Supplemental Brief — Suncor Energy (U.S.A.) Inc., et al., Petitioners v. Board of County Commissioners of Boulder County, et al.
Supreme Court briefApr 5, 2023
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 21-1550
In the Supreme Court of the United States
SUNCOR ENERGY (U.S.A.) INC., ET AL., PETITIONERS
v.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF BOULDER COUNTY, ET AL.
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT
SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF FOR THE PETITIONERS
HUGH QUAN GOTTSCHALK
ERIC L. ROBERTSON
WHEELER TRIGG
O’DONNELL LLP
370 Seventeenth Street,
Suite 4500
Denver, CO 80202
COLIN G. HARRIS
FAEGRE BAKER
DANIELS LLP
1470 Walnut Street,
Suite 300
Boulder, CO 80302
KANNON K. SHANMUGAM
Counsel of Record
WILLIAM T. MARKS
PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND,
WHARTON & GARRISON LLP
2001 K Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20006
(202) 223-7300
kshanmugam@paulweiss.com
THEODORE V. WELLS, JR.
DANIEL J. TOAL
PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND,
WHARTON & GARRISON LLP
1285 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10019
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
A. The decision below implicates conflicts among
the courts of appeals on both questions presented............. 3
B. The decision below is incorrect ............................................. 7
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases:
American Electric Power Co. v. Connecticut,
564 U.S. 410 (2011) ............................................................ 9
BP p.l.c. v. Mayor & City Council of Baltimore,
141 S. Ct. 1532 (2021) ................................................ 1, 2, 8
City of Hoboken v. Chevron Corp.,
45 F.4th 699 (3d Cir. 2022),
pet. for cert. filed, No. 22-821 (Feb. 27, 2023) ................ 7
City of Milwaukee v. Illinois, 451 U.S. 304 (1981) ............. 9
City of New York v. Chevron Corp.,
993 F.3d 81 (2d Cir. 2021) ............................... 2, 4, 5, 6, 10
City of Oakland v. BP p.l.c.,
969 F.3d 895 (9th Cir. 2020) ............................................. 2
Illinois v. City of Milwaukee:
406 U.S. 91 (1972) .............................................................. 9
731 F.2d 403 (7th Cir. 1984) ............................................. 5
International Paper Co. v. Ouellette,
479 U.S. 481 (1987) .................................................... 10, 11
Minnesota v. American Petroleum Institute,
No. 21-1752, ___ F.4th ___,
2023 WL 2607545 (8th Cir. Mar. 23, 2023) ... 3, 4, 8, 9, 11
Otter Tail Power Co., In re,
116 F.3d 1207 (8th Cir. 1997) ........................................... 6
Sam L. Majors Jewelers v. ABX, Inc.,
117 F.3d 922 (5th Cir. 1997) ......................................... 6, 7
Vaden v. Discover Bank, 556 U.S. 49 (2009) ....................... 9
Statutes:
Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. §§ 7401-7671q ..........1, 2, 4, 5, 9, 10
28 U.S.C. 1441(a) .................................................................... 7
(I)
In the Supreme Court of the United States
No. 21-1550
SUNCOR ENERGY (U.S.A.) INC., ET AL., PETITIONERS
v.
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
OF BOULDER COUNTY, ET AL.
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT
SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF FOR THE PETITIONERS
Just two years ago, the United States told this Court
that claims seeking redress for injuries allegedly caused
by the effect of interstate greenhouse-gas emissions on
the global climate are “inherently federal in nature,” even
when labeled as arising under state law. Oral Arg. Tr. at
31, BP p.l.c. v. Mayor & City Council of Baltimore, 141
S. Ct. 1532 (2021). The government explained that, despite the Clean Air Act’s displacement of any remedy under federal common law, “[a]ny putative tort claims that
seek to apply the law of an affected State to conduct in
another State * * * continue to arise under federal, not
state law, for jurisdictional purposes.” U.S. Br. at 27, BP,
supra (internal quotation marks, citation, and emphasis
(1)
2
omitted). The government added that the well-pleaded
complaint rule presented no obstacle to removal. See id.
at 28. And the government took the same position in the
lower courts, explaining that it would be “irreconcilable”
with the “structure of the Constitution” for state law, rather than federal law, to govern such claims. U.S. Br. at
3-12, City of Oakland v. BP p.l.c., 969 F.3d 895 (9th Cir.
