Opposition Brief — California Sea Urchin Commission, et al., Petitioners v. Susan Combs, Acting Assistant Secretary for Fish, Wildlife, and Parks, et al.
Supreme Court briefSep 14, 2018
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 17-1636
In the Supreme Court of the United States
CALIFORNIA SEA URCHIN COMMISSION, ET AL.,
PETITIONERS
v.
SUSAN COMBS, ACTING ASSISTANT SECRETARY
FOR FISH, WILDLIFE, AND PARKS, ET AL.
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
BRIEF FOR THE FEDERAL RESPONDENTS
IN OPPOSITION
NOEL J. FRANCISCO
Solicitor General
Counsel of Record
JEFFREY H. WOOD
Acting Assistant Attorney
General
ANDREW C. MERGEN
RACHEL HERON
Attorneys
Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530-0001
SupremeCtBriefs@usdoj.gov
(202) 514-2217
QUESTION PRESENTED
The southern sea otter, or California sea otter, is a
threatened species protected by the Endangered Species
Act of 1973, 16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq., and Marine Mammal
Protection Act of 1972, 16 U.S.C. 1361 et seq. In support
of conservation efforts by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service), Congress also enacted species-specific
legislation providing that the Service “may develop and
implement * * * a plan for the relocation and management of a population of California sea otters from the existing range of the parent population to another location,” and articulating several “specifications” for any
plan that the Service chose to adopt. Act of Nov. 7, 1986,
Pub. L. No. 99-625, § 1(b), 100 Stat. 3500 (capitalization
omitted). The Service decided to exercise this discretionary authority and, in 1987, promulgated regulations to
create an experimental population by relocating sea otters to San Nicolas Island, California. In 2012, the Service determined that the plan had failed to achieve its
purposes and repealed the implementing regulations.
The question presented is whether the court of appeals correctly upheld the Service’s determination that
it had the statutory authority to repeal the implementing
regulations after determining that the plan had failed to
achieve its purposes.
(I)
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Opinions below .............................................................................. 1
Jurisdiction .................................................................................... 1
Statement ...................................................................................... 2
Argument..................................................................................... 17
Conclusion ................................................................................... 28
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases:
Americans for Clean Energy v. EPA, 864 F.3d 691
(D.C. Cir. 2017) ................................................................... 25
Anna Jacques Hosp. v. Burwell, 797 F.3d 1155
(D.C. Cir. 2015) ................................................................... 25
Bayou Lawn & Landscape Servs. v. Secretary of
Labor, 713 F.3d 1080 (11th Cir. 2013) .............................. 26
Catawba County v. EPA, 571 F.3d 20 (D.C. Cir.
2009) ..................................................................................... 25
Chamber of Commerce of the U.S. v. NLRB,
721 F.3d 152 (4th Cir. 2013) ............................................... 26
Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Res. Def. Council,
Inc., 467 U.S. 837 (1984) ......................................... 15, 16, 18
EPA v. EME Homer City Generation, L.P.,
134 S. Ct. 1584 (2014) ......................................................... 19
Entergy Corp. v. Riverkeeper, Inc., 556 U.S. 208
(2009) .................................................................................... 19
Food & Drug Admin. v. Brown & Williamson
Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000) ............................. 19, 24
Gonzales v. Oregon, 546 U.S. 243 (2006) ............................. 24
Halo Elecs., Inc. v. Pulse Elecs., Inc., 136 S. Ct. 1923
(2016) .................................................................................... 21
Holloway v. United States, 526 U.S. 1 (1999) ..................... 18
(III)
IV
Cases—Continued:
Page
Louisiana Pub. Serv. Comm’n v. FCC, 476 U.S. 355
(1986) .................................................................................... 19
Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (1992) .... 12, 28
MCI Telecomms. Corp. v. AT&T Co., 512 U.S. 218
(1994) .................................................................................... 24
Marlow v. New Food Guy, Inc., 861 F.3d 1157
(10th Cir. 2017) .................................................................... 26
