecutiveOrder13045:Protectionof J

a

ngotherthings,instructedtheEPA

ChildrenFrom EnvironmentalHealth tomo

thefilterablePM andcompliance

r

e

view the2020finalruletitled

RisksandSafetyRisks

options,andwhatareourresponses?

NationalEmissionStandardsfor

H.ExecutiveOrder13211:Actions

D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal

HazardousAirPollutants:Coal-and

ConcerningRegulationsThat

approachanddecisionsforthefilterable

Oil-FiredElectricUtilitySteam

SignificantlyAffectEnergySupply,

PM (asasurrogatefornon-HgHAP

GeneratingUnits—Reconsiderationof

Distribution,orUse

metals)standardandcompliance

SupplementalFindingandResidual

I.NationalTechnologyTransferand

demonstrationoptions?

AdvancementAct(NTTAA)and1CFR RiskandTechnologyReview(85FR

V.Whatistherationaleforourfinal

Part51

decisionsandamendmentstotheHg

1286;May22,2020)(2020Final

emissionstandardforlignite-firedEGUs J.ExecutiveOrder12898:FederalActions 3

Ac

tion)andtoconsiderpublishinga

ToAddressEnvironmentalJusticein not

from review ofthe2020Technology

iceofproposedrulemaking

MinorityPopulationsandLow-Income suspe

Review?

nding,revising,orrescindingthat

PopulationsandExecutiveOrder14096: ction.

A.WhatdidweproposepursuanttoCAA

The2020FinalActionincluded

RevitalizingOurNation’sCommitment a

section112(d)(6)forthelignite-fired

twoparts:(1)afindingthatitisnot

toEnvironmentalJusticeforAll

EGUsubcategory?

appropriateandnecessarytoregulate

B.How didthetechnologyreview change K.CongressionalReview Act(CRA)

coal-andoil-firedEGUsunderCAA

forthelignite-firedEGUsubcategory? I.GeneralInformation

section112;and(2)theRTRforthe

C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon

theHgemissionstandardforlignite-fired A.ExecutiveSummary

2012MATSFinalRule.

EGUs,andwhatareourresponses?

TheEPAreviewedbothpartsofthe

1.BackgroundandPurposeofthe

D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal

2

0

20FinalAction.Theresultsofthe

approachanddecisionsforthelignite- RegulatoryAction

EPA’

sreview ofthefirstpart,findingit

firedEGUHgstandard?

sappropriateandnecessarytoregulate

Exposuretohazardousairpollutants iEGUs

VI.Whatistherationaleforourotherfinal (‘‘HAP,

rCAAsection112,were

sometimesknownastoxicair oposunde

decisionsandamendmentsfrom review pollutio’’

edonFebruary9,2022(87FR

n,includingHg,chromium, pr

ofthe2020TechnologyReview?

624)(2022Proposal)andfinalizedon

A.WhatdidweproposepursuanttoCAA arsenic,andlead)cancausearangeof 7

March6,2023(88FR13956).Inthe

section112(d)(6)fortheotherNESHAP adversehealtheffectsincluding

2022Proposal,theEPAalsosolicited

requirements?

harmingpeople’scentralnervous

B.How didthetechnologyreview change system;damagetotheirkidneys;and informationontheperformanceand

fortheotherNESHAPrequirements?

ostofnew orimprovedtechnologies

ancer.Theseadverseeffectscanbe ctha

C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon c

tcontrolHAPemissions,improved

pa

r

t

i

c

ul

a

r

l

y

a

c

ut

e

f

o

r

c

o

mmuni

t

i

e

s

theotherNESHAPrequirements,and livingnearsourcesofHAP.Recognizing met

hodsofoperation,andrisk-related

whatareourresponses?

i

nf

o

rmationtofurtherinform theEPA’s

t

he

da

ng

e

r

s

po

s

e

d

b

y

HAP,

Co

ng

r

e

s

s

D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal

eview ofthesecondpart,the2020

nactedCleanAirAct(CAA)section rMATS

approachanddecisionsregardingthe e

RTR.TheEPAproposed

112.UnderCAAsection112,theEPA mendme

otherNESHAPrequirements?

ntstotheRTRonApril24,

VII.StartupDefinitionfortheCoal-andOil- isrequiredtosetstandardsbasedon a

2023(88FR24854)(2023Proposal)and

FiredEGUSourceCategory

ma

x

i

mum

a

c

hi

e

v

a

b

l

e

c

o

nt

r

o

l

thisactionfinalizesthoseamendments

A.WhatdidweproposefortheCoal-and technology(knownas‘‘MACT’’

Oil-FiredEGUsourcecategory?

a

ndpresentsthefinalresultsofthe

1ofHAP

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

)

f

o

r

ma

j

o

r

s

o

ur

c

e

s

B.How didthestartupprovisionschange that‘‘requirethemaximum degreeof EPA’sreview oftheMATSRTR.

fortheCoal-andOil-FiredEGUsource reductioninemissionsofthehazardous 2.SummaryofMajorProvisionsofthe

category?

irpollutants...(includinga

gulatoryAction

C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceiveon a

prohibitiononsuchemissions,where ReCo

thestartupprovisions,andwhatareour a

al-andoil-firedEGUsremainone

chievable)thattheAdministrator,

responses?

fthelargestdomesticemittersofHg

takingintoconsiderationthecostof oand

D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal

manyotherHAP,includingmanyof

approachandfinaldecisionsforthe

achievingsuchemissionreduction,and theno

n-HgHAPmetals—including

startupprovisions?

a

ny

no

na

i

r

q

ua

l

i

t

y

he

a

l

t

h

a

nd

l

e

a

d,

a

rsenic,chromium,nickel,and

VIII.Whatotherkeycommentsdidwe

environmentalimpactsandenergy

cadmium—andhydrogenchloride

receiveontheproposal?

r

e

q

ui

r

e

me

nt

s

,

de

t

e

r

mi

ne

s

i

s

IX.SummaryofCost,Environmental,and achievable.’’42U.S.C.7412(d)(2).The (HCl).ExposuretotheseHAP,atcertain

EconomicImpactsandAdditional

ation,isassociatedwith

EPAisfurtherrequiredto‘‘review,and laevvaerliseatyndofdur

AnalysesConducted

a

dv

ersehealtheffects.Inthe

A.Whataretheaffectedfacilities?

2

0

1

2

MATS

Fi

na

lRule,theEPA

1

The

t

e

r

m

‘

‘

ma

j

o

r

s

o

ur

c

e

’

’

me

a

ns

a

ny

s

t

a

t

i

o

na

r

y

B.Whataretheairqualityimpacts?

e

s

t

a

b

l

i

s

he

d

nume

ricalstandardsforHg,

s

o

ur

c

e

o

r

g

r

o

up

o

f

s

t

a

t

i

o

na

r

y

s

o

ur

c

e

s

l

o

c

a

t

e

d

wi

t

hi

n

C.Whatarethecostimpacts?

acontiguousareaandundercommoncontrolthat non-HgHAPmetals,andacidgasHAP

D.Whataretheeconomicimpacts?

emitsorhasthepotentialtoemitconsidering

sionsfrom coal-andoil-firedEGUs.

E.Whatarethebenefits?

rols,intheaggregate,10tonsperyearormore emisEPA

alsoestablishedworkpractice

F.Whatanalysisofenvironmentaljustice ocofnt

anyhazardousairpollutantor25tonsperyear The

standardsforemissionsoforganicHAP.

didweconduct?

ormoreofanycombinationofhazardousair

X.StatutoryandExecutiveOrderReviews pollutants.42U.S.C.7412(a)(1).

Toaddressemissionsofnon-HgHAP

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00003 Fmt4703a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38510

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

metals,theEPAestablishedindividual thesurroundingcommunities;andreal- sulfurdioxide(SO2)emissionstandard),

emissionlimits2foreachofthe10non- timeidentificationofwhencontrol whichservesasasurrogateforallacid

HgHAPmetals emittedfrom coal-and technologiesarenotperformingas

gasHAP(HCl,hydrogenfluoride(HF),

oil-firedEGUs.Alternatively,affected expected,allowingforquickerrepairs. selenium dioxide(SeO2))forexisting

Afterconsideringupdatedinformation coal-firedEGUs.TheEPAproposedto

sourcescouldmeetanemission

standardfor‘‘totalnon-HgHAPmetals’’ onthecostsforquarterlyperformance requirePM CEMSforexistingintegrated

bysummingtheemissionratesofeach testingcomparedtothecostsofPM

asificationcombinedcycle(IGCC)

ofthenon-HgHAPmetalsormeetafPM CEMSandthemeasurementcapabilities gEGUs

butisnotfinalizingthis

emissionstandardasasurrogateforthe ofPM CEMS,aswellasthemany

r

e

q

ui

r

e

ntduetotechnicalissues

non-HgHAPmetals.Forexistingcoal- benefitsofusingPM CEMS,theEPAis calibratme

i

ng

CEMSonthesetypesof

finalizing,asproposed,arequirement EGUsandthe

firedEGUs,almosteveryunithas

relatedfactthatfPM

chosentodemonstratecompliancewith thatallcoal-andoil-firedEGUs

e

mi

s

s

i

o

ns

f

r

o

m

IGCCsareverylow.

thenon-HgHAPmetalssurrogatefPM demonstratecompliancewiththe

finalstandards,as

I

n

e

s

t

a

b

l

i

s

hi

ng

emissionstandardof0.030pounds(lb) revisedfPM emissionstandardbyusing discussedindetaitlhe

i

n

ctionsIV.,V.,

offPM permillionBritishthermalunits PM CEMS.AstheEPAexplainedinthe VI.,andVII.ofthispresaemb

EPA

2023Proposal,byrequiringfacilitiesto consideredthestatutorydirleec,ttihe

ofheatinput(lb/MMBtu).

o

n

and

PursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), usePM CEMS,thecurrentcompliance

utbyCongressinCAA

theEPArevieweddevelopmentsinthe methodfortheLEEprogram becomes sfaeccttoiorsnl1a1id2.oSe

rately,pursuantto

costsofcontroltechnologies,andthe superfluoussinceLEEisanoptional ExecutiveOrdepa

r12866andExecutive

effectivenessofthosetechnologies,as program inwhichstacktestingoccurs Order14904,the

preparedan

wellasthecostsofmeetingafPM

infrequently,andtherevisedfPM limit lysisofthepoEPA

tentialcostsand

emissionstandardthatismorestringent isbelow thecurrentfPM LEEprogram abna

enefitsassociatedwiththisaction.

than0.030lb/MMBtuandtheother limit.Therefore,theEPAisfinalizing, Thi

lysis,RegulatoryImpact

statutoryfactors.Basedonthatreview, asproposed,theremovalofthefPM LEE Anaslyasna

isfortheFinalNationalEmission

theEPAisfinalizing,asproposed,a program.

rdsforHazardousAirPollutants:

Basedoncommentsreceivedduring Staanda

revisednon-HgHAPmetalsurrogate

l-andOil-FiredElectricUtility

fPM emissionstandardforallexisting thepubliccommentperiod,theEPAis Co

coal-firedEGUsof0.010lb/MMBtu. notremoving,butinsteadrevisingthe Steam GeneratingUnitsReviewofthe

ResidualRiskandTechnologyReview

Thisstrengthenedstandardwillensure alternativeemissionlimitsforthe

thattheentirefleetofcoal-firedEGUs individualnon-HgHAPmetalssuchas (Ref.EPA–452/R–24–005),isavailable

lead,arsenic,chromium,nickel,and inthedocket,andisbrieflysummarized

isperformingatthefPM pollution

controllevelscurrentlyachievedbythe cadmium andforthetotalnon-HgHAP insectionsI.A.3.andIX.ofthis

vastmajorityofregulatedunits.The metalsproportionaltothefinalized4fPM preamble.

emissionlimitof0.010lb/MMBtu.

EPAfurtherconcludesthatitisthe

lowestlevelcurrentlycompatiblewith OwnersandoperatorsofEGUsseeking 3.CostsandBenefits

theuseofPM CEMSfordemonstrating tousethesealternativestandardsmust InaccordancewithExecutiveOrder

compliance.

requestandreceiveapprovaltousea 12866and14094,theEPAprepareda

Relatedly,theEPAisalsofinalizinga HAPmetalcontinuousmonitoring

RegulatoryImpactAnalysis(RIA).The

revisiontotherequirementsfor

system (CMS)asanalternativetest

RIApresentsestimatesoftheemission,

demonstratingcompliancewiththe methodunder40CFR63.7(f).

cost,andbenefitimpactsofthisfinal

revisedfPM emissionstandard.

TheEPAisalsofinalizing,as

rulemakingforthe2028to2037period;

Currently,affectedEGUsthatdonot proposed,amoreprotectiveHg

seestimatesaresummarizedinthis

qualifyforthelow3 emittingEGU(LEE) emissionstandardforexistinglignite- tsho

e

c

t

program forfPM candemonstrate

firedEGUs,requiringthatsuchlignite- ion.

firedEGUsmeetthesameHgemission Thepowerindustry’scompliance

compliancewiththefPM standard

standardasEGUsfiringothertypesof costsarerepresentedintheRIAasthe

eitherbyconductingquarterly

projectedchangeinelectricpower

performancetesting(i.e.,quarterlystack coal(i.e.,bituminousand

testing)orbyusingparticulatematter subbituminous),whichis1.2lbofHg generationcostsbetweenthebaseline

(PM)continuousemissionmonitoring pertrillionBritishthermalunitsofheat andfinalrulescenarios.Thequantified

systems(PM CEMS).PM CEMSconfer input(lb/TBtu)oranalternativeoutput- emissionestimatespresentedintheRIA

significantbenefits,includingincreased basedstandardof0.013lbpergigawatt- includechangesinpollutantsdirectly

coveredbythisrule,suchasHgand

hour(lb/GWh).Finally,theEPAis

transparencyregardingemissions

performanceforsources,regulators,and finalizing,asproposed,theremovalof non-HgHAPmetals,andchangesin

thesecondoptionfordefiningthe

otherpollutantsemittedfrom thepower

2Thet

ennon-HgHAPmetalsareantimony,

up

pe

r

i

o

d

f

o

r

MATSa

f

f

e

c

t

e

d

EGUs

.

s

t

a

r

t

sectorduetothecomplianceactions

arsenic,beryllium,cadmium,chromium,cobalt,

TheEPAdidnotproposeandisnot projectedunderthisfinalrule.The

lead,manganese,nickel,andselenium.

inalizingmodificationstotheHCl

cumulativeprojectednational-level

3I

nordertoqualifyforfPM LEEstatus,anEGU f

emissionstandard(northealternative emissionsreductionsoverthe2028to

mustdemonstratethatitsfPM emissionrateis

2037periodunderthefinalized

below 50percentofstandard(or0.015lb/MMBtu) 4

Theemissionlimitsfortheindividualnon-Hg requirementsarepresentedintable1.

from quarterlystacktestsfor3consecutiveyears.

HAPmetalsandthetotalnon-HgHAPmetalshave

OnceasourceachievesLEEstatusforfPM,the

supportingdetailsforthese

sourcemustconductstacktestingevery3yearsto beenreducedbytwo-thirds,consistentwiththe The

demonstratethatitsemissionrateremainsbelow 50 revisionofthefPM emissionlimitfrom 0.030lb/ estimatescanbefoundintheRIA.

percentofthestandard.

MMBtuto0.010lb/MMBtu.

BILLING CODE 6560–50–P

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00004 Fmt4704a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38511

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00005 Fmt4705a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

ER07MY24.065</GPH>

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

benefitsareunmonetizedandarethus limitations,theEPAisalsounableto

TheEPAexpectsthatemission

reductionsunderthefinalrulemaking notdirectlyreflectedinthequantified quantifypotentialemissionsimpactsor

willresultinreducedexposuretoHg netbenefitestimates(seesectionIX.B. monetizepotentialbenefitsfrom

andnon-HgHAPmetals.TheEPAalso inthispreambleandsection4ofthe continuousmonitoringrequirements.

projectshealthbenefitsdueto

RIAformoredetails).Inparticular,

Thepresentvalue(PV)andequivalent

improvementsinparticulatematterwith estimatingtheeconomicbenefitsof annua

ue(EAV)ofcosts,benefits,

adiameterof2.5micrometersorless reducedexposuretoHAPgenerallyhas andneltvbaelne

fitsofthisrulemakingover

(PM2.5)andozoneandclimatebenefits pr

o

v

e

n

di

f

f

i

c

ul

t

f

o

r

a

numb

e

r

o

f

r

e

a

s

o

ns

:

t

he

2

0

2

8

t

o

2

riodin2019dollars

from reductionsincarbondioxide(CO2) itisdifficulttoundertakeepidemiologic areshownin0t3ab7lpe

e2.Inthistable,

emissions.TheEPAalsoanticipates studiesthathavesufficientpowerto resultsarepresent

edusinga2percent

benefitsfrom theincreasedtransparency quantifytherisksassociatedwithHAP discountrate.Resul

tsunderother

tothepublic,theassurancethat

exposuresexperiencedbyU.S.

discountratesandsupportingdetailsfor

standardsarebeingmetcontinuously, po

pul

a

t

i

o

ns

o

n

a

da

i

l

y

b

a

s

i

s

;

da

t

a

us

e

d

theestimatescanbefoundintheRIA.

andtheacceleratedidentificationof oestimateexposuresincritical

anomalousemissionsduetorequiring tmi

croenvironmentsarelimited;and

PM CEMSinthisfinalrule.

t

he

reremainsinsufficienteconomic di

HAPemissionsfrom coal-andoil-firedEGUsand

TheEPAestimatesnegativenet

scussiononthelimitationstomonetizingand

t

i

o

n

o

f

HAP

r

e

s

e

a

r

c

h

t

o

s

uppo

r

t

v

a

l

ua

quantifyingbenefitsfrom HAPreductions.Seealso

monetizedbenefitsofthisrule(seetable benefitsmadeevenmorechallengingby Na

onalEmissionStandardsforHazardousAir

2below).However,thebenefitestimates thewidearrayofHAPandpossible Poltliut

nts:Coal-andOil-FiredElectricUtility

informingthisresultrepresentonlya HAPeffects.5Inaddition,duetodata SteamaGe

neratingUnits—Revocationofthe2020

partialaccountingofthepotential

Re

c

o

ns

i

de

rationandAffirmationoftheAppropriate

5Seesect

benefitsofthisfinalrule.Several

ionII.B.2.fordiscussionofthepublic andNecessarySupplementalFinding,88FR13956,

categoriesofhumanwelfareandclimate healthandenvironmentalhazardsassociatedwith 13970–73(March6,2023).

38512

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

Court)byJuly8,2024.UnderCAA

C.WherecanIgetacopyofthis

TheEPAnotesthatanalysisofsuch documentandotherrelated

section307(b)(2),therequirements

impactsisdistinctfrom the

information?

establishedbythisfinalrulemaynotbe

determinationsfinalizedinthisaction Inadditiontobeingavailableinthe challengedseparatelyinanycivilor

underCAAsection112,whichare

riminalproceedingsbroughtbythe

cket,anelectroniccopyofthisfinal cEPA

basedonthestatutoryfactorstheEPA do

toenforcetherequirements.

a

c

t

i

o

n

wi

l

l

a

l

s

o

b

e

a

v

a

i

l

a

b

l

e

o

n

t

he

discussesinsectionII.A.andsections internet.Followingsignaturebythe

Section307(d)(7)(B)oftheCAA

IV.throughVII.below.

therprovidesthatonlyanobjection

EPAAdministrator,theEPAwillposta ftur

oaruleorprocedurethatwasraised

copyofthisfinalactionat:https://

B.Doesthisactionapplytome?

withreasonablespecificityduringthe

www.epa.gov/stationary-sources-air- pe

riodforpubliccomment(including

Regulatedentities.Thesource

po

l

l

ut

i

o

n/

me

r

c

ur

y

a

nda

i

r

t

o

x

i

c

s

categorythatisthesubjectofthisaction standards.Followingpublicationinthe anypublichearing)mayberaised

iscoal-andoil-firedEGUsregulatedby deralRegister,theEPAwillpostthe duringjudicialreview.Thissectionalso

providesamechanism fortheEPAto

NESHAPunder40CFRpart63,subpart Fe

deralRegisterversionandkey

reconsidertheruleifthepersonraising

UUUUU,commonlyknownasMATS. Fe

t

e

c

hni

c

a

l

do

c

ume

nt

s

a

t

t

hi

s

s

a

me

anobjectioncandemonstratetothe

TheNorthAmericanIndustry

bsite.

Administratorthatitwasimpracticable

ClassificationSystem (NAICS)codesfor weAddi

t

i

o

na

l

i

nf

o

r

ma

t

i

o

n

i

s

a

v

a

i

l

a

b

l

e

o

n

toraisesuchobjectionwithintheperiod

thecoal-andoil-firedEGUsource

t

he

RTR

we

b

s

i

t

e

a

t

ht

t

ps

:

/

/

forpubliccommentorifthegroundsfor

categoryare221112,221122,and

www.

e

pa

.

g

o

v

/

s

t

a

t

i

o

na

r

y

s

o

ur

c

e

s

a

i

r

921150.ThislistofNAICScodesisnot pollution/risk-and-technology-review- suchobjectionaroseaftertheperiodfor

publiccomment(butwithinthetime

intendedtobeexhaustive,butratherto tional-emissions-standardsspecifiedforjudicialreview)andifsuch

provideaguideforreadersregarding na

ha

z

a

r

do

us

.

Thi

s

i

nf

o

r

ma

t

i

o

n

i

nc

l

ude

s

entitieslikelytobeaffectedbythefinal anoverview oftheRTRprogram and objectionisofcentralrelevancetothe

actionforthesourcecategorylisted.To linkstoprojectwebsitesfortheRTR outcomeoftherule.Anypersonseeking

tomakesuchademonstrationshould

determinewhetheryourfacilityis

sourcecategories.

ubmitaPetitionforReconsiderationto

affected,youshouldexaminethe

D.JudicialReviewandAdministrative tshe

OfficeoftheAdministrator,U.S.

applicabilitycriteriaintheappropriate Re

consideration

EPA,Room 3000,WJCSouthBuilding,

NESHAP.Ifyouhaveanyquestions

regardingtheapplicabilityofanyaspect UnderCAAsection307(b)(1),judicial 1200PennsylvaniaAve.,NW,

review ofthisfinalactionisavailable Washington,DC20460,withacopyto

ofthisNESHAP,pleasecontactthe

onlybyfilingapetitionforreview in boththeperson(s)listedinthe

appropriatepersonlistedinthe

precedingFORFURTHERINFORMATION theUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfor precedingFORFURTHERINFORMATION

theDistrictofColumbiaCircuit(the CONTACTsection,andtheAssociate

CONTACTsectionofthispreamble.

