Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Dan Robert, et al., Petitioners v. Lloyd J. Austin, III, Secretary of Defense, et al.
Supreme Court briefNov 22, 2023
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. _________
================================================================================================================
In The
Supreme Court of the United States
---------------------------------♦--------------------------------DAN ROBERT AND HOLLIE MULVIHILL,
Petitioners,
v.
LLOYD J. AUSTIN, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY
AS SECRETARY OF DEFENSE, U.S. DEPARTMENT
OF DEFENSE, XAVIER BECERRA, IN HIS
OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN
SERVICES, AND ROBERT CALIFF, IN HIS
OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS COMMISSIONER OF
THE U.S. FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION,
Respondents.
---------------------------------♦--------------------------------On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari
To The United States Court Of Appeals
For The Tenth Circuit
---------------------------------♦--------------------------------PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
---------------------------------♦--------------------------------ANDREW L. SCHLAFLY
939 Old Chester Road
Far Hills, NJ 07931
(908) 719-8608
aschlafly@aol.com
Counsel for Petitioners
================================================================================================================
i
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
1. Whether the unlawful implementation of the
harmful Covid vaccine mandate in the Armed
Services properly evades judicial review based
on repeal of the mandate and separation of a
service member who is subject to recall to duty.
2. Whether it is proper and authorized for a court
of appeals to engage in factfinding, while going
outside of the record, to dismiss service
members’ appeal without reaching its merits.
3. Whether the government may properly force
citizens to receive an experimental genemodifying injection, recognized in the medical
literature as causing severe adverse effects.
ii
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDINGS
Petitioners, plaintiffs-appellants below, are Dan
Robert and Hollie Mulvihill.
Respondents, defendants-appellees below, are
Lloyd J. Austin, in his official capacity as Secretary of
Defense, U.S. Department of Defense, Xavier
Becerra, in his official capacity as Secretary of the
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, and
Robert Califf, in his official capacity as Commissioner
of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
RELATED PROCEEDINGS
Robert and Mulvihill v. Austin, et al., No. 22-1032,
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.
Judgments entered on July 6, 2023 and Aug. 30,
2023.
Robert and Mulvihill v. Austin, et al., No. 21-cv02228-RM-STV, U.S. District Court for the District of
Colorado. Judgment entered on Jan. 11, 2022.
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Pages
QUESTIONS PRESENTED ......................................... i
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDINGS .......................... ii
RELATED PROCEEDINGS........................................ ii
OPINIONS BELOW .................................................... 1
JURISDICTION .......................................................... 1
STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED .................. 1
STATEMENT OF THE CASE..................................... 2
A. Factual Background ............................................ 3
B. Proceedings Below............................................... 6
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION .......... 8
I. There Is Exceptional Importance to
Judicial Review of Unlawful Biological
Injections into Members of the
Armed Services ................................................... 9
A. The Illegality of the Mandate ...................... 10
B. Harm Caused by the Mandate .................... 12
C. Judicial Review of the Life-Changing
mRNA Technology – Never Authorized
by Congress – Was Improperly
Denied ........................................................... 16
II. The Decision Below Creates a Circuit Split
as to the Appropriateness of Appellate
Factfinding Reaching Beyond the Record ....... 18
CONCLUSION .......................................................... 20
iv
APPENDIX CONTENTS
Published Order
Robert v. Austin,
72 F.4th 1160 (10th Cir. 2023) ...................... App. 1
Unpublished Orders
Robert v. Austin, Civil Action
No. 21-cv-02228-RM-STV
(D. Colo. Jan. 11, 2022) .............................. App. 11
Robert v. Austin, Final Judgment
(D. Colo. Jan. 11, 2022) ............................... App. 19
Robert v. Austin, Denial of Rehearing,
No. 22-1032 (10th Cir. Aug. 30, 2023) ......... App. 21
v
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Pages
Cases
Anderson v. Bessemer City,
470 U.S. 564 (1985) ....................................... 19
Ass’n for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad
Genetics, Inc., 569 U.S. 576 (2013) ......... 16, 17
Brutsche v. Commissioner,
585 F.2d 436 (10th Cir. 1978) ...................... 19
Church v. Biden, Civ. No. 21-2815 (CKK),
2021 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 215069
(D.D.C. Nov. 8, 2021) ........................................ 7
Feds for Med. Freedom v. Biden,
63 F.4th 366 (5th Cir. 2023) ............................. 8
Freedom Holdings, Inc. v. Cuomo,
624 F.3d 38 (2d Cir. 2010) ............................. 19
Heinold Hog Mkt., Inc. v. Superior Feeders,
Inc., 623 F.2d 636 (10th Cir. 1979) .............. 19
June Med. Servs. L.L.C. v. Russo,
140 S. Ct. 2103 (2020) ................................... 19
McCarty v. McCarty, 453 U.S. 210 (1981) ........... 7
Nat’l Fed’n of Indep. Bus. v. DOL, OSHA,
595 U.S. 109 (2022) ......................................... 8
Robert v. Austin,
72 F.4th 1160 (10th Cir. 2023) ......................... 1
United States v. Soto, 48 F.3d 1415
(7th Cir. 1995)................................................ 19
Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research,
395 U.S. 100 (1969) ....................................... 19
Constitutional Provision and Statutes
U.S. CONST., amend. XIII.................................... 17
vi
U.S. CONST., amend. XIV ...................................... 6
10 U.S.C. §1107....................................... 1, 5, 6, 10
10 U.S.C. §1107a..................................... 2, 5, 6, 10
21 U.S.C. §360bbb-3 ............................................. 2
21 U.S.C. §360bbb-3(e)(1)(A)(ii)(III)..................... 2
28 U.S.C. §1254(1) ................................................ 1
28 U.S.C. §1331..................................................... 6
28 U.S.C. §1346..................................................... 6
28 U.S.C. §1361..................................................... 6
50 U.S.C. §1520..................................................... 6
Other
K. Acevedo-Whitehouse and R. Brunob,
“Potential health risks of mRNA-based vaccine
therapy: A hypothesis,” Med Hypotheses
171:111015 (Feb. 2023)
https://tinyurl.com/y3tn7t79 ......................... 16
Army Center for Synthetic Biology
https://www.arl.army.mil/collaborate-withus/opportunity/army-center-forsynthetic-biology/ ............................................ 16
Army Regulation 40–562,
Medical Services, “Immunizations and
Chemoprophylaxis for the
Prevention of Infectious Diseases”
https://armypubs.army.mil/epubs/DR_pubs/
DR_a/pdf/web/r40_562.pdf .............................. 6
Asst. Secretary of Defense Memorandum,
“Mandatory Vaccination of Service Members
Using the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 and
COMIRNATY COVID-19 Vaccines”
(Sept. 14, 2021) ................................................. 5
vii
Lloyd Austin, Memorandum for Senior
Pentagon Leadership Commanders
of the Combatant Commands Defense
Agency and DOD Field Activity Directors
(Aug. 24, 2021) https://tinyurl.com/2ucrj74j .... 4
Anika Binnendijk, et al., “U.S. Military
Applications and Implications, An Initial
Assessment,” RAND Corporation (2020)
https://www.rand.org/pubs/
research_reports/RR2996.html ...................... 17
David A. Bluemke, M.D., Ph.D., COVID-19
Vaccines and Myocardial Injury,”
308 Radiology No. 3 (Sept. 2023)
https://pubs.rsna.org/doi/10.1148/
radiol.232244 ................................................... 8
Meghan Bowman, “Florida surgeon general
Ladapo suggests link between cardiac
arrest and COVID vaccine” (Aug. 4, 2023)
https://www.wlrn.org/health/2023-08-04/
florida-surgeon-general-ladapo-suggests-linkbetween-cardiac-arrest-and-covid-vaccine ... 13
Natacha Buergin, et al., “Sex-specific
differences in myocardial injury incidence
after COVID-19 mRNA-1273 booster
vaccination,” European Journal of Heart
Failure 1871 (2023)
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/
10.1002/ejhf.2978 ............................................ 13
CDC, “Myocarditis and Pericarditis”
(Nov. 3, 2023) https://www.cdc.gov/
coronavirus/2019ncov/vaccines/safety/myocarditis.html ......... 12
viii
Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks,
Policy Statement on Patentability of
Animals, 1077 Off. Gaz. Pat. Office 24
(April 7, 1987), reprinted in
Donald S. Chisum, Chisum on Patents
app. 24-2 (1998) ............................................. 18
Dept. of the Navy, Bureau of Medicine and
Surgery Memorandum, “Interchangeability
of the FDA-Approved Pfizer-BioNTech
Vaccine COMIRNATY and FDA-Authorized
Pfizer-BioNTech Vaccine Under EUA”
(Sept. 3, 2021) ................................................... 5
Mike Gooding, “Measuring the costs of U.S.
