Amicus Curiae Brief — HollyFrontier Cheyenne Refining, LLC, et al., Petitioners v. Renewable Fuels Association, et al.
Supreme Court briefMar 31, 2021
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Nos. 20-472
In the Supreme Court of the United States
_____________________________
HOLLYFRONTIER CHEYENNE REFINING, LLC, ET AL.,
Petitioners,
v.
RENEWABLE FUELS ASSOCIATION, ET AL.,
Respondents.
_____________________________
On Writ of Certiorari to the United States
Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit
______________________________
BRIEF FOR THE STATES OF IOWA,
NEBRASKA, ILLINOIS, MICHIGAN,
MINNESOTA, OREGON, SOUTH DAKOTA,
AND VIRGINIA AS AMICI CURIAE
SUPPORTING RESPONDENTS
______________________________
DOUGLAS J. PETERSON
THOMAS J. MILLER
Attorney General of
Nebraska
JEFFREY THOMPSON
JAMES A. CAMPBELL
Solicitor General
JUSTIN D. LAVENE
JOSHUA E. DETHLEFSEN
Assistant Attorneys
General
2115 State Capitol
Lincoln, NE 68509
(402) 471-2682
Attorney General of Iowa
Solicitor General
SAMUEL P. LANGHOLZ
Assistant Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
1305 E. Walnut
Des Moines, Iowa 50319
(515) 281-5164
sam.langholz@ag.iowa.gov
(Additional counsel on signature page)
i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ...................................... ii
INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE ............................... 1
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT.................................... 1
ARGUMENT .............................................................. 5
I.
Authorizing the unfettered granting of new
small-refinery exemptions would gut the
Renewable Fuel Standard. .................................. 5
II. Petitioners’ broad interpretation would cause
substantial economic harm to the rural
economies of many States. ................................ 11
III. An ineffective Renewable Fuel Standard
would harm the environment and efforts to
obtain energy independence. ............................ 14
CONCLUSION ......................................................... 18
APPENDIX—Ethanol and Biodiesel Production
Facilities in the States ...................................... 1a
ii
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases
Ams. for Clean Energy v. EPA,
864 F.3d 691 (D.C. Cir. 2017) .................. 5, 6, 8, 14
Conn. Nat’l Bank v. Germain,
503 U.S. 249 (1992) ................................................ 2
United States v. Great N. Ry. Co.,
287 U.S. 144 (1932) ............................................ 3, 4
Statutes
42 U.S.C. § 7545(o) ..................................................... 5
42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(3)(B)(i) ........................................ 5
42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(5) ................................................ 6
42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(9)(A) ........................................... 2
42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(9)(B) ........................................... 1
Energy Independence & Security Act,
Pub. L. No. 110-140, 121 Stat. 1492 (2007) ..... 5, 14
Minn. Stat. ch. 216H ................................................ 15
Regulations
40 C.F.R. §§ 80.1425-29 ............................................. 6
EPA Regulation of Fuels and Fuel Additives:
2011 Renewable Fuel Standards,
75 Fed. Reg. 76790 (Dec. 9, 2010) .......................... 6
Other Authorities
Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading
Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts (2012) ...... 2
iii
Background on Renewable Identification
Numbers Under the Renewable Fuel Standard:
Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Energy &
Commerce Subcomm. on Environment, 115th
Cong. (2018) (statement of Gabriel E. Lade,
Assistant Professor, Center for Agricultural &
Rural Development, Iowa State University) ......... 9
Donnelle Eller, Poet Writes an End to Crop
Residue Ethanol: S.D. Firm Says Feds Failed
to Give Effort Full Support, Des Moines Reg.,
Nov. 20, 2019, at A1-2 .......................................... 11
Jan Lewandrowski et al., The Green-house Gas
Benefits of Corn Ethanol – Assessing Recent
Evidence, 10 Biofuels 361 (2019) ......................... 14