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00006 Fmt4706a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

ER07MY24.066</GPH>

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

BILLING CODE 6560–50–C

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38513

NESHAPmustreflect‘‘themaximum 1084(D.C.Cir.2008);Associationof

GeneralCounselfortheAirand

RadiationLaw Office,OfficeofGeneral degreeofreductioninemissionsofthe BatteryRecyclers,Inc.v.EPA,716F.3d

Counsel(MailCode2344A),U.S.EPA, [HAP]subjecttothissection(including 667(D.C.Cir.2013).TheEPAmay

aprohibitiononsuchemissions,where considercostindecidingwhetherto

1200PennsylvaniaAve.NW,

achievable)thattheAdministrator, revisethestandardspursuanttoCAA

Washington,DC20460.

t

akingintoconsiderationthecostof section112(d)(6).Seee.g.,Nat’lAss’n

II.Background

achievingsuchemissionreduction,and forSurfaceFinishing,v.EPA,795F.3d

A.Whatisthestatutoryauthorityfor anynonairqualityhealthand

1,11(D.C.Cir.2015).TheEPAis

thisaction?

environmentalimpactsandenergy

requiredtoaddressregulatorygaps,

requirements,determinesis

suchasmissingMACTstandardsfor

1.StatutoryLanguage

a

c

hi

e

v

a

b

l

e

.

’

’

(

e

mpha

s

i

s

a

dde

d)

.

The

s

e

airtoxicsknowntobeemitted

Thestatutoryauthorityforthisaction standardsarecommonlyreferredtoas lfirsotmedthe

sourcecategory.Louisiana

isprovidedbysections112and301of MACTstandards.CAAsection112(d)(3) Environme

alActionNetwork(LEAN)

theCAA,asamended(42U.S.C.7401et establishesaminimum controllevelfor v.EPA,955nt

F.

3d1088(D.C.Cir.2020).

seq.).Section112oftheCAA

MACT

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

,

k

no

wn

a

s

t

he

MACT

The

r

e

s

i

dua

l

r

i

skreview andthe

6I

establishesamulti-stageregulatory

f

l

o

o

r

.

’

’

‘

‘

n

c

e

r

t

a

i

n

i

ns

t

a

nc

e

s

,

a

s

t

e

c

hno

l

o

g

y

r

e

v

iew aredistinct

processtodevelopstandardsfor

pr

o

v

i

de

d

i

n

CAA

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

1

1

2

(

h)

,

t

he

r

e

q

ui

r

e

me

nt

s

a

ndarebothmandatory.

emissionsofHAPfrom stationary

I

n

t

hi

s

a

c

t

i

o

n,

theEPAisfinalizing

EPA

ma

y

s

e

t

wo

r

k

pr

a

c

t

i

c

e

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

i

n

sources.Generally,duringthefirst

a

me

ndme

nt

s

t

o

t

heMACTstandards

l

i

e

u

o

f

nume

r

i

c

a

l

e

mi

s

s

i

o

n

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

.

stage,CongressdirectedtheEPAto

b

a

s

e

d

o

n

t

wo

i

nde

ndentsourcesof

The

EPA

mus

t

a

l

s

o

c

o

ns

i

de

r

c

o

nt

r

o

l

establishtechnology-basedstandardsto optionsthataremorestringentthanthe authority:(1)itsrepe

v

i

e

the2020

ensurethatallmajorsourcescontrol floor.Standardsmorestringentthanthe FinalAction’sriskandwtoecfhno

logy

HAPemissionsatthelevelachievedby floorarecommonlyreferredtoas

r

e

v

i

e

w

pur

s

ua

nt

t

o

t

he

EPA’

s

s

ory

thebest-performingsources,referredto ‘‘beyond-the-floor’’standards.Forarea authorityunderCAAsection1t1a2t,ut

a

nd

astheMACT.Afterthefirststage,

(

2

)

t

he

EPA’

s

i

nhe

r

e

nt

a

ut

ho

r

i

t

y

t

o

s

o

ur

c

e

s

,

CAA

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

1

1

2

(

d)

(

5

)

a

l

l

o

ws

CongressdirectedtheEPAtoreview theEPAtosetstandardsbasedon

reconsiderpreviousdecisionsandto

thosestandardsperiodicallyto

r

evise,replace,orrepealadecisionto

g

e

ne

r

a

l

l

y

a

v

a

i

l

a

b

l

e

c

o

nt

r

o

l

t

e

c

hno

l

o

g

i

e

s

determinewhethertheyshouldbe

t

he

extentpermittedbylaw and

o

r

ma

na

g

e

me

nt

pr

a

c

t

i

c

e

s

(

GACT

7 support

strengthened.Within8yearsafter

yareasonedexplanation.

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

)

i

n

l

i

e

u

o

f

MACT

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

.

promulgationofthestandards,theEPA Forcategoriesofmajorsourcesand FCCv.FeodxbTe

ations,Inc.,556

mustevaluatetheMACTstandardsto anyareasourcecategoriessubjectto U.S.502,515(l2ev0i0s9io);nseSt

e

alsoMotor

determinewhethertheemission

MACT

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

,

t

he

ne

x

t

s

t

a

g

e

i

n

Ve

hi

c

l

e

Mf

r

s

.

As

s

’

n

v

.

St

a

Farm

standardsshouldberevisedtoaddress standard-settingfocusesonidentifying MutualAuto.Ins.Co.,463teU.

S.29,42

anyremainingriskassociatedwithHAP andaddressinganyremaining(i.e., (1983).

emissions.Thissecondstageis

l’’)riskpursuanttoCAA

2.StatutoryStructureandLegislative

commonlyreferredtoasthe‘‘residual ‘s‘ercetsiiodua

n

1

1

2

(

f

)

(

2

)

.

The

r

e

s

i

dua

l

r

i

s

k

History

riskreview.’’Inaddition,theCAAalso iew requirestheEPAtoupdate

Inadditiontothetextofthespecific

requirestheEPAtoreview standardsset rsetavnda

ifneededtoprovideanample sub

sectionsofCAAsection112

underCAAsection112onanongoing marginrds

o

f

s

a

f

e

t

y

t

o

pr

o

t

e

c

t

pub

l

i

c

he

a

l

t

h.

scussedabove,thestatutorystructure

basisnolessthanevery8yearsand

Concurrentwiththatreview,andthen di

revisethestandardsasnecessarytaking atleastevery8yearsthereafter,CAA andlegislativehistoryofCAAsection

thersupporttheEPA’sauthority

intoaccountany‘‘developmentsin

section112(d)(6)requirestheEPAto t1o12tafkur

saction.ThroughoutCAA

practices,processes,andcontrol

review standardspromulgatedunder sectioent1hi

12anditslegislativehistory,

technologies.’’Thisreview iscommonly CAAsection112andrevisethem ‘‘as

Congressmadeclearitsintenttoquickly

referredtoasthe‘‘technologyreview,’’ necessary(takingintoaccount

andistheprimarysubjectofthisfinal developmentsinpractices,processes, securelargereductionsinthevolumeof

rule.Thediscussionthatfollows

andcontroltechnologies).’’SeePortland HAPemissionsfrom stationarysources

identifiesthemostrelevantstatutory CementAss’nv.EPA,665F.3d177,189 basedontechnologicaldevelopmentsin

sectionsandbrieflyexplainsthe

(D.C.Cir.2011)(‘‘ThoughEPAmust controltechnologiesbecauseofits

contoursofthemethodologyusedto review andrevisestandards‘noless recognitionofthehazardstopublic

implementthesestatutoryrequirements. oftenthaneveryeightyears,’42U.S.C. healthandtheenvironmentthatresult

InthefirststageoftheCAAsection

(6),nothingprohibitsEPAfrom from exposuretosuchemissions.CAA

112standard-settingprocess,theEPA r7e4a1s2s(ed)

s

s

ingitsstandardsmoreoften.’’). section112anditslegislativehistory

promulgatestechnology-basedstandards Inconduc

thisreview,whichwe alsorevealCongress’sunderstanding

underCAAsection112(d)forcategories callthe‘‘teticng

hno

eview,’’theEPAis thatfullycharacterizingtherisksposed

ofsourcesidentifiedasemittingoneor notrequiredtorleocgaylcrul

tetheMACT byHAPemissionswasexceedingly

moreoftheHAPlistedinCAAsection floorsthatwereestablisahe

rlier difficult.Thus,Congresspurposefully

112(b).SourcesofHAPemissionsare rulemakings.NaturalResoduricneesaDe

fense replacedaregimethatrequiredtheEPA

eithermajorsourcesorareasources,and Council(NRDC)v.EPA,529F.3d1077, tomakeanassessmentofriskinthefirst

CAAsection112establishesdifferent 6

instance,withoneinwhichCongress

requirementsformajorsourcestandards ‘‘floSpe

cifically,forexistingsources,theMACT

determinedriskexistedanddirectedthe

or’’shallnotbelessstringentthantheaverage EPA tomakeswiftandsubstantial

andareasourcestandards.‘‘Major

ssionreductionachievedbythebestperforming reductionsbaseduponthemost

sources’’arethosethatemitorhavethe 1emi

2

pe

ofexistingsources.42U.S.C.7412(d)(3).

potentialtoemit10tonsperyear(tpy) Fornercwent

sourcesMACTshallnotbelessstringent stringentstandardstechnologycould

rolthatisachievedin

ormoreofasingleHAPor25tpyor thantheemissiobnesctocnt

eve.

ontrolledsimilarsource.Id. achi

moreofanycombinationofHAP.All pra7cFoticrecabtyegthe

Spe

ifically,in1990,Congress

fareasourcessubjecttoGACT radicac

othersourcesare‘‘areasources.’’For standards,theorrieesisono

llytransformedsection112ofthe

r

e

q

ui

r

e

me

nt

t

o

a

ddr

e

s

s

majorsources,CAAsection112(d)(2) residualrisk,but,similartothemajorsource

CAAanditstreatmentofHAPthrough

categories,thetechnologyreview isrequired.

providesthatthetechnology-based

theCleanAirActAmendments,by

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00007 Fmt4707a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38514

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

practicebythebestperformingsources evaluateeveryNESHAPnolessoften

amendingCAAsection112tobea

inthecategoryorsubcategorybasedon thanevery8yearstodeterminewhether

technology-drivenstandardsetting

provisionasopposedtotherisk-based emissionsdataavailabletotheEPAat additionalcontrolisnecessaryafter

onethatCongressinitiallypromulgated thetimeofpromulgation.This

takingintoconsideration

inthe1970CAA.Thelegislativehistory technology-basedapproachenabledthe ‘‘developmentsinpractices,processes,

EPAtoswiftlysetstandardsforsource andcontroltechnologies,’’separatefrom

ofthe1990Amendmentsindicates

categorieswithoutdeterminingtherisk itsobligationtoreview residualrisk.

Congress’sdissatisfactionwiththe

EPA’sslow paceaddressingHAPunder orcostineachspecificcase,astheEPA CAAsection112(f)requirestheEPAto

the1970CAA:‘‘Intheory,[hazardous haddonepriortothe1990

ensurewithin8yearsofpromulgatinga

airpollutants]weretobestringently Amendments.Inotherwords,this

NESHAPthattherisksareacceptable

controlledundertheexistingCleanAir approachtoregulationquicklyrequired andthattheMACTstandardsprovide

Actsection112.However,...only7 thatallmajorsourcesandmanyarea anamplemarginofsafety.

sourcesofHAPmeetanemission

ofthehundredsofpotentially

Thestatutoryrequirementtoestablish

standardconsistentwiththetop

hazardousairpollutantshavebeen

technology-basedstandardsunderCAA

regulatedbyEPAsincesection112was performersineachcategory,whichhad section112eliminatedtherequirement

enactedin1970.’’H.R.Rep.No.101– theeffectofobtainingimmediate

fortheEPAtoidentifyhazardstopublic

490,at315(1990);seealsoid.at151 reductionsinthevolumeofHAP

healthandtheenvironmentinorderto

emissionsfrom stationarysources.The justifyregulationofHAPemissions

(notingthatin20years,theEPA’s

statutoryrequirementthatsources

establishmentofstandardsforonly

rom stationarysources,reflecting

sevenHAPcovered‘‘asmallfractionof obtainlevelsofemissionlimitationthat fCo

ngress’sjudgmentthatsuch

themanysubstancesassociated... haveactuallybeenachievedbyexisting emi

ssionsareinherentlydangerous.See

withcancer,birthdefects,neurological sources,insteadoflevelsthatcould S.Re

p.No.101–228,at148(‘‘The

theoreticallybeachieved,inherently8 MACT

damage,orotherserioushealth

standardsarebasedonthe

reflectsabuilt-incostconsideration. performa

impacts.’’).

nceoftechnology,andnoton

Further,afterdeterminingthe

Inenactingthe1990Amendments

t

he

he

a

l

t

h

environmentaleffectsof

withrespecttothecontrolofHAP, minimum stringencylevelofcontrol,or the[HAP].’a’nd

)

.

The

logyreview

MACTfloor,CAAsection112(d)(2) requiredinCAAsetecctihno

Congressnotedthat‘‘[p]ollutants

o

n

1

12(d)(6)

controlledunder[section112]tendto directstheEPAto‘‘requirethe

f

ur

t

he

r

ma

nda

t

e

s

t

ha

t

t

he

EPA

belesswidespreadthanthoseregulated maximum degreeofreductionin

continuallyreassessstandardsto

[underothersectionsoftheCAA],but emissionsofthehazardousair

determineifadditionalreductionscan

areoftenassociatedwithmoreserious pollutantssubjecttothissection

b

eobtained,withoutevaluatingthe

(includingaprohibitiononsuch

healthimpacts,suchascancer,

s

pe

riskassociatedwiththeHAP

emissions,whereachievable)’’thatthe emicsisfiiocns

neurologicaldisorders,and

thatwouldbereduced.

reproductivedysfunctions.’’Id.at315. EPAdeterminesareachievableafter Notably,Co

ressrequiredtheEPAto

Initssubstantial1990Amendments, consideringthecostofachievingsuch conducttheng

CAA

section112(d)(6)

Congressitselflisted189HAP(CAA standardsandanynon-air-quality

r

e

v

i

e

w

o

f

wha

t

a

ddi

lreductions

section112(b))andsetforthastatutory healthandenvironmentalimpactsand maybeobtainedbasteiodna

o

n

new

energyrequirementsofadditional

structurethatwouldensureswift

t

e

c

hno

l

o

g

y

e

v

e

n

a

f

t

e

r

t

he

EPA

s

regulationofasignificantmajorityof control.Indoingso,thestatutefurther conductedtheone-timeCAAsha

e

c

t

ion

theseHAPemissionsfrom stationary specifiesinCAAsection112(d)(2)that 112(f)(2)riskreview anddetermine

d

theEPAshouldconsiderrequiring

sources.Specifically,afterdefining

t

ha

t

t

he

e

x

i

s

t

i

ng

s

t

a

nda

r

d

wi

l

l

pr

o

t

e

majorandareasourcesandrequiring sourcestoapplymeasuresthat,among thepublicwithanamplemarginofct

theEPAtolistallmajorsourcesand otherthings,‘‘reducethevolumeof,or safety.Thetworequirementsare

eliminateemissionsof,suchpollutants distinct,andbotharemandatory.

manyareasourcesofthelisted

pollutants(CAAsection112(c)),the ...’’(CAAsection112(d)(2)(A)),

B.WhatistheCoal-andOil-FiredEGU

new CAAsection112requiredtheEPA ‘‘enclosesystemsorprocessesto

sourcecategoryandhowdoesthe

toestablishtechnology-basedemission eliminateemissions’’(CAAsection

standardsforlistedsourcecategorieson 112(d)(2)(B)),and‘‘collect,capture,or NESHAPregulateHAPemissionsfrom

apromptscheduleandtorevisitthose treatsuchpollutantswhenreleased... thesourcecategory?

technology-basedstandardsevery8 ’’(CAAsection112(d)(2)(C)).The1990 1.SummaryofCoal-andOil-FiredEGU

yearsonanongoingbasis(CAAsection Amendmentsalsobuiltinaregular SourceCategoryandNESHAP

review ofnew technologiesandaone- gulations

112(d)(emissionstandards);CAA

section112(e)(scheduleforstandards timereview ofrisksthatremainafter ReThe

EPApromulgatedtheCoal-and

andreview)).The1990Amendments impositionofMACTstandards.CAA

l-FiredEGUNESHAP(commonly

alsoobligatedtheEPAtoconductaone- section112(d)(6)requirestheEPAto Oi

referredtoasMATS)onFebruary16,

timeevaluationoftheresidualrisk

8Congressrecogni

2012(77FR9304)(2012MATSFinal

zedasmuch:‘‘The

within8yearsofpromulgationof

Administratormaytakethecostofachievingthe Rule).Thestandardsarecodifiedat40

technology-basedstandards.CAA

maximum emissionreductionandanynon-air

CFRpart63,subpartUUUUU.Thecoalsection112(f)(2).

ualityhealthandenvironmentalimpactsand

andoil-firedelectricutilityindustry

Insettingthestandards,CAAsection eqne

rgyrequirementsintoaccountwhen

consistsoffacilitiesthatburncoaloroil

112(d)requirestheEPAtoestablish de

terminingtheemissionslimitationwhichis

chievableforthesourcesinthecategoryor

l

atedatbothmajorandareasources

technology-basedstandardsthatachieve asub

stconsiderationsarereflectedinthe oofcHAP

emissions.Anexistingaffected

the‘‘maximum degreeofreduction,’’ seleccattieognooryf.eCo

mi

s

s

i

o

ns

l

i

mi

t

a

t

i

o

ns

whi

c

h

ha

v

e

b

e

e

n

‘‘includingaprohibitiononsuch

achievedinpractice(ratherthanthosewhichare sourceisthecollectionofcoal-oroilemissionswhereachievable.’’CAA

merelytheoretical)bysourcesofasimilartypeor firedEGUsinasubcategorywithina

acter.’’ALegislativeHistoryoftheCleanAir singlecontiguousareaandunder

section112(d)(2).Congressspecified cAchatrAme

ntsof1990(CAALegislative

thatthemaximum degreeofreduction History),ndme

Vo

l

5

,pp.8508–8509(CAAAmendments commoncontrol.A new affectedsource

mustbeatleastasstringentasthe

of1989;p.168–169;ReportoftheCommitteeon iseachcoal-oroil-firedEGU forwhich

constructionorreconstructionbegan

EnvironmentandPublicWorksS.1630).

averagelevelofcontrolachievedin

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00008 Fmt4708a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38515

afterMay3,2011.AnEGUisafossil oil-firedEGUswithanannualcapacity dietaryandnutritionalriskfactorsare

oftenparticularlypronouncedin

fuel-firedcombustionunitofmorethan factoroflessthan8percentofits

25megawatts(MW)thatservesa

maximum ornameplateheatinputare vulnerablecommunitieswithpeopleof

generatorthatproduceselectricityfor alsosubjecttoaworkpracticestandard colorandlow-incomepopulationsthat

havehistoricallyfacedeconomicand

sale.Aunitthatcogeneratessteam and consistingofperiodiccombustion

electricityandsuppliesmorethanone- processtune-upsbutarenotsubjectto environmentalinjusticeandare

thirdofitspotentialelectricoutput anynumericemissionlimits.Emission overburdenedbycumulativelevelsof

capacityandmorethan25MW electric limitsforexistingEGUsandadditional pollution.Inadditiontoadverse

outputtoanyutilitypowerdistribution informationofthehistoryandother neurodevelopmentaleffects,thereis

system forsaleisalsoconsideredan requirementsofthe2012MATSFinal evidencethatexposureto

thylmercuryinhumansandanimals

EGU.The2012MATSFinalRule

eareavailableinthe2023Proposal me

canhaveadverseeffectsonboththe

definesadditionaltermsfordetermining Rul

pr

e

a

mb

l

e

(

8

8

FR

2

4

8

5

4

)

.

ruleapplicability,including,butnot 2.PublicHealthandEnvironmental developingandadultcardiovascular

limitedto,definitionsfor‘‘coal-fired HazardsAssociatedWithEmissions system.

Alongwiththehumanhealthhazards

electricutilitysteam generatingunit,’’ From Coal-andOil-FiredEGUs

associatedwithmethylmercury,itis

‘‘oil-firedelectricutilitysteam

well-establishedthatbirdsand

generatingunit,’’and‘‘fossilfuel-fired.’’ Coal-andoil-firedEGUsarea

In2028,theEPAexpectsthesource significantsourceofnumerousHAPthat mammalsarealsoexposedto

categorycoveredbythisMACT

areassociatedwithadverseeffectsto methylmercurythroughfish

standardtoinclude314coal-firedsteam humanhealthandtheenvironment, consumption(MercuryStudy).At

higherlevelsofexposure,theharmful

generatingunits(140GW at157

ludingHg,HF,HCl,selenium,

effectsofmethylmercuryincludeslower

facilities),58oil-firedsteam generating ianc

r

s

e

ni

c

,

c

hr

o

mi

um,

c

o

b

a

l

t

,

ni

c

k

e

l

,

growthanddevelopment,reduced

units(23GW at35facilities),and5

hydrogencyanide,beryllium,and

reproduction,andprematuremortality.

IGCCunits(0.8GW at2facilities).

c

a

dmi

um

e

mi

s

s

i

o

ns

.

Hg

i

s

a

pe

r

s

i

s

t

e

nt

effectsofmethylmercuryon

Forcoal-firedEGUs,the2012MATS

bioaccumulativetoxicmetalthat, The

wildlifearevariableacrossspeciesbut

FinalRuleestablishedstandardstolimit aond

nc

e

r

e

l

e

a

s

e

d

f

r

o

m

po

we

r

pl

a

nt

s

i

nt

o

havebeenobservedintheenvironment

emissionsofHg,acidgasHAP(e.g.,

ambientair,canbereadily

fornumerousavianspeciesand

HCl,HF),non-HgHAPmetals(e.g., tthe

r

a

ns

po

r

t

e

d

a

nd

de

po

s

i

t

e

d

t

o

s

o

i

l

a

nd

mammalsincludingpolarbears,river

nickel,lead,chromium),andorganic aquaticenvironmentswhereitis

HAP(e.g.,formaldehyde,dioxin/furan). transformedbymicrobialactioninto otters,andpanthers.

EGUsarealsothelargestsourceof

EmissionstandardsforHClserveasa methylmercury.9Methylmercury

surrogatefortheacidgasHAP,withan bioaccumulatesintheaquaticfoodweb HCl,HF,andselenium emissions,and

areamajorsourceofmetallicHAP

alternatestandardforSO2thatmaybe eventuallyresultinginhighly

usedasasurrogateforacidgasHAPfor concentratedlevelsofmethylmercury emissionsincludingarsenic,chromium,

ckel,cobalt,andothers.Exposureto

thosecoal-firedEGUswithfluegas

thinthelargerandlonger-livingfish ni

theseHAP,dependingonexposure

desulfurization(FGD)systemsandSO2 (wi

e

.

g

.

,

c

a

r

p,

c

a

t

f

i

s

h,

t

r

o

ut

,

a

nd

pe

r

c

h)

,

durationandlevelsofexposures,is

CEMSinstalledandoperational.

chcanthenbeconsumedby

associatedwithavarietyofadverse

StandardsforfPM serveasasurrogate whi

huma

ns

.

healtheffects.Theseadversehealth

forthenon-HgHAPmetals.Work

particularconcernischronic

effectsmayincludechronichealth

practicestandardslimitformationand preOf

na

t

a

l

e

x

po

s

ur

e

v

i

a

ma

t

e

r

na

l

disorders(e.g.,pneumonitis,decreased

emissionsoforganicHAP.

onsumptionoffoodscontaining

pulmonaryfunction,pneumonia,or

Foroil-firedEGUs,the2012MATS cme

t

hy

l

me

r

c

ur

y

.

