Amicus Curiae Brief — Volkswagen Group of America, Inc., et al., Petitioners v. The Environmental Protection Commission of Hillsborough County, Florida, et al.
Supreme Court briefSep 27, 2021
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 20-994
In the Supreme Court of the United States
VOLKSWAGEN GROUP OF AMERICA, INC., ET AL.,
PETITIONERS
v.
THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION COMMISSION OF
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, FLORIDA, ET AL.
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES AS AMICUS CURIAE
BRIAN H. FLETCHER
Acting Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
BRUCE S. GELBER
Deputy Assistant Attorney
General
MALCOLM L. STEWART
Deputy Solicitor General
BENJAMIN W. SNYDER
Assistant to the Solicitor
General
DAVID S. GUALTIERI
Attorney
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530-0001
SupremeCtBriefs@usdoj.gov
(202) 514-2217
QUESTION PRESENTED
Whether the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. 7401 et seq.,
preempts local governments’ claims for civil monetary
penalties under state or local law based on an automobile manufacturer’s tampering with the emissioncontrol systems of in-use vehicles within those governments’ jurisdictions, where that tampering was neither
required by the Clean Air Act nor approved by the Environmental Protection Agency.
(I)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Interest of the United States....................................................... 1
Statement:
A. The Clean Air Act ..................................................... 1
B. Petitioners’ conduct .................................................. 6
C. The proceedings below ............................................. 8
Discussion .................................................................................... 11
I. The Clean Air Act does not preempt respondents’
claims alleging post-sale tampering ............................ 12
A. Section 209(a) does not expressly preempt
respondents’ claims ................................................. 12
B. The Clean Air Act does not impliedly preempt
respondents’ claims ................................................. 18
II. The decision below does not warrant further
review .............................................................................. 22
A. The decision below does not implicate a
substantial conflict of authority ............................. 22
B. This case is an unsuitable vehicle for clarifying
the preemption rules that would apply to state
or local regulation of modifications that EPA
has required or approved ....................................... 23
Conclusion ................................................................................... 25
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases:
Allway Taxi, Inc. v. City of New York,
340 F. Supp. 1120 (S.D.N.Y.), aff ’d,
468 F.2d 624 (2d Cir. 1972) ...................................... 9, 13, 15
Buckman Co. v. Plaintiffs’ Legal Comm.,
531 U.S. 341 (2001).............................................................. 20
Engine Manufacturers Ass’n. v. EPA,
88 F.3d 1075 (D.C. Cir. 1996) ............................................. 13
Engine Manufacturers Ass’n. v. South Coast Air
Quality Management Dist., 541 U.S. 246 (2004) ............ 13
(III)
IV
Cases—Continued:
Page
English v. General Electric Co., 496 U.S. 72 (1990)........... 24
General Motors Corp. v. United States,
496 U.S. 530 (1990)................................................................ 2
Kansas v. Garcia, 140 S. Ct. 791 (2020) .............................. 21
Mutual Pharmaceutical Co. v. Bartlett,
570 U.S. 472 (2013).............................................................. 19
State v. Volkswagen AG, 279 So. 3d 1109
(Ala. 2018) ...................................................................... 22, 23
State ex rel. Slatery v. Volkswagen
Aktiengesellschaft, No. M2018-0079-COA-R9-CV,
2019 WL 1220836 (Tenn. Ct. App. Mar. 13, 2019) ..... 22, 23
State ex rel. Swanson v. Volkswagen
Aktiengesellschaft, No. A18-544, 2018 WL 6273103
(Minn. Ct. App. Dec. 3, 2018) ....................................... 22, 23
State ex rel. Yost v. Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft,
No. 2020-92, 2021 WL 2654338
(Ohio June 29, 2021), petition for cert. pending,
No. 21-312 (Filed Aug. 27, 2021) ........................... 22, 23, 24
Washington v. General Motors Corp.,
406 U.S. 109 (1972)........................................................ 14, 18
Williamson v. Mazda Motor of America, Inc.,
562 U.S. 323 (2011).............................................................. 19
Statutes, regulations, and rule:
Act of Dec. 17, 1963, Pub. L. No. 88-206,
77 Stat. 392 ............................................................................ 1
Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. 7401 et seq. ..................................... 1
Tit I:
42 U.S.C. 7401(a)(3) ..................................................... 5
42 U.S.C. 7416 (§ 116)............................................ 5, 18
Tit. II, 42 U.S.C. 7521-7590 (§§ 202-250) ........................ 2
42 U.S.C. 7521 ............................................................ 18
V
Statutes, regulations, and rule—Continued:
Page
42 U.S.C. 7521(a)(1) (§ 202(a)(1)) ............................... 2
42 U.S.C. 7522(a) (§ 203(a)) ........................................ 5
42 U.S.C. 7522(a)(1) (§ 203(a)(1)) ......................... 2, 18
42 U.S.C. 7522(a)(3)(A) (§ 203(a)(3)(A)) .............. 4, 15
42 U.S.C. 7522(a)(3)(B) (§ 203(a)(3)(B)) ................ 4, 5
42 U.S.C. 7523-7524 ..................................................... 5
42 U.S.C. 7525 (§ 206).................................................. 2
42 U.S.C. 7541(a)(1) ..................................................... 3
42 U.S.C. 7541(b) (§ 207(b)) ........................................ 3
42 U.S.C. 7541(c)(1) ..................................................... 3
42 U.S.C. 7542(a) ......................................................... 3
42 U.S.C. 7543 (§ 209)............................................ 5, 18
42 U.S.C. 7543(a) (§ 209(a)) ............................. passim
42 U.S.C. 7543(b) (§ 209(b)) .................................. 6, 12
42 U.S.C. 7543(d) (§ 209(d)) ........................ 5, 6, 10, 17
42 U.S.C. 7545 (§ 211).................................................. 5
42 U.S.C. 7545(c)(4) ..................................................... 5
42 U.S.C. 7507 .............................................................. 6
42 U.S.C. 7550(3) ................................................... 2, 12
42 U.S.C. 7573 (§ 233).................................................. 5
40 C.F.R.:
Pt. 85:
Subpt. S:
Section 85.1803-85.1804......................................... 3
App. A .................................................................. 3
Subpt. T:
Section 85.1902(d) .................................................. 3
Section 85.1904....................................................... 3
Section 85.1904(b) .................................................. 3
Pt. 86 ................................................................................... 4
Section 86.1805-04 .................................................... 2
VI
Regulations and rule—Continued:
Page
Section 86.1848-01 ....................................................... 2
Rules of the Environmental Protection Commission
of Hillsborough County, Florida (Aug 20, 2012):
Rule 1-8.05(1) ..................................................................... 8
Rule 1-8.05(6) ..................................................................... 8
Utah Admin. Code R307-201-4 (2021) ................................... 8
Sup. Ct. R. 10(a) ..................................................................... 22
Miscellaneous:
EPA:
Office of Air & Waste Management, Mobile
Source Air Pollution Control Advisory Circular No. 2B, Field Fixes Related to Emission
Control-Related Components (Mar. 17, 1975),
https://iaspub.epa.gov/otaqpub/display_file.
