Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Michael Lee Mac Cleary, Petitioner v. United States
Supreme Court briefSep 26, 2023
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
APPENDIX
TABLE OF CONTENTS
APPENDIX A, Appendix A, Unpublished Memorandum
Disposition of the U.S. Court of Appeals
for the Ninth Circuit, April 25, 2023………………………………………………………1a
APPENDIX B, Order of the U.S. Court of
Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, denying
petition for rehearing en banc,
June 28, 2023................................................................................................................7a
APPENDIX C, Transcript of Sentencing
Hearing, November 1, 2021, U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of
California.......................................................................................................................8a
APPENDIX D, Compiled Medical Record……………………………………………….39a
(1 of 6)
Case: 21-50240, 04/25/2023, ID: 12702195, DktEntry: 40-1, Page 1 of 6
APPENDIX A
FILED
NOT FOR PUBLICATION
APR 25 2023
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
No.
Plaintiff-Appellee,
MOLLY C. DWYER, CLERK
U.S. COURT OF APPEALS
21-50240
D.C. No.
3:20-cr-02361-LAB-1
v.
MICHAEL LEE MAC CLEARY,
MEMORANDUM*
Defendant-Appellant.
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Southern District of California
Larry A. Burns, District Judge, Presiding
Submitted April 21, 2023**
Pasadena, California
Before: WARDLAW and KOH, Circuit Judges, and MCMAHON,*** District
Judge.
Michael Lee Mac Cleary pleaded guilty to knowing importation of
methamphetamine, in violation of 21 U.S.C. §§ 952 and 960. He was sentenced,
This disposition is not appropriate for publication and is not precedent
except as provided by Ninth Circuit Rule 36-3.
*
The panel unanimously concludes this case is suitable for decision
without oral argument. See Fed. R. App. P. 34(a)(2).
**
The Honorable Colleen McMahon, United States District Judge for
the Southern District of New York, sitting by designation.
***
1a
(2 of 6)
Case: 21-50240, 04/25/2023, ID: 12702195, DktEntry: 40-1, Page 2 of 6
principally, to a term of 84 months incarceration and a five-year term of supervised
release that included—among other conditions—a digital search condition.
Alleging procedural and substantive errors in connection with his sentence, Mac
Cleary appealed. We have jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1291, and we affirm. 1
1. The district court did not procedurally err in its consideration of Mac
Cleary’s medical condition. Mac Cleary’s claim for procedural unreasonableness is
reviewed for abuse of discretion. 2 Although Mac Cleary received inadequate
medical care for his colostomy bag in the past, the district court’s conclusion that
he was getting adequate medical treatment in the Bureau of Prisons at the time of
sentencing was “plausible, rational, and based on the record; therefore, it [was] not
clearly erroneous.” See United States v. Graf, 610 F.3d 1148, 1158 (9th Cir. 2010)
(citing United States v. Hinkson, 585 F.3d 1247, 1261 (9th Cir. 2009) (en banc)).
In particular, the note in Mac Cleary’s medical records concerning his colostomy
bag change—which mentions “ineffective health care maintenance”— refers to his
The parties are familiar with the facts of this case, so we include them only as
necessary to resolve the appeal.
1
The government argues that the procedural errors Mac Cleary alleges are subject
to plain error review because they were not raised below. See United States v.
Burgum, 633 F.3d 810, 812 (9th Cir. 2011). However, it appears that Mac Cleary’s
lawyer did not have a full opportunity to assert her objections, so plain error review
is inappropriate. Fed. R. Crim. P. 51(b); United States v. Martinez, 850 F.3d 1097,
1100 n.1 (9th Cir. 2017).
2
2a
(3 of 6)
Case: 21-50240, 04/25/2023, ID: 12702195, DktEntry: 40-1, Page 3 of 6
previous issues with inadequate medical care but does not mention continued
inadequacy.
2. The district court properly considered Mac Cleary’s childhood abuse
when evaluating the 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a) sentencing factors. The presentence
report indicates that Mac Cleary had suffered sexual abuse, which the court
expressly recognized in considering Mac Cleary’s history and characteristics.
Given the nature and seriousness of the offense, Mac Cleary’s extensive criminal
record, and that his conviction was for the same offense as his previous conviction
(only two years prior), the district court did not abuse its discretion by not giving
“a lot of weight” to Mac Cleary’s abuse as a child. See United States v. Stoterau,
524 F.3d 988, 1001–1002 (9th Cir. 2008) (explaining that abuse a defendant
suffered as a child, along with other considerations, did not render 151-month
sentence unreasonable).
3. The district court did not impose a substantively unreasonable sentence.
Mac Cleary’s sentence is not “shockingly high,” and there is nothing illogical or
“otherwise unsupportable” about the district court’s 84-month sentence. See United
States v. Ressam, 679 F.3d 1069, 1088 (9th Cir. 2012) (en banc) (quoting United
States v. Rigas, 583 F.3d 108, 123 (2d Cir. 2009)); see also Gallo v. United
States, 552 U.S. 38, 52 (2007) (“[T]hat the appellate court might reasonably have
3a
(4 of 6)
Case: 21-50240, 04/25/2023, ID: 12702195, DktEntry: 40-1, Page 4 of 6
concluded that a different sentence was appropriate is insufficient to justify
reversal of the district court.”).
Mac Cleary received a sentence at the low-end of the Sentencing Guidelines.
The district court expressly considered the range of sentencing factors, including
the nature and seriousness of the offense, as well as Mac Cleary’s history and
characteristics, and concluded that a within-Guidelines sentence was appropriate.
See United States v. Amezcua-Vasquez, 567 F.3d 1050, 1055 (9th Cir. 2009) (“[A]
Guidelines sentence will usually be reasonable.”) (internal quotation marks and
citations omitted). The offense was Mac Cleary’s sixth felony conviction and the
court found that it was part of a “pattern of continuing criminal activity” that was
“getting more serious.” Mac Cleary attempted to import distributable quantities of
methamphetamine twice in a span of two years, and he had not been deterred by a
lesser sentence.
4. The computer search condition in Mac Cleary’s written judgment is not
unlawful. Supervised release conditions are reviewed “deferentially, for abuse of
discretion.” United States v. Weber, 451 F.3d 552, 557 (9th Cir. 2006). Whether a
written judgment conflicts with an oral pronouncement of sentence is reviewed de
novo. United States v. Napier, 463 F.3d 1040, 1042 (9th Cir. 2006). Where a
district court’s oral pronouncement of sentence is “ambiguous,” the written
4a
(5 of 6)
Case: 21-50240, 04/25/2023, ID: 12702195, DktEntry: 40-1, Page 5 of 6
judgment controls to the extent that it clarifies that ambiguity. United States v.
Munoz-Dela Rosa, 495 F.2d 253, 256 (9th Cir. 1974).
The district court stated at the hearing that Mac Cleary would be “subject to
search of his person, his property, his residence, and his vehicle by the probation
officer.” The court’s written judgement merely clarifies what “property” was
subject to search, including not only “residence” and “vehicle” (both of which
were mentioned at sentencing), but also “house” and “papers,” as well as
“computers” and “electronic or digital storage devices.” At most, the court’s oral
pronouncement is ambiguous about whether the word “property,” includes
computers and digital storage devices. See United States v. Allen, 157 F.3d 661,
668 (9th Cir. 1998) (“[An oral sentence] is ambiguous when it is capable of two or
more different constructions, both of which are reasonable.”). But “where there is
an ambiguity in the oral pronouncement of a sentence, [the] unambiguous written
judgment controls.” Fenner v. U.S. Parole Com’n, 251 F.3d 782, 787 (9th Cir.
2001); see also Green v. United States, 447 F.2d 987, 987 (9th Cir. 1971) (“That
the sentence in writing should be referred to in order to resolve ambiguities in the
oral pronouncement is well settled.”).
Mac Cleary alternatively argues that the district court erred in imposing the
computer search condition because the court did not articulate a nexus between the
search condition and the sentencing goals set forth at 18 U.S.C. § 3583(d). “The
5a
(6 of 6)
Case: 21-50240, 04/25/2023, ID: 12702195, DktEntry: 40-1, Page 6 of 6
law only requires some nexus between the computer search condition and
furthering ‘the goal of deterrence, protection of the public, or rehabilitation of the
offender.’” United States v. Bare, 806 F.3d 1011, 1019 (9th Cir. 2015) (quoting
United States v. T.M., 330 F.3d 1235, 1240 (9th Cir. 2003)).
The search condition here applies only if “reasonable suspicion exists that
the offender has violated a condition of his supervision and that the areas to be
searched contain evidence of this violation,” and the supervised release conditions
are themselves designed to deter the defendant from further criminal conduct, to
protect the public, and to encourage defendant’s successful rehabilitation. See
United States v. King, 608 F.3d 1122, 1131 (9th Cir. 2010) (affirming a
reasonable-suspicion-based search condition as “reasonably related to protecting
the public and preventing recidivism”). Accordingly, the required nexus between
the search condition and the goals of probation is satisfied.
AFFIRMED.
6a
Case: 21-50240, 06/28/2023, ID: 12744603, DktEntry: 44, Page 1 of 1
APPENDIX B
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
FILED
JUN 28 2023
MOLLY C. DWYER, CLERK
U.S. COURT OF APPEALS
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
No.
Plaintiff-Appellee,
21-50240
D.C. No.
3:20-cr-02361-LAB-1
Southern District of California,
San Diego
v.
MICHAEL LEE MAC CLEARY,
ORDER
Defendant-Appellant.
Before: WARDLAW and KOH, Circuit Judges, and MCMAHON,* District Judge.
The panel has unanimously voted to deny the petition for panel rehearing.
The petition for panel rehearing is DENIED.
*
The Honorable Colleen McMahon, United States District Judge for
the Southern District of New York, sitting by designation.
7a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.174 Page 1 of 31
APPENDIX C
1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
2
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
3
4
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
5
Plaintiff,
6
v.
7
MICHAEL LEE MAC CLEARY,
8
Defendant.
_________________________________
9
10
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
No. 20-CR-2361-LAB
November 1, 2021
12:09 p.m.
San Diego, California
TRANSCRIPT OF SENTENCING
BEFORE THE HONORABLE LARRY ALAN BURNS
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
11
12
APPEARANCES:
13
For the Plaintiff:
UNITED STATES ATTORNEYS OFFICE
By: LYNDZIE MARIE CARTER, ESQ.
880 Front Street
San Diego, California 92101
For the Defendant:
FEDERAL DEFENDERS OF SAN DIEGO, INC.
By: ZAINAB KHAN, ESQ.
225 Broadway
San Diego, California 92101
Court Reporter:
CYNTHIA R. OTT, RDR, CRR
District Court Clerk's Office
333 West Broadway, Suite 420
San Diego, California, 92101
cynthia_ott@casd.uscourts.gov
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Reported by Stenotype, Transcribed by Computer
8a
1
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.175 Page 2 of 31
1
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA, NOVEMBER 1, 2021, 12:09 P.M.
2
3
* * * *
THE CLERK:
Calling number 13 on the calendar,
4
20-CR-2361, United States of America versus Michael Lee
5
Mac Cleary.
6
If counsel could state their appearance, please.
MS. KHAN:
Good afternoon, Your Honor.
Zainab Khan
7
from Federal Defenders, appearing for Mr. Mac Cleary.
8
apologize for making the Court wait.
9
Battaglia arguing motions in limine.
THE COURT:
Okay.
11
MS. CARTER:
Good afternoon, Your Honor.
Lyndzie
Carter on behalf of the United States.
13
THE COURT:
14
Mr. Mac Cleary is present.
15
I
I was in with Judge
10
12
All right.
Ms. Carter, good afternoon.
Good morning,
Mr. Mac Cleary.
16
THE DEFENDANT:
17
THE COURT:
Good morning, sir.
This matter is on for sentencing.
18
Mr. Mac Cleary has pled guilty to importing methamphetamine.
19
One of the things that I've reviewed to prepare for sentencing
20
is a presentence report.
21
22
Ms. Khan, did you go over the presentence report with
your client.
23
MS. KHAN:
I did, Your Honor.
24
THE COURT:
Here's what else I have looked at and
25
2
considered.
First, a sentencing memorandum, filed on behalf of
9a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.176 Page 3 of 31
3
1
the defendant.
2
Mr. Mac Cleary, which I've looked at, and some medical records.
3
I have reviewed all of those.
4
Attached to that is a letter from
The defense sentencing recommendation is contained in
5
their sentencing memo.
6
summary chart, which includes their recommendation.
7
looked at that as well.
8
The government filed a sentencing
I have
The defendant's filed objections to the presentence
9
report.
And those objections have been responded to by a
10
probation officer in an addendum.
11
reviewed.
12
submitted beyond -- beyond what I reviewed?
So those are the things I've
Have I failed to mention anything that either side
13
MS. KHAN:
No, Your Honor.
14
MS. CARTER:
No, Your Honor.
15
THE COURT:
Okay.
16
First are factual objections to paragraphs 7 and 9.
Let me start with the objections.
17
Paragraph 7 says that following his arrest, the defendant
18
admitted his involvement in the drug smuggling venture.
19
started by telling agents he'd been released from county jail
20
in May for a previous smuggling conviction.
21
He
He noted he was placed in a hotel upon his release due
22
to the pandemic, included that he was able to extend his stay
23
at the hotel with financial assistance from a family member.
24
And the objection is that looking at the videotape of his
25
post-arrest statement, he didn't state that he was placed in a
10a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.177 Page 4 of 31
4
1
hotel upon his release from custody, but instead said he was
2
homeless until he was able to stay at the hotel.
3
None of that will affect the Court's sentencing
4
discretion on this, whatever the reasons were for him being at
5
the hotel, so I'll resolve that that way.
6
Paragraph 57 contains another factual objection.
And
7
in 57, it's reported that when the defendant was arrested for a
8
previous smuggling offense at the border, that a week before he
9
was arrested for that offense, which was, by the way, August
10
2nd, 2019, he was involved in a physical altercation with
11
someone in Tijuana, a man.
12
He stated he had no knowledge that the male was
13
somehow connected to the local cartel.
After he -- after the
14
altercation, he was telephonically contacted by the man, told
15
if he wanted to avoid his group from taking revenge, he'd have
16
to unlawfully transport drugs.
17
The defendant agreed, a taxi cab picked him up, took
18
him to an apartment complex where he was given eight packages
19
which were taped to his legs and groin.
20
then sent him to the border.
21
Mexican pesos for cab fare and trolley fare.
22
received a smuggling payment.
23
defendant made an unsolicited statement that he committed the
24
crime for the sole purpose of financial gain.
25
The taxi cab driver
And he admitted he was given 650
He denied he
During fingerprinting, the
The objection is that he didn't make an unsolicited
11a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.178 Page 5 of 31
1
statement that he committed the crime for financial gain.
2
says he was under duress, so he maintains that.
3
to the offense in state court?
4
MS. KHAN:
Yes, Your Honor.
5
THE COURT:
All right.
5
He
He pled guilty
The Court will rely on the
6
guilty plea, rather than any of the attending circumstances of
7
what the defendant said.
8
that he was criminally liable for the crime of importing drugs
9
into the United States on that occasion.
10
The guilty plea, of course, admits
He was given a 16-month sentence that he served, so
11
that's the way I'll resolve that.
12
generally, Ms. Khan, on behalf of Mr. Mac Cleary.
13
MS. KHAN:
I'm happy to hear from you
Yes, of course, Your Honor.
Your Honor, I
14
don't think Your Honor addressed some other factual objections
15
made in my first objection.