El

e

v

a

t

e

d

e

x

po

s

ur

e

ha

s

FinalRuleestablishedstandardstolimit beenassociatedwithdevelopmental lungdamage;detrimentaleffectsonthe

emissionsofHClandHF,totalHAP neurotoxicityandmanifestsaspoor centralnervoussystem;damagetothe

kidneys)andalimentaryeffects(suchas

metals(e.g.,Hg,nickel,lead),and

performanceonneurobehavioraltests, na

useaandvomiting).Asof2021,three

organicHAP(e.g.,formaldehyde,

pa

r

t

i

c

ul

a

r

l

y

o

n

t

e

s

t

s

o

f

a

t

t

e

nt

i

o

n,

f

i

ne

ofthekeymetalHAPemittedbyEGUs

dioxin/furan).StandardsforfPM also motorfunction,language,verbal

c,chromium,andnickel)have

serveasasurrogatefortotalHAP

memory,andvisual-spatialability. (baeresneni

c

l

assifiedashumancarcinogens,

metals,withstandardsfortotaland

idencealsosuggestspotentialfor whilethr

eeothers(cadmium,selenium,

individualHAPmetalsprovidedas Ev

a

dv

e

r

s

e

e

f

f

e

c

t

s

o

n

t

he

c

a

r

di

o

v

a

s

c

ul

a

r

andlead)areclassifiedasprobable

alternativeequivalentstandards.Work system,adultnervoussystem,and

practicestandardslimitformationand immunesystem,aswellaspotentialfor humancarcinogens.Overall(metaland

nmetal),theEPAhasclassifiedfour

emissionsoforganicHAP.

ausingcancer.Becausetheimpactsof ono

MATSincludesstandardsforexisting tche

ftheHAPemittedbyEGUsashuman

ne

ur

o

de

v

e

l

o

pme

nt

a

l

e

f

f

e

c

t

s

o

f

andnew EGUsforeightsubcategories: methylmercuryaregreatestduring

carcinogensandfiveasprobablehuman

threeforcoal-firedEGUs,oneforIGCC periodsofrapidbraindevelopment, carcinogens.

EGUs,oneforsolidoil-derivedfuel- developingfetuses,infants,andyoung WhileexposuretoHAPisassociated

firedEGUs(i.e.,petroleum coke-fired), childrenareparticularlyvulnerable. withavarietyofadverseeffects,

uantifyingtheeconomicvalueofthese

andthreeforliquidoil-firedEGUs.

ldrenborntopopulationswithhigh qimpa

ctsremainschallenging.

EGUsinsevenofthesubcategoriesare fChi

hconsumption(e.g.,people

Epi

de

ologicstudies,whichreporta

subjecttonumericemissionlimitsfor ciosns

umingfishasadietarystaple)or centrami

l

e

stimateofpopulation-levelrisk,

allthepollutantsdescribedabove

irednutritionalstatusmaybe

a

r

e

g

e

ne

r

allyusedinanairpollution

exceptfororganicHAP(limited-use eimpa

speciallysusceptibletoadverse

b

e

ne

f

i

t

s

a

ssessmenttoestimatethe

liquidoil-firedEGUsarenotsubjectto ne

numericemissionlimits).Emissionsof urodevelopmentaloutcomes.These numberofattributablecasesofevents.

ExposuretoHAPistypicallymore

organicHAPareregulatedbyawork

EPA.1997,MercuryStudyReportto

unevenandmorehighlyconcentrated

practicestandardthatrequiresperiodic Co9ngU.rS.

e

s

s

,

EPA–

4

5

2

/

R–

9

7

–

0

0

3

(

De

c

e

mb

e

r

1

9

9

7

)

;

s

e

e

amongasmallernumberofindividuals

combustionprocesstune-ups.EGUsin also76FR24976(May3,2011);80FR75029

thanexposuretocriteriapollutants.

thesubcategoryoflimited-useliquid (December1,2015).

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00009 Fmt4709a

1 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

38516

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

Hence,conductinganepidemiologic analysesbutareoftenlackingforHAP, Action.Theresultsoftherisk

madeevenmorechallengingbythe assessmentarepresentedbrieflyintable

studyforHAPisinherentlymore

widearrayofHAPandpossible

challenging;forstarters,thesmall

3ofthisdocument,andinmoredetail

populationsizemeanssuchstudies noncancerHAPeffects.

i

nthedocumenttitledResidualRisk

oftenlacksufficientstatisticalpowerto Finally,estimatingtheeconomic

As

sessmentfortheCoal-andOil-Fired

detecteffects(particularlyoutcomeslike valueofHAPismadechallengingbythe EGU

urceCategoryinSupportofthe

humanhealthendpointsaffected.For 2020So

cancer,forwhichtherecanexista

Ri

s

andTechnologyReviewFinal

multi-yeartimelagbetweenexposure example,thoughEPAcanquantifythe Rule(riskkdo

umentforthefinalrule),

numberandeconomicvalueofHAP- availableintche

andtheonsetofthedisease).By

docket(DocumentID

attributabledeathsresultingfrom

contrast,sufficientpowergenerally

No

.

EPA–

HQ–

OAR–

8–0794–4553).

cancer,itisdifficulttomonetizethe TheEPAsummarize2d0t1he

existstodetecteffectsforcriteria

resultsand

valueofreducinganindividual’s

pollutantsbecauseexposuresare

f

i

ndi

ng

s

o

f

t

he

2

0

2

0

Re

s

i

dua

lRisk

ubiquitousandavarietyofmethods potentialcancerriskattributabletoa Review inthepreambleofthe

2023

existtocharacterizethisexposureover lifetimeofHAPexposure.An

Pr

o

po

s

a

l

(

8

8

FR

2

4

8

5

4

)

,

a

nd

a

ddi

tional

spaceandtime.

alternativeapproachofconducting

i

nf

o

r

ma

t

i

o

n

c

o

nc

e

r

ni

ng

t

he

r

e

s

i

dua

Forthereasonsnotedabove,

willingnesstopaystudiesspecifically review canbefoundinourNationall-risk

epidemiologicstudiesdonotgenerally onriskreductionmaybepossible,but ScaleMercuryRiskEstimatesfor

existforHAP.Instead,theEPAtendsto suchstudieshavenotyetbeenpursued. Cardiovascularand

relyonexperimentalanimalstudiesto C.Summaryofthe2020ResidualRisk NeurodevelopmentalOutcomesforthe

identifytherangeofeffectswhichmay Re

view

NationalEmissionStandardsfor

beassociatedwithaparticularHAP

zardousAirPollutants:Coal-and

AsrequiredbyCAAsection112(f)(2), Ha

exposure.Humancontrolledclinical

l-FiredElectricUtilitySteam

studiesareoftenlimitedduetoethical theEPAconductedtheresidualrisk Oi

ratingUnits—Revocationofthe

review (2020ResidualRiskReview)in Gene

barriers(e.g.,knowinglyexposing

0Reconsideration,andAffirmation

someonetoacarcinogen).Generally, 2020,8yearsafterpromulgatingthe 2o0f2the

AppropriateandNecessary

robustdataareneededtoquantifythe 2012MATSFinalRule,andpresented

magnitudeofexpectedadverseimpacts theresultsofthereview,alongwithour Finding;NoticeofProposedRulemaking

from varyingexposurestoaHAP.These decisionsregardingriskacceptability, memorandum (DocumentIDNo.EPA–

amplemarginofsafety,andadverse HQ–OAR–2018–0794–4605).

dataarenecessarytoprovidea

foundationforquantitativebenefits environmentaleffects,inthe2020Final BILLING CODE 6560–50–P

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00010 Fmt4710a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38517

thattheexistingairpollutioncontrol furans,areregulatedbyaworkpractice

logiesthatwereinusewerewell- standardthatrequiresperiodicburner

D.Summaryofthe2020Technology teesctahno

blishedandprovidedthecapture tune-upstoensuregoodcombustion.

Review

nciesnecessaryforcompliance TheEPAfoundthatthisworkpractice

PursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), effitchiethe

MATSemissionlimits.Based continuedtobeapracticalapproachto

theEPAconductedatechnologyreview wi

ensuringthatcombustionequipment

o

n

t

he

e

f

f

enessandproven

(2020TechnologyReview)inthe2020 reliabilityeoctfitvhe

secontroltechnologies, wasmaintainedandoptimizedtorunto

FinalAction,whichfocusedon

andtherelativelyshortperiodoftime reduceemissionsoforganicHAPand

identifyingandevaluating

continuedtobemoreeffectivethan

incethepromulgationofthe2012

developmentsinpractices,processes, sMATS

e

stablishinganumericstandardthat

Fi

na

l

Rul

e

,

t

he

EPA

di

d

no

t

andcontroltechnologiesforthe

annotreliablybemeasuredor

dentifyanydevelopmentsinpractices, cmo

emissionsourcesinthesourcecategory ipr

tored.Basedontheeffectiveness

ocesses,orcontroltechnologies,nor ndni

thatoccurredsincethe2012MATS

provenreliabilityofthework

nynew technologiesorpractices,for apr

FinalRulewaspromulgated.Control athe

acticestandard,andtherelatively

controlofnon-HgHAPmetals,acid sho

technologiestypicallyusedtominimize gasHAP,

rtamountoftimesincethe

orHg.However,inthe2020 promul

emissionsofpollutantsthathave

gationofthe2012MATSFinal

Te

c

hno

l

o

g

y

Re

v

i

e

w,

t

he

EPA

di

d

no

t

numericemissionlimitsunderthe2012 iderdevelopmentsinthecostand Rule,the

EPAdidnotidentifyany

MATSFinalRuleincludeelectrostatic ceoffns

de

v

e

l

o

pme

ntsinworkpracticesnorany

e

c

t

i

v

e

ne

s

s

o

f

t

he

s

e

pr

o

v

e

n

precipitators(ESPs)andfabricfilters technologies,nordidtheEPAevaluate new workpr

cesoroperational

(FFs)forcontroloffPM asasurrogate thecurrentperformanceofemission proceduresfoarcttihi

ssourcecategory

fornon-HgHAPmetals;wetscrubbers,

regardingtheadditionalcontrolof

dryscrubbers,anddrysorbentinjection reductioncontrolequipmentand

forcontrolofacidgases(SO2,HCl,and strategiesatexistingMATS-affected organicHAP.

EGUs,todeterminewhetherrevisingthe Afterconductingthe2020Technology

HF);andactivatedcarboninj

ection

(ACI)andotherHg-specifictechnologies standardswaswarranted.OrganicHAP, Review,theEPAdidnotidentify

developmentsinpractices,processes,or

forcontrolofHg.TheEPAdetermined includingemissionsofdioxinsand

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00011 Fmt4711a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

ER07MY24.067</GPH>

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

BILLING CODE 6560–50–C

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38518

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

controltechnologiesand,thus,didnot thelevelofthefinalfPM standard), includeschangestothe2023Proposal

shouldtheAgencynotfinalizethe

afterconsiderationofcomments

proposechangestoanyemission

receivedduringthepubliccomment

standardsorotherrequirements.More removalofthenon-HgHAPmetals

perioddescribedinsectionsIV.,V.,VI.,

informationconcerningthattechnology limits.

TheAgencyalsoproposedtolower andVII.ofthispreamble.

review isinthememorandum titled

TechnologyReview fortheCoal-and theHgemissionstandardforlignite- A.Whatarethefinalruleamendments

firedEGUsfrom 4.0lb/TBtuto1.2lb/ asedonthetechnologyreviewforthe

Oil-FiredEGUSourceCategory,

availableinthedocket(DocumentID TBtuandsolicitedcommentonthe bCo

Oil-FiredEGUsource

No.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794–0015), performanceofHgcontrolsandoncost cataelg-oarnd

y

?

a

nd

e

f

f

e

c

t

i

v

e

ne

s

s

o

f

c

o

nt

r

o

l

s

t

r

a

t

e

g

i

e

s

t

o

andintheFebruary7,2019,proposed

Wedeterminedthatthereare

rule.84FR2700.OnMay20,2020,the meetmorestringentHgstandards.

velopmentsinpractices,processes,

Lastly,theEPAdidnotidentifynew de

EPAfinalizedthefirsttechnology

controltechnologiesthatwarrant

developmentsincontroltechnologiesor raend

review requiredbyCAAsection

isionstotheMACTstandardsforthis

112(d)(6)forthecoal-andoil-firedEGU improvedmethodsofoperationthat sovur

cecategory.Therefore,tosatisfythe

sourcecategoryregulatedunderMATS. wouldwarrantrevisionstotheHg

requirementsofCAAsection112(d)(6),

Basedontheresultsofthattechnology emissionstandardsfornon-lignite

wearerevisingtheMACTstandardsby

review,theEPAfoundthatnorevisions EGUs,fortheorganicHAPwork

revisingthefPM limitforexistingcoaltoMATSwerewarranted.See85FR practicestandards,fortheacidgas

from 0.030lb/MMBtuto

standards,orforstandardsforoil-fired f0i.r0e1d0EGUs

31314(May22,2020).

l

b

/

MMBt

requiringtheuse

EGUs

.

The

r

e

f

o

r

e

,

t

he

Ag

e

nc

y

di

d

no

t

E.SummaryoftheEPA’sReviewofthe proposechangestothesestandardsin ofPM CEMSfourcaond

a

l

a

ndoil-firedEGUs

2020RTRandthe2023Proposed

t

o

de

mo

ns

t

r

a

t

e

c

o

mpl

i

ancewiththe

t

he

2

0

2

3

Pr

o

po

s

a

l

b

ut

di

d

s

o

l

i

c

i

t

RevisionstotheNESHAP

revisedfPM standard,asproposed.We

c

o

mme

nt

o

n

t

he

EPA’

s

pr

o

po

s

e

d

arealsofinalizing,asproposed,aHg

PursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), indingsthatnorevisionswere

limitforlignite-firedEGUsof1.2lb/

theEPAconductedareview ofthe2020 fwa

r

r

a

nt

e

d

a

nd

o

n

t

he

a

ppr

o

pr

i

a

t

e

ne

s

s

o

f

TBtu,whichalignswiththeexistingHg

TechnologyReview andpresentedthe theexistingstandards.

limitthathasbeenineffectforother

resultsofthisreview,alongwithour

Addi

t

i

o

na

l

l

y

,

t

he

EPA

pr

o

po

s

e

d

t

o

coal-firedEGUssince2012.Thisrevised

proposeddecisions,inthe2023

removeoneofthetwooptionsfor

Hglimitforlignite-firedEGUsismore

Proposal.Theresultsofthetechnology de

f

i

ni

ng

t

he

s

t

a

r

t

up

pe

r

i

o

d

f

o

r

MATSstringentthanthelimitof4.0lb/TBtu

review arepresentedbrieflybelow in affectedEGUs.

thatwasfinalizedforsuchunitsinthe

thispreamble.Moredetailonthe

I

n

t

he

2

0

2

3

Pr

o

po

s

a

l

,

t

he

EPA

2012MATSFinalRule.Therationale

proposedtechnologyreview isinthe determinednottoreopenthe2020

forthesechangesisdiscussedinmore

memorandum 2023TechnologyReview Re

s

i

dua

l

Ri

s

k

Re

v

i

e

w,

a

nd

a

c

c

o

r

di

ng

l

y

fortheCoal-andOil-FiredEGUSource didnotproposeanyrevisionstothat detailinsectionsIV.andV.below.

Basedoncommentsreceivedduring

Category(‘‘2023TechnicalMemo’’) review.AstheEPAexplainedinthe

thepubliccommentperiod,theEPAis

(DocumentIDNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–

pr

o

po

s

a

l

,

t

he

EPA

f

o

und

i

n

t

he

2

0

2

0

tfinalizingtheproposedremovalof

2018–0794–5789).

thatrisksfrom theCoal-andOil- no

thenon-HgHAPmetalslimitsfor

Basedontheresultsofthetechnology RTR

Fi

r

e

d

EGU

s

o

ur

c

e

c

a

t

e

g

o

r

y

due

t

o

xistingcoal-firedEGUs(seesectionV.).

review,theEPAproposedtolowerthe

ssionsofairtoxicsareacceptable eAddi

tionally,thisfinalruleisrequiring

fPM standard,thesurrogatefornon-Hg eami

nd

t

ha

t

t

he

e

x

i

s

t

i

ng

NESHAP

pr

o

v

i

de

s

HAPmetals,forcoal-firedEGUsfrom anamplemarginofsafetytoprotect theuseofPM CEMSforcompliance

0.030lb/MMBtuto0.010lb/MMBtu. publichealth.Asnotedintheproposal, demonstrationforcoal-andoil-fired

EGUs(excludingEGUsinthelimitedTheAgencysolicitedcommentonthe theEPAalsoacknowledgesthatit

controltechnologyeffectivenessand receivedapetitionforreconsideration useliquidoil-firedsubcategory),butnot

IGCCEGUs(seesectionVI.).

costassumptionsusedintheproposed

ironmentalorganizationsthat, forBe

causethisfinalruleincludes

rule,aswellasonamorestringentfPM firnormeleevnv

a

nt

pa

r

t

,

s

o

ug

ht

t

he

EPA’

s

revisionstotheemissionsstandardsfor

limitof0.006lb/MMBtuorlower.

r

e

c

o

ns

i

de

r

a

t

i

o

n

o

f

c

e

r

t

a

i

n

a

s

pe

c

t

s

o

f

t

he

Additionally,theAgencyproposedto 2020ResidualRiskReview.TheEPA fPM asasurrogatefornon-HgHAP

metalsforexistingcoal-firedEGUs,the

requiretheuseofPM CEMSforallcoal- grantedinparttheenvironmental

PM emissionstandardcompliance

fired,oil-fired,andIGCCEGUsfor

rganizations’petitionwhichsoughtthe fde

monstrationrequirements,theHg

demonstratingcompliancewiththefPM oEPA’

s

r

e

v

i

e

w

o

f

s

t

a

r

t

up

a

nd

s

hut

do

wn

standard.AstheAgencyproposedto provisionsinthe2023Proposal,88FR emissionstandardforlignite-fired

,andthedefinitionof‘‘startup,’’

requirePM CEMSforcompliance

4885,andtheEPAcontinuestoreview tEGUs

he

EPA

endseachportionofthis

demonstration,wealsoproposedto a2nd

llrespondtootheraspe

ctsofthe ruletobeint

severablefrom eachotheras

removetheLEEoption,aprogram based petitwi

10

i

o

n

i

n

a

s

e

pa

r

a

t

e

a

c

t

i

o

n.

itismultifacetedandaddressesseveral

oninfrequentstacktesting,forfPM and

non-HgHAPmetals.AsEGUswouldbe III.Whatisincludedinthisfinalrule? distinctaspectsofMATSfor

independentreasons.Thisincludesthe

requiredtodemonstratecompliance

ThisactionfinalizestheEPA’s

revisedemissionstandardforfPM asa

withPM CEMS,theAgencyalso

de

t

e

r

mi

na

t

i

o

ns

pur

s

ua

nt

t

o

t

he

RTR

urrogatefornon-HgHAPmetalsand

proposedtoremovethealternate

provisionsofCAAsection112forthe sthe

fPM compliancedemonstration

emissionstandardsfornon-HgHAP Co

a

l

a

nd

Oi

l

Fi

r

e

d

EGU

s

o

ur

c

e

c

a

t

e

g

o

r

y

metalsandtotalHAPmetals,because andamendstheCoal-andOil-Fired requirementtoutilizePM CEMS.While

theEPAconsideredthetechnical

almostallregulatedsourceshave

EGUNESHAPbasedonthose

feasibilityofPM CEMSinestablishing

chosentodemonstratecompliancewith de

t

e

r

mi

na

t

i

o

ns

.

Thi

s

a

c

t

i

o

n

a

l

s

o

thenon-HgHAPmetalstandardsby finalizeschangestothedefinitionof therevisedfPM standard,theEPAfinds

thereareindependentreasonsfor

demonstratingcompliancewiththe startupforthisrule.Thisfinalrule

adoptingeachrevisiontothestandards,

surrogatefPM standard,andsolicited

commentonproratedmetallimits

10SeeDocumentI

DNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018– andthateachwouldcontinuetobe

workablewithouttheotherintheplace.

(adjustedproportionallyaccordingto 0794–4565athttps://www.regulations.gov.

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00012 Fmt4712a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38519

TheEPAintendsthatthevarious reflecttheAgency’sjudgmentthatthe UUUUU,untiltheapplicable

piecesofthispackagebeconsidered elementisindependentlyjustifiedand compliancedateoftheamendedrule.

independentofeachother.Forexample, appropriate,andthateachelementcan TheEPAhasconsideredtheconcerns

functionindependentlyevenifoneor sedbycommentersthatthese

theEPAnotesthatourjudgments

regardingdevelopmentsinfPM control moreotherpartsoftherulehasbeenset rcaoimpl

iancedeadlinescouldaffect

technologyfortherevisedfPM standard aside.

reliabilityandconcludedthat

e

l

e

c

t

r

i

c

asasurrogatefornon-HgHAPmetals B.Whatotherchangeshavebeenmade giventhe

flexibilitiesdetailedfurtherin

largelyreflectthatthefleetwas

t

o

t

he

NESHAP?

t

hi

s

s

e

c

t

i

o

therequirementsofthe

reportingfPM emissionrateswellbelow TheEPAisfinalizing,asproposed, finalrulefn,

o

r

existingsourcescanbemet

thecurrentstandardandwithlower theremovaloftheworkpractice

wi

t

ho

ut

a

dv

e

rselyimpactingelectric

coststhanestimatedduring

reliability.Inparticular,theEPAnotes

tandardsofparagraph(2)ofthe

promulgationofthe2012MATSFinal sde

theflexibilityofpermittingauthorities

tionof‘‘startup’’in40CFR

Rule;whileourjudgmentsregardingthe 3f.1ini

allow,ifwarranted,afourthyearfor

0042.Underthefirstoption,startup ctoompl

abilityforlignite-firedEGUstomeetthe 6ends

eunderCAAsection

nanyofthesteam from the 112(i)(i3a)nc

samestandardforHgemissionsasother boilerwhe

(B).Thisflexibility,ifneeded,

isusedtogenerateelectricityfor

coal-andoil-firedEGUsrestona

wouldaddressmanyoftheconcerns

aleoverthegridorforanyother

separateanalysisspecifictolignite-fired spur

se(includingon-siteuse).Under thatcommentersraised.Furthermore,in

units.Thus,therevisedfPM surrogate thepo

secondoption,startupends4hours theeventthatanisolated,localized

emissionsstandardisfeasibleand

EGUgenerateselectricitythat concernweretoemergethatcouldnot

appropriateevenabsenttherevisedHg aisftseorltdhe

orusedforanyotherpurpose beaddressedsolelythroughthe1-year

standardforlignite-firedunits,andvice (includi

on-siteuse),or4hoursafter extensionunderCAAsection112(i)(3),

versa.Similarly,theEPAisfinalizing theEGUng

makesusefulthermalenergy theCAAprovidesadditional

changestothefPM compliance

hasheatorsteam)forindustrial, flexibilitiestobringsourcesinto

demonstrationrequirementbasedonthe (souc

mmercial,heating,orcooling

iancewhilemaintaining

technology’sabilitytoprovideincreased cpur

ses,whicheverisearlier.Thefinal creolmpl

transparencyforownersandoperators, rulepo

i

a

b

i

ity.

resthatallEGUsusethework ThelEPA

regulators,andthepublic;andtheEPA practriecqeui

testhatsimilarconcerns

standardsinparagraph(1)of regardingreno

isfinalizingchangestothestartup

l

i

a

litywereraisedabout

thedefinitionof‘‘startup,’’whichis the2012MATSbiFi

definitionbasedonconsiderations

lRule—arulethat

alreadybeingusedbythemajorityof projectedtheneedna

raisedbyenvironmentalgroupsin

f

o

rsignificantly

EGUs

.

petitionsforreconsideration.Bothof

g

r

e

a

t

e

r

i

ns

t

a

l

l

a

t

i

o

n

o

f

controlsandother

theseactionsareindependentfrom the C.Whataretheeffectiveand

talinvestmentsthanthiscurrent

EPA’srevisionstothefPM surrogate compliancedatesofthestandards? rceavpi

ision.Inthe2012MATSFinalRule,

standard,andtheHgstandardfor

revisionstotheMACTstandards theEPAemphasizedthatmostunits

lignite-firedunits.Accordingly,theEPA beThe

ingpromulgatedinthisactionare shouldbeabletocomplywiththe

findsthateachsetofstandardsis

requirementsofthefinalrulewithin3

effectiveonJuly8,2024.The

severablefrom eachothersetof

y

ears.However,theEPAalsomadeit

c

o

mpl

i

a

nc

e

da

t

e

f

o

r

a

f

f

e

c

t

e

d

c

o

a

l

f

i

r

e

d

standards.

sourcestocomplywiththerevisedfPM clearthatpermittingauthoritieshave

Finally,theEPAfindsthat

tof0.010lb/MMBtuandforlignite- theauthoritytogranta1-year

implementationofeachsetofstandards, fliirmi

edsourcestomeetthelowerHglimit complianceextensionwherenecessary,

compliancedemonstration

of1.2lb/TBtuis3yearsafterthe

inarangeofsituationsdescribed1in1the

requirements,andrevisionstothe

effectivedateofthefinalrule.The

2

012MATSFinalRulepreamble. The

startupdefinitionareindependent.That Ag

encybelievesthistimelineisas

EPA’

sOfficeofEnforcementand

is,asourcecanabidebyanyoneof expe

ditiousaspracticableconsidering Compl

nceAssurance(OECA)also

theseindividualrequirementswithout thepo

tentialneedforsomesourcesto issueditahe

Enfo1r2cementResponse

abidingbyanyothers.Thus,theEPA’s upgrade

acepollutioncontrols. policy(DecMATS

.