jsp?docid=14316&flag=1 ............................... 4, 20, 21
Office of Transportation & Air Quality, Office
of Air & Radiation, Voluntary Emissions
Recall and Voluntary Service Campaign
(Apr. 6, 2015), https://iaspub.epa.gov/otaqpub/
display_file.jsp?docid=34621&flag=1 ................ 20
35 Fed. Reg. 17,288 (Nov. 10, 1970) ..................................... 21
42 Fed. Reg. 28,123 (June 2, 1977) ......................................... 3
46 Fed. Reg. 50,464 (Oct. 13, 1981) ...................................... 21
50 Fed. Reg. 30,960 (July 31, 1985) ................................ 14, 19
51 Fed. Reg. 10,198 (Mar. 25, 1986) ..................................... 19
59 Fed. Reg. 31,306 (June 17, 1994) ..................................... 13
In the Supreme Court of the United States
No. 20-994
VOLKSWAGEN GROUP OF AMERICA, INC., ET AL.,
PETITIONERS
v.
THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION COMMISSION OF
HILLSBOROUGH COUNTY, FLORIDA, ET AL.
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES AS AMICUS CURIAE
INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES
This brief is submitted in response to the Court’s order inviting the Acting Solicitor General to express the
views of the United States. In the view of the United
States, the petition for a writ of certiorari should be denied.
STATEMENT
A. The Clean Air Act
Congress enacted the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. 7401
et seq., to assist state efforts to control air pollution. See
Act of Dec. 17, 1963, Pub. L. No. 88-206, 77 Stat. 392.
(1)
2
The Act has been a paradigmatic example of cooperative federalism, under which “the States and the Federal Government [are] partners in the struggle against
air pollution.” General Motors Corp. v. United States,
496 U.S. 530, 532 (1990).
1. This litigation primarily concerns Title II of the
Act, which governs control of pollution from mobile
sources, including motor vehicles. See 42 U.S.C. 75217590 (§§ 202-250). Generally speaking, Congress gave
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) exclusive
authority to establish emissions standards for new motor vehicles, while encouraging federal, state, and local
regulators to act in concert to address emissions from
in-use vehicles.
a. Section 202(a)(1) of the Act directs EPA to establish “standards applicable to the emission of any air pollutant from * * * new motor vehicles.” 42 U.S.C.
7521(a)(1); see 42 U.S.C. 7550(3) (defining “new motor
vehicle” to mean, subject to an exception not pertinent
here, “a motor vehicle the equitable or legal title to
which has never been transferred to an ultimate purchaser”). The Act establishes several mechanisms
through which EPA can implement those standards.
Under Sections 203(a)(1) and 206, a manufacturer
may not sell a new motor vehicle unless it obtains a “certificate of conformity” reflecting EPA’s determination
that the vehicle will comply with federal emissions
standards throughout its “useful life” (generally 10
years or 120,000 miles for light-duty vehicles). 42
U.S.C. 7522(a)(1), 7525; see 40 C.F.R. 86.1805-04,
86.1848-01. In addition, manufacturers must warrant to
consumers that (inter alia) the vehicle’s emission-control
system is “free from defects in materials and workman-
3
ship which cause such vehicle or engine to fail to conform with applicable regulations for its useful life.” 42
U.S.C. 7541(a)(1).
b. EPA also plays an active role in ensuring vehicles’
continuing compliance with federal emissions standards
throughout their useful lives. Under Section 207(b) of
the Act, EPA has established procedures for testing the
emission-control systems of vehicles in “actual use.” 42
U.S.C. 7541(b). Manufacturers must perform such testing and report the results to EPA. See 42 U.S.C.
7542(a). If EPA determines that a substantial number
of in-use vehicles of a particular model are exceeding
federal emissions standards, EPA may order a mandatory recall. 42 U.S.C. 7541(c)(1). Under a mandatory
recall, the manufacturer must implement an EPAapproved plan to remedy the nonconformity in all
properly maintained and used vehicles. See 40 C.F.R.
85.1803-85.1804 and App. A to Subt. S of Pt. 85; see also
42 U.S.C. 7541(c)(1). Such mandatory recalls are rare;
EPA has not issued one in more than two decades.
