Response to application from respondents Phil Murphy, et al. — Kevin Robinson, et al., Applicants v. Phil Murphy, Governor of New Jersey, et al.

Supreme Court briefDec 3, 2020

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No. 20A95

In the Supreme Court of the United States

REV. KEVIN ROBINSON AND RABBI YISRAEL A. KNOPFLER,

Applicants,

v.

PHILIP D. MURPHY, ET AL.,

Respondents.

APPENDIX FOR RESPONDENTS – VOLUME III OF IV, PAGES 400-602

GURBIR S. GREWAL

Attorney General of New Jersey

JEREMY M. FEIGENBAUM*

State Solicitor

DANIEL M. VANNELLA

Assistant Attorney General

AUSTIN HILTON

BRYAN EDWARD LUCAS

JUSTINE LONGA

ROBERT J. MCGUIRE

STEPHANIE MERSCH

JESSICA JANNETTI SAMPOLI

MICHAEL R. SARNO

Deputy Attorneys General

December 3, 2020

Richard J. Hughes Justice Complex

25 Market Street, Trenton, NJ 08625

(609) 292-4925

jeremy.feigenbaum@njoag.gov

*Counsel of Record

Counsel for Respondents

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

Michelle L. Holshue, et al., First Case of 2019 Novel Coronavirus in the

United States, N. ENGL. J. MED. 382:929–36 (Mar. 5, 2020) ............ R.A. 1

New Virus Discovered

Investigating Pneumonia Outbreak,

Natasha

Khan,

by

Chinese

Scientists

WALL STREET J. (Jan. 8, 2020) ........................................................ R.A. 17

Berkeley Lovelace, Jr. & William Feuer, CDC Confirms First Human-toHuman Transmission of Coronavirus in US,

CNBC (Jan. 30, 2020) ......................................................................... R.A. 1

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ("CDC"), Coronavirus

Disease

2019

–

Frequently

Asked

Questions,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/faq.html (last visited May

26, 2020) ............................................................................................ R.A. 21

Declaring a National Emergency Concerning the Novel Coronavirus

Disease (COVID-19) Outbreak, Proclamation No. 9994, 85 Fed. Reg.

15337-38 (2020)................................................................................. R.A. 60

Prioritizing and Allocating Health and Medical Resources to Respond to

the Spread of Covid-19, Exec. Order No. 13909,

85 Fed. Reg. 16227 (2020) ................................................................ R.A. 64

CDC, How to Protect Yourself & Others, Coronavirus Disease 2019

(COVID-19),

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/preventgetting-sick/prevention.html (last visited May 26, 2020) ............... R.A. 68

R.A. i

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Camilla Rothe, et al., Transmission of 2019-nCoV Infection from an

Asymptomatic Contact in Germany, N. ENGL. J. MED. 382:970–71 (Mar.

5, 2020) .............................................................................................. R.A. 71

Lea Hamner, et al., CDC, High SARS-CoV-2 Attack Rate Following

Exposure at a Choir Practice—Skagit County, Washington, March 2020,

Morbidity

and

Mortality

Weekly

Report

(MMWR),

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6919e6-H.pdf (last

visited May 26, 2020) ....................................................................... R.A. 74

Allison James, et al., CDC, High COVID-19 Attack Rate among

Attendees at Events at a Church, Arkansas, March 2020, MMWR,

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6920e2-H.pdf (last

visited May 26, 2020) ....................................................................... R.A. 80

Isaac Ghinai, et al., CDC, Community Transmission of SARS-CoV-2 at

Two Family Gatherings, Chicago, Illinois, February-March 2020,

MMWR,

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/pdfs/mm6915e1H.pdf (last visited May 26, 2020) ..................................................... R.A. 85

Youjin Shin, et al., How a South Korean Church Helped Fuel the Spread

of Coronavirus, WASH. POST (Mar. 25, 2020)................................... R.A. 91

Anna Kim, Glenview Church Hit by COVID-19 Is Now Streaming Service

Online, as Pastor Remembers Usher Who Died of Disease, CHICAGO TRIB.

(Mar. 31, 2020) .................................................................................... R.A. 6

Chris Epp, "I Would Do Anything for a Do-Over": Calgary Church Hopes

Others Learn from Their Tragic COVID-19 Experience, CTV NEWS (May

10, 2020) .......................................................................................... R.A. 111

R.A. ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Richard Read, A Choir Decided to Go Ahead with Rehearsal. Now Dozens

of Members Have COVID-19 and Two Are Dead, L.A. TIMES (Mar. 29,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 117

Maggie Holmes, Two People Die of COVID-19 as a Result of Church

Gathering in KCK, KCTV NEWS5 (Apr. 8, 2020) .......................... R.A. 131

Bailey Loosmore & Mandy McLaren, Kentucky County "Hit Really,

Really Hard" by Church Revival that Spread Deadly COVID-19,

LOUISVILLE COURIER J. (Apr. 1, 2020) ............................................ R.A. 134

Mario Koran, California Megachurch Linked to Spread of More than 70

Coronavirus Cases, GUARDIAN (Apr. 3, 2020) ................................ R.A. 137

Dakin Andone & Artemis Moshtaghian, A Person Who Was Covid-19

Positive Attended a Church Service and Exposed 180 People, Officials

Say, CNN (May 17, 2020) ............................................................... R.A. 142

Johns Hopkins Univ., COVID-19 Dashboard, https://coronavirus.jhu.edu

/map.html (last visited May 27, 2020) ........................................... R.A. 147

CDC, Coronavirus Disease 2019 – Cases in the U.S.,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/cases-in-us.ht

ml (last visited May 27, 2020) ........................................................ R.A. 149

N.J. Dep't of Health, New Jersey COVID-19 Dashboard,

https://www.nj.gov/health/cd/topics/covid2019_dashboard.shtml

(last

visited May 27, 2020) ..................................................................... R.A. 156

R.A. iii

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Sheri Fink, Worst-Case Estimates for U.S. Coronavirus Deaths, N.Y.

TIMES (Mar. 13, 2020) ..................................................................... R.A. 158

Ashley Balcerzak, Nearly All Businesses in NJ Are Closed. Why Are

Liquor Stores Considered "Essential"?, MSN (Mar. 29, 2020) ..... R.A. 169

Press Releases, New Jersey Attorney General, Enforcement of COVID19 Restrictions (March 27, 2020; April 1, 2020; April 3, 2020; April 5-9,

2020; April 11, 2020; April 13, 2020; April 15-16, 2020; April 19, 2020;

April 24, 2020; May 8, 2020; and May 22, 2020)........................... R.A. 174

Carlie Porterfield, Church-Related Coronavirus Outbreaks Reported as

Trump Pushes for Reopening, FORBES (May 23, 2020) ................. R.A. 231

Zeeshan Aleem, One German Church Service Resulted in More Than 100

Coronavirus Infections, VOX (May 24, 2020) ................................. R.A. 235

Transcript of the Oral Decision of the Hon. Robert B. Kugler, U.S.D.J.,

Dwelling Place Network v. Murphy, Civil Action No. 20-6281

(June 15, 2020)................................................................................ R.A. 240

CDC,

Coronavirus

Disease

2019

–

About

Masks,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-sick/aboutface-coverings.html (last visited August 17, 2020) ....................... R.A. 329

Nathan W. Furukawa, et al., Evidence Supporting Transmission of

Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 While

Presymptomatic or Asymptomatic, EMERGING INFECTIOUS DISEASES 2020;

26(7) (July 2020), https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/26/7/20-1595_article

......................................................................................................... R.A. 332

R.A. iv

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Seungjae Lee, et al., Clinical Course and Molecular Viral Shedding

Among Asymptomatic and Symptomatic Patients with SARS-CoV-2

Infection in a Community Treatment Center in the Republic of Korea,

JAMA

INTERNAL

MEDICINE

(Aug.

6,

2020),

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2769

235 ................................................................................................... R.A. 339

Kate Conger, et al., Churches Were Eager to Reopen. Now They Are

Confronting Coronavirus Cases, N.Y. TIMES (July 10, 2020) ....... R.A. 346

Chacour Koop, "It Spread Like Wildfire." How One Man at Church with

COVID-19 Led to 91 Cases in Ohio, KANSAS CITY STAR (Aug. 5, 2020)

......................................................................................................... R.A. 353

Taylor Stuck, Virus Outbreaks in Churches Continue, THE HERALDDISPATCH (Aug. 15, 2020) ............................................................... R.A. 356

Mike Valente, Berea Church Suspends In-Person Services after COVID19 Outbreak, LEX 18 (Aug. 12, 2020)............................................ R.A. 360

Payton Potter, Pastor Addresses Coronavirus Outbreak Linked To

Windham Church, PATCH (Aug. 10, 2020) ..................................... R.A. 363

Jenna Rae, COVID-19 Outbreak at Athens Church, WAFF 48, (Aug. 10,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 367

CDC, Coronavirus Disease 2019 – Cases in the U.S.,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/cases-in-us.ht

ml (last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ....................................................... R.A. 369

R.A. v

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

N.J. Dep't of Health, New Jersey COVID-19 Dashboard,

https://www.nj.gov/health/cd/topics/covid2019_dashboard.shtml

(last

visited Aug. 17, 2020) ..................................................................... R.A. 373

Coronavirus in the U.S.: Latest Map and Case Count, N.Y. TIMES,

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/us/coronavirus-us-cases.html

(last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ............................................................. R.A. 375

Madeline Holcombe & Dakin Andone, Experts Say US Is Not Doing

Enough To Contain Covid-19 As Nation Approaches 5 Million Cases,

CNN (Aug. 8, 2020)......................................................................... R.A. 389

CDC, Coronavirus Disease 2019 – Deciding to Go Out,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/daily-life-coping/deciding-togo-out.html (last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ........................................ R.A. 395

Peter Sullivan, Evidence Mounts That Outside Is Safer When It Comes

to COVID-19, THE HILL (May 6, 2020) .......................................... R.A. 400

Tara Parker-Pope, How Safe Are Outdoor Gatherings?, N.Y. TIMES (July

5, 2020) ............................................................................................ R.A. 404

Are Outdoor Gatherings Safe? Here's What Experts Say, ADVISORY

BOARD, (July 17, 2020) ................................................................... R.A. 409

Press Release, CDC, CDC Calls On Americans to Wear Masks to Prevent

COVID-19 Spread, (July 14, 2020) ................................................ R.A. 414

R.A. vi

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Susanna Esposito, et al., Universal Use of Face Masks For Success

against COVID-19: Evidence and Implications for Prevention Policies,

EUROPEAN RESPIRATORY J. (Apr. 21, 2020) .................................... R.A. 419

Xiaowen Wang, et al., Association Between Universal Masking in a

Health Care System and SARS-CoV-2 Positivity Among Health Care

Workers, J. OF THE AM. MED. ASS'N (July 14, 2020) ...................... R.A. 429

M. Joshua Hendrix, et al., Absence of Apparent Transmission of SARS-

CoV-2 from Two Stylists after Exposure at a Hair Salon with a Universal

Face Covering Policy—Springfield, Missouri, May 2020, MMWR (July 17,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 432

Diana Kwon, How Face Masks Can Help Prevent the Spread of COVID19, THE SCIENTIST (July 8, 2020) ................................................... R.A. 436

Trisha Greenhalgh, Face Coverings for the Public: Laying Straw Men to

Rest, J. OF EVALUATION IN CLINICAL PRACTICE (May 6, 2020) ...... R.A. 442

Siddhartha Verma, et al., Visualizing the Effectiveness of Face Masks in

Obstructing Respiratory Jets, PHYSICS OF FLUIDS 32, 061708 (June 30,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 451

Philip Anfinrud, et al., Visualizing Speech-Generated Oral Fluid

Droplets with Laser Light Scattering, N. ENGL. J. OF MED.

(Apr. 15, 2020) ................................................................................ R.A. 460

Abhiteja Konda, et al., Aerosol Filtration Efficiency of Common Fabrics

Used in Respiratory Cloth Masks, ACS NANO (Apr. 24, 2020)..... R.A. 463

R.A. vii

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Jeremy Howard, et al., Face Masks Against COVID-19: An Evidence

Review, PROCEEDINGS OF THE NAT'L ACAD. OF SCI. OF THE UNITED STATES

OF AMERICA (Apr. 10, 2020) ............................................................ R.A. 473

New IHME COVID-19 Forecasts See Nearly 300,000 Deaths by

December 1, However, Consistent Mask-Wearing Could Save about

70,000 Lives, INST. FOR HEALTH METRICS AND EVALUATION

(Aug. 6, 2020) .................................................................................. R.A. 482

Andy Markowitz, State-by-State Guide to Face Mask Requirements,

AARP,

https://www.aarp.org/health/healthy-living/info-2020/statesmask-mandates-coronavirus.html

(last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ............................................................. R.A. 488

Wei Lyu & George L. Wehby, Community Use of Face Masks And

COVID-19: Evidence From A Natural Experiment Of State Mandates In

The US, HEALTH AFFAIRS (June 16, 2020) ..................................... R.A. 510

Christopher T. Leffler, et al., Association of Country-Wide Coronavirus

Mortality with Demographics, Testing, Lockdowns, and Public Wearing

of Masks (July 2, 2020)................................................................... R.A. 518

CDC, Coronavirus Disease 2019 – How to Wear Masks,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-sick/how-towear-cloth-face-coverings.html (last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ......... R.A. 603

German Lopez, Just 6 States Meet These Basic Criteria to Reopen and

Stay Safe, VOX (July 22, 2020) ....................................................... R.A. 606

R.A. viii

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Covid Act Now, New Jersey, https://covidactnow.org/state/NJ?s=844163

(last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ............................................................. R.A. 619

Johns Hopkins University & Medicine, COVID-19 Dashboard,

https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html

(last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ............................................................ R.A. 628

CDC, Coronavirus Disease 2019 – Considerations for Wearing Masks,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-sick/clothface-cover-guidance.html

(last visited Aug. 17, 2020) ............................................................. R.A. 633

Holly Yan, 200,000 people have died from COVID-19 in the US. That's

more than the US battle deaths from 5 wars combined, CNN (Sept. 22,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 639

Joel Achenbach and Rachel Weiner, Experts project autumn surge in

coronavirus case, with a peak after Election Day, WASH. POST (Sept. 5,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 644

IMHE

Model,

https://covid19.healthdata.org/united-states-ofamerica?view=total-deaths&tab=trend

(last visited Sept. 22, 2020) ............................................................ R.A. 648

Mathieu Pollet, Coronavirus second wave: Which countries in Europe are

experiencing a fresh spike in COVID-19 cases?, EURONEWS (Sept. 22,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 654

Associated Press, Eighth death linked to Millinocket wedding outbreak,

(Sept. 19, 2020) ............................................................................... R.A. 659

R.A. ix

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Rachel Needham, Anatomy of an Outbreak: Church Revival Blamed for

Many of Rural County's COVID-19 Cases, RAPPAHANNOCK NEWS (Aug.

29, 2020) .......................................................................................... R.A. 664

Aubrey Whelan & Ellie Silverman, After Philly's First Church-linked

COVID-19 Outbreak, Pastors Urge Prayers for Sick, PHILA. INQUIRER

(Aug. 21, 2020) ................................................................................ R.A. 669

George Stockburger, Chemung County Releases New Details in

Lighthouse Baptist Church COVID-19 Cluster Death, WETM 18 (Sept.

17, 2020) .......................................................................................... R.A. 672

Covid

Act

Now,

New

Jersey,

https://www.covidactnow.org/us/nj?s=1059230 (last visited Sept. 22,

2020) ................................................................................................ R.A. 675

CDC, COVID Data Tracker,

https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-datatracker/?CDC_AA_refVal=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cdc.gov%2Fcoronavir

us%2F2019-ncov%2Fcases-updates%2Fcases-inus.html#cases_deathsper100k (last visited Sept. 22, 2020) ......... R.A. 684

CDC,

COVID

Data

Tracker,

https://covid.cdc.gov/coviddatatracker/?CDC_AA_refVal=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cdc.gov%2Fcoro

navirus%2F2019-ncov%2Fcases-updates%2Fcases-inus.html#cases_deathsinlast7days (last visited Sept. 22, 2020) ... R.A. 688

CDC, COVID Data Tracker,

https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-datatracker/?CDC_AA_refVal=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cdc.gov%2Fcoronavir

us%2F2019-ncov%2Fcases-updates%2Fcases-inus.html#cases_casesper100k (last visited Sept. 22, 2020) ........... R.A. 691

R.A. x

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Orion Rummler, CDC Director Suggests Face Masks Offer More COVID19 Protection Than Vaccine Would, AXIOS

(Sept. 16, 2020) ............................................................................... R.A. 700

Dr. Francis Collins, Masks Save Lives, NIH DIRECTOR'S BLOG

(Aug. 25, 2020) ................................................................................ R.A. 703

Colin J. Worby & Hsiao-Han Chang, Face Mask Use in the General

Population and Optimal Resource Allocation During COVID-19

Pandemic, NATURE COMMC'NS (Aug. 13, 2020) .............................. R.A. 708

CDC,

Coronavirus

Disease

2019

–

Social

Distancing,

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-sick/socialdistancing.html (last visited Nov. 6, 2020).................................... R.A. 736

CDC,

How

COVID-19

Spreads,

https://tools.cdc.gov/api/v2/resources/media/407478/content.html

(last

visited Nov. 6, 2020) ....................................................................... R.A. 740

Nevada Declaration of Emergency Directive 022

(June 9, 2020).................................................................................. R.A. 744

CDC, Interim Guidance: Get Your Mass Gatherings or Large Community

Events Ready for Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) (last visited

Nov. 6, 2020) ................................................................................... R.A. 750

R.A. xi

TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont’d)

Lindy Washburn, The Second Coronavirus Wave is here in NJ. Here's

Why It's Different from Last Time, NORTHJERSEY.COM (last updated Oct.

