Amicus Curiae Brief — County of Maui, Hawaii, Petitioner v. Hawaii Wildlife Fund, et al.

Supreme Court briefJul 19, 2019

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

No. 18-260

================================================================

In The

Supreme Court of the United States

-----------------------------------------------------------------COUNTY OF MAUI,

Petitioner,

v.

HAWAI‘I WILDLIFE FUND, et al.,

Respondents.

-----------------------------------------------------------------On Writ Of Certiorari To The

United States Court Of Appeals

For The Ninth Circuit

-----------------------------------------------------------------BRIEF OF AMICUS CURIAE

FOND DU LAC BAND OF LAKE SUPERIOR

CHIPPEWA IN SUPPORT OF RESPONDENTS

-----------------------------------------------------------------ELISE L. LARSON

Counsel of Record

KEVIN S. REUTHER

MINNESOTA CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCACY

1919 University Avenue West, Ste. 515

St. Paul, MN 55104-3435

651-223-5969

elarson@mncenter.org

Counsel for Amicus Curiae

================================================================

COCKLE LEGAL BRIEFS (800) 225-6964

WWW.COCKLELEGALBRIEFS.COM

i

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

INTEREST OF THE AMICUS CURIAE ...............

1

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT ................................

3

ARGUMENT ...........................................................

5

I. THE BAND RELIES ON THE CLEAN

WATER ACT TO PROTECT CRITICAL

NATURAL RESOURCES FROM LARGE

INDUSTRIAL POLLUTERS .......................

5

A. Production And Consumption Of Traditional Foods, Including Manoomin And

Freshwater Fish, Are Important To The

Ojibwe ....................................................

5

1. Manoomin .........................................

6

2. Freshwater Fish ...............................

8

B. The Band’s Freshwater Resources Are

Sensitive To Water Pollutants, Particularly Sulfate And Mercury ....................

9

1. Sulfate...............................................

10

2. Methylmercury .................................

11

C. Large Industrial Point Sources Are Decimating Manoomin With Discharges To

Surface Waters That Migrate Through

Groundwater .......................................... 13

1. Minntac .............................................

13

2. PolyMet .............................................

20

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS – Continued

Page

II.

THIS COURT SHOULD ADOPT RESPONDENTS’ CLEAN WATER ACT INTERPRETATION BECAUSE IT IS CONSISTENT

WITH THE PLAIN LANGUAGE AND

PROTECTS IMPORTANT TRIBAL RESOURCES .................................................... 22

A. The Clean Water Act’s Plain Language

Includes Discharges Fairly Traceable

To A Point Source .................................. 23

B. The County’s Interpretation Would Not

Protect The Band’s Important Natural

Resources ............................................... 27

1. Dischargers could easily evade the

Clean Water Act permit requirement ................................................ 27

2. Petitioner’s assertion that other regulatory requirements sufficiently

control groundwater-mediated discharges to surface waters is inaccurate .................................................... 30

CONCLUSION .......................................................

36

iii

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

Page

CASE LAW

Burlington N. & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. United

States, 556 U.S. 599 (2009)......................................35

Friends of Santa Fe Cty. v. LAC Minerals, Inc.,

892 F. Supp. 1333 (D.N.M. 1995) ............................14

Gross v. FBL Fin. Servs., Inc., 557 U.S. 167

(2009) .......................................................................23

Hardt v. Reliance Standard Life Ins. Co., 560

U.S. 242 (2010) .................................................. 23, 27

In re Determination of the Need for an Envtl. Impact Statement for the Minntac Mine Extension Project in Mountain Iron, St. Louis Cty.,

Minn., No. A13–0837, 2014 WL 274077 (Minn.

Ct. App. 2014) ..........................................................14

Meghrig v. KFC W., Inc., 516 U.S. 479 (1996) .............34

Minn. Chamber of Commerce v. Minn. Pollution

Control Agency, No. A12-0950, 2012 WL 6554544

(Minn. Ct. App. Dec. 17, 2012) ................................32

Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc. v. Envtl. Protection

Agency, 824 F.2d 1258 (1st Cir. 1987) .....................34

Ohio Valley Envtl. Coal., Inc. v. Hernshaw Ptnrs.,

LLC, 984 F. Supp. 2d 589 (S.D. W. Va. 2013) ..........14

Rhodes v. Cty. of Darlington, S.C., 833 F. Supp.

1163 (D.S.C. 1992) ...................................................36

Trs. for Alaska v. Envtl. Protection Agency, 749

F.2d 549 (9th Cir. 1984) ..................................... 13, 14

United States v. Great N. Ry., 287 U.S. 144 (1932) ......23

iv

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES – Continued

Page

United States v. Gonzales, 520 U.S. 1 (1997)..............26

Wash. Wilderness Coal. v. Hecla Min. Co., 870

F. Supp. 983 (E.D. Wash. 1994) ...............................14

STATUTES, REGULATIONS, AND TREATIES

Treaty of LaPointe, 10 Stat. 1109 (Sept. 30

1854) .................................................................. 1, 2

Treaty with the Chippewa, 7 Stat. 536 (July 29,

1837) ...................................................................... 1, 2

Treaty with the Chippewa, 7 Stat. 591 (Oct. 4,

1842) ...................................................................... 1, 2

84 Fed. Reg. 1200 (Feb. 1, 2019) ...................................1

16 U.S.C. § 1455 ..........................................................33

33 U.S.C. § 1251 .............................................. 30, 31, 36

33 U.S.C. § 1341 ............................................................1

33 U.S.C. § 1362 .................................................... 23, 25

42 U.S.C. § 9601 ..........................................................36

42 U.S.C. § 6902 ..........................................................34

40 C.F.R. § 143.3 .........................................................32

40 C.F.R. § 146.3 .........................................................35

40 C.F.R. § 261.4 .........................................................34

40 C.F.R. § 302.4 .........................................................36

Minn. R. 7045.0120 .....................................................34

Minn. R. 7050.0140 .....................................................31

v

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES – Continued

Page

Minn. R. 7050.0220 .....................................................32

Minn. R. 7050.0221 ............................................... 31, 32

Minn. R. 7050.0224 ............................................... 18, 32

Minn. R. 7060.0200 .....................................................31

Minn. Stat. §§ 115B.01-115B.53 .................................36

H.R. Rep. No. 1185 (1974) ..........................................35

AGENCY DECISIONS

In re Determination of Adequacy of the Envtl.

Impact Statement for the U.S. Steel – Minntac

Water Inventory Reduction Project Mountain

Iron, Minn. (Minn. Pollution Control Agency

Nov. 22, 2005) ..........................................................15

In re Reissuance of an NPDES/SDS Permit to

U.S. Steel Corp. for Its Minntac Facility (Minn.