Methodist Hosp. of Sacramento v. Shalala,
38 F.3d 1225 (D.C. Cir. 1994) ............................................. 25
Monroe Energy, LLC v. EPA, 750 F.3d 909
(D.C. Cir. 2014) ................................................................... 25
Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Ass’n of the U.S., Inc. v. State
Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 463 U.S. 29 (1983) ................. 21
National Cable & Telecomms. Ass’n v. Brand X
Internet Servs., 545 U.S. 967 (2005) .................................. 24
Oregon Rest. & Lodging Ass’n v. Perez,
816 F.3d 1080 (9th Cir. 2016), cert. denied,
138 S. Ct. 2670, and 138 S. Ct. 2697 (2018) ....................... 26
Railway Labor Execs. Ass’n v. National Mediation
Bd., 29 F.3d 655 (D.C. Cir. 1994), cert. denied,
514 U.S. 1032 (1995)............................................................ 25
Steel Co. v. Citizens for a Better Env’t, 523 U.S. 83
(1998) .................................................................................... 27
United States v. Home Concrete & Supply, LLC,
566 U.S. 478 (2012).............................................................. 19
Utility Air Reg. Grp. v. EPA, 134 S. Ct. 2427 (2014) ........ 19
Constitution, statutes, and regulations:
U.S. Const. Art. III ............................................................... 27
Act of Nov. 7, 1986, Pub. L. No. 99-625,
100 Stat. 3500 ........................................................................ 4
§ 1(a)(3), 100 Stat. 3500 ................................................... 22
V
Statutes and regulations—Continued:
Page
§ 1(a)(5)(A), 100 Stat. 3500 ............................................. 22
§ 1(b), 100 Stat. 3500 ............................................... 4, 5, 20
§ 1(b)(3), 100 Stat. 3500 ..................................................... 5
§ 1(b)(3)-(5), 100 Stat. 3500-3501.................................... 22
§ 1(b)(4), 100 Stat. 3501 ................................................. 5, 7
§ 1(b)(4)(B), 100 Stat. 3500 ................................. 5, 8, 9, 22
§ 1(c), 100 Stat. 3501 ........................................................ 22
§ 1(c)(2), 100 Stat. 3501 ..................................................... 5
§ 1(d), 100 Stat. 3501 ....................................................... 22
§ 1(f ), 100 Stat. 3501.......................................................... 4
Endangered Species Act of 1973,
16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq. ............................................................ 2
16 U.S.C. 1532(6) ............................................................... 2
16 U.S.C. 1532(19) ............................................................. 3
16 U.S.C. 1532(20) ............................................................. 2
16 U.S.C. 1533(a)(1) ........................................................... 2
16 U.S.C. 1533(f )(1) ........................................................... 2
16 U.S.C. 1538(a)(1)(B)-(C) .............................................. 2
16 U.S.C. 1539( j)(1) ........................................................... 4
16 U.S.C. 1539( j)(2)(A) ..................................................... 4
Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972,
16 U.S.C. 1361 et seq. ............................................................ 3
16 U.S.C. 1361(2) ............................................................... 3
16 U.S.C. 1362(6) ............................................................... 3
16 U.S.C. 1362(13) ............................................................. 3
16 U.S.C. 1371 .................................................................... 3
16 U.S.C. 1372(a) ............................................................... 3
50 C.F.R.:
Section 17.21(c) .................................................................. 2
Section 17.31(a) .................................................................. 2
Section 17.81(c)(4) ............................................................. 6
VI
Miscellaneous:
Page
131 Cong. Rec. 20,992 (1985) ................................................ 22
42 Fed. Reg. 2965 (Jan. 14, 1977) ....................................... 2, 3
51 Fed. Reg. 29,362 (Aug. 15, 1986) ............................. 3, 4, 22
52 Fed. Reg. 29,754 (Aug. 11, 1987) ................... 6, 7, 8, 10, 11
77 Fed. Reg. 75,266 (Dec. 19, 2012) ................... 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
In the Supreme Court of the United States
No. 17-1636
CALIFORNIA SEA URCHIN COMMISSION, ET AL.,
PETITIONERS
v.
SUSAN COMBS, ACTING ASSISTANT SECRETARY
FOR FISH, WILDLIFE, AND PARKS, ET AL.
