Joint Appendix — Seven County Infrastructure Coalition, et al., Petitioners v. Eagle County, Colorado, et al.
Supreme Court briefAug 28, 2024
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 23-975
In the
Supreme Court of the United States
________________
SEVEN COUNTY INFRASTRUCTURE COALITION
and UINTA BASIN RAILWAY, LLC,
Petitioners,
v.
EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADO et al.,
Respondents.
________________
On Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals for the
District of Columbia Circuit
________________
CORRECTED JOINT APPENDIX
Volume I of II
________________
NATHANIEL H. HUNT
PAUL D. CLEMENT
KAPLAN KIRSCH
MATTHEW D. ROWEN
KEVIN WYNOSKY*
& ROCKWELL LLP
CLEMENT & MURPHY, PLLC
1675 Broadway
706 Duke Street
Suite 2300
Alexandria, VA 22314
Denver, CO 80202
(202) 742-8900
(303) 825-7000
nhunt@kaplankirsch.com paul.clement@clementmurphy.com
* Supervised by principals of the firm
who are members of the Virginia bar
Counsel for Eagle County Counsel for Petitioners
(Additional Counsel Listed on Inside Cover)
August 28, 2024
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Filed Mar. 4, 2024
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Granted June 24, 2024
WENDY PARK
CENTER FOR
BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY
1212 Broadway
Suite 800
Oakland, CA 94612
(510) 844-7138
wpark@biologicaldiversity.org
Counsel for Center for
Biological Diversity, et al.
JAY C. JOHNSON
FRED R. WAGNER
VENABLE LLP
600 Massachusetts Ave. NW
Washington, DC 20001
JONATHAN A. STEARMER
625 South 400 West
Vernal, UT 84078
Counsel for Petitioners
ELIZABETH B. PRELOGAR
Solicitor General
UNITED STATES
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
950 Pennsylvania Ave., NW
Washington, DC 20530
(202) 514-2217
supremectbriefs@usdoj.gov
Counsel for United States
JA i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Volume I
Excerpts from Seven County Infrastructure
Coalition’s Response to OEA Request for
Information (Apr. 19, 2019) .......................... JA-1
J. Putnam Letter to J. Wayland, Colorado
Department
of
Public
Health
and
Environment
Preliminary
Comments
(May 9, 2019) ................................................. JA-7
E. Gaddis Letter to J. Wayland, Utah Department
of Environmental Quality Preliminary
Comments (June 14, 2019).......................... JA-13
S. Hackett Letter to J. Wayland, Colorado
Department of Public Health & Environment
Scoping Comments (Aug. 5, 2019) .............. JA-22
Excerpts from SCIC Response to OEA’s Second
Request for Information (Oct. 10, 2019) ..... JA-28
Excerpts from SCIC Uinta Basin Oil Pipeline
Study: Final Report (Sept. 2017) ................ JA-33
Excerpts from R.L. Banks & Associates to SCIC,
Pre-Feasibility Study of a Prospective
Railroad Connecting the Uinta Basin to the
National Rail Network (Aug. 9, 2018) ........ JA-35
Eagle County Comments on Draft Environmental
Impact Statement Before the Surface
Transportation Board (Feb. 12, 2021) ........ JA-41
EPA
Map
of
Counties
Designated
“Nonattainment” for Clean Air Act’s National
Ambient Air Qualty Standards (NAAQS)
(Feb. 12, 2021) ............................................. JA-93
JA ii
Table of Contents Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway,
Final Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............... JA-94
Summary Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-106
Section 2 Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-138
Section 3.2 Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-194
Section 3.3 Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-206
Section 3.4 Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-243
Section 3.6 Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-303
Section 3.7 Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-309
Section 3.13 Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway,
Final Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-326
Volume II
Section 3.15, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-348
JA iii
Appendix C, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-475
Appendix E, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-487
Appendix L Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-497
Appendix S Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-506
Appendix T Excerpts, Unita Basin Railway, Final
Environmental Impact Statement, STB
Docket No. FD 36284 (Aug. 2021)............. JA-511
Table
3
Excerpts,
Energy
Information
Administration, Capacity of Operable
Petroleum Refineries by State as of January 1,
2022 (2022) ................................................ JA-544
Ute
Indian
Tribe
of
Uintah
and
Ouray Reservation Support Statement
(Sept. 22, 2021)) ......................................... JA-546
Excerpts from Center for Biological Diversity’s
Supplemental Comments (Oct. 18, 2021) . JA-548
SCIC, Industry Support Letters for Rail, 2018,
cited in Center for Biological Diversity’s
Supplemental Comments (Oct. 18, 2021) . JA-572
JA iv
The following opinions, decisions, judgments, and
orders have been omitted in printing this joint
appendix because they appear on the following page in
the appendix to the Petition for Certiorari:
Appendix A
Opinion of the United States Court of Appeals for
the D.C. Circuit (Aug. 18, 2023).......... Pet.App.1a
Appendix B
Order Denying Petition for Rehearing En Banc
(Dec. 4, 2023) ..................................... Pet.App.72a
Appendix C
Surface Transportation Board Final Decision
(Dec. 15, 2021) ................................... Pet.App.74a
Appendix D
Surface Transportation Board Decision (Jan. 4,
2021)................................................. Pet.App.190a
JA 1
Excerpts from Seven County Infrastructure
Coalition’s Response to OEA Request for
Information (Apr. 19, 2019)
Craig Route
MP 0.0 to South Myton Bench and Leland Bench—Up
to 200 feet each side of centerline with potential
variance to 500 feet each side of centerline
OEA Information Request: Provide any currently
available information regarding the terminus points of
the proposed rail line at Myton and Leland Bench in
the Uinta Basin, including available information
related to the types of facilities that could be
constructed at those points and information regarding
any existing proposals for new facilities at those
locations.
Coalition Response: Each of the three alternative
routes proposed (Indian Canyon, Wells Draw, and
Craig) would have one or two terminus points within
the Uinta Basin. All three routes would have one
terminus
point
located
at
Leland
Bench,
approximately 9.5 miles south of Fort Duchesne,
Utah. Wells Draw and Craig would have a second
terminus point located at South Myton Bench,
approximately 3.5 miles southwest of Myton, Utah.
These terminus points are in essence “ends of track”
in areas that the Coalition believes will provide access
to an area of freight shipper and/or receiver interest.
The Coalition anticipates that a transload facility
would be constructed in the vicinity of one or both of
these ends of track.
At this time, the Coalition is not proposing to
construct any transload facilities. Unless those plans
change (at which time, the Coalition would notify the
JA 2
STB), the Coalition anticipates that any transload
facilities will be constructed by shippers, receivers, or
third-party freight consolidators or distributors.
However, there are currently no existing proposals for
new transload facilities at these locations. While the
Coalition anticipates discussing potential transload
facilities with third-parties (e.g., the Ute Indian Tribe,
private developers, operators, freight consolidators,
shippers, or receivers), the Coalition has not entered
into any formal negotiations with such parties at this
time. The Coalition notes that it has signed a
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with Uintah
Advantage, the developer of a proposed crude oil
upgrader facility near the Leland Bench end-of-track.
This MOU contemplates that Uintah Advantage
would potentially require railway freight services and
that it may provide to the Coalition certain land it
currently controls at this location, to enable
construction of a transload facility by the Coalition or
others.
Shippers and receivers may in fact determine that
other locations for transload facilities are more
suitable for their needs, and may choose to construct
facilities at any location alongside the proposed
routes, or at a separate location connected to the
proposed routes by a private industrial spur track.
However, to facilitate access to the rail line, the
Coalition selected the proposed terminus points based
on:
1. Proximity to Primary Traffic Source: The
railway’s anticipated primary traffic source is the
crude oil production industry, which produces
crude oil and consumes fracturing sand and
JA 3
tubular product (e.g., steel pipe and drill stem). As
shown in Figure 1 below, the two selected
terminus points are in close proximity to the
principal production areas of the major crude oil
production field in the Uinta Basin. The proposed
Terminus points would also provide convenient
access for other Uinta Basin commodities (e.g.,
agricultural products).
Figure 1: Uinta Basin Oil Production Heat Map,
2015-2018
2. Topography and Location: Economical
development of railway transload facilities
requires topography that is conducive to railway
terminal construction. Economical sites must be
mostly flat, not cut by watercourses or wetlands,
and not occupied by uses that would require
expensive relocations. This typically precludes
sites that have been already developed for
industrial use, residential use, or are occupied by
major pipeline or electrical transmission
JA 4
infrastructure. Sites for transload facilities must
also be appropriately zoned or readily able to be
rezoned.
3. Surrounding Land Uses: The terminus points
were chosen based on the potential for transload
facility developers to assemble real estate in
sufficient size to construct a facility capable of
handling complete unit trains. Generally, a
terminal or transload capable of accepting unit
trains must be at least 200 acres in size.
Because the Uinta Basin Railway would be a commoncarrier rail line, it would be open to all shippers and
receivers of goods and commodities at any location
along its route where shippers and receivers propose
to deliver or receive rail cars or trains from the
railway. Shippers and receivers may choose to
construct their own individual transloads, work
cooperatively to construct joint transloads, or contract
with developers and operators of transloads.
Developers and operators would contract with
shippers and receivers to transload, store, or
distribute their goods and commodities, and contract
with the Uinta Basin Railway for transportation
services.
The number and size of potential transload
facilities is unknown at this time. However, generally,
a transload facility would:
•
Transfer goods and commodities from railway
cars to trucks for immediate furtherance to
another location, or to storage facilities for
future furtherance to another location, or to
manufacturing plants;
JA 5
•
Transfer goods and commodities to railway
cars from trucks and pipelines, from storage
facilities, or from manufacturing plants;
•
Reload goods and commodities delivered by
railway cars, truck or pipeline, onto other
railway cars, trucks or pipelines;
•
Accept intact inbound trains from the railway
for unloading or loading, and stage outbound
trains for operation by the railway after
loading or unloading; and
•
Store, distribute, consolidate, sort, process, or
manufacture goods and commodities.
It is possible that one or more transloaders of
small volumes of inbound or outbound commodities
(e.g., lumber and other building materials or
agricultural products), or manufacturing plants or
processing plants generating less-than-trainload
volumes, would be constructed on the railway. In such
a case, the typical practice would be to handle these
small volumes as added “head end” cars to unit trains
of other commodities. An inbound unit train would
stop momentarily to drop off inbound miscellaneous
head end cars to the small transload facility or
manufacturing or processing plant before proceeding
to its own destination, and outbound unit trains would
stop momentarily to pick-up outbound miscellaneous
cars.
Locomotives inbound on unit trains are
anticipated to either layover at unit-train capable
transload facilities until an outbound train is ready, or
may be aggregated by the railway and operated to
another transload facility or back to the railway’s
JA 6
connection with the national railway network. Minor
servicing and refueling of locomotives at unit-train
capable transload facilities is a typical industry
practice.
The proposed Uinta Basin Railway may construct
a small terminal at an additional location for servicing
or storage of locomotives, track maintenance
machinery and rail cars used in track maintenance,
material storage, small quantities of rail cars carrying
miscellaneous inbound or outbound freight, or empty
cars awaiting loads of miscellaneous outbound freight.
This small terminal may be co-located with a large
unit train transload terminal, or at a different
location. The need for a small terminal is
indeterminate at this time, as is the location(s).
OEA Information Request: Confirm that the
proposed rail line would be constructed as a single
track.
Coalition Response: The proposed rail line
would be constructed as a single main track, with
sidings to enable trains to meet and/or pass at
locations to be determined (a siding is a track of
sufficient length to contain a complete train, parallel
to the main track and connected at both ends to the
main track).
JA 7
J. Putnam Letter to J. Wayland, Colorado
Department of Public Health and Environment
Preliminary Comments
May 9, 2019
Re: Colorado Department of Public Health and
Environment’s Preliminary Comments on the
Proposed Uinta Rail Line
Dear Mr. Wayland:
The Colorado Department of Public Health and
Environment (CDPHE) appreciates the opportunity to
provide preliminary scoping comments on the Seven
County Infrastructure Coalition Uinta Basin Railway
proposal. We are encouraged to see that the Surface
Transportation Board’s Office of Environmental
Analysis is preparing an Environmental Impact
Statement (EIS) that will analyze the potential
environmental impacts for the proposed rail line.
CDPHE conducts National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA) reviews and provides comments as a
cooperative agency to ensure compliance with
applicable Federal and State requirements intended
to avoid or minimize impacts to public health and the
environment. We respectfully submit the following
preliminary comments.
CDPHE believes it is essential to expand the
study area contemplated for the EIS in order to
capture potential effects from enabling more trains
every day, some portion of which will be carrying
crude oil, Gilsonite and other substances in
environmentally sensitive and populated areas in
Colorado. Regardless of the alternative chosen, your
letter indicates that the proposed project will induce
additional rail activity—as many as six trains per day.
JA 8
This activity would likely travel through Colorado,
both on the Union Pacific line east of Axial or on the
main east-west Union Pacific line from the Utah
border to the the Denver area and then south and east
to the Colorado border.
The EIS needs to thoroughly analyze and discuss
the safety risks associated with routing additional
hazardous rail cargo along the environmentally
sensitive corridors to which the new project would
connect. Any rail traffic induced by the proposed
project and using the Union Pacific system would
transit through metropolitan Denver, and depending
on the route, through populated areas like Pueblo,
Colorado Springs, Glenwood Springs, Steamboat
Springs, Craig, and Grand Junction (along with many
other cities and towns). Adding more oil train traffic
in particular raises safety risks for the often densely
populated areas that must be carefully analyzed. The
EIS should include consideration of the environmental
justice implications of these additional hazardous
trains.
Similarly, both the Craig Line and main UP line
parallel sensitive river systems—the Yampa and
Colorado Rivers, along with South Boulder Creek.
Both could be affected by any spills that may occur
from incidents associated with the new rail traffic
induced by the project. The Yampa River is a vital wild
river and the rail line follows the Yampa just
upstream of Dinosaur National Park. Any spills could
have catastrophic effects on wildlife, recreation,
agriculture and drinking water. Similarly, the
Colorado River is the most important river in the
Southwest United States, providing water supply for
JA 9
millions, habitat for endangered species, heavily-used
recreation resources and irrigation water. South
Boulder Creek is a critical source for water for the
Denver Water system, habitat for the Prebles’
Meadow Jumping Mouse and valuable recreation.
CDPHE regulates water quality in all of these river
systems.
Air quality impacts from pollutant emissions are
limited by regulations, standards and implementation
plans established under the federal Clean Air Act, as
Administered by CDPHE’s Air Pollution Control
Division (APCD) under authorization of the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency. In order to provide
thorough comments, APCD requests additional
information regarding the commodities and products
that will be transported into Colorado as a result of
the proposed project. We recommend that the EIS
include a cumulative effects analysis, including
climate change impacts, with a description of the
anticipated environmental impacts of the proposed
action in relationship to all other effects from past,
present and reasonably foreseeable future federal,
non-federal, and private actions within the spatial and
temporal bounds of the proposed project.
The proposed project may require a Land
Development Air Pollutant Emissions Notice (APEN).
Under Colorado air quality regulations, land
development refers to all land clearing activities,
including but not limited to land preparation such as
excavating or grading, for residential, commercial or
industrial development. Land development activities
release fugitive dust, a pollutant regulated by APCD.
Small land development activities are not subject to
JA 10
the same reporting and permitting requirements as
large land activities. Specifically, land development
activities that are less than 25 contiguous acres and
less than six months in duration do not need to report
air emissions to the APCD. However, it is important
to note that even if a permit is not required, fugitive
dust control measures included in the Land
Development APEN Form APCD-223 must be
followed at the site. APCD also has APEN
requirements for internal combustion engines;
however, non-road engines are not required to submit
an APEN. APEN forms and guidance documents can
be accessed online: https://www.colorado.gov/pacific/
cdphe/air/air-permit. All applicable requirements and
permits should be discussed in the EIS.
APCD recognizes that the transportation of
products and commodities via rail could potentially
reduce transportation emissions as compared to the
current method of truck transportation. However,
according to the Uinta Basin Railway Project website,
the proposed action may result in increased oil and
gas, agriculture, and mining activity. Emissions from
these activities can travel great distances, affecting
air quality and public health including in the
Denver/North Front Range ozone nonattainment area.
In addition, Colorado recently established new
greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction goals of
50% GHG reductions by 2030 and 90% GHG
reductions by 2050 (based on 2005 levels) stemming
from House Bill 1261, which was signed by Governor
Polis on May 1, 2019. Therefore, we request an
analysis of intrastate and interstate air pollution
transport from criteria pollutant and GHG emissions
that may result from the proposed project and
JA 11
potential mitigation measures. Consideration of these
indirect, secondary and cumulative impacts is
required by the Council on Environmental Quality
regulations
implementing
the
National
Environmental Policy Act.
Several sections of the proposed Craig Route are
less than 10 miles away from Dinosaur National
Monument (DNM), as depicted in Figure 3—Craig
Study Area. DNM is a class II air quality “floor” under
the prevention of significant deterioration federal
1963 Clean Air Act, as amended, but is a class I area
by Colorado standards for sulfur dioxide (SO2). This
means that development can be permitted in the
vicinity (within 10-25 kilometers depending on the
size of the development) of the park as long as the
levels of all criteria pollutants except SO2 do not
exceed the Class II increment requirements. Class I
increment consumption requirements apply for SO2
(Colorado Regulation No. 3, Part D, §VIII.B).
According to the National Park
Service, ozone, visibility, and nitrogen deposition
impacts are of significant concern for DNM. Increased
energy development in the Uinta Basin may emit
significant quantities of air pollutants in the DNM
area, resulting in visibility degradation, adverse
effects to human health, and adverse ecosystem effects
from nitrogen deposition and ozone impacts to
vegetation. These effects should be thoroughly
discussed in the EIS.