Pollution Control Agency Nov. 30, 2018) .......... 14, 15

ADDITIONAL AUTHORITIES

Lawrence A. Baker, Evaluation of Minntac Tailings Basin on Little Sandy and Sandy Lakes

(2016) .......................................................................17

Barr Eng’g, Groundwater Modeling of the NorthMet Flotation Tailings Basin Containment

System (2015) ..........................................................21

Barr Eng’g, NorthMet Project Water Modeling

Data Package Volume 2 (2015) ...............................20

vi

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES – Continued

Page

Barr Eng’g, NPDES/SDS Permit Application,

Vol. II (2017) ...................................................... 20, 21

Earth Economics, The Food That Grows Out of

the Water: The Economic Benefits of Wild Rice

in Minnesota (2018) ..................................................8

Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa,

Expanding the Narrative of Tribal Health: The

Effects of Wild Rice Water Quality Rules Changes

on Tribal Health (2018)........................... 5, 6, 7, 8, 10

Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa,

2008 Integrated Resource Management Plan

(2008) .......................................................................12

Fond du Lac Reservation Office of Water Protection, Tribal Report Under Section 305(b),

Clean Water Act (2004) ..............................................9

J. A. Foran et al., Evaluation of Mercury Exposure Reduction through a Fish Consumption

Advisory Program for Anishinaabe Tribal Members in Northern Wisconsin, Michigan, and

Minnesota, 2010 J. Envtl. & Pub. Health 1

(2010) .........................................................................6

Kim Lapakko & Ann Jagunich, Sulfate Release

from the USX Tailings Basin and Quantification of Sulfate Sources (1991) .................................17

April E. Lindala, Anishinaabe Migration and

History on the Marquette Iron Range, https://

lib.nmu.edu/voices/anishinaabe.php ........................7

Patricia McCann, Mercury Levels in Blood from

Newborns in the Lake Superior Basin (2011) ........12

vii

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES – Continued

Page

Minn. Dep’t of Nat. Res., Final Environmental

Impact Statement (2015)................................... 20, 21

Minn. Dep’t of Nat. Res., Natural Wild Rice in

Minnesota (2008) .......................................................6

Minn. Envtl. Quality Bd., Governor’s Task Force

on Wild Rice (2019) .................................................10

Minn. Pollution Control Agency, Draft Minntac

Water Inventory Reduction Environmental Impact Statement (2004)........................................ 13, 14

Minn. Pollution Control Agency, National Pollutant Elimination System (NPDES)/State Disposal System (SDS) Permit Program Fact Sheet

Permit Reissuance (2016) .................................. 15, 16

Minn. Pollution Control Agency et al., A Roadmap to Delisting: St. Louis River Area of Concern Remedial Action Plan Update (2013) .............28

Minn. Tribal Wild Rice Task Force, 2018 Tribal

Wild Rice Task Force Report (2018) ........................11

Catherine A. O’Neill, Environmental Justice in

the Tribal Context: A Madness to EPA’s Method,

38 Envtl. L. 495 (2008) .............................. 8, 9, 11, 12

PolyMet Mining, NorthMet Project Adaptive Water Management Plan (2017) ..................................20

Antonin Scalia & Bryan A. Garner, Reading

Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts

(2012) ................................................................. 24, 25

viii

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES – Continued

Page

H. James St. Arnold & Sue Erickson, Ojibwe

Treaty Rights Understanding and Impact

(2006) ..................................................................... 2, 5

U.S. Dep’t of Agric., Basic Report 20089, Wild

Rice, Cooked (2019) ...................................................7

Thomas Vennum, Wild Rice and the Ojibway

People (1988)..............................................................7

Darren J. Vogt, Sandy Lake and Little Sandy

Lake Monitoring (2010-2017) (2018) ......................17

Letter from Melissa Thompson, Wildlife Lake

Specialist, Minn. Dep’t of Nat. Res, to Erik

Smith, Industrial Division, Minn. Pollution

Control Agency (Jan. 24, 2018) ...............................18

Letter from Margaret Watkins, Grand Portage

Water Quality Specialist, and Nancy Schuldt,

Fond du Lac Water Projects Coordinator, to

Erik Smith, Minnesota Pollution Control Agency

(Dec. 22, 2016) .........................................................18

Addition, Merriam-Webster.com, https://www.

merriam-webster.com/dictionary/addition .............25

Fish Contaminant Study, Fond du Lac Band of

Lake Superior Chippewa, http://www.fdlrez.

com/RM/waterfish.htm............................................12

Mercury, Minn. Pollution Control Agency, https://

www.pca.state.mn.us/water/mercury .....................11

ix

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES – Continued

Page

MPCA Wild Rice Database, https://www.pca.state.

mn.us/document/wq-s6-43xxlsx ..............................17

Sediment Studies: St. Louis River Area of Concern, Minn. Pollution Control Agency, https://

www.pca.state.mn.us/water/sediment-studiesst-louis-river-area-concern ......................................28

Sulfate in Well Water, Minn. Dep’t of Health,

https://www.health.state.mn.us/communities/

environment/water/wells/waterquality/sulfate.

html ............................................................. 31, 32, 35

Water Quality Standards Regulations: Fond du

Lac Band of the Minnesota Chippewa, Envtl.

Protection Agency, https://www.epa.gov/wqstech/water-quality-standards-regulations-fonddu-lac-band-minnesota-chippewa.............................2

Watershed Health Assessment Framework, Minn.

Dep’t Nat. Resources, http://bit.ly/2Yhq2Sm ...........27

1

INTERESTS OF AMICUS CURIAE1

Amicus curiae Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior

Chippewa (the “Band”) is a federally-recognized tribe

and a member of the Minnesota Chippewa Tribe (“MCT”),

whose members have resided in northern Minnesota

for centuries. See 84 Fed. Reg. 1200, 1202 (Feb. 1, 2019).

The Band has the inherent sovereign authority and

duty to protect the natural resources and retained

treaty rights upon which its members depend both on

and off the Fond du Lac Reservation (the “Reservation”). See Treaty of LaPointe, 10 Stat. 1109 (Sept. 30

1854) [hereinafter, “1854 Treaty”]; Treaty with the

Chippewa, 7 Stat. 591 (Oct. 4, 1842) [hereinafter, “1842

Treaty”]; Treaty with the Chippewa, 7 Stat. 536 (July

29, 1837) [hereinafter, “1837 Treaty”]. In this capacity,

the Band has Treatment-As-A-State (“TAS”) status

under the Clean Water Act and administers and enforces water-quality standards on the Reservation. See

33 U.S.C. § 1341; Water Certification Standards, FDL

1

Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 37.2(a), all parties have

consented to this brief ’s filing. Counsel of record for all parties

received the requisite notice of the intent of amicus curiae to file

this brief. Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 37.6, amicus curiae

states that no counsel for any party authored this brief in whole

or in part and that no entity or person, aside from amicus curiae

and its counsel, made any monetary contribution toward this

brief ’s preparation or submission.

2

Ordinance No. 01/06;2 Water Quality Standards, FDL

Ordinance No. 12/98.3

The Band also holds off-Reservation usufructuary

rights in lands ceded to the United States, which extend throughout the entire northeast portion of Minnesota and parts of Wisconsin and upper Michigan

(“Ceded Territories”).4 10 Stat. 1109; 7 Stat. 536; 7 Stat.

591. The Band retains and exercises these usufructuary rights, including the right to hunt, fish, and harvest manoomin (Zizania palustris) – known as wild

rice in English – guaranteed under the 1837, 1842, and

1854 Treaties. H. James St. Arnold & Sue Erickson,

Ojibwe Treaty Rights Understanding and Impact 13-17

(2006).5 The Band co-manages the Ceded Territories

with Minnesota and the other MCT Bands who share

usufructuary rights in the Ceded Territories. Id. at 1920.

The Band submits this brief based on its interest

as a regulator ensuring the Clean Water Act’s National

2

A copy of FDL Ordinance No. 01/06 is available at http://

www.fdlrez.com/government/ords/01-06ord.pdf.

3

A copy of FDL Ordinance No. 12/98 is available at https://

www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2014-12/documents/chippewatribe.pdf. The Band was granted TAS status on May 16, 1996.

Water Quality Standards Regulations: Fond du Lac Band of the

Minnesota Chippewa, Envtl. Protection Agency, https://www.epa.

gov/wqs-tech/water-quality-standards-regulations-fond-du-lac-bandminnesota-chippewa (last visited June 18, 2019).

4

A map of the 1837, 1842, and 1854 Ceded Territories are

available at http://www.fdlrez.com/RM/fdlmaps.htm.

