Motion to Proceed In Forma Pauperis — Jan M. Gawlik, Petitioner v. Scott Semple, et al.

Supreme Court briefOct 3, 2023

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No.

ORIGINAL

gU %

IN THE

FILED

OCT 0 3 2023

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OFFICE OF THE CLERK

SUPREME COURT. U.8.

GAWLIK.JAN.M.

— PETITIONER

(Your Name)

VS.

SEMPLE,SCOTT.ET.AL.COM'R — RESPONDENT(S)

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS

The petitioner asks leave to file the attached petition for a writ of certiorari

without prepayment of costs and to proceed in forma pauperis.

Please check the appropriate boxes:

IS Petitioner has previously been granted leave to proceed in forma pauperis in

the following court(s):

U.S.SUPREME COURT/DOCKET NO'S/20-7108,20-8437,22-6742.

NEW HAVEN SUPERIOR COURT,235 CHURCH STYREET,NEW HAVEN,CT.06510

□Petitioner has not previously been granted leave to proceed - in forma

pauperis in any other court.

........... ........

_____

------M Petitioner’s affidavit or declaration in support of this motionis attached hereto.

□ Petitioner’s affidavit or declaration is not attached because the court belowappointed counsel in the current proceeding, and:

□ The appointment was made under the following provision of law:---------- —

or

□ a copy of the order of appointment is appended.

ai

■e

AFFIDAVIT OR DECLARATION

IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PROCEED IN FORMA PAUPERIS

j

GAWLIK, JAN.M.

am the petitioner in the above-entitled case. In support of

my motion to proceed in forma pauperis, I state that because of my poverty I am unable to pay

the costs of this case or to give security therefor; and I believe I am entitled to redress.

1. For both you and your spouse estimate the average amount of money received from each of

the following sources during the past 12 months. Adjust any amount that was received

weekly, biweekly, quarterly, semiannually, or annually to show the monthly rate. Use gross

amounts, that is, amounts before any deductions for taxes or otherwise.

Income source

Average monthly amount during

the past 12 months

Amount expected

next month

You

Spouse

You

Spouse

Employment

$_o

$__0

$_0

$ 0

Self-employment

$_0

$__0

$ 0

$_0

Income from real property

(such as rental income)

$_0

$__0

$ 0

$ 0

$ 0

$A

Interest and dividends

$_2

Gifts

$_0

$__0

$_0

$

0

Alimony

$

0

$

0

$ 0

$

0

Child Support

$_0

$

0

$ 0

$_0

Retirement (such as social

security, pensions,

annuities, insurance) ---------

$_0

$

"Disability (such as social

~ $ 1,382.00 -$

security, insurance payments)

Unemployment payments

Public-assistance

(such as welfare)

Other (specify):

Total monthly income:

$_2

$_2

$_2

$_?.

°

$_2

$_2

0

$100.00+/- $_2;

$_0

$_2

$_2

$

$ 0

$_2

0

2. List your employment history for the past two years, most recent first. (Gross monthly pay

is before taxes or other deductions.)

Employer

Address

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Gross monthly pay

Dates of

Em^lo^ment

$ N/A

$HZa

N/A

N/A

a n/a

3. List your spouse’s employment history for the past two years, most recent employer first.

(Gross monthly pay is before taxes or other deductions.)

Employer

Address

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Gross monthly pay

Dates of

Employment

N/A

a N/A

a n/a

$

N/A

N/A

4. How much cash do you and your spouse have? $-----------------------------;-------- _■

.

Below, state any money you or your spouse have in bank accounts or m any other hnanciai

institution.

Type of account (e.g., checking or savings)

0

^

0

0

Amount you have

0

$.

0

$.

$.

o

Amount your spouse has

$_0

$_o

a °

5. List the assets, and their values, which you own or your spouse owns, Do not list clothing

and ordinary household furnishings.

□ Home

Value

□ Other real estate

Value N/A

N/A

□ Motor Vehicle #1

Year, make & model

Value N/A

□ Other assets

Description _

Value N/A

N/A

N/A

□ Motor Vehicle #2

Year, make & model

Value N/A

N/A

6. State every person, business, or organization owing you or your spouse money, and the

amount owed. .

Person owing you or

your spouse money

N/A

Amount owed to you

Amount owed to your spouse

$__0

$_0

N/A

N/A.

7. State the persons who rely on you or your spouse for support, For minor children, list initials

instead of names (e.g. “J.S.” instead of “John Smith”).

Relationship

Age

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Name

8. Estimate the average monthly expenses of you and your family.

Show separately the amounts

paid by your spouse. Adjust any payments that are made weekly, biweekly, quarterly, or

annually to show the monthly rate.

You

Your spouse

$ 0

$_0

Utilities (electricity, heating fuel,

water, sewer, and telephone)

$

$

-Home-maintenance (repairs..and .upkeep).

l1

Rent or home-mortgage payment

(include lot rented for mobile home)

Are real estate taxes included? □ Yes □ No

Is property insurance included? □ Yes □ No

0

Clothing

t-1

$.