21, 2020), http://www.northjersey.com/story/news/coronavirus/2020/10/1

9/covid-nj-cases-second-wave-hits-heres-why-its-differenttime/3676551001/............................................................................ R.A. 757

Brent Johnson, N.J. Reports 2,472 new COVID-19 Cases, 9 More Deaths

— 2nd Time in a Week with more Than 2,000 Cases, NJ.COM (last

updated Nov. 5, 2020) ..................................................................... R.A. 763

Matt Arco, N.J. Reports 2,104 New COVID-19 Cases, 12 New Deaths as

Second Wave Spike Escalates, NJ.COM

(last updated Nov. 5, 2020) ............................................................ R.A. 772

Brent Johnson, N.J.'s Second Wave of COVID-19 Outbreak May Not

Peak Until Early Next Year, Health Official Says, NJ.COM

(Nov. 3, 2020) .................................................................................. R.A. 781

William Wan and Jacqueline Dupree, U.S. Hits Highest Daily Number of

Coronavirus Cases Since Pandemic Began,

WASH. POST. (Oct. 23, 2020) ........................................................... R.A. 786

R.A. xii

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-5

Page:

400

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 311/06/2020

of 31 PageID: 1969

EXHIBIT QQ

R.A. 400

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-5

Page:

401

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 411/06/2020

of 31 PageID: 1970

Evidence mounts that outside is safer when it comes to

COVID-19

thehill.com/policy/healthcare/496483-evidence-mounts-that-outside-is-safer-when-it-comes-to-covid-19

Peter Sullivan

May 6, 2020

By Peter Sullivan - 05/06/20 05:30 PM EDT

Health experts say people are significantly less likely to get the coronavirus while outside, a

fact that could add momentum to calls to reopen beaches and parks closed during the

COVID-19 pandemic.

Being outside shouldn’t be seen as completely safe, health experts say. People should

continue to avoid crowds and maintain six feet of distance from others to keep away from

the virus.

But experts are increasingly confident in evidence showing that the coronavirus spreads

much more readily indoors than outdoors, a finding that could help guide policymakers

seeking to figure out ways to end lockdowns that have shuttered much of the nation’s

economy.

“Parks, beaches — as long as they're not cheek to jowl, cycling, walking, this is good,” said

Tom Frieden, the former director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

“Enjoy nature. It’s good for us, and it has very low risk of spreading the virus.”

Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan (R) on Wednesday said coronavirus figures suggested the

state might be able to begin reopening next week. If it does, he said it would include

opening state parks and beaches and allowing outdoor gym classes and religious services.

“Studies suggest activities held outdoors as temperatures warm pose lower COVID risk

than those done in confined indoor spaces,” tweeted Scott Gottlieb, the former Food and

Drug Administration commissioner. “As we re-open, states should look to ease rules to

allow more recreational, religious, and business activities to occur outside.”

Some cities are already considering options that might help local businesses while keeping

people safe.

Hartford, Conn., is one of the cities exploring allowing restaurants to expand their outdoor

seating options into parking lots or other outdoor spaces.

Vilnius, the capital of Lithuania, has gone further by opening its central square and other

outdoor areas to restaurant seating.

“We need creative solutions, and I think things like closing down streets and having some

R.A. 401

1/3

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-5

Page:

402

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 511/06/2020

of 31 PageID: 1971

dispersed [seating] from restaurants is a nice creative solution,” said Eleanor Murray, a

professor at Boston University School of Public Health.

“We can’t continue this lockdown indefinitely,” she said. “It’s just not going to be

psychologically or economically feasible.”

Gottlieb pointed to a study, which has not yet been peer-reviewed, that examined

outbreaks in 320 Chinese cities outside Hubei province, where the coronavirus is believed

to have originated, between Jan. 4 and Feb. 11 and found only one outbreak that occurred

outdoors.

Experts warned that people are not completely safe outdoors and that it is important

to stay six feet away from people outside.

“You don’t want to be in a crowd, regardless of where that crowd is,” Murray said.

California Gov. Gavin NewsomGavin NewsomCalifornia coronavirus case count tops

600,000 California slams 'inaccurate and outdated beliefs' of parents suing to reopen

schools Bass on filling Harris's Senate spot: 'I'll keep all my options open' MORE

(D) ordered beaches in Orange County to close last week after they became packed with

people during a heat wave.

Murray said that even outside on the beach, people who do not live together should stay six

feet apart and that activities such as beach volleyball should be avoided because multiple

people touching the same equipment can spread the virus.

That means playgrounds also are a danger, she said.

“While it’s great to have parks and beaches, you probably don’t want playground

equipment open,” Murray said.

The virus is harder to transmit outdoors because the droplets that spread it are more easily

disturbed or dispersed outside in the elements than in a closed, confined, indoor setting.

“It definitely spreads more indoors than outdoors,” said Roger Shapiro, a professor at

Harvard University's T.H. Chan School of Public Health. “The virus droplets disperse so

rapidly in the wind that they become a nonfactor if you're not really very close to someone

outdoors — let’s say within six feet.”

As people go outside for their daily exercise and pass by one another, experts offered

reassurance that simply passing someone for a split second outdoors presents a low risk.

“The virus can’t magically teleport,” said Amesh Adalja, a senior scholar at the Johns

Hopkins University Center for Health Security. “It needs a cough or sneeze or something,

singing, talking, spitting. ... It’s not magnetism or something like that.”

R.A. 402

2/3

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-5

Page:

403

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 611/06/2020

of 31 PageID: 1972

Adalja said some of the decisions around activities such as sitting closer than six feet away

from a friend outside on the grass have to do with how much risk someone is personally

willing to accept.

“There’s not some kind of black or white answer to all of this stuff,” he said. “People are

going to have to make a lot of decisions about what risk tolerance they have.”

Indoor spaces such as barbershops are certainly higher risk, though. There are more

shared surfaces that could transmit the virus, such as the barber’s chair. Another danger,

especially in the summer, is air conditioning, which can circulate the virus through the air.

“If you're in an indoor space that has the air conditioning blasting ... that air conditioning

might be blowing the droplets straight at you,” said Murray, the Boston University

professor.

Even outdoors, Adalja said people should be mindful of keeping their distance and

washing their hands.

“You can go to the beach, you can go to the park, and it can be safe,” he said. “It’s just you

have to be cognizant of the fact that the virus is there.”

The Hill 1625 K Street, NW Suite 900 Washington DC 20006 | 202628-8500 tel | 202-628-8503 fax

The contents of this site are ©2020 Capitol Hill Publishing Corp., a

subsidiary of News Communications, Inc.

R.A. 403

3/3

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-5

Page:

404

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 711/06/2020

of 31 PageID: 1973

EXHIBIT RR

R.A. 404

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-5

Page:

405

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 811/06/2020

of 31 PageID: 1974

How Safe Are Outdoor Gatherings?

The New York Times

July 5, 2020 Sunday 18:52 EST

Copyright 2020 The New York Times Company All Rights Reserved

Section: WELL; live

Length: 1098 words

Byline: Tara Parker-Pope

Highlight: With the virus raging in many parts of the country, new

restrictions have left many wondering about the safety of a backyard

barbecue or picnic.

Body

With the virus raging in many parts of the country, new restrictions

have left many wondering about the safety of a backyard barbecue or

picnic.

Is it still safe to socialize outside?

As the coronavirus continues to rage throughout the country, public

health officials are telling us to stay home this holiday weekend.

Beaches in Texas, Florida and California are closed. And now some

recentbackyard gatherings are being blamed for new cases of Covid-19.

The new restrictions and outbreaks have led to new confusion about the

safety of socializing outdoors. But experts say the science hasn’t

changed: Your risk of catching the virus is much lower outdoors than

indoors. If you want to spend time with friends, taking the party

outside will reduce your risk of contracting Covid-19.

“Outside is definitely safer,” said Erin Bromage, a comparative

immunologist and biology professor at the University of Massachusetts,

Dartmouth. “But it’s the type of interactions you have when you’re

outside that are important.”

A Japanese study of 100 casesfound that the odds of catching the

coronavirus are nearly 20 times higher indoors than outdoors. Outdoor

gatherings lower risk because wind disperses viral droplets, and

sunlight can kill some of the virus. Open spaces prevent the virus from

building up in concentrated amounts and being inhaled, which can happen

R.A. 405

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-5

Page:

406

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 911/06/2020

of 31 PageID: 1975

How Safe Are Outdoor Gatherings?

indoors when infected people exhale in a confined space for long

stretches of time, said Dr. Julian W. Tang, a virologist at the

University of Leicester.

If you socialize outdoors, it’s important to keep the guest list small.

Socializing with just one additional household is safer than mixing

multiple households. Make sure that the rate of Covid-19 in your

community is low and falling. It’s safest to socialize when the test

positivity rate is at5 percent or lower — a level that reduces your

chances of inviting an infected person to the party.

Recent clusters of cases have been linked to home gatherings that

appear to have broken those rules. After an estimated 100 people

gathered for a party in Rockland County, N.Y., public health officials

tracked nine cases to the event. In Washington D.C., a June 18 backyard

fund-raiser with about two dozen guests made headlines when the host

and a few guests were reportedly diagnosed with Covid-19. In Texas, a

May 30 surprise party infected 18 family members.

But adding to the confusion about outdoor gatherings is the fact that

the continuing protests over police brutality and the killing of George

Floyd in Minneapolis have not been associated with spikes in cases. The

reason the protests haven’t caused a surge may be because protesters

were often moving, lowering the risk of spending extended time with an

infected person. Many marchers were also wearing masks.

“I can tell you from our own testing in Minnesota, which has been

substantial, we have seen no evidence of any kind of measurable impact

of protests on cases,” said Michael Osterholm, director of the Center

for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of

Minnesota. “There could have been cases, surely, but it was not a major

amplifying event.”

Julia Marcus, an infectious disease epidemiologist and assistant

professor in the department of population medicine at Harvard Medical

School, said the data collected from protesters so far, along with

studies

suggesting that outdoors is lower risk for transmission,

should reassure public health officials about the safety of masked

outdoor gatherings and prompt them to open beaches and public outdoor

spaces to help people gather more safely during the pandemic.

“Outdoors is what will save us,” Dr. Marcus said. “Why can’t the

message be: ‘We understand you want to get together with friends. There

are ways to do this safely.’ We’re just telling them not to gather.

That doesn’t recognize basic human behavior and basic human needs.”

A review of 7,000 cases in China documented only a single instance of

outdoor transmission — but it apparently occurred during a long

R.A. 406

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:10

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed407

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1976

How Safe Are Outdoor Gatherings?

conversation between two friends. One of them had just returned from

Wuhan, the center of the outbreak.

If you attend a social event and find yourself in close conversation

with someone from outside your household, even outdoors, wear a mask.

Keep music levels low so people don’t have to shout. (Loud speaking

expels more droplets than a quiet voice.) Don’t share food or serving

utensils.

“I think people hear that it’s outdoors and think everything is fine,”

said Linsey Marr, an engineering professor and aerosol scientist at

Virginia Tech. “But it should be outdoors with distancing. If you have

an outdoor gathering with a lot of people talking, you stand close.

It’s loud, so you talk louder.”

Limiting the number of partygoers not only lowers your risk of running

into someone who has the virus, but small numbers also make it easier

to keep track of just a few people and maintain physical distance, said

Dr. Asaf Bitton, executive director of Ariadne Labs at Brigham and

Women’s Hospital and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

Dr. Bitton notes that when a group gets larger, even outdoors, it can

affect our overall spatial awareness, including proprioception — which

is knowing where our body is in space without relying on visual cues.

Add in alcohol, and our ability to keep our distance falls short.

“We also know that alcohol or other drugs and medications can

significantly alter all senses, with a particularly large effect on

proprioception,” Dr. Bitton said.

Dr. Osterholm agreed that people should be aware of the effect alcohol

can have on efforts to keep a physical distance.

“One of the problems that happens with parties or events like this if

alcohol is involved, even the most well-meaning individual who is

trying to stay apart a certain number of feet, it’s an unnatural act,”

he said. “People do come together. That’s just human nature.”

Even though socializing outdoors is relatively safe, people need to

stay aware and vigilant. While it’s easy to keep your distance from

strangers, it’s tougher to stay six feet from people you know, Dr. Tang

said.

“It is different when you are interacting with people that you know. I

was chatting to my gardener outside earlier this week when I realized

that neither of us had masks on and we were getting too close,” Dr.

Tang said. “So whilst people can be more socially distanced when

outdoors, especially amongst strangers, with friends and family and

R.A. 407

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:11

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed408

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1977

How Safe Are Outdoor Gatherings?

once you start talking to someone at a garden party, people forget

themselves, and they get too close.”

PHOTO:

(PHOTOGRAPH BY Getty Images FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES)

Load-Date: July 14, 2020

End of Document

R.A. 408

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:12

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed409

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1978

EXHIBIT SS

R.A. 409

Are outdoor gatherings safe? Here's what experts say. | Advisory Board Daily Briefing

Page 1 of 4

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:13

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed410

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1979

https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2020/07/17/outdoor-gathering

R.A. 410

8/17/2020

Are outdoor gatherings safe? Here's what experts say. | Advisory Board Daily Briefing

Page 2 of 4

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:14

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed411

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1980

https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2020/07/17/outdoor-gathering

R.A. 411

8/17/2020

Are outdoor gatherings safe? Here's what experts say. | Advisory Board Daily Briefing

Page 3 of 4

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:15

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed412

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1981

https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2020/07/17/outdoor-gathering

R.A. 412

8/17/2020

Are outdoor gatherings safe? Here's what experts say. | Advisory Board Daily Briefing

Page 4 of 4

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:16

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed413

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1982

https://www.advisory.com/daily-briefing/2020/07/17/outdoor-gathering

R.A. 413

8/17/2020

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:17

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed414

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1983

EXHIBIT TT

R.A. 414

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:18

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed415

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1984

CDC calls on Americans to wear masks to prevent COVID-19

spread

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Documents and Publications

July 14, 2020

Copyright 2020 Federal Information and News Dispatch, Inc.

Section: PRESS RELEASE, MEDIA STATEMENTS, PUBLIC DOCUMENTS

Length: 982 words

Body

CDC calls on Americans to wear masks to prevent COVID-19 spread

JAMA editorial reviews latest science, while case study shows masks

prevented COVID spread

Tuesday, July 14, 2020

Contact: Media Relations (https://www.cdc.gov/media)

(404) 639-3286

Americans are increasingly adopting the use of cloth face masks to slow

the spread of COVID-19, and the latest science may convince even more

to do so.

In an editorial published today in the Journal of the American Medical

Association (JAMA), CDC reviewed the latest science and affirms that

cloth face coverings are a critical tool in the fight against COVID-19

that could reduce the spread of the disease, particularly when used

universally within communities. There is increasing evidence that cloth

face coverings help prevent people who have COVID-19 from spreading the

virus to others.

"We are not defenseless against COVID-19," said CDC Director Dr. Robert

R. Redfield. "Cloth face coverings are one of the most powerful weapons

we have to slow and stop the spread of the virus - particularly when

used universally within a community setting. All Americans have a

responsibility to protect themselves, their families, and their

communities."

This review included two case studies out today, one from JAMA, showing

that adherence to universal masking policies reduced SARS-CoV-2

transmission within a Boston hospital system, and one from CDC's

R.A. 415

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:19

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed416

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1985

CDC calls on Americans to wear masks to prevent COVID-19 spread

Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR), showing that wearing a

mask prevented the spread of infection from two hair stylists to their

customers in Missouri.

Additional data in today's MMWR showed that immediately after the White

House Coronavirus Task Force and CDC advised Americans to wear cloth

face coverings when leaving home, the proportion of U.S. adults who

chose to do so increased, with 3 in 4 reporting they had adopted the

recommendation in a national internet survey.

The results of the Missouri case study provide further evidence on the

benefits of wearing a cloth face covering. The investigation focused on

two hair stylists -- infected with and having symptoms of COVID-19 -whose salon policy followed a local ordinance requiring cloth face

coverings for all employees and patrons. The investigators found that

none of the stylists' 139 clients or secondary contacts became ill, and

all 67 clients who volunteered to be tested showed no sign of

infection.

The finding adds to a growing body of evidence that cloth face

coverings provide source control - that is, they help prevent the

person wearing the mask from spreading COVID-19 to others. The main

protection individuals gain from masking occurs when others in their

communities also wear face coverings.

COVID-19 prevention in a Missouri hair salon

When two stylists at a Missouri hair salon tested positive for the

virus that causes COVID-19, researchers from CoxHealth hospitals,

Washington University, the University of Kansas, and the SpringfieldGreene County Health Department worked together to trace contacts,

investigate the cases, and publish their findings in the MMWR.

One of the stylists developed respiratory symptoms but continued to see

clients for eight days. The other, who apparently became infected from

her co-worker, also developed respiratory symptoms and continued to see

clients for four days.