CDPHE expects that the EIS will thoroughly
consider alternatives such as the use of pipelines for
oil transportation, along with mitigation for all of the
JA 12
safety risk, water, species, air quality and climate
impacts that may be associated with impacts.
CDPHE appreciates the opportunity to provide
these preliminary scoping comments and looks
forward to reviewing the project EIS. If you have any
questions or need additional assistance, please call me
at
303-692-3397
or
me
at
john.putnam@state.co.us.
Sincerely,
[signature]
John Putnam
Director of Environmental Programs
JA 13
E. Gaddis Letter to J. Wayland, Utah
Department of Environmental Quality
Preliminary Comments
June 14, 2019
Dear Mr. Wayland,
Thank you for the opportunity to submit
preliminary comments on the Seven County
Infrastructure Coalition proposal to build an 80-mile
rail line to transport commodities and products in and
out of the Uinta Basin.
The Utah Department of Environmental Quality’s
Division of Water Quality (DWQ) is tasked with
protecting, maintaining, and enhancing the quality of
Utah’s surface and underground waters for their
designated beneficial uses. Beneficial uses include
drinking water, recreation, protection of aquatic life,
and agriculture. To protect these beneficial uses, the
state develops numeric and narrative water quality
standards for surface waters in Utah. DWQ collects
water-quality data, monitors the health of the state’s
waterways, issues permits for surface water
discharges, evaluates the condition of watersheds, and
coordinates with partners on water-quality issues
associated with specific public health concerns.
DWQ’s scoping comments address common
impacts to water quality from railways in general as
well as conditions that are specific to the local area
covered by the three proposed routes.
General Comments
Soil erosion and product spills pose the greatest
water-quality impacts from rail line construction and
operations. According to Priscila Silva Lucas, et.al,
JA 14
railway disturbances can often result in significant
impacts to the environment:1
“The abrupt change of soil required to establish
the railway embankment leads to vegetation loss,
compresses the soil, and compromises water drainage
(Ferrell and Lautala 2010). Thus, soil becomes
exposed and subject to an increasing runoff that
promotes its erosion (Chen et al. 2015).
The erosion of rail embankments can result in a
washing out of sediments (Jin et al. 2008) that cause
water pollution.
Infrastructures associated with railways (e.g.,
leakages of petroleum products from fuel storage
tanks) contribute, together with pollutants, to aquatic
ecosystems. (Schweinsberg et al. 1999; Vo et al. 2015).
Levengood et al. (2015) documented high
concentrations of PAHs [polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons] and heavy metals in waterways
bisected or bordered by railways. They showed that
the PAH concentration was higher downstream than
upstream of the railway (Levengood et al. 2015). They
also found that phenanthrene and dibenzo (a, h)
anthracene (a PAH element) concentrations at some
sites represented a risk to aquatic life.”
Water quality impacts will vary based on railway
alignment,
acreage
disturbed,
proximity
to
waterways, frequency of rail traffic, and products and
Lucas P.S., de Carvalho R.G., Grilo C. 2017, Railway
Disturbances on Wildlife: Types, Effects, and Mitigation
Measures. In: Borda-de-Agua L., Barrientos R., Beja P., Pereira
H. (eds), Railway Ecology. Springer, Cham.
1
JA 15
commodities carried on the rail line.2 These impacts
will also vary between the construction and postconstruction (operational) phases.
•
•
Impacts during the construction phase
o
Soil erosion and subsequent impacts on water
quality are greatest during construction.
Removal of vegetation for initial clearing and
grading activities expose soil and make it
more susceptible to erosion. Rail line
alignment, location of construction staging,
and erosion control measures could
ameliorate some of these impacts.
o
Heavy-machinery traffic may increase
erosion depending on the type of roadways
used (paved versus gravel or dirt roads).
o
Heavy-machinery emissions and deposition
may also be an issue depending on proximity
to waterways. (See comments below on
impacts from emissions).
Impacts during the operational phase (postconstruction)
o
There is high potential for an increase in
runoff and erosion due to elevated railways.
The extent of the impacts depends on the rail
alignment and proximity to waterways.
o
Soils in the area are subject to freeze-thaw
cycles that could increase the potential for
Environmental Protection Agency. 1996. Indicators of the
Environmental Impacts of Transportation: Highway, Rail,
Aviation, and Maritime Transport. EPA 230-R-96-009
2
JA 16
erosion, particularly during spring runoff and
storm events.
o
Exhaust emissions of carbon monoxide (CO),
oxides of nitrogen (NOx), volatile organic
compounds (VOCs), sulfur dioxide (SO2),
particulate matter, particulate matter (PM),
carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4),
nitrous oxide (N20), and ammonium (NH4)
from train traffic are expected. The impact to
water quality from dry and wet deposition of
these chemicals into nearby waterways is
unclear.3 Emissions of creosote, polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and phenols
from railroad ties treated with creosote are
also a source of concern.4
o
Spills of waxy crude, fracturing sand, coal,
soda ash, Gilsonite, phosphorus, and diesel
fuel leaks or discharges into waterways could
cause significant water-quality impacts,
depending on the extent and location of the
spill. Effective spill prevention and response
protocol will be critical to protecting water
resources along the route.
o
Soils in proximity to rail lines have higher
levels of PAHs from fuel and creosote
3 Ibid.
4 Martin Kohler,*, Tina Künniger, Peter Schmid, Erika Gujer,
Rowena Crockett, and Max Wolfensberger. 2000.
Inventory and emission factors of creosote, polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons (PAH) and phenols from railroad ties treated with
creosote. Environmental Science & Technology 34 (22), 4766-4772
DOI: 10.1021 /es000103h
JA 17
leaching from railway ties.5 There could be
potential impacts to aquatic life from PAHs
depending on the hydrocarbon load that
reaches the waterway from runoff or erosion.
Utah does not currently have water-quality
criteria for PAHs as they are still considered
an emerging contaminant. National criteria
could
be
referenced
to
compare
concentrations in affected waters.
o
Livestock transport along the rail line could
result in increased fecal matter entering
nearby waterways from either direct
deposition or runoff, depending on the
frequency of livestock transport and
proximity of the rail line to waterways.
o
Herbicides along the rail route could be an
additional source of water pollution.6 “...
Schweinsberg et al. (1999) discovered that in
Germany before the 1990s, a much higher
total amount of these compounds [herbicides]
were applied on railway tracks than in
agriculture. Recently, Vo et al. (2015) showed
that many herbicides applied during the
operation of the railway are at concentrations
that are lethal to most of the aquatic fauna,
particularly fish populations; they indicate
that compounds such as Imazapyr or Diuron
concentrations can take 6 and 48 months,
5 Wilkomirski B, Sudnik-Wøjcikowska B, Galera H, Wierzbicka
M, Malawska M. 2011. Railway transportation as a serious
source of organic and inorganic pollution. Water Air Soil
Pollution. 218(1-4):333- 345. DOI:10.1007/s11270-010-0645-0
6 Op. cit., Railway Disturbances on Wildlife.
JA 18
respectively, to drop below 50 (percent) of
their original levels.”
Comments Specific to the Affected Area
Erosion will be one of the primary issues for all
routes since the geology/soils in the region are
significant natural sources of soluble salts. Geologic
features are dominated by the slightly-to-moderately
saline Uinta and Duchesne River formations and the
highly saline Mancos Shale formation. Total dissolved
solids (TDS), selenium (Se), arsenic (As), and boron (B)
water-quality impairments in the area are generally
due to the composition of the bedrock coupled with
erosion-causing activities such as oil and gas
operations, irrigation, grazing, and road construction.
The proposed setback distance from surface waters
and wetlands will play a large role in the severity of
erosion-related impacts.
Watershed planning is an important tool for
protecting vital water resources. The Duchesne River
Watershed Restoration Plan covers portions of the
proposed routes and is intended to help local
communities, watershed organizations, and agencies
operating within the Duchesne River watershed
develop and implement plans to meet water-quality
standards, protect water resources and provide a
cohesive strategy for implementing needed waterquality improvements in the Duchesne River and
tributaries.7 One of the goals of the plan is to “improve
Uinta Basin Watershed Council. 2015. Duchesne River
Watershed Restoration Plan. https://deg.utah.gov/legacy/
programs/water-quality/watersheds/docs/2015/08Aug/Duchesne.
7
JA 19
water quality in the watershed by decreasing total
dissolved solids (TDS) and sediment loads.” Railroad
construction is contradictory to this goal, since the
project will likely increase erosion and related water
quality impacts. The Duchesne Plan, however, is not
intended to prevent projects that increase erosion.
Rather, it focuses on responsible erosion-control
practices to reduce erosion from anthropogenic
activities in the watershed.
All three proposed routes cross impaired water
segments, designated geographically as water-quality
assessment units (AUs). An AU is deemed impaired
when it fails to meet the water-quality standards
associated with its beneficial uses. Following Section
303(d) of the Clean Water Act, DWQ identifies and
prioritizes impaired waters that require restoration to
meet water-quality standards. As part of the
restoration process, total maximum daily loads
(TMDLs) are written to mandate the maximum
allowable discharge of a pollutant from both point and
non-point sources to a water segment while still
meeting applicable water-quality standards. Several
of the assessment units associated with the rail lines
have TMDLs in place for total dissolved solids and/or
are impaired for other pollutants commonly associated
with soil disturbance in these areas. DWQ has
attached a table with the beneficial use(s),
impairments, and TMDLs for AUs along the proposed
routes as an addendum to this letter.
Conclusion
Erosion and spills present the most significant
impacts to water quality along the three proposed
routes. The extent of the erosion impacts will depend
JA 20
on the alignment of the routes and their proximity to
waterways. Spills are always a concern along
transportation corridors, but safety and response
protocols can minimize these impacts. Increases to rail
traffic beyond the frequency proposed in the scoping
document would likely increase impacts from erosion
and possible spills and should be taken into
consideration along with other impacts that may
qualify as cumulative impacts under 40 CFR § 1508.7.
The project as proposed will require construction
storm water permit coverage since it will disturb more
than one acre. The UPDES Construction General
Permit Number UTRC00000 permit application and
requirements are available on the DWQ webpage.
Projects that require a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
(USACE) Individual Section 404 Permit will require a
Section 401 Water Quality Certification through
DWQ. The purpose of the Section 401 Certification is
to allow the state to certify whether projects/activities
will violate any applicable state water-quality
standards. An application for a Section 401 Water
Quality Certification should be made simultaneously
with an application for a Section 404 Permit through
USACE.
JA 21
Thank you again for the opportunity to comment
on the proposed rail line in the Uinta Basin. Please
feel
free
to
contact
Elise
Hinman
at
ehinman@utah.gov or (801) 536-4346 with any
questions or concerns.
Sincerely,
[signature]
Erica Gaddis, PhD
Director
EBG/EH/blj
JA 22
S. Hackett Letter to J. Wayland, Colorado
Department of Public Health & Environment
Scoping Comments
August 5, 2019
Re: Colorado Department of Public Health and
Environment’s Scoping Comments on the Seven
County Infrastructure Coalition—Uinta Basin
Railway Environmental Impact Statement
Dear Mr. Wayland:
The Colorado Department of Public Health and
Environment (CDPHE) appreciates the opportunity to
provide scoping comments on the Seven County
Infrastructure Coalition (Coalition) Uinta Basin
Railway proposal (Uinta Basin Railway or Railway).
We are encouraged to see that the Surface
Transportation Board’s Office of Environmental
Analysis is preparing an Environmental Impact
Statement (EIS) that will analyze the potential
environmental impacts for the Uinta Basin Railway.
CDPHE conducts National Environmental Policy Act
(NEPA) reviews and provides comments as a
cooperative agency to ensure compliance with
applicable Federal and State requirements intended
to avoid or minimize impacts to public health and the
environment. Based on its potential negative impacts
to public health and the environment, as well as
potential wildlife impacts identified by Colorado Parks
and Wildlife, CDPHE recommends that the Craig
route not be chosen as the final route for this project.
CDPHE believes it is essential to expand the
study area contemplated for the EIS in order to
capture potential effects from enabling more trains
every day, some portion of which will be carrying
JA 23
crude oil, gilsonite, coal and other mineral and
agricultural products in environmentally sensitive
and populated areas in Colorado. Regardless of the
alternative chosen, the Coalition estimates that the
Uinta Basin Railway will induce additional rail
activity—as many as seven trains per day. If the
Coalition chooses the Craig Route, this additional rail
activity would enter into Colorado via the Union
Pacific (UP) rail line east of Axial. After passing
through the UP Craig Subdivision, it would travel
through the Denver area and then south and east to
the Colorado border.
The EIS needs to thoroughly analyze and discuss
the safety risks associated with routing additional
hazardous rail cargo along the environmentally
sensitive corridors to which the Uinta Basin Railway
would connect. Any rail traffic induced by the Railway
and using the UP system would transit through
metropolitan Denver, and depending on the route,
through populated areas like Pueblo, Colorado
Springs, Glenwood Springs, Steamboat Springs,
Craig, and Grand Junction (along with many other
cities and towns). Adding more oil train traffic in
particular raises safety risks for the often densely
populated areas that must be carefully analyzed. The
EIS should include consideration of the environmental
justice implications of this additional rail activity.
Similarly, both the Craig Line and main UP line
parallel sensitive river systems—the Yampa and
Colorado Rivers. Both could be affected by any spills
that may occur from incidents associated with the new
rail traffic induced by the Uinta Basin Railway. The
Yampa River is a vital wild river and the rail line
JA 24
follows the Yampa just upstream of Dinosaur National
Park. Any spills could have catastrophic effects on
wildlife, recreation, agriculture and drinking water.
Similarly, the Colorado River is the most important
river in the Southwest United States, providing water
supply for millions, habitat for endangered species,
heavily-used recreation resources and irrigation
water. CDPHE regulates water quality in these river
systems.
Air quality impacts from pollutant emissions are
limited by regulations, standards and implementation
plans established under the federal Clean Air Act, as
Administered by CDPHE’s Air Pollution Control
Division (APCD) under authorization of the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). CDPHE
recommends that the EIS include a cumulative effects
analysis, including climate change impacts, with a
description of the anticipated environmental impacts
of the proposed action in relationship to all other
effects from past, present and reasonably foreseeable
future federal, non-federal, and private actions within
the spatial and temporal bounds of the proposed
project.
While the notice indicates that the EIS will
evaluate potential air quality impacts from the
operation of trains on the Uinta Basin Railway, the
freighted product and rail line construction activities,
it does not indicate that the EIS will quantify potential
greenhouse gas emissions resulting from the
downstream combustion of the crude oil, gilsonite and
coal that it will transport. Because the Uinta Basin
Railway is a necessary precondition for the
downstream combustion of these products, they are
JA 25
connected actions under NEPA and they must be
considered together in a single EIS.
The proposed project may require a Land
Development Air Pollutant Emissions Notice (APEN).
Under Colorado air quality regulations, land
development refers to all land clearing activities,
including but not limited to land preparation such as
excavating or grading, for residential, commercial or
industrial development. Land development activities
release fugitive dust, a pollutant regulated by APCD.
Small land development activities are not subject to
the same reporting and permitting requirements as
large land activities. Specifically, land development
activities that are less than 25 contiguous acres and
less than six months in duration do not need to report
air emissions to the APCD. However, it is important
to note that even if a permit is not required, fugitive
dust control measures included in the Land
Development APEN Form APCD-223 must be
followed at the site. APCD also has APEN
requirements for internal combustion engines;
however, non-road engines are not required to submit
an APEN. APEN forms and guidance documents can
be accessed online: https://www.colorado.gov/pacific/
cdphe/air/air-permit.
All applicable requirements and permits should
be discussed in the EIS.
APCD recognizes that the transportation of
products and commodities via rail could potentially
reduce transportation emissions as compared to the
current method of truck transportation. However,
according to the Uinta Basin Railway website, the
proposed action may result in increased oil and gas,
JA 26
agriculture, and mining activity. Emissions from
these activities can travel great distances, affecting
air quality and public health including in the
Denver/North Front Range ozone nonattainment area.
In addition, Colorado recently established new
greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions reduction goals of
50% GHG reductions by 2030 and 90% GHG
reductions by 2050 (based on 2005 levels) stemming
from House Bill 1261, which was signed by Governor
Polis on May 30, 2019. Therefore, we request an
analysis of intrastate and interstate air pollution
transport from criteria pollutant and GHG emissions
that may result from the proposed project and
potential mitigation measures. Consideration of these
indirect, secondary and cumulative impacts is
required by the Council on Environmental Quality
regulations implementing NEPA.
Several sections of the proposed Craig Route are
in close proximity to Dinosaur National Monument
(DNM). DNM is a class II air quality “floor” under the
prevention of significant deterioration federal 1963
Clean Air Act, as amended, but is a class I area by
Colorado standards for sulfur dioxide (SO2). This
means that development can be permitted in the
vicinity (within 10- 25 kilometers depending on the
size of the development) of the park as long as the
levels of all criteria pollutants except SO2 do not
exceed the Class II increment requirements. Class I
increment consumption requirements apply for SO2
(Colorado Regulation No. 3, Part D, §VIII.B).
According to the National Park Service, ozone,
visibility, and nitrogen deposition impacts are of
significant concern for DNM. Increased energy
development in the Uinta Basin may emit significant
JA 27
quantities of air pollutants in the DNM area, resulting
in visibility degradation, adverse effects to human
health, and adverse ecosystem effects from nitrogen
deposition and ozone impacts to vegetation. These
effects should be thoroughly discussed in the EIS.
CDPHE expects that the EIS will thoroughly
consider alternatives such as the use of pipelines for
oil transportation, along with mitigation for all of the
safety risk, water, species, air quality and climate
impacts that may be associated with impacts.
CDPHE appreciates the opportunity to provide
these scoping comments and looks forward to
reviewing the project EIS. If you have any questions
or need additional information, please call me at 303692-3662 or email me at sean.hackett@state.co.us.