EPA regulations separately establish a process for a
voluntary recall “initiated and conducted by a manufacturer to remedy any emission-related defect.” 40
C.F.R. 85.1902(d). More than 800 voluntary recalls
have occurred during the past decade. When initiating
a voluntary recall, a manufacturer must notify EPA
about identified defects and describe the steps the manufacturer will take to correct them. 40 C.F.R. 85.1904.
The manufacturer also must report to EPA about the
recall campaign’s progress. 40 C.F.R. 85.1904(b). Unlike mandatory recall plans, however, “voluntary recall
plans are not subject to EPA approval.” 42 Fed. Reg.
28,123, 28,127 (June 2, 1977).
4
Manufacturers also undertake what are known as
“field fixes,” which are (with rare exceptions) not implemented through EPA’s voluntary-recall program but
serve a similar function. EPA regulations do not address field fixes, but in sub-regulatory guidance issued
in 1975, EPA described an optional “field fix approval
procedure” through which manufacturers could obtain
EPA’s views about planned modifications. Office of Air
& Waste Management, EPA, Mobile Source Air Pollution Control Advisory Circular No. 2B, Field Fixes Related to Emission Control-Related Components 2 (Mar.
17, 1975) (Circular). Informal approval under that process “does not * * * carry the force of law.” Ibid.
Finally, manufacturers may modify the emissioncontrol system for a vehicle line through a “running
change,” which is implemented while vehicles are still in
production. As with voluntary recalls and field fixes,
EPA pre-approval is not required. See 40 C.F.R. Part
86.
Although voluntary recalls, field fixes, and running
changes do not require EPA pre-approval, the Act authorizes EPA to pursue relief if it determines that a
manufacturer—or any other person—has made modifications that impede a vehicle’s emission-control system.
Section 203(a)(3)(A) makes it unlawful for “any person
to remove or render inoperative any device or element
of design” that has been installed in a vehicle to comply
with federal emissions requirements.
42 U.S.C.
7522(a)(3)(A). That prohibition applies both before
“sale and delivery to the ultimate purchaser” and—
where a person acts “knowingly”—“after such sale and
delivery.” Ibid. In addition, Section 203(a)(3)(B) makes
it unlawful knowingly to install a “part or component
* * * a principal effect” of which “is to bypass, defeat,
5
or render inoperative” a vehicle’s emission-control system. 42 U.S.C. 7522(a)(3)(B); see 42 U.S.C. 7523-7524
(authorizing injunctive and monetary relief for violations of Section 203(a)).
2. The Clean Air Act gives States and localities a
substantial role in controlling air pollution. The Act reflects Congress’s view that “air pollution control at its
source is the primary responsibility of States and local
governments.” 42 U.S.C. 7401(a)(3). Section 116 accordingly provides that, in general, “nothing in” the Act
“shall preclude or deny the right of any State or political
subdivision thereof to adopt or enforce * * * requirement[s] respecting control or abatement of air pollution.” 42 U.S.C. 7416. That broad statement is made
subject, however, to provisions in Sections 209, 211, and
233 that expressly “preempt[] certain State regulation
of moving sources.” Ibid. (citing, inter alia, 42 U.S.C.
7543, 7545(c)(4), and 7573).
Section 209 is the only one of those provisions that
addresses motor-vehicle emissions. It provides:
No State or any political subdivision thereof shall
adopt or attempt to enforce any standard relating to
the control of emissions from new motor vehicles or
new motor vehicle engines subject to this part. No
State shall require certification, inspection, or any
other approval relating to the control of emissions
from any new motor vehicle or new motor vehicle engine as condition precedent to the initial retail sale,
titling (if any), or registration of such motor vehicle,
motor vehicle engine, or equipment.
42 U.S.C. 7543(a). Section 209(d) then specifies that
“[n]othing in this part shall preclude or deny to any
State or political subdivision thereof the right otherwise
to control, regulate or restrict the use, operation, or
6
movement of registered or licensed motor vehicles.” 42
U.S.C. 7543(d). 1
B. Petitioners’ Conduct
Petitioners are involved in the manufacture and distribution of motor vehicles for sale and use in the United
States. Beginning in 2006, petitioners developed, and
subsequently installed in their diesel-engine vehicles,
software that would substantially reduce the effectiveness of the vehicles’ emission-control systems at times
when the vehicles were not undergoing emissions testing. Pet. App. 6a-7a. That “defeat device[]” software
allowed the vehicles to appear compliant with federal
emissions standards when tested, but avoided the expense and engineering difficulty of designing engines
that could actually comply with those standards during
ordinary on-road conditions. Ibid. As a result, petitioners’ diesel vehicles substantially exceeded federal emissions standards when driven—in some cases producing
nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions 35 times higher than
the federal limit. Id. at 7a.
Around 2012, petitioners’ diesel-engine vehicles began to experience hardware failures. Pet. App. 8a. Petitioners concluded that the failures likely were occurring because their defeat-device software was not activating as intended, so that emission-control systems
were functioning in “testing” mode even during normal
driving conditions. Ibid. Because the vehicles “were
not designed to comply with NOx emissions standards
Under Section 209(b), EPA may permit California to enforce its
own standards notwithstanding Section 209(a), and other States
may then adopt California’s standards. See 42 U.S.C. 7543(b), 7507.
That provision is not implicated in this case, because neither Florida
nor Utah has adopted California’s standards.
1
7
except during the short periods of testing,” petitioners
suspected that the “increased stress on the exhaust system from being driven too long in compliance with NOx
standards” was causing the failures. Ibid.
