Opposition Brief — Jessie Hoffman, Petitioner v. Gary Westcott, Secretary, Louisiana Department of Public Safety and Corrections, et al.
Supreme Court briefMar 17, 2025
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Nos. 24A893 & 24-6778
In the Supreme Court of the United States
JESSIE HOFFMAN,
Applicant-Petitioner,
v.
GARY WESTCOTT, ET AL.,
Respondents.
BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO APPLICATION FOR STAY OF EXECUTION AND PETITION
FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
ELIZABETH B. MURRILL
Attorney General
J. BENJAMIN AGUIÑAGA
Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
ZACHARY FAIRCLOTH
Principal Deputy
Solicitor General
MORGAN BRUNGARD
KELSEY L. SMITH
Deputy Solicitors General
CAITLIN HUETTEMANN
Assistant Solicitor General
LOUISIANA DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
1885 N. Third St.
Baton Rouge, LA 70802
(225) 506-3746
AguinagaB@ag.louisiana.gov
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ......................................................................................... iii
INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1
STATEMENT ................................................................................................................. 3
ARGUMENT .................................................................................................................. 9
I.
ON THE EQUITIES, PLAINTIFF’S DELAYS ALONE WARRANT THE DENIAL OF A
STAY. ..................................................................................................................... 9
II. IF THE COURT REACHES THE MERITS, THERE IS NO REASONABLE
PROBABILITY THAT THE COURT WILL GRANT CERTIORARI OR FAIR
PROSPECT THAT PLAINTIFF WILL SUCCEED ON THE MERITS. .............................. 12
A. Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment Question Is Not Cert-Worthy and Has No
Merit. ............................................................................................................... 12
1. Plaintiff’s question presented mischaracterizes the decision
below—and Plaintiff would receive no effectual relief from the
Court answering it....................................................................................... 12
2. Plaintiff’s real question presented is fact-bound, satisfies none of this
Court’s cert criteria, and identifies no error............................................... 15
3. The Fifth Circuit’s decision is independently correct because there are
legitimate penological reasons to choose nitrogen hypoxia over the
firing squad. ................................................................................................. 20
B. Plaintiff’s RLUIPA Question Is Not Cert-Worthy and Has No Merit. ......... 21
1. Plaintiff cannot use RLUIPA to stop his execution. .................................. 21
2. Plaintiff’s conceded inability to appeal the underlying merits ruling
presents an obvious vehicle problem. ......................................................... 23
3. Plaintiff’s RLUIPA question does not satisfy the cert criteria. ................. 24
4. The district court did not abuse its discretion in declining to reconsider
its dismissal of Plaintiff’s fact-bound RLUIPA claim. ............................... 24
CONCLUSION............................................................................................................. 29
ii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases
Barr v. Lee,
591 U.S. 979 (2020) .................................................................................................... 1
Bucklew v. Precythe,
587 U.S. 119 (2019) .............................................................................. 2, 9, 11, 13, 20
Calderon v. Thompson,
523 U.S. 538 (1998) .................................................................................................. 11
Caribbean Mgmt. Grp., Inc. v. Erikon LLC,
966 F.3d 35 (1st Cir. 2020) ................................................................................. 23, 24
Dunn v. Smith,
141 S. Ct. 725 (2021) ................................................................................................ 28
Frazier v. Hamm,
2025 WL 361172 (M.D. Ala. Jan. 31, 2025) ................................................... 1, 21, 26
Grayson v. Comm’r, Ala. Dep’t of Corr.,
121 F.4th 894 (11th Cir. 2024) ................................................................................. 13
Grayson v. Hamm,
145 S. Ct. 586 (2024) .................................................................................................. 1
Grayson v. Hamm,
2024 WL 4701875 (M.D. Ala. Nov. 6, 2024) ........................................................ 1, 26
Hill v. McDonough,
547 U.S. 573 (2006) ............................................................................................ 10, 28
Hoffman v. Jindal,
No. 12-cv-796 (M.D. La. June 14, 2024) ................................................................ 5, 6
Hoffman v. Louisiana,
531 U.S. 946 (2000) .................................................................................................... 4
In re Blodgett,
502 U.S. 236 (1992) .................................................................................................. 11
In re Ohio Execution Protocol Litig.,
881 F.3d 447 (6th Cir. 2018) .................................................................................... 13
iii
In re Westcott,
No. 25-30088 (5th Cir.) ......................................................................................... 6, 10
Moran v. Burbine,
475 U.S. 412 (1986) .................................................................................................. 11
Nelson v. Campbell,
541 U.S. 637 (2004) .................................................................................................. 11
Ramirez v. Collier,
595 U.S. 411 (2022) .................................................................................. 9, 21, 22, 28
Smith v. Comm’r, Ala. Dep’t of Corr.,
2024 WL 266027 (M.D. Ala. Jan. 24, 2024) ............................................................... 1
Smith v. Hamm,
144 S. Ct. 414 (2024) .................................................................................................. 1
Smith v. Hamm,
2024 WL 1160303 (M.D. Ala. Jan. 10, 2024) ............................................................. 1
SPV-LS, LLC v. Transamerica Life Ins. Co.,
912 F.3d 1106 (8th Cir. 2019) ............................................................................ 23, 24
State v. Biden,
10 F.4th 538 (5th Cir. 2021) ..................................................................................... 17
State v. Hoffman,
2020-00137 (La. 10/19/21), 326 So. 3d 232 ................................................................ 4
State v. Hoffman,
768 So. 2d 542 (La. 2000) ....................................................................................... 3, 4
Statutes
42 U.S.C. § 2000 ..................................................................................................... 21, 28
La. R.S. 15:569 ............................................................................................................... 4
iv
TO THE HONORABLE SAMUEL A. ALITO, JR., ASSOCIATE JUSTICE OF THE SUPREME
COURT OF THE UNITED STATES AND CIRCUIT JUSTICE FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT.
INTRODUCTION
Plaintiff’s strategy to jam this Court less than 48 hours away from his
execution is inexplicable. The Fifth Circuit’s decision vacating the district court’s
injunction against his execution came out on Friday. Yet he did not touch this Court’s
docket until midnight on Sunday. Not only that, but his questions presented today
also could have been litigated over eight months ago—i.e., the amount of time Plaintiff
has tried to use Rule 60(b)(6) to reopen an old method-of-execution challenge rather
than file this new lawsuit. In a context where an applicant’s diligence is paramount,
these days- and months-long delays alone foreclose Plaintiff’s demand for “lastminute intervention.” Barr v. Lee, 591 U.S. 979, 981 (2020) (per curiam).
