Joint Appendix — PennEast Pipeline Company, LLC, Petitioner v. New Jersey, et al.
Supreme Court briefMar 1, 2021
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
NO. 19-1039
In the
Supreme Court of the United States
________________
PENNEAST PIPELINE COMPANY, LLC,
Petitioner,
v.
STATE OF NEW JERSEY, et al.,
Respondents.
________________
On Writ of Certiorari to the
United States Court of Appeals
for the Third Circuit
________________
JOINT APPENDIX
Volume I of II
________________
JEREMY M. FEIGENBAUM
PAUL D. CLEMENT
Counsel of Record
Counsel of Record
OFFICE OF THE NEW
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
JERSEY ATTORNEY
1301 Pennsylvania Ave., NW
GENERAL
Washington, DC 20004
25 Market Street
(202) 389-5000
Trenton, NJ 08611
paul.clement@kirkland.com
(609) 376-2690
jeremy.feigenbaum@njoag.gov
Counsel for Respondents
State of New Jersey, et al.
Counsel for Petitioner
(Additional Counsel Listed on Inside Cover)
March 1, 2021
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Filed Feb. 18, 2020
Petition for Writ of Certiorari Granted Feb. 3, 2021
MATTHEW LITTLETON
Counsel of Record
DONAHUE, GOLDBERG,
WEAVER & LITTLETON
1008 Pennsylvania Avenue, SE
Washington, DC 20003
(202) 683-6895
matt@donahuegoldberg.com
JENNIFER L. DANIS
EDWARD LLOYD
MORNINGSIDE HEIGHTS
LEGAL SERVICES
435 W. 116th Street
New York, NY 10027
(201) 306-3382
jld2228@columbia.edu
elloyd@law.columbia.edu
Counsel for Respondent New Jersey
Conservation Foundation
JA i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Volume I
Relevant Docket Entries, United States Court of
Appeals for the Third Circuit, In re: PennEast
Pipeline Co., LLC, No. 19-1191 ..................... JA-1
Relevant Docket Entries, United States
District Court for the District of New Jersey,
In re: PennEast Pipeline Co., LLC,
No. 3:18-cv-01597 ........................................ JA-26
Order Issuing Certificates, PennEast Pipeline Co.,
LLC, 162 FERC ¶ 61,053 (Jan. 19, 2018) ... JA-35
Order Granting Rehearings for Further
Consideration, PennEast Pipeline Co., LLC,
No. CP15-558-001 (Feb. 22, 2018) ............ JA-212
Order on Rehearing, PennEast Pipeline Co., LLC,
164 FERC ¶ 61,098 (Aug. 10, 2018) .......... JA-213
Volume II
Declaratory Order, PennEast Pipeline Co., LLC,
170 FERC ¶ 61,064 (Jan. 30, 2020) .......... JA-363
Order Denying Rehearing, PennEast Pipeline Co.,
LLC, 171 FERC ¶ 61,135 (May 22, 2020) . JA-460
The following opinions, decisions, judgments, and
orders have been omitted in printing this joint
appendix because they appear on the following page in
the appendix to the Petition for Certiorari:
Appendix A
Opinion, United States Court of Appeals for
the Third Circuit, In re: PennEast Pipeline
Company, LLC, Nos. 19-1191-19-1232
(Sept. 10, 2019) ...................................... Pet.App-1
JA ii
Appendix B
Order, United States Court of Appeals for the
Third Circuit, In re: PennEast Pipeline
Company, LLC, Nos. 19-1191-19-1232
(Nov. 5, 2019) ....................................... Pet.App-32
Appendix C
Opinion, United States District Court for the
District of New Jersey, In re: PennEast
Pipeline
Company,
LLC,
No. 18-1585
(Dec. 14, 2018) ..................................... Pet.App-34
Appendix D
Relevant Statutory Provisions .......... Pet.App-103
15 U.S.C. § 717 ............................ Pet.App-103
15 U.S.C. § 717a .......................... Pet.App-105
15 U.S.C. § 717b .......................... Pet.App-106
15 U.S.C. § 717b-1 ....................... Pet.App-111
15 U.S.C. § 717c .......................... Pet.App-114
15 U.S.C. § 717c-1 ....................... Pet.App-118
15 U.S.C. § 717d .......................... Pet.App-118
15 U.S.C. § 717e .......................... Pet.App-119
15 U.S.C. § 717f ........................... Pet.App-120
15 U.S.C. § 717g .......................... Pet.App-125
15 U.S.C. § 717h .......................... Pet.App-127
15 U.S.C. § 717i ........................... Pet.App-128
15 U.S.C. § 717j ........................... Pet.App-129
15 U.S.C. § 717k .......................... Pet.App-130
15 U.S.C. § 717l ........................... Pet.App-131
15 U.S.C. § 717m ......................... Pet.App-131
JA iii
15 U.S.C. § 717n .......................... Pet.App-135
15 U.S.C. § 717o .......................... Pet.App-138
15 U.S.C. § 717p .......................... Pet.App-138
15 U.S.C. § 717q .......................... Pet.App-140
15 U.S.C. § 717r .......................... Pet.App-141
15 U.S.C. § 717s .......................... Pet.App-145
15 U.S.C. § 717t .......................... Pet.App-147
15 U.S.C. § 717t-1 ....................... Pet.App-147
15 U.S.C. § 717t-2 ....................... Pet.App-148
15 U.S.C. § 717u .......................... Pet.App-151
15 U.S.C. § 717v .......................... Pet.App-151
15 U.S.C. § 717w ......................... Pet.App-152
15 U.S.C. § 717x .......................... Pet.App-152
15 U.S.C. § 717y .......................... Pet.App-153
15 U.S.C. § 717z .......................... Pet.App-162
JA 1
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT
________________
No. 19-1191
________________
IN RE: PENNEAST PIPELINE COMPANY, LLC
STATE OF NEW JERSEY; NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; NEW JERSEY STATE
AGRICULTURE DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE; DELAWARE
& RARITAN CANAL COMMISSION; NEW JERSEY WATER
SUPPLY AUTHORITY; NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF
TRANSPORTATION; NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF THE
TREASURY; NEW JERSEY MOTOR VEHICLE COMMISSION,
Appellants.
________________
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
Date Filed
Docket Text
01/25/2019 CIVIL CASE DOCKETED.
Notice filed by Appellants
Delaware & Raritan Canal
Commission,
New
Jersey
Department of Environmental
Protection,
New
Jersey
Department of Transportation,
New Jersey Department of the
Treasury, New Jersey Motor
Vehicle
Commission,
New
Jersey
State
Agriculture
Development Committee, New
Jersey Water Supply Authority
JA 2
Date Filed
Docket Text
and State of New Jersey in
District Court No. 3-18-cv01597.
(KR)
[Entered:
01/25/2019 03:42 PM]
01/30/2019 CLERK ORDER consolidating
the Appeals at Nos. 19-1191
through
19-1232
for
all
purposes. The parties are
advised that all case opening
forms, motions and briefs must
be electronically filed in all
cases on the Court’s electronic
case filing (ECF) system. All
required case opening forms
should be filed within 14 days of
the date of this Order. For ease
of
docketing,
the
State
Defendants have been added to
the case by department as listed
on the notice of appeal rather
than by how the State
Defendants were listed on each
individual docket, filed. [191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 19-
JA 3
Date Filed
Docket Text
1218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] (LML)
[Entered: 01/30/2019 11:39 AM]
*
*
*
03/05/2019 ECF FILER: Motion filed by
Appellants Delaware & Raritan
Canal Commission, New Jersey
Department of Environmental
Protection,
New
Jersey
Department of Transportation,
New Jersey Department of
Treasury, New Jersey Motor
Vehicle
Commission,
New
Jersey
State
Agriculture
Development Committee, New
Jersey Water Supply Authority
and State of New Jersey to stay
District Court Order Pending
Resolution of the Appeal, to
Expedite the motion and the
appeals with proposed briefing
schedule. Certificate of Service
dated 03/05/2019. Service made
by ECF. [19-1191, 19-1192, 191193, 19-1194, 19-1195, 191196, 19-1197, 19-1198, 191199, 19-1200, 19-1201, 191202, 19-1203, 19-1204, 191205, 19-1206, 19-1207, 19-
JA 4
Date Filed
Docket Text
1208, 19-1209, 19-1210, 191211, 19-1212, 19-1213, 191214, 19-1215, 19-1216, 191217, 19-1218, 19-1219, 191220, 19-1221, 19-1222, 191223, 19-1224, 19-1225, 191226, 19-1227, 19-1228, 191229, 19-1230, 19-1231, 191232]--[Edited 03/05/2019 by
KR]
(MAC)
[Entered:
03/05/2019 03:18 PM]
*
*
*
03/08/2019 ECF FILER: Response filed by
Appellee County of Mercer to
motion for stay, motion to
Expedite
the
appeals.
Certificate of Service dated
03/08/2019. [19-1191, 19-1192,
19-1227]--[Edited 03/08/2019 by
KR] (PRA) [Entered: 03/08/2019
10:35 AM]
*
*
*
03/15/2019 ECF
FILER:
Reply
by
Appellants Delaware & Raritan
Canal Commission, New Jersey
Department of Environmental
Protection,
New
Jersey
Department of Transportation,
New Jersey Department of
Treasury, New Jersey Motor
Vehicle
Commission,
New
Jersey
State
Agriculture
JA 5
Date Filed
Docket Text
Development Committee, New
Jersey Water Supply Authority
and State of New Jersey to
Response to motion for stay,
motion to Expedite, filed.
Certificate of Service dated
03/15/2019. Service made by
ECF, US mail [19-1191, 191192, 19-1193, 19-1194, 191195, 19-1196, 19-1197, 191198, 19-1199, 19-1200, 191201, 19-1202, 19-1203, 191204, 19-1205, 19-1206, 191207, 19-1208, 19-1209, 191210, 19-1211, 19-1212, 191213, 19-1214, 19-1215, 191216, 19-1217, 19-1218, 191219, 19-1220, 19-1221, 191222, 19-1223, 19-1224, 191225, 19-1226, 19-1227, 191228, 19-1229, 19-1230, 191231,
19-1232]--[Edited
03/15/2019 by KR] (MAC)
[Entered: 03/15/2019 03:26 PM]
03/19/2019 ORDER
(CHAGARES
and
JORDAN,
Circuit
Judges)
granting in part motion for stay
filed by Appellants New Jersey
Department of Environmental
Protection,
New
Jersey
Department of Transportation,
State of New Jersey, New
JA 6
Date Filed
Docket Text
Jersey Department of Treasury,
New Jersey Motor Vehicle
Commission, New Jersey State
Agriculture
Development
Committee, New Jersey Water
Supply Authority and Delaware
& Raritan Canal Commission.
In
the
event
Appellee
transitions from the surveying
and testing phase to the
construction phase of the
pipeline
project,
physical
construction of the pipeline
shall be stayed pending this
appeal. Additionally, the just
compensation portion of the
litigation is stayed pending this
appeal. Appellants’ Motion to
Expedite is granted. Appellants’
Opening Brief of no more than
14,000 words must be filed and
served within thirty (30) days
from the date of this order.
Appellee’s Brief must be filed
and served within twenty (20)
days of service of Appellants’
Brief. A reply brief, if any, must
be filed and served within ten
(10) days of service of the
Appellee’s Brief. The matter will
be assigned to the first merits
panel
available
at
the
conclusion of briefing, filed.
JA 7
Date Filed
Docket Text
Panel
No.:
ECO-026E.
Chagares, Authoring Judge.
[19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] (KR)
[Entered: 03/19/201911:38 AM]
*
*
*
04/18/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
BRIEF on behalf of Appellants
Delaware & Raritan Canal
Commission,
New
Jersey
Department of Environmental
Protection,
New
Jersey
Department of Transportation,
New Jersey Department of
Treasury, New Jersey Motor
Vehicle
Commission,
New
Jersey
State
Agriculture
Development Committee, New
Jersey Water Supply Authority
and State of New Jersey in 19-
JA 8
Date Filed
Docket Text
1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232, filed.
Certificate of Service dated
04/18/2019 by ECF, US mail.
[19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230,
19-1231,19-1232]
[Appendix has been removed
from this entry by the Clerk as
it was filed separately]--[Edited
JA 9
Date Filed
Docket Text
04/24/2019 by MS] (MAC)
[Entered: 04/18/2019 08:56 PM]
*
*
*
04/24/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
JOINT APPENDIX on behalf of
Appellants Delaware & Raritan
Canal Commission, New Jersey
Department of Environmental
Protection,
New
Jersey
Department of Transportation,
New Jersey Department of
Treasury, New Jersey Motor
Vehicle
Commission,
New
Jersey
State
Agriculture
Development Committee, New
Jersey Water Supply Authority
and State of New Jersey in 191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232, filed.
Certificate of service dated
JA 10
Date Filed
Docket Text
04/24/2019 by ECF. [19-1191,
19-1192, 19-1193, 19-1194, 191195, 19-1196, 19-1197, 191198, 19-1199, 19-1200, 191201, 19-1202, 19-1203, 191204, 19-1205, 19-1206, 191207, 19-1208, 19-1209, 191210, 19-1211, 19-1212, 191213, 19-1214, 19-1215, 191216, 19-1217, 19-1218, 191219, 19-1220, 19-1221, 191222, 19-1223, 19-1224, 191225, 19-1226, 19-1227, 191228, 19-1229, 19-1230, 191231, 19-1232] (MAC) [Entered:
04/24/2019 11:20 AM]
*
*
*
04/25/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
AMICUS BRIEF on behalf of
Niskanen Center in support of
Appellant/Petitioner,
filed.
Certificate of Service dated
04/25/2019 by ECF. F.R.A.P.
29(a) Permission: YES.[191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 19-
JA 11
Date Filed
Docket Text
1215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] (JS)
[Entered: 04/25/2019 10:14 PM]
*
*
*
05/08/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
BRIEF on behalf of Appellee
PennEast Pipeline Co LLC in
19-1191, 19-1192,19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232, filed.
Certificate of Service dated
05/08/2019 by 3rd party, ECF.
[19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 19-
JA 12
Date Filed
Docket Text
1206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] (JMG)
[Entered: 05/08/2019 04:57 PM]
*
*
*
05/15/2019 Amended
Oral
Argument
Notification
for
Monday,
06/10/2019. Courtroom & Time:
Maris
Courtroom/2:00p.m..
Location: Philadelphia, PA. [191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] (TLG)
[Entered: 05/15/2019 03:06 PM]
JA 13
Date Filed
Docket Text
05/15/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
AMICUS
BRIEF
with
Supplemental
Appendix
attached on behalf of Interstate
Natural Gas Association of
America,
American
Gas
Association,
American
Petroleum Institute, Chamber
of Commerce of the United
States of America, and National
Association of Manufacturers in
support of Appellee/Respondent,
filed. Certificate of Service
dated 05/15/2019 by ECF.
F.R.A.P. 29(a) Permission: YES.
[19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] - [Entry
edited by the Clerk to reflect
that
Supp.
Appendix
is
attached]--[Edited 05/16/2019
JA 14
Date Filed
Docket Text
by MS] (AMM) [Entered:
05/15/2019 05:33 PM]
*
*
*
05/16/2019 ECF FILER: Motion filed by
Amicus Appellees American
Gas Association, American
Petroleum Institute, Chamber
of Commerce of the United
States of America, Interstate
Natural Gas Association of
America
and
National
Association of Manufacturers in
19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232 to
Extend the Record and File
Supplemental Appendix With
Amicus Brief. Certificate of
Service
dated
05/16/2019.
Service made by ECF. [19-1191,
19-1192, 19-1193, 19-1194, 19-
JA 15
Date Filed
Docket Text
1195, 19-1196, 19-1197, 191198, 19-1199, 19-1200, 191201, 19-1202, 19-1203, 191204, 19-1205, 19-1206, 191207, 19-1208, 19-1209, 191210, 19-1211, 19-1212, 191213, 19-1214, 19-1215, 191216, 19-1217, 19-1218, 191219, 19-1220, 19-1221, 191222, 19-1223, 19-1224, 191225, 19-1226, 19-1227, 191228, 19-1229, 19-1230, 191231, 19-1232] (AMM) [Entered:
05/16/2019 06:36 PM]
05/20/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
REPLY BRIEF on behalf of
Appellants Delaware & Raritan
Canal Commission, New Jersey
Department of Environmental
Protection,
New
Jersey
Department of Transportation,
New Jersey Department of
Treasury, New Jersey Motor
Vehicle
Commission,
New
Jersey
State
Agriculture
Development Committee, New
Jersey Water Supply Authority
and State of New Jersey in 191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 19-
JA 16
Date Filed
Docket Text
1203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232, filed.
Certificate of Service dated
05/20/2019 by ECF, US mail.
[19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] (MAC)
[Entered: 05/20/2019 06:07 PM]
05/21/2019 ORDER (JORDAN, BIBAS and
NYGAARD, Circuit Judges)
granting Motion by Amicus
Appellees
Natural
Gas
Association of America, et al. for
JA 17
Date Filed
Docket Text
Leave to Extend the Record and
File Supplemental Appendix
with Amicus Brief, filed. Kent A.
Jordan, Authoring Judge. [191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230, 19-1231, 19-1232] (MS)
[Entered: 05/21/2019 04:41 PM]
*
*
*
06/10/2019 ARGUED on Monday, June 10,
2019. Panel: JORDAN, BIBAS
and
*NYGAARD,
Circuit
Judges. Jeremy Feigenbaum
arguing for Appellant New
Jersey
Department
of
Environmental
Protection;
James M. Graziano arguing for
Appellee PennEast Pipeline Co
LLC. *(Participated in Video
Conference). [19-1191, 19-1192,
19-1193, 19-1194, 19-1195, 19-
JA 18
Date Filed
Docket Text
1196, 19-1197, 19-1198, 191199, 19-1200, 19-1201, 191202, 19-1203, 19-1204, 191205, 19-1206, 19-1207, 191208, 19-1209, 19-1210, 191211, 19-1212, 19-1213, 191214, 19-1215, 19-1216, 191217, 19-1218, 19-1219, 191220, 19-1221, 19-1222, 191223, 19-1224, 19-1225, 191226, 19-1227, 19-1228, 191229, 19-1230, 19-1231, 191232]
(PM)
[Entered:
06/10/2019 03:32 PM]
*
*
*
09/10/2019 PRECEDENTIAL
OPINION
Coram: JORDAN, BIBAS and
NYGAARD, Circuit Judges.