16
that, you know, he didn't say he intended to transport the
17
drugs to Apple Valley.
18
statement, and I just wanted to make that clear as well.
I just wanted to bring them forth,
I reviewed them myself, the post-arrest
19
THE COURT:
20
I'm sorry I jumped over that.
21
And the defendant explained he intended to smuggle the
22
methamphetamine and transport the drugs to Apple Valley.
23
What did he say with regard to that?
24
MS. KHAN:
25
Oh, okay.
Well, let me back up, then.
Let's see.
That's paragraph 9.
Your Honor, he said that he had heard that
someone could sell drugs for more money if sold in northern
12a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.179 Page 6 of 31
1
California.
2
know where the drugs would be sold.
3
And that near the end, he reiterated he didn't
THE COURT:
Okay.
There's no objection to paragraph
4
8, though, right?
5
In paragraph 8, he says that, once he received the drugs, his
6
friend, Mirabelle, helped him package them, so that he could
7
transport them.
8
Then took a taxi cab to cross the border.
You didn't list an objection to paragraph 8.
He placed the packages on his body himself.
9
MS. KHAN:
No, I don't object to that.
10
THE COURT:
Okay.
Well, I'll consider all that in
11
context of 8 and 9 together, and 7, for that matter.
12
accept your exception that he didn't definitively say he was
13
going to Apple Valley to distribute the drugs.
But I'll
14
MS. KHAN:
Thank you, Your Honor.
15
THE COURT:
So, Ms. Khan, I'm happy to hear from you,
MS. KHAN:
Thank you, Your Honor.
16
then.
17
Your Honor,
18
admittedly, I recognize that some of the circumstances of this
19
case would give the Court pause.
20
and, you know, the circumstances of his arrest.
21
recognize that.
22
sentence, Your Honor, is that I do believe that Mr. Mac Cleary
23
has certainly looked at what his actions were in the past two
24
years.
25
6
Of course, his recent prior
I certainly
The reason I'm asking for a three-year
He wrote what I thought was a wonderful letter to the
13a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.180 Page 7 of 31
7
1
Court, admitting that -- you know, accepting responsibility for
2
what he did previously, and then what he did in this case.
3
You know, he -- you know, hadn't -- I think he had a
4
difficult situation occur, and a case resulted state side.
5
then he, you know, left custody in the middle -- right when the
6
pandemic and everything shut down in March of 2020.
7
And
And he wasn't getting his Social Security disability
8
insurance.
He was in a lot of pain, he needed health care
9
certainly.
I've included a lot of medical records or a summary
10
of the medical records that Mr. Mac Cleary was dealing with.
11
Mr. Mac Cleary has been dealing with pain all his
12
life.
You know, he was in a crane accident about a decade ago,
13
and a crane hit him in his back.
14
spine.
It certainly messed up his
It provided -- it produced a lot of injuries.
15
And after that, he sustained a car accident in which,
16
again, he suffered through a lot of injuries for that as well.
17
And then he suffered a gunshot wound to his back as well.
18
mean, there's been repeated hemorrhaging of his back certainly.
19
I
Since then he has had to manage his pain through
20
opioids.
And it's been extremely, extremely difficult for him
21
just to live a life of constant pain.
22
He's also, you know, dealt with a lot growing up.
23
think Mr. Mac Cleary, you know, when he was younger, he was
24
unfortunately molested at a very young age by a neighbor.
25
I
And he -- you know, he acted out in ways when he was
14a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.181 Page 8 of 31
8
1
younger that had his parents put him into psychiatric treatment
2
and other things like that.
3
derailed him from finishing school.
4
deal with those emotions.
5
he had this terrible work accident.
6
And it took a -- you know, it
He wasn't able to properly
And then he began working, and then
And he, unfortunately, also due to his pain, became
7
addicted to methamphetamine.
8
in Mr. Mac Cleary's life that has led him to this point.
9
will also note, Your Honor, when Mr. Mac Cleary was arrested in
10
this case, I recognize he understood the COVID pandemic was
11
occurring, conditions of confinement were harsh, but, you know,
12
he took this action during a pandemic.
13
So there's been a lot happening
I
I recognize that.
However, he did have a colostomy bag when he entered
14
custody, and it was not properly cared for.
15
recognize, and I know the Court said this in other cases, where
16
our clients, you know, go into custody during the pandemic,
17
having committed a crime during the pandemic, they are aware
18
that conditions will be harsh.
19
So I certainly can
Certainly, I think that there may be some truth to
20
that certainly, but I do think that here, there was a complete
21
lack of medical care.
22
just nose dived since he entered custody.
23
of COVID.
24
e-mail the marshals multiple times to talk to the facilities to
25
get him new changes to colostomy bags.
Mr. Mac Cleary has -- his health has
And not for purposes
His colostomy bag was not getting changed.
15a
I had to
And he would wake up in
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.182 Page 9 of 31
9
1
his mess repeatedly.
2
how his colostomy bag site became infected, and it led to other
3
symptoms as well.
4
And, you know, the medical records detail
It ended up becoming that, you know, I really pushed
5
for a surgery to occur for his colostomy bag to be removed.
6
And when that eventually happened months and months later of
7
Mr. Mac Cleary suffering, they did remove it.
8
realized that due to the lack of care that had occurred, it
9
produced other -- other symptoms as well and other illnesses.
10
He -- you know, I can tell you that I met
But then they
11
Mr. Mac Cleary when he was first arrested.
12
now, he looks completely different.
13
know, he's been in the hospital for months.
14
this sentencing for several months because he's been in the
15
hospital.
16
And what he looks
He has certainly -- you
We've continued
It's my understanding that he has another operation
17
scheduled for April.
18
really wanted to be sentenced.
19
for him.
20
that he could go to a medical facility.
21
little bit easier than being at the hospital, because they put
22
his legs in handcuffs, his hands in handcuffs the entire time.
23
So I thought -- and Mr. Mac Cleary just
It's been a very anxious time
And he also wanted to, you know, be designated, so
And it would be a
He's actually gotten two blood clots in his legs
24
because of that, and he will have to be operated on for that as
25
well.
So it's just been a very difficult time for him,
16a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.183 Page 10 of 31
10
1
medically speaking.
2
this crime, and that there has to be punishment.
3
asking for three years, which is certainly more than what he
4
did last time.
5
asking for that is so that he can, you know, get the care that
6
he needs while in BOP custody, but then also, you know, the
7
after care is not a burden upon the BOP, but instead he uses
8
his Social Security and disability benefits to get the care
9
that he needs, once he's released.
10
And, Your Honor, I recognize he committed
And we're
And you know I think the reason that we're
I also included that, you know, he became infected
11
with COVID-19 during this time as well.
12
that's been happening with Mr. Mac Cleary, in terms of his
13
health.
So he's been in custody for about 15 months and 20
14
days now.
You know, there was a very low amount of drugs
15
involved in this case, about 394 grams of methamphetamine was
16
found on his person.
17
So there's been a lot
He completed Safety Valve successfully.
Due to his
18
health issues and just the things that he's faced in his life,
19
including the sexual abuse at the age of 11, including the loss
20
of his only child.
21
three from a SIDS-like incident.
22
devastating to him.
23
the mother of his deceased child.
24
25
His daughter passed away at the age of
And this was extremely
And it really ended his partnership with
And I think it's just been one thing after another.
And he certainly hasn't helped himself by engaging in this type
17a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.184 Page 11 of 31
11
1
of conduct, but he has certainly -- and when he speaks, it will
2
be clear that he certainly does not want to live the rest of
3
his life in jail.
4
I think even the crane injury, even the car accident,
5
and everything else that he's been through, the pain
6
management, his current hospitalization has been much worse
7
than what he's ever experienced before.
8
And it's left upon him that his life is short and he
9
doesn't want to spend it in jail.
10
has been deterred.
11
stay, Your Honor.
12
13
So he certainly, I think,
And that's why we're asking for a 36-month
If you have any other questions, we're happy to answer
them.
14
THE COURT:
All right.
Thank you, Ms. Khan.
15
Mr. Mac Cleary, what do you have to say on your own behalf this
16
morning?
17
THE DEFENDANT:
I want to get across the part that I
18
don't want to stay in jail.
19
the same room.
20
and handcuffs on him.
21
There's a man that's next to me in
He's 68 years old, and they're putting chains
I want no part of that.
I -- obviously, I haven't taken advantage of anything
22
that anybody has done for me in the past.
23
mean?
24
you do with vinegar, and I've had vinegar my whole life.
25
But I get it.
And you know what I
You know, you get more with honey than
I have -- I'm encouraged -- I'd like to tell you that
18a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.185 Page 12 of 31
12
1
I want to go to school to learn how to cut hair, while I'm on
2
probation, when I come out.
3
successful, you know, that's -- I'm done.
You know, I mean, and be
4
I mean, you will never see me again.
5
You hear that all the time, and they come back to you.
6
a 99 percent recidivism rate.
7
because I was in the Feds before.
8
the people go back.
9
within the first year.
10
the COVID, you know, I thought I could get away with it.
11
be honest.
12
And I get it.
There's
But I beat probation last time,
And, you know, 99 percent of
I was one of four that didn't go back
12 years later, I messed up because of
I'll
You know what I mean?
And I don't know that -- what I thought success was,
13
but I for sure didn't anticipate staying in jail.
And then
14
going to the hospital, and being in the hospital.
I've been in
15
there six months, handcuffed to a bed 23 and a half hours a
16
day.
17
can barely walk.
18
And that's real harsh.
The food is better, but I mean, I
I'm on this -- one of them walker things.
This is the
19
first time I've walked with a cane in six months.
20
want to come in here in a wheelchair.
21
wheelchair out there, because I'm proud.
22
that, hey, I'm going to do this, because, for no other reason,
23
that people don't believe that I'll do it.
24
like that.
25
I didn't
You know, I left the
I just wanted to show
I'm hard-headed
You know, I live in Mexico, because I can't afford to
19a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.186 Page 13 of 31
1
live in San Diego.
2
what I mean?
3
across the border versus $2,000.
4
Security.
5
That's the God's honest truth.
13
You know
It's $250 for a one-bedroom apartment right
And I get $950 Social
So there's no money there.
And I didn't do the best -- I mean, I made mistakes.
6
I rushed it.
7
more money, I think, on my Social Security, but I didn't.
8
didn't do a lot of things.
9
And, you know, I get it.
10
-- I've been warned by Homeland Security that if they catch me
11
again, they're going to whisper in your ear that I don't
12
deserve to come out.
13
THE COURT:
14
I did all kinds of stuff when I could have gotten
I
And I aim to make corrections.
Two strikes, and you know, you're on
And I would agree with that.
Well, let me assure you, they don't
contact me or whisper in my ear or anything.
15
THE DEFENDANT:
16
THE COURT:
17
may have said that.
I'm telling you what they told me.
It sounds like an idle threat that they
18
THE DEFENDANT:
19
THE COURT:
20
THE DEFENDANT:
It worked.
Okay.
Anything else?
Other than thank you, Ms. Khan, for
21
everything that you've done and said on my behalf.
22
for that.
23
going forward, sir.
24
THE COURT:
25
behalf of the United States?
I thank you
And anything you could do, you know what I mean,
All right.
20a
Thank you, Mr. Mac Cleary.
On
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.187 Page 14 of 31
1
MS. CARTER:
Thank you, Your Honor.
14
The government
2
isn't recommending minor role in this case.
3
recommending the minus four Fast Track.
4
criminal history, as the Court is aware, spanning from 1984 to
5
2019, but he did accept responsibility for his offense
6
immediately in the post-arrest.
7
agreement within two months.
8
However, we are
He has a significant
And I believe signed his plea
We're also recommending the minus two variance for the
9
waiver of indictment.
10
relates to that.
11
further variance down to 60 months.
12
I understand the Court's position as it
And then ultimately, we are requesting a
As Ms. Khan had indicated, this is a small amount, 394
13
grams actual.
14
addiction problem, and has significant medical issues.
The
15
government appreciated his letter that he had written.
It
16
was -- it came across as very genuine, but given the criminal
17
history that he has, the fact that he committed this offense a
18
month after being released from the state after a smuggling
19
conviction, the government is submitting that a 60-month
20
sentence would be appropriate in his case.
21
I recognize that the defendant does have an
THE COURT:
I think it was a little bit longer, wasn't
22
it?
23
the probation report.
24
so it was a short time, but more than a month.
25
He was released in March of 2020, March 23rd, according to
MS. CARTER:
And he committed this offense in August,
Thank you, Your Honor.
21a
That is correct.
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.188 Page 15 of 31
15
1
So on that, Your Honor, we would submit on our recommendation.
2
We would defer to the Court for any further variances, given
3
the medical outline that the defense counsel has submitted to
4
the Court.
5
THE COURT:
All right.
Thank you.
The Court finds as
6
follows:
7
involved the importation of methamphetamine, two levels are
8
added.
9
minor role, nor has the defense.
10
brief, and there's no argument that's been made.
11
The base offense level here is a 32.
Because this
As the prosecutor points out, they have not recommended
I've read the sentencing
I don't know that I'm required to address that sua
12
sponte, but given the fact that the defendant had committed a
13
very similar offense in 2019, the year before, I would not be
14
inclined to find minor role in consideration of the 3B factors
15
and his criminal record overall.
16
moot.
17
But, again, I think it's
Neither side has recommended minor role here.
The government has recommended Safety Valve.
The
18
defendant, under the current guidelines, is not eligible for
19
Safety Valve, so the Court will follow that recommendation, but
20
do so by giving the defendant a variance, rather than
21
correctly -- rather than calculating as part of the guidelines,
22
which would be an incorrect calculation at this point.
23
remain at 34.
24
25
So we
Three points come off for acceptance, four points
comes off for Fast Track.
22a
I grant that adjustment and that
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.189 Page 16 of 31
1
departure.
2
just -- just the guidelines.
3
find that the defendant's offense level, then, is actually 27,
4
not 25.
5
So from 34, seven points come off.
16
And this is
Seven points come off.
He's in criminal history category IV.
And I
And these
6
guidelines, I find, are a hundred to 125 months, rather than 84
7
to 105, as listed in the government's sentencing summary chart.
8
Turning to the 3553 factors, and keeping in mind the
9
guidelines, the Court first adjusts downward -- varies downward
10
two levels to account for the Fast Track.
11
I do so because there's now a conflict between the
12
criteria for -- I'm sorry, Fast Track -- Safety Valve.
13
now a conflict between the current guidelines and the First
14
Step Act regarding what qualifies for Safety Valve.
15
defendant would qualify under the latter, but does not qualify
16
under the present iteration of the guidelines, but it seems to
17
me it's a matter of time before that gets corrected.
18
There's
The
The Sentencing Commission does not have a quorum at
19
this point, so it can't take that action, but everyone
20
anticipates that it will.
21
variance is warranted, because the defendant gave a full
22
account of his involvement.
23
case would not be disqualifying.
24
105 on the guidelines.
25
In all events, I find that a
And the record under the Lopez
So that gets us down to 84 to
I find that this offense is serious, not because of
23a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.190 Page 17 of 31
17
1
the amount of drugs involved.
2
this is -- it kind of pales in comparison to cases that, even
3
this day, I've had.
4
methamphetamine.
5
As the prosecutor points out,
The last one was 86 kilos of
Another one was 54 kilos.
This fellow, you know, compared to them is a piker.
6
But what does set him apart is he's got a long record.
7
told that, well, it's -- you know, a lot of this is due to his
8
addiction, but -- and the addiction was due to his health
9
problems, but the record sort of belies that, in my judgment.
10
He began committing crimes at 18 years old, and he's
11
now 55.