Sincerely,
______________________
Sean Hackett
CDPHE Energy Liaison
JA 28
Excerpts from SCIC Response to OEA’s Second
Information Request, FD 36284
October 10, 2019
*
*
*
OEA Request: If it is assumed that “helper”
locomotives would be used on the proposed rail line,
provide the estimated number of helper locomotives
that would be used on a train, the type of train
(manifest or oil), and where along the proposed rail
line they would be used, with references to mileposts.
Response:
The use of “helper” locomotives is not anticipated
on the UBRY. Trains are expected to operate with
eight 4,300 to 4,400-horsepower locomotives without
addition or subtraction en route between the railroad’s
proposed interchange with the national railroad
network at Kyune, and the loading terminal(s)
proposed at South Myton Bench and Leland Bench. It
is expected that a 110-car loaded train will require
30,000 horsepower, or seven 4,300-horsepower
locomotives, to overcome gravity and rolling
resistance. It is anticipated that an eighth locomotive
will be added to reduce the risk of train stalling should
a locomotive experience mechanical failure.
OEA Request: Indicate whether the estimated
average number of crude oil trains per day assumes
that crude oil currently trucked to Salt Lake City
refiners would continue to move by truck or whether
it would be transported as part of the 3.5 loaded trains
per day estimate.
JA 29
Response:
The estimated average number of crude oil trains
per day assumes that rail transportation will not
displace truck transportation for purposes of shipping
crude oil to Salt Lake City refiners. Based on recent
analysis, rail shipment from the Uinta Basin to Salt
Lake City refiners is not economically viable for
several reasons including (1) the lack of infrastructure
to receive and unload crude oil unit trains in the
vicinity of the Salt Lake City-area refineries and then
transport that oil via pipeline to the refineries and
additional costs associated with constructing and
operating such infrastructure; (2) the operating and
capital cost of transloading oil from truck to rail within
the Uinta Basin, which is not required for the existing
all-truck haul; and (3) the relatively short haul by a
connecting carrier (either UP or BNSF) to the Salt
Lake City area, which reduces the economies of rail
transportation. Thus, it is not anticipated that crude
oil will be shipped by rail from the Uinta Basin to Salt
Lake City refiners.
OEA Request: Provide any assumptions made
regarding the number of new oil and gas wells that
would be drilled to provide production sufficient to
supply the anticipated number (trains/day, plus
trucking, if applicable) of crude oil transport.
Response:
Oil production in the Uinta Basin is expected to
continue transitioning from a historic pattern of
vertical wells with a single completion per well and
each well on a single well pad, to vertical wells with
multiple laterals per well (“horizontal wells”) at
various depths and in various directions radiating
JA 30
from the vertical well. This transition is expected to
result in multiple completions per well and multiple
wells on a single well pad. Laterals are typically
completed sequentially, i.e., after the oil from the first
lateral completed for a given well is extracted, the
second lateral is completed and its oil resource
extracted, and so forth. “Completion” consists of the
activity of hydraulically fracturing the lateral.
•
To produce 130,000 barrels of oil per day, it is
anticipated that 130 new lateral completions will
be required initially, and 26 new lateral
completions will be required per year to sustain
that production level to account for the gradual
decline in production of the initial 130 lateral
completions.
•
To produce 350,000 barrels of oil per day, it is
anticipated that 350 new lateral completions will
be required initially and 70 new lateral
completions will be required per year to sustain
that production level to account for the gradual
decline in production of the initial 350 lateral
completions.
At present, new oil well completions in the Uinta
Basin are initially producing between 500 and 3,000
barrels per day, with an average of 500 barrels per day
for wells producing from the Green River Formation,
and 1,000 barrels per day for wells producing from the
Wasatch Formation.
As of October 2019, five oil rigs were drilling oil
wells in Uintah and Duchesne Counties, sustaining a
production of approximately 90,000 barrels of oil per
day. Accordingly, each rig is sustaining approximately
18,000 barrels per day of production. Of the
JA 31
approximately 90,000 barrels of oil produced each day,
approximately 70,000 to 80,000 barrels of oil are
trucked to refineries in the Salt Lake City area each
day. The balance of the oil produced in Uintah and
Duchesne Counties is trucked to rail transload
facilities outside of the Uinta Basin and then
transported by rail to refineries or export terminals in
areas other than Salt Lake City. Assuming oil rig
productivity neither declines nor improves, a total of
11.66 oil rigs would be required to produce 130,000
barrels of oil per day in addition to the maximum of
80,000 barrels per day that can be consumed by Salt
Lake City refineries. Assuming oil rig productivity
neither declines nor improves, a total of 23.66 oil rigs
would be required to produce 350,000 barrels per day
in addition to the maximum of 80,000 barrels per day
that can be consumed by Salt Lake City refineries.
Regardless of whether the UBRY is developed, it is
anticipated that new oil production in the Uinta Basin
will be driven by market factors and will continue to
be transported by truck.
No assumptions have been made about the
number of gas wells that could be drilled in the future.
While natural gas has historically been produced in
the Uinta Basin, it is not expected that natural gas, in
either its gas or liquid form, will be shipped via the
UBRY. Natural gas produced in the Uinta Basin is
currently being transported by pipeline on a regional
basis; this practice is expected to continue regardless
of the UBRY project.
OEA Request: Indicate if it was assumed that most
new oil and gas wells would be drilled in Duchesne and
JA 32
Uintah counties, given that is where most of the
current oil and gas production occurs.
Response:
It is assumed that all crude oil shipped on the
UBRY will come from known oil resources and
reserves in Duchesne and Uintah counties. At present,
there are no other known significant sources of crude
oil that would be economically available for railway
transportation, as opposed to pipeline or truck
transportation, in the area of the UBRY. No gas (e.g.,
liquified natural gas) is expected be shipped on the
UBRY, regardless of location of production.
OEA Request: Provide assumptions used in
estimating the number of manifest trains, including
assumptions about the quantity of fracking sand, well
pipe and equipment, and other goods that would be
needed for new wells and the production of crude at
the assumed/forecast level. Also provide assumptions
about the number of carloads, averaged per day and
per year, of such commodities that would be
transported to the Uinta Basin on the proposed rail
line.
Response:
As stated previously, no manifest trains are
expected to be operated on the UBRY. Thus, no such
assumptions have been made.
JA 33
Excerpts from SCIC Uinta Basin Oil
Pipeline Study: Final Report
September 2017
3.2 Refiner Interviews
Interview Process
•
Refiner interviews were conducted either in
person, by telephone and/or via e-mail
•
Purpose of the interviews was to ultimately
identify:
o Alternate market locations for Uinta waxy
crude oil.
o Rank those alternate market locations by
‘Higher Priority’ and ‘Lower Priority’.
o Identify refinery locations and/or regions
where there is significant local
o opposition to receipt of crude oil by rail.
o Identify refinery locations where Uinta waxy
crude oil is NOT a good fit.
•
Refiner interview questions included the
following:
o How waxy crude oils are captured in refiner
linear program runs.
o Views on prospective Uinta waxy crude oil
pricing differentials vis-a-vis WTI.
o Potential demand for Uinta crude oil.
o Potential opportunities to blend Uinta Basin
waxy crude oil with other crude oils in
o order to obtain a price uplift.
o Other commercial considerations
Findings Summary
•
There are nine top rated refinery targets outside
the SLC refining region.
•
Seven of the nine are in the USGC:
JA 34
Louisiana
Calumet Shreveport
ExxonMobil Baton Rouge
Marathon Garyville
Valero St Charles
Texas
ExxonMobil Baytown
Shell Deer Park
Valero Port Arthur
•
The other two top rated refinery targets are both
BP refineries.
Indiana
BP Whiting
Washington
BP Ferndale
Six of the nine top rated refineries have rail
offload. The three that do not are all interested in
adding rail offload capability.
•
There are no top rated California refineries owing
to significant local opposition to crude by rail – of
any kind.
In all, there are 64 refining locations with the
capability of processing some Uinta waxy crude oil in
meaningful quantities. See Table 8 and Table 9 in
Appendix 1 for a complete list.
•
Appendix 1 Table 8: Refinery Targets
(see foldout on next page)
USCA Case #22-1019
Document #1989949
Filed: 03/13/2023
JA34-a
Page
444OilofPipeline
615 Study
Unita Basin
Seven County Infrastructure Coalition
Appendix 1
Table 8: Refinery Targets
Refiner
Location
State
Atmospheric
Distillation
Potential Products
Catalytic
Distillate Gas Oil Residual Total
Fuels Solvent
Lubricant
Produced From
Distance from
Reforming High
Hydro- Hydro- Hydro- HydroDeasphalting
Capacity Running Uinta Basin Uinta basin
Pressure
cracking cracking cracking cracking
Waxy Crude
Scale Distance
Rail
Steam
Notes
Offload Capability
Salt Lake City Refineries - Presently Served by Trucks
Big West Oil
Chevron
North Salt Lake
Utah
Salt Lake City
Utah
32,000
56,000
8,500
8,500
HollyFrontier
Woods Cross
Utah
26,400
8,400
Tesoro
Salt Lake City
Utah
63,000
177,400
11,400
1%
65,000
6,000
9,000
124
119
Small
Closer
N
N
Small
Closer
N
N
9,000
RPPs, Extracted Base
Oil, Converted Base
Oil
126
Small
Closer
N
N
-
RPPs
119
Small
Closer
N
N
Converted Base Oil
1,048
1,347
1,310
Medium Medium
Y
N
RPPs
RPPs
Top-Ranked Alternate Market Locations
BP Cherry Point
BP Products
Calumet Specialty Products
Ferndale
Washington
Whiting
Indiana
Shreveport
Louisiana
236,000
430,000
60,000
ExxonMobil
Baton Rouge
Louisiana
523,200
ExxonMobil
Baytown
Texas
584,000
Marathon Petroleum
Garyville
Louisiana
574,000
Shell / PEMEX
Deer Park
Texas
340,000
Valero
Valero
Port Arthur
Texas
St Charles
Louisiana
415,000
220,000
3,382,200
24%
31,000
65,000
47,000
65,000
12,500
27,000
27,000 16,500
29,500
29,500 28,000
38,000
117,000
117,000
60,000
60,000
123,000
28,000 70,000
123,000
98,000
24,500
RPPs
Base Oil User
Converted Base Oil,
Base Oil User
Extracted Base Oil,
Converted Base Oil,
Base Oil User
Extracted Base Oil,
Converted Base Oil
RPPs, Converted
Base Oil
Converted Base Oil
Converted Base Oil
May be difficult to reconfigure rail rack to add steam - designed for Bakken offload
Large
Medium
Small
Medium
Y
Y
Considering rail rack with steam for offload of Canadian underdiluted bitumen blend
Uinta yellow wax is an approved crude. Shreveport will NOT take in black wax crude.
1,581
Large
Distant
Y
Y
Genesis Energy Terminal, Baton Rouge 60,000 bbls/d
1,412
Large
Medium
N
1,622
Large
Distant
N
N
Proposed Pinoak terminal in Garyville would be a potential fit.
1,338
Large
Medium
Y
Y
Kinder Morgan Deer Park rail terminal is immediately to the west of the refinery site.
1,475
1,640
Large
Medium
Y
Y
Rail offload at Valero's Lucas terminal in Beaumont
Medium Distant
Y
Y
30,000 bbls/d rail offload at the refinery.
1,654
Large
Distant
N
N
1,439
Large
Medium
N
N
2,091
2,093
Medium Distant
Y
N
Medium Distant
Y
1,636
Medium Distant
2,106
Large
Distant
Y
1,475
Large
Medium
Y
1,640
Large
Distant
1,617
Large
Distant
1,406
Large
Medium
Y
Trafigura Terminal in Corpus Christi 30,000 bbls/d offload
1,065
Small
Medium
Y
Sovereign Development rail offload in Ardmore 40,000 bbls/d offload
1,667
Medium Distant
Better fit from refinery perspective than Baton Rounge, but have not created rail offload capability at Baytown
Lower-Ranked Alternate Market Locations
Marathon Petroleum
Catlettsburg
Kentucky
292,000
Marathon Petroleum
Galveston Bay
Texas
481,000
PBF
PBF
Paulsboro
New Jersey
Delaware City
Delaware
166,000
190,200
PBF
Toledo
Phillips 66
Linden (Bayway)
Motiva
Port Arthur
Motiva
RPPs, Extracted Base
Oil
Extracted Base Oil,
75,000 144,000
Converted Base Oil
Base Oil User
12,000
13,000
17,000
-
69,000
22,300
51,800
52,000
22,300
Converted Base Oil
52,000
RPPs, Converted
Base Oil
Ohio
188,000
New Jersey
251,000
Texas
635,000
82,000
82,000 39,000
Norco (St Charles)
Louisiana
250,000
44,000
44,000
Motiva
Convent
Louisiana
255,000
40,000
Valero
Corpus Christi
Texas
300,000
10,000
Valero
Ardmore
Oklahoma
88,000
Valero
Meraux
Louisiana
128,000
Valero
Sunray
Texas
172,000
Valero
Valero
Memphis
Tennessee
Texas City
Texas
195,000
231,000
33,500
Valero
Houston
Texas
103,000
18,000
Valero
Three Rivers
Texas
22,000
-
14,000
22,000
18,000
14,500
91,000
10,000
29%
10,500
50,000
14,000
48,700
48,700
27,000
27,000
28,500
4,016,200
RPPs, Converted
Base Oil
RPPs, Converted
Base Oil
52,000 52,000
50,000
Converted Base Oil
Extracted Base Oil,
Converted Base Oil
RPPs, Extracted Base
Oil, Converted Base
Oil
Converted Base Oil
28,500
-
71,900
Extracted Base Oil
71,900
28,000
28,000
Extracted Base Oil
Converted Base Oil,
Base Oil User
Converted Base Oil
1,900
Extracted Base Oil,
Converted Base Oil
RPPs, Extracted Base
Oil, Converted Base
Oil, Base Oil User
745
Medium Closer
1,499
1,402
Medium Medium
1,389
Small
Medium
1,337
Small
Medium
No rail at Paulsboro refinery, but can rail to PBF's Delaware City refinery and barge the oil to Paulsboro.
70,000 bbls/d rail offload servicing PBF's Delaware City and Paulsboro refineries
75,000 bbls/d rail offload
N
Have own rail offload? Can be served by Jefferson (Beaumont) or GT Logistics (Port Arthur) rail terminals
Potential rail service by IMTT (St Rose), LBC (Geismar), EnLink (St Gabriel)
Potential rail service by IMTT (St Rose), LBC (Geismar), EnLink (St Gabriel)
Potential rail service by IMTT (St Rose), LBC (Geismar), EnLink (St Gabriel)
Medium Medium
22
JA 35
Excerpts from R.L. Banks & Associates to
SCIC, Pre-Feasibility Study of a Prospective
Railroad Connecting the Uinta Basin to the
National Rail Network
August 9, 2018
*
*
*
Because of the more speculative nature of these
prospects, RLBA used Higher and Lower forecasts,
with Lower forecasts reflecting lower, later developing
or no forecasted rail carloads and Higher forecasts
reflecting the dates and volumes presented by the
interviewee, translated into carloads.
3. Prospective Uinta Basin Rail Shippers
with Limited Traffic Volume Forecasting
Ability - Forecasts of conventional oil production were
handled a third way that RLBA deemed more
appropriate to the situation. More specifically,
attempts to use a more conventional approach to
forecasting potential use of the UBRR by crude oil
producers would have been thwarted by the fact that
producers don’t tend to forecast as far into the future
as required to support prospective railroad carloads
and that production is distributed across a large
number of producers. So, in the alternative, RLBA
decided to discuss potential total Uinta Basin
production with almost all of the largest producers
currently in the Basin and to use the extremes
manifest in their estimates to drive its Lower and
Higher carload forecasts. Further detail on RLBA’s
Higher and Lower forecasts for each commodity can be
found in the following sections.
JA 36
2.3 Developing Higher and Lower Forecast
Volumes
The railroad industry is different from most other
industries in two major ways: 1) it requires a small
cost of materials relative to revenues earned to
produce its outputs; and 2) it also requires a high
capital investment relative to revenues. However,
once a railroad achieves a break-even level of freight
traffic, a surprisingly large percentage of incremental
revenue drops to the “bottom line” as traffic is added
and a railroad can become highly profitable when
measured against just about any metric except return
on invested capital. A common expression of this
phenomenon is that the railroad industry is said to
manifest extremely high operating leverage. As a
result, for a railroad to succeed, it must attract and
keep a significant volume of traffic on which it can
charge competitive rates. The need to achieve and
sustain a high volume of traffic and revenue is even
more critical in the case of a railroad such as that
investigated herein because the financial performance
of the Uinta Basin Railroad will be tested further by
the need to overcome the extremely high capital costs
that are a necessary element of a railroad being
constructed in excess of 126 miles.