To address this problem, petitioners modified their
defeat-device software in two ways. See Pet. App. 8a.
The first caused a vehicle’s emission-control system to
start at reduced effectiveness, switching to its highereffectiveness testing mode only if the system determined that it was undergoing an emissions test. Ibid.;
C.A. E.R. 50. The second improved the vehicle’s ability
to differentiate between testing conditions and ordinary
driving conditions. Pet. App. 8a.
Petitioners used the modified software when manufacturing new vehicles. Pet. App. 8a. They also installed it in existing in-use vehicles, including through a
voluntary recall program in which they deceived both
EPA and vehicle owners about the true purpose and effect of the update. Ibid.
Eventually, EPA learned of the defeat-device software through third-party road testing and an extensive
investigation. See Pet. App. 9a. The federal government subsequently filed civil and criminal charges
against a number of Volkswagen-related entities, including petitioners Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.,
and Porsche Cars North America, Inc., for installing
defeat-device software in approximately 585,000 vehicles between 2009 and 2015, in violation of the Clean Air
Act and other federal laws. Id. at 7a-9a. Those petitioners pleaded guilty to the criminal charges and settled
the civil claims by entering into consent decrees with
the United States. Id. at 9a-10a. The plea agreement
8
and consent decrees did not give petitioners “any protection against prosecution” by state or local governments. Id. at 10a.
C. The Proceedings Below
1. While EPA was pursuing federal charges,
respondents—municipal governments in Florida and
Utah—filed their own suits alleging that petitioners’ actions had violated state and local laws. Respondents’
primary claims sought civil monetary penalties under
anti-tampering laws that specifically address vehicle
emissions. Utah’s anti-tampering regulation states that
“[n]o person shall remove or make inoperable the [emission control] system” of a motor vehicle except to install
an “equally or more effective” control system. Utah Admin. Code R307-201-4 (2021). The Rules of the Environmental Protection Commission (EPC) of Hillsborough County, Florida, provide that “[n]o person
shall tamper, cause, or allow the tampering of the emission control system of any motor vehicle,” nor shall any
person “defeat or render inoperable any component of
a motor vehicle’s emission control system.” EPC Rules
1-8.05(1), (6) (Aug. 20, 2012). See Pet. App. 12a-13a.
In the operative amended complaints, respondents
alleged that petitioners had violated those laws by (1)
installing defeat-device software when manufacturing
new vehicles that were subsequently registered in respondents’ jurisdictions, and (2) installing modified
defeat-device software in vehicles that were already in
use in those jurisdictions. See Pet. App. 53a-54a. The
Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation transferred
respondents’ suits to the United States District Court
for the Northern District of California, which granted
petitioners’ motions to dismiss. Id. at 11a, 47a-87a.
9
a. The district court held that Section 209(a) expressly preempts respondents’ claims concerning presale installation of defeat-device software, because
those claims seek to enforce a “standard relating to the
control of emissions from new motor vehicles,” 42
U.S.C. 7543(a). Pet. App. 61a-64a. Those claims are not
at issue in this Court.
b. With respect to respondents’ claims concerning
petitioners’ post-sale software updates, the district
court held that Section 209(a)’s express-preemption
rule is inapplicable because the vehicles involved “had
already been sold to consumers and were in use within
[respondents’ jurisdictions], not ‘new motor vehicles.’ ”
Pet. App. 65a. The court recognized that, under “the
relation-back concept discussed in” an influential
district-court decision and later “cited favorably by
EPA,” Section 209(a) may preempt some state emissioncontrol measures that apply immediately after a vehicle
is purchased, since such measures could effectively
compel manufacturers to “ensure that their new vehicles complied with [the state or local government’s] inuse control measures.” Id. at 66a (discussing Allway
Taxi, Inc. v. City of New York, 340 F. Supp. 1120
(S.D.N.Y.), aff ’d, 468 F.2d 624 (2d Cir. 1972)). The court
concluded, however, that “the relation-back principle is
not implicated here.” Id. at 67a. The court explained
that respondents “are not attempting to impose emission measures that would require manufacturers to
change the way they construct new vehicles,” but instead “are attempting to prevent manufacturers from
tampering with their vehicles after the vehicles are
sold.” Ibid.; see id. at 64a-67a.
10
Although the district court held that Section 209(a)
does not expressly preempt respondents’ claims alleging post-sale tampering, it concluded that the Clean Air
Act as a whole impliedly preempts those claims. The
court acknowledged that States and localities can enforce emissions standards “on an individual vehicle basis at the end-user level.” Pet. App. 73a. The court concluded, however, that the Act reflects Congress’s intent
that “only EPA” will regulate “post-sale software
changes” made “on a model-wide basis.” Id. at 82a-83a;
see id. at 67a-87a.
2. The court of appeals affirmed in part and reversed in part. Pet. App. 1a-46a.
Like the district court, the court of appeals held that
Section 209(a) expressly preempts the claims related to
new vehicles, but not those related to in-use vehicles.
See Pet. App. 28a-31a. The court concluded that, because Section 209(a) addresses only “state and local regulations ‘relating to the control of emissions from new
motor vehicles,’ ” that provision “clearly does not”
preempt all application of anti-tampering rules “as applied to post-sale vehicles.” Id. at 30a (citation omitted).
The court found Allway Taxi’s relation-back principle
to be inapposite because respondents’ claims of postsale tampering would neither require “compl[iance]
with a local emission standard that is different from the
federal standard,” nor “effectively require car manufacturers to alter their manufacture of new vehicles before
sale.” Id. at 31a.
