Amicus Curiae Brief — Cambridge Christian School, Inc., Petitioner v. Florida High School Athletic Association, Inc.
Supreme Court briefJul 10, 2025
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 24-1261
In the Supreme Court of the United States
ɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆɆ
CAMBRIDGE CHRISTIAN SCHOOLS, INC.,
Petitioner,
v.
FLORIDA HIGH SCHOOL ATHLETIC ASSOCIATION, INC.,
Respondent
___________________
On Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
___________________
BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE THE AMERICAN LEGION
IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER
___________________
Shae McPhee
PERKINS COIE LLP
1201 Third Avenue
Suite 4900
Seattle, WA 98101-3099
Michael R. Huston
Counsel of Record
Jordan M. Buckwald
PERKINS COIE LLP
2525 E. Camelback Road
Suite 500
Phoenix, AZ 85016-4227
(202) 434-1630
mhuston@perkinscoie.com
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Interest of Amicus Curiae .................................................. 1
Summary of Argument ....................................................... 2
Argument ............................................................................. 4
A. The American Legion has a long tradition of
civic engagement and religious expression. ......... 4
1. The American Legion’s founding principles
and civic mission reflect its enduring
commitment to constitutional freedoms. ........ 4
2. The American Legion’s programs reflect
civic engagement rooted in tradition and
steeped in religious exercise. ........................... 5
B. The decision below threatens the American
Legion’s valuable civic traditions. ....................... 12
C. The decision below is incorrect. ........................... 17
1. Cambridge Christian School’s prayers are
not government speech. .................................. 17
2. The Eleventh Circuit’s decision improperly
revives Lemon. ................................................ 21
Conclusion .......................................................................... 25
ii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Pages
CASES
American Legion v. American Humanist Ass’n,
588 U.S. 29 (2019) ............................................... 1, 22, 23
Good News Club v. Milford Cent. Sch.,
533 U.S. 98 (2001) ......................................................... 18
Kennedy v. Bremerton School District,
597 U.S. 507 (2022) ............................................. 1, 20, 22
Lamb’s Chapel v. Ctr. Moriches Union Free Sch. Dist.,
508 U.S. 384 (1993) ....................................................... 18
Lee v. Weisman,
505 U.S. 577 (1992) ....................................................... 20
Lemon v. Kurtzman,
403 U.S. 602 (1971) ....................................... 3, 17, 20, 21
Marsh v. Chambers,
463 U.S. 783 (1983) ........................................... 22, 23, 24
McCreary Cnty., Ky. v. A.C.L.U. of Ky.,
545 U.S. 844 (2005) ....................................................... 22
Pleasant Grove City v. Summum,
555 U.S. 460 (2009) ....................................................... 19
Rosenberger v. Rector & Visitors of Univ. of Virginia,
515 U.S. 819 (1995) ....................................................... 18
Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe,
530 U.S. 290 (2000) ................................................. 20, 21
Shurtleff v. City of Boston,
596 U.S. 243 (2022) ........................... 3, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21
Town of Greece v. Galloway,
572 U.S. 565 (2014) ................................................. 22, 23
iii
Walker v. Texas Div., Sons of Confederate Veterans, Inc.,
576 U.S. 200 (2015) ................................................. 18, 19
Zorach v. Clauson,
343 U.S. 306 (1952) ........................................... 21, 22, 24
STATUTES
Federal Reserve Act, ch. 59, § 3, 41 Stat. 285 (1919)........ 4
Pub. L. No. 105-225, § 21701, 112 Stat. 1253 (1998) ......... 4
OTHER AUTHORITIES
American Legion, 2024 Officer’s Guide
and Manual of Ceremonies,
https://archive.legion.org/_flysystem/fedora/202
4-03/aa011597.pdf ........................................................... 6
American Legion, 2025 American Legion Legacy
Run, https://www.legion.org/getinvolved/community-programs/american-legionriders/the-american-legion-legacy-run ........................ 9
American Legion, About Boys State & Boys
Nation, https://www.legion.org/getinvolved/youth-programs/boys-state-boysnation/about-boys-state-boys-nation.......................... 11
American Legion, American Legion Chaplains,
https://www.legion.org/informationcenter/honor-remembrance/american-legionchaplains .......................................................................... 9
American Legion Auxiliary, ALA Girls State,
https://www.legion-aux.org/ala-girls-state ................ 11
American Legion, Chaplain’s Handbook: Service to
God and Country,
https://www.ohiolegion.com/wp-content/uploads/
Chaplains-Handbook.pdf ............................................... 9
iv
American Legion, Four Chaplains Day,
https://www.legion.org/getmedia/8474d80607ab-4638-be52-710cf8d16d37/60mag0120-fourchaplains-brochure-0.pdf ............................................. 10
American Legion, History of the American Legion,
https://www.legion.org/about/organization/history .... 4
American Legion, Legion Outlines Support for
Mental Health Legislation in Statement for the
Record (Apr. 29, 2025), https://www.legion.org .......... 8
American Legion, Memorial Day with the
American Legion Family (June 1, 2023),
available at https://www.legion.org .............................. 7
American Legion National Commander Honors
Four Chaplains in Florida,
YOUTUBE (Jan. 30, 2024),
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gn4BysYb5
X8 ................................................................................... 10
American Legion, Peace Cross,
https://www.legion.org/memorials/united-states/
maryland/united-states-maryland-peace-cross .......... 8
American Legion, Preamble to the Constitution,
https://www.legion.org/about/organization/