12
These were misdemeanor charges.
13
He was arrested in 1984 at age 18.
I'm
Again, in '88.
In 2002, before the onset of these medical problems,
14
he was convicted of possessing methamphetamine as a felony
15
charge, and was given a probationary sentence for that.
16
that, as far as I can tell from his history and what's
17
self-reported, as well as in the medical records and police
18
report -- I'm sorry, probation report, all of that preceded --
19
the possession of methamphetamine preceded any addiction to
20
drugs caused by an injury.
21
And
2003, again, preceding the onset of the medical
22
problems, he's convicted of delivering methamphetamine.
23
years custody suspended, two years, probation.
24
Willful injury and causing bodily injury.
25
felony.
10
On and on.
He pled guilty to a
The probation report notes that there were three
24a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.191 Page 18 of 31
1
18
victims involved.
2
2004, an assault.
Again, in 2004, this is the federal
3
conviction the defendant alluded to, possession of a firearm by
4
a convicted felon.
5
make it through supervised release without being violated.
He did 46 months.
As he points out, he did
6
2010, minor offense, driver's license or something.
7
2012, he pled guilty to possessing K2 and marijuana, under an
8
ounce.
And also some kind of traffic offense.
9
But by 2019, you know, he's back to serious bad
10
behavior.
11
actus reus is concerned, very similar circumstances to this
12
crime.
13
He's in almost -- well, at least, as far as the
He's in the pedestrian lanes at San Ysidro.
He comes
14
by, and he gets caught with 520 grams of methamphetamine
15
strapped to his thigh.
16
And to his groin.
And then he tells this pretty fantastic story about
17
coming to the aid of someone.
18
oh, they're going to come after him.
19
really explained.
20
says about how he was struggling to get by.
21
hotel for 250.
22
had a cell phone or something, but to tell you the truth,
23
Ms. Khan, the whole thing seemed contrived to me.
24
25
And then getting a call that,
And none of that is
And particularly curious in light of what he
He 's living in a
I don't know how they reached him.
Maybe he
In all events, without regard to the facts, he pled
guilty and he was given 16 months.
25a
I note, and according to
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.192 Page 19 of 31
1
2
19
the probation report, he only served six months of that.
And I don't know if it was because he was released
3
early, the release date was right at the beginning of the
4
pandemic, March 23rd, 2020.
5
halftime credit, but even with that, he was sentenced 9/16/19,
6
and he's out in March, which is about six months.
7
even less than the halftime credits.
8
would be eight months.
9
I understand the state court gives
So that's
Halftime on 16 months
He did less than that.
And in all events, you've pointed to that as the
10
sentence, and it does not provide a benchmark for me,
11
particularly because the halftime credits, and I don't know the
12
circumstances, but the state court sentences are typically
13
very, very low.
14
I don't know whether they take into account his
15
criminal history or not.
16
practiced in state court, criminal history used to be part of
17
the equation in the sentence, but who knows what goes on now.
18
Maybe they do.
They used to.
When I
In all events, I don't consider it a benchmark for the
19
sentence imposed here, which is imposed with consideration of
20
the advisory guidelines and 3553 factors.
21
In terms of his history and characteristics, I'd note
22
that he does have substantial medical issues.
23
corroborated by the medical reports in this case.
24
points out, up to this point, he's been on a walker.
25
and he obviously needs additional medical attention.
26a
Those are
And as he
You know,
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.193 Page 20 of 31
1
20
I paid attention as you described his particular
2
problem with the colostomy and the bag, and the bag not being
3
treated correctly.
4
And I do have that in mind as well.
5
I think that's been resolved at this point.
But, at the same time, his criminal history is -- is
6
mixed.
7
some adversities in life.
8
And he's 55 years old.
9
-- and I don't mean to discount that, but you know, there's
10
been a lot of water under the bridge since that happened as a
11
child.
12
I don't give a lot of weight to that factor.
13
upsetting and tragic that he lost a child.
14
mind.
15
I'm sorry, his personal history is mixed.
You mentioned he lost a daughter.
I don't know when he was molested, but
And he's now 55, and been in jail many, many times.
not a fake in any respect.
17
condition.
18
accidents and dope addiction.
So
And it's -- it's
I have that in
And then I have his physical condition in mind.
16
19
He's had
It's
He's not faking any kind of medical
He's truly suffered from injuries in the past and
You know, I note that his purpose here was to cross
20
methamphetamine in order to sell it.
21
in his personal statement to me.
22
he writes, planned to walk across the border, so I could take
23
it into the U.S. and make some good money.
24
25
He even reiterates that
I got 330 grams of crystal,
So he was going to distribute this.
matter of crossing.
It wasn't just a
It wasn't a personal use amount.
27a
He
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.194 Page 21 of 31
21
1
intended to make money off of it.
2
what he says about his financial condition, that provides some
3
explanation.
4
a variance down to 30 months is -- or 36 months is warranted,
5
given his criminal record and the fact that, you know, he did
6
this not a month later, but about three months or four months
7
after he got out, he did the same thing again.
8
And I suppose in light of
But with all respect, Ms. Khan, I don't find that
And, you know, the larger picture is, it's just a
9
pattern of continuing criminal conduct.
10
serious.
11
he's here, notwithstanding the small amount, because, you know,
12
they tried by sending him to state court.
13
lenient sentence.
14
we're not going to do that again.
15
actual reasoning is, but you know, that would make sense to me.
16
So I decline to vary down to 36 months.
17
And it's getting more
Now he's back in federal court again.
He got six months.
And I assume
And he got a fairly
And they said, you know,
I don't know what their
The government's asked me to vary down to 60 months.
18
And they point out that, well, he waived his right -- he waived
19
his right to appeal, Speedy Trial Act provisions.
20
noted, Ms. Khan, I've not accepted that justification for a
21
variance before.
22
a fellow who was in custody, in custody during the pandemic.
23
He was released in March, right at the beginning of the
24
pandemic, but we knew about it.
25
it.
As you've
Let's put this in its proper context.
28a
Here's
And he must have known about
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.195 Page 22 of 31
1
22
And, again, I don't know this for sure, but it's
2
possible that his early release from custody -- appears to be
3
early was on account of the pandemic.
4
began, here, I was the chief judge.
5
in custody.
We made a concerted effort to cull the jail
6
population.
We got it down to 1900.
7
the same thing.
8
At the time the pandemic
We had over 3,000 people
Maybe the state court did
It was a dangerous place to be.
But who knew that best?
The defendant.
The defendant
9
knew that best.
10
And it was not a place where you wanted to be in close contact
11
during the pandemic.
12
subjects himself to being arrested again, with the natural and
13
probable consequence that he would go back to jail, and be back
14
in that same condition.
15
He was in custody with all of these folks.
And yet months later, he goes out and
So for the government to say, well, number one, you
16
know, give him a variance because of COVID.
17
time, place, and manner to do this.
18
15th to do this.
19
that point, particularly the defendant.
20
defendant.
21
22
He picked the
He picked the date of July
Everyone was well aware of the pandemic at
Particularly the
And yet he did this then.
Second -- no, no, I've heard from you fully, Ms. Khan,
I'm not going to revisit this.
23
Second, the idea that he waived his right to a speedy
24
trial.
You know, look, he waived that by pleading guilty.
25
everyone knows that it's black letter law, Tollett versus
29a
And
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.196 Page 23 of 31
23
1
Henderson decided by the Supreme Court in 1973 makes clear that
2
all nonjurisdictional claims, including, in particular, speedy
3
trial claims, are waived when one pleads guilty.
4
So if he tried to raise that, it would, you know,
5
immediately run up against that legal obstacle.
6
second, what were we supposed to do?
7
Ninth Circuit has not said we were supposed to be trying cases
8
in the middle of the pandemic.
9
April.
10
because he picked the, you know, onset of the pandemic to
11
commit this offense, and then gave up certain rights, I reject
12
both of those as basis for a variance.
13
Second --
Well, we know that the
They decided the Olson case in
So the idea that he's entitled to some kind of credit
You've asked me to consider his medical condition and
14
his hardships that I've already referred to as a basis for
15
further variance.
16
the first variance for Safety Valve are 84 to 105 months.
17
There's nothing, nothing that says that there's a presumption
18
that I have to give the low end of the guidelines.
19
guideline range is to be considered.
20
consider and weigh the equities that are argued in favor of the
21
defendant, and those that cut against him.
22
And here, I've done that.
Now, the guidelines here, even giving him
The
And the Court's to
You know, if it weren't for
23
the equities, I'd certainly be at 105 months on this case.
24
Even though it's a smaller amount, the defendant's criminal
25
record, and the fact that he'd just done this, and just been
30a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.197 Page 24 of 31
1
punished before would push me to find that this was an
2
aggravated case.
3
24
I am taking into consideration all of the equities
4
that you wrote about, the things that he's mentioned, the
5
things that he said today, including, in particular, his
6
medical condition, which, by the way, he's getting adequate
7
treatment for, I find now in the Bureau of Prisons.
8
that into consideration in setting his sentence within the
9
guidelines.
10
sentence at the low end of the range, 84 months.
11
The Court imposes 84 months.
But I take
And I find that from 105, they justify setting the
That's to be followed by
12
five years supervised release.
13
Mexico during the period of supervised release.
14
reapply or ask for a reconsideration of the amount you get
15
through Social Security if you can't survive here on that.
16
The defendant is not to go into
There may be other forms of aid, but being in Mexico
17
is not a good thing for you.
18
last year by trying to smuggle drugs in.
19
You'll have to
You've proved that twice in the
He's subject to search of his person, his property,
20
his residence, and his vehicle by the probation officer.
He
21
must participate in a program of drug and alcohol abuse
22
treatment, including drug testing.
23
regimen as three random tests per month for the first year.
24
He's not to have any drugs in his system, including marijuana,
25
no illicit drugs.
The Court sets the testing
And he's not to miss any tests without a
31a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.198 Page 25 of 31
1
good excuse.
2
If after the first year, he's tested clean, and he's
3
shown up for all the tests, the probation officer will have
4
discretion to reduce or eliminate the drug testing regimen.
5
He must provide complete disclosure of his personal
6
and financial records.
7
to seek and maintain employment.
8
Security disability, right?
The Court is not going to require him
9
THE DEFENDANT:
10
THE COURT:
11
25
I assume you're on Social
That's correct.
Yeah, so he's not able to work, so I don't
order that.
12
He may reside in a residential reentry center for up
13
to 120 days, once he's released from custody.
14
nonpunitive condition.
15
your feet back on the ground, find a place to go live, and not
16
be out on the street while you adjust and assimilate back to
17
society.
18
This is a
It's a way to give you a place to get
I impose no fine.
I don't impose a hundred dollar
19
penalty assessment, if the government will remit it.
He
20
doesn't look like he's in any condition to work in prison
21
industries.
22
MS. CARTER:
So remitted, Your Honor.
23
THE COURT:
So no penalty assessment based on the
24
government's motion.
25
supervised release, Mr. Mac Cleary, and 84 months in custody.
So that's the sentence.
32a
Thank you.
Five years
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.199 Page 26 of 31
1
You have a right to appeal.
2
provision, but it cut off at below the low end of the
3
guidelines at 71 months.
4
sentence 13 months higher than the appeal.
5
26
You signed a waiver of appeal
And I have obviously imposed a
So if you disagree with the sentence that I have
6
imposed, if you think I made the wrong decision, or I've messed
7
up procedurally, whatever your reasons are, you can appeal.
8
You need to speak to Ms. Khan, and she'll file the papers for
9
you.
10
But here's what you need to know about the right to
11
appeal.
You have 14 days to make your decision and get the
12
paper filed, if that's what you choose to do.
13
understand?
14
THE DEFENDANT:
15
THE COURT:
16
I do.
If you had one more thing you wanted to
say, you can tell me.
17
MS. KHAN:
18
THE DEFENDANT:
19
MS. KHAN:
20
THE DEFENDANT:
21
Do you
Please do not discuss any appeals.
No, no, no.
This has nothing --
Well, I would rather you not say anything.
Where my probation is.
My probation
is, I want to go back home to Omaha.
22
THE COURT:
Okay.
You can make that request at the
23
time.
You know, if you've done fine in jail, there haven't
24
been problems, I have no problem granting a transfer of
25
supervision to Nebraska.
33a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.200 Page 27 of 31
1
THE DEFENDANT:
Thank you very much.
That's where I
2
have cousins at, and you know, people that will take care of
3
me, and I can afford to live.
4
THE COURT:
5
Okay, good.
That sounds like a good plan.
And I'll embrace it if the recommendation is made.
6
MS. KHAN:
Your Honor, if I could make two requests.
7
I would ask that he be designated to as close to Omaha as
8
possible.
9
THE COURT:
Okay.
The Court will make that request,
10
that he do his time as close to Omaha, Nebraska as possible.
11
What's the other one?
12
13
14
15
16
27
MS. KHAN:
I would also request that the Court
recommend RDAP.
THE COURT:
Yeah, I'll recommend RDAP for him, too.
He's got a longstanding drug problem.
MS. KHAN:
And the final thing, Your Honor, is that I
17
just wanted to make an objection to the sentence, because there
18
will be an appeal of substantive and procedural defects.
19
THE COURT:
What are the procedural defects?
20
Substance is -- you don't even have to raise that.
21
automatically preserved if the sentence is just too long.
22
23
What are the procedural problems?
It's
What didn't I do
that I should have done?
24
MS. KHAN:
Your Honor --
25
THE COURT:
Because we can cure them now.
34a
I mean, if
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.201 Page 28 of 31
28
1
there's really a problem where I just glossed over something or
2
didn't follow what the Ninth Circuit says I need to do.
3
think the guidelines were correctly calculated.
4
went through all my reasons.
5
What procedural problem was there?
6
MS. KHAN:
I
And I think I
I embraced all your arguments.
Your Honor -- I would say, Your Honor, that
7
the criminal history was a little mischaracterized, while the
8
Court was going through it.
9
THE COURT:
10
11
How so?
How so?
I read right from the
probation report.
MS. KHAN:
I think, Your Honor, there was that one
12
point, where you said that there was a trafficking conviction,
13
where instead it was a possession of methamphetamine
14
conviction.
15
history does not score.
16
Court didn't properly, you know, look at how many years had
17
gone between the different various --
18
There was also, you know, a lot of his criminal
THE COURT:
It's several years ago.
I think the
No, you're wrong about that, Ms. Khan.
I
19
went through year by year, and gave the year of each offense to
20
which I was alluding.
21
concerned, he pled guilty, this is page 8, paragraph 40, to
22
delivery of methamphetamine, according to the probation report.
23
Delivery of methamphetamine, possession of controlled substance
24
with intent to deliver while in possession of a firearm.
25
looks like they dropped the firearm charge.
As far as the trafficking conviction's
35a
It
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.202 Page 29 of 31
1
That's certainly a trafficking charge.
Delivery is
2
trafficking.
3
importing.
4
told me in his own letter that his purpose was to traffic in
5
drugs.
6
7
8
29
And then, of course, there's a second offense of
And then in this case, as I mentioned, you know, he
He was going to sell them in the United States.
So I don't want to belabor this.
Do you have any
other objections?
MS. KHAN:
Yes, Your Honor.
I think the Court should
9
have taken -- knowing that Mr. Mac Cleary has been hospitalized
10
at the very beginning of sentencing, I think there should have
11
been some questioning of whether he was in -- he was able to
12
proceed to sentencing.
13
THE COURT:
Able to?
14
MS. KHAN:
Proceed on sentencing.
15
THE COURT:
Today?