Food

%

0

0

0

0

Laundry and dry-cleaning

. Medical and dental expenses

0

$

0

You

Your spouse

Transportation (not including motor vehicle payments)

$—2

$

Recreation, entertainment, newspapers, magazines, etc.

$.

0 fu

0

$_2

Insurance (not deducted from wages or included in mortgage payments)

$_2

Homeowner’s or renter’s

$_2

Life

$.

Health

$_2

Motor Vehicle

$___

„ o

$_2

Other:

$_2

$_2

0

0

$.

Taxes (not deducted, from wages or included in mortgage payments)

(specify):

$_2

$_2

$_2

$J.

$_f

$_2

.$

$

Installment payments

Motor Vehicle

Credit card(s)

Department store(s)

Other:

iHimdhjVmaihtenance7ahd “sUpport paid to-others

$.

0

0

Other (specify):

0

Total monthly expenses:

Q

0 .

-

Regular expenses for operation of business, profession,

or farm (attach detailed statement)

0

$.

$.

0

$_2

0

$.

9. Do you expect any major changes to your monthly income or expenses or in your assets or

liabilities during the next 12 months?

□ Yes

P No

If yes, describe on an attached sheet.

10. Have you paid - or will you be paying - an attorney any money for services in connection

with this case, including the completion of this form? □ Yes B No

If yes, how much?___________________ —

If yes, state the attorney’s name, address, and telephone number:

11. Have you paid—or will you be paying—anyone other than an attorney (such as a paralegal or

a typist) any money for services in connection with this case, including the completion of this

form?

□ Yes

H No

If yes, how much?

’--------- -----------------

If yes, state the person’s name, address, and telephone number:

/

12. Provide any other information that will help explain why youcannot pay the costs of this case.

----------- (piSABLED/INCARCERATED)

—------- :------------------ -----------------------

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.

Executed on:

DECEMBER 20th

,2023

nature)

Your New JBtenent Amouu

BENEFICIARY'S^NAME: JOHN GAWLIK

Your Social Security benefits will increase bybaoSt^motuat to receive food,

Of living. You can use this 'ferJhe°J°“ "^tPh™ bu ‘

totag this letter could save you

1-1 office and w^g in line to obtain anew docent

TBfrvw Much Will 1 Get And When?

.

$1.486.90.

a Your monthly amount (before deductions) is

.

$104.90.

a lie amount we deduct for Medicare medical insurance is

(If you didnotbave Medicare as of Nov. 15,2012,

■

or if someone else pays your premium, we show $0.00.)

$0.00.

• The amount we deduct for your Medicare prescription

v

.

nf yon did not elect withholding as of Nov. 1 2012, we show $0 00.)

$0.00.

-The amount we deduct for voluntary Federal tax withholding

(If yon did not elect voluntary tax withlioldmg as of

Nov 15,2012, we show $0.00.)

. .

$1,382.00 ■

■ After we trice any other deductions, you will receive.

on Jan. 3,2013.

within'60 days from th© date

you

Yju may receive your benefits feough

to^i efoctrouic payment hy

KLn

5

WhatJriJLHaye_Questioiis?.....

.

more information and a variety of online

Please visit our website f

meat to. a representative from 7 am until 7 pm,

services: You also can call l-80^72;1213 ™ 5> serviGes^-e available 24 hours a day. Our lines

Monday through Friday. Recorded mfonna

. „ ^z the week between Christmas •are busiest early in the week, early m ^ monflv as

hard of faring, call our ■

and New Year’s Day; it is best to call atother

d ^ yon can contact any U.S.

TTY number, 1-800-325-0778 If you are outs

rkY niU3lber available when you

embassy or consulate office. Please have.your

Security If you are inside the United'

States, and nee

233 MAIN STREET 2ND FL

NEW BRITAIN CT ■

_ SOCIAL SECURITY BENEFH

POR.M SSA-1099

iAl

^41 n

OPCURITY BENEFITS SHOWN IN BOX 5 MAY B E TAXABLE INCOME.

: Se'Serse^moRE information.

ial Security Number

Box 2. Beneficiary’s Soc

MSBl

,o*1. Name

JOHN GAWUE

^x~3. Benefits PaidinMkF-

Box

^BenefttTRepaid to'SSA in 2012

CD

NONE

*$17,542.90

DESCRIPTION OF AWIOUNT IN BOX 4

NONE

----- ---------- ^isCRiPTlONoFAMOUNT IN BOX 3

Paid by check or direct deposit

Medicare Part B premia aeducted

from yotir "benefits

Total Additions

Benefits for 2012

)

\

J '

■

$16,228.70

g

ui

CD

St

un

vo

VO

?

$1,314.20 '

$17,542.90

$17,542.90

.