As a consequence of the above, it is absolutely
essential that the SCIC be provided one or more traffic
volume and associated revenue forecasts in which it
can repose confidence. Through the course of the
study, RLBA determined there to be four significant
potential challenges to the achievement of the
projected volumes forecasted herein, including:
JA 37
1. Stability of the Future Price of Oil - The
World oil market has been anything but stable since
1973, and there is every reason to think that such
volatility might continue. The viability of the UBRR is
grounded on the assumption that oil markets will be
stable or favorable, which is a reasonable assumption
to make. However, a significant and long-term
downturn in the price of WTI, particularly in the early
years of the prospective railroad, could result in
significant shortfalls from the performance indicated
herein;
2. Barriers to Timely Construction of the
UBRR - There are risks that permits or financing associated with the UBRR might be denied or delayed
significantly, to the point that prospective Uinta Basin
rail shippers might seek alternative “take away”
capability or divert investment dollars to other
regions, thereby diverting or postponing volumes of
crude oil and other commodities which otherwise
might traverse the UBRR;
3. Reluctance to Commit - While the economics
of the UBRR may be promising, the region’s producers
might be reluctant or otherwise unable to make the
commitments necessary to secure financing, even if
such assurances are ultimately required to advance
the project and;
4. Unknown Demand - The demand for Uinta
Basin’s waxy crude, which is not well known outside
of Utah, in large part due to lack of transportation
infrastructure to ship product out of the Uinta Basin,
may not be as readily accepted as initial indications
would suggest. While there appear to be a large
number of refineries at least prospectively interested
JA 38
in Uinta Basin crude, additional work should be
undertaken to increase the likelihood that sufficient
demand will manifest itself by the time the UBRR is
about to be constructed. Ideally, that demand will
manifest itself not only in interest expressed by outof-state refineries that the Basin’s waxy crudes have
been modeled successfully by the refineries, but also
that the volumes desired are significant enough in
total to consume the supply side at pricing at or near
WTI taking into consideration the need to unload unit
trains at or nearby refineries to keep rail transport
costs to a minimum, and that arrangements already
have been or can be made to provide sufficient heating
to prevent the waxy crude from “setting up.”
In light of these challenges, to best define the
potential volumes, RLBA developed forecasts of the
carloads it believes are reasonable to assume would be
carried by the prospective railroad during the period
2022 through 2034 (and every year beyond) were it
built, managed and operated at a reasonable cost.
More specifically, RLBA developed “Lower” and
“Higher” forecasts in connection with crude oil and
seven other commodities it believes might be hauled
on that railroad in its early years.
A summary of estimated annual Higher and
Lower forecasts of various commodities is shown in
Table 2-2.
The carloads in the Higher forecast reflect
assumptions made by RLBA consistent with a theme
that decisions would be made that would result in
actions that would be favorable to the prospective
railroad’s viability. Primary among those favorable
assumptions is that Basin oil producers will be able
JA 39
and motivated to extract, and market conditions will
encourage the extraction of, no less 225,000 bpd on a
consistent basis if the railroad is built and operated as
presently envisioned. That threshold volume has been
articulated by several major oil producers in the Basin
even though it represents almost a tripling of recent
production volumes there. The application of those
assumptions results in a forecast of [redacted]
carloads over the prospective railroad in its first full
year, 2022, in the Higher case and carloads hauled by
that railroad in the Higher case in 2034 and beyond.
As a sensitivity test, RLBA also developed a Lower
case in which [redacted] carloads were forecast to be
carried in 2022 and [redacted] were assumed to be
hauled in 2034 and beyond.
Table 2-2
Estimated Annual Carloads
Originating/Terminating in Uinta Basin,
2022-2044
[redacted]
In both the Higher and Lower cases, railroad
volumes were assumed to ramp up in the early years
of the forecast, driven by increased production of crude
oil in the Basin and the inputs that enable same, as
well as greater and greater acceptance of the Basin’s
crudes at various refineries, primarily located in Gulf
Coast states. Similarly, and perhaps more
importantly, the viability of the prospective railroad is
extremely dependent upon and sensitive to
assumptions made about the ramp up rate and total
production of crude oil in the Basin. Not only is crude
oil by far the largest single commodity moved on the
prospective railroad, but frac sand and steel pipe
JA 40
movements into the Uinta Basin, supporting the
production of crude oil are obviously equally
dependent upon how much oil is extracted in the Basin
and are also significant contributors to the prospective
railroad’s viability.
2.4 Additional Study Contributions
To further assist in the study, the SCIC
contracted with Marc Eckels, an experienced oil and
gas consultant based in Park City, UT, to interview
representatives of select refineries primarily in the
Gulf Coast and discuss with them in detail, to the
extent possible, the prospective interest of those
refineries in the Basin’s oil. After interviewing in
person representatives of five companies operating
eleven refineries believed to be possible consumers of
Basin crudes, Mr. Eckels concluded that demand
exists today for at least somewhere between 320,000
and 340,000 bpd of Basin oil.
Several caveats should be taken into
consideration in digesting that forecast. First, and
most importantly, the work performed by Mr. Eckels
is not complete, as he was only able to meet with
officials representing eleven of the nineteen refineries
he originally targeted. It is the intent of Mr. Eckels to
make a good faith effort to complete interviews with
representatives of the remaining eight refineries. As
such, the results of this report are subject to change
pending the outcome of said interviews.
Map 4-1: Proposed National Destinations and
Routings for Uinta Basin Crude Oil
(see foldout on next page)
A REP OR T TO:
SE VEN COUN T Y IN FR ASTRUC TURE COALITION
JA40-a
USCA Case #22-1019
Map 4-1
Proposed National Destinations and Routings for Uinta Basin Crude Oil
ANACORTES, WA
(Marathon Petroleum)
PORTLAND, OR
(Interchange)
CHICAGO, IL
(Interchange)
CATTLESBURG, KY
(Marathon Petroleum)
SALT LAKE CITY, UT
(Existing Customers)
PRICE, UT
Document #1989949
CRAIG, CO
CUSHING, OK
(Crude Oil Distribution)
RIFLE, CO
MEMPHIS, TN
(Interchange)
SHREVEPORT, LA
(Calumet Specialty Products)
DEER PARK, TX
(Shell / Permex)
BATON ROUGE, LA
(Exxon Mobil)
GARYVILLE, LA
(Marathon Petroleum)
PASCAGOULA, MS
(Chevron)
NEW ORLEANS, LA
(Interchange)
GALVESTON BAY, TX
(Marathon)
PORT ARTHUR, TX
(Valero)
Filed: 03/13/2023
BAYTOWN, TX
(Exxon Mobil)
NORCO, LA
(Shell)
BNSF Railway
Union Pacific Railroad
Other Railroads
Origin
Destination
Interchange
0
100
200
300
600
SCALE OF MILES
Map not necessarily to scale, not all lines shown
PAGE 51
N
Page 450 of 615
CONVENT, LA
(Shell)
P REPARED BY:
THE R.L. BAN KS & ASSOCIATES, IN C. TEAM
JA 41
Eagle County Comments on Draft
Environmental Impact Statement Before the
Surface Transportation Board, STB Docket
No. FD 36284 (Feb. 12, 2021)
Introduction
The Board of County Commissioners of Eagle County
Colorado (“Eagle County”), a political subdivision of
the State of Colorado, hereby submits the following
comments in response to the Uinta Basin Railway
Draft Environmental Impact Statement (“DEIS”),
issued by the Surface Transportation Board’s (“STB”
or “Board”) Office of Environmental Analysis (“OEA”)
on October 30, 2020, in Seven County Infrastructure
Coalition—Construction and Operation—in Utah,
Carbon, Duchesne, and Uintah Counties, Utah,
Finance Docket No. FD 36284. Chaffee County, Lake
County, the Town of Buena Vista, the City of Salida,
and Eagle River Watershed Council have authorized
Eagle County to represent that they each adopt and
join in these comments.
In accordance with the National Environmental
Policy Act of 1969 (“NEPA”), the OEA has prepared
the DEIS in order to evaluate the environmental
impacts of a proposal submitted by the Seven County
Infrastructure Coalition (“Coalition”) to construct an
approximately 85-mile rail line connecting the Uinta
Basin in Utah to the national rail network (“Uinta
Basin Railway” or “Project”), primarily for the
purposes of shipping crude oil produced in the Uinta
Basin to markets elsewhere, and its alternatives. As
one of the jurisdictions through which the DEIS
projects an overwhelming majority of the shipments of
crude oil are projected to pass, and whose communities
JA 42
are accordingly likely to bear potentially far-reaching
impacts, Eagle County is a key stakeholder in the
outcome of the Project and an important voice in this
environmental review process. As such, Eagle County
urges the OBA to address serious flaws in the DEIS,
including most importantly the lack of consideration
of a proposal to offer new service on a 163.1 mile long
connecting line between Parkdale, Colorado, and a
location known as Sage, near Dotsero, Colorado,
known as the Tennessee Pass Line (Colorado, Midland
and Pacific Railway Co. (“CMP”), Verified Notice-Lease
and Operation Exemption Containing Interchange
Commitment-Union Pacific R.R. Co., STB Docket No.
36471 (Filed December 31, 2020) (the “CMP Notice of
Exemption”)), as well as failures to adequately state
the Project’s purpose and need, consider downline
impacts and reasonable alternatives, evaluate
environmental impacts, or propose mitigation
measures. Because CMP filed its Notice of Exemption
after the STB issued the DEIS, this Board must, at a
minimum, publish a supplement to the DEIS to
address the potential effects of the Project on the
Tennessee Pass Line.
I.
Factual and Procedural Background
Eagle County, CO, is one of several western
Colorado counties through which the vast majority of
shipments resulting from the Project are anticipated
to pass via a line owned by the Union Pacific Railroad
Company (“UP”) known as the Central Corridor. See
DEIS at 2-1; 3.1-13; Colorado Department of
Transportation, Colorado Freight and Passenger Rail
Plain, 22, 50 (2018) (“Colorado State Rail Plan”),
available
at:
https://www.codot.gov/programs/
JA 43
transitandrail/plans-studies-reports/statewidetransit
plan/2018-colorado-freight-and-passenger-railplan.pdf. The Central Corridor is the only regularly
used rail line to cross the Colorado Rocky Mountains,
via a route that is known as the Moffat Tunnel
Subdivision, and is therefore an important route for
UP and BNSF Railway (“BNSF”), which has operating
rights over the Central Corridor. Colorado State Rail
Plan at 22. The Central Corridor also is used to serve
Amtrak’s California Zephyr daily passenger service as
well as seasonal ski train passenger service between
Denver and Winter Park, Colorado. Colorado State
Rail Plan at 21.
Eagle County, CO, is also the county in which the
Tennessee Pass Line, the only east-west rail
alternative in Colorado to the Moffat Tunnel
Subdivision, connects to the Central Corridor near the
community of Dotsero on the western border of the
County. The Tennessee Pass Line is owned by UP and
has not been abandoned, although it has not seen
freight service in over 20 years. Colorado State Rail
Plan at 50. The Tennessee Pass Line runs through the
Eagle River Valley alongside a portion of the I-70
Corridor, which is home to a number of burgeoning
communities that have developed substantially over
the past few decades, with future growth anticipated.
Colorado Department of Transportation, I-70
Mountain
Corridor
Final
Programmatic
Environmental Impact Statement 1-14 to 1-15 (2011),
available at: https://www.codot.gov/projects/i-70-oldmountaincorridor/final-peis/final-peis-filedownload.html. The alpine character of the area, with
stunning vistas and rugged terrain, also creates
challenges in the operation and maintenance of
JA 44
transportation infrastructure. Id. at 1-1. On its
eastern end the Tennessee Pass Line joins BNSF/UP
mainlines at Pueblo, CO.
On October 30, 2020, OEA issued the DEIS for the
Project, which is a proposal to construct an
approximately 85-mile long rail line connecting two
tennini in the Uinta Basin near South Myton Bench,
Utah, and Leland Bench, Utah to the national rail
network via an existing line at Kyune, Utah. DEIS at
1-1. The Project has been submitted for STB review by
the Coalition, an independent political subdivision of
the State of Utah composed of member counties
Carbon, Daggett, Duchesne, Emery, San Juan, Sevier,
and Uintah Counties. DEIS at S-2. The Coalition does
not propose to operate the Uinta Basin Railway itself,
but rather intends to contract with an existing rail
carrier, the Rio Grande Pacific Corporation (“RGPC”),
to provide common carrier rail service. DEIS at S-2, 11. The stated purpose of the Project is “to provide
common carrier rail service connecting the Basin to
the interstate common carrier rail network using a
route that would provide shippers with a viable
alternative to trucking.” DEIS at 1-3.
On December 9, 2020, in response to requests
from a number of parties for extension of the comment
period, the STB extended the initial 45-day public
comment period for the DEIS, originally requiring
submissions due by December 14, 2020, to January 28,
2021. Notice, Docket No. FD 36284 (Service Date Dec.
9, 2020). In light of the December 31, 2020, filings by
RGPC and its subsidiary and the apparent
connections between the Uinta Basin Railway and the
proposed operations on the Tennessee Pass Line,
JA 45
described further below, Eagle County filed a Motion
for Extension of Time and Petition for Reconsideration
of the STB’s regulatory process for the Uinta Basin
Railway proposal on January 25, 2020. The Board
further extended the deadline for comment to
February 12, 2021, in response to Eagle County’s
request. Notice, Docket No. FD 36284 (Service Date
January 28, 2021).
On December 31, 2020, CMP, a wholly-owned
subsidiary of the RGPC, submitted a Notice of
Exemption announcing that CMP would be entering
into a lease with UP for the majority of the Tennessee
Pass rail line between Parkdale and Sage, Colorado,
and that it had filed for common carrier authority to
operate. Verified Notice of Exemption, Rio Grande
Pacific Corp.—Continuance in Control Exemption—
Colorado, Midland & Pacific Ry. Co., STB Docket No.
FD 36470 (filed Dec. 31, 2020) (the “RGP Notice of
Exemption”);·see also the CMP Notice. In its press
release announcing the lease with UP, CMP stated
that it intended to explore development opportunities
for freight rail services originating or terminating on
the Tennessee Pass Line.1
II. Legal Background
NEPA is “our basic national charter for protection
of the environment.” Barnes v. U.S. Dep’t of Transp.,
655 F.3d 1124, 1131 (quoting former 40 C.F.R.
1 See https://rgpc.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/TN-Pass-
press-release-final-CMP.pdf.
JA 46
§ 1500.1(a) (2019)).2 NEPA is intended to ensure that
Federal agencies consider the environmental impacts
of their actions in the decision-making process
concerning proposed federal actions. “For any
proposed major federal action ... NEPA requires the
agency to prepare an [EIS].” Lands Council v. Powell,
395 F.3d 1019, 1026 (9th Cir. 2004). An EIS must
provide “full and fair discussion of significant
environmental impacts and [] inform decision makers
and the public of reasonable alternatives that would
avoid or minimize adverse impacts or enhance the
quality of the human environment.” 40 C.F.R. § 1502.l
(2020). Specifically, an EIS must include details on the
environmental impact of a proposed action, any
adverse environmental effects which cannot be
avoided should the proposal be implemented, and
alternatives to the proposed action. 42 U.S.C.
§ 4332(2)(C)(i)-(iii). Environmental impacts that must
be covered in an EIS include reasonably foreseeable
environmental trends and planned actions in the area.
49 C.F.R. § 1502.15. Reasonably foreseeable impacts
are those that are “sufficiently likely to occur that a
person of ordinary prudence would take it into account
in reaching a decision.” Mid States Coalition for
Progress v. STB, 345 F.3d 520, 549 (8th Cir. 2003). The
fact that the specifics of a reasonably foreseeable
impact are not known with precision does not mean
that they may be ignored when the nature of the effect
is reasonably foreseeable. Id. 345 F.3d at 549-50.
As discussed in this section, new NEPA regulations were
promulgated in 2020. Hereinafter, where a NEPA regulation is
not dated or is dated 2020, it refers to the current regulations.
2
JA 47
A. Council on Environmental
NEPA Regulations
Quality
The Council on Environmental Quality (“CEQ”)
first promulgated regulations governing the
implementation of NEPA in 1978. See 40 C.F.R.
§§ 1500-1508. In July 2020, the CEQ adopted
comprehensive revisions to these regulations. 85 Fed.
Reg. 43,304 (July 16, 2020). On January 20, 2021,
President Biden signed Executive Order 13990,
“Protecting Public Health and the Environment and
Restoring Science to Tackle the Climate Crisis.” 86
Fed. Reg. 7037 (Jan. 25, 2021). Simultaneously,
President Biden announced a list of agency actions
that heads of agencies would review in accordance
with Executive Order 13990, which included, inter
alia, CEQ’s July 2020 NEPA regulations.3
While the relevant portions of CEQ’s July 2020
NEPA regulations do not conflict with its NEPA
regulations that preceded those revisions, i.e. it is
possible for the STB to comply with both versions, we
note that the July 2020 regulations appear to be
narrower in some respects. Given the uncertainty
around the status of CEQ’s current interpretation of
NEPA, we urge OEA to ensure that the DEIS
comports with both the pre-2020 NEPA regulations
and those NEPA regulations adopted in July 2020.
Inasmuch as CEQ’s pre-2020 NEPA regulations were
based upon and implemented statute, and inasmuch
as federal court decisions interpreting those
regulations were also grounded in statute, they are
See https://web.archive.org/web/20210120151809/https:/build
backbetter.gov/press-releases/fact-sheet-list-of-agency-actionsfor-review/
3
JA 48
still good law and should guide OEA’s preparation of
the EIS for the Uinta Basin Railway.
B. STB’s NEPA Regulations
The STB has also adopted its own regulations
governing how NEPA applies to railroad construction
projects. 49 C.F.R. Part 1105. Under these
regulations, the OEA generally prepares an EIS for
new railroad construction proposals. 49 C.F.R.
§ 1105.6(a). The STB invites public comment on the
scope of the environmental review and on the DEIS.
49 C.F.R. § 1105.l0(a). The FEIS should discuss the
comments received on the DEIS and note any changes
made in response to them. Id. When determining
whether to authorize a construction project, the STB
considers the environmental record, which includes
the FEIS and any comments and responses concerning
environmental issues. Id. § 1105.l0(f).
III. Comments
A. The Federal Railroad Administration
and Pipeline and Hazardous Materials
Safety
Administration
Must
Be
Cooperating Agencies.