Total
Pages:
35.Judge:
JORDAN Authoring. [19-1191,
19-1192, 19-1193, 19-1194, 191195, 19-1196, 19-1197, 191198, 19-1199, 19-1200, 191201, 19-1202, 19-1203, 191204, 19-1205, 19-1206, 191207, 19-1208, 19-1209, 191210, 19-1211, 19-1212, 191213, 19-1214, 19-1215, 191216, 19-1217, 19-1218, 191219, 19-1220, 19-1221, 191222, 19-1223, 19-1224, 191225, 19-1226, 19-1227, 19-
JA 19
Date Filed
Docket Text
1228, 19-1229, 19-1230, 191231,19-1232] (KR) [Entered:
09/10/2019 08:33 AM]
09/10/2019 JUDGMENT, Vacated and
Remanded. Parties to bear their
own costs. [19-1191, 19-1192,
19-1193, 19-1194, 19-1195, 191196, 19-1197, 19-1198, 191199, 19-1200, 19-1201, 191202, 19-1203, 19-1204, 191205, 19-1206, 19-1207, 191208, 19-1209, 19-1210, 191211, 19-1212, 19-1213, 191214, 19-1215, 19-1216, 191217, 19-1218, 19-1219, 191220, 19-1221, 19-1222, 191223, 19-1224, 19-1225, 191226, 19-1227, 19-1228, 191229, 19-1230, 19-1231, 191232] (KR) [Entered: 09/10/2019
08:36 AM]
09/11/2019 ORDER
AMENDING
OPINION (Clerk) It has come to
the attention of the Clerk that
Lela Hollabaugh counsel for
amicus appellees Interstate
Natural Gas Association of
America, et al, was not listed as
counsel on the opinion of this
Court in addition American Gas
Association was not listed as an
amicus appellee. Accordingly, it
JA 20
Date Filed
Docket Text
is hereby ORDERED that the
listing of counsel on the opinion
is amended as follows, filed.
(See Order for Corrections) Nda
regenerated to show American
Gas Association was also added
to the order with counsel. [191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230,
19-1231,
19-1232]-[Edited 09/11/2019 by PDB]
(PDB) [Entered: 09/11/2019
11:40 AM]
*
*
*
09/19/2019 ORDER
AMENDING
OPINION (Clerk) It has come to
the attention of the Clerk that
Mark A. Collier and Jeremy
Feigenbaum are employed by
the Office of the Attorney
General of New Jersey, Division
JA 21
Date Filed
Docket Text
of Law, not the Division of
Criminal Justice, filed. [191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230,19-1231, 19-1232] (KR)
[Entered: 09/19/2019 02:42 PM]
*
*
*
10/22/2019 ECF FILER: Petition filed by
Appellee PennEast Pipeline Co
LLC for Rehearing before
original panel and the court en
banc. Certificate of Service
dated 10/22/2019. Service made
by ECF, US mail. [19-1191, 191192, 19-1193, 19-1194, 191195, 19-1196, 19-1197, 191198, 19-1199, 19-1200, 191201, 19-1202, 19-1203, 191204, 19-1205, 19-1206, 191207, 19-1208, 19-1209, 191210, 19-1211, 19-1212, 19-
JA 22
Date Filed
Docket Text
1213, 19-1214, 19-1215, 191216, 19-1217, 19-1218, 191219, 19-1220, 19-1221, 191222, 19-1223, 19-1224, 191225, 19-1226, 19-1227, 191228, 19-1229, 19-1230, 191231,
19-1232]--[Edited
10/23/2019 by KR] (JCM)
[Entered: 10/22/2019 01:33 PM]
*
*
*
10/29/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
AMICUS BRIEF on behalf of
Amicus Appellees American
Gas Association, American
Petroleum Institute, Interstate
Natural Gas Association of
America
and
National
Association of Manufacturers in
support of Appellee’s Pettion for
Rehearing.
Certificate
of
Service dated 10/29/2019 by
ECF. [19-1191, 19-1192, 191193, 19-1194, 19-1195, 191196, 19-1197, 19-1198, 191199, 19-1200, 19-1201, 191202, 19-1203, 19-1204, 191205, 19-1206, 19-1207, 191208, 19-1209, 19-1210, 191211, 19-1212, 19-1213, 191214, 19-1215, 19-1216, 191217, 19-1218, 19-1219, 191220, 19-1221, 19-1222, 19-
JA 23
Date Filed
Docket Text
1223, 19-1224, 19-1225, 191226, 19-1227, 19-1228, 191229, 19-1230, 19-1231, 191232]--[Edited 10/30/2019 by
KR]
(AMM)
[Entered:
10/29/2019 04:12 PM]
*
*
*
10/29/2019 ECF FILER: ELECTRONIC
AMICUS BRIEF on behalf of TC
Energy Corporation in support
of Appellee’s petition for
rehearing. Certificate of Service
dated 10/29/2019 by ECF.
F.R.A.P. 29(a) Permission: NO.
[19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230,
19-1231,
19-1232]-[Edited 10/30/2019 by KR]
(CES) [Entered: 10/29/2019
04:38 PM]
*
*
*
JA 24
Date Filed
Docket Text
11/05/2019 ORDER (SMITH, Chief Judge,
CHAGARES,
JORDAN,
KRAUSE, RESTREPO, BIBAS,
PORTER, MATEY, PHIPPS
and
NYGAARD*,
Circuit
Judges) denying Petition En
Banc and Panel Rehearing filed
by Appellee PennEast Pipeline
Co LLC. Jordan, Authoring
Judge. *Judge Nygaard’s vote is
limited to panel rehearing only.
[19-1191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 191200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230,
19-1231,
19-1232]-[Edited 11/05/2019 by LML to
attach corrected order] (LMR)
[Entered: 11/05/2019 08:04 AM]
11/13/2019 MANDATE ISSUED, filed. [191191, 19-1192, 19-1193, 191194, 19-1195, 19-1196, 191197, 19-1198, 19-1199, 19-
JA 25
Date Filed
Docket Text
1200, 19-1201, 19-1202, 191203, 19-1204, 19-1205, 191206, 19-1207, 19-1208, 191209, 19-1210, 19-1211, 191212, 19-1213, 19-1214, 191215, 19-1216, 19-1217, 191218, 19-1219, 19-1220, 191221, 19-1222, 19-1223, 191224, 19-1225, 19-1226, 191227, 19-1228, 19-1229, 191230,
19-1231,
19-1232]-[Edited 11/13/2019 by TMK]
(TMM) [Entered: 11/13/2019
09:30 AM]
*
*
*
JA 26
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
________________
No. 3:18-cv-01597
________________
IN RE: PENNEAST PIPELINE COMPANY, LLC,
V.
Plaintiff,
A PERMANENT EASEMENT FOR 1.92 ACRES AND
TEMPORARY EASEMENT FOR 2.05 ACRES IN HOPEWELL
TOWNSHIP, MERCER COUNTY, NEW JERSEY, TAX
PARCEL NO. 1106-59-13.01, et al.,
Defendants.
________________
RELEVANT DOCKET ENTRIES
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
02/06/2018
1
COMPLAINT
against
A
PERMANENT
EASEMENT
FOR
1.92
ACRES
AND
TEMPORARY
EASEMENT
FOR
2.05
ACRES
IN
HOPEWELL
TOWNSHIP,
MERCER COUNTY, NEW
JERSEY, TAX PARCEL NO.
1106-59-13.01, COUNTY OF
MERCER, JERSEY CENTRAL
POWER
AND
LIGHT
COMPANY, STATE OF NEW
JERSEY,
BY
THE
JA 27
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
SECRETARY OF THE NEW
JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION,
TOWNSHIP
OF HOPEWELL, VERIZON
NEW JERSEY, INC. ( Filing
and Admin fee $ 400 receipt
number 0312-8457293), filed by
PENNEAST
PIPELINE
COMPANY,
LLC.
(Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover
Sheet, # 2 NOTICE OF
CONDEMNATION,
#
3
PROPOSED ORDER TO SHOW
CAUSE, # 4 Brief, # 5
DECLARATION OF DANIEL
MURPHY, # 6 DECLARATION
OF JEFFREY ENGLAND AND
EXHIBITS, # 7 Text of Proposed
Order)(GRAZIANO,
JAMES)
(Entered: 02/06/2018)
03/22/2018
04/02/2018
21
36
*
*
*
ANSWER to Complaint with
JURY
DEMAND
by
TOWNSHIP OF HOPEWELL.
(DUGGAN,
TIMOTHY)
(Entered: 03/22/2018)
*
*
*
ANSWER to Complaint with
JURY DEMAND (with Cert of
Service) by VERIZON NEW
JERSEY, INC..(DALCORTIVO,
JA 28
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
KATHLEEN)
04/02/2018)
04/03/2018
05/17/2018
38
44
(Entered:
*
*
*
ANSWER to Complaint with
JURY DEMAND by COUNTY
OF MERCER. (Attachments: #
1 Supplement Cover Letter)
(ADEZIO, PAUL) (Entered:
04/03/2018)
*
*
*
BRIEF
Final
Summation
(Attachments: # 1 Brief, # 2
Certification Appleget, # 3
Certification DeChristie, # 4
Certification
Gates,
#
5
Certification
Payne,
#
6
Certification
Yeany,
#
7
Certificate
of
Service)
(COLLIER, MARK) (Entered:
05/17/2018)
*
*
*
BRIEF
Plaintiff
PennEast
Pipeline Company, LLC Final
Written
Summation
(Attachments: # 1 Certificate of
Service)(GRAZIANO, JAMES)
(Entered: 05/18/2018)
05/18/2018
46
05/21/2018
47
BRIEF (DUGGAN, TIMOTHY)
(Entered: 05/21/2018)
06/04/2018
48
BRIEF
Pipeline
Plaintiff
PennEast
Company,
LLC
JA 29
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
Response to Closing Argument
of the State of New Jersey
(Attachments: # 1 Certificate of
Service) (GRAZIANO, JAMES)
(Entered: 06/04/2018)
*
*
*
BRIEF (DUGGAN, TIMOTHY)
(Entered: 12/10/2018)
12/10/2018
59
12/10/2018
60
BRIEF (DUGGAN, TIMOTHY)
(Entered: 12/10/2018)
12/14/2018
61
OPINION filed. Signed by
Judge Brian R. Martinotti on
12/14/2018. (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit A) (mps) (Entered:
12/14/2018)
12/14/2018
62
VACATED - ORDER Denying
the State Defendants’ request
for
dismissal;
PennEast’s
application
for
orders
of
condemnation
and
for
preliminary injunctive relief
allowing immediate possession
of the respective Rights of Way
in advance of any award of just
compensation
is
Granted;
PennEast shall post security in
the form of a surety bond into
the Courts Registry pursuant to
Local Civil Rule 67.1(a); upon
PennEast’s post of appropriate
security,
PennEast
is
JA 30
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
authorized to immediately enter
and take possession of the
Rights of Way for all purposes
allowed under the FERC Order;
The
Court
appoints
the
individuals listed herein as
Special Masters/Condemnation
Commissioners to adjudicate
and determine compensation;
CASE
MANAGEMENT
CONFERENCE
set
for
2/14/2019, at 10:00AM in
courtroom 1; PennEast shall
submit a revised, case-specific
forms of orders by 1/4/2019..
Signed by Judge Brian R.
Martinotti
on
12/14/2018.
(Attachments: # 1 Exhibit
A)(mps) (Entered: 12/14/2018)
12/28/2018
64
12/28/2018
65
*
*
*
MOTION for Reconsideration
by STATE OF NEW JERSEY,
BY THE SECRETARY OF THE
NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT
OF
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION. (Attachments:
# 1 Brief, # 2 Certificate of
Service, # 3 Text of Proposed
Order) (COLLIER, MARK)
(Entered: 12/28/2018)
MOTION to Stay by STATE
OF NEW JERSEY, BY THE
JA 31
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
SECRETARY OF THE NEW
JERSEY
DEPARTMENT
OF
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION. (Attachments:
# 1 Brief, # 2 Certificate of
Service, # 3 Text of Proposed
Order) (COLLIER, MARK)
(Entered: 12/28/2018)
01/08/2019
70
01/08/2019
71
01/11/2019
73
*
*
*
BRIEF in Opposition filed by
PENNEAST
PIPELINE
COMPANY,
LLC
re
64
MOTION for Reconsideration
(Attachments: # 1 Certificate of
Service)(GRAZIANO, JAMES)
(Entered: 01/08/2019)
BRIEF in Opposition filed by
PENNEAST
PIPELINE
COMPANY,
LLC
re
65
MOTION to Stay (Attachments:
#
1
Certificate
of
Service)(GRAZIANO, JAMES)
(Entered: 01/08/2019)
*
*
*
NOTICE OF APPEAL as to 62
Order,,, 61 Opinion by STATE
OF NEW JERSEY, BY THE
SECRETARY OF THE NEW
JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION. Filing fee $ 505,
receipt number 0312-9301226.
JA 32
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
The Clerk’s Office hereby
certifies the record and the
docket sheet available through
ECF to be the certified list in
lieu of the record and/or the
certified copy of the docket
entries. (Attachments: # 1
Certificate of Service)(MILES,
KRISTINA)
(Entered:
01/11/2019)
01/15/2019
01/23/2019
75
82
*
*
*
REPLY BRIEF to Opposition to
Motion filed by STATE OF
NEW JERSEY, BY THE
SECRETARY OF THE NEW
JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION re 65 MOTION
to Stay (Attachments: # 1
Certificate
of
Service)
(COLLIER, MARK) (Entered:
01/15/2019)
*
*
*
ORDER
that
the
State
Defendants’
Motion
for
Reconsideration is denied. The
State Defendants’ Motion to
Stay is denied as moot. Signed
by Judge Brian R. Martinotti on
1/23/2019. (Attachments: # 1
Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B) (mps)
(Entered: 01/23/2019)
JA 33
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
01/25/2019
83
VACATED - ORDER that
PennEast has substantive right
to condemn a permanent Right
of Way and temporary easement
to be taken on the subject
property within this Order.
PennEast shall post security in
the form of a surety bond into
the Court’s Registry in the
amount of $112,200.00. The
Court, along with the Special
Master/Condemnation
Commissioners, shall hold a
case management conference on
2/14/2019, at 10:00 AM in
Courtroom 1, regarding the
protocol for determining just
compensation, Signed by Judge
Brian
R.
Martinotti
on
1/25/2019. (mmh) (Entered:
01/25/2019)
01/25/2019
84
USCA Case Number 19-1191 for
73 Notice of Appeal (USCA)
filed by STATE OF NEW
JERSEY,
BY
THE
SECRETARY OF THE NEW
JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION. USCA Case
Manager
Kirsi
(Document
Restricted - Court Only) (ca3kr)
(Entered: 01/25/2019)
JA 34
Date Filed
#
Docket Text
*
*
*
JA 35
Order Issuing Certificates, PennEast Pipeline
Co., LLC, 162 FERC ¶ 61,053 (Jan. 19, 2018)
1. On September 24, 2015, PennEast Pipeline
Company, LLC (PennEast) filed an application
pursuant to section 7(c) of the Natural Gas Act (NGA) 1
and Parts 157 and 284 of the Commission’s
regulations, 2 requesting authorization to construct
and operate a new 116-mile natural gas pipeline from
Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, to Mercer County,
New Jersey, along with three laterals extending off
the mainline, a compression station, and appurtenant
above ground facilities (PennEast Project). The project
is designed to provide up to 1,107,000 dekatherms per
day (Dth/d) of firm transportation service. PennEast
also requests a blanket certificate under Part 284,
Subpart G of the Commission’s regulations to provide
open-access transportation services, and a blanket
certificate under Part 157, Subpart F of the
Commission’s regulations to perform certain routine
construction activities and operations.
2. As explained herein, we find that the benefits that
the PennEast Project will provide to the market
outweigh any adverse effects on existing shippers,
other pipelines and their captive customers, and on
landowners and surrounding communities. Further,
as set forth in the environmental discussion below, we
agree with Commission staff’s conclusion in the
Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) that the
project will result in some adverse environmental
impacts, but that these impacts will be reduced to
1 15 U.S.C. § 717f(c) (2012).
2 18 C.F.R. pt. 157 (2017).
JA 36
acceptable levels with the implementation of the
applicant’s
proposed
mitigation
and
staff’s
recommendations, as modified herein, and adopted as
conditions in the attached Appendix A of this order.
Therefore, for the reasons stated below, we grant the
requested authorizations, subject to the conditions
discussed herein.
I.
Background and Proposal
3. PennEast 3 is a Delaware limited liability
company organized and existing under the laws of the
State of Delaware, managed by UGI Energy Services,
LLC, pursuant to a Project Management Agreement.
Upon the commencement of operations proposed in its
application, PennEast will become a natural gas
company within the meaning of section 2(6) of the
NGA, 4 and will be subject to the Commission’s
jurisdiction.
A. Facilities and Services
4. PennEast proposes to construct a new greenfield
pipeline system to provide up to 1,107,000 Dth/d of
firm natural gas transportation service to markets in
New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, and
surrounding states. The project extends from various
receipt point interconnections with the interstate
PennEast is a joint venture owned by Red Oak Enterprise
Holdings, Inc., a subsidiary of AGL Resources Inc. (20 percent
interest); NJR Pipeline Company, a subsidiary of New Jersey
Resources (20 percent interest); SJI Midstream, LLC, a
subsidiary of South Jersey Industries (20 percent interest); UGI
PennEast, LLC, a subsidiary of UGI Energy Services, LLC (20
percent interest); and Spectra Energy Partners, LP (20 percent
interest).
3
4 15 U.S.C. § 717a(6) (2012).