2020).
Now, the government has casually junked that position. With an all-too-familiar citation to the “change in
Administration,” it argues that the well-pleaded complaint rule precludes removal and that, in the wake of the
Clean Air Act, federal law no longer exclusively governs
claims alleging injury from interstate emissions. See Br.
7-16. Perhaps the current administration genuinely does
have a different view on questions of federal jurisdiction
than the last one. But given the federal government’s institutional interest in taking a broad view of federal jurisdiction, it is hard to escape the conclusion that the change
in position is being driven by the fact that the questions
are arising in the context of climate-change lawsuits—and
by a desire to signal virtue to political bedfellows who are
behind these lawsuits.
Given that apparent motivation, it is difficult to take
anything the government says here at face value. But
even so, the government’s arguments against review wilt
under scrutiny. The government argues that no genuine
circuit conflict exists, but it does so only by ignoring the
Second Circuit’s reasoning in City of New York v. Chevron
Corp., 993 F.3d 81 (2021), and the decisions of other circuits expressly rejecting that reasoning. On the merits,
the government parrots respondents’ arguments, yet it
makes no effort to grapple with petitioners’ responses. At
a minimum, the very fact that the last two administrations
3
have taken contrary positions confirms that there are substantial legal arguments on both sides.
And for all of its flip-flopping on the merits, the government does not dispute that the questions presented
here are exceedingly important ones worthy of this
Court’s review. There are now six petitions pending before the Court arising from similar climate-change cases
that present the same basic questions. Nor does the government dispute that this case is an ideal vehicle for addressing those questions, particularly because it is less
likely than the other pending cases to present recusal issues.
After the government filed its brief, a prominent judge
wrote that cases such as this one should give rise to federal jurisdiction and urged the Court definitively to resolve whether they do. See Minnesota v. American Petroleum Institute, No. 21-1752, ___ F.4th ___, 2023 WL
2607545, at *8-*11 (8th Cir. Mar. 23, 2023) (Stras, J., concurring). It is preposterous to suggest that the fate of
these cases—with their potentially enormous consequences for an entire sector of the global economy—
should be left to handpicked state courts without a decision by this Court sanctioning that outcome. Given the
importance of the questions presented, the circuit conflicts on each question, the substantial arguments on both
sides, and the prudential reasons for review in this particular case, the petition for a writ of certiorari should be
granted.
A. The Decision Below Implicates Conflicts Among The
Courts Of Appeals On Both Questions Presented
The courts of appeals are divided on both questions
presented: whether federal law necessarily and exclusively governs climate-change claims and whether a federal district court has federal-question jurisdiction over
4
such claims, even when the plaintiff labels them as arising
under state law. See Pet. 11-24; Reply Br. 2-6. The government attempts to diminish those conflicts (Br. 16-22),
but it merely regurgitates the arguments respondents
made last summer in their brief in opposition. Those arguments are no more persuasive now than they were then.
1. On the first question presented: like respondents,
the government addresses only the conflict between the
decision below and the Second Circuit’s decision in City of
New York. See Br. 17-20. But two other circuits, the First
and Fourth, expressly rejected the Second Circuit’s holding that federal common law governs materially identical
climate-change claims. See Pet. 16-17.
As for the decision below, the government’s attempt to
reconcile it with the Second Circuit’s decision falls flat.
The government understands the Second Circuit to have
held only that “the prior applicability of federal common
law [is] relevant in determining the post-Clean Air Act viability of state-law claims.” Br. 19. But the Second Circuit expressly concluded that, although the plaintiff used
state-law labels, it had brought “federal claims” that must
arise “under federal common law”; indeed, the court
viewed the case as “simply beyond the limits of state law.”
City of New York, 993 F.3d at 92, 95; see Minnesota, 2023
WL 2607545, at *9-*10 (Stras, J., concurring). The Second Circuit further held that the displacement of any remedy under federal common law did not affect the analysis,
because state law is not “competent to address issues that
demand a unified federal standard.” 993 F.3d at 98.