But, even if the Court reaches the merits stay factors, Plaintiff does not satisfy
them—not least because Plaintiff seeks a stay of execution by nitrogen hypoxia, a
request that this Court, the Eleventh Circuit, and Alabama district courts have
uniformly rejected as to executions under a virtually identical protocol. See Frazier v.
Hamm, 2025 WL 361172 (M.D. Ala. Jan. 31, 2025) (no appeal); Grayson v. Hamm,
2024 WL 4701875 (M.D. Ala. Nov. 6, 2024), aff’d sub nom., Grayson v. Comm’r, Ala.
Dep’t of Corr., 121 F.4th 894 (11th Cir. 2024), stay of execution denied, Grayson v.
Hamm, 145 S. Ct. 586 (2024); Smith v. Hamm, 2024 WL 1160303 (M.D. Ala. Jan. 10,
2024), aff’d sub nom., Smith v. Comm’r, Ala. Dep’t of Corr., 2024 WL 266027 (M.D.
Ala. Jan. 24, 2024), stay of execution denied, Smith v. Hamm, 144 S. Ct. 414 (2024).
The district court in this case enjoined Plaintiff’s execution on March 11, holding that
1
execution by firing squad qualified as an adequate alternative. See Bucklew v.
Precythe, 587 U.S. 119, 134 (2019) (Plaintiff bears the burden of proving “a feasible
and readily implemented alternative method of execution that would significantly
reduce a substantial risk of severe pain and that the State has refused to adopt
without a legitimate penological reason”). On the State’s motion, however, the Fifth
Circuit vacated that injunction on Friday, March 14, as “not just wrong” but
“[c]onstitution[ally] backwards.” Pet.App.2a (Ho and Oldham, JJ.). For it was
“premised on the odd notion that the Eighth Amendment somehow requires
Louisiana to use an admittedly more painful method of execution—namely, execution
by firing squad rather than by nitrogen hypoxia,” which everyone agrees is physically
painless. Id.
The Court is not reasonably likely to grant certiorari, much less reverse.
Plaintiff claims that the Fifth Circuit deemed superadded psychological (rather than
physical) pain “not relevant” to the Eighth Amendment analysis—and thus
contradicted this Court’s and other circuits’ precedents. Pet.19. That is unequivocally
false. The Fifth Circuit held that Plaintiff “presented no such evidence of superadded
terror to the court—let alone evidence of how execution by a firing squad would
substantially mitigate that terror.” Pet.App.8a. There is no split of authority, and
Plaintiff is left with only fact-bound arguments that are wrong and, in any event, call
for mere error-correction. Plaintiff also claims that the Fifth Circuit erred by refusing
to address the district court’s denial of Plaintiff’s motion to reconsider the dismissal
of his Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) claim—i.e.,
2
that he must be able to breathe oxygen when he dies. But this Court’s precedents
hold that Plaintiff cannot use RLUIPA to stop his execution; the Court is hardly likely
to grant certiorari when unable to directly review the underlying merits
determination given that the district court dismissed that claim earlier in the
litigation in a non-final order; and in all events, the district court properly denied
reconsideration of that claim.
Plaintiff offers no reason to depart from this Court’s and others’ judgments in
uniformly denying stays of execution by nitrogen hypoxia, which (again, everyone
agrees) is physically painless. The Court should deny the application and the petition.
STATEMENT
In the interests of time and efficiency, the State here addresses only the core
relevant facts, and it expounds where necessary in the argument section below.
A. On the night before Thanksgiving Day in 1996, Plaintiff Jessie Hoffman
kidnapped, robbed, and raped Mary “Molly” Elliot. State v. Hoffman, 768 So. 2d 542,
550 (La. 2000). Plaintiff kidnapped Molly at gunpoint, drove her to an ATM, forced
her to withdraw $200, and robbed her. Id. Plaintiff subsequently raped Molly in the
backseat of her own car in a remote area of St. Tammany Parish. Id. He then marched
her—still naked—“down a dirt path which was overgrown with vegetation and in an
area full of trash used as a dump.” Id. “Her death march ultimately ended at a small,
makeshift dock” on Middle Pearl River, where Plaintiff “forced [her] to kneel” and
“shot [her] in the head, execution style.” Id. Molly “likely survived for a few minutes
after being shot.” Id. But she was not discovered until Thanksgiving Day, when a
3
duck hunter came across her naked body on the dock. Id. at 549. For his part, Plaintiff
“soon thereafter” took his girlfriend shopping with Molly’s money. Id. at 550.
A jury convicted Plaintiff of first degree murder, and he was sentenced to
death. Id. at 549; see App.15 ¶ 61. His direct appeal was litigated to finality. Hoffman
v. Louisiana, 531 U.S. 946 (2000) (denying petition). And he exhausted all of his state
and federal post-conviction remedies. See State v. Hoffman, 2020-00137 (La.
10/19/21), 326 So. 3d 232, 235–36, 242 (collecting his post-conviction cases).
B. Although lethal injection was Louisiana’s method of execution when
Plaintiff murdered Molly, drug companies have since made it extraordinarily difficult
for States to obtain the necessary drugs. As a result, Louisiana and other States
recently have turned to nitrogen hypoxia because there are no supply concerns with
nitrogen. For Louisiana, that time came in the spring of 2024, when the Legislature
amended La. R.S. 15:569 to adopt nitrogen hypoxia as a method of execution.
Nitrogen hypoxia is Louisiana’s only currently available method. App.450 ¶ 17;
App.724.
Over the past year, Louisiana’s Department of Public Safety & Corrections
constructed a nitrogen hypoxia system that mirrors Alabama’s—and since 2024,
Alabama itself has successfully carried out four nitrogen hypoxia executions. In
general terms, the system delivers pure nitrogen to a full-face silicon mask with a
plexi-glass screen known as a “source respirator”—industrial grade and superior to
medical grade masks. App.452–53 ¶ 31; App.834. Thick, cushion material presses
against the face and creates a “virtually air tight seal.” Id. The mask has a one-way
4
inlet valve allowing for airflow into the mask from the industrial tube that delivers
both ambient air and nitrogen. Id. The mask also allows for exhaling through another
one-way exhaust valve. Id. (Plaintiff appears to complain that the system “uses
industrial grade, not medical grade, nitrogen,” Pet.5; he omits that medical grade
nitrogen is comparatively inferior because it has more impurities than does
Louisiana’s ultra-high grade nitrogen. App.452 ¶ 28; App.680–81.)
