Application — Christopher Marlowe, Applicant v. James M. LeBlanc, Secretary, Louisiana Department of Public Safety and Corrections, et al.
Supreme Court briefMay 13, 2020
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
CASE No. ______
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
___________________________________________________________
CHRISTOPHER MARLOWE
Applicant,
v.
STATE OF LOUISIANA THROUGH THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY AND
CORRECTIONS; JAMES W. LEBLANC, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS SECRETARY OF THE
LOUISIANA DPSC; DR. RAMAN SINGH, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE FORMER MEDICAL
AND MENTAL HEALTH DIRECTOR AT THE LOUISIANA DPSC; DR. PAM HEARD, IN HER OFFICIAL
CAPACITY AS THE FORMER INTERIM MEDICAL AND MENTAL HEALTH DIRECTOR AT THE LOUISIANA
DPSC; DR. JOHN MORRISON, IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS THE MEDICAL AND MENTAL
HEALTH DIRECTOR AT THE LOUISIANA DPSC; WARDEN TIMOTHY HOOPER, IN HIS
OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS THE WARDEN OF ELAYN HUNT CORRECTIONAL CENTER
[EHCC], A FACILITY OWNED AND OPERATED BY DPSC; DEPUTY WARDEN STEPHANIE
MICHEL, IN HER OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS THE DEPUTY WARDEN OF MEDICAL
CARE AT EHCC; ASSISTANT WARDEN MORGAN LEBLANC, IN HIS OFFICIAL AND
PERSONAL
CAPACITIES
DEVELOPMENT
CAMPBELL,
AND
AS
MEAL
THE
FORMER
PLANNING
AT
ASSISTANT
WARDEN
RESPONSIBLE
FOR
MENU
EHCC; ASSISTANT WARDEN DARRYL
IN HIS OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS AN ASSISTANT WARDEN
RESPONSIBLE FOR MENU DEVELOPMENT AND MEAL PLANNING AT EHCC; DR. PREETY SINGH,
IN HER OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS THE MEDICAL DIRECTOR AT EHCC; GAIL LEVY,
IN HER INDIVIDUAL AND OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS THE FOOD MANAGER AT EHCC; POLLY
SMITH, IN HER INDIVIDUAL AND OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS A FORMER NURSE PRACTITIONER AT
EHCC; FALLON STEWART, IN HIS INDIVIDUAL AND OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS A FORMER
EMERGENCY MEDICAL TECHNICIAN
AT EHCC; ELIZABETH GAUTHREAUX, IN HER
INDIVIDUAL AND OFFICIAL CAPACITIES AS AN EMT AT EHCC; JONATHAN TRAVIS, IN HIS
OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS A PHARMACIST AT EHCC; MASTER SGT. ANGEL
HORN, IN HER OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS A CORRECTIONAL OFFICER WORKING AT
THE PILL CALL WINDOW AT EHCC; MASTER SGT. ROLANDA PALMER, IN HER OFFICIAL
AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS A CORRECTIONAL OFFICER WORKING AT THE PILL CALL WINDOW
AT EHCC; AND SGT CHERMAINE BROWN, IN HER OFFICIAL AND PERSONAL CAPACITIES AS A
CORRECTIONAL OFFICER WORKING AT THE PILL CALL WINDOW AT EHCC
Respondents.
___________________________________________________________
EMERGENCY APPLICATION TO JUSTICE ALITO TO VACATE STAY PENDING
APPEAL OF PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ENTERED BY THE UNITED STATES
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT
APPENDIX
___________________________________________________________
Submitted by:
EMILY POSNER
7214 St. Charles Ave. Box 913
New Orleans, Louisiana 70118
Phone:
225-746-8820
Fax:
225-208-1439
Email:
ep@emilyposnerlaw.com
Counsel for Applicant
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Document
Appendix Page
Court of Appeal Order Granting Defendant’s Motion to Stay
of the Preliminary Injunction (5th Cir. Apr. 27, 2020).
1(a)
District Court Ruling and Order (M.D. La. Apr. 23, 2020).
12(a)
Applicant’s Application and Supplemental Memorandum of
Support for a Temporary Restraining Order and Supporting Exhibits.
26(a)
Respondents’ Opposition to Application and Supplemental Memorandum
of Support for a Temporary Restraining Order and Supporting Exhibits.
369(a)
Applicant’s Reply Memorandum and Exhibits in Support for a
Temporary Restraining Order and Supporting Exhibits.
407(a)
Transcript of April 7, 2020 Telephonic Evidentiary Hearing.
418(a)
Respondents’ Post-Hearing Brief and Supporting Exhibits.
493(a)
Applicant’s Post-Hearing Brief and Supporting Exhibits.
540(a)
Applicant’s Notice to Update the Court.
662(a)
Respondents’ Emergency Motion to Stay Enforcement of the
TRO (Rec. Doc. 115) Pending Appeal.
665(a)
Applicant’s Opposition to Defendants’ Emergency Motion to Stay Enforcement
of the TRO (Rec. Doc. 115) Pending Appeal and Supporting Exhibits.
687(a)
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396991
Page: 1
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
United States Court of Appeals
FIFTH CIRCUIT
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
LYLE W. CAYCE
CLERK
TEL. 504-310-7700
600 S. MAESTRI PLACE,
Suite 115
NEW ORLEANS, LA 70130
April 27, 2020
MEMORANDUM TO COUNSEL OR PARTIES LISTED BELOW:
No. 20-30276
Christopher
Marlowe
Secretary, et al
USDC No. 3:18-CV-63
v.
James
LeBlanc,
Enclosed is an order entered in this case.
Sincerely,
LYLE W. CAYCE, Clerk
By: _________________________
Melissa V. Mattingly, Deputy Clerk
504-310-7719
Ms. Phyllis Esther Glazer
Mr. Michael L. McConnell
Ms. Suzanne Quinlan Mooney
Ms. Emily Henrion Posner
001a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 1
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT
No. 20-30276
CHRISTOPHER MARLOWE,
Plaintiff - Appellee
v.
JAMES M. LEBLANC, SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY
AND CORRECTIONS; RAMAN SINGH, Doctor; TIMOTHY HOOPER,
Warden; STEPHANIE MICHEL, Deputy Warden; MORGAN LEBLANC,
Assistant Warden; PREETY SINGH, Doctor; GAIL LEVY; POLLY SMITH;
FALLON STEWART; ELIZABETH GAUTHREAUX; JONATHAN TRAVIS;
STATE OF LOUISIANA THROUGH THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC
SAFETY AND CORRECTIONS; PAM HEARD, Doctor; DARRYL
CAMPBELL, Assistant Warden; JOHN MORRISON; ANGEL HORN, Master
Sergeant; ROLANDA PALMER, Master Sergeant; CHERMAINE BROWN,
Sergeant,
Defendants - Appellants
Appeal from the United States District Court
for the Middle District of Louisiana
Before JONES, HIGGINSON, and OLDHAM, Circuit Judges.
PER CURIAM:
This appeal concerns the efforts of Louisiana’s Department of Public
Safety and Corrections (“DPSC”) to respond to the rapidly evolving COVID-19
pandemic on behalf of one prisoner in one unit. On April 23, 2020, the United
States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana issued an injunction
requiring Defendants to comply with their own internal policies and submit a
002a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 2
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
plan to ensure proper social distancing and hygiene practices. Dist. Ct. Order
at 13–14. This order came just one day after this court stayed a similar
injunction against the Texas Department of Criminal Justice. Valentine v.
Collier, No. 20-20207, 2020 WL 1934431 (5th Cir. Apr. 22, 2020). We conclude
that Valentine’s reasoning controls here and accordingly stay the district
court’s injunction pending appeal.
BACKGROUND
Plaintiff, a prisoner currently detained at the Rayburn Correctional
Center (“RCC”), originally filed suit against Defendants in 2018, alleging they
exhibited deliberate indifference toward his medical needs by providing a
constitutionally deficient meal service that resulted in his developing diabetes
and then failing to adequately treat his illness. On April 1, 2020, Plaintiff filed
a motion tangential to the ongoing dispute, requesting a temporary restraining
order authorizing his supervised release until spread of the COVID-19 virus is
no longer a threat within the Department of Corrections. Defendants opposed
the motion on the basis of jurisdictional obstacles, Plaintiff’s failure to exhaust
administrative remedies, and the deficiency of Plaintiff’s constitutional claim
on its merits.
The district court conducted a telephonic evidentiary hearing on April 7.
Following the evidentiary hearing, Defendants submitted a memorandum
updating the district court on the numerous procedures taken at RCC to
contain the spread of COVID-19. Plaintiff responded that these procedures
were “woefully inadequate” and “deliberately indifferent” to his medical needs.
He also suggested, for the first time, that, in lieu of temporary release, the
court could order that RCC create conditions that allow for proper social
distancing to protect him. The district court latched on to this eleventh-hour
request. After determining that Plaintiff was likely to prevail on the merits of
2
003a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 3
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
his deliberate indifference claim, it ordered Defendants to “comply with the
Governor’s recommendations and their own internal policies concerning
disinfection of common areas and the wearing of masks by staff and certain
categories of offenders.” Dist. Ct. Order at 13. It further ordered Defendants
to “submit to the [c]ourt a [p]lan to ensure the implementation of proper
hygiene practices in the dormitory in which Plaintiff is assigned, and to
implement social distancing practices to limit the spread of COVID-19.” Id. at
14. The Defendants were ordered to submit said plan within five days, i.e. by
Tuesday, April 28. Id.
Defendants, relying heavily on this court’s just-issued Valentine
decision, requested that the district court stay enforcement of the injunction.
The district court has yet to rule on that motion. Defendants then appealed to
this court, requesting a stay pending appeal.
ANALYSIS 1
Four well established factors govern the propriety of a stay pending
appeal: “(1) whether the stay applicant has made a strong showing that he is
likely to succeed on the merits; (2) whether the applicant will be irreparably
injured absent a stay; (3) whether issuance of the stay will substantially injure
the other parties interested in the proceeding; and (4) where the public interest
lies.” Nken v. Holder, 556 U.S. 418, 426, 129 S. Ct. 1749, 1761 (2009) (quoting
Hilton v. Braunskill, 481 U.S. 770, 776, 107 S. Ct. 2113, 2119 (1987)). “The
first two factors . . . are the most critical.” Id. at 434.
1 Plaintiff contends that the district court’s order is a TRO, governed by Fed. R. Civ. P. 65(b) and
normally unappealable. See Faulder v. Johnson, 178 F.3d 741, 742 (5th Cir. 1999). However,
precedent makes clear that when a court holds a hearing on a preliminary motion and the motion is
strongly contested, its resulting order constitutes an injunction appealable under 28 U.S.C.
§ 1291(a)(1). See Sampson v. Murray, 415 U.S. 61, 87, 94 S. Ct. 937, 951 (1974) (“[W]here an adversary
hearing has been held, and the court’s basis for issuing the order strongly challenged, classification of
[a] potentially unlimited order as a temporary restraining order seems particularly unjustified.”).
3
004a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 4
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
We begin by considering Defendants’ likelihood of success on appeal. In
making this assessment, we are bound by a decision in which this court
recently resolved a motion for stay raising nearly identical issues.
See
Valentine v. Collier, No. 20-20207, 2020 WL 1934431 (5th Cir. Apr. 22, 2020).
Although Valentine’s facts are slightly different from the facts of this case, we
might have expected the district court to at least mention Valentine. Perhaps
Defendants did not apprise the district court of our decision before the issuance
of its injunction. Valentine was decided just one day earlier. But Defendants
repeatedly cite Valentine in their motion to stay enforcement of the injunction
pending appeal. And yet, for whatever reason, the district court has not ruled
on that motion. Regardless of the basis for the district court’s decision, we
must consider Defendants’ arguments in light of Valentine, and, for three
independent reasons, conclude that Defendants are likely to succeed on appeal.
First, Pennhurst State School & Hospital v. Halderman, 465 U.S. 89, 104
S. Ct. 900 (1984), prohibits the injunction imposed by the district court. As
this court explained in Valentine, a district court cannot enjoin a state facility
to follow state law. Valentine, 2020 WL 1934431, at *4. Yet that is exactly
what the district court did here. It concluded that “Defendants do not appear
to be following” their own policy statements. Dist. Ct. Order at 10. For
instance, “despite taking some steps to deter the spread of the virus, [RCC] has
not effectively implemented the [Department of Correction] policies that
require staff members and orderlies to wear masks and other [personal
protective equipment] to protect the prison population, including the Plaintiff.”
Id. at 11. The court further determined that RCC “failed to meaningfully
implement social-distancing procedures and other measures aimed at
thwarting the spread of the coronavirus.” Id. The court therefore ordered
Defendants to comply with “their own internal policies” and “implement social
4
005a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 5
No. 20-30276
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
distancing practices to limit the spread of COVID-19.”
Id.
at 13–14.
Pennhurst forbids this.
Plaintiff contends the court’s injunction does not run afoul of Pennhurst
because it is intended to correct constitutionally deficient medical care. The
court did not so express itself, and in any event, the essence of Pennhurst is
that a federal court lacks jurisdiction to sit as a super-state executive by
ordering a state entity to comply with its own law.
Second, the district court’s analysis falls woefully short of satisfying
either the objective or subjective requirements of Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U.S.
825, 114 S. Ct. 1970 (1994). We do not question that COVID-19 presents a risk
of serious harm to those confined in prisons, nor that Plaintiff, as a diabetic, is
particularly vulnerable to the virus’s effects. But, for purposes of resolving
Plaintiff’s Eighth Amendment claim, we are not tasked with resolving
whether, absent RCC’s precautionary measures, the COVID-19 pandemic
presents a substantial risk of serious harm to prisoners like Plaintiff. Rather,
the question here is whether the Eighth Amendment requires RCC to do more
than it has already done to mitigate the risk of harm. The district court’s
laconic analysis provides little basis for concluding that RCC’s mitigation
efforts are insufficient. Indeed, because the district court made few (if any)
factual findings, it left no reviewable basis to conclude that the measures
implemented by Defendants are constitutionally deficient. 2 Plaintiff cites no
precedent supporting a contrary conclusion, and we are aware of none.
Even assuming that Plaintiff’s testimony somehow satisfies Farmer’s
objective requirement, the district court cited no evidence establishing that
2 Warden Robert Tanner, the Warden of RCC, offered a declaration that blunts many (if not all) of
Plaintiff’s concerns, giving us further cause to doubt that Plaintiff has come close to satisfying the
“extremely high standard” of deliberate indifference. Cadena v. El Paso Cty., 946 F.3d 717, 728 (5th
Cir. 2020).
5
006a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 6
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
Defendants subjectively believed that the measures they were (and continue)
taking were inadequate. If anything, the record proves just the opposite.
Defendants point to a plethora of measures they are taking to abate the risks
posed by COVID-19, from providing prisoners with disinfectant spray and two
cloth masks to limiting the number of prisoners in the infirmary lobby and
painting markers on walkways to promote social distancing. Plaintiff’s own
counsel conceded at the April 7 evidentiary hearing that “everyone here is
trying their very, very best to make sure that nobody gets sick at [RCC].” The
district court’s analysis resembles the analysis we condemned in Valentine,
where the district court had treated inadequate measures as dispositive of the
defendants’ mental state. “Such an approach,” we explained, “resembles the
standard for civil negligence, which Farmer explicitly rejected.” Valentine,
2020 WL 1934431, at *4.
In opposing this stay, Plaintiff now asserts, contrary to the above-quoted
statement, that RCC’s measures in fact demonstrate deliberate indifference.
Plaintiff’s evidence is no different, however, and indeed, Defendants have been
heightening their efforts to contain the virus. Although the virus has spread
within RCC, given the many prevention measures RCC has taken, an increase
in infection rate alone is insufficient to prove deliberate indifference.
Third, the district court’s exhaustion analysis under the Prison
Litigation Reform Act runs counter to Supreme Court precedent. The district
court acknowledged that Plaintiff failed to exhaust administrative remedies.
It nonetheless excused Plaintiff, reasoning that “the interests of justice”
compelled it to act on an emergency basis. See Johnson v. Ford, 261 F. App’x
752, 755 (5th Cir. 2008).
As this court explained in Valentine, such an
approach is out-of-step with Supreme Court precedent, see Valentine, 2020
1934431, at *6–7, and this court has disavowed the “interests of justice”
6
007a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 7
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
exception embraced in Johnson, see Gonzalez v. Seal, 702 F.3d 785, 788 (5th
Cir. 2012) (holding that Underwood v. Wilson, 151 F.3d 292 (5th Cir. 1998),
which Johnson relied on, was “tacitly overruled and is no longer good law to
the extent it permits prisoner lawsuits challenging prison conditions to proceed
in the absence of pre-filing administrative exhaustion”).
It must be
acknowledged that Superintendent LeBlanc issued an order on March 23
temporarily suspending the administrative deadlines for replying to
grievances, and such order may have affected the “availability” of exhaustion.
But Plaintiff makes no effort to explain the impact of that order on his refusing
to file a grievance or on the way in which it would have been processed. The
record, moreover, indicates that grievances are currently being processed
within 48 hours. Dist. Ct. Order at 6 n.3.
For at least these three, independent reasons, 3 we conclude that
Defendants have demonstrated a substantial likelihood of success on the
merits.
