Joint Appendix — Arizona, et al., Petitioners v. Alejandro Mayorkas, Secretary of Homeland Security, et al.
Supreme Court briefJan 18, 2023
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 22-592
In the Supreme Court of the United States
__________________
STATES OF ARIZONA, LOUISIANA, MISSOURI, ALABAMA,
ALASKA, KANSAS, KENTUCKY, MISSISSIPPI, MONTANA,
NEBRASKA, OHIO, OKLAHOMA, SOUTH CAROLINA, TEXAS,
TENNESSEE, UTAH, VIRGINIA, WEST VIRGINIA, AND WYOMING,
Petitioners,
v.
ALEJANDRO MAYORKAS, SECRETARY OF HOMELAND
SECURITY, ET AL.,
Respondents.
__________________
On Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court of
Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
__________________
JOINT APPENDIX
__________________
ELIZABETH B. PRELOGAR
Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
Washington, DC 20530
(202) 514-2217
SupremeCtBriefs@usdoj.gov
Counsel for Federal Respondents
LEE GELERNT
Counsel of Record
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION
125 Broad Street
New York, NY 10004
(212) 549-2616
lgelernt@aclu.org
Counsel for Plaintiff-Respondents
January 18, 2023
JEFF LANDRY
Attorney General
ELIZABETH B. MURRILL
Solicitor General
JOSEPH SCOTT ST. JOHN
Deputy Solicitor General
LOUISIANA DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE
1885 N. Third St.
Baton Rouge, LA 70802
(225) 326-6766
murrille@ag.louisiana.gov
DREW C. ENSIGN
Counsel of Record
202 E. Earll Drive
Suite 425
Phoenix, AZ 85004
(602) 492-5969
drew@ensignlawgroup.com
Counsel for Petitioners
Louisiana, et al.
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI FILED DECEMBER 19, 2022
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI GRANTED DECEMBER 27, 2022
i
JOINT APPENDIX
TABLE OF CONTENTS
December 16, 2022 D.C. Circuit Order Denying
Emergency Motion for Intervention and Stay. . JA1
November 15, 2022 D.D.C. Order . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA8
November 15, 2022 D.D.C. Opinion . . . . . . . . . . JA10
November 22, 2022 D.D.C. Judgment . . . . . . . . . JA54
D.D.C. Docket Entry – December 9, 2022 Order
denying stay pending appeal . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA56
D.D.C. Docket Entry – November 16, 2022
Order granting stay “not for the pendency of
appeal” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA57
December 12, 2022 Declaration of James K. Rogers
and Exhibits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA59
December 15, 2022 Second Declaration of James K.
Rogers and Exhibits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA115
August 31, 2022 Defendants’ Opposition to
Plaintiffs’ Motion for Partial Summary
Judgment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA149
September 28, 2022 Defendants’ Surreply in
Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Partial
Summary Judgment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA208
November 15, 2022 Defendants’ Motion for
Temporary Stay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA213
December 7, 2022 Defendants’ Notice Regarding
Decision to Appeal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA218
ii
October 26, 2021 D.C. Circuit Order Denying Texas
Intervention . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA222
October 15, 2021 Excerpts of Defendants’ First
Intervention Opp. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA224
October 15, 2021 Excerpts of Plaintiffs’ First
Intervention Opp. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA232
November 16, 2022 Department of Justice’s Notice
to W.D. La. Regarding D.D.C. Decision Vacating
Title 42 Order . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA238
States’ December 9, 2022 Notice and Alternative
Motion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA241
November 21, 2022 Declaration of Joseph Scott St.
John with Exhibits 4, 7, 8, and 9 . . . . . . . . JA247
October 11, 2021 The State of Texas’ Motion to
Intervene as Intervenor-Defendant . . . . . . . JA276
October 18, 2021 The State of Texas’ Reply in
Support of Motion to Intervene as IntervenorDefendant . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . JA299
JA1
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
No. 22-5325
September Term, 2022
1:21-cv-00100-EGS
[Filed: December 16, 2022]
__________________________________________
Nancy Gimena Huisha-Huisha, and her
)
minor child, et al.,
)
)
Appellees
)
)
v.
)
)
Alejandro N. Mayorkas, Secretary of
)
Homeland Security, in his official capacity, )
et al.,
)
)
Appellants
)
__________________________________________)
BEFORE: Millett, Walker, and Pan, Circuit Judges
ORDER
Upon consideration of the motion to exceed the word
limits; the motion for leave to intervene on appeal, the
December 14, 2022 notice regarding filings, the
responses to the motion, and the lodged reply; the
emergency motion for stay, the responses thereto, and
the reply; and the motion for leave to file a brief as
amicus curiae in support of a stay, it is
JA2
ORDERED that the motion to exceed the word
limits be granted. The Clerk is directed to file the
lodged reply. It is
FURTHER ORDERED that the motion for leave
to intervene on appeal be denied. The movantintervenors (the “States”) may, however, participate as
amici curiae. As no statute or rule governs intervention
at the appellate stage, this court applies the policies
underlying intervention in the district courts outlined
in Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 24. See Cameron v.
EMW Women’s Surgical Ctr., P.S.C., 142 S. Ct. 1002,
1010 (2022); Karsner v. Lothian, 532 F.3d 876, 885
(D.C. Cir. 2008). Those factors are: “(1) the application
to intervene must be timely; (2) the applicant must
demonstrate a legally protected interest in the action;
(3) the action must threaten to impair that interest;
and (4) no party to the action can be an adequate
representative of the applicant’s interests.” Deutsche
Bank Nat’l Tr. Co. v. F.D.I.C., 717 F.3d 189, 192 (D.C.
Cir. 2013) (quoting Karsner, 532 F.3d at 885).
“Timeliness is an important consideration” to be
determined from all the circumstances, Cameron, 142
S. Ct. at 1012, “especially weighing the factor[] of time
elapsed since the inception of the suit,” Smoke v.
Norton, 252 F.3d 468, 471 (D.C. Cir. 2001) (quoting
United States v. AT&T, 642 F.2d 1285, 1295 (D.C. Cir.
1980)). Intervention “will usually be denied where a
clear opportunity for pre-judgment intervention was
not taken.” Associated Builders & Contractors, Inc. v.
Herman, 166 F.3d 1248, 1257 (D.C. Cir. 1999) (quoting
Dimond v. District of Columbia, 792 F.2d 179, 193
(D.C. Cir. 1986)); see NAACP v. New York, 413 U.S.
JA3
345, 365 (1973) (“If [an application] is untimely,
intervention must be denied.”); Associated Builders,
166 F.3d at 1257 (“If the motion was not timely, there
is no need for the court to address the other factors
that enter into an intervention analysis.”); Amador
County v. Department of the Interior, 772 F.3d 901,
903 (D.C. Cir. 2014) (“At the threshold * * * the motion
to intervene must be timely.”) (citing United States v.
British Am. Tobacco Austl. Servs., Ltd., 437 F.3d 1235,
1238 (D.C. Cir. 2006)).
In this case, the inordinate and unexplained
untimeliness of the States’ motion to intervene on
appeal weighs decisively against intervention.
First, although this litigation has been pending for
almost two years, the States never sought to intervene
in the district court until almost a week after the
district court granted plaintiffs’ partial summary
judgment motion and vacated the federal government’s
Title 42 policy. The filing was so late in the litigation
process that the federal government’s filing of a notice
of appeal shortly thereafter, in the States’ view,
deprived the district court of jurisdiction even to act on
the motion. Notice Re: Pending Mot. to Intervene and
Alternative Renewed Mot. to Intervene at 2–4, HuishaHuisha v. Mayorkas, No. 22-5325 (D.C. Cir. Dec. 9,
2022). As a result, the States have asked this court to
allow them to intervene for the first time in this
litigation when the case is already on appeal. Id. at 4.
Second, long before now, the States have known
that their interests in the defense and perpetuation of
the Title 42 policy had already diverged or likely would
diverge from those of the federal government’s should
JA4
the policy be struck down. Fourteen months ago,
Texas—one of the States seeking intervention
now—filed a motion to intervene in this court on the
ground that “[e]volving circumstances * * * have made
it apparent that Texas’ interests diverge from [the
federal] Defendants’ and that Texas’ intervention is
necessary for its interests to be adequately
represented.” Mot. to Intervene at 2, Huisha-Huisha v.
Mayorkas, No. 21-5200 (D.C. Cir. Oct. 11, 2021). Texas
cited as grounds for the differing interests its concerns
that the federal government would settle or otherwise
not vigorously pursue preservation of its existing
immigration policy, id. at 2–3, and actions by the
federal government that “have called into question
whether Defendants will continue to defend the
Title 42 Process, or whether they might take action
(i.e., a settlement, failure to pursue an appeal, or
otherwise) that would be adverse to Texas,” id. at 3
(emphasis added). See also id. at 14 (“[T]he potential
for Defendants’ representation to be inadequate has
recently come to the fore in light of the Defendants’
representations in Texas’ other litigations * * * and
because of Defendant Mayorkas’s recent promulgation
of final guidance” on immigration matters.) (citation
omitted); id. at 18 (“There is a palpable prospect that
Defendants might resolve this litigation in a way that
would harm Texas[.]”).
Despite that “palpable” divergence in interests that
already existed in October 2021, neither Texas nor any
of the States here moved to intervene in district court
on remand from this court or during the summary
judgment proceedings.
JA5
On top of that, more than eight months ago, the
federal government issued an order terminating the
Title 42 policy. Because of the asserted consequences of
that significant change in position by the federal
government, the same States seeking to intervene in
this case sued the federal government for failing to
perpetuate the Title 42 policy and obtained a
preliminary injunction against implementation of the
termination order, which the federal government has
appealed. See Louisiana v. CDC, __ F. Supp. 3d ___,
2022 WL 1604901 (W.D. La. May 20, 2022), appeal
pending, No. 22-30303 (5th Cir.). These events not only
“should have alerted the would-be intervenors” that the
federal government’s stake in perpetuating Title 42
differed from theirs, Cameron, 142 S. Ct. at 1013
(citing NAACP, 413 U.S. at 367), it actually did alert
them. They told the district court two weeks ago: “For
most of 2022, it has been clear that CDC/DHS wanted
* * * to end Title 42[.]” Reply Memo. in Support of Mot.
to Intervene at 1, Huisha-Huisha v. Mayorkas,
No. 1:21-cv-00100 (D.D.C. Dec. 2, 2022), ECF No. 177
(emphasis added).
While the States applaud the federal government’s
legal arguments at summary judgment in the district
court, Reply to Resps. in Support of Mot. to Intervene
at 3–4, Huisha-Huisha v. Mayorkas, No. 22-5325 (D.C.
Cir. Dec. 15, 2022), Texas’ prior effort to intervene as
well as the federal government’s attempted termination
of the Title 42 policy put the States on notice—in their
own words—“[f]or most of 2022” that their interests in
keeping Title 42 in place had long since ceased to
overlap with the United States’ interests. Further,
given the fact that eight months ago the federal
JA6
government indicated its intent to drop the Title 42
policy, it should come as no surprise to the States that
the federal government has now chosen not to pursue
the “extraordinary relief” of a stay pending appeal.
Citizens for Responsibility & Ethics in Wash. v. FEC,
904 F.3d 1014, 1017 (D.C. Cir. 2018). Yet these longknown-about differing interests in preserving Title 42
—a decision of indisputable consequence—are the only
reasons the States now provide for wanting to
intervene for the first time on appeal. Nowhere in their
papers do they explain why they waited eight to
fourteen months to move to intervene.
Given that record, this case bears no resemblance to
Cameron or United Airlines, Inc. v. McDonald, 432 U.S.
385, 394 (1977), on which the States rest their claim to
intervention on appeal. The States’ own prior filings
show that they did not seek intervention “as soon as it
became clear” that the intervenor’s interests would no
longer be protected by existing parties. Cameron, 142
S. Ct. at 1012 (quoting United Airlines, Inc., 432 U.S.
at 394). While in United Airlines, “there was no reason
for the respondent to suppose that [the named
plaintiffs] would not later take an appeal until * * *
after the trial court had entered its final judgment,”
432 U.S. at 394, intervenor-movant Texas voiced that
very risk more than a year ago when it told this court
that “[t]here is a palpable prospect that Defendants
might resolve this litigation in a way that would harm
Texas—whether through a settlement, failure to
pursue further appeal, or otherwise.” Mot. to Intervene
at 18, Huisha-Huisha v. Mayorkas, No. 21-5200 (D.C.
Cir. Oct. 11, 2021). And the rest of the intervenormovant States have known that the United States no
JA7
longer shared their interest in preserving Title 42’s
operation “[f]or most of 2022[.]” Reply Memo. in
Support of Mot. to Intervene at 1, Huisha-Huisha v.
Mayorkas, No. 1:21-cv-00100 (D.D.C. Dec. 2, 2022),
ECF No. 177. It is
FURTHER ORDERED that the emergency motion
for stay or administrative stay be dismissed as moot. It
is
FURTHER ORDERED that the motion for leave
to file an amicus brief in support of a stay be dismissed
as moot.
Per Curiam
FOR THE COURT:
Mark J. Langer, Clerk
BY:
/s/
Laura M. Morgan
Deputy Clerk
JA8
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Civ. Action No. 21-100(EGS)
[Filed: November 15, 2022]
__________________________________________
NANCY GIMENA HUISHA-HUISHA, et al., )
)
Plaintiffs,
)
)
v.
)
)
ALEJANDRO MAYORKAS, in his official
)
capacity as Secretary of Homeland
)
Security, et al.,
)
)
Defendants.
)
__________________________________________)
ORDER
For the reasons stated in the accompanying
Memorandum Opinion, it is hereby
ORDERED that Plaintiffs’ Motion for Partial
Summary Judgment, ECF No. 144, is GRANTED. The
Court vacates and sets aside the Title 42 policy—
consisting of the regulation at 42 C.F.R. § 71.40 and all
orders and decision memos issued by the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention or the U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services suspending
the right to introduce certain persons into the United
States; and declares the Title 42 policy to be arbitrary
and capricious in violation of the Administrative
Procedure Act and permanently enjoins Defendants
JA9
and their agents from applying the Title 42 policy with
respect to Plaintiff Class Members; and it is further
ORDERED that any request to stay this Order
pending appeal will be denied for the reasons stated in
the accompanying Memorandum Opinion.
SO ORDERED.
Signed: Emmet G. Sullivan
United States District Judge
November 15, 2022
JA10
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Civil Action No. 21-100 (EGS)
[Filed: November 15, 2022]
__________________________________________
NANCY GIMENA HUISHA-HUISHA, et al., )
)
Plaintiffs,
)
)
v.
)
)
ALEJANDRO MAYORKAS, in his official
)
capacity, Secretary, Department of
)
Homeland Security, et al.,
)
)
Defendants.
)
__________________________________________)
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Plaintiffs—a group of asylum-seeking families who
fled to the United States—bring this lawsuit against
Alejandro Mayorkas, in his official capacity as
Secretary of Homeland Security, and various other
federal government officials (“Defendants” or the
“government”) for violations of the Administrative
Procedure Act (“APA”), 5 U.S.C. § 701, et seq.; the
Immigration and Nationality Act (“INA”), 8 U.S.C.
§ 1101, et seq.; and the Foreign Affairs Reform and
Restructuring Act of 1998 (“FARRA”), 8 U.S.C. § 1231
note; and the Public Health Service Act of 1944, 42
U.S.C § 201, et seq. See generally Second Am. Compl.,
JA11
ECF No. 131.1 Pending before the Court is Plaintiffs’
Motion for Partial Summary Judgment.2 See Mot.
Partial Summ. J., ECF No. 144. Upon consideration of
the motion, the responses and replies thereto, the
applicable law, the entire record, and for the reasons
stated below, the Court GRANTS Plaintiffs’ motion.
I.
Background
A. Factual Background
Since 1893, federal law has provided federal officials
with the authority to stem the spread of contagious
diseases from foreign countries by prohibiting, “in
whole or in part, the introduction of persons and
property from such countries.” Act of February 15,
1893, ch. 114, § 7, 27 Stat. 449, 452 (“1893 Act”). Under
current law:
Whenever the Surgeon General determines that
by reason of the existence of any communicable
disease in a foreign country there is serious
danger of the introduction of such disease into
the United States, and that this danger is so
1
When citing electronic filings throughout this Memorandum
Opinion, the Court cites to the ECF page number, not the page
number of the filed document.
2
On August 12, 2022, the Court converted Plaintiffs’ second
motion for preliminary injunction to a motion for partial summary
judgment, and consolidated the second motion for preliminary
injunction with a determination on the merits with regard to the
issue of whether the Title 42 policy is arbitrary and capricious
under the Administrative Procedure Act (“APA”). See Fed. R. Civ.
P. 65(a)(2).
JA12
increased by the introduction of persons or
property from such country that a suspension of
the right to introduce such persons and property
is required in the interest of the public health,
the Surgeon General, in accordance with
regulations approved by the President, shall
have the power to prohibit, in whole or in part,
the introduction of persons and property from
such countries or places as he shall designate in
order to avert such danger, and for such period
of time as he may deem necessary for such
purpose.
42 U.S.C. § 265 (“Section 265”). In 1966, the Surgeon
General’s Section 265 authority was transferred to the
Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”),
which in turn delegated this authority to the Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”) Director.
See P.J.E.S. v. Wolf, 502 F. Supp. 3d 492, 503 (D.D.C.
2020); 31 Fed. Reg. 8855 (June 25, 1966), 80 Stat. 1610
(1966).