JA 37
natural gas pipeline system of Transcontinental Gas
Pipe Line Company, LLC (Transco) and with
gathering systems in the eastern Marcellus Shale
region operated by UGI Energy Services, LLC,
Williams Partners, L.P., and Energy Transfer
Partners, L.P., to multiple delivery point
interconnections in natural gas-consuming markets in
New Jersey and Pennsylvania, terminating at a
delivery point with Transco in Mercer County, New
Jersey. 5 PennEast states that the project is designed
to bring lower cost natural gas to markets in New
Jersey, Pennsylvania, and New York and to provide
shippers with additional supply flexibility, diversity,
and reliability. 6
5. PennEast proposes to construct the following
facilities:
•
•
approximately 116 miles of 36-inch-diameter
mainline transmission pipeline originating in
Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, and extending
to Mercer County, New Jersey, traversing
Luzerne, Carbon, Northampton, and Bucks
Counties, Pennsylvania, and Hunterdon and
Mercer Counties, New Jersey;
three lateral pipelines extending off of the
mainline consisting of:
• the approximately 2.1-mile, 24-inchdiameter
Hellertown
Lateral
in
Northampton County, Pennsylvania to
connect with Columbia Gas Transmission,
LLC, and UGI Utilities, Inc.;
5 See PennEast’s Application at 3.
6 Id. at 4, 8-10.
JA 38
the approximately 0.6-mile, 12-inchdiameter Gilbert Lateral in Hunterdon
County, New Jersey to connect with NRG
REMA, LLC, and Elizabethtown Gas at the
Gilbert Electric Generating Station; and
• the approximately 1.54-mile, 36-inchdiameter
Lambertville
Lateral
in
Hunterdon County, New Jersey to connect
with Algonquin Gas Transmission, LLC,
and Texas Eastern Transmission, LP;
• one new compressor station in Carbon County,
Pennsylvania; and
• various associated aboveground facilities,
including interconnects, launchers, receivers,
and mainline block valves.
PennEast estimates that the proposed facilities will
cost approximately $1.13 billion.
6. PennEast states that it conducted an open season
for the project from August 11 to August 29, 2014. As
a result of the open season, PennEast states that it has
executed long-term precedent agreements with the
following 12 shippers for 990,000 Dth/d of firm
transportation service, or approximately 90 percent of
the project’s capacity:
•
Shipper (* indicates PennEast Contracted
Affiliate)
Volumes (Dth/d)
New Jersey
Company*
Natural
Gas
180,000
PSEG Power, LLC*
125,000
Texas Eastern Transmission,
LP*
125,000
South Jersey Gas Company*
105,000
JA 39
ConEd of New York
100,000
Elizabethtown Gas*
100,000
UGI Energy Services, Inc.*
100,000
Cabot Oil & Gas Corp.
50,000
Talen Energy Marketing, LLC
50,000
Enerplus Resources Corp.
30,000
Warren Resources, Inc.
15,000
NRG Rema LLC
10,000
PennEast proposes to provide service to the project
shippers at negotiated rates.
7. PennEast also requests approval of its pro forma
tariff. PennEast proposes to offer open-access
transportation services under Rate Schedules FTS
(Firm Transportation Service), ITS (Interruptible
Transportation Service), and PALS (Parking and
Lending Service).
B. Blanket Certificates
8. PennEast requests a blanket certificate of public
convenience and necessity pursuant to Part 284,
Subpart G of the Commission’s regulations
authorizing PennEast to provide transportation
service to customers requesting and qualifying for
transportation service under its proposed FERC Gas
Tariff, with pre-granted abandonment authorization. 7
9. PennEast requests a blanket certificate of public
convenience and necessity pursuant to Part 157,
Subpart F of the Commission’s regulations
7 18 C.F.R. § 284.221 (2017).
JA 40
authorizing certain future facility
operation, and abandonment. 8
construction,
II. Procedural Issues
A. Notice, Interventions,
Comments
Protests,
and
10. Notice of PennEast’s application was published in
the Federal Register on October 15, 2015. 9 Timely,
unopposed motions to intervene are granted by
operation of Rule 214 of the Commission’s Rules of
Practice and Procedure. 10 Late interventions were
granted by notice issued on March 23, 2017, and May
18, 2017.
11. Numerous entities, landowners, individuals, and
New Jersey State representatives filed protests and
adverse comments raising the following issues: (1) the
need for an evidentiary hearing; (2) the need for the
project; and (3) whether the use of eminent domain is
appropriate for this project. On November 13, 2015,
PennEast filed a Motion for Leave to Answer and
Answer to the protests, as well as to various comments
filed on the project. Although the Commission’s Rules
of Practice and Procedure generally do not permit
answers to protests, 11 we will accept PennEast’s
answer because it clarifies the concerns raised and
provides information that has assisted in our decision
making. These concerns are addressed below.
8 Id. § 157.204 (2017).
9 80 Fed. Reg. 62,068 (2015).
10 18 C.F.R. § 385.214 (2017).
11 Id. § 385.214(c) (2017).
JA 41
12. In addition, numerous comments were filed
raising concerns over the environmental impacts of
the project. These comments are addressed in the
Final Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) and, as
appropriate, below.
B. Request for Evidentiary Hearing
13. New Jersey Senator Shirley K. Turner, New
Jersey Assemblyman Reed Gusciora, and New Jersey
Assemblywoman Elizabeth Muoio requested an
evidentiary hearing to determine the need for the
project, and explore whether less disruptive, more
cost-effective alternatives exist to meet demand.
Similarly, the New Jersey Conservation Foundation
(NJCF) and Stony Brook-Millstone Watershed
Association (Stony Brook) assert that a hearing is
necessary in order to develop a record to determine the
public benefits of the project and whether the project
is viable without subsidies.
14. An evidentiary, trial-type hearing is necessary
only where there are material issues of fact in dispute
that cannot be resolved on the basis of the written
record. 12 No party has raised a material issue of fact
that the Commission cannot resolve on the basis of the
written record. As demonstrated by the discussion
below, the existing written record provides a sufficient
basis to resolve the issues relevant to this proceeding.
The Commission has satisfied the hearing
requirement by giving all interested parties a full and
complete opportunity to participate through
12 See, e.g., Southern Union Gas Co. v. FERC, 840 F.2d 964, 970
(D.C. Cir. 1988); Dominion Transmission, Inc., 141 FERC
¶ 61,183, at P 15 (2012).
JA 42
evidentiary submission in written form. 13 Therefore,
we will deny the request for a trial-type evidentiary
hearing.
III. Discussion
15. As PennEast’s proposed pipeline system would be
used to transport natural gas in interstate commerce
subject to the Commission’s jurisdiction, the
construction and operation of the facilities are subject
to the requirements of subsections (c) and (e) of section
7 of the NGA. 14
A. Application of the Certificate Policy
Statement
16. The Certificate Policy Statement provides
guidance for evaluating proposals to certificate new
construction. 15 The Certificate Policy Statement
establishes criteria for determining whether there is a
need for a proposed project and whether the proposed
project will serve the public interest. The Certificate
Policy Statement explains that in deciding whether to
authorize the construction of major new pipeline
facilities, the Commission balances the public benefits
against the potential adverse consequences. The
Commission’s goal is to give appropriate consideration
to the enhancement of competitive transportation
alternatives, the possibility of overbuilding,
subsidization by existing customers, the applicant’s
13 Moreau v. FERC, 982 F.2d 556, 568 (D.C. Cir. 1993).
14 15 U.S.C. §§ 717f(c), (e) (2012).
15 Certification of New Interstate Natural Gas Pipeline Facilities,
88 FERC ¶ 61,227 (1999), clarified, 90 FERC ¶ 61,128 (2000),
further clarified, 92 FERC ¶ 61,094 (2000) (Certificate Policy
Statement).
JA 43
responsibility for unsubscribed capacity, the
avoidance of unnecessary disruptions of the
environment, and the unneeded exercise of eminent
domain in evaluating new pipeline facilities
construction.
17. Under this policy, the threshold requirement for
pipelines proposing new projects is that the pipeline
must be prepared to financially support the project
without relying on subsidization from its existing
customers. The next step is to determine whether the
applicant has made efforts to eliminate or minimize
any adverse effects the project might have on the
applicant’s existing customers, existing pipelines in
the market and their captive customers, or
landowners and communities affected by the
construction. If residual adverse effects on these
interest groups are identified after efforts have been
made to minimize them, we will evaluate the project
by balancing the evidence of public benefits to be
achieved against the residual adverse effects. This is
essentially an economic test. Only when the benefits
outweigh the adverse effects on economic interests
will we proceed to consider the environmental analysis
where other interests are addressed.
1.
Subsidization
and
Existing Customers
Impact
on
18. As discussed above, the threshold requirement for
pipelines proposing new projects is that the pipeline
must be prepared to financially support the project
without relying on subsidization from existing
customers. As PennEast is a new company, it has no
existing customers. As such, there is no potential for
JA 44
subsidization on PennEast’s system or degradation of
service to existing customers.
2.
Need for the Project
19. Numerous parties and commenters challenge the
need for the project. 16 They raise a variety of
arguments including: (1) insufficient demand for
natural gas in New Jersey and Pennsylvania; (2) the
need for a regional analysis to determine if the project
is needed; (3) the availability of alternatives, including
renewable energy and capacity on existing and
proposed interstate pipelines, to meet future demand;
(4) the public benefits of the project, including cost
savings, supply flexibility and reliability, and local
employment impacts are unfounded or are overstated;
(5) the use of precedent agreements with affiliated
entities to demonstrate project need; and (6) that a
portion of the gas transported on the project may be
exported.
20. A number of commenters claim that the project is
not needed because there is little or no forecasted load
growth in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. 17 In
16 Many of the commenters conflate the balancing of economic
benefits (market need) and effects under the Certificate Policy
Statement with the distinct description of purpose and need in
the final EIS. The purpose and need statement in the final EIS
complied with Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ)
regulations that provide that this statement “shall briefly specify
the underlying purpose and need to which the agency is
responding in proposing the alternatives including the proposed
actions” for purposes of its environmental analysis. 40 C.F.R.
§ 1502.13 (2017).
17 See, e.g., October 29, 2015 Comments of NJCF at 9; February
11, 2016 Comments of Delaware Riverkeeper (citing attached
affidavit of David Berman, Labyrinth Consulting Services);
JA 45
addition, the New Jersey Division of Rate Counsel
(NJRC) cites to filings made by local distribution
companies (LDCs) before state regulatory agencies in
Pennsylvania and New Jersey which show that the
peak day requirements of the LDCs will be largely
stable through 2020, and can be met through existing
supply arrangements. 18
21. Numerous commenters suggest that increased
use of renewable resources to generate electricity and
energy conservation could eliminate the need for the
project. Several other commenters claim that there is
no need to construct a new pipeline, as PennEast’s
shippers could source gas on existing pipelines or on
other to be constructed, but already-authorized
pipeline capacity. 19 NJRC states that the fact that
utilization rates of several long-haul pipelines
declined from 2007 to 2013 suggests that there is
available firm capacity on these existing pipelines. 20
October 27, 2015 Comments of the West Amwell Citizens Against
the Pipeline.
18 See September 12, 2016 Comments of NJCF (citing attached
Affidavit of David E. Dismukes). On October 17, 2016, PennEast
filed an answer to NJRC. On November 14, 2016, the New Jersey
Division of Rate Council (NJRC) filed a Motion for Leave to
Answer and Answer to PennEast. Although the Commission’s
Rules of Practice and Procedure generally do not permit answers
to answers, we will accept NJRC’s answers because it clarifies
the concerns raised and provides information that has assisted in
our decision making.
19 See, e.g., October 29, 2015 Comments of NJCF at 10.
20 September 12, 2016 Comments of NJCF at 6-8 (citing Denny
Young, Black & Veatch, Has Emerging Natural Gas Shale
Production Affected Financial Performances of Interstate
pipelines? (2013).
JA 46
22. Multiple commenters assert that PennEast’s
claims that the project will provide cost-savings for
end users, and provide increased reliability and
supply diversity are unfounded or overstated. 21 The
NJCF filed a report prepared by Skipping Stone, LLC,
(Skipping Stone Report) which challenges the findings
in the Concentric study filed by PennEast 22 that the
PennEast Project would lower costs to consumers. 23
Among other things, the Skipping Stone Report
concludes that local gas distribution companies
already have more than enough capacity to meet peak
winter demand, suggesting that increased demand by
providers of gas-fired electric generation could be
more cost effectively met by dual fuel switching or by
purchasing gas from LNG facilities, and that the
PennEast Project could increase, rather than decrease
costs to consumers. Commenters also claim that the
employment and economic benefits of the project
See, e.g., November 14 Answer of NJRC, October 27, 2015
Comments of the West Amwell Citizens Against the Pipeline.
21
22 In Exhibit F-1, Resource Report 5, PennEast submitted a study
by Concentric Energy Advisors, Estimated Energy Market
Savings from Additional Pipeline Infrastructure Serving Eastern
Pennsylvania and New Jersey) (Concentric Study) that finds that
the project would provide increased access to low-cost natural gas
in New Jersey and Pennsylvania that could save consumers
nearly $900 million. Resource Report 5 also includes a study by
Econsult Solutions & Drexel University, Economic Impact Report
and Analysis: PennEast Pipeline Project Economic Impact
Analysis (2015) (Econsult Study) that estimates the total (direct,
indirect, and induced) jobs that would be supported during
construction and operation of the project.
See Report of Skipping Stone, LLC, attached to NJCF’s
December 1, 2016 Comments (Skipping Stone Report).
23
JA 47
contained in the Econsult study cited by PennEast
have been overstated, possibly significantly so. 24
23. Several commenters allege that because a large
portion of the project’s capacity has been subscribed by
affiliates of the pipeline, additional evidence of need
must be presented as precedent agreements with
pipeline affiliates may not be the result of an “armslength negotiation,” or reflect the competitive
market. 25 Commenters further claim that the project
is being cross-subsidized by the captive customers of
the affiliated shippers, and may not be financially
viable without these subsidies. 26
24. The NJCF and Stony Brook claim that the NGA
requires the Commission to evaluate the need for new
pipeline infrastructure on a regional basis. 27 They
state that the public interest cannot be effectively
safeguarded through the approval of individual
pipelines without coordinated planning to ensure that
pipeline proposal fits within long-term, regional plans.
Therefore, they assert that the Commission should
implement a planning process for natural gas
infrastructure development that is similar to the
planning process for electric transmission.
See November 7, 2015 Comments of NJCF (citing attached
Report of the Goodman Group, ltd.), September 8, 2016
Comments of the NJCF; September 8, 2016 Comments of Jeffrey
R. Shafer.
24
25 Id. at 9-10.
26 See October 20, 2016 Comments of the Eastern Environmental
Law Center, citing attached Report of Dr. Steve Isser, “Natural
Gas Pipeline Certification and Ratemaking.
27 NJCF Comments at 24-27.
JA 48
25. Finally, a few commenters contend that the
PennEast Project is not being proposed to benefit
United States markets but to support the growing
LNG export market. 28
PennEast’s Answers
26. PennEast filed several answers disputing
commenters’ claims that the project was not needed.
PennEast maintains that that substantial need for the
project has been demonstrated by precedent
agreements for long-term firm service for
approximately 90 percent of the project’s capacity. 29
PennEast filed a study that responds to NJRC’s
assessment of the need for the project that explains
that shippers contract for pipeline capacity for a
variety of reasons beyond simply the need to be able to
meet peak demands, including costs savings, supply
security, and price stability. 30 PennEast asserts that
the various studies by market experts that it filed in
the proceeding provide ample market data and
analysis supporting the market need for the project.
Commission Determination
27. The Certificate Policy Statement established a
policy under which the Commission will allow an
applicant to rely on a variety of relevant factors to
demonstrate need, rather than continuing to require
28 See, e.g., October 27, 2015 Comments of West Amwell Citizens
Against the Pipeline at 15-17; February 11, 2016 Comments of
Delaware Riverkeeper (attaching opinion of Labyrinth
Consulting Services, Inc.).
29 See PennEast’s October 17, and December 1, 2016 Answers.
30 PennEast’s October 17 Answer (attaching report of Concentric
Energy Advisors, Inc).
JA 49
that a percentage of the proposed capacity be
subscribed under long-term precedent or service
agreements. 31 These factors might include, but are not
limited to, precedent agreements, demand projections,
potential cost savings to consumers, or a comparison
of projected demand with the amount of capacity
currently serving the market. 32 The Commission
stated that it will consider all such evidence submitted
by the applicant regarding need. Nonetheless, the
Certificate Policy Statement made clear that,
although precedent agreements are no longer required
to be submitted, they are still significant evidence of
demand for the project. 33 As the court stated in
Minisink Residents for Environmental Preservation &
Safety v. FERC, and again in Myersville Citizens for a
Rural Community, Inc., v. FERC, nothing in the
Certificate Policy Statement or in any precedent
construing it suggest that the policy statement
requires, rather than permits, the Commission to
assess a project’s benefits by looking beyond the
market need reflected by the applicant’s precedent
agreements with shippers. 34 Moreover, it is current
Certificate Policy Statement, 88 FERC ¶ 61,227 at 61,747.
Prior to the Certificate Policy Statement, the Commission
required a new pipeline project to have contractual commitments
for at least 25 percent of the proposed project’s capacity. See
Certificate Policy Statement, 88 FERC ¶ 61,227 at 61,743.
PennEast, at 90 percent subscribed, would have satisfied this
prior, more stringent, requirement.
31
32 Id. at 61,747.
33 Id. at 61,748.
34 Minisink Residents for Envtl. Pres. & Safety v. FERC, 762 F.3d
97, 110 n.10 (D.C. Cir. 2014); see also Myersville Citizens for a
Rural Cmty., Inc., v. FERC, 183 F.3d 1301, 1311 (D.C. Cir. 2015).