Box 6; Voluntary Federal Inco me

Tax Withheld

NONE

Box 7. Address

SScSfoCE® m1

]s[EW BRITAIN GT 06053-^.01

2at

is

Ln

vo

Box 8. Claim Number (Use

this number if you need to contact SSA.)

CD

g

ILI

Cl

5 ■

U3

VO

CJ

IwwiihiiS’

-r .....-

SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION

Office of Hearings and Appeals

DECISION

CLAIM FOR

IN THE CASE OF

John Gawlik

(Claimant)

(Wage Earner)

Period of Disability and

Disability Insurance Benefits

/

(Social Security Number)

INTRODUCTION

On May 28, 1999, the claimant filed an application for Disability Insurance Bene^s- ^ claun

was denied initially and on reconsideration, and a request for hearing was timelyfiled on

September 5, 2000. A hearing was subsequently held on March 19, 2001 in Hartfor

_

.

Connecticut.' Appearing and offering testimony at the hearing were the following: the clamant

The claimant alleges disability beginning June 26,1996 due to a back injury with chrome pam

and depression. Mr. Thomas P. Tabellione, an attorney, represents the claimant in this matter.

The general issue is whether the claimant is entitled to a period of disability and Disability

Insurance Benefits under sections 216(i) and 223 of the Social Security Act. The specific issue

is whether he is under a disability, which is defined as the mability to engage m any substantial

gainful activity by reason of any medically determinable physical or mental impairment tnat can

pected to result in death or that has lasted or can be expected to last for a continuous period

.be ex

of not less than 12 months.

With respect to the claim for Disability Insurance Benefits, there is an additional issue: pertaining

to insured status, A review of the claimant's earnings record reveals that he has earned sufficient

ed at least through the date of this decision.

quarters of coverage to remain rnsirr

i

EVALUATION OF THE EVIDENCE

The claimant is a thirty-six year-old individual with a high school education plus a two year

electrical program. He has past relevant work as a computer grinder. He has not engaged in

substantial gainfiil activity at any time since the alleged onset date. Afiei: the date of alleged

onset of disability, the claimant worked for three weeks m February and March 1997 m an

attempt at lighter duty that was unsuccessful with increased pain.

John Gawlii

Page 2 of 5

The claimant has the following medically determinable severe impairments: lumbar disc disease

and major depression. Mr. Gawlik has a history of back pain with radiation and numbness to his

right leg and foot beginning June 26, 1996 while lifting an eighty pound box at work. An MR1 .

' August 1-2, 1996 demonstrated degenerative changes at L5-S1 with a central disc protrusion

(Exhibit IF/16). Orthopedic surgeon Stanley P. Filewicz M.D. wrote July IS, 1998 that when

first seen in July 1996 through March 24, 1997 “he was not capable of working at all”, having

attempted work briefly with severe pain (Exhibit 7F). He was treated with oral medications and

injections without improvement and underwent a right L5-S1 discectomy February 17,

a

New Britain General Hospital (Exhibit 5F) with worsening of his pain according to his

testimony. Post surgical follow-up in April 1998 corroborated that the claimant was unable to

tolerate physical therapy after six visits with increased symptoms (Exhibit 6F).

Neurosurgeon Joseph Aferzon M.D. reported July 22,1998, “This gentleman presents after disc

surgery, which had absolutely no benefit for him. He remains with complaints ofradic ar pain.

He is still seeing Dr. Brodey for pain management.” Dr. Aferzon followed him until May 1, .

2000, stating then that “as a neurosurgeon, I have very little to offer him in terms of chronic pain

management.” He noted, “He is still out of work and is quite debilitated by his back problem

(Exhibit 16F/15,19)

He was evaluated several months following his injury: April 2, 1997 by clinical psychologist

Kathryn T. Vullo Ph.D. as part of his pain therapy for depression “as evidenced by disrupted

sleep cycle, flattened affect, tearfulness as well as decreased concentration, motivation an

libido ” Dr Vullo noted that “Mr. Gawlik is struggling with his pain and physical Imitations ai

this time” and recommended psychological pain management intervention with weekly sessions.

Her diagnosis was adjustment disorder with mixed emotional features (Exhibit 3F). James F.

Brodey M D of Pain Management Associates saw the claimant January 14,1998 at the request

of his neurosurgeon. Dr. BaileyfOund that he was “significantly depressed and anxious riom his

pain and leads a pain contingent lifestyle”. Analgesic medications were prescribed pending

surgery (Exhibit 4F). Dr. Brodey reported on March 13, 2001 that he has been treating Mr.

Gawlik since January 1998 for his back pain and depression. His current medications include

- percocet, Oxycodone, Soma, Amitriptyline, and.Effexor (Exhibit 25F).

'

The claimant testified that he has numbness in both legs; the right is worse than the left. He has

undergone varied treatments for his hack pain without success. Some injections helped for

“maybe three days”. Other injections and surgery made the pain worse. He stated that he is able

to stand for twenty-five minutes and sit for thirty minutes at a time. His pain worsens w en it

rains or snows. He stated that he spends his days reading and takes care of his elderly father Hq

lies down and rests during the day. He has had no income for five years; his parents have helped

him Hr requires pain medication daily.