On March 20, 2020, as the COVID-19 virus spread
globally, HHS issued an interim final rule pursuant to
Section 265 that aimed to “provide[] a procedure for
CDC to suspend the introduction of persons from
designated countries or places, if required, in the
interest of public health.” Interim Final Rule, Control
of Communicable Diseases; Foreign Quarantine:
Suspension of Introduction of Persons Into United
States From Designated Foreign Countries or Places
for Public Health Purposes, 85 Fed. Reg. 16559-01,
2020 WL 1330968, (March 24, 2020) (“Interim Final
Rule”). Pursuant to the Interim Final Rule, the CDC
JA13
Director could “suspend the introduction of persons
into the United States.” Id. at 16563. The Interim Final
Rule stated, in relevant part:
(1) Introduction into the United States of
persons from a foreign country (or one or more
political subdivisions or regions thereof) or place
means the movement of a person from a foreign
country (or one or more political subdivisions or
regions thereof) or place, or series of foreign
countries or places, into the United States so as
to bring the person into contact with persons in
the United States, or so as to cause the
contamination of property in the United States,
in a manner that the Director determines to
present a risk of transmission of a
communicable disease to persons or property,
even if the communicable disease has already
been introduced, transmitted, or is spreading
within the United States;
(2) Serious danger of the introduction of such
communicable disease into the United States
means the potential for introduction of vectors of
the communicable disease into the United
States, even if persons or property in the United
States are already infected or contaminated with
the communicable disease; and
(3) The term “Place” includes any location
specified by the Director, including any carrier,
as that term is defined in 42 CFR 71.1, whatever
the carrier’s nationality.
Id. at 16566-67.
JA14
The CDC’s interim rule went into effect
immediately. Id. at 16565. The CDC explained that,
pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 553(b)(3)(B) of the APA, HHS had
concluded that there was “good cause” to dispense with
prior notice and comment. Id. Specifically, the CDC
stated that “[g]iven the national emergency caused by
COVID-19, it would be impracticable and contrary to
the public health—and, by extension, the public
interest—to delay these implementing regulations until
a full public notice-and-comment process is completed.”
Id.
Pursuant to the Interim Final Rule, the CDC
Director issued an order suspending for 30 days the
introduction of “covered aliens,” which he defined as
“persons traveling from Canada or Mexico (regardless
of their country of origin) who would otherwise be
introduced into a congregate setting in a land Port of
Entry [(“POE”)] or Border Patrol station at or near the
United States borders with Canada and Mexico.” Notice
of Order Under Sections 362 and 365 of the Public
Health Service Act Suspending Introduction of Certain
Persons From Countries Where a Communicable
Disease Exists, 85 Fed. Reg. 17060-02, 17061, 2020 WL
1445906 (March 26, 2020) (“March 2020 Order”). The
March 2020 Order declared that “[i]t is necessary for
the public health to immediately suspend the
introduction of covered aliens” and “require[d] the
movement of all such aliens to the country from which
they entered the United States, or their country of
origin, or another location as practicable, as rapidly as
possible.” Id. at 17067. The CDC Director then
“requested that [the Department of Homeland Security
(“DHS”)] implement th[e] [March 2020 Order] because
JA15
CDC does not have the capability, resources, or
personnel needed to do so.” Id. The CDC Director also
noted that U.S. Customs and Border Protection
(“CBP”), a federal law enforcement agency of DHS, had
already “developed an operational plan for
implementing the order.” Id.
Soon thereafter, the CBP issued a memorandum on
April 2, 2020 establishing its procedures for
implementing the March 2020 Order. See Ex. E to
Cheung Decl. (“CAPIO Memo”), ECF No. 57-5 at 15.
The CAPIO Memo instructed that agents may
determine whether individuals are subject to the CDC’s
order “[b]ased on training, experience, physical
observation, technology, questioning and other
considerations.” CAPIO Memo, ECF No. 57-5 at 15. If
an individual was determined to be subject to the
order, they were to be “transported to the nearest POE
and immediately returned to Mexico or Canada,
depending on their point of transit.” Id. at 17. Those
who are “not amenable to immediate expulsion to
Mexico or Canada, will be transported to a dedicated
facility for limited holding prior to expulsion” to their
home country. Id.
On April 22, 2020, the March 2020 Order was
extended for an additional 30 days. See Extension of
Order Under Sections 362 and 365 of the Public Health
Service Act; Order Suspending Introduction of Certain
Persons From Countries Where a Communicable
Disease Exists, 85 Fed. Reg. 22424-01, 2020 WL
1923282 (April 22, 2020) (“April 2020 Order”). The
order was then extended again on May 20, 2020 until
such time that the CDC Director “determine[s] that the
JA16
danger of further introduction of COVID-19 into the
United States has ceased to be a serious danger to the
public health.” Amendment and Extension of Order
Under Sections 362 and 365 of the Public Health
Service Act; Order Suspending Introduction of Certain
Persons From Countries Where a Communicable
Disease Exists, 85 Fed. Reg. 31503-02, 31504, 2020 WL
2619696 (May 26, 2020) (“May 2020 Order”).
On September 11, 2020, the CDC published the
final rule. See Control of Communicable Diseases;
Foreign Quarantine: Suspension of the Right To
Introduce and Prohibition of Introduction of Persons
Into United States From Designated Foreign Countries
or Places for Public Health Purposes, 85 Fed. Reg.
56424-01, 2020 WL 5439721, (Sept. 11, 2020) (Effective
October 13, 2020) (“Final Rule”). The Final Rule
“defin[ed] the phrase to ‘[p]rohibit, in whole or in part,
the introduction into the United States of persons’ to
mean ‘to prevent the introduction of persons into the
United States by suspending any right to introduce
into the United States, physically stopping or
restricting movement into the United States, or
physically expelling from the United States some or all
of the persons.’” Id. at 56445. The CDC Director then
replaced the March, April, and May 2020 Orders with
a new order on October 13, 2020. Order Suspending the
Right To Introduce Certain Persons From Countries
Where a Quarantinable Communicable Disease Exists,
85 Fed. Reg. 65806, 65808 (Oct. 16, 2020) (“October
2020 Order”).
In February 2021, the President ordered the HHS
Secretary and the CDC Director, in consultation with
JA17
the DHS Secretary, to “promptly review and determine
whether termination, rescission, or modification of the
[October order and the September regulation] is
necessary and appropriate.” Exec. Order No. 14,010,
§ 4(ii)(A), 86 Fed. Reg. 8267, 8269 (Feb. 2, 2021). On
August 2, 2021, the CDC issued the order at issue in
this case, “Public Health Assessment and Order
Suspending the Right to Introduce Certain Persons
from Countries Where a Quarantinable Communicable
Disease Exists,” which replaced and superseded the
October 2020 Order. Public Health Reassessment and
Order Suspending the Right to Introduce Certain
Persons from Countries Where a Quarantinable
Communicable Disease Exists, 86 Fed. Reg. 42828
(“August 2021 Order”). The August 2021 Order stated
that “CDC has determined that an Order under 42
U.S.C. § 265 remains necessary to protect U.S. citizens,
U.S. nationals, lawful permanent residents, personnel
and noncitizens at the ports of entry (POE) and U.S.
Border Patrol stations, and destination communities in
the United States during the COVID-19 public health
emergency.” Id. at 42829-30. The August 2021 Order
continued to prohibit the introduction of “covered
noncitizens”—which is defined to include “family
units”—into the United States along the U.S. land and
adjacent coastal borders. Id. at 7. The Court refers to
the process developed by the CDC and implemented by
the August 2021 Order as the “Title 42 policy.”
On April 1, 2022, the CDC terminated the August
2021 Order, with an implementation date of May 23,
2022. Public Health Determination and Order
Regarding Suspending the Right To Introduce Certain
Persons From Countries Where a Quarantinable
JA18
Communicable Disease Exists, 87 Fed. Reg. 19941,
19942. CDC explained that “[w]hile earlier phases of
the pandemic required extraordinary actions by the
government and society at large,” “epidemiologic data,
scientific knowledge, and the availability of public
health mitigation measures, vaccines, and therapeutics
have permitted the country to safely transition to more
normal routines.” Id. The agency explained that
“although COVID-19 remains a concern, the readily
available and less burdensome public health mitigation
tools to combat the disease render a [Title 42 order] . . .
unnecessary.” Id. at 19953. In view of the changed
circumstances, CDC stated that “the previously
identified public health risk is no longer commensurate
with the extraordinary measures instituted by the CDC
Orders.” Id.
B. Procedural History
Plaintiffs filed this action on January 12, 2021. See
Compl., ECF No. 1. Plaintiffs filed a motion for class
certification on January 28, 2021, see Mot. Certify
Class, ECF No. 23; and they filed a motion for
preliminary injunction on February 5, 2021, see Mot.
Prelim. Inj., ECF No. 57. On September 16, 2021, the
Court granted both motions. See Huisha-Huisha, 560
F. Supp. 3d at 155. The Court certified Plaintiffs’ class
and preliminarily enjoined Defendants from expelling
Plaintiffs pursuant to the Title 42 policy. Id. In
granting the preliminary injunction, the Court
concluded that Plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the
merits of their claim that Section 265 did not authorize
deportations, that Plaintiffs would face grave harm if
they were expelled without the opportunity to seek
JA19
humanitarian relief, and that the balance of the
equities and public interest favored an injunction. Id.
at 167, 172, 174.
Defendants appealed the Court’s decision, and the
United States Court of Appeals for the District of
Columbia Circuit (“D.C. Circuit”) affirmed the
preliminary injunction in part. Huisha-Huisha, 27
F.4th at 735. The circuit court held that, pursuant to
Section 265, “the Executive can expel the Plaintiffs
from the country,” but “it cannot expel them to places
where they will be persecuted or tortured.” Id. at 722.
Moreover, the D.C. Circuit agreed with this Court’s
findings that Plaintiffs have established they will
suffer irreparable harm absent a preliminary
injunction and that the balance of the equities favored
their request. Id. at 733.
Although the CDC terminated the August 2021
Order one month after the D.C. Circuit’s decision, see
87 Fed. Reg. at 19,942; on May 20, 2022, the
termination order was preliminarily enjoined in a
separate litigation in the United States District Court
for the Western District of Louisiana on the ground
that the order violated the APA’s notice-and-comment
requirements, see Louisiana v. CDC, No. 22-cv-885,
2022 WL 1604901 (W.D. La. May 20, 2022). The
government appealed the decision but did not seek to
undertake notice and comment regarding the
termination order.
Plaintiffs filed a second motion for preliminary
injunction on August 10, 2022. See Pls.’ Second Mot.
Prelim. Inj., ECF No. 141. On August 12, 2022, the
Court issued a Minute Order converting the second
JA20
motion for preliminary injunction to a motion for
partial summary judgment and consolidating the
second motion for preliminary injunction with a
determination on the merits with regard to the issue of
whether the Title 42 policy is arbitrary and capricious
under the APA. Min. Order (Aug. 12, 2022). The Court
considered the second motion for preliminary
injunction to be withdrawn without prejudice. Id. In
view of the Court’s Minute Order, Plaintiffs filed a
motion for partial summary judgment on August 15,
2022, see Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144; Defendants filed
their opposition on August 31, 2022, see Defs.’ Opp’n,
ECF No. 147; and Plaintiffs filed their reply on
September 14, 2022, see Pls.’ Reply, ECF No. 149-1.
The Court granted Defendants’ motion for leave to file
a surreply on September 22, 2022, and further ordered
Plaintiffs to file their response to the surreply on
September 30, 2022. See Defs.’ Surreply, ECF No. 160;
Pls.’ Response, ECF No. 159. The motion is ripe for
adjudication.
II.
Legal Standards
A. Administrative Procedure Act
The APA establishes a “basic presumption of
judicial review [for] one ‘suffering legal wrong because
of agency action.’” Abbott Laboratories v. Gardner, 387
U.S. 136, 140 (1967) (quoting 5 U.S.C. § 702). That
presumption can be rebutted by a showing that the
relevant statute “preclude[s]” review, § 701(a)(1); or
that the “agency action is committed to agency
discretion by law,” 5 U.S.C. § 701(a)(2). “The former
applies when Congress has expressed an intent to
preclude judicial review.” Heckler v. Chaney, 470 U.S.
JA21
821, 830 (1985). The latter applies: (1) “in those rare
instances where statutes are drawn in such broad
terms that in a given case there is no law to apply,”
Citizens to Preserve Overton Park, Inc. v. Volpe, 401
U.S. 402, 410 (1971); and (2) when “the statute is
drawn so that a court would have no meaningful
standard against which to judge the agency’s exercise
of discretion,” Heckler, 470 U.S. at 830. “Agency actions
in these circumstances are unreviewable because the
courts have no legal norms pursuant to which to
evaluate the challenged action, and thus no concrete
limitations to impose on the agency’s exercise of
discretion.” Sierra Club v. Jackson, 648 F.3d 848, 855
(D.C. Cir. 2011) (citation omitted).
If reviewable, courts consider “both the nature of
the administrative action at issue and the language
and structure of the statute that supplies the
applicable legal standards for reviewing that action” in
determining whether an action is committed to agency
discretion. Sec. of Labor v. Twentymile Coal Co., 456
F.3d 151, 156 (D.C. Cir. 2006) (citation omitted).
However, Section 701(a)(2) “provides a ‘very narrow
exception’ that applies only in ‘rare instances.’” Cody v.
Cox, 509 F.3d 606, 610 (D.C. Cir. 2007) (quoting
Citizens to Preserve Overton Park, Inc. v. Volpe, 401
U.S. 402, 410 (1971)). Courts “begin with the strong
presumption that Congress intends judicial review of
administrative action[] unless there is persuasive
reason to believe that such was the purpose of
Congress.” Ramah Navajo School Bd., Inc. v. Babbitt,
87 F.3d 1338, 1343-44 (D.C. Cir. 1996) (citations
omitted).
JA22
B. Summary Judgment
Plaintiffs seek review of an administrative decision
under the APA. Therefore, the standard articulated in
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 56 is inapplicable
because the Court has a more limited role in reviewing
the administrative record. Wilhelmus v. Geren, 796
F. Supp. 2d 157, 160 (D.D.C. 2011) (internal citation
omitted). “[T]he function of the district court is to
determine whether or not as a matter of law the
evidence in the administrative record permitted the
agency to make the decision it did.” See Sierra Club v.
Mainella, 459 F. Supp. 2d 76, 90 (D.D.C. 2006)(internal
quotation marks and citations omitted). “Summary
judgment thus serves as the mechanism for deciding,
as a matter of law, whether the agency action is
supported by the administrative record and otherwise
consistent with the APA standard of review.”
Wilhelmus, 796 F. Supp. 2d at 160 (internal citation
omitted).
III.
Analysis
Plaintiffs argue that the Title 42 Process is
arbitrary and capricious because: (1) the CDC failed to
apply the “least restrictive means” standard when
authorizing the policy; (2) the policy does not rationally
serve its stated purpose in view of the alternatives; and
(3) the CDC failed to consider the harm the policy
would inflict on impacted individuals. Pls.’ Mot., ECF
No. 144-1 at 10-11. For the reasons below, the Court
concludes that summary judgment is appropriate for
Plaintiffs.
JA23
A. Plaintiffs’ Claim Is Reviewable
Defendants contend that Plaintiffs’ claim is
exempted from judicial review under the APA because
the decision to “issue, modify, or terminate a Title 42
order” is committed to the CDC’s discretion by law, and
Title 42 “is drawn so that a court would have no
meaningful standard against which to judge the
agency’s exercise of discretion.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF
No. 147 at 17 (citing 5 U.S.C. § 701(a)(2); Lincoln v.
Vigil, 508 U.S. 182, 191-93 (1993)). The Court,
however, concludes that Defendants have not overcome
the “strong presumption of reviewability” under the
APA. Steenholdt v. FAA, 314 F.3d 633, 638 (D.C. Cir.
2003) (citing Abbott Labs. v. Gardner, 387 U.S. 136,
140 (1967)).
First, the Title 42 Process “does not fall into one of
the narrow categories that usually satisfies the
strictures of subsection 701(a)(2).” Cody v. Cox, 509
F.3d 606, 610 (D.C. Cir. 2007) (citing Lincoln, 508 U.S.
at 191-92). This case does not involve “second-guessing
executive branch decision[s] involving complicated
foreign policy matters,” id. (quoting Legal Assistance
for Vietnamese Asylum Seekers v. Dep’t of State, 104
F.3d 1349, 1353 (D.C. Cir. 1997)); “an agency’s refusal
to undertake an enforcement action,” id. (citing Heckler
v. Chaney, 470 U.S. 821, 831 (1985)); or a
“determination about how to spend a lump-sum
appropriation,” id. (citing Lincoln, 508 U.S. at 192).
Second, and contrary to Defendants’ assertion, the
fact that CDC’s determination under Section 265 may
“involve[] a complicated balancing of a number of
factors which are peculiarly within the agency’s
JA24
expertise,” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 18; does not on
its own compel the conclusion that such decisions are
unreviewable, see, e.g., Louisiana v. CDC, No. 6:22-cv00885, 2022 WL 1604901, at *17 (W.D. La. May 20,
2022) (holding that CDC’s decision to terminate its
prior Title 42 orders was subject to judicial review);
Texas v. Biden, No. 4:21-cv-0579-P, 2022 WL 658579,
at *11-12 (N.D. Tex. Mar. 4, 2022) (finding CDC’s July
2021 and August 2021 orders were not committed to
agency discretion); Health Freedom Def. Fund, Inc. v.
Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP, 2022 WL 1134138,
at *18-20 (M.D. Fla. Apr. 18, 2022) (reviewing CDC
regulation mandating mask usage in certain locations
during COVID-19 pandemic); Florida v. Becerra, 544
F. Supp. 3d 1241, 1292-94 (M.D. Fla. 2021) (reviewing
CDC’s “no-sail orders” that halted the cruise industry’s
operation from March 2020 through October 2020). As
Plaintiffs point out, “nearly every agency decision
involves a balancing of factors, and frequently involve
highly technical issues, so Defendants’ rule would
essentially gut the APA’s strong presumption favoring
review.” Pls.’ Reply, ECF No. 149-1 at 9. Indeed, the
D.C. Circuit rejected a similar argument in Cody v.
Cox, 509 F.3d 606 (D.C. Cir. 2007). In Cody, the circuit
court addressed whether a provision requiring an
agency retirement home to provide “high quality and
cost-effective” health care was reviewable under the
APA. 509 F.3d at 610. The D.C. Circuit concluded that
although the statute gave the agency “broad discretion
in administering care” and “‘high quality and costeffective’ health care is a tricky standard for a court to
apply,” the provisions at issue did not commit decisions
to agency discretion by law. Id.