The salon in which they worked had a policy requiring both stylists and

their clients to wear face coverings, consistent with the local

government ordinance. Both stylists wore double-layered cloth face

coverings or surgical masks when seeing clients. The median appointment

time was 15 minutes and ranged from 15 to 45 minutes. More than 98% of

clients wore a face covering--47% wore cloth face coverings, 46% wore

surgical masks, and about 5% wore N-95 respirators.

When customers were asked whether they had been ill with any

respiratory symptoms in the 90 days preceding their appointment, 87

R.A. 416

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:20

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed417

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1986

CDC calls on Americans to wear masks to prevent COVID-19 spread

(84%) reported that they had not. None of the interviewed customers

developed symptoms of illness. Among 67 (48%) customers who volunteered

to be tested, all 67 tested negative for the virus that causes COVID19. Several family members of one of the stylist's subsequently

developed symptoms and received a diagnosis of COVID-19.

Survey: Acceptance of face-mask guidance increased

CDC analyzed data from an internet survey of a national sample of 503

adults during April 7-9 and found that about 62% said they would follow

the newly announced recommendations to wear a face mask when outside

the home. A repeat survey during May 11-13 showed that the percentage

of adults endorsing face mask wearing increased to more than 76%.

The increase was driven largely by a significant jump in approval by

white, non-Hispanic adults, from 54% to 75%. Approval among Black, nonHispanic adults went up from 74% to 82%, and remained stable among

Hispanic/Latino adults at 76% and 77%.

There was also a large increase in face-mask approval among respondents

in the Midwest, from 44% to 74%. Approval was greatest in the

Northeast, going from 77% to 87%.

Resources:

CDC's

Information

on

Cloth

Face

Coverings:

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-sick/diycloth-face-coverings.html

- CDC Editorial in JAMA: Brooks JT, Butler JC, Redfield RR. Time for

universal masking and prevention of transmission of SARS-CoV-2. JAMA.

Published

online

July

14,

2020.

doi:10.1001/jama.2020.13107

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/10.1001/jama.2020.131

07

- MMWR Article: No Transmission of Symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 After

Significant Exposure With Universal Face Mask Use at a Hair Salon Springfield,

Missouri,

May

2020

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6928e2.htm?s_cid=mm6928e2_w

MMWR Article: Factors Associated with Cloth Face Coverings Use during

the COVID-19 Pandemic -- United States, April and May 2020

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6928e3.htm?s_cid=mm6928e3_w

Page last reviewed: July 14, 2020

Load-Date: July 15, 2020

R.A. 417

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:21

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed418

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1987

CDC calls on Americans to wear masks to prevent COVID-19 spread

End of Document

R.A. 418

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:22

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed419

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1988

EXHIBIT UU

R.A. 419

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:23

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed420

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1989

Early View

Correspondence

Universal use of face masks for success against

COVID-19: evidence and implications for

prevention policies

Susanna Esposito, Nicola Principi, Chi Chi Leung, Giovanni Battista Migliori

Please cite this article as: Esposito S, Principi N, Leung CC, et al. Universal use of face masks

for success against COVID-19: evidence and implications for prevention policies. Eur Respir J

2020; in press (https://doi.org/10.1183/13993003.01260-2020).

This manuscript has recently been accepted for publication in the European Respiratory Journal. It is

published here in its accepted form prior to copyediting and typesetting by our production team. After

these production processes are complete and the authors have approved the resulting proofs, the article

will move to the latest issue of the ERJ online.

Copyright ©ERS 2020. This article is open access and distributed under the terms of the Creative

Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Licence 4.0.

R.A. 420

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:24

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed421

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1990

Universal use of face masks for success against COVID-19: evidence and implications

for prevention policies

Susanna Esposito1, Nicola Principi2, Chi Chi Leung3, Giovanni Battista Migliori4

1

Pediatric Clinic, Pietro Barilla Children‟s Hospital, University of Parma, Parma, Italy;

2

Università degli Studi di Milano, Milan, Italy

3

Hong Kong Tuberculosis, Chest and Heart Diseases Association, Hong Kong, China

4

Servizio di Epidemiologia Clinica delle Malattie Respiratorie, Istituti Clinici Scientifici

Maugeri IRCCS, Tradate, Italy.

Take home message (max 256 characters, including spaces): Cloth masks are a simple,

economic and sustainable alternative to surgical mask as a means of source control of SARSCoV-2 for general community.

Running title: Face masks for success against COVID-19.

Key-words: COVID-19; facial mask; surgical mask; prevention, airborne diseases

Address correspondence to: Susanna Esposito, Pietro Barilla Children‟s Hospital, Department

of Medicine and Surgery, University of Parma, Via Gramsci 14, 43126 Parma, Italy. Phone:

+39 0521 903524. E-mail: susanna.esposito@unimi.it

Text (word count): 837

R.A. 421

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:25

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed422

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1991

Dear Editor,

A hot debate is taking place on the use of face masks (including cloth and surgical) as

a prevention tool in the community vis-à-vis the recent World Health Organization (WHO)

recommendations. To shed light on this important topic we reviewed relevant literature

focused on the key words „infection control‟, „prevention‟, „masks‟, „respirators‟, „viral

infections‟ and „COVID-19‟ without time restrictions to identify a minimum set of references

from an electronic database (PUBMED), existing guidelines, viral diseases, airborne diseases,

and grey literature.

The core findings of the references identified are summarised in Table 1.

According to the WHO report from February 2020 (https://www.who.int/docs/defaultsource/coronaviruse/who-chinajoint-mission-on-covid-19-final-report.pdf.), the proportion of

truly asymptomatic carriers of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV2) infection was relatively small and not a major driver of virus circulation, infection

transmission, and new disease development. However, in blanket testing of an isolated

village of approximately 3,000 people in northern Italy, 50%-75% of people with positive

pharyngeal molecular tests were totally asymptomatic [1]. This finding was echoed by a more

recent daily surveillance report from China, where all people arriving from overseas were

rigorously tested [2]: among 166 persons with newly identified infections, 78% were

asymptomatic. Although the infective dose associated with transmission is not known, the

viral load in the respiratory tract in an asymptomatic patient has been reported to be similar to

patients with symptoms [3], and transmission of SARS-CoV-2 infection from an

asymptomatic contact has also been described [4].

Until some weeks ago, it was thought that the virus could be transmitted only by

droplets that are coughed or sneezed out or by contaminated fomites, with differences

according to the initial load and surface characteristics [5]. Airborne transmission of SARSCoV-2 was considered possible only when care procedures generating aerosols (e.g.

intubation, bronchoscopy, and positive-pressure ventilation) are performed [6]. However,

other studies seem to indicate the opposite, i.e., the virus can be present in exhaled air

produced by talking and breathing [6]. Moreover, a potential role of aerosols in virus

diffusion was evident in a complex laboratory study. Aerosols containing a viral load quite

similar to that observed in human respiratory samples were created to generate an aerosolized

environment. SARS-CoV-2 was detected up to 3 hours after the start of the study [7].

Although these findings were not considered fully convincing by some authors [5], they

R.A. 422

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:26

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed423

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1992

deserve attention and require further studies to establish whether and when airborne

transmission of SARS-CoV-2 truly occurs and how it can be reduced.

It is well known that surgical masks can prevent the inhalation of large droplets and

sprays but have limited ability to filter submicron-sized airborne particles [8,9]. As SARSCoV-2 is also embedded in aerosols <5 μm in diameter, it cannot be determined whether

they are always effective. However, mask wearing by patients with pulmonary tuberculosis

(an airborne infectious disease) has been shown to reduce infectivity to guinea pigs by 56%

[9,10]. The surgical mask has also been shown to intercept other human coronaviruses during

coughing [11]. A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials also showed that surgical

masks and N95 respirators were similarly effective in preventing influenza-like illness and

laboratory-confirmed influenza among healthcare workers [12]. Similar results were obtained

in a case-control study comparing the protective effect of surgical masks and N95 respirators

against SARS among healthcare workers in five Hong Kong hospitals [13].

Controlling a respiratory infection at source by a face mask is a well-established

strategy. For example, symptomatic patients with cough or sneezing are generally advised to

put on a face mask, and this applies equally to patients with pulmonary tuberculosis (airborne

transmission) and influenza (predominantly droplet-transmitted). With the large number of

asymptomatic patients unware of their own infection [1,2], the comparable viral load in their

upper respiratory tract [3], droplet and aerosol dispersion even during talking and breathing

[6], and prolonged viral viability outside our body [7], we strongly advocate universal use of

face mask as a means of source control in public places during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Extreme forms of social distancing is not sustainable, and complete lockdown of cities or

even whole countries is extremely devastating to the economy. Universal masking in public

complements social distancing and hand hygiene in containing or slowing down the

otherwise exponential growth of the pandemic. Universal masking protects against crosstransmission through unavoidable person-to-person contact during the lockdown and reduces

the risk for resurgence during relaxation of social distancing measures on reopening.

A high degree of compliance will maximize the impact of universal masking in

public. The global shortage of surgical masks and N95 respirators is a serious concern. In line

with the recent recommedation by US CDC for healthy people to wear a cloth face cover in

public [14], we strongly support the use of cloth masks as a simple, economic and sustainable

alternative to surgical mask as a means of source control for general community use, so that

disposable surgical masks and N95 respirators can be reserved for use in health care facilities.

Such intervention is likely to be life-saving in many resource limited settings.

R.A. 423

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:27

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed424

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1993

Author contributions

S.E. and N.P. co-wrote the manuscript. GBM and CCL wrote sections of the

manuscript, edited the text for major intellectual components and designed the Table. All

authors approved the text.

Conflict of interest

Authors declare no competing interests.

Acknowledgements

The article is part of the activities of WAidid (World Association for Infectious Diseases and

Immunological Disorders), the Global Tuberculosis Network (GTN) and the WHO Collaborating

Centre for Tuberculosis and Lung Diseases, Tradate, ITA-80, 2017-2020- GBM/RC/LDA.).

R.A. 424

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:28

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed425

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1994

Table 1. Main studies on severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV2) transmission.

Authors

Setting

Study

Main findings and comments

Day M. BMJ

2020;368:m1165.

[1]

Vo‟

Euganeo,

Italy

RNA testing of the

entire village

population (3,000

inhabitants)

Day M. BMJ

2020;

369:m1375. [2]

China

Screening on overseas

arrivals

Zou L et al. N

Engl J Med 2020;

382: 1177–79. [3]

Zhuhai,

Guangdong,

China

Rhote C. et al. N

Engl J Med

2020;382:970971. [4]

World Health

Organization.

Modes of

transmission of

virus causing

COVID-19:

implications for

IPC precaution

recommendations

. [5]

Lewis D. Is the

coronavirus

airborne? Experts

can‟t agree.

Nature 2020. [6]

van Doremalen

N. et al. N Engl J

Med 2020. [7]

Munich,

Germany

Monitoring SARSCoV-2 viral loads in

upper respiratory

specimens of 18

patients

Report of transmission

of COVID-19 from an

asymptomatic

individual to 4 contacts

Precaution

recommendations

50-75% of infected individuals asymptomatic,

representing “a formidable source” of

contagion. Isolation of asymptomatic

individuals essential for controlling virus spread

and epidemic seriousness

130 of 166 new infections (78%) identified in

the 24 hours to the afternoon of Wednesday 1

April 2020 were asymptomatic. Asymptomatic

infections would not be able to cause another

major outbreak of COVID-19 if such

individuals were kept in isolation.

Higher viral loads were detected soon after

symptom onset and viral load in an

asymptomatic patient was similar to that in the

symptomatic patients.

University of

Maryland.

ScienceDaily, 3

April 2020. [8]

Migliori GB, et

al. Eur Respir J

2019; 53(6). [9]

USA

Global

USA

Europe

The fact that asymptomatic persons are potential

sources of COVID-19 infection may warrant a

reassessment of transmission dynamics of the

current outbreak.

The routes of COVID-19 transmission are via

droplet, fomites and airborne transmission of

droplet nuclei (<5µm), with less evidence for

intestine transmission. WHO continues to

recommend droplet and contact precautions and

not airborne precautions.

Reporting of different

viewpoints

Arguments in favour and against airborne

transmission and related prevention are

discussed.

Stability of SARSCoV-2 and

SARS-CoV-1 in

aerosols and on various

surfaces was evaluated

and their decay rates

estimated using a

Bayesian regression

model

Aerosol and fomite transmission of

SARS-CoV-2 is plausible, since the virus can

remain viable and infectious in aerosols for

hours and on surfaces up to days.

WHO Consensus

document

R.A. 425

Wearing surgical masks in public could help

slow COVID-19 pandemic's advance: masks

may limit the spread diseases including

influenza, rhinoviruses and coronaviruses.

The core components of infection control are

discussed, together with precautions to prevent

unnecessary admissions, with focus on

tuberculosis. The importance of personal

protection (respirators to protect health care

staff, other patients and visitors and surgical

masks for infectious patients) is discussed.

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:29

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed426

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1995

Dharmadhikari

AS. et al. Am J

Respir Crit Care

Med 2012;

185(10): 1104–

1109. [10]

South Africa

17 MDR-TB patients

wore face masks on

alternate days. Ward air

was exhausted to two

identical chambers,

each housing 90 guinea

pigs breathing ward air

either when patients

wore surgical face

masks (intervention

group) or when patients

did not wear masks

(control group).

Sixty-nine of 90 control guinea pigs (76.6%)

became infected, compared with 36 of 90

intervention guinea pigs (40%) representing a

56% (95% CI, 33–70.5%) decreased risk of TB

transmission when patients used masks.

Surgical face masks on patients with MDR-TB

significantly reduced transmission and offer an

adjunct measure for reducing TB transmission

from infectious patients.

Leung NHL et al.

Nature Medicine

2020.

[11]

Hong Kong

246 patients were studied. Surgical face masks

significantly reduced detection of influenza

virus RNA in respiratory droplets and

coronavirus RNA in aerosols, with a trend

toward reduced detection of coronavirus RNA

in respiratory droplets. The results indicate that

surgical face masks could prevent transmission

of human coronaviruses and influenza viruses

from symptomatic individuals.

Long Y. J Evid

Based Med 2020.

[12]

China

Seto WH. Lancet

2003;361:15191520. [13]

Hong Kong

Quantification of the

amount of respiratory

virus in exhaled breath

of participants with

medically attended

ARIs and

determination of the

potential efficacy of

surgical face masks to

prevent respiratory

virus transmission

Systematic Review and

meta-analysis on the

effectiveness of N95

respirators versus

surgical

masks to prevent

influenza

Case-control study in 5

hospitals

Centers for

Disease Control

and Prevention.

Coronavirus

Disease 2019

(COVID-19).

How to Protect

Yourself &

Others.[14]

USA

Guidance to the public

R.A. 426

The use of N95 respirators compared with

surgical masks is not associated with a lower

risk of laboratory-confirmed influenza. It

suggests that N95 respirators should not be

recommended for general public and non highrisk medical staff those are not in close contact

with influenza patients or suspected patients.

241 non-infected and 13 infected staff were

surveyed about use of mask, gloves, gowns, and

hand-washing.

69 staff reporting use of all four measures were

not infected, while all infected staff omitted at

least one

measure (p=0.0224). Fewer staff who wore

masks (p=0.0001), gowns (p=0.006), and

washed their hands (p=0.047) were infected

compared with those who did not; stepwise

logistic regression was significant only for

masks (p=0.011). Practice of droplets

precaution and contact precaution is adequate in

significantly reducing the risk of infection after

exposures to patients with SARS. The protective

role of masks suggests

that in hospitals, infection is transmitted by

droplets.

Core recommendations are: 1. Clean your hands

often; 2. Avoid close contact; 3. Cover your

mouth and nose with a cloth cover when around

others; 4. Cover cough and sneezes; 5. Clean

and disinfect.

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:30

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed427

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1996

References

1.

Day M. Covid-19: identifying and isolating asymptomatic people helped eliminate

virus in Italian village. BMJ 2020;368:m1165.

2.

Day M. Covid-19: four fifths of cases are asymptomatic, China figures indicate. BMJ.

2020; 369:m1375.

3.

Zou L, Ruan F, Huang M, et al. SARS-CoV-2 viral load in upper respiratory

specimens of infected patients. N Engl J Med 2020; 382: 1177–79.

4.

Rothe C, Schunk M, Sothmann P, Bretzel G, Froeschl G, Wallrauch C, Zimmer T,

Thiel V, Janke C. Transmission of 2019-nCoV Infection from an Asymptomatic

Contact in Germany. N Engl J Med. 2020;382:970-971.

5.

World Health Organization. Modes of transmission of virus causing COVID-19:

implications for IPC precaution recommendations. https://www.who.int/newsroom/commentaries/detail/modes-of-transmission-of-virus-causing-covid-19implications-for-ipc-precaution-recommendations Accessed on: April 3, 2020.

6.

Lewis

D.

Is

the

coronavirus

airborne?

Experts

can‟t

agree.

Nature

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-00974-w. Accessed on: April 3, 2020.

7.

van Doremalen N, Bushmaker T, Morris DH, Holbrook MG, Gamble A, Williamson

BN, et al. Aerosol and Surface Stability of SARS-CoV-2 as Compared with SARSCoV-1 N Engl J Med. 2020; Epub Mar 17. doi: 10.1056/NEJMc2004973.

8.

University of Maryland. "Wearing surgical masks in public could help slow COVID19 pandemic's advance: Masks may limit the spread diseases including influenza,

rhinoviruses

and

coronaviruses."