1

6

,

2

0

11) which

overallapproachtothissourcecategory Asdiscusosrerdepl

reinthis

de

s

c

r

i

b

e

d

t

he

a

ppr

o

continuestobefullyimplementable preamble,weealrseewhe

addingarequirement issueofCAAsectionac1h13re(ag)ardingthe

evenintheabsenceofanyoneormore thatcompliancewi

fPM limitbe administrativeorderswithrespecttothe

oftheelementsincludedinthisfinal demonstratedusingthPMtheCEMS.

Based sourcesthatmustoperatein

rule.

commentsreceivedduringthe

Thus,theEPAhasindependently oconmme

ncompliancewiththeMATSrulefor

ntperiodandourunderstanding no

consideredandadoptedeachportionof ofsuppl

up

o1yeartoaddressspecific

iersofPM CEMS,theEPAis doctume

thisfinalrule(includingtherevised finalizing

edreliabilityconcerns.While

requirementthataffected severalant

fPM emissionstandardasasurrogatefor sourcesustehe

f

f

requestedand

PM CEMSforcompliance weregranteecdtead1EGUs

non-HgHAPmetals,thefPM

y

e

a

r

CAA

section

monstrationby3yearsafterthe

compliancedemonstrationrequirement, de

1

1

2

(

i

)

(

3

)

(

B)

c

o

mpl

i

a

nc

e

e

x

t

e

nsionby

therevisedHgemissionstandardfor effectivedateofthefinalrule.The

t

he

i

r

pe

r

mi

t

t

i

ng

a

ut

ho

r

i

t

y

,

OECA

compliancedateforexistingaffected issuedfiveadministrativeordersionnly

lignite-firedunits,andtherevised

startupdefinition)andeachisseverable sourcestocomplywithamendments onnectionwiththeEnforcement

shouldtherebejudicialreview.Ifa pertainingtothestartupdefinitionis cRe

sponsepolicy.The2012MATSFinal

courtweretoinvalidateanyoneofthese 180daysaftertheeffectivedateofthe Rul

sultimatelyimplementedover

finalrule,asfew EGUsareaffected,and thee20wa

elementsofthefinalrule,theEPA

1

5

—2016timeframewithout

intendstheremainderofthisactionto changesneededtocomplywith

c

ha

l

l

e

ng

e

stogridreliability.

remaineffective.Importantly,theEPA paragraph(1)ofstartupareachievable

designedthedifferentelementsofthis byallEGUsatlittletonoadditional

1177FR9406.

expenditures.Allaffectedfacilities

finalruletofunctionsensiblyand

12ht

tps://www.epa.gov/enforcement/

independently.Further,thesupporting remainsubjecttothecurrent

enforcement-response-policy-mercury-and-airbasesforeachelementofthefinalrule requirementsof40CFRpart63,subpart toxics-standard-mats.

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00013 Fmt4713a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38520

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

IV.Whatistherationaleforourfinal preparedthatwilleasedataediting, rate.Afterconsiderationofpublic

importing,andexportingandis

comments,theAgencyisfinalizing

decisionsandamendmentstothe

filterablePM (asasurrogatefornon-Hg expectedtobeavailablepriortothedate updatedlimitsfornon-HgHAPmetals

HAPmetals)standardandcompliance bywhichEGUsarerequiredtousePM andtotalnon-HgHAPmetalsthathave

CEMS.

optionsfrom the2020Technology

beenreducedproportionaltothe

Review?

tionofthefPM emissionlimit

A.Whatdidweproposepursuantto frreoduc

m 0.030lb/MMBtutothenew final

Inthissection,theEPAprovides

CAA

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

1

1

2

(

d)

(

6

)

f

o

r

t

he

Co

a

l

a

nd

fPM emissionlimitof0.010lb/MMBtu.

descriptionsofwhatweproposed,what l-FiredEGUsourcecategory?

EGUownersoroperatorswhowould

wearefinalizing,ourrationaleforthe Oi

1.ProposedChangestotheFilterable choosetocomplywiththenon-HgHAP

finaldecisionsandamendments,anda PM

Standard

metalsemissionlimitsinsteadofthe

summaryofkeycommentsand

limitmustrequestandreceive

TheEPAproposedtolowerthefPM faPM

responsesrelatedtotheemission

ovalofanon-HgHAPmetalCMS

standardforfPM,non-HgHAPmetals, limit,asurrogatefortotalnon-HgHAP appr

lternativetestmethod(e.g.,

metals,forcoal-firedEGUsfrom 0.030 santi-ame

andthecompliancedemonstration

talCMS)undertheprovisions

options.Forallcommentsnotdiscussed lb/MMBtuto0.010lb/MMBtu.TheEPA omul

f40CFR63.7(f).

inthispreamble,commentsummaries furthersolicitedcommentonan

andtheEPA’sresponsescanbefound emissionstandardof0.006lb/MMBtuor 2.ComplianceDemonstrationOptions

inthecommentsummaryandresponse lower.TheEPAdidnotproposeany

ntsreceivedonthe

documentNationalEmissionStandards changestothefPM emissionstandard Comme

iancedemonstrationoptionsfor

forHazardousAirPollutants:Coal-and foroil-firedEGUsorforIGCCunits.The ccooampl

l-andoil-firedEGUsalsodidnot

EPAalsoproposedtoremovethetotal

Oil-FiredElectricUtilitySteam

ngetheresultsofthetechnology

GeneratingUnitsReviewoftheResidual andindividualnon-HgHAPmetals creha

v

i

thereforetheAgencyis

RiskandTechnologyReviewProposed emissionlimits.TheEPAalsosolicited finaleiw,

zingtheuseofPM CEMSfor

RuleResponsetoComments,available commentonadjustingthetotaland

ompliancedemonstrationpurposes

individualnon-HgHAPmetalsemission acnd

inthedocket.

vingthefPM andnon-HgHAP

limitsproportionallytotherevisedfPM metarlesmo

Basedonitsreview,theEPAis

LEE

ionsforallcoal-fired

finalizingarevisednon-HgHAPmetal limitratherthaneliminatingthelimits EGUsandfoorpt

oil-firedEGUs(except

surrogatefPM emissionstandardforall altogether.

thoseinthelimiteduseliquidoil-fired

existingcoal-firedEGUsof0.010lb/ 2.ProposedChangestothe

EGUsubcategory).TheAgencyreceived

MMBtuandisrequiringthatallcoal- RequirementsforCompliance

commentsthatsomePM CEMSthatare

andoil-firedEGUsdemonstrate

Demonstration

currentlycorrelatedforthe0.030lb/

compliancewiththerevisedfPM

ufPM emissionlimitmay

EPAproposedtorequirethatall MMBt

emissionstandardbyusingPM CEMS. coThe

riencesomedifficultiesshouldreal-andoil-firedEGUs(IGCCunitsare ceoxrpe

TherevisedfPM standardwillensure di

relationbenecessaryatalowerfPM

cussedinsectionVI.)usePM CEMS standa

thattheentirefleetofcoal-firedEGUs tosde

rd.Basedonthesecommentsand

nstratecompliancewiththe onaddi

achievesperformancelevelsthatare fPM emo

tionalreview ofPM CEMStest

mi

s

s

i

o

n

l

i

mi

t

.

The

EPA

a

l

s

o

consistentwiththoseofthevast

reports,asmentionedinsectionsIV.C.2.

oposedtoremovetheoptionof

majorityofregulatedunitsoperating pr

andIV.D.2.,theAgencyhasmademinor

monstratingcomplianceusing

today—i.e.,thatthesmallminorityof ide

calrevisionstoshiftthebasisof

nfrequentstacktestingandtheLEE tceocrhni

unitsthatcurrentlyemitsignificantly pr

r

e

l

a

tiontestingfrom samplinga

o

g

r

a

m

(

whe

r

e

s

t

a

c

k

t

e

s

t

i

ng

o

c

c

ur

s

higherlevelsofHAPthantheirpeers quarterlyfor3years,theneverythird minimum

lumeperruntocollecting

useproventechnologiestoreducetheir yearthereafter)forbothPM andnon-Hg aminimumvoma

ssorminimum sample

HAPtothelevelsachievedbytherest HAPmetals.

volumeperrunandhasadjustedthe

ofthefleet.Further,theEPAfindsthat

qualityassurance(QA)criterion

a0.010lb/MMBtufPM emission

Howdidthetechnologyreview

otherwiseassociatedwiththenew

standardisthelowestlevelcurrently cB.

ha

ng

e

f

o

r

t

he

Co

a

l

a

nd

Oi

l

F

i

r

e

d

EGU

emissionlimit.Thesechangeswill

compatiblewithPM CEMSfor

cecategory?

enablePM CEMStobeproperly

demonstratingcompliance,whichthe s1o.ur

certifiedforuseindemonstrating

EPAfindsprovidessignificantbenefits FilterablePM EmissionStandard

compliancewiththelowerfPM

includingincreasedtransparency

Commentersprovidedboth

andardwithahighdegreeofaccuracy

regardingemissionsperformancefor supportiveandopposingargumentsfor satnd

sources,regulators,andthesurrounding issuesregardingthefPM limitthatwere reliability.

communities;andreal-time

presentedintheproposedreview ofthe C.Whatkeycommentsdidwereceive

identificationofwhencontrol

2020TechnologyReview.Comments onthefilterablePM andcompliance

technologiesarenotperformingas

receivedontheproposedfPM limitfor ions,andwhatareourresponses?

expected,allowingforquickerrepairs. coal-firedEGUs,alongwithadditional 1o.pt

Inaddition,therule’scurrent

analyses,didnotchangetheAgency’s CommentsontheFilterablePM

requirementtoshiftelectronicreporting conclusionsthatwerepresentedinthe EmissionStandard

Comment:Somecommenters

ofPM CEMSdatatotheEmissions

2023Proposal,and,therefore,the

supportedtheproposedfPM limitof

CollectionandMonitoringPlanSystem Agencyisfinalizingthe0.010lb/

(ECMPS)willenableregulatory

MMBtufPM emissionlimitforexisting 0.010lb/MMBtuasreasonableand

achievable,notingthatthislimitis

authorities,nearbycitizens,andothers, coal-firedEGUs,asproposed.

Additionally,commentersurgedthe slightlygreaterthanthefPM emission

includingmembersofthepublicand

limitrequiredfornew and

media,toquicklyandeasilylocate, Agencytoretaintheoptionof

review,anddownloadfPM emissions complyingwithindividualnon-HgHAP reconstructedunits.Additionally,

usingsimple,user-directedinquiries. metal(e.g.,lead,arsenic,chromium, commentersstatedCAAsection112was

Anenhanced,web-basedversionof nickel,andcadmium)emissionratesor intendedtoimprovetheperformanceof

ECMPS(ECMPS2.0)iscurrentlybeing withatotalnon-HgHAPmetalemission laggingindustrialsourcesandthata

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00014 Fmt4714a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38521

standardthatfallsfarbehindwhatthe sectionandinsectionIV.D.1.ofthis substantialactiontocomplywiththe

vastmajorityofsourceshavealready preamble,theEPAfindscaselaw and proposedlimit.

achieved,asthecurrentstandarddoes, substantialadministrativeprecedent

sponse:TheEPAagreesthatmost

supporttheEPA’sdecisiontoupdate facRe

isinadequate.Othercommenters

i

l

i

tyoperatorsnormallytargetan

thefPM limitbaseduponthese

opposedtheproposedfPM limitof

e

mi

s

s

ionlevelbelow theemissionlimit

velopments.

0.010lb/MMBtuastoostringent.For deCo

b

y

i

nc

orporatingacompliancemargin

mment:Manycommenters

instance,somecommentersstatedthat recomme

o

r

ma

r

ginoferrorincaseofequipment

ndedthattheEPAadda

theEPAdidnotprovideadequate

ma

l

f

unc

tionsorfailures.Asthe

iancemargininitsachievability comment

supportfortheproposedlimit.Other caossmpl

ersnoted,theAgencyhas

umptions.Thesecommenters

commentersstatedthatthefactthatthe conv

pr

e

v

i

o

us

l

yrecognizedthatsome

eyedthatmostEGUstypically

vastmajorityofunitsareachieving

o

pe

r

a

t

o

r

s

emissionlevel20to

ratewellbelow thelimittoallow for 50percenttabregleotwanthe

emissionratesbelow thecurrentlimit oape

mit.However,no

ompliancemarginintheeventofan commentersprovidedlida

doesnotconstitute‘‘developmentsin eqcui

tatosuggest

pmentmalfunctionorfailure,

practices,processes,andcontrol

t

ha

t

ESPs

o

r

FF

a

r

e

una

b

l

etoachievea

whichtheyencouragedtheEPAto

technologies.’’

l

o

we

r

f

PM

l

i

mi

t

.

Fur

t

he

r

mo

e,the

iderwhensettingnew limits.These Agencydoesnotprescribesrpe

Response:TheEPAdisagreesthatthe ccoons

cifically

ntersclaimedthatwitha

Agencyhasnotadequatelysupported promme

ho

w

a

n

EGU

c

o

nt

r

o

l

s

i

t

s

e

mi

s

s

or

sedfPM limitof0.010lb/MMBtu, how theunitoperates.Thechoiiocns

theproposedfPM limit.Asdescribedin anapo

e

t

o

ppropriatedesignmarginof20

theproposalpreamble,theAgency

targetalower-levelemissionratefora

percentnecessitatesthatcontrol

conductedareview ofthe2020

iancemarginisthesoledecision

chnologiesmustbeabletoachievea ocofmpl

TechnologyReview pursuanttoCAA tleimi

o

wne

operators.Forfacilities

008lb/MMBtuorlowerin withmorrseatnd

section112(d)(6),whichfocusedon practtiocfe0..The

ha

n

oneEGUinthesame

yalsoexpressedconcerns subcategory,owne

identifyingandevaluating

operatorsmay

ttheEPAdidnottakedesignmargin findemissionsaverrsagoirng

developmentsinpractices,processes, tiha

(40CFR

nt

o

c

o

ns

i

de

r

a

t

i

o

n

i

n

t

he

c

o

s

t

a

na

l

y

s

i

s

.

andcontroltechnologiesforthe

6

3

.

1

0

0

0

9

)

,

c

o

upl

e

d

wi

t

h

o

withouta

Theystatedthatbynotincludingthe compliancemargin,couldrhe

emissionsourcesinthesourcecategory ne

lpthe

e

d

f

o

r

a

de

s

i

g

n

ma

r

g

i

n,

whi

c

h

t

he

thatoccurredsincepromulgationofthe EPAhasacknowledgedtheneedforin facilityattainandmaintainemission

2012MATSFinalRule.Basedonthat tleasttwooftheAgency’spublications limitsasaneffective,low-cost

review,theEPAfoundthatamajorityof a(NESHAP

approach.Additionally,nocommenters

lysisofControl

sourceswerenotonlyreportingfPM TechnologAna

provideddatatoindicatethatevery

y

Ne

e

ds

f

o

r

Re

v

i

s

e

d

Pr

o

po

s

e

d

emissionssignificantlybelow the

o

wneroroperatoraimstocomplywith

EmissionStandardsforNewSource the

currentemissionlimit,butalsothatthe Co

fPM limitwiththesamecompliance

a

l

f

i

r

e

d

EGUs

,

Do

c

ume

nt

I

D

No

.

fleetachievedlowerfPM ratesatlower EPA–HQ–OAR–2009–0234–20223and margin.Becausesomeoperatorsmight

coststhantheEPAestimatedwhenit

argercompliancemarginthan

CEMSCapabilitiesSummaryfor aoitmhefros,riatlwo

promulgatedthe2012MATSFinalRule. PM

dbedifficulttoselecta

PerformanceSpecification11,NSPS, particularasul

TheEPAexplainsthesefindingsin

sumptionaboutcompliance

a

nd

MACT

Rul

e

s

,

Do

c

ume

nt

I

D

No

.

moredetailinsectionIV.D.1.ofthis EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794–5828),the marginforthecostanalysis.Every

preambleandelsewhereintherecord. EPAunderpredictedthenumberof operatorplansforcompliance

Further,theEPAfindsthatthereare unitsthatwouldrequireretrofits.These differentlyandtheEPAcannotknow

technologicaldevelopmentsand

veryoperator’splansforacompliance

commentersstatedthatthecombination ema

improvementsinPM control

in.EveniftheEPAweretoassume

erylow fPM limitandhavingto a20rgpe

technology,whichalsocontrolsnon-Hg oacfcaovunt

rcentcompliancemargininits

f

o

r

t

he

me

a

s

ur

e

me

nt

HAPmetals,sincethe2012MATSFinal uncertaintyandcorrelation

evaluationofPM controls,theresultsof

Rulethatinformedthe2023Proposal methodologyofPM CEMSwouldlikely theanalysiswouldnotchangetheEPA’s

andthisaction,asdiscussedfurtherin cessitatean‘‘operationaltargetlimit’’ decisiontoadoptalowerfPM limit.

sectionIV.D.1.below.Forexample, one

Specifically,a20percentcompliance

f50percentoftheapplicablelimit. ma

industryhasimplemented‘‘best

rginassumptiontoafPM limitof

So

me

c

o

mme

nt

e

r

s

r

e

f

e

r

e

nc

e

d

t

he

practices’’formonitoringESPoperation NationalRuralElectricCooperative 0.010lb/MMBtuwouldincreasethe

morecarefully,andmoredurable

numberofaffectedEGUsfrom 33to53

sociation(NRECA)technical

materialshavebeenadoptedforFFs eAs

(14.1to23.9GW affectedcapacity)and

v

a

l

ua

t

i

o

n

f

o

r

t

he

2

0

2

3

Pr

o

po

s

a

l

t

i

t

l

e

d

sincethe2012MATSFinalRule.The

theannualcompliancecostsfrom

chnicalCommentsonNational

EPAalsofindsthatthesearecognizable Te

$87.2M to$147.7M.Thenumberof

Emi

s

s

i

o

ns

St

a

nda

r

d

f

o

r

Ha

z

a

r

do

us

Ai

r

developmentsforpurposesofCAA

EGUsthatdemonstratedanabilityto

Po

l

l

ut

a

nt

s

:

Co

a

l

a

nd

Oi

l

f

i

r

e

d

El

e

c

t

r

i

c

section112(d)(6).Asothercommenters UtilitySteam GeneratingUnitsReview meetthelowerfPM limit,butdonotdo

noted,inNationalAssociationfor

soonaverageandthereforewould

ofResidualRiskandTechnology.13

SurfaceFinishingv.EPA,795F.3d1,11 The

requireO&M,wouldincreasefrom 17to

y

s

a

i

d

t

ha

t

,

e

v

e

n

us

i

ng

t

he

EPA’

s

(D.C.Cir.2015),theD.C.Circuitfound unrealistic‘‘baselinefPM rates’’andthe 27(includingthecompliancemargin).

thattheEPA‘‘permissiblyidentified lowestpossiblecompliancemarginof Similarly,thenumberofESPupgrades

andtookintoaccountcognizable

(previously11)andbagupgrades

20percent,theNRECAtechnical

developments’’basedontheEPA’s

(previously3)wouldalsoincrease(to20

e

v

a

l

ua

t

i

o

n

e

s

t

i

ma

t

e

d

t

ha

t

3

7

uni

t

s

—

interpretationoftheterm as‘‘notonly almosttwiceasmanyastheEPA’s

and4,respectively).Therewouldbeno

whollynew methods,butalso

hangeinthenumberofnew FF

estimate—wouldberequiredtotake icns

technologicalimprovements.’’

talls.Therefore,cost-effectiveness

Similarly,heretheEPAidentifieda Sta13nda

TechnicalCommentsonNationalEmission valuesforfPM andindividualandtotal

zardousAirPollutants:Coal-and

cleartrendincontrolefficiency,costs, Oil-firedrdsElfeocrtrHa

n-HgHAPmetalswouldonly

icUtilitySteam GeneratingUnits no

andtechnologicalimprovements,which ReviewofResidua

increaseslightly.Moreover,the30l

Ri

s

k

a

nd

Te

c

hno

l

o

g

y

.

theEPAisaccountingforinthisaction. Cichanowicz,etal.June19,2023.AttachmentAto boileroperatingdayaveragingperiod

cumentIDNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794–5994. usingPM CEMSforcompliance

Further,asdiscussedelsewhereinthis Do

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00015 Fmt4715a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38522

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

demonstrationprovidesflexibilityfor alreadydemonstratedtheabilitytomeet reduced,soitshouldnotbeconsidered

ownersandoperatorstoaccountfor thelimit,butdonotdosoonaverage. either.