JA25
Moreover, Defendants cite no case law supporting
their contention that an agency’s public health
decisions are outside the judiciary’s purview. Rather,
Defendants point to a line of cases standing for the
proposition that courts typically grant agencies
deference when reviewing their public health
determinations. See Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 1819. However, whether an agency is given deference is
a different issue from whether an agency’s decision is
reviewable in the first instance, and none of the cases
Defendants cite involve the application of Section
701(a)(2). See FDA v. Am. Coll. Of Obstetricians &
Gynecologists, 141 S. Ct. 578, 579 (2021) (Roberts, C.J.,
concurring in grant of stay application) (stating that
the question before the court was “whether the District
Court properly ordered the FDA to lift [certain]
established requirements because of the court’s own
evaluation of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic”);
S. Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom, 140
S. Ct. 1613, 1613 (2020) (Roberts, C.J., concurring)
(finding that it was “improbable” that California’s
restrictions on social gatherings during the pandemic
were unconstitutional, where party sought emergency
relief in an interlocutory posture); Marshall v. United
States, 414 U.S. 417, 427 (1974) (considering
“petitioner’s claim that the provisions of Title II of the
Narcotic Addict Rehabilitation Act of 1966 . . . deny due
process and equal protection by excluding from
discretionary rehabilitative commitment, in lieu of
penal incarceration, addicts with two or more prior
felony convictions”); Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197
U.S. 11, 30 (1905) (reviewing constitutionality of state
provisions relating to vaccination).
JA26
Third, the Court also disagrees that Section 265 “is
drawn so that a court would have no meaningful
standard against which to judge the agency’s exercise
of discretion.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 19. Section
265 mandates that, whenever the CDC Director
determines that there is a “serious danger of the
introduction” of a “communicable” disease into the
country, the CDC “shall have the power to prohibit, in
whole or in part, the introduction of persons and
property from such countries or places as he shall
designate in order to avert such danger, and for such
period of time as he may deem necessary for such
purpose” and when “required in the interest of public
health.” 42 U.S.C. § 265 (emphasis added); see also 87
Fed. Reg. 19941, 19955 (Apr. 2022 Order) (“[T]his
authority extends only for such period of time deemed
necessary to avert the serious danger of the
introduction of a quarantinable communicable disease
into the United States.”). Despite the use of the words
“may” and “deem” in the statute, the D.C. Circuit has
“regularly found Congress has not committed decisions
to agency discretion under far more permissive and
indeterminate language.” Cody, 509 F.3d at 610-11
(citing Dickson v. Sec’y of Def., 68 F.3d 1396 (D.C. Cir.
1995) (reviewing provision stating that agency “may”
take an action if it finds it to be “in the interest of
justice”); see also Marshall Cty. Health Care Auth. v.
Shalala, 988 F.2d 1221, 1224 (D.C. Cir. 1993) (“[T]he
government, in our view, puts too much emphasis on
the word ‘deem.’”). The statute, therefore, “limit[s] the
agency’s discretion in discrete ways.” Sierra Club v.
U.S. Fish & Wildlife Serv., 930 F. Supp. 2d 198, 209
(D.D.C. 2013).
JA27
As the D.C. Circuit has explained, “[t]he mere fact
that a statute grants broad discretion to an agency does
not render the agency’s decisions completely
nonreviewable under the ‘committed to agency
discretion by law’ exception unless the statutory
scheme, taken together with other relevant materials,
provides absolutely no guidance as to how that
discretion is to be exercised.” Robbins v. Reagan, 780
F.2d 37 (D.C. Cir. 1985) (emphasis added) (“[G]iven the
fact that the statute limits the uses for which the funds
can be used, we see no barrier to our assessing whether
the agency’s decision was based on factors that are
relevant to this goal.”). Because Section 265 provides
meaningful standards against which to examine agency
action, Plaintiffs’ claim is reviewable.
B. The Title 42 Process Is Arbitrary and
Capricious
1. Defendants Failed to Apply the Least
Restrictive Means Standard
The D.C. Circuit has explained that “[r]easoned
decision-making requires that when departing from
precedents or practices, an agency must ‘offer a reason
to distinguish them or explain its apparent rejection of
their approach.’” Physicians for Social Responsibility v.
Wheeler, 956 F.3d 634, 644 (D.C. Cir. 2020) (quoting
Sw. Airlines Co. v. FERC, 926 F.3d 851, 856 (D.C. Cir.
2019)). Not “every agency action representing a policy
change must be justified by reasons more substantial
than those required to adopt a policy in the first
instance.” Grace v. Barr, 965 F.3d 883, 900 (D.C. Cir.
2020) (quoting FCC v. Fox Television Stations, Inc., 556
U.S. 502, 514 (2009)). However, the agency may not
JA28
“gloss[] over or swerve[] from prior precedents without
discussion.” Id. (quoting Sw. Airlines, 926 F.3d at 856).
Plaintiffs argue that the Title 42 Process is
arbitrary and capricious because the CDC (1) failed to
impose the “least restrictive means necessary to
prevent the spread of disease” when implementing the
policy and (2) failed to explain its departure from this
“settled practice.” Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 11-12.
According to Plaintiffs, CDC had previously “clarif[ied]”
this standard in Control of Communicable Diseases, 82
Fed. Reg. 6890, 6912 (Jan. 19, 2017) (“2017 Final
Rule”). Pls.’ Reply, ECF No. 149-1 at 14 (quoting 82
Fed. Reg. 6890, 6912). The 2017 Final Rule amended
CDC regulations “governing its domestic (interstate)
and foreign quarantine regulations” following the
“largest outbreak of Ebola virus disease . . . on record”
and the “outbreak of Middle East Respiratory
Syndrome (MERS).” 82 Fed. Reg. at 6890-91. The rule
was intended to “enhance HHS/CDC’s ability to
prevent the introduction, transmission, and spread of
communicable diseases into the United States and
interstate by clarifying and providing greater
transparency regarding its response capabilities and
practices.” Id. Among other things, the 2017 Final Rule
“clarif[ied]” that “in all situations involving quarantine,
isolation, or other public health measures, it seeks to
use the least restrictive means necessary to prevent
spread of disease.” Id. at 6912.
Defendants, however, dispute that CDC’s Title 42
orders are subject to the “least restrictive means”
standard. In Defendants’ view, the 2017 Final Rule
provided that the standard applies solely in the context
JA29
of quarantine and isolation, and only with regard to
measures implemented “under this [2017] Final Rule.”
Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 28 (quoting 82 Fed. Reg.
at 6890). The Court disagrees with Defendants.
First, the Court is not convinced that the Title 42
orders do not fall into the category of a “quarantine,
isolation, or other public health measures,” as
contemplated by the 2017 Final Rule. The August 2021
Order, after all, specifically concerns “quarantinable
communicable diseases,” discusses the feasibility of
quarantine or isolation of individuals, and lists 42
U.S.C. § 268 as its legal authority, which in turn sets
out the “[q]uarantine duties of consular and other
officers.” 86 Fed. Reg. at 42838; 42 U.S.C. § 268; see
also id. § 268(b) (“It shall be the duty of the customs
officers and of Coast Guard officers to aid in the
enforcement of quarantine rules and regulations.”).
Moreover, Dr. Anne Schuchat, the former CDC
principal deputy director in 2020, testified before the
House of Representatives that some in the agency did
not believe that the agency’s adoption of the March
2020 Order was appropriately “based on criteria for
quarantine.”3 Ex. A to Cheung Decl., ECF No. 144-3
3
The Court considers Dr. Schuchat’s extra-record testimony to
evaluate the existence of a “least restrictive means” standard with
respect to public health measures generally. See, e.g., Hispanic
Affairs Project v. Acosta, 901 F.3d 378, 386 n.4 (D.C. Cir. 2018)
(“The district court struck many of the Project’s declarations
because they were outside of the administrative record considered
by the Labor Department in promulgating its 2015 Rule. But as
relevant here, the Project employs the declarations for the distinct
and permissible purpose of proving that the Department of
JA30
at 7 (emphasis added). She further testified that “the
typical issue is, the least restrictive means possible to
protect public health is when you exert a quarantine
order versus other measures. And the bulk of the
evidence at that time did not support this policy
proposal.” Id.
Even the examples the 2017 Final Rule provided of
measures requiring the “least restrictive means” test
did not include quarantine or isolation as their primary
recommendations. Rather, the 2017 Final Rule stated:
HHS/CDC agrees and clarifies that in all
situations involving quarantine, isolation, or
other public health measures, it seeks to use the
least restrictive means necessary to prevent
spread of disease. Regarding quarantine, as an
example, during the 2014-2016 Ebola epidemic,
HHS/CDC recommended monitoring of
potentially exposed individuals rather than
quarantine. Most of these people were free to
travel and move about the community, as long
as they maintained daily contact with their
health department. For some individuals with
higher levels of exposure, HHS/CDC
recommended enhanced monitoring (involving
direct observation) and, in some cases
restrictions on travel and being in crowded
places, but did not recommend quarantine.
HHS/CDC has the option of “conditional release”
Homeland Security has a practice or policy of routinely extending
H-2A visa status for three years.” (internal citation omitted)).
JA31
as a less restrictive alternative to issuance of an
order of quarantine or isolation.
82 Fed. Reg. at 6912. The August 2021 Order similarly
considered the availability of facilities for isolation and
quarantine before determining it was not a feasible
option. See e.g., 86 Fed. Reg. at 42836 (stating that
releasing family units to communities required, among
other things, quarantine facilities, but that such
facilities would not be available for all individuals).
And significantly, the CDC applied the “least
restrictive means” standard in the April 2022 Order
terminating the Title 42 policy, stating that the agency
had “determined that less restrictive means are
available to avert the public health risks associated
with the introduction, transmission, and spread of
COVID-19 into the United States.” 87 Fed. Reg. at
19955 (emphasis added); see also 87 Fed. Reg. at 15252
(rescinding Title 42 policy as to unaccompanied
children and explaining “CDC is committed to using
the least restrictive means necessary and avoiding the
imposition of unnecessary burdens in exercising its
communicable disease authorities.”).
Further, whether the specific goals of the 2017 Final
Rule does not preclude a finding that the agency’s
practice was to apply the “least restrictive means” test
more broadly. After all, the 2017 Final Rule did not
state that it was applying the “least restrictive means”
test for the first time; instead, the CDC explained that
the intent behind the rule was “to clarify the agency’s
standard operating procedures and policies.” 82 Fed.
Reg. at 6931. For example, in noting that the agency
had “received several comments requesting the ‘least
JA32
restrictive’ means with respect to quarantine and
isolation,” the CDC not only clarified that it used the
“least restrictive means” with respect to those two
specific contexts, but also “agree[d] and clarifie[d]” that
the agency sought to use that standard “in all
situations involving quarantine, isolation, or other
public measures.” 82 Fed. Reg. at 6912 (emphasis
added). Defendants’ contention that the “least
restrictive” standard applies only to U.S. citizens
similarly fails because the CDC has clarified that it
“appl[ies] communicable disease control and prevention
measures uniformly to all individuals in the United
States, regardless of citizenship, religion, race, or
country of residency.” 89 Fed. Reg. at 6894 (emphasis
added).
Finally, Defendants point to other CDC regulations
governing mask mandates and pre-departure COVID19 testing requirements as examples of measures CDC
implemented without applying the standard at issue.4
Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 28-29 (citing 86 Fed. Reg.
69256 (Dec. 7, 2021); 86 Fed. Reg. 8025 (Feb. 3, 2021);
85 Fed. Reg. 86933 (Dec. 31, 2020)). Defendants argue
that these examples demonstrate that “CDC routinely
implements [public health] measures without regard”
to the standard. Id. However, the Court agrees with
Plaintiffs that “masking or testing are among the least
restrictive COVID-19 measures available,” and, by
4
Defendants also cite to “regulations governing medical
examinations of certain noncitizens seeking to enter the United
States.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 28-29. This regulation,
however, was implemented prior to the 2017 Final Rule’s policy
clarification.
JA33
contrast, “Title 42 expulsions are, in the CDC’s own
view, ‘among the most restrictive measures CDC has
undertaken’ against COVID-19.’” Pls.’ Reply, ECF
No. 149-1 at 15-16 (quoting 87 Fed. Reg. at 19951).
Moreover, the CDC has applied the standard to more
comparable public health measures, such as those
regarding the introduction of persons into the country
during the Ebola virus outbreak. See Control of
Communicable Diseases, 82 Fed. Reg. 6890, 6896
(stating that “HHS/CDC used the best available science
and risk assessment procedures . . . and principles of
least restrictive means to successfully ensure that
measures to ban travel between the United States and
the affected countries were unnecessary” during Ebola
outbreak).
Defendants argue, however, that “[i]n any event,
CDC’s August 2021 order ultimately was in fact the
least restrictive means available to prevent the further
introduction of COVID-19 into the United States at the
borders at the time it was issued.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF
No. 147 at 29. They contend that “while CDC may not
have expressly used the term ‘least restrictive means,’
the substance of CDC’s August order makes clear that
CDC did, in practice, issue an order that was in fact the
least restrictive means available to protect the country
from further introduction, transmission, and spread of
COVID-19.” Id. at 30. However, a plain reading of the
August 2021 Order does not indicate that the CDC
instituted the “least restricted means available,” and a
discussion of potential mitigation measures does not
necessarily mean that the least burdensome measures
were selected.
JA34
The Court therefore concludes that the August 2021
Order is arbitrary and capricious due to CDC’s “failure
to acknowledge and explain its departure from past
practice.” Grace, 965 F.3d at 903. (finding that agency’s
“failure to acknowledge the change in policy is
especially egregious given its potential consequences
for asylum seekers”).
2. Defendants Failed to Consider the
Consequences of Suspending
Immigration to Covered Noncitizens
Plaintiffs further argue that the Title 42 orders are
arbitrary and capricious because the CDC failed to
consider the harms to migrants subject to expulsion.
Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 26. Defendants, in
opposition, argue that the CDC was not required to
consider the harms to noncitizens because “neither the
statute nor the implementing regulation calls for the
CDC Director to engage in any such balancing of
harms.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 41-42. The “sole
inquiry,” in Defendants’ view, is whether a Title 42
order “is required in the interest of the public health.”
Id. at 42.
As an initial matter, consideration of the negative
impacts that the measures would have on migrants
was required by the least restrictive means standard.
See, e.g., 82 Fed. Reg. at 6896 (weighing the necessity
of measures to ban travel to the United States against
the “dramatic negative implications for travelers and
industry”).
Moreover, and as set forth above, the APA requires
that agencies engage in “reasoned decisionmaking.”
JA35
Dep’t of Homeland Sec. v. Regents of the Univ. of Calif.,
140 S. Ct. 1891, 1913 (2020). “Under this narrow
standard of review, a court is not to substitute its
judgment for that of the agency, but instead to assess
only whether the decision was based on a consideration
of the relevant factors and whether there has been a
clear error of judgment.” Id. at 1905 (2020) (internal
quotation marks omitted) (citation omitted). “That task
involves examining the reasons for agency
decisions—or, as the case may be, the absence of such
reasons.” Judulang v. Holder, 565 U.S. 42, 53 (2011).
Here, the consequences of suspending immigration
proceedings for all covered noncitizens was a “relevant
factor,” or an “important aspect of the problem,” that
CDC should have considered. Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n
v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins., 463 U.S. 29, 43 (1983).
And contrary to Defendants’ argument, the factors
that an agency must consider are not limited to those
that are expressly mentioned within a statute or
regulation. For example, the Supreme Court in
Department of Homeland Security v. Regents of the
University of California, 140 S. Ct. 18981 (2020), held
that the agency was required to consider any reliance
interests prior to terminating Deferred Action for
Childhood Arrivals, despite the lack of statute or
regulation mandating that the agency do so. See
Regents, 140 S. Ct. at 1914-15 (considering whether
agency appropriately addressed whether there was
“legitimate reliance” on DACA program prior to
rescission).
Although Defendants are correct that Section 265 is
concerned with preventing the introduction of
JA36
communicable disease into the United States, the
means of prevention is just as relevant. It is
unreasonable for the CDC to assume that it can ignore
the consequences of any actions it chooses to take in
the pursuit of fulfilling its goals, particularly when
those actions included the extraordinary decision to
suspend the codified procedural and substantive rights
of noncitizens seeking safe harbor. See Huisha-Huisha,
27 F.4th at 724-25 (describing the “procedural and
substantive rights” of aliens, such as asylum seekers,
“to resist expulsion”); cf. Regents, 140 S. Ct. at 1914-15
(holding that agency should have considered the effect
rescission of DACA would have on the program’s
recipients prior to the agency making its decision). As
Defendants concede, “a Title 42 order involving persons
will always have consequences for migrants,” Defs.’
Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 42, and numerous public
comments during the Title 42 policy rulemaking
informed CDC that implementation of its orders would
likely expel migrants to locations with a “high
probability” of “persecution, torture, violent assaults, or
rape.” See Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 27; see also id.
at 27-28 (listing groups subject to expulsion under
Title 42, including “survivors of domestic violence and
their children, who have endured years of abuse”;
“survivors of sexual assault and rape, who are at risk
of being stalked, attacked, or murdered by their
persecutors in Mexico or elsewhere”; and “LGBTQ+
individuals from countries where their gender identity
or sexual orientation is criminalized or for whom
expulsion to Mexico or elsewhere makes them prime
targets for persecution” (citing AR, ECF No. 154 at 2829, 47, 153) (cleaned up)). It is undisputed that the
impact on migrants was indeed dire. See, e.g., Huisha-
JA37
Huisha, 27 F.4th at 734 (finding Plaintiffs would suffer
irreparable harm if expelled to places where they would
be persecuted or tortured).
The CDC “has considerable flexibility in carrying
out its responsibility,” Regents, 140 S. Ct. at 1914, and
the Court is mindful that it “is not to substitute its
judgment for that of the agency,” FCC v. Fox Television
Stations, Inc., 556 U.S. 502, 513 (2009). But regardless
of the CDC’s conclusion, its decision to ignore the harm
that could be caused by issuing its Title 42 orders was
arbitrary and capricious.