5

The Great Lakes Indian Fish & Wildlife Commission published this report and a copy is available at https://www.glifwc.

org/publications/pdf/OTRUI2006.pdf.

3

Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (“NPDES”)

permitting scheme prevents all point source discharges that impact Reservation surface waters and

interfere with the Band’s usufructuary rights in the

Ceded Territories.

------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

The Band depends on the Clean Water Act to protect its natural resources, including manoomin and

freshwater fish. Manoomin and fish are central elements of the Ojibwe diet, and also play an important

cultural, spiritual, and economic role in the life of Band

members. Pollutants regulated under the Clean Water

Act, for example, sulfate and mercury, directly threaten

the manoomin and freshwater fish Band members consume; Petitioner’s proposed limitation on the Clean

Water Act’s reach would have devastating consequences

for the Band’s resources.

Upstream from the Fond du Lac Reservation and

in the Ceded Territories lie large iron ore and precious

metal reserves. Mining companies mine, or propose to

mine, those mineral reserves, posing real threats to

water quality in Minnesota’s water-rich environment.

The Clean Water Act’s plain language requires, as

the Ninth Circuit concluded, permitting for pollutants

discharged from a point source through groundwater

to navigable waters. The canons of construction instruct

that this Court must derive a statute’s meaning from

the words used in the statute without supplementation.

4

Yet, Petitioner asks this Court to do the opposite, seeking to supplement the statutory text to limit its reach

to “any direct addition of any pollutant to a navigable

water from any point source.” Congress, however, prohibited any person from making “any addition” – direct

or indirect, continuous or intermittent, permanent or

temporary – of any pollutant to navigable waters from

any point source without a permit.

Petitioner’s proposed loophole in the Clean Water

Act would allow dischargers to avoid the Clean Water

Act’s reach by simply moving an outfall underground

or onto a beach, leaving surface waters unprotected

and contravening the Clean Water Act’s purpose. Contrary to Petitioner’s assertions, other regulatory requirements do not provide sufficient protections. For

example, Minnesota’s surface water quality standard

to protect manoomin requires no higher sulfate concentration than 10 mg/L; the groundwater standard allows for a sulfate concentration of 250 mg/L. Petitioner

simply errs when it asserts that other regulatory regimes can plug the gaping hole Petitioner’s interpretation leaves in the bedrock law intended to restore and

maintain the integrity of the Nation’s waters.

------------------------------------------------------------------

5

ARGUMENT

I.

THE BAND RELIES ON THE CLEAN WATER

ACT TO PROTECT CRITICAL NATURAL

RESOURCES FROM LARGE INDUSTRIAL

POLLUTERS

The Band relies on the Clean Water Act to protect

critical natural resources. Traditionally, Ojibwe people,

also known as Anishinaabeg or Chippewa, were hunters, fishers, and gatherers, living on both sides of the

Great Lakes in what is now United States and Canada.

Arnold & Erickson, supra, at 6-7. Ojibwe people continue to consume diets rich in traditional foods, including manoomin and fish. For decades, large industrial

point sources in the Ceded Territories have discharged,

or plan to discharge, through groundwater into surface

waters. These discharges contain contaminants that

decimate manoomin stands and expose Band members

to toxins in the food they eat.

A. Production And Consumption Of Traditional Foods, Including Manoomin And

Freshwater Fish, Are Important To The

Ojibwe.

Ojibwe culture is rooted in caring for the earth.

See Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, Expanding the Narrative of Tribal Health: The Effects of

Wild Rice Water Quality Rules Changes on Tribal Health,

15 (2018) [hereinafter, “Wild Rice Tribal Health Study”].6

6

A copy of Wild Rice Trial Health Study is available at https://

www.health.state.mn.us/communities/environment/hia/hiainmn.html.

6

As such, Ojibwe people, living in an environment dominated by lakes and streams, produce and consume

greater quantities of foods cultivated in freshwater.

See id. at 33; J. A. Foran et al., Evaluation of Mercury

Exposure Reduction through a Fish Consumption Advisory Program for Anishinaabe Tribal Members in

Northern Wisconsin, Michigan, and Minnesota, 2010 J.

Envtl. & Pub. Health 1, 1 (2010).7

Two resources of particular importance to the

Ojibwe are manoomin and freshwater fish; large industrial point sources in the Ceded Territories threaten

both resources.

1. Manoomin

Manoomin is an aquatic grass native to North

America. Minn. Dep’t of Nat. Res., Natural Wild Rice

in Minnesota 7 (2008) [hereinafter, “Natural Wild

Rice”].8 Manoomin is a spiritual, cultural, social, nutritional, and medicinal staple of the Ojibwe. Manoomin’s

importance is rooted in Ojibwe history and spirituality.

According to Ojibwe oral tradition, the Ojibwe originally resided along the Atlantic Coast. See Wild Rice

Tribal Health Study, supra, at 8. Seven prophets came

to the Ojibwe during a time of prosperity and left the

Ojibwe with seven predictions about the future, known

7

A copy of this article is available at https://www.hindawi.

com/journals/jeph/2010/802584/ (select “Full-Text PDF”).

8

A copy of this article is available at https://files.dnr.state.mn.

us/fish_wildlife/wildlife/shallowlakes/natural-wild-rice-in-minnesota.

pdf.

7

as the Seven Fires Prophesy. See April E. Lindala,

Anishinaabe Migration and History on the Marquette

Iron Range, https://lib.nmu.edu/voices/anishinaabe.php

(last visited July 16, 2019). The prophets instructed

the Ojibwe to travel west until they reached a place

where food grew upon the water. Wild Rice Tribal

Health Study, supra, at 8. For over five centuries, the

Ojibwe migrated west to the Great Lakes region,

stretching across the upper Midwestern United States

and central Canadian provinces. Thomas Vennum,

Wild Rice and the Ojibway People 1 (1988).

Since arrival, the Ojibwe relied on manoomin – the

food that grows on water – to sustain them physically,

socially, and spiritually. See Wild Rice Tribal Health

Study, supra, at 8, 15-16. The migration and fulfillment of the prophesies are essential elements of the

teachings of the Seven Fires Prophesy, which forms the

spiritual backbone of Ojibwe people. See id.; see also

Lindala, supra.

Ojibwe people use manoomin in their cultural

practices, social traditions, nutrition, and medicinal

customs. See Wild Rice Tribal Health Study, supra, at

8, 15-16. Manoomin plays a central role in ceremonies

and celebrations, which perpetuate and protect its connection to the survival of the Ojibwe. Vennum, supra,

at 58-59. Manoomin is also a healthy, traditional food.

Wild Rice Tribal Health Study, supra, at 3. Manoomin

has been referred to as a “super food” because it offers

a healthy composition of protein, minerals, vitamins,

dietary fiber, healthy carbohydrates, and low fat content. Id. at 33-37; see also U.S. Dep’t of Agric., Basic

8

Report 20089, Wild Rice, Cooked (2019) (describing manoomin’s nutritional properties).9

Finally, the seasonal manoomin harvest offers important economic opportunity for Ojibwe harvesters,

their tribes, and their business communities. This economic benefit, while separate from the cultural importance of manoomin, is important to tribal economic

development, providing hundreds of jobs, millions of

dollars in labor income, and millions more in direct and

indirect economic effect, all largely in regions where

economic growth is needed. See Wild Rice Tribal Health

Study, supra, at 46-47; see also Earth Economics, The

Food That Grows Out of the Water: The Economic Benefits of Wild Rice in Minnesota 4 (2018).10

In sum, manoomin is a social, cultural, spiritual,

nutritional, medicinal, and economic resource for the

Band.