Turning to the second stay factor, Defendants have shown that they will
be irreparably injured absent a stay. “When the State is seeking to stay a
preliminary injunction, it’s generally enough to say ‘[a]ny time a State is
enjoined by a court from effectuating statutes enacted by representatives of its
people, it suffers a form of irreparable injury.’” Valentine, 2020 WL 1934431,
at *4 (quoting Maryland v. King, 567 U.S. 1301, 133 S. Ct. 1, 3 (2012)). The
Louisiana Legislature assigned the prerogatives of prison policy to DPSC. See
LA. STAT. § 36:401. “The district court’s injunction prevents the State from
3 Defendants also argue that they are likely to succeed on appeal “because the claims upon which the
injunctive relief were granted are not pleaded in this lawsuit.” We offer no opinion on this argument
at this stage of the appeal.
7
008a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 8
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
effectuating the Legislature’s choice and hence imposes irreparable injury.”
Valentine, 2020 WL 1934431, at *4. 4
As if that weren’t enough, the Supreme Court has repeatedly warned
that “it is ‘difficult to imagine an activity in which a State has a stronger
interest, or one that is more intricately bound up with state laws, regulations,
and procedures, than the administration of its prisons.’” Woodford v. Ngo, 548
U.S. 81, 94, 126 S. Ct. 2378, 2388 (2006) (quoting Preiser v. Rodriguez, 411 U.S.
475, 491–92, 93 S. Ct. 1827, 1837 (1973)). Here, the district court invaded
Louisiana’s interests by requiring Defendants to create a plan within five days
“to ensure the implementation of proper hygiene practices in the dormitory in
which Plaintiff is assigned,” “to implement social distancing practices to limit
the spread of COVID-19,” and “to minimize Plaintiff’s exposure to possible
infected persons while visiting infirmary and cafeteria areas of the prison.”
Dist. Ct. Order at 14. The harm to Louisiana’s interests is “particularly acute
because the district court’s order interferes with the rapidly changing . . .
approach that [DPSC] has used to respond to the pandemic so far.” Valentine,
2020 WL 1934431, at *5. In light of these concerns, the second factor weighs
in Defendants’ favor.
The remaining two factors—balance of the harms and the public
interest—likewise weigh in favor of staying the district court’s injunction.
COVID-19 unquestionably poses risks of harm to all Americans—particularly
those like Plaintiff who have underlying health conditions. “But the question
4 See also In re Abbott, 954 F.3d 772, 792 (5th Cir. 2020) (“As Jacobson repeatedly instructs, . . . if the
choice is between two reasonable responses to a public crisis, the judgment must be left to the
governing state authorities. ‘It is no part of the function of a court or a jury to determine which one of
two modes [i]s likely to be the most effective for the protection of the public against disease.’ . . . Such
authority properly belongs to the legislative and executive branches of the governing authority.”
(second alteration in original) (quoting Jacobson v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11, 30,
25 S. Ct. 358, 363 (1905))).
8
009a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 9
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
is whether Plaintiff[] has shown that [he] will suffer irreparable injuries even
after accounting for the [DPSC’s] protective measures . . . . Neither the
Plaintiff[] nor the district court suggest the evidence satisfies that standard.
And ‘[b]ecause the State is the appealing party, its interest and harm merge
with that of the public.’” Id. (emphasis in original) (quoting Veasey v. Abbott,
870 F.3d 387, 391 (5th Cir. 2017)).
Because Defendants have satisfied all four stay factors, their motion to
stay the preliminary injunction pending appeal is GRANTED.
STEPHEN A. HIGGINSON, Circuit Judge, concurring in the judgment:
I concur in the court’s stay order because I agree that the Appellants
have demonstrated a substantial likelihood of success on their claim that
Marlowe failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. It is undisputed that
Marlowe did not file a grievance with the prison until several days after he
filed his motion with the district court. See Valentine v. Collier, -- F.3d --, No.
20-20207, 2020 WL 1934431, at *7 (5th Cir. Apr. 22, 2020) (Higginson, J.,
concurring in judgment). Though Marlowe now argues that Appellants’
suspension
of
the
grievance
deadline
process
renders
the
prison’s
administrative remedies “unavailable,” the district court was apparently
presented with this evidence and still came to the conclusion that the prison is
required to adjudicate Marlowe’s grievance by May 7, 2020. In their request
for a stay, the Appellants do not dispute that May 7, 2020 is the deadline for
their response. Should the prison fail to adjudicate Marlowe’s grievance by
May 7, 2020, there may well be an argument that the administrative grievance
process is “unavailable.” See Ross v. Blake, 136 S. Ct. 1850, 1859 (2016).
Finally, this order does not foreclose Marlowe, a diabetic, from
continuing to seek relief through other appropriate channels, such as the state
parole process. Marlowe’s September 2019 application for commutation, which
9
010a
Case: 20-30276
Document: 00515396990
Page: 10
Date Filed: 04/27/2020
No. 20-30276
appears to be pending, includes over 100 pages of exhibits and letters that
purport to show that he has been a model prisoner while in the custody of the
Louisiana Department of Corrections. 5
5 Although we respect that it is the exclusive prerogative of the Louisiana Pardon and Parole Board
to conclude if this evidence demonstrates that he is entitled to relief, all judges on this panel concur
that the clemency petition appears well-supported.
10
011a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 1 of 14
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRISTOPHER MARLOWE
CIVIL ACTION
VERSUS
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
NO.: 18-63-BAJ-EWD
RULING AND ORDER
Before the Court is Plaintiff’s Motion for Temporary Restraining Order
and/or Emergency Motion for Temporary Release (Doc. 93). Plaintiff has filed
an Amended Memorandum in Support (Doc. 100), a Response (Doc. 102), and a PostHearing Reply (Doc. 110). Defendants filed an Opposition (Doc. 101) and Sur-Reply
Memorandum in Opposition (Doc. 108). For the reasons stated herein, Plaintiff’s
Motion (Doc. 93) is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART.
I.
FACTS
Plaintiff seeks emergency relief authorizing his temporary supervised release,
or other appropriate but unspecified forms of relief, while the spread of the COVID19 virus remains a threat within the Louisiana Department of Corrections system.
(Doc. 100 at p. 1). The Court notes that both the President of the United States and
the Governor of Louisiana have declared a state of emergency in response to this
pandemic 1. As a diabetic, Plaintiff alleges that he is especially vulnerable to
1 See, Proclamation Declaring a National Emergency Concerning the Novel Coronavirus Disease
(COVID-19) Outbreak issued March 13, 2020 by President Donald J. Trump. See also, Declaration of
1
012a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 2 of 14
experiencing complications associated with the virus, which is actively circulating at
the Rayburn Correctional Center (“Rayburn”), where he is assigned. (Id. at 1).
According to the evidence presented at the hearing on the Motion, at least 25 people
within the facility, including 23 inmates, have tested positive for COVID-19. (Doc.
110, at p. 1).
Plaintiff originally filed this action in 2018, alleging that Defendants, staff at
the Elayn Hunt Correctional Center, exhibited deliberate indifference towards his
medical needs and provided constitutionally deficient meal service that resulted in
Plaintiff developing diabetes and that the failure to adequately treat his illness later
exacerbated the symptoms. (Doc. 1, at ¶4). Plaintiff filed Amended Complaints, which
Defendants have moved to dismiss. See (Doc. 84). While this case was pending,
Plaintiff was transferred to the Rayburn. He now brings the instant Motion for
Temporary Restraining Order and/or Emergency Motion for Temporary Release (Doc.
93).
The Court held a status conference on April 3, 2020 (Doc. 95) and an
evidentiary hearing on April 7, 2020 (Doc. 109). Additionally, both parties have filed
numerous memoranda to keep the Court apprised of evolving conditions at the
facility.
In his Amended Memorandum in Support (Doc. 100), Plaintiff alleges that his
medical condition places him “at extreme risk to develop life-threatening
complications should he contract COVID-19.” (Doc. 100 at p. 2). He argues that the
Public Health Emergency in Response to COVID-19 issued March 11, 2020 by Governor John Bel
Edwards.
2
013a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 3 of 14
primary steps recommended by the Governor to limit the spread of COVID-19 have
not been and cannot be meaningfully implemented within the Department of
Corrections because prisoners are housed in compact and confined spaces. Id. In his
memorandum, Plaintiff alleges that he shares a dormitory with approximately 78
other inmates who sleep in bunk rows and share five toilets. (Doc. 110–1 at p. 56).
During the evidentiary hearing, Plaintiff provided testimony about numerous
common areas used by the prisoners, including a common water fountain, microwave
ovens, telephones, and a common cafeteria. Id. at 56-61. He also testified that many
prisoners do not take social-distancing measures seriously, that the Warden arranged
for social distance markers to be removed from the floors, and that he had received
no official guidance concerning social-distancing measures from prison officials. Id.
at 64. As noted, at least 23 offenders at Rayburn have tested positive for COVID-19.
(Doc. 110, at p. 1).
In opposition, Defendants allege that they are protected by Eleventh
Amendment immunity and that the Plaintiff fails to sufficiently plead a claim of
unconstitutional conditions. (Doc. 108, at p. 2). Defendants additionally argue that
the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure do not allow a Plaintiff to request new relief or
a new cause of action by way of the filing of a TRO, that Plaintiff lacks standing, and
that Plaintiff failed to fully exhaust administrative remedies, which is typically a
prerequisite to bringing a prisoner claim in federal court. See (Doc. 101).
3
014a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
II.
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 4 of 14
LEGAL STANDARD
To obtain injunctive relief by way of a Temporary Restraining Order, Plaintiff
must establish: (1) a substantial likelihood of prevailing on the merits; (2) a
substantial threat of irreparable injury if the injunction is not granted; (3) that the
threatened injury outweighs any harm that will result to the non-movant if the
injunction is granted; and (4) that the injunction will not disserve the public interest.
See Ridgely v. Fed. Emergency Mgmt. Agency, 512 F.3d 727, 734 (5th Cir. 2008).
III.
DISCUSSION
A. Jurisdiction
As an initial matter, the Court reviews its jurisdiction to consider the Motion.
Defendants allege that it is improper for Plaintiff to allege new claims, not included
in the initial complaint, through the filing of this TRO. While Defendants are correct
that Plaintiff’s Second Amended Complaint (Doc. 64) does not specifically address the
outbreak of the novel coronavirus, it is fully premised upon Plaintiff’s diabetes
diagnosis and the prison facility’s alleged inability to effectively provide medical care
related to it. 2 Plaintiff has been moved to another facility, but remains within the
custody of the Louisiana Department of Corrections, a named Defendant. An
enhanced risk of contracting COVID-19 due to his condition, while not foreseeable at
the time Plaintiff originally filed this lawsuit, stems from the same factual nexus as
the original and amended Complaints.
2 The underlying Complaint is premised upon allegations against personnel at the Elayn Hunt
Correctional Center who allegedly contributed to Plaintiff’s diagnosis of diabetes.
4
015a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 5 of 14
In addition to the factual similarities, the Court finds that it serves the
interests of judicial economy to adjudicate the instant Motion within this ongoing
case. The Court is sufficiently familiar with the claims and defenses asserted by the
Parties and finds that an efficient resolution is warranted by the adjudication of the
Motion by this Court, given the unique circumstances.
Next, the Court shall consider Plaintiff’s standing to bring this claim.
Defendants argue that Plaintiff has failed to allege an injury in fact because the
potential
harms
complained
of
(contracting
coronavirus
and
experiencing
complications associated with it) are not sufficiently likely due to the procedures
implemented at Rayburn to prevent the spread of COVID-19. (Doc. 101 at p. 5–6).
However, the Court notes that when this Motion was filed, only two inmates had
tested positive for COVID-19. As of April 13, 2020, less than two weeks later, that
number had escalated to 25 infections among inmates and staff. (Doc. 110, at p. 1).
As noted, the exponential growth of the novel coronavirus has resulted in
emergency declarations by the President and the Governor, as well as governors of
numerous other states. Due to the nature of this virus, the Court finds that the risk
of contracting the virus in a prison environment, where at least 23 inmates have
already tested positive, poses a sufficiently high risk, rendering this matter ripe for
adjudication even though Plaintiff has not contracted the virus. The United States
Supreme Court has held that the risk of contracting a serious disease may indeed
constitute an unsafe, life-threatening condition that violates the Eighth Amendment.
Helling v. McKinney, 509 U.S. 25, 33, 113 S. Ct. 2475, 2481, 125 L. Ed. 2d 22 (1993).
5
016a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 6 of 14
Further, the Supreme Court held that it would “be odd to deny an injunction to
inmates who plainly proved an unsafe, life-threatening condition in their prison on
the ground that nothing yet had happened to them.” Id. With the clear danger posed
by COVID-19 in the Rayburn facility, Plaintiff has adequately demonstrated
standing.
Regarding Defendants’ assertion that Plaintiff failed to exhaust the
administrative remedies available to him, Plaintiff admits that he did not exhaust
administrative remedies and did not file a request to initiate the Administrative
Remedy Procedure (ARP) related to this claim until April 7, 2020, after filing the
instant Motion. (Doc. 102–2, at p. 2). Plaintiff initially contended that he could not
file a claim because he lacked access to a computer and the ARP process had been
closed because it was “non-essential.” 3 (Doc. 102 at 5).
Generally, under the Prison Labor Reform Act (“PRLA”), pre-litigation
exhaustion of available administrative remedies is mandatory for any suits brought
under § 1983 by prisoners. Porter v. Nussle, 534 U.S. 516, 524, 122 S. Ct. 983, 988,
152 L. Ed. 2d 12 (2002); see also 42 U.S.C. § 1997e(a). Despite the strict approach
required within this Circuit concerning PLRA exhaustion requirements, the United
States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has recognized that a district court must
afford a prisoner an opportunity to show that he has either exhausted the available
administrative remedies or that he should be excused from complying with them.
3 Warden Robert Tanner testified at the hearing that this was not the case, and that ARP requests
would be processed within 48 hours.
6
017a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 7 of 14
Johnson v. Ford, 261 F. App'x 752, 755 (5th Cir. 2008) (holding that, while the facts
presented in that case did not justify excusal, PLRA exhaustion requirements may be
excused where dismissal would be “inefficient and would not further the interests of
justice or the purposes of the exhaustion requirement”).
Here, the statutory 30-day period to adjudicate Plaintiff’s administrative claim
will not expire until May 7, at which point Defendants contend the Court may then
properly hear this matter if it is not satisfactorily resolved through administrative
proceedings sooner. Because of the nature of COVID-19, especially considering its
ability to spread with great rapidity among densely populated communities, like
prisons, the Court must reject Defendants plea and find that the interests of justice
demand action by the Court on an emergency basis. 4 Further, the Court is vested
with a traditional equitable power to issue injunctions to prevent irreparable injury,
pending such exhaustion of administrative remedies. Johnson v. Ford, 261 F. App'x
752, 755 (5th Cir. 2008); Jackson v. D.C., 254 F.3d 262, 268 (D.C. Cir. 2001). Due to
the important implications of this case to the Plaintiff, the Court shall exercise its
authority while the administrative proceedings brought by Plaintiff are still under
review by prison authorities.
4 The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) issued specific guidelines pertaining to the
spread of COVID-19 within correctional and detention facilities. The CDC explained that it was issuing
guidance because detention facilities have a heightened risk for the spread of COVID-19 due to
offenders living within congregate environments, the inability to leave, staff ingress and egress,
transfers between facilities, and more. See CDC Interim Guidance on Management of Coronavirus
Disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Correctional and Detention Facilities (Mar. 23, 2020), at
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/downloads/guidancecorrectional-detention.pdf.
7
018a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 8 of 14
Lastly, sovereign immunity does not apply to Defendants with respect to the
relief requested in the instant Motion. It is axiomatic that state officials acting in
their official capacity can nonetheless be sued for prospective injunctive relief to
correct ongoing violations of federal law. Saahir v. Estelle, 47 F.3d 758, 761 (5th Cir.
1995), citing Pennhurst State Sch. & Hosp. v. Halderman, 465 U.S. 89, 105, 104 S.
Ct. 900, 910, 79 L. Ed. 2d 67 (1984). Here, Plaintiff seeks relief based on alleged
ongoing violations of the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution. Thus,
this Court is appropriately vested with jurisdiction to consider the claim.
B. Request for Relief
Plaintiff’s claim arises under the Eight Amendment, which, as he notes, may
hold an official liable for “deliberate indifference.” (Doc. 110, at p. 2). The Court has
held conferences, conducted an evidentiary hearing and reviewed several filings in
this case that all demonstrate the officials at Rayburn have taken numerous steps to
implement policies to contain the spread of COVID-19 during these challenging
times. While the number of infected inmates has grown, so too have the protective
measures implemented at Rayburn by the DOC in response. Indeed, the demands
made upon corrections officials in their effort to contain the spread of this pandemic
within their facilities is unprecedented.
Robert Tanner, the warden at Rayburn, testified that meetings are held at
least three times weekly to assess the facility’s response to the coronavirus, often
resulting in daily changes. (Doc. 110–1, at p. 26). He further testified that
quarantined offenders receive masks, as do staff members and offenders assigned to
8
019a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 9 of 14
the kitchen, laundry, the infirmary, and anyone the medical director deems should
wear a mask. (Doc. 110–1, at p. 33). Masks are also provided when “medically
necessary.” 5 Warden Tanner admitted that all offenders in the institution could be
provided with a mask, if necessary. Id. at 33–34. Additionally, the guidelines provided
by the DOC list numerous precautions being taken to handle the COVID-19 outbreak
within the prison system. Such guidelines are applicable at Rayburn. Inmates who
are asymptomatic, but have been in close contact with an inmate or employee
confirmed or suspected to have COVID-19, are required to be quarantined for a
minimum of 14 days. (Doc. 108–1, at p. 9). Defendants assert that these measures
are adequate to protect Plaintiff from contracting the disease.