3. The Title 42 Policy Failed to
Adequately Consider Alternatives
Plaintiffs also argue that the Title 42 policy is
arbitrary and capricious because CDC failed to
adequately consider alternatives and the policy did not
rationally serve its stated purpose. See Pls.’ Mot., ECF
No. 144-1 at 10-11.
First, Plaintiffs contend that “CDC failed to
adequately consider other ‘alternative way[s] of
achieving [its] objective’ that were raised by
commenters and were available from the very
beginning—namely self-quarantine and outdoor
processing.” Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 21.
With regard to self-quarantine measures, the Court
disagrees. The record shows that commenters informed
CDC that the “vast majority (approximately 92%) of
migrants have family or friends already in the United
States,” and proposed that covered noncitizens could
self-quarantine or self-isolate in these homes or in the
shelters of community and faith-based organizations.
JA38
Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 21. In responding to this
proposed alternative, CDC stated that even if it “were
to assume that many covered aliens have family or
close friends in the United States,” the commenters
had not provided evidence that the “family or close
friends had personal residences and, if so, whether they
would make them available as self-quarantine or selfisolation locations.” 85 Fed. Reg. at 56452. Nor did the
commenters “look at whether residences were suitable
for self-quarantine or self-isolation in compliance with
HHS/CDC guidelines.” Id. CDC “maintain[ed] that its
implementation of a self-quarantine or self-isolation
protocol for covered aliens would consume undue
HHS/CDC and CBP resources without averting the
serious danger of the introduction of COVID-19 into
CBP facilities” and that “[e]xpulsion is a more effective
public health measure for CBP facilities that preserves
finite HHS/CDC resources for other public health
operations.” Id. Thus, based on the record evidence, it
appears that CDC considered the possibility of
permitting self-quarantining, but ultimately concluded
that lack of resources made it impractical.
However, Defendants failed to consider another
“obvious and less drastic alternative” and give a
reasoned explanation for its rejection of the alternative.
Yakima Valley Cablevision, Inc. v. FCC, 794 F.2d 737,
746 n.36 (D.C. Cir. 1986); see also Spirit Airlines, Inc.
v. U.S. Dep’t of Transp., 997 F.3d 1247, 1255 (D.C. Cir.
2021). In the August 2021 Order, the CDC noted the
risk of spreading COVID-19 to others “when people are
in close contact with one another . . . , especially in
crowded or poorly ventilated indoor settings.” 86 Fed.
Reg. at 42832. Due to this risk, the CDC indicated that
JA39
processing under Title 42 presented a safer alternative
to processing under Title 8 because “processing an
individual for expulsion under the CDC order takes
roughly 15 minutes and generally happens outdoors.”
Id. at 42836. However, the August 2021 Order makes
no mention of whether Title 8 processing could also
take place outdoors, as suggested by at least one
commenter as a less drastic measure to expulsion. See
generally id.; AR, ECF No. 154 at 9; Pls.’ Mot., ECF
No. 144-1 at 20-21. And although Defendants state in
their opposition brief that “[o]utdoor processing . . . was
unavailable in August 2021,” they do so without
citation to the record. Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 33.
It is well-established that courts “look only to what the
agency said at the time of the [action]—not to its
lawyers’ post-hoc rationalizations,” Grace, 965 F.3d at
903 (quoting Good Fortune Shipping SA v. Comm’r of
Internal Revenue Serv., 897 F.3d 256, 263 (D.C. Cir.
2018)). Because Defendants’ explanation “falls well
short of what is needed to demonstrate the agency
grappled with an important aspect of the problem
before it considered another reasonable path forward,”
Spirit Airlines, 997 F.3d at 1255; CDC’s failure to
consider such an important alternative is arbitrary and
capricious, see, e.g., Yakima Valley, 794 F.2d at 746
n.36 (noting that “[t]he failure of an agency to consider
obvious alternatives has led uniformly to reversal”);
Allied Local & Reg’l Mfrs. Caucus v. EPA, 215 F.3d 61,
80 (D.C. Cir. 2000) (“To be regarded as rational, an
agency must . . . consider significant alternatives to the
course it ultimately chooses”).
Next, Plaintiffs argue that “Defendants could have
instituted testing, vaccination, and quarantine
JA40
protocols, rather than continuing to authorize
expulsions.” Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 17.
Defendants dispute Plaintiffs’ contention, arguing that
CDC had determined that “[o]n-site COVID-19 testing
for noncitizens at CBP holding facilities [was] very
limited,” off-site testing would harm community
healthcare facilities, and “vaccination programs [were]
not available at th[at] time.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147
at 32-33.
“Agencies ‘have an obligation to deal with newly
acquired evidence in some reasonable fashion,’ . . .
[and] to ‘reexamine’ their approaches ‘if a significant
factual predicate changes.’” Portland Cement Ass’n v.
EPA, 665 F.3d 177, 187 (D.C. Cir. 2011) (quoting
Catawba Cty. v. EPA, 571 F.3d 20, 45 (D.C. Cir. 2009);
Bechtel v. FCC, 957 F.2d 873, 881 (D.C. Cir. 1992)).
Moreover, an agency’s statements “must be one of
‘reasoning’; it must not be just a ‘conclusion’; it must
‘articulate a satisfactory explanation’ for its action.”
Butte Cty. v. Hogen, 613 F.3d 190, 194 (D.C. Cir. 2010)
(quoting Tourus Records, Inc. v. DEA, 259 F.3d 731,
737 (D.C. Cir. 2001)).
Here, the March 2020 Order listed the lack of
vaccines, “approved therapeutics,” and rapid testing as
justifications for the emergency measures. See 85 Fed.
Reg. at 17062. Thus, the relevant “significant factual
predicate change[]” with regard to the August 2021
Order was the development and disbursal of COVID-19
vaccines, on-site rapid antigen tests, and effective
therapeutics. See Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 17-18;
see also 86 Fed. Reg. at 42833 (mentioning the wide
availability of vaccines and antigen tests). The CDC
JA41
therefore was required to “reexamine” its approach in
view of the rapidly changing healthcare environment.
The Court concludes that CDC failed to
appropriately consider the availability of effective
therapeutics that “reduce[d] the risk of hospitalization”
by approximately 70 percent in its August 2021 Order.
See Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 18; AR, ECF No. 154
at 143 (listing the availability of monoclonal antibody
doses and their effectiveness against COVID-19).
Defendants do not dispute that the August 2021 Order
failed to even mention such treatments or their overall
availability. Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 33. Instead,
Defendants cite to the April 2022 termination order as
explaining that the treatments were not as widespread
or as diverse in August 2021 and were difficult to
administer. Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 33 (citing 87
Fed. Reg. at 19950); see also 87 Fed. Reg. at 19950
(“Although monoclonal antibodies were available in
August 2021 and some continue to be effective and
were widely used during the Omicron wave, such
treatments must be administered by infusion and are
cumbersome to administer.”). However, whether CDC
analyzed the availability of treatments in April 2022
does not establish that it did so in August 2021. CDC
therefore failed to “deal with newly acquired evidence
in some reasonable fashion” with regard to
therapeutics. Portland, 665 F.3d at 187.
With regard to whether Defendants could have
“ramped up vaccinations, outdoor processing, and all
the other available public health measures,” Butte Cty.,
613 F.3d at 194, the Court finds that CDC failed to
articulate a satisfactory explanation for why such
JA42
measures were not feasible. Defendants argue that
CDC did consider the availability of mitigation
measures, but ultimately, they were limited by the
“operational reality.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 3233. For example, in August 2021, Defendants explained
that DHS had not yet begun initiating a vaccination
program and on-site testing was “very limited.” Id.
Moreover, quarantine measures were unavailable
because CDC “‘lacks the resources, manpower, and
facilities to quarantine covered aliens’ and must rely on
the ‘Department of Defense, other federal agencies, and
states and local governments to provide both logistical
support and facilities for federal quarantines.’” Id. at
33 (quoting 85 Fed. Reg. at 17,067 n.66). However,
CDC’s statements are largely conclusory and do not
reflect any serious analysis of whether reasonable steps
could have been taken to at least begin instituting
vaccination programs, particularly given that all
Americans had been eligible for the vaccine for more
than three months by that point, and increasing the
supply of on-site testing. See AR, ECF No. 154 at 56.
Further, despite CDC’s finding in March 2020 that
DHS could “build and start bringing hard-sided
facilities online” in “90 days (likely more),” 85 Fed. Reg.
at 17067 n.66; there is no indication why those efforts
still would not have addressed the public health
emergency months later. The Court agrees with
Plaintiffs that Defendants cannot rest on the
“operational reality” when Defendants themselves had
the power to change that reality. See Pls.’ Reply, ECF
No. 149-1 at 22 (“After leaning on DHS to implement
Title 42, CDC cannot now turn around and claim that
DHS had no responsibility to take steps to avoid the
continued human suffering of so many vulnerable
JA43
asylum-seekers.”); see also Portland, 665 F.3d at 187
(“It is nothing more than a determination that EPA
would not address the problem unless it happened to
appear at an inconvenient time—an eventuality over
which EPA had full control. The refrain that EPA must
promulgate rules based on the information it currently
possesses simply cannot excuse its reliance on that
information when its own process is about to render it
irrelevant.”).
Finally, Plaintiffs argue that the Title 42 policy did
not rationally serve its stated purpose because
“COVID-19 was already rampant in the United States
in August 2021, the egregious disjuncture between its
stated goal of banning infectious migration and the
narrow group of travelers it actually targeted, and the
ways the Title 42 Policy contributed to spreading
disease.” Defs.’ Reply, ECF No. 149-1 at 22 (internal
citations omitted).
The Court finds that the fact that COVID-19 was
already “widespread” within the United States at the
time of the August 2021 Order is not sufficient to show
that the Title 42 policy did not rationally serve its
stated purpose. See Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 22-23.
The relevant regulation defines “serious danger of the
introduction of [a] quarantinable communicable disease
into the United States” as “the probable introduction of
one or more persons capable of transmitting the
quarantinable communicable disease into the United
States, even if persons or property in the United States
are already infected or contaminated with the
quarantinable communicable disease.” 42 C.F.R.
§ 71.40(b)(3). Although Plaintiffs contend that CDC’s
JA44
definition “simply cannot be a rational public health
rule,” they otherwise do not provide any arguments
regarding why the Court should not defer to CDC’s
interpretation of the term “serious danger.” See Pls.’
Reply, ECF No. 149-1 at 22-23. In view of CDC’s
scientific and technical expertise, the Court does not
find the definition to be unreasonable.
However, despite the above, Defendants have not
shown that the risk of migrants spreading COVID-19
is “a real problem.” District of Columbia v. U.S. Dep’t of
Agric., 444 F. Supp. 3d 1, 27 (D.D.C. 2020) (citing Nat’l
Fuel Gas Supply Corp. v. FERC, 468 F.3d 831, 841
(D.C. Cir. 2006)). “Professing that an agency action
ameliorates a real problem but then citing no evidence
demonstrating that there is in fact a problem is not
reasoned decisionmaking.” Id. (cleaned up); see HuishaHuisha, 27 F.4th at 735 (“[W]e would be sensitive to
declarations in the record by CDC officials testifying to
the efficacy of the § 265 Order. But there are none.”).
As Plaintiffs point out, record evidence indicates that
“during the first seven months of the Title 42 policy,
CBP encountered on average just one migrant per day
who tested positive for COVID-19.” Pls.’ Mot., ECF
No. 144-1 at 22 (citing Sealed AR, ECF No. 155-1 at
23). In addition, at the time of the August 2021 Order,
the rate of daily COVID-19 cases in the United States
was almost double the incidence rate in Mexico and
substantially higher than the incidence rate in Canada.
See 86 Fed. Reg. at 42831 (noting 137.9 daily cases per
100,000 people in the United States, compared to 68.6
in Mexico and 8.0 in Canada). The lack of evidence
regarding the effectiveness of the Title 42 policy is
especially egregious in view of CDC’s previous
JA45
conclusion that “the use of quarantine and travel
restrictions, in the absence of evidence of their utility,
is detrimental to efforts to combat the spread of
communicable disease,” Control of Communicable
Diseases, 82 Fed. Reg. 6890, 6896; as well as record
evidence discussing the “recidivism” created by the
Title 42 policy, which actually increased the number of
times migrants were encountered by CBP, see AR, ECF
No. 154 at 45 (commenter describing recidivism); AR,
ECF No. 155-1 at 4 (January/February 2021 statistics
showing nearly 40% of family units DHS encountered
in January-February 15, 2021 were migrants who had
attempted to cross at least once before).
Moreover, it is undisputed that the suspension of
immigration under Title 42 covered only approximately
0.1% of land border travelers, see Pls.’ Mot., ECF
No. 144-1 at 23. And though Defendants claim that
their focus was on the risk of spreading COVID-19 in
congregate settings, see Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at
39, millions of others were permitted to cross the
border under less restrictive measures, even if they
traveled in congregate setting such cars, buses, and
trains, see Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 23-24; see id.
(“CBP’s own data shows that in July 2021 alone, over
11 million people entered from Mexico by land,
including over 8.4 million people in cars, buses, and
trains.”).
In view of the above, the Court concludes that the
Title 42 policy is arbitrary and capricious.
JA46
C. Remedies
Having concluded that the Title 42 policy is
arbitrary and capricious, the question of remedy
remains. For the reasons below, the Court shall vacate
the Title 42 policy and enjoin Defendants from applying
the Title 42 policy with respect to Plaintiff Class
Members.
1. The Title 42 Policy Is Vacated
Plaintiffs first request that the Court vacate the
Title 42 policy. Pls.’ Reply, ECF No. 149-1 at 30.
Defendants oppose the request, contending that
“[b]ecause any order granting partial summary
judgment would be interlocutory and ineffective until
final judgment except in limited circumstances, the
Court should not grant any relief premised on any such
order but should defer consideration of the issue of
remedy until the Court has adjudicated all of Plaintiffs’
claims.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 160 at 2.
“[U]nsupported agency action normally warrants
vacatur.” Advocates for Highway & Auto Safety v. Fed.
Motor Carrier Safety Admin., 429 F.3d 1136, 1151
(D.C. Cir. 2005). However, courts have discretion to
remand without vacatur if “there is at least a serious
possibility that the [agency] will be able to substantiate
its decision,” and if “vacating would be disruptive.”
Radio-TV News Directors Ass’n v. FCC, 184 F.3d 872,
888 (D.C. Cir. 1999) (alteration in original) (citation
omitted); see Allied-Signal, Inc. v. U.S. Nuclear Reg.
Comm’n, 988 F.2d 146, 150-51 (D.C. Cir. 1993) (“The
decision whether to vacate depends on the seriousness
of the order’s deficiencies . . . and the disruptive
JA47
consequences of an interim change that may itself be
changed.” (citation omitted)). “Alternatively, a court
may vacate the unlawful action but stay its order of
vacatur for a limited time to allow the agency to
attempt to cure the defects that the court has
identified.” NAACP v. Trump, 298 F. Supp. 3d 209, 244
(D.D.C. 2018) (citing Friends of Earth, Inc. v. EPA, 446
F.3d 140, 148 (D.C. Cir. 2006)).
Here, because this action can be disposed of based
on Plaintiffs’ arbitrary and capricious claim, the Court
finds that vacatur is not premature at this stage. See,
e.g., Child.’s Hosp. Ass’n of Texas v. Azar, 300 F. Supp.
3d 190, 205 (D.D.C. 2018), rev’d and remanded on other
grounds, 933 F.3d 764 (D.C. Cir. 2019); see also Zhang
v. USCIS, 344 F. Supp. 3d 32, 66 & n.10 (D.D.C. 2018).
Moreover, the Allied-Signal factors do not compel a
different result. The CDC has already terminated the
August 2021 Order based on “significantly improved
public health conditions,” and the Title 42 policy only
remains in effect because another federal court has
preliminarily enjoined the termination order, which
Defendants are opposing before the Fifth Circuit. Defs’
Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 9. Given the agency’s current
position, it is unlikely that the agency would seek to
justify a renewal of the policy on remand, and vacatur
would not be disruptive given CDC’s rescission of the
policy. See id. at 15-16.
Particularly in view of the harms Plaintiffs face if
summarily expelled to countries they may be
persecuted or tortured, the Court therefore vacates the
Title 42 policy. Cf. Nat. Res. Def. Council v. EPA, 489
F.3d 1250, 1262-64 (D.C. Cir. 2007) (Randolph, J.,
JA48
concurring) (“A remand-only disposition is, in effect, an
indefinite stay of the effectiveness of the court’s
decision and agencies naturally treat it as such.”).
2. Plaintiffs Are Entitled to Injunctive
Relief
Plaintiffs also request that the Court permanently
enjoin Defendants and their agents from applying the
Title 42 policy with respect to Plaintiff Class Members.
See Pls.’ Proposed Order, ECF No. 144-2 at 1.
A permanent injunction “is a drastic and
extraordinary remedy.” Monsanto Co. v. Geertson Seed
Farms, 561 U.S. 139, 165 (2010). It “should not be
granted as a matter of course,” id., and “[s]uccess on an
APA claim does not automatically entitle the prevailing
party to a permanent injunction,” In re Fed. Bureau of
Prisons’ Execution Protocol Cases, 908 F.3d 123, 128
(D.C. Cir. 2020). Rather, a permanent injunction
“should issue only if the traditional four-factor test is
satisfied.” Monsanto, 561 U.S. at 157. The four-factor
test requires that a plaintiff demonstrate that: (1) “it
has suffered an irreparable injury”; (2) “remedies
available at law, such as monetary damages, are
inadequate to compensate for that injury”;
(3) “considering the balance of hardships between the
plaintiff and defendant, a remedy in equity is
warranted”; and (4) “the public interest would not be
disserved by a permanent injunction.” Id. at 156-57
(quoting eBay Inc. v. MercExchange, LLC, 547 U.S.
388, 391 (2006)).