JA 50
Commission policy to not look beyond precedent or
service agreements to make judgments about the
needs of individual shippers. 35
28. We find that PennEast has sufficiently
demonstrated that there is market demand for the
project. PennEast has entered into long-term, firm
precedent agreements with 12 shippers for 990,000
Dth/d of firm transportation service, approximately 90
percent of the project’s capacity. 36 Further, Ordering
Paragraph (C) of this order requires that PennEast file
a written statement affirming that it has executed
contracts for service at the levels provided for in their
precedent
agreements
prior
to
commencing
construction. PennEast has entered into precedent
agreements for long-term, firm service with 12
shippers. Those shippers will provide gas to a variety
of end users, including local distribution customers,
electric generators, producers, and marketers and
those shippers have determined, based on their
assessment of the long-term needs of their particular
customers and markets, that there is a market for the
natural gas to be transported and the PennEast
Project is the preferred means for delivering or
receiving that gas. Given the substantial financial
commitment required under these contracts by project
35 Id. at 61,744 (citing Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Corp., 82
FERC ¶ 61,084, at 61,316 (1998)).
36 Constitution Pipeline Company, LLC, 154 FERC ¶ 61,046, at P
21 (2016) (“Although the Certificate Policy Statement broadened
the types of evidence certificate applicants may present to show
the public benefits of a project, it did not compel an additional
showing … [and] [n]o market study or other additional evidence
is necessary where … market need is demonstrated by contracts
for 100 percent of the project’s capacity.”).
JA 51
shippers, we find that these contracts are the best
evidence that the service to be provided by the project
is needed in the markets to be served. We also find
that end users will generally benefit from the project
because it would develop gas infrastructure that will
serve to ensure future domestic energy supplies and
enhance the pipeline grid by providing additional
transportation capacity connecting sources of natural
gas to markets in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
29. We are unpersuaded by the studies submitted by
commenters in their attempt to show that there is
insufficient demand for the project and by their
assertions that the Commission is required to examine
the need for pipeline infrastructure on a regional
basis. Commission policy is to examine the merits of
individual projects and assess whether each project
meets the specific need demonstrated. While the
Certificate Policy Statement permits the applicant to
show need in a variety of ways, it does not suggest that
the Commission should examine a group of projects
together and pick which project(s) best serve an
estimated future regional demand. In support of their
arguments regarding demand, commenters cite
general forecasts for load growth in Pennsylvania and
New Jersey or certain LDC supply forecast projections
through 2020 made to state commissions. 37 However,
projections regarding future demand often change and
are influenced by a variety of factors, including
economic growth, the cost of natural gas,
environmental regulations, and legislative and
regulatory decisions by the federal government and
individual states. Given this uncertainty associated
37 NJRC Comments at 5.
JA 52
with long-term demand projections, including those
presented in the studies noted by commenters above,
where an applicant has precedent agreements for
long-term firm service, the Commission deems the
precedent agreements to be the better evidence of
demand. The Commission evaluates individual
projects based on the evidence of need presented in
each proceeding. Under section 7(c) of the NGA, the
Commission shall issue a certificate for any proposal
found to be required by the public convenience and
necessity. 38 Where, as here, it is demonstrated that
specific shippers have entered into precedent
agreements for project service, the Commission places
substantial reliance on those agreements to find that
the project is needed.
30. Commenters also overlook the fact that shippers
on PennEast’s system have noted several reasons
other than load growth for entering into precedent
agreements with PennEast to source gas from the
Marcellus Shale region. 39 Project shippers state they
believe that the project will provide a reliable, flexible,
and diverse supply of natural gas that will lead to
increased price stability, and the opportunity to
expand natural gas service in the future. 40 Based on
38 15 U.S.C. § 717(f) (2012).
39 See Exhibit F-1 of PennEast’s application, Resource Report 1 -
General Project Description, section 1.1 - Purpose and Need.
40 See Motion to Intervene and Comments in Support of New
Jersey Natural Gas Co. (filed October 28, 2015); Pivotal Utility
Holdings, Inc., d/b/a Elizabethtown Gas (filed October 28, 2015);
Consolidated Edison Company of New York, Inc. (filed October
29, 2015); Texas Eastern Transmission, LP (filed October 29,
JA 53
the record before us, we find no reason to second guess
the business decisions of these shippers that they need
the service to which they have subscribed.
31. With respect to the ability of alternatives to meet
the project’s need, our environmental review
considered the potential for renewable energy and
energy conservation, and the availability of capacity
on existing or proposed natural gas systems, to serve
as alternatives to the project and concluded that they
do not presently serve as practical alternatives to the
project. 41 Specifically, the final EIS stated that
renewable energy and energy efficiency measures to
reduce the dependence on natural gas is not a
comparable replacement for the transportation of
natural gas to be provided by the project. 42 Moreover,
the final EIS found that there is not sufficient
available capacity on existing pipeline systems to
transport all of the volumes contemplated to be
transported by the PennEast Project to the range of
delivery points proposed by PennEast, and that
expansion of existing pipeline systems was not a
feasible alternative. 43 The EIS also found that the
proposed Atlantic Sunrise Project could not serve as a
practical system alternative because there is customer
demand for both projects (noting that approximately
100 percent of capacity of the Atlantic Sunrise Project,
and 90 percent of the capacity of the PennEast Project
2015); PSEG Energy Resources & Trade LLC (filed October 29,
2015); and South Jersey Gas (filed October 29, 2015).
41 Final EIS at 3-1 - 3-8.
42 Id. at 3-3.
43 Id. at ES-16; 3-4 - 3-7.
JA 54
has been contracted for), as well as the fact that the
Atlantic Sunrise Project would not provide for the
same delivery points for customers that have been
identified for the PennEast Project. 44
32. We also find that NJRC’s assertion that the
PennEast Project is not needed based on the fact that
pipeline utilization on long-haul pipelines from the
Gulf Coast to markets in the Northeast has declined
in recent years is unavailing. Pipeline utilization rates
reflect actual gas flows over the facilities but do not
indicate whether there is available firm capacity on
the pipelines. As indicated above, the EIS found that
there was insufficient firm capacity available on
existing pipeline systems to provide the service
proposed by PennEast.
33. Moreover, the fact that 6 of the 12 shippers on the
PennEast Project are affiliated with the project’s
sponsors does not require the Commission to look
behind the precedent agreements to evaluate project
need. 45 There is no evidence in the record of any
44 Id. at 3-7 - 3-8. The Atlantic Sunrise Project was authorized by
Commission order issued February 3, 2017 (see Transcontinental
Gas Pipe Line Company, LLC, 158 FERC ¶ 61,125 (2017)) and is
currently under construction.
45 Millennium Pipeline Co., L.P., 100
FERC ¶ 61,277, at P 57
(2002) (“as long as the precedent agreements are long-term and
binding, we do not distinguish between pipelines’ precedent
agreements with affiliates or independent marketers in
establishing the market need for a proposed project”); Eastern
Shore Natural Gas Co., 132 FERC ¶ 61,204, at P 31 (2010) (“the
Commission gives equal weight to contacts with affiliates and
non-affiliates.” See also Certificate Policy Statement, 88 FERC at
61,748 (explaining that the Commission’s policy is less focused on
whether the contracts are with affiliated or unaffiliated shippers
and more focused on whether existing ratepayers would subsidize
JA 55
impropriety or abuse in connection with any of the
affiliate agreements. The mere fact that six of the
shippers are affiliates of PennEast does not call into
question their need for the new capacity or otherwise
diminish the showing of market support. Indeed, three
of the six affiliates, subscribing to 38 percent of the
total project design capacity, are LDCs with service
obligations toward their retail customers. The
Commission has found it reasonable for LDCs seek
additional sources of supply, and has emphasized its
disinclination to second-guess reasoned business
decisions by pipelines’ customers evidenced by
precedent agreements, as well as binding contracts. 46
Further, when considering applications for new
certificates, the Commission’s primary concern
regarding affiliates of the pipeline as shippers is
whether there may have been undue discrimination
against a non-affiliate shipper. 47 Here, no such
allegations have been made, nor have we found that
the project sponsors have engaged in any
the project); see also id. at 61,744 (the Commission does not look
behind precedent agreements to question the individual shippers’
business decisions to enter into contracts) (citing
Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Corp., 82 FERC ¶ 61,084, at
61,316 (1998)).
See Millennium Pipeline Co., L.P., 100 FERC ¶ 61,277, at P
201 (2002). See also, Midwestern Gas Transmission Co., 116
FERC ¶ 61,182, at P 42 (2006); Southern Natural Gas Co., 76
FERC ¶ 61,122, at 61,635 (1996), order issuing certificate and
denying reh’g, 79 FERC ¶ 61,280 (1997), order amending
certificate and denying stay and reh’g, 85 FERC ¶ 61,134 (1998),
aff’d Midcoast Interstate Transmission, Inc. v. FERC, 198 F.3d
960 (D.C. Cir. 2000).
47 See 18 C.F.R. § 284.7(b) (2017) (requiring transportation
service to be provided on a non-discriminatory basis).
46
JA 56
anticompetitive behavior. As discussed above,
PennEast held an open season for capacity on the
project and all potential shippers had the opportunity
to contract for service. Moreover, PennEast’s tariff, as
discussed below, ensures that any future shipper will
not be unduly discriminated against.
34. We also do not find merit in the commenters’
assertion that the proposed project will be subsidized
by the affiliated LDC shippers’ captive customers.
First, to the extent a ratepayer receives a beneficial
service, paying for that service does not constitute a
“subsidy.” 48 Further, state regulatory commissions are
responsible for approving any expenditures by stateregulated utilities. Moreover, PennEast is required to
calculate its recourse rates based on the design
capacity of the pipeline, thereby placing PennEast at
risk for costs associated with any unsubscribed
capacity.
35. Finally, allegations that the project is not needed
because gas that is transported by it may be exported
through an LNG terminal are not persuasive. There is
no evidence in the record that indicates that the
expansion capacity will be used to transport natural
gas for export. A number of the project shippers are
LDCs, which will locally distribute gas or use it to
generate electricity. Further, even if there was
evidence that some of the gas would be exported, the
Commission does not have jurisdiction over the
exportation or importation of natural gas. Such
jurisdiction resides with the Secretary of Energy, who
48 See Certificate Policy Statement, 88 FERC ¶61,227 at 61,746.
JA 57
must act on any applications for natural gas export or
import authority. 49
36. In conclusion, we find that the PennEast Project
will provide reliable natural gas service to end use
customers and the market. Precedent agreements
signed by customers for approximately 90 percent of
the project’s capacity adequately demonstrate that the
project is needed.
49 Section 3(a) of the NGA provides, in part, that “no person shall
export any natural gas from the United States to a foreign
country or import any natural gas from a foreign country without
first having secured an order of the Commission authorizing it to
do so.” 15 U.S.C. § 717b(a) (2012). In 1977, the Department of
Energy Organization Act transferred the regulatory functions of
section 3 of the NGA to the Secretary of Energy. 42 U.S.C.
§ 7151(b) (2012). Subsequently, the Secretary of Energy
delegated to the Commission authority to “[a]pprove or
disapprove the construction and operation of particular facilities,
the site at which such facilities shall be located, and with respect
to natural gas that involves the construction of new domestic
facilities, the place of entry for imports or exit for exports.” DOE
Delegation Order No. 00-004.00A (effective May 16, 2006). The
proposed facilities are not located at a potential site of exit for
natural gas exports. Moreover, the Secretary of Energy has not
delegated to the Commission any authority to approve or
disapprove the import or export of the commodity itself, or to
consider whether the exportation or importation of natural gas is
consistent with the public interest. See Corpus Christi
Liquefaction, LLC, 149 FERC ¶ 61,283, at P 20 (2014) (Corpus
Christi). See also National Steel Corp., 45 FERC ¶ 61,100, at
61,332-61,333 (1988) (observing that DOE, “pursuant to its
exclusive jurisdiction, has approved the importation with respect
to every aspect of it except the point of importation” and that the
“Commission’s authority in this matter is limited to consideration
of the place of importation, which necessarily includes the
technical and environmental aspects of any related facilities”).
JA 58
3.
Existing
Pipelines
Customers
and
their
37. PennEast’s project is not intended to replace
service on other pipelines, and no pipelines or their
customers have filed adverse comments regarding
PennEast’s proposal. Thus, we find that PennEast’s
project will not adversely affect other pipelines or their
captive customers.
4.
Landowners and Communities
38. Regarding the project’s impacts on landowners
and communities, the project would impact
approximately 1,588 acres of land during construction,
and approximately 788.3 acres of land during
operation. Approximately 44.5 miles, or 37 percent of
the 120.2 mile-long pipeline route, will be located
alongside existing rights-of-way.
39. While we are mindful that PennEast has been
unable to reach easement agreements with a number
of landowners, for purposes of our consideration under
the Certificate Policy Statement, we find that
PennEast has generally taken sufficient steps to
minimize adverse impacts on landowners and
surrounding
communities.
The
Commission
encourages pipeline companies to engage with project
stakeholders throughout the life of the project, and
provide all stakeholders and potential impacted
residents with informational materials, and hold
community meeting to enable stakeholders to learn
about the project, and educate project developers
about local concerns. 50 PennEast participated in the
50 Commission, Suggested Best Practices for Industry Outreach
Programs to Stakeholders at 11-17 (2015).
JA 59
pre-filing process, and held over 200 meetings with
public officials, as well as 15 “informational sessions”
for impacted landowners. 51 PennEast incorporated 70
of 101 identified route variations into its final
proposed pipeline route for various reasons, including
landowner requests, community impacts, and the
avoidance of sensitive resources. 52 Accordingly, we
find that PennEast’s proposal has taken appropriate
steps to minimize impacts on landowners and the
surrounding communities.
5.
Conclusion
40. Based on the benefits the project will provide to
the shippers, the lack of adverse effects on existing
customers, other pipelines and their captive
customers, and effects on landowners and
surrounding communities, we find, consistent with the
Certificate Policy Statement and section 7 of the NGA,
that the public convenience and necessity requires
approval of PennEast’s proposal, subject to the
conditions discussed below.
B. Eminent Domain Authority
41. Several
commenters
assert
that
it
is
inappropriate for PennEast to obtain property for the
project through eminent domain, as PennEast is a forprofit company, and has not shown that there is a
genuine need for the project, or that the public it is
intended to serve will benefit from it. 53
51 PennEast Application at 5.
52 Final EIS at 3-27 - 3-32.
53 See, e.g., Homeowners Against Land Taking-PennEast.
JA 60
42. Under section 7 of the NGA, the Commission has
jurisdiction to determine if the construction and
operation of proposed interstate pipeline facilities are
in the public convenience and necessity. Once the
Commission makes that determination, it is section
7(h) of the NGA that authorizes a certificate holder to
acquire the necessary land or property to construct the
approved facilities by exercising the right of eminent
domain if it cannot acquire the easement by an
agreement with the landowner. 54 In constructing this
provision, Congress made no distinction between forprofit and non-profit companies. Further, as discussed
above, need for the project has been demonstrated by
the existence of long-term precedent agreements for
approximately 90 percent of the project’s capacity.
Just as the precedent agreements provide evidence of
market demand/need, they are also evidence of the
public benefits of the project. 55
C. Blanket Certificates
43. PennEast requests a Part 284, Subpart G blanket
transportation certificate to provide open-access
transportation services to its shippers. Since a Part
284 blanket certificate is required for PennEast to
offer these services, we will grant PennEast a Part
284, Subpart G blanket certificate, subject to the
conditions imposed herein.
54 15 U.S.C. § 717f(h) (2012).
55 See Sierra Club v. FERC, 867 F.3d 1357, 1379 (D.C. Cir. 2017);
see also Florida Southeast Connection, LLC, 156 FERC ¶ 61,160,
at P 5 (2016); see also Minisink Residents for Environmental
Preservation and Safety v. FERC, 762 F.3d 97, 111, at n.10 (D.C.
Cir. 2014).
JA 61
44. PennEast has also applied for a Part 157, Subpart
F blanket construction certificate to automatically, or
after prior notice, perform certain activities related to
the construction, acquisition, abandonment, and
replacement and operation of pipeline facilities. This
blanket certificate includes requirements for
landowner notification before construction may begin.
45. The Trustees of the Joseph D. Ceader Family
Memorial Fund (Ceader Family) express concern over
issuing PennEast a Part 157, Subpart F blanket
certificate, alleging that doing so would grant
PennEast “carte blanche” (emphasis included)
authority to condemn land via eminent domain, and
construct significant facilities that could have
negative impacts on the environment and their
property value, without “extensive environmental
review” or findings of need. In addition, Hopewell
Township Citizens Against the PennEast Pipeline,
LLC, (Hopewell Township) oppose the issuance of a
blanket certificate to PennEast as it would be a “‘one
size fits all solution’” that is inappropriate for such a
project.
46. Neither the Ceader Family nor Hopewell
Township) present any arguments why PennEast’s
specific request for a blanket certificate should be
denied; rather they seem to take general issue with
the Commission’s blanket certificate program. Part
157, Subpart F of the Commission’s regulations
authorizes a certificate holder to engage in a limited
number of routine activities under a blanket
certificate, subject to certain reporting, notice, and
JA 62
protest requirements. 56 The blanket certificate
procedures are intended to increase flexibility and
reduce regulatory and administrative burdens.
Because the eligible activities permitted under a
blanket certificate regulations can satisfy our
environmental requirements and meet the blanket
certificate cost limits, they will have minimal impacts,
such that the close scrutiny involved in considering
applications for case-specific certificate authorization
is not necessary to ensure compatibility with the
public convenience and necessity. For almost all
eligible activities, a certificate holder seeking to
engage in such activities must notify landowners prior
to commencing the activity. 57 For activities that
require prior notice, an opportunity to protest is
afforded once notice of the certificate holder’s request
is issued to the public. 58 If a protest cannot be
resolved, then the certificate holder may not perform
the requested activity under a blanket certificate. 59
47. Receipt of a Part 157 blanket certificate does
confer the right of eminent domain authority under
section 7(h) of the NGA. 60 However, Commission
regulations require companies to include information
56 See 18 C.F.R. § 157.203 (2017).
57 See id. § 157.203(d).
58 See id. § 157.205.
59 See id. § 157.205(f).
15 U.S.C. § 717f(h) (2012); also Columbia Gas
Transmission, LLC v. 1.01 Acres, 768 F.3d 300, 314 (3rd Cir.