The court of appeals reversed the district court’s
implied-preemption holding, however, concluding that
respondents’ claims alleging post-sale tampering can go
forward. See Pet. App. 31a-46a. The court emphasized
that Section 209(d) explicitly preserves certain state
11
and local authority over post-sale vehicles, and it found
no evidence in the Act that Congress intended to displace the anti-tampering laws in effect in numerous
States and municipalities. See id. at 32a-35a.
The court of appeals denied rehearing and rehearing
en banc without recorded dissent. Pet. App. 88a-89a.
DISCUSSION
The court of appeals correctly held that the Clean
Air Act does not preempt respondents’ civil-monetarypenalty claims alleging post-sale tampering with the
emission-control systems of in-use vehicles. That holding does not warrant further review.
No appellate court has accepted petitioners’ primary
argument (Pet. 24-31) that Section 209(a) expressly
preempts claims like those at issue here. Although petitioners accurately identify a conflict with respect to
their claim of implied preemption, that shallow conflict
is unlikely to deepen—and may even resolve itself—in
light of the court of appeals’ persuasive opinion in this
case. Petitioners speculate that States or municipalities
might seek to hold manufacturers liable for software
updates that EPA has ordered or approved. But because EPA never directed or approved the updates at
issue here, this case would be an unsuitable vehicle for
clarifying the preemption rules that would apply in the
circumstances that petitioners posit. The petition for a
writ of certiorari should be denied.
12
I. THE CLEAN AIR ACT
RESPONDENTS’ CLAIMS
TAMPERING
DOES NOT PREEMPT
ALLEGING POST-SALE
A. Section 209(a) Does Not Expressly Preempt Respondents’
Claims
1. Section 209(a) of the Clean Air Act expressly
preempts state and local adoption or enforcement of
“any standard relating to the control of emissions from
new motor vehicles.” 42 U.S.C. 7543(a); see 42 U.S.C.
7543(b) (describing exception for standards established
by California); p. 6 n. 1, supra. That provision ensures
that newly manufactured vehicles that comply with federal emissions standards may be sold throughout the
United States without the need for State-by-State or
locality-by-locality customization. But as every appellate court to address the question has correctly held,
Section 209(a) does not bar States and localities from
imposing civil penalties for post-sale changes that reduce the effectiveness of emission-control systems in
vehicles that are already in use.
By preempting “standard[s] relating to the control
of emissions from new motor vehicles,” 42 U.S.C.
7543(a), Section 209(a) prevents interference with the
federal government’s responsibility for setting emissions standards applicable to motor vehicles that have
not yet been “transferred to an ultimate purchaser.” 42
U.S.C. 7550(3) (defining “new motor vehicle”). Because
Section 209(a) refers to standards “relating to the control of emissions from new motor vehicles,” 42 U.S.C.
7543(a) (emphasis added), its preemptive effect also extends beyond explicit regulation of conduct that precedes a vehicle’s initial sale.
13
For example, EPA and the courts have long recognized that Section 209(a) prevents a State from “impos[ing] its own emission control standards the moment
after a new car is bought and registered.” Allway Taxi,
Inc. v. City of New York, 340 F. Supp. 1120, 1124
(S.D.N.Y.), aff ’d, 468 F.2d 624 (2d Cir. 1972); see 59
Fed. Reg. 31,306, 31,330 (June 17, 1994) (“EPA expects
that the principles articulated in Allway Taxi will be applied by the courts to any State adoption of in-use controls.”); Engine Manufacturers Ass’n v. EPA, 88 F.3d
1075, 1086 & n. 39 (D.C. Cir. 1996) (endorsing Allway
Taxi rationale). Although such state regulation would
formally govern post-sale conduct, it would have an evident practical tendency to alter manufacturers’ choices
regarding the emission-control systems they install in
new motor vehicles. Cf. Engine Manufacturers Ass’n
v. South Coast Air Quality Management Dist., 541 U.S.
246, 254 (2004) (holding that Section 209(a) preempts
certain state rules that would pressure manufacturers
to change the design of new engines even when “not enforced through manufacturer-directed regulation”).
Section 209(a) likewise prohibits States and municipalities from implementing “recall programs” that require manufacturers to modify the “original manufacture of the engine” of an in-use vehicle. 59 Fed. Reg. at
31,330 n.28. Although such regulations “may be characterized as ‘in-use’ regulations,” they are preempted
because “they are effectively regulations on the design
of new engines rather than on the use of ‘in-use’ engines.” Id. at 31,331.
Section 209(a) generally does not, however, preempt
state or local laws that prohibit tampering with the
existing emission-control systems of in-use vehicles.
Respondents’ claims for monetary penalties based on
14
petitioners’ post-sale tampering do not “relat[e] to the
control of emissions from new motor vehicles,” 42
U.S.C. 7543(a), because they do not require petitioners—
either expressly or practically—to modify the design or
emission-control features of new vehicles. See Pet.
App. 31a. Instead, they come within what this Court
has described as the States’ “broad residual power over
used motor vehicles.” Washington v. General Motors
Corp., 406 U.S. 109, 115 n.4 (1972); see ibid. (observing
that States retain this power “[b]ecause federal motor
vehicle emission control standards apply only to new
motor vehicles”).
The fact that anti-tampering laws sometimes treat a
vehicle’s pre-sale design as a baseline from which future
modifications are judged (see Pet. 27) does not change
that conclusion. Since every in-use vehicle was once
new, every regulation of in-use vehicles’ emissions has
some connection to the emission-control features of a
new vehicle. Congress presumably intended, however,
that Section 209(a)’s specific reference to “new motor
vehicles” would meaningfully limit the provision’s preemptive scope. Use of a vehicle’s original emissions
equipment as a benchmark, to determine whether unlawful post-sale tampering has occurred, takes the manufacturer’s choice of new-vehicle emission-control equipment
as given and therefore is unlikely to affect that choice.