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
BRIEF FOR THE FEDERAL RESPONDENTS
IN OPPOSITION
OPINIONS BELOW
The opinion of the court of appeals (Pet. App. A1-A22)
is reported at 883 F.3d 1173. The opinion of the district
court in petitioners’ first case (Pet. App. C1-C19) is reported at 239 F. Supp. 3d 1200. The opinion of the district
court in petitioners’ second case (Pet. App. E1-E25) is not
published in the Federal Supplement but is available at
2015 WL 5737899.
JURISDICTION
The judgment of the court of appeals was entered on
March 1, 2018. The petition for a writ of certiorari was
filed on May 30, 2018. The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked under 28 U.S.C. 1254(1).
(1)
2
STATEMENT
1. a. The southern sea otter, also known as the California sea otter, historically inhabited waters off the western coast of the United States. After centuries of intense
hunting, by the early 1900s, only a few dozen sea otters
remained in existence. 15-56672 C.A. E.R. 95. By the
1970s, the population gradually increased to between 1000
and 2000. 42 Fed. Reg. 2965, 2966 (Jan. 14, 1977). Nonetheless, the sea otter remained in danger of extinction because of its small population size and its vulnerability to
potential oil spills by tankers traversing the California
coast. Id. at 2966-2967. 1
In the 1970s, Congress enacted several statutes establishing protections for the sea otter and related species.
The Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA), 16 U.S.C.
1531 et seq., directs the Secretary of the Interior to identify and list species that are “endangered” or “threatened.” 16 U.S.C. 1533(a)(1). 2 The ESA directs the U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) to “develop and implement * * * ‘recovery plans’[] for the conservation and
survival of endangered species and threatened species.”
16 U.S.C. 1533(f )(1). The ESA and implementing regulations also generally make it unlawful to “take” a protected
species, 16 U.S.C. 1538(a)(1)(B)-(C); see 50 C.F.R. 17.21(c),
17.31(a), meaning to “harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot,
1
Unlike most marine mammals, sea otters do not have blubber to
provide insulation, but instead depend upon dense, water-resistant
fur. Oil contamination can destroy the insulating properties of seaotter fur, leading to hypothermia and death. 15-56672 C.A. E.R. 134.
2
An “endangered species” is “any species which is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range,” 16 U.S.C.
1532(6), while a “threatened species” is “any species which is likely to
become an endangered species within the foreseeable future throughout all or a significant portion of its range,” 16 U.S.C. 1532(20).
3
wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect [the species], or to attempt to engage in any such conduct,” 16 U.S.C. 1532(19).
In 1977, the Service listed the southern sea otter as a
threatened species under the ESA. See 42 Fed. Reg. at
2966.
In addition, the Marine Mammal Protection Act of
1972 (MMPA), 16 U.S.C. 1361 et seq., establishes similar
protections for marine mammals, including sea otters,
without regard to whether they are endangered or threatened. See 16 U.S.C. 1362(6) (defining “marine mammal”).
In enacting the MMPA, Congress found that marine
mammals “should not be permitted to diminish below
their optimum sustainable population” and that “[f ]urther
measures should be immediately taken to replenish any
species or population stock which has already diminished
below that population.” 16 U.S.C. 1361(2). Similar to the
ESA, the MMPA imposes prohibitions against the “tak[ing]” of marine mammals. 16 U.S.C. 1371, 1372(a); see
16 U.S.C. 1362(13) (defining “take”).
In the early 1980s, as part of its recovery planning efforts, the Service concluded that it would be desirable to
establish a sea otter colony that was sufficiently distant
from the existing (“parent”) population to ensure that “an
environmental catastrophe like an oil spill would not endanger the entire species.” Pet. App. A5. The Service
identified San Nicolas Island, an island in the Channel Islands off the coast of Ventura County, California, as a suitable site for the experimental population. 51 Fed. Reg.
29,362, 29,363 (Aug. 15, 1986). The Service proposed regulations that would implement this plan, see id. at 29,380-
4
29,383, as well as “criteria * * * to describe the circumstances in which the Service would consider the translocation to be a failure,” id. at 29,371. 3
The Service contemplated, however, that further legislative authorization would likely be required. 51 Fed.
Reg. at 29,367-29,368. The ESA authorized the Service to
“permit, under prescribed terms and conditions, any acts
necessary for the establishment and maintenance of an
experimental population” of an endangered or threatened
species. Id. at 29,367; see 16 U.S.C. 1539( j)(1) and (2)(A).