However, Plaintiff’s credible testimony paints a very different picture. For
example, Plaintiff testified that the common water fountain in his dormitory is not
wiped clean after each use by the inmates. He also testified that telephones in the
dormitory are spaced a mere 12 inches apart and that no prisoner separation
procedures have been implemented in the area of the telephones. The microwave
ovens made available to the offenders are not regularly cleaned and disinfected. Also,
no procedures have been implemented to avoid chokepoints in the walkways in the
dormitory. According to the Plaintiff, foot traffic often results in offenders and staff
“almost touching” each other. During mealtimes, inmates allegedly stand in line in
the cafeteria in a heel-to-toe fashion to receive meals. After receiving their meals,
inmates sit directly next to one another at tables in the cafeteria. More troubling is
5 This term was not defined by the Defendants.
9
020a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 10 of 14
the Plaintiff’s testimony that the inmates who serve the food only occasionally wear
face masks in a proper manner while serving food. And the computers used by the
inmates to communicate with family members and attorneys are not cleaned or
sanitized after each use.
Plaintiff contends that Rayburn has struggled to sufficiently execute its own
policies. Plaintiff’s uncontroverted testimony has adequately demonstrated that,
under the circumstances, his Eighth Amendment claim will likely prevail on the
merits. Deliberate indifference is “a stringent standard of fault, requiring proof that
a municipal actor disregarded a known or obvious consequence of his action.” Board
of County Com’rs of Bryan Cnty., Okl. v. Brown, 520 U.S. 397, 410 (1997).
Of particular concern to the Court is the fact that there remain several
instances in which Plaintiff is seemingly unable to properly protect himself from
infection, despite efforts currently being taken by the facility. For example, Plaintiff
testified that while in his bunk, he is capable of touching his bunk neighbor if he
reaches to his left. (Doc. 110-1, at p. 55). Also, as a diabetic, he must frequently visit
the infirmary for testing and treatment. He alleges that he is required to wait in line
at the infirmary in a “shoulder-to-shoulder” manner, thereby increasing the risk of
contracting COVID-19. Id, at 69.
The most recent policy statements provided by the Defendants, which include
the DOC Medical Division’s COVID-19 Guidance (the Policy) issued April 6, 2020,
lists several requirements that Defendants do not appear to be following, thereby
exposing Plaintiff to an unreasonable risk of serious harm. For example, the Policy
10
021a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 11 of 14
requires routine and frequent cleaning of high-touch surfaces and shared resident
equipment. Such cleaning must be conducted using EPA-registered hospital-grade
disinfectants. (Doc. 108–1 at p. 2). On April 13, Plaintiff reported that he had received
a spray-bottle to clean high-touch surfaces as contemplated. See (Doc. 112). However,
a few days later, Plaintiff notified the Court that the bottle was often empty. (Doc.
113, at p. 3). He also informed the Court of several other shortcomings. For example,
he alleges that two medical orderlies who work in the infirmary that he regularly
visits have not worn the proper personal protective equipment recommended for
protection of themselves or others who utilize the services of the infirmary. Id.
Plaintiff has also allegedly witnessed officers and cafeteria workers wearing PPE
incorrectly with their noses exposed from the masks. Id.
It would appear, therefore, that despite taking some steps to deter the spread
of the virus, Rayburn has not effectively implemented the DOC policies that require
staff members and orderlies to wear masks and other PPE to protect the prison
population, including the Plaintiff. (Doc. 108–1 at p. 12–14). The prison has also failed
to meaningfully implement social-distancing procedures and other measures aimed
at thwarting the spread of the coronavirus. Although the DOC policy defines “social
distancing,” it does not require that it be implemented at Rayburn or any other DOC
facilities. Id. at 5. The Court finds it troubling that DOC officials, at least at Rayburn,
have apparently disregarded the importance of social distancing in preventing the
spread of this unique disease, when numerous public health officials, and the
Governor of Louisiana, have consistently urged the residents of the state to observe
11
022a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 12 of 14
such measures to slow the spread of the illness. 6 Defendants’ failure to implement
their own internal protective policies may itself entitle Plaintiff to relief from the
Court. See Johnson v. Epps, 479 F. App'x 583, 590 (5th Cir. 2012) (holding that an
inmate sufficiently stated a claim for deliberate indifference where prison officials
adopted a policy mandating more sanitary procedures, but failed to enforce the
policy).
Accordingly, the Court finds that Plaintiff has shown a substantial likelihood
of prevailing on the merits of this Motion. He has also demonstrated a sufficiently
substantial threat of irreparable injury if relief is not immediately ordered. The
threatened injury that he has proven outweighs any harm that may result to the
State if the injunction is not granted, and the injunction contemplated herein will not
disserve the public. Accordingly, the Court finds that the Plaintiff has met the
requirements for injunctive relief. See, Ridgely at 734.
C.
Remedies
The Court will deny Plaintiff’s request to modify his sentence, to include
temporary release with monitoring conditions. Plaintiff’s sentence was imposed by a
state court, and this Court cannot now conclude that the conditions of confinement,
despite the lack of sufficient precautionary measures, entitles him to immediate
6 The Governor has credited social distancing practices with helping to slow the rate of new COVID-
19 infections within Louisiana. See Gov. Edwards: Social Distancing Working in Coronavirus Fight
(April 10, 2020), available at https://www.kalb.com/content/news/Gov-Edwards-provides-updates-onCOVID-19-on-Good-Friday-569540141.html. Also, the CDC has observed that the best way to prevent
contracting COVID-19 is to practice social distancing, as well as other preventative measures such as
frequent hand-washing, disinfecting surfaces, and covering one’s mouth and nose. See CDC: How to
Protect Yourself and Others (April 13, 2020), available at https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019ncov/prevent-getting-sick/prevention.html.
12
023a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 13 of 14
release. Therefore, the Court will not disturb the judgment of the sentencing court.
Counsel for the Plaintiff have acknowledged that although officials have
implemented several measures aimed at addressing the prevention of the coronavirus
at Rayburn, more must be done, and some remedy other than Plaintiff’s immediate
release may be appropriate.
Based on the evidence presented and the policies provided by Defendants, the
Court finds that Defendants are capable of providing Plaintiff with the care necessary
to protect him from COVID-19 without requiring relief in the form of temporary
compassionate release during the duration of the COVID-19 crisis. Plaintiff’s request
to modify his sentence is therefore DENIED.
IV.
CONCLUSION
Defendants must comply with the Governor’s recommendations and their own
internal policies concerning disinfection of common areas and the wearing of masks
by staff and certain categories of offenders, particularly those who work in the
infirmary and cafeteria where the Plaintiff is assigned. Officials must also implement
reasonable social-distancing measures to limit the spread of COVID-19 to the
Plaintiff.
Accordingly,
IT IS ORDERED that Plaintiff’s Motion for Temporary Restraining
Order and/or Emergency Motion for Temporary Release (Doc. 93) is
GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART.
13
024a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 115
04/23/20 Page 14 of 14
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendants shall submit to the Court a
Plan to ensure the implementation of proper hygiene practices in the dormitory in
which Plaintiff is assigned, and to implement social distancing practices to limit the
spread of COVID-19, as recommended by the Center For Disease Control and other
public health authorities, in Plaintiff’s immediate living area, for the protection of the
Plaintiff. Defendants shall also submit a Plan to minimize Plaintiff’s exposure to
possible infected persons while visiting the infirmary and cafeteria areas of the
prison.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendants shall submit the Plan herein
ordered within 5 days of the date of this Order.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiff’s request for an Order
authorizing his immediate supervised released is DENIED.
The Parties are advised that the Court may impose additional substantive
precautionary measures following its review and evaluation of the Plan.
Baton Rouge, Louisiana, this 23rd day of April, 2020.
_______________________________________
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
14
025a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 93
04/01/20 Page 1 of 4
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER AND/OR
EMERGENCY MOTION FOR TEMPORARY RELEASE
NOW INTO COURT, through undersigned counsel, comes Plaintiff, Mr. Christopher
Marlowe, to file this Notice of Emergency Motion and Emergency Motion for Temporary
Release; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P.
65(b), and thereafter, a preliminary injunction pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 65(a), and request
that the matter be heard as soon as possible.
Mr. Marlowe, a diabetic prisoner, seeks emergency relief that is currently only in this
Court. Without immediate intervention, the conditions of Mr. Marlowe’s confinement continue
to expose him to the COVID-19 virus that is currently circulating at the Rayburn
Correctional Center.
As a diabetic prisoner, Mr. Marlowe could develop serious and
life-threatening complications should he contract COVID-19.
As explained in greater
detail below, it is impossible for him to exercise any degree of social distancing as
recommended by the Center for Disease Control and the State of Louisiana. Consequently, he
asks this Court to immediately issue an order that temporarily releases him to home
confinement and/or community supervision
1
026a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 93
04/01/20 Page 2 of 4
Given the urgency, Plaintiff requests that the Court set an expedited briefing schedule and
review this motion as soon as practicable. Plaintiff waives any right to file a reply. The Motion is
based on this Notice of Motion and Motion, the Accompany Memorandum of Points and
Authorities, and the supporting documents filed herewith.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
Upon the respective exhibits provided therewith, and the accompanying memorandum of
law, Plaintiff respectfully moves this Court to:
1. Enter an Order authorizing his temporary supervised release with or without location
monitoring until spread of the COVID-19 virus is no longer a threat within the Louisiana
Department of Corrections system.
2. Such other relief as the Court deems just and proper.
WHEREFORE, it is respectfully requested that this Court grant this application for a temporary
restraining order and preliminary injunction that temporarily releases Mr. Marlowe from the
custody of the DPS&C and places him temporarily on supervised release with or without
location monitoring
Dated: April 1, 2020
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Emily H. Posner
______________________________
Emily H. Posner (La. Bar No. 35284)
7214 St. Charles Box 913
New Orleans, Louisiana 70118
Phone: 225-746-8820
Cell: 207-930-5232
Fax: 225-208-1439
2
027a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 93
04/01/20 Page 3 of 4
ep@emilyposnerlaw.com
/s/ Alexander Bollag
______________________________
Alexander “Sascha” Bollag (La. Bar No. 34447)
5208 Magazine St, #191
New Orleans, Louisiana 70115
Phone: 504.913.7740
Fax: 813.774.6595
Email: sbollag@greenjusticelegal.org
Attorneys for Mr. Marlowe
3
028a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 93
029a
04/01/20 Page 4 of 4
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 1 of 21
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
PLAINTIFF’S AMENDED MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
TEMPORARY RESTRAINING ORDER AND/OR EMERGENCY
MOTION FOR TEMPORARY RELEASE
MAY IT PLEASE THE COURT
INTRODUCTION
The current declared State of Emergency concerning the COVID-19 Pandemic requires
expedited and emergency relief in the form of temporarily releasing Mr. Marlowe from custody
to supervised release with or without location monitoring. Such relief may very well save his
life. The relief requested should only last until the spread of COVID-19 ceases within the
Louisiana Department of Safety & Corrections (“DPS&C”) system. As outlined below, the
COVID-19 disease has infected staff and prisoners housed at the B.B. Rayburn Correctional
Center (“Rayburn”) where Mr. Marlowe is housed.
As of this writing, per the DPS&C’s website, 15 inmates at Rayburn have tested positive
for the virus. Louisiana Department of Safety & Corrections, COVID-19 Inmate Positives,
https://doc.louisiana.gov/doc-covid-19-testing/ (last accessed Apr. 5, 2020).
1
030a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 2 of 21
As a diabetic prisoner, Mr. Marlowe is at extreme risk to develop life-threatening
complications should he contract COVID-19. It is impossible for Mr. Marlowe to abide by the
social distancing and isolation measures suggested by the Center for Disease Control (“CDC”)
under the current conditions of his confinement.
Louisiana is today under a state of emergency due to the spread of the novel coronavirus
and COVID-19, the deadly disease it causes. Like the rest of the country and the world, the State
is bracing for the potentially catastrophic ravages of this pandemic. The Governor has taken
significant steps to flatten the curve of new cases before hospitals are overwhelmed and the death
toll skyrockets, as it has elsewhere. See, e.g., Exhibit A, Governor John Bel Edwards March 11,
2020 Proclamation Number 25 JBE 2020); Edwards March 13, 2020 Proclamation Number JBE
2020—27); Edwards March 16, 2020 Proclamation Number JBE 2020—30); Edwards March 19,
2020 Proclamation Number JBE 2020—32); Edwards March 22, 2020 Proclamation Number 33
JBE 2020), available at https://gov.louisiana.gov/index.cfm/newsroom/category/10. The primary
components of the governor’s action have been to require social distancing to keep Louisianans
at least six feet apart at all times and to prepare hospitals and health care workers for the coming
surge in cases.
Those steps have not been, and cannot be, meaningfully implemented in the Louisiana
Department of Public Safety and Corrections (DPS&C) for one simple reason: the system houses
prisoners in compact spaces. DPS&C houses tens of thousands of people in crowded dormitories
where they live, sleep, and bathe within just a few feet of each other. Thousands of these
prisoners, like Mr. Marlowe, are those that most vulnerable to death or severe complications
2
031a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 3 of 21
from COVID-19: the elderly and people with serious underlying medical conditions. These
conditions pose an unacceptable risk of harm for people who live and work in DPS&C facilities,
as well as to the broader public: prison walls cannot stop the spread of pandemic disease.
Already, there has been an outbreak of the coronavirus at a federal prison in Louisiana and at
least five prisoners have died from, and eleven prisoners have tested positive for, the COVID-19
virus. Caroline Habetz, Fifth Inmate at Oakdale Federal Prison Dies from COVID-19 (Apr. 3,
2020), https://www.kplctv.com/2020/04/03/fifth-inmate-oakdale-federal-prison-dies-covid-/.
In addition, two prisoners housed in the Orleans Parish Justice Center, along with seven
medical workers and twenty-two employees at the facility have tested positive for COVID-19.
See Orleans Parish Sheriff’s Office Update Regarding Covid-10 Precaution and Activities (Apr.
3, 2020), http://www.opcso.org. As well, at least two prisoners at the East Baton Rouge Parish
Prison have tested positive for COVID-19. See Rachael Thomas, et al., 2 EBR inmates test
positive
for
COVID-19;
wing
of
prison
quarantined
(Mar.
30
2020),
https://www.wafb.com/2020/03/31/ebr-inmate-tests-positive-covid-after-reported-drugoverdose-wing-prison-quarantined/.
Mr. Marlowe is currently housed at the B.B. Rayburn Correctional Center (“Rayburn”) in
Angie, Louisiana. Rayburn is no different from any other correctional facility, and faces all of
the problems mentioned above. Mr. Marlowe reports his Rayburn dormitory houses 79
individuals and is approximately a 5,000 square foot space. See Exhibit B, Mr. Marlowe’s jpay
communications. There are only five (5) toilets shared amongst all of these men. Mr. Marlowe is
part of the most vulnerable population, as he suffers from diabetes (the subject of the underlying
3
032a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 4 of 21
lawsuit), thus is acutely at risk of death or severe complication should he become infected with
COVID-19.
On March 31, 2020, undersigned counsel received verification that the coronavirus is
present at the Rayburn facility, putting Mr. Marlowe at extreme risk of contracting this disease.
See Exhibit C, Email Confirmation from Lt. Carol Jordan that COVID is present at Rayburn. As
of April 5, 2020, per DPS&C’s COVID-19 website, 15 prisoners at Rayburn have tested
positive for the virus. Louisiana Department of Safety & Corrections, COVID-19 Inmate
Positives, https://doc.louisiana.gov/doc-covid-19-testing/ (last accessed Apr. 5, 2020).1
Therefore, this court should immediately enter a Temporary Restraining Order and
Preliminary Injunction ordering Mr. Marlowe’s immediate temporary release until the
danger of the COVID-19 pandemic in the DPS&C system and Rayburn has passed.
Mr. Marlowe has been an exemplary resident of the DPS&C system, with only one
writeup in 10 years of incarceration. As demonstrated by his DPS&C calculated Targeted
Interventions Gaining Enhanced Re-entry (TIGER) score, Mr. Marlowe is a low risk to reoffend
and is not a flight risk. See Exhibit D, Mr. Marlowe’s TIGER score.
Mr. Marlowe can be temporarily released to the US Probation Office or the Louisiana
Office of Probation and Parole with or without location monitoring, at his cousin’s house in
Leesville, Louisiana or at his mother’s rural property in Lufkin, Texas. See Exhibit E, email
confirmations from Brooklynn Roberts and Liz Norton.
1
Undersigned counsel waited until 11:30 AM to file the foregoing. The DPS&C website indicates that it will provid
updated numbers of prisoners who have tested positive with COVID-19. However, as of 11:30 AM, the website has
not been updated with numbers for April 6, 2020.
4
033a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 5 of 21
Considering the foregoing, Mr. Marlowe requests that this Honorable Court grant him
this limited and temporary relief.
I.
OVERCROWDING OF MEDICALLY VULNERABLE PEOPLE AND THOSE
HOUSED IN CONGREGATE LIVING AREAS CAUSES AN UNACCEPTABLE
RISK OF HARM DURING THE GLOBAL COVID-19 PANDEMIC
A.
COVID-19 Is a Deadly, Easily Transmissible Virus.