And if use of new-vehicle emissions equipment as a
baseline were sufficient to trigger Section 209(a), States
and municipalities could not apply their anti-tampering
laws even to vehicle owners or mechanics who modify
factory-installed emission-control systems. Petitioners
acknowledge, however, that the Act does not preempt
enforcement of state or local law in such cases. See Pet.
27; see also 50 Fed. Reg. 30,960, 30,961 (July 31, 1985)
15
(expressing EPA approval of an Indiana anti-tampering
law prohibiting any person from disabling “any emission control system installed by the manufacturer”).
2. Contrary to petitioners’ contentions (Pet. 25-27),
Section 209(a) does not establish a special preemption
rule for manufacturers. Neither Section 209(a) itself,
nor any other Clean Air Act provision, suggests that the
express-preemption inquiry—i.e., the determination
whether a state or local anti-tampering rule “relat[es]
to the control of emissions from new motor vehicles,” 42
U.S.C. 7543(a)—turns on the identity of the alleged
tamperer. The Act’s own anti-tampering provision
groups all potential violators together, making it unlawful for “any person” to tamper with an emission-control
system. 42 U.S.C. 7522(a)(3)(A). There is no textual
basis for reading Section 209(a) to confer a broad,
manufacturer-specific immunity from otherwise valid
state and local anti-tampering laws.
Petitioners’ reliance (Pet. 25-26) on Allway Taxi is
misplaced. The Allway Taxi court correctly explained
that, while States and localities may not enforce their
“own emission control standards the moment after a
new car is bought and registered,” they are generally
free to adopt emissions rules that apply to vehicles at a
later point, such as “upon the resale or reregistration of
the automobile.” 340 F. Supp. at 1124. The court observed that, in that context, “the burden of compliance”
with permissible standards generally “would be on individual owners and not on manufacturers and distributors.” Ibid. But the court in Allway Taxi did not state
—and the Act cannot reasonably be read to mean—that
manufacturers are categorically exempt from otherwise
valid state and local emissions regulations.
16
3. Petitioners contend (Pet. 27) that respondents’
claims are preempted because they “rest on the fact
that, as manufactured, the vehicles violated EPA
standards.” That argument is based (ibid.) on the
premise that petitioners’ “post-sale updates reduced
emissions,” so that the updates’ only deficiency was
their failure to reduce emissions by “enough to comply
with the [federal] emissions standards.”
That premise, however, contradicts the allegations of
the operative complaints, which must be taken as true
at this stage of the case. While petitioners assert that
their modifications partially reduced emissions, the
complaints allege that petitioners’ post-sale tampering
had the opposite effect. See Pet. App. 65a (district court
explains that “[respondents’] allegations support that
the post-sale software changes increased emissions”);
C.A. E.R. 96, ¶ 88; id. at 125, ¶ 42. And in connection
with the federal criminal guilty plea, Volkswagen
acknowledged that the post-sale updates “improve[d]
the defeat device’s precision in order to reduce the
stress on the emissions control systems,” meaning that
the changes allowed those emission-control systems to
operate at reduced capacity (i.e., not in compliance with
federal emissions standards) more than the factoryinstalled software had. C.A. E.R. 51. 2 Accordingly, even
assuming that Section 209(a) would preempt anti-
Petitioners point to a statement by the government that regulators found “a ‘limited reduction in the rates of emissions of NOx’ ” in
the modified vehicles. Pet. 27 (citation omitted). That statement,
however, reflected in part the preliminary results of tests that petitioners’ software was designed to circumvent. The government has
never determined that petitioners’ post-sale modifications actually
reduced real-world emissions from their vehicles.
2
17
tampering claims that depended on showing deficiencies in a vehicle’s pre-sale design, respondents’ claims
cannot be dismissed on that basis.
4. Petitioners argue (Pet. 28-31) that the court of appeals misconstrued Section 209(d), which states that
“[n]othing in this part shall preclude or deny to any
State or political subdivision thereof the right otherwise
to control, regulate, or restrict the use, operation, or
movement of registered or licensed motor vehicles.” 42
U.S.C. 7543(d). The court appeared to read that provision broadly, as extending beyond a driver’s “operation”
of a vehicle on the roads to encompass the way in which
the vehicle’s emission-control system functions. See
Pet. App. 24a-25a. We agree with petitioners that Section 209(d) does not authorize States to impose post-sale
emissions standards that would have the practical effect
of compelling manufactures to modify the original design of their vehicles. See pp. 12-13, supra; see also Pet.
29 (identifying narrower definitions of “operation”).
Other aspects of the court of appeals’ opinion, however, suggest that the court would not read Section
209(d) in that expansive manner. See Pet. App. 30a-31a
(discussing “the leading case of Allway Taxi,” and emphasizing that respondents’ anti-tampering rules do not
“impose a standard that would effectively require car
manufacturers to alter their manufacture of new vehicles before sale”). In any event, because Section 209(a)
by its own terms does not preempt respondents’ claims
based on modifications that allegedly increased emissions from in-use vehicles, the court of appeals’ reading
of Section 209(d) was unnecessary to its resolution of
the express-preemption issue in this case. Indeed, the
court did not cite Section 209(d) in addressing that issue. See ibid.
18
B. The Clean Air Act Does Not Impliedly Preempt
Respondents’ Claims
The district court held (Pet. App. 67a-87a), and petitioners continue to assert (Pet. 31-34), that the Clean
Air Act impliedly preempts respondents’ claims. That
argument lacks merit.