The claimant does not have an impairment that meets or equals the criteria of any listed

impairment. A determination must therefore be made of whether he retains the residual

functional capacity to perform the requirements of his past relevant work or can adjust to other

work.

John Gawlik (

Page 3 of 5

The witten evidence supports a finding that the claimant retains the residual functional capacityto lift and/or carry a maximum of ten pounds. His capacity for sedentary work is diminished by

his inability to stand and/or walk for two hours' in an eight-hour workday or to sit for six hours in

an eight-hour workday. He also has moderate limitations in his ability to maintain concentration

and attention.

In reaching this conclusion, the undersigned has considered the claimant's own. subjective

allegations and has found them generally credible in light of his well documented treatment

history and corroboration of his chronic pain and depression by his treating sources. He has not

been able to recover from his June 1996 injury and resume his previously active lifestyle.

Consideration has also-been given the reports of the state agency medical consultants as well as

to other treating, examining and non-examining medical sources. Those opinions were based on

information' contained in the record at the time of the state agency reconsideration determination

in this case, and no medical records generated or provided after that date were considered by the

state examiners. However, additional medical evidence received in the course of developing the

claimant s case for review at the hearing, as well as evidence in the form of credible testimony at

the hearing, consistent with medical evidence in the record justifies a conclusion as per Social

Security Ruling 96-6p that the claimant's impairments are more limiting than-was concluded by

the state examiners. The claimant’s allegations of his limitations due to chronic pain have been

considered as required by Social Security Ruling 96-3p and deemed credible.

In- his former work as a computer grinder, the claimant was required to perform tasks at an

exertional and mental level that is beyond his current capacity.

As the claimant has demonstrated that he lacks the residual functional capacity to perform the

requirements of any past relevant work, the burden shifts to the Social Security Administration to

show that there are other jobs that the claimant can perform. This determination is made in

conjunction with the medical-vocational guidelines of Appendix 2 of Subpart P of the

regulations (20 CFR Part 404). Appendix 2 contains a series of rules that direct a conclusion of

either disabled or not disabled" depending upon the claimant's age, education, work

experience, and residual functional capacity.

Bom January 18, 1965, the claimant was thirty-one years old on June 26,1996. For "the purpose

of this decision, he is considered to be a younger individual age 18-44. -He has at least a high -.. school education and has a skilled work background without skills that are transferable to his

residual functional capacity.

The claimant's capacity for the full range of sedentary work is reduced by additional limitations

that narrow the range of work he can perform. Social Security Ruling 85-15 states that a

substantial loss of ability to meet any one of several basic work-related activities on a sustained

basis (i.e., 8 hours a day, 5 days a week, or an equivalent work schedule), will substantially erode

the unskilled sedentary occupational base and would justify a finding of disability. Given the

claimant s residual functional capacity, -which is for a very narrow range of sedentary work and

the vocational factors of age, education, and past relevant work experience, there are no jobs

existing in significant numbers that the claimant is capable of performing. The claimant is under

a disability m accordance with Social Security Ruling 85-15 and section 201.00(h) of the

•Page 4 of 5

John Gawlik '(

medical vocational guidelines. A finding of "disabled may therefore be reached within the

framework of medical-vocational rule 201.28.

June 26,1996, he is

May 28,1999.

FINDINGS

After careful consideration of the entire record, the Ad miinistrative Law Judge makes the

following findings:

i.

2.

The claimant has not engaged in substantial gainfiil activity since June 26,1996.

medical evidence establishes that the claimant has the following severe impairments,

The

lumbar disc disease and major depression.

,

,3.

The claimant has no impairment that meets or equals the criteria of any impairment listed m

Appendix 1, Subpart P, Regulations No. 4.

4.

The claimant's assertions concerning his ability to work are credible.

5.

The claimant retains the residual functional capacity to lift and; or carry a maximum.

pounds. His capacity for sedentary work is diminished by his inability to stand.an. ax

for two hours in an eight-hour' workday or to sit for six hours m an eight-hour workday. He

also has moderate limitations in his ability to maintain concentration and attention. .

6.

The claimant is unable to perfonn the requirements of his past relevant work.

7.

residual functional capacity for the full range of sedentary work is reduced by

The claimant's

additional limitations.

8.

On June 26,4996, the claimant was a younger individual age 18-44

9.

The claimant has at least a high school education.

skilled wdrk background without skills that are transferable to his

10. The claimant has a

residual functional capacity.

11.

reached within the framework of medical-vocational rule 201.28.

12 The claimant has been under a disability, as defined in the Social Security- Act, since

’ June 26, 1996 (20 CFR §404.1520(f)).

