Reply Brief — Patricia Morrison, Petitioner v. Quest Diagnostics Inc., et al.
Supreme Court briefJun 3, 2022
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 21-1371
3fa Wyt
Supreme Court of tfje ®ntteb g>tate$
PATRICIA MORRISON,
Administratrix for THE ESTATE of TOMMY MORRISON,
Petitioner,
v.
QUEST DIAGNOSTICS INCORPORATED, JOHN HIATT,
DR. MARGARET GOODMAN, NEVADA STATE
ATHLETIC COMMISSION, and MARC RATNER,
Respondents.
On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari
To The United States Court Of Appeals
For The Ninth Circuit
REPLY BRIEF FOR PETITIONER
Patricia Morrison
Petitioner, Pro Se
Administratrix for the Estate of Tommy Morrison
P.O. Box 454
Rose Hill, Kansas 67133
Tel: 1-865-296-9973
Email: TommyandTrishaMorrison@yahoo.com
COCKLE LEGAL BRIEFS (800) 225-6964
WWW.COCKLELEGALBRIEFS.COM
RECEIVED
JUN -7 2022
SUPR#MEFCTONR(f|Ll^.K
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS........................................
1
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES..................................
n
INTRODUCTION..................................................
1
ARGUMENT...........................................................
4
I. The Circuit Split Is Real On Statute Of
Limitations When Seeking DNA/HIV
4
Testing..........................................................
II. DNA/HIV Test Was Not Available At The
Time Of Judgment....................................... 5
III. The Ninth Circuit Flouted The DNA Act
And FRCP 60(b)(6)................................... 10
IV. The Questions Presented Are Exception
ally Important............................................. 12
CONCLUSION........................................................ 14
APPENDIX
Photos and article excerpts
App. 1
Photos and article excerpts
App. 2
Photos and article excerpts
App. 3
Photos and article excerpts
App. 4
Photos and article excerpts
App. 5
11
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page
Cases
Allen v. Wright
468 U.S. 737 (1984)......................
14
Brady v. Maryland,
373 U.S. 83 (1963)........................
5
California v. Texas,
141 S. Ct. 2104 (2021)..................
14
Cooter & Gell v. Hartmarx,
496 U.S. 384 (1990)......................
2
DaimlerChrysler Corp. v. Cuno,
547 U.S. 332 (2006)......................
14
Dilley u. Gunn,
64 F.3d 1365 (9th Cir.1995).........
12
McDonough v. Smith,
139 S. Ct. 2149 (2019).................
2
Midwest Supply, Inc v. Waters,
89 Nev. 210, 510 P.2d 876 (1973)
9
Mooney u. Holohan,
294 U.S. 103 (1935)......................
5
Nevitt v. United States,
886 F.2d 1187 (9th Cir.1989)......
1,10,11,12
Pierce v. Underwood,
487 U.S. 552 (1988)......................
2
Ringsby Truck Lines, Inc. v. Western Conference
of Teamsters,
686 F.2d 720 (9th Cir.1982)...............................
12
Ill
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES - Continued
Page
Rodney Reed v. Bryan Goertz, etal.,
21-442 (2022)................................ ........
2
Savory v. Lyons,
469 F.3d 667 (7th Cir.2006).................
5
Schmerber v. California,
384 U.S. 757, 86 S.Ct. 1826,
16 L.Ed.2d 908(1966).........................
13
Skinner v. Switzer,
562 U.S. 521 (2011)..............................
1
State v. Hale,
306 Neb. 725, 947 N.W.2d 313 (2020)
6
State v. hotter,
266 Neb. 758, 669 N.W.2d 438 (2003)
6
United States v. International Boxing
Club of New York,
348 U.S. 236 (1955)..............................
13
Van Poyck v. McCollum,
646 F.3d 865 (11th Cir.2011)..............
4
Wallace v. Kato,
549 U.S. 384 (2007)..............................
2
Winslow v. Smith,
696 F.3d 716 (8th Cir.2012).................
2
Constitution, Acts, Statutes and Rules
The DNA Act..................................................
..passim
Innocence Protection Act of 2004..............
....10,11
Fourth Amendment......................................