military’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate;
critics say policy harmed force,”
13NewsNow (July 28, 2023)
https://tinyurl.com/2bpph2yw ....................... 10
A. Magnani, “V. BIOTECHNOLOGY AND
MEDICAL DEVICES: 1. Patenting
Lifeforms: a) Chimeras: The Patentability
of Human-Animal Chimeras,” 14 Berkeley
Tech. L.J. 443 (1999) ..................................... 18
James A. Thorp, M.D., et al., “COVID-19
Vaccines: The Impact on Pregnancy
Outcomes and Menstrual Function,”
28 Journal of American Physicians and
Surgeons (No. 1) 28 (Spring 2023)
https://jpands.org/vol28no1/thorp.pdf .......... 15
1
OPINIONS BELOW
The published opinion of the court of appeals from
which this appeal is taken is reported at Robert v.
Austin, 72 F.4th 1160 (10th Cir. 2023), and
reproduced in the appendix hereto (“App.”) at 1-10.
The underlying opinion of the U.S. District Court is
included in the appendix at 11-18. The order by the
court of appeals to deny the petition for rehearing en
banc was issued on August 30, 2023 (App. 21-22).
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
Tenth Circuit was entered on July 6, 2023. (App. 110) A timely petition for rehearing en banc was filed,
and then denied on August 30, 2023. (App. 21-22)
The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked pursuant to
28 U.S.C. § 1254(1).
STATUTORY PROVISIONS INVOLVED
10 U.S.C. §1107 requires:
(a) Notice required.
(1) Whenever the Secretary of Defense requests or requires a member of the armed forces to receive an investigational new drug or a
drug unapproved for its applied use, the Secretary shall provide the member with notice containing the information specified in subsection
(d). …
(d) Content of notice. The notice required under subsection (a)(1) shall include the following:
2
(1) Clear notice that the drug being
administered is an investigational new drug or
a drug unapproved for its applied use.
(2) The reasons why the investigational new
drug or drug unapproved for its applied use is
being administered.
(3) Information regarding the possible side
effects of the investigational new drug or drug
unapproved for its applied use, including any
known side effects possible as a result of the
interaction of such drug with other drugs or
treatments being administered to the members
receiving such drug. …
10 U.S.C. §1107a requires:
(a) Waiver by the President.
(1) In the case of the administration of a product authorized for emergency use under section
564 of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic
Act [21 USCS § 360bbb-3] to members of the
armed forces, the condition described in section
564(e)(1)(A)(ii)(III) of such Act [21 USCS §
360bbb-3(e)(1)(A)(ii)(III)] and required under
paragraph (1)(A) or (2)(A) of such section
564(e), designed to ensure that individuals are
informed of an option to accept or refuse administration of a product, may be waived only
by the President only if the President determines, in writing, that complying with such
requirement is not in the interests of national
security.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Petitioners Dan Robert and Hollie Mulvihill were
staff sergeants in the U.S. Army and Marine Corps,
3
respectively, but were driven out by the unlawful
implementation of a mandate by the Biden
Administration to receive the mRNA biological
injection known as the Covid vaccine. This mandate
by the Biden Administration was invalidated by the
Supreme Court with respect to private employers,
and by the Fifth Circuit with respect to government
workers. But Petitioners were denied their day in
court to challenge the illegal implementation of this
mandate against them. Federal law prohibits using
any unlicensed vaccine on service members without
their informed consent and without an express and
timely presidential waiver of service members’ rights,
which were both lacking.
The district court never reached the merits of
Petitioners’
claims,
by
ruling
they
were
nonjusticiable, and then the court of appeals
dismissed their appeal based on mootness by going
outside of the record to engage in factfinding. This
was procedurally improper and substantively
erroneous on an issue of exceptional importance:
unlawful experimentation on members of the Armed
Services with a novel biological agent having
untested long-term side effects and indisputable
short-term, sometimes fatal harm to some recipients.
A.
Factual Background.
On August 24, 2021, as part of a sweeping
program of mandates by the Biden Administration to
impose vaccination by the mRNA product on as many
people as possible, Defendant Lloyd Austin signed an
order requiring “full vaccination of all members of the
Armed Forces under DOD authority on active duty or
4
in the Ready Reserve.”1 This was a command, and
was not optional. Penalties for non-compliance were
not specified but the violation of any higher order by
an enlisted man or woman is subject to harsh
punishment.
Staff sergeants in the U.S. Army and U.S. Marine
Corps, Petitioners Dan Robert and Hollie Mulvihill,
objected, lost opportunities, and ultimately separated
from the military due in large part to this unlawful
order, and at least Robert has remained subject to
recall as most service members are. Both were
harmed by the preclusion of likely advancement in
the military due to this command to take the mRNA
injection.
This vaccine mandate took effect immediately
despite the unavailability of any fully licensed Covid
vaccines; all the available Covid Vaccines were
offered under only the Emergency Use Authorizations
in Investigatory New Drugs (EUA/IND’s). On August
23, 2021, Rear Admiral Denise Hinton, Chief
Scientist of Defendant FDA, sent a letter to Pfizer
advising it that the EUA previously issued by the
FDA for Pfizer-BNT162b2 Covid-19 vaccine (“Pfizer
BNT”) would remain in place due to the
unavailability of any licensed vaccines as required
by applicable statutes.
The FDA’s website and documents listed the
Pfizer-BNT vaccine as being offered under an EUA
1Lloyd
Austin, Memorandum for Senior Pentagon Leadership
Commanders of the Combatant Commands Defense Agency and
DOD
Field
Activity
Directors
(Aug.
24,
2021)
https://tinyurl.com/2ucrj74j (viewed Nov. 17, 2023).
5
rather than fully licensed. The labeling and other
requirements remained unsatisfied and the PfizerBNT vaccine remained an EUA product because the
approved, but not yet licensed, Comirnaty was
unavailable at the relevant time.
Even though it was impossible lawfully to satisfy
the requirement that only fully licensed vaccines be
used – they were unavailable – commanders within
the Department of Defense (“DOD”) swiftly imposed
the mandate using the EUA Pfizer-BNT vaccine that
remained unlicensed by the FDA. Various units
within DOD received guidance that they could
involuntarily vaccinate service members with
unlicensed vaccines, which expanded to a servicewide practice. (See Asst. Secretary of Defense
Memorandum, “Mandatory Vaccination of Service
Members Using the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 and
COMIRNATY COVID-19 Vaccines” (Sept. 14, 2021);
Dept. of the Navy, Bureau of Medicine and Surgery
Memorandum, “Interchangeability of the FDAApproved Pfizer-BioNTech Vaccine COMIRNATY
and FDA-Authorized Pfizer-BioNTech Vaccine Under
EUA” (Sept. 3, 2021).) DOD then administered many
thousands of involuntary inoculations, without the
required informed consent and without using a fully
licensed vaccine as required.