ScienceDaily.

3

April

2020.

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/04/200403132345.htm. Accessed on: April 3,

2020.

9.

Migliori GB, Nardell E, Yedilbayev A, et al. Reducing tuberculosis transmission: a

consensus document from the World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe.

Eur Respir J 2019; 53(6).

10. Dharmadhikari AS, Mphahlele M, Stoltz A, et al. Surgical face masks worn by

patients with multidrug-resistant tuberculosis: impact on infectivity of air on a

hospital ward. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2012; 185(10): 1104–1109.

11. Leung NHL, Chu DKW, Shiu EYC, Chan KH, McDevitt JJ, Hau BJP, et al.

Respiratory virus shedding in exhaled breath and efficacy of face masks. Nature

Medicine 2020; doi: 10.1038/s41591-020-0843-2

R.A. 427

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-5Page:

Date Page

Filed:31

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed428

08/17/20

of 31 PageID: 1997

12. Long Y, Hu T, Liu L, Chen R, Guo Q, Yang L, et al. Effectiveness of N95 respirators

versus surgical masks against influenza: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J

Evid Based Med. 2020; Epub Mar 13. doi: 10.1111/jebm.12381.

13. Seto WH, Tsang D, Yung RW, Ching TY, Ng TK, Ho M, et al. Effectiveness of

precautions against droplets and contact in prevention of nosocomial transmission of

severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS). Lancet. 2003;361:1519-1520.

14. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19).

How

to

Protect

Yourself

&

Others

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-

ncov/prevent-getting-sick/prevention.html. Accessed on: April 3, 2020.

R.A. 428

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

429

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 111/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 1998

EXHIBIT VV

R.A. 429

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

430

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 211/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 1999

Letters

reduction strategy involving systematic testing of symptomatic

HCWs and universal masking of all HCWs and patients with surgical masks.4 This study assessed the association of hospital masking policies with the SARS-CoV-2 infection rate among HCWs.

RESEARCH LETTER

Association Between Universal Masking

in a Health Care System and SARS-CoV-2 Positivity

Among Health Care Workers

The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, caused by

severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2),

has severely affected health care workers (HCWs).1 As a result, hospital systems began testing

HCWs2 and implementing inEditorial

fection control measures to

mitigate workforce depletion and prevent disease spread.3 Mass

General Brigham (MGB) is the largest health care system in

Massachusetts, with 12 hospitals and more than 75 000 employees. In March 2020, MGB implemented a multipronged infection

Methods | The institutional review board of MGB approved the

study and waived informed consent. Using electronic medical

records, we identified HCWs providing direct and indirect patient care who were tested for SARS-CoV-2 with reverse transcriptase–polymerase chain reaction between March 1 and April

30, 2020. The primary criterion for testing HCWs in our health

care system was having symptoms consistent with SARSCoV-2 infection. Information on the job description of each HCW

was obtained by linking their record to the MGB Occupational

Health Services and Human Resources databases.

Figure. Temporal Trend in Percentage Positivity of SARS-CoV-2 Testing Among HCWs

No. of HCWs tested per day

<20

20-100

101-200

>200

SARS-Cov-2 positivity rate in MGB HCWs, %

35

Universal

masking

for HCWs

30

Universal

masking

for patients

25

20

15

10

5

P <.001

0

March

6

March

10

March

16

March

25

April

6

April

11

April

29

Date (2020)

March 10: Massachusetts declares state of emergency

Interventions

in

Massachusetts

March 16: Massachusetts closes schools

March 17: Massachusetts reduces public transportation

March 24: Massachusetts issues stay-at-home orders for nonessential workers

March 12: MGB restricts visitors

March 14: MGB restricts elective procedures

Interventions

at MGB

March 16: MGB restricts all business travel and limits on-site working

March 25: MGB universal masking of HCWs

April 6: MGB universal masking of patients

HCW indicates health care worker; MGB, Mass General Brigham; SARS-CoV-2,

severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2. All dates given are for the year

2020. The size of each data marker is proportional to the total number of

SARS-CoV-2 tests performed each day over the time of the study period (x-axis),

while the position of each data marker along the y-axis shows the percentage of

daily test results that were positive among HCWs. The horizontal bars below the

x-axis represent the timing of key interventions implemented in the state of

Massachusetts and at MGB. The dotted lines represent the implementation dates

of hospital policies. The study period is divided into 3 phases: a preintervention

period before implementation of universal masking of HCWs (pink), which includes

March 26, the day after implementation of universal masking for HCWs, to account

for HCWs who became symptomatic after business hours on March 25 and were

tested on March 26; a transition period until implementation of universal masking

of patients (purple) plus an additional lag period (yellow); and the intervention

period (green). For the preintervention and intervention periods, daily tests were

fitted by weighted nonlinear regression (curves). The change in overall slope was

compared between the 2 curves to determine any statistically significant changes

in trend (as shown by the P value).

jama.com

(Reprinted) JAMA Published online July 14, 2020

© 2020 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by Bryan Edward Lucas on 08/17/2020

R.A. 430

E1

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

431

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 311/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 2000

Letters

We identified 3 phases during the study period: a preintervention period before implementation of universal masking of

HCWs (March 1-24, 2020); a transition period until implementation of universal masking of patients (March 25–April 5, 2020)

plus an additional lag period to allow for manifestations of symptoms (April 6-10, 2020), as previously defined5; and an intervention period (April 11-30, 2020). Positivity rates included the

first positive test result for all HCWs in the numerator and HCWs

who never tested positive plus those who tested positive that

day in the denominator. For each HCW, any tests subsequent

to their first positive test result were excluded. Using weighted

nonlinear regression, we fit the best curve for the preintervention and intervention periods (based on R2 value). The number of daily tests was used as the weight such that days with more

tests had more weight in determining the curve. The overall

slope of each period was calculated using linear regression to

estimate the mean trend, regardless of curve shape. The change

in overall slope between the preintervention and intervention

periods was compared to determine any statistically significant change in mean trend, using a 2-sided α = .05. The analysis was conducted using R version 4.0 (R Foundation).

Results | Of 9850 tested HCWs, 1271 (12.9%) had positive results for SARS-CoV-2 (median age, 39 years; 73% female; 7.4%

physicians or trainees, 26.5% nurses or physician assistants,

17.8% technologists or nursing support, and 48.3% other). During the preintervention period, the SARS-CoV-2 positivity rate

increased exponentially from 0% to 21.32%, with a weighted

mean increase of 1.16% per day and a case doubling time of 3.6

days (95% CI, 3.0-4.5 days). During the intervention period,

the positivity rate decreased linearly from 14.65% to 11.46%,

with a weighted mean decline of 0.49% per day and a net slope

change of 1.65% (95% CI, 1.13%-2.15%; P < .001) more decline

per day compared with the preintervention period (Figure).

Discussion | Universal masking at MGB was associated with a significantly lower rate of SARS-CoV-2 positivity among HCWs. This

association may be related to a decrease in transmission between

patients and HCWs and among HCWs. The decrease in HCW infections could be confounded by other interventions inside and

outside of the health care system (Figure), such as restrictions

on elective procedures, social distancing measures, and increased

masking in public spaces, which are limitations of this study. Despite these local and statewide measures, the case number continued to increase in Massachusetts throughout the study

period,6 suggesting that the decrease in the SARS-CoV-2 positivity rate in MGB HCWs took place before the decrease in the general public. Randomized trials of universal masking of HCWs during a pandemic are likely not feasible. Nonetheless, these results

support universal masking as part of a multipronged infection

reduction strategy in health care settings.

Corresponding Author: Deepak L. Bhatt, MD, MPH, Brigham and Women’s

Hospital, 75 Francis St, Boston, MA 02115 (dlbhattmd@post.harvard.edu).

Accepted for Publication: July 1, 2020.

Published Online: July 14, 2020. doi:10.1001/jama.2020.12897

Author Contributions: Dr Bhatt had full access to all of the data in the study

and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data

analysis. Drs Wang and Ferro contributed equally to this article.

Concept and design: Wang, Ferro, Hashimoto, Bhatt.

Acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data: All authors.

Drafting of the manuscript: Wang, Ferro.

Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: All authors.

Statistical analysis: Wang, Zhou.

Administrative, technical, or material support: Wang, Ferro, Hashimoto.

Supervision: Hashimoto, Bhatt.

Conflict of Interest Disclosures: Dr Bhatt discloses the following

relationships: advisory board: Cardax, CellProthera, Cereno Scientific,

Elsevier Practice Update Cardiology, Level Ex, Medscape Cardiology,

PhaseBio, PLx Pharma, Regado Biosciences; board of directors:

Boston VA Research Institute, Society of Cardiovascular Patient Care,

TobeSoft; chair: American Heart Association Quality Oversight Committee,

NCDR-ACTION Registry Steering Committee, VA CART Research and

Publications Committee; data monitoring committees: Baim Institute for Clinical

Research, Cleveland Clinic, Contego Medical, Duke Clinical Research Institute,

Mayo Clinic, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, Population Health Research

Institute; honoraria: American College of Cardiology, Baim Institute for Clinical

Research, Belvoir Publications, Duke Clinical Research Institute, HMP Global,

Journal of the American College of Cardiology, K2P, Level Ex, Medtelligence/

ReachMD, MJH Life Sciences, Population Health Research Institute, Slack

Publications, Society of Cardiovascular Patient Care, WebMD; deputy

editorship: Clinical Cardiology; research funding: Abbott, Afimmune, Amarin,

Amgen, AstraZeneca, Bayer, Boehringer Ingelheim, Bristol-Myers Squibb,

Cardax, Chiesi, CSL Behring, Eisai, Ethicon, Ferring Pharmaceuticals, Forest

Laboratories, Fractyl, Idorsia, Ironwood, Ischemix, Lexicon, Lilly, Medtronic,

Pfizer, PhaseBio, PLx Pharma, Regeneron, Roche, Sanofi Aventis, Synaptic, The

Medicines Company; royalties: Elsevier; site coinvestigator: Biotronik, Boston

Scientific, CSI, St Jude Medical, Svelte; trustee: American College of Cardiology;

unfunded research: FlowCo, Merck, Novo Nordisk, Takeda. No other disclosures

were reported.

Additional Contributions: We thank Stacey A. Duey, MT(ASCP), MCHP, Mass

General Brigham, for assistance in extracting data from the Research Patient

Data Registry, and Karen Hopcia, ScD, ANP-BC, Mass General Brigham, for

assistance in extracting data from Occupational Health Services. No

compensation was received for their roles.

1. Adams JG, Walls RM. Supporting the health care workforce during the

COVID-19 global epidemic. JAMA. 2020;323(15):1439-1440. doi:10.1001/jama.

2020.3972

2. Hunter E, Price DA, Murphy E, et al. First experience of COVID-19 screening

of health-care workers in England. Lancet. 2020;395(10234):e77-e78. doi:10.

1016/S0140-6736(20)30970-3

3. Black JRM, Bailey C, Przewrocka J, Dijkstra KK, Swanton C.

COVID-19: the case for health-care worker screening to prevent hospital

transmission. Lancet. 2020;395(10234):1418-1420. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736

(20)30917-X

4. Klompas M, Morris CA, Sinclair J, Pearson M, Shenoy ES. Universal masking

in hospitals in the Covid-19 era. N Engl J Med. 2020;382(21):e63. doi:10.1056/

NEJMp2006372

5. Sen S, Karaca-Mandic P, Georgiou A. Association of stay-at-home orders with

COVID-19 hospitalizations in 4 states. JAMA. 2020;323(24):2522-2524. doi:10.

1001/jama.2020.9176

Xiaowen Wang, MD

Enrico G. Ferro, MD

Guohai Zhou, PhD

Dean Hashimoto, MD, JD

Deepak L. Bhatt, MD, MPH

E2

Author Affiliations: Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Brigham and Women’s

Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts (Wang, Bhatt); Department of Medicine,

Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts (Ferro); Center for

Clinical Investigation, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts

(Zhou); Occupational Health Services, Mass General Brigham, Boston,

Massachusetts (Hashimoto).

6. Massachusetts Department of Public Health COVID-19 dashboard—April 30,

2020. Accessed June 27, 2020. https://www.mass.gov/doc/covid-19dashboard-april-30-2020/download

JAMA Published online July 14, 2020 (Reprinted)

jama.com

© 2020 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.

Downloaded From: https://jamanetwork.com/ by Bryan Edward Lucas on 08/17/2020

R.A. 431

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

432

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 411/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 2001

EXHIBIT WW

R.A. 432

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

433

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 511/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 2002

Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report

Absence of Apparent Transmission of SARS-CoV-2 from Two Stylists After

Exposure at a Hair Salon with a Universal Face Covering Policy —

Springfield, Missouri, May 2020

M. Joshua Hendrix, MD1; Charles Walde, MD2; Kendra Findley, MS3; Robin Trotman, DO4

On July 14, 2020, this report was posted as an MMWR Early

Release on the MMWR website (https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr).

On May 12, 2020 (day 0), a hair stylist at salon A in

Springfield, Missouri (stylist A), developed respiratory symptoms

and continued working with clients until day 8, when the stylist

received a positive test result for SARS-CoV-2, the virus that

causes coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). A second hair

stylist (stylist B), who had been exposed to stylist A, developed

respiratory symptoms on May 15, 2020 (day 3), and worked

with clients at salon A until day 8 before seeking testing for

SARS-CoV-2, which returned a positive result on day 10.

A total of 139 clients were directly serviced by stylists A and B

from the time they developed symptoms until they took leave

from work. Stylists A and B and the 139 clients followed the

City of Springfield ordinance* and salon A policy recommending the use of face coverings (i.e., surgical masks, N95

respirators,† or cloth face coverings) for both stylists and clients

during their interactions. Other stylists at salon A who worked

closely with stylists A and B were identified, quarantined, and

monitored daily for 14 days after their last exposure to stylists A

or B. None of these stylists reported COVID-19 symptoms.

After stylist B received a positive test result on day 10, salon A

closed for 3 days to disinfect frequently touched and contaminated areas. After public health contact tracings and 2 weeks

of follow-up, no COVID-19 symptoms were identified among

the 139 exposed clients or their secondary contacts. The

citywide ordinance and company policy might have played

a role in preventing spread of SARS-CoV-2 during these

exposures. These findings support the role of source control

in preventing transmission and can inform the development

of public health policy during the COVID-19 pandemic. As

stay-at-home orders are lifted, professional and social interactions

in the community will present more opportunities for spread of

SARS-CoV-2. Broader implementation of masking policies could

mitigate the spread of infection in the general population.

Stylist A worked from day 0 to day 8 with COVID-19

symptoms before receiving a diagnosis of COVID-19 by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing. Although self-isolation

* Springfield, Missouri, city ordinance went into effect May 6, 2020, restricted

seating in waiting areas to 25% of normal capacity and recommended social

distancing and use of face coverings for employees and clients when social

distancing was not or could not be followed. https://www.springfieldmo.

gov/5140/Masks-and-Face-Coverings.

† Particulate-filtering facepiece respirators that filter ≥95% of airborne particles

(https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/topics/respirators/disp_part/n95list1.html).

930

MMWR / July 17, 2020 / Vol. 69 / No. 28

was recommended after testing on day 6, stylist A continued

to work until the test returned a positive result, at which time

stylist A was excluded from work by salon A. On day 3, after

working with stylist A, stylist B developed respiratory symptoms. During Stylist A’s symptomatic period, the two stylists

interacted while neither was masked during intervals between

clients. Stylist B worked from day 3 to day 8 while symptomatic

before self-isolating and seeking PCR testing, which returned

a positive result for SARS-CoV-2 on day 10. Stylist A worked

with clients for 8 days while symptomatic, as did stylist B for

5 days. During all interactions with clients at salon A, stylist A

wore a double-layered cotton face covering, and stylist B wore

a double-layered cotton face covering or a surgical mask.

The Greene County Health Department (Missouri) conducted contact tracing for all 139 exposed clients back to the

dates that stylists A and B first developed symptoms. The 139

clients were monitored after their last exposure at salon A. Clients

were asked to self-quarantine for 14 days and were called or

sent daily text messages to inquire about any symptoms; none

reported signs or symptoms of COVID-19. Testing was offered

to all clients 5 days after exposure, or as soon as possible for

those exposed >5 days before contact tracing began. Overall,

67 (48.2%) clients volunteered to be tested, and 72 (51.8%)

refused; all 67 nasopharyngeal swab specimens tested negative

for SARS-CoV-2 by PCR. Telephone interviews were attempted

1 month after initial contact tracings to collect supplementary

information. Among the 139 exposed clients, the Greene County

Health Department interviewed 104 (74.8%) persons.

Among the 139 clients, the mean age was 52 years

(range = 21–93 years); 79 clients (56.8%) were male (Table 1).

Salon appointments ranged from 15 to 45 minutes in length

(median = 15 minutes; mean = 19.5 minutes). Among the 104

interviewed clients, 102 (98.1%) reported wearing face coverings for their entire appointment, and two (1.9%) reported

wearing face coverings part of the time (Table 2). Types of

face covering used by clients varied; 49 (47.1%) wore cloth face

coverings, 48 (46.1%) wore surgical masks, five (4.8%) wore

N95 respirators, and two (1.9%) did not know what kind of face

covering they wore. Overall, 101 (97.1%) interviewed clients

reported that their stylist wore a face covering for the entire

appointment; three did not know. When asked about the type of

face coverings worn by the stylists, 64 (61.5%) reported that their

stylist wore a cloth face covering (39; 37.5%) or surgical mask

US Department of Health and Human Services/Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

R.A. 433

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

434

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 611/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 2003

Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report

TABLE 1. Characteristics* of clients (N = 139) who visited hair salon A

and were exposed to stylists A and B with COVID-19 —Springfield,

Missouri, May 2020

Summary

What is already known about this topic?