preamble.......................................................................... 4
American Legion, ‘Statue of Liberation’ Presented
to New Orleans Foundation (Aug. 28, 2024),
https://www.legion.org/informationcenter/news/convention/2024/august/statue-ofliberation-presented-to-new-orleans-foundation#:~:text=Mere%2DEglise.,would%20be%2
0proud%20of%20this.%E2%80%9D............................. 6
v
American Legion, VA Volunteer Services,
https://www.legion.org/get-involved/communityprograms/volunteering/va-volunteer services ............ 9
AP-NORC, The public’s opinion on religion in sports
(Sept. 29. 2022), https://apnorc.org/projects/thepublics-opinion-on-religion-in-sports/ ........................ 22
Chris McPherson, Eagles celebrate the life of Herb Lusk
(Sept. 26, 2022),
https://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/news/eaglescelebrate-the-life-of-herb-lusk-praying-tailback ...... 23
Congressman Van Orden attends West Salem’s
Memorial Day service (May 27, 2024),
https://vanorden.house.gov/media/in-thenews/wkbt-congressman-van-orden-attendswest-salems-memorial-day-service .............................. 7
Emily Canning-Dean, Medina’s American Legion
honors Mayor Hanwell with Four Chaplains
Award,
Cleveland Community News (Sept. 3, 2024),
https://www.cleveland.com/community/2024/09/
medinas-american-legion-honors-dennishanwell-with-four-chaplains-award.html................... 10
Iowa Dept. of Veterans Affairs, Rededication of a
Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Des Moines,
Iowa, https://dva.iowa.gov/events/iowa-vietnamveterans-recognition-day............................................... 7
vi
Jackson Thompson, ESPN airs pre-game prayer
for Cotton Bowl after backlash for not showing
national anthem after terror attack,
FOX NEWS (Jan. 11, 2025),
https://www.foxnews.com/sports/espn-airs-pregame-prayer-cotton-bowl-after-backlash-notshowing-national-anthem-after-terror-attack .......... 24
Jeff Stoffer, 500 Festival Memorial Service:
A Pause to Reflect (May 23, 2025), available at
https://www.legion.org ................................................... 7
Jeff Stoffer, National Chaplain: ‘God is Calling
You to be the One’ (Aug. 25, 2024), available at
https://www.legion.org ................................................. 10
Matt Grills, Georgia Post Invites Public to
Inaugural Four Chaplains Day Program (Jan.
30, 2025), available at https://www.legion.org ........... 10
Ruth Graham, Prayers for Damar Hamlin Show
Bond Between Football and Faith,
N.Y. Times (Jan. 7, 2023),
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/05/us/damarhamlin-prayers-football-religion.html ....................... 23
Senator Ruben Gallego, FACEBOOK (May 26, 2025),
https://www.facebook.com/SenRubenGallego/po
sts/honored-to-spend-memorial-day-at-my-ownpost-american-legion-post-41-with-golds/1263357725154367/ ...................................................... 7
1
INTEREST OF AMICUS CURIAE 1
The American Legion is one of the nation’s oldest and
most respected veterans’ service organizations. Since
1919, the American Legion has demonstrated an enduring
commitment to fostering patriotism, civic engagement,
and the values upon which the United States was founded.
Among its core values, the Legion sponsors youth programs that teach the rights, privileges, and responsibilities of citizenship; advocates for upholding and defending
the Constitution; and honors veterans by paying perpetual respect for all past military sacrifices to ensure they
are never forgotten by new generations. The Legion promotes these civic values in numerous ways, including by
organizing memorial services and maintaining veterans’
monuments across the country.
Many of these activities and memorials incorporate
religious imagery and expression, and the American
Legion has been steadfast in defending them against legal
challenges in this and other Courts. Among other cases,
the Legion successfully argued that the Bladensburg
Peace Cross—a memorial to soldiers lost in the First
World War—does not constitute an establishment of religion in violation of the First Amendment. See American
Legion v. American Humanist Ass’n, 588 U.S. 29 (2019).
The Legion also supported a high school football coach’s
First Amendment right to pray on the field in Kennedy v.
Bremerton School District, 597 U.S. 507 (2022).
Under Rule 37.2, amicus provided timely notice of its intention to
file this brief. Under Rule 37.6, no counsel for a party authored this
brief in whole or in part, and no person other than amicus or its counsel made a monetary contribution to its preparation or submission.
1
2
The American Legion urges this Court to grant the
petition for a writ of certiorari in this case to preserve
civic ceremonies that sometimes incorporate private religious expression—particularly when honoring those who
gave the last full measure of devotion to this country.
Local governments’ perennial litigation against religious
expression not only threatens to limit the role of religion
in important American traditions; it signals intolerance
towards citizens’ religious faith. As amicus curiae, the
Legion has an interest in ensuring States recognize the
significance of their citizens’ faiths and protect citizens’
rights to religious expression in the public sphere.
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
The American Legion, since its founding in 1919, has
played a central role in American civic life, blending patriotic service with a longstanding tradition of religious
expression. Its mission, as outlined in its federal charter
and constitution, emphasizes service to veterans, communities, and the nation, with a particular focus on upholding
constitutional freedoms, including religious liberty. The
Legion’s activities—commemoration events, public monument dedications, community service initiatives, support
for chaplaincy services, and civic education programs,
among many more—regularly incorporate some religious
elements such as prayers, hymns, invocations, and benedictions. These practices are rooted in our nation’s history
and tradition, and they are vital expressions of the values
and beliefs of many Americans, especially veterans and
their families.