The MMPA, however, contained no express provision allowing the Service the flexibility to take all steps necessary to facilitate the establishment of an experimental
population. “Concerned with whether it had sufficient authority to carry out the plan, the Service asked Congress
to extend its powers” to ensure that it would be able to
carry out an experimental relocation. Pet. App. A5.
Congress responded by passing the Act of November
7, 1986 (P.L. 99-625), Pub. L. No. 99-625, 100 Stat. 3500.
P.L. 99-625 provides that the Service “may develop and
implement * * * a plan for the relocation and management of a population of California sea otters from the existing range of the parent population to another location.”
§ 1(b), 100 Stat. 3500 (emphasis added). It also exempts
the Service, state agencies, and their authorized agents
from any liability under the ESA or MMPA arising from
the relocation or management of sea otters under such a
plan. § 1(f ), 100 Stat. 3501. The statute directs that any
such plan “must be developed by regulation and administered by the Service in cooperation with the appropriate
Petitioner California Abalone Association submitted a comment
on the proposed regulations stating that it was “pleased to see * * *
criteria for failed translocation” included in the proposed rule.
15-56672 C.A. Supp. E.R. 7.
3
5
State agency,” and specifies certain features that a plan
“shall include” if undertaken. § 1(b), 100 Stat. 3500.
As relevant here, P.L. 99-625 directs that any plan include two geographical “zone[s]”: a “translocation zone
* * * to which the experimental population will be relocated,” § 1(b)(3), 100 Stat. 3500, and a surrounding “management zone” that “facilitate[s] the management of sea
otters and the containment of the experimental population within the translocation zone,” § 1(b)(4), 100 Stat.
3500-3501. Congress provided that within such a “management zone,” the “Service shall use all feasible nonlethal means and measures to capture any sea otter * * *
and return it to either the translocation zone or to the
range of the parent population.” Ibid. Congress did not
specify a maximum or minimum size for such a zone, but
did direct that the management zone “[must] not include
the existing range of the parent population or adjacent
range where expansion is necessary for the recovery of
the species.” § 1(b)(4)(B), 100 Stat. 3500.
Congress contemplated that, if the Service did choose
to implement a plan, dispersal by sea otters from the experimental population into the management zone could
lead to “conflict with other fishery resources.” P.L. 99625, § 1(b)(4), 100 Stat. 3501. Nonetheless, as enacted,
P.L. 99-625 generally retains a prohibition against the
taking of sea otters within the management zone. See
§ 1(c)(2), 100 Stat. 3501 (providing that “Section 9 of the
[ESA] applies to members of the experimental population” while “within the management zone”). The statute
provides, however, that “any incidental taking of such a
member during the course of an otherwise lawful activity
within the management zone[] may not be treated as a violation of the [ESA] or the [MMPA].” Ibid.
6
b. The Service chose to exercise its discretionary authority under P.L. 99-625 to develop and implement a plan
for an experimental population of southern sea otters. In
1987, the Service issued a final rule promulgating regulations governing the relocation-and-management plan.
52 Fed. Reg. 29,754 (Aug. 11, 1987). The Service’s rule
identified San Nicolas Island as the translocation zone for
the experimental population, and it proposed to translocate up to 250 sea otters to the island. Id. at 29,765-29,766.
With respect to the management zone, the Service designated the entire southern coast of California from Point
Conception (northwest of Santa Barbara) to the border
with Mexico. See id. at 29,769 (“The management zone
* * * consists of all waters, islands, islets, and land areas
seaward of mean high tide subject to the jurisdiction of
the United States * * * located south of Point Conception
* * * except for any area within the translocation zone.”).
Reflecting the experimental nature of the plan that
Congress had authorized, the Service also established a
set of “five specific ‘failure conditions.’ ” Pet. App. A9 (citation omitted); cf. 50 C.F.R. 17.81(c)(4) (requiring “[a]
process for periodic review and evaluation of the success
or failure” of experimental populations designated under
the ESA). The Service’s regulation provided that the
translocation of sea otters “would generally be considered
to have failed” if “any one of these criteria” was satisfied,
in which case “t[he] rulemaking will be amended to terminate” the plan. 52 Fed. Reg. at 29,772. Additionally, in
that scenario, “all otters remaining within the translocation zone” would be captured and returned to the parent
population, and “all reasonable efforts” would be made to
“remove all otters that were still within the management
zone at the time of the decision to terminate” the plan. Ibid.