John M. Urbanchuk, Contribution of the Ethanol
Industry to the Economy of the United States
in 2020 (Feb. 2, 2021) ........................................... 13
John M. Urbanchuk, Contribution of the
Renewable Fuels Industry to the Economy of
Iowa (Jan. 28, 2021) ............................................. 12
Jonathan Coppess & Scott Irwin, EPA and the
Small Refinery Exemption Issue in the
Renewable Fuel Standard Mandates,
farmdoc daily, Dep’t of Agric. & Consumer
Econ., Univ. of Ill. at Urbana-Champaign,
Mar. 12, 2020 ................................................ 8, 9, 10
Kathleen Brooks et al., Economic Impacts of the
Nebraska Ethanol and Ethanol Co-Products
Industry 2015-2017 (2019) ................................... 12
iv
Ken Ditzel et al., The Biodiesel Industry: Impacts
on the Economy, Environment and Energy
Security (2018) ...................................................... 13
Letter from Kim Reynolds, Governor of Iowa, to
Andrew Wheeler, EPA Administrator
(Nov. 7, 2019) .................................................. 11, 12
Marc Chupka et al., Blending In: The Role of
Renewable Fuel in Achieving Policy Goals
(2017) .................................................................... 17
Michael Wang et al., Well-to-Wheels Energy Use
and Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Ethanol
from Corn, Sugarcane and Cellulosic Biomass
for US Use, Envtl. Res. Letters 7 (2012) ............. 14
Minn. Dep’t of Agric., Minnesota Biodiesel
Industry Economic Impact (2017) ........................ 13
Minn. Dep’t of Transp., Pathways to
Decarbonizing Transportation in Minnesota
(2019) .............................................................. 15, 16
Minn. Office of the Leg. Auditor, Evaluation
Report, Biofuel Policies and Programs (2009) ..... 15
Protecting the RFS: The Trump Administration’s
Abuse of Secret Waivers: Hearing before H.
Comm. On Energy & Commerce Subcomm. on
Environment & Climate Change, 116th Cong.
(2019) (statement of Geoff Cooper, President
& CEO, Renewable Fuels Ass’n) .................... 11, 12
Renewable Fuels Association, Essential Energy:
2021 Ethanol Industry Outlook (2021) ................ 4a
v
Scott Irwin, Clearing the Logjam on the RFS and
SREs: A Simple Proposal, farmdoc daily, Dep’t
of Agric. & Consumer Econ., Univ. of Ill. at
Urbana-Champaign, Sept. 19, 2019 .............. 6, 7, 8
Scott Irwin, Small Refinery Exemptions and
Biomass-Based Diesel Demand Destruction,
farmdoc daily, Dep’t of Agric. & Consumer
Econ., Univ. of Ill. at Urbana-Champaign,
March 14, 2019 ....................................................... 7
U.S. Biodiesel Plants, Biodiesel Magazine,
https://perma.cc/3jjj-sh28 ..................................... 4a
U.S. Dep’t of Energy, Biodiesel Vehicle
Emissions, Alternative Fuels Data Center ......... 15
U.S. Energy Info. Admin., How Much Oil
Consumed by the United States Comes from
Foreign Countries?, https://www.eia.gov/tools/
faqs/faq.php?id=32&t=6 ....................................... 17
U.S. Energy Info. Admin., March 2021 Monthly
Energy Review (2021) ........................................... 17
U.S. EPA, RFS Small Refinery Exemptions,
https://www.epa.gov/fuels-registrationreporting-and-compliance-help/rfs-small-ref
inery-exemptions .................................................... 7
1
INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE
The renewable fuel and agricultural industries are
the cornerstone of the economies of many States,
including Iowa and Nebraska. These industries—and
the rural economies that they anchor—have grown
over the past 16 years in reliance on the promise of
the Renewable Fuel Standard (“RFS”). And all States
have an interest in the environmental benefits and
energy independence that the RFS promises to
achieve.
But the Environmental Protection Agency’s recent
trend of freely granting small-refinery exemptions
has undermined these promises. This case presents
the opportunity to affirm the limited authority of the
EPA under the plain language of 42 U.S.C.
§ 7545(o)(9)(B) to grant small-refinery exemptions
only to refiners that have previously received and
continuously held the exemption. And the amici
States urge this Court to use this opportunity to
secure the intended promises of the RFS rather than
permanently break them.