Characteristic

Consistent and correct use of cloth face coverings

is recommended to reduce the spread of SARS-CoV-2.

Demographic characteristic

Male, no. (%)

Age, yrs. mean (range)

Encounter information

Appointment date range

Exposure to stylist A, no. (%)

Exposure to stylist B, no. (%)

Appointment duration, mins, median (range)

Client testing

Clients tested, no. (%)

Negative tests, no. (%)§

What is added by this report?

Among 139 clients exposed to two symptomatic hair stylists

with confirmed COVID-19 while both the stylists and the

clients wore face masks, no symptomatic secondary cases were

reported; among 67 clients tested for SARS-CoV-2, all test

results were negative. Adherence to the community’s and

company’s face-covering policy likely mitigated spread of

SARS-CoV-2.

What are the implications for public health practice?

Value

79 (56.8)

52 (21–93)

May 12–20 (days 0–8†)

84 (60.4)

55 (39.6)

15 (15–45)

67 (48.2)

67 (100)

Abbreviation: COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019.

* All interviews were conducted via telephone by the Greene County Health

Department.

† After onset of symptoms in stylist A.

§ Among those tested.

As stay-at-home orders are lifted, professional and social

interactions in the community will present more opportunities

for spread of SARS-CoV-2. Broader implementation of face

covering policies could mitigate the spread of infection in the

general population.

(25; 24.0%); 40 (38.5%) clients did not know or remember the

type of face covering worn by stylists. When asked whether they

had experienced respiratory symptoms in the 90 days preceding

their appointment, 87 (83.7%) clients reported that they had

not. Of those who did report previous symptoms, none reported

testing for or diagnosis of COVID-19.

Six close contacts of stylists A and B outside of salon A were

identified: four of stylist A and two of stylist B. All four of

stylist A’s contacts later developed symptoms and had positive PCR test results for SARS-CoV-2. These contacts were

stylist A’s cohabitating husband and her daughter, son-in-law,

and their roommate, all of whom lived together in another

household. None of stylist B’s contacts became symptomatic.

Discussion

SARS-CoV-2 is spread mainly between persons in close proximity to one another (i.e., within 6 feet), and the more closely

a person interacts with an infected person and the longer the

interaction, the higher the risk for transmission (1). At salon A

in Springfield, Missouri, two stylists with COVID-19 symptoms

worked closely with 139 clients before receiving diagnoses of

COVID-19, and none of their clients developed COVID-19

symptoms. Both stylists A and B, and 98% of the interviewed

clients followed posted company policy and the Springfield city

ordinance requiring face coverings by employees and clients in

businesses providing personal care services. The citywide ordinance

reduced maximum building waiting area seating to 25% of normal

capacity and recommended the use of face coverings at indoor and

outdoor public places where physical distancing was not possible.

Both company and city policies were likely important factors in

preventing the spread of SARS-CoV-2 during these interactions

between clients and stylists. These results support the use of face

coverings in places open to the public, especially when social

distancing is not possible, to reduce spread of SARS-CoV-2.

Although SARS-CoV-2 is spread largely through respiratory

droplets when an ill person coughs or sneezes (1), data suggest that

viral shedding starts during the 2-to-3-day period before symptom

onset, when viral loads are at their highest (2). Although the rate

of transmission of SARS-CoV-2 from presymptomatic patients

(those who have not yet developed symptoms) and asymptomatic

persons (those who do not develop symptoms) is unclear, these

persons likely contribute to the spread of SARS-CoV-2 (3). With

the potential for presymptomatic and asymptomatic transmission,

widespread adoption of policies requiring face coverings in public

settings should be considered to reduce the impact and magnitude

of additional waves of COVID-19.

Previous studies show that both surgical masks and homemade

cloth face coverings can reduce the aerosolization of virus into the

air and onto surfaces (4,5). Although no studies have examined

SARS-CoV-2 transmission directly, data from previous epidemics (6,7) support the use of universal face coverings as a policy to

reduce the spread of SARS-CoV-2, as does observational data for

COVID-19 in an analysis of 194 countries that found a negative

association between duration of a face mask or respirator policy

and per-capita coronavirus-related mortality; in countries that

did not recommend face masks and respirators, the per-capita

coronavirus-related mortality increased each week by 54.3%

after the index case, compared with 8.0% in those countries

with masking policies (CT Leffler, Virginia Commonwealth

University, unpublished data, 2020).§ Similar outcomes have

been observed for other respiratory virus outbreaks, including

the 2002–04 outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome

§ https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.05.22.20109231.

US Department of Health and Human Services/Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

R.A. 434

MMWR / July 17, 2020 / Vol. 69 / No. 28

931

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

435

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 711/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 2004

Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report

TABLE 2. Hair salon clients’ (N = 104) responses to interview

questions* about their interactions with two stylists with COVID-19

during salon appointments — Springfield, Missouri, May 12–20, 2020

Interview question

Did you wear a face

covering?

What type of

face covering did

you wear?

Did the stylist wear

a face covering?

What type of

face covering did

the stylist wear?

Did you have a

respiratory illness in

the past 90 days?

Response

Yes, for the entire appointment

Yes, for part of the appointment

No, not at all

Did not know

Cloth face covering

Surgical mask

N95 respirator†

Did not know

Did not answer question

Yes, for the entire appointment

Yes, for part of the appointment

No, not at all

Did not know

Cloth face covering

Surgical mask

N95 respirator

Did not know

Did not answer question

Yes

No

Did not know

Did not answer the question

No. (%)

102 (98.1)

2 (1.9)

0 (—)

0 (—)

49 (47.1)

48 (46.1)

5 (4.8)

2 (1.9)

0 (—)

101 (97.1)

0 (—)

0 (—)

3 (2.9)

39 (37.5)

25 (24.0)

0 (—)

35 (33.7)

5 (4.8)

7 (6.7)

87 (83.7)

1 (1.0)

9 (8.7)

Acknowledgments

Alina Ainyette, Megan Rippee-Brooks, Jodi Caruthers.

Corresponding author: Robin Trotman, robintrotman@sbcglobal.net.

Abbreviation: COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019.

* All interviews were conducted via telephone by the Greene County Health

Department.

† Particulate-filtering facepiece respirators that filter ≥95% of airborne particles

(https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npptl/topics/respirators/disp_part/n95list1.

html).

(SARS) (6) and the 2007–08 influenza season (7). A systematic

review on the efficacy of face coverings against respiratory

viruses analyzed 19 randomized trials and concluded that use

of face masks and respirators appeared to be protective in both

health care and community settings (8).

The findings in this report are subject to at least four limitations. First, whereas the health department monitored all

exposed clients for signs and symptoms of COVID-19, and

no clients developed symptoms, only a subset was tested; thus,

asymptomatic clients could have been missed. Similarly, with

a viral incubation period of 2–14 days, any COVID-19 PCR

tests obtained from clients too early in their course of infection

could return false-negative results. To help mitigate this possibility, all exposed clients were offered testing on day 5 and were

contacted daily to monitor for symptoms until day 14. Second,

although the health department obtained supplementary data,

no information was collected regarding underlying medical

conditions or use of other personal protective measures, such as

gloves and hand hygiene, which could have influenced risk for

infection. Third, viral shedding is at its highest during the 2 to

3 days before symptom onset; any clients who interacted with

the stylists before they became symptomatic were not recruited

for contact tracing. Finally, the mode of interaction between

stylist and client might have limited the potential for exposure

to the virus. Services at salon A were limited to haircuts, facial hair

932

MMWR / July 17, 2020 / Vol. 69 / No. 28

trimmings, and perms. Most stylists cut hair while clients are facing away from them, which might have also limited transmission.

The results of this study can be used to inform public health

policy during the COVID-19 pandemic. A policy mandating the

use of face coverings was likely a contributing factor in preventing

transmission of SARS-CoV-2 during the close-contact interactions

between stylists and clients in salon A. Consistent and correct

use of face coverings, when appropriate, is an important tool for

minimizing spread of SARS-CoV-2 from presymptomatic, asymptomatic, and symptomatic persons. CDC recommends workplace

policies regarding use of face coverings for employees and clients in

addition to daily monitoring of signs and symptoms of employees,

procedures for screening employees who arrive with or develop

symptoms at work, and posted messages to inform and educate

employees and clients (https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019ncov/community/organizations/businesses-employers.html).

1Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri; 2University

of Kansas Medical Center, Kansas City, Missouri; 3Springfield-Greene County

Health Department, Springfield, Missouri; 4CoxHealth Infection Prevention

Services, Springfield, Missouri.

All authors have completed and submitted the International

Committee of Medical Journal Editors form for disclosure of

potential conflicts of interest. Robin Trotman reports personal fees

from Merck outside the published work. No other potential conflicts

of interest were disclosed.

References

1. CDC. Clinical questions about COVID-19: questions and answers.

Atlanta, GA: US Department of Health and Human Services, CDC;

2020. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/faq.html

2. He X, Lau EHY, Wu P, et al. Temporal dynamics in viral shedding and

transmissibility of COVID-19. Nat Med 2020;26:672–5. https://doi.

org/10.1038/s41591-020-0869-5

3. Oran DP, Topol EJ. Prevalence of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection:

a narrative review. Ann Intern Med 2020;M20–3012. https://doi.

org/10.7326/M20-3012

4. Konda A, Prakash A, Moss GA, Schmoldt M, Grant GD, Guha S. Aerosol

filtration efficiency of common fabrics used in respiratory cloth masks.

ACS Nano 2020;14:6339–47. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsnano.0c03252

5. MacIntyre CR, Seale H, Dung TC, et al. A cluster randomised trial of

cloth masks compared with medical masks in healthcare workers. BMJ

Open 2015;5:e006577. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2014-006577

6. Lau JT, Tsui H, Lau M, Yang X. SARS transmission, risk factors, and

prevention in Hong Kong. Emerg Infect Dis 2004;10:587–92. https://

doi.org/10.3201/eid1004.030628

7. Aiello AE, Perez V, Coulborn RM, Davis BM, Uddin M, Monto AS.

Facemasks, hand hygiene, and influenza among young adults: a

randomized intervention trial. PLoS One 2012;7:e29744. https://doi.

org/10.1371/journal.pone.0029744

8. MacIntyre CR, Chughtai AA. A rapid systematic review of the efficacy

of face masks and respirators against coronaviruses and other respiratory

transmissible viruses for the community, healthcare workers and sick

patients. Int J Nurs Stud 2020;108:103629. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.

ijnurstu.2020.103629

US Department of Health and Human Services/Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

R.A. 435

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

436

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 811/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 2005

EXHIBIT XX

R.A. 436

How Face Masks Can Help Prevent the Spread of COVID-19 | The Scientist Magazine®

Page 1 of 5

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-2 71-6

Page:

437

Date Filed:

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed

08/17/20

Page 911/06/2020

of 61 PageID: 2006

Home / News & Opinion

How Face Masks Can Help Prevent the Spread of COVID-19

As communities and businesses reopen amidst the pandemic, masks—in addition

to other social distancing measures—are crucial for preventing new outbreaks.

Diana Kwon

Jul 8, 2020

F

ace masks have been a matter of intense debate during the

COVID-19 pandemic. Early on, several government officials and

health authorities were discouraging healthy people from wearing

ABOVE: ©

ISTOCK.COM, PIXELFIT

masks—noting that there was little evidence for the practice’s ability

to prevent spread among the general public and citing concerns that protective face coverings,

which were desperately needed by healthcare workers, were in short supply. Gradually, however,

governments began to either require or recommend that their citizens wear face masks in public.

In June, the World Health Organization (WHO) recommended widespread mask-use as a way to

prevent coronavirus transmission. One model estimates that if at least 95 percent of people wear

masks in public between June and October, approximately 33,000 deaths could be avoided in the

US.

There are three broad categories of face coverings: tight-fitting masks known as N95 respirators

that are designed to filter out both aerosols (often defined as particles that are smaller than 5

micrometers in diameter) and larger airborne droplets, loose-fitting surgical masks that are fluid

resistant and capable of filtering out the bigger particles, and cloth masks, which vary widely based

on how they’re made.

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/how-face-masks-can-help-prevent-the-spread-... 8/17/2020

R.A. 437

How Face Masks Can Help Prevent the Spread of COVID-19 | The Scientist Magazine®

Page 2 of 5

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:10

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed438

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2007

Different Types of Masks

© SONJA PINSKER

N95 respirator: Tight-fitting single-use masks typically made with synthetic materials such as

polyester and polypropylene. These masks are able to filter out at least 95 percent of both large

airborne droplets and aerosols.

Surgical/medical masks: Loose-fitting single-use masks made with three or more layers of

synthetic materials. These can filter out large airborne particles, but some aerosols can leak

through, and particle-containing air is able to flow around the edges.

Fabric masks: These often-homemade masks vary widely in their construction and

effectiveness. Aerosols are likely to leak through, and particle-containing air is able to flow

around the edges. With appropriate washing or a couple of days to decontaminate, fabric

masks are reusable.

See full infographic: WEB

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/how-face-masks-can-help-prevent-the-spread-... 8/17/2020

R.A. 438

How Face Masks Can Help Prevent the Spread of COVID-19 | The Scientist Magazine®

Page 3 of 5

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:11

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed439

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2008

A growing body of research supports the use of all three types of masks, though the quality of

evidence varies. One of the most comprehensive examinations to date, published in The Lancet in

early June, systemically assessed 172 observational studies—mostly conducted in healthcare

settings—looking at the effect of physical distancing, face masks, and eye protection on the

transmission of SARS-CoV-2 and two related coronaviruses. The results revealed that N95

respirators provided 96 percent protection from infection and surgical masks (or comparable

reusable masks made with 12 to 16 layers of cotton or gauze) were 67 percent protective.

While research on cloth masks is much more limited, one group of researchers demonstrated that,

in the lab, multilayer masks made of hybrid materials (cotton and silk, for example) could filter up

to 90 percent of particles between 300 nanometers and 6 micrometers in size. However, it’s

important to note this is only the case when there are no gaps around the edges of the mask,

which are often present when people wear cloth or surgical masks. Indeed, the researchers’

findings suggest that gaps around any mask can reduce filtration by 60 percent or more. Still,

scientists using computational models have reported that, in general, widespread use of

facemasks, when combined with lockdowns, may help prevent future waves of infection.

“We’re recommending that N95s still be primarily saved for the healthcare situation,” says Kirsten

Koehler, a professor of environmental health and engineering at Johns Hopkins University. “For

individuals in the public, wearing a fabric mask is probably still the way to go.”

There are several factors, including the number

of layers and type of material they are made

from, that contribute to how effective a mask

will be, explains Raina MacIntrye, a professor of

global biosecurity at the University of New South

Wales in Australia. According to the WHO, fabric

masks should ideally have at least three layers:

None of these masks are

going to be perfect,

especially against the

aerosols.

an inner layer made with absorbent material

—Kirsten Koehler, Johns Hopkins University

(e.g., cotton), an outer layer with water-resistant

material (e.g., polyester), and a middle layer (made with absorbent or water-resistant material) to

act as a filter. In addition, MacIntrye adds, “the design should fit around the edges of the face

because air will flow down the path of least resistance.” In other words, if there are gaps on the

sides of your mask, your breath will slip through those cracks instead of being filtered through the

mask itself.

Although evidence is building to support the use of masks to stem the coronavirus’ spread, many

questions remain, such as whether the coronavirus spreads through aerosols or just through larger

respiratory droplets. There is also little research on the efficacy of face masks, particularly cloth

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/how-face-masks-can-help-prevent-the-spread-... 8/17/2020

R.A. 439

How Face Masks Can Help Prevent the Spread of COVID-19 | The Scientist Magazine®

Page 4 of 5

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:12

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed440

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2009

ones, in stopping the spread of COVID-19 in community settings, Julii Brainard, a senior research

associate at Norwich Medical School in the UK, tells The Scientist in an email.

Amidst the uncertainty, what is clear is that mask wearing is not the only action people should take

to slow the spread of COVID-19, Koehler says. “None of these masks are going to be perfect,

especially against the aerosols. You want to continue to encourage people to work from home,

avoid being crowds—things like that are going to work, regardless of how good your mask is.”

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/how-face-masks-can-help-prevent-the-spread-... 8/17/2020

R.A. 440

How Face Masks Can Help Prevent the Spread of COVID-19 | The Scientist Magazine®

Page 5 of 5

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:13

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed441

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2010

© SONJA PINSKER

See full infographic: WEB

Keywords:

coronavirus, COVID-19, disease & medicine, infectious disease, masks, n95 mask, outbreak, pandemic, SARS-CoV-2,

social distancing, transmission

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/how-face-masks-can-help-prevent-the-spread-... 8/17/2020

R.A. 441

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:14

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed442

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2011

EXHIBIT YY

R.A. 442

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:15

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed443

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2012

Received: 28 April 2020

Revised: 5 May 2020

Accepted: 6 May 2020

DOI: 10.1111/jep.13415

COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW

Face coverings for the public: Laying straw men to rest

Trisha Greenhalgh MD

Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health

Sciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK

Abstract

Background

Correspondence

Trisha Greenhalgh, Nuffield Department of

Primary Care Health Sciences, University of

Oxford, Oxford, UK.