2. Freshwater Fish

Ojibwe people also have a deep connection to freshwater fish and harvesting. Catherine A. O’Neill, Environmental Justice in the Tribal Context: A Madness to

EPA’s Method, 38 Envtl. L. 495, 510 (2008). Not only do

fish act as an important means of subsistence, fish are

also culturally, spiritually, and politically important.

9

A copy of this report is available at https://ndb.nal.usda.

gov/ndb/foods/show/20089.

10

A copy of this report is available at http://www.fdlrez.com/

RM/downloads/WQSWildRiceBenefits.pdf.

9

Id. at 509-10. Fishing fosters economic independence

among tribal members and provides an important nutritional resource. Id. at 510. Traditional ceremonies

also include fish as a central element. Id. And Ojibwe

people transfer important cultural knowledge when

they fish together. Id.

Fishing and consuming fish also plays an important

role in the Band’s ability to exercise its treaty rights

and “engage in cultural self-determination.” Id. Because fish are important to the Ojibwe, Ojibwe people

consume fish at a higher rate than the general public.

Id. at 504, 509-11; see also Fond du Lac Reservation

Office of Water Protection, Tribal Report Under Section

305(b), Clean Water Act 1, 4-5 (2004).11

B. The Band’s Freshwater Resources Are

Sensitive To Water Pollutants, Particularly Sulfate And Mercury.

As a community rooted in caring for the earth and

people focused on consuming resources that come from

freshwater ecosystems, the Band is particularly concerned with point sources discharging pollutants that

damage its resources. In particular, manoomin is highly

sensitive to sulfate discharges and fish consumption

becomes dangerous to human health when fish tissue

becomes contaminated with high levels of methylmercury.

11

This report is available at http://www.fdlrez.com/RM/downloads/

2003%20tribal%20305(b)%20water%20report.pdf.

10

1. Sulfate

As an aquatic species, manoomin grows exclusively in water. Wild Rice Tribal Health Study, supra,

at 47. Ideal habitat for manoomin include water bodies

with some movement, such as rivers, streams, flowages, and lakes with inlets and outlets. Id. at 47-48.

Water depth must either remain stable or decline gradually over the growing season. Id. at 51. Manoomin is

most consistently productive when growing in lake

bottoms with soft, organic sediment. Id. at 47-48.

Historically, manoomin ranged throughout the upper Midwest. Today, however, manoomin’s range has

dramatically diminished due cumulatively to land use

changes, altered hydrology, climate change, invasive

species, and pollution. Id. at 49. Given manoomin’s historical, economic, cultural, spiritual, and ecological importance, the Band has an understandable concern for

the future of manoomin. Id. at 3. One major concern:

sulfate’s effect on manoomin when it converts to sulfide.

Sulfide is a toxic compound known to adversely affect manoomin. Minn. Envtl. Quality Bd., Governor’s

Task Force on Wild Rice 6, 32, 34 (2019).12 Sulfate

interacting with bacteria in water creates sulfide. Id.

at 6. Because manoomin grows exclusively in water,

and sulfate in water becomes toxic sulfide, hydrologic

12

A copy of this report is available at https://www.eqb.

state.mn.us/sites/default/files/documents/FINAL%20Governor%27s

%20Task%20Force%20on%20Wild%20Rice%20Report%20January

%203%202019%20v2.pdf.

11

sulfate discharges can significantly harm manoomin.

Id. at 32. When sulfate becomes sulfide it reduces

manoomin seedling growth and development. Minn.

Tribal Wild Rice Task Force, 2018 Tribal Wild Rice

Task Force Report 23 (2018).13 Seedling emergence,

survival, biomass growth, viable production, and seed

mass all decrease as sulfide levels increase. Id. While

several factors can impact manoomin’s growth and

health, sulfide in sediment porewater has been determined to be a primary controlling feature of manoomin

occurrence. Id. at 23-25.

2. Methylmercury

Methylmercury in fish tissue constitutes another

contaminant with major implications for Band-member

health. Methylmercury occurs when mercury enters

water bodies and is methylated by microorganisms

present in the water. O’Neill, supra, at 500. In this

form, methylmercury is highly bioavailable and easily

absorbed by fish in affected waters. Id. Over time,

methylmercury bioaccumulates in fish, which in turn

acts as a source of methylmercury contamination for

organisms (including humans) consuming those fish.

Id. at 500-01.

Methylmercury is a neurological toxin that is harmful to humans. Mercury, Minn. Pollution Control Agency,

https://www.pca.state.mn.us/water/mercury (last visited

July 16, 2019). In 2011, a Minnesota Department of

13

A copy of this report is available at http://mnchippewatribe.

org/pdf/TWRTF.Report.2018.pdf.

12

Health study found that eight percent of Minnesota

babies born in the Lake Superior basin had unhealthy

levels of mercury, which can affect brain and nervous

system development. Patricia McCann, Mercury Levels

in Blood from Newborns in the Lake Superior Basin 11

(2011).14 Fishing peoples, such as the Ojibwe, face

greater harm from mercury pollution because certain

seasonal or cultural constraints can result in acute

doses of methylmercury when tribal consumption is especially high. O’Neill, supra, at 511.

Methylmercury is especially concerning in the St.

Louis River watershed, the river forming the northern

and eastern border of the Reservation. Fond du Lac

Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, 2008 Integrated Resource Management Plan 19-20 (2008).15 The St. Louis

River watershed’s unique hydrology, geology, and topology more easily converts mercury into methylmercury – the form capable of accumulating in fish. Fish

Contaminant Study, Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, http://www.fdlrez.com/RM/waterfish.htm.

Consequently, mercury discharges into the St. Louis

River and its watershed create human health concerns

for those consuming fish from tribal waters both on the

Reservation and in the Ceded Territories.

14

A copy of the Minnesota Department of Health’s study is

available at https://www.health.state.mn.us/communities/environment/

fish/docs/glnpo.pdf.

15

A copy of the Integrated Resource Management Plan is

available at http://www.fdlrez.com/RM/downloads/IRMP.pdf.

13

C. Large Industrial Point Sources Are Decimating Manoomin With Discharges To

Surface Waters That Migrate Through

Groundwater.

The Ceded Territories intersect two large mineral

deposits: the Mesabi Iron Range and Duluth Complex.

As a result, numerous industrial mining operations

have been proposed or constructed in and around the

Ceded Territories. These large industrial point sources

threaten, or have damaged, manoomin and human

health by adding elevated levels of sulfate to surface

waters by discharging additional mercury in the St.

Louis River and its watershed.

1. Minntac

One example in the Mesabi Iron Range is the Minntac mine. In the 1960s, prior to the Clean Water Act’s

enactment, U.S. Steel Corporation (“U.S. Steel”) constructed Minntac to mine taconite – a low grade iron

ore. Minn. Pollution Control Agency, Draft Minntac

Water Inventory Reduction Environmental Impact

Statement S-1 (2004) [hereinafter, “Minntac EIS”].16

The Minntac facility includes an 8,000-acre tailings

basin,17 used to dispose waste from ore processing. In

16

A copy of the Minntac EIS is available at https://www.

pca.state.mn.us/sites/default/files/minntac-deis.pdf.

17

Federal courts have held that “when mining activities release pollutants from a discernible conveyance, they are subject

to NPDES regulation, as are all point sources.” Trs. for Alaska v.

Envtl. Protection Agency, 749 F.2d 549, 558 (9th Cir. 1984) (discussing consistent findings in 10th and 5th Circuits). This includes

14

re Determination of the Need for an Envtl. Impact

Statement for the Minntac Mine Extension Project in

Mountain Iron, St. Louis Cty., Minn. (“In re Minntac

Extension”), No. A13–0837, 2014 WL 274077, *1 (Minn.