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT
The Tenth Circuit got it right. The EPA’s authority
under 42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(9)(B) is limited to granting
“an extension” of the small-refinery exemption to a
refinery that previously received and continuously
held the exemption. This interpretation reflects the
ordinary meaning of “extension,” which requires an
existing subject to be extended or prolonged. And it
fits in the broader statutory context.
The statute is structured not as an independent
exemption for economic hardship, but as “an
2
extension of the exemption under subparagraph (A).”
42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(9)(B). And that subparagraph
creates a blanket “[t]emporary exemption” for small
refineries until 2011 that could be extended another
two or more years based on a study of the effect of the
RFS on small refineries. 42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(9)(A).
The Tenth Circuit properly reasoned that unless a
refinery has continuously sought and received
extensions since the initial exemption ended, there
would be nothing for the EPA to extend.
This should be the beginning and the end of the
analysis. See Conn. Nat’l Bank v. Germain, 503 U.S.
249, 253 (1992) (“We have stated time and again that
courts must presume that a legislature says in a
statute what it means and means in a statute what it
says there. When the words of a statute are
unambiguous, then, this first canon is also the last:
judicial inquiry is complete.” (cleaned up)); see also
Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The
Interpretation of Legal Texts 56 (2012) (“The words of
a governing text are of paramount concern, and what
they convey, in their context, is what the text
means.”).
But Petitioners and their amici invite this Court
to venture further. They argue that Congress could
not have intended this plain meaning of the statute
because it would foreclose most small refineries from
now obtaining the exemption. And without the
exemption, they contend, small refineries could not
remain in business. Pet. Br. 39-46; Wyo. et al. Amici
Br. 14-25; Small Ref. Coal. Amicus Br. 20-29; AFPM
Amicus Br. 17-27; CountryMark Amicus Br. 17-19.
3
These alleged harms to small refineries under the
plain-language interpretation, however, are only a
small part of the economic terrain surrounding the
RFS. If this Court accepts the invitation to “travel[],
in . . . search for the meaning of the lawmakers,
beyond the borders of the statute,” it should do so with
a more complete tour of the landscape. United States
v. Great N. Ry. Co., 287 U.S. 144, 154 (1932).
The expansive interpretation of the small-refinery
exemption advanced by Petitioners has the practical
effect of cutting the renewable fuel mandates
significantly below the levels required by statute.
This guts the RFS, rendering it ineffective in creating
demand for renewable fuel. And without the demand
created by the RFS, the renewable fuel industry will
continue to suffer substantial economic harm.
This harm is not hypothetical. Over the past few
years, we have seen the direct effects of the EPA’s
unfettered granting of small-refinery exemptions. For
compliance years 2016 through 2018, these
exemptions reduced the RFS mandate by an average
of 7% each year—causing more than $2 billion in lost
demand for renewable fuel each year. Renewable fuel
plants have been slowed, idled, and shuttered. And if
the gates are thrown open for all small refineries to
be granted exemptions anew—even though they have
previously complied with the RFS—the reduction
could be even more drastic.
Because the renewable fuel industry anchors
many rural economies, the harms inflicted by
reversing the Tenth’s Circuit decision would ripple
out to devastating effect on rural communities and
States.
4
A gutted RFS also harms the environment and our
nation’s energy independence efforts. Growing
evidence shows that corn ethanol has greenhouse gas
and air pollution emissions significantly below
petroleum gasoline. Biodiesel likewise reduces carbon
dioxide emissions substantially compared to
petroleum diesel over its life cycle. Some States have
thus developed state-level plans for reducing carbon
emissions and improving air quality that rely on
increasing use of renewable fuels as an attainable
near-term approach. And aside from these
environmental benefits, every gallon of new capacity
to produce renewable fuel is many future gallons of
petroleum-based fuel that we will not need to import.
But without the predictable RFS mandate to drive
demand, fewer investments are made to reap these
benefits.
All these negative effects undermine the purpose
of the RFS. And thus a full survey of the landscape
“beyond the borders of the statute,” Great N. Ry. Co.,
287 U.S. at 154, supports the plain meaning of the
statute—not Petitioners’ expansive interpretation.
The Tenth Circuit’s decision should be affirmed.
5
ARGUMENT
I.