7
Over the course of implementing and administering
the plan, the Service encountered several problems.
First, as the Service subsequently explained, capturing
sea otters from the existing population and transferring
them to San Nicolas Island proved more dangerous to sea
otters than expected. 77 Fed. Reg. 75,266, 75,269 (Dec.
19, 2012). Of the 252 sea otters that were captured for
possible experimental release, only 140 were deemed suitable for translocation. Id. at 75,269. Six animals “died of
stress-related conditions” before they could be transferred, and others died after release at San Nicolas Island. Ibid. After three years of transfer efforts, in 1991,
the Service “stopped translocating sea otters to San Nicolas Island due to high rates of dispersal and poor survival.” Ibid.
Second, removing sea otters from the management
zone also proved more hazardous to the animals than expected. Although the Service had originally believed that
“effective containment [could be] carried out” using “nonlethal methods,” 52 Fed. Reg. at 29,757, it later became
“concerned that sea otters were dying as a result
of [its] containment efforts” in the management zone,
77 Fed. Reg. at 75,269, and moreover, that its efforts had
also “proven to be less effective and more labor-intensive
than originally predicted,” ibid. In 1993, the Service suspended all efforts to capture sea otters within the management zone pending further evaluation. Ibid.; cf. P.L.
99-625, § 1(b)(4), 100 Stat. 3501 (requiring Service to remove sea otters from management zone to the extent “feasible, nonlethal means” were available). The Service’s
state-agency counterpart later notified the Service that it
would “no longer be able to assist” with “capturing sea otters in the management zone.” 77 Fed. Reg. at 75,269.
8
Third, although the Service had expected “dispersal [of
sea otters] away from San Nicolas Island * * * to be negligible,” 52 Fed. Reg. at 29,768, many of the translocated
sea otters in fact “swam back to the parent population,”
77 Fed. Reg. at 75,269; see also id. at 75,267 (as of 2012,
it is “now well established that sea otters can return rapidly to areas from which they have been removed”). Indeed, through a combination of mortality and emigration,
three years into the experiment, only 14 “independent
(non-pup) southern sea otters” were believed to remain at
San Nicolas Island, or only “10 percent” of the number of
sea otters that had been transferred there. Ibid.
Finally, although P.L. 99-625 specified that the management zone must not include “the existing range of the
parent population or adjacent range where expansion is
necessary for the recovery of the species,” P.L. 99-625,
§ 1(b)(4)(B), 100 Stat. 3500, it soon became apparent that
the parent population was naturally migrating into that
zone. “In 1998, a group of approximately 100 southern sea
otters moved from the parent range into the northern end
of the management zone, inaugurating a pattern of seasonal movements of large numbers of sea otters into and
out of the management zone.” 77 Fed. Reg. at 75,269.
That southward migration of the parent population had
occurred even though its population was declining, not
growing. See ibid. (noting that “rangewide counts * * *
indicated a decline of approximately 10 percent between
1995 and 1998”). After consulting with a “team of biologists with expertise pertinent to southern sea otter recovery,” the Service determined that it should not attempt to
capture and move any of the sea otters migrating into the
management zone, “because moving large groups of
southern sea otters and releasing them within the parent
range would be disruptive to the social structure of the
9
parent population,” id. at 75,270, and would “likely jeopardize the continued existence and impede the recovery
of the species,” id. at 75,272; see ibid. (summarizing findings of 2000 revised biological opinion); id. at 75,286 (finding that management zone’s “boundaries, as currently
determined, [were] not in compliance with” P.L. 99-625,
§ 1(b)(4)(B), 100 Stat. 3500).
In 2001, the Service announced that it intended to undertake a “full and final evaluation” of the relocation-andmanagement program. 77 Fed. Reg. at 75,272. In 2003,
the Service issued a revised recovery plan that recommended “declar[ing] the translocation program a failure
and discontinu[ing] maintenance of a ‘no-otter’ management zone.” Id. at 75,267; see id. at 75,270. After the Service did not promptly rescind its regulations, in 2009, several environmental groups brought suit against the Service, and two of the petitioners (California Sea Urchin
Commission and California Abalone Association) intervened as defendants. That litigation was resolved through
a consent decree, agreed to by all parties (including the
two petitioner defendants), that committed the Service to
making a further “determination as to whether the translocation program has failed” and, if so, to conduct a rulemaking to “terminate the program.” 09-cv-4610 Docket
entry No. 67, at 4 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 23, 2010).