One of the obligations that Defendant Austin has,
under 10 U.S.C. §1107 with respect to use of an
investigational new drug (“IND”) or drug unapproved
for its applied use, is to provide detailed, written
notice to the service member, as quoted supra.
Neither Defendant Austin nor anyone else in the
Biden Administration provided this.
Another
applicable statute, 10 U.S.C. §1107a (also quoted
6
supra), requires nothing less than a written
Presidential waiver of service members’ right to
informed consent, and no such waiver ever occurred.
Petitioners had personally contracted and
recovered
from
Covid-19
infections, thereby
developing natural immunity as demonstrated to or
documented by the military. Army Regulation 40562, “Immunization and Chemoprophylaxis for the
Prevention of Infectious Diseases,”2 presumptively
exempts from any vaccination requirement a service
member that the military knows has had a
documented previous infection.
B. Proceedings Below.
Petitioners Robert and Mulvihill filed their
lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of
Colorado on August 17, 2021, where jurisdiction
existed under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1346, and 1361. Six
days after Defendant Austin issued his order for the
compulsory Covid vaccination, Petitioners filed on
August 30 their unsuccessful motion for a TRO and
subsequently sought a Preliminary Injunction. After
obtaining leave to amend, they filed their Amended
Complaint on October 6, asserting five causes of
action: violations of (1) the Administrative Procedure
Act, (2) 10 U.S.C. §1107, (3) 10 U.S.C. §1107a, (4) 50
U.S.C. §1520, and (5) the Fourteenth Amendment of
the U.S. Constitution. Plaintiffs further moved for a
preliminary injunction. (Dist. Ct. Dkt. 16)
2 This document is an all-service publication and has an equiva-
lent name for each of the applicable services.
https://armypubs.army.mil/epubs/DR_pubs/
DR_a/pdf/web/r40_562.pdf (viewed Nov. 20, 2023).
7
The district court dismissed the Amended
Complaint in its entirety on January 11, 2022, by
finding the allegations to be non-justiciable, and
likewise denied Plaintiffs’ pending motion for a
preliminary injunction. The district court never
reached the unlawfulness of the implementation of
Defendant Austin’s order, and the ruling below was
not based on any deference to decision-making by the
military. Instead, the district court relied heavily on
a District of Columbia district court decision that had
denied a request for a preliminary injunction, in
Church v. Biden, Civ. No. 21-2815 (CKK), 2021 U.S.
Dist. LEXIS 215069, at *3 (D.D.C. Nov. 8, 2021). But
that other decision did not dismiss service members’
claims, and instead merely denied a request for a
preliminary injunction only because exemption
requests were still pending.
On appeal, the Tenth Circuit never reached the
merits of this case either.
In a published,
precedential decision, a panel of the Tenth Circuit
granted a motion by the government to dismiss the
appeal based on mootness. Rather than remand for
additional factfinding, the appellate court went
outside of the record to incorrectly conclude that
because Petitioners were separated from the Armed
Services, they no longer had a valid claim. This was
false, as separated service members (including
Robert) are subject to recall, and both Petitioners lost
opportunities due to the unlawful implementation of
the vaccine mandate. See, e.g., McCarty v. McCarty,
453 U.S. 210, 222 (1981) (a “retired officer
remains subject to recall to active duty by the
Secretary of the Army at any time”) (inner quotations
omitted). The court of appeals also cited the repeal of
8
the mandate by Congress, but that repeal did not
provide a full remedy for those who, like Petitioners,
had declined to be subjected to the unlawful vaccine
mandate.
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION
This Court should grant the Petition to address a
matter of exceptional importance: whether a
President may violate federal law to coercively inject
novel biological agents into members of the Armed
Services, and then evade review of it in federal court.
Military enlistment is to defend our country, not to
become guinea pigs for politically motivated biological
mandates that were properly enjoined when applied
against employees of private companies and against
government workers. See Nat’l Fed’n of Indep. Bus.
v. DOL, OSHA, 595 U.S. 109 (2022) (blocking vaccine
mandate against private employers); Feds for Med.
Freedom v. Biden, 63 F.4th 366 (5th Cir. 2023)
(blocking vaccine mandate against government
workers). If our national defense is a matter of
exceptional importance – and it certainly is – then
respecting due process by our enlisted men and
women to protect themselves against invasion of their
bodily integrity to alter their genes is also highly
important.
“Vaccine manufacturers are aware of the adverse
effects of mRNA vaccines,”3 is a candid admission
published recently in a peer reviewed medical journal
3 David A. Bluemke, M.D., Ph.D., COVID-19 Vaccines and Myo-
cardial Injury,” 308 Radiology No. 3, at p. 2 (Sept. 2023)
https://pubs.rsna.org/doi/10.1148/radiol.232244 (viewed Nov. 16,
2023).
9
about the Covid vaccines at issue here. Yet despite
their known adverse effects, these mRNA vaccines
were imposed on our service members in violation of
federal law. These mRNA products were rushed to
implementation and illegally injected without legal
accountability during or after. This was a medical
experiment on a scale larger than anything ever
allowed before in our country, and never authorized
by Congress.
Due process requires meaningful
judicial review for the objecting service members,
including those subject to recall to duty as presented
here.
Yet to deny substantive review of Petitioners’
claims below, the Tenth Circuit went beyond the
record and engaged in appellate factfinding without
any of the procedural protections required in district
court. The Tenth Circuit did so in a published
decision that creates a circuit split concerning
procedure, which is an additional reason for review
by this court. Litigants, and particularly current and
former members of our Armed Services, should be
afforded full due process in district court on a remand
by an appellate court whenever it seeks more
factfinding.
For the foregoing reasons as explained further
below, this Petition should be granted.
I. There Is Exceptional Importance to
Judicial Review of Unlawful Biological
Injections into Members of the Armed Services.
The Biden Administration imposed on members of
the Armed Services injections by a novel mRNA
biological agent. This mandate was enjoined by
federal appellate courts when imposed by President
10
Biden on employees of private companies and on
government workers.
The enlistment men and
women of our military did not waive their relevant
rights under federal law by agreeing to serve, and are
not to be made guinea pigs for what became the
equivalent of a large-scale medical experiment.
A. The Illegality of the Mandate.
The illegality of the implementation of this
mandate against the Armed Services is clear.
Federal law allows compelled vaccination of service
members with an Investigational New Drug or
unlicensed vaccine only when the Secretary of
Defense has complied with all the legal requirements
of 10 U.S.C. §1107 or §1107a. Defendants failed to
thereby comply and there was no such timely waiver,
or waiver of any kind, by the President of the United
States of service members’ right to informed consent
to participate in the largest phase 3 clinical study
ever undertaken in the history of the military. To
this day Defendants refuse to restore unvaccinated
service members without penalty for their personal
decisions to decline the Covid vaccine. “[O]ver 8,300
military service members have been discharged due
to non-compliance,” and “another 19,000 troops
remain unvaccinated.”4
It is exceptionally important that there be redress
and accountability in the courts for the unlawful
mandate that injected a biological agent having life4 Mike Gooding, “Measuring the costs of U.S. military's COVID-
19 vaccine mandate; critics
13NewsNow (July 28, 2023).