On March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization (“WHO”) declared a global
pandemic. See World Health Organization, Director-General Opening Remarks (March 11,
2020),
https://www.who.int/dg/speeches/detail/who-director-general-s-opening-remarks-at-the-
media-briefing-on-covid-19---11-march-2020. Citing “deep[] concern[] both by the alarming
levels of spread and severity, and by the alarming levels of inaction,” it called for countries to
take “urgent and aggressive action.” Id.; see also NPR, Coronavirus: COVID-19 Is Now
Officially
a
Pandemic,
WHO
Says,
(March
11,
2020),
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2020/03/11/814474930/coronavirus-covid-19-isnow-officially a-pandemic-who-says.
The number of people infected is growing exponentially. The death toll in Italy, which
began experiencing this epidemic about a week earlier than the first diagnosed American case,
saw a rise of 30% overnight in the 24 hours between March 5, 2020, and March 6, 2020 and a
rise of 25% on March 15 alone—a day on which 368 people died in Italy from COVID-19.
Crispian Balmer & Angelo Amante, Reuters, Italy coronavirus deaths near 200 after biggest
daily jump, (Mar. 6, 2020), https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-italy/italycoronavirus-deaths-near-200-after-biggest-daily-jump-idUSKBN20T2ML.
5
034a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 6 of 21
Experts predict similarly rapid growth in the United States. This pandemic has prompted
the federal, state, and local governments to declare a state of emergency. White House
Proclamation, Proclamation on Declaring a National Emergency Concerning the Novel
Coronavirus
Disease
(COVID-19)
Outbreak
https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/proclamation-
(March
13,
2020),
declaring-national-emergency-
concerning-novel-coronavirus-disease-covid-19-outbreak/; see also Louisiana Office of the
Governor, Gov. Edwards Declares Public Health Emergency in Response to COVID-19 (March
11, 2020), https://gov.louisiana.gov/index.cfm/newsroom/detail/2400; Katelyn Umholtz, New
Orleans mayor declares state of emergency after officials confirm 13 cases, Times-Picayune,
(March 11, 2020), https://www.nola.com/news/coronavirus/article_68df3890-63e5-11ea-a4ca2f0e871e7eaf.html.
The exponential growth of coronavirus cases in Louisiana has been staggering. Data
released March 21, 2020 by a researcher at the University of Louisiana Lafayette found that
Louisiana presently has the fastest spread of COVID-19 of any region in the world. See
Louisiana Governor’s Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness, COVID-19
Louisiana Case Info, https://gov.louisiana.gov/assets/docs/covid/govCV19Brief-2.pdf. As of
April 5, 2020, there are 13,010 confirmed coronavirus cases in Louisiana, 477 individuals have
died and 1,803 are in the hospital. Louisiana Department of Health, Coronavirus (COVID-19),
http://ldh.la.gov/Coronavirus/ (last accessed Apr. 5, 2020). At a news conference on March 24,
2020, Louisiana Governor John Bel Edwards announced that the state had “the fastest growth
6
035a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 7 of 21
rate of confirmed cases in the world in the first 13 days.” Hollie Silverman, Louisiana Governor
Says His State Has the Fastest Growth Rate of Coronavirus Cases in the World, CNN (Mar. 24,
2020),
https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/23/us/louisiana-coronavirus-fastest-growth/index.html.
The number of cases on March 31, 2020 increased by thirty percent from the day before. See
John Bowden, Coronavirus cases in Louisiana spike by more than 30 percent in 24 hours (Mar.
31,
2020),
https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/490408-coronavirus-cases-in-louisiana-
spike-by-more-than-30-percent-in-24-hours.
The Louisiana Department of Health has reported that, “[b]elow is what we know about
the underlying conditions among COVID-19 deaths to date, as of March 29:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Louisiana
Pulmonary (12%)
Cardiac (21%)
Diabetes (40%)
Chronic Kidney Disease (23%)
Chronic Liver Disease (2%)
Immunocompromised (4%)
Neurological (6%)
Obesity (25%)
No Underlying Conditions (3%).”
Department
of
Health
Updates
for
3/30/2020,
http://ldh.la.gov/index.cfm/newsroom/detail/5521. In addition, staff and prisoners throughout the
Louisiana Department of Corrections have contracted COVID-19. See Sledge, Matt, Louisiana
Corrections
Staffer
and
inmate
die
from
coronavirus
2020),https://www.nola.com/news/coronavirus/article_38a10bb0-72d4-11ea-bc5a-
7
036a
(Mar.
30,
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 8 of 21
77c8d83cba3d.html; see also Louisiana Department of Safety & Corrections, COVID-19 Inmate
Positives, https://doc.louisiana.gov/doc-covid-19-testing/ (last accessed Apr. 5, 2020).
Of particular importance, the COVID-19 virus is currently circulating in B.B.
Rayburn Correctional Center (“RCC”) where Mr. Marlowe, a diabetic prisoner, is
currently housed. As of April 5, 2020 15 inmates at Rayburn have tested positive. See
Louisiana
Department
of
Safety
&
Corrections,
COVID-19
Inmate
Positives,
https://doc.louisiana.gov/doc-covid-19-testing/ (last accessed Apr. 5, 2020. In just two days since
the parties held a telephone conference with the Court, the number of COVID-19 prisoners at
Rayburn has tripled.
There is no vaccine for COVID-19, and there is no cure. See Exhibit F, Dr. Michael Stern
Declaration. No one has prior immunity. Id. It is easily transmissible—spreading “through
droplets generated when an infected person coughs or sneezes, or through droplets of saliva or
discharge from the nose.” Id. It is believed “that a significant amount of transmission may be
from people who are infected but asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic.” Id. at ¶ 5. Once a person
has been exposed to the virus, she may show symptoms within as little as two days, and her
condition might “seriously deteriorate in as little as five days (perhaps sooner) after that.” Id.
The effects of COVID-19 are very serious and can include severe respiratory illness,
major organ damage, and, for a significant number of people, death. Stern Decl. ¶¶ 6, 7, 13. The
risk of death or serious illness is especially high for vulnerable populations, including people
over the age of 50 and people, regardless of age, with “underlying health problems such as—but
not limited to—weakened immune systems, hypertension, diabetes, blood, lung, kidney, heart,
8
037a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 9 of 21
and liver disease, and possibly pregnancy.” Id. ¶ 6. People infected with COVID-19, especially
those in vulnerable populations, may require significant medical attention, including ventilator
assistance for respiration and intensive care. Id. ¶ 7.
B.
COVID-19 Will Spread Rapidly in the Prison Environment, and
Incarcerated People Are at Particular Risk Due to Serious Medical
Conditions and Crowded Congregate Living Spaces.
Mr. Marlowe, a diabetic incarcerated prisoner at RCC, is at heightened risk of serious
illness or death from COVID-19. See Exhibit G, Mr. Marlowe’s University Medical Center
Records. As discussed supra, the Louisiana Department of Health reports that having diabetes is
the leading underlying medical complication of all coronavirus deaths in the State.
The WHO has recognized that incarcerated people “are likely to be more vulnerable to
the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak than the general population because of the
confined conditions in which they live together.” See WHO Preparedness, prevention and control
of COVID-19 in prisons and other places of detention (Mar. 13, 2020), available at
http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/434026/Preparedness-prevention-andcontrol-of-COVID-19-in-prisons.pdf?ua=1.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”), in guidance on
management of COVID-19 in correctional and detention facilities, has identified that COVID-19
presents a particularly heightened danger in correctional facilities because “incarcerated/detained
populations have higher prevalence of infectious and chronic diseases and are in poorer health
than the general population, even at younger ages.” See CDC Interim Guidance on Management
of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Correctional and Detention Facilities (Mar. 23,
9
038a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
available
2020),
at
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 10 of 21
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/downloads/guidance-
correctional-detention.pdf. On March 27, 2020, a group of Louisiana physicians and
epidemiologists wrote to Gov. Edwards to urge him to “take immediate action to safeguard the
lives of those involved in our statewide court system and the Louisiana Department of Public
Safety and Corrections, including those who work or are detained in these facilities, their
families, and their communities.” Exhibit H, Letter from Katherine Andrinopoulos, et al. to Gov.
John Bel Edwards, March 27, 2020. The letter further explained that:
Prisons and jails contain high concentrations of people in close proximity, and are
breeding grounds for the uncontrolled transmission of SARS-CoV-2, the virus
that causes COVID-19. People are housed cheek-by-jowl, in tightly-packed and
poorly-ventilated dormitories; they share toilets, showers, and sinks; they wash
their bedsheets and clothes infrequently; and often lack access to basic personal
hygiene items. These facilities lack the ability to separate sick people from well
people and to quarantine those who have been exposed without endangering
others. Adequate medical care is hard to provide, even without COVID-19, and in
light of this pandemic jails and prisons are tinderboxes, ready to explode and
endanger our entire country.
Id. (emphasis added).
C.
The Most Critical Prevention and Control Strategies—Social Distancing and
Isolation to Prevent Transmission—Cannot be Implemented at Rayburn Due
to Existing Crowding and Space Constraints.
The only way to control the virus is to use preventive strategies, including social
distancing.” See Stern Decl. ¶ 4. Put simply, limiting person-to-person contact “is critical to
saving lives.” Id. ¶ 8. That is why Gov. Edwards has ordered all individuals living in the State of
Louisiana to stay home or at their place of residence until April 30, 2020. See Exhibit A. That is
also why the CDC, in guidance on management of COVID-19 in correctional and detention
10
039a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 11 of 21
facilities, named social distancing as “a cornerstone of reducing transmission of respiratory
diseases such as COVID-19.” See CDC Interim Guidance on Management of Coronavirus
Disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Correctional and Detention Facilities (Mar. 23, 2020), available at
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/downloads/guidance-correctional-detention.pdf.
The CDC stated also that social distancing requires people—including those who are
asymptomatic—to remain at least six feet from each other at all times. Id. (emphasis added).
Recognizing the critical importance of social distancing and the difficulty of achieving it
under existing conditions in correctional and detention facilities, numerous international, state,
and local jurisdictions have taken immediate steps to reduce the number of incarcerated people.
Iran, for example, has temporarily released around 85,000 people from its prisons as of March
24, 2020. See Nasser Karimi, Iran state TV: Khamenei to pardon 10,000 more prisoners (Mar.
19, 2020), https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/iran-state-tv-khamenei-pardon-10000prisoners-69679695.
States and counties across the United States have undertaken similar measures. For
example, the Iowa Department of Corrections plans to expedite the release of 700 incarcerated
people, and the North Dakota Parole Board has granted early release to 56 of the 60 people who
applied for consideration this month. See Times-Republican, Iowa’s prisons will accelerate
release
of
approved
inmates
to
mitigate
COVID-19
(Mar.
23,
2020),
https://www.timesrepublican.com/news/todays-news/2020/03/iowas-prisons-will-acceleraterelease-of-approved-inmates-to-mitigate-covid-19/. Los Angeles, Denver, and Philadelphia all
have instituted policies aimed at reducing jail populations, including reducing or delaying arrests
11
040a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 12 of 21
and releasing individuals being held for drug offenses. Id. In Maine, the Department of
Corrections has released at least 29 prisoners to Supervised Community Confinement. See
Judy Harrison, Inmate population in Maine falls in wake of coronavirus outbreak (Mar. 28,
2020), https://bangordailynews.com/2020/03/28/news/bangor/inmate-population-in-maine-fallsin-wake-of-coronavirus-outbreak/. (emphasis added).
Similarly in New Orleans, the Judges of the Criminal District Court issued an en banc
order requiring the Orleans Parish Sheriff to immediately release “all persons detained in his
custody for violations of the following:
a.
b.
c.
d.
Arrests for Failure to Appear on Probation Status;
Misdemeanor Pre-Trials;
Contempt of Court; and
Defendants remanded for positive drug tests with a bond in effect.”
See En Banc Order, Orleans Parish Criminal District Court (Marc. 25, 2020), available at
http://www.criminalcourt.org/uploads/2/5/3/5/25359518/2020-03-25_orleanscriminal.pdf.
Additionally, on April 2, 2020, Louisiana Supreme Court Chief Justice Bernette Joshua
Johnson sent a letter to all Louisiana District Court judges urging them to “minimize the number
of people detained in jails where possible,” as “an outbreak of COVID-19 in our jails would be
potentially catastrophic for jail staff, the families of jail staff, and inmates.” Exhibit I, Letter
from Chief Justice Bernette Joshua Johnson to Louisiana District Court Judges, Apr. 2, 2020.
DPS&C, however, has not taken any action to accommodate prisoners like Mr. Marlowe
who are at extreme risk to develop life-threatening complication should they contract COVID19. Namely, medical parole continues to not be an option for Mr. Marlowe, because current
12
041a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 13 of 21
regulations require at least a sixty-day notification to the public about a medical parolee’s
hearing date. In addition, the Secretary has the authority to furlough thousands of prisoners
pursuant to La. R. S. 15:833. Such action would greatly reduce the DP&C’s prison population
and potentially create the climate for prisoners not eligible for furlough to properly socially
distance themselves from one another. However, to date, undersigned counsel know of no such
action taken by DPS&C.
Consequently, Mr. Marlowe – a known prisoner at high-risk to develop severe or fatal
consequences should he contract COVID-19 – has been left in a facility where COVID-19 is
circulating widely. In the absence of action from the State of Louisiana concerning convicted
prisoners like Mr. Marlowe, the only humane action to take would be to temporarily release him.
Indeed, keeping Mr. Marlowe in prison under such conditions would be a violation of his
constitutional rights, specifically his right not to be subjected to cruel and unusual punishment
under the Eighth Amendment. Indeed, the risk of contracting “serious contagious diseases” may
constitute an “unsafe, life-threatening condition” in violation of the Eighth Amendment. Helling
v. McKinney, 509 U.S. 25, 33 (1993); see also Hutto v. Finney, 437 U.S. 678, 682-685 (1978)
(recognizing the need for a remedy where prisoners were crowded into cells and some had
infectious diseases).
Mr. Marlowe lives in daily fear of contracting this deadly disease. Living with no
control over one’s environment in such a dangerous climate is especially cruel and unusual.
Courts across the country have already created processes for efficient and widespread review of
such dangers. See e.g. Committee for Pub. Counsel Servs. v. Chief Justice of the Trial Court,
13
042a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 14 of 21
Massachusetts SJC Docket No. SJ-2020-0115 (appointing an Associate Justice to oversee a
petition seeking (among other things) release for post-conviction inmates “who are vulnerable to
COVID-19, near the end of their sentence, or who do not pose a threat to the public”).
The conditions at Rayburn simply do not allow for proper prevention and management
strategies, as they are physically impossible due to the number of inmates and the facility’s
design. Mr. Marlowe reports the following conditions at Rayburn on March 30, 2020:
we don't have free access to bleach or cleaning agents. we dont have anything to
wipe the phones with, no alcohol pads or anything like they told dad at the
meeting. there are no paper towels to dry hands. they issue us one bar of soap
every two weeks to bathe and wash hands with. we live 20-30" apart in our beds.
there are 79 inmates in approx 5,000sqft. we share 5 toilets and sinks. all of our
clothes/bed sheets are being washed together with other dorms.
we eat at tables, 4 to a table, in a cafeteria that has now proven to have had covidpositive people working until 3 days ago, but the others that worked with him are
still there. so, we have possibly contaminated people cooking our food/handling
dishes and pots. plus they obviously reuse all trays, cups, and spoons for the
whole compound exacerbating the potential for cross contamination.
See Exhibit B.
On March 31, 2020 he reported the following:
they just quarantined another dorm, 158 more people. 3 or 4 of the residents had
fevers and went the infirmary. that's a total of 316 on dorm quarantine. they are
also keeping people in solitary confinement cells for quarantine and others in
makeshift housing areas in the visiting shed, besides what is in quarantine in the
infirmary.the scary part is that they decided to do a bed shuffle on Monday and
put two of guys from that dorm in my bed area. one or two staff were sent home
due to symptoms, also. one minute ago: two guys on my tier just got
quarantined, they work for the staff that was sent home. we may be next as a
whole dorm. she was the commissary officer.
Id.
14
043a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 15 of 21
On April 1, 2020, Mr. Marlowe reported the following about his conditions at Rayburn:
I have, when I'm layin in my bed, within my 5ft bubble I have 3 people , 11
people within 8 ft of me. if we're not in bed and are standing, its 5-6 ft...
and solution to magically fix this is go head to toe... makes no difference. just
makes sleep uncomfortable.
Id.
On April 5, 2020, Mr. Marlowe reported:
the yard times have changed, but that doesn't stop people being close, since every
yard has 316 inmates living together, ours has half since the other side is a cell
block.
no other changes... I'm nervous, but c'est la vie.
did a lot of introspection today. I'm really hoping to have the chance to do good
for the world, be a dad, and make my parents proud...
people in here are scared and trying make the best of it, but other inmates are still
being retarded and cooking and eating together, hanging out close. . .
Id.
Of particular importance, as Mr. explains below, putting him in an isolation cell is not an
option because it puts him at great risk to develop further diabetic complications
cell blocks are horrible idea for a diabetic because you loose any control over
access to emergency foods or attention by medical. you are only dealt with during
meals and pill call. if I take insulin and it happens to be in excess of what I need
and I do have access to my food, I die. most don't understand the dynamics of
diabetes and the problem is so big because its hard to maintain as a type one.
you're not allowed food, candy, no commissary, and no med attention until pill
calls. well, I don't eat rice or bread because of the glucose influence, and if I can't
substitute with oatmeal or something, I can die from insulin overdose. of course
the simple answer is to take less insulin, but then if I eat too much or eat wrong, I
can
enter
ketoacidosis
or
have
a
stroke.
that's the diabetic reason. that's why diabetics tend to be the best behaved inmates
15
044a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 16 of 21
- we're afraid to die because of a dinner roll. the cell block has the very real
potential to turn any diabetic's sentence into a death sentence by lethal injection.
this is NOT a dramatization.