The Eleventh Circuit’s recent decision significantly
expands the government-speech doctrine and thereby
threatens those civic and religious traditions. By treating
private religious expression at public events as government speech, the decision below risks suppressing or
3
chilling such expression and undermining the historical
partnership between veterans’ organizations and public
institutions. The opinion also distorts the First Amendment’s Religion and Free Speech Clauses, potentially
countenancing the wholesale exclusion of religious content from public ceremonies, memorials, and educational
programs. If other state and local governments were permitted to adopt the same anti-religion attitude that prevailed in the court of appeals here, then American culture
and civic life would suffer. Veterans, for example, would
be forced to censor their appeals to God when honoring
their fallen comrades from a public dais.
The court of appeals fundamentally erred by incorrectly classifying private religious expression—prayers
offered by a private individual at a public event—as government speech, despite the absence of any government
control or authorship over the message. Properly understood, this is not a government-speech case, and this
Court should grant the petition to correct the Eleventh
Circuit’s misunderstanding of this Court’s “holistic” test
for cases like this one. Shurtleff v. City of Boston, 596 U.S.
243, 252 (2022). The Eleventh Circuit neglected to consider the broader historical context of religious speech at
public events, the clear private identity of the speaker
here, and the lack of government involvement in shaping
the message. The court’s analysis not only confuses the
government-speech doctrine but risks reviving the muchmaligned and now firmly buried Lemon test, leading to
unwarranted suppression of religious expression in public
forums. Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U.S. 602 (1971).
This Court should grant the petition to make even
more clear that allowing private individuals to offer prayers at public events does not violate the Establishment
Clause. Doing so would respect this Court’s longstanding
4
precedent and American tradition, and prevent erosion of
First Amendment protections for religious speech.
ARGUMENT
A. The American Legion has a long tradition of civic
engagement and religious expression.
1. The American Legion’s founding principles and
civic mission reflect its enduring commitment to
constitutional freedoms.
The American Legion, chartered by Congress in 1919,
stands as one of the nation’s most prominent and enduring
civic organizations. See Federal Reserve Act, ch. 59, § 3,
41 Stat. 285 (1919); Pub. L. No. 105-225, § 21701, 112 Stat.
1253 (1998); American Legion, History of the American
Legion. 2 From its inception, the American Legion has
understood its role as much more than a veterans’ organization. The Legion’s federal charter, codified at 36 U.S.C.
§ 21701, charges it with upholding and defending the Constitution, promoting peace and good will, preserving the
memories and incidents of the nation’s wars, and encouraging mutual helpfulness and service to country. 36
U.S.C. § 21701. The preamble to the Legion’s constitution
captures this ethos: “For God and Country we associate
ourselves together for [these] purposes.” American
Legion, Preamble to the Constitution. 3
Those purposes are not abstract ideals; they are realized through concrete programs and public ceremonies
that bring together Americans of all backgrounds in the
shared work of civic life. With more than 1.6 million members and over 12,000 local posts worldwide, the American
2
https://www.legion.org/about/organization/history.
3
https://www.legion.org/about/organization/preamble.
5
Legion’s mission has always been rooted in service—to
veterans, communities, and the nation as a whole. Central
to this mission is a deep commitment to the values of citizenship, patriotism, and constitutional freedoms.
Among these freedoms, the right to religious expression has always held a special place in the Legion’s activities and traditions. Those expressions—encompassing a
wide range of religious belief systems—reflect the understanding that faith is not a purely private matter but a
source of strength, comfort, and moral guidance for many
Americans, especially for many of those who have served
in the armed forces and their families.
2. The American Legion’s programs reflect civic
engagement rooted in tradition and steeped in
religious exercise.
The American Legion carries out its commitment to
civic engagement through a wide array of programs that
reach millions of Americans each year. These are enormously valuable events that bring communities together.
They give comfort to grieving families, or teach future
generations to embrace love of country and neighbor.
Because of the nature of the Legion’s events, they
often involve private expressions of religious belief in public settings. Some examples include:
Commemorative Events. The American Legion is a
leading sponsor of military funerals, war memorials, and
similar commemorative ceremonies across the country,
many of which thoughtfully incorporate religious elements to honor the profound role of faith in the lives of
servicemembers and their families. Prayers, hymns, and
religious readings are longstanding features at these
events, serving to solemnize occasions where the Legion
pays tribute to those who have served or fallen, as well as
6
to their loved ones. See, e.g., The American Legion, 2024
Officer’s Guide and Manual of Ceremonies. 4
These traditions are especially evident during major
civic observances such as the Fourth of July, Memorial
Day, Veterans Day, POW and MIA Recognition Day, and
flag retirement ceremonies. Earlier this year, for example, Springfield American Legion Post 32 hosted the 91st
Annual American Legion National Pilgrimage to President Lincoln’s tomb—a ceremony that celebrates President Lincoln, veterans, freedom, and country. The
ceremony’s opening remarks echoed Lincoln’s own words:
“With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us
strive on to finish the work we are in, to bind up our
nation’s wounds… .” The ceremony concluded with a call
to “Honor the Soldier and Sailor everywhere … Honor
also the citizen who cares for his brother in the field …
Honor to him, only less than to him, who braves, for the
common good, the storms of heaven and the storms of battle.” Similarly, during a 2024 D-Day remembrance ceremony honoring Theordore Roosevelt Jr., American
Legion National Commander Daniel J. Seehafer invoked
the words of Scripture, reflecting that Roosevelt Jr. had
demonstrated, by his life, the truth that “Greater love
hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his
friends.” John 15:13 (KJV). See American Legion, ‘Statue
of Liberation’ Presented to New Orleans Foundation
(Aug. 28, 2024). 5
https://archive.legion.org/_flysystem/fedora/2024-03/aa011597.pdf
(describing standards for prayer during American Legion events).