mment:Somecommentersstated Thecommentersprovidedthe

equipmentmalfunctions,operational Co

tcosteffectivenessisanimportant followingexamplesofprevious

variability,andotherissues.Lastly,as tcha

onsiderationintechnologyreviews rulemakingswhereEPAfoundcontrols

describedinthe2023Proposal,and

tonotbecost-effective:

rCAAsection112(d)(6)and

updatedhere,thevastmajorityofcoal- unde

RefinerySector

wledgedthattheEPAundertook •InthePetroleum

firedEGUsarereportingfPM emissions accokstno

ctivenessanalysesforthethree technologyreview,15theEPAdeclined

wellbelow therevisedfPM limit.For fPM-setfafenda

rdsonwhichtheAgency torevisethefPM emissionlimitfor

instance,themedianfPM rateofthe296 htcomme

existingfluidcatalyticcrackingunits

nt.However,the

coal-firedEGUsassessedinthe202414 csooug

afterfindingthatitwouldcost$10

ntersstated,theNRECA

TechnicalMemois0.004lb/MMBtu, tecmme

hnicalevaluationfoundmeaningful millionpertonoftotalnon-HgHAP

or60percentbelow therevisedfPM

metalsreduced(inthatcase,equivalent

rrorsintheEPA’scostanalysis,

limitof0.010lb/MMBtu.Themedian ienc

ludingunreasonablylow capitalcost to$23,000pertonoffPM reduced),

fPM rateofaquarterofthebest

snotcost-effective.

tesforESPrebuildsandafailure whichnwa

performingsources(N=74)is0.002lb/ etostcima

theIronOre1Pr

ocessing

onsiderthevariabilityoffPM dueto tec•I

MMBtu,about80percentbelow the chang

logyreview,6theEPAdeclined

sinoperationorfacilitydesign, torhno

revisedfPM limitof0.010lb/MMBtu. bynoteut

ethenon-HgHAPmetalslimit

acompliancemargin. afteervfiisndi

Therefore,forthesereasons,theEPA Theyasseilritzeidngtha

thatinstallingwet

ttheseerrorsresulted scrubbersng

disagreeswithcommentersthata

wo

uldcost$16millionper

i

n

s

i

z

e

a

b

l

e

c

o

s

t

e

f

f

e

c

t

i

v

e

ne

s

s

compliancemarginneedstobe

onofnon-HgHAPmetalsreduced,

underestimatesthaterodedtheEPA’s twhi

consideredinthecostanalysis.

chwasnotcost-effective.

ldeterminationthattheproposed •I

TheupdatedPM analysis,detailedin overalilmi

ntheIntegratedIronandSteel

tiscost-effective.These

thememorandum 2024Updatetothe fcPM

Ma

nuf

a1c7turingFacilitiestechnology

o

mme

nt

e

r

s

a

l

s

o

a

s

s

e

r

t

e

d

t

ha

t

t

he

EPA’

s

2023ProposedTechnologyReviewfor rationalewasarbitraryonitsface

r

e

v

i

e

w,

theEPAdeclinedtorevisethe

theCoal-andOil-FiredEGUSource becauseitreversed,without

no

nHg

HAP

metalslimitafterfinding

Category(‘‘2024TechnicalMemo’’) explanation,theEPA’sprior

t

ha

t

upg

r

a

di

ng

allfume/flame

availableinthedocket,estimatesthat acknowledgementsthatacosts

uppr

e

s

s

a

nt

s

a

t

nacesto

thenumberofEGUsthatwillneedto effectivenessanalysisshouldaccount baghouseswoulbdlacsotstfur

$

7

millionperton

improvetheirfPM emissionrateto

o

f

no

nHg

HAP

me

t

a

l

s

r

e

duc

ed,which

f

o

r

t

he

c

o

s

t

e

f

f

e

c

t

i

v

e

ne

s

s

o

f

c

o

nt

r

o

l

s

a

t

achievea0.010lb/MMBtulimithas eachaffectedfacilityandnotsimplyon wasnotcost-effective.TheAg

y

increasedfrom the20EGUsassumedin anaggregatenationwidebasis.They madeasimilarfindingforapreonc

po

d

the2023Proposalto33EGUs,whichis statedthatfacility-specificcostsshould limitthatwouldhavecost$14,000sepe

r

moreconsistentwiththeNRECA

t

o

n

o

f

v

o

l

a

t

i

l

e

HAP

r

e

duc

e

d.

f

a

c

t

o

r

i

nt

o

t

he

EPA’

s

a

s

s

e

s

s

me

nt

o

f

wha

t

technicalevaluationestimateof37

•InthePortlandCement

is‘‘necessary’’pursuanttothe

EGUs.Thisincreaseisaresultof

Ma

nufact1ur

ingbeyond-the-floor

pr

o

v

i

s

i

o

ns

o

f

CAA

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

1

1

2

(

d)

(

6

)

a

nd

updatedmethodologythatutilizesboth CAAsection112(f)(2).

8t

a

na

l

y

s

i

s

,

heEPAdeclinedtoimpose

thelowestachievedfPM rate(i.e.,the Somecommentersassertedthat,even amorestring

entnon-HgHAPmetals

lowestquarter’s99thpercentile)andthe usingtheEPA’scost-effectiveness

l

i

mi

t

b

e

c

a

us

e

tresultedin

averagefPM rateacrossallquarterly figures,theproposed0.010lb/MMBtu ‘‘significantlyihi

ghercosteffectiveness

datawhenassessingPM upgradeand limitisnotcost-effective.These

f

o

r

PM

t

ha

n

EPA

hasacceptedinother

costsassumptionsfortheevaluated commentersstatedthattheEPA’s

NESHAP.

’

’

The

EPA

tedinthat

limits.TheAgencydisagreeswiththe proposaltorevisethefPM standardto rulemakingthatithadnopr

eviously

commenters,however,thatthe37EGUs 0.010lb/MMBtubasedonacost‘

‘

r

e

j

e

c

t

[

e

d]

$

4

8

,

5

0

1

pe

r

t

o

nofPM asnot

intheNRECAtechnicalevaluation

c

o

s

t

e

f

f

e

c

t

i

v

e

f

o

r

PM,

’

’

a

nd

notedprior

e

f

f

e

c

t

i

v

e

ne

s

s

e

s

t

i

ma

t

e

o

f

up

t

o

$

1

4

.

7

wouldrequire‘‘substantialactionto millionpertonoftotalnon-HgHAP EPAstatementsinasubseque

complywiththeproposedstandard.’’In metalsremoved(equivalentto$44,900 rulemakingprovidingthat$26nt

8,000per

theAgency’srevisedanalysis,only13 pertonoffPM removed)isinconsistent tonofHAPremovedwasahighe

rcostEGUswouldrequirecapitalinvestments withtheEPA’sprioractionsbecausethe effectivenessestimatethantheEPA

had

tomeetafPM limitof0.010lb/MMBtu. cost-effectivenessestimateis

a

c

c

e

pt

e

d

i

n

o

t

he

r

NESHAP

r

ul

e

ma

k

i

ngs.

Ofthese,onlytwoEGUsatonefacility substantiallyhigherthanestimatesthe Incontrast,othercommentersfocus

(Colstrip)currentlywithoutthemost Agencyhaspreviouslyfoundtobenot ontheEPA’sestimatedcost-effectiveed

effectivePM controlsareprojectedto cost-effective.Theyfurthersaidthat,in estimatesforfPM (whichisasurrogate

requireinstallationofaFF,thecostliest thepast,theEPAhasdecidedagainst fornon-HgHAPmetals)andarguedthat

PM controlupgradeoption,tomeet

fPM standardsbasedoncost- 15Petroleum RefinerySectorRiskandTechnology

0.010lb/MMBtu.Theremainingnine reeffveicstiing

v

e

ne

tessubstantially ReviewandNewSourcePerformanceStandards,80

EGUsprojectedbytheEPAtorequire lowerthanstsheesctoima

s

t

e

eness

FR75178,75201(December1,2015).

capitalinvestmentsareestimatedto estimateshere.Theyfsfaeicdtitvha

t

t

he

EPA

NationalEmissionStandardsforHazardous

requirevariouslevelsofESPupgrades. shouldfollow theseprecedentsand Ai1r6Po

ants:TaconiteIronOreProcessing

TheEPAestimatesthatmorethanhalf acknowledgethat$12.2to$14.7million Residuallut

lRiskandTechnologyReview,85FR

6,45483(July28,2020).

(20EGUs)wouldbeabletocomply

rtonofnon-HgHAPmetalsreduced 451477Na

tionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous

withoutanycapitalinvestmentsand ipe

s

no

t

c

o

s

t

e

f

f

e

c

t

i

v

e

.

The

y

a

r

g

ue

d

t

ha

t

AirPollutants:IntegratedIronandSteel

wouldinsteadrequireimprovementsto theAgencyshouldnotfinalizethe

nufacturingFacilitiesResidualRiskand

theirexistingFForESPastheyhave proposedstandardof0.010lb/MMBtu Ma

TechnologyReview,85FR42074,42088(July13,

2020).

forthatreason.Further,these

14Fort

herevisedfPM analysis,theEPAusestwo commentersarguedthatthealternative, 18NationalEmissionStandardsforHazardous

methodstoassesstheperformanceofthefleet:

AirPollutantsforthePortlandCement

morestringentlimitof0.006lb/MMBtu Ma

averageandthe99thpercentileofthelowest

nufacturingIndustryandStandardsof

isevenlesscost-effectiveat$25.6

quarterofdata.Valuesreportedhereusethe

PerformanceforPortlandCementPlants,78FR

averagefPM rateforeachEGU.

millionpertonofnon-HgHAPmetals 10006,10021(February12,2013).

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00016 Fmt4716a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38523

Labadie,werenotthecostsassociated

thoseestimatesweresubstantiallylower pollutionatlow costtothepower

thanestimatesthattheEPAhas

sector.Theyconcludedthatallthese withanESPrebuild,butinsteadwere

consideredtobecost-effectiveinother metricsandapproachestoconsidering

costsassociatedwiththefull

technologyreviews.Therefore,these costsshow thatafPM limitof0.006lb/ trhe

e

pl

mentofanESP.Thecommenter

commentersconcludedthattheEPA MMBtuwouldrequirecost-effective stateadcetha

renretrofittedthe

shouldstrengthenthelimittoatleast reductionsandcanbeachievedata entireESPt,t‘r‘aAme

i

ns

o

ntwounitsin2014/

0.010lb/MMBtu.Thesecommenters reasonablecostthatwouldnot

2

0

1

5

.

On

e

a

c

h

o

f

t

he

seunitstwoofthe

alsopointedtoa2023reportb1y9

jeopardizethepowersector’sfunction. threeoriginalexisting

hadtobe

Additionally,somecommenterscited abandonedandoneofESPs

AndoverTechnologyPartners that

t

he

e

x

istingESPs

foundthatthecosttocomplywithan SierraClubv.Costle,657F.2d298,330 wasretrofittedwithnew powe

rsupplies

emissionlimitof0.006lb/MMBtuona (D.C.Cir.1981),andsaidthecase

fluegasflow modifications.Anew

fleetwidebasiswassignificantlyless supportstheEPA’sdiscretiontoweigh astnd

ate-of-the-artESPwasaddedtoeach

thanthecostsestimatedbytheEPA. cost,energy,andenvironmental

unittosupplementtheretrofitted

AndoverTechnologyPartnersattributed impacts,recognizingtheAgency’s

ESPs.’’AnESPreplacementisdifferent

thisdifference‘‘totheassumptionsEPA authoritytotakethesefactorsinto

rebuild,andthereforethe

maderegardingthepotentialemission account‘‘inthebroadestsenseatthe fcroosmtsaonfaESP

nESPreplacementdonot

reductionsfrom ESPupgrades,which nationalandregionallevelsandover inform the

costsofanESPrebuild.The

timeasopposedtosimplyattheplant

resultinamuchhigherestimateof

baghouseretrofitsinEPA’sanalysisfor levelintheimmediatepresent.’’These ESPrebuildcostprovidedfortheother

anemissionrateof0.006lb/MMBtu.’’ commenterssaidthattheEPAhasthe facility,Petersburg,waslessthanthe

EPA’sfinalassumptionregardingthe

Thesecommentersstatedthatmeeting authoritytorequirecoststhatare

theloweremissionlimitof0.006lb/ reasonablefortheindustryevenifthey typicalcostofanESPrebuildona

MMBtuistechnologicallyfeasibleusing arenotreasonableforeveryfacility. capacity-weightedaveragebasis.Neither

currentlyavailablecontrols,andthey Thesecommentersacknowledgedthat oftheseexamplesprovidedbythe

urgedtheEPAtoadoptthislimit.They theEPAhasdiscretiontoconsidercost commenterdemonstratethattheEPA

statedthatalthoughcosteffectivenessis effectivenessunderCAAsection

restimatedcosts.Forthesereasons,

lessrelevantintheCAAsection112 112(d)(2),citingNRDCv.EPA,749F.3d unde

t

he

EPA

sagreeswiththese

contextthanforotherCAAprovisions, 1055,1060–61(D.C.Cir.2014),but commentdi

e

r

s.Additionally,theEPA

arguedthatthedollar-per-toncostthe$103,000pertonoffPM and

di

s

a

g

r

e

e

s

wi

ththesecommentersthat

$209,000pertonoffilterablefinePM2.5 effectivenessmetricislessrelevant theAgencymus

taddacompliance

estimatesthattheEPAcalculatedforthe underCAAsection112thanunder

ma

r

g

i

n

i

n

i

t

s

c

o

s

tassumptions.As

0.006lb/MMBtulimitwerereasonable otherCAAprovisionsbecausethe

describedabove,theAgencydoesnot

Agencyisnotchargedwithequitably pr

andcomparabletopastpracticein

escribespecificallyhow anEGUmust

technologyreviewsunderCAAsection distributingthecostsofemission

becontrolledorhow itmustbe

112(d)(6).TheynotedthattheEPAhas reductionsthroughauniform

rated,andthechoiceof

previouslyfoundacontrolmeasurethat compliancestrategy,astheEPAhas oope

vercomplianceisatthesolediscretion

resultedinaninflation-adjustedcostof doneinitstransportrules.The

$185,000pertonofPM2.5reducedtobe commentersconcludedthattheAgency oftheownersandoperators.

shouldrequiremaximum reductionsof

cost-effectivefortheferroall2o0ys

nerally,theEPAagreeswith

HAPemissionsfrom eachregulated coGe

productionsourcecategory and

mme

ersthatcosteffectiveness,i.e.,

sourcecategoryandhasnoauthorityto thecostnt

proposedalimitforsecondarylead

s

pe

runitofemissions

smeltingsourcesthatcostaninflation- balancecosteffectivenessacross

r

e

duc

t

i

o

n,

i

s

ametricthattheEPA

industries.

adjusted2$1114,000pertonoffPM

c

o

ns

i

s

t

e

nt

l

y

c

iders,oftenalongside

sponse:Inthisaction,theEPAis othercostmetorins

reduced. Theyarguedthat,usingthe actRe

c

s

,inCAAsection112

ingunderitsauthorityinCAA

AndoverTechnologyPartnerscost

r

ul

e

ma

k

i

ng

s

whe

r

eitcanconsidercosts,

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

1

1

2

(

d)

(

6

)

t

o

‘

‘

r

e

v

i

e

w,

a

nd

r

e

v

i

s

e

estimates,the0.006lb/MMBtulimithas asnecessary(takingintoaccount

e

.

g

.

,

b

e

y

o

ndt

he

f

l

ooranalysesand

evenbettercost-effectivenessestimates developmentsinpractices,processes, technologyreviews

agreeswith

atabout$72,000pertonoffPM reduced andcontroltechnologies),emission commenterswhore,caond

g

ni

ethatthe

and$146,000pertonoffilterablePM2.5 standards’’promulgatedunderCAA Agencyhasdiscretioninzho

w it

reduced.Thesecommentersnotedthat section112.AstheEPAexplainedin considersstatutoryfactorsunde

rCAA

theEPAalsocalculatedcost

section112(d)(6),includingcosts.See

the2023Proposal,thistechnology

effectivenessbasedonallowable

e.g.,AssociationofBatteryRecyclers,

review isseparateanddistinctfrom

emissions(i.e.,assumingemission

otherstandard-settingprovisionsunder Inc.v.EPA,716F.3d667,673–74(D.C.

reductionsachievedifallevaluated CAA

section112,suchasestablishing Cir.2013)(allowingthattheEPAmay

EGUsemitatthemaximum allowable

floors,conductingthebeyond- considercostsinconductingtechnology

amountoffPM,or0.030lb/MMBtu)at MACT

-flooranalysis,andreviewing

reviewsunderCAAsection112(d)(6));

$1,610,000perton,showingthatalimit trhe

esidualrisk.

of0.006lb/MMBtuallowsfarless

s

ealsoNat’lAss’nforSurface

RegardingthecommentsthattheEPA Feini

ngv.EPA,795F.3d1,11(D.C.

19AssessmentofPot

underestimatedcoststoanextentthat Cir.s2hi

entialRevisionstothe

0

1

EPAacknowledgesthat

MercuryandAirToxicsStandards.Andover

underminestheEPA’soverallcost- thecost-5e)f.fThe

ectivenessvaluesforthese

TechnologyPartners.June15,2023.DocketIDNo. effectivenessassumptions,theEPA

standardsarehigherthancostEPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794.Alsoavailableat

https://www.andovertechnology.com/wp-content/ disagreesthattheAgency

e

ffectivenessvaluesthattheEPA

unde

r

e

s

t

i

ma

t

e

d

t

he

t

y

pi

c

a

l

c

o

s

t

s

o

f

ESP

upl

o

a

ds

/

2

0

2

3

/

0

6

/

C_

2

3

_

CAEL

P_

F

i

na

l

.

pdf

.

c

oncludedwerenotcost-effectiveand

20Nat

ionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous rebuilds.Thecommentersprovidedcost we

ighedagainstimplementingmore

AirPollutants:FerroalloysProduction,80FR37381 examplesfrom onlytwofacilitiesto

(June30,2015).

s

t

r

i

ngentstandardsforsomepriorrules.

s

uppo

r

t

t

he

i

r

a

s

s

e

r

t

i

o

ns

r

e

g

a

r

di

ng

t

he

21Nat

ionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous costsofESPrebuilds.Thecosts

The

EPAdisagrees,however,thatthere

AirPollutants:SecondaryLeadSmelting,76FR

29032(May19,2011).

providedforoneofthosefacilities, isanyparticularthresholdthatrenders

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00017 Fmt4717a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38524

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

Therearealsouniqueattributesofthe

arulecost-effectiveornot.22TheEPA’s twofacilitiestodecidewhetherto

powersectorthattheEPAfindssupport

priorfindingsaboutcosteffectivenessin deployastanda2r4dacrossthemuch

widerindustry. Hereincontrast,the thefinalizationofrevisedstandardsfor

otherruleswerespecifictothose

rulemakingsandtheindustriesatissue EPAisbasingupdatestofPM standards fPM andnon-HgHAPmetalsdespitethe

inthoserules.Ascommentershave forcoal-firedEGUsondevelopments relativelyhighcost-effectivenessvalues

acrossthemajorityoftheindustryand ofthisrulemakingascomparedtoother

pointedout,inconsideringcost

theperformanceofthefleetasawhole, CAAsection112rulemakings.Asthe

effectiveness,theEPAwilloften

EPAhasdemonstratedthroughoutthis

considerwhatestimatesithasdeemed whichhasdemonstratedthe

record,therearehundredsofEGUs

cost-effectiveinpriorrulemakings. achievabilityofamorestringent

regulatedunderMATSwithwellHowever,theEPAroutinelyviewscost standard.Additionally,thereare

rentdifferencesbetweenthepower performingcontrolequipmentthatare

effectivenessinlightofotherfactors, inhe

alreadyreportingemissionratesbelow

ctorandotherindustriesthat

suchasotherrelevantcostsmetrics sseimi

rlydistinguishprioractionsfrom therevisedstandards,whereasonlya

(e.g.,totalcosts,annualcosts,andcosts thisrlaul

king.Forexample,because handfuloffacilitieswithlargely

comparedtorevenues),impactstothe ofthesiezma

eofthepowersector(314coal- outdatedorunderperformingcontrols

regulatedindustry,andindustryareemittingsignificantlymorethan

EGUsat157facilities),and

specificdynamicstodeterminewhether fierecdaus

ethissourcecategoryisoneof theirpeers.Thatmeansthatthe

thereare‘‘developmentsinpractices, bthe

ststationarysourceemittersof communitieslocatednearthesehandful

processes,andcontroltechnologies’’ Hg,laarrsgeeni

c,andHClandisoneofthe offacilitiesmayexperienceexposureto

thatwarrantupdatestoemissions

higherlevelsoftoxicmetalemissions

largestregulatedstatio2na

rysource

standardspursuanttoCAAsection

ttersoftotalHAP,5even

thancommunitieslocatednearsimilarly

112(d)(6).Somecommenters,pointing ecmi

ideringthatthisruleaffectsonlya sizedwell-controlledplants.Thisis

topriorCAAsection112rulemakings froans

ctionofthesector,theestimatedHAP whattherevisedstandardsseekto

wheretheEPAchosenottoadoptmore reduc

nsinthisfinalrule(8.3tpy)are remedy,andasdiscussedthroughout

stringentcontrols,mischaracterizedcost highertitoha

nthoseintheprior

thisrecord,thisgoalisconsistentwith

effectivenessasthesolecriterionin rulemaking

tedbythecommenters theEPA’sauthorityunderCAAsection

thosedecisions.Thesecommenters (asaretheesstciima

reductions 112(d)(6)andthepurposeofCAA

omittedanydiscussionofotherrelevant 2,537tpy)usedatsedasPM

urrogatefornon- section112moregenerally.

factorsfrom thoserulemakingsthat,in (Hg

metals).Incontrast,inthe2020 U.S.EGUsareamajorsourceofHAP

additiontocosteffectiveness,counseled InteHAP

ratedIronandSteelManufacturing metalsemissionsincludingarsenic,

theEPAagainstadoptingmorestringent rulegma

,thesourcecategorycovered beryllium,cadmium,chromium,cobalt,

standards.Forexample,inthe2014 includekding

y11facilities,andthe

lead,nickel,manganese,andselenium.

Ferroalloysrulemakingthatcommenters estimatedornl

ductionstheEPA

SomeHAPmetalsemittedbyU.S.EGUs

citedto,theEPArejectedapotential consideredewo

remo

v

e

d

3

t

py

areknowntobepersistentand

controloptionduetoquestionsabout ofHAPand120ultdpyhaovfePM.