Id.
D. Time is of the Essence to Prevent the Spread of COVID-19 to Mr. Marlowe – a
High Risk, Diabetic Prisoner.
Action must be taken immediately if there is any chance to stop the global COVID-19
pandemic from running rampant in prison systems and striking down the most vulnerable people
in custody. As Rick Raemisch, the former executive director of the Colorado Department of
Corrections, recognized: “These prisons are bacteria factories. I don’t think people understand
the gravity of what’s going to happen if this runs in a prison, and I believe it’s inevitable. You’re
going to see devastation that’s unbelievable.” David Montgomery, Prisons Are Bacteria
Factories’;
Elderly
Most
at
Risk,
2
(Mar.
25,
2020),
available
at
https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2020/03/25/prisons-arebacteria-factories-elderly-most-at-risk.
To date, DPS&C has not made public any plans whatsoever as to how it intends to
encourage social distancing and manage any cases of COVID-19 in its facilities, let alone how it
intends to respond to an outbreak. Even if DPS&C had a robust plan in place, it would still be in
its interest and the public interest to release medically vulnerable people, which they have not
made any commitment to do.
As such, this Court should immediately order that Mr. Marlowe, a high-risk diabetic
prisoner, be temporarily placed in a supervised release program with or without location
16
045a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 17 of 21
monitoring at either his cousin’s or mother’s home for the duration of this pandemic. Otherwise,
Mr. Marlowe remains at grave immediate risk of contracting this serious and potentially fatal
disease. This risk is heightened by the confirmation that COVID-19 is now widespread at
Rayburn.
The relief requested by Mr. Marlowe will greatly contribute to flattening the curve of
COVID-19 cases among incarcerated populations and limit the impact of transmission both
inside correctional facilities and in the community after incarcerated people are released. Such
measures will also reduce the burden on the correctional system in terms of stabilizing and
transferring critically ill patients, as well as the burden on the community health care system to
which such patients will be sent. Each person needlessly infected in a correctional setting who
develops severe illness will be one too many. See Exhibit J, Matthew J. Akiyama, Flattening the
Curve for Incarcerated Populations – Covid-19 in Jails and Prisons, THE NEW ENGLAND
JOURNAL OF MEDICINE (Apr. 2, 2020) (stating also “we believe that we need to prepare now, by
“decarcerating,” or releasing, as many people as possible, focusing on those who are least likely
to commit additional crimes.”).
II.
MR. MARLOWE IS NOT A RISK TO REOFFEND OR DISOBEY CONDITIONS
OF AN ORDER FOR TEMPORARY RELEASE
A.
Brief Procedural History of Mr. Marlowe’s Criminal Case.
Mr. Marlowe is currently serving a twenty-year sentence for attempted second-degree
murder. The alleged underlying offense occurred outside of a hotel where Mr. Marlowe was
hired as private-security post-Katrina, and a scuffle ensued between him and a fellow private
17
046a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 18 of 21
citizen. Mr. Marlowe’s defense rested on a theory of self-defense. The matter proceeded to trial
on June 15, 2009. On June 16, 2009, the matter went before a jury, which returned with a hung
verdict. On September 21, 2009, a second trial commenced. On September 24, 2009, the jury
returned a non-unanimous 11-1 verdict.2
Prior to this incident, Mr. Marlowe’s only prior interactions with the criminal justice
system were a few parking and speeding tickets. Mr. Marlowe is a decorated veteran of the U.S.
Army. See Exhibit K, Mr. Marlowe’s Clemency/Pardon Petition. He served from 2002-2006
(Serial Number 099-76-5315). Id. He was honorably discharged and served in Iraq. During his
service he received the following Decorations:
•
•
•
•
•
•
Id.
National Defense Service Medal
Global War on Terrorism Service Medal
Louisiana Honor Medal
Korea Defense Service Medal
Aviation Badge
Army Achievement Medal
Mr. Marlowe is a rehabilitated man. He requests that the Court review his clemency
application, which is currently pending before the pardon board.3 He has thus far served ten
years at hard labor in the Department of Corrections. Id. In that time period, he has received only
2
In 2018, Louisiana amended its constitution to require unanimous juries for felony convictions.
However, the law does not apply retroactively. Had Mr. Marlowe been tried today, he would never have
been convicted and would not be in prison now and facing the heightened risk of contracting COVID-19.”
3
Mr. Marlowe has been waiting since January of this year to have the pardon board calendar hearing on
this matter. Due to the current state of emergency, the parole and pardon board are no longer meeting.
See Letter from Francis Abbot (Mar. 13, 2020), available at https://s32082.pcdn.co/wpcontent/uploads/2020/03/Coronavirus-Hearing-Suspension-031320.pdf.
18
047a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 19 of 21
one write-up, which was eight years ago in 2012. Id. During his incarceration, Mr. Marlowe has
earned the following accolades:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Bachelor of Arts in Communication (Dec. 2019)
Associate of Arts in General Studies (Sep. 2018)
Dean’s List (2018/2019)
Living in Freedom (2017)
Construction Project Manager (2016)
Construction Project Supervisor (2016)
Construction Project Foreman (2016)
Tutor Training (2015)
Toastmaster (2015)
PTSD Peer Counselor (2018)
Heavy Equipment Operator, Level 1, 2, 3 (2015)
HVAC Technician (2014)
Theological Seminar (2014)
Plumbing Helper (2011)
Adult Education Tutor (2010)
Anger Management (certificate attached)
Substance Abuse (certificate attached)
Parenting (certificate attached)
Beat the Streets (certificate attached)
AA/NA (certificate attached)
Hospice Care (certificate attached)
Financial Management (certificate attached)
Id.
Mr. Marlowe is a Class A Trusty and works with the canine chase team. Id. Undersigned
counsel believe that any official at Rayburn would confirm all of this and recommend Mr.
Marlowe for release. Mr. Marlowe’s DPS&C generated TIGER score provides further strong
evidence of his rehabilitation and the lack of likelihood of recidivism. See Exhibit D,
Moreover, Mr. Marlowe is a diabetic inmate. His chronic illness is exceedingly difficult
to manage in a prison setting under normal circumstances. He does not have access to regular
19
048a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 20 of 21
dental, podiatry and optometry appointments to help manage his diabetes. Further, his access to
appropriate food choices that would best manage his diabetes are extremely limited.
Lastly, and most importantly, Mr. Marlowe’s diabetic condition puts him at grave
immediate risk to develop serious complications should he contract COVID-19. Due to the
unavoidable conditions at RCC, it is impossible for Mr. Marlowe to abide by CDC social
distancing recommendations to help reduce his likelihood of contracting the illness.
Mr. Marlowe has a loving and supportive family. Should he be released, he can live with
either his mother at her property in Lufkin, Texas or with his cousin in Leesville, Louisiana. See
Exhibit E, Letters from Liz Norton and Brooklynn Roberts (Mar. 31, 2020).
CONCLUSION
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Court grant this application for a
temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction that temporarily releases Mr. Marlowe
from the custody of the DPS&C and places him temporarily in a supervised release program with
or without location monitoring.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Emily H. Posner
______________________________
Emily H. Posner (La. Bar No. 35284)
7214 St. Charles Box 913
New Orleans, Louisiana 70118
Phone: 225-746-8820
Cell: 207-930-5232
Fax: 225-208-1439
emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com
20
049a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100
04/06/20 Page 21 of 21
/s/ Alexander Bollag
______________________________
Alexander “Sascha” Bollag (La. Bar No. 34447)
5208 Magazine St, #191
New Orleans, Louisiana 70115
Phone: 504.913.7740
Fax: 813.774.6595
Email: sbollag@greenjusticelegal.org
Attorneys for Mr. Marlowe
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on April 6, 2020 a copy of the foregoing was filed electronically with
the Clerk of Court using the CM/ECF system. Notice of this filing will be sent to all counsel of
record by operation of the Court’s electronic filing system.
/s/ Emily H. Posner
Emily H. Posner
21
050a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 1 of 16
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
EXHIBIT A
051a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 2 of 16
_.
" t'I'1I
l.,·~;
EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT
PROCLAMATION NUMBER 25 JBE 2020
PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY - COVID-19
WHEREAS,
the Louisiana Health Emergency Powers Act, La. R.S. 29:760, et seq., confers
upon the Governor of the State of Louisiana emergency powers to deal with
public health emergencies, including an occurrence or imminent threat of an
illness or health condition that is believed to be caused by the appearance of a
novel or previously controlled or eradicated infectious agent or biological toxin,
in order to ensure that preparations of this state will be adequate to deal with such
emergencies or disasters and to preserve the health and lives of the people of the
State of Louisiana;
WHEREAS,
when the Governor after consultation with the public health authority determines
that a public health emergency has occurred, or the threat thereof is imminent,
La. R.S. 29:766(A) empowers him to declare a state of emergency by executive
order or proclamation;
WHEREAS,
the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ("CDC") is responding to an
outbreak of respiratory disease caused by a novel (new) coronavirus that was first
detected in China and which has now been detected in many other countries,
including in the United States. The virus has been named "SARS-Co V-2" and the
disease it causes has been named "coronavirus disease 2019" (abbreviated
"COVID-19");
WHEREAS,
according to the CDC's website, person-to-person spread has been subsequently
reported in countries outside China, including in the United States. Some
international destinations now have apparent community spread with the virus
that causes COVID-19, as do some parts of the United States. Community spread
means some people have been infected and it is not known how or where they
became exposed;
WHEREAS,
on January 30, 2020, the International Health Regulations Emergency Committee
of the World Health Organization declared the outbreak a "public health
emergency of international concern" (PHEIC). On January 31, 2020, Health and
Human Services Secretary Alex M. Azar II declared a public health emergency
(PHE) for the United States to aid the nation's healthcare community in
responding to COVID-19;
WHEREAS,
a World Health Organization statement released March 7, 2020 stated that the
global number of confirmed cases of COVID-19 has surpassed 100,000;
WHEREAS,
as of March II, 2020, the CDC's website reports that 38 states, including the
District of Columbia, have reported cases of COVID-19 to CDC, for a total of
938 confirmed cases, and that states have reported 29 deaths resulting from
COVID-19;
052a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 3 of 16
WHEREAS,
on March, 11,2020, the World Health Organization designated the COVID-19
outbreak as a worldwide pandemic;
WHEREAS,
on March, 9, 2020, a Louisiana resident, pursuant to CDC protocol, was tested
for COVID-19, with the test being presumptively positive;
WHEREAS,
in the last two days, several more Louisiana residents have tested presumptively
positive for COVID-19;
WHEREAS,
the State of Louisiana has reason to believe that COVID-19 may be spread
amongst the population by various means of exposure, therefore posing a high
probability of widespread exposure and a significant risk of substantial future
harm to a large number of Louisiana citizens;
WHEREAS,
the Governor of the State of Louisiana has consulted with the public health
authority regarding COVID-19;
WHEREAS,
the Governor, after such consultation, finds that a threat of a public health
emergency is imminent;
WHEREAS,
a declaration of public health emergency is necessary to allow state agencies to
thoroughly prepare for any eventuality related to public health needs and deploy
additional resources to assist local authorities, if necessary; and
WHEREAS,
the Secretary of the Department of Health and the State Health Officer have
requested that a public health emergency be declared.
NOW THEREFORE, I, JOHN BEL EDWARDS, Governor of the State of Louisiana, by virtue
of the authority vested by the Constitution and the laws of the state of Louisiana, do hereby order
and direct as follows:
SECTION 1:
Pursuant to the Louisiana Health Emergency Powers Act, La. R.S. 29:760, et seq.,
a statewide public health emergency is declared to exist in the State of Louisiana
as a result of the imminent threat posed to Louisiana citizens by COVID-19,
which has created emergency conditions that threaten the lives and health of the
citizens of the State.
SECTION 2:
The Governor's Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness and
Secretary of the Department of Health are hereby expressly empowered to take
any and all actions authorized under the Louisiana Health Emergency Powers
Act, La. R.S. 29:760 et seq. in relation to this public health emergency.
SECTION 3:
The Secretary of the Department of Health and/or the State Health Officer are
hereby expressly empowered to take any and all actions authorized thereto under
Titles 29 and 40 of the Louisiana Revised Statutes and under the State Sanitary
Code (LAC Title 51) in relation to this public health emergency.
SECTION 4:
Pursuant to La. R.S. 29:724(D)(I), the Louisiana Procurement Code (La. R.S.
39:1551, et seq.) and Louisiana Public Bid Law (La. R.S. 38:2211, et seq.) and
their corresponding rules and regulations are hereby suspended for the purpose
of the procurement of any good or services necessary to respond to this
emergency.
SECTION 5:
Pursuant to La. R.S. 29:732(A), prices charged or value received for goods and
services sold may not exceed the prices ordinarily charged for comparable goods
and services in the same market area at or immediately before the time of the state
of emergency, unless the price by the seller is attributable to fluctuations in
applicable commodity markets, fluctuations in applicable regional or national
market trends, or to reasonable expenses and charges and attendant business risk
053a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 4 of 16
incurred in procuring or selling the goods or servIces during the state of
emergency.
SECTION 6:
SECTION 7:
SECTION 8:
In addition to any authority conferred generally herein or by law, the Governor's
Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness, through consultation
with the Secretary of the Department of Health, shall have the primary
jurisdiction, responsibility and authority for:
I.
Planning and executing public health emergency assessment, mitigation,
preparedness response, and recovery for the state;
2.
Coordinating public health emergency response between state and local
authorities;
3.
Collaborating with relevant federal government authorities, elected officials
of other states, private organizations or companies;
4.
Coordinating recovery operations and mitigation initiatives subsequent to
public health emergencies;
5.
Organizing public information activities regarding public health emergency
response operations; and
6.
Taking any other measures deemed necessary and proper, as authorized by
law.
The following travel restrictions will apply to all state employees:
A.
All state employees intending to travel beyond the continental United States
shall review the CDC's website at htlp:llwwwnc.cdc.gov/travellnotices to
determine if the country to be visited has been identified as posing a threat
of contracting COVID-19;
B.
All state employees traveling on state business to areas designated as
Warning Level 2 or Level 3 or above by the CDC are hereby directed to
cancel or postpone these trips; all employees traveling internationally to
other countries are hereby required to obtain specific authorization from the
Commissioner of Administration;
C.
All state employees intending to travel internationally for non-official
reasons are hereby directed to notify their supervisor and Human Resources
Director of the travel as soon as possible, but in no event later than fortyeight (48) hours prior to travel, and immediately upon return to the United
States;
D.
All state employees with household members who intend to travel or have
traveled to areas designated as Warning Level 2 or Level 3 or above by the
CDC are hereby directed to notify their supervisor and Human Resources
Director of the travel as soon as possible, but in no event later than fortyeight (48) hours prior to the household member's departure, to state the
household member's expected date of return, and to notify their supervisor
and Human Resources Director immediately upon the household member's
actual return to the United States; and
E.
All state employees shall notify their supervisor and Human Resources
Director if the employee or a household member develops symptoms
associated with COVID-19.
The Civil Service Commission and the Division of Administration are hereby
directed to develop a set of guidelines for state employees who are infected with
COVID-19 or under quarantine for possible exposure to COVID-19. Such
guidelines shall include direction for the management of sick leave by state
054a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 5 of 16
employees and provide for direction, if possible, for the employee to work
remotely. The guidelines developed by the Civil Service Commission and the
Division of Administration shall be put into effect by this order.
SECTION 9:
All orders allowing for visitation by the parent of a foster child that resides in a
home that is quarantined or isolated due to COVID-19 are hereby suspended. The
Department of Child and Family Services is hereby ordered to make all
reasonable efforts to allow for alternative visitation.
SECTION 10: This Proclamation shall be disseminated promptly by means reasonably
calculated to bring its contents to the attention of the general public. The
Proclamation shall also be promptly filed with the Governor's Office of
Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness, with the Department of Health,
Office of Public Health, and with the Secretary of State.
SECTION 11: All departments, commissions, boards, agencies and officers of the State, or any
political subdivision thereof, are authorized and directed to cooperate in actions
the State may take in response to the effects of this event.
SECTION 12: This order is effective upon signature and shall remain in effect from Wednesday,
March 11, 2020 to Thursday, April 9, 2020, unless terminated sooner.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have set my hand
officially and caused to be affixed the Great Seal of
Louisiana in the City of Baton Rouge on this II th day
of March
o.
OR OF LOUISIANA
ATTEST BY THE SECRETARY
OF STATE
055a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 6 of 16
1.1'.t \tD'"I.K
.
.
EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT
PROCLAMATION NUMBER JBE 2020 - 27
ADDITIONAL MEASURES FOR COVID-19
PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Louisiana Homeland Security and Emergency Assistance and
Disaster Act, La. R,S. 29:721, et seq. , the Governor declared a Public Health
emergency in Proclamation Number 25 JBE 2020;
WHEREAS, the worldwide outbreak of COVID-19 and the effects of its extreme risk of personto-person transmission throughout the United States and Louisiana significantly
threatens the safety, health, and security of the citizens of the state, along with
public facilities, including, but not limited to schools, workplaces, nursing homes,
hospitals, etc.;
WHEREAS, Centers for Disease Control (CDC) guidance for responding to the COVID-1 9
pandemic suggests aggressive measures for limiting the possible interaction of the
public with individuals exposed to or infected with COVID-19, including limiting
large public gatherings;
WHEREAS, limitations in interactions between members of the public includes school age
children, who may be in a position to pass COVID-19 to vulnerable populations,
including the elderly or those with underlying medical conditions;
WHEREAS, CDC guidance also encourages social distancing and prevention of unnecessary
personal interactions;
WHEREAS, in only a matter of weeks, COVID-1 9 has had an economic impact on thousands of
workers in the State of Louisiana, and will likely result in impacts to many more;
WHEREAS, individuals who are impacted by COVID-19 may not be able to report to work, they
may need to be isolated or quarantined, they may have to care for a sick family
member care for a child whose school is closed or be forced to quit their jobs;
WHEREAS, in addition, COVID-19 may cause businesses to shut down due to a slow down or
lack of demand, institute temporary or partial layoffs;
WHEREAS, an individuals' inability to report to work due to a COVID-1 9 diagnosis, an
individual being isolated or quarantined, caring for a sick family member, caring
for a child whose school is closed and the extraordinary volume of resulting
unemployment claims pose serious challenges to the effective and timely
administration of the unemployment compensation system;
WHEREAS, the State of Louisiana intends to proactively address the significant emotional and
economic impact upon Louisiana workers;
WHEREAS, Louisiana Revised Statute 29:724 confers upon the Govemor emergency powers to
deal with emergencies and disasters and to ensure that preparations of this state will
be adequate to deal with such emergencies or disasters, and to preserve the lives
and property of the citizens of the State of Louisiana, including the authority to
suspend the provisions of any regulatory statute prescribing the procedures for
conduct of state business, or the orders, rules, or regulations of any state agency, if
strict compliance with the provisions of any statute, order, rule, or regulation would
056a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 7 of 16
in any way prevent, hinder, or delay necessary action in coping with the emergency;
and
WHEREAS, the Secretary of the Louisiana Workforce Commission has requested the Governor,
due to the extreme volume of claims to be processed, suspend the application of
La. R.S. 23:1533, 1552, 1600(2) and (3), and 1601(1), (2) and (7)(a), (b) and (d)
for emergency-related claims, so as to allow the timely and fair administration of
the unemployment insurance program.
.
NOW THEREFORE, I, JOHN BEL EDWARDS, Governor of the State of Louisiana, by virtue
of the authority vested by the Constitution and the laws ofthe State of Louisiana, do hereby order
and direct as follows:
SECTION 1: In an effort to reduce and limit the spread of COVID-19 in Louisiana, and to
preserve the health and safety of all members of the public, all gatherings of 250
people or more between Friday, March 13,2020 and Monday, April 13, 2020 shall
be postponed or cancelled. This applies only to gatherings in a single space at the
same time where individuals will be in close proximity to one another. It does not
apply to nonnal operations at locations like airports, medical facilities, shopping
centers or malls, office buildings, factories or manufacturing facilities, or grocery
or department stores. This provision may be extended beyond Monday, April 13,
2020 by further order.
SECTION 2: All public schools in the State of Louisiana shall close facilities to students until
April 13, 2020. Schools may offer complete distance learning, as capabilities exist.
With appropriate social distancing measures, schools shall, if able, continue to
provide meals or other essential services with applicable staff. Instructional minute
requirements shall be temporarily suspended for distance education courses and for
curriculum delivery. The required 63,720 instructional minute requirement per year
shall also be suspended. The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education shall
report to the Governor and the Legislature any further actions necessary to ensure
that eligible students achieve successful student grading, promotion, and
graduation.
SECTION 3: To reduce the burden on members of the public and to limit the interactions of
individuals with state employees in govenunental offices, the following regulatory
statutes are hereby suspended as follows:
A.
Department of Public Safety
1.
The deadlines for the period to request an administrative hearing
pursuant to La. R.S. 15:542.1.3(B)(4) which expired on or after March
9,2020 but before May 10,2020 is suspended and extended until June
9,2020.
2.
Further, with regard to Concealed Handgun Permits, the rules related to
expiration of penn its at LAC 55: 1.1307(D) and LAC 55: 1.1309(F) shall
be suspended until May 10, 2020.
B.
Office of Motor Vehicles
1.
Late fees for driver's license which would be charged beginning on
March 9, 2020 through May 10, 2020, are suspended until May 20,
2020.
2.
The three-day period mandated in La. R.S. 32:863.1 to appear at an
Office of Motor Vehicle field office for a notice of violation served on
or after March 9, 2020 but before May 10, 2020, are suspended until
May 13, 2020.
3.
The expiration date of temporary registration plates issued pursuant to
La. R.S. 47:519 and La. R.S. 47:519.2 which expired on or before March
9,2020 is suspended until May 10,2020.
4.
The expiration date oflicense plates issued pursuant to La. R.S. 47:462,
et seq., which expired on or after March 9, 2020 but before May 10,
2020 is suspended until May 10, 2020.
057a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 8 of 16
The notice of default issued pursuant to La. R.S. 32:429.4 that would be
issued on or after March 9, 2020 but before May IS, 2020 is suspended,
and the notices will not be issued until after May IS, 2020.
The expiration date of an apportioned registration issued under the
International Registration Plan which expires March 31, 2020 is
suspended and the expiration date is extended to May 31, 2020.
The period to request an administrative hearing submitted to the
Department pursuant to La. R.S. 32:667, La. R.S. 32:863, La. R.S. 863.1
and LAC Title 55, Part III, Chapter I, § 159 which expired on or after
March 9, 2020 but before May 10, 2020 are suspended and extended
until June 10, 2020.
The sixty-day delay for the Department to submit the administrative
hearing record to the Division of Administrative Law pursuant to La.
R.S. 32:667(D)(1) for an arrest which occurred on or after March 9,
2020 but before May 10, 2020 is extended until August 8, 2020
Office of Motor Vehicles may offer services by remote customer
services agent interaction in current Office of Motor Vehicles office
locations.
SECTION 4: Any state depmiment or agency or political subdivision is hereby granted authority
to extend any non-essential deadline for a period of no longer than 30 days if
deemed necessary to respond to the threat ofCOVID-19.
SECTION 5: The Louisiana Legislature is hereby requested to consider a suspension resolution
which would allow for the suspension of any legal requirements to ensure the
continued operation of state and local government, including such issues as legal
deadlines and quomm requirements for open meetings.
SECTION 6: For the purpose of this executive order, "emergency-related claims" shall mean
claims for unemployment compensation filed by persons whose unemployment is
directly due to the impact of COVID-19 or due to their inability to get to their job
or worksite because they are sick, isolated or quarantined, caring for a sick family
member, or when an employees' child's school is closed as detennined by the
administrator of the state's unemployment compensation program, i.e., the
executive director of the Louisiana Workforce Commission. Emergency-related
claims will not necessarily include all claims in all parishes included in COVID-19
proclamations, declarations or orders.
SECTION 7: The following statutes relative to unemployment insurance are hereby suspended
to the extent and in the manner described below:
A.
La. R.S. 23: 1533, which provides for claimants' benefits to be charged'
against base period employers for purposes of employers' tax experience
rating and the protesting of such charges by employers, shall be suspended
for emergency-related claims made during the effective period of this
Order.
B.
La. R.S. 23:1552, which provides for the charging of claimants' benefits to
certain employers, shall be suspended for emergency-related claims made
during the effective period of this Order.
C.
La. R.S. 23:1600(2) and (3) shall be suspended while this Order is in effect
for emergency-related claims to the extent that they require claimants to
register and search for work, but the requirements in La. R.S. 23:1600(2)
that claimants continue to report at an employment office in the manner
prescribed by the administrator, and in La. R.S. 23:1600(3) that claimants
be able to work and be available for work, are not waived. The requirement
to continue to report at an employment office, which is accomplished
through either an automated telephone system or the Internet, is not
impractical and avoids overpayments, which claimants would be liable to
repay. Such activities are not practical by an individual who is impacted by
COVID-19.
058a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 9 of 16
SECTION 8: Any organization licensed by the Louisiana Department of Revenue Office of
Charitable Gaming to conduct games of chance pursuant to the Charitable Raffles,
Bingo and Keno Licensing Law shall not be authorized to hold or conduct any
sessions as defined in La. R.S. 4:740 for the period beginning Friday, March 13 ,
2020 and ending on Sunday, April 12, 2020.
SECTION 9: All departments, commissions, boards, agencies and officers of the State, or any
political subdivision thereof, are authorized and directed to cooperate in actions the
State may take in response to the effects of this event.
SECTION lO:This state of emergency extends from Friday, March 13, 2020 to Thursday, April
9,2020, unless terminated sooner.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have set my hand
officially and caused to be affixed the Great Seal of
Louisiana in the City of Baton Rouge, on this 13 th
day of March, 2020.
ATTEST BY THE
SECRETARY OF STATE
059a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
_.
.I ftl·
., 'Iflla
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 10 of 16
~'
EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT
PROCLAMA nON NUMBER JBE 2020 - 32
ADDITIONAL MEASURES FOR COVID-19
PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Louisiana Homeland Security and Emergency Assistance and
Disaster Act, La. R.S. 29:721 , el seq., the Governor declared a Public Health
emergency in Proclamation Number 25 JBE 2020;
WHEREAS, the worldwide outbreak of COVID-19 and the effects of its extreme risk of personto-person transmission throughout the nited States and Louisiana significantly
threatens the safety, health, and security of the citizens of the state, along with
public facilities, including, but not limited to schools, workplaces, nursing homes,
hospitals, etc.;
WHEREAS, on March 13,2020, the Governor issued Proclamation Number 27 JBE 2020 which,
among other protective measures, ordered that all public schools in Louisiana be
closed to students until April 13, 2020;
WHEREAS, administration of the Louisiana Education Assessment Program (LEAP) and the
End of Course examinations (EOCs) after April 13, 2020, with students having
been out of the classroom for a month, will result in examination results that do not
accurately reflect student success;
WHEREAS, to assure that the students of Louisiana can be assessed properly in light of the
exceptional circumstances created by the threat of COVID-19, it is necessary to
suspend certain provisions relating to educational performance;
WHEREAS, it is further necessary to suspend certain provisions which have limited the
availability of COVID-19 testing in Louisiana and place restrictions on health care
providers which do not allow for proper response in this declared emergency,
including encouraging the use of telehealth and allowing for in increase in the
nursing capacity of the state;
WHEREAS, in addition, the director of the Department of Health' s Bureau of Emergency
Medical Services has been notified that companies operating offshore oil and gas
platforms are screening workers for COVID-19 upon deployment and return from
offshore platforms, but are running out of paramedics to perform these assessments;
WHEREAS, ambulance providers in the state have contacted the Department of Health's Bureau
of Emergency Medical Services with concerns that they will be unable to
sufficiently respond to the increased number of ambulance transports caused by the
COVID-19 outbreak without a suspension of the ambulance staffing requirements
set forth in R.S. 40:1 135.1 (A)(2)(a);
WHEREAS, the number of EMS practitioners available in the state to respond to this emergency
are insufficient, and there is a need to suspend the ambulance staffing requirements
set forth in R.S. 40: 1135.I(A)(2)(a) in order to ensure that ambulance services can
sufficiently respond to those persons affected by this emergency;
060a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 11 of 16
WHEREAS, the Secretary of the Department of Health and the Director of the Department of
Health's Bureau of Emergency Medical Services have requested that the ambulance
staffing requirements set forth in R.S. 40:1135.1(A)(2)(a) be temporarily
suspended; and
WHEREAS, the Office of Motor Vehicles has requested that there be an additional suspension
of driving schools and proof of school attendance during the pendency of this
emergency.
NOW THEREFORE, I, JOHN BEL EDWARDS, Governor of the State of Louisiana, by virtue
of the authority vested by the Constitution and the laws of the State of Louisiana, do hereby order
and direct as follows:
SECTION 1:
(A)
The provisions of La. R.S. 17:24.4 and BESE Bulletin 741 that mandate
annual administration of testing under the Louisiana Education Assessment
Program and End of Course examinations are hereby suspended for the
entirety of the 2019-2020 school year contingent upon receipt of a waiver
of the accountability mandates in the Every Student Succeeds Act from the
United States Department of Education.
(B) The provisions of La. R.S . 17:4023 and La. R.S. 47:6301(B)(2)(ii) that
require nonpublic schools to administer testing under the Louisiana
Education Assessment Program and End of Course examinations to
students participating in the Louisiana Student Scholarships for Educational
Excellence program and to students receiving scholarships from donations
to school tuition organizations are hereby suspended for the entirety of the
2019-2020 school year upon receipt of a waiver of the accountability
mandates in the Every Student Succeeds Act from the United States
Department of Education.
(C) The provisions of La. R.S. 17: I 0.1 that provide for the School and District
Accountability System and any rules or regulations adopted by the Board
of Elementary and Secondary Education pertaining to the School and
District Accountability System are hereby suspended for the 2019-2020
school year upon receipt of a waiver of the accountability mandates in the
Every Student Succeeds Act from the United States Department of
Education.
(D) The provisions of La. R.S . 17:391.2 et seq. that provide for public school
accountability and assessment are hereby suspended for the entirety of the
2019-2020 school year upon receipt of a waiver of the accountability
mandates in the Every Student Succeeds Act from the United States
Department of Education.
(E)
The provisions of La. R.S. 17:154.3 that require teachers to work a
minimum number of days per school year are hereby suspended for the
entirety of the 2019-2020 school year.
(F)
The provisions of La. R.S. 17:221 that mandate every person having
control or charge of a child to send that child to a public or nonpublic
school are hereby suspended for the entirety of the 2019-2020 school year.
(H) The provisions of La. R.S. 17:232 that require attendance to be checked
daily at all schools are hereby waived for the entirety of the 2019-2020
school year.
(I)
The provisions of La. R.S. 17:3881 et seq., La. R.S. 17:3901 et seq., and
La. R.S. 17:3997(D) that provide for the use of value-added data in teacher
evaluation and as criteria for receipt of teaching credentials are hereby
suspended for the entirety of the 2019-2020 school year upon receipt of a
waiver of the accountability mandates in the Every Student Succeeds Act
from the United States Department of Education.
(1)
The provisions of La. R.S. 17:3991 (C)(I )(b) thatrequire charter schools to
adhere to certain student application and enrollment procedures are hereby
suspended for the entirety of the 2019-2020 school year.
061a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 12 of 16
(K) The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education shall apply to the
United States Department of Education for a waiver of the relevant
provisions of the Every Student Succeeds Act necessary to effect the
suspension of the statutes requiring a federal waiver described in the
sections above.
(L) The provisions of La. R.S. 17: I 94(B) are hereby suspended to allow for the
school districts to have greater flexibility for administration of a nutrition
program for students affected by this emergency.
(M) The Board of Elementary and Secondary Education shall adopt emergency
rules as necessary to effect the suspension of the statutes described in the
sections above.
SECTION 2:
The following provisions of the Public Bid Law, La. R.S. 38:2211 , el seq., are
hereby suspended during this emergency:
(A) Louisiana Public Bid Law (La. R.S. 38:2211 , el seq.) and its corresponding
rules and regulations relating to deadlines for advertisement for bids for
public works, submission of bids and ancillary documents, award and
execution of public works contracts, and any other deadlines related to the
advertisement, award, and execution of a public works contract mandated
by statute or by said rules and regulations.
(B) The provisions of La. R.S. 39: 124 through 126 regarding periodic meetings
and/or inspections of capital outlay projects by facility planning and control,
including inspection of a project prior to the expiration of the guarantee
period, and prior approval of change orders are hereby suspended and any
meetings and/or inspections shall be limited to only those inspections or
meetings determined to be absolutely necessary for the advancement of the
capital outlay project.
SECTION 3:
Because of the threat posed to health care workers from COVID-19 and the need
to allocate resources to respond to this disaster, there is a need to allow for
additional telehealth opportunities. To facilitate the provision of telehealth
services where available and appropriate, the following guidelines are adopted:
(A) The requirement ofR.S. 40: 1223.4 that each state agency or professional or
occupational licensing board or commission that regulates the practice of a
healthcare provider promulgate any rules necessary to provide for, promote,
and regulate the use of telehealth in the delivery of healthcare services
within the scope of practice regulated by the licensing entity is hereby
suspended during the term of this emergency declaration.
(B)
All licensing boards are encouraged to adopt emergency rules, if necessary,
so that it will not be considered unethical nor a violation of any licensing
standards of the healthcare provider, solely as a result of the provision of
such care via telehealth.
(C) The practice of the healthcare provider administered via telehealth must be
within the scope of the provider's license, skill, training, and experience.
The services provided to the patient must meet the standard of care that
would be provided if the patient were treated on an in-person basis.
(D) Prescribing of any controlled substances via telehealth must be medically
appropriate, well-documented and continue to conform to rules applicable
to the prescription of such medications.
SECTION 4:
In an effort to reduce and limit the spread ofCOVID-19 in Louisiana. and to
preserve the health and safety of all members of the pUblic. all Public Postsecondary institutions and proprietary schools within the state of Louisiana
that are licensed by the Louisiana Board of Regents shall be allowed to
substitute in-person clinical and classroom instruction with online and lab
simulations for enrolled students for the duration of the declared emergency.