2014) (finding that the plain meaning of the Commission’s Part
157 blanket certificate regulations grants the holder of a blanket
certificate the right of eminent domain to obtain easements from
landowners.).
60 See
JA 63
on relevant eminent domain rules in notices to
potentially affected landowners. 61 The compensation
landowners receive for property rights is a matter of
negotiation between the pipeline company and
landowner, or is determined by a court in an eminent
domain proceeding. In view of the above-noted blanket
program procedures and protections, we expect the
Ceader Family and Hopewell Township will have the
opportunity to raise specific concerns and seek specific
relief regarding PennEast’s reliance on blanket
authority in undertaking a future activity.
48. Because PennEast will become an interstate
pipeline with the issuance of a certificate to construct
and operate the proposed facilities, we will issue
PennEast the requested blanket certificate authority
under Parts 157 and 284 of the Commission’s
regulations.
D. Rates
1.
Initial Rates
49. PennEast proposes an initial maximum
reservation recourse charge of $16.0799 per Dth per
month, and an initial usage charge of $0.0024 per Dth
for firm transportation service under Rate Schedule
FTS. 62 PennEast developed its proposed initial rates
based on a total first-year cost of service of
$224,270,492. The proposed cost-based rates reflect a
Straight-Fixed Variable rate methodology. The FTS
reservation rate is designed using the fixed costs of the
61 18 C.F.R. § 157.203(d)(2)(v) (2017).
62 Exhibit P, Schedule 2, of PennEast’s Application.
JA 64
project 63 and annual reservation design determinants
of 13,905,896 Dth. 64 The FTS usage rate is derived
using the variable costs of the project and billing
determinants of 282,838,500 Dth, based on a 70
percent load factor of the project’s annual design
throughput. 65
50. The proposed cost of service is based on a
depreciation rate of 2.5 percent for pipeline facilities
and 4 percent for compression and metering
facilities. 66 PennEast proposes a capital structure of
40 percent debt and 60 percent equity. PennEast’s
proposed rates include a return on equity of 14 percent
and a cost of debt of 6 percent. PennEast states that
the overall rate of return of 10.8 percent is consistent
with the range the Commission has found acceptable
for new greenfield pipelines. 67 PennEast’s proposed
cost of service also includes a federal corporate income
tax rate of 35 percent. 68
51. PennEast proposes an initial charge of $0.5310
per Dth for interruptible service under Rate Schedule
IT and for interruptible parking and lending service
63 Id. PennEast estimates the first year fixed costs of the project
to be $223,604,821.
64 Id. The annual reservation design determinants are based on
the project’s daily design capacity of 1,107,000 Dth plus 51,825
Dth of imputed IT billing determinants, as described further,
times 12.
65 The project’s daily design capacity of 1,107,000 Dth, times 365,
times 70 percent.
66 Exhibits L, O and P of PennEast’s Application.
67 PennEast’s Application at 32.
68 Id.
JA 65
under Rate Schedule PAL, based on a 100 percent load
factor equivalent of its Rate Schedule FTS rates. 69
52. Commission policy requires new pipelines to
allocate costs to all services (including interruptible
and short-term firm transportation) or credit revenues
generated by these services to maximum rate
shippers. 70 To comply with this policy, PennEast
proposes to assign $10 million of costs to interruptible
services, reflected as 51,825 Dth/d of imputed billing
determinants for interruptible service. PennEast
included the additional imputed billing determinants
for interruptible service in the calculation of the FT
reservation charge, which results in a lower FT
reservation charge for firm shippers.
53. The Commission has reviewed PennEast’s
proposed initial rates, cost of service, use of the
Straight Fixed-Variable method of cost classification,
billing determinants, and the treatment of
interruptible services and interruptible rate
calculations, and finds they reasonably reflect current
Commission policy, with the modifications and
conditions imposed below.
Return on Equity, Capital Structure, Debt Costs,
and Federal Corporate Tax Issues
54. In comments on the draft environmental impact
statement, the NJRC argues that PennEast’s
requested 60 percent equity capitalization, 14 percent
69 Exhibit P, Schedule 2, of PennEast’s Application.
70 Transcontinental Gas Pipe Line Corp., 78 FERC ¶ 61,057, at
61,209-61,210 (1997).
JA 66
return on equity, and 6 percent debt costs are
excessive.
Return on Equity and Capital Structure
55. NJRC asserts that a 14 percent return on equity
is too high because PennEast faces little risk as a new
market entrant constructing a new greenfield
pipeline. In support, NJRC notes that PennEast’s
system capacity is 90 percent subscribed, and that the
majority of that capacity is subscribed by local
distribution companies that are “all but guaranteed to
pay their bills.” 71 In addition, NJRC claims that
markets have changed significantly since the
Commission began granting 14 percent returns nearly
20 years ago due to the increase in hydraulic
fracturing and liquefied natural gas exports, and that
current capital markets lack the risk to necessitate
such high equity returns. 72
56. NJRC also asserts that returns on equity have
been trending down over the last few years as reflected
in both pipeline rate cases and a number of Federal
Power Act complaints regarding electric utilities, and
points out that average approved rates of return over
the last 5 years for LDCs has been less than 10
percent. 73 NJRC further points to a recent
Commission order in which it claims the Commission
“ordered a new pipeline” to use a 10.55 percent return
71 NJRC Comments at 11.
72 Id. at 11-12 (citing Alliance Pipeline L.P., 80 FERC ¶ 61,149,
at 61,552 (1997)).
73 Id. at 9-13.
JA 67
on equity, 74 and asserts that the Commission should
not “reflexively” award PennEast a 14 percent return
on equity “simply because earlier pipelines have
received that return on equity.” 75
57. Alternatively, if the Commission approves a 14
percent return on equity, NJRC contends that recent
Commission orders require the Commission to limit
PennEast’s capital structure to no more than 50
percent equity. 76
Commission Determination
58. For new pipelines, the Commission has approved
equity returns of up to 14 percent as long as the equity
component of the capitalization is no more than 50
percent. 77 As pointed out by NJRC, PennEast has
74 Id. at 13 (citing First ECA Midstream LLC, 155 FERC ¶ 61,222,
at P 23 (2016) (First ECA Midstream)).
75 Id.
Id. at 14 (citing Ingleside Energy Center, LLC, 112 FERC
¶ 61,101, at PP 32-33 (2005), vacated on other grounds, 136
FERC ¶ 61,114 (2011) (reducing a proposed 70% equity structure
to 50%).
76
See, e.g., Florida Southeast Connection, LLC, 154 FERC
¶ 61,080 (2016) (approving a 14 percent return on equity after
requiring the capital structure be modified to include at least 50
percent debt), MarkWest Pioneer, L.L.C., 125 FERC ¶ 61,165, at
P 27 (2008) (approving 14 percent return on equity based on 50
percent debt and 50 percent equity ratios); Corpus Christi LNG,
L.P., 111 FERC ¶ 61,081, at P 33 (2005) approving a 14 percent
return on equity based on 50 percent debt and 50 percent equity
ratios); Gulfstream Natural Gas System, L.L.C., 105 FERC
¶ 61,052, at n.26 (2003) and 91 FERC ¶ 61,119, at 61,463 (2000)
(approving 14 percent return on equity based on 70 percent debt
and 30 percent equity ratios); Georgia Strait Crossing Pipeline
LP, 98 FERC ¶ 61,271, at 62,054 (2002) (approving 14 percent
77
JA 68
proposed to establish its rates based only on a 40
percent debt capitalization. With such a debt ratio,
everything else being equal, PennEast will not face the
same level of financial risks as any of the new
pipelines that have been previously granted a 14
percent return on equity. Imputing a capitalization
containing a 60 percent equity ratio is more costly to
ratepayers, since equity financing is typically more
costly than debt financing, and also because the
interest on indebtedness is tax deductible. 78
Accordingly, the Commission will approve PennEast’s
proposed 14 percent return on equity, but will require
that it design its cost-based rates on a capital
structure that includes at least 50 percent debt. As a
result of the change to the capital structure required
here, we will require PennEast to recalculate its rates
in its compliance filing.
59. However, we reject NJRC’s request that we
reduce the proposed return of 14 percent, in addition
to requiring a lower equity capitalization. In
modifying PennEast’s proposed capital structure, we
are ensuring that consumers are protected and that
PennEast’s rates are on a level playing field with other
new pipelines. The Commission’s policy of approving
equity returns of up to 14 percent with an equity
capitalization of no more than 50 percent for new
pipeline companies reflects the fact that greenfield
pipelines undertaken by a new entrant in the market
face higher business risks than existing pipelines
proposing incremental expansion projects. For
return on equity based on 70 percent debt and 30 percent equity
ratios).
78 MarkWest Pioneer, L.L.C., 125 FERC ¶ 61,165, at P 27 (2008).
JA 69
example, in contrast to an existing pipeline company,
a new pipeline entrant does not have historical cost
data on which to base its cost-of-service estimates. In
addition, a new pipeline entrant is likely to face higher
risks in securing financing than an existing pipeline. 79
Thus, approving PennEast’s requested 14 percent
return on equity in this instance is not merely
“reflexive;” it is in response to the risk PennEast faces
as a new market entrant, constructing a new
greenfield pipeline system.
60. NJRC’s reliance on the Commission’s decision in
First ECA Midstream is misplaced. That proceeding
did not involve a greenfield project undertaken by a
new entrant in the market. Rather, the applicant was
an existing company proposing to operate its existing
non-jurisdictional gathering system as an interstate
pipeline. In approving a 10.55 percent return on
equity, the Commission specifically found that the
applicant had “more in common with existing
pipelines than with the greenfield pipeline projects
that have received returns of 14 percent.” 80
61. In addition, we find no support for NJRC’s
assertion that PennEast faces less risk than other new
pipelines that have received returns of 14 percent due
to its 90 percent subscription level. We have
consistently approved equity returns of 14 percent for
See, e.g., Rate Regulation of Certain Natural Gas Storage
Facilities, Order No. 678, 115 FERC ¶ 61,343, at P 127 (2006)
(“As a going concern with existing customers and financial
relationships, the risk associated with acquiring financing is
lower for incremental expansions than the risk associated with a
greenfield project undertaken by a new entrant in the market.”).
79
80 First ECA Midstream at P 23.
JA 70
new pipelines that have firm contracts subscriptions
equivalent or higher than PennEast’s 90 percent
subscription level. 81 Moreover, the returns approved
for electric utilities and LDCs are not relevant because
there is no showing that these companies face the
same level of risk as faced by greenfield projects
proposed by a new natural gas pipeline company. 82
62. Further, as explained below, we are requiring
PennEast to file a cost and revenue study at the end
of its first three years of actual operation to justify its
existing cost-based rates. The three-year study will
provide an opportunity for the Commission and the
public to review PennEast’s original estimates, upon
which its initial rates are based, to determine whether
PennEast is over-recovering its cost of service with its
approved initial rates, and whether the Commission
should exercise its authority under section 5 of the
NGA to establish just and reasonable rates.
Alternatively, PennEast may elect to make a NGA
section 4 filing to revise its initial rates. Should
PennEast elect to make such a filing, the public would
have an opportunity to review PennEast’s proposed
return on equity and other cost of service components
See, e.g. Florida Southeast Connection, LLC. 154 FERC
¶ 61,080 (2016). (approving a 14 percent return on equity where
project was 94 percent subscribed); Sierrita Gas Pipeline, LLC,
147 FERC ¶ 61,192 (2014), clarified 149 FERC ¶ 61,101 (2014)
(approving a 14 percent return on equity where project was fully
subscribed).
81
The Commission has previously concluded that distribution
companies are less risky than a pipeline company. See, e.g.
Trailblazer Pipeline Co., 106 FERC ¶ 63,005, at P 94 (2004)
(rejecting inclusion of LDCs in a proxy group because they face
less risk than a pipeline company.).
82
JA 71
at that time and would have an opportunity to raise
issues relating to the rate of return, as well as all other
cost components.
63. In section 7 certificate proceedings, the
Commission reviews initial rates for service using
proposed new pipeline capacity under the public
convenience and necessity standard, which is a less
rigorous standard than the just and reasonable
standard under NGA sections 4 and 5. 83 As
83 Atlantic Refining Co. v. Public Serv. Comm’n of New York, 360
U.S. 378, 390-391 (1959) (Atlantic Refining). In Atlantic Refining,
the Court contrasted the Commission’s authority under sections
4 and 5 of the NGA to approve changes to existing rates using
existing facilities and its authority under section 7 to approve
initial rates for new services and services using new facilities.
The court recognized “the inordinate delay” can be associated
with a full-evidentiary rate proceeding and concluded that was
the reason why, unlike sections 4 and 5, section 7 does not require
the Commission to make a determination that an applicant’s
proposed initial rates are or will be just and reasonable before the
Commission certificates new facilities, expansion capacity,
and/or services. Id. at 390. The Court stressed that in deciding
under section 7(c) whether proposed new facilities or services are
required by the public convenience and necessity, the
Commission is required to “evaluate all factors bearing on the
public interest,” and an applicant’s proposed initial rates are not
“the only factor bearing on the public convenience and necessity.”
Id. at 391. Thus, as explained by the Court, “[t]he Congress, in
§7(e), has authorized the Commission to condition certificates in
such manner as the public convenience and necessity may
require when the Commission exercises authority under section
7,” id., and the Commission therefore has the discretion in section
7 certificate proceedings to approve initial rates that will “hold
the line” and “ensure that the consuming public may be
protected” while awaiting adjudication of just and reasonable
rates under the more time-consuming ratemaking sections of the
NGA. Id. at 392.
JA 72
conditioned herein, we find that the approved initial
rates will “hold the line” and “ensure that the
consuming public may be protected,” until just and
reasonable rates can determined through the more
thorough and time-consuming ratemaking sections of
the NGA. 84
Debt Costs
64. NJRC argues that PennEast has not supported its
request for a 6 percent cost of debt. Referencing a
Moody’s report for Long-term Bond Yields in 2016,
NJRC states that long-term utility bond rates have
declined from January 2016 to July. 85 Thus, NJRC
asserts that the Commission should impute a debt cost
consistent with “actual debt market rates” and
consistent with the Commission’s approval of a debt
cost of 3 percent. 86
65. We find that PennEast’s proposed 6 percent cost
of debt is consistent with the cost of debt the
Commission has approved for recent greenfield
pipeline projects. The Commission has approved cost
of debt percentages ranging from 4.8 to 9.3. 87
Moreover, as explained above, the initial rates
established in First ECA Midstream, including
84 Id. at 392.
85 NJRC Comments at 15.
86 First ECA Midstream LLC, 115 FERC ¶ 61,222 at PP 22-23.
87 UGI Sunbury, LLC, 155 FERC ¶ 61,115, at 20 (2016) (7 percent
cost of debt); Florida Southeast Connection, LLC, 154 FERC
¶ 61,080 at n.141 (7 percent cost of debt); Ruby Pipeline, L.L.C.,
128 FERC ¶ 61,224, at P 43 (2009) (9.3 percent cost of debt);
Sierrita Gas Pipeline, LLC, 147 FERC ¶ 61,192, at P 40 (2014)
(4.8 percent cost of debt).
JA 73
approval of the applicant’s proposed 3 percent cost of
debt, are inapplicable to this proceeding. Therefore,
we will approve PennEast’s proposal to utilize a 6
percent cost of debt.
Federal Corporate Tax Issues
66. As noted above, PennEast used a federal
corporate income tax rate of 35 percent in calculating
its proposed cost of service. However, effective
January 2018, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017
changed several provisions of the federal tax code,
including a reduction in the federal corporate income
tax rate to 21 percent and allowing certain
investments to receive bonus depreciation treatment.
Because these changes impact PennEast’s proposed
cost of service and the resulting initial recourse rates,
we direct PennEast to recalculate its initial recourse
rates consistent with the new 2018 federal corporate
tax law when it files actual tariff records. In order to
ensure compliance with this directive, we also require
PennEast to provide supporting work papers in
electronic spreadsheet format, including formulas.
2.
Negotiated Rates
67. PennEast states that it will provide service to the
project’s shippers under negotiated rate agreements
pursuant to its negotiated rate authority in section 24
of its pro forma General Terms and Conditions
(GT&C). PennEast must file either its negotiated rate
agreements or tariff records setting forth the essential
terms of the agreements in accordance with the
Alternative Rate Policy Statement 88 and the
88 Alternatives to Traditional Cost-of-Service Ratemaking for
Natural Gas Pipelines; Regulation of Negotiated Transportation
JA 74
Commission’s negotiated rate policies. 89 PennEast
must file the negotiated rate agreements or tariff
records at least 30 days, but not more than 60 days,
before the proposed effective date for such rates. 90
3.
Fuel
68. PennEast states it will use an in-kind fuel
tracking mechanism to recover fuel and lost and
unaccounted for gas (L&U) through a fuel retainage
percentage (FRP). PennEast has proposed an initial
FRP of 0.81 percent, calculated using engineering
principles and manufacturer’s specifications for the
proposed compressor engines, and an L&U percentage
of 0.00 percent. We will approve PennEast’s proposed
initial FRP rate of 0.81 percent, and its proposed
initial L&U rate of 0.00 percent.
69. In addition, PennEast proposes a fuel tracker as
part of its pro forma tariff. Section 20.3(a) of the GT&C
of PennEast’s pro forma tariff states:
With each filing hereunder for a specified
calendar period Pipeline shall calculate a
FRP as the quotient obtained by dividing (a)
Services of Natural Gas Pipelines, 74 FERC ¶ 61,076 (1996);
clarification granted, 74 FERC ¶ 61,194 (1996), order on reh’g, 75
FERC ¶ 61,024 (1996).
89 Natural Gas Pipelines Negotiated Rate Policies and Practices;
Modification of Negotiated Rate Policy, 104 FERC ¶ 61,134
(2003), order on reh’g and clarification, 114 FERC ¶ 61,042
(2006), reh’g dismissed and clarification denied, 114 FERC
¶ 61,304 (2006).