Ct. App. 2014). During the ore-extraction process, U.S.

Steel mixes the waste – known as fine tailings – with

water to create a slurry. Minntac EIS at S-5. U.S. Steel

discharges the slurry into the tailings basin. Findings

of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order ¶ 3, In re Reissuance of an NPDES/SDS Permit to U.S. Steel Corp. for

Its Minntac Facility (Minn. Pollution Control Agency

Nov. 30, 2018) [hereinafter, “Minntac Reissuance Order”].18 The slurry fills the tailings basin with pollutants, including sulfate. See In re Minntac Extension,

2014 WL 274077, at *1.

U.S. Steel installed environmental controls, but

designed the tailings basin to release contaminated

water into the environment. Minntac Reissuance Order ¶¶ 5-7. U.S. Steel surrounded the tailings basin

with dikes, but declined to install a liner or other

barrier to prevent contaminated water from seeping

through the dikes or the bottom of the tailings basin.

Id. ¶¶ 6-7. As a result, the tailings basin discharges

tailings basins. Wash. Wilderness Coal. v. Hecla Min. Co., 870

F. Supp. 983, 988 (E.D. Wash. 1994); see also Trs. for Alaska, 749

F.2d at 558 (sluice boxes); Ohio Valley Envtl. Coal., Inc. v. Hernshaw Ptnrs., LLC, 984 F. Supp. 2d 589, 599, (S.D. W. Va. 2013)

(mining valley fill); Friends of Santa Fe Cty. v. LAC Minerals, Inc.,

892 F. Supp. 1333, 1355 (D.N.M. 1995) (overburden piles).

18

A copy of the Minntac Reissuance Order is available at https://

www.pca.state.mn.us/sites/default/files/wq-wwprm1-28f.pdf.

15

pollution through groundwater into adjacent surface

waters. Id.

In 2005, the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency

estimated seepage discharges were approximately

3,000 gallons per minute, equaling 1.5 billion gallons

of wastewater per year. See Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order ¶ 8, In re Determination of Adequacy of the Envtl. Impact Statement for the U.S. Steel

– Minntac Water Inventory Reduction Project Mountain Iron, Minn. (Minn. Pollution Control Agency Nov.

22, 2005) [hereinafter, “Minntac Adequacy Order”].19

Since then, U.S. Steel installed a seepage collection and

return system, but approximately 1,000 gallons per

minute continue to escape. Minn. Pollution Control

Agency, National Pollutant Elimination System (NPDES)/

State Disposal System (SDS) Permit Program Fact Sheet

Permit Reissuance 11-12 (2016) [hereinafter, “NPDES

Fact Sheet”].20

19

A copy of the Minntac Adequacy Order is available at https://

www.pca.state.mn.us/sites/default/files/minntac-sd.pdf.

20

A copy of the NPDES Fact Sheet is available at https://

www.pca.state.mn.us/sites/default/files/Fact%20Sheet%20-%20MN

0057207%20-%202016_2.pdf

16

Figure 1. Minntac Tailings Basin.21

A copy of this map is available in NPDES Fact Sheet,

supra, at 14, fig. 2.

21

17

The tailings basin’s contaminated water discharges

into two watersheds: the Sand River and Dark River.

The Twin Lakes – also known as Sandy Lake and Little Sandy Lake – lie immediately to the east. Darren J.

Vogt, Sandy Lake and Little Sandy Lake Monitoring

(2010-2017) 2 (2018).22 The Twin Lakes outlet to the

Sand River which merges into the Pike River and, ultimately, Lake Vermillion; all are manoomin-producing

lakes and rivers. Kim Lapakko & Ann Jagunich, Sulfate Release from the USX Tailings Basin and Quantification of Sulfate Sources 1-2 (1991); see also MPCA

Wild Rice Database, https://www.pca.state.mn.us/document/wq-s6-43xxlsx (last visited July 16, 2019).

The Twin Lakes once hosted vibrant manoomin

stands. Lapakko & Jagunich, supra, at 1-2. Historically, the Twin Lakes could seasonally produce 200

acres of manoomin. Id. at 1. Since the 1980s, however,

manoomin production has steadily declined. See id.

(noting “fair” crops in 1980 and 1981 and “poor” corps

in 1982 and 1984-1987); see also Vogt, supra, at 16.

(“Rice production generally declined through the 1970s

and 1980s, with little or no rice found in the lakes during a 1987 survey. Rice production has since remained

poor.”). Scientists and Minnesota agencies attribute

the decimation of the Twin Lakes’ manoomin stands

to the extremely high sulfate levels in the contaminated water seeping from Minntac’s tailings basin. See

Lawrence A. Baker, Evaluation of Minntac Tailings

22

A copy of this report is available at http://www.1854treaty

authority.org/management/biological-resources/fisheries/reports.

html?id=122&task=document.viewdoc.

18

Basin on Little Sandy and Sandy Lakes 12 (2016); Letter from Melissa Thompson, Wildlife Lake Specialist,

Minn. Dep’t of Nat. Res, to Erik Smith, Industrial Division, Minn. Pollution Control Agency (Jan. 24, 2018)

(“When the Twin Lakes sulfate amounts range from

66.4 mg/L to 589 mg/L in 2017, and other lakes in the

area have natural sulfate amounts around 1-3 mg/L, it

is difficult to not acknowledge the impact the seepage

is having on downstream habitats.”) (on file with Counsel of Record). As of 2017, sulfate levels ranged up to

589 mg/L, more than fifty-eight times higher than the

state water quality standard with an overall upward

trend. Letter from Thompson to Smith, supra, at 2; see

also Minn. R. 7050.0224 (setting a 10mg/L water quality standard for sulfates); Letter from Margaret Watkins, Grand Portage Water Quality Specialist, and

Nancy Schuldt, Fond du Lac Water Projects Coordinator, to Erik Smith, Minnesota Pollution Control Agency

3 (Dec. 22, 2016) (illustrating the trend in sulfate levels

over time) (on file with Counsel of Record).

Minntac is only one example of the threat manoomin faces from large industrial polluters in the

Ceded Territories. Large mining companies own mineral leases, have explored those mineral resources, and

proposed future mining projects within the Ceded Territories. Those projects, like Minntac, risk discharging

sulfate into manoomin-growing waters in the Ceded

Territories with high levels of sulfate. The Reservation,

the 1854 Ceded Territory, current mining projects, and

the St. Louis River watershed are illustrated in the

map below:

19

Figure 2. 1854 Ceded Territory with Mine Locations.23

23

Heather Fox, a GIS Specialist for the Grand Portage Reservation, created this map for the Band’s use.

20

2. PolyMet

An example from the Duluth Complex provides

an illustration for how industrial point sources discharging to surface water through groundwater could

increase mercury concentrations if Petitioner’s Clean

Water Act interpretation prevails. Poly Met Mining,

Inc. (“PolyMet”) proposed a copper-nickel mine in the

St. Louis River watershed. Minn. Dep’t of Nat. Res., Final Environmental Impact Statement 1-5 (2015) [hereinafter, “PolyMet FEIS”].24 PolyMet intends to release

water contaminated with mercury into the groundwater from two sources.

For a waste rock stockpile, PolyMet proposes to release contaminated water into the groundwater, capture the contaminated groundwater, and subsequently

treat the contaminated water prior to discharge at

an outfall.25 Barr Eng’g, NPDES/SDS Permit Application, Vol. II at 42 (2017) [hereinafter, “NPDES Application”].26 PolyMet knows some water will escape

the capture system and reach surface waters. PolyMet

24

A copy of the PolyMet FEIS is available at https://files.dnr.

state.mn.us/input/environmentalreview/polymet/feis/NMet_FEIS_

Complete.pdf.