1. The text and structure of the Clean Air Act do not
reflect congressional intent broadly to displace state
and local anti-tampering laws. See Pet. App. 31a-36a.
On the contrary, most applications of such laws are consistent with the regime of cooperative federalism that
the Act establishes, under which the federal government possesses generally exclusive authority to regulate “new” motor vehicles but States retain “broad residual power over used motor vehicles.” General Motors Corp., 406 U.S. at 115 n.4.
Section 116 of the Act preserves “the right of any
State or political subdivision thereof to adopt or enforce
* * * requirement[s] respecting control or abatement
of air pollution,” except where doing so would be inconsistent with other provisions of the Act. 42 U.S.C. 7416;
see ibid. (citing, inter alia, Section 209 of the Act, 42
U.S.C. 7543). Respondents’ claims for civil monetary
penalties would not give rise to any such inconsistencies. Because those claims do not seek to enforce
“standard[s] relating to the control of emissions from
new motor vehicles,” they are not inconsistent with Section 209(a). 42 U.S.C. 7543(a); see pp. 12-17, supra. And
by discouraging manufacturers from disabling emissioncontrol systems that were necessary to obtain pre-sale
EPA certificates of conformity, claims like respondents’
can further Congress’s purpose of limiting vehicles’
emissions throughout their useful lives. See 42 U.S.C.
7521, 7522(a)(1).
19
EPA accordingly has long maintained that a “State
or local government is free to adopt and enforce an antitampering law on its own, if it feels that such a law
would contribute to reducing motor vehicle emissions.”
51 Fed. Reg. 10,198, 10,206 (Mar. 25, 1986); see 50 Fed.
Reg. at 30,961. EPA’s view that such laws generally do
not undermine the Clean Air Act’s objectives “should
make a difference” in a court’s preemption analysis.
Williamson v. Mazda Motor of America, Inc., 562 U.S.
323, 335 (2011) (citation omitted). That is particularly
true here, where petitioners have identified no instance
in which a state or local anti-tampering law has obstructed the Act’s proper operation, even though such
laws exist in “the vast majority of states.” Pet. App.
33a. The agency’s informed judgment that federal,
state, and local enforcement efforts can beneficially coexist, combined with petitioners’ inability to identify
concrete examples of past conflicts, weighs strongly
against a finding of implied preemption here.
2. Petitioners’ contrary argument (Pet. 31-34; Reply
Br. 11-12) rests principally on their assertion that state
and local anti-tampering claims are likely to obstruct
EPA’s regulation of manufacturers’ post-sale conduct.
No such obstruction has occurred in the past or exists
in the circumstances of this case, however, and any future conflicts can appropriately be addressed on a caseby-case basis if and when they arise.
Petitioners do not contend that it would have been
“impossible” in this case “to comply with both state and
federal requirements.” Mutual Pharmaceutical Co. v.
Bartlett, 570 U.S. 472, 480 (2013) (citation omitted). Far
from being required by the Clean Air Act, the post-sale
modifications alleged here would violate the Act and
other federal laws. Petitioners could have complied
20
with federal, state, and local anti-tampering laws simply
by not making those modifications.
This case likewise does not involve state or local attempts to impose liability for “EPA-approved updates.”
Pet. 5. EPA has suggested that it is “prudent” for manufacturers to “consult with [EPA] prior to initiating a
voluntary emissions recall * * * to avoid EPA raising
concerns after the campaign has been released”; but
“[t]he regulations do not require a manufacturer to
get EPA approval,” and petitioners did not do so here.
Office of Transportation & Air Quality, Office of Air &
Radiation, EPA, Voluntary Emissions Recall and Voluntary Service Campaign (Apr. 6, 2015). Nor do petitioners claim to have pursued the “field fix approval
procedure” described in EPA’s 1975 Circular. Circular
2; cf. Pet. 19 (asserting that “respondents’ theory would
permit them to challenge even EPA-approved updates,”
but not contending that this case involves such a challenge).
Thus, while state or local anti-tampering claims
based on EPA-required or EPA-approved modifications likely would be preempted in at least some circumstances, this case does not involve any such interference
with EPA regulatory or enforcement activities. And because petitioners never obtained EPA approval of the
modifications at issue, there is likewise no basis for petitioners’ characterization of respondents’ claims as depending upon “fraud on EPA.” Pet. 34 (discussing
Buckman Co. v. Plaintiffs’ Legal Comm., 531 U.S. 341
(2001)).
Under current EPA practice, moreover, no substantial number of conflicts between EPA-approved modifications and state or local anti-tampering laws is likely
21
to arise. When it issued the 1975 Circular on which petitioners and their amici focus (Pet. 10; Alliance for Automotive Innovation Br. 13-14), EPA stated that it
would generally “treat requests for approval of field
fixes in the same manner that running changes are
treated.” Circular 2. At that time, EPA regulations established a procedure for mandatory EPA pre-approval
of running changes. See 35 Fed. Reg. 17,288, 17,293
(Nov. 10, 1970). In 1981, however, EPA revised those
rules to allow manufacturers to “implement running
changes without prior EPA approval,” 46 Fed. Reg.
50,464, 50,465 (Oct. 13, 1981), and EPA regulations no
longer establish a process for agency pre-approval of
running changes. As a result, EPA currently has no formal procedure by which manufacturers may request
pre-approval for field fixes either, and no regular practice of providing such pre-approvals exists.