Authorizing the unfettered granting of new
small-refinery exemptions would gut the
Renewable Fuel Standard.
Congress and the President enacted the RFS
Program “to ‘move the United States toward greater
energy independence and security’ and ‘increase the
production of clean renewable fuels.’” Ams. for Clean
Energy v. EPA, 864 F.3d 691, 697 (D.C. Cir. 2017)
(Kavanaugh, J.) (quoting Energy Independence &
Security Act, Pub. L. No. 110-140, preamble, 121 Stat.
1492, 1492 (2007)). The RFS accomplishes these goals
by requiring gradually increasing sales of renewable
fuels in place of crude oil fuel in the United States.
See 42 U.S.C. § 7545(o). “By requiring upstream
market participants such as refiners and importers to
introduce increasing volumes of renewable fuel into
the transportation fuel supply, Congress intended the
Renewable Fuel Program to be a market forcing policy
that would create demand pressure to increase
consumption of renewable fuel.” Ams. for Clean
Energy, 864 F.3d at 705 (cleaned up).
Annually, the EPA sets percentage standards by
rulemaking, which inform refiners and importers
what proportion of their fuel must be renewable fuel
for the upcoming year. 42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(3)(B)(i).
The EPA must calculate the percentages at a level
“that ensures” the total volume requirements
mandated by statute—with any authorized adjustments—are met. Ibid.; see also Ams. for Clean Energy,
864 F.3d at 698-99.
A refiner or importer demonstrates compliance
with its RFS obligation by providing sufficient
6
Renewable Identification Numbers (“RINs”)—
tradeable credits accounting for a gallon of renewable
fuel. RINs can be obtained by purchasing them on the
open market or by producing or buying renewable fuel
to blend into transportation fuel. Those with excess
RINs may sell them or carry them over to the next
compliance year. See 42 U.S.C. § 7545(o)(5); 40 C.F.R.
§§ 80.1425-29; Ams. for Clean Energy, 864 F.3d at
699-700.
A small refinery that obtains an exemption from
the RFS under § 7545(o)(9)(B) does not have to comply
with these requirements. It does not have to acquire
any RINs to prove compliance to the EPA. And if it
has accumulated some, it can sell them or carry them
forward to the next compliance year.
But the EPA does not readjust an issued annual
percentage standard after granting a new smallrefinery exemption. See EPA Regulation of Fuels and
Fuel Additives: 2011 Renewable Fuel Standards, 75
Fed. Reg. 76790, 76804 (Dec. 9, 2010) (explaining
EPA’s position that adjustment to account for new
exemptions “would be inconsistent with the statutory
text, and would introduce an undesirable level of
uncertainty for obligated parties”). So the portion of
the total renewable fuel volume that would have been
satisfied by the exempt small refinery is left unmet.
When many small refineries receive the exemption,
even greater proportions of the RFS mandate are left
unfulfilled. See Scott Irwin, Clearing the Logjam on
the RFS and SREs: A Simple Proposal, farmdoc daily,
Dep’t of Agric. & Consumer Econ., Univ. of Ill. at
Urbana-Champaign, Sept. 19, 2019, at 2, https://perm
a.cc/n8dh-bekn.
7
For this reason, the expansive interpretation of
the small-refinery exemption advanced by Petitioners
has the practical effect of cutting the renewable fuel
mandates significantly below the levels required by
statute. This guts the RFS and renders it ineffective
in creating demand for renewable fuel. And without
the demand created by the RFS, the renewable fuel
industry will continue to suffer substantial economic
harm.
This harm is not hypothetical. Since 2017, the
EPA has granted 86 small-refinery exemptions across
three compliance years. U.S. EPA, RFS Small
Refinery Exemptions, https://www.epa.gov/fuels-reg
istration-reporting-and-compliance-help/rfs-small-ref
inery-exemptions (last updated March 18, 2021). The
exemptions led to an average reduction of 1.35 billion
gallons of renewable fuel per year from the RFS
mandate. Irwin, Clearing the Logjam, supra, at 3.