The State’s expert, Dr. Antognini, is the only expert in this case who inspected
and tested Louisiana’s system. Specifically, he laid down on the gurney with the mask
on at the intended flow rate—and he testified that he “could breathe very comfortably
with the mask on.” App.838. He also took a video (Defs.’ Ex. 19; App.842)
demonstrating how quickly pure nitrogen displaces oxygen in the mask: By 30
seconds, the air inside the mask is only 4.4% oxygen; 1.8% by 40 seconds; and so on.
App.849.
C. Almost immediately after the Legislature adopted nitrogen hypoxia,
Plaintiff attempted to reopen a dismissed-as-moot case challenging Louisiana’s
lethal-injection protocol. See Hoffman v. Jindal, No. 12-cv-796 (M.D. La.). That case
was dismissed a few years ago because Louisiana was (and still is) currently unable
to obtain the necessary drugs. With nitrogen now permitted under Louisiana law,
however, Plaintiff filed a Rule 60(b)(6) motion claiming that “there has since been a
material and extraordinary change of circumstances that gives rise to a live
controversy between the parties.” Mem. in Support of Mot. for Relief from J. at 1,
Hoffman v. Jindal (Hoffman I), No. 12-cv-796 (M.D. La. June 14, 2024), ECF 318-1.
5
For the next eight months, however, the district court took no action on that motion—
and Plaintiff refused to file this lawsuit.
Indeed, it was not until Plaintiff’s death warrant issued in early February 2025
that the Hoffman I docket bounced back. The district court issued an order reopening
the case—“on procedurally dubious grounds,” as the Fifth Circuit in this case would
later observe, Pet.App.3a. Hoffman I, ECF 337. The State sought mandamus relief
and secured an administrative stay on the basis that this was an improper exercise
of Rule 60(b)(6) authority. See In re Westcott, No. 25-30088 (5th Cir.).
D. Once Plaintiff realized that he would be unable to use his old case as a
subterfuge for challenging Louisiana’s new method of execution, he filed this lawsuit
(on February 25) and sought (on February 26) to enjoin his execution. App.1–61
(Complaint); App.62–102 (preliminary-injunction motion). In the ensuing two weeks,
the parties engaged in expedited discovery, motions practice, and an evidentiary
hearing on Friday, March 7, followed by proposed findings and conclusions filed at
9am on Sunday, March 9.
This case has substantially narrowed in the meantime because the district
court partially granted the State’s motion to dismiss certain claims from the bench
(App.522–24), and the court held (App.942–44) in its injunctive order that Plaintiff
was unlikely to succeed on certain other claims. As things stand, therefore, the only
live claim presented to the Fifth Circuit (and thus this Court) is Plaintiff’s Eighth
Amendment challenge to nitrogen hypoxia.
6
Here are a few key facts that inform that challenge. To begin, as the district
court recognized, both Plaintiff’s and the State’s experts “agree that nitrogen hypoxia
does not produce physical pain.” App.934. Plaintiff’s case thus depends on alleged
psychological pain. To that end, he testified that he is Buddhist and engages in
meditative breathing twice a day, which requires concentrated “deep breaths”—both
inhaling and exhaling. App.455 ¶ 42. He also testified that he plans to use his
breathing techniques during his execution. App.455 ¶ 44. He put on a PTSD expert,
Dr. Sautter, who agreed that Plaintiff has mastered his breathing techniques to
control any PTSD issues—and so long as “he can practice the breathing, then he will
be able to decrease his distress.” App.491 ¶ 166. Plaintiff also put on another expert,
Dr. Bickler, who testified that—with normal breathing, and especially with deep
breaths as Plaintiff intends—unconsciousness will occur in less than a minute after
pure nitrogen begins to flow into the mask. App.481 ¶ 138; App.783. Dr. Bickler also
testified that, at least in the assisted-suicide context, “allowing the free flow of a gas
into the lungs but with no oxygen causes a gentle hypoxic death.” App.803. His only
excuse for taking the opposite position with respect to the use of nitrogen here was
“that’s a very different context than forced asphyxiation with nitrogen in a death
chamber.” App.804.
The State’s expert, Dr. Antognini (whom the Alabama courts have uniformly
credited), agreed on the key facts: “His opinion is that Louisiana’s system will cause
unconsciousness within 35 to 40 seconds (or perhaps sooner) once Plaintiff begins to
inhale pure nitrogen—and he expects death to follow ‘rapidly,’ within 10 to 15
7
minutes.” App.480 ¶ 137; see App.832. “I do not believe the inmate would suffer any
pain ... with that system.” App.832.
For his part, Plaintiff proposed the firing squad and a drug cocktail known as
DDMAPh as alternative methods of execution that render nitrogen hypoxia
unconstitutional. In granting Plaintiff’s motion for preliminary injunction on March
11, the district court rejected DDMAPh (because the State cannot use drugs for
execution purposes, App.941), but agreed that the firing squad is a suitable
alternative. App.938–40.
On March 14, the Fifth Circuit (Ho and Oldham, JJ.) vacated that injunction
as “not just wrong” but “[c]onstitutional[ly] backwards.” Pet.App.2a. Specifically, the
Fifth Circuit rejected the idea “that the Eighth Amendment somehow requires
Louisiana to use an admittedly more painful method of execution—namely, execution
by firing squad rather than nitrogen hypoxia.” Id. The Fifth Circuit recognized that
both sides’ experts testified about pain from the firing squad while also agreeing that
nitrogen hypoxia is physically painless. Pet.App.7a. The Fifth Circuit thus held that,
as a matter of law, Plaintiff could not carry his burden under Bucklew and related
cases to show that execution by firing squad would significantly reduce a substantial
risk of severe pain from nitrogen hypoxia. Id. On top of that, the Fifth Circuit
emphasized that, although he invoked “superadded terror,” Plaintiff “presented no
such evidence of superadded terror to the court—let alone evidence of how execution
by a firing squad would substantially mitigate that terror.” Pet.App.8a.
8
“In sum, the district court didn’t just get the legal analysis wrong—it turned
the Constitution on its head by relying on an indisputably more painful method of
execution” than nitrogen hypoxia. Id. “Reasonable minds can differ on the proper
understanding of the Eighth Amendment in certain cases, but surely we can all agree
that it does not require State officials to favor more painful methods of execution over
less painful ones.” Id.
Judge Haynes dissented on the ground that “there are issues that need more
time to be resolved and decided.” Pet.App.9a. She also believed that “the majority
opinion does not adequately address the facts as properly found by the district court.”
Pet.App.10a.
ARGUMENT
I.
ON THE EQUITIES, PLAINTIFF’S DELAYS ALONE WARRANT THE DENIAL OF A
STAY.