4
https://www.legion.org/information-center/news/convention/2024/august/statue-of-liberation-presented-to-new-orleansfoundation#:~:text=Mere%2DEglise.,would%20be%20proud%20of%20this.%E2%80%9D.
5
7
At events like these, American Legion officers (including the National Commander, State Commanders, and
Judge Advocates) frequently join elected officials—from
local mayors to governors to members of Congress and
the President of the United States—in offering prayers,
leading anthems, performing rifle salutes, and laying
wreaths. These ceremonies, often held at cemeteries,
memorials, or war monuments, are often conducted with
open microphones for all to hear, and sometimes receive
coverage from local news and media outlets. See, e.g., Jeff
Stoffer, 500 Festival Memorial Service: A Pause to
Reflect (May 23, 2025); 6 American Legion, Memorial Day
with the American Legion Family (June 1, 2023) (listing
notable public figures); 7 Congressman Van Orden attends
West Salem’s Memorial Day service (May 27, 2024); 8 Senator Ruben Gallego, FACEBOOK (May 26, 2025). 9
Public Monument Dedications. The American Legion
has long played a pivotal role in the stewardship and dedication of public monuments that incorporate religious
imagery or inscriptions, such as crosses or Biblical references, on government property. See, e.g., Rededication of
a Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Des Moines, Iowa. 10
Currently the Legion is actively preparing for the upcoming centennial celebration of the Bladensburg Peace
6
Available at https://www.legion.org.
7
Ibid.
https://vanorden.house.gov/media/in-the-news/wkbt-congressmanvan-orden-attends-west-salems-memorial-day-service.
8
https://www.facebook.com/SenRubenGallego/posts/honored-tospend-memorial-day-at-my-own-post-american-legion-post-41-withgold-s/1263357725154367/ (last visited July 9, 2025).
9
https://dva.iowa.gov/events/iowa-vietnam-veterans-recognitionday (last visited July 9, 2025).
10
8
Cross memorial in Maryland—an event that will prominently feature religious elements as part of its commemoration. See American Legion, Peace Cross. 11
This tradition is not unique to places like Bladensburg.
National ceremonies—such as the dedication of the Wall
of Remembrance at the National Korean War Veterans
Memorial—have historically begun with invocations and
concluded with the singing of “God Bless America,”
underscoring the integration of faith into the public remembrance of national sacrifice. Nearly all such ceremonies include some references to God, the Creator, or faith,
reflecting the deeply held beliefs of many participants and
the rich historical tradition of these observances.
Community Service and Support for Veterans. In its
service to veterans and their families, the American
Legion recognizes that spiritual well-being is a vital component of overall health. The organization actively supports chaplaincy services in VA hospitals and at Legion
posts, and is dedicated to destigmatizing mental health
support, providing peer-to-peer resources, and working
to end veteran suicide. See, e.g., American Legion, Legion
Outlines Support for Mental Health Legislation in Statement for the Record (Apr. 29, 2025) (describing the
Legion’s “Be the One” initiative).12 Private religious
expression is an integral part of this mission: the Legion
draws on both explicit and implicit religious messages to
foster hope and resilience among its members, veterans,
and their families.
The Legion also sponsors the American Legion Legacy Run, which since 2006 has raised $16 million dollars
https://www.legion.org/memorials/united-states/maryland/unitedstates-maryland-peace-cross.
11
12
Available at https://www.legion.org/.
9
for a scholarship fund supporting children who lost a parent in active military service on or after 9/11. See American Legion, 2025 American Legion Legacy Run. 13 And
Legion members are deeply involved in the Department
of Veterans Affairs Voluntary Service program, with
7,000 volunteers contributing 900,000 hours annually at
hospitals across the country. American Legion, VA Volunteer Services. 14 Each of these events is typically infused
with some amount of religious language.
Spiritual Leadership and the Role of Chaplains.
Chaplains hold key positions within the American Legion,
serving as spiritual guides whose purpose is to “help persons grow in their relationship with God and with
another.” American Legion, American Legion Chaplains. 15 The American Legion chaplaincy is intentionally
non-denominational and non-sectarian, ensuring that all
members, regardless of faith tradition, can find support
and comfort. The Chaplain’s Handbook provides guidance
for this inclusive ministry, emphasizing service to the
entire veteran community. The American Legion, Chaplain’s Handbook: Service to God and Country. 16
The Legion’s commitment to spiritual leadership is
also reflected in its public recognition and ceremonies.
For example, the organization has honored civic leaders,
https://www.legion.org/get-involved/community-programs/american-legion-riders/the-american-legion-legacy-run (last visited July 9,
2025).
13
https://www.legion.org/get-involved/community-programs/volunteering/va-volunteer-services.
14
https://www.legion.org/information-center/honor-remembrance/american-legion-chaplains.
15
https://www.ohiolegion.com/wp-content/uploads/Chaplains-Handbook.pdf.