Under NEPA, a “cooperating agency” means any
Federal agency, other than a lead agency, that has
jurisdiction by law or special expertise with respect to
any environmental impact involved in a proposed
project or project alternative.” 40 C.F.R. § 1508.5. The
lead agency is required to “[ r]equest the participation
of each cooperating agency in the NEPA process at the
earliest possible time.” 40 C.F.R. § 1501.6(a)(1). An
agency may also request the lead agency to designate
it a cooperating agency. Id. § 1501.6. In this instance,
the knowledge arising from the Federal Railroad
JA 49
Administration’s (“FRA”) general rail safety expertise
and the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety
Administration’s (“PHMSA”) regulation of hazardous
materials shipments is essential to a thorough
analysis of potential risks and anticipated impacts in
connection with the Project.
Between 1992 and 1998, the Central Corridor was
among the locations in Utah and Colorado that
experienced seven derailments that caused releases of
diesel fuel, taconite, and sulfuric acid into rivers
adjacent to the railroad serious enough to trigger
enforcement of the Clean Water Act.4 UP entered into
a consent decree with the U.S. Department of Justice
in 2000 that required the railroad to pay $800,000 in
fines and institute a number of operating safety
measures, including the “implementation of a
comprehensive rock fall hazard mitigation project”.5
Given the history of wrecks and spills in the
Central Corridor, the proposed shipment of crude oil
from the Project presents elevated risks and potential
impacts to communities along the line in the event of
a derailment or other accident. The DEIS identifies
the potential for 40% increased risk of rail-related
accidents along UP’ s Central Corridor. DEIS at 3.2-6.
In a 2018 report to Congress comparing the shipment
of crude oil by rail, truck, and pipeline, PHMSA noted
that the safety record of crude oil shipments by rail
between 2007 and 2016 was highly variable, with rail
4 U.S. Dept. of Justice, Press Release, June 8, 2000, available at:
https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2000/June/328enrd.htm.
5 U.S. v. Southern Pac. Transp. Co., Notice of Lodging of Consent
Decree Under the Sections 309(b) and 311(b) of the Clean Water
Act, 65 Fed. Reg. 38,574 (Dep’t of Justice, June 21, 2000).
JA 50
in some years involving almost 900% more crude oil
spills than either pipeline or truck shipments.6
PHMSA noted that variability of rail’s safety record
for crude oil spills was driven by “high-impact
incidents.”7 In other words, when things go wrong
with shipments of crude oil by rail, they go
dramatically wrong. Accordingly, the Project does not
consist solely of the construction of rail facilities and
generalized operations, but expressly involves the
shipment of a commodity whose handling is governed
by a specific and specialized regulatory regime.8
The expertise of these sister U.S. Department of
Transportation agencies will aid in the thorough
evaluation of risks and potential impacts of the Project
and will not be duplicative or redundant with the
STB’s role as lead agency. For instance, “Congress
vested the FRA with primary authority over national
rail safety policy and assigned the [Surface
Transportation Board] the duty to ... [assess]
individual railway proposals subject to its authority.”
Tyrrell v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co., 248 F.3d 517,523 (6th Cir.
2001). Although the DEIS reflects that OEA “sent
consultation letters to agencies soliciting their input,
comments, ideas, and concerns” of a generic nature
(DEIS at 5-2), Table 5.1 of the DEIS lists FRA, but not
PHMSA, among the agencies contacted, and does not
reflect the affirmative outreach to those two agencies
6 PHMSA,
Report to Congress—Shipping Crude Oil by Truck,
Rail and Pipeline (March 19, 2019), at 7, Fig. 3. Available at:
https://www.plm1sa.dot.gov/news/report-congress-shippingcrude-oil-truck-rail-and-pipeline,
7 Id.
8 49 C.F R. part 174.
JA 51
as their respective expertise would demand in
accordance with the CEQ regulations.
B. The Project’s DEIS Fails To Consider
New Proposed Operation Over the Tennessee
Pass Line, Either As a Connected Action or In Its
Downline Impact Analysis
CMP’s recent Notice of Exemption to conduct
freight service on the Tennessee Pass Line in Colorado
demonstrates that the proposal to provide new service
on the Tennessee Pass Line and the Uinta Basin
Railway are connected actions, and they must be
analyzed together in a Supplemental DEIS. Despite
the assertions of CMP’s parent, RGP, that it does not
currently plan to ship crude oil over the Tennessee
Pass Line (Seven County Infrastructure Coalition,
Comment, STB Docket No. FD 36284—STB OEA
Document Number EI-27080 (Filed January 26, 2021),
Verified Statement of Mark W. Hemphill), the
Coalition also observes in that filing that the
Tennessee Pass Line has not been abandoned, and
therefore remains part of the national freight rail
network. The Coalition does not rule out what future
operations CMP may conduct on the Tennessee Pass
Line.
According to the DEIS, if the STB authorizes the
proposed construction and operation of the Uinta
Basin Railway, RGPC would operate and maintain the
line. DEIS at 2-L Further, OEA states that RGPC is
intended to be included when the DEIS refers to the
Coalition. DEIS at 1-1 n. 1, 2-1 n. 1. Accordingly,
RGPC is the party that will be subject to a common
carrier obligation and is effectively an applicant in this
proceeding.
JA 52
On December 31, 2020, RGPC announced that its
wholly owned subsidiary, CMP, had entered into a
lease with Union Pacific Railroad for the majority of
the Tennessee Pass Line between Parkdale and Sage,
Colorado, and that it had filed for common-carrier
authority to operate with the STB. RGP Notice of
Exemption. In its press release announcing the lease
with UP, CMP stated that it intended to explore
development opportunities for freight rail services
originating or terminating on the Tennessee Pass
Line.9 While the same release states that RGPC had
no plans to carry crude oil from Utah over the
Tem1essee Pass Line, it appears this was included
only to address speculation and community concern;
nothing in the RGPC Notice of Exemption or CMP
Notice of Exemption precludes transport of oil and, as
a common carrier, RGPC would be required to provide
rail service to any shipper upon reasonable request.
1.
The proposal to reinstitute freight
rail service on the Tennessee Pass
Line is a federal action that must be
considered connected and evaluated
together with the Project for the
purposes of NEPA
The Tennessee Pass rail line is connected to the
Uinta Basin Railway for the purposes of NEPA
analysis. CEQ regulations provide that an agency
must consider connected actions in determining the
scope and significance of a federal action. 40 C.F.R.
§§ 1501.3(b), 1501.9(e)(1). Actions are connected if
See https://rgpc.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/TN-Passpress-release-final-CMP.pdf.
9
JA 53
they are “closely related,” 40 C.F.R. § 1501.9(e)(1).
CMP is a wholly owned subsidiary of RGPC, a real
party in interest in the instant STB proceeding, and a
physical connection between the Uinta Basin Railway
line and the Tennessee Pass line in Colorado could be
readily established. Moreover, the Tennessee Pass
line would connect the Project line with the most likely
markets for the crude oil that is expected to be
transported from the Uinta Basin, and would serve as
an alternative route to the line that has been
identified as likely to be used for the vast majority of
daily shipments expected to result from the Project.
The Uinta Basin Railway and the Tennessee Pass line
are interrelated parts of a larger action—a rail
network in Utah and Colorado for the transport of
freight -- and they depend on this larger action for
their justification. Id. § 1501.9(e)(1)(iii).
CMP’s lease with UP and related STB proceeding
to transpo1t freight over the Tennessee Pass Line
represent fundamental changes in the scope of the
“project” to be analyzed in the Uinta Basin Railway
EIS. The introduction of freight service on the
Tennessee Pass Line—including, potentially, oil from
the Uinta Basin—presents a significant new
circumstance that raises new environmental concerns
about the impacts of the Uinta Basin Railway.
Transport of crude oil over the remote, steep, winding,
and mountainous Tennessee Pass Line would
introduce risks associated with accidents, including
spills or releases in or near sensitive areas such as a
river, wetland, important wildlife habitat area, or
recreational sites.
JA 54
In such circumstances, OEA must prepare a
Supplemental DEIS. The duty to prepare a
Supplemental DEIS is based on the need to facilitate
informed decision making. S. Utah Wilderness
Alliance v. Norton, 301 F. 3d 1217, 1238 (10th Cir.
2002), rev’d on other grounds and remanded, 542 U.S.
55 (2004). A supplement is required where there are
“significant new circumstances or information
relevant to environmental concerns and bearing on
the proposed action or its impacts.” 40 C.F.R.
§ 1502.9(d)(1)(ii).10
While failure to issue a supplemental EIS is not
unlawful if the relevant environmental impacts have
already been considered in the NEPA process, Friends
of Marolt Park v. U.S. Dept. of Transp., 382 F.3d 1088,
1097 (10th Cir. 2004), that is not the case here. The
DEIS for the Project considers downline impacts in
Colorado only in the Moffat Tunnel Subdivision, and
the Tennessee Pass Line is not mentioned at all.
Indeed, the Tennessee Pass Line could conceivably
serve as an alternative to the UP’s Moffat Tunnel
Subdivision to Denver, which under the DEIS is
currently expected to carry the vast majority of
increased rail traffic caused by the Project. See the
10 STB’s regulations implementing NEPA provide that an EIS
“may be supplemented” in the face of significant new and
relevant information, see 49 C.F.R. § 1510(a)(5), whereas CEQ’s
regulations make supplementation mandatory in circumstances
where there is significant new information relevant to
environmental concerns. Compare 49 C.F.R. § 1510(a)(5) with 40
C.F.R. § 1502.9(d)(1)(ii). Where an agency’s regulations conflict
with NEPA and the implementing regulations promulgated by
the CEQ, CEQ’s regulations are controlling. Sierra Club v. US.
Dept. of Agriculture, 777 F. Supp. 2d 44, 68 (D.D.C. 2011).
JA 55
Map attached as Exhibit A to these Comments,
showing the relationship between the Project, the
Tennessee Pass Line, the connection both lines share
to the UP Central Corridor, and the surrounding
freight rail network. Consideration of the Tennessee
Pass Line proposal in conjunction with the Uinta
Basin Railway is necessary to prevent OEA from
conducting piecemeal environmental reviews that will
not result in an understanding of the full impacts of
the rail system additions being contemplated. See, e.g.,
W Chi. V United States Nuclear Regulatory Com., 701
F.2d 632, 650 (7th Cir. 1983) (“piecemealing” allows
an agency to evade NEPA requirements “by
segmenting an overall plan into smaller parts
involving action with less significant environmental
effects”). This is contrary to the intent of NEPA to
provide a comprehensive, full, understanding of a
proposal’s impact prior to approving a project. See,
e.g., Citizens Comm. To Save Our Canyons v. United
Stales Forest Serv., 297 F.3d 1012, 1028 (10th Cir.
2002) (“One of the primary reasons for requiring an
agency to evaluate connected actions in a single EIS is
to prevent agencies from minimizing the potential
environmental consequences of a proposed action (and
thus short-circuiting NEPA review) by segmenting or
isolating an individual action that, by itself, may not
have a significant environmental impact.”).
Accordingly, OEA must prepare a Supplemental
DEIS that analyzes the impacts of reintroducing
service on the Tennessee Pass line along with the
other impacts of the Uinta Basin Railway identified in
the DEIS.
JA 56
2.
Even if not a connected action,
opening of the Tennessee Pass Line
must be considered as part of the
downline impacts of the Project
Even if the introduction of new service along the
Tennessee Pass Line did not constitute a “connected
action,” it would nevertheless need to be considered in
the downline impact analysis. The DEIS defines the
“downline study area” as “segments of existing rail
lines outside of the Uinta Basin that could experience
an increase in rail traffic above OEA’s thresholds at 49
C.F.R. § 1105.7(e)(5) if the proposed rail line were
constructed.” DEIS at 3.2-1.
As discussed above, the OBA analyzed potential
markets and rail routes in order to identify rail lines
over which downline impacts should be assessed. This
assessment did not anticipate the introduction of new
service over the Tennessee Pass Line, although it has
not been abandoned. However, RGPR’s and CMP’s
recent filings regarding renewed operations over the
Tennessee Pass Line, combined with the strategic
connection that the Tennessee Pass Line makes
between the Project and the most likely markets for
Uinta Basin-sourced crude oil, make consideration of
the downline impacts to the area and communities
adjacent to the Tennessee Pass Line necessary in
order to consider all reasonably foreseeable impacts
caused by the Project.
The need to evaluate impacts is particularly the
important here given the general absence of service
along this line for more than 20 years, the growth of
development in the area that may increase the
severity of safety risks and impacts, and the often-
JA 57
difficult access and challenging terrain of the route.
The Board’s environmental regulations at 49 C.F.R.
§ 1105.7(e)(3) require the assessment of impacts a
project may have on land use patterns in affected
communities, including:
(i) Based on consultation with local and/or
regional planning agencies and/or a review of
the official planning documents prepared by
such agencies, state whether the proposed
action is consistent with existing land use
plans. Describe any inconsistencies.
(ii) Based on consultation with the U.S. Soil
Conservation Service, state the effect of the
proposed action on any prime agricultural land.
The terrain through which the Tennessee Pass
Line travels is characterized by rangelands and a
narrow mountain river valley. Communities along the
line have experienced significant development since
the line was last active in the mid-l 990s and many are
laid out longitudinally in parallel with the river and
rail line because of the topographic limitations
imposed by steep canyon sides. Examples of
development that a Supplemental DEIS must take
into account include:
•
The Town of Minturn has developed and is
expanding a significant network of trails. See
the Town of Minturn 2009 Community Plan at
21-22,
available
at:
https://www.mintum.org/sites/g/files/vyhlif348
6/f/uploads/2009communityplan.pdf
•
The rail line runs through the downtown Avon,
which has been developed as a pedestrian and
bicycle zone that is a significant focus of
JA 58
resident and visitor activity. See the Town of
Avon’s
website
at:
https://www.avon.org/2038/Free-Spaces-toExplore.
•
The Town of Buena Vista is bisected by the rail
line, and any slow or stopped trains that block
at-grade crossings would hamper emergency
response.
•
In general, the re-introduction of freight rail
service will drive additional expense and
impose the administrative burden on
municipalities
of
training
local
first
responders to address rail-related accidents
and incidents.
C. The DEIS’s Existing Downline Impact
Analysis Is Insufficient
Among other requirements for environmental
reporting, the STB’s environmental regulations
require rail construction proposals to “ [d]escribe the
effects, including indirect or downline impacts, of the
new or diverted traffic over the line if the thresholds
governing energy, noise and air impacts in
§§ l105.7(e)(4), (5), or (6) are met.” 49 C.F.R.
§ 1105.7(e)(11)(v).
The threshold for energy according to 49 C.F.R.
§ l105.7(e)(4) is: “If the proposed action will cause
diversions from rail to motor carriage of more than:
(A) 1,000 rail carloads a year; or (B) An average of 50
rail carloads per mile per year for any part of the
affected line, quantify the resulting net change in
energy consumption and show the data and
methodology used to arrive at the figure given.” Id.
§ 1105.7(e)(4)(iv).
JA 59
The threshold for air according to § l105.7(e)(5) is
(as is relevant here):
•
“If the proposed action will result in ... [a]n
increase in rail traffic of at least 100 percent
(measured in gross ton miles annually) or an
increase of at least eight trains a day on any
segment of the rail line affected by the
proposal,” Id. § 1105.7(e)(5)(i); or
•
“If the proposed action affects a class I or
nonattainment area under the Clean Air Act,
and will result in , ... [a]n increase in rail traffic
of at least 50 percent (measured in gross ton
miles annually) or an increase of at least three
trains a day on any segment of rail line.” Id.
§ 1105.7(e)(5)(ii).
•
However, these regulations also provide that for
new construction of a line or reinstitution of
service over a previously abandoned line, only
the train car threshold (not the percentage
threshold) applies. Id. §§ 1105.7(e)(5)(i)(C),
1105.7(e)(5)(ii)(C).
The threshold for noise according to § 1105.7(e)(6)
is: “If any of the thresholds identified in
[§ 1105.7(e)(5)(i), i.e. the air quality threshold] are
surpassed, state whether the proposed action will
cause (i) An incremental increase in noise levels of
three decibels Ldn or more; or (ii) An increase to a
noise level of 65 decibels Ldn or greater.”
§ 1105.7(e)(6).
The DEIS states that “to assess the potential
impacts of increased rail traffic on main lines outside
of the immediate Project area, OEA defined a
downline study area that extends from the proposed
JA 60
connection near Kyune to the northern, eastern, and
southern edges of the Denver Metro/North Front
Range air quality nonattainment area.” DEIS at S-11.
For the downline study area, the DEIS identifies that
“[t]he impacts from the additional traffic on these
main lines could include air quality impacts associated
with locomotive exhaust, increased wayside noise,
increased risk of accidents at at-grade road crossings,
and increased vehicular delay at road crossings.” Id.
However, in the DEIS the OEA states that it “does not
expect that downline impacts would be significant.”
Id. The downline study area, based expressly on the
threshold levels in 49 C.F.R. § 1105.7(e)(5), were
applied in the DEIS to analyze downline impacts
related to roadway vehicle safety and delay (DEIS at
3.1.-1 to 3.1-2), and rail operations safety (DEIS at 3.21), in addition to air quality (DEIS at 3.7-3).
Appendix C to the DEIS provides how the OEA
identified the study area for its downline impact
analysis. Appendix C first notes the STB’s
environmental regulations provided at § 1105.7(e) and
provides that OEA determined that the eight- and
three-train thresholds for air impacts and the noise
thresholds in § 1105.7(e)(6) were applicable to the
Project. The OEA further provides that, “[b]ased on its
experience applying the thresholds for air and noise
on freight rail construction and operation projects,
OEA has determined that these thresholds should also
apply to freight rail safety and grade-crossing safety
and delay.” DEIS App. C, at C-1. In determining which
potential downline routes might be affected, and
therefore must be analyzed, Appendix C provides that:
JA 61
There are many factors that determine
possible destinations for loaded crude oil
trains originating in the Basin and the routes
those trains could take within the national
(downline) freight rail network to reach those
destinations. The possible destinations and
routes then determine where the estimated
increase in rail traffic could warrant analysis
based on the Board’s thresholds. OEA
determined the downline study area by first
considering the likely destinations for crude
oil that would be transported by the proposed
rail line. OEA then considered potential
routing to those destinations and where the
estimated project-related rail traffic would
exceed the analysis thresholds.