90 Pipelines are required to file any service agreement containing
non-conforming provisions and to disclose and identify any
transportation term or agreement in a precedent agreement that
survives the execution of the service agreement.
JA 75
the projected annual quantities of Fuel for the
upcoming calendar period, plus the amount of
any under-collection of Gas in-kind pursuant
to the prior period FRP or less the amount of
any over-collection of Gas in-kind pursuant to
the prior period FRP and (b) the projected
annual throughput for the upcoming calendar
period.
70. Section 154.403(c)(10) of the Commission’s
regulations 91 states that “[a] step-by step explanation
of the methodology used to reflect changes in the fuel
reimbursement percentage including the allocation
and classification of the fuel use and unaccounted-for
natural gas” must be included in the GT&C. PennEast
is directed to revise section 20 of the GT&C to include
an explanation of how the projected annual quantities
of fuel and projected annual throughput are
determined.
71. In addition, PennEast’s proposed language in
section 20.3(b) of the GT&C explains that it will
estimate the L&U quantities, but does not explain the
methodology PennEast will use to calculate those
estimates. Therefore, when PennEast files actual
tariff records in accordance with the ordering
paragraphs herein, it is directed to revise section 20 of
the GT&C to include an explanation of how PennEast
will calculate the estimates for the L&U quantities
required for the upcoming calendar period.
4.
Three-Year Filing Requirement
72. Consistent
with
Commission
precedent,
PennEast is required to file a cost and revenue study
91 18 C.F.R. § 154.403(c)(10) (2017).
JA 76
no later than three months after the end of its first
three years of actual operation to justify its existing
cost-based firm and interruptible recourse rates. 92 In
its filing, the projected units of service should be no
lower than those upon which PennEast’s approved
initial rates are based. The filing must include a cost
and revenue study in the form specified in section
154.313 of the Commission’s regulations to update
cost of service data. 93 PennEast’s cost and revenue
study should be filed through the eTariff portal using
a Type of Filing Code 580. In addition, PennEast is
advised to include as part of the eFiling description, a
reference to Docket No. CP15-558-000 and the cost
and revenue study. 94 After reviewing the data, the
Commission will determine whether to exercise its
authority under NGA section 5 to investigate whether
the rates remain just and reasonable. In the
alternative, in lieu of this filing, PennEast may make
a NGA general section 4 rate filing to propose
alternative rates to be effective no later than three
years after the in-service date for its proposed
facilities.
5.
Tariff
73. As part of its application, PennEast filed a pro
forma open-access tariff for the Commission’s
approval. PennEast proposed tariff generally
92 Bison Pipeline, LLC, 131 FERC ¶ 61,013, at P 29 (2010); Ruby
Pipeline, LLC, 128 FERC ¶ 61,224, at P 57 (2009) (Bison);
MarkWest Pioneer, L.L.C., 125 FERC ¶ 61,165, at P 34 (2008).
93 18 C.F.R. § 154.313 (2017).
94 Electronic Tariff Filings, 130 FERC ¶ 61,047, at P 17 (2010).
JA 77
conforms to the Commission’s requirements. We will
approve the tariff, as conditioned below.
Rate Schedule ITS
74. Section 2.5 of Rate Schedule ITS provides that the
pipeline shall not be required to provide
transportation service if the quantities tendered are so
small as to cause operational difficulties, such as with
measurement. Under sections 284.7(b) and 284.9(b) of
the Commission’s regulations, a transporter may not
discriminate as to the level of volumes transported. 95
In previous determinations, however, the Commission
has allowed a pipeline to include a minimum volume
restriction in its tariff when the pipeline was able to
show that the transportation of quantities below the
threshold were too small to be metered, and where the
company has provided operational and cost
justification for the restriction. 96 For example, the
Commission accepted a proposal for a 100 Dth/d
threshold for connections of new receipt and delivery
points, where the applicant demonstrated that serving
Section 284.7(b)(1) provides “[a]n interstate pipeline or
intrastate pipeline that offers transportation service on a firm
basis under Subpart B, C, or G must provide such service without
undue discrimination, or preference, including undue
discrimination or preference in the quality of service provided,
the duration of service, the categories, prices, or volumes of
natural gas to be transported, customer classification, or undue
discrimination or preference of any kind.” (emphasis added).
Section 284.9(b) applies these provisions regarding nondiscriminatory access to interruptible service.
95
96 See, e.g., Gulf South Pipeline Co., LP, 103 FERC ¶ 61,105, at P
13, n.7 (2003) (Gulf South); Trailblazer Pipeline Co., 39 FERC
¶ 61,103, at 61,336 (1987); Texas Eastern Transmission Corp., 37
FERC ¶ 61,260, at 61,680-61,681 (1986).
JA 78
small volume points presented operational challenges
because these receipt points were difficult to measure,
increasing the potential for lost system gas, and that
the cost of operating these delivery points was greater
than the maximum rate for service. In addition, the
applicant demonstrated that the costs associated with
operating small points would be greater than the
maximum rate would cover. 97
75. Here, PennEast has neither provided justification
nor has it provided a proposed threshold for minimum
volumes to be transported. Therefore, the Commission
requires PennEast to eliminate the proposed
minimum volume condition or, in the alternative,
state what that minimum volume is and provide the
justification to support it.
Rate Schedule PAL
76. Section 8.6 of Rate Schedule PAL provides that
parked quantities of gas shall become the property of
PennEast when: 1) a customer fails to comply with
notifications that receipts of parked quantities are to
be suspended or reduced; 2) a customer fails to comply
with notifications that customer’s parked quantities
must be removed; or 3) a PAL account reflects a
balance at the termination date of a PAL Service
Agreement. The Commission has found that a
pipeline’s confiscation of gas is an operationally
justified deterrent to shipper behavior that could
threaten the system or degrade service to firm
shippers. However, the Commission requires that the
value of such confiscated gas be credited to existing
97 Gulf South, 103 FERC ¶ 61,105, at PP 9-13.
JA 79
customers. 98 PennEast has not proposed a crediting
mechanism in its tariff. Therefore, we direct PennEast
to revise its tariff to include a mechanism to credit the
value of any confiscated gas, net of costs, to nonoffending shippers.
GT&C Section 5: Service Nomination
Procedures
77. PennEast proposes at section 5.1(c) of the GT&C:
Pipeline shall have the right to refuse to
receive or deliver any Gas not timely and
properly nominated. Pipeline shall not be
liable to Customer or any other person as a
direct or indirect consequence of such refusal
and Customer shall indemnify Pipeline from
and against any and all losses, damages,
expenses, claims, suits, actions and
proceedings whatsoever threatened, incurred
or initiated as a result of such refusal unless
such refusal was due to Pipeline’s gross
negligence, undue discrimination or willful
misconduct.
78. The Commission has found that a simple
negligence standard is appropriate for the liability and
indemnification provisions of open-access tariffs, as
this standard prohibits pipelines from limiting their
liability in a way that would immunize them from
direct damages resulting from simple negligence and
“gives service providers a powerful incentive to
operate their systems in a reasonable and prudent
98 AES Sparrows Point LNG, LLC and Mid-Atlantic Express,
LLC, 126 FERC ¶ 61,019, at P 42 (2009), (citing Colorado
Interstate Gas Co., 122 FERC ¶ 61,256, at P 102 (2008)).
JA 80
manner.” 99 The Commission, however, has allowed
pipelines to limit their liability for simple negligence
to direct damages, so that they are only liable for
indirect, consequential, incidental or punitive
damages where there is gross negligence, willful
misconduct, or bad faith. 100
79. PennEast’s proposed liability standard is
inconsistent with Commission policy because it
immunizes the pipeline from direct damages resulting
from simple negligence. Therefore, when it submits its
actual tariff filing, the Commission will require
PennEast to revise its liability standard proposed in
section 5.1(c) of the GT&C so as to not exclude it from
liability for direct damages arising from its own simple
negligence. Similarly, PennEast must revise sections
8.6 (Curtailment), 12.5 (Quality of Gas), and 37
(Nonrecourse Obligation of Pipeline’s Members and
Operator) of the GT&C, which also immunize the
pipeline from direct damages resulting from simple
negligence.
GT&C Section 6: Service Scheduling
80. Section 6.1 of PennEast’s GT&C lists the priority
order
in
which
quantities
nominated
for
transportation will be scheduled. Section 6.1(c) states:
99 See, e.g., Trailblazer Pipeline Co. LLC, 142 FERC ¶ 61,007, at
P 8 (2012); CenterPoint Energy Gas Transmission Co., LLC, 139
FERC ¶ 61,064, at P 19 (2012); Orbit Gas Storage, Inc., 126
FERC ¶ 61,095, at P 58 (2009)).
100 See, e.g., Bison, 131 FERC ¶ 61,013, at P 37; El Paso, 130
FERC ¶ 61,096, at P 4-5; ANR Pipeline Co., 100 FERC ¶ 61,132,
at 61,505 (2002).
JA 81
Pro rata among firm service Customers
utilizing a Secondary Point or Points with at
least one of such points being outside the
Contract Path or the nominated quantity
being in excess of the firm contractual
entitlement(s) for any pipeline segment as
described in subsection (g) below. (emphasis
added) 101
The emphasized language above appears to address
authorized overrun quantities. However, section
6.1(d) of the GT&C provides that authorized overrun
quantities will have the same scheduling priority as
interruptible services (“All interruptible service
Customers, excluding park and loan service
Customers, and Customers nominating authorized
overrun quantities in sequence starting with the
Customer paying the highest rate.”). 102 Commission
policy requires that nominations for authorized
overrun and interruptible services should have the
same scheduling priority. 103 Thus, we find that the
101 Section 6.1(g) of the GT&C provides, in part, “[i]n addition, for
any movement of Gas that traverses a segment(s) in which the
total nominated quantity for that contract exceeds the firm
contractual entitlement, the quantity in excess of the contractual
entitlement shall be deemed to be outside of the Customer’s
Contract Path.”
102 Section 6 of Rate Schedule FTS also provides that authorized
daily overrun quantities will be transported on an interruptible
basis.
103 Sierrita Gas Pipeline, LLC, 147 FERC ¶ 61,192, at P 66 (2014);
Central New York Oil and Gas Co., LLC, 114 FERC ¶ 61,105, at
P 9 (2006) (citing CNG Transmission Corp., 81 FERC ¶ 61,346,
at 62,592 (1997) and Tennessee Gas Pipeline Co., 62 FERC
¶ 61,250, at 62,676 (1993)).
JA 82
emphasized language in section 6.1 (c) of the GT&C
that applies to authorized overrun quantities is
inconsistent with Commission policy, as well as other
provisions of PennEast’s tariff. We direct PennEast to
delete this provision.
GT&C Section 8: Curtailment
81. PennEast proposes at section 8.1 of the GT&C:
Pipeline shall have the right to curtail or
discontinue transportation services, in whole
or in part, on all or a portion of its system at
any time for reasons of Force Majeure or
when, in Pipeline’s sole judgment, capacity or
operating conditions so require or it is
desirable or necessary to make modifications,
repairs or operating changes to its system.
(emphasis added.)
82. The Commission has held that pipelines should
plan routine repair, maintenance, and improvements
through the scheduling process, and should not curtail
confirmed scheduling nominations in order to perform
such work. 104 The Commission has found that
pipelines may only “curtail” service in an emergency
situation or when an unexpected capacity loss occurs
after the pipeline has scheduled service, and the
pipeline is therefore unable to perform the service
which it has scheduled. 105 The term “modifications,
repairs or operating changes” is not limited to an
104 CenterPoint Energy Gas Transmission Co., LLC, 144 FERC
¶ 61,195, at P 75 (CenterPoint).
105 Id.; Ryckman Creek Resources, LLC, 136 FERC ¶ 61,061, at P
68 (2011); MarkWest Pioneer, L.L.C., 125 FERC ¶ 61,165, at P 52
(2008).
JA 83
emergency situation or an unexpected loss of capacity,
and the pipeline should take outages required for
routine repair, maintenance, and operating changes
into account when it is scheduling service, rather than
curtailing service after it is scheduled. Therefore,
PennEast is required to revise the emphasized phrase
to comply with Commission policy.
83. In sections 8.2 (a) through (e) of the GT&C,
PennEast provides the order in which it would curtail
service. Sections 8.2 (d) and (e) of the GT&C set forth
the priorities for curtailing firm service and provide:
(d) Fourth, Pipeline shall curtail scheduled
service to those Customers receiving service
under the firm rate schedule at a Secondary
Point or Points, with at least one of such
points being outside the Contract Path, if the
operating condition that necessitates the
curtailment affects a location outside of the
Customers’ Contract Path, on a pro rata basis
among affected Customers;
(e) Fifth, Pipeline shall curtail scheduled
service to those Customers receiving service
under the firm rate schedule at Primary
Points of Receipt and Primary Points of
Delivery and at a Secondary Point or Points,
which points are wholly within the Contract
Path pro rata on the basis of scheduled
quantities.
84. The Commission rejects PennEast’s proposal as it
relates to curtailing firm transportation services.
Commission policy requires that once firm service is
scheduled, all scheduled firm transactions, whether
primary or secondary, must be curtailed on a pro rata
JA 84
basis. 106 PennEast’s proposed tariff is inconsistent
with this policy because it would curtail certain types
of scheduled firm transportation before other
scheduled firm transportation. PennEast is required,
in its tariff compliance filing, to revise sections 8.2 (d)
and (e) to provide that scheduled firm volumes may
only be curtailed on a pro rata basis.
85. Section 8.4 of PennEast’s GT&C states:
All volumes received and/or taken in violation
of Pipeline’s curtailment or interruption
orders shall constitute unauthorized receipts
or deliveries of Gas for which a penalty charge
equal to the higher of $50.00 per Dth and
150% times the Platts Gas Daily “Daily Price
Survey” High Common price for “Transco,
zone 6 non- N.Y. North” per Dth shall be
assessed, in addition to any other applicable
rate, charge or penalty. (emphasis added).
86. In addition to the above penalty, PennEast’s tariff
contains a “Usage Rate outside Tolerances” 107 penalty
provision that may result in penalizing the same
infraction twice. Commission policy prohibits multiple
106 Algonquin Gas Transmission Co., 104 FERC ¶ 61,118, at P 34
(2003); Order No. 636-B, 61 FERC ¶ 61,272, at 62,013 (1992).
107 Sections 3.2.B(2) of Rate Schedule FTS and 3.2A(2) of Rate
Schedule ITS provide, in part: “The Usage Charge outside
Tolerances as set forth on the Statement of Rates for Rate
Schedule FTS or the Statement(s) of Negotiated Rates, as
applicable, multiplied by that portion of the total quantity of Gas
deliveries on any Day pursuant to the effective Service
Agreement, except for authorized overrun quantities, which is in
excess of the lesser of 110% of scheduled service levels for such
Day or 102% of MDQ.”
JA 85
penalties for the same infraction. 108 Therefore,
PennEast is directed to revise its tariff to be consistent
with Commission policy. 109
GT&C Section 26: Force Majeure
87. PennEast’s proposed definition of force majeure
events in section 26.1 of the GT&C includes
“compliance with any court order, law, regulation or
ordinance promulgated by any governmental
authority having jurisdiction, whether federal, Indian,
state or local, civil or military, the necessity for testing
(as required by governmental authority or as deemed
necessary for safe operation by the testing party).”
PennEast’s proposed tariff language conflicts with
Commission policy because it can be interpreted to
include regular, periodic maintenance activities
required to comply with government actions as force
majeure events. The Commission has clarified the
basic distinction as to whether outages resulting from
governmental actions are force majeure or non-force
majeure events. 110 The Commission found that
outages necessitated by compliance with government
standards
concerning
the
regular,
periodic
108 Columbia Gas Transmission Corp., 100 FERC ¶ 61,084, at P
201 (2002).
109 E.g. MoGas Pipeline LLC, 151 FERC ¶ 61,201, at PP 22-23
(2015) (approving tariff language that permitted the imposition
of the greater penalty).
110 Kinder Morgan Louisiana Pipeline LLC, 154 FERC ¶ 61,145,
at P 30 (2016); DBM Pipeline, LLC, 152 FERC ¶ 62,056, at 64,159
(2015); TransColorado Gas Transmission Co., LLC, 144 FERC
¶ 61,175, at PP 35-43 (2013); Gulf South Pipeline Co., LP, 141
FERC ¶ 61,224, at PP 28-47 (2012), order on reh’g, 144 FERC
¶ 61,215, at PP 31-34 (2013).
JA 86
maintenance activities a pipeline must perform in the
ordinary course of business to ensure the safe
operation of the pipeline, including the Pipeline and
Hazardous
Materials
Safety
Administration’s
(PHMSA) integrity management regulations, are nonforce majeure events requiring full reservation charge
credits. Outages resulting from one-time, nonrecurring government requirements, including
special, one-time testing requirements after a pipeline
failure, are force majeure events requiring only partial
crediting. 111
88. In addition, PennEast’s proposed definition of
force majeure events in section 26.1 includes “any
other cause, whether of the kind herein enumerated,
or otherwise, not within the control of the party
claiming suspension and which by the exercise of due
diligence such party is unable to prevent or overcome.”
(emphasis added). The Commission has defined force
majeure outages as events that are both “unexpected
and uncontrollable.” 112 The Commission directs
PennEast to revise section 26.1 of the GT&C to comply
with Commission Policy, as discussed above.
111 See Algonquin Gas Transmission LLC, 153 FERC ¶ 61,038, at
P 104 (2015).
112 North Baja Pipeline, LLC v. FERC, 483 F.3d 819, 823 (D.C.
Cir. 2007), aff’g, North Baja Pipeline, LLC, 109 FERC ¶ 61,159
(2004), order on reh’g, 111 FERC ¶ 61,101 (2005). See also Kinder
Morgan Louisiana Pipeline LLC, 154 FERC ¶ 61,145, at P 29
(2016); Algonquin Gas Transmission LLC, 153 FERC ¶ 61,038 at
P 103.
JA 87
GT&C Section 32: North American
Energy Standards Board (NAESB)
89. PennEast adopted the Business Practices and
Electronic Communications Standards of NAESB
Wholesale Gas Quadrant’s (WGQ) Version 2.0.