Page 5 of 5

John Gawlik l

DECISION

It is the decision of the Administrative Law Judge that, based on the application filed on

May 28,1999, the claimant is entitled to a pexiod of disability commencing June 26,1996, and to

Disability Insurance Benefits under sections 216(1) and 223, respectively, of the Social Security

Act.

Administrative Law Judge

MAY 1 8 2001

Date

LIST OF EXHIBITS

Claimant:

SSN:

John Gawlik

Exh. Part

No. No.

No. of

Pages

Description

PAYMENT DOCUMENTS/DECISIONS

1 '

A.

2

A

Initial Disability Determination by State Agency, Title II, dated 12-27-99

1

Reconsideration Disability Determination by State Agency, Title II, dated 6-19-00

1

/.

JURISDICTIONAL DOCUMENTS/NOTICES

1

B

Social Security Notice dated 12-29-99

2

B

Request for Reconsideration filed 1 -28-00

3

B

Social Security Notice of Reconsideration dated 6-20-00

4

B

Request for Hearing filed 9-5-00

Letter of Acknowledgement of Request for Hearing dated 9-29-00

B

' 4

1

4

1

2

NON-DISABILITY development

1

D

Application for Disability Insurance Benefits filed 5-28-99

2

D

Earnings record (dated/certified) 2-16-01

3

D

Detailed Earnings Record (DEQY) for Years 1985-2000, dated 2-16-01

(

. 3

2

4

LIST OF EXHIBITS

Claimant:

,

SSN:

John Gawlik

Exh. Part

No. No.

Description

No. of

Pages

DISABILITY DELATED DEVELOPMENT AND DOCUMENTATION

4

1

E

Disability Report -Field Office dated 5-28-99

2

E

Disability Report dated 5-28-99

3

E

Symptoms Questionnaire dated 6-13-99

4

E

Daily Activities Questionnaire dated 6-13-99

5

E

Vocational Analysis by state agency dated 12-27-99

6

E

Reconsideration Disability Report dated 1-28-00

E

Symptoms Questionnaire dated 2-15-00

E

Daily Activities Questionnaire dated 6-13-99

10

7

8

9

E

Claimant's

undated

Statement When Request for Hearing is Filed and the Issue is Disability

3

9

1

6

3

9

2

ivnrDTCAI RECORDS

18

1

F

Filewicz, M.D.

Medical Records covering the period tarn 8-8-97 to 10-10-97 from Jonathan Kost, M.D ./

2

F

8

Bristol Hospital-Pain Management .

7

1

'

F

■ 4

Medical Evaluation Report dated 1-14-98, by James F. Brodey, M.D.

4

■

LIST OF EXHIBITS

Claimant:

SSN:

John Gawlik

Exh. Part.

No. No.

Description

No. of

Pages

5

F

Hospital Records for admission on 2-17-98 through discharge on 2-18-98 from New

Britain General Hospital

11

6

F

Physical Therapy Report dated 4-16-98, from Physical Therapy & Sports Medicine

1

Associates

1

7

F

Medical Report/Letter dated 7-13-98, by Stanely P. Filewicz, M.D.

8

F

Medical Report/Letter dated 9-11 -98, by Joseph Aferzon, M.D.

9

F

Consultative Examination dated 11-12-99 by David Mantell, Ph.D.

10

F

Consultative Examination dated 11-19-99 by Steven E. Isaacs, M.D.

11

F

Residual Functional Capacity Assessment - Physical (completed by DDS physician)

RECdated 12-6-99

9

12

F

Psychiatric Review Technique Form (completed by DDS physician) dated 12-27-99

10

13

F

Medical Report/Letter~dated 2-3-00, by James F. Brodey, M.D.

F

Medical Report/Questionnaire dated 4-19-00, by James F. Brodey, M.D.

15

F

Consultative Examination dated 4-25-00 by Jonathan Dixon, M.D.

2

16

F

Treatment/Progress Reports dated 9-5-96 to 5-1-00, wiith attached Radiology Reports dated

4-11-97 to 1-10-98, from Joseph Aferzon, M.D.

24

F

Residual Functional Capacity Assessment - Physical (completed by DDS physician)

RFC dated 6-16-00

9

17

18

F

Psychiatric Review Technique Form (completed by DDS physician) dated 6-19-00

9

19

F

Medical report by Dr. Ira Spar, M.D. dated 2\26\91

20

F

Medical Report by New Britain General Hospital dated 2\12\93 to 2\15\94

15

21

F

MRISCAN of the Lumbosacral Spine with Hospital Record attached dated 8\12\96 8\18\97

8.

22

F

Medical Report by Connecticut Valley Neurosurgical Associated dated 9\5\96 7\24\97

16

14

1

3

2

1

3

1

.

LIST OF EXHIBITS

Claimant:

Exh. Part

No. No.

23

F

SSN:

John Gawlik

Description

Pain Therapy Report by Specialists in Pain Management Rehabilitation Center dated

.

No. of

Pages

32

11\1\96 to 3\20\97

F

Postoperative Diagnosis Report by New Britain General Hospital dated 2\17\98

'3 .