25

The waste rock stockpile is known to be “a major source of

sulfate.” Don E. Richard, Summary of Non-Mechanical Treatment

Plans for PolyMet 4 (2016).

26

A copy of the NPDES Application is available at https://www.

pca.state.mn.us/regulations/water-quality-permit-northmet (select

“NPDES/SDS Permit Application – Vol. II: Mine Site”).

21

Mining, NorthMet Project Adaptive Water Management

Plan 20 (2017).27

PolyMet also plans to use an existing, Minntac-like

tailings basin – known to discharge water contaminated

with mercury through groundwater to surface waters

– and add more waste to the basin. NPDES Application, supra, Vol. V, at 13-14; PolyMet FEIS, supra, at

4-41. PolyMet’s proposed method to protect the environment is to allow contaminated water to seep into

the groundwater, capture the contaminated groundwater, and either send the water back to the tailings basin

or treat the water prior to discharge. NPDES Application, supra, at 20-22. But again, PolyMet knows the

containment system will not collect all pollutants and

those that escape will discharge through groundwater

to surface waters. Barr Eng’g, Groundwater Modeling

of the NorthMet Flotation Tailings Basin Containment

System 2 (2015); Barr Eng’g, NorthMet Project Water

Modeling Data Package Volume 2 160-68 (2015).28

PolyMet illustrates that industrial polluters will

continue production and propose new projects that discharge, or have the potential to discharge, mercury into

the St. Louis River watershed. PolyMet also illustrates

how designed projects like PolyMet could be easily

modified to remove containment systems and allow

27

A copy of the NorthMet Project Adaptive Water Management Plan is available at https://files.dnr.state.mn.us/lands_

minerals/northmet/permit_to_mine/appendix_11_4_dec17.pdf.

28

A copy of this report is available at https://files.dnr.state.

mn.us/lands_minerals/northmet/water-approp/references/plant-sitewater-model-data-package-vol2-v11.pdf.

22

discharges into surface waters through groundwater

with no treatment at all. Without the Clean Water Act,

protecting the Band from these discharges will be

much more difficult.

For the foregoing reasons, the Band asserts the

Minntac and PolyMet examples strongly support the

Ninth Circuit’s and Respondents’ Clean Water Act interpretation.

II.

THIS COURT SHOULD ADOPT RESPONDENTS’ CLEAN WATER ACT INTERPRETATION BECAUSE IT IS CONSISTENT WITH

THE PLAIN LANGUAGE AND PROTECTS

IMPORTANT TRIBAL RESOURCES

Under existing federal environmental laws, the

Clean Water Act’s plain language represents the only

statutory path to protect the Band’s natural resources

from point source discharges. Petitioner’s and the U.S.

Environmental Protection Agency’s (“EPA”) proffered

interpretations undermine these protections and allow

large industrial discharges to destroy the Band’s natural resources in the Ceded Territories. Therefore, consistent with the Clean Water Act’s plain language and

purpose, the Band respectfully requests this Court

adopt Respondents’ Clean Water Act interpretation.

23

A. The Clean Water Act’s Plain Language

Includes Discharges Fairly Traceable

To A Point Source.

The Clean Water Act’s clear prohibition that it is

illegal to discharge a pollutant from a point source to a

navigable water without a NPDES permit includes circumstances, such as those at issue in this case, where

a discharger injects treated sewage through groundwater to a navigable water. Similarly, applying the

facts related to the Band’s protection of manoomin and

freshwater fish, the Clean Water Act’s prohibitions include circumstances where pollutants are discharged

from a tailings basin through groundwater to navigable waters and damage the Band’s natural resources.

To conclude otherwise would require this Court to disregard the Clean Water Act’s plain language and purpose.

The Clean Water Act defines the discharge of a pollutant as “any addition of any pollutant to navigable

waters from any point source.” 33 U.S.C. § 1362(12).

Further, a “point source” is a “conveyance” (for example

a “pipe” or “container”) “from which pollutants are or

may be discharged.” 33 U.S.C. § 1362(14). To interpret

this language, the Court must first analyze “the statutory language, ‘assum[ing] that the ordinary meaning

of that language accurately expresses the legislative

purpose.’ ” Hardt v. Reliance Standard Life Ins. Co., 560

U.S. 242, 251 (2010) (quoting Gross v. FBL Fin. Servs.,

Inc., 557 U.S. 167, 175 (2009)). This Court enforces

“plain and unambiguous statutory language according

to its terms.” Id. The Court need not travel “beyond the

borders of the statute” to find the meaning of these

24

definitions. United States v. Great N. Ry., 287 U.S. 144,

154 (1932).

As Justice Scalia described in his treatise on the

canons of statutory construction, courts are guided

by a “supremacy-of-text principle.” Antonin Scalia &

Bryan A. Garner, Reading Law: The Interpretation of

Legal Texts 56 (2012). A statute’s purpose “must be derived from the text” and that purpose must be “defined

precisely” and “described as concretely as possible.” Id.

at 56-57. Importantly, what is not included in the text

of a statute is equally as significant in divining its

meaning and purpose. See id. at 57-58 (“[T]he limitations of a text – what a text chooses not to do – are as

much a part of its ‘purpose’ as its affirmative dispositions. These exceptions or limitations must be respected, and the only way to accord them their due is

to reject the replacement or supplementation of text

with purpose.”)

Here, the statute means what it says – when

pollutants are added to a navigable water from any

discrete source, such as a pipe, container, or other “conveyance . . . from which pollutants . . . may be discharged,” the discharge requires a permit under the

Clean Water Act. In Petitioner’s case, no one disputes

that the County adds pollutants (treated effluent) to a

navigable water (Pacific Ocean) from a point source

(injection well). (Pet. Br. 6-7).

Petitioner and its supporting amici curiae ignore

the definition of a pollutant discharge in the Clean Water Act, and instead impose their own purpose on the

Clean Water Act based on a limitation not found in the

25

text. Petitioner argues that the Clean Water Act’s purpose is only to regulate pollutants added directly to

navigable waters from a point source. (Id. at 27-31). In

fact, the text prohibits “any addition,” not just “any direct addition” of pollutants from a point source to navigable waters. Petitioner engages in the exact practice

Justice Scalia condemns and its interpretation should

be rejected.

There are three concepts at issue in the relevant

definition: (1) addition of pollutants, (2) to a navigable

water, (3) from a point source. The Clean Water Act further defines the terms “navigable waters” and “point

sources.” 33 U.S.C. §§ 1362(7), (14). Applying those definitions, no one disputes that the Pacific Ocean constitutes a navigable water, and the injection well, a point

source. The term most relevant to the Court’s certified

question is the word “addition.” What kind of “addition”

is intended? Must the “addition” be direct, or can it be

indirect? Is it still an “addition” if the pollutant moves

through groundwater to reach a navigable water?

The text answers these questions.

The undefined term “addition” is a general word.

“Without some indication to the contrary, general words

(like all words, general or not) must be accorded their

full and fair scope. They should not be arbitrarily limited.” Scalia & Garner, supra, at 101. The word “addition”

means “the act or process of adding; a recipe enhanced

by the addition of freshly ground pepper.” Addition,

Merriam-Webster.com, https://www.merriam-webster.com/

dictionary/addition (last visited July 16, 2019).