The Court need address nothing more than Plaintiff’s litigation conduct to deny
a stay of execution and his petition for writ of certiorari. The Court has long held that
“late-breaking changes in position, last-minute claims arising from long-known facts,
and other ‘attempt[s] at manipulation’ can provide a sound basis for denying
equitable relief in capital cases.” Ramirez v. Collier, 595 U.S. 411, 434 (2022) (citation
omitted). Accordingly, “[c]ourts should police carefully against attempts to use such
challenges as tools to interpose unjustified delay.” Bucklew, 587 U.S. at 150. “Lastminute stays should be the extreme exception, not the norm, and ‘the last-minute
nature of an application’ that ‘could have been brought’ earlier, or ‘an applicant’s
9
attempt at manipulation,’ ‘may be grounds for denial of a stay.’” Id. (quoting Hill v.
McDonough, 547 U.S. 573, 584 (2006)).
That is this case—at least twice over. First, there is no good reason why
Plaintiff waited to file his stay application and cert petition until midnight last night,
leaving the State just a few hours to prepare this response and this Court little more
than a day to adjudicate these filings. The Fifth Circuit’s decision came out on Friday,
March 14. This is a quintessential “[l]ast-minute stay” request that “should be the
extreme exception”—and Plaintiff has identified no reason why this case is
exceptional. Id.
Second, Plaintiff told the Fifth Circuit two weeks ago that he has had a live
controversy for eight months. See Pls’ Opp. to Request for Admin. Stay at 9, In re
Westcott, No. 25-30088 (5th Cir. Feb. 27, 2025) (“Plaintiffs diligently moved to reopen
the proceedings [in July 2024] prior to the change in the law, as soon as a justiciable
controversy re-emerged.”). Yet he refused to file this lawsuit eight months ago.
Instead, he put all his eggs in a “procedurally dubious” (Pet.App.3a) basket of hope
that the district court would reopen his long-dismissed suit and allow him to skip the
hassle of filing a new lawsuit. That strategy is inexplicable—and also an undisputed
fact.
Now, Plaintiff tries to turn his delay on the State by protesting the denial of
some grievances from nearly a year ago (and also the State’s opposition to Plaintiff’s
abuse of Rule 60(b)(6)). Appl.8. That is misdirection. His own timeline (id.) makes
clear that he sat on his hands from July 2024 until February 2025, refusing to file
10
this lawsuit until three weeks ago. It is thus remarkable to read his representation
that he “has been diligently pursuing his rights in state and federal courts alike.”
Appl.9. He, the State, and the Court are in this eleventh-hour time crunch solely
because he refused to file this lawsuit eight months ago when he says he had a
justiciable controversy. And to drive this point home, there is nothing in the district
court’s analysis or the Fifth Circuit’s decision that could not have been written
months ago. Whether the Court deems that delay or manipulation, it is a fact that
tilts the equities in the State’s favor.
The State (and therefore also the public because the factors merge) has an
unquestionably compelling interest in Plaintiff’s execution. See Bucklew, 587 U.S. at
150 (“Under our Constitution, the question of capital punishment belongs to the
people and their representatives ....”); Nelson v. Campbell, 541 U.S. 637, 644 (2004)
(“[A] State retains a significant interest in meting out a sentence of death in a timely
fashion.”); Calderon v. Thompson, 523 U.S. 538, 556 (1998) (“To unsettle these
expectations [of finality] is to inflict a profound injury to the ‘powerful and legitimate
interest in punishing the guilty,’ an interest shared by the State and the victims of
crime alike.” (quotation omitted)); In re Blodgett, 502 U.S. 236, 239 (1992) (The State’s
“sovereign power to enforce [its] criminal law” carries “great weight.”); Moran v.
Burbine, 475 U.S. 412, 426 (1986) (recognizing “society’s compelling interest in
finding, convicting, and punishing those who violate the law”). On the equities factors
alone, therefore, the Court should deny Plaintiff’s application and petition.
11
II.
IF THE COURT REACHES THE MERITS, THERE IS NO REASONABLE
PROBABILITY THAT THE COURT WILL GRANT CERTIORARI OR FAIR PROSPECT
THAT PLAINTIFF WILL SUCCEED ON THE MERITS.
A.
Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment Question Is Not Cert-Worthy and
Has No Merit.
Plaintiff’s first question presented asks
[w]hether a method of execution that superadds psychological
suffering—including terror and mental anguish—compared to an
available alternative method violates the Eighth Amendment’s bar on
cruel and unusual punishment.
Pet.i. That is puzzling because the Fifth Circuit did not answer no—and Plaintiff
would not benefit from this Court’s answering yes. That is because the Fifth Circuit
held that Plaintiff failed to substantiate the premise of this question: that execution
by nitrogen hypoxia, in fact, superadds “psychological suffering” compared to
execution by firing squad. By failing to appeal that fact-bound and split-less question,
Plaintiff has effectively conceded that both cert and reversal are exceedingly unlikely.
1. Plaintiff’s question presented mischaracterizes the decision
below—and Plaintiff would receive no effectual relief from
the Court answering it.
Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment question presented rests on a straw man. He
claims that the Fifth Circuit rejected his Eighth Amendment claim on the ground
that so-called “psychological terror” “was not relevant” to the Eighth Amendment
analysis—that only “physical pain” is relevant. Pet.19, 21. He then concocts a circuit
split based off of the Fifth Circuit’s supposed “physical-pain-only approach.” Pet.21. 1
That blatantly mischaracterizes the Fifth Circuit’s decision below.
1 “Concocts” because there is no circuit split. No court of appeals holds that
12
The Fifth Circuit determined that Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment claim “fails
on multiple levels.” Pet.App.7a (emphasis added). The first level, as Plaintiff
recognizes, is that “the district court heard expert testimony from both parties that
nitrogen hypoxia is painless.” Id.; see App.934 (district court finding that “[b]oth
experts agree that nitrogen hypoxia does not produce physical pain”). By contrast,
“experts for both parties agreed that death by firing squad can cause pain—and would
therefore necessarily be more painful than execution by nitrogen hypoxia.”
Pet.App.7a; compare App. 494 (citing App.877) (only the State’s expert making this
comparison), with App.932–34 (district court ignoring this fact). The Fifth Circuit
thus correctly recognized that Plaintiff “cannot possibly” satisfy this Court’s Bucklew
standard, which required (among other things) Plaintiff to identify a feasible
alternative “that would significantly reduce a substantial risk of severe pain.” 587
U.S. at 134.