(viewed Nov. 18, 2023).
say policy harmed force,”
https://tinyurl.com/2bpph2yw
11
changing characteristics into our service members.
Federal law protects the enlisted, and yet the courts
below avoided addressing the plain violations of
federal law as properly alleged by Petitioners. The
district court prematurely dismissed this case by
finding it to be nonjusticiable, and then the court of
appeals dismissed it by declaring it moot. Both bases
for failing to reach the merits of this case were in
error on a matter of enormous significance: the
personal autonomy of our service members. Due
process should not be denied to them.
None of the traditional deference to military
decision-making applies here. This was a mandate
that was likewise imposed against civilians and
everyone who was allegedly under some authority of
the President. Federal appellate courts properly
enjoined the same mandate against civilians, and for
the same reason should have enjoined this abuse of
power against service members in the Armed Forces.
The order at issue here even implicitly authorized the
use of force against young service members if they
objected to this genetic modification of their bodies by
this biological agent, the novel mRNA technology.
Moreover, the injections imposed had typically not
been fully approved as required.
The decision below denying judicial review is
precedential, and unless reversed will be used to
preclude future review of similar abuses of power. No
one expects the Covid pandemic to have been the last
of its kind. Those who risk their lives in defense of
our country are entitled to redress in the courts
under federal law, with full due process. Upon
revelation that this technology causes fatal heart
conditions and otherwise modifies the recipients’
12
genes, judicial review is essential when any segment
of our population, military or civilian, is subjected to
this. Nothing is more repugnant to our inalienable
rights and God-given liberties than being compelled
to receive a biological agent that transforms our
natural composition. The context of the mandate
shows that this was not a military decision for
national security, and legitimate deference to the
military was never an issue here.
B. Harm Caused by the Mandate.
While the Biden Administration went full tilt into
coercing injection by the mRNA Covid vaccine into
everyone it could possibly coerce, the CDC belatedly
admitted to the severe harm it was causing. By
September 2022, long before the precedential
decision was rendered by the court of appeals below,
the CDC admitted to widely reported, sometimes
fatal adverse effects of the mRNA vaccine mandated
against Petitioners and other service members:
myocarditis, which is a sometimes deadly
inflammation of the heart muscle, and pericarditis,
which is an inflammation of the outer lining of the
heart.5
These side effects particularly harmed healthy
young adults – the same demographic subjected to
the Covid vaccine against the military. Of course the
CDC tried to downplay this side effect for a
government-mandated vaccine, but Florida Surgeon
General Joseph Lapado, M.D., Ph.D., has been more
5 CDC, “Myocarditis and Pericarditis” (Nov. 3, 2023)
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019ncov/vaccines/safety/myocarditis.html (viewed Nov. 17, 2023).
13
candid. Among his many public statements warning
against this mRNA vaccine was the following:
Two USC basketball players experience cardiac
arrest in the past year and both almost certainly
were forced or misled into taking a vaccine never
proven to meaningfully benefit young, healthy
people, but definitely proven to cause cardiac
injury.
Meghan Bowman, “Florida surgeon general Ladapo
suggests link between cardiac arrest and COVID
vaccine” (Aug. 4, 2023).6
Now numerous reports confirm this deadly side
effects of this mRNA vaccine on young people who are
in the prime of their life, as our Armed Services
enlisted men and women are. Harvard-trained for
both his M.D. and Ph.D. degrees, Florida Surgeon
General Ladapo has been proven right, and has been
able to speak out because he has independence from
the Biden Administration, in contrast with most
researchers who are beholden for funding on the
National Institutes for Health and other federal
agencies. Lapado cited data compiled by the State of
Florida and a peer-reviewed, published Switzerland
study that indeed confirms that “vaccine-associated
myocardial injury was more common than previously
thought.”7
6 https://www.wlrn.org/health/2023-08-04/florida-surgeon-
general-ladapo-suggests-link-between-cardiac-arrest-and-covidvaccine (viewed Nov. 17, 2023).
7 Natacha Buergin, et al., “Sex-specific differences in myocardial
injury incidence after COVID-19 mRNA-1273 booster vaccination,” European Journal of Heart Failure 1871, 1879 (2023)
14
Similar evidence was presented below, yet never
addressed.
For example, the compelling sworn
affidavit by Lieutenant Colonel Theresa Long, MD,
MPH, FS, is part of the record in this case:
37. I personally observed the most physically fit
female Soldier I have seen in over 20 years in the
Army, go from Collegiate level athlete training for
Ranger School, to being physically debilitated
with cardiac problems, newly diagnosed pituitary
brain tumor, thyroid dysfunction within weeks of
getting vaccinated. Several military physicians
have shared with me their firsthand experience
with a significant increase in the number of young
soldiers with migraines, menstrual irregularities,
cancer, suspected myocarditis and reporting
cardiac symptoms after vaccination. Numerous
soldiers and DOD civilians have told me of how
they were sick, bed-ridden, debilitated, and unable
to work for days to weeks after vaccination. I
believe the illnesses and injuries observed are the
proximate and causal effect of the COVID-19
vaccinations. I have also recently reviewed three
flight crew members’ medical records, all of which
presented with both significant and aggressive
systemic health issues. I cannot attribute
anything other than the COVID-19 vaccines
recently received as the source of these maladies
….
(Appellate Appendix below, 109-10)
This mRNA vaccine has been linked to fertility
and pregnancy problems in young women, and
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/ejhf.2978
(viewed Nov. 18, 2023).
15
Petitioner Mulvihill was pregnant at the time of this
mandate.
“When normalized by time-available,
doses-given, or number of persons vaccinated, all
COVID-19 vaccine [adverse events] AEs far exceed
the safety signal on all recognized thresholds.
These results necessitate a worldwide moratorium on
the use of COVID-19 vaccines in pregnancy.” James
A. Thorp, M.D., et al., “COVID-19 Vaccines: The
Impact on Pregnancy Outcomes and Menstrual
Function,” 28 Journal of American Physicians and
Surgeons (No. 1) 28 (Spring 2023).8 These experts
pointed out that, other than the politically motivated
Biden Administration, “Governments and public
health agencies worldwide are stepping back from
COVID-19 vaccine mandates and are beginning to
recommend against or even prohibiting COVID-19
mandates and vaccinations for vulnerable groups
such as children, pregnant women, and lactating
women.” Id. at 33.
Studies released this year confirm how improper
this vaccine mandate was from a medical perspective.
As foreign researchers wrote about the Covid vaccine:
Furthermore, despite the assumption that there is
no possibility of genomic integration of
therapeutic synthetic mRNA, only one recent
study has examined interactions between vaccine
mRNA and the genome of transfected cells, and
reported that an endogenous retrotransposon,
LINE-1 is unsilenced following mRNA entry to the
cell, leading to reverse transcription of full length
vaccine mRNA sequences, and nuclear entry. This
finding should be a major safety concern, given
8 https://jpands.org/vol28no1/thorp.pdf (viewed Nov. 18, 2023).
16
the possibility of synthetic mRNA-driven
epigenetic and genomic modifications arising.
K. Acevedo-Whitehouse and R. Brunob, “Potential
health risks of mRNA-based vaccine therapy: A
hypothesis,” Med Hypotheses. 2023 Feb; 171:
111015.9
C. Judicial Review of the Life-Changing
mRNA Technology – Never Authorized by
Congress – Was Improperly Denied.
Defendants alone have control of their own
extensive Covid vaccine data in the military which
continues to be withheld from the public.
Defendants have access to the data about service
members harmed by the Covid vaccine; there is an
Army Center for Synthetic Biology relating to
synthetic biological products, which the mRNA
(vaccine) product at issue here is.10 This mRNA
product makes alterations in the molecular structure
of human deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and
ribonucleic acid (RNA), and the Supreme Court has
expressly recognized how harmful that can be.