What is more, the Second Circuit concluded that federal common law is “still require[d]” to govern extraterritorial aspects of claims challenging undifferentiated
global emissions, because the Clean Air Act “does not regulate foreign emissions.” 993 F.3d at 95 n.7; see id. at 101.
City of New York can thus only be understood to hold that
5
federal law continues to govern in this area, even after the
enactment of the Clean Air Act.
The Second Circuit’s reliance on the Seventh Circuit’s
decision in Illinois v. City of Milwaukee, 731 F.2d 403
(1984), confirms that understanding. There, the Seventh
Circuit considered the question whether state law could
govern claims for interstate water pollution after the
Clean Water Act displaced any remedy available under
federal common law. See id. at 406.
The Seventh Circuit held that state law remained unavailable. See 731 F.3d at 406-411. The court reasoned
that “[t]he very reasons th[is] Court gave for resorting to
federal common law” in cases involving interstate pollution are “the same reasons why the [S]tate claiming injury
cannot apply its own state law to out-of-state discharges
now.” Id. at 410. The court explained that the statutory
displacement of any remedy under federal common law
“did nothing to undermine that result”; the pollution of interstate waters remained a “problem of uniquely federal
dimensions requiring the application of uniform federal
standards.” Id. at 410-411. The Seventh Circuit thus concluded that “federal law must govern in this situation except to the extent that [Congress] authorizes resort to
state law.” Id. at 411.
In City of New York, the Second Circuit similarly held
that federal law continues to govern claims founded on interstate emissions even after the statutory displacement
of any remedy under federal common law. See 993 F.3d
at 98. And while the court below may not have addressed
the merits question “whether the Clean Air Act authorized or preempted respondents’ claims,” U.S. Br. 19, it did
squarely hold that the Clean Air Act’s displacement of any
federal-common-law remedy allows a plaintiff to assert
“only state-law claims” in this area. Pet. App. 30a. That
6
holding is irreconcilable with City of New York, and the
resulting conflict warrants this Court’s review.
2. On the second question presented: the government attempts to distinguish In re Otter Tail Power Co.,
116 F.3d 1207 (8th Cir. 1997), and Sam L. Majors Jewelers v. ABX, Inc., 117 F.3d 922 (5th Cir. 1997). See Br. 2022. That effort also fails.
The government first argues that Otter Tail “rested
not on the artful-pleading doctrine” but instead on the fact
that “the allegations actually set forth in the plaintiff’s
complaint” demonstrated the presence of a substantial
federal question. Br. 20. But the government has no explanation for the Eighth Circuit’s statement that “[a]
plaintiff ’s characterization of a claim as based solely on
state law is not dispositive of whether federal question jurisdiction exists.” 116 F.3d at 1213 (citation omitted).
More broadly, the complaint in Otter Tail sought to enforce a right under state law, see id. at 1211; the need to
apply federal common law was evident because the complaint itself discussed an earlier federal judgment concerning principles of tribal sovereignty, see id. at 12131214.
The complaint here similarly alleges facts that demonstrate the need to apply federal law: namely, the allegations of injury caused by the effect of interstate greenhouse-gas emissions on the global climate. See Pet. 24-25.
Even analyzed as a case involving the “substantial federal
question” doctrine, therefore, Otter Tail supports removal. See Reply Br. 5. *
The government notes that the court below stated that petitioners
had “waived” any argument that federal common law provided a basis
for removal under the “substantial federal question” doctrine. See
Br. 10, 20-21. Petitioners have already explained why that is incorrect. See Reply Br. 5. In addition, it would be particularly odd for
*
7
The government’s attempt to distinguish Sam L. Majors is similarly flawed. See Br. 21. Regardless of
whether the Fifth Circuit “framed its ruling” as an application of the “well-pleaded complaint rule” as opposed to
the “artful-pleading doctrine,” ibid., the court upheld the
removal of putative state-law claims on the ground that
they were governed by federal common law. See 117 F.3d
at 924. The government also argues that Congress “preserv[ed]” the relevant common law in Sam L. Majors,
whereas Congress “displaced” it here. Br. 21-22. But that
is a distinction without a difference, because several
courts of appeals have held that federal common law is
never an independent ground to remove a putative statelaw claim. See Pet. 20-23.