This amounts to a 7% reduction in renewable fuel
demand each year. Ibid. And it caused losses
averaging more than $2 billion per year—or $6.4
billion over the three years—especially by
devastating biodiesel demand. Id. at 4; see also Scott
Irwin, Small Refinery Exemptions and BiomassBased Diesel Demand Destruction, farmdoc daily,
Dep’t of Agric. & Consumer Econ., Univ. of Ill. at
Urbana-Champaign, March 14, 2019, https://perm
a.cc/cb44-gaq7.
And it could become even worse if this Court
accepts Petitioners’ expansive interpretation of the
statute. So far, the EPA has not granted more than 35
small-refinery exemptions for a single compliance
year. U.S. EPA, RFS Small Refinery Exemptions,
8
supra. Those exemptions led to a 9.3% reduction of the
mandated volume for the 2017 compliance year.
Irwin, Clearing the Logjam, supra, at 3. But if any
small refinery can receive an exemption—even one
that has no current exemption to extend—and all 54
obtain one, more than 10% of the statutory RFS
mandate could be erased. See Wyo. et al. Amici Br. 18.
One might think that these 7% or 10% reductions
in the mandated renewable fuel volume are relatively
insignificant to the industry and the purpose of the
RFS. But the difference between this reduced demand
and the full RFS mandate is critical.
The RFS mandate exerts demand pressure only if
it requires the use of more renewable fuel than the
market would support on its own. The fuel market
supports a substantial volume of ethanol for E10
blend. But that demand drops off abruptly because of
physical limits in how much E10 can be used. See
Ams. for Clean Energy, 864 F.3d at 700 (discussing
the “E10 blendwall”).
While the RFS mandate for recent years is set high
enough to push demand beyond the market, it
appears that the reduced mandate caused by the
excessive granting of the small-refinery exemptions
has moved to where it is without economic effect. See
Jonathan Coppess & Scott Irwin, EPA and the Small
Refinery Exemption Issue in the Renewable Fuel
Standard Mandates, farmdoc daily, Dep’t of Agric. &
Consumer Econ., Univ. of Ill. at Urbana-Champaign,
Mar. 12, 2020, at 4-6, https://perma.cc/d3ha-9jvq.
This is shown on the figure below:
9
Id. at 5.
The adverse effects of the reduced demand can
also be seen in the RIN market. Because RINs can be
bought and sold on the open market, their price is an
efficient measure of ethanol demand. Background on
Renewable Identification Numbers Under the
Renewable Fuel Standard: Hearing Before the H.
Comm. on Energy & Commerce Subcomm. on
Environment, 115th Cong., at 5-6 (2018) (statement of
Gabriel E. Lade, Assistant Professor, Center for
Agricultural & Rural Development, Iowa State
University), https://perma.cc/3erv-k9cr. Indeed the
price of RINs is also a measure of the effectiveness of
the RFS because their price serves as a subsidy to
renewable fuels and a tax on regular gasoline. Ibid.
10
Tellingly, the RIN markets for both ethanol (in
red below) and biodiesel (blue) plummeted to historically low levels as the small-refinery exemptions
exploded—only starting to rise again after the Tenth
Circuit’s decision in this case. Coppess & Irwin, EPA
and the Small Refinery Exemption, supra, at 3.
Ibid.
In short, the reduction in demand caused by the
expansive interpretation of the small-refinery
exemption has an outsized impact and leaves the RFS
ineffective. Because Petitioners’ interpretation would
undermine the statutory purpose, the Court should
not depart from the statute’s plain meaning.
11
II. Petitioners’ broad interpretation would
cause substantial economic harm to the
rural economies of many States.
The harm flowing from Petitioners’ interpretation
is more than mere economic theory. The reduced
demand caused by the unfettered granting of smallrefinery exemptions has had real world impacts on
people’s lives.
Over the last few years, renewable fuel plants
have been slowed, idled, and closed. See Letter from
Kim Reynolds, Governor of Iowa, to Andrew Wheeler,
EPA Administrator (Nov. 7, 2019), https://perma.cc/
t9wb-fmjv (discussing the shuttering of biofuels
plants in the Iowa towns of Crawfordsville,
Emmetsburg, Merrill, and Sioux Center); Donnelle
Eller, Poet Writes an End to Crop Residue Ethanol:
S.D. Firm Says Feds Failed to Give Effort Full
Support, Des Moines Reg., Nov. 20, 2019, at A1-2,
https://perma.cc/5d3c-nuyv (describing the pause in
production at a cellulosic ethanol plant in Iowa
because of the EPA’s granting of small-refinery
exemptions).