The second level on which Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment claim fails comes from
“the fact that the Supreme Court has previously ‘upheld a sentence of death by firing
terror categorically is irrelevant to the Eighth Amendment analysis. All Plaintiff can
muster for that view is that the Sixth Circuit “appears” to hold it. Pet.21 (citing In re
Ohio Execution Protocol Litig., 881 F.3d 447, 450 (6th Cir. 2018)). The cited Sixth
Circuit decision, however, simply says that ordinary psychological pain and suffering
that “is a likely result of being sentenced to death and anticipating the execution”
does not alone violate the Eighth Amendment. In re Ohio Execution Protocol Litig.,
881 F.3d at 450 (citation omitted). And the Eleventh Circuit—which Plaintiff
characterizes as splitting with the Sixth Circuit, Pet.21–22—agrees. See Grayson v.
Comm’r, Ala. Dep’t of Corr., 121 F.4th 894, 900 n.3 (11th Cir. 2024) (acknowledging
that “[t]here may exist a form of execution that induces psychological terror or pain
that is severe enough to support an Eighth Amendment claim,” but affirming as not
clearly erroneous the district court’s finding “that the likely psychological pain [in
Grayson] is ‘a type of pain that would exist regardless of the method of execution’”).
13
squad.’” Pet.App.7a (citation omitted). “So Hoffman has the impossible task of
challenging a method of execution that he admits is less painful than other
established methods of execution that the Supreme Court has already blessed.” Id.
(It bears noting, moreover, that Plaintiff does not dispute any of this.)
At this point, Plaintiff claims that the Fifth Circuit ended its analysis and
“categorical[ly] reject[ed] [] psychological suffering as a constitutional consideration.”
Pet.3; see Pet.21 (“constitutionally irrelevant”), 23 (“discarded in the Eighth
Amendment analysis”). That is unequivocally false. The Fifth Circuit expressly noted
that the third level on which Plaintiff’s claim fails is his and the district court’s
“focus[] on psychological terror.” Pet.App.7a. The Fifth Circuit emphasized that “the
Constitution only forbids the ‘superaddition’ of terror that is greater than an
alternative method of execution.” Pet.App.7a–8a. (Which is exactly what the other
circuits recognize, too. See supra n.1.) And the fatal defect here, said the Fifth Circuit,
is that Plaintiff “presented no such evidence of superadded terror to the court—let
alone evidence of how execution by a firing squad would substantially mitigate that
terror.” Pet.App.8a. Instead, Plaintiff and the district court pointed to no more than
the usual “measure of psychological terror” that accompanies every execution, which
does not make out an Eighth Amendment violation (again, as the circuits recognize).
Id.
Plaintiff’s question presented thus whistles past the key defect below. He asks
this Court to answer whether “a method of execution that superadds psychological
suffering” violates the Eighth Amendment. Pet.i. But he failed to prove that execution
14
by nitrogen hypoxia is such a method in the first place. Whether the Court answers
yes or no to the question presented, therefore, would give Plaintiff no effectual relief
because that ruling would leave undisturbed the Fifth Circuit’s holding that Plaintiff
“presented no such evidence of superadded terror to the court—let alone evidence of
how execution by a firing squad would substantially mitigate that terror.”
Pet.App.8a. The Court is thus exceedingly unlikely to grant cert on this question,
much less reverse.
2. Plaintiff’s real question presented is fact-bound, satisfies
none of this Court’s cert criteria, and identifies no error.
Indeed, the best evidence of this is that Plaintiff’s “circuit-split” argument
fades into a complaint that the Fifth Circuit improperly conducted its own abuse-ofdiscretion and clear-error review. Pet.24–27. Of course, that complaint implicates no
circuit split and is, by definition, fact-bound and a plea for error correction—and the
Court’s analysis could stop there. But Plaintiff does not even identify an error. He
says “[j]ust two examples suffice.” Pet.26.
a. First, he complains that “the panel majority never acknowledged the district
court’s finding that conscious terror and a sense of suffocation endures for at least 35
to 40 seconds but can last up to three to five minutes.” Id. (emphases omitted). He
then accuses the Fifth Circuit of “ma[king] its own factual finding that ‘[b]reathing
100% pure nitrogen causes unconsciousness in less than a minute.’” Id. (quoting
Pet.App.3a).
Plaintiff misrepresents the record. The district court itself credited Plaintiff’s
expert, Dr. Bickler, who “candidly concede[d] that a person who is administered 100%
15
pure nitrogen and is breathing normally will lose consciousness in less than one
minute.” App.934. The Fifth Circuit did not “make up its own factual findings.”
Moreover, the Fifth Circuit did not reference the alleged “three to five minutes”
of suffering because there is no valid basis for it. That number comes from the district
court’s assumption that Plaintiff might hold his breath, refuse to breathe nitrogen,
and thus increase any alleged sense of terror. The court did so by invoking Plaintiff’s
expert, Dr. Bickler. See App.934 (“[I]f the condemned holds his breath, Dr. Bickler
opines that it could take 3 to 5 minutes to lose consciousness.”); accord App.935, 936.
And Dr. Bickler himself acknowledged that he was inflating his opinion with the
“expect[ation] that [Plaintiff] would hold his breath and then probably attempt to
breathe shallowly and then only slowly get hypoxic, all the while experiencing the
effects of the progressing hypoxia and buildup of carbon dioxide in his blood.”
App.758. This is misdirection. 2
For one, as the district court acknowledged, “Plaintiff admits that he will have
the ability to breathe in the nitrogen as it is administered.” App.925. In fact, Plaintiff
testified that he “plan[s] to use [his] meditative breathing techniques,” which involve
“deep breaths,” when he is executed through nitrogen hypoxia. App.490 ¶ 164; accord
App.925 (district court’s conclusion that “there is no substantial burden to his
2 The same goes for Plaintiff’s characterization of Dr. Antognini as testifying
that Plaintiff will endure “severe emotional suffering.” Pet.11. He omits that the cited
transcript reflects Dr. Antognini’s answers to Plaintiff’s counsel’s questions about
“hold[ing] your breath”—Dr. Antognini did not testify that Plaintiff would hold his
breath. App.886–87.
16
exercise of rhythmic breathing”). There is thus no basis for the district court’s and
Dr. Bickler’s speculation that Plaintiff might self-inflict harm by refusing to breathe.
For another, as just explained, this point matters because it directly impacts
the amount of time between the initiation of pure nitrogen and Plaintiff’s loss of
consciousness. Again, Dr. Bickler “candidly conceded that a person who is
administered 100% pure nitrogen and is breathing normally will lose consciousness
in less than one minute.” App.934. But the court omitted that Dr. Bickler also
conceded that it is possible that “[a] person who is taking deep breaths”—as Plaintiff
testified he intends to do—“will lose consciousness even quicker than that.” App.481
¶ 138; App.783. Because that window will be exceedingly narrow, the district court’s
trumpeting of “conscious psychological suffering” for several minutes is completely
baseless. App.936.