Notably, in one of the other climate-change cases now
pending before this Court, the Third Circuit acknowledged that Sam L. Majors supports removal and expressly declined to follow it. See City of Hoboken v. Chevron Corp., 45 F.4th 699, 708 (2022), pet. for cert. filed, No.
22-821 (Feb. 27, 2023). The Court’s guidance is badly
needed to resolve the conflicts on both questions presented.
B. The Decision Below Is Incorrect
The government devotes much of its brief to the merits (Br. 7-16), repudiating its previous position that claims
such as respondents’ “arise under federal, not state law
for jurisdictional purposes” and “may be removable under
28 U.S.C. 1441(a) on the ground that, although nominally
the Court to ignore the “substantial federal question” doctrine if it
granted review here, when the petitioners in some of the other climate-change cases now pending before this Court (which may present recusal issues not present here) indisputably made that argument. See, e.g., Chevron Corp. v. City of Hoboken, No. 22-821; Sunoco
LP v. City & County of Honolulu, No. 22-523.
8
couched as state-law claims, they are inherently and necessarily federal in nature.” U.S. Br. at 26, 27, BP, supra.
The government’s previous position was right; its current
position is wrong.
1. The government heavily relies on the well-pleaded
complaint rule (Br. 9-11), but its understanding of the rule
is internally incoherent. The government initially argues
that, under the rule, federal jurisdiction depends on the
“plaintiff’s own statement” of the cause of action. Br. 9.
The government apparently means that the complaint
must expressly invoke federal law, either as creating the
cause of action or as governing a particular issue. See
ibid. Federal jurisdiction would thus turn on a magicwords requirement: did the plaintiff expressly invoke federal law in the complaint?
Two pages later, however, the government acknowledges that “[a] federal court may uphold removal even
though no federal question appears on the face of the
plaintiff’s complaint if the court concludes that the plaintiff has artfully pleaded claims by omitting to plead necessary federal questions.” Br. 11 (internal quotation marks
and citation omitted). But the artful-pleading doctrine is
the opposite of a magic-words approach: it requires consideration of the substance of the allegations in the complaint in order to determine the presence of federal jurisdiction.
“Artful pleading comes in many forms,” and “[t]his is
one of them.” Minnesota, 2023 WL 2607545, at *8 (Stras,
J., concurring). And analyzing the substance of the complaint, rather than the mere labels used by the plaintiff,
comports with this Court’s precedent. When the Court
has stated that a “plaintiff’s statement of his own cause of
action” must show that it is “based upon federal law,” it
has contrasted such a case with one in which federal law
9
is relevant only because of an “actual or anticipated defense.” Vaden v. Discover Bank, 556 U.S. 49, 60 (2009)
(citation omitted). Where, as here, the facts pleaded in
support of the plaintiff’s claim demonstrate that it is necessarily and exclusively governed by federal law, the federal character of the suit arises from the asserted cause of
action, not from any federal defense.
The exercise of federal jurisdiction over such cases is
thus consistent with a proper understanding of the wellpleaded complaint rule. Were it otherwise, a plaintiff
could confine an inherently federal cause of action to state
court simply by labeling the claim a state-law claim.
“There is no reason for the removal rules to operate in
such a confounding way.” Minnesota, 2023 WL 2607545,
at *11 (Stras, J., concurring).
2. The government further argues (Br. 11-15) that
federal common law does not necessarily and exclusively
govern respondents’ claims because any such common law
has been “displaced” by the Clean Air Act. That argument conflates the jurisdictional question (whether a
claim arises under federal law) with the merits question
(whether the claimant has a valid cause of action under
federal law)—questions this Court has made clear are distinct. See, e.g., American Electric Power Co. v. Connecticut, 564 U.S. 410, 422 (2011).
In so arguing, the government fundamentally mischaracterizes petitioners’ position. This Court’s precedents establish that the structure of the Constitution itself
precludes the application of state law to claims seeking redress for harms allegedly caused by interstate pollution.