F

Medical letter by Dr. James F. Brodey Pam Specialsit dated 3\13 2001

1

24

25

i

\

Porter v. Aetna Casualty & oui tay wu., o. - - •-•

:1'.5/2017. ,

Svante®

''Research

Documen

v

More

a

© .

t Porter v. Aetna Casualty ^Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159

Porter v

Actions '•

. Aetna Casualty 8c Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159

QcopyCitati o n

Supreme Court of the United States

April 25, 1962, Argued ; 3une 11, 1962, Decided

No. 604

Reporter

370 U.S.159

| ioo U S. I FX1S 1128.

* | no d r.t. 1231 ** I BJ ■ Ed. 2d 407

PORTER v. AETNA CASUALTY Sl SURETY CO.

FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT.

CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

Prior History. _[****_11

ip.1 oqfi F.2d 389, reversed.

Disposition: 111 U. S, Anp. D. C.

Core Terms

, investments; benefits, savings account

exempt, Veterans1, funds, deposits

checking account, holder, liquid, moneys

association

, withdrawal, bonds, federal savings and loan

Case Summary

i

Procedural Posture

■

_

Respondent insurance companvj>rouglrt

veferan to recover on a judgment it had obtained against

^ vKe|,„,s SCOJUnts were exempt torn ettachment under 34

the veteran. The district court, on mo m

,oan >JsodaSon accounts and the Court of Appeals for

-tic r c s 31 Olfa'l. The company appealed as to twos

y ..

........... “V ....................

, “T^TTTmbie revemed

. dWedopWon. Ccrtiomr, w.s gmnted.

---------1-

I

I

ns'-Administration.retained their exempt

Overview

The case raised the question of whether benef.

Pa

^ g

savjngs and ,oan association . The company attached

•status under SJlQUal after bein9 deposite in an

associations,- all of which had been established by the

a checking account and two accounts in local federa ® 9

^ as disabjnty compensation due the veteran. On

veteran's committee with funds received from the Vete

review, the Court reversed the judgment o■ te

,< c ^

^ reversed ^ district court's judgment, which held

;iQt^ shou,d be liberally construed to protect funds

granted by'ti^e'^mgres^for" th^rnaintenance anC'd^l^°^)j.^d ^JjQia^e^Congress^n^ended that'^terans in me3'

Y

^

,or “ purP“e'

j provided the

eht investments.

benefit funds had not been converted into permane

Outcome

The Court reversed.

I„Q.;.TCRQ^w.QnRR-«Wefiab512d6&Ddsearchtenris=

370+us+159&pdstartin= s napshot&pdiypeo-.. 1/6

• r.

Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159

3/15/2017

^ LexisNexis® Headnotes

> Enforcemenm^ecution^ > 1 B^mEtionsfmDlJxecutionCivil Procedure > ti i figments> rz*npml Overview^

Law > Veterans- > general BenefitsConnecteiDeath^DisaMitX- > ElisMMMilitary &. Veterans

r.nmpen^ation for Service ------—

> rtpneral Rp.nefits- > 1

Military &. Veterans Law > ..

HNli. See 7a 11 5.C.S. 5.

3101fal- ^ Mnrp like *~hiq Headnote

c;h*parr1l7P. - Narrow by this Headnote £6j

.,

» Flnannial InstiMans-> Mai * AgnPlafenS^

Banking Law > Jypea.

p.m.-c.m.nf A Executed > 1 £-'"PHW Frorn Executm,Civil Procedure > judgments - >

> ConpraI Overview —

> Qpneral BenefitsMilitary & Veterans Law > Veterans. protect funds granted by the Congress for the

u.—•».

maintenance and support: of the Penedciades

bv - United States Veterans'

^ congress

intended that veterans in the

safekeeping

a^^itvsr^ne;! - not -

— —■

O, Mnrp like t~Hig Headnote

ahrpxrdize - Narrow

y

hy 1-hM Hearlnnte71011

Lawyers’ Edition Display

Summary

A JudgmenTcSdltor of an Incompetent Air■

-which had been-established, by^g/^eran s co_m

ourtforthe 'DistfidTof'Columbia-quashed the attachments on the —

compensation to the oetemn. Tde United States D.rtnd:Courtfot

c r

^ pr„id5sa,at paym.nts

zez&tjsjss* —

Columbia reversed. (111 App DC 262

:r;

, 795 F2d 389.1

*• c°urt - appm,s " "e Dis“of

held that the benefit payments in

Court reversed. In an opinion by Clark, J., it was

needed for support and

were readily available as

anent investments.

onden ,ne

- o ^ ,„B pem

i Douglas-,

_..1., in a-=:= ===“..—■ nd support of the veteran.

Warren-, Ch. I., and Frankfurter, 3., did not participate.