After analyzing the feasibility and market
dynamics of a number of refineries with actual or
potential rail connections between them and the Uinta
Basin Railway, OEA concluded that “a reasonable
estimated distribution of destinations for Uinta Basinsourced crude oil transported on the proposed rail line
would be 50 percent to Houston/Port Arthur, 35
percent to Louisiana Gulf Coast, 10 percent to Puget
Sound, and 5 percent to P ADD 2 refineries in Kansas
and Oklahoma.” DEIS App. C, at C-3 to C-4.
The OEA then estimated the most likely routing
between the Uinta Basin and these destinations on UP
and BNSF Railway lines using a routing program and
calculated the number of additional trains per day
expected on each route for both low and high
estimates. DEIS App. C, at C-4. It concluded that the
overwhelming majority of rail traffic from Kyune to
JA 62
Denver would travel along UP’s Central Corridor via
the Moffat Tunnel Subdivision, and that the
regulatory threshold for air quality would be exceeded
along this route and within the metropolitan Denver
area. DEIS App. C, at C-5 to C-6.11 Furthermore, for
Uinta Basin-related traffic from Denver to
Houston/Port Arthur and Louisiana, the high traffic
scenario exceeded three trains a day, and nearly met
the three train threshold for the low rail traffic
scenario. DEIS App. C Table C-4, at C-5. In fact, OEA
calculated that the total average trains per day
reaching Houston/Port Arthur in the high traffic
scenario would be 5.26 trains, and likewise the
average daily trains for the Louisiana destination
under the high traffic scenario would be 3.68 trains,
both above the three-train threshold. Id.
The OEA states that because Denver is a
nonattainment area (i.e. the three train threshold
applies there), and because of uncertainty associated
with the estimated distribution of rail traffic out of
Denver, it set the downline study area for the Project
as the boundaries of the Denver Metro/North Front
Range air quality nonattainment area. DEIS App. C,
at C-5.
11 The DEIS does not expressly identify the route as the Central
Corridor or the Moffat Tunnel Subdivision, but the map on page
C-6 of Appendix C and the OEA’s description reflects this.
JA 63
1.
The downline impact analysis
inappropriately omits consideration
of other hazardous or dangerous
commodities and of the uniquely
hazardous character of crude oil
shipments
In addition to conventional crude oil, the Coalition
admits that other commodities, including natural gas
and coal, may also be shipped over the constructed rail
line to other markets. DEIS at 2-1. Indeed, in addition
to some of the largest oil shale deposits in the world,
the Uinta Basin is also home to some of the largest
natural gas fields in Utah, as well as marginal coal
deposits. See Michael D Vanden Berg, Utah’s Energy
Landscape, Circular 121, Utah Geological Survey,
Utah
Department
of
Natural
Resources,
16,
29,
34
(2016),
available
at:
https://ugspub.nr.utah.gov/publications/circular/c121.pdf.
However,
although
shipment
of
these
commodities is expressly contemplated, the DEIS
analysis of downline impacts focuses exclusively on oil
shipments, based on the assertions of the Coalition
that the primary commodity expected to be
transp01ied over the constructed rail lines will be
crude oil. DEIS at 2-1; App. C, at C-1. Accordingly,
expected shipping routes for crude oil have informed
the downline study area, excluding routes that are
likely to serve markets for other commodities,
including oil shale, natural gas, coal, and other
mineral deposits. Id. For instance, the OEA’s analysis
eliminated westward routes from consideration under
its downline impact analysis due to its market
JA 64
analysis for crude oil, even though West Coast ports
may very well serve as the logical rail destination for
expanding
international
markets
for
other
commodities such as natural gas.
Many of the additional non-oil commodities that
are explicitly identified as potentially transported
have particular impacts that cannot be properly
assessed by merely looking at the shipment of oil. To
take but two examples, the unique and dangerous
aspects of coal (e.g. impacts of fugitive coal dust and
combustion) and natural gas (e.g. vaporization and
flammability) require specific consideration. See
PHMSA, Risk Assessment of Surface Transport of
Liquid
Natural
Gas,
Final
Report,
92
(March
20,
2019),
available
at:
https://www.phmsa.dot.gov/sites/phmsa.dot.gov/files/
docs/research-anddevelopment/hazmat/reports/7l651
/fr2-phmsa-hmtrns16-oncall-20mar20l9-v3.pdf
(noting the particular difficulty in cleaning up an LNG
incident); Robert. Kotchenruther, Fugitive Dust .from
Coal Trains. Factors Effecting Emissions &
Estimating PM2. 5, EPA Region 10, NW-AIRQUEST
(2013).
Changing market factors and transportation
dynamics, as well as the effects of induced demand,
discussed below at Section III.E, suggest that even if
current expected volumes of non-oil shipments are
low, they may not remain that way. This is
particularly so considering the significance of
resources in the Uinta Basin and the long-term
presence and operability of rail infrastructure.
Yet no explanation is provided for why the
impacts from shipment of these other commodities,
JA 65
which are clearly reasonably foreseeable, are not or
should not be considered in assessing downline
impacts. The complete reliance on oil shipments in
considering downline impacts reflects the same sort of
shortcut analysis used in applying air quality
standards to rail safety impacts, discussed further
below at III.C.2.
2.
The threshold for assessing air
quality issues is inadequate to
analyze safety issues particular to
shipping oil
The OEA states that “[b]ased on its experience
applying the thresholds for air and noise on freight
rail construction and operation projects, OEA has
determined that these thresholds should also apply to
freight rail and safety and grade-crossing safety and
delay.” DEIS App. C, at C-1. Unless OEA “describes
its basis for applying the standard under which it has
arrived at this conclusion, supported by plausible
explanation,” there is no basis for determining
whether the decision is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse
of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with the
law. See Ober v. Whitman, 243 F.3d 1190, 1195 (9th
Cir. 2001). A review of STB decisions indicates no
explanation of why OEA could use the threshold for
air for freight rail and safety and grade-crossing safety
and delay.
Even if OBA may have applied these thresholds
for safety-related issues in other cases, simply relying
on prior use is not sufficient because “[e]ach project is
different, and the agency is required to rationally
explain its decision in the context of project-specific
effects.” Northern Plains Resource Council, Inc. v.
JA 66
Surface Transp. Bd., 668 F.3d 1067, 1078 (9th Cir.
2011). The particularly hazardous nature of crude oil
makes air quality standards inadequate for analyzing
the safety issues presented by these trains throughout
their trip from the Uinta Basin to their likely
destinations,
including
Houston/Port
Arthur,
Louisiana, Puget Sound, Kansas, and Oklahoma.
DEIS App. C, at C-3 to C-4. As the Congressional
Research Service recently noted, “[u]nit trains of crude
oil concentrate a large amount of potentially
environmentally harmful and flammable material,
increasing the probability that, should an accident
occur, large fires and explosions could result.” John
Frattelli et al., US. Rail Transportation of Crude Oil:
Background and Issues for Congress, Congressional
Research Service, 12 (2014), available at:
https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R43390.pdf. The risks
involved with crude oil accidents are arguably less
about volume of oil and more about where a spill
occurs; a spill near a sensitive ecosystem, such as a
river, will have a greater impact and cost more to clean
up than a larger spill in a less sensitive area. Id. at.
11.
OBA attempts to downplay the downline safety
risks of the Project by focusing on the “waxy” semisolid
character of Uinta Basin crude oil at room
temperatures, which makes it potentially easier to
contain event of a spill. DEIS at 3.3-29. However
“cleanup friendly” it may be compared to other crude
oils, waxy crude remains a highly flammable
commodity
whose
dangers
should
not
be
underestimated or considered through the rubric of an
air quality standard. Furthermore, waxy crude
presents its own unique logistical challenges and
JA 67
impacts, including, for instance, the need to heat it at
various stages to enhance its fluidity.
Accordingly, it is therefore in error to use air
quality limits completely unconnected to the risks
associated with waxy crude oil to establish the
standard for evaluating the downline impacts
envisioned under the Project.
3.
The OEA incorrectly limits analysis
to contiguous rail segments where
an applicable regulatory threshold
is reached rather than to anticipated
routes serving a project that has
reached the applicable regulatory
threshold(s)
OEA does not explain why it does not consider all
downline impacts for the entire journey to expected
refining destinations, rather than focus only on
individual segments over which the increase in traffic
is expected to exceed the regulatory threshold
provided in the STB’s regulations for air quality
impacts. In its methodology, OEA apparently limited
the scope of the downline study area by only including
contiguous12 segments of rail connected to the Project
that were themselves expected to see an increase of
traffic. DEIS App. C. at C-1. However, the STB’s
regulations require rail construction proposals to
“describe the downline impacts if the thresholds
governing energy, noise and air impacts in
12 As discussed below, OEA does not mention or explain why only
contiguous segments of rail line that meet the regulatory
thresholds are included in the downline study area, even though
OEA’s own analysis indicates that this threshold may be met in
other areas of the country as a result of the project.
JA 68
§ 1105.7(e)(4), (5), or (6) are met.” 49 C.F.R.
§ l105.7(e)(11)(v). The regulations do not limit the
evaluation of downline impacts only to segments
where thresholds are met; rather they logically
require downline impacts to be considered when the
thresholds are met by the project. Otherwise, it would
be possible to completely discount all downline
impacts if routes connecting to the Project were
numerous enough to diffuse the average number of
trips per route. This would certainly undermine the
purpose of 49 C.F.R. § 1105.7(e)(11)(v).
Here, according to the proponent’s and OEA’s own
analysis, the regulatory thresholds are met by the
Project, both on the line to be constructed and on
existing segments, particularly the segments between
Kyune and Denver. No explanation is given as to why
it is appropriate to completely ignore downline
impacts over the great majority of the routes that the
project-generated traffic would use; rather doing so
would conflict with the requirement of 49 C.F.R.
§ 1105.7(e)(11)(v) to “describe the effects ... , of the new
or dive1ted traffic over the line.”
4.
The scope of the downline study area
does not include analysis of
segments of rail line outside of Utah
and Colorado that may or will likely
exceed the regulatory thresholds
that OEA uses
Even if OEA were correct in the manner in which
it applied the regulatory thresholds to define the
downline impact study area, the resulting study area
does not reflect OEA’s own methodology. In
establishing the downline study area OEA relies on
JA 69
the thresholds provided in 49 C.F.R. § 1105.7(e)(5)
relating to air impacts, i.e. an increase in eight trains
a day on average, or three trains a day on average in
air quality non-attainment areas. See DEIS at 3.1-1 to
3.1-2; 3.2-1; 3.7-3; App. C, at C-1). Nothing in the
threshold or methodology suggests that segments of
rail line, yards, or terminals that meet the threshold
but are non-contiguous with other lines that meet the
threshold, should be excluded. OEA does not mention
or explain why segments of rail lines outside of Utah
and Colorado that may meet the regulatory thresholds
are not included in the downline study area, even
though OEA’s own analysis indicates that the
increased traffic may result in exceeding the threshold
there. OEA’s analysis clearly establishes the
expectation that Uinta Basin crude oil will likely end
up in only a few places, mostly in Houston/Port Arthur
and Louisiana. Although OEA does not share the
specific routing data it used, the routes owned by the
two railroads analyzed (BNSF and UP), and the
incentive to route efficiently, would suggest that much
or all of this traffic would likely take the same limited
number of routes and pass through the same yards,
some of which may be within nonattainment areas.
Not considering the impacts in these areas, let alone
not including them in the downline study area, is
irrational.
For instance, the greater Houston metropolitan
area, through which traffic between Houston and the
Uinta Basin is expected to be the greatest, and
through which through traffic to Louisiana appears
likely to travel, is identified as a nonattainment area.
See EPA, Green Book, https://www3.epa.gov/
airquality/greenbook/map/mapnpoll.pdf (EPA Green
JA 70
Book) (visited Jan. 21, 2021); Texas Department of
Transportation, Texas Non-Attainment Areas,
https://gistxdot.opendata.arcgis.com/datasets/texasnonattainment-areas (visited Jan. 21, 2021). Areas in
Kansas and Louisiana through which Uinta Basinrelated trains might travel may also qualify under the
established regulatory air thresholds for nonattainment areas. See EPA Green Book.
OEA estimates in the high rail traffic scenarios
that 5.26 additional trains per day on average will
travel between Houston/Port Arthur and Uinta Basin,
and that 3.68 additional trains per day on average will
travel between Uinta Basin and Louisiana. DEIS,
App. C, Table C-4, at C-5. Averaging the high and low
rail traffic scenarios for traffic to Houston/Port Arthur
also results in an average that exceeds the threshold
for nonattainment areas (3.55 trains per day on
average), indicating that the range of expected
increased traffic to this destination is above the
regulatory threshold OEA uses. OEA does not even
mention these expected exceedances, let alone explain
why they would not qualify to be included in the
downline study area.
5.
The OEA incorrectly excludes
multiple routes that in aggregate
would
meet
the
regulatory
thresholds that OEA uses to identify
the scope of the downline impacts
Even if specific routes east of the Denver
metropolitan area individually would not experience
expected increases in traffic that would reach the
regulatory threshold cited by OEA, OEA’s data clearly
shows that in the aggregate routes to some of the
JA 71
destinations for traffic would exceed thresholds under
the high rail traffic scenario. Specifically,
Houston/Port Arthur and Louisiana would see 5.26
and 3.68 more trains per day on average, respectively,
under the high rail traffic scenario. Combined, these
two destinations would also see 3.13 more trains per
day on average under the low rail traffic scenario, and
8.94 more trains per day on average under the high
rail traffic scenario. These increases would all exceed
the threshold for nonattainment areas, such as the
Houston metropolitan area, and the combined high
rail traffic scenario would exceed the eight trains per
day threshold applicable for all rail lines in aggregate
along all of the potential routes to Houston. OEA does
not explain how the aggregate impact of these trains
would not result in comparable impacts that should be
taken into account as downline impacts. This is
particularly the case with rail-related accidents,
which will still have the same likelihood of occurring
whether they are calculated along one or several lines.
Increased downline impacts do not vanish or decrease
merely because there are two or three routes to the
same destination, rather than one.
D. The Project DEIS’s Stated Purpose and
Need Is Unsupported
An environmental impact statement must include
a discussion of the purpose of and need for the
proposed action. 40 C.F.R. § 1502.13. When reviewing
an application for authorization, the agency is to base
the purpose and need on the goals of the applicant and
the agency’s authority. Id.
In the DEIS, OEA states that the purpose of the
Project is “to provide common carrier rail service
JA 72
connecting the Basin to the interstate common carrier
rail network using a route that would provide shippers
with a viable alternative to trucking.” DEIS at 1-3.
The Project is needed, according to the Coalition,
because freight from the Uinta Basin can only move
into and out of the basin on one of two two-lane
highways (U.S. Highways 191 and 40). Id. The DEIS
states that the Project is to “provide customers in the
Basin with multi-modal options for the movement of
freight to and from the Basin; promote a safe and
efficient system of freight transportation in and out of
the Basin; further the development of a sound rail
transpo1tation system; and foster sound economic
conditions in transportation and effective competition
and coordination between differing modes of
transportation.” Id. Based on these assertions, OEA
states that the Coalition’s stated purposes “appear to
be consistent with” the public convenience and
necessity standard contained in 49 U.S.C. § 10901(c)
and the Rail transportation Policy contained in 49
U.S.C. § 10101.
1.
Purpose and need conclusions are
unsupported in the record
OEA fails adequately to justify its statement of
the purpose and need for the Project. In particular, the
alleged need for the Project - to provide an alternative
means to transport crude oil from the Basin to
markets across the United States—is unsupported.
While an agency may not completely ignore a project
proponent’s stated objectives, Colo Envtl. Coalition v.
Dombeck, 185 F.3d 1162, 1175 (10th Cir. 1999), it also
may not simply accept a proponent’s stated objectives.
Id. Rather, an agency must develop its own purpose
JA 73
and need based on the agency’s independent review of
the underlying problem or opportunity, informed by
the goals of the applicant and the agency’s authority.
40 C.F.R. § 1502.13.
Here, OEA fails to provide a justification for its
acceptance of the asserted need for alternative
transporation modes into and from the Uinta Basin.
OEA does not analyze whether opportunities for
highway transport of crude oil from the Uinta Basin
are currently inadequate, whether a pipeline exists or
might be constructed to transport crude oil from the
Basin, or whether markets exist for any increased
crude oil that development of this proposed rail line
might facilitate or make more likely. On the contrary,
OEA seems simply to accept that the absence of a
railroad in this area demonstrates the need for one.
2.
The DEIS suggests without support
that the public convenience and
necessity supports the purpose and
need of the Project
OEA states that the Coalition’s purpose appears
to be consistent with the public convenience and
necessity contained in 49 U.S.C. § 10901 and the Rail
Transportation Policy contained in 49 U.S.C. § 10101,
without explaining how the public convenience and
necessity analysis actually fits into the Project’s
purpose and need.
In authorizing construction of a rail line, the STB
is required to grant authorization unless it would be
inconsistent with the public convenience and
necessity. 49 U.S.C. § 10901(c). See also Alaska
Survival v. STB, 705 F.3d 1073, 1085 (9th Cir. 2013).