16
MS. KHAN:
Yes.
17
THE COURT:
You're saying today?
18
MS. KHAN:
Yes.
19
THE COURT:
Look, Ms. Khan, that's so disingenuous,
20
because I was willing to continue the case.
21
no, don't continue the case anymore.
22
from the hospital.
23
MS. KHAN:
Yes.
24
THE COURT:
And to say that I should have said, oh,
25
And you told me,
He's ready to be brought
That's the background here.
well, he really doesn't want to come, even though he told me he
36a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.203 Page 30 of 31
1
wants to come.
And you told me explicitly in e-mails.
2
then to raise the idea that I should have questioned that?
3
That's disingenuous on your part, Ms. Khan.
4
MS. KHAN:
No, Your Honor, I mean --
5
THE COURT:
That's enough.
6
7
That's all.
30
And
We're in
recess.
(The proceedings concluded at 12:49 p.m., November 1, 2021.)
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
37a
Case 3:20-cr-02361-LAB Document 56 Filed 08/15/22 PageID.204 Page 31 of 31
1
31
COURT REPORTER'S CERTIFICATE
2
3
I, CYNTHIA R. OTT, Official Court Reporter, United States
4
District Court, Southern District of California, do hereby
5
certify that pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §753 the foregoing is a
6
true, complete and correct transcript of the stenographically
7
reported proceedings had in connection with the above-entitled
8
matter and that the transcript page format is in conformance
9
with the regulations of the Judicial Conference of the United
10
States.
11
12
DATED at San Diego, California, December 3, 2021.
13
14
15
_/s/ CYNTHIA R. OTT
CYNTHIA R. OTT, RDR, CRR
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
38a
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 54 of 128
APPENDIX D
DATE
11/28/2007
12/5/2007
12/27/2007
1/24/2008
6/5/2010
EVENT
Discharged from hospital in good condition. Pain controlled with
meds, advised to wear Aspen collar for three months at all times.
Meds: Ranitidine 20mg; Colace 100mg; Percocet 5mg; Bacitracin –
topical
Spouse- Brenda MacCleary
Scalp stables removed. He is unable to control pain (taking Tylenol,
Percocet, Ibuprofen) will try adjusting his meds to obtain better pain
control (prescribed OxyContin 30mg every 12 hours -12 tabs;
Percocet 5mg-10 tabs; Ibuprofen -30 tabs 800mg).
Impressions: neuralgia 2) scapula fracture 3) HTN (hypertension) 4)
scalp laceration staple removed
Admitted to ED in Omaha (lives in Council Bluffs, IA) for cervical
spine MRI – mild broad based disc protrusion at C6-C7 fracture
RECORD
4
BATES
MACCLEARY_0024516
4
MACCLEARY_002520-24
4
MACCLEARY_002532-34
MRI shoulder – mild to mod hypertrophic panus involving AC joint w
mild impingement upon supraspinatus muscle
X-ray of spine shows cervical fracture
4
Admitted to the Creighton Medical Center ED in Omaha, NE 4
(discharged same day). 44 year old, car accident 3 days
ago. Driver hit by another car– injured neck, back, right
wrist, r foot, and left wrist; headache, neck pain, numbness
and weakness. Broke dentures and glasses during accident.
Past history – chronic pain. Lives with spouse,
unemployed. Current meds: ibuprofen 800mg, Lyrica
75mg; Percocet 10mg 4xday; Methadone 10mg 3xday
Diagnosis: contusion and musculoskeletal strain.
Impressions: Radiculopathy LLe (lower left extremity), t
strain
39a
ER-54
MACCLEARY_002539
MACCLEARY_002541-47
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 55 of 128
DATE
5/25/2012
3/6/2014
4/3/2014
5/1/2014
EVENT
Admitted to the Creighton Medical Center ED, Omaha NE, for
narcotic withdrawal. Experiencing Nausea/ vomiting (15x in 24
hours). Ill-appearing and anxious. Moderate distress; History of
abdominal surgery. Methadone pills fell in the sink – sick when
doesn’t have pills, vomited 3x during assessment; diarrhea on
stretcher. Given Dilaudid i/m and Phenergan. Prescription for
Percocet 10mg (10tabs) and Phenergan (helps nausea)
Current meds: ibuprofen 800mg, Lyrica 75mg; Percocet 10mg 4xday;
Methadone 10mg 3xday
Seen at pain management clinic for f/u and med refills. Complains of
right arm cramping. Med history: arthritis, hep c, HTN.
Assessments: other symptoms referable to back; displacement of
lumbar intervertebral disc without myelopathy
Current meds: Oxycodone 10mg 1 4/day; Percocet 10mg (1tab every
4hours, 180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen
800mg 2/day. Lyrica 100mg. Cyclobenzaprine 10mg. Given refills
for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; displacement of lumbar intervertebral disc without
myelopathy.
Current meds: Oxycodone 10mg 4xday; Percocet 10mg (1tab every
4hours, 180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen
800mg 2/day. Lyrica 100mg. Cyclobenzaprine 10mg. Given refills
for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; pain in joint, shoulder region; displacement of lumbar
intervertebral disc without myelopathy; pain in soft tissues of limb.
40a
ER-55
RECORD
4
BATES
MACCLEARY_002548-56
5
MACCLEARY_002681-82
5
MACCLEARY_002679-80
5
MACCLEARY_002677-78
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 56 of 128
DATE
5/29/2014
EVENT
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Lyrica 100mg. Given refills for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; pain in joint, shoulder region; displacement of lumbar
intervertebral disc without myelopathy.
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002675-76
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Ran out of meds
5
earlier, not tolerating the decrease so well; neck pain with rue
radiculopathy Med history: arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other
symptoms referable to back; pain in joint, shoulder region;
displacement of lumbar intervertebral disc without myelopathy.
MACCLEARY_002677-74
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Lyrica 100mg. Given refills for Percocet and methadone
6/26/2014
8/19/2014
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Lyrica 100mg. Given refills for Percocet and methadone.
Seen at for pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; pain in joint, shoulder region; displacement of lumbar
intervertebral disc without myelopathy; pain in soft tissues of limb.
5
MACCLEARY_002671-72
9/17/2014
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Lyrica 100mg. Given refills for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; pain in joint, shoulder region; displacement of lumbar
intervertebral disc without myelopathy; pain in soft tissues of limb
5
MACCLEARY_002669-70
41a
ER-56
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 57 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
BATES
11/10/2014
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Lyrica 100mg. Given refills for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; pain in joint, shoulder region; displacement of lumbar
intervertebral disc without myelopathy; pain in soft tissues of limb
5
MACCLEARY_002667-68
12/9/2014
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Refills for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; pain in joint, shoulder region; displacement of lumbar
intervertebral disc without myelopathy; pain in soft tissues of limb.
5
MACCLEARY_002665-66
5
MACCLEARY_002663-64
5
MACCLEARY_002659-60
3/17/2015
5/12/2015
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Lyrica 100mg. Given refills for all meds.
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Waiting for
primary care to do blood work. Med history: arthritis, hep c, HTN.
Assessments: other symptoms referable to back; pain in joint,
shoulder region; displacement of lumbar intervertebral disc without
myelopathy; pain in soft tissues of limb
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Given refills for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for f/u and med refills. Med history:
arthritis, hep c, HTN. Assessments: other symptoms referable to
back; pain in joint, shoulder region; displacement of lumbar
42a
ER-57
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 58 of 128
DATE
8/5/2015
9/8/2015
EVENT
intervertebral disc without myelopathy (protrusion or herniated
disc); pain in soft tissues of limb
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Given refills for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management clinic for follow up. Low back pain,
radiating down both legs, meds are doing well.
Current meds: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs);
Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg 2/day.
Given refills for Percocet and methadone
Seen at pain management for med refill. Patient ran out of
methadone for 4 days now, he was out of town so unable to make
appt – he’s going through what he thinks are withdrawals.
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002657-58
5
MACCLEARY_002655-56
Med history: arthritis, hep c, HTN
Assessments: other symptoms referable to back; pain in joint,
shoulder region; displacement of lumbar intervertebral disc without
myelopathy; pain in soft tissues of limb
2/3/2016
Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours, 180tabs); Methadone 10mg
(1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but
5
meds take edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis (inflammation bottom layers of
skin) affecting regions of neck and back; lumbosacral (5
joints, lumbar vertebrae and sacrum region); other
intervertebral disc displacement (herniated disc),
43a
ER-58
MACCLEARY_002652-54
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 59 of 128
DATE
3/30/2016
4/27/2016
5/25/2016
6/20/2016
EVENT
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every
4hours, 180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
30 tabs
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
44a
ER-59
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002649-51
5
MACCLEARY_002646-48
5
MACCLEARY_002643-45
5
MACCLEARY_002640-42
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 60 of 128
DATE
7/20/2016
8/17/2016
9/14/2016
EVENT
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs) Ibuprofen 800mg,
60 tabs
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
45a
ER-60
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002637-39
5
MACCLEARY_002634-36
5
MACCLEARY_002631-33
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 61 of 128
DATE
10/12/2016
11/15/2016
12/14/2016
1/17/2017
EVENT
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain rated 9/10 –
intensified by cold weather.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
46a
ER-61
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002628-30
5
MACCLEARY_002625-27
5
MACCLEARY_002623-24
5
MACCLEARY_002620-22
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 62 of 128
DATE
2/15/2017
3/21/2017
4/25/2017
EVENT
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs) Ibuprofen 800mg,
60tabs
47a
ER-62
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002617-19
5
MACCLEARY_002614-16
5
MACCLEARY_002611-13
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 63 of 128
DATE
5/23/2017
6/24/2017
8/2/2017
9/6/2017
10/4/2017
EVENT
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Pain clinic does a Tox Screen - Results positive for THC, Methadone
and Percocet
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
48a
ER-63
RECORD
5
BATES
MACCLEARY_002608-10
5
MACCLEARY_002697-99
5
MACCLEARY_002605-07
5
MACCLEARY_002602-04
5
MACCLEARY_002599-01
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 64 of 128
DATE
11/8/2017
12/19/2017
1/17/2018
1/17/2018
EVENT
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs)
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity. Assessments: panniculitis affecting
regions of neck and back; lumbosacral region; other intervertebral
disc displacement, lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab
every 4hours, 180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs);
Ibuprofen 800mg
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity. Stopped marijuana 1/2/2018.
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002596-98
5
MACCLEARY_002593-95
5
MACCLEARY_002590-92
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (2 tabs every 8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen
800mg
Tox Screen for pain management clinic. Positive for THC,
5
Hydrocodone, Hydromorphone, Dihydrocodeine, Norhydrone,
Oxycodone, Methadone, EDDP, Acetaminophen
49a
ER-64
MACCLEARY_002693-96
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 65 of 128
DATE
3/6/2018
3/6/2018
3/20/2018
3/20/2018
4/24/2018
5/22/2018
EVENT
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity. Stretched out medications due to being
late.
Med history: arthritis, viral hep c, HTN
Surgical history: Gunshot wound to back
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
90tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 90tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Tox Screen for pain management clinic. Positive for THC,
Methadone, EDDP, Naproxen, Diphenhydramine
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Tox Screen for pain management: Pos for THC, Oxycodon,
Oxymorphone, Noroxycodone Methadone, EDDP, Acetaminophen
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
50a
ER-65
RECORD
5
BATES
MACCLEARY_002587-89
5
MACCLEARY_002690-92
5
MACCLEARY_002583-85
5
MACCLEARY_002687-89
5
MACCLEARY_002580-82
5
MACCLEARY_002577-79
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 66 of 128
DATE
5/22/2018
6/19/2018
7/7/2018
EVENT
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Tox Screen for pain management clinic: Pos for THC, Oxycodon,
Oxymorphone, Noroxycodone Methadone, EDDP, Acetaminophen
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Admitted to hospital for sigmoid perforation (page 1896)
[colon perforation is a puncture, cut, or tear in the wall of
the colon (large intestine). Can cause air and intestinal
material to leak into the abdomen.]
CT Abdomen & pelvis:
1. Perforated viscus & associated findings as described. The
site of perforation may lie in the sigmorectal junction.
2. Other findings - Significant hepatic fatty infiltration.
Secondary enteritis with probable inflammatory changes
noted. Adrenal gland
enlargement.
Findings: Perforated viscus with free air and complex
moderate ascites.
Descending colon and sigmoid colon has moderate wall
thickening.
51a
ER-66
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002683-86
5
MACCLEARY_002574-76
9
SCRIPPS_Page 764-765
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 67 of 128
DATE
7/8/2018
EVENT
Large amount of stool with some liquid materials in the
colon. The
sigmorectal junction may be site of perforation with
unusual sinus track right laterally. Mid small bowel mild to
moderate wall thickening and inflammatory changes are
present
The lower lungs have atelectasis without large
consolidations.
Significant hepatic fatty infiltration. Pancreatic fatty
atrophy.
Moderate diffuse left adrenal gland enlargement and mild
right adrenal gland enlargement. Mild prostatic
enlargement with minor dystrophic calcifications. Small
hiatal hernia. Mild atherosclerosis.
Received patient from OR (page 137]). Intubated to vent,
sedated. Sedated on fentanyl and ketamine drip (page 48)
RECORD
BATES
9
SCRIPPS_Page 22
9
SCRIPPS_Page 2225
Stoma pinkish w minimal bloody secretion in colostomy
bag (page 33)
Post ex lap and colostomy. Mid abdomen incision stapled
half up and lower half of incision open with gauze packing
(page 36)
Preoperative diagnosis: perforated intestine (page 119)
7/8/2018
Post op diagnosis: perforated recto sigmoid colon.
Procedures: Partial colectomy with end colostomy
(removing part of colon but not rectum)
Mobilization of the splenic flexure for partial colectomy
Case Manager notes. History: Hep C, chronic shoulder pain/goes to
methadone clinic, gunshot wound/exploratory abdominal surgery in
52a
ER-67
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 68 of 128
DATE
7/9/2018
7/12/2018
7/13/2018
7/14/2018
7/15/2018
EVENT
2010. Admitted with sigmoid perforation after a week of constipation
and either enema or colonoscopy In Mexico.
OR (operating room) for partial colectomy and end colostomy, now
sedated and on ventilator. No family has been here with patient. Will
await change in patient's level of consciousness for full assessment.
Hospitalized at Scripps Mercy – here for wound vac placement in
abdomen. No drain for now, JP and colostomy intact.
Assist with locating family.
Restless and delirious – given Haldol. CT scan of head w/out
contrast – No CT evidence of acute intracranial abnormality.
History: Sigmoid colon perforation. Encephalopathic
Abdomen Ultrasound - No definite abdominal pathology identified
on sonogram. No biliary obstruction identified.
Needs restraints bc keeps pulling feeding tube out and pulling gown
off
Came to hospital with severe abdominal pain over last 6 days;
constipated, water enema in TJ (lives in Mexico). Continued pain.
Abdominal surgery for GSW in abdomen, Nebraska 2010 (this is
actually a MVA, not a GSW – don’t seem to have the GSW records)
History:
1. HEP C (accdg to patient)
2. Chronic pain, shoulder injury, motorcycle accident –
methadone from pain clinic
3. Denied Diabetes mellitus
Assessment:
1. perforated viscus sigmoid/rectal junction area
2. Hx of constipation, r/u iatrogenic perforation
3. Anion gab metabolic acidosis, secondary to perforated viscus
4. Sepsis secondary to perforated viscus and acute abdomen
53a
ER-68
RECORD
BATES
9
SCRIPPS_Page 12; Page 31
9
SCRIPPS_Page 59 & Page
2391
9
SCRIPPS_Page 2411
9
SCRIPPS_Page 309
9
SCRIPPS_Page 403
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 69 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
BATES
7/16/2018
Pain controlled with methadone 40mg and oxy before wound vac
change
9
SCRIPPS_Page 15
9
SCRIPPS_Page 1846
9
SCRIPPS_Page 538-539
HEP C, GSW hx, chronic pain (page 150)
Discharge planning - patient lives alone and does not have support;
never been to a SNF before (skilled nursing facility). (page 174)
7/17/2018
Was living in a trailer in Mexico, but recently sold it and has no place
to go (page 219)
Re Eval due to surgical debridement of wound.