“Changes in the genetic sequence are called
mutations. … Some mutations are harmless, but
others can cause disease or increase the risk of
disease.” Ass’n for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad
Genetics, Inc., 569 U.S. 576, 582 (2013) (emphasis
added).
9 https://tinyurl.com/y3tn7t79 (viewed Nov. 20, 2023).
10 Army Center for Synthetic Biology
https://www.arl.army.mil/collaborate-with-us/opportunity/armycenter-for-synthetic-biology/ (viewed Nov. 18, 2023).
17
Indeed, this Court’s ruling in Molecular Pathology
foreshadowed the mRNA product here, underscoring
the exceptional importance of this case:
One [product development] method begins with an
mRNA molecule and uses the natural bonding
properties of nucleotides to create a new, synthetic
DNA molecule. … Myriad’s patents would, if valid,
give it the exclusive right to isolate an individual’s
BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes (or any strand of 15 or
more nucleotides within the genes) by breaking
the covalent bonds that connect the DNA to the
rest of the individual’s genome.
Molecular Pathology, 569 U.S. at 582, 585. There
this Court rejected ownership of that genetic
engineering, implying the illegality of forcing anyone
to submit their own bodies to such ownership as at
issue here.
The exceptional importance of this issue is
reinforced by how more biological experimentation on
our service members is in the pipeline.
In
“development [are] implantable neural interfaces able
to transfer data between the human brain and the
digital world … to monitor a soldier’s cognitive
workload ….” Anika Binnendijk, et al., “U.S. Military
Applications
and
Implications,
An
Initial
Assessment,” RAND Corporation (2020) (also
describing a “Silent Talk” neurological program that
has been funded since 2009).11 The U.S. Patent and
Trademark Office has ruled that the Thirteenth
Amendment to the U.S. Constitution prohibits the
issuance of any patent on a human being, and
https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR2996.html
(viewed Nov. 17, 2023).
11
18
likewise novel biological agents should not be
imposed by government against anyone. See Thomas
A. Magnani, “V. BIOTECHNOLOGY AND MEDICAL
DEVICES: 1. Patenting Lifeforms: a) Chimeras: The
Patentability of Human-Animal Chimeras,” 14
Berkeley Tech. L.J. 443, 444 (1999) (citing
Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks, Policy
Statement on Patentability of Animals, 1077 Off.
Gaz. Pat. Office 24 (April 7, 1987), reprinted in
Donald S. Chisum, Chisum on Patents app. 24-2
(1998).
This mRNA vaccine was never authorized by
Congress, and this mandate was enjoined by federal
appellate courts with respect to private and
government workers. It is a matter of exceptional
importance whether this mandate was properly
imposed on the Armed Services, and judicial review
of this issue was improperly denied below.
II. The Decision Below Creates a Circuit
Split as to the Appropriateness of Appellate
Factfinding Reaching Beyond the Record.
The published court of appeals decision was based
on erroneous appellate factfinding found nowhere in
the record of this case, and contravened precedent.
This Court, the Tenth Circuit itself, and other circuits
have emphasized that a remand is necessary for
further development of the facts, which was denied to
these service members as Plaintiffs. For example,
prior Tenth Circuit cases held that:
the function of appellate review is to decide
whether the correct rule of law was applied to
the facts found. When there has been an
insufficient development of the facts by the
19
parties, so as to amount to the failure of proof of
either position advanced, then … [a] remand for
further development of the facts must follow.
Heinold Hog Mkt., Inc. v. Superior Feeders, Inc., 623
F.2d 636, 637 (10th Cir. 1979) (emphasis added). See
also Brutsche v. Commissioner, 585 F.2d 436, 443
(10th Cir. 1978) (“Because we are without power to
consider the doctrine of estoppel as an initial trier of
fact, the case is remanded to the Tax Court for
findings of fact from the record ….”).
This Court and other circuits have held likewise.
See, e.g., Zenith Radio Corp. v. Hazeltine Research,
395 U.S. 100, 123 (1969) (“appellate courts must
constantly have in mind that their function is not
to decide factual issues de novo”) (emphasis
added); June Med. Servs. L.L.C. v. Russo, 140 S. Ct.
2103, 2121 (2020) (same); Anderson v. Bessemer City,
470 U.S. 564, 573 (1985) (same); Freedom Holdings,
Inc. v. Cuomo, 624 F.3d 38, 54 (2d Cir. 2010) (same);
United States v. Soto, 48 F.3d 1415, 1421 (7th Cir.
1995) (same).
Finally, the congressional repeal in December
2022 of the mandate does not moot this case, as
service members are long subject to recall and thus
continue to be at risk of retaliation and lost
opportunities due to their objection to the unlawful
vaccine mandate. Factual issues were necessary to
resolve first, which should have happened on a
remand to the district court, rather than close the
courthouse doors entirely to those who served our
country honorable for the benefit of all.
20
The foregoing circuit split, the lack of
congressional authorization for the mandate, and the
incompleteness of its repeal support this Petition.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, this Petition for a Writ
of Certiorari should be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
ANDREW L. SCHLAFLY
939 OLD CHESTER ROAD
FAR HILLS, NJ 07931
(908) 719-8608
aschlafly@aol.com
Counsel for Petitioners
Dated: November 22, 2023
i
APPENDIX TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Published Order
Robert v. Austin,
72 F.4th 1160 (10th Cir. 2023) ......................... App. 1
Unpublished Orders
Robert v. Austin, Civil Action
No. 21-cv-02228-RM-STV
(D. Colo. Jan. 11, 2022)................................... App. 11
Robert v. Austin, Final Judgment
(D. Colo. Jan. 11, 2022)................................... App. 19
Robert v. Austin, Denial of Rehearing,
No. 22-1032 (10th Cir. Aug. 30, 2023) ............ App. 21
App. 1
PUBLISH
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DAN ROBERT; HOLLIE
MULVIHILL; and other
similarly situated individuals,
Plaintiffs - Appellants,
v.
LLOYD J. AUSTIN, in his
official capacity as Secretary
of Defense, U.S. Department
of Defense; XAVIER
BECERRA, in his official
capacity as Secretary of the
U.S. Department of Health
and Human Services; ROBERT
CALIFF, in his official capacity
as Commissioner of the U.S.
Food and Drug Administration,
No. 22-1032
(D.C. No.
1:21-CV-02228-RM-STV)
(D. Colo.)
Defendants - Appellees.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1
During the pendency of this appeal, Appellants left active
service in the United States Armed Forces. The original case
caption reflected their previous respective ranks while actively
serving in the military. The updated caption mirrors Robert and
Mulvihill’s new status.
App. 2
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ORDER
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(Filed Jul. 6, 2023)
Before HOLMES, Chief Judge, McHUGH, and EID,
Circuit Judges.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------EID, Circuit Judge.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Plaintiff-Appellants Dan Robert and Hollie Mulvihill are former members of the United States Armed
Forces who object to the military’s past COVID-19 vaccination requirement. They sued the Department of
Defense (“DoD”), the Food and Drug Administration,
and the Department of Health and Human Services,
claiming to bring the action on behalf of themselves
and all other similarly situated service members and
alleging that DoD lacked authority to require they receive a COVID-19 vaccine. The district court found
that the allegations were not justiciable, declined to
certify a class, denied a request for costs and attorneys’
fees, and dismissed the complaint. Robert and Mulvihill appealed. Exercising jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C.