7,10,13
IV
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES - Continued
Page
Fourteenth Amendment
7,10,13
Nebraska Revised Statute 29-4120, 2019
6
FRCP 52(a)(6)...........................................
13
FRCP 60....................................................
passim
FRCP 60(b)(6)...........................................
passim
1
INTRODUCTION
The court of appeals disposed of Tommy Morri
son’s (TOMMY’S) case solely on timeliness grounds, so
it didn’t address the merits, and this Court is one “of
review, not of first view.” Skinner, 562 U.S. at 521 (cita
tion omitted).
Petitioner MORRISON contends although the
Ninth Circuit did not reach the issue, TOMMY’S case
may be entitled to relief under Rule 60(b)(6).
Just like in Skinner, if this Court resolves the
threshold questions presented in TOMMY’S favor, the
merits will be “ripe for consideration on remand.” Id.
There are no questions of fact here to be disturbed.
MORRISON has demonstrated there is more than a
scintilla of evidence creating a genuine issue of mate
rial fact on which a jury could reasonably find for
TOMMY. Overwhelming, undisputed evidence on the
record scientifically confirms TOMMY did not have,
nor did he die of, HIV/AIDS.
Certiorari is warranted because the Ninth Circuit
interpreted Nevitt u. United States, 886 F.2d 1187,1188
(9th Cir.1989) and Fed.R.Civ.P.60 (1946) to improperly
withhold and forbid access to a constitutional proce
dure of DNA/HIV testing that will prove the Quest Di
agnostics 1996 LDT (laboratory developed test) result
did not detect HIV in TOMMY on February 10, 1996.
(LDT’s are not approved by the FDA).
The Ninth Circuit reviewed the district court’s de
cision under the wrong legal standard — de novo — the
2
Court should vacate the judgment and remand for con
sideration under the proper legal standard - abuse of
discretion. Abuse of discretion is the proper standard.
See Cooter & Gell v. Hartmarx, 496 U.S. 384 (1990);
Pierce v. Underwood, 487 U.S. 552 (1988). As this Court
explained in Pierce, many decisions applying law to
facts should be reviewed for abuse of discretion. 487
U.S. at 559-60. Deferential review is appropriate when
“one judicial actor is better positioned than another to
decide the issue in question.”
Indeed, just this past month, (May 02, 2022) this
Court granted certiorari in Case 21-442 Rodney Reed
v. Bryan Goertz, et al., based on the statute of limita
tions in another denial of DNA testing. As McDonough
reaffirmed, accrual occurs once there is “a complete
and present cause of action.” 139 S. Ct. at 2149 (quot
ing Wallace v. Kato, 549 U.S. 384, 388 (2007)). As in
Reed, TOMMY’S “Defendants may be held liable if they
recklessly ignored evidence suggesting the Plaintiff’s
innocence or systematically pressured witnesses to
manufacture false testimony to fill gaps in an inves
tigation.” Winslow v. Smith, 696 F.3d 716, 734 (8th
Cir.2012).
Respondents/Defendants NSAC, RATNER, GOOD
MAN (collectively “NSAC”) filed a WAIVER.
Respondents/Defendants QUEST DIAGNOSTICS
and HIATT (collectively “QUEST”) filed a BIO. Ms.
Caldwell, the author of QUEST’S BIO, is not an expert
in HIV/AIDS and cannot provide a reliable opinion in
this case and has never held board certification in
3
immunology, pathology, neurology, or the sub-specialty
of infectious diseases. Ms. Caldwell has never produced
any hospital discharge summaries signed by any phy
sician using ICD-9 codes which would be required if
they were confirming an HIV/AIDS diagnoses.
Undisputed by all Respondents, TOMMY was cer
tified physically and mentally fit for competition and
to be licensed to fight on February 10,1996. TOMMY
complied with the Legislative recorded 1996 boxing li
cense regulation which did not require the search and
seizure of blood, and TOMMY was never diagnosed
with HIV by anyone in Las Vegas, Nevada.
Having no documented basis for forcing an imme
diate, indefinite, worldwide suspension on TOMMY’S
profession, all on one day, February 10,1996, makes
NSAC’S and QUEST’S actions “arbitrary and capri
cious.”
If any tradition is relevant here, it is the constitu
tional tradition of equal treatment for all. DNA/HIV
testing does not in and of itself, detect or implicate any
criminal wrongdoing.