Dx: Sigmoid perforation
7/18/2018
Debridement - removal, thoroughly cleaning the wound
and removing all hyperkeratotic (thickened skin or
callus), infected, and nonviable (necrotic or dead) tissue,
foreign debris, and residual material from dressings
Social worker notes: Pt endorses symptoms associated with anxiety,
depression or PTSD. Pt believes he suffers from PTSD following work
accident - beam fell killing seven of his coworkers and severely
injuring him.
Denied family history of mental illness as well as any current or
previous SI/ HI. Provided outpatient mental health resources
including Family Health Centers and Access and Crisis Line for
outpatient follow up.
Pt lives alone in SSH located in Tijuana, Mexico.
54a
ER-69
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 70 of 128
DATE
7/19/2018
EVENT
SW provided extensive emotional support and supportive counseling
as pt discussed "near death" experience of sigmoid perforation
caused by negligent medical care in Mexico.
Surgery performed 1) partial colectomy with end colostomy
2) Mobilization of the splenic flexure for partial colectomy
RECORD
BATES
9
SCRIPPS_Page 527
9
SCRIPPS_Page 1775 &
Page 2486]
Pre Op diagnosis: perforated intestine
Post op diagnosis: perforated rectosigmoid colon
Perforation of rectum or sigmoid -not uncommon and can
occur in any age group. Rectosigmoid colon is
characterized by inadequate blood supply and high
pressure due to less caliber which is the rationale behind
perforation of the distal part of the colon
7/21/2018
CT scan of abdomen/pelvis showed left capsular hematoma
and possible PE at the right lower lobe. CT angiogram and
venous doppler. Another surgical intervention pending
doctor’s recommendation.
Findings:
1. Bilateral pyelonephritis (infection of kidney) with no
hydronephrosis or urinary tract calculi.
2. Moderate consolidation left lower lobe possibly from
pneumonia and aspiration. Moderate left pleural effusion.
3. Fat stranding throughout the small bowel mesentery,
greater omentum from recent bowel perforation with
postsurgical change. Persistent peritonitis possible.
55a
ER-70
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 71 of 128
DATE
EVENT
4. Large left perisplenic fluid collection with rim
enhancement. Probably subcapsular given the mass effect
on the spleen. No active bleed. Most likely from a subacute
subcapsular hematoma. Superinfection is possible.
RECORD
BATES
5. Status post recent Hartmann procedure with surgical
drain. No abnormal fluid collections identified adjacent to
the surgical drain. Thickening of rectum, distal colon
probably from mild colitis, proctitis.
6. Small bowel ileus.
7. Metallic shrapnel in the spine.
8. Possible pulmonary embolism at the right lower lobe.
Consider CT
angiogram of the chest for evaluation.
7/21/2018
9. Findings of possible pulmonary embolism (blood clot),
perisplenic hematoma, pyelonephritis
CT Angio Chest Impressions:
1. Acute moderate bilateral pulmonary emboli. No
pulmonary artery
hypertension or right heart strain.
2. Moderate to severe consolidation left lower lobe with air
bronchograms from pneumonia or aspiration. Adjacent
moderate pleural effusion. Patchy mild pneumonia right
upper lobe.
3. Moderate thickening of the distal esophagus could be
from esophagitis.
56a
ER-71
SCRIPPS_Page 2506 2508
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 72 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
BATES
9
SCRIPPS_Page 13
9
SCRIPPS_Page 1577
9
SCRIPPS_Page 290
9
SCRIPPS_Page 425
5
MACCLEARY_002571-73
5
MACCLEARY_002566-70
4. Metallic foreign body (shrapnel) embedded in the
posterior elements at T11-T12. MRI is contraindicated. Old
fracture deformity right scapula.
7/22/2018
7/25/2018
7/26/2018
7/29/2018
9/26/2018
10/23/2018
Surgical wound mid abdomen connected to wound vac. Colostomy at
left abdomen JP Drain at right abdomen. S/P prior to admit at left
buttock
VU Venous Duplex Lower Ext: Negative for deep vein thrombosis in
both lower extremities [page 2524]
Pt on flagyl PO, wound vac still present to abdominal wound. RLQ JP
drain in place, dressing changed.
Closure of abdominal wound on Friday. Going to Skilled nursing
facility - Windsor Gardens San Diego. Friend Andres plans to cross
border and pick him up after rehab done
Ready to transfer to Windsor Gardens
Chest x-rays: Improving but persistent patchy left basilar
consolidation
with small left pleural effusion.[page 2585]
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity.
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Seen at pain management for med refill. Sore all over, achy muscles;
can’t get up
57a
ER-72
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 73 of 128
DATE
11/20/2018
12/19/2018
1/22/2019
EVENT
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Seen at pain management for med refill. Pain present, but meds take
edge of & allow daily activity
Assessments: panniculitis affecting regions of neck and back;
lumbosacral region; other intervertebral disc displacement,
lumbosacral region. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
Seen at pain management clinic for med refills. Pain still present –
meds take edge off. Refill: Percocet 10mg (1tab every 4hours,
180tabs); Methadone 10mg (1-2/8hours, 150tabs); Ibuprofen 800mg
RECORD
BATES
5
MACCLEARY_002565-67
5
MACCLEARY_002559-64
5
MACCLEARY_002559-61
8
EMR_Page 588
last date of these records
3/11/2019
Prehospital admission. Chief complaint: medication refill,
generalized body pain. In July 2017 – major trauma victim –
multiple bone fractures and colostomy bag placed. Crossing border
bc he resides in TJ to seek attention and get pain meds refilled.
Requesting non emergent transportation assistance to hospital –they
pick him up
58a
ER-73
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 74 of 128
DATE
3/12/2019
EVENT
Admitted at Scripps Chula Vista ED via ambulance for
abdominal pain (discharged same day). Started over a week
ago, chronic, nauseated, sharp off and on pain in LLQ.
RECORD
8
BATES
EMR_Page 557-589
8
EMR_Page 553-554
53 yo male w extensive abdominal history of colonic
perforation and colostomy. Chronic abdominal pain
slightly worse of the last couple of days. Increased output in
the colostomy & complaining of double vision (intermittent
but concerning) since an auto versus pedestrian accident in
March. Came across the border today for pain management
as he has run out of his pain medicines. (Pg 567)
Past medical: Rectosigmoid colonic perforation status post
colectomy
Bilateral pulmonary emboli status post IVC filter;
Anemia of chronic disease;
Chronic pain from abdomen;
shoulder pain from motor vehicle accident – on methadone
from clinic in Apple Valley.
3/12/2019
Morphine injection 2mg.
CT Head without contrast at Scripps. History: head trauma,
headache, double vision.
Findings: no acute infarct; no intracranial hemorrhage.
Other findings: ventricles are mildly enlarged -probably from normal
variation.
Sulci are within normal limits.
Brain parenchyma is unremarkable.
vascular structures - normal limits for age.
Midline structures - normal limits.
Paranasal sinuses show mild mucosal thickening of the ethmoid air
cells.
Bony structures - normal limits for age.
59a
ER-74
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 75 of 128
DATE
EVENT
Soft tissues show high density in the external auditory canals
consistent with cerumen.
RECORD
BATES
9/28/2019
At Scripps Health Liberty Station – needs flu vaccine
8
EMR_Page 549-552
8/24/2020
Referral from ICE to Alvarado Radiology – fell during “Mexican
basketball play” about a week ago. Pain in right elbow – requesting
x-ray
1
MACCLEARY_001842
9/1/2020
9/11/2020
At Scripps Health Express Solana Beach – needs flu vaccine
Medical wound follow up – scheduled colostomy bag change
9/10/20. Stoma normal appearing – no medical concerns
8
3
EMR_Page 544-548
MACCLEARY_002313
3
MACCLEARY_002450
3
MACCLEARY_002325-32
Change colostomy bag every 2 weeks
Meds:
amlodipine 10mg
Atorvastatin calcium 20 mg
Colace 100mg
Ibuprofen 600mg
Lisinopril 10mg
9/13/2020
10/15/2020
Colostomy bag changed. Stoma appears normal with no sign of
infection. Return in 2 days
Initial Intake Screening – arrived with negative TB
Weight: 239 Height: 6’1
Alcohol withdrawal in June 2020
Pain from accident injuries, 11/26/2007
Chronic generalized pain
60a
ER-75
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 76 of 128
DATE
10/15/2020
10/15/2020
10/16/2020
EVENT
Meds:
amlodipine 10mg
Atorvastatin calcium 20 mg
Colace 100mg
Ibuprofen 600mg
Lisinopril 10mg
RECORD
Reports history of ADD/ADHD
NEGATIVE COVID-19 test
1
Urgent mental health appt for 10/16- reports inability to sleep due to 3
PTSD r/t accident in 2007
Health appraisal: Complaints - pain right shoulder, back, neck, arms. 3
Impaired vision; Muscle, joint pain
Drug & alcohol: Alcohol – 1 pint/day for 2mos; tobacco daily for 35
years, last used 3/23/20; marijuana 40 daily, last used 7/11/20
Mother & Father – deceased; Brother – unknown
Medical/surgeries: HTN, HCV since 2007 – never treated, no IV
drug use.
7/2018 colostomy r/t GSW- got sick in hospital (Dr Sue at Sharp CV);
2007 – hit by crane, c6-c7 sheared off end bone, torn brachial plexus,
shattered scapula, broken left foot, 4 toes and right foot, BL hands
broken
54 yo, healthy appearing, with colostomy in place to LLQ, tattoos
generalized; LROM (limited range of motion) to left arm
Problem list: colostomy care, colostomy present; S/P partial
colectomy; Hypertension benign
Housing: lower bunk, job limited, and program
61a
ER-76
BATES
MACCLEARY_001887
MACCLEARY_002312
MACCLEARY_002329-32
&
MACCLEARY_002453-55
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 77 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
BATES
10/16/2020
Cardiac chronic care: Conditions - Hypertensive since 2007;
Dyslipidemia since 2007; S/P colostomy
3
MACCLEARY_002319-22
3
3
3
MACCLEARY_002342
MACCLEARY_002310
MACCLEARY_002308-09
3
MACCLEARY_002397
Intolerant diet; Hospitalizations: GSW
Obese w colostomy mid abdomen – weight: 237.4lbs. BP: 114/63
Recommended diet for health; daily exercise
Medications:
Amlodipine 10mg
atorvastatin calcium 20mg
Lisinopril 10mg
Ibuprofen 600mg
Tylenol extra strength
10/16/2020
10/17/2020
10/18/2020
10/18/2020
Ran out of meds for 3wks for HTN – got meds 2 days ago
All over body pain from old crane injury. Pain 8 out of 10
Colostomy bag changed
Colostomy bag changed at request. Wants to speak directly to
medical director re renewing chronos
Meds:
amlodipine 10mg
Atorvastatin calcium 20 mg
Colace 100mg
Ibuprofen 600mg
Lisinopril 10mg
Tylenol extra strength 500mg
NEGATIVE COVID-19 test
62a
ER-77
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 78 of 128
DATE
10/19/2020
RECORD
3
BATES
MACCLEARY_002346-47
3
MACCLEARY_002306-07
3
MACCLEARY_002305
Abdomen – non distended, hyperactive bowel sounds
10/23/2020 COVID-19 test Positive results
1
MACCLEARY_001887
10/26/2020
3
MACCLEARY_002304
3
MACCLEARY_002303
3
MACCLEARY_002301-02
3
MACCLEARY_002299
10/19/2020
10/22/2020
EVENT
Mental Health – no current or past mental health symptoms. Drug
abuse/dependence – alcohol & cigarettes
Requesting cotton blanket – wool allergy. Colostomy and wants ABD
binder to support his ABD (unsure what this is)
Colostomy bag changed at patients request; requesting renewal of
chronos
Stoma bag change is due tomorrow
Assessment: ineffective healthcare management
10/27/2020
Requesting blanket chrono – hasn’t had one since coming back from
Arizona – approved
10/29/2020 Asked about dressing changes (s/p partial colectomy);
should be getting dressing changes every two days – but
hasn’t received dressing supplies for three days (10/25/20).
Doesn’t get all the supplies he needs. Housing unit in
quarantine - supplies brought to housing
11/1/2020
Scheduled for dressing changes M, W, F
Issues sleeping, feeling run down. Colostomy not changed
since Thursday and needs to be changed every 2 days –
bruise on right ring finger
Meds:
amlodipine 10mg
Atorvastatin calcium 20 mg
Colace 100mg
Ibuprofen 600mg
Lisinopril 10mg
63a
ER-78
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 79 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
Tylenol extra strength 500mg
Right 4th finger – proximal interphalangeal joint slightly red purplish 3
– assured may have tiny vascular rapture and might get bruises that’ll
resolve
F/u for COVID recovery – c/o headache, loss of smell,
3
cough, loss of taste, body aches, malaise – not recovered
BATES
c/o headache, loss of smell, cough – thick white sputum;
loss of taste; body aches and malaise. Patient appears
unkempt
F/u for COVID positive – intermittent loss of smell, taste,
fatigue – return to housing unit tomorrow; observed doing
tricep dips
3
MACCLEARY_002295
3
MACCLEARY_002293
11/5/2020
F/u for COVID positive – reports feeling fine. Recovered
3
MACCLEARY_002291-92
11/9/2020
(had) Positive COVID test– seen for medical clearance; housed in
quarantine; loss of taste, regained smell – patient stable /recovered
from COVID-19
3
MACCLEARY_002288
11/12/2020
Complaints of RLS (restless leg syndrome) with inability to sleep –
feels like running in sleep; the cold aggravates
3
MACCLEARY_002287
11/13/2020
Complains about diet– wants to cont. on the allergy/intolerant diet
3
MACCLEARY_002285
11/15/2020
3
MACCLEARY_002284
11/16/2020
11/19/2020
Unable to sleep at night – RLS, kicks and moves; requesting
colostomy supplies
Colostomy bag supplies
Missing all teeth except #21-29 (extract 29-26)
3
3
MACCLEARY_002283
MACCLEARY_002361-62
11/20/2020
Given Colostomy supplies
3
MACCLEARY_002281
11/2/2020
11/3/2020
11/3/2020
11/4/2020
64a
ER-79
MACCLEARY_002297-98
MACCLEARY_002295-96
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 80 of 128
DATE
11/23/2020
EVENT
Complains about RLS and his diet intolerance bc of GERD. He didn’t
receive correct diet this am. Colostomy changed during visit.
1) RLS
2) GERD
3) Colostomy care
Start Mirapex .125mg
RECORD
3
BATES
MACCLEARY_002279-80
3
3
MACCLEARY_002356-57
MACCLEARY_002338-41
3
MACCLEARY_002414
3
MACCLEARY_002276-77
3
3
MACCLEARY_002300
MACCLEARY_002272
Meds: amlodipine 10mg
Atorvastatin calcium 20 mg
Colace 100mg
Flucelvax 05ml injection
Ibuprofen 600mg
Lisinopril 10mg
Magox 400mg
Tylenol extra strength 500mg
11/24/2020
11/28/2020
11/29/2020
11/30/2020
12/1/2020
12/5/2020
Dental - Teeth extracted - #26-29
Other skin conditions: Both legs are swollen and red –
onset 10 days ago
BP: 136/74. Weight: 248.8. Discolorations in skin – pink,
warm to touch.
