Respondents Brief — Ohio, et al., Petitioners v. Environmental Protection Agency, et al.
Supreme Court briefNov 21, 2024
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 24-450
In the Supreme Court of the United States
O HIO , ET AL .,
Petitioners,
v.
E NVIRONMENTAL P ROTECTION A GENCY , ET AL.
Respondents.
ON PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
BRIEF OF INDUSTRY RESPONDENTS IN
SUPPORT OF THE PETITION
David M. Flannery
Counsel of Record
Kathy G. Beckett
Edward L. Kropp
Keeleigh S. Huffman
STEPTOE & JOHNSON PLLC
Post Office Box 1588
Charleston, WV 25326
(304) 353-8000
Dave.Flannery@steptoe-johnson.com
Counsel for Midwest Ozone Group, American Forest &
Paper Association, and American Iron and Steel Institute
(additional counsel listed at the end)
i
QUESTION PRESENTED
Whether the Clean Air Act permits remand to the
EPA to supplement the administrative record with
new information and justifications after a rule is
promulgated.
ii
CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS
American Chemistry Council has no parent
corporation, and no publicly held company has 10
percent or greater ownership in American Chemistry
Council.
American Forest & Paper Association has
no parent corporation, and no publicly held company
has 10 percent or greater ownership in American
Forest & Paper Association.
American
Fuel
&
Petrochemical
Manufacturers has no parent companies, and no
publicly held company has a 10 percent or greater
ownership interest in American Fuel & Petrochemical
Manufacturers.
American Iron and Steel Institute has no
parent corporation, and no publicly held company has
10 percent or greater ownership in the American Iron
and Steel Institute.
American Petroleum Institute has no
parent corporation, and no publicly held corporation
has a 10 percent or greater ownership in American
Petroleum Institute.
America’s Power has no parent corporation,
and no publicly held company owns a 10 percent or
greater interest in America’s Power.
Arkansas League of Good Neighbors has no
parent corporation, and no publicly held company has
iii
10 percent or greater ownership in Arkansas League
of Good Neighbors.
Associated Electric Cooperative has no
parent company and no publicly held company has a
10 percent or greater ownership interest in Associated
Electric Cooperative.
Buckeye Power, Inc. does not have a parent
corporation and no publicly held corporation owns 10
percent or more of its stock or other membership
interests.
Deseret Power Electric Cooperative nor its
member cooperatives issue stock, and therefore no
publicly traded company owns 10 percent or more of
their stock.
Enbridge (U.S.) Inc. has no parent companies
and no publicly held company owns a 10 percent or
greater interest in Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.
Energy Transfer LP does not have a parent
corporation, and no publicly held corporation owns 10
percent or more of its stock.
Hybar LLC is 100 percent owned by Hybar
Intermediate Holdings LLC, which is 100 percent
owned by Green & Clean Holdings LLC. No publicly
held corporation owns 10 percent or more of the stock
of Hybar LLC, Hybar Intermediate Holdings LLC, or
Green & Clean Holdings LLC.
iv
Interstate Natural Gas Association of
America has no parent corporation, and no publicly
held corporation has a 10 percent or greater
ownership in Interstate Natural Gas Association of
America.
Kinder Morgan, Inc. does not have a parent
corporation, and no publicly held corporation holds 10
percent or more of Kinder Morgan’s stock.
Midwest Ozone Group has no parent
corporation, and no publicly held company has 10
percent or greater ownership in the Midwest Ozone
Group.
National Mining Association has no parent
corporation, and no publicly held company has 10
percent or greater ownership in in National Mining
Association.
The National Rural Electric Cooperative
Association has no parent corporation, and no
publicly held company has 10 percent or greater
ownership in National Rural Electric Cooperative
Association.
Ohio Valley Electric Corporation has no
parent company. American Electric Power Company,
Inc., and Buckeye Power, Inc., each owns greater than
10 percent of the equity in Ohio Valley Electric
Corporation.
The Portland Cement Association has no
parent corporation, and no publicly held company
v
owns a 10% or greater interest in the Portland
Cement Association.
TransCanada PipeLine USA Ltd. is an
indirectly owned subsidiary of TC Energy
Corporation. TC Energy Corporation is a federally
registered
Canadian
corporation,
with
its
headquarters in Calgary, Alberta. TC Energy
Corporation is a publicly held corporation with no
parent corporation. No entity (whether publicly or
privately held) has an ownership interest in TC
Energy Corporation of 10 percent or more.
United States Steel Corporation has no
parent company. The following publicly held
company has a 10% or greater ownership interest in
it: BlackRock, Inc.