§ 1291, we grant the government’s motion to dismiss
this case as moot.2
2
Another jurisdictional hurdle Appellants must clear is Article III standing. But “a federal court has leeway to choose among
threshold grounds for denying audience to a case on the merits.”
App. 3
I.
Appellants object to the military’s previous COVID19 vaccination requirement. When this suit was filed,
Robert was actively serving in the United States
Army and Mulvihill was actively serving in the United
States Marine Corps; both were subjected to the prior
vaccination requirement the time. Following litigation,
the district court dismissed their complaint as nonjusticiable. Appellants timely appealed. But after the
district court made its decision, Robert and Mulvihill
both separated from the Armed Forces. Before oral
argument, the government filed a motion contending that Appellants’ departure from the military moots
this case. The government also believes that legislative
and executive branch action offers another reason this
appeal is moot. On January 10, 2023, in accord with
the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year
2023, Secretary of Defense Lloyd J. Austin rescinded
the military’s COVID-19 vaccination requirement. Dep’t
of Def., Rescission of August 24, 2021 and November 30,
2021 Coronavirus Disease 2019 Vaccination Requirements for Members of the Armed Forces (Jan. 10, 2023),
available at https://perma.cc/L9L2-PF6F.3
Valenzuela v. Silversmith, 699 F.3d 1199, 1205 (10th Cir. 2012)
(cleaned up). We decline to address standing and resolve this case
on mootness concerns alone. See Dunn v. Austin, No. 22-15286,
2023 WL 2319316, at *1 (9th Cir. Feb. 27, 2023) (holding that
DoD’s rescission of the vaccination requirement mooted an appeal
of the denial of a preliminary injunction); Short v. Berger, No. 2215755, 2023 WL 2258384, at *1 (9th Cir. Feb. 24, 2023) (same).
3
On January 12, 2023, this Court directed the parties to file
simultaneous briefs addressing whether this appeal is moot due
App. 4
II.
“The Constitution gives federal courts the power
to adjudicate only genuine Cases and Controversies.”
Kerr v. Polis, 20 F.4th 686, 692 (10th Cir. 2021) (en
banc) (cleaned up). “This case-or-controversy requirement subsists through all stages of federal judicial proceedings . . . [and] requires a party seeking relief to
have suffered, or be threatened with, an actual injury
traceable to the appellee and likely to be redressed by
a favorable judicial decision by the appeals court.”
Prison Legal News v. Fed. Bureau of Prisons, 944 F.3d
868, 879 (10th Cir. 2019) (cleaned up). “Thus, even where
litigation poses a live controversy when filed, the doctrine requires a federal court to refrain from deciding
it if events have so transpired that the decision will
neither presently affect the parties’ rights nor have a
more-than-speculative chance of affecting them in the
future.” Schell v. OXY USA Inc., 814 F.3d 1107, 1114
(10th Cir. 2016) (cleaned up).
“Mootness is a threshold issue because the existence of a live case or controversy is a constitutional
prerequisite to federal court jurisdiction.” Id. at 1113
(cleaned up). “As Article III requires an actual controversy, we lack subject-matter jurisdiction over a case
that is moot. We review mootness determinations de
novo. A case becomes moot when the issues presented
are no longer live or the parties lack a legally cognizable interest in the outcome.” Smith v. Becerra, 44 F.4th
to the fact that Secretary Austin rescinded the COVID-19 vaccination requirement for military service members.
App. 5
1238, 1247 (10th Cir. 2022) (cleaned up). “The crucial
question is whether granting a present determination
of the issues offered . . . will have some effect in the real
world.” Id. (emphasis added) (cleaned up). “No matter
how vehemently the parties continue to dispute the
lawfulness of the conduct that precipitated the lawsuit,
the case is moot if the dispute is no longer embedded
in any actual controversy about the plaintiffs’ particular legal rights.” Id. (cleaned up).
III.
Robert and Mulvihill sought declaratory and injunctive relief, as well as costs and attorneys’ fees.
Their supplemental briefing before this Court does not
ask for back pay as a form of relief, but refers to Appellants losing opportunities and back wages due to DoD’s
rescinded COVID-19 vaccination requirement.
“We take a claim-by-claim approach to mootness
and must decide whether a case is moot as to each
form of relief sought.” Id. (cleaned up). “The defendant
bears the burden of establishing that a once-live case
has become moot.” Id. (cleaned up). “An injunctive relief claim becomes moot when the plaintiff ’s continued
susceptibility to injury is no longer reasonably certain
or is based on speculation and conjecture.” Id. (cleaned
up). “Similarly, a declaratory relief claim is moot if the
relief would not affect the behavior of the defendant
toward the plaintiff.” Id. (cleaned up).
App. 6
a.
We start with Appellants’ claim for declaratory
relief. Their complaint asked the district court to “declare that any order issued by DoD requiring the Plaintiffs to receive inoculation with COVID-19 vaccines
are per se unlawful.” App’x Vol. I at 30. This claim is
moot for two reasons. First, the claim is moot because
Appellants left military service. Schell, 814 F.3d at
1113 (cleaned up) (“[T]he existence of a live case or controversy is a constitutional prerequisite to federal
court jurisdiction.”). Mulvihill departed military service before oral argument, and Robert’s retirement was
completed shortly thereafter. Appellants cannot be
subjected to any vaccine requirement associated with
service in the military because they no longer serve in
the military. Smith, 44 F.4th at 1247 (cleaned up) (“A
case becomes moot when . . . the parties lack a legally
cognizable interest in the outcome.”). Thus, we lack jurisdiction over Appellants’ moot claim.
Second, Appellants’ claim is also moot because
Congress passed legislation requiring DoD to rescind
the COVID-19 vaccine mandate, and the Secretary of
Defense has since done so. See Dunn v. Austin, No. 2215286, 2023 WL 2319316, at *1 (9th Cir. Feb. 27, 2023);
Short v. Berger, No. 22-15755, 2023 WL 2258384, at *1
(9th Cir. Feb. 24, 2023). Appellants cannot be subject to
a vaccine requirement that no longer exists. Smith, 44
F.4th at 1247 (cleaned up) (“[T]he case is moot if the
dispute is no longer embedded in any actual controversy about the plaintiffs’ particular legal rights.”); see
also Schell, 814 F.3d at 1114 (cleaned up) (“Thus, even
App. 7
where litigation poses a live controversy when filed . . .
a federal court [must] refrain from deciding it if events
have so transpired that the decision will neither presently affect the parties’ rights nor have a more-thanspeculative chance of affecting them in the future.”).
It is true that federal courts recognize two exceptions to the mootness doctrine. “[U]nder the voluntary
cessation exception to mootness, a defendant cannot
automatically moot a case simply by ending its unlawful conduct once sued.” Prison Legal News, 944 F.3d at
880 (cleaned up). We “view voluntary cessation with a
critical eye, lest defendants manipulate jurisdiction to
insulate their conduct from judicial review.” Brown v.
Buhman, 822 F.3d 1151, 1166 (10th Cir. 2016) (cleaned
up). However, “[t]he voluntary cessation exception does
not apply, and a case is moot, if the defendant carries
the formidable burden of showing that it is absolutely
clear the allegedly wrongful behavior could not reasonably be expected to recur.” Prison Legal News, 944 F.3d
at 881 (cleaned up). “Even when a legislative body has
the power to reenact an ordinance or statute, ordinarily an amendment or repeal of it moots a case challenging the ordinance or statute.” Smith, 44 F.4th at 1250
(cleaned up).
The second exception is conduct capable of repetition yet evading review. Fleming v. Gutierrez, 785 F.3d
442, 445 (10th Cir. 2015). “Under this exception, which
courts reserve for exceptional situations, issues under
review are not moot if they (1) evade review because
the duration of the challenged action is too short to be
fully litigated prior to its cessation or expiration, and
App. 8
(2) are capable of repetition, such that there is a reasonable expectation that the same complaining party
will be subjected to the same action again.” Id. (cleaned
up).