As of October 2019—and before any impact from
the current pandemic—19 ethanol plants had closed
across the nation. Protecting the RFS: The Trump
Administration’s Abuse of Secret Waivers: Hearing
before H. Comm. On Energy & Commerce Subcomm.
on Environment & Climate Change, 116th Cong., at 9
(2019) (statement of Geoff Cooper, President & CEO,
Renewable Fuels Ass’n), https://perma.cc/mpe4-h9r7.
These closures led to many job losses and furloughs.
And because the renewable fuel industry anchors
many rural economies, undercutting that industry
12
harms local farmers, retailers, and other service
providers. “It’s not uncommon for the local grain
elevator and biofuels facility to be the largest
employers in the region, supporting the livelihoods of
hundreds of Midwest families from the surrounding
towns.” Letter from Gov. Reynolds, supra; see also
Protecting the RFS, supra, at 10 (estimating that
every job in an ethanol plant supports 4 to 6 jobs
indirectly including farming, transportation, manufacturing, engineering, construction, and legal jobs).
This economic impact is particularly significant
for a State like Iowa, where the renewable fuel
industry accounted for $4 billion—about 2%—of the
State’s gross domestic product in 2020. John M.
Urbanchuk, Contribution of the Renewable Fuels
Industry to the Economy of Iowa, at 4 (Jan. 28, 2021),
https://perma.cc/2kcb-w2lr. It supported more than
37,000 jobs and generates $1.8 billion of income for
Iowa household. Ibid.
Nebraska also depends on the renewable fuel
industry to grow rural jobs. From 2010 to 2017, the
industry directly contributed between 3,508 to 4,900
Nebraskan jobs each year. And these mostly rural
jobs had average annual earnings of $78,300, with
total income generated of $255 to $352 million per
year. Kathleen Brooks et al., Economic Impacts of the
Nebraska Ethanol and Ethanol Co-Products Industry
2015-2017, at 16 (2019), https://perma.cc/f3s3-bt5b.
These economic impacts do not come solely from
ethanol. Biodiesel is also a significant component of
the renewable fuel economy. For example, in 2016,
Minnesota produced 74 million gallons of biodiesel
alone, which is associated with $1.7 billion in total
13
output impact and 5,397 jobs. Minn. Dep’t of Agric.,
Minnesota Biodiesel Industry Economic Impact
(2017), https://perma.cc/9eha-mgc5.
More broadly, the renewable fuel industry plays
an important economic role across the nation. In
2020—despite the negative effects on demand caused
by the granting of small-refinery exemptions and the
COVID-19 pandemic—the industry had an estimated
$34.7 billion impact on the GDP. And it supported
more than 300,000 jobs and $18.6 billion of household
income. John M. Urbanchuk, Contribution of the
Ethanol Industry to the Economy of the United States
in 2020, at 9 (Feb. 2, 2021), https://perma.cc/de8ah2gt; see also Ken Ditzel et al., The Biodiesel Industry:
Impacts on the Economy, Environment and Energy
Security, at 1 (2018), https://perma.cc/v8dg-c5xj. With
more than 300 biofuel plants—across 40 States—built
upon the promise of the RFS, the renewable fuel
industry’s economic importance should not be
forgotten. See App. 1a-4a. Yet Petitioners’ reading of
the statute threatens to do just that.
14
III. An ineffective Renewable Fuel Standard
would harm the environment and efforts to
obtain energy independence.
Increased use of cleaner fuels and greater energy
independence are both explicit goals of the RFS. See
Ams. for Clean Energy, 864 F.3d at 697 (citing Pub. L.
No. 110-140, preamble, 121 Sta. at 1492).
Recent evidence shows that greenhouse gas
emissions from corn ethanol are significantly lower
than petroleum gasoline. For example, a study by a
senior USDA economist found that emissions from
producing and using ethanol are 39% lower than
gasoline. See Jan Lewandrowski et al., The Greenhouse Gas Benefits of Corn Ethanol – Assessing Recent
Evidence, 10 Biofuels 361, 373 (2019), https://perma.
cc/6kwu-pgbr. The reduction is even greater—43%—
when the ethanol is produced with natural-gas power.