For yet another, even if this record were to suggest that Plaintiff intended to
hold his breath, that would bar him from obtaining a preliminary injunction or stay
of his execution. For it is hornbook law that “a party may not satisfy the irreparable
harm requirement if the harm complained of is self-inflicted.” State v. Biden, 10 F.4th
538, 558 (5th Cir. 2021) (alteration and citation omitted) (collecting authorities).
And on top of all this, remember that Dr. Bickler likewise testified that, at
least in the assisted-suicide context, the administration of 100% nitrogen would cause
a “gentle hypoxic death.” App.804, 806. Why not here? Because “that’s a very different
context than forced asphyxiation with nitrogen in a death chamber.” App.804. Dr.
Bickler’s tailor-made “death when the State does it is different” excuse does not work.
17
See, e.g., Frazier, 2025 WL 361172, at *12 (rejecting complaints about suffering that
“is inherent in any execution”). For these reasons, Plaintiff identifies no cert-worthy
issue regarding the Fifth Circuit’s ignoring the alleged “three to five minutes”
speculation from the district court and Dr. Bickler.
b. Second, Plaintiff complains that the Fifth Circuit “ignored the district
court’s finding that execution by firing squad would render Mr. Hoffman unconscious
in three to four seconds.” Pet.26. In his view, the Fifth Circuit refused to “engage with
the district court’s comparative assessment of conscious terror caused by [the firing
squad and nitrogen hypoxia],” and instead “summarily concluded that Mr. Hoffman
had presented ‘no evidence of superadded terror.’” Id. (cleaned up).
Plaintiff has three problems. One, he submitted no evidence or testimony
actually conducting a “comparative assessment of conscious terror” caused by the two
methods—in fact, he did not submit any evidence or testimony describing the
“conscious terror” presented by the firing squad at all. His firing-squad expert, Dr.
Williams, expressly testified that he “offered no psychological evidence.” App.634. The
district court thus had no evidentiary basis to evaluate any alleged terror from the
firing squad, much less to compare that terror against alleged terror from execution
by nitrogen hypoxia.
Two, despite that evidentiary gap, the district court simply assumed that all
terror is created equal and compared final potential moments of consciousness: the
three to four seconds after being shot by the firing squad and the 30 to 40 seconds
after 100% nitrogen begins to flow. See App.939. That makes zero sense. For one,
18
imagine the terror of being alive and conscious with a gaping hole in your chest. It is
easy to suspect that such terror would far exceed any, for example, alleged terror from
“short[ness] of breath” that may come as Plaintiff loses consciousness from nitrogen
hypoxia. App.911 (Dr. Bickler’s testimony). For another, common sense suggests that
any firing squad-related terror would come long before shots ring out—think about
being led to the execution chair, positioned in front of the firing squad or gun ports,
restrained, and hooded, and then waiting for the shots that will end your life. The
district court’s blinkered focus on the three to four seconds after shots are fired makes
no sense.
Three, and perhaps most damning, the district court left out that Plaintiff’s
PTSD expert, Dr. Sautter, testified that Plaintiff’s traumatic history of being held at
gunpoint is “one of the stimuli” that could trigger Plaintiff’s PTSD—and he
acknowledged that this would be a problem if Plaintiff were “placed in front of a firing
squad.” App.495–96 ¶ 179; App.589. It was thus preposterous for the district court to
gerrymander the three to four seconds after a firing squad fires its shots and
summarily proclaim that Plaintiff “has clearly demonstrated that he is substantially
likely to prevail in his assertion that nitrogen hypoxia superadds pain and terror as
compared to firing squad.” App.939.
*
*
*
In short, Plaintiff’s cursory and fact-bound Eighth Amendment arguments do
not withstand scrutiny—and they certainly are not cert-worthy.
19
3. The Fifth Circuit’s decision is independently correct because
there are legitimate penological reasons to choose nitrogen
hypoxia over the firing squad.
Although the Court need not reach this issue (and the Fifth Circuit did not
need to reach it either), Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment claim independently fails
because there are legitimate penological reasons to prefer nitrogen hypoxia over the
firing squad.
As the Fifth Circuit explained, the undisputed evidence is that the firing squad
is more physically painful than nitrogen. In its effort to efficiently and humanely
carry out death sentences, therefore, Louisiana reasonably selected the least
physically painful method vis-à-vis firing squad. Cf. Bucklew, 587 U.S. at 134 (even
“traditionally accepted methods of execution—such as hanging, the firing squad,
electrocution, and lethal injection—are [not] necessarily rendered unconstitutional
as soon as an arguably more humane method like lethal injection becomes available”).
Consider also the logistical and emotional costs of the firing squad—requiring
multiple individuals (who will know whether they fired a live or blank round, App.496
¶ 181; App.632) to pull the trigger; preparing to clean an execution chamber covered
in blood, bones, and tissue; and handling the shattered body of the condemned postexecution. None of these serious issues are presented by nitrogen hypoxia, which is
quick and clinical. Cf. Bucklew, 587 U.S. at 134 (“a State has a legitimate interest in
selecting a method it regards as ‘preserving the dignity of the procedure’”).
And finally, it is worth noting that—after being unable to obtain lethalinjection drugs for years—Louisiana adopted nitrogen on the heels of Alabama’s first
successful execution by nitrogen hypoxia. Louisiana’s gravitation toward a viable
20
method of execution (for which “‘[n]o supply concerns exist’”) is itself a “valid
penological reason to decline to adopt [Plaintiff’s] proposed alternative method.”
Frazier, 2025 WL 361172, at *13–14.
At bottom, therefore, Louisiana had legitimate penological reasons not to adopt
the firing squad—and that independently dooms Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment
claim.
B.
Plaintiff’s RLUIPA Question Is Not Cert-Worthy and Has No
Merit.
Plaintiff also presents the question
[w]hether execution by nitrogen gassing substantially burdens Mr.
Hoffman’s Buddhist faith, in violation of the Religious Land Use and
Institutionalized Persons Act, 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc et seq. (“RLUIPA”), by
denying him the opportunity to meditatively breathe during his final
moments.
Pet.i. As an initial matter, this Court’s decision in Ramirez makes clear that Plaintiff
cannot use RLUIPA to stay his execution. But, even if that were not so, this question
is not cert-worthy because it comes to this Court only under the deferential standard
of review for the denial of a motion for reconsideration, and because it satisfies none
of the Court’s cert criteria. And finally, the district court did not abuse its discretion
in resolving this fact-bound reconsideration issue against Plaintiff.