26

Far from placing a limitation on the type of addition the Clean Water Act covers, Congress chose to forbid “any addition” of pollutants to navigable waters

from a point source absent a permit. As this Court previously noted “the word ‘any’ has an expansive meaning, that is, ‘one or some indiscriminately of whatever

kind.’ ” United States v. Gonzales, 520 U.S. 1, 5 (1997)

(citing Webster’s Third New International Dictionary

97 (1976)). In Gonzales, the Court construed a mandatory sentencing statute forbidding a sentence that

would run concurrently with “any other term of imprisonment” for certain offenses. Id. The Court rejected an

effort to narrow the statute’s application to only federal offenses because “federal” did not appear in the

statute. Id. “Congress did not add any language limiting the breadth of that word, and so we must read [the

statute] as referring to all ‘term[s] of imprisonment,’

including those imposed by state courts.” Id.

As in Gonzales, here no basis exists to limit the

Clean Water Act which, by its plain text, prohibits “any

addition” – that is, an addition “of whatever kind” – of

pollutants to navigable waters from a point source. By

using the term “any,” Congress expressly included all

kinds of additions – direct or indirect, continuous or

intermittent, permanent or temporary, etc.

Petitioner’s interpretation requires this Court to

re-write the statute, adding a modifier to the statutory

definition so it would read: “any direct addition of any

pollutant to a navigable water from any point source.”

This Court’s canons of construction do not allow such

a re-write. The Court “must enforce plain and

27

unambiguous statutory language according to its

terms.” Hardt, 560 U.S. at 251. That includes not adding words to a statute. Id. (where “prevailing party”

does not appear in fee shifting statute, it is error to

limit eligibility for fees to prevailing parties). Indeed,

Petitioner’s argument, which asks the Court to add unincluded terms, seeks to “invent” rather than “interpret” the statute. Id.

For these reasons, the Ninth Circuit and Respondents correctly interpret the Clean Water Act, and this

Court should reject Petitioner’s misconstruction.

B. The County’s Interpretation Would Not

Protect The Band’s Important Natural

Resources.

The interpretation Petitioner and supporting amici

offer, if adopted by this Court, would have severe consequences for water quality and natural resource protection. A narrow construction that exempts any point

source pollutant discharge through groundwater to

navigable waters from the Clean Water Act threatens

the Band’s resources both on the Reservation and in

the Ceded Territories.

1. Dischargers could easily evade the

Clean Water Act permit requirement.

Resources on the Reservation and within the

Ceded Territories lie downstream from numerous permitted water pollution discharges regulated under the

Clean Water Act. Watershed Health Assessment

28

Framework, Minn. Dep’t Nat. Resources, http://bit.

ly/2Yhq2Sm (mapping tool that highlights all upstream feedlots, wastewater treatment facilities, and

open pit mines). Dischargers include both publiclyowned facilities like wastewater treatment works, as

well as private industries like mines, paper mills, and

power plants. Many of these discharges flow into the

St. Louis River watershed and include pollutants ranging from bacteria and nutrients to heavy metals and

other toxics.

As described above, the St. Louis River and its watershed are vitally important to the Band. See Part

I.B.2. Due to historic, pre-Clean Water Act pollution,

the St. Louis River was designated a Great Lakes

Area of Concern in 1987. Sediment Studies: St. Louis

River Area of Concern, Minn. Pollution Control Agency,

https://www.pca.state.mn.us/water/sediment-studies-stlouis-river-area-concern (last visited July 16, 2019).

Overall, more than $420 million has been invested in

the St. Louis River’s clean-up and restoration since its

designation. Minn. Pollution Control Agency et al., A

Roadmap to Delisting: St. Louis River Area of Concern

Remedial Action Plan Update 2 (2013).29 Yet mining

companies continue to propose new projects – like

PolyMet – that without stringent Clean Water Act protections could stymie the progress made to remediate

the St. Louis River watershed.

29

A copy of the Remedial Action Plan Update is available

at https://stlouisriver.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Roadmap

SummaryBrochureSLR2013.pdf.

29

The rigid pipe-into-water interpretation Petitioner

seeks to force on the statute contravenes the Clean Water Act’s purpose and creates a perverse incentive for

dischargers to simply discharge unregulated, nonpoint

source pollution. In the National Association of Clean

Water Agencies et al.’s Amicus Brief, for example, amici

assert that a “discrete source of pollution cannot be a

point source when groundwater or another intervening

nonpoint source diffuses pollutants and carries them

to navigable waters.” (Amicus Curiae Nat’l Ass’n of

Clean Water Agencies Br., 9). In other words, amici

suggest that if the pollution from a discrete source –

wastewater in a pipe, for instance – is first diffused –

sprayed on the ground, for example – it is beyond the

reach of the Clean Water Act’s permitting program.

Such a rule would eviscerate the Clean Water Act.

What would prevent existing or new dischargers from

simply removing their outfalls from a surface water

and instead placing them into adjacent groundwater,

or allowing them to discharge on beaches or fields, or

even spraying them as mist into the air? In PolyMet’s

case, this would require little more than removing the

containment systems and simply allowing contaminates to flow into the groundwater untreated.

Petitioner’s interpretation threatens decades of

achievement to clean the Nation’s surface waters, creating an incentive for polluters to design their discharges to travel through a “nonpoint” to avoid the

need for a NPDES permit. The giant loophole Petitioner’s interpretation would create contravenes Congress’s intent to “restore and maintain the chemical,

30

physical, and biological integrity of the Nation’s waters.” 33 U.S.C. § 1251(a). The plain meaning of the

statutory text compels the result the Ninth Circuit

reached. The Clean Water Act’s prohibition applies to

any addition of pollutants to navigable waters from a

point source, not just direct discharges.

2. Petitioner’s assertion that other regulatory requirements sufficiently control groundwater-mediated discharges

to surface waters is inaccurate.

Maintaining Clean Water Act jurisdiction over

point sources that contaminate surface waters through

groundwater seepage is vital to the protection of manoomin in the Ceded Territories. Petitioner suggests

Clean Water Act jurisdiction is unnecessary because

other existing laws provide the protections the Clean

Water Act affords – particularly state laws governing

groundwater and drinking water, and the federal Safe

Drinking Water Act (“SDWA”), Coastal Zone Act (“CZA”),

Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensations, and Liability Act (“CERCLA”), and Resource

Conservation and Recovery Act (“RCRA”). (Pet. Br. 43-44).

But Minntac and its damage to manoomin exemplify

why limiting the Clean Water Act would allow unregulated discharges to contaminate surface waters and,

thereby, destroy the Band’s important resource.

31

a. State Groundwater Protection

Petitioners contend state groundwater protection

laws sufficiently regulate underground discharges

from point sources such that Clean Water Act jurisdiction is superfluous. (Pet. Br. 43). But in Minnesota,

standards governing groundwater are not equivalent

to surface water standards and are often inadequate to

protect the natural environment, including the protection of manoomin. Where the Clean Water Act’s purpose extends to preserving the biological integrity of

the Nation’s waters, see 33 U.S.C. § 1251(a), Minnesota’s groundwater laws focus on groundwater’s importance for human consumption, see Minn. R. 7050.0140

(designating Class 1 waters for “[d]omestic consumption”); 7050.0221 (underground waters designated

Class 1); 7060.0200 (nondegradation policy focused

on maintaining a potable water supply for future generations). Consequently, Minnesota sets groundwater

standards based on impact to human health, rather

than impact on the environment.