To determine public convenience and necessity, the
JA 74
STB looks at a “variety of circumstances” surrounding
the proposed action. Northern Plains, 668 F.3d at
1078. ln the context of an authorization to construct or
operate a rail line, the factors commonly cited by the
STB have been “whether: (1) the applicant is
financially fit to undertake the construction and
provide service; (2) there is a public demand or need
for the proposed service; and (3) the construction
project is in the public interest and will not unduly
harm existing services. Public convenience and
necessity is also evaluated in light of the rail
transportation policy of 49 U.S.C. § 10101.” Dakota,
Minnesota and Eastern R.R. Corp. Construction Into
the Powder River Basin, STB Finance Docket
No. 33407, slip op. at 16 (Service Date Dec. 10, 1998).
See also Northern Plains, 668 F.3d at 1092. While the
statutory language has been read to emphasize the
interests of private parties, particularly shippers,
some broader consideration of the public interest must
still be considered. See Alaska Survival, 705 F.3d at
1085. Exemption from the application process under
49 U.S.C. § 10502 requires a finding, in part, that the
procedures are not necessary to carry out the rail
transportation policy set forth in 49 U.S.C. § 10101.
Aside from quoting the policy statements
provided in 49 U.S.C. § 10101 and noting the benefit
to certain shippers, the DEIS contains no analysis or
assessment of the public convenience and necessity.
DEIS at 1-3 to 1-4. In fact, several of the federal policy
objectives in Section 10101, such as promotion of a
safe, efficient, and competitive rail transportation
system, may be hindered by limitations in the
economic situation or market positioning of the Project
proposal. 49 U.S.C. § 10101(3), (4), (5). The Project’s
JA 75
consequences will likely also detract rather than
encourage and promote energy conservation, 49
U.S.C. § 10101(14), while there is also serious concern
that construction and operation will be to the
detriment of public health and safety, 49 U.S.C.
§ 10101(8).
Rather than considering the public convenience
and necessity standard, OEA attempts to boot the
issue over to the Board, stating that “[w]hile the Board
will ultimately determine whether to authorize or
deny the petition, the Coalition’s stated purposes
appear to be consistent with the PC&N contained in
§ 10901 and the Rail Transportation Policy contained
in § 10101.” DEIS at 1-3. Yet in its January 5, 2021
decision
granting
exemption
status
and
“preliminarily” determining the “transportation
merits” of the proposed construction, the Board
suggests the opposite, stating that “[t]he decision
issued today is a preliminary determination that does
not prejudge the Board’s final decision, nor diminish
the agency’s environmental review process concerning
the proposed Line’s construction.” Seven County
Infrastructure Coalition—Rail Construction &
Operation Exemption—In Utah, Carbon, Duchesne,
and Uintah Counties, Utah, STB Docket No. FD
36284, slip op. at 10 (Service Date Jan. 5, 2021).
Unfortunately, the Board’s January 5th decision does
exactly that by suggesting that the Board’s public
convenience and necessity standard has been met
without engaging in by far the most important public
engagement component that is part of the approval
process. As a result, the OBA and the full Board can
each refer to the other while neither actually does the
work of considering the public interest component that
JA 76
both federal statute and the STB’s own precedent
states is required. Two incomplete and insufficient
analyses of the public convenience and necessity do
not add up to a complete and sufficient analysis under
this standard.
E. The Project’s DEIS Fails To Analyze The
Increased Risk of Cataclysmic Wildfire
in The Project Area and in DroughtRavaged Adjacent To Downline Rightsof-Way
The DEIS fails to adequately assess the potential
consequences that the increased risk of fire due to the
additional
shipments
of
highly
flammable
commodities such as crude oil will have on impacted
communities and ecosystems, particularly those
downline of the Project.
Focusing predominantly on wildfires caused by
regular railroad operations--e.g., exhaust sparks and
hot brake shoe fragments-the analysis in the DEIS
completely omits consideration of ignition due to the
primary commodity proposed to be shipped, crude oil,
which is highly flammable. See DEIS at 3.4-38–39.
Given that the DEIS itself projects a collision or
derailment to occur within the project area alone every
3-10 years, DEIS at 3 .2-4, and accidents along certain
downline routes eve1y 2-4 years, DEIS at 3.2-6, it is
unreasonable to fail to consider the potential risk and
effect of wildfires caused by the contents of the
commodities to be shipped in addition to regular
railroad operations.
Furthermore, in its analysis of wildfire risks due
to the Project the OEA also focuses primarily on the
probability of accidents without considering their
JA 77
potential severity. OEA’s conclusion that the risk of
fire from train accidents is “very low” is based largely
on low probabilities relative to other sources of
wildfire. See DEIS at 3.4-39. For instance, the DEIS
states that “[o]f all the wildfires with a reported cause,
approximately 0.5 percent and 0.2 percent of the fires
in the lower 48 states and Utah, respectively, were
caused by railroads.” DEIS at 3.4-13. Although the
percentage of wildfires caused by railroads may
appear small in comparison to the many causes of such
blazes, this statistic fails to measure the size and
impact of rail-caused wildfires in remote regions
where firefighting crews may have difficulty gaining
access. Additionally, the Project would introduce a
new causal risk of wildfire to an area where such
hazards currently do not exist.
The potential impact of catastrophic fires and
explosions caused by crude-by-rail shipments is far
from unforeseeable. In 2013, the blaze and explosions
from an oil train derailment in Lac Megantic, Canada,
left 47 people dead, 2000 people forced from their
homes, and much of the downtown core destroyed.13 In
2014-2015, the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials
Safety Administration (“PHMSA”) embarked on a
rulemaking process regarding safety measures for
shipping high-hazard flammable trains precisely
because of this risk. See, e.g., Notice of proposed
rulemaking, 79 Fed. Reg. 45,015 (Sept. 30, 2014). In
doing so, PHMSA noted that “[t]he growing reliance
on trains to transport large volumes of flammable
liquids poses a significant risk to life, property, and
https://www.tsb.gc.ca/eng/rappor1s-reports/rail/2013/rl
3d0054/r 13d0054-r-es.html.
13
JA 78
the environment. These significant risks have been
highlighted by the recent instances of trains carrying
crude oil that derailed in Casselton, North Dakota;
Aliceville, Alabama; and Lac-Megantic, Quebec,
Canada.” Id. 79 Fed. Reg. at 45,016.
In terms of geographic scope, there is no
discussion of increased fire risk in downline routes
through Colorado in Appendix C, “Downline Analysis
Study Area and Train Characteristics”, or serious
consideration anywhere in the DEIS regarding the
downline impact of wildfires. The assumed route to
Denver over the UP Moffat Tunnel Subdivision runs
adjacent to hundreds of thousands of acres of public
lands, including the Colorado National Monument
near Grand Junction, the White River National Forest
from Palisade through Glenwood Canyon to Dotsero,
and the Medicine Bow-Routt and Arapaho Roosevelt
National Forests to the East. In 2020, Colorado’s
historic wildfires ravaged many of these areas.
•
•
The Pine Gulch Fire, (north of Grand Junction)
was at the time the largest fire in Colorado
history, burning 139,000 acres.14
Surpassing the Pine Gulch Fire in size was the
East Troublesome Fire, (adjacent to the UP
ROW near Grandby) which, when fully
contained on November 30, had burned a total
of 193,812 acres.15
14
“Pine Gulch, Fire Information—lnciWeb the Incident
Information System”. https://inciweb.nwcg.gov/incident/6906/
“East Troublesome Fire Information—InciWeb Incident
Information System”, https://inciweb.nwcg.gov/incident/7242/.
15
JA 79
•
The Grizzly Creek Fire that surrounded the UP
ROW in Glenwood Canyon burned 323,631
acres, closed Interstate 70 through the canyon,
and forced rerouting of freight and Amtrak rail
traffic north over UP’s Wyoming route between
Denver and Salt Lake City.16
In total, the suppression costs for all fires during the
2020 Colorado fire season amounted to well over $200
million.17 The lack of consideration in the DEIS
evaluating how the Project will exacerbate the risk of
wildfire, and the ensuing costs to local communities
who are most directly affected, is glaring.
The mitigation measures for wildfire in the DEIS
are likewise inadequate. OEA concludes that the
probability of a major rail accident that could cause a
fire would be low if the mitigation measures set forth
in the Draft EIS are implemented. OEA recommends
requiring the Coalition develop and implement a
wildfire management plan in consultation with
appropriate state and local agencies, including local
fire departments. “The plan should incorporate
specific information about operations, equipment, and
personnel on the rail line that might be of use in case
See https://inciweb.nwcg.gov/incident/6942/.
https://www.postindependent.com/news/amtrak-union-pacific
divert-trains-from-glenwood-springs-while-grizzly-creek-firerages-in-canyon/.
https://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/wildfire/train-serviceresumes-in-area-struck-by-grizzly-creek-fire
16
17 Victoria Carodine, How 2020 Has Affected the Way We Should
Manage Forest Fires, 5280, https://www.5280.com/2020/12/how2020-has-affected-the-way-we-should-manage-forest-fires/ (Dec.
15, 2020)
JA 80
a fire occurs and should evaluate and include, as
appropriate, site-specific techniques for fire
prevention and suppression. If OEA’s recommended
mitigation is implemented, OEA concludes that the
impacts of wildfire on vegetation would not be
significant.” DEIS at 3.4-39.
The DEIS ‘s mitigation measures do not take into
account the increased risk of wildfire based on climate
change. The DEIS ignores the reality that any such
response plan may not prevent a fire from spreading
quickly under the current high drought conditions in
Colorado and Utah, conditions that are predicted to
persist and increase due to climate change. In
Colorado and Utah, like in other Western states,
wildfires over the past few decades have become larger
and more frequent, and global climate model
projections indicate an increase in the frequency and
severity of heatwaves, drought, and wildfires due to
climate change warming. See Amber Childress et al.,
Colorado Climate Change Vulnerability Study, A
Report by the University of Colorado Boulder and
Colorado State University to the Colorado Energy
Office, at 14, 32-33 (2015), available at:
https://wwa.colorado.edu/climate/co2015vulnerability
/co_vulnerability_report_2015_final.pdf;
Colorado
Department of Public Safety, 2018-2023 Colorado
Hazard Mitigation Plan, at 3-238, 3-306 (2018),
available
at:
https://www.colorado.gov/pacific/mars/atom/151586;
Utah Department of Public Safety, Division of
Emergency Management, 2019 Utah State Hazard
Mitigation Plan, at 268 (2019) (“Utah SHMP”),
available
at:
https://hazards.utah.gov/wpcontent/uploads/UtahState-Hazard-Mitigation-Plan-
JA 81
2019.pdf.; U.S. Environmental Protection Agency,
What Climate Change Means for Colorado, EPA 430F-16-008, at 1 (Aug. 2016), available at:
https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/sites/producti
on/files/2016-09/documents/climate-change-co.pdf.
Increased wildfires will significantly impact
ecosystems and communities both directly and
indirectly through their impact on water quality and
supply. Childress et al., supra, at 33, 67, 69. Increased
risks of wildfire, heatwaves, and other climate-related
impacts also increase the risk of damage to
infrastructure, including rail lines and associated
facilities. Childress et al., at 119; Utah SHMP at 246.
The DEIS acknowledges the general threat of
wildfire but fails to meaningfully or adequately apply
this info1mation through analysis. The Discussion of
“Wildfire Ecology” within the Project area (DEIS at
3.4-13-15) generally recognizes that Utah suffers from
increasing risk of catastrophic wildfires, with an
estimate of 800 to 1,000 wildfires every summer, and
in 2017 consuming over 200,000 acres in the state. The
DEIS states: “In Utah, firefighters suppress 95
percent of wildfires on initial attack, but adverse
weather and topography, heavy fuel loads, and urban
development all combine to create catastrophic
wildfire conditions in the state (Utah Division of
Emergency Management 2019).” DEIS 3.4-13. OEA
also recognizes that the impacts of fire can last many
years. “Forest fires along portions of US 191 and
Argyle Canyon Road in 2019 have left behind hillsides
with few shrubs, little herbaceous vegetation, and
charred trunks. Once the forest begins to regrow, over
many years, these areas would provide a partial visual
buffer from the proposed rail line.” DEIS at 3.12-8
JA 82
(Emphasis added). However, the DEIS fails to
consider the foreseeable implications of these
statements or connect them to other data included in
the DEIS. For instance, likelihood of drought and
wildfire will likely further postpone any regrowth,
while the acknowledged vulnerability of the Project
area to landslides (see DEIS at 3.57 to 3.5-8) will be
exacerbated by the lack of vegetation. Similarly,
climate-related considerations addressed in the DEIS
are largely limited to air quality assessment,
notwithstanding the predicted effect that such
warming will have on wildfire risks. See DEIS at 3.71, 3.15-27.
F. The Project’s DEIS Fails To Consider the
Increase in Environmental Impacts
Resulting From the Increased Fossil
Fuel Extraction and Consumption That
Will Result From the Project
NEPA requires consideration of connected
actions,
which
includes
actions
that
are
interdependent parts of a larger action and depend on
the larger action for their justification. 40 C.F.R.
§ 1501.9(e)(1)(iii). The pre-2020 NEPA regulations
also require the consideration of reasonably
foreseeable “indirect effects,” which “may include
growth inducing effects and other effects related to
induced changes in the pattern of land use, population
density, or growth rate, and related effects on air and
water and other natural systems, including
ecosystems.” 40 C.F.R. § 1508.8(b) (2019). While
express reference to “indirect effects” is not included
in CEQ’s 2020 NEPA regulations, CEQ has noted that
the elimination of this phrase was merely intended to
JA 83
simplify
analysis
by
avoiding
unnecessary
categorizations, in order to focus on effects “that are
reasonably foreseeable and have a reasonably close
causal relationship to the proposed action.” 85 Fed.
Reg. 43,343. This may include effects both direct and
indirect—notably, the CEQ declined in its 2020
changes to affirmatively state that consideration of
indirect effects is not required. 85 Fed. Reg. at 43,344.
Here, the growth inducing effects leading to
reasonably foreseeable impacts are clear from the
Project description. The Project will result in the
establishment of common carriage service, which is by
law required to serve all shippers upon reasonable
request, 49 U.S.C. § 11101(a), and is generally open to
all commodities and products, Union Pacific R.R.
Co.—Petition for Declaratory Order, STB Finance
Docket No. 35219, slip op. at 3 (Service Date June 11,
2009), including those such as crude oil, coal, natural
gas.
The Uinta Basin is home to significant crude oil
fields, oil shale deposits, and natural gas fields, as well
as some coal deposits in the area. See Vanden Berg,
supra, 16, 22, 29, 34. While various factors, such as
specific commodity characteristics, infrastructure
needs, and market fluctuations may affect the
likelihood of transport of these commodities on rail
over the proposed rail line (as is the case with crude
oil as well as coal, natural gas, and other
commodities), it would be unreasonable to conclude
that construction of durable long-term transportation
infrastructure such as a rail line would not induce
additional exploitation of natural resources in the
Uinta Basin.
JA 84
The Project’s proponents are clearly looking to
proactively expand access to markets for resources
sourced from within their jurisdictions, a consequence
of which would inevitably accelerate resource
extraction. This is reflected in the Project proposal
itself as well as in other potentially unrelated
activities by Coalition members. For instance,
members of the Seven County Coalition (including
Carbon, Emery and Sevier Counties) appear to have
sought to support development of a rail-marine
intermodal terminal in Oakland, California, to export
coal to China using the same state funding vehicle
that is now supporting development of the Uinta
Basin Railway. See Robin Kaizer-Schatzlein, Lawsuit
over proposed fossil fuel railway in Utah moves
forward, High Country News, Dec. 15, 2020,
https://www.hcn.org/articles/energy-industrylawsuitover-proposed-fossil-fuel-railway-in-utah-movesforward; Brian Maffly, Utah coal: California, here it
comes—and not everyone is happy, The Salt Lake
Tribune,
Apr.
27,
2015,
https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=2425141&ity
pe=CMSID. While not strictly connected to the
Project, such activity clearly indicates the foreseeable
inducement of increased extraction in the Uinta Basin
beyond the current levels that serve as the basis for
analysis under the DEIS. This reasonably foreseeable
consequence of the Project must be considered in the
DEIS.
Given that the Uinta Basin has coal deposits and
large natural gas fields, and that the Coalition notes
that these commodities may be another commodity
that is shipped (DEIS at 2-1), OEA should consider the
additional natural gas and coal-related impacts that
JA 85
construction of the rail line could induce. This requires
reassessment of the downline study area.
G. The Project’s DEIS Failed To Contain
Adequate Mitigation for Anticipated
Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Although some federal case law originally
questioned the need to evaluate climate impacts under
NEPA, jurisprudence has become increasingly settled
that such impacts must be included in NEPA
analyses. NEPA also requires an agency to “include
appropriate mitigation measures not already included
in the proposed action or alternatives.” 40 C.F.R.
§§ 1502.14(e).
While NEPA requires consideration and
discussion of mitigation measures, it does not have a
“substantive requirement that a complete mitigation
plan be actually formulated and adopted.” Robertson
v. Methow Valley Citizens Council, 490 U.S. 332, 35153 (1989). Nonetheless, the Tenth Circuit has held
that a discussion of mitigation measures “must be
reasonably complete in order to properly evaluate the
severity of the adverse effects of a proposed project
prior to making a final decision.” Colorado Envtl. Coal.
v. Dombeck, 185 F.3d 1162, 1173 (10th Cir. 1999)
(internal quotation marks and citations omitted). The
CEQ has made clear in a guidance document that even
where an impact is not considered “significant,”
mitigation measures must still be identified:
“The mitigation measures discussed in an
EIS must cover the range of impacts of the
proposal. ... Mitigation measures must be
considered even for impacts that by
themselves would not be considered
JA 86
‘significant.’ Once the proposal itself is
considered as a whole to have significant
effects, all of its specific effects on the
environment (whether or not “significant”)
must be considered, and mitigation measures
must be developed where it is feasible to do
so.”18
In the DEIS, OEA estimates the reasonably
foreseeable greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions that
would result from implementation of the Project, both
during the construction phase and the operations
phase.