Union Electric Company, d/b/a Ameren
Missouri, a Missouri corporation’s parent company is
Ameren Corporation, and the only subsidiary of Union
Electric Company that is not wholly owned by the
company is STARS Alliance, LLC, in which the
company owns a 25 percent interest. The only publicly
held company that has a 10 percent or greater
ownership interest in Union Electric Company is
Ameren Corporation
Wabash Valley Power Association d/b/a
Wabash Valley Power Alliance nor its member
cooperatives issue stock, and therefore no publicly
traded company owns 10 percent or more of their
stock.
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS
QUESTION PRESENTED .......................................... i
CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENTS ......... ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................... vi
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ..................................... vii
INTRODUCTION ........................................................1
REASONS FOR GRANTING CERTIORARI .............3
CONCLUSION ............................................................6
vii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases
Page(s)
Ohio v. EPA, 144 S. Ct. 2040 (2024) ..........................3
Statutes
42 U.S.C. § 7607 .....................................................3, 4
1
INTRODUCTION
Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 12.6,
Respondents American Chemistry Council, American
Forest & Paper Association, American Fuel &
Petrochemical Manufacturers, American Iron and
Steel Institute, American Petroleum Institute,
America’s Power, Arkansas League of Good
Neighbors, Associated Electric Cooperative, Buckeye
Power, Inc., Deseret Power Electric Cooperative,
Enbridge (U.S.) Inc., Energy Transfer LP, Hybar LLC,
Interstate Natural Gas Association of America,
Kinder Morgan, Inc., Midwest Ozone Group, National
Mining Association, National Rural Electric
Cooperative Association, Ohio Valley Electric
Corporation,
Portland
Cement
Association,
TransCanada Pipeline USA Ltd., United States Steel
Corporation, Union Electric Company, Wabash Valley
Power Association Alliance (collectively, “Industry
Respondents”) submit this brief in support of the
Petition for Writ of Certiorari filed by the States of
Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, and West Virginia
(“Petitioners”).
Industry Respondents wholeheartedly agree
with the Petitioners as to why this Court should
grant the Petition. See Pet. 17–29. Industry
Respondents file this brief to emphasize Petitioners’
arguments and to further explain why declining to
answer the Question Presented would provide the
2
United States Environmental Protection Agency
(“EPA”) with justification for its unlawful practice of
seeking a second bite of the apple after courts deem
its rules – or its records – lacking.
3
REASONS FOR GRANTING CERTIORARI
Industry Respondents agree with Petitioners
that EPA has intentionally undermined this Court
and the Clean Air Act.
In its June 27, 2024 opinion granting the
requested emergency stay of the Good Neighbor Plan,
this Court noted that after oral argument, EPA issued
a document attempting to justify its actions related to
the Good Neighbor Plan. See Ohio v. EPA, 144 S. Ct.
2040, 2055 (2024) (“Supreme Court Stay”). This Court
concluded that “the Clean Air Act prevents us (and
courts that may in the future assess the FIP’s merits)
from consulting explanations and information after
the rule’s promulgation.” Supreme Court Stay at 2055
n.11 (citing 42 U.S.C. § 7607(d)(6)(C), (d)(7)(A)). The
plain meaning of this quote is that any consideration
of this information or the explanations contained
therein would be improper under the Clean Air Act.
However, EPA chose to disregard this point entirely
and sought remand to supplement the deficiencies in
the record of the Good Neighbor Plan in the lower
court after merits briefing and before the merits have
been reached as to the current record. By granting
remand, the D.C. Circuit gave EPA a license to
subvert its responsibilities to promulgate fully
justified rules by allowing ongoing revisions to the
record as flaws are pointed out mid-litigation.
4
The remand order was unjustified and failed to
meaningfully explain how remand is appropriate in
these circumstances. A review of the Clean Air Act
and the order of this Court is clear. See 42 U.S.C. §
7607(d)(6)(C) (“The promulgated rule may not be
based (in part or whole) on any information or data
which has not been placed in the docket as the date of
such promulgation”); see also id. § 7607(d)(7)(A)
(limiting judicial review to only this information). The
remand order most certainly runs afoul of the Court’s
explicit language and ignores the appropriate remedy
available under the Clean Air Act – reversal.
Reversal, rather than remand would have been the
appropriate remedy for the badly broken Good
Neighbor Plan. There is no amount of record
supplement Band-Aids that EPA can use to address
all the deficiencies in the Rule, its record, and its
intended implementation scheme. The deficiencies
are substantive and any changes to the record will
fundamentally modify the circumstances such that
the Rule would not look remotely like the one
promulgated in 2023, which is counter to the Clean
Air Act. To allow EPA to construct a new rule and
record during the course of litigation of the original
rule without the opportunity for stakeholders to
comment, only to have the agency claim the two are
the same, is absurd and conflicts with basic principles
of administrative law.