Id. at 374; see also Michael Wang et al., Well-toWheels Energy Use and Greenhouse Gas Emissions of
Ethanol from Corn, Sugarcane and Cellulosic
Biomass for US Use, Envtl. Res. Letters 7, at 9
(2012), https://perma.cc/t4ty-ff65 (describing findings
of Argonne National Labs study that corn-starch
ethanol reduced greenhouse gas emissions 19% to
48%).
Blending corn ethanol into conventional gasoline
is also particularly effective in reducing the emissions
of other pollutants in urban areas. One analysis
comparing E85 corn ethanol with gasoline found
reductions of 40% in sulfur oxides; 22% in nitrogen
oxides; 13% in particulate matter; 5% in volatile
organic compounds; and 2% in carbon monoxide.
Minn. Office of the Leg. Auditor, Evaluation Report,
15
Biofuel Policies and Programs 52 (2009), https://perm
a.cc/c2kr-3v3h. States like Minnesota that have dense
urban areas where the pollutants may otherwise
accumulate have found these reductions to be
particularly important to their efforts to prevent
disproportionate exposure to urban communities.
Biodiesel likewise reduces carbon dioxide
emissions by 75% compared to petroleum diesel over
its life cycle of production and use. See U.S. Dep’t of
Energy, Biodiesel Vehicle Emissions, Alternative
Fuels Data Center, https://perma.cc/3dyn-rvsa.
Because of these environmental benefits, some
States have chosen to make renewable fuels a part of
their state-level efforts to address air quality. One
example is Minnesota’s bipartisan Next Generation
Energy Act enacted in 2007, which sets specific
greenhouse gas reduction targets for the State. See
Minn. Stat. ch. 216H (requiring Minnesota to reduce
greenhouse gas emissions by 80% between 2005 and
2050—with interim reduction goals of 15% by 2015
and 30% by 2025—while supporting clean energy and
energy efficiency and supplementing renewable
energy standards).
In the wake of this legislation, Minnesota
determined that its transportation sector has become
the largest emitter of greenhouse gases. And in 2019,
a multi-agency collaborative study concluded that
increasing use of renewable fuels was a critical
component to fulfilling Minnesota’s environmental
goals. See Minn. Dep’t of Transp., Pathways to
Decarbonizing Transportation in Minnesota 7 (2019),
https://perma.cc/dc89-l2lm. This is particularly so in
the near-term because it is the most attainable
16
solution while Minnesota transitions to longer-term
clean energy technologies. The figure below shows
this significant role of renewable fuels to Minnesota’s
greenhouse gas reduction efforts over the next thirty
years:
Id. at 5. These state-level efforts relying on renewable
fuels to address air quality depend on a strong
renewable fuel industry with growing capacity.
Likewise, every gallon of new capacity to produce
renewable fuel is many future gallons of petroleum-
17
based fuel that the United States will not need to
import. Since the RFS was enacted, the United States
has been steadily decreasing its net imports of
petroleum, apparently aided at least in part by
growing renewable fuel production during the same
period. See Marc Chupka et al., Blending In: The Role
of Renewable Fuel in Achieving Policy Goals iii, 3-11
(2017), https://perma.cc/6cpt-zfxm; see also U.S.
Energy Info. Admin., March 2021 Monthly Energy
Review 58 (2021), https://perma.cc/38vy-znsc (showing historical petroleum net imports).
In 2020, for the first time since the U.S. Energy
Information Administration began keeping data in
1949, the United States exported more petroleum
than it imported. U.S. Energy Info. Admin, March
2021, supra, at 59. This export surplus amounted to
approximately 0.65 million barrels of petroleum per
day, or 3.6% of the daily consumption of petroleum.
U.S. Energy Info. Admin., How Much Oil Consumed
by the United States Comes from Foreign Countries?,
https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=32&t=6
(last updated March 29, 2021). But even so, the
United States continues to import nearly 8 million
barrels per day, so there is still plenty of room for
more domestic fuel production growth. U.S. Energy
Info. Admin, March 2021, supra, at 59.