PennEast has identified those standards incorporated
by reference in GT&C Section 32. Those standards not
incorporated by reference by PennEast have also been
identified, along with the tariff record in which they
are located. In the event an updated version of the
NAESB WGQ standards is adopted by the
Commission prior to PennEast’s in-service date, the
Commission directs PennEast to file revised tariff
records, 30 to 60 days prior to its in-service date,
consistent with the then current version.
GT&C Section 39:
Charge Crediting
Reservation
90. Sections 39.1 and 39.2 of the GT&C provide that
the pipeline will provide full reservation charge
credits to shippers during non-force majeure events
and partial reservation credits during force majeure
events, respectively, except as provided for in section
39.3.
91. Section 39.3 exempts PennEast from providing
reservation charge credits in a number of
circumstances including:
(xi) if Customer is provided service pursuant
to a negotiated rate agreement executed after
November 1, 2017, or any successor
negotiated rate agreement thereto, and such
agreement does not explicitly require
reservation charge credits.”
JA 88
92. The Commission has found that it is unreasonable
for a pipeline to apply a proposed new contractual
prerequisite for negotiated rate contracts to qualify for
reservation charge credits to agreements entered into
before the effective date of the proposed tariff
language. 113 Although section 39.3 (xi) of the GT&C
provides such protection to the agreements prior to the
filing of PennEast’s application, this provision does
not address any agreements that may be reached with
shippers before the effective date of the tariff.
Acceptance of PennEast’s proposal with respect to
existing
negotiated
rate
agreements
would
unreasonably deny reservation charge credits to
shippers which may have been unaware of PennEast’s
future contracting requirement. Therefore, the
Commission directs PennEast to revise this language
to apply only to negotiated rate contracts entered into
after the effective date of that tariff provision.
E. Environmental Analysis
1.
Pre-filing and Application Review
93. Commission
staff
began
a
pre-filing
environmental review of the project on October 10,
2014. On January 13, 2015, Commission staff issued a
Notice of Intent to Prepare an Environmental Impact
Statement for the Planned PennEast Pipeline Project,
Request for Comments on Environmental Issues, and
Notice of Public Scoping Meetings (NOI). This notice
was published in the Federal Register on February 3,
113 Florida Southeast Connection, LLC, et al., 154 FERC ¶ 61,080,
at P 176 (2016); Iroquois Gas Transmission Sys., LP, 145 FERC
¶ 61,233, at PP 67-71 (2013).
JA 89
2015, 114 and sent to more than 4,300 interested
entities, including representatives of federal, state,
and local agencies; elected officials; environmental
and public interest groups; Native American tribes;
potentially affected landowners as defined in the
Commission’s regulations (i.e., landowners crossed or
adjacent to pipeline facilities or within 0.5 mile of a
compressor station); concerned citizens; and local
libraries and newspapers. The NOI briefly described
the project and the environmental impact statement
(EIS) process, provided a preliminary list of issues
identified by staff, invited written comments on the
environmental issues that should be addressed in the
EIS, and listed the date and location of five public
scoping meetings. 115 On January 28, 2015,
Commission staff issued a Notice of Extension of
Comment Period and Clarification of Location of
Public Comment Meetings for the PennEast Pipeline
Project, which extended the comment period until
February 27, 2015. 116 At the public scoping meetings,
a total of 250 speakers provided verbal comments
about the project. In addition, more than 6,000 letters
were filed providing comments about the project. 117
94. To satisfy the requirements of the National
Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), Commission staff
114 80 Fed. Reg. 5744 (2015).
115 Commission staff held the public scoping meetings between
February 10 and 12, 2015 and February 25 and 26, 2015 in
Bethlehem, Jim Thorpe, and Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania; and
Trenton and Hampton, New Jersey.
116 80 Fed Reg. 4557 (2015).
117 Table 1.4-1 of the final EIS provides a detailed and
comprehensive list of issues raised during scoping.
JA 90
prepared a draft EIS for the project. The U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers (USACE), U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA), and the U.S. Department of
Agriculture’s Natural Resources Conservation Service
participated in the NEPA review as cooperating
agencies. Commission staff issued the draft EIS for
the project on July 22, 2016, which addressed the
issues raised during the scoping period and included
staff’s independent analysis of the environmental
impacts of the project.
95. Notice of the draft EIS was published in the
Federal Register on July 29, 2016, establishing a 45day public comment period that ended on September
12, 2016. 118 The draft EIS was mailed to over 4,280
stakeholders, which included the entities that were
mailed the NOI and additional interested entities.
Commission staff held six public comment sessions
between August 15 and 17, 2016, to receive comments
on the draft EIS. 119 Approximately 670 individuals
attended these public sessions, including 420 who
provided verbal comments. A total of 4,169 comment
letters were filed in response to the draft EIS before
the comment period closed on September 12, 2016.
The transcript of the public comment sessions and all
written comments on the draft EIS are part of the
public record for the project.
96. On September 23, 2016, PennEast filed 33 route
modifications, totaling 21.3 miles in length, to address
118 82 Fed. Reg. 49,971 (2017).
Commission staff held draft EIS comment sessions in
Bethlehem, Pennsylvania; Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania; Clinton,
New
Jersey;
Lahaska,
Pennsylvania;
Wilkes-Barre,
Pennsylvania; and Trenton, New Jersey.
119
JA 91
environmental and engineering concerns. On
November 4, 2016, Commission staff issued a letter to
newly affected landowners describing the route
modifications and inviting comments on the route
modifications, and opening an additional 30-day
comment period, which concluded on December 5,
2016. Comments received after the close of the
comment periods (between September 12 and
November 4, 2016, and after December 5, 2016)
continued to be posted to the Commission’s eLibrary
website and were reviewed by staff for substantive
concerns.
97. The final EIS for the project was issued on April
7, 2017, and a public notice of the availability of the
final EIS was published in the Federal Register on
April 14, 2017. 120 The final EIS addresses all
substantive comments received on the draft EIS, the
November 4, 2016 letter, and comments received prior
to December 31, 2016. 121 The final EIS was mailed to
the same parties as the draft EIS, as well as additional
parties. 122 The final EIS addresses geology; soils;
water resources; wetlands; aquatic resources;
vegetation and wildlife; threatened, endangered, and
special status species; land use, recreation, and visual
resources; socioeconomics; cultural resources; air
120 82 Fed. Reg. 17,988 (2017).
121 All comments received prior to the end of the comment period
and in response to the November 4, 2016 letter that included
additional substantive concerns are included in the comment
responses contained in Appendix M of the final EIS (Volume II).
Any new issues raised after December 31, 2016, which were not
previously identified, are addressed in this order.
122 The distribution list is provided in Appendix A of the final EIS.
JA 92
quality and noise; reliability and safety; cumulative
impacts; and alternatives. The major environmental
issues raised during this proceeding, and comments
from stakeholders not addressed in the final EIS, as
well as substantive comments on the final EIS, are
discussed below.
98. The final EIS concludes that while the project will
result in some adverse environmental impacts, these
impacts will be reduced to less than significant levels
with the implementation of PennEast’s proposed
impact avoidance, minimization, and mitigation
measures, together with staff’s recommended
environmental conditions, now adopted, as modified,
as conditions in the attached Appendix A of this order.
While, the Commission recognizes that there are
incomplete surveys due to lack of access to landowner
property, the conclusions in the final EIS, and
affirmed by the Commission here, were based on the
information contained in the record, including
PennEast’s application and supplements, as well as
information developed through Commission staff’s
data requests, field investigations, the scoping
process, literature research, alternatives analysis, and
contacts with federal, state, and local agencies, as well
as with individual members of the public. As part of
its environmental review, staff developed specific
mitigation measures that we find will adequately and
reasonably reduce the environmental impacts
resulting from the construction and operation of the
PennEast Project. We believe that the substantial
environmental record and mitigation measures
sufficiently support reaching a decision on this project.
JA 93
99. Once a certificate is issued, the Commission’s
environmental staff is charged with ensuring that the
project will be constructed in compliance with the
Commission’s order, including the conclusions
regarding the project’s expected impacts upon the
environment. Recognizing that there are necessary
field surveys that are outstanding on sections of the
proposed route where survey access was denied, we
are imposing several environmental conditions that
require filing of additional environmental information
for review and approval once survey access is
obtained. This includes items such as site-specific
plans, survey results, documentation of consultations
with agencies, and additional mitigation measures.
The additional information ensures the EIS’s analyses
and conclusions are verified based on the best
available data, enabling us to improve and finalize
certain mitigation plans and ensure stakeholder
concerns are addressed. The information will also
provide Commission staff with the site-specific details
necessary to appropriately evaluate compliance
during the construction process. In addition,
Environmental Condition 10 requires that before
construction can commence, PennEast must file
documentation that it has received all applicable
authorizations required under federal law (or evidence
of waiver thereof).
100. Further, the final EIS has adequately
identified, as required by section 1502.22 of the
Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) regulations,
where information is lacking. 123 CEQ regulations
recognize that some information simply may not be
123 40 C.F.R. § 1502.22 (2017).
JA 94
available. 124 Moreover, the final EIS contains
mitigation plans that provide for using the correct
mitigation measures, sediment control measures, and
restoration requirements based on the actual site
conditions experienced during construction. The
conditions in the order will ensure that all
environmental resources will be adequately protected.
101. The Commission needs to consider and study
environmental issues before approving a project, but
it does not require all environmental concerns to be
definitively resolved before a project’s approval is
issued. NEPA does not require every study or aspect
of an analysis to be completed before an agency can
issue a final EIS, and the courts have held that
agencies do not need perfect information before it
takes any action. 125 In U.S. Department of the Interior
v. FERC, the court held that “[v]irtually every decision
must be made under some uncertainty; the question is
whether
the
Commission’s
response,
given
uncertainty, is supported by substantial evidence and
is not arbitrary and capricious.” 126 Similarly, in State
of Alaska v. Andrus, the court stated that “[i]f we were
to impose a requirement that an impact statement can
never be prepared until all relevant environmental
124 Id.
125 U.S. Dep’t of the Interior v. FERC, 952 F.2d 538, 546 (D.C. Cir.
1992); State of Alaska v. Andrus, 580 F.2d 465, 473 (D.C. Cir.
1978), vacated in part sub nom. W. Oil & Gas Ass’n v. Alaska, 439
U.S. 922, 99 S. Ct. 303, 58 L. Ed. 2d 315 (1978) (“NEPA cannot
be ‘read as a requirement that complete information concerning
the environmental impact of a project must be obtained before
action may be taken’”).
126 U.S. Dep’t of the Interior v. FERC, 952 F.2d 538, 546.
JA 95
effects were known, it is doubtful that any project
could ever be initiated.” 127 There must, however, be
sufficient information in the record to enable the
Commission to take the requisite “hard look” required
by NEPA. As indicated above, we believe the record in
this proceeding meets that requirement. 128
2.
The EIS Process and Procedural
Concerns
102. Commenters requested public meetings be held
in areas affected by PennEast’s minor route
modifications, as identified in PennEast’s September
23,
2016
Supplemental
Information
filing.
Commission staff mailed notice on November 4, 2016,
to all landowners potentially affected by the
modifications, government officials, and other
stakeholders. The notice described the proposed route
changes, invited participation, and opened a special
30-day limited scoping period. Over 400 comments
were filed in response to the notice, which are
addressed in the final EIS. Commission staff
determined that additional public meetings were not
required and that written comments received from the
public were sufficient to identify potential concerns
associated with the minor route changes.
127 State of Alaska v. Andrus, 580 F.2d 465, 473.
See also Independence Pipeline Co., 91 FERC ¶ 61,102, at
61,352 (2000) (finding that despite landowners denying survey
access, the final EIS was sufficiently detailed to inform the
Commission and the public for purposes of NEPA); Southern
Natural Gas Co., 85 FERC ¶ 61,134, at 61,512 (1998) (finding
paper record sufficient even though landowners denied pipeline
survey access).
128
JA 96
103. In addition, several commenters asserted that
the comment period for the draft EIS was not
sufficient, and should have been extended in order to
allow parties additional time to study the draft EIS
and provide comment. Commission staff continued to
accept and review comments after the close of the
comment period for the draft EIS. All filings are
available on the docket for public review and
inspection. For these reasons, we concur that an
extended comment period was not needed.
3.
Major Environmental Issues and
Comments on the Final EIS
a.
Geology
104. Several commenters express concern regarding
construction near active quarries and in karst terrain.
Comments were also filed regarding the potential for
naturally occurring arsenic to mobilize and
contaminate groundwater, drinking water wells, and
surface waters. Commenters also express concerns for
landslide risks, as well as the potential for soil
compaction.
105. After the close of the draft EIS comment period,
United States Representative Matt Cartwright of
Pennsylvania forwarded a letter from his constituent,
Phyllis Jacewicz, particularly for residences on East
Saylor Avenue in Plains Township, Luzerne County,
Pennsylvania, citing concerns about construction of
the project near an active quarry. As stated in the final
EIS, PennEast has adjusted the pipeline route
through Luzerne County to avoid future expansion of
the quarry, PennEast also evaluated average quarry
blasting vibration, concluding there would be no effect
JA 97
from these activities on the pipeline. 129 Additionally,
PennEast provided documentation regarding the
expansion of the Trap Rock Quarry located at milepost
(MP) 99 in Delaware Township, New Jersey, and
provided a blasting assessment based on site-specific
data (geology, distance and wave propagation) and a
scaling relationship to solve for blast-induced effects
(peak particle velocity) on the pipeline. Based on the
blasting analysis, the EIS concludes that no impacts
on the pipeline from quarry blasting are
anticipated. 130 In response to comments received
regarding the accuracy of the explosive weights for the
blasting analysis, Environmental Condition 14
requires PennEast to file an updated report verifying
the explosive weights used by the quarry operator;
incorporate this information this into the final design
of the project; and to seek concurrence from Trap Rock
Quarry regarding the input parameters to the blasting
analysis. The updated report will be reviewed by
Commission staff prior to construction to confirm the
conclusions in the EIS remain valid.
106. In comments on the final EIS, Susan D.
Meacham discusses the potential risks of construction
in karst areas and the potential risk for scouring
where the pipeline will cross the floodplain along the
New Jersey side of the proposed horizontal directional
drill (HDD) crossing of the Delaware River. The final
EIS determines that there are approximately 13.8
miles of the project, in Carbon, Northampton, and
Bucks Counties, Pennsylvania, and Hunterdon
129 See final EIS at 4-5.
130 Id. at 4-5.
JA 98
County, New Jersey, where a karst hazard may be
present; approximately 50 percent of the karst survey
has been completed. 131 As discussed in the EIS,
PennEast developed a project-specific Karst
Mitigation Plan, as well as a specific HDD plan for
drilling through karst terrain. The project-specific
Karst Mitigation Plan, which provides guidance to
mitigate karst-related concerns during construction,
was developed using maps of known or suspected
karst areas, and field investigations completed todate. The HDD Drilling Plan for Karst Terrain
establishes
operational
procedures
and
responsibilities for the prevention, containment, and
clean-up of inadvertent returns of drilling muds and
losses associated with HDD through karst areas.
Further, we note that PennEast continues to complete
additional geophysical investigations as landowner
access becomes available, and will incorporate the
findings into an updated Karst Mitigation Plan. The
final updated plan will enable PennEast to finalize its
HDD design based on a detailed understanding of the
subsurface conditions, and more precisely identify
locations where the approved mitigation procedures
will be implemented. Accordingly, Environmental
Condition 16 requires PennEast to file for approval a
final Karst Mitigation Plan prior to construction,
which includes the results of all outstanding field
investigations, as well as requirements of the
Pennsylvania
Department
of
Environmental
Protection (PADEP), New Jersey Department of
Environmental Protection (NJDEP) and local
planning commissions. Based on staff’s review of the
131 Id. at 4-10.
JA 99
Karst Mitigation Plan, the HDD Drilling Plan for
Karst Terrain, and compliance with Environmental
Condition 16, we agree with the final EIS’s conclusion
that PennEast will adequately minimize impacts in
geologically sensitive areas. 132 Regarding the risk of
scour, PennEast’s HDD of the Delaware River will
drill underneath the river’s flood plain, with the HDD
entry/exit point on the New Jersey side of the river
approximately 1,100 feet east of the river’s edge,
outside of the flood zone and below the potential scour
depth. The segment of pipeline installed by HDD will
be considerably deeper than sections of pipeline
installed by standard trenching and will be below the
potential scour depths. Thus, scour from flooding on
the Delaware River will not affect the pipeline.
107. Several commenters expressed concern that the
final EIS contains an inadequate analysis of the
potential for construction and operation of the project
to contribute to arsenic contamination of groundwater
and the release of radioactivity. Comments were filed
from stakeholders, including a letter from
Congressman Brian Fitzpatrick on behalf of Bucks
County, Pennsylvania, from Dr. Tullis Onstott from
the Princeton University Department of Geosciences,
Dr. Julia Barringer, a retired U.S. Geologic Survey
research geochemist, and from the Township of
Kingwood, New Jersey, regarding the potential risk of
arsenic contamination of groundwater. Drs. Onstott
and Barringer contend that the final EIS fails to
address the potential for the project to increase
arsenic mobility, as well as the release of radioactivity.
Drs. Onstott and Barringer also comment that the
132 See final EIS at ES-5.
JA 100
pipeline has the potential to cause boron
contamination of the Lambertville, New Jersey
drinking water supply reservoir, and further state
that cathodic protection on the pipeline has the
potential to “promote the growth of microbes that
stimulate arsenic” while a potential methane leak
would input carbon into the soil, which could serve to
stimulate microbial activity, which in turn could
stimulate arsenic. 133 Further, Drs. Barringer and
Onstott state that the final EIS fails to fully analyze
the potential release of arsenic to local streams from
HDDs. In addition, several comments were filed
stating that the final EIS does not sufficiently address
the risk of uranium and uranium decay product
radionuclides potentially being released by blasting of
Newark Basin sedimentary bedrock.