26Li

kewise, bioaccumulativeandothershavethe

technicalfeasibilityandsignificant inthe2013PortlandCement

tentialtocausecancer.Exposureto

economicimpactstheoptionwould rulemaking,theEPAdeterminednotto po

theseHAPmetals,dependingon

createfortheindustry,including

suemorestringentcontrolsforthe exposuredurationandlevelsof

potentialfacilityclosuresthatwould pur

ctorafterfindingthestandardwould exposures,isassociatedwithavariety

impactsigni2f3icantportionsofindustry osenl

yresultin138tpyofnationwidePM ofadversehealtheffects.Theseadverse

production. Incontrasthere,the

tionsandthattherewasahi

gh healtheffectsmayincludechronic

controlsatissuearetechnicallyfeasible rceoduc

2

7

s

t

f

o

r

s

uc

h

mo

de

s

t

r

e

duc

t

i

o

ns

.

re, healthdisorders(e.g.,irritationofthe

(theyareusedatfacilitiesthroughout theEPAestimatessignificantlygreaHe

ter lung,skin,andmucusmembranes;

thecountry)andwillnothave

HAPemissionreductions,andfPM

decreasedpulmonaryfunction,

significanteffectsontheindustry.

emissionreductionsthatareordersof pneumonia,orlungdamage;

Indeed,theEPAdoesnotprojectthat ma

nitudegr2e8aterthanbothprior

detrimentaleffectsonthecentral

thefinalrevisionstoMATSwillresult rulegma

kings.

nervoussystem;damagetothekidneys;

inincrementalchangesinoperational

andalimentaryeffectssuchasnausea

coal-firedcapacity.

finerySectorRiskandTechnology andvomiting).Theemissions

Similarly,intheotherrulemakings Re2v4iePewtraondleumNewReSo

ePerformanceStandards,80 reductionsprojectedunderthisfinal

thesecommenterspointedto,wherethe FR75178,75201(Deurcecmb

er1,2015).

ulefrom theuseofPM controlsare

52020Nat

EPAfoundsimilarcost-effectiveness htt2ps

ionalEmissionsInventory(NEI)Data; r

//www.epa.gov/air-emissions-inventories/ expectedtoreduceexposureof

valuestothosethattheEPAidentified 2020-:na

-emissions-inventory-nei-data.

individualsresidingnearthesefacilities

fortherevisedfPM standardhere,there 26NatitoionanallEmi

andardsforHazardous tonon-HgHAPmetals,including

aredistinctaspectsofthoserulemakings AirPollutants:IntsesgiroanteSt

IronandSteel

carcinogenicHAP.

andindustriesthatdistinguishthose ManufacturingFacilitiesdRe

sidualRiskand

EGUsprojectedtobeimpactedbythe

chnologyReview,85FR42074,42088(July13, rev

prioractionsfrom thisrulemaking.In Te

isedfPM standardsrepresentasmall

2020).

the2015Petroleum Refineries

27Nat

f

r

a

c

tionofthetotalnumberofthecoali

o

na

l

Emi

s

s

i

o

n

St

a

nda

r

ds

f

o

r

Ha

z

a

r

do

us

rulemaking,theEPAconsideredthecost AirPollutantsforthePortlandCement

f

i

r

e

d

EGUs(11percentforthe0.010lb/

effectivenessofdevelopmentsatonly Ma

nufacturingIndustryandStandardsof

MMBt

ufPM limit).Inaddition,many

PerformanceforPortlandCementPlants,78FR

regulatedfacilitiesareelectingtoretire

22Seee.

g.,NationalEmissionsStandardsfor

10006,10020–10021(February12,2013).

HazardousAirPollutants:FerroalloysProduction,

80FR37366,37381(June30,2015)(‘‘[I]tis

importanttonotethatthereisnobrightlinefor

determiningacceptablecosteffectivenessforHAP

metals.Eachrulemakingisdifferentandvarious

factorsmustbeconsidered.’’).

23Nat

ionalEmissionStandardsforHazardous

AirPollutants:FerroalloysProduction,79FR

60238,60273(October6,2014).

28I

naddition,whilecommentersarecorrectthat

theEPAdeterminednottoadoptmorestringent basedontheinstallationofwetESPsinaddition

controlsundertheironoreprocessingtechnology towetscrubbers,basedontheEPA’sdetermination

thatsuchimprovementswerenotnecessaryto

review,theaspectsoftherulemakingthatthe

commenterscitetoconcernedwhetheradditional provideanamplemarginofsafetytoprotectpublic

controlswerenecessarytoprovideanamplemargin health.SeeNationalEmissionStandardsfor

HazardousAirPollutants:TaconiteIronOre

ofsafetyunderaresidualriskreview.Inthat

instance,theEPAdeterminednottoimplement ProcessingResidualRiskandTechnologyReview,

84FR45476,45483(July28,2020).

morestringentstandardsundertheriskreview

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00018 Fmt4718a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38525

duetofactorsindependentoftheEPA’s underCAAsection112(d)(6),suchas 112(d)(6).’’30WhiletheEPAhas

regulations,andtheEPAtypicallyhas costs.TheyconcludedthatCAAsection consideredrisksasafactorin3s1ome

moreinformationonplantretirements 112(d)(6)requirestheEPAto

previoustechnologyreviews, that

doesnotcompeltheAgencytodosoin

forthissectorthanothersectors

promulgatethemaximum HAP

regulatedunderCAAsection112.Both reductionspossiblewhereachievableat thisrulemaking.Indeed,inother

ofthesefactorscontributetorelatively reasonablecostandisseparatefrom the instances,theEPAhasadoptedthe

highercost-effectivenessestimatesin EPA’sresidualriskanalysis.

samestandardsunderbothCAA

thisrulemakingascomparedtoother Response:TheEPAhasan

sections112(f)(2)and112(d)(6)basedon

sectorswheretheEPAisnotableto independentstatutoryauthorityand independentrationaleswherenecessary

accountforfacilityretirementsand

anamplemarginofsafety

toconductthetechnology taondprboevciade

factorinshorteramortizationperiods orebvliigeawtisoenpa

useitistechnicallyappropriate

r

a

t

e

f

r

o

m

t

he

EPA’

s

forthepriceofcontrols.

andnecessarytodoso,emphasizingthe

horitytoconductaresidualrisk

Whilesomecommentersstatedthat raeut

i

pendentauthorit3y2ofthetwo

iew,andtheAgencyagreeswith snde

meetinganevenloweremissionlimitof covmme

t

a

t

ut

oryprovisions.

ntersthatrecognizedthatthe

The

languageandstructureofCAA

0.006lb/MMBtuistechnologically

EPAisnotrequiredtoaccountfor

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

2,alongwithitslegislative

feasibleusingcurrentlyavailable

ormationobtainedduringaresidual history,1f1ur

therunderscoresthe

controls,theAgencydeclinestofinalize rinf

iskreview inconductingatechnology independent

tureofthesetwo

thislimitprimarilyduetothe

w.TheEPA’sfindingthatthereis provisions.33na

technologicallimitationsofPM CEMSat raenvaiempl

Whi

EPAisonly

rginofsafetyunderthe requiredtoundertlaektehe

thisloweremissionlimit(asdiscussed residualerima

t

he

skreview innowayinterferes once(8yearsafterpromulrgiastkiornevoifewthe

inmoredetailinsectionsIV.C.2.and withtheEPA’

igationtorequire originalMACTstandards),itisrequired

IV.D.2.below).Additionally,theEPA morestringentssotbalnda

rdsunderthe

consideredthehighercostsassociated technologyreview whe

toundertakethetechnologyreview

redevelopments mul

withamorestringentstandardas

tipletimes(atleastevery8years

warrantsuchstandards.TheD.C.

comparedtothefinalstandard

a

f

t

e

r

promulgationoftheoriginalMACT

CircuithasrecognizedtheCAAsection standa

presentedinsectionIV.D.1.

rd).ThatCongresschargedthe

Finally,asmentionedintheResponse 112(d)(6)technologyreview and

EPA

t

o

ensureanamplemarginofsafety

toCommentsdocument,theEPAfinds 112(f)(2)residualreview are‘‘distinct, throughtheriskreview,yetstill

thatuseofPM CEMS,whichprovide parallelanalyses’’thattheEPA

requiredthetechnologyreview tobe

continuousfeedbackwithrespectto undertakes‘‘[s]eparately.’’Nat’lAss’n conductedonaperiodicbasis,

fPM variability,inlieuofquarterlyfPM forSurfaceFinishingv.EPA,795F.3d demonstratesthatCongressanticipated

emissionstesting,willrendermootthe 1,5(D.C.Cir.2015).Inotherrecent thattheEPAwouldstrengthen

commenter’ssuggestionthatmarginof residualriskandtechnologyreviews, standardsbasedontechnological

compliancehasnotbeentakeninto theEPAdeterminedadditionalcontrols developmentsevenafterithad

account.

concludedtherewasanamplemarginof

rewarrantedundertechnology

Comment:Somecommentersargued rwe

safety.CAAsection112’soverarching

e

v

i

e

ws

pur

s

ua

nt

t

o

CAA

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

thatthelow residualriskstheEPA

c

hargetotheEPAto‘‘requirethe

1

1

2

(

d)

(

6

)

a

l

t

ho

ug

h

t

he

Ag

e

nc

y

foundinitsreview ofthe2020Residual determinedadditionalstandardswere ma

degreeofreductionin

RiskReview obviatetheneedforthe notnecessarytomaintainanample emixsismum

i

o

ns

o

thehazardousair

EPAtorevisethestandardsunderthe marginofsafetyunderCAAsection pollutantssfub

ttothissection

separatetechnologyreview,andthat 112(f)(2).29TheEPAhasalsomadeclear (includingaprjoechi

tiononsuch

residualriskshouldbearelevantaspect thattheAgency‘‘disagree[s]withthe emissions)’’furthebride

monstratesthat

oftheEPA’stechnologyreview ofcoal- view thatadeterminationunderCAA Congresssoughttomini

zethe

andoil-firedEGUs.Thesecommenters section112(f)ofanamplemarginof emissionofhazardousaimi

r

po

lution

arguedthatitisarbitraryandcapricious safetyandnoadverseenvironmental whereverfeasibleindependelnt

a

fortheEPAtoimposehighcostson effectsalonewill,inallcases,causeus findingofrisk.Moreover,asdisocfus

sed

facilities,whichtheyclaimedwillonly todeterminethatarevisionisnot

s

upr

a

,

i

n

e

na

c

t

i

ng

t

he

1

9

9

0

CAA

resultinmarginalemissionreductions,

Amendments,Congresspurposefully

whentheEPAdeterminedthereisnot necessaryunderCAAsection

r

placedthepreviousrisk-based

anunreasonablerisktotheenvironment 29See,e.g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor aeppr

oachtoestablishingstandardsfor

orpublichealth.

HAP

thatechnology-driven

Ha

z

a

r

do

us

Ai

r

Po

l

l

ut

a

nt

s

:

Re

f

r

a

c

t

o

r

y

Pr

o

duc

t

s

Othercommentersagreedwiththe ManufacturingResidualRiskandTechnology approwi

a

c

h.Thistechnology-driven

view,86FR66045(November19,2021);National

EPA’s‘‘two-pronged’’interpretationthat Re

Emi

s

s

i

o

n

St

a

nda

r

ds

f

o

r

Ha

z

a

r

do

us

Ai

r

Po

l

l

ut

a

nt

s

:

CAAsection112(d)(6)provides

NationalEmissionStandardsforHazardous

SiteRemediationResidualRiskandTechnology Ai3r0Po

authoritiestotheEPAthataredistinct Re

llutantEmissions:GroupIPolymersand

v

i

e

w,

8

5

FR

4

1

6

8

0

(

J

ul

y

1

0

,

2

0

2

0

)

;

Na

t

i

o

na

l

sins;MarineTankVesselLoadingOperations;

from theEPA’srisk-basedauthorities EmissionStandardsforHazardousAirPollutants: Re

PharmaceuticalsProduction;andthePrintingand

OrganicLiquidsDistribution(Non-Gasoline)

underCAAsection112(f)(2).These Re

PublishingIndustry,76FR22566,22577(April21,

s

i

dua

l

Ri

s

k

a

nd

Te

c

hno

l

o

g

y

Re

v

i

e

w,

8

5

FR

commenterssaidthatifthecriteria

2011).

4

0

7

4

0

,

4

0

7

4

5

(

J

ul

y

7

,

2

0

2

0

)

;

Na

t

i

o

na

l

Emi

s

s

i

o

n

underCAAsection112(d)(6)aremet, andardsforHazardousAirPollutants:Generic 31See,e.g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor

OrganicHazardousAirPollutantsFrom the

theEPAmustupdatethestandardsto St

Maximum AchievableControlTechnology

ntheticOrganicChemicalManufacturing

andardsResidualRiskandTechnologyReview ISy

reflectnew developmentsindependent St

try,71FR76603,76606(December21,2006);

hyleneProduction,85FR40386,40389(July sndus

oftheriskassessmentprocessunder f6o,r2Et

eealsoProposedRules:NationalEmission

NationalEmissionStandardsfor

CAAsection112(f)(2).Theysaidthe Haz0a2r0do);us

andardsforHalogenatedSolventCleaning,73FR

PollutantsforChemicalRecovery St

4,62404(October20,2008).

technology-basedreview conducted CombustionAiSorur

cesatKraft,Soda,Sulfite,and 623328Na

ionalEmissionsStandardsforHazardous

AloneSemichemicalPulpMills,82FR47328 AirPolltut

underCAAsection112(d)(6)neednot (StOcands:SecondaryLeadSmelting,77FR

tober11,2017);NationalEmissionStandards 556,564(aJant

accountforanyinformationlearned forHa

nuary5,2012).

usAirPollutants:GenericMaximum

duringtheresidualriskreview under Achievzaabrldo

33Seesect

ionII.A.2.aboveforfurtherdiscussion

eControlTechnologyStandards;and

CAAsection112(f)(2)unlessthat

ofthestatutorystructureandlegislativehistoryof

ManufactureofAmino/PhenolicResins,79FR

CAAsection112.

informationpertainstostatutoryfactors 60898,60901(October8,2014).

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00019 Fmt4719a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38526

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

approachrecognizestheabilityforthe notanticipatethisrulewillhaveany priorCAArulemakingshavenotbeen

EPAtoachievesubstantialreductionsin implicationsforresourceadequacy. borneoutinreality.Forexample,inthe

Nevertheless,itispossiblethatsome staylitigationovertheCross-StateAir

HAPbasedontechnological

ownersmayconcludethatretiring PollutionRule(CSAPR),claimswere

improvementswithouttheinherent aEGU

rticularEGUandreplacingitwith madethatallowingtheruletogointo

difficultyinquantifyingriskassociated nepa

pacityisamoreeconomicoption effectwouldcompromisereliability.Yet

withHAPemissionexposuregiventhe owmctahe

perspectiveoftheunit’s

inthe2012ozoneseasonstartingjust

complexitiesofthepathwaysthrough fcrus

rsand/orownersthanmaking over4monthsaftertherulewasstayed,

whichHAPcauseharm andinsufficient invetostme

ntsinnew emissionscontrols EGUscoveredbyCSAPRcollectively

availabilityofdatatoquantifytheir attheme

unit.TheEPAunderstandsthat emittedbelow theoverallprogram

effectsdiscussedinsectionII.B.2.

beforeimplementingsucharetirement budgetsthattherulewouldhave

Independentofrisks,itwouldbe

cision,theunit’sownerwillfollow imposedinthatyeariftherulehadbeen

inconsistentwiththetext,structure,and de

theprocessesputinplacebythe

allowedtotakeeffect,withmost

legislativehistoryfortheEPAto

antregionaltransmission

vidualstatesemittingbelow their

concludethatCongressintendedthe roerlgeavni

n(RTO),balancingauthority, rindi

e

s

pe

ctivestatebudgets.Similarly,in

statute’stechnology-basedapproachto orstatezarteigoul

atortoprotectelectric

t

he

l

i

t

igationoverthe2015CleanPower

besidelinedaftertheEPAhad

system reliability.Theseprocesses

Pl

a

n,

a

ssertionsthattherulewould

concludedtheriskreview.

typicallyincludeanalysisofthe

t

hr

e

a

t

e

ctricsystem reliabilitywere

Comment:Somecommenters

tentialimpactsoftheproposedEGU madebnyesloeme

utilitiesortheir

expressedconcernthatsomeportionof po

retirementonelectricalsystem

r

e

pr

e

s

e

nt

a

t

i

v

e

s

ughthe

affectedunitscouldsimplyretire

eliability,identificationofoptionsfor SupremeCourt,sytaeyteedvetnhetho

r

ul

ein2016,

insteadofcomingintocompliancewith rmi

tigatinganyidentifiedadverse

t

he

i

ndus

t

r

y

a

c

hi

e

v

e

d

t

he

r

ul

e

new requirements,potentiallyoccurring impa

insomecases,temporary emissionreductiontargetsyea’rssahead

beforenew generationcouldbebuiltto provicstiso,nand,

ofadditionalrevenuesto

fschedulewithouttheruleevergoing

replacethelostgeneration.Duringthis supportthe

scontinuedoperation oint

effect.SeeWestVirginiav.EPA,

period,alackofdispatchablegeneration untillonger-EGU’

term mitigationmeasures 142oS.

Ct.2587,2638(2022)(Kagan,J.,

couldsignificantlyincreasethe

canbeputinplace.Nocommenter

di

s

s

e

nt

)(‘‘[T]heindustrydidn’tfall

likelihoodofoutages,particularly

atedthatthisrulewouldsomehow shortofing

t

he

[CleanPower]Plan’sgoal;

duringperiodsofsevereweather.In astut

rizeanyEGUownertounilaterally rather,theindus

tryexceededthattarget,

addition,somecommentersarguedthat retiho

twithoutfollowingthese allonitsown....

Atthetimeofthe

revisingthefPM limitwasunnecessary prorceesaseuni

mecommenters

r

e

pe

a

l

...

‘

t

he

r

e

[

wa

s]likelytobeno

asthereisacontinuingdownwardtrend neverthesle,syseatsssoume

withoutany

di

f

f

e

r

e

nc

e

b

e

t

we

e

n

a

wo

rldwherethe

inHAPemissionsfrom early

tionalethatishow multipleEGU

[

Cl

e

a

n

Po

we

r

Pl

a

n

wa

s

]

i

emented

retirementsofcoal-firedEGUs,whereas roawne

rswouldproceed,inviolationof andonewhereit[was]nompl

t

.

’

’

’

quoting

acceleratingthistrendcouldhave

irobligationstoRTOs,balancing 84FR32561).Inotherwords,)t(he

claims

potentialadverseeffectsonreliability. tahe

uthorities,orstateregulatorsrelatingto thattheseruleswouldhavehadadv

Somecommentersalsostatedthatas the

ovisionofreliableelectricservice. reliabilityimpactsprovedtobe erse

morecapacityandgenerationisshifted Inpr

a

tion,theAgencyhasgranted groundless.

awayfrom coal-firedEGUsduetothe themaddi

x

i

mum

timeallowedfor

EPAnotesthatsimilarconcerns

InflationReductionAct(IRA)andother complianceunde

rCAAsection112(i)(3) regThe

a

r

di

reliabilitywereraisedabout

regulatoryandeconomicfactors,the of3years,andindi

lfacilitiesmay the201ng

2

MATS

nalRule—arulethat

totalannualfPM andHAPemissions seek,ifwarranted,avnidua

additional1-year projectedtheneeFi

d

nificantly

from industrywilldecline,regardlessof extensionofthecompl

edatefrom greaterinstallationfoofrcsoignt

rolsandother

whetherthefPM limitismademore theirpermittingauthoriiatyncpur

suantto capitalinvestmentsthanthi

scurrent

stringent.

CAA

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

1

1

2

(

i

)

(

3

)

(

B)

.

The

3

4

r

e

v

i

s

i

o

n.

As

wi

t

h

t

he

c

ur

r

e

rule,the

Response:TheEPAdisagreesthatthis nstructionofanyadditionalpollution flexibilityofpermittingauthont

r

i

tiesto

rulewouldthreatenresourceadequacy ccoont

r

o

l

t

e

c

hno

l

o

g

y

t

ha

t

EGUs

mi

g

ht

a

l

l

o

w

a

f

o

ur

t

h

y

e

a

r

f

o

r

c

o

mpl

i

a

nc

s

orotherwisedegradeelectricsystem installforcompliancewiththisrulecan availableinabroadrangeofsituaetiowa

reliability.Commentersprovidedno becompletedwithinthistimeandwill andintheeventthatanisolated, ns,

credibleinformationsupportingthe notrequiresignificantoutagesbeyond localizedconcernweretoemergethat

argumentthatthisfinalrulewould

whatisregularlyscheduledfortypical couldnotbeaddressedsolelythrough

resultinasignificantnumberof

maintenance.Facilitiesmayalsoobtain, the1-yearextensionunderCAAsection

retirementsoralargeramountof

fwarranted,anemergencyorderfrom 112(i)(3),theCAAprovidesflexibilities

capacityneedingcontrols.TheAgency tihe

DepartmentofEnergypursuantto tobringsourcesintocompliancewhile

estimatesthatthisrulewillrequire

s

e

c

t

ion202(c)oftheFederalPowerAct maintainingreliability.Wehaveseenno

additionalfPM controlatlessthan12 (16U.

824a(c))thatwouldallow the evidenceinthelastdecadetosuggest

GW ofoperablecapacityin2028,which facilityS.tC.

otemporarilyoperate

isabout11percentofthetotalcoal-fired notwithstandingenvironmentallimits 34TheEPAprojectedthatthe2012MATSFinal

EGUcapacityprojectedtooperatein whentheSecretaryofEnergy

Rulewoulddrivetheinstallationofanadditional

thatyear.Theunitsrequiringadditional determinesdoingsoisnecessaryto

20GW ofdryFGD(dryscrubbers),44GW ofDSI,

GW ofadditionalACI,102GW ofadditionalFFs,

fPM controlsareprojectedtogenerate addressashortageofelectricenergyor 6939GW

crubberupgrades,and34GW ofESP

lessthan1.5percentoftotalgeneration otherelectricreliabilityemergency. upgradeosf.sWhi

leasubsequentanalysisfoundthat

Further,despitethecomments

in2028.Moreover,theEPAdoesnot

t

he

i

ndus

t

r

y

ul

telyinstalledfewercontrols

assertingconcernsoverelectricsystem thanwasprojectitma

projectthatanyEGUswillretirein

ed,thecontrolinstallationsthat

ccurredfollowingthepromulgationofthe2012

responsetothestandardspromulgated reliability,nocommentercitedasingle oMATS

lRulewerestillsignificantlygreater

instancewhereimplementationofan thantheFiina

inthisfinalrule.BecausetheEPA

nstallationsthatareestimatedtooccuras

EPAprogram causedanadverse

projectsnoincrementalchangesin

aresultofthisfinalrule(where,forexample,the

existingoperationalcapacitytooccurin reliabilityimpact.Indeed,similar

estimatesthatlessthan2GW ofcapacity

wouldinstallFFtechnologyforcompliance).

responsetothefinalrule,theEPAdoes claimsmadeinthecontextoftheEPA’s EPA

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00020 Fmt4720a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38527

viabletoconstructsignificantcontrol foundthat,basedonitsownassessment

thattheimplementationofMATS

upgradesforarevisedstandardthat andthatofcommenters,onlyafew

causedpowersectoradequacyand

reliabilityproblems,andonlyahandful wouldbecomeeffectiveinmid-2027, facilitieswouldlikelybeeligiblefora

only5yearsbeforetheunit’spermanent near-term retirementsubcategoryand

ofsourcesobtainedadministrative

ordersundertheenforcementpolicy retirement.Commentersfurthernotedif thatitwouldnotsignificantlyreduce

issuedwithMATStoprovidereliefto theEPAdoesnotestablishsucha

thecostsoftherevisedstandards.

reliabilitycriticalunitsthatcouldnot subcategoryortakeotheractionto

AccordingtotheEPA’sas3s7essment,67

ensuretheseunitsarenotnegatively ofthe296EGUsassessed have

complywiththeruleby2016.