Without a predictable RFS mandate to drive
demand, fewer investments will be made to reap these
environmental and energy independence benefits.
Petitioners’ expansive interpretation of the smallrefinery exemption would render the RFS ineffective
to advance these purposes.
18
CONCLUSION
For these reasons, the judgment of the court of
appeals should be affirmed.
Respectfully submitted,
THOMAS J. MILLER
Attorney General of Iowa
JEFFREY THOMPSON
Solicitor General
SAMUEL P. LANGHOLZ
Assistant Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
1305 E. Walnut
Des Moines, Iowa 50319
(515) 281-5164
sam.langholz@ag.iowa.gov
DOUGLAS J. PETERSON
Attorney General of
Nebraska
JAMES A. CAMPBELL
Solicitor General
JUSTIN D. LAVENE
JOSHUA E. DETHLEFSEN
Assistant Attorneys General
2115 State Capitol
Lincoln, NE 68509
(402) 471-2682
Counsel for Additional Amici
KWAME RAOUL
Attorney General
State of Illinois
19
DANA NESSEL
Attorney General
State of Michigan
KEITH ELLISON
Attorney General
State of Minnesota
ELLEN F. ROSENBLUM
Attorney General
State of Oregon
JASON R. RAVNSBORG
Attorney General
State of South Dakota
MARK R. HERRING
Attorney General
State of Virginia
Counsel for Amici Curiae States
March 31, 2021
1a
APPENDIX
Ethanol and Biodiesel
Production Facilities in the States
Number of Facilities and
Capacity (Million Gallons per Year)
State
Ethanol
Biodiesel
Total
IA
43
(4,593)
11
(394)
54
(4,987)
NE
26
(2,296)
3
(51.25)
29
(2,347.25)
IL
14
(1,867)
8
(182.6)
22
(2,049.6)
MN
19
(1,384)
3
(63)
22
(1,447)
IN
15
(1,337)
2
(94.42)
17
(1,431.42)
SD
16
(1,223)
ND
6
(542)
2
(259)
8
(801)
TX
4
(395)
9
(375.5)
13
(770.5)
16
(1,223)
2a
OH
7
(676)
1
(70)
8
(746)
KS
14
(615)
2
(64)
16
(679)
WI
9
(603)
2
(25)
11
(628)
MO
6
(287)
7
(231)
13
(518)
MI
5
(350)
3
(15.9)
8
(365.9)
CA
5
(217)
9
(132)
14
(349)
TN
3
(237)
3
(82)
6
(319)
PA
1
(120)
2
(95)
3
(215)
NY
2
(165)
GA
1
(120)
CO
5
(143)
MS
2
(165)
3
(27.5)
4
(147.5)
5
(143)
4
(119.5)
4
(119.5)
3a
AR
3
(114)
3
(114)
WA
2
(110)
2
(110)
KY
2
(50)
3
(47.1)
5
(97.1)
NC
1
(57)
2
(9)
3
(66)
ID
1
(60)
OR
2
(42)
AZ
1
(55)
1
(60)
1
(17)
3
(59)
1
(55)
SC
3
(45.3)
3
(45.3)
OK
1
(45)
1
(45)
CT
1
(40)
1
(40)
NJ
1
(25)
1
(25)
AL
1
(20)
1
(20)
4a
2
(16.2)
2
(16.2)
2
(8.6)
3
(10.6)
RI
2
(9.2)
2
(9.2)
NH
1
(6.5)
1
(6.5)
HI
1
(5.5)
1
(5.5)
MA
2
(2.95)
2
(2.95)
ME
1
(1.5)
1
(1.5)
AK
1
(0.3)
1
(0.3)
104
(2,804.82)
313
(20,240.82)
FL
VA
TOTAL
(40)
1
(2)
209
(17,436)
Sources: Renewable Fuels Association, Essential
Energy: 2021 Ethanol Industry Outlook at 7 (2021),
https://perma.cc/6cn4-ekr5; U.S. Biodiesel Plants,
Biodiesel Magazine, https://perma.cc/3jjj-sh28 (last
modified Dec. 15, 2020).
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.