Plan – elevate legs, sick call if swelling and pain doesn’t
decrease. F/U on 11/30/20. F/U with Thompson on 11/30
Chest x-ray – hazy opacity in lef lower lobe, could be atelectasis,
scarring, promint paracardiac fat pad or pneumonia
Seen for c/o tooth pain; swelling/redness improved from water pill;
colostomy site irritation from old adhesive. Meds: Furosemide 20mg
Notified about COVID test result
Signed up for water pills
65a
ER-80
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 81 of 128
DATE
RECORD
BATES
12/07/2020 Reports pain at colostomy site – started on weds after
changing bag pain 8/10; sharp radiating from outer
colostomy to stoma. Site is “angry red” stoma growing in
size. Taking Ibuprofen 500m, but not helping
12/10/2020
Requesting meds for RLS. He’s cold and requests an extra blanket
3
MACCLEARY_002258
3
MACCLEARY_002270
12/16/2021
3
MACCLEARY_002267
3
MACCLEARY_002265
3
MACCLEARY_002262
3
MACCLEARY_002259
3
MACCLEARY_002256
12/17/2020
12/18/2020
12/25/2020
EVENT
Meds for RLS not working. RLS started 1 ½ years ago after he quit
taking methadone
Needs something diff for RLS, asks for lotion for dry legs/flakey skin.
Given A&D ointment
Requesting eye glasses; agitated that others have received glasses, he
still hasn’t and he’s requested three times. Informed he did not meet
criteria to receive eye glasses.
Provided with colostomy bag supplies
Seen for stoma bag and flange change. Supplies provided to patient.
Stoma paste not in stock; stoma site in poor condition, surface of skin
eroded back 10 cm around opening and oozing fluid; unwilling to
change stoma care techniques. Noted that he ripped the wafer (part
of the appliance that goes against the skin and has a hole that fits
around your stoma) with fingers to make to opening, then used
medipore and paper tape to adhere stoma wafer to abdomen; patient
expressed dissatisfaction with stoma supplies.
12/28/2020 Pain at colostomy site for past 10 days – lower abdomen;
increased severity in past three days. Sharp, radiating pain
through left abdomen increased in size. Requesting
additional ostomy bag supplies – asks for supplies that will
decrease irritation at ostomy site; changes dressing
3x/week. Experiencing similar abdomen pain resulted in
66a
ER-81
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 82 of 128
DATE
12/29/2021
1/2/2021
1/4/2021
EVENT
hospitalization – polypectomy scheduled then deferred due
to Covid
X-ray of abdomen – nonspecific bowel gas pattern; mild constipation
RECORD
BATES
3
3
MACCLEARY_002255;
MACCLEARY_002412
MACCLEARY_002252
3
MACCLEARY_002250-51
3
MACCLEARY_002247
3
MACCLEARY_002245
Requesting help with colostomy change, “my bag is leaking” 3
and can’t do it by himself, medical says they can pass
supplies through the food port. Patient refused stating he
MACCLEARY_002246
Skin irritation and leaking from colostomy bag after using
the new bag supply. Requesting thicker ostomy bag which
didn’t’ break or as difficult to keep intact. Supplied with
extra bags
Seen for RLS. C/O sharp pain around colostomy
site/radiating pain in middle of colostomy; lower abdomen
swollen/distended; been swollen for 1 ½ months; abdomen
is bloated and swollen around colostomy.
Colostomy only supposed to be temporary until Jan 2019but arrested and incarcerated. Saw a GI surgeon in Jan
2020 – Sharp to Tri City Vista hospital. Colonoscopy in Jan
2020 – multiple polyps detected – then sent back to George
Bailey- not seen a GI specialist since
1/5/2021
1/8/2021
1/7/2021
Changed own bag. Mirapex changed from 1 to 2 tabs at
night
Reports current colostomy bags are falling off and he’s
running out of supplies; he has no backing for the bags
which is why they keep falling. Asks for a blanket bc he’s
cold.
Macerated skin noticed around the stoma – resistant to teaching &
would enlarge the circumference of properly cut stoma.
67a
ER-82
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 83 of 128
DATE
1/11/2021
EVENT
needs help. Pod is currently on lockdown – security says
unsafe and not an option to bring patient out
Requesting furosemide – helpful for lower leg edema. Discontinued
bc he’d refused meds several times. Noticed leg swelling so re
ordered
RECORD
BATES
3
MACCLEARY_002243
1/13/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002404
1/21/2021
Refusing medical – he wants to get colostomy bag changed later
3
MACCLEARY_002417
1/25/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002402
1/26/2021
Follow up on restless leg syndrome. Medication increased but now
getting RLS during the day
3
MACCLEARY_002238
1/27/2021
Evaluated at Chula Vista Emergency Room - parastomal
hernia detected
1
MACCLEARY_001158
1/28/2021
Admitted to ED. 55 yo seen at Alvarado Hospital for pain
1
and swelling at colostomy site. Emergency colonic surgery
in 2018 & colostomy bag placed – does not recollect the
nature of surgery or why it was done. Believes he was living
in Mexico and brought emergency to San Diego – states
surgery at Sharp Hospital, but no records found.
MACCLEARY_0011581161
Patient underwent colonoscopy in Jan 2020 – multiple
polyps found. Scheduled for takedown of colostomy but
canceled due to Covid.
Evaluated on 1/27/21 – parastomal hernia. Medical history:
restless leg; hypertension; hyperlipidemia. Surgery:
emergency colostomy 2018.
Social history: smoking history
68a
ER-83
(copy in record set 3
MACCLEARY_002374-77)
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 84 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
BATES
3
MACCLEARY_002237
Meds: amlodipine 10mg; Atorvastatin 20 mg daily; Colace
100 mg daily; Ibuprofen prn; Lisinopril 10 mg daily;
Mirapex 0.125 mg daily; Tylenol prn
Also seen at Tri City – trying to get those records
1/28/2021
Plan: requires surgery bc large parastomal hernia;
probable colostomy takedown at same time
Patient returned from offsite, no injuries, no signs of pain
1/29/2021
Restless leg syndrome – meds help at night, getting RLS during day.
Changed meds – Mirapex am / pm; pramipexole dihydrochloride am
/ pm
3
MACCLEARY_002236
2/1/2021
Reddened left extremity with few scabs – leg cramp kept awake.
3
MACCLEARY_002231
2/1/2021
Requesting plastic chair to help with chronic back pain;
lower leg swelling – doctor won’t assign personal chair
3
MACCLEARY_002223
2/2/2021
2/2/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
f/u lower leg swelling 3-4 mos; mild erythema, redness with pitting
edema in both lower legs; skin scratches w dry blood and mile
erythema around left lower leg; takes amlodipine for BP control can
cause edema – will prescribe topical abx to prevent skin infection
1
3
MACCLEARY_001887
MACCLEARY_002229
2/2/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002401
2/9/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002400
2/11/2021
Asks for Covid vaccine
3
MACCLEARY_002227
69a
ER-84
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 85 of 128
DATE
2/16/2021
EVENT
Refused to come down and change bag or sign refusal form
RECORD
3
2/16/2021
Colostomy bag change – small polyp present on right side of stoma;
site is red and intact; bag changed by patient
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002242
MACCLEARY_002249
3
MACCLEARY_002399
2/16/2021
BATES
2/17/2021
Colostomy bag leaks – leaks all over clothes, underwear,
uniform – needs supplies
3
MACCLEARY_002224
2/18/2021
Needs to drain out ear – ear lavage 10 years ago worked great
3
MACCLEARY_002223
2/19/2021
3
MACCLEARY_002221
2/23/2021
Colostomy bag leaking and soiling his clothes, distressing
bc of contents on clothing; ear lavage – profuse wax
drainage from both ears, decreased hearing
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002426
3/3/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002391
3/9/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002398
3/13/2021
Seen for puss draining from leg for 8 days, “need my bags
Monday, wed, Friday.”
3
MACCLEARY_0022152216
3/14/2021
Seen for superficial skin tear left shin – seen for wound care dressing changed
3
MACCLEARY_0022132214
3/15/2021
COVID-19 – negative test
3
MACCLEARY_002389
3/17/2021
Offsite referral to general surgery for colonic reanstomosis
per consult
1
MACCLEARY_001845
70a
ER-85
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 86 of 128
DATE
3/17/2021
EVENT
Presents with history of gunshot wound to abdomen status
post laparotomy with partial colectomy and descending
colostomy. Patient underwent colonoscopy and evaluation
of rectal stump. Patient is now requesting reversal of his
colostomy.
RECORD
1
BATES
MACCLEARY_0011621165
[also located in record set
3, MACCLEARY_00237173]
Past surgery: laparotomy w Hartman’s procedure
Family history: father - lung cancer, mother – cancer
Morbid obesity
Diabetes mellitus
hyperlipidemia
Substance abuse in remission; incarcerated
Dental - only four or five teeth left on lower
Past neck injury
Stasis dermatitis from ankles down
3/19/2021
3/19/2021
3/24/2021
4/3/2021
4/8/2021
Presents offsite for surgery consult 2 days ago for ostomy
closure and hernia repair. Ostomy placed after 2018 GSW
– doesn’t know any details just woke up with ostomy bag.
Incarceration delayed treatment of temporary colostomy.
Not confirmed by records yet, patient good historian
Seen at housing unit for restless leg syndrome- not better
with Mirapex; unable to sleep at night bc of RLS, wakes 6+
times a night. C/O leg edema and open sores spontaneously
appear on left leg. Increased dosage of Mirapex
Seen for colostomy bag change.
Seen for colostomy bag change & rash on both knees (poss from
laundry) putting hydrocortisone cream but not helping
Cardiac chronic care –
71a
ER-86
3
MACCLEARY_002208
3
MACCLEARY_0022102211
3
1
MACCLEARY_002206
MACCLEARY_002203
3
MACCLEARY_002314-18
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 87 of 128
DATE
EVENT
Hypertensive since 2007
Dyslipidemic since 2007
RECORD
BATES
3
MACCLEARY_002387-88
3
MACCLEARY_002510-11
Chronic diseases: colostomy status, trauma, chronic pain
Intolerant diet
Hospitalizations: GSW, trauma
Obese w colostomy mid abdomen – weight: 277
Cholesterol 143 (1/5/21)
Abnormal EKG found on 11/18/2021
Covid-19 vaccination when available.
Medications:
Amlodipine 10mg
atorvastatin calcium 20mg
Loratadine 10mg
Lisinopril 10mg
Pramipaxole .125
Pramipexole dihydrochloride .125mg
Ibuprofen 600mg
Tylenol extra strength
Change in meds: Norvasc 10mg & Lisinopril 10mg
4/16/2021
4/13/2021
Ran out of meds for 3wks for HTN – got meds 2 days ago
Labs – high triglycerides; hemoglobin 6.0 (increased risk for
diabetes
Imaging left leg – no evidence of hemodynamically sign etenosis;
ankle brachial indices could not be performed due to vessel
incompressibility
72a
ER-87
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 88 of 128
DATE
5/10/2021
EVENT
No evidence of deep vein thrombosis
Seen for colostomy bag supplies; ear pain, nasal congestion; ointment
for dry leg
Seen for colostomy bag supplies
Dental - missing all but 5 teeth. Gingiva – inflames; masticating
efficiency: poor. Prosthesis needed for upper and lower denture –
extraction of decayed teen #22-26
Refused medical treatment this am
5/13/2021
Chest x-ray – normal
3
MACCLEARY_002405
5/13/2021
Patient snapshot sent to Core Civic:
x Abdominal pain
x Allergy
x Back pain
x Colostomy care
colostomy present on admission
x Covid-19 w multiple comorbidities
x Dependent edema
x Dry skin
x Dyslipidemia
x Immunization
x Covid test
x Generalized joint pain
x GERD
x Health maintenance
x Hearing loss due to cerumen impaction
x Restless leg syndrome
x Hypertension
x Impacted cerumen
x Leg edema
1
MACCLEARY_001903
4/28/2021
4/30/2021
5/5/2021
73a
ER-88
RECORD
BATES
3
MACCLEARY_002187
3
3
MACCLEARY_002184
MACCLEARY_002350-53
1
MACCLEARY_001913
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 89 of 128
DATE
5/13/2021
5/17/2021
5/19/2021
5/19/2021
5/19/2021
5/20/2021
EVENT
x Leg pain
x Mouth pain
x Obesity
x s/p partial colectomy
x skin tear of lower leg without complication
Treated for restless legs (RLS) with pramipexole (meds seem to be
working) Current Meds at Otay Mesa Detention Center:
x A&D ointment;
x amlodipine;
x atorvastatin (check sp?) calcium
x Golytely solution
x Hydrochlorothiazide
x Lisinopril
x Electrolyte solution
x Pramipexole dihydrochloride
x Tylenol extra strength
Asks for ear lavage because he can’t hear well. Receives lavage before
returning to pod
COVID-19 – negative test
Labs – consistent with diabetes
Sick call for bilateral ear ringing – ear pressure & pops when yawns;
previous problem resolved with ear wax cleaning – ear lavage
scheduled
Admitted to hospital for surgery - colostomy reversal with
repair of parastomal hernia, appendectomy, & extensive
lysis of adhesions. Under general anesthesia
Appendix removed to prevent future complications
74a
ER-89
RECORD
BATES
3
MACCLEARY_0021792180
3
MACCLEARY_002178
1
3
3
MACCLEARY_001887
MACCLEARY_002380
MACCLEARY_002185-86
1
MACCLEARY_001166-70
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 90 of 128
DATE
EVENT
Findings: extensive adhesions, rectal stricture, large
parastomal hernia containing small bowel.
RECORD
BATES
1
MACCLEARY_001166-77
1
MACCLEARY_001183
Monitored for safety (falls); pain, psychosocial needs
during hospital stay. Remains at hospital until 6/1/21.
History of GSW to abdomen status post laparotomy w
partial colectomy and descending colostomy. Presented to
ED earlier this year secondary to pain and change in stool
habits. Undergone colonoscopy and evaluation of rectal
stump. Now requesting reversal of colostomy
Assessment: parastomal hernia, obesity
5/21/2021
Weight: 282lbs. Scheduled meds:
x •atorvastatin 20 mg
x •hydroCHLOROthiazide 12.5 mg
x •lisinopril 20 mg Oral Daily
x •pantoprazole 40 mg Oral QAM AC
x •pramipexole 0.125 mg Oral TID
Infusing meds:
x Dextrose
x Lactated ringers
5/21/2021
PRN meds:
x acetaminophen, 650 mg, Q6H PRN
x docusate sodium, 100 mg, Daily PRN
x HYDROmorphone, 1 mg, Q3H PRN
x • ondansetron, 4 mg, Q4H PRN
Hospital Plan:
1. Parastomal hernia
75a
ER-90
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 91 of 128
DATE
5/22/2021
5/22/2021
5/23/2021
EVENT
-Status post surgical repair
-Reversal colostomy
-Continue pain management
-Monitor by surgery
2. Hypertension
-Monitor trend and justification accordingly
3. Acute renal failure
-Secondary to acute tubular necrosis
-Continue with IV fluid
-Monitor BMP urine output
-Renal consult if indicated
Additional problem added to his medical plan:
Tachycardia
-Unclear etiology
-Continue with pain management
-Monitor on telemetry
Post surgery: worsening acute renal failure Post 1
colostomy reversal #2
prostatectomy #3 previous laparotomy for gunshot wound.