Neither mootness exception saves this claim. The
voluntary cessation exception offers Appellants no relief because the government has met its arduous burden of showing the allegedly wrongful behavior could
not reasonably be expected to recur. Prison Legal
News, 944 F.3d at 881. Neither does the capable of
repetition but evading review exception benefit Appellants. The duration of the challenged action—here
DoD’s past vaccine mandate as applied to Robert and
Mulvihill—was not too short to be fully litigated before
its expiration. Fleming, 785 F.3d at 445. Furthermore,
nothing in the record leads to a reasonable expectation
they will be subjected to the same action again. Id. Appellants are no longer actively serving in the military
and the Secretary of Defense has rescinded the challenged policy. This is not the exceptional situation the
exception is designed for. Id.
b.
We turn to Robert and Mulvihill’s injunctive relief
claim. They asked the district court to “[e]njoin [ ] DoD
from vaccinating any service members. . . .” App’x
Vol. I at 31. This claim fares no better than the declaratory relief claim. Congress’s revocation of DoD’s vaccine mandate, and DoD’s implementation of Congress’s
App. 9
instruction, means there is no more vaccine mandate
to enjoin. The claim is therefore moot.
c.
Next, we address Appellants’ request for “costs
and attorneys’ fees.” App’x Vol. I at 31. Robert and
Mulvihill raised the matter below, but failed to discuss
it in their briefing before this Court. “We routinely
have declined to consider arguments that are not
raised, or are inadequately presented, in an appellant’s opening brief. . . .” Schneider v. City of Grand
Junction Police Dep’t, 717 F.3d 760, 773 (10th Cir.
2013) (cleaned up). “Stated differently, the omission of
an issue in an opening brief generally forfeits appellate
consideration of that issue.” Id. (cleaned up). We decline to consider Robert and Mulvihill’s request for
costs and attorneys’ fees.
d.
We finish our review with Appellants’ cursory
mention of lost opportunities and back pay. Robert and
Mulvihill’s supplemental briefing superficially alleges
they “continue to lose opportunities and back[ ]pay”
because of the now-rescinded vaccine mandate. Aplt.
Supp. Br. at 1. But they failed to allege lost opportunities or back pay in the district court. “[A]bsent extraordinary circumstances, arguments raised for the
first time on appeal are waived.” Little v. Budd Co.,
Inc., 955 F.3d 816, 821 (10th Cir. 2020), as corrected
(Apr. 6, 2020). “This is true whether the newly raised
App. 10
argument is a bald-faced new issue or a new theory on
appeal that falls under the same general category as
an argument presented at trial.” Id. (cleaned up). Robert and Mulvihill have waived any argument involving
lost opportunities or back pay.
IV.
We GRANT the government’s motion to dismiss
and DISMISS this appeal as moot.
Entered for the Court
Allison H. Eid
Circuit Judge
App. 11
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO
Judge Raymond P. Moore
Civil Action No. 21-cv-02228-RM-STV
DAN ROBERT, SSG, U.S. Army,
HOLLIE MULVIHILL, SSgt, U.S. Marine Corps,
and other similarly situated individuals,
Plaintiffs,
v.
LLOYD AUSTIN, in his official capacity as Secretary
of Defense, U.S. Department of Defense,
XAVIER BACERRA, in his official capacity as
Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services, and
JANET WOODCOCK, in her official capacity as
Acting Commissioner of the U.S. Food and Drug
Administration,
Defendants.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Filed Jan. 11, 2022)
Before the Court are Plaintiffs’ Motion for Preliminary Injunction (ECF No. 30) and Defendants’ Motion
to Dismiss (ECF No. 36), which they have combined
with their Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion with the
Court’s permission. Plaintiffs filed a Reply in support
of their Motion (ECF No. 43) and, belatedly, a separate
App. 12
Response to the Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 46). Defendants then filed a Reply (ECF No. 47) in support of
their Motion. Also pending is a Motion for Leave to File
Amicus Curiae (ECF No. 42), filed by Pritish Vora, “an
individual concerned U.S. citizen” who is not an attorney. For the reasons below, the Court denies Plaintiffs’
Motion, grants Defendants’ Motion, and denies the Motion for Leave.
I.
LEGAL STANDARDS
A. Preliminary Injunction
To obtain injunctive relief, a plaintiff must establish “(1) a substantial likelihood of prevailing on the
merits; (2) irreparable harm unless the injunction is
issued; (3) that the threatened injury outweighs the
harm that the preliminary injunction may cause the
opposing party; and (4) that the injunction, if issued,
will not adversely affect the public interest.” Diné Citizens Against Ruining Our Environment v. Jewell, 839
F.3d 1276, 1281 (10th Cir. 2016) (quotation omitted).
The final two requirements merge when the government is the opposing party. See Nken v. Holder, 556
U.S. 418, 435 (2009). An injunction is an extraordinary
remedy, and therefore the plaintiff must demonstrate
a right to relief that is clear and unequivocal. Schrier
v. Univ. of Colo., 427 F.3d 1253, 1258 (10th Cir. 2005).
The fundamental purpose of preliminary injunctive relief is to preserve the relative positions of the parties
until a trial on the merits can be held. Id.
App. 13
B. Motion to Dismiss
Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(1), a court may
dismiss a complaint for “lack of jurisdiction over the
subject matter.” “The general rule is that subject matter jurisdiction may be challenged by a party or raised
sua sponte by the court at any point in the proceeding.”
McAlester v. United Air Lines, Inc., 851 F.2d 1249, 1252
(10th Cir. 1988). Although the burden of establishing
subject matter jurisdiction is on the party asserting jurisdiction, “[a] court lacking jurisdiction must dismiss
the cause at any stage of the proceeding in which it
becomes apparent that jurisdiction is lacking.” Smith
v. Krieger, 643 F. Supp. 2d 1274, 1289 (D. Colo. 2009)
(quotation omitted).
In evaluating a motion to dismiss under Fed. R.
Civ. P. 12(b)(6), a court must accept as true all wellpleaded factual allegations in the complaint, view those
allegations in the light most favorable to the plaintiff,
and draw all reasonable inferences in the plaintiff’s
favor. Brokers’ Choice of Am., Inc. v. NBC Universal,
Inc., 757 F.3d 1125, 1136 (10th Cir. 2014); Mink v. Knox,
613 F.3d 995, 1000 (10th Cir. 2010). The complaint
must allege a “plausible” right to relief. Bell Atl. Corp.
v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 569 n.14 (2007); see also id.
at 555 (“Factual allegations must be enough to raise a
right to relief above the speculative level.”). Conclusory
allegations are insufficient, Cory v. Allstate Ins., 583
F.3d 1240, 1244 (10th Cir. 2009), and courts “are not
bound to accept as true a legal conclusion couched as a
factual allegation,” Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555 (quotation omitted).
App. 14
C. Leave to File a Brief as Amicus Curiae
Participation as an amicus to brief and argue as a
friend of the court is a privilege within the sound discretion of the courts and is contingent on a finding that
the proffered information of amicus is timely, useful, or
otherwise necessary to the administration of justice.
See United States v. Michigan, 940 F.2d 143, 165 (6th
Cir. 1991).
II.