062a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 13 of 16
Further, all proprietary schools within the state of Louisiana that are licensed by
the Louisiana Board of Regents shall be allowed to substitute in-person clinical
and classroom instruction with online and lab simulations for currently enrolled
students as of March 1, 2020.
SECTION 5:
The ambulancc stafling requirements set forth in R.S. 40: 1135.1 (A)(2)(a) are
hereby temporarily suspended as to ambulance drivers, provided that such
driver possesses a driv(;)r"s license valid in the State of Louisiana and meets
the criminal back!,'Tound check requirements of R.S. 40: 1203.1 et seq.
Except as expressly suspended herein, all other requirements of R.S. 40: 1135.1
shall remain in place, including the requirement that an ambulance be staffed
with a minimum of two persons, one of whom shall be a licensed emergency
medical technician.
SECTION 6:
In addition to the suspension of legal deadlines in Section 5 of JBE 20-30, the
deadlines established in Title 46 of Louisiana Revised Statutes, Public Welfare
and Assistance are hereby suspended.
Further, this order clarifies that the suspension of Title 23 of the Louisiana
Revised Statutes in JBE 20-30 does not apply to the payment of wages in La. R.S.
23:631-653.
SECTION 7:
The licensing and certification requirements for Louisiana Clinical
Laboratory Personnel set fOl1h in R.S. 37: 1318. including any requirements
for criminal background checks. be temporarily suspended for thosc
laboratory personnel conducting COVID-19 testing who demonstrate
molecular biology polymerase chain reaction (PCR) experience andlor lor
those who demonstrate serological experience in testing clinical samples.
when such testing and related activities are performed under the oversight and
responsibility of a licensed physician or doctor of philosophy (Ph.D.) with
demonstrated expericnc(;) in the related laboratory activities who ensures the
quality of results.
SECTION 8:
All driving schools in the State of Louisiana shall close for in class instruction
until April 13,2020.
In addition, the form documenting school attendance for minors shall not be
required for the issuance or renewal of driver's permit or license to operate a
motor vehicle until May 10, 2020.
SECTION 9:
All departments, commissions, boards, agencies and officers of the State, or any
political subdivision thereof, are authorized and directed to cooperate in actions
the State may take in response to the effects of this event.
SECTION 10: The provisions in this state of emergency extend from Thursday, March 19,2020
to Monday, April 13,2020, unless terminated sooner.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have set my hand
officially and a sed to be affixed the Great Seal of
Louisiana in
ity of aton Rouge, on this 19th
day of Marc ,2 O.
ATTEST BY THE
SECRETARY OF STATE
SECRETAR~STATE
063a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 14 of 16
EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT
P R OCLAMATION NUMBER 33 JBE 2020
ADDITIONAL MEASURES FOR COVID-I9
STAYATHOME
WHEREAS,
pursuant to the Louisiana Home land Security and Emergency Assistance and
Disaster Act. La. R.S. 29:72 1, el seq., the Governor declared a Public Health
emergency in Proclamation Number 25 lBE 2020 in responsc to the threat posed
by COVID-19;
WHEREAS,
on March I L 2020. in Emergency Proclamation Number 25 .!BE 2020, the
Governor declared that a statewide public health emergency exists in the State of
Lou isiana because of COV ID-19 and expressly empowered the Governor's
Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness and the Secretary of
the Department of Health and/or the State Health OfTicer to take all actions
authorized under state law;
WHEREAS,
on March 13, 2020, in Emergency Proclamation N umber 27 .IBE 2020. the
Governor supplemented the measures taken iil his declaration ofa Public Hea lth
Emergency with add itional restrictions and suspension s of deadlines and
regulations in order to protect the health and safety of the public because of
COVID-19:
WHEREAS,
the extraordinary threat posed by COVID-19 has caused critical shortages of
health care eq uipment, personal protective equipment, and possible sho rtages in
hospita l beds. throughout the state;
WHEREAS,
without additional measures to slow the spread of COV ID-19 in the state. health
care facilities in parts of the state or even throughout the state are at significant
ri sk of being overwhelmcd:
WHEREAS,
in line with gu idance fi'om the Cen ters for Disease Control (CDC) and after
consultation with the State Health Officer and the Director of the National
Institute of Allergy and Infec tious Disease. it is clear that additional measures
are necessary to protect the hea lth and safety of the public, to mitigate the
impact of COVI 0-19. and to di s rupt the spread of the virus;
WHEREAS,
after declaration of a publ ic health emergency. the Governor is authorized by La.
R.S. 29:766(D)(7) to control "ingress and egress to and li'om a disaster area. the
movement of persons within the area, and the occupancy of premises therein":
WHEREAS,
in addition to the temporary closure of certain businesses ordered because of this
emergency in Section 2 of Proclamation Number 30 .IB E 2020, certain additional
businesses need to be temporarily closed to the public during this emerge ncy;
WHEREAS,
further. in addition to businesses closed to the public by this order. other
businesses throughout the state will need to reduce o pera tio ns to continue w ith
minimum contact with m e mbers of the public a nd o nly essential
e mploy e es, w hil e re quiring pro per social distancing ;
WHEREAS,
these measures relating to cl osure of certain businesses and to lim it the operati ons
of non-essentia l businesses are necessary because o f the propens ity of the
COVID-19 virus to spread via personal interactions and because of physical
contaminati on of property due to its ability to attach to surfaces fo r prolonged
periods of time; and
064a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
WHEREAS,
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 15 of 16
these measures are necessary to protect the health and safety of the people of
Louisiana.
NOW THEREFORE, I, JO HN BEL EDWARDS, Governor of the State of Loui siana, by virtue
of th e authori ty vested by th e Co nstitution and th e laws of the State of Lo uis iana, do hereby order
and direct as foll ows:
SECTION 1:
All state office buildings are closed to the public, effective immediately.
However, essential state functions shall continue.
SECTION 2:
Section 1 of Proclamation Number 30 lBE 2020 is hereby amended as
follows:
In an effort to reduce and limit the spread of COVID-1 9 in Louisiana, and to
preserve the health and safety of all members of the public, all gatherings of 10
people or more shall be postponed or cancelled. This applies only to gatherings
in a single space at the same time where individuals will be in close proximity to
one another. It does not apply to normal operations at locations like airports,
medical facilities, office buildings, factories or manufacturing facilities , or
grocery stores. This provision may be extended beyond Monday, April 13 , 2020
by further order.
SECTION 3:
To preserve the public health and safety, and to ensure the health care
system is capable of serving all citizens in need , especially those at high
risk and vulnerable to COVID-1 9, all individuals within the state of
Louisiana are under a general stay-at-h ome order and are directed to stay
home unless performing an essential activity. An activity is essential if the
purpose of the activ ity is one of the following:
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
SECTION 4:
(A)
Obtaining food , medicine, and other similar goods necessary for
the individual or a family member of the individual.
Obtaining non-elective medical care and treatment and other
similar vital services for an individual or a family member of the
individual.
Going to and from an individual's workplace to perform a job
function necessary to provide goods or services being sought in
Subsections (A) and (B) of this Section, or as otherwise deemed
essential worker functions. Guidance provided by the U .S.
Department of Homeland Security , Cybersecurity & Infrastructure
Security Agency (CISA) on what workers are essential is outlined
at https:1/vvvvw. c isa.gov liden ti fy ing-cri ti ca 1- infi·astruc ture-d uri ng-co vi d19.
Going to and from the home of a family member.
Going to and from an individual's place of worship.
Engaging in outdoor activity , provided individuals maintain a
distance of six feet from one another and abide by the 10-person
limitation on gathering size established in this proclamation.
Further, in addition to businesses that are closed to the public
pursuant to Proclamation Number 30 lBE 2020, the following
nonessential businesses shall be closed to the public and members:
I.
2.
All places of public amusement, whether indoors or outdoors,
including but not limited to, locations with amusement rides,
carnivals, amusement parks, water parks, trampoline parks,
aquariums, zoos, museums, arcades , fairs , pool halls ,
children's play centers, playgrounds, theme parks, any
theaters , concert and music halls, adult entertainment venues,
racetracks , and other similar businesses.
All personal care and grooming businesses, including but not
limited to, barber shops, beauty salons, nail salons, spas,
massage parlors, tattoo parlors, and other similar businesses.
065a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
3.
(B)
Document 100-1
04/06/20 Page 16 of 16
All malls, except for stores in a mall that have a direct outdoor
entrance and exit that provide essential services and products
as provided by CISA guidelines.
Businesses closed to the public pursuant to this provision shall not
be prohibited from conducting necessary activities such as payroll,
cleaning services, maintenance or upkeep as necessary.
SECTION 5:
Any business not covered by the guidance from the CISA discussed in
Section 3 and not ordered temporarily closed in Section 4 shall reduce
operations to continue with minimum contact with members of the public
and essential employees, while requiring proper social distancing. Further,
the IO-person limitation on gathering size shall apply to such business
operations. Early learning centers and child care facilities adhering to the
guidance issued by the Louisiana Department of Education and Office of
Public Health may continue to operate.
SECTION 6:
The Governor's Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness is
directed to ensure compliance with this order, and is empowered to exercise all
authorities pursuant to La. R.S. 29 :721 , el seq., and La. R.S. 29:760, et seq.
SECTION 7:
Unless otherwise provided in this order, these provis ions are effect ive from 5:00
p.m . on Mond ay, March 23 , 2020 (0 Monday. Apr il 13.2020, unl ess terminated
soone r.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have set my hand
officially and caused to be affixed the Great Seal of
Louisiana in the City of Baton Rouge, on this 22 nd day
of March, 2020.
ATTEST BY THE
SECRETARY OF STATE
SECRETARY
F TATE
066a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-2
04/06/20 Page 1 of 6
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
EXHIBIT B
067a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-2
04/06/20 Page 2 of 6
Inmate Search
Home
Send Money
Inbox (132)
Prison Search
Help
Music
My Account
Inbox
Compose
Delete
Sent
Buy Stamps (40)
Transfer Stamps
Transaction History
Reply
Prev
From:
CHRISTOPHER MARLONE
Date:
3/31/2020 10:15:33 AM
To:
Emily Posner
Next
Attachments:
the medical staff has gloves, masks, etc. but since there is a shortage we dont know how often they are changing them. they were
told to take them home and rewear their masks, according to staff. I dont go to pill call. but the same nurses that are in he
quarantine ward issue insulin and no one knows if they change gloves. the diabetics in quarantine come and use the same glucose
meters/counters and a few hours later we are back to use them againn- which contaminates the equipment. again the same nurses
deal with them, and we don't know or see if they change gloves or masks. and is the budget and supply shortage are critical, I
doubt it. they've told us for weeks that everyone that went to sick call had 'allergies' or flu without testing. they stopped running sick
call, hence me having to make an emergency. they are sending people away if they dont have fever. they have not announced sick
call in 3 days.
one dorm of 140 inmates is under quarantine, but the whole place is probably a few days away from it. but that doesn't stop
anything, since staff are free roaming. there are two stories - at either 6 total or six new cases are confirmed which would make 9
cases. it was one 3 days ago.
we don't have free access to bleach or cleaning agents. we dont have anything to wipe the phones with, no alcohol pads or
anything like they told dad at the meeting. there are no paper towels to dry hands. they issue us one bar of soap every two weeks
to bathe and wash hands with. we live 20-30" apart in our beds. there are 79 inmates in approx 5,000sqft. we share 5 toilets and
sinks. all of our clothes/bed sheets are being washed together with other dorms'.
we eat at tables, 4 to a table, in a cafeteria that has now proven to have had covid-positive people working until 3 days ago, but the
others that worked with him are still there. so, we have possibly contaminated people cooking our food/handling dishes and pots.
plus they obviously reuse all trays, cups, and spoons for the whole compound exacerbating the potential for cross contamination.
they rotate staff all over the place, possibly cross contaminating covid to other dorms. we're being told its our fault and officers are
quitting. they've cancelled all call outs and trips.
its hard to think about this since all of us are pigeon holed. I try to eat from canteen but its expensive...
JPay.com
Home
About
Inmate Search
Prison Search
Contact Us
Help
Legal Agreements
Inmate Services
Money Transfer
Email & VideoGram
Education
JPay Tablet
Video Visitation
Parole & Probation
Restitution
Supervision Fees
Court Fees
Self-Report Fees
Release Cards
Social
blog.jpay.com
forum.jpay.com
Our Community
Are You a Corrections Agency?
| Consumer Protection | Privacy Policy
A Securus Technologies Company
© 2002-2020 JPay LLC All Rights Reserved
JPay LLC is licensed by the Georgia Department of Banking and Finance; NMLS #926932. We are also licensed as a Money Transmitter by the New York State Department of Financial Services.
068a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-2
04/06/20 Page 3 of 6
Inmate Search
Home
Send Money
Inbox (132)
Prison Search
Help
Music
My Account
Inbox
Compose
Delete
Sent
Buy Stamps (40)
Transfer Stamps
Transaction History
Reply
Prev
From:
CHRISTOPHER MARLONE
Date:
3/31/2020 5:46:10 PM
To:
Emily Posner
Next
Attachments:
past 3 hours:
they took our temperature today.
they just quarantined another dorm, 158 more people. 3 or 4 of the residents had fevers and went the infirmary. that's a total of 316
on dorm quarantine. they are also keeping people in solitary confinement cells for quarantine and others in makeshift housing areas
in the visiting shed, besides what is in quarantine in the infirmary.
the scary part is that they decided to do a bed shuffle on Monday and put two of guys from that dorm in my bed area.
one or two staff were sent home due to symptoms, also.
one minute ago: two guys on my tier just got quarantined, they work for the staff that was sent home. we may be next as a whole
dorm. she was the commissary officer.
will update as more develops.
JPay.com
Home
About
Inmate Search
Prison Search
Contact Us
Help
Legal Agreements
Inmate Services
Money Transfer
Email & VideoGram
Education
JPay Tablet
Video Visitation
Parole & Probation
Restitution
Supervision Fees
Court Fees
Self-Report Fees
Release Cards
Social
blog.jpay.com
forum.jpay.com
Our Community
Are You a Corrections Agency?
| Consumer Protection | Privacy Policy
A Securus Technologies Company
© 2002-2020 JPay LLC All Rights Reserved
JPay LLC is licensed by the Georgia Department of Banking and Finance; NMLS #926932. We are also licensed as a Money Transmitter by the New York State Department of Financial Services.
069a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-2
04/06/20 Page 4 of 6
Inmate Search
Home
Send Money
Inbox (137)
Prison Search
Help
Music
My Account
Inbox
Compose
Delete
Sent
Buy Stamps (14)
Transfer Stamps
Transaction History
Reply
Prev
From:
CHRISTOPHER MARLONE
Date:
4/1/2020 9:02:00 PM
To:
Emily Posner
Next
Attachments:
I have, when I'm layin in my bed, within my 5ft bubble I have 3 people , 11 people within 8 ft of me. if we're not in bed and are
standing, its 5-6 ft...
and solution to magically fix this is go head to toe... makes no difference. just makes sleep uncomfortable.
need anything from me for the other thing, media, etc?
JPay.com
Home
About
Inmate Search
Prison Search
Contact Us
Help
Legal Agreements
Inmate Services
Money Transfer
Email & VideoGram
Education
JPay Tablet
Video Visitation
Parole & Probation
Restitution
Supervision Fees
Court Fees
Self-Report Fees
Release Cards
Social
blog.jpay.com
forum.jpay.com
Our Community
Are You a Corrections Agency?
| Consumer Protection | Privacy Policy
A Securus Technologies Company
© 2002-2020 JPay LLC All Rights Reserved
JPay LLC is licensed by the Georgia Department of Banking and Finance; NMLS #926932. We are also licensed as a Money Transmitter by the New York State Department of Financial Services.
070a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-2
04/06/20 Page 5 of 6
Inmate Search
Home
Send Money
Inbox (137)
Prison Search
Help
Music
My Account
Inbox
Compose
Delete
Sent
Buy Stamps (14)
Transfer Stamps
Transaction History
Reply
Prev
From:
CHRISTOPHER MARLONE
Date:
4/3/2020 5:51:25 AM
To:
Emily Posner
Next
Attachments:
Emily,
they are housing the covid positive people with it in the cell block, sick quarantine as well. so if I go, not sick, I will guarantee get
sick. the whole block is sick and covid positive people right now. 5 people went there last night sick with fever and breathing probs.
that's the only place to put them safely.
cell blocks are horrible idea for a diabetic because you loose any control over access to emergency foods or attention by medical.
you are only dealt with during meals and pill call. if I take insulin and it happens to be in excess of what I need and I do have access
to my food, I die. most don't understand the dynamics of diabetes and the problem is so big because its hard to maintain as a type
one. you're not allowed food, candy, no commissary, and no med attention until pill calls. well, I don't eat rice or bread because of
the glucose influence, and if I can't substitute with oatmeal or something, I can die from insulin overdose. of course the simple
answer is to take less insulin, but then if I eat too much or eat wrong, I can enter ketoacidosis or have a stroke.
that's the diabetic reason. that's why diabetics tend to be the best behaved inmates - we're afraid to die because of a dinner roll. the
cell block has the very real potential to turn any diabetic's sentence into a death sentence by lethal injection. this is NOT a
dramatization.
besides that, I'm traumatized from the last time I was in there for 6 months. I don't want to experience that again. I lost my mind. I
do not want solitary confinement. I'd rather die. period. I don't want to become a blathering idiot. this is projected to last for the rest
of the year. I cannot do a cell time that long but even in the cell blocks aren't totally isolated. they bring you food, deal with medical,
and ever cell is at capacity with a cell mate. that is NOT an option I want to explore. I get stomach cramps and nausea thinking
about the blocks and being confined again.
there are no social distance areas, since the point is to herd us and maintain supervision.
in the cell block, socially, our communication would stop. they are not allowed any phone, jpay, or anything in the block. there are no
TVs, no books, and nothing to do. its total lockdown there. and now since its a sick ward, its a health gauntlet.
please, no... - Chris
JPay.com
Home
About
Inmate Search
Prison Search
Contact Us
Help
Legal Agreements
Inmate Services
Money Transfer
Email & VideoGram
Education
JPay Tablet
Video Visitation
Parole & Probation
Restitution
Supervision Fees
Court Fees
Self-Report Fees
Release Cards
Social
blog.jpay.com
forum.jpay.com
Our Community
Are You a Corrections Agency?
| Consumer Protection | Privacy Policy
A Securus Technologies Company
© 2002-2020 JPay LLC All Rights Reserved
JPay LLC is licensed by the Georgia Department of Banking and Finance; NMLS #926932. We are also licensed as a Money Transmitter by the New York State Department of Financial Services.