The information is intended to provide evidence of
a person’s identity. A DNA/HIV sample is evidence only
of one’s genetic code which in this case will determine
if TOMMY’S preserved tissue includes a genetic code
that either contains or excludes DNA/HIV.
The error and irreparable, harmful, effects of the
Ninth Circuit’s ruling requires this Court’s urgent at
tention.
4
The petition should be granted because good cause
has been shown.
ARGUMENT
I.
The Circuit Split Is Real On Statute Of
Limitations When Seeking DNA/HIV Test
ing.
As the petition explained, the circuits have split
over whether the statute of limitations for newly dis
covered evidence in a federal civil case, seeking
DNA/HIV testing begins to run at the end of statecourt litigation or at the moment the state trial court
first denies testing, despite any subsequent appeal.
Had TOMMY’S case arisen in the Eleventh Circuit
rather than the Ninth Circuit, DNA/HIV testing would
have been timely. Instead, the lower courts tossed the
testing, leaving a petitioner without access to exculpa
tory evidence - including the testing - that could help
provide TOMMY’S identity of innocence on February
10,1996 when Respondents regarded TOMMY as hav
ing the human immunodeficiency virus (“HIV”) and
immediately, indefinitely, worldwide suspended him
from boxing, cancelled the fight that night, and lost a
multi-million dollar contract to fight Mike Tyson.
In the Eleventh Circuit, the limitations period be
gins to run from the end of the state-court litigation
denying testing, Van Poyck v. McCollum, 646 F.3d
865, 867 (11th Cir.2011) (per curiam). TOMMY’S case
would have been timely there.
5
In the Fifth and Seventh Circuits, the limitations
period runs from the moment the state trial court de
nies DNA testing, despite any appeal. Savory v. Lyons,
469 F.3d 667,672 (7th Cir.2006). TOMMY’S case would
have been timely there.
This Court repeatedly told courts not to define
clearly established law at a high level of generality and
has responded to the unfairness that would result if
the presentation of the issue were barred by time lim
itations and has found both the use of perjured testi
mony and the withholding of exculpatory evidence to
violate the due process clause, Mooney v. Holohan, 294
U.S. 103, 112 (1935) (perjured testimony); Brady v.
Maryland, 373 U.S. 83, 87 (1963) (exculpatory evi
dence).
II.
DNA/HIV Test Was Not Available At The
Time Of Judgment.
Because of today’s technological advances in 2022,
TOMMY’S biological evidence is preserved in perpe
tuity (forever). The biological evidence is at the
University of Nebraska Medical Center in Omaha, Ne
braska. (UNMC). UNMC is accredited by the American
Society of Crime Laboratory Directors-LAB-Laboratory
Accreditation Board.
QUEST has now come clean its test was an LDT.
The FDA warns unapproved LDT’S lack, among other
things, medical laboratory testing and controls, and
provide inaccurate results and are not reliable in de
tecting the presence of HIV.
6
QUEST’S BIOp02 promises the Court its testing
on TOMMY complied with the “clinical standard of
care for HIV testing in 1996.” There was no such “clin
ical standard of care” using LDT’S, nor any reference
to a link to prove a QUEST test for $20-$30 in 1996
even existed. Clinical laboratories do not regulate test
ing - the FDA does that.
Since 1996, the FDA has conducted several inves
tigations of firms selling and promoting unapproved
HIV test kits. QUEST has been under the radar, until
now.
The type of DNA/HIV testing to verify QUEST’S
1996 non-FDA approved home-brew/Laboratory De
veloped Test was not available within one year of Judg
ment. Such testing now available will produce more
accurate and probative results. See State v. hotter, 266
Neb. 758, 669 N.W.2d 438 (2003).
If all the criteria has been met, as shown in the
petition, and the reviewing court finds testing may pro
duce non-cumulative, exculpatory evidence relevant to
the claim TOMMY was wrongfully convicted on Feb
ruary 10,1996: (5) the court must order DNA test
ing. State v. Hale, 306 Neb. 725, 947 N.W.2d 313
(2020). See also Nebraska Revised Statute 29-4120,
2019.