5
EPA’s second bite of the apple here is an
explicit refusal to follow the direction of this Court
and the text of the Clean Air Act. Answering the
Question Presented will provide much needed clarity
about the appropriateness of record curative remands
in Clean Air Act challenges.
6
CONCLUSION
Accordingly, the Court should grant the Petition.
Respectfully submitted,
David M. Flannery
Counsel of Record
Kathy G. Beckett
Edward L. Kropp
Keeleigh S. Huffman
STEPTOE & JOHNSON PLLC
Post Office Box 1588
Charleston, WV 25326
(304) 353-8000
Dave.Flannery@steptoe-johnson.com
Midwest Ozone Group, American
Forest & Paper Association, and
American Iron and Steel Institute
NOVEMBER 21, 2024
7
ADDITIONAL COUNSEL
Laura K. McAfee
BEVERIDGE & DIAMOND, PC
201 North Charles Street, Suite 2200
Baltimore, MD 21201
Counsel for Enbridge (U.S.) Inc.
Brittany M. Pemberton
Jeffrey R. Holmstead
BRACEWELL LLP
2001 M Street N.W.
Suite 900
Washington, D.C. 20036
Counsel for Petitioner TransCanada Pipeline
USA Ltd.
Aaron M. Streett
Matthew L. Kuryla
Beau Carter
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
910 Louisiana Street
Houston, TX 77002
Counsel for Energy Transfer LP
8
Eric D. McArthur
SIDLEY AUSTIN LL P
1501 K Street, NW
Washington, DC 20005
Counsel for Interstate Natural Gas Association
of America and American Petroleum Institute
John D. Lazzaretti
SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS (US) LLP
1000 Key Tower
127 Public Square
Cleveland, OH 44114
Counsel for United States Steel
Corporation
Michael B. Schon
LEHOTSKY KELLER COHN LLP
200 Massachusetts Ave NW
Washington, DC 20001
Mithun Mansinghani
LEHOTSKY KELLER COHN LLP
629 W. Main St.
Oklahoma City, OK 73102
Counsel for National Mining Association
9
Christopher M. Brown
American Chemistry Council
700 2nd Street NE
Washington, DC 20009
Counsel for American Chemistry Council
Mark W. DeLaquil
BAKER & HOSTETLER LLC
Suite 1100
1050 Connecticut Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20036
Martin T. Booher
Joshua T. Wilson
BAKER & HOSTETLER LLC
2000 Ket Tower
127 Public Square
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Counsel for Hybar LLC
Ana M. Gutiérrez
Michael D. Miller
WOMBLE BOND DICKINSON (US) LLP
1899 Wynkoop St.
Denver, CO 80202
Counsel for Kinder Morgan, Inc.
10
Kelly M. McQueen
THE MCQUEEN FIRM, PLLC
12 Woodsong Drive
Roland, AR 72135
Counsel for Arkansas League of Good Neighbors
Elbert Lin
Kevin S. Elliker
David N. Goldman
HUNTON ANDREWS KURTH LLP
951 East Byrd Street, East Tower
Richmond, VA 23219
F. William Brownell
E. Carter Chandler Clements
HUNTON ANDREWS KURTH LLP
2200 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W.
Washington, DC 20037
Counsel for Union Electric Company, d/b/a Ameren
Missouri, and Arkansas League of Good Neighbors
Richard S. Moskowitz
American Fuel & Petrochemical
Manufacturers
1800 M Street, NW, Suite 900N
Washington, DC 20036
Counsel for Petitioner American Fuel &
Petrochemical Manufacturers
11
Allison D. Wood
Makram B. Jaber
Aaron M. Flynn
MCGUIRE WOODS LLP
888 16th Street N.W., Suite 500
Black Lives Matter Plaza
Washington, DC 20006
Counsel for Associated Electric Cooperative, Inc.,
Deseret Generation & Transmission Co-Operative
d/b/a Deseret Power Electric Cooperative, Ohio
Valley Electric Corporation, Wabash Valley Power
Association, Inc. d/b/a Wabash Valley Power
Alliance, America’s Power, National Rural Electric
Cooperative Association and Portland Cement
Association
Michael E. Born
Cheri A. Budzynski
Krystina E. Garabis
SHUMAKER, LOOP & KENDRICK, LLP
Huntington Center
41 South High Street
Suite 2400
Columbus, OH 43215
Counsel for Buckeye Power, Inc. and Ohio Valley
Electric Corporation
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.