Comment:Commenterssuggestedthat impactedbytherulemaking,the

announcedretirementsbetween2029

theEPAuseitsauthoritytocreate

retirementofsomeunitscouldbe

2032—lessthanone-quarterofthe

subcategoriesofaffectedfacilitiesthat acceleratedduetothecostsofinstalling aflnd

e

e

t

—andallbutthreeofthoseEGUs

electtopermanentlyretirebythe

aPM CEMSandtheneedtorebuildor (attwo

s)havealready

compliancedateastheAgencyhas

upgradeanexistingESPorinstallaFF demonsftarcaitleidtiethe

abilitytocomplywith

takeninsimilarproposedrulemakings tosupplementanexistingESP.

t

he

0

.

0

1

0

l

b

/

MMBt

standardon

affectingcoal-andoil-firedEGUs.

CommentersstatedthattheEPAcannot average.AdditionaullyfPM

,

t

he

sethreeEGUs

CommentersstatedtheEPAshould

ignoretheneedforacoordinated

a

l

r

e

a

dy

us

e

PM

CEMS

t

o

de

monstrate

subcategorizethosesourcesthathave retirementofthermalgenerating

c

o

mpl

i

a

nc

e

,

t

he

r

e

f

o

r

e

t

he

c

o

mment

adoptedenforceableretirementdates capacitywhilenew generationsources requestingawaiverofPM CEMS

andnotsubjectthosesourcestoany comeonlinetoavoiddetrimental

installationsforEGUswithnear-term

finalrulerequirements.Theyindicated impactstogridreliability.

r

etirementsisnotrelevant.Becausethe

CommenterssuggestedthatiftheEPA EPA’

thattheEPAisfullyauthorizedto

analysisledtheAgencyto

subcategorizetheseunitsunderCAA decidestoproceedwithfinalizingthe conclsude

ttherewouldbelittle

section112(d)(1).Commentersasked revisedstandardsinthe2023Proposal, utilitytoatha

ne

r-term retirement

theAgencyshouldcreateasubcategory subcategoryaand

thattheEPAconsiderother

uldnotchangethe

simultaneousrulemakings,suchasthe forcoal-firedEGUsthatelectbythe costsoftheruleiintwo

a

me

aningfulway,

proposedGreenhouseGasStandards compliancedateoftherevised

t

he

EPA

de

t

e

r

mi

ne

d

no

t

reatea

andGui

delinesforFossilFuelPower standards(i.e.,mid-2027)toretirethe retirementsubcategoryfotortche

PM

3

5

Plants, wheretheEPAproposedthat unitsbyDecember31,2032,orJanuary standard.Inaddition,theEPAfno

tes

EGUsthatelecttoshutdownbyJanuary 1,2032,iftheEPApreferstotiethe thatallowingunitstooperatewitho

1,2032,mustmaintaintheirrecent 2023ProposaltotheproposedEmission thebestperformingcontrolsforan ut

historicalcarbondioxide(CO2)emission GuidelinesinsteadoftheEffluent

tionalnumberofyearswouldlead

LimitationGuidelines,andmaintainthe atoddi

rateviaroutinemaintenanceand

hi

gherlevelsofnon-HgHAPmetals

currentMATSstandardsforthis

operatingprocedures(i.e.,no

e

mi

s

sionsandcontinuedexposureto

subcategoryofunits.Commenters

degradationofperformance).

t

ho

s

e

ssionsinthecommunities

requestedthattheEPAcoordinatethe aroundemi

Commentersalsoreferencedthe

t

he

eunitsduringthat

retirementdateofDecember31,2032,in requiredretirementdateforthe2023 timeframe.sRe

gardingafPM compliance

Proposalwithotherrulessothatall requirementsub

theEPAOfficeofWater’spropo3s6ed

categoryforEGUswith

retirementdatesalign.Commenters near-term retireme

EffluentLimitationGuidelines.

nts,theAgency

Commentersclaimedthatcreatinga reiteratedthattheEPAhasmultiple estimates26of67EGUs

arealready

subcategoryforunitsfacingnear-term authoritieswithoverlappingstatutory us

i

ng

PM

CEMS

f

o

r

c

o

mpl

iance

retirementsthatharmonizesthe

timelinesthataffectcommenters’plans monstrationandfindstha

tthecosts

retirementdateswithotherrulemakings regardingtheorderlyretirementofcoal- de

t

o

i

ns

t

a

l

l

PM

CEMS

f

o

r

f

a

c

i

l

i

swith

wouldgreatlyassistcompanieswith firedEGUsandtheirabilitytocontinue near-term retirementsarereatsioena

ble.

movingforwardonretirementplans theindustry’scleanenergy

The

Ag

e

nc

y

f

i

nds

t

ha

t

t

he

t

r

a

ns

pa

rency

withoutrunningtheriskofbeingforced transformationwhileprovidingthe

ovidedbyPM CEMSandthe

toretireearly,whichcouldcreate

reliabilityandaffordabilitythattheir pr

increasedabilitytoquicklydetectand

reliabilityconcernsor,inthe

customersdemand.Commenters

orrectpotentialcontroloroperational

alternative,forcedtodeliberatewhether suggestedthatEGUsthatplantoretire cpr

blemsusingPM CEMSfurthers

toinstallcontrolsanddelaying

by2032shouldhavetheopportunityto Coong

ress’sgoaltoensurethatemission

retirementtorecoupinvestmentsinthe seekawaiverfrom PM CEMS

r

e

duc

tionsareconsistentlymaintained

controls.Commentersalsosuggested installationaltogetherandcontinue andma

kesPM CEMSthebestchoicefor

thatEGUswithlimitedcontinued

quarterlystacktestingduringthe

t

hi

s

r

ul

e

operationbeallowedtocontinueto remaininglifeoftheunit.Theyalso EGUs. ’scompliancemonitoringforall

perform quarterlystacktestingto

suggestedthatifaunitdoesnotretire

demonstratecompliancewiththefPM bythespecifieddate,itshouldbe

mmentsontheProposedChanges

limitations(ratherthanhavingtoinstall requiredtoimmediatelyceaseoperation t2o.Co

t

he

ComplianceDemonstration

PM CEMS).Commenterssuggestedthat ormeetthestandardsoftherule.

Opt

i

o

ns

imposingdifferentstandardsonthese Commentersstatedthatunderthis

Comment:TheAgencyreceivedboth

subcategoriesshouldcontinuethestatus recommendationanEGU’sfailureto suppo

tiveandopposingcomments

quofortheseunitsuntilretirement. complywouldthenbeaviolationofthe requirirng

useofPM CEMSfor

Commentersclaimedthatitwouldmake 2023Proposal’sfinalrulesubjectto compliancthe

e

de

monstration.Supportive

orcement.

nosensefortheEPAtorequireanEGU enf

c

o

mme

nt

e

r

s

s

t

a

tedtheEPAmust

Re

s

po

ns

e

:

I

n

r

e

s

po

ns

e

t

o

c

o

mme

nt

e

r

s

’

slatedtoretireinthenearterm to

r

e

q

ui

r

e

t

he

us

e

o

fPM CEMStomonitor

concerns,theEPAevaluatedthe

expendsubstantialresourceson

t

he

i

r

e

mi

s

s

i

o

ns

o

fnon-HgHAPmetals

f

e

a

s

i

b

i

l

i

t

y

o

f

c

r

e

a

t

i

ng

a

s

ub

c

a

t

e

g

o

r

y

f

o

r

controlsintheinterim sincethese

facilitieswithnear-term retirementsbut 7Inthisfinalrule,theEPAreviewedfPM

sourcesareveryunlikelytofindit

disagreeswithcommentersthatsucha co3mpl

iancedatafor296coal-firedEGUsexpected

3588FR33245(

s

ub

c

a

t

e

g

o

r

y

i

s

a

ppr

o

pr

i

a

t

e

f

o

r

t

hi

s

May23,2023).

t

o

b

e

o

perationalonJanuary1,2029.Thisreview

3688FR18824,18837(

March29,2023).

isexplainedindetailinthe2024TechnicalMemo.

rulemaking.Inparticular,theEPA

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00021 Fmt4721a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38528

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

demonstratingcompliancewiththe allowingalargercriterionorby

asPM CEMSarenow morewidely

deployedthanwhenMATSwasfirst revisedfPM standard,statingthatthe modifyingthecalculationandallowing

alessstringentnumberinthe

promulgated,andexperiencewithPM requirementsofPerformance

CEMShasenabledoperatorstomore Specification11of40CFRpart60, denominator.Withthesechangestothe

QAcriteriaandcorrelationprocedures,

promptlydetectandcorrectproblems appendixB(PS–11)willbecome

theEPAbelievesEGUswillbeableto

withpollutioncontrolsascomparedto extremelyhardtosatisfyatthelow

othermonitoringandtestingoptions emissionlimitsproposed.ForPS–11, usePM CEMStodemonstrate

allowedunderMATS(i.e.,periodic relativecorrelationaudit(RCA),and complianceattherevisedlevelofthe

fPM standard.

stacktestingandparametricmonitoring relativeresponseaudit(RRA),the

Comment:Somecommentersasserted

toleranceintervalandconfidence

forPM),therebyloweringHAP

tiftheEPAfinalizestherequirement

emissions.Theysaidthatthefactthat intervalrequirementsareexpressedin ttha

odemonstratecomplianceusingPM

termsoftheemissionstandardthat CEMS,

PM CEMShavebeenusedto

willnotbeabletocomply

demonstratecomplianceinamajorityof appliestothesource.Thecommenters withalEGUs

owerfPM limitonacontinuous

reviewedtestdatafrom operatingunits basisand

unitsin38theeightbestperforming

hataccompanyingalower

deciles providesstrongevidencethat andfoundsignificantlyhigherPS–11 limitwithtmo

restrictivemonitoring

PM CEMScanbeusedeffectivelyto failure(>80percent),RCAfailure(>80 requirementsraedds

theregulatory

measurelow levelsofPM emissions. percent),andRRAfailure(60percent) burdenofaffectedstoour

OpposingcommentersurgedtheEPA ratesatthemorestringentproposed permittingauthorities.cesand

toretainallcurrentoptionsfor

emissionlimits.Theystatedthatthe

sponse:TheEPAdisagreeswith

demonstratingcompliancewithnon-Hg cost,complexity,andfailurerateof coRe

nters’claim thatthatEGUswill

HAPmetalstandards,including

equipmentcalibrationremainsoneof nomme

tbeabletodemonstratecompliance

quarterlyPM andmetalstesting,LEE, thebiggestchallengeswiththeuseof cont

inuouslywithafPM limitof0.010

andPM CPMS.Thesecommenterssaid PM CEMSandthereforeother

u.TheEPAbelievesthatCEMS

removingthesecomplianceflexibility compliancedemonstrationmethods ilnb/gMMBt

ralandPM CEMSinparticular

optionsgoesbeyondthescopeofthe shouldberetained.Commentersalso enabelne

rsandoperatorstodetect

RTRanddoesnotaddresswhythe

notedthatrepeatedtestsduetofailure ndqeuiocwne

klycorrectcontroldeviceor

reasonstheseoptionswereoriginally couldresultinhighertotalemissions apr

ocessissuesinmanycasesbeforethe

includedinMATSarenolongervalid. from theunits.

ssuesbecomecomplianceproblems.

Commenterssaidtheyhavepreviously Response:TheAgencyisawareof iCo

rarytothecommenter’sassertion

raisedconcernsaboutPM CEMSthat oncernsbysomecommentersthatPM thant

t

EGUs

llnotbeabletocomply

theEPAhasavoidedbystatingthat cCEMS

currentlycorrelatedforthe0.030 withalowewi

rfPM limitonacontinuous

CEMSarenottheonlycompliance

l

b

/

MMBt

u

f

PM

e

mi

s

s

i

o

n

l

i

mi

t

ma

y

basis,asmentionedintheJune2023

methodforPM.Theystatedthat

riencedifficultiesshouldreAndover3Te

chnologyPartners

previously,theEPAhasdetermined ecxope

r

r

e

l

a

t

i

o

n

b

e

ne

c

e

s

s

a

r

y

;

a

nd

t

ho

s

e

nalysis,9over80percentofEGUs

thesecompliancemethodswereboth concernsarealsoascribedtoyet-to-be aus

ingPM CEMSforcompliance

adequateandfrequentenoughto

installedPM CEMS.Inresponsetothose pur

seshavealreadybeenableto

demonstratecompliance.

erns,theAgencyhasshiftedthe achipo

eveandarereportingandcertifying

Response:TheAgencydisagreeswith cboanc

s

i

s

o

f

c

o

r

r

e

l

a

t

i

o

n

t

e

s

t

i

ng

f

r

o

m

consistentachievementoffPM rates

commenterswhosuggeststhattherule equiringonlythecollectionofa

below 0.010lb/MMBtu.40TheEPAis

shouldretainallpreviousoptionsfor rmi

ni

mum

v

o

l

ume

pe

r

r

un

t

o

a

l

s

o

wareofanyadditionalburden

demonstratingcompliancewitheither allowingthecollectionofaminimum una

periencedbythoseEGUownersor

theindividualmetals,totalmetals,or massperrunandhasadjustedtheQA oexpe

irregulatoryauthorities

fPM limits.CongressintendedforCAA criterionotherwiseassociatedwiththe withrarteograsrodrttohe

PM CEMSuseatthese

section112toachievesignificant

ne

w

e

mi

s

s

i

o

n

l

i

mi

t

.

The

s

e

c

ha

ng

e

s

wi

l

l

remissionlevels,anddoesnot

reductionsofHAP,andtheEPAagrees easethetransitionforcoal-andoil-fired leoxwe

pectadditionalburdentobeplaced

withothercommentersthattheuseof EGUsusingonlyPM CEMSfor

EGUownersoroperatorswithregard

CEMSingeneralandPM CEMSin

compliancedemonstrationpurposes. otonPM

CEMSfrom applicationofthe

particularenablesownersoroperators The

f

i

r

s

t

c

ha

ng

e

,

a

l

l

o

wi

ng

t

he

f

a

c

i

l

i

t

y

t

o

revisedemissionlimit.However,this

todetectandquicklycorrectcontrol chooseeitherthecollectionofa

lruleincorporatesapproaches,such

deviceorprocessissuesinmanycases nimum massperrunoraminimum afisna

s

wi

tchingfrom aminimum sample

beforetheissuesbecomecompliance mi

volumeperrun,shouldreducehigh- volume

perruntocollectionofa

problems.Consistentwiththe

l

e

v

e

l

c

o

r

r

e

l

a

t

i

o

n

t

e

s

t

i

ng

dur

a

t

i

o

n,

discussioncontainedinthe2023

essingotherconcernsabout

39AssessmentofPot

entialRevisionstothe

Proposal(88FR24872),theAgency aeddr

x

t

e

nde

druntimeswithdegraded

MercuryandAirToxicsStandards.Andover

findsthetransparencyandabilityto emissions

ntrolorincreased

TechnologyPartners.June15,2023.DocketIDNo.

quicklydetectandcorrectpotential emissions,caond

EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–0794.June2023.Also

s

ho

ul

d

r

e

duc

e

vailableathttps://www.andovertechnology.com/

controloroperationalproblemsfurthers correlationtestingcosts.Thesecond awpntent/uploads/2023/06/C_23_CAELP_

Congress’sgoaltoensurethatemission change,adjustingtheQAcriteria,is Finaclo.pdf

.

reductionsareconsistentlymaintained consistentwithotherapproachesthe

40Seef

orexamplethePM CEMSThirtyBoiler

andmakesPM CEMSthebestchoicefor Agencyhasusedwhenlowerrangesof Ope

ratingDayRollingAverageReportsforDuke’s

thisrule’scompliancemonitoring.

RoxboroSteam ElectricPlantinNorthCarolinaand

trumentationormethodsare

atMinnesotaPower’sBoswellEnergyCenterin

Comment:Somecommentersobjected eins

mpl

o

y

e

d.

Fo

r

e

x

a

mpl

e

,

i

n

s

e

c

t

i

o

n

1

3

.

2

nnesota.Thesereportsandthosefrom other

totheEPA’sproposaltorequiretheuse ofPerformanceSpecification2(40CFR Mi

EGUsreportingemissionlevelsatorlowerthan

ofPM CEMSforpurposesof

uareavailableelectronicallyby

part60,appendixB)theQAcriteriafor 0se.0a1rc0hilbng/MMBt

i

n

t

he

EPA’sWebFactorInformation

t

he

r

e

l

a

t

i

v

e

a

c

c

ur

a

c

y

t

e

s

t

a

udi

t

f

o

r

SO

2

38Anal

ysisofPM andHgEmissionsandControls andNitrogenOxideCEMSarerelaxed RetrievalSystem (WebFIRE)ReportSearchand

from Coal-FiredPowerPlants.AndoverTechnology

RetrievalportionoftheAgency’sWebFIREinternet

Partners.August19,2021.DocumentIDNo.EPA– astheemissionlimitdecreases.Thisis websiteathttps://cfpub.epa.gov/webfire/reports/

HQ–OAR–2018–0794–4583.

accomplishedatloweremissionsby esearch.cfm.

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00022 Fmt4722a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38529

Moreover,theAgencyanticipatesthat

minimum masssampleormassvolume isrequiredtoselectthemostcostthenew fPM limitwillincreasedemand

perrunandadjustingthePM CEMSQA effectiveapproachforcompliance

monitoring.Rather,theAgencyselects for,andperhapsspurincreased

acceptabilitycriteria,toreducethe

productionof,betagaugePM CEMS.

theapproachthatbestprovides

challengeswithusingPM CEMS.

Moreover,the30-boiler-operating-day assurancethatemissionlimitsaremet. D.Whatistherationaleforourfinal

averagingperiodofthelimitprovides PM CEMSannualcostsrepresentavery pproachanddecisionsforthefilterable

flexibilityforownersandoperatorsto smallfractionofatypicalcoal-fired aPM

rogatefornon-HgHAP

accountforequipmentmalfunctions EGU’soperatingcostsandrevenues.As meta(alss)astsaur

nda

rdandcompliance

andotherissues.Consistentwith41the describedintheRatioofRevised

de

mo

ns

t

r

a

t

i

o

n

options?

discussioninthe2023Proposal, the EstimatedNon-BetaGaugePM CEMS

TheEPAisfinalizingalowerfPM

AgencyfindsthatPM CEMSarethebest EUACto2022AverageCoal-FiredEGU emi

rdof0.010lb/MMBtu

GrossProfitmemorandum,availablein forcsosaiol-nfisrteadnda

choiceforthisrule’scompliance

EGUs,asasurrogatefor

monitoringastheyprovideincreased thedocket,ifallcoal-firedEGUswere non-HgHAPme

tals,andtheuseofPM

emissionstransparency,abilityforEGU topurchaseandinstallnew PM CEMS,

forcompliancedemonstration

owner/operatorstoquicklydetectand theEquivalentUniform AnnualCost CEMS

posesforcoal-andoil-firedEGUs

correctpotentialcontroloroperational (EUAC)wouldrepresentlessthanfour pur

ththeexceptionoflimited-useliquid

hundredthsofapercentoftheaverage (owi

problems,andgreaterassuranceof

firedEGUs)basedondevelopments

annualoperatingexpensesfrom coal- inilt-he

continuouscompliance.WhilePM

performanceofsourceswithinthe

firedEGUs.

CEMScanproducevaluesatlower

ategorysincetheEPAfinalizedMATS

Further,asdescribedintheRevised acnd

levelsprovidedcorrelationsare

theadvantagesconferredbyusing

developedappropriately,theAgency EstimatedNon-BetaGaugePM CEMS CEMS

forcompliance.Asdescribedin

establishedthefinalfPM limitof0.010 andFilterablePM TestingCosts

2023Proposal,non-HgHAPmetals

lb/MMBtuafterconsideringfactorssuch technicalmemorandum,availableinthe athe

epredominatelyacomponentoffPM,

rulemakingdocket,theEPAcalculated arnd

asruntimesnecessarytodevelop

controloffPM resultsin

correlations,potentialrandom error averagecostsforPM CEMSand

concomitantreductionofnon-HgHAP

quarterlytestingfrom valuessubmitted me

effects,andcosts.

tals(withtheexceptionofSe,which

Comment:Commentersstatedthatthe bycommentersinresponsetothe

maybepresentinthefilterablefraction

proposal’ssolicitation,whichare

EPA’scostestimatescontradictthe

orinthecondensablefractionasthe

Agency’ssuggestionthattheuseofPM discussedinsectionIV.D.ofthe

idgas,SeO2).TheEPAobservesthat

preamble.Basedonthecommenters’ saicnc

CEMSisamorecost-effective

monitoringapproachthanquarterly suggestions,theserevisedcostsinclude eMATSwasfinalized,thevast

testing,especiallyforunitsthatqualify thecostsofintermittentstacktesting majorityofcoveredunitshave

asLEE.TheysaidthattheEPAused associatedwiththePS–11correlations significantlyoutperformedthestandard,

estimatesfrom theInstituteofCleanAir andongoingcostsofRCAsandRRAs. withasmallnumberofunitslagging

WhiletheaverageEUACforPM CEMS behindandemittingsignificantlyhigher

Companies(ICAC)orEnvea/Altech

levelsoftheseHAPincommunities

whichdonotincludenumerouscosts exceedstheaverageannualcostof

associatedwithPM CEMSthatmake quarterlystackemissiontesting,thecost surroundingthoseunits.TheEPA

deemsitappropriatetorequirethese

them notcost-effective,suchasthecost forPM CEMSdoesnotinclude

ofintermittentstacktestingassociated importantadditionalbenefitsassociated laggingunitstobringtheirpollutant

withthePS–11correlationsandthe withprovidingcontinuousemissions controlperformanceuptothatoftheir

peers.Moreover,theEPAconcludesthat

ongoingcostsofRCAsandRRA,which datatoEGUownersoroperators,

arealargepartofthecostsassociated regulators,nearbycommunitymembers, requiringuseofPM CEMSfor

orthegeneralpublic.Asareminder,the complianceyieldsmanifoldbenefits,

withPM CEMSandwouldrise

substantiallyinconjunctionwiththe EPAisnotobligatedtochoosethemost includingincreasedemissions

inexpensiveapproachforcompliance transparencyanddataavailabilityfor

proposednew PM limits.The

demonstrations,particularlywhenall ownersandoperatorsandfornearby

commenterssaidthattheICAC

benefitsarenotmonetized,eventhough communities.

estimatedrangeofPM CEMS

costscanbeanimportantconsideration. TheEPA’sconclusionswithregardto

installationcostsareparticularly

thefPM standardandrequirementto

understatedandoutdatedandshouldbe Consistentwiththediscussion

ignoredbytheAgency.Theysaidthat containedinthe2023Proposalat88FR usePM CEMSforcompliance

theEPAestimatesmayalsounderstate 24872,theAgencyfindstheincreased demonstrationarecloselyrelated,both

PM CEMScostbyassumingthemost transparencyofEGUfPM emissionsand intermsofCAAsection112(d)(6)’s

commonlyusedlightscatteringbased theabilitytoquicklydetectandcorrect directionfortheEPAtoreduceHAP

potentialcontroloroperational

PM CEMSwillbeusedforall

emissionsbasedondevelopmentsin

applications.Thecommenterssaidthat problems,alongwithgreaterassurance practices,processes,andcontrol

whilemoreexpensive,asignificant ofcontinuouscompliancemakesPM technologies,a4nd

intermsoftechnical

numberofbetagaugePM CEMSare CEMSthebestchoiceforthisrule’s compatibility.2TheEPAfindsthatthe

usedforMATScompliance,especially compliancemonitoring.

manifoldbenefitsofPM CEMSrenderit

TheAgencyacknowledgesthe

wherePM spikingisusedforPS–11

a

ppropriatetopromulgateanupdated

correlationandRCAtestingandthat commenters’suggestionsthatEGU

f

PM

emissionstandardasasurrogatefor

thishigherdegreeofaccuracyfrom beta ownersoroperatorsmayfindthatusing non-Hg

HAPmetalsforwhichPM

gaugePM CEMSmaybeneededfor betagaugePM CEMSismost

CEMS

c

a

nbeusedtomonitor

opriateforthelowerfPM emission

sourceswithoutamarginofcompliance alippr

tintherule;suchsuggestionsare 42 notedinsectionIII.A.above,thereare

underthenew,morestringentemission comi

thelessindependentreasonsforadoptingboth

nsistentwiththeAgency’sview,as tnohenerAs

limit.

evisiontothefPM standardandthePM CEMS

Response:TheEPAdisagreeswiththe expressedin88FR24872.However,the compl

iancedemonstrationrequirementandeachof

commenters’suggestionthattheAgency Agencybelievesotherapproaches,

t

he

s

e

c

hangeswouldcontinuetobeworkable

i

nc

l

udi

ng

s

pi

k

i

ng

,

c

a

n

a

l

s

o

e

a

s

e

wi

t

ho

ut

theotherineffect,suchthattheEPAfinds

41See88FR24872.

thetworevisionsareseverablefrom eachother.

correlationtestingforPM CEMS.