QUEST’S peculiarly strong resistance to this peti
tion can be explained only by its strong desire to avoid
the questions this petition alone forces it to confront.
7
QUEST has “never told” about its technological
challenges and elaborate 20 yearlong fraud of exagger
ated, false, misleading statements about its technology,
business, testing, reporting, of its HIV-LDT’S (labora
tory developed tests). In fact for over 20 years QUEST
has made everyone believe their HIV test was ap
proved by the FDA. The FDA does not approve LDT’S.
When QUEST subpoenaed TOMMY’S FINAL DI
AGNOSIS of September 17, 2013, revealing no HIV
and no AIDS, its first move was to conceal it from the
courts. (Pet.p. 10-12).
When QUEST subpoenaed TOMMY’S negative re
sults for any AIDS diseases, it withheld those records
from its own expert witness. (Pet.p. 12).
QUEST’S resistance is self-evident. QUEST would
prefer to obscure details of its fraudulent scheme, as
this case makes it clear. QUEST prefers not to talk
about the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments, this
case would oblige it to.
QUEST’S BIO repeatedly mentions its summary
judgment record bolstering certiorari because QUEST
fails to mention NSAC finally came clean there was
no law in Nevada requiring a blood test for HIV to ob
tain a boxing license in 1996. The summary judgment
record shows the lower court committed clear error
granting MS J.
8
Attorney General’s Office Dkt#306 P.5:2
. .the regulation was not adopted into
the form cited in Defendant’s motions
until 1997.”
Note Bene: Defendant’s motions (over 300 mo
tions) used a regulation not adopted until 1997, not on
February 10, 1996, earning them the granting of their
MSJ.
QUEST’S BIO repeats blood testing was required
to obtain a license. This is continuing perjured tes
timony.
Some courts have stretched the limitations peri
ods by construing the crimes as “continuing” to toll the
statutes, some under the theory defendants sought to
conceal the crime. Both scenarios apply to Respond
ents’/Defendants’ conduct in TOMMY’S case.
TOMMY was innocent of HIV/AIDS on February
10,1996 and the QUEST 1996 LDT test result in ques
tion is wrong.
The specific evidence to be tested is in Nebraska
and was not previously subjected to DNA/HIV testing
and neither parties knowingly and voluntarily waived
the right to request DNA testing of that evidence in a
court proceeding or knowingly failed to request DNA
testing of that evidence in a prior motion for postcon
viction DNA testing.
MORRISON is requesting DNA/HIV testing using
a new method or technology that is substantially more
9
probative than the QUEST LDT testing of February
1996.
The proposed DNA testing is reasonable in scope,
uses scientifically sound methods, and is consistent
with accepted forensic practices.
MORRISON identifies a theory of defense not
inconsistent with an affirmative defense presented
throughout this case and would establish the actual in
nocence of TOMMY’S “offense” of testing positive for
HIV in Las Vegas, Nevada.
The DNA/HIV testing may produce new material
evidence that would support the theory of defense ref
erenced and raise probability TOMMY did not commit
the violation of what has now been exposed as an ex
post facto law.
Respondents cannot suppress exculpatory evi
dence. It is well settled under Nevada law suppression
or nondisclosure of a material fact, which a party is
bound in good faith to disclose, is equivalent to a false
representation. See Midwest Supply, Inc. v. Waters, 89
Nev. 210, 510 P.2d 876, 878 (1973).
QUEST spends the bulk of its brief re-prosecuting,
raising arguments the court of appeals and district
court already rejected (such as accusing MORRISON
of being vexatious), and attacking MORRISON’S con
stitutional arguments.
Someone reading QUEST’S BIO can quickly rec
ognize it never addresses, much less disputes, the test
10
it used on TOMMY in 1996 was a Laboratory Devel
oped Test - not approved by the FDA.
III. The Ninth Circuit Flouted The DNA ACT
And FRCP 60(b)(6).
Neuitt and FRCP 60 were ruled before the DNA Act
and the Innocence Project Act and it is time for our laws
to reflect science.
In the new, illogical, Ninth Circuit one-size-fits-all
Neuitt rule dating back to 1989, DNA/HIV testing in
2022 can only be made within one year after judgment
has been entered, even if the biological evidence or the
required testing is not available at that time.