16
10
such as a Cleveland mayor, with the Four Chaplains
Award, and local posts regularly host Four Chaplains Day
ceremonies. See, e.g., Emily Canning-Dean, Medina’s
American Legion honors Mayor Hanwell with Four
Chaplains Award, Cleveland Community News (Sept. 3,
2024). 17 This event commemorates the heroic sacrifice of
four military chaplains who gave their life-preserver vests
to others during the sinking of the USAT Dorchester in
World War II. American Legion, Four Chaplains Day. 18
The ceremonies are similarly open to the public and often
feature guests speaking from microphones and/or broadcast over loudspeakers. See, e.g., American Legion National Commander Honors Four Chaplains in Florida,
YOUTUBE (Jan. 30, 2024); 19 Matt Grills, Georgia Post Invites Public to Inaugural Four Chaplains Day Program
(Jan. 30, 2025). 20
At the national level, the American Legion’s spiritual
leadership is further highlighted by the participation of
the National Chaplain, who, for example, presented at the
105th American Legion Convention. Jeff Stoffer, National Chaplain: ‘God is Calling You to be the One’ (Aug.
25, 2024). 21 During his address, the National Chaplain recited Old Testament scripture and focused on the urgent
mission of preventing veteran suicide. See ibid.
Civic Education. Another of the Legion’s signature
initiatives are the Boys State and Girls State programs,
https://www.cleveland.com/community/2024/09/medinas-americanlegion-honors-dennis-hanwell-with-four-chaplains-award.html.
17
https://www.legion.org/getmedia/8474d806-07ab-4638-be52710cf8d16d37/60mag0120-four-chaplains-brochure-0.pdf.
18
19
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gn4BysYb5X8.
20
Available at https://www.legion.org.
21
Ibid.
11
which operate in all but one state and are often held on
public property such as state university campuses or
National Guard facilities. Boys State and Girls State teach
high school students about the rights, privileges, and
responsibilities of citizenship through hands-on participation in mock government. Religious expression is a regular and respected part of these programs. Daily invocations and benedictions—often led by volunteer chaplains or participants—are a staple, as are non-denominational religious services, open to all and attended
voluntarily. Sitting state officials, including governors and
judges, frequently participate in Boys State and Girls
State events that include prayers or religious observances, underscoring the integration of faith and civic
responsibility. See American Legion, About Boys State &
Boys Nation; 22 American Legion Auxiliary, ALA Girls
State. 23
*
Events organized or supported by the American
Legion have been woven into the fabric of the nation’s
public culture, reflecting a longstanding tradition in which
civic organizations collaborate with local communities,
state governments, and even Congress to commemorate
significant occasions. Whether honoring veterans, memorializing the fallen, or fostering civic education among
youth, the Legion’s activities exemplify the enduring
partnership between voluntary associations and public
institutions that has shaped and enriched America’s civic
landscape. The Legion’s century of experience illustrates
that religious expression is not a source of division, but
https://www.legion.org/get-involved/youth-programs/boys-stateboys-nation/about-boys-state-boys-nation.
22
23
https://www.legion-aux.org/ala-girls-state.
12
rather a powerful means of fostering unity and shared
community purpose. Through its events and programs,
the Legion brings people together to honor America and
those who have served it, fostering mutual respect and
understanding. The presence of prayer or religious observances at these types of public events is not an imposition,
but an acknowledgment of the role that faith plays in the
lives of many Americans—especially during moments of
remembrance, mourning, or national reflection.
This Court should grant certiorari in this case to preserve these vital American traditions, which the decision
below threatens to diminish. Granting certiorari and
reversing will help ensure that the nation’s public life
remains open to the full range of private expression—
religious or otherwise—that has always characterized the
American way.
B. The decision below threatens the American Legion’s
valuable civic traditions.
The Legion’s experience offers a powerful lens to view
the dangers posed by the decision below. The Eleventh
Circuit’s sweeping expansion of what qualifies as government speech threatens to upend the careful balance
struck by the First Amendment’s Establishment, Free
Speech, and Free Exercise Clauses. Rather than recognize the Clauses as complementary guarantees of liberty,
the court of appeals pitted the First Amendment against
itself, with the Establishment Clause weaponized to suppress, rather than protect, religious expression. If left
uncorrected, that approach will chill religious and other
private expression at public events, undermine the historical role of veterans’ organizations in shaping national
identity, and erode the pluralism and inclusivity that are
the hallmarks of American civic life.
13
The decision below jeopardizes private appeals to God
in public ceremonies. For generations, American Legion
posts and other veterans’ organizations have participated
in public ceremonies—Memorial Day, Veterans Day, military funerals, state-sponsored memorials, school assemblies, and more. Because those ceremonies often focus on
honoring service and sacrifice, the private persons who
speak at them have regularly said prayers, offered invocations, or made other appeals to God or heaven. Under
the Eleventh Circuit’s rule, however, government officials
could prohibit such private religious expressions simply
by declaring (implausibly) that everything said from the
podium is government speech. They could thereby extinguish the traditions by which veterans and their sacrifices
have historically been honored. But these events are not
mere government productions; they are community gatherings where the voices of veterans and their organizations are expected and valued.
The decision below provides a ready-made justification for local governments to dictate that, if a veterans’
group wishes to participate in a public ceremony using a
government-provided microphone or platform, it must
refrain from any mention of God or religious sentiment.
Local government officials could claim—under the guise
of avoiding “endorsement” of religion—that because the
event is on public property or uses public resources, all
speech is attributable to the government and thus subject
to censorship. This would allow government to single out
and suppress religious speech, even while permitting a
wide range of secular messages from private participants.
The result in some jurisdictions would be to put veterans’
organizations to a choice between participating in civic life
and remaining true to their traditions and beliefs.
14
Deterring veterans’ groups from participating in public events—because of the risk that their private remarks
with religious content will be censored or recharacterized
as government speech—would imperil civic engagement.
Veterans’ organizations are often the bearers of stories,
values, and traditions that enrich public life. Discouraging
their participation impoverishes our communities.