108. PennEast conducted a laboratory arsenic
mobilization study, leaching experiments, and
dilution modeling to determine if trench excavation
and the use of HDDs will oxidize, release, and mobilize
naturally occurring arsenic and potentially increase
arsenic exposure to nearby groundwater users and/or
ecological receptors within waterbodies. The results of
the laboratory study demonstrate that broken
fragments of naturally occurring arsenic-enriched
rock generated during trenching activities and
subsequently returned as backfill, would not result in
an increased risk of arsenic mobilization in
groundwater; that drilling mud would not become
contaminated with particles of naturally occurring
arsenic enriched rock; and that concentrations of
133 See Comments of Drs. Julia Barringer and Tullis Onstott, filed
May 5, 2017 in Docket No. CP15-558-000.
JA 101
arsenic in groundwater will be below the EPA
maximum contaminant level (MCL) of 10 micrograms
per liter (ug/L) for public water supplies and the New
Jersey MCL of 5 micrograms per liter (μg/L) for both
public and private water supplies. Regarding
comments on the project’s ability to contaminate
Lambertville’s water supply from boron, the EIS found
that the pipeline alignment does not cross any stream
that provides water to Lambertville’s water supply
and the Lambertville reservoir is located up-gradient
of the planned PennEast pipeline.
109. As discussed in the final EIS, Drs. Onstott and
Barringers’ comments regarding the chemical
mechanisms that could mobilize arsenic and other
analytes during construction and operation were
found to be speculative, based upon misapplication of
physical principles, containing misinformation about
pipeline corrosion and corrosion prevention systems,
and not supported by empirical data for construction
and operation of natural gas pipelines. Further, the
final EIS found that radionuclides present in
groundwater and household air are “absolutely not
specific” to Newark Basin sedimentary bedrock
(Stockton, Lockatong, and Passaic formations), and
that human exposure issues related to radionuclides
are not likely to play a role in the construction and
operation of natural gas pipelines. Regarding the
potential for methane leaks to increase arsenic
mobility, PennEast has committed to several specific
measures to reduce the risk of methane leaks, which
JA 102
would in turn further reduce the risk of increased
arsenic mobility. 134
110. PennEast has prepared a Well Monitoring Plan
and proposes to conduct groundwater quality testing
of potentially affected wells prior to construction. This
will provide a baseline to determine whether any
arsenic increases in groundwater occur after the
pipeline is installed. In the unlikely event that
construction results in any arsenic impacts on a watersupply well, PennEast will provide a treatment
system to remove arsenic from the drinking water at
individual properties or find an alternative water
source.
111. In its September 20, 2016 comments on the
DEIS, the United States Department of the Interior
(DOI) expressed concern regarding the potential for
arsenic mobilization, and the potential for arsenic
contamination of individual wells, drinking water, and
groundwater. To address these concerns, we require in
Environmental Condition 23 that PennEast revise
and file for review and approval its above-described
Well Monitoring Plan to incorporate the well sampling
quality assurance/quality control elements suggested
by the DOI into its well sampling protocol and to
include provisions for treatment for groundwater
users impacted by increased arsenic levels, as well as
provisions for monitoring and maintaining such
treatment systems.
112. In comments on the final EIS, Lorraine Crown
of Holland Township expressed concern regarding
Route Deviation 1710, which she claims would lead to
134 Id. at 4-250.
JA 103
an increased risk of landslides on Gravel Hill. The
final EIS’ conclusion that that landslide incidences are
low in New Jersey is based on PennEast’s Phase I
Terrain Mapping and Geohazard Risk Evaluation,
which included the review of federal, state and local
geographic information system data, published maps,
available print and digitized terrain data, and sitespecific data collected by PennEast. The final EIS
notes that while generalized data from the United
States Geological Survey indicates that there is a low
risk of landslide potential for the New Jersey portion
of the project, several locations in New Jersey have
recorded landslides in close proximity to the proposed
pipeline. 135 This includes the area near steep slopes 75
and 76 near route deviation 1710 as identified in
Phase 1 of PennEast’s Terrain Mapping and
Geohazard Risk Evaluation Report. PennEast
identified these as areas where it will conduct further
field investigation and analysis. We require in
Environmental Condition 15 that, prior to
construction, PennEast shall file results of the
outstanding site-specific Phase 2 and 3 portions of the
Geohazard Risk Evaluation Report, which will include
a final landslide hazard inventory. The finalized
report will also include any specific measures and
locations where PennEast will implement specialized
pipeline design to mitigate for potential soil stability
or landslide hazards; and include a post-construction
monitoring plan.
113. In comments on the final EIS, the NJDEP
submitted a letter referencing previous comments by
the New Jersey Geological and Water Survey
135 Id. at 4-7.
JA 104
(NJGWS) which indicate that there are important
paleontological sites that are significantly closer than
0.25 mile to the proposed route. The NJDEP requests
that PennEast consult with Dr. William Gallagher
and provide him with the proposed project route
alignment shape files as over 90 percent of the route
crosses rock formations within the Newark Basin.
114. PennEast provided the NJGWS with updated
mapping of the proposed pipeline route in relation to
sites identified as significant paleontological locations
containing trace Triassic-age fossils and various casts,
including footprints. After analyzing the NJDEP
comments on the final EIS, we determined there is
potential for fossilized vertebrate footprints to be
affected by construction of the project through Newark
Basin sedimentary bedrock. Therefore, we have
included a new condition to address potential
discovery of paleontological resources during project
construction. Environmental Condition 20 requires
that PennEast prepare an unanticipated discovery
plan for paleontological resources in coordination with
the NJGWS and Dr. William Gallagher. The plan shall
be focused on areas where bedrock would have allowed
preservation of any significant paleontological
resource. We believe that Environmental Condition 20
sufficiently addresses NJDEP’s concerns and that any
adverse impacts on significant paleontological
resources will be appropriately mitigated.
b.
Soils
115. The project will cross numerous soil types,
which may be affected by pipeline construction
activities, such as clearing, grading, trench
JA 105
excavation, backfilling, and the movement
construction equipment along the right-of-way.
of
116. In comments on the final EIS, Emma A.
Switzler discusses the potential for soil compaction
from an HDD work space proposed on her property.
PennEast identified certain measures which will be
implemented to reduce the potential for soil
compaction, including regular testing of topsoil and
subsoil for compaction. PennEast indicated that it
would avoid construction during periods of high soil
saturation in order to minimize the risk of soil
compaction. Severely compacted topsoil will be plowed
or a green manure such as alfalfa will be planted and
plowed to decrease bulk density and improve soil
structure. 136 Given these measures and PennEast’s
adherence to the Commission’s Upland Erosion
Control, Revegetation, and Maintenance Plan (Plan),
which includes specific measures designed to mitigate
for soil compaction, the final EIS finds that the project
activities will not result in significant adverse soil
structural damage or compaction. 137
117. As stated in the final EIS, implementation of
PennEast’s Erosion and Sediment Control Plan
(E&SCP), FERC’s Plan and FERC’s Wetland and
Waterbody Construction and Mitigation Procedures
(Procedures), and other project-specific plans, will
adequately avoid, minimize, or mitigate construction
impacts on soil resources. Permanent impacts on soils
will mainly occur at the aboveground facilities where
the sites will be converted to industrial use. Based on
136 Id. at 4-28.
137 Id. at 4-21 to 4-22.
JA 106
the final EIS, we conclude that potential impacts on
soils will be avoided or effectively minimized or
mitigated.
c.
Water Resources
118. The project will cross 269 waterbodies. 138
Approximately 74 percent of these waterbodies are
classified as minor, 22 percent as intermediate, and 3
percent classified as major. Numerous commenters
expressed concern regarding the potential effects of
the construction and operation of the project on state
designated streams, with a particular emphasis on
locations where HDD crossing would occur. The final
EIS states that while minor impacts on waterbodies
may
occur
during
construction,
with
the
implementation of PennEast’s planned, and the
Commission’s required mitigation plans, no long-term
effects on surface waters are anticipated. In addition,
PennEast will comply with state regulations
regarding riparian buffers. Finally, PennEast will
comply with regulatory permit conditions that address
scour and sedimentation, flooding, or the introduction
of foreign or toxic substances into the aquatic system.
Accidental spills and leaks during construction and
operations will be prevented or adequately minimized
through implementation of PennEast’s Spill
Prevention Control and Countermeasure Plan.
119. Several comments addressed potential impacts
on state-designated waterbodies. Appendices G-7
through G-9 of the final EIS provide state
classifications for individual waterbody crossings in
Pennsylvania and New Jersey by milepost. The final
138 Id. at 4-45 (table 4.3.2-1).
JA 107
EIS analyzes construction impacts on waterbodies,
and determines that the mitigation measures
identified in our Procedures will adequately minimize
impacts on Pennsylvania and New Jersey statedesignated
waters,
including
High
Quality,
Exceptional Value and Category 1 waters. 139
Generally, PennEast will minimize impacts on statedesignated waterbodies and associated riparian zones
by locating temporary workspace in actively disturbed
areas with a vegetation buffer between the workspace
and the riparian zone. Where the riparian zone cannot
be avoided entirely, PennEast will reduce the
workspace to 75 feet in width and relocate additional
temporary workspaces upslope, or into actively
disturbed areas, to the extent practicable. For drycrossings, the workspace through the waterbody will
be reduced to 60 feet in width and the workspace
outside the waterbody will have a total width of 75 feet
on both sides of the waterbody until actively disturbed
areas are encountered. Where site constraints are
favorable, PennEast will use the HDD method, which
will not require tree clearing or workspace adjacent to
the waterbody, to directly avoid impacts within the
waterbody. PennEast has committed to preparing
sitespecific plans prior to construction for each
waterbody to be crossed via HDD. These site-specific
HDD Plans would include a description of the HDD
work site, justification of the work space required,
cleanup plans in the event of the inadvertent release
139 See final EIS at 4-49.
JA 108
of drilling mud, as well as a contingency plan in the
event the HDD is unsuccessful. 140
120. In comments on the final EIS, West Amwell
Township, New Jersey, expresses concern regarding
the crossing of Alexauken Creek, including the
feasibility of and dangers associated with using the
HDD crossing method; potential temperature and
sedimentation impacts; and PennEast’s plans for
hydrostatic testing. The majority of the HDD crossings
have had some geotechnical work performed, and staff
reviewed this data along with PennEast’s HDD
Inadvertent Returns and Contingency Plan and HDD
profiles. We require in Environmental Condition 19
that PennEast file the final design plans for each HDD
crossing for review and approval. The final design plan
will include the results for all geotechnical borings
conducted at each HDD crossing (lithology, standard
penetration testing and bedrock quality designation),
and a HDD feasibility assessment based on the soil
boring results, including an assessment of the risk for
hydrofracturing and inadvertent return of drilling
fluids at each crossing. Completion of all geotechnical
borings for each specific crossing will allow for a
comprehensive HDD feasibility and hydrofracture/
inadvertent return analysis that staff will review to
ensure PennEast has adequately minimized
environmental risks in the final design of the HDD.
121. Further, as indicated above and in the final
EIS, PennEast will prepare a detailed plan for each
waterbody that will be crossed via HDD that includes
site-specific construction diagrams of work areas;
140 Id. at 4-62.
JA 109
identification of any aboveground disturbance or
clearing between the HDD entry and exit; and a
contingency plan for crossing the waterbody or
wetland in the event the HDD is unsuccessful.
PennEast’s HDD crossing of the Alexauken Creek will
avoid any in-stream disturbance and any direct
impact to the riparian areas between the drilling entry
and exit sites, thus minimizing any potential for
sedimentation or temperature changes. In the
unlikely event that PennEast is required to cross this
waterbody using an alternative crossing method,
Commission staff must review and approve the plans
to verify appropriate mitigation measures will be
implemented
to
minimize
sedimentation.
Furthermore, PennEast’s Erosion and Sedimentation
Control Plan requires site-specific plans to mitigate
sedimentation.
122. We reviewed the hydrostatic test water source
and discharge locations provided by PennEast.
However, during exceptional dry periods when low
flow conditions may be encountered, PennEast will
assess if alternative sources would be necessary. Thus,
Environmental Condition 28 requires that PennEast
file its final hydrostatic test plan identifying the final
hydrostatic test water sources and discharge locations
and provide documentation that it has obtained all
necessary permits and approvals for withdrawal from
each source prior to construction. PennEast has
indicated that its hydrostatic testing program will
comply with state- and Delaware River Basin
Commission-issued water withdrawal and National
Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permits.
JA 110
123. Several comments were received regarding
potential impacts on groundwater supplies,
specifically supplies from private wells and
community aquifers. The final EIS evaluates potential
impacts on groundwater resources, and because
PennEast has not yet completed surveys for water
supply wells along the entire project, includes a
recommendation that PennEast complete all
necessary surveys for water supply wells and
groundwater seeps and springs, identify public and
private water supply wells within the construction
workspace, and file a revised list of wells, seeps, and
springs within 150 feet of any construction workspace
(500 feet in areas characterized by karst terrain). 141
We incorporate this requirement as Environmental
Condition 21 in Appendix A.
124. Although the precise locations of all water
supply wells have not yet been determined, the
avoidance and mitigation measures that will be
implemented are evaluated in the EIS. The final EIS
determines that no significant impacts to
groundwater resources are anticipated from the
construction or operation of the project. Installation of
the pipeline would include digging a trench
approximately 7-10 feet deep, which would have minor
impacts on surficial aquifers, and not impact deeper
bedrock or sole-source aquifers, including their
discharge and recharge patterns. 142 In addition
PennEast reviewed publicly available information
regarding wellhead protection areas to formulate
141 Id. at 4-38.
142 Id. at 4-42 - 4-43.
JA 111
alternatives and has committed to several mitigation
measures in order to further reduce the potential for
impacts to wellhead protection areas, including
prohibition of certain activities and material storage
in proximity to these areas, and consultation with the
appropriate wellhead protection authorities. 143
125. Several comments were received regarding
PennEast’s Well Monitoring Plan. The final EIS
concludes that the current Well Monitoring Plan
contains acceptable measures. As part of its initial
Well Monitoring Plan, PennEast commits to conduct
pre- and post-construction monitoring for water
quality and yield for private and public wells within
150 feet of the proposed construction workspace (500
feet in areas of karst terrain), with the well owner’s
permission. 144 However, the final EIS recommends
additional information regarding DOI’s comments on
PennEast’s initial Well Monitoring Plan, and
landowner comments on the draft EIS. Therefore, as
is discussed above, we require in Environmental
Condition 23 that PennEast file a revised Well
Monitoring Plan. The revised plan will provide
responses to address the DOI’s comments on the draft
plan; include an analysis and mitigation for radon,
radium 226, and radium 228; and provide more
information regarding the types of treatment systems
used, including provisions for monitoring and
maintenance of any treatment systems PennEast
provides.
143 See final EIS at 4-37.
144 See final EIS at 4-38.
JA 112
126. Several commenters raised concerns regarding
impacts to the Swan Creek Upper Reservoir, which is
the primary source of drinking water for the City of
Lambertville. As discussed in the final EIS, the Swan
Creek Upper Reservoir is located approximately 400
feet east of the proposed pipeline route, with the water
supply intake structure located upstream of the
pipeline. Due to the downstream location of the
proposed pipeline crossing, water quality of the active
reservoir will not be adversely affected. Blasting is not
anticipated near the Swan Creek Reservoir; however,
geotechnical evaluations are ongoing. 145 Therefore, we
require in Environmental Condition 25 that PennEast
provide the results of investigations regarding any
anticipated blasting near the Swan Creek Reservoir
prior to construction.
127. In comments on the final EIS, the EPA
recommends that PennEast consult with state
drinking water authorities to ensure state-defined
source water protection areas are not crossed by the
project. PennEast and Commission staff consulted
with federal, state and regional entities to identify
source water protection areas to be crossed by the
project. As noted above, PennEast has proposed
several mitigation measures to prevent impacts to
wellhead protection areas that staff determined will
adequately address potential impacts. In addition, the
final EIS responds to concerns about blasting impacts
on an existing water transmission tunnel managed by
the Bethlehem Authority. The pipeline will be
installed substantially above the location of the
tunnel, with about 480 feet of clearance at the point
145 See final EIS at 4-52.
JA 113
where it first crosses the tunnel, and about 75 feet of
clearance at the second crossing. Environmental
Condition 44 requires that PennEast file additional
information on the crossing, including a site-specific
crossing plan and details regarding potential blasting
within 2,000 feet of the water tunnel, and
documentation of working meetings with water
authority to ensure its concerns are adequately
addressed, prior to construction.
128. Several commenters, including the USACE,
PADEP, and the New Jersey Highlands Water
Protection and Planning Council, commented on the
final EIS and PennEast’s PADEP/USACE Joint
Permit Application, stating that more surveys needed
to be completed before the applications could be
processed, and the true environmental impacts could
be assessed. On April 25, 2017, the PADEP filed a
letter concerning the same application. The PADEP
and USACE state that the application was incomplete
due to lack of survey access. On April 26 and 28, 2017,
the NJDEP commented on the final EIS and
PennEast’s freshwater wetlands individual permit
application, stating that PennEast’s application was
determined administratively deficient, and that until
an application is determined by the NJDEP to be
complete, it is not possible to issue the permit or to
determine a proposed permit issuance date.
129. As previously noted, we are aware that
remaining field surveys need to be completed prior to
construction. For areas where PennEast was unable to
complete field surveys, remote-sensing resources were
used to approximate the locations and boundaries of
wetlands and waterbodies within the project area.
JA 114
Remote-sensing delineations were conducted using a
combination of high-resolution aerial photographic
imagery, National Wetland Inventory data, National
Hydrography Dataset data, hydric soil data
maintained by the Natural Resources Conservation
Service, floodplain and flood elevations maintained by
the Federal Emergency Management Agency,
watershed data from the USGS, and field survey
results on adjacent land parcels where access could be
obtained. Once surveys are completed following
issuance of this order, PennEast will submit any
outstanding survey information to the USACE,
PADEP, and NJDEP to enable the final processing of
its permit applications. Further, we require in
Environmental Condition 10 th
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.