But Neuitt, nor the Legislature, makes no refer
ence to DNA/HIV testing. Sure, Neuitt involves newly
discovered evidence, but actual DNA testing cases rest
in the hands of more updated constitutional rules un
der the DNA ACT, inter alia, which was still a decade
away from Neuitt. DNA samples were not collected or
tested until Congress enacted the 2000 DNA Act, 11
years post Neuitt. That new Ninth Circuit Neuitt rule
departs from this Court’s precedent, splits from the
Ninth Circuit and other courts of appeals and threat
ens massive restrictions on Fourth and Fourteenth
Amendment expressions and makes a mockery of all
other cases gone before TOMMY’S.
The Ninth Circuit also rested its holding on a no
tion that FRCP 60 rule applies to DNA/HIV testing.
This is a first, and is split with other circuit courts,
11
even its own. Accepting the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning
in Nevitt and FRCP 60 would require reversal of cases
from virtually every State and many federal court deci
sions as well. In light of these and many other persua
sive authorities upholding the DNA Act and Innocence
Project Act, MORRISON respectfully suggests that the
Ninth’s Circuit analysis is suspect and Nevitt and
FRCP 60 do not apply in this case and indicate that
the Legislature did not intend to impose a strict one
year limitations period on actions brought to challenge
a presumption of HIV innocence. FRCP 60 suffers from
multiple constitutional deficiencies and does not ad
dress the use of any DNA collection techniques. To be
sure the Ninth Circuit should not have applied those
unconstitutional requirements to TOMMY’S case, and
MORRISON challenges their constitutionality.
In the Ninth Circuit’s view, this Court should re
tain the implied statute of limitations of one year from
judgment because Congress now expects federal judges
to do the job that Congress failed to do itself. That’s not
how the separation of powers exists. If Congress wants
to include a private right of action in a statute, it
should do what Article I anticipated - enact a law. Con
gress should not rely on Judges to fill in the blanks.
Congress knows how to enact a private right of action
when it wants to and that is why the DNA ACT was
enacted. The DNA ACT is frequently used in both civil
and criminal cases and not only helps identify actual
perpetrators of crimes, paternity, but also helps elimi
nate individuals from suspect lists, inter alia.
i
12
The Court should not let the Ninth Circuit’s illog
ical Nevitt rule bar MORRISON’S opportunity to seek
DNA/HIV testing that could exonerate TOMMY of HIV
on February 10,1996, especially when this case would
have gone forward in the Eleventh Circuit.
The Ninth Circuit, flouting a well settled DNA
ACT, could also have applied FRCP 60(b)(6) support
ing “extraordinary circumstances” in light of ‘the con
sequences and attendant hardships of dismissal or
refusal to dismiss’ and ‘the competing values of judg
ment and right to litigation of unreviewed disputes.’
Dilley v. Gunn, 64 F.3d 1365, 1370-71 (9th Cir.1995)
(quoting Ringsby Truck Lines, Inc. v. Western Confer
ence of Teamsters, 686 F.2d 720, 722 (9th Cir.1982)).
IV. The Questions Presented Are Exception
ally Important.
This case is resolved by simple but important and
recurring questions of law.
This Court is presented with clean issues of im
portant but unresolved law. By QUEST’S objections,
and NSAC’s silence, this Court should resolve the ex
ceptionally important questions.
When the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP)
were created in 1938, their purpose was simple: “se
cure the just, speedy, and inexpensive determination of
every action and proceeding.” This purpose has become
muddled over the years especially during pandemics
such as Covid-19. FRCP are not statutes because they
13
are not enacted by Congress and are not regulations
because they are not issued by a federal administrative
agency. Instead, FRCP is drafted by an Advisory Com
mittee, and its proposals are subject to publication and
public comment.
FRCP 60 proposal to deny DNA/HIV testing has
never been publicized nor up for public comment.
The Federal Government can constitutionally “en
croach” on an area previously ‘regulated’ solely by the
‘states’, as already addressed by this Court. United
States u. International Boxing Club of New York, 348
U.S. 236 (1955), (where this Court decided that even
though the boxing matches were indeed of a “local” na
ture, the fact that they were promoted, televised, and
broadcasted on a multistate level made them amena
ble to Federal Law).