Elevated white count hyperkalemia and nausea vomiting
and pain. Appears to have diabetes with elevated glucose
levels; hypertension with probable hypertensive
cardiovascular disease to some component;
gastroesophageal reflux disease; restless leg syndrome
Patient w expected ileus (obstruction of intestine) but non-compliant
as he continues to remove it. Transferred to telemetry for better
monitoring of vital signs
Indication for hospitalization - Acute renal failure most
likely secondary to ATN with associated infection.
76a
ER-91
RECORD
BATES
1
MACCLEARY_001184;
MACCLEARY_001191
1
MACCLEARY_001199
1
MACCLEARY_001208
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 92 of 128
DATE
EVENT
Urine for eosinophils is Positive; consistent with infection
or component of interstitial nephritis with associated
infection; urine sodium is elevated at 36 consistent with
acute tubular necrosis.
RECORD
BATES
1
MACCLEARY_001218
1
MACCLEARY_001224
1
MACCLEARY_001238
1
MACCLEARY_001256 &
001270
Renal ultrasound only shows mild left Hydronephrosis
(kidney enlargement); no significant obstructive uropathy.
Status post colostomy reversal, prostatectomy (partial or
complete prostate removal), appendectomy, and
laparotomy (incision to examine abdominal organs).
Elevated white count; hyperkalemia. Diabetes with
probable end organ disease; hypertension with probable
hypertensive cardiovascular disease.
Gastroesophageal reflux disease; nausea vomiting and pain
syndrome; restless leg syndromes.
5/24/21
5/24/21
5/25/21
5/26/2021
May take 6 to 8 weeks to fully recover renal function;
increased risk for further renal exacerbations.
Renal function slowly improving
Cognition - Overall Cognitive Status Impaired
Orientation: Disoriented to time & situation
Awareness of Errors: Assistance required to identify errors
made
Deficits: Decreased awareness of deficits
Problem Solving: Assistance required to implement
solutions
Patient noted with acute chronic renal failure. Nephrology - Showing
renal improvement
Renal function is improving; disoriented to fact he’s a prisoner
77a
ER-92
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 93 of 128
DATE
5/27/2021
5/28/21
5/29/21
EVENT
Renal function continues to improve. No respiratory distress at this
time. Acute hypoxic respiratory failure
Pulmonary consult: Continue breathing treatment;
Doppler ultrasound to look for DVT;
Unable do CT Angio (heart/blood vessels) due to kidney failure consider VQ scan
No acute distress. Clinically improving. No fever chills. Pain is well
controlled.
Complaining of increased abdominal pain. Surgical consult
notified. KUB done 2 days ago showed possible ileus. Mild
gas, no bowel movement. No surgical intervention at this
time.
RECORD
1
BATES
MACCLEARY_001282 &
001288
1
MACCLEARY_001336
1
MACCLEARY_001337
5/30/21
Patient still complain abdominal pain. No bowel movement; passing
gas. Surgical consult recommended LTAC evaluation. Continue all
current medical management.
1
MACCLEARY_001356
5/31/2021
Patient clinically improving. Abdominal pain has improved, but still
there.
Watery diarrhea. Surgical consult request for LTAC evaluation.
1
MACCLEARY_001370
6/1/2021
Discharged from hospital to US Marshals.
1
MACCLEARY_001392-93
Discharge diagnosis:
1. Parastomal hernia (when intestines press outward near
a stoma) 2. Hypertension 3. Acute renal failure 4. Acute
hypoxic respiratory failure (not enough oxygen in blood) 5.
Deep vein thrombosis (blood clots in veins)
Medications:
Amlodipine 10 MG tablet
Apixaban 5 MG
78a
ER-93
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 94 of 128
DATE
EVENT
Calcium carbonate 500 MG chewable tablet
Clonidine 0.1 MG tablet
DSS 100 MG Caps
Gabapentin 100 MG capsule
Ipratropium-albuterol 0.5-2.5 mg/ml nebulizer
Oxycodone ER 10 MG 12 hr tablet
Oxycodone-acetaminophen 10-325 MG per tablet
Pantoprazole 40 MG tablet
Polyethylene glycol
Hospital course: reversal of his colostomy & parastomal
hernia repair. Acute renal failure secondary to acute
tubular necrosis. - Renal function worsened despite
receiving aggressive IV fluids. Renal ultrasound revealed
mild left hydronephrosis with trace right perinephric fluid.
Renal function gradually improved.
Tachycardia - improved
Hyperlipidemia, obese, history of high blood pressure.
Abdominal pain & some abdominal distention noted; NGT
was placed for slow, intermittent suction.
Per Surgery the patient had an ileus (bowel obstruction)
from narcotics used. Abdominal pain gradually improved
but was still present.
Surgery requested for LTAC evaluation for the patient.
Pulmonary Critical Care consulted - on board for patient’s
acute hypoxic respiratory failure.
79a
ER-94
RECORD
BATES
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 95 of 128
DATE
EVENT
Cont on oxygen supplement and breathing treatments.
Attempts to titrate down on his oxygen resulted to
saturation being in the 80's.
RECORD
BATES
6
MACCLEARY_003030
CT Angiogram could not be done at time of evaluation due
to kidney failure. He was not in any distress and was
started on Eliquis.
LTAC evaluation done & accepted by Select Specialty
Hospital.
Discharged once clinically stable, not in distress, and
cleared by consult services.
6/16/7/2021
Discharge disposition: LONG TERM ACUTE CARE
Admitted to Select Specialty Hospital. History of present
illness: GSW to Abdomen, status post laparotomy with
partial colectomy and descending colostomy. Alvarado ED
earlier this year secondary to pain at the site as well as
change in stool habits. Found to have a parastomal hernia.
Patient has undergone colonoscopy and evaluation of rectal
stump. Been following as outpatient.
On 5/20/2021, pt was admitted to the hospital for reversal
of his colostomy - taken to OR and tolerated procedure
well. However, post op, his renal function deteriorated.
With aggressive IV - renal function improved. Still
complaining of abdominal pain…. surgery team
recommends transfer to LTAC; case manager notified and
transferred to Select Hospital
Surgical history: abdominal surgery & hernia repair
80a
ER-95
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 96 of 128
DATE
6/1/2021
EVENT
Medications at Select Hospital:
x Norvasc 10mg
x Eliquis 5mg
x Lipitor 20mg
x Neurontin 100mg
x Hydrodiuril 12.5
x Zestril 20mg
x OxyContin 10mg
x Protonix 40mg
x Zosyn 3.375mg
x Mirapex .125mg
x Tylenol 650mg
x Tums
x Catapres .1mg
x Colasce 100mg
x Duo-neb 3ml solution
x Zofran 4mg inj
x Percocet 5mg
x
Problem list:
1. Parastomal hernia
2. Hypertension
3. Acute renal failure
4. Acute hypoxic respiratory failure
5. Deep vein thrombosis [MACCLEARY_003033]
RECORD
6
BATES
MACCLEARY_003027;
003032-33
6/2/2021
6/3/2021
Pain managed with Percocet prn and routine OxyContin
JP drain was dislodged; developed loose stools improved after
Imodium
Developed low grade fever
6
6
MACCLEARY_002785
MACCLEARY_002785
6
MACCLEARY_002743
6/5/2021
81a
ER-96
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 97 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
BATES
6/6/2021
Fever - temp of 100.5; suspect stool may be draining from his lower
abdominal wound with odor present.
6
MACCLEARY_002743
6
MACCLEARY_002710
6
MACCLEARY_002709
6
MACCLEARY_002711
6/7/2021
Later temp was 101.2. Cultures and CXR were done; started on
Zosyn. A CT a/p ordered.
Transferred to Select Hospital from Alvarado Hospital to
continue care of drainage tube post-surgery. At Alvarado
for reversal of his colostomy; complicated by worsening
renal function. Aggressive IV fluids improved renal
functioning. Lots of discharge at drainage tube.
Decision made to transfer him to LTAC facility for
continued management so transferred to Select.
6/7/2021
6/7/2021
Patient had just undergone surgical reversal of his
colostomy. He did accidentally pull out his JP drain and
Surgery was consulted and per Surgery there was no need
to replace JP drain
Discharged from Select Specialty Hospital. Diagnosis:
1. Parastomal hernia
2. Hypertension
3. Acute renal failure
4. Acute hypoxic respiratory failure
5. Deep vein thrombosis
6. Sepsis/ abdominal infection
Temperature spiked over the weekend. Possible bowel leakage. May
need transfer to Alvarado so surgery can assess leakage. Pt is
clinically stable. Blood pressure is stable. Awake and alert. No
increase in abdominal pain.
82a
ER-97
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 98 of 128
DATE
6/7/2021
6/76/17/2021
EVENT
Fever, bacteremia, wound infection - blood culture is
positive for GNRs. Chills with constant abdominal pain but
no n/v. He continues to have loose stools. Reports
substernal chest pain. EKG done.
Transferred to Alvarado Emergency Dept
Admitted to Alvarado Emergency Dept for evaluation of
postoperative abdominal pain. Reports worsening
abdominal pain since surgery, worsened over past four
days, noted foul smelling drainage from drain in surgical
site. Feels feverish, diarrhea since surgery, but semiformed stool today; passing gas.
RECORD
6
BATES
MACCLEARY_002743
1
MACCLEARY_001394;
1398
1
MACCLEARY_001540
Brought in by ambulance by SD Court/Law Enforcement.
Discharged on 6/17/21 (MACCLEARY_001157)
6/7/2021
Infectious symptoms not stabilized. Patient at risk of rapid
decompensation. Admitted for careful hydration, antibiotic
therapy, and infectious source control
(MACCLEARY_001398)
Infectious disease is consulted:
x Stricture obstructed distal left ureter with air within the left
renal collecting system and left ureter status post
percutaneous nephrostomy and study showing left ureteral to
small bowel–ureteroenteric fistula. Purulent urine from the
upper tract left renal pelvis. Cultures in progress.
x Positive rectal VRE screen R/Ot urinary retention bladder
outlet obstruction this is now resolved with an indwelling
Foley. Creatinine Improved
x Intra-abdominal fluid collections after elective takedown of a
colostomy with reanastomosis and repair of parastomal hernia
with mesh.
83a
ER-98
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 99 of 128
DATE
6/8/2021
EVENT
x Incidental appendectomy
x Obesity
x Hepatitis C untreated
x Enlarged fatty liver
x No clinical evidence of portal hypertension or splenomegaly
x Hypertension
x Dyslipidemia
x Diabetes
x Tobacco marijuana use
x Maximum creatinine 1.8 now stable at 1.2
Recovering at select long-term acute care facility – increasing
abdominal pain over the weekend with a CT scan suggesting
anastomotic leak with abdominal abscess - patient transferred back
for reassessment and intervention. He has no known drug allergies
Complex comorbid medical history/past medical history:
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
2006 - Diagnosed with hepatitis C - never treated.
2007 - Work-related accident related to a crane with energy
injury.
2018 - sustained gunshot wounds for which he was admitted
to
Sharp Chula Vista & had a colostomy and Hartmann
procedure. Patient very vague about details of those events
that he states he does not remember much about. In addition
in reviewing
GI note from Dr. A Reddy back in February there was no
record of any major surgery done in the sharp healthcare
system.
Lived in Mexico prior to his incarceration
2019 - federal custody
84a
ER-99
RECORD
BATES
1
MACCLEARY_001416
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 100 of 128
DATE
6/8/21
6/9 /21
6/9/2021
6/10/21
EVENT
x Denies injection drug use
x Nonalcoholic Liquor
x half a pack of cigarettes per day
x Recently diagnosed hypertension hyperlipidemia
x Elevated glycosylated hemoglobin
x Parastomal hernia
Procedure performed: anterior intra abdominal drain placement,
ultrasound and fluoroscopic guidance
RECORD
BATES
1
MACCLEARY_0017251728
Admitted with a complicated medical and urological
1
history. Underwent reversal of colostomy with repair of
parastomal hernia approximately 3 weeks ago - persistent
drainage of intra-abdominal fluid into a JP drain which was
traumatically removed in previous facility.
MACCLEARY_001455
CT scan revealed multiple abscesses which were drained
percutaneously by IR; air/gas within the left renal
collecting system and ureter raising the concern for
ureteral enteric fistula or emphysematous pyonephritis.
C/O abdominal pain and left flank pain; denies nausea or
vomiting. Urine is grossly clear.
Recommended surgery for cystoscopy, bilateral retrograde
pyelograms, left ureteral stent placement. The risks, benefits, and
alternatives explained & agreed upon. He understands that they are
unable to place a stent in a retrograde fashion, may require
percutaneous nephrostomy tube drainage thereafter. Continue
antibiotics as per infectious disease recommendations
Surgery performed - Cystoscopy bilateral retrograde
pyelogram, left ureteral stent placement
Preoperative Diagnosis: Left hydronephrosis, air in the left
renal collecting system and left ureter, ureteral enteric
85a
ER-100
1
MACCLEARY_001459
1
MACCLEARY_001478
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 101 of 128
DATE
6/11/2021
6/14/2021
6/15/21
6/17 6/24/2021
EVENT
RECORD
fistula, possible emphysematous pyelonephritis, status post
colostomy takedown and repair of parastomal hernia
Postoperative Diagnosis: Same plus urethral stenosis, left
distal ureteral occlusion
Nephrostomy tube placed for urethral stenosis and left distal ureteral
occlusion and ureteral intestinal fistula seen on cystoscopy
Seemingly stable; reports abdominal pain - diffuse in nature; nausea
or vomiting. Left nephrostomy tube &Foley catheter
May need to be transferred to a tertiary care center.
Problem list:
1) wound infection at surgical site
2) intra-abdominal abscess
3) urinary retention
4) hypertension
5) obesity
6) hyponatremia
7) acute renal failure w atn
8) hypalbuminemia
9) anemia, chronic
10)
parastomal hernia repair and appendectomy
11) deep vein thrombosis
12)
restless leg syndrome
13)
hyperlipidemia
14)
fatty liver
Stable and transferred to Select Specialty Hospital for continued
physical therapy & occupational therapy. Resting comfortably
without SOB; no fever
Medications:
x Norvasc 10mg
86a
ER-101
BATES
6
MACCLEARY_003138
1
MACCLEARY_001555
1
MACCLEARY_001568-69
1
MACCLEARY _003134-35
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 102 of 128
DATE
EVENT
x Eliquis 5mg
x Lipitor 20mg
x Neurontin 100mg
x Hydrodiuril 12.5
x Zestril 20mg
x Percocet 5 mg
x Protonix 40mg
x Zosyn 4.5 g
x Mirapex .125mg
x Tylenol 650mg
x Tums
x Catapres .1mg
x Colasce 100mg
x Dulcolax 10mg
x Duo-neb 3ml solution
x Ambien 5mg
RECORD
BATES
6/17/2021
Estimated stay at Select Specialty is 25 days. Patient is appropriate
for Long Term Acute Care Hospital
Scripps Lab microbiology
6
MACCLEARY_003142
8
EMR_491-497
8
6
8
6
EMR_Page 491-496
MACCLEARY_003205
EMR_479
MACCLEARY_003183
6/176/18/2021
6/18/2021
6/20/2021
6/20/2021
6/21/2021
Lab work at Scripps Mercy Hospital
Blood in nephrostomy tube; urgency to urinate
Labwork at scripps
Difficulty with urinating. Foley in place. Spoke with team at
Alvarado, recommend patient go to UCDS for surgery to
correct complete stenosis of left ureter that is unable to be
stent.