Email: trish.greenhalgh@phc.ox.ac.uk

This article responds to one by Graham Martin and colleagues, who offered a critique

of my previous publications on face coverings for the lay public in the Covid-19 pandemic. Their paper reflects criticisms that have been made of face coverings policies

more generally.

Funding information

National Institute for Health Research, Grant/

Award Number: BRC-1215-20008; Wellcome

Trust, Grant/Award Number: WT104830MA

Method

Narrative rebuttal.

Results

I address charges that my coauthors and I had misapplied the precautionary principle;

drawn conclusions that were not supported by empirical research; and failed to take

account of potential harms

But before that, I remind my critics that the evidence on face coverings goes beyond

the contested trials and observational studies they place centre stage. I set out some

key findings from basic science, epidemiology, mathematical modelling, case studies,

and natural experiments, and use this rich and diverse body of evidence as the backdrop for my rebuttal of their narrowly framed objections. I challenge my critics'

apparent assumption that a particular kind of systematic review should be valorised

over narrative and real-world evidence, since stories are crucial to both our scientific

understanding and our moral imagination.

Conclusion

I conclude by thanking my academic adversaries for the intellectual sparring match,

but exhort them to remember our professional accountability to a society in crisis. It

is time to lay straw men to rest and embrace the full range of evidence in the context

of the perilous threat the world is now facing.

KEYWORDS

evidence-based medicine, public health, systematic reviews

1

|

I N T RO DU CT I O N

negative criticism on social media, I put out a challenge: either write a

point by point critique of my papers or back off. Martin et al

Since the Covid-19 pandemic emerged, I have coauthored several arti-

responded with a preprint paper4 and a rapid BMJ response.5 The

cles in both the academic and lay literature supporting the wearing of

points made in their publications reflect those of other critics of face

face coverings and masks by the general public.1-3 In response to

coverings as a policy response to Covid-19.

This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium,

provided the original work is properly cited.

© 2020 The Author. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd

1070

wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jep

R.A. 443

J Eval Clin Pract. 2020;26:1070–1077.

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:16

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed444

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2013

1071

GREENHALGH

Later in this article, I will address the substantive scientific

Charles de Gaulle aircraft carrier), nursing home staff and residents

points made by Martin et al, which I will put in italics. I have tried

(United States), residents of two homeless shelters (Boston and Los

to represent their points faithfully, without exaggeration, and apol-

Angeles), ex-pats (Japanese evacuated from Wuhan and Greek citi-

ogize in advance if I have not captured their intended nuances. But

zens evacuated from other countries), and pregnant women

first, let me highlight a subtle rhetorical move by Martin et al: they

(New York City obstetric patients). In these diverse cohorts, between

completely ignore various types of evidence—including basic science,

31% and 88% of positive cases were asymptomatic or pre-

mathematical modelling and real-world case examples of asymp-

symptomatic when tested. A recent editorial in the New England

tomatic transmission and super-spreader events. Before addressing

Journal of Medicine argued that the exceptionally high rates of

what they did talk about in their paper,4 I set out some important

asymptomatic transmission of Sars-CoV-2 call for a different approach

scientific evidence that they did not talk about. I draw heavily on

to infection control—specifically, masks or face coverings for the

the primary sources cited in the narrative review by Howard et al.6

public.21

I deliberately avoid the term “mask” when referring to a cloth face

In contrast to the high transmission rates from such individuals in

covering (either home-made or purchased) used by a member of

this case series, there are some impressive case examples of infected

the public.

individuals not passing on the virus when wearing a mask. For example one man flew from China to Toronto wearing a mask for the entire

flight, became symptomatic the next day and tested positive for

2

|

covid-19; none of the other passengers or crew became infected.22

A WI D E R E V I D E N C E B A S E

Another piece of evidence that covering the face could make a

The basic science of Covid-19 is important. The Sars-CoV-2 virus

big difference is super-spreader events, a list of which has been com-

which causes this disease replicates in the upper respiratory tract

piled by Kay.20 Perhaps the most dramatic is the choir practice in

(in contrast to the causative agent of Sars-CoV-1, which is a less con-

Seattle, in which, despite maintaining a degree of social distancing

tagious lower respiratory tract virus).7,8 This means it is likely to be

during the rehearsal, 45 of 60 people became infected and two

transmitted mainly by droplets (which is why there is so much empha-

(so far) have died.23 In all these super-spreader events, extensive

9

sis on hand-washing, since droplets contaminate surfaces). Droplets

transmission was traced back to close contact—but not necessarily

emitted from the human respiratory tract (which are relatively large,

physical touching. As the authors put it: “When do COVID-19 [super-

and are emitted not just by coughing and sneezing but also by speak-

spreader events] happen? … Wherever and whenever people are up in

ing10) quickly turn into aerosols (smaller microdroplets),11 so unless

each other's faces, laughing, shouting, cheering, sobbing, singing, greeting,

they are controlled at source, they become much harder to block.

and praying.”

A crucially important point, which is often overlooked by doctors,

In relation to a community-wide intervention such as face cover-

systematic reviewers and the lay press (and which was not addressed

ings, we do not need to prevent every transmission of every droplet

at all by Martin et al), is that most research on masks and face

or every viral particle. As with hand-washing and social distancing, the

coverings—almost all of which has been undertaken in the context of

objective of the policy is more modest: to achieve a substantial reduc-

health care workers—considers the extent to which they protect the

tion in the transmission rate of the virus. Every infectious disease has

wearer. The current question we need to address is a different one:

a transmission rate (R0). A disease with an R0 of 1.0 means that each

whether covering the face protects other people from droplets emitted

infected person, on average, infects one other person. A disease

by the wearer—a measure known as source control. Source control

whose R0 is less than 1.0 will die out. The strain of flu that caused the

works in a different way to wearer-protection—by blocking large

1918 pandemic had an R0 of 1.8. The R0 of Sars-CoV-2 was esti-

droplets as they are emitted in coughing, sneezing, and talking and

mated at 2.4 by Imperial College researchers,24 and other research

10,12-14

Large droplets (and indeed a

suggests it could even higher.25 A population measure that reduces

proportion of aerosols) are blocked—not perfectly, but significantly—

the transmission rate (“effective R0” or Reff) to below 1.0 will be highly

before they become aerosolised.

10,15-18

effective, even if some cases of transmission still occur.

by cotton home-made coverings.

Face coverings that protect the wearer work by blocking tiny

Mathematical modelling suggests that a face covering that is 60%

aerosolised particles. For this reason, medical-grade masks need to

effective at blocking viral transmission and is worn by 60% of the pop-

meet stringent filtration standards, about which much has been writ-

ulation will reduce R0 to below 1.0.26 This leaves plenty of room for

19

ten (see for example ). In contrast, source control face coverings can

error as people make their own imperfect coverings from old clothing

potentially be very effective even if they only block the larger droplet

and as some people either cannot or will not wear a face covering.

particles. Studies of the efficacy of masks in protecting the wearer are

Not all respiratory viruses are filtered equally; masks appear to be

therefore irrelevant to the question of source control.

more efficient at blocking Sars-Cov-2 than rhinoviruses or adenovi-

Evidence of asymptomatic carriage of Sars-CoV-2 is strong and

ruses, for example.27 Materials scientists have shown that whilst dif-

consistent. Oran and Topol have analysed (to date) 12 such examples

ferent fabrics are more or less efficient at blocking particle

from around the world,20 including cohorts identified for nationwide

transmission, cotton weaves with high thread count or a double layer

testing (Iceland), local population testing (Vo, Italy), passengers or

of two different fabrics (eg, cotton-flannel) typically provides high fil-

crew of three ships (Diamond Princess, USS Theodore Roosevelt, and

tration efficiency.28

R.A. 444

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:17

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed445

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2014

1072

GREENHALGH

There are now many natural experiments of the wearing of masks

and systematic reviews.1 Two preprint systematic reviews30,31 and a

or face coverings in Covid-19, as countries introduce either manda-

narrative review6 were all published the same week. In all those synthe-

tory or voluntary policies. Of note is the example of the Czech Repub-

ses, there is a conspicuous absence of experimental evidence in relation

lic and Austria, both of which introduced social distancing on the

to the wearing of masks in public places, by the lay public, as source con-

same day; the former also introduced compulsory face coverings.

trol to prevent community transmission of any respiratory illness.

New covid-19 infections fell more quickly in the Czech Republic, and

The sum total of randomized trials and observational studies cov-

only began to fall in Austria after masks were made mandatory

ered in these reviews, all of which are irrelevant to the question of

2 weeks later,3 though an alternative interpretation of this natural

source control, comprise: (a) studies of mask-wearing within the home

experiment is that Austrian data was confounded by changes in test-

to reduce contagion to other family members32-41; (b) studies of occu-

29

Also noteworthy is the observation that every single

pational exposure (eg, workers in poultry factories)42,43; (c) studies of

country where masks or cloth face coverings have been introduced as

specific mass events (notably, pilgrimages to the Hajj)44-50; (d) studies

national policy (often but not always alongside other measures), rates

in schools and university halls of residence51-54; (e) studies of air

of transmission fell in the subsequent days.

travel55; (f) studies of health care workers40,56-58; and just two studies

ing policy.

All these various streams of evidence contribute, in different

of general community prevention: an attempt to prevent the common

ways and at different levels, to strengthen the argument for rec-

cold in Finland,59 and a paper on behavioural measures (among other

ommending face coverings, especially in crowded public places

things) in the prevention of SARS, in which those who “always” wore

where social distancing is impossible, during the pandemic. With

a mask when outside the home had a relative risk of developing the

this wider evidentiary context sketched, let me now take on the

disease of 0.3 compared to those who “never” wore one.60

specific claims made by Martin et al in their paper and rapid

response.4,5

Almost all these primary studies were designed to test the

hypothesis that wearing a mask in the specific situation described in

(a) to (g) above protects the wearer; one or two considered the specific

question of whether mask-wearing by a sick family member protects

3 | P R E C A U T I O N A R Y P R I N C I P L E , “ WEAK ”

E V I D E NC E A N D P O T E N T I A L H A R M S

others in the household.35,36,41 The question my colleagues and I have

addressed in our articles1-3 was a completely different one: whether a

face covering worn by a member of the general public protects others

The precautionary principle we invoked to justify wearing

in the community. Martin et al's depiction of the evidence from trials

of masks1 is, Martin et al imply, irrelevant, because it is

and observational cohort studies as “very weak” is incorrect. Such ran-

normally used to advise caution in the uptake of innova-

domized controlled trial evidence, in relation to source control, is

tions with known benefits but uncertain or unmeasurable

entirely absent and unrelated evidence should not be presented as a

downsides, such as exposure of the public to radiation.

possible answer (Note: this does not mean there is no evidence at

all—merely, that there is no evidence valued by the RCT community).

Absence of trial evidence is partly due to the fact that experimen-

The term “precautionary principle” does not have a fixed meaning,

tal studies of mass public health measures are usually impractical. We

though I accept that it is more usually invoked as described by Martin

do not randomize schools to close, towns to go into lockdown, people

et al. It may surely prove equally appropriate (a) when harm is not cur-

to sneeze into their elbows or whole communities to wash their hands

rently happening but a proposed intervention may cause harm and

regularly. That is simply not how mass public health interventions get

(b) when serious harm is currently happening and a proposed inter-

tested.61 The argument that we should not recommend face coverings

vention may reduce that harm. There seems to me to be a strong sym-

because there are no published experiments is out of step with other

metry between these examples. One does not cancel the other out.

public health policy on infection control in general and covid-19 in

Both the omission in the former case and the act in the latter case are

particular. As with other public health measures, we should make a

measures aimed at preventing harm.

decision based on an assessment of the full body of evidence

described above.

“[T]he very weak evidence for face masks should be reiterated”. Trials, say Martin et al, have shown no evidence of

Wearing face masks may cause harm, say Martin et al,

reduced transmission with masks compared to no masks,

specifically (citing the Jefferson systematic review3) “dis-

and observational studies are contaminated with multiple

comfort, dehydration, facial dermatitis, distress, head-

confounders (e.g. parallel introduction of other measures

aches, exhaustion.”

such as hand washing).

It is widely reported that prolonged use of personal protective

The evidence base for face coverings (described above) is not

equipment by health care personnel in pandemic contexts is associ-

weak. However, it was a weak rhetorical move for Martin et al to

ated with all the problems listed (though exhaustion in particular may

ignore the strongest evidence when penning their critique. Our BMJ

have other explanations in such circumstances). Some research stud-

analysis article briefly reviewed the literature from experimental trials

ies have confirmed that prolonged wearing of medical-grade masks by

R.A. 445

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:18

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed446

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2015

1073

GREENHALGH

health care workers can result in physical and psychological

seem to filter up to 90% of them, especially if two different fabrics

harms.62-65 However, neither Martin et al nor the Jefferson system-

with different physical and electrostatic properties are used.15-18

atic review which they cite offer any evidence whatsoever that the

There is some evidence that the Sars-CoV-2 virus relies more heavily

use of home-made face coverings by the lay public for source control

than influenza, adenoviruses, or rhinoviruses on droplets, and will thus

has been shown to cause such harms. Indeed, there is no common

be more easily filtered out by a cloth cover at source than other respi-

sense reason why a covering made out of one's own old t-shirt would

ratory viruses.68,69 As noted above, if 60% of people wear a mask that

cause illness when the t-shirt itself was well-tolerated (and if it wasn't,

is 60% effective, this is likely to be sufficient to substantially reduce

why make a mask out of it?). The possible harmful effects of face cov-

the transmission of Sars-CoV-2. To say that because some people

erings (eg, anecdotal accounts of irritation behind the ears from ill-

may find it difficult to obtain or launder a mask or face cover, we

fitting elastic) should also be weighed against their potential benefits,

should not recommend them for anyone is illogical—especially since

and the potential advantages of novel equipment such as face screens

adverse socioeconomic circumstances is a risk factor for developing

(clear plastic visors) urgently researched.66

Covid-19 and also for poorer prognosis.70 The negative, individualist

emphasis of Martin et al's critique ignores the positive impact of collectively making face coverings as a component of wider community

resilience strategies in Covid-19.71,72 The South African Government,

4 | C A N T H E G E N E R A L P U B LIC BE

TRUSTED?

for example, has recently issued a tender for community sewing cooperatives to supply cloth face masks.73

The general public, propose Martin et al, are unlikely to

use masks “properly”. Even healthcare workers struggle to

Risk compensation (in which people made to wear masks

achieve necessary standards of donning and doffing tech-

reduced other infection control behaviours such as hand-

nique, and “inappropriately discarded masks present an

washing), suggest Martin et al, could occur.

infection risk”.

My critics cite a review from 20 years ago which describes mixed

findings on risk compensation behaviours.74 They do not cite a more

Infection control standards designed for health care workers are not

recent review which suggests that such behaviours appear rare.75

directly relevant to the general public. The infected particles on a health

Both these reviews, however, focused mainly on injury prevention,

care worker's mask are likely to come from patients, and in this situation

not on infection control measures. More relevant perhaps are studies

the health care worker is (hopefully) uninfected and therefore vulnerable.

showing that teenagers vaccinated against human papilloma virus do

In contrast, if a member of the public is wearing a cloth face covering, they

not appear to take more sexual risks,76,77 though there is some

are the most likely source of any infectious particles on it. The more infec-

evidence that pre-exposure prophylaxis for HIV may increase sexual

tious particles that are caught in that covering, the fewer will have been

risk-taking in men who have sex with men.78 The argument that risk

aerosolised to infect others. A face covering that has been removed does

compensation behaviour would occur specifically in relation to face

not need to be disinfected, and formal doffing is not needed (though hand-

coverings in the context of Covid-19 is entirely speculative. It is also

washing would be sensible in case the covering has become contaminated

unlikely. If adverse behaviour change happens to a significant degree,

with droplets from others). Sars-CoV-2 has a lipid membrane which is des-

we would surely have seen some examples from around the world by

troyed by soap or detergent (this, of course, is why hand-washing works).

now, as numerous countries have now made the wearing of masks or

A cloth face covering can be laundered along with other clothing in a nor-

face coverings mandatory. Two recent studies from Hong Kong, based

mal hot wash.67 An alternative option in low-income countries is to wash

on self-reports in online or telephone surveys (hence, relatively weak

the covering with soap and water and leave it to dry in the sun. Imposing

evidence), found that those who reported wearing masks in public

unnecessarily high standards of disinfection on the public is likely to reduce

places were also more likely to report more hand-washing and social

uptake of the measure and be counterproductive.

distancing.79,80

Being able to make, don, doff and disinfect your own

5

cloth mask, suggest Martin et al, is a middle-class privi-

|

UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES?

lege. The efficacy of masks in the general population will

be reduced by “the potential for great variation in mate-

[U]niversal mask-wearing might aggravate the climate of

rials, fit, adherence, touching and adjustment, doffing, dis-

fear already documented for Covid-19.

posal, frequency of laundering and so on”.