This Court has held invasions of the body are
searches and, thus, are entitled to the protections of
the Fourth Amendment. Schmerber v. California, 384
U.S. 757, 767-71, 86 S.Ct. 1826, 16 L.Ed.2d 908 (1966)
(blood).
Nothing prevents or even complicates this Court’s
resolution of the Questions Presented. The Ninth Cir
cuit was supposed to review findings for clear error,
FRCP 52(a)(6), instead it created a double standard by
failing to protect the Fourth and Fourteenth Amend
ments to the same extent they protect other constitu
tional rights.
14
In QUEST’S view none of this matters. But con
trary to QUEST’S argument, the Questions Presented
and statute of limitations will come into play in many
suits seeking DNA/HIV testing because state-court
litigation is rarely swift. The testing is relevant to
TOMMY’S injuries traceable directly to that QUEST
1996 LDT/result, and QUEST’S degree of resistance to
replicate its 1996 result may be admissible to show
consciousness of guilt.
MORRISON can “allege personal injury fairly trace
able to the defendant’s allegedly unlawful conduct and
likely to be redressed by the requested relief.” Califor
nia v. Texas, 141 S. Ct. at 2104 (quoting DaimlerChrysler
Corp. v. Cuno, 547 U.S. 332, 342 (2006)).
MORRISON can connect “the judicial relief re
quested” and the “injury suffered.” Id. (quoting Allen u
Wright, 468 U.S. 737, 753 n.19 (1984)).
CONCLUSION
MORRISON is not an attorney. No Federal Judge,
nor Magistrate Judge, has ever taken into submission
MORRISON is vexatious and harassing as accused in
QUEST’S BIO.
MORRISON is honored and thankful to receive
kind words from the only woman lawyer from the State
of Nevada elected a fellow of the International Society
of Barristers, the International Academy of Trial
Lawyers, and the American College of Trial Lawyers.
15
Magistrate Judge Lean was both a criminal and civil
trial lawyer.
“Ms. Morrison has appeared before the
court and has conducted herself appro
priately. She is an intelligent and articu
late woman.” Order by Magistrate Judge
Peggy A. Lean. (dkt#184 P.2:17-18).
The petition should be granted.
Respectfully submitted,
Patricia Morrison
Petitioner, Pro Se
Administratrix for the Estate of Tommy Morrison
P.O. Box 454
Rose Hill, Kansas 67133
Tel: 1-865-296-9973
Email: TommyandTrishaMorrison@yahoo.com
Dated: June 3, 2022
App. 1
U*$* SUPREME
COURT
For two years, Petitioner has sought access to
HIV/DNA testing on newly discovered biological
evidence, that could prove TOMMY “THE DUKE”
MORRISON, aka TOMMY GUNN from ROCKY V, was
innocent on February 10, 1996 of having “HIV”. The
February 10, 1996, “HIV” test is the injury traceable
to the immediate cancellation of the boxing fight that
night, indefinite, worldwide, medical suspension from
boxing, and cancellation of a multi-milli on-doll ar fight
contract to fight Mike Tyson, and $110 million dollars
in damages in this case. The 1996 Nevada Legisla
ture’s boxing license regulation (NAC 467.027) re
quired Legislative approval to enforce HIV testing. It
was not until August 07,1997, HIV testing was pro
posed, later adopted by the Legislature, and effective
for the first time on December 02, 1997 (NAC 467.027
section (3)(b)). In 2012 and 2013 TOMMY was repeat
edly tested for AIDS by various physicians and labora
tories, including HIV specialists, using different HIV
testing methods-all of which confirmed negative re
sults for any AIDS diseases. TOMMY died September
01, 2013, his September 17, 2013 postmortem pathol
ogy report “Final Diagnosis” lists: “No viral particles
seen. No viral particles were found. No retroviral
budding is present. No Retroviral inclusions pre
sent. No viral particles were seen.”'
App. 2
Between 2012 and 2013, TOMMY was tested by
various labs and physicians, including HIV specialists,
for AIDS defining diseases that would occur if the Vi
rus HIV was present.