The decision below threatens monument dedications
sponsored by veterans’ groups. The American Legion has
played a central role in sponsoring and maintaining countless war memorials and monuments, which have nearly
always included some religious elements as a matter of
tradition and respect. Crucially, such memorials and monuments are not government impositions of faith, but
expressions of the communities and individuals who created them. This case involves the same type of private
religious expression in a public setting: Petitioners asked
to offer a prayer for themselves and anyone else wishing
to participate; no one could have seriously thought the
prayer was being offered by the State.
The Eleventh Circuit’s expansive interpretation of the
government-speech doctrine creates a significant risk
that religious symbols, inscriptions, or speech used at
memorial ceremonies like the American Legion’s dedications could be subject to challenge. This chilling effect
would diminish the richness and authenticity of these public commemorations, dissuading veterans’ groups from
fully participating in the creation and dedication of new
monuments as they historically have.
The threat extends to the very process of planning and
conducting these ceremonies. Local officials, fearing liability or accusations of “endorsement,” may preemptively
bar any religious content from dedication speeches, even
when offered by private citizens or organizations. Veter-
15
ans’ groups may be told that their participation is contingent on omitting the very words and symbols that have
defined their commemorative practices for generations.
Such a sanitized and secularized version of public remembrance would fail to reflect the true diversity and depth of
the communities involved.
The decision’s reach could be expansive. Countless
public events involving veterans’ organizations are not
strictly government events—they are community gatherings where the government provides a platform, such as a
public park or school auditorium, for a range of private
speakers. Accordingly, the Eleventh Circuit’s decision
does not affect the Legion alone; it also impacts other veterans’ organizations—including the Veterans of Foreign
Wars, the Wounded Warrior Project, and numerous
smaller groups nationwide—that likewise use such forums to honor servicemembers and frequently fold religious language into their tributes.
Under the decision below, if a local school district
invites the American Legion—or a non-veterans group
like the Knights of Columbus, a Catholic men’s fraternal
organization dedicated to charity, unity, and patriotism—
to offer a flag presentation or invocation at a school event,
the district may suppress any religious expressions,
thereby chilling these groups’ advocacy and community
engagement (entirely contrary to historical practice). The
opinion’s logic could similarly allow the exclusion of veterans’ chaplain invocations or ceremonial prayers from any
event loosely associated with government facilities—a
radical reworking that impairs long-standing tradition. In
short, the opinion could compel organizations like the
American Legion to secularize and change their identities
to participate in public events.
16
By treating all speech at such events as government
speech, officials who are hostile to religion may feel
emboldened to enforce a blanket ban on religious references, even when the event is otherwise open to a variety
of private speakers. That not only distorts the nature of
the event—transforming it from a community gathering
into a government-scripted production—but also signals
to veterans and their families that their beliefs and traditions are unwelcome.
The decision below undercuts veterans’ sacrifices.
Many veterans have fought and died to defend the same
freedoms of speech and religion at stake in this case.
Silencing their voices at public events dishonors their service and the constitutional values they defended. The
American Legion’s participation in public ceremonies is a
living testament to the First Amendment’s guarantee that
all Americans—including those who have served—may
speak freely and according to conscience in the public
square. Allowing only non-religious, governmentauthored speech at public ceremonies trivializes the experience of generations of veterans, who have historically
deployed both religious and secular means to honor their
fallen comrades and give voice to those who have sacrificed. Excluding any mention of God from such events is
unreasonable and ignores the reality that these prayers
are citizen speech—not government speech.
*
Absent review, the decision below will likely embolden
government actors to censor religious expressions by
claiming government speech, undermining the pluralism
and inclusivity that the First Amendment is designed to
protect. The American Legion urges this Court to grant
certiorari to prevent erosion of the traditions by which a
grateful nation recognizes its veterans. The Eleventh Cir-
17
cuit’s decision, if left unchecked, will chill religious and
patriotic expression at the heart of civic life. This Court’s
intervention is necessary to preserve the space for private, voluntary religious expression, consistent with the
First Amendment and the nation’s history.
C. The decision below is incorrect.
The Eleventh Circuit erred in treating private religious expression at public events as government speech.
This Court should clarify that a private speaker’s appeals
to God or faith are not transformed into government
speech merely because the government organized the
event. This case thus provides a valuable opportunity for
this Court to guide the lower courts in applying the
“holistic” test set forth in this Court’s precedent. Shurtleff
v. City of Boston, 596 U.S. 243, 252 (2022). It is also important for this Court to grant the petition for a writ of
certiorari to ensure that lower courts do not revive Lemon
v. Kurtzman, 403 U.S. 602 (1971), when applying the
government-speech doctrine.
1. Cambridge Christian School’s prayers are not
government speech.
The Eleventh Circuit treated this dispute as a
government-speech case, but that was error. To start,
there was no government action triggering the government-speech doctrine. The lower court should have
focused “on the identity of the speaker.” Shurtleff, 596
U.S. at 263 (Alito, J., concurring). Cambridge Christian
School’s (CCS) prayers were not “formulated by a person
with the power to determine what messages the government will communicate.” Id. at 268. The Florida High
School Athletic Association (FHSAA) never “set the overall message to be communicated” through official action.
Ibid. (cleaned up). CCS’s prayers thus are not government speech.
18
The Eleventh Circuit failed to heed the warning that
courts “must be very careful when a government claims
that speech by one or more private speakers is actually
government speech.” Shurtleff, 596 U.S. at 262. In some
cases, “it can be difficult to tell whether the government
is using the doctrine as a subterfuge for favoring certain
private speakers over others based on viewpoint.” Ibid.