There is no need to standardize the design of masks or fetishise

Fear is perhaps a reasonable response to a deadly pandemic

how they are worn, any more than we do so for the shoes that protect

that has so far affected at least three million people and cost hun-

our feet or the t-shirts we pull over our faces. Cotton and similar

dreds of thousands of lives. There is no evidence that policies

materials do not block droplets entirely—but most double-layer fabrics

which encourage or mandate covering the face increase fear. The

R.A. 446

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:19

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed447

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2016

1074

GREENHALGH

counterargument—that such a measure would help reduce fear—is

conflating politics with science. It is not a legitimate reason to sit idle

equally plausible (though there is no definitive evidence either

when hundreds are dying daily.

way). In studies of community mask use in tuberculosis control,

mask-wearing by affected individuals reduced disease transmission

but increased stigma,81,82 whereas promotion of mask-wearing by

all

members

of

the

community

was

associated

with

6 | “S Y S T E M A T I C ” V S N A R R A T I V E

RE VIE WS

destigmatisation.82 The relevance of these findings to the current

In the first paragraph of their paper, Martin et al contrast “two [pre-

pandemic are unclear.

print] systematic reviews” with “another preprint review, with more

opaque methods but encompassing an eclectic range of disciplinary

Promoting mask-wearing by the lay public could lead to a

perspectives.” The implication is that the conclusions of “systematic”

shortage of medical-grade masks.

reviews which favour controlled experiments are necessarily more

This is a real concern, but it is not a reason to distort or deny the

reliable than those of “opaque” and “eclectic” narrative reviews which

evidence of benefit. There is no reason why the public should wear

bring in so-called anecdotal evidence and findings from basic and

medical-grade masks, since cotton face coverings are more comfort-

social sciences. Elsewhere, colleagues and I have challenged this con-

able, recyclable, and sufficiently effective for source control, especially

ceptual bias.89 In that paper, we distinguish between narrowly defined

given the evidence on how this particular virus behaves (it sits in the

biomedical questions that can be answered using conventional sys-

upper respiratory tract and is emitted mostly in droplets).68,69 A public

tematic review, with meta-analysis where appropriate, and more com-

information campaign would be needed to get this message across to

plex, multifaceted problems that require clarification and insight, for

lay people as well as to clinicians and scientists (most of whom, like

which a more interpretive and discursive synthesis of is needed.

Martin et al, have unjustifiable extrapolated findings from research on

Looking back at the first part of this article, where I summarized

infection control in health care settings and sought to apply the same

the evidence that Martin et al chose to ignore, I am struck by the

standards to the public). In any case, simple surgical masks could

stories they did not examine (the Covid-stricken choir, the air passen-

surely be produced easily and in large numbers by repurposing

ger whose mask may have saved a planeload of people from conta-

manufacturing capacity if the political will and logistical capability was

gion, the cruise ships that became floating quarantine prisons). But

there.83

these stories are crucial to both our scientific understanding and our

moral imagination. Their contrasting plots—tragedy, melodrama, lucky

[B]usinesses or states might see widespread or mandatory

escape—pull together complex chains of influence and remind us that

mask-wearing as a warrant for a premature return to

causality in a pandemic is rarely linear. Anecdotes may be a low form

‘business as usual,’ justifying unsafe workplaces or

of evidence in some taxonomies, but each one calls for an

crowded commuting conditions in terms of the protection

explanation.

offered by masks.4

As my coauthors and I concluded in out article on narrative

review:

This statement is entirely speculative. No evidence is given for it

and it implies that the preferred state is for society to remain in lock84

Training in systematic reviews has produced a generation

The risks to the economy of prolonged lockdown

of scholars who are skilled in the technical tasks of

are dire.85,86 Recession and job losses will have a disproportionate

searching, sorting, checking against inclusion criteria, tab-

down indefinitely.

effect on the poor and socially excluded. There are ethical as well as

ulating extracted data and generating ‘grand means’ and

scientific arguments for considering all measures that may help to

confidence intervals. These skills are important, but …

reduce the lockdown period and get businesses up and running as a

critics may incorrectly assume that they override and

matter of urgency.

make redundant the generation of understanding. …

While there are occasions when systematic review is the

Masks, suggest Martin et al, are an example of a complex

ideal approach to answering specific forms of questions,

intervention in a complex system. Their effects are impos-

the absence of thoughtful, interpretive critical reflection

sible to predict, therefore we should not introduce them.

can render such products hollow, misleading and potentially harmful.89

The papers cited to support this assertion (one of which was

coauthored by me87) actually support the opposite conclusion. Just

because a complex system is unpredictable does not mean we should

7

|

CONC LU SION

do nothing.88 As Martin et al acknowledge, careful data collection and

frequent, timely analysis that feeds into adjustment of policy will allow

In conclusion, I congratulate Martin et al for rising to my challenge to

an adaptive and data-driven response. Their depiction of current

produce a critique of my publications on masks and face coverings for

United Kingdom policy as too “blunt” to respond in this way is

the public. But whilst academic sparring has an important place in

R.A. 447

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:20

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed448

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2017

1075

GREENHALGH

keeping us on our toes, we also need to remember our moral accountability to a society in crisis. The relentless, day on day stories of avoidable deaths from this dreadful disease sicken me. I will do whatever I

can, as an academic, a doctor and a citizen, to reduce that death toll

and help get society back running again.

As Gandhi et al concluded in their NEJM editorial: “This unprecedented pandemic calls for unprecedented measures to achieve its ultimate defeat.”21 It is time to put the straw men to rest and embrace

the full range of evidence in the context of the perilous threat the

world is now facing.

ACKNOWLEDGEMEN TS

Thanks to Mat Mercuri, two anonymous reviewers, and Helene-Mari

van der Westhuizen for helpful comments on an earlier draft, and to

coauthors of my earlier papers (Manuel Schmid, Thomas Czypionka,

Dirk Bassler, Laurence Gruer, Jeremy Howard, Zeynep Tufekci) and

Babak Javid for ideas and inspiration. I acknowledge funding from the

Wellcome Trust (WT104830MA) and UK National Institute for Health

Research (BRC-1215-20008). Responsibility for this article is mine

alone.

ORCID

Trisha Greenhalgh

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2369-8088

RE FE R ENC E S

1. Greenhalgh T, Schmid MB, Czypionka T, et al. Face masks for the

public during the covid-19 crisis. BMJ. 2020;369:m1435. https://doi.

org/10.1136/bmj.m1435.

2. Tufekci Z, Howard J, Greenhalgh T. The real reason to wear a mask.

The Atlantic. April 22, 2020. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/

archive/2020/04/dont-wear-mask-yourself/610336/. Accessed April

27, 2020.

3. Greenhalgh T, Howard J. Masks for all? The science says yes. (blog).

fast.ai; 2020. https://www.fast.ai/2020/04/13/masks-summary/.

Accessed April 27, 2020.

4. Martin G, Hanna E, Dingwall R. Face masks for the public during

Covid-19: an appeal for caution in policy. Preprint; 2020. https://

wwwdoradmuacuk/bitstream/handle/2086/19526/Face%20masks%

20caution%20in%20policy_v1_2020-04-22%20%28with%

20disclaimers%29pdf. Accessed April 27, 2020.

5. Martin G, Hanna E, Dingwall R. Response to Greenhalgh et al.

BMJ rapid responses; 2020. https://www.bmj.com/content/369/bmj.

m1435/rr-43. Accessed April 27, 2020.

6. Howard J, Huang A, Li Z, et al. Face masks against COVID-19: an

evidence review. Preprints; 2020. https://www.preprints.org/manus

cript/202004.0203/v1. Accessed April 27, 2020.

7. van Doremalen N, Bushmaker T, Morris DH, et al. Aerosol and

surface stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-CoV-1.

N Engl J Med. 2020;382:1564-1567. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM

c2004973.

8. Wölfel R, Corman VM, Guggemos W, et al. Virological assessment of

hospitalized patients with COVID-2019. Nature. 2020;1-10.

9. World Health Organisation. Modes of Transmission of Virus Causing

COVID-19: Implications for IPC Precaution Recommendations. Geneva,

Switzerland: WHO; 2020. https://www.who.int/news-room/comm

entaries/detail/modes-of-transmission-of-virus-causing-covid-19implications-for-ipc-precaution-recommendations. Accessed May

4, 2020.

10. Anfinrud P, Stadnytskyi V, Bax CE, et al. Visualizing speech-generated

oral fluid droplets with laser light scattering. N Engl J Med. 2020.

https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMc2007800. Online letter published

April 15, 2020.

11. Papineni RS, Rosenthal FS. The size distribution of droplets in the

exhaled breath of healthy human subjects. J Aerosol Med. 1997;10(2):

105-116.

12. Bourouiba L. Turbulent gas clouds and respiratory pathogen emissions: potential implications for reducing transmission of COVID-19.

JAMA. 2020. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2020.4756. Online communication published March 26, 2020.

13. Duguid J. The size and the duration of air-carriage of respiratory

droplets and droplet-nuclei. Epidemiol Infect. 1946;44(6):471-479.

14. Morawska L, Johnson G, Ristovski Z, et al. Size distribution and sites

of origin of droplets expelled from the human respiratory tract during

expiratory activities. J Aerosol Sci. 2009;40(3):256-269.

15. Davies A, Thompson K-A, Giri K, Kafatos G, Walker J, Bennett A.

Testing the efficacy of homemade masks: would they protect in an

influenza pandemic? Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2013;7(4):

413-418.

16. Rengasamy S, Eimer B, Shaffer RE. Simple respiratory protection—

evaluation of the filtration performance of cloth masks and common

fabric materials against 20–1000 nm size particles. Ann Occup Hyg.

2010;54(7):789-798.

17. van der Sande M, Teunis P, Sabel R. Professional and home-made

face masks reduce exposure to respiratory infections among the general population. PLoS One. 2008;3(7).e2618.

18. Dato VM, Hostler D, Hahn ME. Simple respiratory mask: simple respiratory mask. Emerg Infect Dis. 2006;12(6):1033-1034.

19. Oberg T, Brosseau LM. Surgical mask filter and fit performance.

Am J Infect Control. 2008;36(4):276-282.

20. Kay J. COVID-19 superspreader events in 28 countries: critical patterns and lessons. Quillette. April 23, 2020.

21. Gandhi M, Yokoe DS, Havlir DV. Asymptomatic transmission, the

Achilles' heel of current strategies to control Covid-19. N Engl J Med.

2020.https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMe2009758.

22. Schwartz KL, Murti M, Finkelstein M, et al. Lack of COVID-19 transmission on an international flight. CMAJ. 2020;192(15):E410-E410.

23. Read R. A choir decided to go ahead with rehearsal. Now dozens of

members have COVID-19 and two are dead. Los Angeles Times. March

29, 2020. https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2020-0329/coronavirus-choir-outbreak. Accessed April 27, 2020.

24. Ferguson N, Laydon D, Nedjati Gilani G, et al. Report 9: Impact of

non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to reduce COVID19 mortality and healthcare demand; 2020. https://dsprdpub.cc.ic.ac.uk:8443/

handle/10044/1/77482

25. Liu Y, Gayle AA, Wilder-Smith A, et al. The reproductive number of

COVID-19 is higher compared to SARS coronavirus. J Travel Med.

2020;27: taaa021.1–4.

26. Tian L, Li X, Qi F, et al. Calibrated intervention and containment of

the COVID-19 pandemic. Preprint; 2020. arXiv:200307353v4.

https://arxivorg/pdf/200307353pdf. Accessed April 27, 2020.

27. Leung NH, Chu DK, Shiu EY, et al. Respiratory virus shedding in

exhaled breath and efficacy of face masks. Nat Med. 2020;26 676-680.

28. Konda A, Prakash A, Moss GA, Schmoldt M, Grant GD, Guha S. Aerosol filtration efficiency of common fabrics used in respiratory cloth

masks. ACS Nano. 2020. https://doi.org/10.1021/acsnano.0c03252.

29. DELVE. Face Masks for the General Public. London, England: Royal

Society DELVE (Data Evaluation and Learning for Viral Epidemics) initiative 2020. https://rs-delve.github.io/reports.html. Accessed May

4, 2020.

30. Brainard JS, Jones N, Lake I, et al. Facemasks and similar barriers to

prevent respiratory illness such as COVID-19: a rapid systematic

review. MedRxiv; 2020. doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.01.

R.A. 448

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:21

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed449

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2018

1076

31.

32.

33.

34.

35.

36.

37.

38.

39.

40.

41.

42.

43.

44.

45.

46.

47.

GREENHALGH

20049528. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.01.

20049528v1.abstract;Preprint. Accessed April 12, 2020.

Jefferson T, Jones M, Al Ansari LA, et al. Physical interventions to

interrupt or reduce the spread of respiratory viruses. Part 1-face

masks, eye protection and person distancing: systematic review and

meta-analysis. MedRxiv 2020. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.03.30.

20047217. Accessed April 9, 2020.

Cowling BJ, Fung RO, Cheng CK, et al. Preliminary findings of a randomized trial of non-pharmaceutical interventions to prevent influenza transmission in households. PLoS One. 2008;3(5):e2101. https://

doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0002101.

Cowling BJ, Chan KH, Fang VJ, et al. Facemasks and hand hygiene to

prevent influenza transmission in households: a cluster randomized

trial. Ann Intern Med. 2009;151(7):437-446. https://doi.org/10.7326/

0003-4819-151-7-200910060-00142.

Suess T, Remschmidt C, Schink SB, et al. The role of facemasks and

hand hygiene in the prevention of influenza transmission in households: results from a cluster randomised trial; Berlin, Germany,

2009-2011. BMC Infect Dis. 2012;12(1):26.

Canini L, Andreoletti L, Ferrari P, et al. Surgical mask to prevent

influenza transmission in households: a cluster randomized trial.

PLoS One. 2010;5(11):e13998. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.

pone.0013998.

Larson EL, Ferng Y-H, Wong-McLoughlin J, Wang S, Haber M,

Morse SS. Impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions on URIs and

influenza in crowded, urban households. Public Health Rep. 2010;125

(2):178-191.

MacIntyre CR, Cauchemez S, Dwyer DE, et al. Face mask use and

control of respiratory virus transmission in households. Emerg Infect

Dis. 2009;15(2):233-241.

Barasheed O, Alfelali M, Mushta S, et al. Uptake and effectiveness of

facemask against respiratory infections at mass gatherings: a systematic review. Int J Infect Dis. 2016;47:105-111.

Simmerman JM, Suntarattiwong P, Levy J, et al. Findings from a

household randomized controlled trial of hand washing and face

masks to reduce influenza transmission in Bangkok, Thailand. Influenza Other Respir Viruses. 2011;5(4):256-267. https://doi.org/10.

1111/j.1750-2659.2011.00205.x.

Lau JT, Lau M, Kim JH, et al. Probable secondary infections in households of SARS patients in Hong Kong. Emerg Infect Dis. 2004;10(2):

236-243.

MacIntyre CR, Zhang Y, Chughtai AA, et al. Cluster randomised controlled trial to examine medical mask use as source control for people

with respiratory illness. BMJ Open. 2016;6(12):e012330. https://doi.

org/10.1136/bmjopen-2016-012330.

Jolie R, Backstrom L, Thomas C. Health problems in veterinary students

after visiting a commercial swine farm. Can J Vet Res. 1998;62(1):44-48.

Tahir MF, Abbas MA, Ghafoor T, et al. Seroprevalence and risk factors

of avian influenza H9 virus among poultry professionals in Rawalpindi, Pakistan. J Infect Public Health. 2020;13(3):414-417. https://

doi.org/10.1016/j.jiph.2020.02.030.

Al-Jasser FS, Kabbash IA, Almazroa MA, et al. Patterns of diseases

and preventive measures among domestic hajjis from central, Saudi

Arabia. Saudi Med J. 2012;33(8):879-886.

Choudhry AJ, Al-Mudaimegh KS, Turkistani AM, et al. Hajj-associated

acute respiratory infection among hajjis from Riyadh. East Mediterr

Health J. 2006;12(3–4):300-309.

Alfelali M, Haworth EA, Barasheed O, et al. Facemask versus no

facemask in preventing viral respiratory infections during hajj: a cluster randomised open label trial. 2019. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/

papers.cfm?abstract_id=3349234. Accessed May 15, 2020.

Balaban V, Stauffer WM, Hammad A, et al. Protective practices and

respiratory illness among US travelers to the 2009 hajj. J Travel Med.

2012;19(3):163-168.

48. Deris ZZ, Hasan H, Sulaiman SA, et al. The prevalence of acute respiratory symptoms and role of protective measures among Malaysian

hajj pilgrims. J Travel Med. 2010;17(2):82-88. https://doi.org/10.

1111/j.1708-8305.2009.00384.x.

49. Emamian MH, Hassani AM, Fateh M. Respiratory tract infections and

its preventive measures among hajj pilgrims, 2010: a nested case control study. Int J Prev Med. 2013;4(9):1030-1035.

50. The role of using masks to reduce acute upper respiratory tract infections in pilgrims. 4th Asia Pacific Travel Health Conference, Shanghai,

PR China; 2002.

51. Aiello AE, Murray GF, Perez V, et al. Mask use, hand hygiene, and seasonal influenza-like illness among young adults: a randomized intervention trial. J Infect Dis. 2010;201(4):491-498. https://doi.org/10.

1086/650396.

52. Aiello AE, Perez V, Coulborn RM, et al. Facemasks, hand hygiene,

and influenza among young adults: a randomized intervention trial.

PLoS One. 2012;7(1):e29744. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.

0029744.