071a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-2
04/06/20 Page 6 of 6
Inmate Search
Home
Send Money
Inbox (137)
Prison Search
Help
Music
My Account
Inbox
Compose
Delete
Sent
Buy Stamps (14)
Transfer Stamps
Transaction History
Reply
Prev
From:
CHRISTOPHER MARLONE
Date:
4/5/2020 5:59:41 PM
To:
Emily Posner
Next
Attachments:
18 positive inmate cases, new said there are also 17 confirmed officers sick.
the yard times have changed, but that doesn't stop people being close, since every yard has 316 inmates living together, ours has
half since the other side is a cell block.
no other changes... I'm nervous, but c'est la vie.
did a lot of introspection today. I'm really hoping to have the chance to do good for the world, be a dad, and make my parents
proud...
people in here are scared and trying make the best of it, but other inmates are still being retarded and cooking and eating together,
hanging out close, and just lots of stupidity.
I am trying keep distance.
AG Barr released a crap ton of diabetic and other vulnerable inmates in the feds. wondrrin if Louisiana is going to follow suit.
other then that, we're staying the course. dad said you didn't feel good, so I hope that its not serious and it goes way. not covid..
let me know what's up. hope you're good. - Chris
JPay.com
Home
About
Inmate Search
Prison Search
Contact Us
Help
Legal Agreements
Inmate Services
Money Transfer
Email & VideoGram
Education
JPay Tablet
Video Visitation
Parole & Probation
Restitution
Supervision Fees
Court Fees
Self-Report Fees
Release Cards
Social
blog.jpay.com
forum.jpay.com
Our Community
Are You a Corrections Agency?
| Consumer Protection | Privacy Policy
A Securus Technologies Company
© 2002-2020 JPay LLC All Rights Reserved
JPay LLC is licensed by the Georgia Department of Banking and Finance; NMLS #926932. We are also licensed as a Money Transmitter by the New York State Department of Financial Services.
072a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-3
04/06/20 Page 1 of 2
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
EXHIBIT C
073a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-3
04/06/20 Page 2 of 2
Emily Posner <emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com>
Attorney Calls
CAROL JORDAN <CJORDAN@corrections.state.la.us>
To: Emily Posner <emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com>
Mon, Mar 30, 2020 at 10:23 AM
I'll have to get back to you about this, we have a positive co-vid 19 at this prison and some housing areas are
quarantined.
From:
Emily Posner <emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com>
To:
CAROL JORDAN <cjordan@corrections.state.la.us>
Date:
03/30/2020 10:21 AM
Subject:
Attorney Calls
EXTERNAL EMAIL: Please do not click on links or attachments unless you know the content is safe.
[Quoted text hidden]
074a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-4
04/06/20 Page 1 of 2
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
EXHIBIT D
075a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-4
04/06/20 Page 2 of 2
CHRISTOPHER MARLONE 00558725
Offender Details
First Name:
CHRISTOPHER
Middle Initial:
Last Name:
SID #:
2478137
Docket #:
Date of Birth:
12/05/1984
DOC #:
00558725
Gender:
M
Race:
White
Active:
Institutional
Risk Score: Low
ODARA Score:
Static 99 Score:
Last Updated: 12/05/2019
Last Updated:
Last Updated:
Mini
Need Score: Low
Last Updated: 12/28/2018
Prescription Bundle
Last Updated:
076a
MARLONE
Yes
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-5
04/06/20 Page 1 of 3
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
EXHIBIT E
077a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-5
04/06/20 Page 2 of 3
Emily Posner <emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com>
Chris Marlowe
1 message
Brooklynn <brooklynnroberts@hotmail.com>
To: emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com
Tue, Mar 31, 2020 at 3:59 PM
Hi Emily. Yes Chris Marlowe can stay with me I have a 2 bedroom apartment at 411 Eissman Rd Apt 41 Leesville, LA
71446. I work locally at the hospital. If you have any questions feel free to contact me by phone or email.
Thank you,
Brooklynn Roberts
Sent from my iPhone
078a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-5
04/06/20 Page 3 of 3
Emily Posner <emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com>
Urgent
Elizabeth Norton <liz.norton@yahoo.com>
To: Emily Posner <emilyposnerlaw@gmail.com>
Tue, Mar 31, 2020 at 12:52 PM
Yes, Chris can live in our 2 bedroom frame house that is our second home. It has a complete bath, full kitchen with a
refrigerator and stove, living room, fully furnished , and all utilities. It has a laundry room and a front porch. It is
located on 54 acres in East Texas. Chris is welcome to live there permanently and help with our real estate business
to earn money. We would enjoy the help. The address is 3421 Narroway Loop, Lufkin, TX, 75904.
We will assist Chris with anything he needs. We will stay in our rv so he can quarantine himself for the 14 day period.
We also have a vehicle he can use.
Liz and Mike Norton
936-212-5545
936-366-4900
[Quoted text hidden]
079a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD
Document 100-6
04/06/20 Page 1 of 21
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
MIDDLE DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
CHRIS MARLOWE,
*
CIVIL ACTION
*
VERSUS
*
NO. 18-63-BAJ-EWD
*
JAMES LEBLANC, ET AL.
*
JUDGE BRIAN A. JACKSON
*
*
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
*
ERIN WILDER-DOOMES
******************************************************************************
EXHIBIT F
080a
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD Document 100-6 04/06/20 Page 2 of 21
Case 2:90-cv-00520-KJM-DB Document 6524 Filed 03/25/20 Page 1 of 20
1 DONALD SPECTER – 083925
STEVEN FAMA – 099641
2 ALISON HARDY – 135966
SARA NORMAN – 189536
3 RITA LOMIO – 254501
MARGOT MENDELSON – 268583
4 PRISON LAW OFFICE
1917 Fifth Street
5 Berkeley, California 94710-1916
Telephone: (510) 280-2621
6
MICHAEL W. BIEN – 096891
ERNEST GALVAN – 196065
LISA ELLS – 243657
JESSICA WINTER – 294237
MARC J. SHINN-KRANTZ – 312968
CARA E. TRAPANI – 313411
ROSEN BIEN
GALVAN & GRUNFELD LLP
101 Mission Street, Sixth Floor
San Francisco, California 94105-1738
Telephone: (415) 433-6830
7 Attorneys for Plaintiffs
8
9
10
11
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTS
EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
AND NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT COMPOSED OF THREE JUDGES
PURSUANT TO SECTION 2284, TITLE 28 UNITED STATES CODE
12 RALPH COLEMAN, et al.,
Plaintiffs,
13
14
Case No. 2:90-CV-00520-KJM-DB
THREE JUDGE COURT
v.
15 GAVIN NEWSOM, et al.,
Defendants.
17 MARCIANO PLATA, et al.,
Plaintiffs,
18
16
19
v.
20 GAVIN NEWSOM,
Defendants.
21
Case No. C01-1351 JST
THREE JUDGE COURT
DECLARATION OF MARC STERN,
M.D. IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’
EMERGENCY MOTION TO MODIFY
POPULATION REDUCTION ORDER
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DECLARATION OF MARC STERN, M.D. IN SUPPORT
OF PLAINTIFFS’ EMERGENCY MOTION TO MODIFY
081a
POPULATION REDUCTION ORDER
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD Document 100-6 04/06/20 Page 3 of 21
Case 2:90-cv-00520-KJM-DB Document 6524 Filed 03/25/20 Page 2 of 20
DECLARATION OF MARC STERN, M.D.
1
2 I, Marc Stern, declare as follows:
3
1.
I am a physician, board-certified in internal medicine, specializing in correctional
4 health care. I most recently served as the Assistant Secretary for Health Care at the Washington
5 State Department of Corrections. I served for four years as a medical subject matter expert for the
6 Officer of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, U.S. Department of Homeland Security, and as a
7 medical subject matter expert for one year for the California Attorney General’s division
8 responsible for monitoring the conditions of confinement in Immigration and Customs
9 Enforcement (ICE) detention facilities. I am a court-appointed medical expert in the class action
10 Parsons v. Ryan, CV-12-00601-PHX-ROS. Currently, I am the Medical Advisor for the National
11 Sheriffs’ Association on matters related to preventive measures responding to COVID-19.
12 Additionally, in 2009, at the request of the California Receiver Clark Kelso, I toured 10 California
13 State Prisons to assess whether or not the Receiver’s assignment – to restore the delivery of health
14 services within the California State Prisons – to constitutionally adequate levels – had been
15 completed. I have been Attached as Exhibit A is a copy of my curriculum vitae.
16
2.
COVID-19 is a serious disease that has reached pandemic status, and is straining
17 the health care systems around the world. At least 330,000 people around the world have received
18 confirmed diagnoses of COVID 19, including 33,400 people in the United States. At least 14,000
19 people have died globally as a result of COVID-19, including more than 400 in the United States.
20 These numbers will increase, perhaps exponentially. Moreover, the numbers for the United States
21 currently must be considered in light of nationwide shortages of COVID-19 tests, thus the actual
22 numbers are likely significantly higher than those reported.
23
3.
The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) reports that
24 so far five employees and one incarcerated person have tested positive for COVID-19.
25 https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/covid19/. The actual number of infections is likely to be higher due to
26 the testing shortage.
27
28
082a
1
DECLARATION OF MARC STERN, M.D. IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EMEGERNCY MOTION
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD Document 100-6 04/06/20 Page 4 of 21
Case 2:90-cv-00520-KJM-DB Document 6524 Filed 03/25/20 Page 3 of 20
1
4.
COVID-19 is a novel respiratory virus. It is spread primarily through droplets
2 generated when an infected person coughs or sneezes, or through droplets of saliva or discharge
3 from the nose. There is no vaccine for COVID-19, and there is no cure for COVID-19. No one
4 has prior immunity. The only way to control the virus is to use preventive strategies, including
5 social distancing.
6
5.
The time course of the disease can be very rapid. Individuals can show the first
7 symptoms of infection in as little as two days after exposure and their condition can seriously
8 deteriorate in as little as five days (perhaps sooner) after that. It is believed that people can
9 transmit the virus without being symptomatic and, indeed, that a significant amount of
10 transmission may be from people who are infected but asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic.
11
6.
The effects of COVID-19 are very serious, especially for people who are most
12 vulnerable. Vulnerable people include people over the age of 50, and those of any age with
13 underlying health problems such as – but not limited to – weakened immune systems,
14 hypertension, diabetes, blood, lung, kidney, heart, and liver disease, and possibly pregnancy.
15
7.
Vulnerable people who are infected by the COVID-19 virus can experience severe
16 respiratory illness, as well as damage to other major organs. Treatment for serious cases of
17 COVID-19 requires significant advanced support, including ventilator assistance for respiration
18 and intensive care support. An outbreak of COVID-19 could put significant pressure on or exceed
19 the capacity of local health infrastructure. In the absence of a vaccine and a cure, a significant
20 number of people who are infected with the virus will die. To the extent that the health care
21 infrastructure is overloaded, people will die unnecessarily because necessary respirators and
22 hospital facilities are unavailable.
23
8.
Controlling the spread of the virus by limiting person to person contact is critical to
24 saving lives. This is very challenging in prisons, because they are congregate environments, i.e.
25 places where people live and sleep in close proximity. Social distancing in ways that are
26 recommended by public health officials can be difficult, if not impossible in this environment. To
27 the extent that incarcerated people are housed in close quarters, unable to maintain a six-foot
28 distance from others, and sharing or touching objects used by others, infectious diseases that are
083a
2
DECLARATION OF MARC STERN, M.D. IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EMERGENCY MOTION
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD Document 100-6 04/06/20 Page 5 of 21
Case 2:90-cv-00520-KJM-DB Document 6524 Filed 03/25/20 Page 4 of 20
1 transmitted via the air or touch (like COVID-19) are more likely to spread, placing people at risk.
2 This is especially true when, as in California, the number of incarcerated people is high and when
3 large numbers of people are housed in open dormitories rather than one or two-person cells. For
4 these reasons, if – but more likely when – COVID-19 is introduced into a prison, the risks of
5 spread is greatly, if not exponentially, increased as already evidenced by spread of COVID-19 in
6 two other congregate environments: nursing homes and cruise ships.
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
9.
In addition to the increased risk from COVID-19 to any individual in the prisons,
there is an especially increased risk of harm to the elderly and people with underlying health
conditions. They are not only more likely to become seriously ill, but also, therefore, more likely
to require transport to a community hospital.
10.
California state prisons remain overcrowded, even after the Population Reduction
Order upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court in Brown v. Plata, 563 U.S. 493 (2001). I have
reviewed the Weekly Population Report posted on the website of the CDCR at
https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/research/wp-content/uploads/sites/174/2020/03/Tpop1d200318.pdf. This
report shows that the California state prisons remain at 130% of capacity. Among the 35 state
prisons, all but four are over 100% capacity, and 19 are at or over 130% of design capacity, with
eight over 150% capacity. Among the four which are below capacity, their occupancies are still
high, from a public health standpoint: 90.9%, 96.2%, 97.3%, and 99.7%.
11.
I visited 10 of the California state prisons in 2009, and have observed many of the
large open dormitories, housing groups ranging from a half dozen to scores of incarcerated people.
Additionally, I have reviewed photographs taken in 2019 and provided to me by plaintiffs’ counsel
of living areas and day rooms in four prisons: Central California Women’s Facility, California
Institution for Men, California Medical Facility, and the Substance Abuse Treatment Facility at
Corcoran. I also reviewed a CDCR Institutional Bed Audit dated March 23, 2020 that shows that
many of the CDCR dormitories are very crowded. For example, at Avenal State Prison, all people
are housed in dormitories designed to house 50-100 people. Most of those dormitories are
27
28
084a
3
DECLARATION OF MARC STERN, M.D. IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EMERGENCY MOTION
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD Document 100-6 04/06/20 Page 6 of 21
Case 2:90-cv-00520-KJM-DB Document 6524 Filed 03/25/20 Page 5 of 20
1 currently at 150% capacity. At the Central California Women’s Facility, some of the dormitories
2 are as much as 194% overcrowded.
3
12.
The level of crowding in the California state prisons, as evidenced by the
4 population reports, the Institutional Bed Audit and the photographs I reviewed, is very significant
5 and worrisome from a public health standpoint. These crowded conditions, particularly in the
6 dormitories, make it virtually impossible to maintain social distance.
7
13.
CDCR already has reported confirmed cases of COVID-19 in the prisons. The
8 conditions in CDCR’s prisons will undoubtedly result in the rapid spread of the COVID-19 virus
9 throughout the prisons, absent significant and immediate interventions. In addition, prisons house
10 a higher percentage than the community of people with underlying health conditions that put them
11 at increased risk of serious complications (including death) from COVID-19. Therefore, based on
12 the crowded conditions, coupled with the increased concentration of people with high risk of
13 complications, including death, from COVID-19, incarcerated people in California state
14 prisons are at an extraordinary risk of dying from the COVID-19 virus.
15
14.
I have reviewed the CDCR’s COVID-19 Preparedness webpage listing the
16 precautions they report to have implemented in the prisons. See https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/covid19/.
17 Even if fully implemented as described, these steps reduce, but to not eliminate significant risk
18 compared to risk in the community. Further, according to CDCR’s own plan, it will likely not be
19 able to fully implement its measures. Indeed, according to the website, “staff and inmates are
20 practicing social distancing strategies where possible….” and they will “[adjust] dining schedules
21 where possible” (emphasis added.)
22
15.
For these reasons, I recommend immediately downsizing the population of these
23 prisons, with priority given to those at high risk of harm due to their age and health status, and
24 with the goal of allowing social distancing and recommended public health practices in all
25 ongoing activities. To be effective in reducing the spread of the virus, these downsizing
26 measures must occur now. Currently, the prevalence of the virus in the prisons appears low,
27 limited to a few prisons. This gives the California a critical window of opportunity to contain the
28 virus before it permeates the prison system and becomes completely unmanageable.
085a
4
DECLARATION OF MARC STERN, M.D. IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ EMERGENCY MOTION
Case 3:18-cv-00063-BAJ-EWD Document 100-6 04/06/20 Page 7 of 21
Case 2:90-cv-00520-KJM-DB Document 6524 Filed 03/25/20 Page 6 of 20
1
16.
There are two values to immediate downsizing. First, downsizing will reduce the
2 density of congregation. This will allow people in prison to maintain better social di
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.