BACKGROUND
Plaintiffs are members of the military who were
stationed in North Carolina when they brought this action on behalf of themselves as well as all other similarly situated active-duty National Guard and Reserve
service members who are subject to Department of Defense regulations and have been ordered by the Secretary of Defense, Defendant Austin, to take a Covid-19
vaccine. (ECF No. 29 at 1-2.) As “documented survivors
of Covid-19,” they assert that have acquired immunity
that is “at least as effective” as that achieved via vaccination, and they seek temporary and permanent injunctive relief preventing their forced vaccination. (Id.
at 2-3.) In addition to asserting class action allegations, the Amended Complaint asserts claims for (1)
violation of the Administrative Procedure Act, (2) violation of 10 U.S.C. § 1107, (3) violation of 10 U.S.C.
§ 1107a, (4) violation of 50 U.S.C. § 1520, and (5) violation of the Fourteenth Amendment.
App. 15
III. ANALYSIS
As a threshold matter, the Court finds there are
two—and only two—Plaintiffs in this case. Although
the Amended Complaint contains “class action allegations,” the Court has not certified any class, and Plaintiffs have not even filed a motion for class certification.
See Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(c)(1)(A) (“At an early practicable
time after a person sues . . . as a class representative,
the court must determine by order whether to certify
the action as a class action.” (emphasis added)). Plaintiffs’ attempt to incorporate two additional non-parties
via a footnote in their Reply (ECF No. 43 at 5 n.7) is
wholly inadequate. Thus, for present purposes, the
only relevant allegations are those pertaining to Plaintiffs Robert and Mulvihill.
The Court next considers the issues of standing
and ripeness, both in terms of whether Plaintiffs have
established a likelihood of success on the merits and
whether Defendants’ Motion should be granted. “The
doctrines of standing and ripeness substantially overlap in many cases.” S. Utah Wilderness Alliance v.
Palma, 707 F.3d 1143, 1157, (10th Cir. 2013). To satisfy
Article III’s standing requirements, a plaintiff must
show: (1) he has suffered an injury in fact that is (a)
concrete and particularized and (b) actual or imminent, not conjectural or hypothetical; (2) the injury is
fairly traceable to the challenged action of the defendant; and (3) it is likely, as opposed to merely
speculative, that the injury will be redressed by a favorable decision. Id. at 1153. In evaluating ripeness,
often characterized as standing on a timeline, “the
App. 16
central focus is on whether the case involves uncertain
or contingent future events that may not occur as anticipated, or indeed may not occur at all.” Id. at 1158
(quotation omitted).
Defendants assert that Plaintiffs’ claims are not
yet ripe because Plaintiff Robert has requested an exemption from the vaccination requirement, which remains pending, and Plaintiff Mulvihill has sought and
obtained a temporary medical exemption from the vaccination requirement. (ECF No. 36 at 13-14.) Moreover,
they argue, were the exemptions to be denied or expire,
the military has extensive administrative procedures
that offer Plaintiffs multiple opportunities to present
their arguments to their respective branches and allow
for those branches to respond. In response, Plaintiffs
contend that since Defendants control the exemption
process, “[i]t cannot be that [they] get to control the
federal court’s jurisdiction based upon [their] timing of
the exercise of [their] discretion.” (ECF No. 46 at 3,
¶ 5.) However, on the current record, the Court finds
there is no basis to assume that Plaintiffs’ exemptions
will be denied or revoked.
Under similar circumstances in Church v. Biden,
2021 WL 5179215, at *10 (D.D.C. Nov. 8, 2021), the
court concluded that two active-duty Marines’ claims
of harm rested on theories of injury that were speculative and contingent on their pending appeals being denied—an outcome that might never come to pass. In
finding the Marines’ claims nonjusticiable, the Church
court also cited the well-established principle that a
court should not review internal military affairs in the
App. 17
absence of exhaustion of available interservice corrective measures, concluding that “[g]ranting the urgent
injunctive relief sought by the Service Member Plaintiffs would require the Court to adjudicate internal
military affairs before the military chain of command
has had full opportunity to consider the accommodation requests at issue.” Id. at *10-11.
The Court agrees with the rationale in Church and
concludes that Plaintiffs’ claims involve uncertain and
contingent events that may not occur as anticipated.
As noted in the Court’s previous Order, Plaintiffs’ contention that they may be subject to discipline for refusing to take a vaccine appears to be based on nothing
more than speculation. Because Plaintiffs have not established that their claims are justiciable, a fortiori,
they cannot establish a likelihood of success on the
merits or a clear and unequivocal right to injunctive
relief. See id. at *8 (“The merits on which plaintiff must
show a likelihood of success encompass not only substantive theories but also establishment of jurisdiction.” (quotation omitted)). Moreover, in the absence of
a justiciable claim, Defendants are entitled to dismissal of this case.1
1
Separate and apart from this basis for dismissal of Plaintiffs’ claims, the Court notes the complete lack of allegations pertaining to any conduct by Defendants Bacerra and Woodcock,
sued in their official capacities as representatives of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the U.S. Food and
Drug Administration, respectively, that could be deemed to state
a claim against either entity.
App. 18
With respect to the Motion for Leave and the proposed amicus brief proffered by Pritish Vora, the Court
finds the information therein is not useful or otherwise
necessary to the administration of justice, and therefore the Court declines to consider it further.
IV. CONCLUSION
Accordingly, the Court DENIES Plaintiffs’ Motion
for Preliminary Injunction (ECF No. 30), GRANTS Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 37), and DENIES the Motion for Leave (ECF No. 42). The Clerk is
directed to CLOSE this case.
DATED this 11th day of January, 2022.
BY THE COURT:
/s/ Raymond P. Moore
RAYMOND P. MOORE
United States District Judge
App. 19
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO
Civil Action No. 21-cv-02228-RM-STV
DAN ROBERT, SSG, U.S. Army,
HOLLIE MULVIHILL, SSgt, U.S. Marine Corps,
and other similarly situated individuals,
Plaintiffs,
v.
LLOYD AUSTIN, in his official capacity as Secretary
of Defense, U.S. Department of Defense,
XAVIER BACERRA, in his official capacity as
Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services, and
JANET WOODCOCK, in her official capacity as
Acting Commissioner of the U.S. Food and Drug
Administration,
Defendants.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FINAL JUDGMENT
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Filed Jan. 11, 2022)
In accordance with the orders filed during the pendency of this case, and pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 58(a),
the following Final Judgment is hereby entered.
Pursuant to the Order (Doc. 48) of Judge Raymond
P. Moore entered on January 11, 2022, it is
App. 20
ORDERED that judgment is hereby entered in favor of Defendants Lloyd Austin, Xavier Bacerra, and
Janet Woodcock, and against Plaintiffs Dan Robert,
SSG, and Hollie Mulvihill, SSgt. It is
FURTHER ORDERED that this case is closed.
Dated at Denver, Colorado this 11th day of
January, 2022.
FOR THE COURT:
JEFFREY P. COLWELL, CLERK
s/C. Pearson, Deputy Clerk
App. 21
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DAN ROBERT, SSG, U.S.
Army, et al.,
Plaintiffs - Appellants,
v.
LLOYD J. AUSTIN, in his
official capacity as Secretary
of Defense, U.S. Department
of Defense, et al.,
No. 22-1032
(D.C. No.
1:21-CV-02228-RM-STV)
(D. Colo.)
Defendants - Appellees.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ORDER
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(Filed Aug. 30, 2023)
Before HOLMES, Chief Judge, McHUGH, and EID,
Circuit Judges.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appellants’ petition for rehearing is denied.
The petition for rehearing en banc was transmitted to all of the judges of the court who are in regular
active service. As no member of the panel and no judge
App. 22
in regular active service on the court requested that
the court be polled, that petition is also denied.
Entered for the Court
/s/ Christopher M. Wolpert
CHRISTOPHER M. WOLPERT, Clerk
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.