Having found that Plaintiffs are entitled to
summary judgment on their APA claim, the Court first
JA49
turns to whether Plaintiffs have demonstrated
irreparable injury.
“[T]he basis for injunctive relief in the federal courts
has always been irreparable injury and the inadequacy
of legal remedies.” Weinberger v. Romero-Barcelo, 456
U.S. 305, 312 (1982); see also Chaplaincy of Full Gospel
Churches v. England, 454 F.3d 290, 297 (D.C. Cir.
2006) (same). The movant must demonstrate that it
faces an injury that is “both certain and great; it must
be actual and not theoretical,” and of a nature “of such
imminence that there is a clear and present need for
equitable relief to prevent irreparable harm.” Wis. Gas
Co. v. FERC, 758 F.2d 669, 674 (D.C. Cir. 1985)
(quotation marks and emphasis omitted). This presents
a “very high bar.” Beck v. Test Masters Educ. Servs.
Inc., 994 F. Supp. 2d 98, 101 (D.D.C. 2014) (quoting
Coal. for Common Sense In Gov’t Procurement v.
United States, 576 F. Supp. 2d 162, 168 (D.D.C. 2008)).
Plaintiffs argue that they continue to face
irreparable harm because, despite the D.C. Circuit’s
holding in this case that Defendants may not expel
Class Members to areas where they would be
persecuted or tortured, “[d]ocumented cases of
kidnapping, rapes, and other violence against
noncitizens subject to Title 42 have also risen
dramatically since last year.” Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1
at 30. Defendants, in opposition, contend that “the
situation for class members has improved since the
D.C. Circuit first stayed this Court’s preliminary
injunction [in September 2021].” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF
No. 147 at 45 (citing Huisha-Huisha II, 27 F.4th at
722).
JA50
The Court is mindful that “[e]xpulsion is not
categorically irreparable harm.” Huisha-Huisha II, 27
F.4th at 734 (quoting Nken, 556 U.S. at 435) (internal
quotation marks omitted). Here, however, Defendants
do not argue that its guidance to field officers following
the D.C. Circuit’s opinion in this case has prevented
harms to Plaintiffs, only that it has “improved” the
situation. See Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 45. And
while the Court does not doubt that USCIS screenings
are a vital tool in preventing the expulsion of
individuals to countries in which they could be
persecuted, Defendants have not provided any
information regarding how many screening have
occurred since the D.C. Circuit issued its opinion in
March 2022. See Pls.’ Reply, ECF No. 149-1 at 31.
Meanwhile, Plaintiffs have presented evidence
demonstrating that the rate of summary expulsions
pursuant to the Title 42 policy has nearly doubled since
September 2021. See Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 30
(“At the time of this Court’s original decision,
approximately 14% of families encountered at the
southwest border were being summarily expelled
pursuant to the Title 42 policy. . . . Now, the rate of
expulsions is nearly twice as high, reaching 27%.”); see
also Pls.’ Reply, ECF No. 149-1 at 31 (“[I]n the month
of July 2022 alone, 9,574 members of family units
encountered at the southern border were summarily
expelled pursuant to the Title 42 policy.”). And “[i]n
Mexico alone, recorded incidents” of “kidnapping,
rapes, and other violence against noncitizens subject to
Title 42" have “spiked from 3,250 cases in June 2021 to
over 10,318 in June 2022.” Pls.’ Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at
30 (citing Neusner Decl., ECF No. 118-4; Human
Rights First, The Nightmare Continues: Title 42 Court
JA51
Order Prolongs Human Rights Abuses, Extends
Disorder at U.S. Borders, at 3-4 (June 2022)).
Accordingly, even if the Court accepts Defendants’
unsupported statement that the “situation for class
members has improved,” the evidence demonstrates
that Plaintiffs continue to face irreparable harm that is
beyond remediation. See Huisha-Huisha, 27 F.4th at
733 (“[T]he record is replete with stomach-churning
evidence of death, torture, and rape.”).
The Court next addresses the balance of the equities
and public interest factors, which “merge when the
Government is the opposing party.” Nken, 556 U.S. at
434.
Defendants argue that “the government and the
public have an interest in protecting the integrity of
government’s valid orders.” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147
at 45. However, as explained above, this Court has
determined that the Title 42 policy is arbitrary and
capricious, and “[t]here is generally no public interest
in the perpetuation of unlawful agency action.” League
of Women Voters of U.S. v. Newby, 838 F.3d 1, 12 (D.C.
Cir. 2016); see also Ramirez v. ICE, 310 F. Supp. 3d 7,
33 (D.D.C. 2018) (“The public interest surely does not
cut in favor of permitting an agency to fail to comply
with a statutory mandate.”); R.I.L-R, 80 F. Supp. 3d at
191 (“The Government ‘cannot suffer harm from an
injunction that merely ends an unlawful practice or
reads a statute as required to avoid constitutional
concerns.’”). Because “there is an overriding public
interest . . . in the general importance of an agency’s
faithful adherence to its statutory mandate,”
Jacksonville Port Auth. v. Adams, 556 F.2d 52, 59 (D.C.
JA52
Cir. 1977); the Court concludes that an injunction in
this case would serve the public interest, see A.B.-B. v.
Morgan, No. 20-cv-846, 2020 WL 5107548, at *9
(D.D.C. Aug. 31, 2020) (“[T]he Government and public
can have little interest in executing removal orders
that are based on statutory violations . . . .”).
Moreover, Defendants do not contend that issuing
a permanent injunction would cause them harm or be
inconsistent with the public health. Indeed, “CDC
recognizes that the current public health conditions no
longer require the continuation of the August 2021
order,” Defs.’ Opp’n, ECF No. 147 at 44; see also Pls.’
Mot., ECF No. 144-1 at 30, in view of the “less
burdensome measures that are now available,” 87 Fed
Reg. at 19944; id. at 19949-50. The parties also do not
dispute that Plaintiffs continue to face substantial
harm if they are returned to their home countries,
notwithstanding the availability of USCIS screenings.
See, e.g., Human Rights First, The Nightmare
Continues: Title 42 Court Order Prolongs Human
Rights Abuses, Extends Disorder at U.S. Borders, at 34 (June 2022). As the Supreme Court has explained,
the public has a strong interest in “preventing aliens
from being wrongfully removed, particularly to
countries where they are likely to face substantial
harm.” Nken, 556 U.S. at 436.
Therefore, the balance of the equities also favors
Plaintiffs.
IV.
Conclusion
For the reasons stated above, the Court hereby
GRANTS Plaintiffs’ Motion for Partial Summary
JA53
Judgment, ECF No. 144. The Court vacates and sets
aside the Title 42 policy—consisting of the regulation
at 42 C.F.R. § 71.40 and all orders and decision memos
issued by the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention or the U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services suspending the right to introduce
certain persons into the United States; and declares
the Title 42 policy to be arbitrary and capricious in
violation of the Administrative Procedure Act and
permanently enjoins Defendants and their agents from
applying the Title 42 policy with respect to Plaintiff
Class Members. An appropriate Order accompanies
this Memorandum Opinion.
SO ORDERED.
Signed: Emmet G. Sullivan
United States District Judge
November 15, 2022
JA54
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Civ. A. No. 21-100 (EGS)
[Filed: November 22, 2022]
_______________________________________
NANCY GIMENA HUISHA-HUISHA,
)
on behalf of herself and others
)
similarly situated,
)
)
Plaintiffs,
)
)
v.
)
)
ALEJANDRO MAYORKAS, Secretary of )
Homeland Security, et al.,
)
)
Defendants.
)
_______________________________________)
[Proposed] Final Judgment Under Rule 54(b)
and Stay of Proceedings
Upon consideration of Defendants’ Unopposed
Motion for Entry of Partial Final Judgment (“Motion”),
it is hereby ORDERED that the Motion is GRANTED.
Accordingly, it is
ORDERED that, for the reasons identified in the
Motion and the Court’s November 15, 2022
memorandum opinion and order, ECF Nos. 164, 165,
the Court “expressly determines that there is no just
reason for delay” to enter partial final judgment. Fed.
R. Civ. P. 54(b). It is further
JA55
ORDERED that final judgment as to Count Six of
Plaintiffs’ Second Amended Complaint, ECF No. 131
¶¶ 107–11, is ENTERED in favor of Plaintiffs and
against Defendants pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 54(b) on the grounds set forth in the Court’s
memorandum opinion and order, ECF Nos. 165, 165.
Proceedings before this Court on Plaintiffs’
remaining claims are STAYED pending further order
of this Court. The parties shall submit a joint status
report informing the Court how they wish to proceed 60
days from today.
______________________________
HON. EMMET G. SULLIVAN
U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE
Date: 11/22/2022
JA56
D.D.C. Docket Entry – December 9, 2022 Order
denying stay pending appeal
HUISHA-HUISHA et al v. GAYNOR et al,
1:21CV00100 (2021)
DOCKET PROCEEDINGS (320)
Date: 12/09/2022
Description:
MINUTE ORDER denying 183 motion to stay pending
appeal for the reasons stated in 165 Memorandum
Opinion. Signed by Judge Emmet G. Sullivan on
12/9/2022. (lcegs1) (Entered: 12/09/2022)
JA57
D.D.C. Docket Entry – November 16, 2022 Order
granting stay “not for the pendency of appeal”
HUISHA-HUISHA et al v. GAYNOR et al,
1:21CV00100 (2021)
DOCKET PROCEEDINGS
Date: 11/16/2022
Description:
MINUTE ORDER granting 166 Unopposed Emergency
Motion for Temporary Stay of the Court’s November 15,
2022 Order (“Emergency Mot.”). The government states
that “[t]he requested temporary stay... is not for the
pendency of appeal but rather for only a temporary
period.” Emergency Mot., ECF No. 166 at 3. The
government further states that “DHS requires a short
period of time to prepare for the transition from
Title 42 to Title 8 processing, given the need to resolve
resource and logistical issues that it was unable to
address in advance without knowing precisely when
currently operative August 2021 Title 42 order would
end. Cf. 87 Fed. Reg. at 19,95456 (setting effective date
of Termination Order for 52 days from date of issuance
to, among other things, provide DHS with additional
time to ready operational plans). During this period of
time, DHS will need to move additional resources to
the border and coordinate with stakeholders, including
non-governmental organizations and state and local
governments, to help prepare for the transition to
Title 8 processing. This transition period is critical to
ensuring that DHS can continue to carry out its
mission to secure the Nation’s borders and to conduct
its border operations in an orderly fashion. See, e.g.,
JA58
AARP v. EEOC, 292 F. Supp. 3d 238, 241 (D.D.C. 2017)
(staying effective date of vacatur order for about one
year to avoid the potential for disruption); NAACP v.
Trump, 298 F. Supp. 3d 209, 24445 (D.D.C. 2018)
(staying vacatur order for 90 days to avoid disruption).”
Id. Plaintiffs do not oppose the motion. Pursuant to
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 59 and 60, the Court’s
inherent authority, and in view of the lack of opposition
by Plaintiffs, the government’s representation that the
request for a temporary stay is not for the pendency of
appeal, but rather to enable the government to make
preparations to implement the Court’s Order, the
Court, WITH GREAT RELUCTANCE, grants the
request. The Court’s November 15, 2022 Order is
stayed for five weeks, from November 15, 2022 to
December 20, 2022. The Order will take effect at
midnight on December 21, 2022. Signed by Judge
Emmet G. Sullivan on 11/16/2022. (lcegs1) (Entered:
11/16/2022)
JA59
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
Case No. 22-5325
[Filed: December 12, 2022]
__________________________________________
Nancy Huisha-Huisha et al.,
)
Plaintiff-Appellees,
)
v.
)
Alejandro N. Mayorkas,
)
Defendant-Appellants
)
and
)
States of Arizona, Louisiana, Alabama,
)
Alaska, Kansas, Kentucky, Mississippi,
)
Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Ohio,
)
Oklahoma, South Carolina, Texas,
)
Tennessee, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia,
)
and Wyoming.
)
Proposed Intervenor-Defendants. )
__________________________________________)
DECLARATION OF JAMES K. ROGERS
I, James K. Rogers, declare as follows:
1. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in
Arizona. I am a Senior Litigation Counsel with the
Arizona Office of the Attorney General.
2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and
correct copy of Morgan Phillips, Biden
administration wants $3 BILLION to deal with a
migrant surge when Title 42 ends, DAILY MAIL
(Dec. 9, 2022), https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/
JA60
politics/biden-administration-wants-dollar3billion-to-deal-with-a-migrant-surge-whentitle-42-ends/ar-AA156exA.
3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and
correct copy of Julia Ainsley, The Biden
administration wants more than $3 billion to
prep for a possible migrant surge at the border
after Covid ban ends, NBC NEWS (Dec. 9, 2022),
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/
immigration/biden-admin-wants-2-billion-migra
nt-surge-border-covid- ban-ends-rcna60659.
4. Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and
correct copy of Anna Giaritelli, White House asks
Congress for $3B to cover anticipated rush of
illegal immigrants, WASHINGTON EXAMINER
(Dec. 9, 2022), https://www.washingtone
xaminer.com/policy/immigration/white-houseasks-congress-for-3-billion-end-title-42.
5. Attached hereto as Exhibit D is a true and
correct copy of Jack Newman, Around 1,000
migrants line the Rio Grande waiting to cross into
US as Title 42 is set to lapse, DAILY MAIL (Dec. 12,
2022), https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/
world/around-1000-migrants-line-the-riogrande-waiting-to-cross-into-us-as-title-42-is-setto-lapse/ar-AA15bpdv.
6. Attached hereto as Exhibit E is a true and
correct copy of Adam Shaw, Bill Melugin, and Griff
Jenkins, Border officials seeing massive migrant
numbers, large groups ahead of Title 42’s end,
FOX NEWS (Dec. 10, 2022), https://www.fox
JA61
news.com/politics/border-officials-seeingmassive-migrant-numbers-large-groups-aheadtitle-42s-end.
7. Attached hereto as Exhibit F is a true and
correct copy of Mark Moore, Democratic senators
express ‘deep concerns’ over Biden ending Title 42,
NY POST (Nov. 29, 2022), https://nypost.com/
2022/11/29/senators-have-deep-concernsabout-end-of-title-42/.
8. I declare under penalty of perjury that the
foregoing is true and correct to the best of my
knowledge, and that this declaration was issued on
December 12, 2022, in Phoenix, Arizona.
s/ James K. Rogers
James K. Rogers
JA62
Exhibit A
Biden administration wants $3 BILLION to deal
with a migrant surge when Title 42 ends
The Department of Homeland Security is requesting an
additional $3 billion to deal with the impending
onslaught of migrants as Title 42 is slated to end
December 21.
That is on top of the $56.7 billion President Biden
requested to be included in the fiscal year 2023
spending bill Congress is currently negotiating for the
department (DHS).
Senior DHS officials told NBC News they put the
request for further funding to the White House Office
of Management and Budget and the White House has
now taken it to Congress.
Republicans may be hesitant to approve the new funds
as they have said they want to see stricter border
security before pouring in more money.
JA63
Venezuelan migrants get in line to receive donations of
clothing and food at the camp area on the banks of the
Rio Grande that divides Ciudad Juarez, Mecixo and El
Paso, Texas
JA64
Mexican municipal police take measures as Venezuelan
migrants are evicted from the camp area on the banks
of the Rio Grande that divides Ciudad Juarez and El
Paso, Texas
The Covid-era Title 42 allows border agents to
immediately expel migrants and has been used more
than 2.4 million times to keep border crossers from
claiming asylum since former President Trump
instated the policy in 2020.
The number of migrant encounters at the U.S.-Mexico
border has already reached 7,500-8,000 per day and in
a worst-case scenario could swell up to 18,000 a day,
officials predict. Border Patrol have previously said
their resources are stretched to the max when they see
5,000 encounters per day.
JA65
‘We are in the hole for millions, even without Title 42
lifting,’ one of the DHS officials told NBC.
Once Title 42 is no longer effective, migrants will have
the chance to stay in the U.S. and claim asylum.
Further funding is needed to process, shelter and
transport them.
Though the policy is scheduled to end in less than two
weeks, that date us still in flux as a number of
Republican states have asked to defend it in court.
The Biden administration on Wednesday launched an
appeal of the court ruling by U.S. District Judge
Emmett Sullivan that ended the policy. DHS said it is
not looking to continue Title 42-based expulsions - only
arguing that its past expulsions were lawful.
The appeal seeks to preserve the Centers for Disease
Control (CDC) authority to impose public health orders
to regulate migration.
Last month, Sullivan deemed the policy unlawful and
the Biden administration asked for a five-week stay to
prepare for the end of its key border enforcement
policy.
The CDC declared Title 42 unnecessary to curb the
spread of Covid-19 in April, but Republican-led states
challenged the Biden administration’s attempt to end
the policy and a federal judge in Louisiana halted the
termination at the time.
This week Sens. Kyrsten Sinema and Thom Tillis
worked out a framework on immigration reform and
border security that would extend Title 42 for at least
JA66
one year, but it’s unlikely Congress will act on the
proposal in time for December 21.
Central American migrants surrender to Border Patrol
in Texas
JA67
Exhibit B
The Biden administration wants more than
$3 billion to prep for a possible migrant surge at
the border after Covid ban ends
DHS wants more than $3 billion from Congress to prep
for a migrant surge expected when Covid restrictions
end Dec. 21, money Republicans may not be willing to
approve.
— Migrants seek shelter in a church in Piedras Negras,
Mexico, on Nov. 16. Sergio Flores / AFP via Getty
Images file
Dec. 9, 2022 4:30 AM MST
By Julia Ainsley
JA68
As the Biden administration braces for the record
number of migrants crossing the southern border daily
to rise still more when Covid restrictions end this
month, the Department of Homeland Security wants
more than $3 billion from Congress to fight the surge,
money Republicans may not be willing to approve.
Three senior DHS officials familiar with the planning
say DHS sent a request for billions to the White
House’s Office of Management and Budget. A source
familiar with the matter said the White House has now
asked Congress for more than $3 billion. The money
comes on top of the president’s budget requests as part
of a fiscal year 2023 technical assistance package.