Minntac’s sulfate discharges illustrate why Minnesota’s groundwater laws would not sufficiently protect

the biological integrity of surface waters, particularly

those with manoomin. Sulfate occurs naturally in

much of Minnesota’s groundwater. See Sulfate in Well

Water, Minn. Dep’t of Health, https://www.health.state.

mn.us/communities/environment/water/wells/waterquality/

sulfate.html, (last visited July 16, 2019). While humans unaccustomed to drinking water with elevated

sulfate may experience diarrhea, most adjust after a

few days. Id. The Minnesota Department of Health’s

32

only precautions for human sulfate consumption are

that water exceeding 250 mg/L may have a “bitter” or

“medical taste” and that water with sulfate levels exceeding 500 mg/L should not be used to prepare infant

formula. Id. Correlated with these human health determinations, Minnesota’s groundwater water quality

standard for sulfate is 250 mg/L. See Minn. R. 7050.0220,

subpts. 3a(30), 4a(30) (Class 1B and 1C waters 250

mg/L); 7050.0221, subpts. 1-2 (Class 1A waters apply

EPA standards); 40 C.F.R. § 143.3 (secondary maximum contaminant level for sulfate 250 mg/L).

In contrast, as set forth above, manoomin is very

susceptible to sulfate levels. See Part I.B.1. In 1973, the

Minnesota Pollution Control Agency adopted Minn. R.

7050.0224, subpt. 2 “to protect and support the growth

of manoomin in Minnesota, and to comply with Clean

Water Act requirements set by the U.S. Environmental

Protection Agency.” Minn. Chamber of Commerce v.

Minn. Pollution Control Agency, No. A12-0950, 2012

WL 6554544, at *1 (Minn. Ct. App. Dec. 17, 2012). Minnesota set the surface water quality standard for sulfate at 10 mg/L, see Minn. R. 7050.0224, subpt. 2,

based, in part, on the Minnesota Department of Natural Resource’s recommendations that “sulfate concentrations above that level are a ‘serious detriment to the

natural and cultivated growth of wild rice.’ ” Minn.

Chamber of Commerce, 2012 WL 6554544, at *1.

Plainly, without the surface water 10 mg/L standard, protecting, for example, the Twin Lakes from contamination via underground seepage from Minntac’s

tailings basin would be almost impossible. Seeps from

33

under the tailings basin could discharge with sulfate

levels twenty-five times higher than the surface water

standard, in compliance with Minnesota groundwater

law, and continue to deplete the manoomin in the Twin

Lakes. Consequently, eliminating Clean Water Act jurisdiction over discharges from point sources to surface

water through groundwater would undermine the ability of the Band to protect this natural resource now

and into the future.

b. CZA, RCRA, SDWA, CERCLA, and

Related State Laws

Petitioners also assert the CZA, RCRA, SDWA,

CERCLA, and related state laws adequately regulate

groundwater and surface water pollution such that

Clean Water Act jurisdiction is unnecessary. (Pet. Br.

43-44). Minntac, however, exemplifies exactly why these

statutory schemes do not target the point source discharges Congress intended the Clean Water Act to regulate.

First, Petitioners point to the CZA as evidence

that sufficient environmental protection exists outside

the Clean Water Act. (Id. at 44). But the CZA only protects coastal zones, not inland waters like those on the

Mesabi Iron Range. See 16 U.S.C. § 1455b(a)(1). Thus,

for obvious reasons, the CZA would not protect manoomin from the Minntac discharges.

Second, Petitioners assert RCRA and its accompanying regulations allow EPA to “control[ ] and remediate[ ] groundwater contamination.” (Pet. Br. 44).

34

“RCRA is a comprehensive environmental statute that

governs the treatment, storage, and disposal of solid

and hazardous waste.” Meghrig v. KFC W., Inc., 516

U.S. 479, 483 (1996). Congress intended RCRA “to reduce the generation of hazardous waste and to ensure

the proper treatment, storage, and disposal of that

waste which is nonetheless generated, ‘so as to minimize the present and future threat to human health

and the environment.’ ” Id. (quoting 42 U.S.C. § 6902(b)).

But RCRA does not apply to all solid waste; in fact,

Congress specifically exempted “[s]pent materials . . .

generated within the primary mineral processing industry from which minerals, acids, cyanide, water, or

other values are recovered by mineral processing or by

beneficiation.” 40 C.F.R. § 261.4(a)(17); see also Minn.

R. 7045.0120 (Minnesota’s exemption that mine waste

is not hazardous waste). RCRA, thus, does not apply

to the waste discharged into the environment from

Minntac’s tailings basin.

The SDWA similarly would not protect manoomin

from Minntac’s discharges. In particular, Petitioners

point to the SDWA Part C, governing underground injection control wells, as protective of groundwater. (Pet.

Br. 43). Congress intended Part C “to assure that underground sources of drinking water will not be endangered by any underground injection.” Nat. Res. Def.

Council, Inc. v. Envtl. Protection Agency, 824 F.2d 1258,

1268 (1st Cir. 1987). But Part C specifically applies to

“well[s],” meaning “[a] bored, drilled, or driven shaft

whose depth is greater than the largest surface dimension; or, a dug hole whose depth is greater than the

35

largest surface dimension; or, an improved sinkhole;

or, a subsurface fluid distribution system.” 40 C.F.R.

§ 146.3. The seeps underneath Minntac’s tailings basin

do not meet this definition; the seepage occurs because

the basin is not lined and designed to leak. Minntac

Reissuance Order ¶¶ 5-7.

More generally, however, Congress intended the

SDWA “to assure that the water supply systems serving the public meet minimum national standards for

protection of public health.” H.R. Rep. No. 1185, at 1

(1974) (emphasis added). As such, while the Minnesota

Department of Health lists sulfate in its “List of Contaminants in Water,” as discussed above, the Minnesota Department of Health has few concerns regarding

sulfate, as it naturally occurs in wells throughout the

state. Sulfate in Well Water, supra. Consequently, the

SDWA and state regulations do not protect manoomin

from sulfate contamination where sulfate levels too

high for manoomin are considered safe for human consumption.

Finally, Petitioner avers that CERCLA protects

groundwater from “hazardous substances” such that

regulating point source discharges under the Clean

Water Act is unnecessary. (Pet. Br. 44). But Congress

fundamentally intended CERCLA to serve a very different purpose than the Clean Water Act: promoting

clean-up efforts for sites already contaminated with

hazardous waste. See Burlington N. & Santa Fe Ry. Co.

v. United States, 556 U.S. 599, 602 (2009). This contrasts with the Clean Water Act’s broader purpose to

not only “restore” the Nation’s waters, but also to

36

“maintain” the waters by preventing future pollution.

See 33 U.S.C. § 1251(a). Further, sulfate arguably does

not meet the “hazardous substance” definition under

CERCLA. See 42 U.S.C. § 9601(14); Rhodes v. Cty. of

Darlington, S.C., 833 F. Supp. 1163, 1178 (D.S.C. 1992);

40 C.F.R. § 302.4; see also Minn. Stat. §§ 115B.01115B.53. Thus, the sulfate discharges from Minntac

would not qualify the facility for CERCLA remediation.

For these reasons, Petitioner’s interpretation not

only undermines the Clean Water Act, it leaves valuable

environmental resources unprotected by any federal or

state scheme. The Band asks this Court to apply the

Clean Water Act’s plain language, interpret the statute

consistent with the Clean Water Act’s purpose, and apply the Clean Water Act in a way that protects the

Band’s important natural resources.

------------------------------------------------------------------

CONCLUSION

Because the Ninth Circuit’s and Respondents’

Clean Water Act interpretation is consistent with the

Clean Water Act’s plain language and such an interpretation is necessary to protect the Band’s important

37

resources, amicus curiae urges the Court to affirm the

Ninth Circuit’s decision.

Respectfully submitted,

ELISE L. LARSON

Counsel of Record

KEVIN S. REUTHER

MINNESOTA CENTER FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCACY

1919 University Avenue West, Ste. 515

St. Paul, MN 55104-3435

651-223-5969

elarson@mncenter.org

Counsel for Amicus Curiae

JULY 19, 2019

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.