(cleaned up). Here, however, it is plain that the FHSAA
disfavored religious speech. As in other cases that have
come before this Court, “[t]his dispute arose only because
of a government official’s mistaken understanding of the
Establishment Clause.” Id. at 261 (Kavanaugh, J. concurring). The FHSAA incorrectly believed that allowing CCS
to offer a short prayer would violate the First Amendment, so it precluded CCS’s speech because of its content.
On several occasions, this Court has “rejected the position
that the Establishment Clause even justifies, much less
requires, a refusal to extend free speech rights to religious speakers who participate in broad-reaching government programs neutral in design.” Rosenberger v. Rector
& Visitors of Univ. of Virginia, 515 U.S. 819, 839 (1995);
see, e.g., Good News Club v. Milford Cent. Sch., 533 U.S.
98, 112 (2001); Lamb’s Chapel v. Ctr. Moriches Union
Free Sch. Dist., 508 U.S. 384, 395 (1993). In fact, excluding
religious speech is a “denial of the right of free speech”
indicating “hostility to religion” that would “undermine
the very neutrality the Establishment Clause requires.”
Rosenberger, 515 U.S. at 845-846; see Shurtleff, 596 U.S.
at 273-274 (Alito, J., concurring).
Regardless whether the government-speech doctrine
applies in this case, the Eleventh Circuit’s decision misunderstood this Court’s precedent. Courts should conduct “a
holistic inquiry designed to determine whether the government intends to speak for itself or to regulate private
expression.” Shurtleff, 596 U.S. at 252; see Walker v.
19
Texas Div., Sons of Confederate Veterans, Inc., 576 U.S.
200, 209 (2015); Pleasant Grove City v. Summum, 555
U.S. 460 (2009). And while that inquiry should not be
“mechanical,” this Court’s “past cases have looked to several types of evidence to guide the analysis, including: the
history of the expression at issue; the public’s likely perception as to who (the government or a private person) is
speaking; and the extent to which the government has
actively shaped or controlled the expression.” Shurtleff,
596 U.S. at 252. This Court should grant review to explain
how the Eleventh Circuit failed to conduct a holistic
inquiry that correctly accounted for these three factors.
When considering the history factor, the Eleventh
Circuit myopically focused on the history of the FHSAA’s
program at championship football games, instead of considering the broader history of religious speech at statesponsored sporting events—or even CCS’s history of
offering prayers before its football games. See Pet. App.
35a (“[W]e will focus our government speech inquiry primarily on pregame speech over the PA system at FHSAA
football championship games, as opposed to speech at any
other game, sport, or period of the championship game.”).
That inquiry was far from “holistic.” Shurtleff, 596 U.S. at
252. And it did not reflect this Court’s own analysis in similar cases. See id. at 253-255 (considering “the history of
flag flying”); Walker, 576 U.S. at 210-211 (considering the
“history of license plates”); Summum, 555 U.S. at 470
(considering the history of monuments since “ancient
times”). Taking such a narrow view, the lower court
(unsurprisingly) could identify only “one example” of a
“private speaker using the PA system for a pregame message.” Pet. App. 37a. The court’s incomplete analysis distorted the First Amendment’s protection.
20
In considering the public’s perception of the speech,
the court of appeals again failed to adequately weigh the
fact that a CCS representative—not any government
employee—would have provided the prayer. No reasonable listener could have confused a prayer offered by a
CCS representative with the FHSAA’s official speech.
Especially given the record evidence that FHSAA allowed multiple other private speakers to use the stadium
public address system for other private purposes, including advertising. See Pet. App. 42a. That should have been
sufficient to resolve the government-speech issue. See
Shurtleff, 596 U.S. at 263 (Alito, J., concurring).
The Eleventh Circuit’s analysis under the factor
regarding governmental control over the messaging did
not adequately account for the fact that CCS would have
prepared and offered the prayer without direction or
scripting from FHSAA. That fact differentiates this case
from some of this Court’s other prayer cases, including
Santa Fe Independent School District v. Doe, 530 U.S.
290 (2000), which disallowed prayer over the school’s public address system before football games when the state
was involved “in the selection of the speaker,” implemented a policy permitting “only those messages deemed
‘appropriate’ ” by state officials, and “suggest[ed] that a
solemn, yet nonreligious, message ... would be prohibited.” Id. at 304, 306. It also distinguishes this case from
Lee v. Weisman, 505 U.S. 577, 581 (1992), where the Court
disallowed prayer at a high school graduation in part
because the state provided “Guidelines” recommending
that the prayer be “nonsectarian.”
Lee and Santa Fe were applications of Lemon, which
this Court has already (rightfully) discarded as inconsistent with the history and tradition of the Establishment
Clause. See Kennedy v. Bremerton Sch. Dist., 597 U.S.
21
507, 535 (2022). But this Court need not revisit any Establishment Clause precedents to resolve this case. Instead,
the Court should grant the petition to provide more guidance about when and how the government-speech doctrine applies. The Eleventh Circuit’s conclusion that a
private school representative’s unscripted prayers are
government speech reveals the confusion in this important area of the law.
2. The Eleventh Circuit’s decision improperly revives
Lemon .
The record shows that FHSAA denied CCS’s request
to use the stadium loudspeaker for a brief pregame prayer
in 2015 because it feared violating the Court’s Establishment Clause decision in Santa Fe. But in that case, this
Court applied “the most rigid version” of the now
defunct Lemon test. Santa Fe, 530 U.S. at 319 (Rehnquist,
C.J., dissenting). And the Court’s decision “bristle[d] with
hostility to all things religious in public life.” Id. at 318.