Uretal-colic fistula needs repair
87a
ER-102
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 103 of 128
DATE
6/21/2021
6/22/2021
6/22/2021
6/216/23/2021
6/23/2021
6/24/2021
EVENT
Note: Flomax .8mg added to medications
[MACCLEARY_003190]
Patient missed visit and declining all options for therapy this date
secondary to abdominal discomfort, minimal motivation for OOB,
fatigue. Concerned with abdominal pain and blood in output from
nephrostomy drain.
Blood on TP last night, some upper abdomen pain. Here for ongoing
medical stabilization and wound care [3222]
Pt is very high functioning, demonstrating impairments in
endurance. Had inconsistent participation with therapy so far. Often
limited by abdominal discomfort, pain, low energy.
Barriers to discharge: medical complications and pain
Lab work from Scripps
Barriers to Discharge: Caregiver limitations, Capacity for
self-care, Mobility challenge, Potential need for 24 hour
care, Potential need for skills/non-skilled services
Clinical Barriers: Clinical needs exceed caregiver capacity,
Wound (nephrostomy tube, JP drain)
Admission Diagnoses at Select Specialty (same discharge
diagnoses)
1. Wound infection
2. Intra-abdominal abscess in the left abdominal wall
3. Hx of urinary retention with left hydronephrosis. S/p
nephrostomy tube placed.
4. Hypertension
5. Obesity
6. History of Acute Kidney Injury with ATN. Resolved with
creatinine 1.1
88a
ER-103
RECORD
BATES
6
MACCLEARY_003319
6
MACCLEARY_003192
6
MACCLEARY_003279-80
8
EMR_ 461-490
6
MACCLEARY_003295
6
MACCLEARY_003143 -45
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 104 of 128
DATE
EVENT
7. Hypoalbuminemia with severe protein calorie
malnutrition
8. Deep Venous Thrombosis
9. Restless leg syndrome
10. Hyperlipidemia
11. Uretal-Colic Fistula
Hospital course: 55 y.o. male w complex past medical
history. Restless Leg Syndrome, Hypertension, history of
trauma secondary to a gunshot wound to the abdomen
requiring multiple surgeries.
Hospital course complicated by pain and swelling at the
colostomy site. Gunshot wound in the abdomen and
Exploratory laparotomy done along with partial colectomy
and descending colostomy.
Hospitalized multiple times over the year for complications
including swelling around the colostomy site, presence of a
large parastomal hernia. Followed and managed by Surgery
and GI consults. Seen by Surgery in mid-March and
colostomy reversal & repair of the parastomal hernia done.
Admitted to Alvarado for procedure. Later complicated by
worsening renal failure and persistent abdominal pain.
Transferred to Select Hospital on June 1. Antibiotic
continued and the patient followed by Infectious Disease,
who, at the time, recommended Surgery evaluation of
possible anastomotic leakage.
Patient discharged to Alvarado for Surgical evaluation.
Reversal of his ostomy done by Surgery 2 weeks prior.
89a
ER-104
RECORD
BATES
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 105 of 128
DATE
EVENT
Returned to Select hospital on June 17 to have continued
rehabilitative management per PT/OT.
Admitted to Select and PT/OT Services continued
rehabilitative therapies. Zosyn continued as Abdominal CT
done previously showed evidence of abdominal abscess.
Repeat Ct showed abdominal abscess on the left abdominal
wall.
Nephrostomy tube was placed on the patient on June 11,
2021 due to urethral stenosis and left distal ureteral
occlusion and ureteral intestinal fistula as seen on
cystoscopy. Wound care also provided by the wound nurse.
Discussed with team at Alvarado - recommended patient be
transferred to UCSD for corrective surgery of complete
stenosis of the left ureter that was unable to be stented.
Also has uretal-colic fistula in need of surgical repair the
patient tolerated his treatment and therapies, followed
closely by consult team and improved clinically. No distress
and no complaints of chest pain, palpitations, or
diaphoresis. Remained afebrile and in good spirits.
Nephrostomy tube was in place and draining. Some
hematuria but cleared eventually. Foley was also replaced.
Urinalysis done. Nursing staff reported ST elevation on
monitor. Serial Troponin negative and the patient did not
have complaints of chest pain. Cardiology consulted and
followed the patient - discharged to UCSD for Urology
evaluation once patient clinically stable and cleared by
consult team. Dressings were intact, nephrostomy and
Foley were in place.
90a
ER-105
RECORD
BATES
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 106 of 128
DATE
6/24/2021
6/24/2021
EVENT
RECORD
Infectious Disease recommended continuing the patients
Zosyn for 15 days starting on June 15, at the time of
abdominal wall fluid aspiration. On the day of discharge the
patient was with stable vital signs and not in distress
Pt to be discharged from PT services. Per EMR pt discharged 6/24/21 6
at 2045 to acute facility. Pt with minimal participation with PT
secondary to abdominal pain, low energy, low motivation. Pt had
walked 100ft using FWW during evaluation session only. Further
attempts to walk for endurance pt declined. Provided with a written
HEP. Pt to be re-evaluated as appropriate if returning to the facility.
Recommend follow up with male PT per pt preference.
Admitted to ED in Hillcrest Emergency for surgical
7
problem re evaluation. Bleeding from nephrostomy tube
and recurrent pelvic abscesses.
In custody – sentencing soon. Came in for hematuria; he
states he doesn’t know why brought to ED. Unsure when
urine became bloody Doesn’t need admission or acute
surgical intervention at this point.
Tertiary recommended given complexity of GU problems.
Outpatient follow up for reconstruction workup
Nephrostomy tube bleed; complication of foley catheter;
left flank pain. Final diagnoses:
x hemorrhage of incontinent external stoma of urinary
tract;
x Cutaneous abscess of abdominal wall
x Hydroenphrosis w ureteral stricture; other specified
disorders of kidney and ureter; acute embolism &
thrombosis of right popliteal vein; dorsalgia; contact
w & suspected covid exposure
91a
ER-106
BATES
MACCLEARY _003318
MACCLEARY _004755
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 107 of 128
DATE
EVENT
x Precipitous drop in hematocrit
x Hyperlipidemia
x Essential hypertension
x Obesity
x Long term use of anticoagulants
x Long term drug therapy
x Acquired absence other specified digestive tract
x Personal history of other healed physical injury and
trauma
x Personal history of other venous thrombosis and
embolism
x Other diseases digestive system
x Other diseases respiratory system
x Other diseases of urinary system
RECORD
BATES
6/24/2021
6/25/2021
Covid test – negative
Seen by surgery and cleared for discharge. Abscesses very small, he is
afebrile, hemodynamically stable
CT abdomen and pelvis w contrast – abdominal pain,
Nephrostomy tube bleeding. Placed for diversion due to
ureteroenteric fistula.
7
7
MACCLEARY_004781
MACCLEARY_004771-72
7
MACCLEARY_004797-98
6
MACCLEARY_003694-95
6/25/2021
6/25/2021
Impressions: splemeomegaly; splenic varies; portal
hypertension
On 6/24/21, patient transferred to UCSD for urology consult due to
bloody output from foley. Urology consulted. CT abdomen and pelvis
showed no acute changes. Pt is to be seen with urology outpatient
follow up. Readmitted at Select Specialty.
Diagnosis: 1) gastrointestinal symptom 2) hypertension 3) obesity
Meds:
92a
ER-107
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 108 of 128
DATE
EVENT
TYLENOL 650 mg
NORVASC 20 mg
ELIQUIS 5 mg,
LIPITOR 20 mg,
TUMS
CATAPRES .1
COLACE 100 mg
NEURONTIN 100 mg,
HYDRODIURIL 12.5 mg,
DUO-NEB 0.5-2.5 mg/3 mL nebulizer solution
ZESTRIL 20 mg,
PERCOCET 5-325 MG
PROTONIX EC/DR 40 mg,
ZOSYN 3.375 g
MIRAPEX .125 mg
Appropriate for long term acute care. Length of stay estimated 25
days [MACCLEARY_003698]
Labwork at scripps
6/266/28/2021
6/28No distress / no pain
7/3/2021
7/4/2021
Some leakage from Foley bag
7/5-7/7/2021 Lab work at Scripps
7/5/2021
No new issues
7/6/2021
Patient accidentally moved nephrostomy tube out a little while going
to the bathroom yesterday. No flank pain. Tube is draining out blood.
Renal US was ordered. Pt will have follow up appt with urology
7/7/2021
Nephrostomy tube less bloody. No bright red blood. No flank pain.
Renal U/S results pending.
7/8-7/13
No changes, no pain
93a
ER-108
RECORD
BATES
8
EMR_441-460
6
MACCLEARY_003711
6
8
6
6
MACCLEARY_003711
EMR- Page 429-440
MACCLEARY_003711
MACCLEARY_003711
6
MACCLEARY_003711
6
MACCLEARY_003711
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 109 of 128
DATE
7/9/2021
7/11/2021
7/12/2021
7/14/2021
7/15/2021
7/16/2021
7/16/2021
EVENT
Kidney function is probably deteriorating due to
dehydration. Continue hydration. Resting /good spirits.
Foley catheter ; nephrostomy tube
Nursing note: c/o severe pain, located mainly in the back;
generalized body ache - throbbing and uncomfortable. Can’t sleep –
requested Tylenol PRN. Will continue to monitor pain level
Renal imaging: Right kidney is 10.6 cm. Left kidney is 9.8 cm.
Moderate amount of hydronephrosis in the left kidney. 4 cm cyst in
the right mid kidney. No right hydronephrosis. IMPRESSION: Right
renal cyst.
Currently stable and transferred to Select Hospital for continued
physical therapy as well as occupational therapy. Resting comfortably
in bed without any SOB. Kidney function is probably deteriorating
due to dehydration.
RECORD
6
BATES
MACCLEARY_003730-32
6
MACCLEARY_003873
6
MACCLEARY_003721
6
MACCLEARY_003699
Pt had some leakage from nephrostomy tube. No foul smelling, no
puss [MACCLEARY_003711]
Serangous fluid drained from nephrostomy tube. Trying to make appt 6
with urology. If worsens will get IR involved here at select or UCSD
ER.
MACCLEARY_003708
Ambien 5mg & Flomax added to medications
Patient’s nephrostomy drain is dislodged and leaking, he is unable to
see urology until 8/18 - they may send him to ED. Will continue to
follow up. Clinical updates faxed to US Marshal.
Admitted to Scripps Mercy ED for leakage of nephrostomy
catheter. Nephrostomy complications; kidney infection;
covid-19 vaccination administered
Hospital problems:
Nephrostomy complication (primary)
Bladder infection
94a
ER-109
6
MACCLEARY_003706
8
EMR_Page 191-198
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 110 of 128
DATE
7/16/2021
7/17/2021
7/18/2021
7/19/2021
EVENT
High blood pressure disorder
History of blood clot to lungs
High cholesterol or triglycerides
Collection of pus in the abdomen
Status post insertion of inferior vena caval filter
RECORD
BATES
8
EMR_Page 215
Felling well however, still having drainage coming from nephrostomy 8
tube. Procedure deferred until Monday – non urgent
Reports feeling well with mild left-sided discomfort at the
8
nephrostomy tube site. He reports continuous leakage without bloody
output or purulence. Urinalysis consistent with infectious etiology
therefore Rocephin started.
At Scripps for IR Nephrostomy Tube Change. Tube located in left
8
kidney. Successful replacement. Given non emergent nature
procedure deferred to 7/19/21. Procedure this am without any
complications. Subsequently tolerating a diet without any pain and
would like to transfer back to LTAC. Maintained on his home
medications.
EMR_Page 408
CT Abdomen Impressions:
1. Left ureteral stent in place. No hydronephrosis.
2. Rectosigmoid anastomosis with small amount of soft
tissue fascial thickening along the superior margin. No
loculated fluid.
3. Hepatic steatosis.
Administered J&J COVID-19 vaccine
Current scheduled meds:
acetaminophen (TYLENOL) 325 mg
lisinopriL (PRINIVIL) 20 mg
amLODIPine (NORVASC) 10 mg
pantoprazole (PROTONIX) 40 mg
gabapentin (NEURONTIN) 100 mg
95a
ER-110
EMR_Page 245
EMR_Page 215-219
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 111 of 128
DATE
EVENT
ipratropium-albuterol (DUONEB) .5-2.5mg
pramipexole (MIRAPEX) 0.125 mg
atorvastatin (LIPITOR) 20 mg (page 219)
RECORD
BATES
Clinical impressions:
1) Nephrostomy complication
2) Pyelonephritis
3) COVID-19 vaccine administered
Discharge Diagnosis:
7/19/2021
Nephrostomy complication (CMS/HCC)
History of pulmonary embolus (PE)
Intra-abdominal abscess (CMS/HCC)
Hyperlipidemia
S/P insertion of IVC (inferior vena caval) filter
Essential hypertension
Acute cystitis without hematuria [pg 215]
Discharged from Scripps and transferred to rehab. Discharge
Summary: 55 yo M with a somewhat complicated past medical
history, made more complicated by the fact that he has been to
multiple facilities, and does not recall details from each - currently he
is as at Select Specialty. Also
under custody, and has two guards at his bedside.
Summary of medical care: From past records and LTAC paperwork –
history of GSW to the abdomen, followed by multiple surgeries as
well. He also has a hx of restless leg syndrome, is s/p a parastomal
hernia repair with appendectomy (more recently perhaps?), DVT
HLD, and obesity, and was admitted to Select on 6/7 after a
prolonged
hospital stay. He also had a reversal of an ostomy prior to this. He
thinks he was at Alvarado for this admission.
96a
ER-111
EMR_Page_227-235
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 112 of 128
DATE
EVENT
RECORD
Surgical history includes a rectosigmoid colonic perforation, status
post partial colectomy, end colostomy placement, and wound vac
placement on the midline abdominal wound on 07/08 with
secondary closure of the abdominal wound on 07/27 and bilateral
pulmonary emboli, status post IVC filter placement, not on
anticoagulation secondary to splenic hematoma.
Appears to have been on Zosyn for an E. Coli abdominal abscess;
most recent imaging was 6/14 and reportedly showed a left abd wall
abscess. He had a Foley for urinary retention (no longer) and had
nephrostomy tubes placed on 6/11 for hydronephrosis. This is
reportedly 2/2 urethral stenosis and left distal ureteral occlusion and
ureteral intestinal fistula. He had associated AKI. On 6/24 he was
reportedly transferred to UCSD for a urology consult due to
hematuria, and was supposed to be set up for OP follow up. Doctor
could not find record of this admission in "care everywhere"
Past Medical History
•AKI (acute kidney injury)
•Brachial plexus injury
•Chronic pain
•DVT (deep venous thrombosis)
•E. coli infection
•Hyperlipidemia
•Hypertension
•Intra-abdominal abscess
•Obesity
•Restless leg syndrome
•Scapula fracture
•Urinary retention
•Wound infection
97a
ER-112
BATES
Case: 21-50240, 06/06/2022, ID: 12464860, DktEntry: 10, Page 113 of 128
DATE
8/30/2021
EVENT
Admitted to ED via ambulance, transported from jail with clogged
nephrostomy tube; reports tube is draining, constant pain in left leg.
Diagnosis: malfunction Nephrostomy tube - Tube is replaced and
started on Keflex (antibiotic) Given 4mg morphine. Discharged to
detention facility.
98a
ER-113
RECORD
2
BATES
MACCLEARY_002145-20
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.