1. Plaintiff cannot use RLUIPA to stop his execution.
At the outset, by wielding RLUIPA to try to stop his execution, Plaintiff runs
headlong into Ramirez. There, the Court emphasized that RLUIPA is an
“accommodation” statute. 595 U.S. at 425. Thus, if “a court determines that relief is
appropriate under RLUIPA, the proper remedy is an injunction ordering the
21
accommodation, not a stay of the execution.” Id. at 436. Put otherwise, “a tailored
injunction,” “rather than a stay of execution,” “will be the proper form of equitable
relief when a prisoner raises a RLUIPA claim in the execution context.” Id. at 433–
34. That distinction is critical because, while prisoners “have a strong interest in
avoiding substantial burdens on their religious exercises,” the States and crime
victims have a concomitant “interest in the timely enforcement of a sentence.” Id. at
433 (citation omitted).
Here, however, Plaintiff avowedly wields RLUIPA to stop his execution—not
to obtain a religious accommodation for his execution. His Complaint seeks a
“declar[ation] that it violates RLUIPA for Defendants to execute Mr. Hoffman by
nitrogen gas given Mr. Hoffman’s sincerely held Buddhist religious practices” and an
injunction against his execution on the same basis. App.49. Indeed, as the State
explained below, Plaintiff’s pre-litigation prison grievances never even mentioned
RLUIPA, let alone requested a religious accommodation. App.116–17, 136; see
App.152–59 (grievances). Instead, Plaintiff is doing precisely what the plaintiff in
Ramirez was not: attempting to “delay[] or imped[e] his execution.” 595 U.S. at 434.
To be sure, the Court in Ramirez entered a brief stay of execution so that it
could consider the RLUIPA question, see id. at 420—but that was entirely proper
given that, as the Court ultimately held, the Ramirez plaintiff “request[ed] a tailored
injunction” rather than “an open-ended stay of execution.” Id. at 433. Just the
opposite here: Plaintiff seeks indefinitely to stop his execution. Ramirez bars that
22
attempt on the merits—and thus also bars his attempt to leverage the RLUIPA issue
in service of a stay of execution.
2. Plaintiff’s conceded inability to appeal the underlying merits
ruling presents an obvious vehicle problem.
In all events, Plaintiff appears to recognize that he has a fatal vehicle problem
on this issue. The district court dismissed his RLUIPA claim from the bench in a
ruling that Plaintiff did not (and could not) appeal because that is not an appealable
final order. See ROA.3119–22 (notice of appeal appealing only Friday, March 11,
order); App.522–24 (March 7 dismissal of RLUIPA claim). For that reason, Plaintiff
attempts to bring the RLUIPA issue to this Court by way of the denial of his motion
for reconsideration of the dismissal ruling, since the district court also denied the
motion for reconsideration in the March 11 injunctive order. Pet.15–16 n.1.
And there is the rub: This Court’s review of the facts and law regarding the
RLUIPA issue would be constrained by the steep abuse-of-discretion standard. See,
e.g., Caribbean Mgmt. Grp., Inc. v. Erikon LLC, 966 F.3d 35, 44 (1st Cir. 2020) (“We
review the denial of a motion for reconsideration for abuse of discretion.”); SPV-LS,
LLC v. Transamerica Life Ins. Co., 912 F.3d 1106, 1111 (8th Cir. 2019) (“A district
court has wide discretion over whether to grant a motion for reconsideration of a prior
order, and we will reverse a denial of a motion for reconsideration only for a clear
abuse of discretion.” (cleaned up)). This Court almost always declines this sort of
defective vehicle in favor of a future case where the Court can directly review the
underlying merits ruling itself. It should do the same here.
23
3. Plaintiff’s RLUIPA question does not satisfy the cert criteria.
Further, as Plaintiff’s silence (see Pet.27–31) suggests, this RLUIPA question
does not implicate any division of authority that warrants this Court’s intervention.
And Plaintiff nowhere explains how this question is exceptionally important—it
appears that no one has ever raised it, that it is not recurring, and that it is just a
fact-bound issue intended to stop Plaintiff’s execution altogether. This Court’s Rule
10 criteria thus independently establish that cert is unlikely.
4. The district court did not abuse its discretion in declining to
reconsider its dismissal of Plaintiff’s fact-bound RLUIPA
claim.
If the Court considers the merits, the district court did not abuse its discretion
in its fact-bound denial of Plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration. Under that
deferential standard, “[a]n abuse of discretion will be found only if the district court’s
judgment was based on clearly erroneous factual findings or erroneous legal
conclusions.” SPV-LS, LLC, 912 F.3d at 1111 (citation omitted); see Caribbean Mgmt.
Grp., Inc., 966 F.3d at 44–45 (“To prevail on such a motion, ‘a party normally must
demonstrate either that new and important evidence, previously unavailable, has
surfaced or that the original judgment was premised on a manifest error of law or
fact.’” (citation omitted)). Plaintiff cannot meet that high standard here for at least
three reasons.
a. First, he has waived any argument that he will be unable “to meditatively
breathe during his final moments.” Pet.i. As the district court recounted, Plaintiff’s
argument in the district court was that his “‘sincerely held religious beliefs are
substantially burdened not because he will be unable to breathe’ but because he will
24
be forced to breath[e] nitrogen instead of air.” App.925 (emphasis Plaintiff’s). The
district court then rejected that argument because, although “two Buddhist clerics
testified that air (not nitrogen) is necessary for meditative breathing,” “[t]hey cited
no religious text or instruction by the historical Buddha in support of this
proposition.” Id.
Plaintiff now conspicuously foregoes his argument that he must breathe
ambient air rather than nitrogen—but he cannot switch horses and claim that the
problem is he is unable to breathe at all. He “admit[ted] [below] that he will have the
ability to breathe in the nitrogen as it is administered.” App.925. He testified that he
is “planning to use [his] meditative breathing techniques” when he is executed.
App.545. And so, the district court properly held that “there is no substantial burden
to his exercise of rhythmic breathing.” App.925. Plaintiff cannot now sandbag the
courts below and the State by arguing that, in fact, he cannot breathe.
b. Second, Plaintiff complains that the district court’s RLUIPA findings on
reconsideration conflict with the Eighth Amendment findings. In support of that
complaint, Plaintiff cites “[e]yewitness accounts of all four Alabama executions by
nitrogen gassing [which] reveal that prisoners experienced ‘conscious terror for
several minutes, shaking, gasping, and other evidence of distress.’” Pet.29. Plaintiff’s
reliance is misplaced.