Anticipated
GHG
emissions
during
constructions range from 208,697 metric tons of total
CO2 equivalent for the Indian Canyon alternative to
289,737 CO2e for the Wells Draw Alternative. DEIS
at 3.7-19. GHG emissions during rail operations for
the preferred alternative, Whitmore Park, are
estimated to range from 44,476 CO2e at the low-rail
traffic scenario to 131,169 CO2e at the high-rail traffic
scenario. Id. at 3.7-21. The DEIS seeks to explain
away the significance of these emissions by stating
that they represent a small percentage of existing
emissions. It notes that the Wells Draw alternative
could result in up to 211,621 metric tons of CO2e per
year under the high rail traffic scenario, “which
represents approximately 5 percent of GHG emissions
in the regional study area, 1 percent of statewide GHG
emissions, and 0.0004 percent of global GHG
emissions.” Id.
Forty Most Asked Questions Concerning CEQ’s National
Environmental Policy Act Regulations, 46 Fed. Reg. 18,026,
18,031 (Mar. 23, 1981).
18
JA 87
To address these GHG emissions, OEA is
“recommending mitigation measures requiring the
Coalition consider actions that would reduce GHG
emissions during rail construction and operations,”
id., including:
AQ-MM-4. The Coalition shall require its
contractors to use diesel fuel that contains a
minimum biodiesel content of 5 percent (BS
blend). If B5 is not available from local fuel
suppliers, the Coalition shall use fuel with
the highest biodiesel content that is available
to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
AQ-MM-5. The Coalition shall consider
procuring alternative engine and fuel
technologies, e.g., hybrid-electric diesel
equipment, for construction and operation of
the rail line to reduce greenhouse gas
emissions.
AQ-MM-6. The Coalition shall evaluate the
feasibility of installing solar and wind
microgeneration technologies on site offices,
lodgings, and other project-related facilities
to reduce the use of grid or privately
generated electricity to reduce greenhouse
gas emissions. As part of its evaluation, the
Coalition shall consider the suitability of site
conditions and location of solar and wind
generation and the technical and economic
feasibility of supplementing site electricity
demands with renewable power.
DEIS at 4-14. These mitigation measures are
inadequate to address the GHG emissions anticipated
because they are largely optional and procedural and
JA 88
are therefore unlikely to reduce GHG emissions.
While AQ-MM-4 appears reasonably fashioned to
reduce GHG emissions by directing the Coalition to
require its contractors to use diesel fuel containing a
minimum biodiesel content of 5%, that direction is
excused if such fuel is not available from local
suppliers. AQ-MM-5 is even less likely to result in
GHG-emissions reductions, inasmuch as it only
directs the Coalition to “consider” using hybridelectric diesel equipment for construction and
operation activities. Similarly, AQ-MM-6 directs the
Coalition only to “evaluate” the use of solar and wind
microgeneration technologies at project facilities, and
to “consider” site conditions in its evaluation.
The DEIS should be revised to require the
Coalition to take concrete steps to mitigate the
foreseeable GHG emissions of the Uinta Basin
Railway; directing the Coalition to evaluate and
consider actions is inadequate. NEPA requires a
“reasonably complete discussion of possible mitigation
measures,” such that fair evaluation of the
environmental consequences of the alternatives is
possible. Robertson v. Methow Valley Citizens Council,
490 U.S. 332, 352 (1989).
Here, an analysis of the effectiveness of the
mitigation measures is not only missing—it’s
impossible. One cannot reasonably say what actions
the Coalitions’ “consideration” of alternative fuel or
engine technologies or “evaluation” of installing solar
or wind technologies might yield, let alone what the
mitigative effect of such technologies on GHG
emissions or climate impacts might be. Such general
and vague mitigation measures do not satisfy NEPA’s
JA 89
“hard look” requirement. See Neighbors of Cuddy
Mountain v. U.S. Forest Service, 137 F.3d 1372, 1381
(9th Cir. 1998) (NEPA violated where the mitigation
measures were “so general that it would be impossible
to determine where, how, and when they would be
used and how effective they would be”).
H. The DEIS Fails To Adequately Consider
Reasonable Alternatives Such as a
Pipeline
Federal agencies must “study, develop, and
describe appropriate alternatives to recommended
courses of action.” 42 U.S.C. § 4332(2)(E). CEQ
Regulations require that an EIS shall “[e]valuate
reasonable alternatives to the proposed action, and,
for alternatives that the agency eliminated from
detailed study, briefly discuss the reasons for their
elimination.” 40 C.F.R. § 1502.14(a). Reasonable
alternatives are those that constitute “a reasonable
range of alternatives that are technically and
economically feasible, meet the purpose and need for
the proposed action, and, where applicable, meet the
goals of the applicant.” 40 C.F.R. § 1508.1(z). Each
reasonable alternative discussed must be “considered
in detail, including the proposed action, so that
reviewers may evaluate their comparative merits.” 40
C.F.R. § 1502.14(b). “[A]n EIS need not include every
available alternative where the consideration of a
spectrum of alternatives allows for the selection of any
alternative within that spectrum.” 85 Fed. Reg. at
43,330.
As discussed supra at Section III.D.1, there is no
adequate basis provided in support of the purpose and
need of the Project beyond the stated desire of the
JA 90
Coalition. To the extent a purpose and need is
demonstrated in the DEIS, it reflects providing oil
extraction companies located in “an isolated
geographical region” with an alternative to trucking
oil to outside markets. DEIS at 1-3. Although the
DEIS discusses other shippers besides oil producers,
the Coalition’s assertions reflect that the
overwhelming majority of shipments would be for
crude oil and oil extraction-related materials, and the
proposed alternatives are only evaluated in terms of
the shipment of crude oil. DEIS at 1-3 to 1-4.
To address this purpose and need, the DEIS
considered three action alternatives involving the
construction of rail lines—the Indian Canyon
Alternative, the Wells Draw Alternative, and the
Whitmore Park Alternative—which the DEIS states
were developed over the course of several years of
analysis by the Utah Department of Transportation
(UDOT), the Coalition, and OEA. DEIS, at S-5. All
other alternatives explored similarly involved the
construction of rail lines. DEIS at 2-2.
The DEIS fails to demonstrate consideration of
the full spectrum of potentially reasonable
alternatives. Most glaringly, and perhaps reflecting
the failure to include other key federal agencies with
jurisdiction such as PHMSA, the DEIS does not even
mention, let alone consider, a pipeline alternative to
transporting crude oil by rail. DEIS at 2-2. This is so
even though elsewhere in the DEIS’s impact analysis
there are references to crude oil and natural gas
pipelines that run through the area. DEIS at 3.5-18.
There is nothing in the DEIS’s stated purpose and
need for the Project that suggests that a pipeline
JA 91
alternative would not be a reasonable alternative to
consider even at a preliminary stage. While the
proposed rail line is expected to ship other products
and commodities besides oil, the overwhelming
majority of shipments will be crude oil. The
statements of the Coalition, if taken at face value,
make clear that the economic feasibility is centered on
transporting oil alone. Accordingly, it is reasonable to
consider a pipeline as a transportation alternative.
Indeed, it appears that the Coalition and others
have in fact considered a pipeline alternative in the
past, making its absence in the DEIS alternatives
analysis even more curious. For instance, in 2017 the
Coalition published an oil pipeline study analyzing the
prospects for such a pipeline. See Seven County
Infrastructure Coalition, Uinta Basin Oil Pipeline
Study,
Final
Report
(2017),
available
at:
https://scicutah.org/storage/app/uploads/public/5d0/27
e/9ad/5d027e9adl453049115378.pdf. In addition, in
2014 a company with an oil refinery in Salt Lake City
initiated a study regarding connecting the Uinta
Basin to Salt Lake City via a pipeline specially
designed to accommodate the waxy character of crude
produced from the Uinta Basin. See Uinta-WasatchCache National Forest; Utah; Uinta fapress Pipeline
Project, 79 Fed. Reg. 4657 (Jan. 29, 2014) (US Forest
Service notice of intent to prepare an environmental
impact statement). The prospects identified in these
evaluations and their comparison with rail
alternatives are unknown because the DEIS does not
make the comparison, even though a pipeline appears
to meet the purpose and need of the Project.
JA 92
CONCLUSION
For the reasons set forth above, Eagle County and
its allied jurisdictions respectfully request that OEA
issue a Supplemental DEIS to include FRA and
PHMSA as cooperating agencies, analyze the
potential impacts of the Project on the Tennessee Pass
Line, and rectify areas of insufficient analysis.
Respectfully submitted,
[signature]
Allison I. Fultz
Stephen H. Kaplan
Robert W. Randall
Christian L. Alexander
Kaplan Kirsch & Rockwell LLC
1634 I St., N.W.
Suite 300
Washington, DC 20006
(202) 955-5600
afultz@kaplankirsch.com
skaplan@kaplankirsch.com
brandall@kaplankirsch.com
calexander@kaplankirsch.com
Counsel for Eagle County
February 12, 2021
JA 93
EPA Map of Counties Designated
“Nonattainment” for Clean Air Act’s National
Ambient Air Qualty Standards (NAAQS)
February 12, 2021
(see foldout on next page)
GU
HI
AK
Document #1989949
Filed: 03/13/2023
PR
10/31/2020
Page 189 of 606
** Included in the counts are counties designated for NAAQS and revised NAAQS pollutants.
Revoked 1-hour (1979) and 8-hour Ozone (1997) are excluded. Partial counties, those with part
of the county designated nonattainment and part attainment, are shown as full counties on the map.
* The National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) are health standards for Carbon Monoxide,
Lead (1978 and 2008), Nitrogen Dioxide, 8-hour Ozone (2008), Particulate Matter (PM-10
and PM-2.5 (1997, 2006 and 2012), and Sulfur Dioxide.(1971 and 2010)
Legend **
County Designated Nonattainment for 6 NAAQS Pollutants
County Designated Nonattainment for 5 NAAQS Pollutants
County Designated Nonattainment for 4 NAAQS Pollutants
County Designated Nonattainment for 3 NAAQS Pollutants
County Designated Nonattainment for 2 NAAQS Pollutants
County Designated Nonattainment for 1 NAAQS Pollutant
for Clean Air Act's National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) *
Counties Designated "Nonattainment"
USCA Case #22-1019
JA93-a
JA 94
Table of Contents Excerpts, Unita Basin
Railway, Final Environmental Impact
Statement, STB Docket No. FD 36284
(Aug. 2021)
List of Tables .................................................... viii
List of Figures.................................................... xv
List of Acronyms and Abbreviations ............. xviii
Summary ............................................................... S-1
S.1 Introduction ............................................... S-1
S.1.1 Purpose and Need ................................... S-1
S.1.2 Proposed Action ................................ S-2
S.1.3 Cooperating Agency Actions ............ S-3
S.2 Draft EIS and Final EIS Process ............... S-4
S.2.1 Scoping and Consultation ................ S-4
S.3 Alternatives ................................................ S-6
S.4 Conclusions on Environmental Impacts ... S-8
S.4.1 Major Impacts .................................. S-8
S.4.2 Minor Impacts ................................ S-10
S.4.3 Downline Impacts .......................... S-13
S.4.4 Cumulative Impacts ....................... S-13
S.4.5 Environmentally Preferred
Alternative ............................................... S-13
S.5 Summary of Impacts ................................ S-14
S.6 Mitigation ................................................. S-25
S.7 Public Involvement .................................. S-25
S.7.1 Online Public Meetings .................. S-25
S.7.2 Public Comment Period for the
Draft EIS .......................................... S-25
JA 95
Chapter 1 Purpose and Need............................. 1-1
1.1 Introduction ................................................ 1-1
1.2 Purpose and Need....................................... 1-3
1.3 National Environmental Policy Act
Process ......................................................... 1-4
1.3.1 Lead Agency...................................... 1-4
1.3.2 Cooperating Agencies ....................... 1-4
1.3.3 Scoping Process ................................ 1-6
1.3.4 Public Comment Period for the
Draft EIS ........................................... .1-7
1.3.5 Public Meetings ................................ 1-8
Chapter 2 Proposed Action and
Alternatives .......................................................... 2-1
2.1 Proposed Action .......................................... 2-1
2.2 Alternatives ................................................ 2-2
2.2.1 Alternatives Development ............... 2-2
2.2.2 Routes Considered but Not
Analyzed in the EIS ............................. 2-5
2.2.3 Alternatives Analyzed in the EIS .. 2-20
2.3 Construction and Design Features .......... 2-27
2.3.1 Rail Line, Temporary, and Project
Footprints ......................................... 2-28
2.3.2 Railbed and Track Construction .... 2-30
2.3.3 Rail Line Construction Equipment
and Methods .................................... 2-30
2.3.4 Materials for Rail Line
Construction ..................................... 2-30
2.3.5 Construction Staging Areas ........... 2-31
JA 96
2.3.6 Staffing and Worker Housing ........ 2-31
2.3.7 Bridges, Culverts, and Stream
Realignments .................................... 2-31
2.3.8 Tunnels ........................................... 2-32
2.3.9 Grade Crossings ............................. 2-32
2.3.10 Road Relocations .......................... 2-33
2.3.11 Associated Facilities ..................... 2-33
2.3.12 Construction Schedule ................. 2-34
2.4 Operations ................................................ 2-35
2.4.1 Rail Traffic ...................................... 2-35
2.4.2 Maintenance ................................... 2-36
2.4.3 Staffing ........................................... 2-36
2.5 Summary of Impacts ................................ 2-37
2.6 Environmentally Preferred Alternative .. 2-48
Chapter 3 Affected Environment
and Environmental Consequences .................. 3-1
3.1 Vehicle Safety and Delay ........................ 3.1-1
3.1.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.1-1
3.1.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.1-4
3.1.3 Environmental Consequences ....... 3.1-7
3.1.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects .................. 3.1-20
3.2 Rail Operations Safety ............................ 3.2-1
3.2.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.2-1
3.2.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.2-3
3.2.3 Environmental Consequences ....... 3.2-4
3.2.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects .................... 3.2-8
JA 97
3.3 Water Resources ...................................... 3.3-1
3.3.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.3-1
3.3.2 Affected Environment ................. 3.3-10
3.3.3 Environmental Consequences ..... 3.3-24
3.3.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Impacts ................ 3.3-47
3.4 Biological Resources ................................ 3.4-1
3.4.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.4-1
3.4.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.4-4
3.4.3 Environmental Consequences ..... 3.4-28
3.4.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects .................. 3.4-62
3.5 Geology, Soils, Seismic Hazards, and
Hazardous Waste Sites .......................... 3.5-1
3.5.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.5-1
3.5.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.5-4
3.5.3 Environmental Consequences ..... 3.5-20
3.5.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects .................. 3.5-28
3.6 Noise and Vibration................................. 3.6-1
3.6.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.6-1
3.6.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.6-4
3.6.3 Environmental Consequences ....... 3.6-7
3.6.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects .................. 3.6-16
3.7 Air Quality and Greenhouse Gases ........ 3.7-1
3.7.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.7-1
3.7.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.7-4
JA 98
3.7.3 Environmental Consequences ..... 3.7-11
3.7.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects .................. 3.7-38
3.8 Energy ...................................................... 3.8-1
3.8.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.8-1
3.8.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.8-3
3.8.3 Environmental Consequences ....... 3.8-6
3.8.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Impacts ................ 3.8-13
3.9 Cultural Resources .................................. 3.9-1
3.9.1 Analysis Methods .......................... 3.9-1
3.9.2 Affected Environment ................... 3.9-7
3.9.3 Environmental Consequences ..... 3.9-11
3.9.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects .................. 3.9-16
3.10 Paleontological Resources ................... 3.10-1
3.10.1 Analysis Methods ...................... 3.10-1
3.10.2 Affected Environment ............... 3.10-2
3.10.3 Environmental Consequences ... 3.10-8
3.10.5 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects ................ 3.10-13
3.11 Land Use and Recreation .................... 3.11-1
3.11.1 Analysis Methods ...................... 3.11-1
3.11.2 Affected Environment ............... 3.11-3
3.11.3 Environmental Consequences . 3.11-12
3.11.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects ................ 3.11-28
3.12 Visual Resources.................................. 3.12-1
JA 99
3.12.1 Analysis Methods ...................... 3.12-1
3.12.2 Affected Environment ............... 3.12-5
3.12.3 Environmental Consequences ... 3.12-6
3.12.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects ................ 3.12-35
3.13 Socioeconomics..................................... 3.13-1
3.13.1 Analysis Methods ...................... 3.13-1
3.13.2 Affected Environment ............... 3.13-2
3.13.3 Environmental Consequences ... 3.13-9
3.13.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects ................ 3.13-31
3.14 Environmental Justice ........................ 3.14-1
3.14.1 Analysis Methods ...................... 3.14-1
3.14.2 Affected Environment ............... 3.14-2
3.14.3 Environmental
Consequences .............................. 3.14-11
3.14.4 Mitigation and Unavoidable
Environmental Effects ................ 3.14-19
3.15 Cumulative Impacts ............................ 3.15-1
3.15.1 Analysis Methods ...................... 3.15-1
3.15.2 Cumulative Impacts Study
Area ................................................ 3.15-1
3.15.3 Affected Environment ............... 3.15-1
3.15.4 Other Past, Present, and
Reasonably Foreseeable Future
Actions ........................................... 3.15-3
3.15.5 Cumulative Impacts by
Resource ....................................... 3.15-10
JA 100
Chapter 4 Mitigation ........................................... 4-1
4.1 Introduction and Approach ........................ 4-1
4.2 Limits of the Surface Transportation
Board’s Conditioning Power...................... 4-1
4.2.1 Cooperating Agency Mitigation
Matters ............................................... 4-1
4.2.2 Voluntary Mitigation and Negotiated
Agreements ......................................... 4-2
4.2.3 The Mitigation Process..................... 4-2
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.