Republicans have been reluctant to approve additional
funding for the Democratic administration’s border
efforts, saying they want the border secured before
more money is spent.
In a statement, a White House spokesperson said, “If
Republicans in Congress are serious about border
security, they would ensure that the men and women
of the Department of Homeland Security have the
resources they need to secure our border and build a
safe, orderly, and humane immigration system.”
JA69
Mexican authorities evict Venezuelan migrants from
border camps
Covid-19 restrictions known as Title 42 have kept
migrants from claiming asylum more than 2.4 million
times since the policy began under former President
Donald Trump in 2020. A federal judge has ruled that
the policy must lift on Dec. 21; several Republican
states have sued to keep it in place.
The number of undocumented crossings at the U.S.Mexico border is already near record highs, at 7,500 to
8,000 a day.
“We are in the hole for millions, even without Title 42
lifting,” one of the DHS officials said.
JA70
— Migrants cross the street in Piedras Negras, Mexico,
on Nov. 16. Sergio Flores / AFP via Getty Images file
The number of attempted crossings is projected to
increase by as much as 2,500 a day when the Covid ban
ends, DHS officials said, and it could reach 10,000.
And when the ban ends, instead of being sent back
across the border, more migrants will have the chance
JA71
to stay in the U.S. and claim asylum. The extra money
is needed to process, shelter and transport them.
Without more space in border processing centers, the
facilities could get overcrowded, just as they did in
2019, when migrants said they were being held in
spaces too small to lie down to sleep.
They could also end up being released onto the street in
border cities or bused by Republican governors to cities
inside the U.S.
The Biden administration appealed the federal court
ruling that lifted Title 42 on Wednesday, saying the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention was correct
in implementing it. But the administration did not ask
the judge to keep Title 42 in place.
A senior DHS official told NBC News it could be the
perfect time to lift Title 42, because southern border
migration is typically at its lowest around the holidays.
In addition, Republicans who campaigned on platforms
of tighter border security have wrapped their midterm
campaigns, and the 2024 presidential election is nearly
JA72
two years away, so chaos at the border is less likely to
hurt Biden and Democrats at the polls than it would if
Title 42 lifted closer to an election, the official said.
The Biden administration has long planned for the
lifting of Title 42 by streamlining the asylum process,
allowing Border Patrol officers to conduct interviews
and quickly deporting migrants. But it has warned that
improving the process could take time and funding,
claiming “it won’t be achieved overnight.”
DHS did not respond to a request for comment.
Julia Ainsley
Julia Ainsley is homeland security correspondent for
NBC News and covers the Department of Homeland
Security and the Justice Department for the NBC
News Investigative Unit.
[*** Ads Have Been Omitted
for Printing Purposes***]
JA73
Exhibit C
Washington Examiner
White House asks Congress for $3B to cover
anticipated rush of illegal immigrants
by Anna Giaritelli, Homeland Security Reporter
December 09, 2022 03:34 PM
The Biden administration is privately soliciting $3
billion from Congress to cover the anticipated rising
cost of responding to illegal immigration at the U.S.Mexico border, according to a new report.
Senior Homeland Security officials recently asked the
White House Office of Management and Budget for the
emergency money just weeks before the Biden
administration must stop expelling illegal immigrants
back to Mexico, according to an NBC News report
Friday. The White House signed off on the ask and sent
it to lawmakers on Capitol Hill for approval.
But Republicans could prevent the DHS from getting
the money that it wants — despite Democrats saying it
would go to responding to the border crisis.
Historically, Republicans have traded improvements in
physical border security infrastructure or tightening of
immigration policies with Democrats.
The U.S. government has spent an unknown amount of
money over the past two years reimbursing nonprofit
organizations up and down the southern border for
costs accrued while caring for the more than 1.5 million
people who were released by Border Patrol and
JA74
Immigration and Customs Enforcement rather than
being expelled at the border.
OVER 700 IMMIGRANTS CROSS INTO TEXAS
BORDER TOWN AT ONE TIME: ‘THEY KEPT
COMING’
Nonprofit groups also pay for illegal immigrants to fly
or take buses to family or friends across the country,
costs that the government helps cover. The Heritage
Foundation stated in a report released this week that
illegal immigrants helped by nonprofit organizations at
the border traveled to 434 of the country’s 435
congressional districts.
“The investigation confirmed that a host of NGOs are
actively facilitating the Biden border crisis,” the
Heritage Foundation’s Oversight Project wrote in a
statement. “Overflow from Customs and Border
Protection is being transferred to these organizations
so that Border Patrol avoids overcrowded facilities.
These organizations apply for, and receive, taxpayer
money to provide processing and transportation
services and infrastructure to facilitate the migration
of illegal aliens into the interior of the country.”
It is these types of costs that Republicans would likely
protest on the basis that they entice more immigrants
to cross the border illegally.
The Biden administration defended the request and
blasted Republicans ahead of the potential pushback.
“If Republicans in Congress are serious about border
security, they would ensure that the men and women
of the Department of Homeland Security have the
JA75
resources they need to secure our border and build a
safe, orderly, and humane immigration system,” a
White House official told NBC.
Back in May, when the DHS had planned to end the
Title 42 public health protocol more than two years
after it was implemented, it anticipated needing
$2 billion to cover the policy change.
However, the DHS is forecasting fewer illegal
immigration attempts when Title 42 is slated to end on
Dec. 20 than in May, yet its ask this time around is
greater than the spring.
In May, the DHS was planning for up to 18,000 arrests
of illegal immigrants per day. That termination was
blocked in federal court, but the same judge ordered
this fall that DHS end Title 42 this month.
DHS now anticipates up to 10,000 arrests per day.
During the 2019 crisis at the border, when far fewer
immigrants were encountered illegally entering the
country than each month in the past 20 months, the
Trump administration asked Congress for more than
$4 billion.
JA76
Exhibit D
Around 1,000 migrants line the Rio Grande
waiting to cross into US as Title 42 is set to lapse
A caravan of around 1,000 migrants is preparing to
enter the US after a perilous months-long trek through
Central America, amid an expected surge at the
southern border.
The group, mostly from Cuba, Venezuela, and
Nicaragua, is hoping to cross into the country when
Title 42 is set to lapse next week. The policy expanded
the expulsion of migrants over Covid concerns.
The travellers are lining up on the banks of the Rio
Grande in Juarez where they are spending the night in
shelters as Joe Biden pleads for an extra $3billion to
cope with the impending wave.
Their arrival came hours after hundreds of migrants
were caught crossing illegally back into the US just
hours after they had been bussed out of the US and
sent south of the border with a police escort.
JA77
Migrants cross the Rio Grande river to turn themselves
in to US Border Patrol agents to request asylum in El
Paso, Texas
Border Patrol facilities and shelters are already
stretched beyond capacity, with almost 5,000 migrants
being held in the Central Processing Center, which is
supposed to only hold 3,500 people temporarily.
In October, Customs and Border Patrol figures showed
a record 2,378,944 illegal immigrants intercepted at
the border in the previous 12 months, and the numbers
show no sign of slowing.
The latest caravan had been stopped in Jimenez on
Thursday by Chihuahua state officials who warned
them Juarez was already at breaking point.
JA78
But the group continued on their way to the border city
across from El Paso, Texas.
Marjorie and her six-year-old son were among those
forming the line across the El Paso side of the Rio
Grande, according to El Paso Matters.
Many gathered around fires to stay warm while others
crossed back into Juarez to bring back food and water
while they wait in line.
Carmen, a 29-year-old woman from Peru, said: ‘I am
traumatized from threats in my country and I am
traumatized from the kidnapping here.
The first month of Fiscal Year 2023 showed more than
230,000 encounters with CBP, the third-highest month
JA79
in recent history - the only months with higher figures
also occurred under President Joe Biden
For the Fiscal Year ending September 30, there were
2,378,944 encounters - the highest level ever recorded
by the department
JA80
The group, mostly from Cuba, Venezuela and
Nicaragua, is hoping to cross into the country when
Title 42 is set to lapse next week
JA81
A caravan of around 1,000 migrants is preparing to
enter the US after a perilous months-long trek through
Central America
The travellers are lining up on the banks of the Rio
Grande in Juarez where they are spending the night in
shelters
JA82
Asylum-seeking migrants stand near the border wall
after crossing the Rio Bravo river
JA83
Mexican police brought 20 buses full of migrants back
across the border into Ciudad Juarez, the city across
the border from El Paso
Juarez sits directly across the southern border from El
Paso, Texas
___
What is Title 42 and why was it introduced?
The scheme was implemented by the Trump
administration in March 2020, and designed amid the
pandemic to limit the spread of COVID-19.
Migrants were no longer allowed to be processed in the
US and instead, were sent back across the border to
Mexico.
JA84
President Joe Biden attempted to lift it and set a date
for May 23, arguing that the pandemic-era justification
had passed, but was blocked by a federal court in
Louisiana, which ruled on May 20 that the policy must
stay in place.
Last month, District Judge Emmet Sullivan in
Washington DC ruled that Title 42 should be lifted,
describing it as an ‘arbitrary and capricious in violation
of the Administrative Procedure Act.’
In a case brought by the ACLU against the Biden
administration, Sullivan ruled that Title 42 went too
far, and that it would be lifted immediately.
Supporters of Title 42 have said its repeal paves the
way for a surge in migrant crossings, which the United
States is not able to handle.
Those arguing for its repeal say ending Title 42 has
lifted one of the last remaining Trump administration
barriers to lawful asylum claims.
____
‘All I want is to arrive at a place that is safe. That is all
we’re asking for.’
On December 3, a number of the migrants in the
traveling group were targeted by kidnappers in
Durango.
Men in police uniforms halted the group and directed
them to a house where they held them against their
will for six days and stole their belongings.
JA85
They were eventually rescued by the Mexican military
but were unable to retrieve their stolen phones,
passports and money.
Officials are seeing a migration wave at the southern
border with Title 42 expected to end on December 21.
Title 42 was expanded under Donald Trump to allow
for the rapid expulsion of migrants due to the
pandemic, and an estimated 2.4million people have
been turned away at the border since March 2020.
Last month, a court struck down the public health
order as unlawful, and it is now set to end next week,
pending a potential appeal from the government.
The Justice Department said in response: ‘The
government respectfully disagrees with this Court’s
decision and would argue on appeal, as it has argued in
this Court, that CDC’s Title 42 Orders were lawful.’
Since October, an estimated 485,000 migrants have
crossed into the US and the numbers are expected to
reach half a million by the weekend, sources told Fox
News.
The figures are a surge on this time last year when
517,000 had reached the shores of the US between
October 1 and December 31.
With migrant numbers already soaring, there are fears
among border agents that the end of Title 42 could
spark further chaos.
JA86
The latest caravan had been stopped in Jimenez on
Thursday by Chihuahua state officials who warned
them Juarez was already at breaking point
JA87
Migrant girls, who are traveling with their family, are
seen aboard a highway police patrol
Border Patrol facilities and shelters are already
stretched beyond capacity, with almost 5,000 migrants
being held in the Central Processing Center
JA88
On December 3, a number of the migrants in the
traveling group were targeted by kidnappers in
Durango, Mexico
JA89
Title 42 was expanded under Donald Trump to allow
for the rapid expulsion of migrants due to the pandemic
Last month, a court struck down the public health
order as unlawful, and it is set to end next week,
pending a potential appeal from the government
According to the Texas governor’s website, Gov. Greg
Abbott has sent more than 8,400 migrants to
Washington DC since April, and a further 5,000 to New
York and Chicago - many of whom have ended up in
homeless shelters or on the streets.
He has even dropped some outside Vice President
Kamala Harris’s residence.
Yesterday evening, hundreds of migrants were caught
on camera crossing illegally into the US from Juárez
JA90
just hours after they’d been bussed out of the US and
back south of the border with a police escort.
Video shot by a reporter on the banks of the Rio
Grande on the El Paso side of the border captured
images of long lines of migrants waiting to cross over.
Some may have already have been in the US earlier in
the weekend after Customs and Border Protection took
hundreds back across the border into Mexico by bus
with a police escort.
They were released back only for many of them to
make the journey across the Rio Grande river once
again.
Hundreds of migrants were filmed crossing illegally
into El Paso, Texas, from Ciudad Juarez, Mexico, on
Sunday night
JA91
It had been a busy weekend for CBP officials with
reports by El Paso sector of more than 2,600 crossings
in the 24 hours between Friday and Saturday
JA92
Ahead of the mass crossing, Mexican police brought 20
buses full of migrants back across the border into
Ciudad Juarez, the city across the border from El Paso
One of the migrants who was sent back across the
border into Mexico shared video of their journey back
JA93
Video from one of the passengers inside a migrant bus,
showing their Mexican police escort
It’s thought many of those who were brought back into
Mexico simply repeated the journey in crossing the Rio
Grande river, which separates the two cities
JA94
Migrants, mostly from Nicaragua, check their phones
after being dropped off at a bus station, pictured on
Thursday
JA95
Migrants, mostly from Nicaragua, wait at a bus station
in Downtown El Paso, where many are dropped off by
immigration authorities
This weekend alone, nearly 800 migrants were released
from federal custody into El Paso. A group are pictured
being released by immigration authorities on Thursday
JA96
Officials have described the ‘provisional release’ as ‘a
safe and humane release of migrants, who are placed
into the community; who are placed into removal
proceedings and are pending the next steps in their
immigration process’
JA97
Migrants at an El Paso bus station. The migrants had
been processed and are allowed to remain in the U.S.
as they await their immigration hearings
JA98
Last week, city officials in El Paso aired their fears
over a possible surge in migrants crossing the border.
A group are pictured in a downtown bus station
following their release on Thursday
U.S. officials have put forth a number of drastic options
to stem the flow of migration - including prosecuting
more adults who try to evade Border Patrol and
expelling those who have not first sought legal entry or
applied for protection in other countries, according to
Axios.
During November, El Paso released about 2,000
migrants onto the streets after shelters reached
capacity.
This weekend alone, nearly 800 migrants were released
from federal custody into El Paso, reports CBS4.
286 migrants were released on Saturday with a further
498 released on Sunday.
Officials have described the ‘provisional release’ as ‘a
safe and humane release of migrants, who are placed
into the community; who are placed into removal
proceedings and are pending the next steps in their
immigration process.’
The migrants had been processed and are allowed to
remain in the U.S. as they await their immigration
hearings.
Migrants sleep on streets after eviction from Rio Bravo
camp
JA99
JA100
El Paso Deputy City Manager Mario D’Agostino told
city leaders there is no way for their community to be
prepared for the end of Title 42 come December 21
Venezuelan migrants in line to receive donations of
clothing and food at a camp on the banks of the Rio
Grande, which divides Ciudad Juarez and El Paso,
pictured in November
Last week El Paso Deputy City Manager Mario
D’Agostino told city leaders there is no way for their
community to be prepared for the end of Title 42 come
December 21.
‘It’s not a good state. I mean we could see up to
thousands a day passing through our community,’ said
D’Agostino, who is in charge of the city’s response to
the migrant crisis.
JA101
D’Agostino said after talking with FEMA last week it
became more clear how dire the situation could be
when Title 42, the Covid-era CDC health restriction
that allows for immediate expulsion, ends in ten days.
‘Nobody can keep up with that; there is no number of
shelters you could have for that. It’s going to take an
all-out effort and a lot of that is going to come on the
federal government on what they can do to help
decompress our region in our area,’ D’Agostino warned,
according to CBS 4.
For now, El Paso officials are anxiously waiting for the
funding they’ve requested from the federal government
to prepare for the pandemic-era policy’s end.
‘That additional funding will be for when Title 42 is
lifted or with the fact if they continue with street
releases and they are unable to find shelter, we would
have to step up. But we have been asking for the
funding, and we continue to do that,’ said D’Agostino.
JA102
Migrants, mostly from Nicaragua, board a bus to go to
their destination after being released from U.S. Border
Patrol custody in El Paso, Texas, December 5
JA103
El Paso officials are anxiously waiting for the funding
they’ve requested from the federal government to
prepare for the pandemic-era policy’s end
The administration has also said that the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention is working on a new
regulation that would replace Title 42.
However, the CDC said in April that there was no
longer a public health reason to limit asylum.
‘Based on the public health landscape, the current
status of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the procedures
in place for the processing of covered noncitizens …
CDC has determined that a suspension of the right to
introduce such covered noncitizens is no longer
necessary to protect U.S. citizens,’ the CDC had said.
The restrictions were put in place under former
President Donald Trump at the outset of the COVID-19
pandemic.
The practice was authorized under Title 42 of a broader
1944 law covering public health and has been used to
expel migrants more than 2.4 million times.
The Biden Administration has made use of the policy
to expel even more migrants than the previous
administration - as the border has been flooded with
people coming from the so-called ‘Northern Triangle’
countries of Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador
through Mexico.
Biden hasn’t visited the border since becoming
president in January 2021.
JA104
Exhibit E
FOX NEWS.COM
Border officials seeing massive migrant numbers,
large groups ahead of Title 42’s end
By Adam Shaw, Bill Melugin, Griff Jenkins
Published December 10, 2022
Fox News
Officials at the southern border are seeing massive
migrant numbers at the southern border, along with a
number of large groups, ahead of the expected end of
the ability to expel migrants under the Title 42 public
health order in a few weeks.
Customs and Border Protection (CBP) sources tell Fox
News that migrant numbers for FY 2023, which began
in October, are at over 485,000 and are expected to hit
the half a million mark this weekend. So far, 156,000
have been expelled under Title 42.
That order, implemented during the Trump
administration in response to the COVID-19 pandemic,
has allowed the rapid expulsion of migrants at the
border, However, it is due to expire on Dec. 21 after a
court order ruled that its implementation was
unlawful, leading to widespread and bipartisan fears of
a surge on top of a surge.
The nearly half-million encountered since October
means the numbers are outpacing FY 2022, when there
were over 517,000 encounters by the end of December,
and FY 21 where there were just over 216,000 in the
JA105
same period. In FY 2020, there were only 458,058
encounters for the entire fiscal year.