Headnotes

.

j rno

l—t

_

hoh£.r-tHtwna/-v

Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159

VI5/2017 1

i '--EXEMPTIONS '§6 >

veterans' benefits - deposits in savings and loan associations. -

> Headnote:

■

disability compensation due to him

made by the Veterans' Administration to an incompetent Air Force veteran as

are exempt from attachment

Payments

accounts in federal savings and loan associations

_

and deposited by the veteran's committee in

imtfal where the particular savings and loan associations

by a judgment creditor of the veteran by virtue of 38_USC

checking account, the integrity of the

Y J y

as quickly as a withdrawal from a

involved permit withdrawals from the accounts associations plus federal insurance of the accounts the deposits are neither

• deposits is assured'by federal supervision of the

are the only funds available to meet the veteran s

speculative character nor time deposits at interest, and the deposi

of a

needs.

ASSOCIATIONS §1 > deposits -- nature. -- > Headnote:

LEdHNf2 li. [2]

a shareholder rather than a creditor and'his deposits

federal savings and loan association is

Under the law a depositor in a

are subject to withdrawal only after .a 30-day demand.

EXEMPTIONS §6 >

STATUTES §206 > TAXES §162.5 >

veterans'benefits — liberal construction. —

> Headnote:

I..EdHNr31±\3]

Legislation making benefits paid by the Ve

mainrenance

liberally conned to protect the food, graoted b, Congress for the mamten.noe

legislation.

EXEMPTIONS. §6 > TAXES §162.5

'> veterans' benefits -- safekeeping

— investments. — > Headnote:

LEdHN£41± [4]

Veterans'-Administration nonassigna.ble, exempt rom a _

or after receipt by the beneficiary, except-for

seizure by or under any legal or equitable process w a ever; e^ ^

^ wh(J„y out of such payments, veterans, in the

claims of the United States and taxation of prope

^ commUnity for that purpose, provided that the

safekeeping of *eir

pure

"^““^'“““"“and other forraaltties, are readily available as needed for support and

—ra! "t^e

of raone^,Tnd era not oonvertedlh^anent —■

Syllabus

and deposited by his committee or guardian in an

United States to an incompetent veteran

q 3im Cal when the deposits

Disability benefits paid by the

exempted from attachment by 38JJ . s. c.

account in a federal savings and loan association are

are not permanent

, actually retain the qualities of money and

are readily available as needed for support and maintenance

investments. Pp. 159-162. ■

Counsel: Ethelbert B. Frey argued the cause

and filed a brief for petitioner.

With him on the brief was Richard Whittington Whitlock.

John' L. Laskey argued the cause for respondent.

foFth^Dmte-d-Stat-esT^s-a-mi-cus-curiaerurging-reversal

^^johmG.j^u^yo,aiTgigHeithe e3U%

With-him-on-the-b.d.efjvere

GeneraiTomick and Herbert E. Morris.

Solicitor General Cox, Assistant Attorney

g=mi IB+159&DdstartiF='shapshot&pdtypeo... -3/6nnn-OOUCHUCJ.

Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159

.

in 5/2017

Stewarts, Whjte

Warren

^ and:'Frankfurter took no part in the

judges:

consideration or decision of this case.

Opinion by: CLARK^

Opinion

[***4081 [**1232'

MR. JUSTICE Cl ARK^ delivered the opinion of the Court.

;

,tes Veterans' Administration retain

of whether benefits paid by the United States .

account in a federal

£1IT [l]This case raises the question

r.»4091 U. S. C. i 3101 (a) 0 after boihg [*1601

^^

respondsnl,

their exempt status under 38_^.--------savings and loan association. Patitionar, an incompetent Air Force

“poun^ in ,oca| federal savings and loan

r****21

The latter in an effort to satisfy its judgment atHchgcL“^ clm]tt« with funds received from the Veterans' Administrate

'

associations, all of which had been established y pe

i due the petitioner. The District Cou ,

as disability compensation

statute. IBSRSLmc^Ol- Respondent appealed as to the savings

he|d al| three of the accounts exempt under the

accounts and the Court of Appeals for the

District of Columbia reversed in a divided opinion.

^ a^^itiTthe District Court that the funds

Certiorari was granted in view of the

involved here are exe

—■—™

World War Veteran

S' Act of 1924, 43 Stat. 607, 613. It

tn

_

-

when the benefit funds "lost the

distinctjon was adopted by the Congress when the.

"either before

quality of moneys" and were

Act was [*1-61] amended in

■ “that

or after receipt by the beneficiary

; awrence

such payments." H3 Thereafter In

from veterans'

^

** te-k

"-i-—

and maintenance required . It was

r*i^MlSL negotiable notes and

federal statutory immunity.

on such deposits wo

'States bonds purchased with veteran

were made In the

United r****51_

again amended in 1958, but no significant changes

r^Wr-v. Brvant.M6UJL_545ll939l. The Act was

exemption provision. As so

written it is here at issue.

associations.