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00023 Fmt4723a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

38530

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

demonstrationpurposes.First,thislevel

compliance.However,asthefPM limit Rule.Second,therearetechnical

islowered,operatorsmayencounter developmentsandimprovementsinPM ofcontrolensuresthatthehighest

emittersbringtheirperformancetoa

difficultiesestablishingandmaintaining controltechnologysincethe2012

levelwherethevastmajorityofthefleet

e

t

ha

t

i

nf

o

r

me

d

t

he

existingcorrelationsforthePM CEMS MATSFinalRul

andmaythereforebeunabletoprovide 2023Proposal.44Forexample,while isalreadyperforming.Forexample,as

describedabove,themajorityofthe

accuratevaluesnecessaryfor

ESPtechnologyhasnotundergone

existingcoal-firedfleetsubjecttothis

compliance.TheEPAhasdetermined, fundamentalchangessince2011,

basedoncommentsandonthe

industryhaslearnedandadopted‘‘best finalrulehaspreviouslydemonstrated

additionalanalysisdescribedbelow, practices’’associatedwithmonitoring anabilitytocomplywiththelower

thatthelowestpossiblefPM limit

ESPoperationmorecarefullysincethe 0.010lb/MMBtufPM limitatleast99

consideringthesechallengesatthistime 2012MATSFinalRule.ForFFs,more percentofthetimeduringonequarter,

is0.010lb/MMBtuwithadjustedQA durablematerialshavebeendeveloped inadditiontomeetingthelowerfPM

criteria.Therefore,theEPAdetermined sincethe2012MATSFinalRule,which limitonaverageacrossallquarters

thatthistwo-prongedapproach—

arelesslikelytofailduetochemical, assessed.TheAgencyestimatesthat

requiringPM CEMSinadditiontoa thermal,orabrasionfailureandcreate only33EGUsarecurrentlyoperating

abovethisrevisedlimit.Comparedto

lowerfPM limit—isthemoststringent risksofhighPM emissions.For

someofthebestperformingEGUs,the

optionthatbalancesthebenefitsof instance,fiberglass(oncethemost

usingPM CEMSwiththeemission

widelyusedmaterial)haslargelybeen 33EGUsrequiringadditionalPM

reductionsassociatedwiththetightened replacedbymorereliableandeasierto controlupgradesormaintenanceare

fPM emissionstandard.Further,the cleanmaterials,whicharemorecostly. morelikelytohaveanESPinsteadofa

EPAfindsthatthemorestringentlimit Coatedfabrics,suchasTeflonorP84 FFandtodemonstratecompliance

of0.006lb/MMBtufPM cannotbe

felt,alsocleaneasierthanotherfabrics, usingintermittentstacktesting.In

addition,mostoftheseEGUshave

adequatelymonitoredwithPM CEMSat whichcanresultinlessfrequent

thistime,becausetherandom error cleaning,reducingthewearthatcould operatedatahigherlevelofutilization

thanthecoal-firedfleetonaverage.

componentofmeasurementuncertainty damagefilterbagsandreducethe

from correlationstacktestingistoolarge effectivenessofPM capture.

cond,asdiscussedinsectionII.A.2.

andtheQAcriteriapassingrateforPM Toexaminepotentialrevisions,the abSe

o

v

ngressupdatedCAAsection

CEMSistoosmalltoprovideaccurate EPAevaluatedfPM compliancedatafor 112ien,tCo

he

1990CleanAirAct

(andthereforeenforceable)compliance thecoal-firedfleetandevaluatedthe Amendment

stoachievesignificant

values.Below,wefurtherdescribeour controlefficiencyandcostsofPM

r

e

duc

t

i

o

ns

i

n

HAPemissions,whichit

controlstoachievealowerfPM

rationaleforeachchange.

r

e

c

o

g

ni

z

e

d

a

r

e

rticularlyharmful

rd.Basedoncommentsreceived pollutants,andpa

i

mpl

ntedaregime

1.RationalefortheFinalFilterablePM sotnanda

the2023Proposal,theEPAreviewed underwhichCongreessme

di

rectedtheEPA

EmissionStandard

additionalfPM compliancedatafor62 tomakeswiftandsubstant

tions

Inthe2023Proposal,theAgency

EGUsat33facilities(see2024Technical toHAPbaseduponthemoisatlsrteriduc

ng

e

nt

proposedalowerfPM emission

Memoandattachmentsfordetailed

s

t

a

nda

r

ds

t

e

c

hno

l

o

g

y

c

o

ul

d

a

c

hi

e

v

e

.

standardforcoal-firedEGUsasa

information).Thereview ofadditional sisevidencedbyCongress’scharge

surrogatefornon-HgHAPmetalsbased fPM compliancedatashowedthatmore Thi

totheEPAto‘‘requirethemaximum

ondevelopmentsinpractices,

EGUshadpreviouslydemonstratedan de

greeofreductioninemissionsof

processes,andcontroltechnologies abilitytomeetalowerfPM rate,as

ha

z

ardousairpollutants(includinga

pursuanttoCAAsection112(d)(6), showninfigure4ofthe2024Technical prohi

uchemissions),’’thatis

includingtheEPA’sassessmentofthe Memo.Comparedtothe2023Proposal achievbaitbiolenaocncosunt

for‘‘thecostof

differingperformanceofsourceswithin where91percentofexistingcapacity achievingsuchemiisng

s

i

o

tion,and

thecategoryandupdatedinformation demonstratedanabilitytomeet0.010 anynon-airqualityheanlthreaduc

nd

aboutthecostofcontrols.Asdescribed lb/MMBtu,theupdatedanalysisshowed environmentalimpactsandenergy

inthe2023Proposal,non-HgHAP

that93percentaredemonstratingthe

rements....’’CAAsection

metalsarepredominatelyacomponent abilitytomeet0.010lb/MMBtuwith r1e1q2ui

(

d)

.Further,bycreatingseparate

offPM,andcontroloffPM resultsin existingcontrols.TheEPAreceived anddis(2ti)nc

trequirementsfortheEPAto

reductionofnon-HgHAPmetals(with commentsonthecostassumptionsfor considerupda

CAAsection112

theexceptionofSe,whichmaybe

upgradingPM controlsandfoundthat pursuanttobottehstteochno

ogyreview

presentinthefilterablefractionorin thecostsestimatedatproposalwerenot underCAAsection112(ld)

(6)and

thecondensablefractionastheacidgas, onlytoohigh,butthatthecost

r

e

s

i

dua

l

r

i

s

k

r

e

v

i

e

w

unde

r

section

SeO2).

effectivenessofPM upgradeswasalso 112(f)(2),CongressanticipaCAA

t

e

d

t

ha

Inconductingthistechnologyreview, underestimated(i.e.,thestandardis EPAwouldstrengthenstandards tthe

theEPAfoundimportantdevelopments morecost-effectivethantheEPA

pursuanttotechnologyreviews‘‘as

thatinformeditsproposal.First,from believedatproposal).

necessary(takingintoaccount

TheEPAisfinalizingthefPM

reviewinghistoricalinf4o3rmation

velopmentsinpractices,processes,

emissionlimitof0.010lb/MMBtuwith de

containedinWebFIRE, theEPA

a

nd

controltechnologies),’’CAAsection

observedthatmostEGUswerereporting adjustedQAcriteria,basedon

1

1

2

(

d)(6),evenaftertheEPAconcluded

fPM emissionrateswellbelow the0.030 developmentssince2012,forthe

t

he

r

e

sanamplemarginofsafety

reasonsdescribedinthisfinalruleand basedwa

lb/MMBtustandard.Thefleetwas

o

n

therisksthattheEPAcan

achievingtheseperformancelevelsat inthe2023Proposalasthelowest

45Ast

q

ua

nt

i

f

y

.

heEPAexplainedinthe

achievablefPM limitthatallowsforthe

lowercoststhanestimatedduring

promulgationofthe2012MATSFinal useofPM CEMSforcompliance

45EPA’

sCAAsection112(f)(2)quantitativerisk

assessmentsevaluatecancerriskassociatedwitha

lifetimeofexposuretoHAPemissionsfrom each

from theElectronicReportingTool(ERT)andis from Coal-FiredPowerPlants.AndoverTechnology sourceinthesourcecategory,thepotentialforHAP

searchableathttps://cfpub.epa.gov/webfire/reports/ Partners.August19,2021.DocumentIDNo.EPA– exposuretocauseadversechronic(orlong-term)

esearch.cfm.

HQ–OAR–2018–0794–4583.

noncancerhealtheffects,andthepotentialforHAP

43WebFI

REincludesdatasubmittedtotheEPA

44Anal

ysisofPM andHgEmissionsandControls

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00024 Fmt4724a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

khammondonDSKJM1Z7X2PRODwithRULES4

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

38531

TheNorthernCheyenneReservation

proposal,theEPAdoesconsidercosts, duetotheveryhighPM control

technicalfeasibility,andotherfactors effectivenessofwell-performingESPs is20milesfrom theColstripfacilityand

whenevaluatingwhetheritisnecessary andFFs,oftenexceeding99.9percent. theTribeexerciseditsauthorityin1977

toreviseexistingemissionstandards Buttheperformanceofaminorityof

requireadditionalairpollution

underCAAsection112(d)(6)toensure unitslagswellbehindthevastmajority tcoont

rolsonthenew Colstripunits

thestandards‘‘requirethemaximum ofthefleet.Asindi

t

wo

c

a

t

e

d

b

y

t

he

(

Co

l

s

p3and4,thesameEGUsstill

degreeofemissionsreductions... highestfPM rates,47EGUswithoutthe operattriing

y),recognizingtheareaas

achievable.’’CAAsection112(d)(2).The mosteffectivePM controlshavenot aClassIaitrosda

he

dundertheCAA.

text,structure,andhistoryofthis

b

e

e

n

a

b

l

e

t

o

de

mo

ns

t

r

a

t

e

f

PM

r

a

t

e

s

Ac

c

o

r

di

ng

t

o

c

o

mmentssubmittedby

provisiondemonstrateCongress’s

c

o

mpa

r

a

b

l

e

t

o

t

he

r

e

s

t

o

f

t

he

f

l

e

e

t

.

t

he

No

r

t

he

r

n

Che

yenneTribe,their

directiontotheEPAtorequire

cifically,theColstripfacility,a

t

r

i

b

a

l

me

mb

e

r

s

—b

oththoselivingon

reductioninHAPwheretechnologyis Spe

1

,

5

0

0

MW

s

ub

b

i

t

umi

no

us

f

i

r

e

d

po

we

r

t

he

Re

s

e

r

v

a

t

i

o

n

a

nd

selivinginthe

availabletodosoandtheEPAaccounts plantlocatedinColstrip,Montana, nearbycommunityotfho

Co

lstrip—have

fortheotherstatutoryfactors.

o

pe

r

a

t

e

s

t

he

o

nl

y

t

wo

c

o

a

l

f

i

r

e

d

EGUs

i

n

b

e

e

n

di

s

pr

o

po

r

t

i

o

na

l

l

y

i

mpa

y

Accordingly,theEPAfindsthat

thecountrywithoutthemostmodern exposuretoHAPemissionsfcrotemdtbhe

bringingthissmallnumberofunitsto PM

rols(i.e.,ESPorFF).Instead, Colstripfacility.51

theperformancelevelsoftherestofthe thiscfaocnt

i

l

ilizesventuriwet

fleetservesCongress’smandatetothe scrubbersityasut

TheEPAbelievesafPM emission

i

t

sprimaryPM control limi

EPAinCAAsection112(d)(6)to

f0.010lb/MMBtuappropriately

c

hno

l

o

g

y

a

nd

ha

s

s

t

r

ug

g

l

e

d

t

o

me

e

t

t

e

continuallyconsiderdevelopments theoriginal0.030lb/MMBtufPM limit, taketsoint

oconsiderationthecostsof

‘‘thatcreateopportunitiestodoeven evenwhileemployingemissions

c

o

nt

r

o

l

s

.

EPAevaluatedthecoststo

better.’’SeeLEAN,955F.3dat1093.As averagingacrosstheoperatingEGUsat improvecThe

ur

r

e

PM controlsystems

such,theEPAhasanumberoftimesin thefacility.Colstripisalsotheonly andthecosttont

i

ns

llbetterperforming

thepastupdateditsMACTstandardsto cilitywheretheEPAestimatesthe PM controls(i.e.,atane

w FF)toachieve

reflectdevelopmentswherethemajority cfaur

r

e

nt

c

o

nt

r

o

l

s

wo

ul

d

b

e

una

b

l

e

t

o

a

mo

r

e

s

t

r

i

ng

e

nt

e

mi

s

s

limit.Costsof

ofsourceswerealreadyoutpe4r6forming meetalowerfPM limit.Specifically,the PM upgradesaremuchiolonwe

thanthe

theoriginalMACTstandards. Indeed, 2018secondquartercompliancestack EPAestimatedin2012,andtrhe

thisfinalruleisconsistentwiththe testsshowedaveragefPM emissionrates reviseditscostsassumptionsasAgency

EPA’sauthoritypursuanttoCAA

0.030lb/MMBtufPM limit,in scribedinthe2024TechnicalMemo,

section112(d)(6)totakedevelopments avbioolvaetitohe

nofitsAirPermit.TalenEnergy, ade

vailableinthedocket.Table4ofthis

inpractices,processes,andcontrol oneofthe

rsofthefacility,agreed do

cumentsummarizestheupdatedcost

technologiesintoaccounttodetermine topay$450o,wne

000to4s8ettletheseair

e

f

f

e

ssofthethreefPM emission

ifmorestringentstandardsare

qualityviolations. Asaresult,the limicttsivceone

ns

redinthe2023Proposal

achievablethanthoseinitiallysetbythe pl

wasofflineforapproximately2.5 fortheexisitde

i

ng

coal-firedfleet.Forthe

EPAinestablishingMACTfloors,based moant

hswhiletheplant’soperator

ondevelopmentsthatoccurredinthe wornt

pur

po

s

e

o

f

e

s

t

i

ma

tingcosteffectiveness,

kedtocorrecttheproblem.

interim.SeeLEANv.EPA,955F.3d Comme

t

he

a

na

l

y

s

i

s

pr

e

s

e

nt

edinthistable,

sfrom Colstrip’smajority

1088,1097–98(D.C.Cir.2020).The ownersnt

de

s

c

r

i

b

e

d

i

n

de

t

a

i

l

i

2023and2024

discusstheeffortsthisfacility TechnicalMemos,isnbtahe

technologicalstandardapproachofCAA hasunde

s

e

onetoimprovetheirwetPM observedemissionratesodfaolnletxhe

section112isbasedonthepremisethat, scrubbersr,gwhi

ting

ystateremove99.7 coal-firedEGUsexceptforthoseitsha

totheextenttherearecontrolsavailable percentofthefclhyathe

t

particulatebut haveannouncedplanstoretirebythe

toreduceHAPemissions,andthose agreewiththeEPAshtha

t

a

ddi

t

i

o

na

l

controlsareofreasonablecost,sources controlswouldbeneededtomeeta endof2028.Theanalysispresentedin

shouldberequiredtousethem.

4estimatedthecostsassociatedfor

0.010lb/MMBtulimit.However,as etaabclheuni

Thefleethasbeenableto‘‘over

upgradetheirexistingPM

tatedinNorthWesternEnergy’sAnnual controlsttotome

comply’’withtheexistingfPM standard sPCCAM

etalowerfPM standard.

F4i9lingandApplicationofTariff Inthecaseswhe

xistingPM controls

Changes, ‘‘Colstriphasahistoryof wouldnotachievreeethe

exposuretocauseadverseacute(orshort-term)

necessary

noncancerhealtheffects.

o

pe

r

a

t

i

ng

v

e

r

y

c

l

o

s

e

t

o

t

he

uppe

r

e

nd

46See,e.

g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor

r

e

duc

t

i

o

ns

,

uni

t

s

pe

c

i

f

i

cFFinstallcosts

l

i

mi

t

:

f

o

r

4

3

pe

r

c

e

nt

o

f

t

he

6

5

1

da

y

s

o

f

HazardousAirPollutants:SiteRemediation

complianceprecedingtheforcedoutage wereestimated.Unlikethecostand

ResidualRiskandTechnologyReview,85FR

its[WeightedAverageEmissionRateo50r] benefitprojectionspresentedintheRIA,

41680,41698(July10,2020)(proposed84FR

46138,46161;September3,2019))(requiring

WAERwaswithin0.03lb/dekatherm theestimatesinthistabledonot

compliancewithmorestringentequipmentleak ofthelimit[...tocomplywiththeAir accountforanyfuturechangesinthe

definitionsunderatechnologyreview,whichwere PermitandMATS,Colstrip’sWAER

sitionoftheoperationalcoalwidelyadoptedbyindustry);NationalEmissions mus

tbeequaltoorlessthan0.03lb/ cfiorempo

d

EGU

fleetthatarelikelytooccur

StandardsforMineralWoolProductionand

FiberglassManufacturing,80FR45280,45307(July dekatherm].’’

b

y

2

0

2

8

a

s

aresultofotherfactors

29,2015)(adoptingmorestringentlimitsforglassaffectingthepowersector,suchasthe

meltingfurnacesunderatechnologyreview where 47Seefigure4ofthe2024TechnicalMemo.

theEPAfoundthat‘‘allglass-meltingfurnaceswere 48SeeDocumentCLT–1TTestimony,CLT–11, IRA,futureregulatoryactions,or

achievingemissionreductionsthatwerewellbelow and

hangesineconomicconditions.For

CL–12inDocket190882athttps://www.utc. c

theexistingMACTstandardsregardlessofthe

example,ofthemorethan14GW of

ov/documents-and-proceedings/dockets.

controltechnologyinuse’’);NationalEmissions wa4.9gSe

coal-firedcapacitythattheEPA

eNorthWesternEnergy’sAnnualPCCAM

StandardsforHazardousAirPollutantsFrom

FilingandApplicationforApprovalofTariff

SecondaryLeadSmelting,77FR556,564(January Cha

stimateswouldrequirecontrol

nges,DocketNo.2019.09.058,FinalOrder7708f e

5,2012)(adoptingmorestringentstacklead

i

mpr

ovementstoachievethefinalfPM

ragraph21(November18,2020)(notingthat

emissionlimitunderatechnologyreview ‘‘basedon pa

‘‘Colstriphasahistoryofoperatingveryclosetothe rate,lessthan12GW isprojectedtobe

emissionsdatacollectedfrom industry,which

upperendlimit’’),availableathttps://reddi.mt.gov/ 51

indicatedthatwell-performingbaghousescurrently pr

SeeDocumentIDNo.EPA–HQ–OAR–2018–

web.

usedbymuchoftheindustryarecapableof

50Forref

erence,adekatherm isequivalenttoone 5984athttps://www.regulations.gov.

achievingoutletleadconcentrationssignificantly

millionBtus(MMBtu).

lowerthanthe[current]limit.’’).

VerDateSep<11>2014 16:50May06,2024 Jkt262001 PO00000 Frm 00025 Fmt4725a

01 Sfmt4700 E:\FR\FM\07MYR4.SGM 07MYR4

38532

FederalRegister/Vol.89,No.89/Tuesday,May7,2024/Rulesand Regulations

operationalin2028(seesection3ofthe

RIAforthisfinalrule).

BILLING CODE 6560–50–P

maintenancecosting$100,000/year utilityboilersweremuchlowerthanthe

TheEPAhasupdateditscosts

(2022$).Thisadditionalcostrepresents EPAwasawareofatproposal.These

analysesforthisfinalrulebasedon

i

ncreasedvigilanceinmaintainingESP updates,aswellasimprovingour

commentsreceivedandadditionaldata pe

rformanceandincludestechnician methodologywhichincreasesthe

review,whichisdescribedinmore

l

a

b

ortomonitorperformanceoftheESP numberofEGUsestimatedtoneedPM

detailinthe2024TechnicalMemo

a

nd

riodicallymaketypicalrepairs upgrades,slightlylowerthedollarper

availableinthedocket.Inresponseto (e.g.,torepe

pl

ntoffailedinsulators, tonestimatesfrom whatwaspresented

commentersstatingthattheuseofthe damagedaecleecme

t

r

o

desorotherinternals inthe2023Proposal.

lowestquarter’s99thpercentile,orthe thatmayfail,repa

iringleaksintheESP TheEPAconsiderscostsinvarious

lowestachievablefPM rate,isnot

c

a

s

i

ng

,

duc

t

wo

r

k

,

orexpansionjoints, ways,dependingontheruleand

indicativeofoverallEGUoperationand andperiodictesting

ofESPflow balance affectedsector.Forexample,theEPA

emissionperformance,theEPAaddeda andanyneededadjustments).

hasconsidered,inpreviousCAA

review ofaveragefPM rates.Inthese

Additionally,theAgencyreceived section112rulemakings,cost

commentsthatthePM upgradecosts effectiveness,thetotalcapitalcostsof

updatedanalyses,boththelowest

quarter’s99thpercentileandtheaverage estimatedatproposalweretoohighon proposedmeasures,annualcosts,and

fPM ratemustbebelow thepotential adollarpertonbasisandthesecosts costscomparedtototal52revenues(e.g.,

havebeenupdatedandareprovidedin costtorevenueratios). Asmuchofthe

fPM limitfortheEPAtoassumeno

additionalupgradesareneededtomeet the2024TechnicalMemo.Specifically, 52

See,e.g.,NationalEmissionStandardsfor

arevisedlimit.IfanEGUhaspreviously commentersdemonstratedthatthe

HazardousAirPollutants:MercuryCellChlorobservedpercentreductionsinfPM

demonstratedanabilitytomeeta

Al

k

a

liPlantsResidualRiskandTechnologyReview,

attributabletoESPupgradeswere

potentiallowerfPM limit,butthe

87FR27002,27008(May6,2022)(considered

significantlygreaterthanthepercent annualcolsotgsyand

averagefPM rateisgreaterthanthe

averagecapitalcostsperfacili

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.