All AIDS tests came back negative for Pneumo
cystis Carinii Pneumonia (PCP); Kaposi Sarcoma;
Cryptococcus; HIV-2; HTLV-1; HTLV-2;
Even Histoplasmosis Nov. 04. 2012 was negative
by Michele Steckelberg, MD; negative for Cytomeg
alovirus (CMV) May. 08, 2013 by Scott Heasty, MD;
negative for J.C. Polyoma Virus by Rick Pesano, MD,
PhD on May 20,2013.
1'I
%
The CDC and Dr. Anthony Fauci classified an
AIDS diagnosis in 1984 as someone testing positive for
PCP (Pneumocystis Carinii Pneumonia) and KP (Ka
posi Sarcoma). TOMMY’S test results came back neg
ative for both those AIDS diseases.
Negative for PCP (Pneumocystis Carinii Pneumo
nia) on Jun. 11, 2013 by William R. Bauman, MD,
negative again for PCP on Aug. 05, 2013 by Subodh
M. Lele, MD. Negative for KP (Kaposi Sarcoma) on
Jul. 11,2013 by Jessica A. Kozel, MD.
U.S.SUPREME
COURT
App. 3
Prior to TOMMY’S death:
Also, in July 2012, TOMMY’S blood was tested by
another independent, infectious disease accredited la
boratory, and the findings were the same as the post
mortem report - “No viral inclusions, fungi or
bacterial forms are identified.” This antemortem
i
r"
1
1
\
1
P
L
U-S.SUPREME
COURT
x
4
£
G. Petur Nielsen, MD
Page. 11/12
Pathologist,
Massachusetts General
Hospital
Professor of Pathology,
Harvard Medical School
12
pathology report was authored and signed by board
certified pathologist Gunnlaugur Petur Nielsen,
MD at Boston Massachusetts General Hospital’s Infec
tious Disease Department and has also been on the
record throughout this case.
App. 4
TOMMY died September 01,2013 after fighting 21
months of septic shock, septicemia, heart issues, and a
botched surgery where 12 feet of tightly packed surgi
cal gauze was “mistakenly” left in his chest for 8 days
to rot following a surgery on December 01, 2011.
TOMMY’S blood was drawn and at Petitioner’s request
a blood autopsy was performed. On September 17,
2013 P. Smith, MD, head of the Infectious Disease De
partment at the University of Nebraska Medical Cen
ter, (“UNMC”), called Petitioner to inform her of the
results — Final Diagnosis — negative for HIV. The
U.S. SUPREME
COURT
"W
Page. 10/11
A
i
%*,«***
'h
-
S
IH Getty Images
Dr. Phil Smith,
li
4
fH—a_
# ’ Or. Steven
Hinrichs
► ■ Appointed to
U Federal
Committee
October 1,
2017 | Categories!
postmortem pathology report was written up with the
methodology used and signed as authentication by
Pathologist S. Hinrichs, MD, and faxed to Petitioner
and has been on the record since the inception of this
case. The UNMC’ legal department informed Peti
tioner that Respondents were sent the postmortem to
gether with an Affidavit of Records in response to
QUEST’S subpoena.
As a note: Dr. Steven Hinrichs was Professor and
Chair in the Department of Pathology and Microbiol
ogy at the University of Nebraska Medical Center
(UNMC); previously Director of the Nebraska Public
Health Laboratory (APHL) and Biosecurity; responsi
ble for the development program for the rapid identification of biological agents of mass destruction: was
App. 5
Page*15
SUPREME
COURT
(8). In 2020 Respondents were caught having
used ex post facto laws on TOMMY on February 10,
1996, and throughout this case. These ex post facto
statutes coerced Judge Richard F. Boulware II to grant
Respondents’ 2016 MSJ. Respondents’ Ex post facto
statutes were used in Federal, Appellate Courts and in
this U.S. Supreme Court and included: (NRS. 469.1005
did not exist at all); (NRS. 467.100(2) did not exist until
1999, not in 1996); (NRS.467,1005 did not exist until
1999, not in 1996); (NRS. 467.100(3) did not exist until
2003, not in 1996) (NAC.467.027(3) did not exist until
1997, not in 1996); (NAC.467.027(3b) did not exist un
til 1997, not in 1996). If not reversed and remanded,
this case sets a precedence for civil cases to violate The
Constitution and The Administrative Procedures Act.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.