£21? [2]It appears that the practices and procedures

deposits are subject to withdrawal only ^

Under theiif**fiL la* the depositor is a sh=r«ho . ^

g withdrawa, from the accounts here involved could be made as

after a 30-day deman d. However, the District Court

c.nriim, Qf the deposits was assured by federal

quickly as a

withdrawaTfrom a checking accountm^

such conditions the funds were subject to

^

monevs " As to whether the deposits were

supervision of the associations plus federal insurer.

"d tt of ripetelahveTeralr nor .era tee, time deposits at "£££? "

immediate [*162] and certain access

"permanent investments," we note they were i

■

nays from the savings and loan fund,for his support and mamtenan

affirmatively appeara that at times petitioner drew mo

available to him, his disability payments having been out oft I

requirements and that no other funds whatever are now

, rather than being investments, are the only funds

therefore appears dear to us that the savings and loan deposits

presently available to me et petitioner's needs.

TmtfprM. Tenr‘°‘rcgp supra, at

" t^idurios thereof,

/ pwrp.ncp v- Shaw,.

^ [3]£^ WSlnce

believe, intended that

veterans in the safekeeping of their benefits sh

fP[-hnicai|ties of title and other formalities, are readily available as

='=:=...„------- —-1—

.Jo vestment.,

Reversed.

A 1C

' '

Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 4/u U.b. loa

3)15/2017, ^

.

.

or decision of this case.

’ ' -TSVE CHIEF JUSTICE and MR. JUSTICE FRANKFURTER took no part in the consideration

MR. JUSTICE DOUGLAS'r.

whether the funds had taken the form of "permanent-investments/' on

Heretofore the test of exemption under this Act has been

the other were "subject to [*163] draft upon demand," as in

the one hand ( Tmf+p.r v. Tennessee, 290 U.S. 354, 35?], or on

j-***:*3] Negotiable notes and United States bonds were

9/iaw. 300 U.5. .245. 250.

the case of checking accounts. Lawrence_w

same

held t. be nonexempt in

™

^ ^^^1.™ *rda«l^oys,

or e r***A1l1 comparable degree of'liquidity as the present share account in the fed“

a

d

cash

ho,d these accounts exempt. Stodts and bonds cannot, o, coume, **-»» “ £ ^ bonds may be

Today, however, we

may be done with savings accounts and checking accounts.-But sto

_[------ —

in small amounts, such as

as well as any bank deposit, the needs of the veteran.

so liquid as to be tantamount to cash in hand and therefore serve,

accounts in federal savings and loan associations are "investments."

be withdrawn only after 30 days

notice. The

"more nearly comparable to a stockholder of a bank than one of its ^ors. —createdf makes dear that its’

r****91 Moreover, the Home Owners' Loan Act, under w ic

.................

392.

purpose is "to provide local mutual thrift institutions in which people may invest

adld.) Its capita, 0 is in "shares"

^

s 1464 fal. (Italics

funds.

^

l

accounts who apply for a withdrawal of funds do not thereby become creditors. [2±J

—............ L-rrrr^rr.-.rurr

r****iQl In some

listed on an exchange or actively traded over-the-counter. The true

not the moneys are kept in a form in which they are usable, if need be

at 250.

Chief Justice Hughes said in / awrence"J. Shaw, supra

, "for the maintenance and support of the veteran, as

References

f

\

Annotation References:

1. Deposit of exempt funds as affecting debtor's exemption. 67 ALR 1203.

claims of creditors of amounts

of provisions of Federal statutes in relation to exemption from

2. Construction and application

or other relief for veterans. 109 ALR 433.

risk insurance, compensation, bonus,

paid as pensions, war

pensions, war

Footnotes

HiI

W Payments gf benefits dee or to become due

S. eSgmffe except to the

Km ofoSors, and shall not be liable to

*■

beneficiary shall be exempt from taxation,’3uh®“ 3, or ea^iteble process whatever, either before or after receipt by the

Sd”?^m^recS'in9lenK°nc".nshall not apply “

ofe^%Uu"^^

«sr sr.sssi.-n5 asiJ.v

chapter 19 of this title; or of servicemen s Indemnity.

- insurar“oth™auth0

■^^t-of-Mar—3—1-873—Rv-S.-§-4-7.47-Ci8.7.8.).p-WQrid_y\[q.cVeteransLAct_of_1924Lc_320 § 22, 43 Stat. 607, 613; Act of Aug.

-1-2^1.935,-0.-510., §-3,.49-Stat._607,.609,_--------------------- --n—----------- ™

R/fi

Porter v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., 370 U.S. 159

urchased with

•a'15/2017:'

faM°withinX^ei«al immunizing language.

S’s: Rssrs

.

in the capital" of the association. liinLii——

■*• °™erah,p of lhe

made shall remain holders of savings accounts

Hi

»“ ^F'SSfiSm p-«

!_

\

*•

•••

Ell-

Goto r

«_RELX Group1"

^„.-y^@;Lexi$Ne*is^

__I__AO — Jt.

fi/fi

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.