FOX NEWS CREW WITNESSES DRAMATIC
HUMAN SMUGGLING BUSTS BY TEXAS
AUTHORITIES
Dec. 10 2022: Migrants apprehended at the border in
Texas.
These numbers, coming in typically quieter months at
the border, are leaving Border Patrol agents
overwhelmed as agents get hit with enormous migrant
groups. In the last 24 hours, there were more than
2,100 illegal crossings in Del Rio Sector.
In Eagle Pass, Texas, Fox News witnessed as a massive
group of 650 migrants crossing illegally into Eagle
Pass. At the same time, another 350 crossed into the
JA106
other side of town — meaning 1,000 people crossed in
an hour.
TEXAS LAUNCHES TASK FORCE WITH K9S,
DRONES TO STOP ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT
‘GOTAWAYS’ AMID SPIKE IN NUMBERS
In the El Paso Sector, Fox obtained video showing
hundreds crossing into El Paso from across the river,
before forming a single line and surrendering to
authorities. Sources in the sector tell Fox that there
have been more than 2,600 illegal crossings in the last
24 hours alone in the sector — numbers that are
unheard of for December.
The numbers are likely only to fuel concerns about the
impending ending of Title 42. The Department of
Homeland Security has said repeatedly that it has a
six-point plan in place to cope with what it accepts will
be an immediate surge in numbers.
That plan includes an increase of resources and
manpower, as well as a greater use of alternative
authorities such as expedited removal and
punishments for illegal crossings. The administration
has also emphasized its anti-smuggling campaigns and
cooperation with Western Hemisphere countries.
But a number of Republicans and Democrats have said
that plan is insufficient to deal with the historic
numbers that agents may face. In recent days,
lawmakers in the Senate have been thrashing out a
potential agreement on a framework that would extend
Title 42 for a year and provide additional border
security funding in exchange for a pathway to
JA107
citizenship for two million illegal immigrants who came
to the U.S. as minors.
However, that proposal has already seen opposition
from Democrats and Republicans, and it is unclear
whether lawmakers can get a deal in place before
Congress recesses on Dec. 21 and before Republicans
take control of the House in January.
Adam Shaw is a politics reporter for Fox News Digital,
primarily covering immigration and border security.
He can be reached at adam.shaw2@fox.com or on
Twitter.
URL
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/border-officialsseeing-massive-migrant-numbers-large-groups-aheadtitle-42s-end
JA108
Exhibit F
NEW YORK POST
Democratic senators express ‘deep concerns’ over
Biden ending Title 42
By Mark Moore
November 29, 2022 | 10:18am | Updated
Four Democratic senators have told Homeland Security
Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas they have “deep
concerns” about the Biden administration’s plans for
ending the Title 42 health policy, which is expected to
bring a surge of migrants to the United States.
The Trump administration enacted Title 42 during the
early days of the coronavirus pandemic in March 2020
to allow for the quick removal of migrants at the border
JA109
— but a federal judge ruled Nov. 15 the rule was
“arbitrary and capricious” and no longer in line with
public health conditions in the country.
The policy will expire on Dec. 21.
“We have expressed concern with DHS’ preparations
for the end of Title 42, especially as the situation has
deteriorated at times. Record annual encounters have
led to untenable situations,” Sens. Mark Kelly and
Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona, Maggie Hassan of New
Hampshire and Jon Tester of Montana wrote in the
letter made public on Monday.
Four Democratic senators sent a letter to Homeland
Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas seeking
answers on how the administration will handle the end
of Title 42.
AFP via Getty Images
JA110
“In Arizona, shelters have been forced well beyond
capacity. This month, El Paso has seen over 700
migrants released directly onto city streets due to
overcrowding. This is not safe, and creates a dangerous
situation for migrants and communities,” the letter
continued.
Title 42 has been used to remove more than 2.3 million
migrants since March 2020 and White House officials
believe the end of the policy could lead to as many as
18,000 migrants crossing the southern border each day.
Samuel Guerra, a migrant from Venezuela, told The
Post earlier this month that he will be among an
“avalanche” of immigrants entering the US once Title
42 expires.
Guerra is one of thousands of migrants living in a tent
city a stone’s throw away from El Paso, Texas.
JA111
Sen. Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona expressed her concern
to Mayorkas.
AP
Sen. Jon Tester represents Montana.
Getty Images
“Once Title 42 goes away, it just means we’re going to
be releasing even more people into the United States —
which, of course, just encourages more people to come,”
Brandon Judd told The Post earlier this month.
Mayorkas, appearing before the Senate Homeland
Security Committee earlier this month, insisted the
administration has a plan to deal with the
consequences of Title 42.
JA112
Sen. Mark Kelly represents Arizona.
Antranik Tavitian/The Republic/USA
Network/Sipa USA
Today
JA113
Sen. Maggie Hassan represents New Hampshire.
Getty Images
“We are enhancing the consequences for unlawful
entry, especially with respect to individuals who seek
to evade law enforcement, including removal, detention
and criminal prosecution when warranted,” he said at
the Nov. 17 hearing.
Republicans, who won control of the House in the
midterm elections, plan to launch a series of
investigations into the administration’s lax border
policies, and Minority Leader Rep. Kevin McCarthy,
expected to be elected House speaker, has already said
Mayorkas should step down or face potential
impeachment.
JA114
“We will use the power of the purse and the power of
subpoena. Let me be clear: Those responsible for this
disaster will be held accountable,” McCarthy (R-Calif.)
told reporters last week in El Paso.
“If Secretary Mayorkas does not resign, House
Republicans will investigate every order, every action
and every failure to determine whether we can begin
impeachment inquiries.”
JA115
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA CIRCUIT
Case No. 22-5325
[Filed: December 15, 2022]
__________________________________________
Nancy Huisha-Huisha et al.,
)
Plaintiff-Appellees,
)
v.
)
Alejandro N. Mayorkas,
)
Defendant-Appellants
)
and
)
States of Arizona, Louisiana, Alabama,
)
Alaska, Kansas, Kentucky, Mississippi,
)
Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Ohio,
)
Oklahoma, South Carolina, Texas,
)
Tennessee, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia,
)
and Wyoming.
)
Proposed Intervenor-Defendants. )
__________________________________________)
SECOND DECLARATION OF
JAMES K. ROGERS
I, James K. Rogers, declare as follows:
1. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in
Arizona. I am a Senior Litigation Counsel with the
Arizona Office of the Attorney General.
2. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and
correct copy of Stef W. Kight, Biden braces for
potentially 14,000 migrants a day, AXIOS (Dec. 13,
JA116
2022), https://www.axios.com/2022/12/14/title-42migrant-surge-mexico-border.
3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and
correct copy of Adam Shaw and Rich Edson, Biden
admin seeks $4 billion in additional border
funding, predicts post-Title 42 border surge, FOX
NEWS (Dec. 13, 2022), https://www.foxnews.com/
politics/_biden-admin-seeks-4-billion-additionalborder-funding-predicts-post-title-42-border-su
rge.
4. Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and
correct copy of Priscilla Alvarez and Phil
Mattingly, Biden administration prepares for
surge of migrants ahead of the forced end of a
Trump-era border policy, CNN (Dec. 14, 2022),
https://www.cnn.com/2022/12/14/politics/bid
en-administration-prepares-surge/index.html.
5. Attached hereto as Exhibit D is a true and
correct copy of Timothy H.J. Nerozzi, Newsom says
California about to ‘break’ amid flood of illegal
migrants when Title 42 expires, FOX NEWS (Dec.
14, 2022), https://www.foxnews.com/politics/
newsom-says-california-break-flood-illegalmigrants-title-42-expires.
6. Attached hereto as Exhibit E is a true and
correct copy of Nick Allen, Joe Biden’s border
policies risk breaking my state, says governor in
his own party, THE TELEGRAPH (Dec. 14, 2022),
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2022/1
2/14/joe-bidens-border-policies-risk-breakingstate-says-gavin-newsom/.
JA117
7. Attached hereto as Exhibit F is a true and
correct copy of CBS News, Deputy Attorney General
Lisa Monaco on end of Title 42 border policy, CBS
NEWS (Dec. 14, 2022), https://www.cbsnews.com
/news/title-42-deputy-attorney-general-lisamonaco-norah-odonnell-interview/.
8. I declare under penalty of perjury that the
foregoing is true and correct to the best of my
knowledge, and that this declaration was issued on
December 15, 2022, in Mesa, Arizona.
s/ James K. Rogers
James K. Rogers
JA118
Exhibit A
Biden braces for potentially 14,000 migrants a
day
Stef W. Kight
Hundreds of migrants wait to cross the border on the
banks of the Rio Grande that divides Ciudad Juárez in
Mexico and El Paso, Texas. Photo: Jose Zamora/
Anadolu Agency via Getty Images
The possibility of 14,000 migrant crossings a day is
pushing the Biden administration toward a new rule
that would severely limit migrants’ ability to qualify for
asylum at the southern border, Axios has learned.
Why it matters: Officials are concerned that Border
Patrol stations will face acute overcrowding and
Department of Homeland Security resources will be
overwhelmed when the pandemic-era Title 42 policy
JA119
ends on Dec. 21, according to sources familiar with the
plans.
Driving the news: Title 42, implemented during the
Trump administration and extended by President
Biden, allows for the rapid expulsion of migrants and
asylum seekers at the border. It’s scheduled to be lifted
in less than two weeks, barring last-minute court
intervention.
• Encounters with migrants at the southern border
are already at record levels, with the daily tally
surpassing 9,000 three times in the first week and
a half of December, the sources told Axios.
• Officials now are preparing for the possibility of
between 12,000 to 14,000 migrants attempting to
cross every day.
Behind the scenes: A draft rule that would impose an
asylum ban for roughly five months — initially — has
been circulated internally.
• It would apply to both migrant single adults and
families who cross the border illegally — as well as
those who arrive at legal ports of entry without
already having proper authorization to enter.
• A final decision on adopting the new rule hasn’t
been made.
• A White House spokesperson referred Axios to a
recent tweet by press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre
that emphasized “no such decisions have been
made” regarding policy changes.
JA120
• “The Administration is committed to continuing to
secure our borders while maintaining safe, orderly
and humane processing of migrants. This will
remain the case when Title 42 is lifted,” JeanPierre said.
The big picture: The consideration of a drastic move
such as automatically rejecting people from asylum —
similar to efforts under the Trump administration — is
a sign of just how concerned top Biden officials are
about the situation at the U.S.- Mexico border.
• It also builds upon similar moves officials believe
were critical in lowering the number of Ukrainians
and Venezuelans attempting to cross the border.
• The new strategy for Venezuelans and Ukrainians
offers new — and legal — pathways for people
fleeing their home countries, paired with stricter
consequences for attempting to cross the border
illegally.
• NBC News reported Tuesday that the
administration was also solidifying plans to cut the
number of people who qualify for asylum while
considering expanding pathways to parole for
Nicaraguans, Haitians and Cubans.
Details: The new rule is still in the process of being
finalized but would lead to people being considered
ineligible for asylum (as was previously reported by
Axios) unless they meet any of the following criteria:
• Applied for legal pathways to the U.S. like refugee
status or new parole processes, such as the one
created for Venezuelans in October.
JA121
• First sought protection in a country they had to
travel through to get to the U.S.
• Scheduled a meeting at a legal entry point ahead of
time through an app run by border authorities — a
brand new process.
• Are facing extreme circumstances, such as a
medical emergency or other immediate, severe
harm.
The bottom line: Biden officials know they have both
a political and potential humanitarian crisis on their
hands. The very consideration of these rules is an
indication of how seriously they are taking the
problem.
JA122
Exhibit B
FOXNEWS.COM
Biden admin seeks $4 billion in additional border
funding, predicts post-Title 42 border surge
By Adam Shaw, Rich Edson
Published December 13, 2022
Fox News
The Biden administration is requesting billions in
additional funding for the border as it predicts an
enormous spike in migrant encounters when the Title
42 authority to quickly expel migrants due to the
COVID-19 pandemic ends later this month.
According to a congressional aide, the Biden
administration is seeking $2 billion for additional
funding for Customs and Border Protection (CBP) , as
well as $2 billion for Immigration and Customs
Enforcement (ICE).
That request, Fox is told, is based off the Department
of Homeland Security’s estimation of daily encounters
once Title 42 is ended on Dec. 21. A court ordered the
administration to stop using the authority -- which has
been used since March 2020 to quickly return migrants
to Mexico -- after finding it to be unlawful.
That “flow estimation” predicts between 9,000 and
15,000 migrant crossings a day once Title 42 ends. For
context, the average for fiscal year 2022 -- in which
there were a record 2.3 million migrant crossings -- was
approximately 6,500 crossings a day.
JA123
FOX NEWS FOOTAGE SHOWS MASS RELEASE
OF MIGRANTS INTO US, AS NUMBERS HIT
500,000 FOR FY 23
Migrants stand across the Rio Grande from El Paso,
Texas. Thousands of migrants have illegally crossed
into the city in recent days, prompting concerns from
city officials. (Border Patrol)
The $4 billion funding request would fund “border
management” and DHS would use it on soft-sided
facilities, migrant care, transportation, processing, and
the Emergency Food and Shelter program. That is part
of a six-point plan the administration has released that
includes surging resources to the border, antismuggling operations and an increased use of
alternative expulsion authorities such as expedited
removal.
JA124
In a statement to Fox News Digital, the White House
called on Republicans to support the funding request.
“If Republicans in Congress are serious about border
security, they would ensure that the men and women
of the Department of Homeland Security have the
resources they need to secure our border and build a
safe, orderly, and humane immigration system,” White
House Assistant Press Secretary Abdullah Hasan said.
The request comes as authorities at the border have
already been overwhelmed with the high numbers they
have been encountering in recent weeks. Fox News
reported on Tuesday that there have been more than
500,000 encounters already this fiscal year, which
began in October. There have been over 505,000
encounters, averaging at just under 7,000 a day. Of
those, 162,547 have been expelled under Title 42.
That number is on track to outpace prior years. There
were 517,000 encounters by the end of December in FY
2022, and FY 21 where there were just over 216,000 in
the same period. In FY 2020, there were only 458,058
encounters for the entire fiscal year.
Fox News captured footage this week of migrants who
have been released in El Paso after a huge migrant
caravan hit the border on Monday -- dozens of migrants
could be seen camping out on a street corner.
Agents in the El Paso Sector have made 2,416
encounters in the last 24 hours. One Border Patrol
agent told Fox that the numbers “continue to
overwhelm exhausted Border Patrol agents, who
continue to do their best in spite of the evident lack of
support and leadership.”
JA125
MIGRANT CARAVAN OF MORE THAN 1,000
CROSSES ILLEGALLY INTO EL PASO, TEXAS,
VIDEO SHOWS
CBP acknowledged that it has seen a spike in
encounters along the border in recent days.
“Customs and Border Protection’s El Paso Sector on the
Texas border with Mexico has seen an increase in
encounters,” CBP said in a statement to Fox News on
Monday afternoon. “In order to process individuals as
safely and expeditiously as possible, Border Patrol
agents from Big Bend and CBP Officers from El Paso
Field Office are assisting with processing.”
Meanwhile, in Brownsville, Texas, Fox News witnessed
repeated mass releases of several hundred migrants in
a parking garage. Migrants were dropped off by the
hundreds, at which point they walked across to a local
non-governmental organization where they were given
travel paperwork. From there they are free to take a
flight or bus across the country.
Fox News’ Bill Melugin and Griff Jenkins contributed
to this report.
URL
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/biden-admin-seeks4-billion-additional-border-funding-predicts-post-title
-42-border-surge
JA126
Exhibit C
CNN politics
Biden administration prepares for surge of
migrants ahead of the forced end of a Trump-era
border policy
By Priscilla Alvarez and Phil Mattingly, CNN
Published 6:00 AM EST, Wed December 14, 2022
Migrants queue near the border wall to request asylum
in the US city of El Paso, Texas as seen from Ciudad
Juarez, Mexico December 12, 2022.
(CNN) — As administration officials considered a
border proposal reminiscent of the Trump era this
month, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer called
Ron Klain, President Joe Biden’s chief of staff, with
JA127
concerns, according to three sources with knowledge of
the call.
The call – one of many that have come in from
lawmakers to the White House – was indicative of the
politically precarious position for Biden as officials try
to fend off Republicans pounding the administration
over its handling of the border and appease Democrats
concerned about barring asylum seekers from the US.
The Biden administration now faces a December
deadline to terminate a public health authority, known
as Title 42, that was invoked at the onset of the
coronavirus pandemic and allowed officials to turn
away migrants encountered at the US southern border
– putting immigration back at the forefront.
The termination of the authority is expected to lead to
an increase in border crossings since authorities will no
longer be able to quickly expel them as has been done
since March 2020.
During the call between Schumer and Klain, the
Senate majority leader raised concerns about the
administration’s preparation for the looming
termination and whether officials were indeed
considering a new asylum policy, according to two
sources with knowledge of the call.
Schumer and Klain speak regularly and often daily or
more in critical moments like the year-end legislative
sprint currently underway. But the border issue’s
emergence in discussion provides a window into a
complex policy and political moment.
JA128
Schumer, a New York Democrat who has long pressed
the administration to terminate Title 42, is far from
alone. Administration officials have received a steady
stream of calls from lawmakers as well as state and
local officials, reflecting often sharply divergent views
on the merits of the authority, people familiar with the
matter said. The calls, however, all echoed consistent
concerns about the termination of Title 42 and what it
will mean along the border in recent weeks.
It’s a dynamic that has played out as the Biden
administration intensively prepares for a moment
officials have long grappled with how to navigate. To
some degree, it’s the latest phase of an effort that has
long been underway, with officials keenly aware since
the opening days in office that at some point the
pandemic-era policy would come to an end. Personnel
and technology infrastructure have been directed to
key entry points, with increased levels and resources
expected to be announced in the days ahead.
Asked about concerns inside the administration about
the potential for a surge at the border once Title 42
goes away, White House press secretary Karine
Jean-Pierre listed off a series of personnel, processing
and infrastructure efforts that have been put into
place.