3. Petitioners contend (Pet. 32-34) that allowing
state and local penalty claims will make it harder for
EPA to negotiate settlements with manufacturers and
will prevent EPA from setting the maximum civil penalties those manufacturers might face. That possibility
is always present, however, when federal, state, and local governments share overlapping regulatory authority, and “the possibility that federal enforcement priorities might be upset is not enough to provide a basis for
preemption.” Kansas v. Garcia, 140 S. Ct. 791, 807
(2020). The possibility of follow-on state or local suits is
equally present in federal anti-tampering cases against
mechanics or consumers, yet petitioners acknowledge
(Pet. 27) that such suits are consistent with the Clean
Air Act. Petitioners identify no persuasive reason for
treating manufacturers differently.
22
II. THE DECISION BELOW
FURTHER REVIEW
DOES
NOT
WARRANT
Although the decision below implicates a shallow
conflict of authority, that conflict does not warrant this
Court’s review. And while petitioners identify circumstances in which state or local regulation of vehicle updates might impede EPA’s enforcement of the Clean
Air Act, those circumstances are not present here.
A. The Decision Below Does Not Implicate A Substantial
Conflict Of Authority
Petitioners’ primary argument on the merits (see
Pet. 22-31) is that Section 209(a) expressly preempts respondents’ claims. Every appellate court to have addressed that argument has rejected it. See Pet. App.
30a-31a; State v. Volkswagen AG, 279 So. 3d 1109, 1119
(Ala. 2018) (Alabama); State ex rel. Swanson v.
Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, No. A18-544, 2018 WL
6273103, at *6 (Minn. Ct. App. Dec. 3, 2018) (Minnesota); State ex rel. Yost v. Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, No. 2020-92, 2021 WL 2654338, at *3-*5 (Ohio
June 29, 2021) (Ohio), petition for cert. pending, No. 21312 (filed Aug. 27, 2021); State ex rel. Slatery v.
Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft, No. M2018-00791COA-R9-CV, 2019 WL 1220836, at *10 (Tenn. Ct. App.
Mar. 13, 2019) (Tennessee).
Petitioners identify a conflict of authority only on
their implied-preemption argument. As to that issue,
they correctly observe (Pet. 14) that the decision below
conflicts with the decision of one “state court of last resort,” Sup. Ct. R. 10(a), a 2018 decision of the Alabama
Supreme Court.
That shallow conflict does not warrant this Court’s
review. The Alabama Supreme Court offered essentially no independent analysis of the implied-preemption
23
question, instead relying on an eight-page block quotation from the opinion of the district court in this case.
See Alabama, 279 So. 3d at 1121-1129. In light of the
court of appeals’ subsequent decision rejecting the district court’s analysis, the Alabama Supreme Court may
reconsider the issue if it arises in a future case. Other
state courts—including in Minnesota and Tennessee,
where the issue has previously been addressed only in
unpublished decisions by intermediate appellate
courts—may also follow the court of appeals’ analysis,
as the Ohio Supreme Court did in the most recent decision to address the issue. See Ohio, 2021 WL 2654338,
at *5-*7; see also Minnesota, 2018 WL 6273103, at *6*10; Tennessee, 2019 WL 1220836, at *10-*14.
B. This Case Is An Unsuitable Vehicle For Clarifying The
Preemption Rules That Would Apply To State Or Local
Regulation Of Modifications That EPA Has Required
Or Approved
Petitioners predict (Pet. 4) that enforcement of state
and local anti-tampering laws against manufacturers
will interfere with EPA determinations about, for example, modifications that would reduce emissions of one
pollutant but increase emissions of another, or settlements that bring in-use vehicles into only partial compliance with federal standards. They assert (Pet. 19)
that in Ohio, supra, the State “claimed that it has” authority “to challenge even EPA-approved updates”; and
they contend (Pet. 21) that in Environmental Protection Commission of Hillsborough County v. MercedesBenz USA, LLC, No. 20-cv-2238 (M.D. Fla.), the plaintiff municipality has sought injunctive relief that could
potentially conflict with an EPA consent decree.
24
The United States takes no position here on the
proper result in those particular cases. It agrees, however, that efforts to punish conduct that EPA has
deemed necessary or appropriate under the Clean Air
Act, or to obtain injunctive relief that conflicts with or
impairs the effectiveness of an existing EPA settlement, might well be preempted. Such claims could
“stand[] as an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the full purposes and objectives of Congress,”
English v. General Electric Co., 496 U.S. 72, 79 (1990)
(citation omitted), or could relate back to the control of
emissions from new vehicles in a way that would trigger
express preemption under Section 209(a). As discussed
above, pp. 19-20, supra, however, this case involves no
such conflicts. Far from seeking to punish conduct that
EPA required or approved, respondents’ claims are
based on post-sale modifications designed to violate the
Clean Air Act.
Nor is it clear that the Court will ever need to clarify
the preemption rules that would apply if manufacturers
were subjected to state- or local-law liability for conduct
that EPA had mandated or approved. Petitioners point
only to legal arguments that litigants in other cases
have raised; they identify no court that has actually
granted relief of the sort they hypothesize. Indeed, the
Ohio Supreme Court emphasized that its decision
should not be understood as permitting relief “for actions taken in response to EPA guidelines or for modifications approved by the EPA.” Ohio, 2021 WL
2654338, at *5. Other courts can likewise be expected
to restrain overreaching claims. If they do not, this
Court may choose to grant review in a future case that
actually involves the sort of conflict that petitioners
posit.
25
CONCLUSION
The petition for a writ of certiorari should be denied.
Respectfully submitted.
BRIAN H. FLETCHER
Acting Solicitor General
BRUCE S. GELBER
Deputy Assistant Attorney
General
MALCOLM L. STEWART
Deputy Solicitor General
BENJAMIN W. SNYDER
Assistant to the Solicitor
General
DAVID S. GUALTIERI
Attorney
SEPTEMBER 2021
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.