The Alabama courts have uniformly rejected attempts to use those media
reports as evidence that (a) the eyewitnesses knew when nitrogen began flowing and
(b) the prisoners were conscious during any movement. Those accounts are
25
“insufficiently reliable because [the eyewitnesses] d[id] not know”—and could not
know—“when the nitrogen began to flow.” Frazier, 2025 WL 361172, at *11 (footnote
omitted). Because they did not know time zero, the witnesses could not “‘reliably
pinpoint’” how soon after the introduction of nitrogen “‘an inmate los[t]
consciousness.’” Id. On top of that, the courts have recognized that “unconscious
individuals experience involuntary movements,” such as “‘muscle tremors and
convulsion-like activity.’” Id. at *12. It is thus “not supris[ing]” that the condemned
inmates exhibited “breaths and even convulsions[] after the introduction of an inert
gas—when a person is unconscious and unable to feel pain.” Id. For that reason, “the
evidence of Smith’s, Miller’s, and Grayson’s movements during their respective
executions does not support a finding that any of them experienced severe
psychological pain or distress over and above what is inherent in any execution.” Id.;
see id. at *11 (rejecting argument that these reports “are evidence that inmates
remained conscious after the nitrogen began flowing and were distressed and in
pain”). 3 And that was one of the glaring problems in the district court’s injunction
3 To the extent this district court also invoked the Smith execution, the court
ignored that his execution was principally complicated by his own “non-cooperation
with the execution process,” specifically his “breath-holding,” which “would have
increased the level of carbon dioxide in his body, acidifying his blood and increasing
discomfort and distress.” App.488 ¶ 158. As the Alabama courts recognized, the
evidence from the Smith execution showed that Smith refused to inhale the nitrogen,
which caused the reaction Plaintiff now highlights. Frazier, 2025 WL 361172, at *5
& nn.9–10, *11 n.20; Grayson, 2024 WL 4701875, at *21 (“Smith held his breath and
struggled against the restraints while Miller did not.”). On top of that, Smith’s
autopsy showed that he had “a synthetic cannabinoid” in his blood that “can cause
hallucinations, vomiting, paranoia, and convulsions (seizures)”—which, in turn, may
have made Smith’s “convulsions more likely and pronounced.” App.488 ¶ 158;
Grayson, 2024 WL 4701875, at *17 n.18. None of this has anything to do with
26
order that Plaintiff does not now defend: Without acknowledging the Alabama
decisions to the contrary, the district court said that those “[e]yewitness accounts
from these executions are the most probative evidence of what death by forced
inhalation of nitrogen looks like.” App.931.
Perhaps because Plaintiff knows about this problem, he also cites Dr. Bickler’s
testimony as “consistent” with these accounts. Pet.29. But he omits that Dr. Bickler
expressly based his opinions (and the only paper cited in his expert declaration—his
own two-page opinion piece, ROA.139, 211) on those reports’ suggestion that the
Alabama executions “were prolonged, apparently agonizing, evidently painful and
traumatic.” ROA.3356; accord ROA.3384. Dr. Bickler’s opinions thus suffer from the
same unreliability that caused the Alabama courts to discount the media reports in
the first place. Plaintiff also tries (Pet.29) to puff up Dr. Bickler based on his “human
hypoxia” research. But he does not explain what that actually involves: “slowly
dropping subjects’ ‘oxygen saturation level to about 70 percent and sometimes lower,
down to 50 percent,’” and then holding them in that reduced-oxygen state for several
minutes. App.488 ¶ 159; App.867–68; App.769–70. That, of course, is nothing like the
facts here, which will involve rapid administration of pure nitrogen. As Dr. Antognini
put it, “probably at the 30- or 40-second level in the nitrogen hypoxia system, you’ve
already gone past the lower level of what Dr. Bickler ... would normally study. So
nitrogen’s constitutionality or efficacy as a method of execution—it has everything to
do with Smith’s own actions.
27
there isn’t really a lot of time for somebody to develop symptoms before they become
unconscious.” App.868. The puffery thus gets Dr. Bickler nowhere.
In short, for all the reasons why the district court’s and Dr. Bickler’s reliance
on the Alabama media reports was wrong as an Eighth Amendment matter, those
reports do nothing to undercut the district court’s holding that Plaintiff has no viable
RLUIPA claim.
c. Third, even if the Court reached the merits, Plaintiff’s RLUIPA claim would
not get off the ground. RLUIPA generally provides that the State shall not “impose a
substantial burden on the religious exercise” of a prisoner, unless the burden is “in
furtherance of a compelling governmental interest” and “the least restrictive means
of furthering that compelling governmental interest.” 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc-1(a).
Here, as explained above, Plaintiff failed to identify a substantial burden on
his religious exercise because he unquestionably can (and said he intends to) engage
in his meditative breathing as he is executed. But, even setting that aside, the State
would satisfy strict scrutiny.
There is no serious question that the State has a compelling interest in
pursuing justice by carrying out executions. Cf. Dunn v. Smith, 141 S. Ct. 725, 726
(2021) (Kavanaugh, J., dissenting from denial of application to vacate injunction)
(referencing “the State’s compelling interests in ensuring the safety, security, and
solemnity of the execution room”); Ramirez, 595 U.S. at 433 (“Both the State and the
victims of crime have an important interest in the timely enforcement of a sentence.”
(quoting Hill, 547 U.S. at 584)). Moreover, Defendants have no less restrictive means
28
of furthering that interest. There certainly is none under Louisiana law because
nitrogen is the only currently available method of execution. App.945 (district court
finding that “Louisiana has no readily available electric chair and cannot get the
drugs needed for lethal injunction” (footnotes omitted)). And Plaintiff has never
argued that there is a legally appreciable difference between his breathing as he fades
into unconsciousness by nitrogen hypoxia and his breathing as he would fade into
unconsciousness after being shot by a firing squad. Even on strict scrutiny, therefore,
Plaintiff’s RLUIPA claim would fail.
CONCLUSION
The Court should deny the Application to Stay Execution and the Petition for
Writ of Certiorari.
Respectfully submitted,
ELIZABETH B. MURRILL
Attorney General
J. BENJAMIN AGUIÑAGA
Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
ZACHARY FAIRCLOTH
Principal Deputy
Solicitor General
MORGAN BRUNGARD
KELSEY L. SMITH
Deputy Solicitors General
CAITLIN HUETTEMANN
Assistant Solicitor General
LOUISIANA DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
1885 N. Third St.
Baton Rouge, LA 70802
(225) 506-3746
AguinagaB@ag.louisiana.gov
29
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.