The decision is incompatible with this Court’s modern
Establishment Clause jurisprudence. And yet, through
the Eleventh Circuit’s incorrect application of the
government-speech doctrine, Lemon will “shuffle from its
grave” any time a state administrator decides that a private person’s religious speech at a public event would
inappropriately create an establishment of religion.
Shurtleff, 596 U.S. at 285 (Gorsuch, J., concurring).
The Court should grant the petition and take the
opportunity to make clear that allowing private persons
to invoke religious language at public events does not violate the Establishment Clause. The First Amendment
“does not say that in every and all respects there shall be
a separation of Church and State.” Zorach v. Clauson, 343
U.S. 306, 312-313 (1952). On the contrary, this Court has
long recognized that Americans “are a religious people
22
whose institutions presuppose a Supreme Being.” Id. at
313-314. Even today, more “than 6 in 10 think a coach
leading a team in prayer, a player leading a team in
prayer, or a coach praying on the field without asking the
team to join in should all be allowed at public high school
sporting events.” AP-NORC, The public’s opinion on
religion in sports (Sept. 29. 2022). 24 Far from violating the
Establishment Clause, state administrators follow “the
best of our traditions” when they “encourage religious
instruction or cooperate with religious authorities by
adjusting the schedule of public events to sectarian
needs.” Zorach, 343 U.S. at 313-314 (cleaned up).
Especially in its recent jurisprudence, this Court has
reaffirmed that religious language and symbols at public
events and in public places do not violate the Establishment Clause—no matter “whether those expressions take
place in a sanctuary or on a field.” Kennedy, 597 U.S. at
543 (football coach’s private prayer on the field after the
game was not unconstitutional); see also, e.g., American
Legion v. American Humanist Ass’n, 588 U.S. 29, 89
(2019) (war memorial in the shape of a large Latin cross
at a busy intersection did not violate the Establishment
Clause); Town of Greece v. Galloway, 572 U.S. 565, 591592 (2014) (town did not violate the Establishment Clause
by “opening its meetings with prayer”); Marsh v. Chambers, 463 U.S. 783, 792 (1983) (state legislature did not
violate the Establishment Clause by paying a chaplain or
opening with prayer). The reason is simple: “governmental invocation of God is not an establishment.” McCreary
Cnty., Ky. v. A.C.L.U. of Ky., 545 U.S. 844, 899-900 (2005)
(Scalia, J., dissenting).
https://apnorc.org/projects/the-publics-opinion-on-religion-insports/.
24
23
As this Court has said: Invoking “Divine guidance on
a public body entrusted with making the laws” is not an
establishment or even “a step toward establishment.”
Marsh, 463 U.S. at 792. Much as a “prayer offered by a
paid chaplain” to open a legislative session does not violate
the Establishment Clause, id. at 787, so too a prayer
offered by private persons before a football game does not
violate the First Amendment. That is especially true
because legislative prayer is constitutional not merely
because of “its historical foundation.” Town of Greece, 572
U.S. at 576; see American Legion, 588 U.S. at 61 (plurality op.). Rather, the practice is constitutional because the
Establishment Clause should be interpreted “by reference to historical practices and understandings.” Town of
Greece, 572 U.S. at 576 (citation omitted). And the fact
that the First Congress chose to “provide[ ] for the appointment of chaplains only days after approving language for the First Amendment demonstrates that the
Framers considered legislative prayer a benign acknowledgment of religion’s role in society.” Ibid.
Similarly, prayers and religious demonstrations in
sporting events are common in American life and have
been for decades. The first NFL player who knelt in
prayer in the endzone—a common sight today—was Philadelphia Eagles running back Herb Lusk, after he ran 70
yards to score a touchdown in 1977. See Chris McPherson,
Eagles celebrate the life of Herb Lusk (Sept. 26, 2022). 25
More recently, Buffalo Bills players huddled in prayer
after their teammate, Damar Hamlin, collapsed mid-game
in early 2023. See Ruth Graham, Prayers for Damar
Hamlin Show Bond Between Football and Faith, N.Y.
https://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/news/eagles-celebrate-thelife-of-herb-lusk-praying-tailback.
25
24
Times (Jan. 7, 2023). 26 And just months ago ESPN aired
the pre-game prayer for the Cotton Bowl between Ohio
State and Texas. Jackson Thompson, ESPN airs pregame prayer for Cotton Bowl after backlash for not showing national anthem after terror attack, FOX NEWS (Jan.
11, 2025). 27
This rich American tradition reflects “beliefs widely
held among the people of this country.” Marsh, 463 U.S.
at 792. Allowing private persons to offer a prayer over a
loudspeaker before a football game does not establish
religion any more than a prayer before a legislative session. It simply “respects the religious nature of our people
and accommodates the public service to their spiritual
needs.” Zorach, 343 U.S. at 314.
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/05/us/damar-hamlin-prayersfootball-religion.html.
26
https://www.foxnews.com/sports/espn-airs-pre-game-prayer-cotton-bowl-after-backlash-not-showing-national-anthem-after-terrorattack.
27
25
CONCLUSION
The Court should grant the petition for a writ of certiorari.
Respectfully submitted,
Shae McPhee
PERKINS COIE LLP
1201 Third Avenue
Suite 4900
Seattle, WA 98101-3099
July 10, 2025
Michael R. Huston
Counsel of Record
Jordan M. Buckwald
PERKINS COIE LLP
2525 E. Camelback Road
Suite 500
Phoenix, AZ 85016-4227
(202) 434-1630
mhuston@perkinscoie.com
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.