In such disputes, “[t]he rule of decision [must] be[] federal,” Illinois v. City of Milwaukee, 406 U.S. 91, 108 n.10
(1972), and “state law cannot be used” at all, City of Milwaukee v. Illinois, 451 U.S. 304, 313 n.7 (1981).
10
The fact that Congress acted to displace any remedy
otherwise available under federal common law does nothing to alter the exclusively federal nature of this area of
law. As the Second Circuit explained, “state law does not
suddenly become presumptively competent to address issues that demand a unified federal standard simply because Congress saw fit to displace a federal court-made
standard with a legislative one.” City of New York, 993
F.3d at 98.
The government reads this Court’s decision in International Paper Co. v. Ouellette, 479 U.S. 481 (1987), as
demonstrating that, “[n]ow that the Clean Air Act has displaced the prior federal-common-law regime,” “ordinarypreemption principles” apply to determine “the viability
of state-law claims” in this area. Br. 14. That is incorrect.
In Ouellette, the question was whether a suit for injury
allegedly caused by interstate water pollution could proceed under the law of the State of injury, rather than the
law of the source State, after the Clean Water Act displaced the remedy previously available under federal
common law. See 479 U.S. at 483-484. The Court held
that the suit could not proceed under the law of the State
of injury. See id. at 497. The Court noted that, while the
Act sought to “establish an all-encompassing program of
water pollution regulation,” they contained a saving
clause that “negate[d] the inference that Congress left no
room for state causes of action.” Id. at 492. Still, the
Court concluded that Congress’s “pervasive regulation”
of interstate water pollution, and “the fact that the control
of interstate pollution is primarily a matter of federal
law,” meant that “the only state suits that remain available are those specifically preserved by the Act.” Ibid.
Even if the Ouellette Court framed its analysis in
terms of ordinary preemption, therefore, it expressly re-
11
lied not only on the displacing statute but also on the inherently federal character of suits concerning interstate
pollution. Ouellette is thus consistent with the principle
that federal law continues exclusively to govern actions
concerning interstate pollution, even after a statute has
displaced any remedy under federal common law.
*
*
*
*
*
Rarely has this Court seen a more cynical change in
position. The current administration’s view of this case is
shot through with flaws. The well-pleaded complaint rule
does not allow a plaintiff to block federal courts from adjudicating a cause of action necessarily and exclusively
governed by federal law. And the statutory displacement
of any remedy previously available under federal common
law does not alter the inherently federal character of such
a cause of action. Those questions have now divided the
courts of appeals, as well as two consecutive administrations. And the answer to them will dictate whether the
numerous climate-change lawsuits pending in courts
across the country—lawsuits that “seek[] a global remedy
for a global issue,” Minnesota, 2023 WL 2607545, at *9
(Stras, J., concurring)—should proceed in federal or state
court. As one judge recently wrote, “only * * * [this]
Court gets to make that call.” Id. at *11. Given the consequential questions presented and the enormous stakes,
no objective observer could dispute that the Court’s guidance is urgently needed.
12
*
*
*
*
*
The petition for a writ of certiorari should be granted.
Respectfully submitted.
HUGH QUAN GOTTSCHALK
ERIC L. ROBERTSON
WHEELER TRIGG
O’DONNELL LLP
370 Seventeenth Street,
Suite 4500
Denver, CO 80202
Counsel for Petitioners
Suncor Energy (U.S.A.) Inc.,
Suncor Energy Sales Inc.,
and Suncor Energy Inc.
KANNON K. SHANMUGAM
WILLIAM T. MARKS
PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND,
WHARTON & GARRISON LLP
2001 K Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20006
(202) 223-7300
kshanmugam@paulweiss.com
THEODORE V. WELLS, JR.
DANIEL J. TOAL
PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND,
WHARTON & GARRISON LLP
1285 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10019
COLIN G. HARRIS
FAEGRE BAKER
DANIELS LLP
1470 Walnut Street,
Suite 300
Boulder, CO 80302
Counsel for Petitioner
Exxon Mobil Corporation
APRIL 2023
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.