53. Kim CO, Nam CM, Lee DC, et al. Is abdominal obesity associated with

the 2009 influenza A (H1N1) pandemic in Korean school-aged children? Influenza Other Respir Viruses. 2012;6(5):313-317. https://doi.

org/10.1111/j.1750-2659.2011.00318.x.

54. Uchida M, Kaneko M, Hidaka Y, et al. Effectiveness of vaccination

and wearing masks on seasonal influenza in Matsumoto City, Japan,

in the 2014/2015 season: an observational study among all elementary schoolchildren. Prev Med Rep. 2017;5:86-91. https://doi.org/10.

1016/j.pmedr.2016.12.002.

55. Zhang L, Peng Z, Ou J, et al. Protection by face masks against influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 virus on trans-Pacific passenger aircraft, 2009.

Emerg Infect Dis. 2013;19(9):1403-1410. https://doi.org/10.3201/

eid1909.121765.

56. Sung AD, Sung JA, Corbet K, et al. Surgical mask usage reduces the

incidence of parainfluenza virus 3 in recipients of stem cell transplantation. Blood. 2012;120:462.

57. Wu S, Ma C, Yang Z, et al. Hygiene behaviors associated with

influenza-like illness among adults in Beijing, China: a large,

population-based survey. PloS One. 2016;11(2).e0148448.

58. Lau JT, Tsui H, Lau M, et al. SARS transmission, risk factors,

and prevention in Hong Kong. Emerg Infect Dis. 2004;10(4):

587-592.

59. Shin K, Wakabayashi H, Sugita C, et al. Effects of orally administered

lactoferrin and lactoperoxidase on symptoms of the common cold. Int

J Health Sci. 2018;12(5):44-50.

60. Wu J, Xu F, Zhou W, et al. Risk factors for SARS among persons without known contact with SARS patients, Beijing, China. Emerg Infect

Dis. 2004;10(2):210-216.

61. Ogilvie D, Adams J, Bauman A, et al. Using natural experimental studies to guide public health action: turning the evidence-based medicine

paradigm on its head. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2020;74(2):

203-208.

62. Al Badri FM. Surgical mask contact dermatitis and epidemiology of

contact dermatitis in healthcare workers. Curr Allergy Clin Immunol.

2017;30(3):183-188.

63. Zuo Y, Hua W, Luo Y, Li L. Skin reactions of N95 masks and medial

masks among health care personnel: a self-report questionnaire survey in China. Contact Dermatitis. 2020.https://doi.org/10.1111/cod.

13555.

64. Warshaw EM, Schlarbaum JP, Silverberg JI, et al. Safety equipment:

when protection becomes a problem. Contact Dermatitis. 2019;81(2):

130-132.

65. Yan Y, Chen H, Chen L, et al. Consensus of Chinese experts on protection of skin and mucous membrane barrier for healthcare workers

fighting against coronavirus disease 2019. Dermatol Ther. 2020;

e13310.https://doi.org/10.1111/dth.13310.

R.A. 449

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:22

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed450

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2019

1077

GREENHALGH

66. Perencevich EN, Diekema DJ, Edmond MB. Moving personal protective equipment into the community: face shields and containment of

COVID-19. JAMA. 2020.https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2020.7477.

67. (US) CfDCaP. Cleaning and Disinfecting for Households. Atlanta, GA:

CDC 2020. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/preventgetting-sick/cleaning-disinfection.html?CDC_AA_refVal=https%3A%

2F%2Fwww.cdc.gov%2Fcoronavirus%2F2019-ncov%2Fprepare%2F

cleaning-disinfection.html. Accessed April 27, 2020.

68. Andersen KG, Rambaut A, Lipkin WI, Holmes EC, Garry RF. The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2. Nat Med. 2020;26(4):450-452.

69. Lai C-C, Shih T-P, Ko W-C, et al. Severe acute respiratory syndrome

coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) and corona virus disease-2019 (COVID19): the epidemic and the challenges. Int J Antimicrob Agents. 2020;55

(3):105924

70. World Health Organization. Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19): Situation Report, 72. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO; 2020.

71. Ngai R. Volunteering in a lockdown: a stay-at-home mask-making

sewing bee. Microsoft News; April 9, 2020. https://news.microsoft.

com/en-hk/2020/04/09/volunteering-in-a-lockdown-a-stay-at-homemask-making-sewing-bee/. Accessed April 27, 2020.

72. Cheng KK, Lam TH, Leung CC. Wearing face masks in the community during the COVID-19 pandemic: altruism and solidarity. Lancet.

2020.https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30918-1.

73. Anonymous. A Call Out to Existing South African Owned, Registered

and Tax Compliant SMMEs and Cooperatives to Submit Information in

the Following Categories. Johannesberg, South Africa: South African

Government, Department of Small Business Development. 2020.

http://www.dsbd.gov.za/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/RFI-4-Requ

est-For-Information-Fabric-Cloth-Face-Masks-13.04.-2020-Final.pdf.

Accessed April 27, 2020.

74. Hedlund J. Risky business: safety regulations, risk compensation, and

individual behavior. Inj Prev. 2000;6(2):82-89.

75. Pless B. Risk compensation: revisited and rebutted. Safety. 2016;2

(3):16.

76. Kasting ML, Shapiro GK, Rosberger Z, Kahn JA, Zimet GD. Tempest in

a teapot: a systematic review of HPV vaccination and risk compensation research. Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2016;12(6):1435-1450.

77. Madhivanan P, Pierre-Victor D, Mukherjee S, et al. Human papillomavirus vaccination and sexual disinhibition in females: a systematic

review. Am J Prev Med. 2016;51(3):373-383. https://doi.org/10.

1016/j.amepre.2016.03.015.

78. Traeger MW, Schroeder SE, Wright EJ, et al. Effects of pre-exposure

prophylaxis for the prevention of human immunodeficiency virus

infection on sexual risk behavior in men who have sex with men: a

systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Infect Dis. 2018;67(5):676686. https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciy182.

79. Kwok KO, Li KK, Chan HH, et al. Community responses during the

early phase of the COVID-19 epidemic in Hong Kong: risk perception,

information exposure and preventive measures. medRxiv. February

27, 2020. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.26.

20028217v1. Accessed May 4, 2020.

80. Cowling BJ, Ali ST, Ng TW, et al. Impact assessment of nonpharmaceutical interventions against COVID-19 and influenza in

Hong Kong: an observational study. medRxiv 2020. https://www.

medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.12.20034660v1.abstract.

Accessed April 7, 2020.

81. Joachim G, Acorn S. Stigma of visible and invisible chronic conditions.

J Adv Nurs. 2000;32(1):243-248.

82. Buregyeya E, Mitchell EM, Rutebemberwa E, et al. Acceptability of

masking and patient separation to control nosocomial tuberculosis in

Uganda: a qualitative study. J Public Health. 2012;20(6):599-606.

83. Reagan C. Retailers shift production to make masks, gowns for

health-care workers in coronavirus pandemic. CNBC Online. March

26, 2020. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/26/coronavirus-retailersmake-masksgowns-for-healthcare-workers.html. Accessed April

1, 2020.

84. Kai D, Goldstein G-P, Morgunov A, et al. Universal masking is urgent in

the COVID-19 pandemic: SEIR and agent based models, empirical validation, policy recommendations. arXiv preprint. arXiv:200413553 2020.

85. Doward J. Nearly seven million jobs at risk if lockdown lasts for

months. Guardian. April 19, 2020. https://www.theguardian.com/

world/2020/apr/19/nearly-seven-million-jobs-at-risk-if-lockdownlasts-for-months. Accessed April 27, 2020.

86. Anonymous. Covid-19 causes Britain's fastest economic contraction

on record. Economist. April 19, 2020. https://www.economist.com/

britain/2020/04/11/covid-19-causes-britains-fastest-economic-cont

raction-on-record. Accessed April 27, 2020.

87. Plsek PE, Greenhalgh T. Complexity science: the challenge of complexity in health care. BMJ. 2001;323(7313):625-628.

88. Greenhalgh T, Papoutsi C. Studying complexity in health services

research: desperately seeking an overdue paradigm shift. BMC Med.

2018;16 95https://doi.org/10.1186/s12916-018-1089-4.

89. Greenhalgh T, Thorne S, Malterud K. Time to challenge the spurious

hierarchy of systematic over narrative reviews? Eur J Clin Invest.

2018;48(6):e12931.

How to cite this article: Greenhalgh T. Face coverings for the

public: Laying straw men to rest. J Eval Clin Pract. 2020;26:

1070–1077. https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.13415

R.A. 450

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:23

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed451

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2020

EXHIBIT ZZ

R.A. 451

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:24

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed452

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2021

Visualizing the effectiveness of face masks

in obstructing respiratory jets

Cite as: Phys. Fluids 32, 061708 (2020); https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0016018

Submitted: 31 May 2020 . Accepted: 06 June 2020 . Published Online: 30 June 2020

Siddhartha Verma

, Manhar Dhanak

, and John Frankenfield

COLLECTIONS

Paper published as part of the special topic on Flow and the Virus

Note: This paper is part of the Special Topic, Flow and the Virus.

This paper was selected as Featured

ARTICLES YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Elastohydrodynamics of a deformable porous packing in a channel competing under shear

and pressure gradient

Physics of Fluids 32, 061901 (2020); https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0010317

Sneezing and asymptomatic virus transmission

Physics of Fluids 32, 073309 (2020); https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0019090

Asymptotic estimates of SARS-CoV-2 infection counts and their sensitivity to stochastic

perturbation

Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science 30, 051107 (2020); https://

doi.org/10.1063/5.0008834

Phys. Fluids 32, 061708 (2020); https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0016018

© 2020 Author(s).

R.A. 452

32, 061708

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:25

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed453

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2022

Physics of Fluids

LETTER

scitation.org/journal/phf

Visualizing the effectiveness of face masks

in obstructing respiratory jets

Cite as: Phys. Fluids 32, 061708 (2020); doi: 10.1063/5.0016018

Submitted: 31 May 2020 • Accepted: 6 June 2020 •

Published Online: 30 June 2020

Siddhartha Verma,a)

Manhar Dhanak,b)

and John Frankenfieldc)

AFFILIATIONS

Department of Ocean and Mechanical Engineering, Florida Atlantic University, Boca Raton, Florida 33431, USA

Note: This paper is part of the Special Topic, Flow and the Virus.

a)

Also at: Harbor Branch Oceanographic Institute, Florida Atlantic University, Fort Pierce, FL 34946, USA. Author to whom

correspondence should be addressed: vermas@fau.edu. URL: http://www.computation.fau.edu

b)

Electronic mail: dhanak@fau.edu

c)

Electronic mail: jfranken@fau.edu

ABSTRACT

The use of face masks in public settings has been widely recommended by public health officials during the current COVID-19 pandemic. The

masks help mitigate the risk of cross-infection via respiratory droplets; however, there are no specific guidelines on mask materials and designs

that are most effective in minimizing droplet dispersal. While there have been prior studies on the performance of medical-grade masks, there

are insufficient data on cloth-based coverings, which are being used by a vast majority of the general public. We use qualitative visualizations

of emulated coughs and sneezes to examine how material- and design-choices impact the extent to which droplet-laden respiratory jets are

blocked. Loosely folded face masks and bandana-style coverings provide minimal stopping-capability for the smallest aerosolized respiratory

droplets. Well-fitted homemade masks with multiple layers of quilting fabric, and off-the-shelf cone style masks, proved to be the most

effective in reducing droplet dispersal. These masks were able to curtail the speed and range of the respiratory jets significantly, albeit with

some leakage through the mask material and from small gaps along the edges. Importantly, uncovered emulated coughs were able to travel

notably farther than the currently recommended 6-ft distancing guideline. We outline the procedure for setting up simple visualization

experiments using easily available materials, which may help healthcare professionals, medical researchers, and manufacturers in assessing

the effectiveness of face masks and other personal protective equipment qualitatively.

Published under license by AIP Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0016018., s

Infectious respiratory illnesses can exact a heavy socioeconomic toll on the most vulnerable members of our society, as

has become evident from the current COVID-19 pandemic.1,2 The

disease has overwhelmed healthcare infrastructure worldwide,3 and

its high contagion rate and relatively long incubation period4,5 have

made it difficult to trace and isolate infected individuals. Current

estimates indicate that about 35% of infected individuals do not display overt symptoms6 and may contribute to the significant spread

of the disease without their knowledge. In an effort to contain

the unabated community spread of the disease, public health officials have recommended the implementation of various preventative

measures, including social-distancing and the use of face masks in

public settings.7

The rationale behind the recommendation for using masks or

other face coverings is to reduce the risk of cross-infection via the

transmission of respiratory droplets from infected to healthy individuals.8,9 The pathogen responsible for COVID-19 is found primarily in respiratory droplets that are expelled by infected individuals

during coughing, sneezing, or even talking and breathing.10–15 Apart

from COVID-19, respiratory droplets are also the primary means

of transmission for various other viral and bacterial illnesses, such

as the common cold, influenza, tuberculosis, SARS (Severe Acute

Respiratory Syndrome), and MERS (Middle East Respiratory Syndrome), to name a few.16–19 These pathogens are enveloped within

respiratory droplets, which may land on healthy individuals and

result in direct transmission, or on inanimate objects, which can

lead to infection when a healthy individual comes in contact with

them.10,18,20,21 In another mode of transmission, the droplets or their

evaporated contents may remain suspended in the air for long periods of time if they are sufficiently small. This can lead to airborne

32, 061708-1

Phys. Fluids 32, 061708 (2020); doi: 10.1063/5.0016018

Published under license by AIP Publishing

R.A. 453

Case: 20-3048 Document:

23-271-6Page:

Date Page

Filed:26

11/06/2020

Case 2:20-cv-05420-CCC-ESK

Document

Filed454

08/17/20

of 61 PageID: 2023

Physics of Fluids

LETTER

transmission19,22 when they are breathed in by another person, long

after the infected individual may have left the area.

Several studies have investigated respiratory droplets produced

by both healthy and infected individuals when performing various activities. The transport characteristics of these droplets can

vary significantly depending on their diameter.23–28 The reported

droplet diameters vary widely among studies available in the literature and usually lie within the range 1 μm–500 μm,29 with a

mean diameter of ∼10 μm.30 The larger droplets (diameter >100 μm)

are observed to follow ballistic trajectories under the effects of

gravity and aerodynamic drag.20,31 Intermediate-sized droplets20,31,32

may get carried over considerable distances within a multiphase

turbulent cloud.33–35 The smallest droplets and particles (diameter

< 5 μm–10 μm) may remain suspended in the air indefinitely, until

they are carried away by a light breeze or ventilation airflow.20,32

After being expelled into the ambient environment, the respiratory droplets experience varying degrees of evaporation depending on their size, ambient humidity, and temperature. The smallest droplets may undergo complete evaporation, leaving behind

a dried-out spherical mass consisting of the particulate contents

(e.g., pathogens), which are referred to as “droplet nuclei.”36 These

desiccated nuclei, in combination with the smallest droplets, are

potent transmission sources on account of two factors: (1) they

can remain suspended in the air for hours after the infected individual has left the area, potentially infecting unsuspecting individuals who come into contact with them and (2) they can penetrate deep into the airways of individuals who breathe them in,

which increases the likelihood of infection even for low pathogen

loads. At present, the role of droplet nuclei in the transmission

of COVID-19 is not known with certainty and the matter is the

subject of ongoing studies.37–39 In addition to generating microscopic droplets, the action of sneezing can expel sheet-like layers

of respiratory fluids,40 which may break apart into smaller droplets

through a series of instabilities. The majority of the fluid contained within the sheet falls to the ground quickly within a short

distance.

Regardless of their size, all droplets and nuclei expelled by

infected individuals are potential carriers of pathogens. Various

studies have investigated the effectiveness of medical-grade face

masks and other personal protective equipment (PPE) in reducing

the possibility of cross-infection via these droplets.13,33,41–47 Notably,

such respiratory barriers do not prove to be completely effective

against extremely fine aerosolized particles, droplets, and nuclei. The

main issue tends to be air leakage, which can result in aerosolized

pathogens being dispersed and suspended in the ambient environment for long periods of time after a coughing/sneezing event has

occurred. A few studies have considered the filtration efficiency of

homemade masks made with different types of fabric;48–51 however,

there is no broad consensus regarding their effectiveness in minimizing disease transmission.52,53 Nonetheless, the evidence suggests

that masks and other face coverings are effective in stopping larger

droplets, which, although fewer in number compared to the smaller

droplets and nuclei, constitute a large fraction of the total volume of

the ejected respiratory fluid.

While detailed quantitative measurements are necessary for the

comprehensive characterization of PPE, qualitative visualizations

can be invaluable for rapid iteration in early design stages, as well

as for demonstrating the proper use of such equipment. Thus, one

of the aims of this Letter is to describe a simple setup for visualization experiments, which can be assembled using easily available

materials. Such setups may be helpful to healthcare professionals,

medical researchers, and industrial manufacturers, for assessing the

effectiveness of face masks and other protective equipment qualitatively. Testing designs quickly and early on can prove to be crucial,

especially in the current pandemic scenario where one of the central

objectives is to reduce the severity of the anticipated resurgence of

infections in the upcoming months.

The visualization setup used in the current

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Response to application from respondents Phil Murphy, et al. — Kevin Robinson, et al., Applicants v. Phil Murphy, Governor of New Jersey, et al. | Frix