“We’re going to do the work, we’re going to be prepared,
and we’re going to make sure we have a humane
process moving forward,” Jean-Pierre told reporters
Tuesday at the White House briefing.
Still, the cross-cutting viewpoints on border policy have
converged with the significant diplomatic component
JA129
tied to managing a rapid shift in the countries of origin
of the migrants apprehended at the border, one that
has added a new layer of difficulty for the
administration.
Throughout, administration officials have stressed that
the only viable long-term solution will come from
congressional action, noting encouragement with a
bipartisan framework released in the Senate last week.
But there are no clear signs that effort has gained
traction and despite a legal process that remains up in
the air, officials are deep into preparation as they stare
down ominous signs of what may come next.
Already, over the weekend, more than 2,400 migrants
crossed into the United States each day in only one
section of the border, according to a senior Border
Patrol official, marking what he described as a “major
surge in illegal crossings” in the El Paso, Texas, sector.
Homeland Security officials have described the mood
within the administration as concerned and worried
about an influx in the near term.
In the face of losing Title 42 and amid concerns of a
surge, officials have weighed what immigrant
advocates have described as a draconian approach by
creating hurdles for migrants seeking asylum in the
United States. The asylum proposal was included in a
memo sent from the Department of Homeland Security
to the White House, one source told CNN.
White House officials have also been in daily
conversations with DHS officials about planning,
sources told CNN. The National Security Council,
JA130
which has been heavily involved in migration
management amid mass movement across the Western
hemisphere, has also played a critical role, sources
said.
“The team has been working really hard to ensure
we’re taking steps to manage the expiration of Title 42
and put in place a process that’s orderly and humane.
And we believe in doing so, we can protect our security
concerns,” national security adviser Jake Sullivan said
Monday.
If adopted, the asylum proposal would be reminiscent
of a policy put in place during the Trump
administration that dramatically limited the ability of
migrants to claim asylum in the US if they resided or
traveled through other countries prior to coming to the
US. No decision has been made on the proposal.
Administration officials have also set other plans in
motion in anticipation of a surge of migrants when
Trump-era Covid restrictions are lifted this month
following a court order blocking the use of Title 42. The
legal fight intensified this week when 19 Republicanled states asked a federal appeals court to rule on their
request to suspend the termination of the policy by
Friday, according to a court filing.
Since March 2020, when the authority was invoked,
border officials have turned away migrants at the
US-Mexico border more than two million times.
The Department of Homeland Security is preparing
temporary facilities to process migrants, including in El
Paso, as well as discussing ways to return non-Mexican
migrants to Mexico through existing legal mechanisms
JA131
aside from Title 42, according to two Homeland
Security officials who stressed there’s been hourslong
meetings daily to plan for an influx of migrants.
In a document outlining border security preparedness
and obtained by CNN, DHS broke down its six-pillar
plan, which was released in the spring and has since
been updated. It includes scaling up ground and air
transportation capabilities to transport migrants for
processing and remove them, leaning on a CBP One
mobile application to process asylum seekers, and
increasing referrals for prosecutions for repeat border
crossers, the document said.
In it, DHS also stressed the need for congressional
action to update outdated statutes and help create a
functioning asylum system, as the current one is under
immense strain.
But just days away from the anticipated end of Title
42, plans are still being sorted out.
“The 21st (is) going to be a disaster. There are so many
things in the pipeline, but nothing is ready (to) go,” one
official said, referring to December 21 when Title 42 is
set to end.
Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas
underscored the whole of government approach in a
statement, noting that mass movement of people
around the globe has posed a uniquely difficult
challenge.
“Despite our efforts, our outdated immigration system
is under strain; that is true at the federal level, as well
as for state, local, NGO, and community partners. In
JA132
the absence of congressional action to reform the
immigration and asylum systems, a significant
increase in migrant encounters will strain our system
even further,” he said.
“Addressing this challenge will take time and
additional resources, and we need the partnership of
Congress, state and local officials, NGOs, and
communities to do so,” he added.
Democratic Rep. Henry Cuellar of Texas, however, has
called Title 42 critical and criticized what he called a
“whack a mole” approach to the issue.
“If there’s a surge in the valley, they’ll move people
down there. If there is more people crossing let’s say,
Del Rio, Eagle Pass they’ll move agents over there.
Now they’re moving agents to El Paso. This is not the
way to secure the border,” Cuellar said Wednesday on
“CNN This Morning,” adding a call for Biden to visit
the border and see the situation for himself.
“I don’t know why they keep avoiding the border and
saying there’s other things more important than
visiting the border,” he said. “If there’s a crisis, show
up. Just show up.”
Major surge in arrivals expected
Officials have already been contending with thousands
of migrants crossing the border daily and expect those
numbers to increase in the coming days and weeks,
overwhelming already-strained resources.
CNN previously reported that DHS is preparing for
multiple scenarios, including projections of between
JA133
9,000 to 14,000 migrants a day, more than double the
current number of people crossing.
Over the weekend, US border authorities apprehended
more than 16,000 people, US Border Patrol Chief Raul
Ortiz said on Twitter. Among the cities seeing an influx
in migrants is El Paso, which has previously grappled
with a surge of migrants.
El Paso city officials said Tuesday they’re monitoring
the situation and are in ongoing discussions with
federal, state, and local partners. Mayorkas also visited
El Paso on Tuesday where he met with the Customs
and Border Protection workforce and local officials.
The Biden administration is also asking Congress for
more than $3 billion as it prepares for the end of Title
42, according to a source familiar with the ask.
The request is intended to shore up resources for
border management and technology and is part of
broader funding discussions. It is not specific to the end
of Title 42, the source said.
“If Republicans in Congress are serious about border
security, they would ensure that the men and women
of the Department of Homeland Security have the
resources they need to secure our border and build a
safe, orderly, and humane immigration system,” White
House spokesperson Abdullah Hasan said in a
statement.
Other border cities are also bracing for an influx of
arrivals, including Laredo, Texas.
JA134
Cuellar, who represents Texas’ 28th District, told CNN
he’s in close touch with the city of Laredo about
preparations, adding that the city may bus migrants to
other locations as they’ve done in the past if nonprofits
can’ handle the influx of arrivals.
CNN’s Shawna Mizelle contributed to this report.
JA135
Exhibit D
FOXNEWS.COM
Newsom says California about to ‘break’ amid
flood of illegal migrants when Title 42 expires
By Timothy Nerozzi
Published December 14, 2022
Fox News
Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom of California warned
Monday that President Biden’s plan to reverse former
President Donald Trump’s border policies could “break”
his state.
The Biden administration is planning to lift the
Trump-era Title 42 policy, which allows police and
border officers to expedite the expulsion of illegal
immigrants.
Newsom, speaking to ABC News on Monday, said, “The
fact is, what we’ve got right now is not working and is
about to break in a post-42 world unless we take some
responsibility and ownership.”
CALIFORNIA REPARATIONS PROPOSAL
COULD MEAN $223K PER PERSON IN
PAYMENTS FOR BLACK RESIDENTS
JA136
California Gov. Gavin Newsom speaks during a press
conference in San Francisco, California. (Justin
Sullivan/Getty Images)
“I’m saying that as a father,” the governor added. “I’m
saying that as someone that feels responsible for being
part of the solution and I’m trying to do my best here.”
Newsom claimed the U.S. government is sending “more
and more” migrants to California because the state is
“taking care of folks.”
“The more we do, the burden is placed disproportionate
on us,” he said.
“We’re already at capacity at nine of our sites,”
Newsom continued. “We can’t continue to fund all of
these sites because of the budgetary pressures now
being placed on this state and the offsetting issues that
I have to address.… The reality is, unless we’re doing
what we’re doing, people will end up on the streets.”
JA137
Newsom’s comments come as a surprise after years of
championing policies to accommodate and expand
protections to illegal migrants entering California.
NEWSOM PROPOSES UNIVERSAL HEALTH
CARE FOR ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS
Migrants stand across the Rio Grande from El Paso,
Texas. Thousands of migrants have illegally crossed
into the city in recent days, prompting concerns from
city officials. (Border Patrol)
About 22% of California’s nearly 11 million immigrants
are in the United States illegally, according to the
Public Policy Institute of California.
In September, Newsom signed a bill allowing illegal
immigrants to obtain state ID, saying, “We’re a state of
refuge – a majority-minority state, where 27% of us are
immigrants.”
JA138
In January, Newsom unveiled his 2022-23 California
budget plan, which included universal health care
benefits for all low-income residents, including illegal
migrants.
About 22% of California’s nearly 11 million immigrants
are in the United States illegally, according to the
Public Policy Institute of California. (John Moore/Getty
Images)
The Biden administration is requesting billions in
additional funding for the border as it predicts an
enormous spike in migrant encounters when the Title
42 authority to quickly expel migrants due to the
COVID-19 pandemic ends later this month.
A court ordered the administration to stop using the
authority – which has been used since March 2020 to
quickly return migrants to Mexico – after finding it to
be unlawful.
JA139
URL
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/newsom-sayscalifornia-break-flood-illegal-migrants-title-42-expires
JA140
Exhibit E
Joe Biden’s border policies risk breaking my
state, says governor in his own party
Gavin Newsom says California under pressure with
power that allows illegal immigrants to be sent back to
Mexico about to lapse
Josie Ensor, US Correspondent, in New York
14 December 2022 • 8:51pm
Gavin Newsom is seen by some as a likely successor to
Joe Biden Credit: Anadolu
Gavin Newsom, the Democrat governor of California,
has accused Joe Biden of risking “breaking” his state by
allowing an immigration crisis to develop at the USMexico border.
JA141
His comments come just a week before an order
introduced by Donald Trump during the pandemic
under which illegal immigrants can be immediately
expelled to Mexico - known as Title 42 - is set to be
lifted, raising fears of a surge of arrivals at the US
border.
Mr Biden has committed to ending the ruling, which
aimed to stop the spread of Covid-19, rather than
waiting for court dates in the United States.
It is currently expected to lapse on Dec 21 and border
states including California are bracing for heightened
numbers of border crossings.
Speaking on a visit to the border Mr Newsom said:
“The fact is, what we’ve got right now is not working,
and it’s about to break in a post-42 world unless we
take some responsibility and ownership.”
“I’m saying that as a Democrat. I’m not saying that to
point fingers. I’m saying that as a father, I’m saying
that as someone that feels responsible for being part of
the solution, and I’m trying to do my best here.”
JA142
A sign reads ‘good trip’ as migrants walk across the Rio
Grande in Texas Credit: AFP
The comments by Mr Newsom, who is seen by many as
the party’s most probable successor to Mr Biden, were
also taken as a swipe at his fellow Californian, vice
president Kamala Harris, who was placed in charge of
efforts to solve border problems.
He added: “The federal government is sending more
and more flights, and more and more buses, directly
here to California because this state is doing what no
other state’s doing.”
He said California was “doing health care screenings,
and taking care of folks” but the “burden is placed
disproportionately on us”.
JA143
The state was already at capacity at nine of its sites for
migrants and “the reality is, unless we’re doing what
we’re doing, people will end up on the streets,” he said.
Under Title 42, Mexico accepts returning Mexicans,
Guatemalans, Salvadorans, Hondurans and
Venezuelans. A court has ruled that Title 42 is
unlawful but several Republican-led states have
challenged that, and may appeal to the US Supreme
Court.
Mr Newsom, 55, was re-elected to the governorship of
California in a landslide in last month’s midterm
elections.
He has increased his national profile, giving speeches
in other states, and running TV adverts in Florida
against its governor Ron DeSantis, the favourite for the
Republican presidential nomination in 2024.
Mr Newsom has also previously criticised his own
party’s leadership for not being “aggressive” enough in
attacking Republicans.
There has been uneasiness in the White House that he
could launch a primary challenge against Mr Biden in
2024.
However. last month, Mr Newsom publicly and
privately assured Mr Biden that he had no such
intention.
The latest Democrat spat came as Eric Adams, the
Democrat mayor of New York, criticised the city’s press
for negative coverage of its crime problem, saying it
was putting off visitors.
JA144
Eric Adams has told crime reporters they are damaging
his city Credit: AP
Mr Adams, who was elected last year on an anti-crime
platform, told journalists they were harming New
York’s economic recovery.
He said: “We have to tell our news publications:
enough. Enough. Enough.”
The mayor suggested that bad news did not make the
front pages of newspapers so relentlessly elsewhere in
the world.
He recently returned from a visit to Qatar for the
World Cup.
Mr Adams said: “Don’t point at every scar we have. We
have a face, New York, and that face is not always
perfect. But we don’t need to look at the worst part of
our day and highlight that again and again and again.”
JA145
Crime is up in New York City by 30 per cent this year,
including a 33 per cent increase in robberies, and an 11
per cent increase in rapes, according to New York
Police Department figures.
JA146
Exhibit F
Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco on end of
Title 42 border policy
December 14, 2022 / 6:16 PM
With Title 42 set to end next week, Deputy Attorney
General Lisa Monaco said she is “concerned about the
increase in illegal immigration” as well as “human
smuggling” and “drug smuggling.”
“There is a growing concern that there will now be a
tsunami of fentanyl flowing through the southern
border when Title 42 ends next week. Is that something
you’re concerned about?” “CBS Evening News” anchor
and managing editor Norah O’Donnell asked Monaco in
an interview Wednesday.
“Absolutely we’re concerned about that, which is why
we are focusing, as I said, relentlessly on these two
ruthless criminal drug organizations, the Sinaloa
Cartel and the Jalisco New Generation Cartel,” Monaco
said.
JA147
Monaco, who oversees the Drug Enforcement
Administration, said the agency is using “intelligence,”
“cyber means,” “informants” and “data” to “attack” the
supply chain.
A court ruling invalidated Title 42, a public health
order that the U.S. has used to expel migrants en
masse from the border during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The Justice Department said it would appeal the
ruling.
JA148
Watch more of Norah O’Donnell’s interview with Deputy
Attorney General Lisa Monaco tonight on the “CBS
Evening News.”
JA149
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Civ. A. No. 21-100 (EGS)
[Filed: August 31, 2022]
__________________________________________
NANCY GIMENA HUISHA-HUISHA, et al., )
)
Plaintiffs,
)
)
v.
)
)
ALEJANDRO MAYORKAS, Secretary of
)
Homeland Security, et al.,
)
)
Defendants.
)
__________________________________________)
DEFENDANTS’ OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’
MOTION FOR PARTIAL
SUMMARY JUDGMENT
[*** Table of Contents and Table of Authorities
Have Been Omitted for Printing Purposes***]
INTRODUCTION
Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in March
2020, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
(“CDC”) has issued a series of orders (“Title 42 orders”)
invoking its authority under the Public Health Service
Act, 42 U.S.C. § 265 (“Section 265”), to temporarily
suspend the right to introduce into the United States
certain noncitizens traveling from Mexico and Canada
who would otherwise be held in congregate settings in
JA150
ports of entry or U.S. Border Patrol stations. The
currently operative order was issued in August 2021,
when the highly transmissible Delta variant was
raging in the United States, driving a stark increase in
COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations, and deaths. After
conducting a comprehensive assessment of the public
health conditions as applied to border facilities, CDC
determined that unlike unaccompanied children,
excepting noncitizen single adults and family units
from the order would pose a significant public health
risk. CDC thereafter terminated the August order
based on significantly improved public health
conditions, but another federal court has preliminarily
enjoined that termination order.
Plaintiffs and class members are noncitizen family
units subject to the August 2021 order. They previously
moved for and obtained a preliminary injunction based
on their statutory claims, but the D.C. Circuit held
that, subject to certain limitations, CDC likely has
statutory authority to expel the class members, thus
narrowing the scope of the preliminary injunction.
Plaintiffs now move for partial summary judgment on
their remaining claim that CDC’s “Title 42 Policy” is
arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative
Procedure Act (“APA”), focusing primarily on the
operative August order.
This Court should deny the motion. As a threshold
matter, CDC’s decision in issuing the August 2021
order is committed to the agency’s discretion by law
and not reviewable under the APA. This is so because
CDC’s exercise of its Section 265 authority involved a
complicated analysis of a variety of factors uniquely
JA151
within CDC’s expertise and scientific judgment, and
the statute provides no standards to guide the Court’s
review of the public health determination that the
August order was necessary to prevent the serious
danger of the introduction of COVID-19 into the United
States.
On the merits, Plaintiffs’ arbitrary and capricious
claim fails as a matter of law. Despite Plaintiffs’
attempt to challenge the rationality of the August 2021
order based on more current public health conditions,
this Court’s review is limited to the administrative
record before CDC at the time of the August order.
Here, the administrative record amply demonstrates
that the August order was the result of reasoned
decision-making. Central to CDC’s public health
determination was the rapid spread of the Delta
variant, which was a particularly formidable threat to
the unvaccinated, especially those in congregate
settings. And yet, a significant number of incoming
covered noncitizens who otherwise would be held in the
border facilities’ congregate setting for hours to days
were coming from countries with low vaccination rates.
Moreover, border facilities are ill-equipped to manage
an outbreak and must rely on local healthcare systems
for medical care to noncitizens, but there were
worrisome signs of stress in healthcare resources in the
southern regions of the United States. The United
States was also experiencing a migratory surge of
noncitizens entering the United States that threatened
to lengthen the time noncitizens spent in border
facilities. In the face of a confluence of factors, CDC
reasonably concluded that the August 2021 order was
necessary in the interest of public health.
JA152
Plaintiffs’ attempts to argue otherwise are
unavailing. They contend that CDC unreasonably
deviated from its alleged “least restrictive means”
standard for implementing public health measures. But
CDC has no such all-encompassing agency policy. The
2017 CDC regulation Plaintiffs cite that adopted such
a standard was in the specific context of quarantine
orders applicable to U.S. citizens and others, which can
implicate constitutionally protected liberty interests.
Even if the standard were applicable here, the August
order clearly met it because CDC considered and
rejected various alternatives to expulsion precisely
because those alternatives were either unavailable or
inadequate to protect the public health.
Ultimately, Plaintiffs’ challenge boils down to the
idea that the government should have done
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.