Consistent with the consent decree, in 2012, the Service issued a final rule determining that the relocation
plan had failed and rescinding its implementing regulations. See 77 Fed. Reg. at 75,266-75,268. The Service
noted that the plan had met “failure criterion 2,” id. at
75,267: that is, “within three years from the initial transplant [i.e., as of 1991], fewer than 25 otters remain[ed] in
the translocation zone and the reason for emigration or
10
mortality [could not] be identified and/or remedied,”
52 Fed. Reg. at 29,784.
The Service also identified five further reasons why it
considered the program a failure: (1) even as of 2012, the
population of sea otters at San Nicolas Island “remain[ed]
small, and its ability to become established and persist is
uncertain” 4; (2) in light of further study of environmental
risks, the Service determined that even a well-established
colony at San Nicolas Island would “not provide an adequate safeguard should the mainland southern sea otter
population be adversely affected by a catastrophic event”;
(3) any further “attempts to limit natural range expansion
of southern sea otters” into the management zone would
“disrupt seasonal patterns of movement and hinder recovery” of the species; (4) “capturing and moving sea otters”
out of the management zone “ha[d] proven to be ineffective” given the difficulties of sea otter capture, the “ability
of sea otters to return rapidly” upon release, and “the elevated mortality associated with the holding, transport,
and release of sea otters”; and (5) the Service’s “recovery
strategy for the southern sea otter has changed since the
original recovery plan was released in 1982, in part because of [the points] above.” 77 Fed. Reg. at 75,267.
The Service noted that its rescission of the regulations
would eliminate all special legal rules associated with the
program, including “any exemptions from incidental take
liability,” Pet. App. A9, and any “obligation to remove
southern sea otters in perpetuity from an ‘otter-free’ management zone,” 77 Fed. Reg. at 75,266, and thus returned
to the generally applicable ESA and MMPA regimes. The
Service also determined that, upon termination of the
Petitioners’ assertion that “[t]he Service declined to consider the
[San Nicolas] population’s subsequent growth or the size of the population in 2012,” Pet. 13-14, is thus erroneous. See also Pet. App. A9.
4
11
plan, it would be inappropriate to seek to remove sea otters from San Nicolas Island or the management zone.
The Service acknowledged that its 1987 rule had provided
that, in the event of failure, efforts would be made to capture “otters remaining within the translocation zone * * *
[and] within the management zone” and to release them
“into the range of the parent population.” 52 Fed. Reg. at
29,784. The Service, found, however, that “[t]he attempted removal of sea otters from San Nicolas Island or
the management zone, even over the short term, could result in increased mortality of the removed sea otters and
temporarily disrupt behavior throughout the range of the
species.” 77 Fed. Reg. at 75,267. The Service also reasoned that “attempting these removals would be not only
harmful but likely futile,” insofar as “sea otters can return
rapidly to areas from which they have been removed.”
Ibid. The Service therefore rescinded its regulations in
toto, including the provision that contemplated the capture and removal of sea otters upon the plan’s termination. Ibid.
2. Petitioners are four associations representing the
interests of commercial fishermen who operate in coastal
California waters, including within the former management zone. Pet. 14-15; Pet. App. C1.
a. In 2013, petitioners filed a suit in the Central District of California challenging the Service’s decision to terminate the relocation-and-management plan and to rescind its implementing regulations. Pet. App. A10. The
district court initially dismissed the suit as untimely, but
the court of appeals reversed. 828 F.3d 1046. On remand,
the Service moved for summary judgment, arguing both
that petitioners lacked standing and that its rescission of
the regulations was lawful.
12
The district court granted the Service’s motion. Pet.
App. C1-C19; see id. at D1-D2 ( judgment). At the threshold, the court addressed petitioners’ “two theories of
standing.” Id. at C4. The court rejected petitioners’ assertion of standing based on an alleged “appreciable risk
of incurring [take] liability as a result of the challenged
regulation,” ibid., explaining that petitioners had failed to
offer evidence showing that “they engage in activities that
are likely to result in liability” under the ESA or MMPA,
id. at C5-C6; see id. at C4 (noting that “the plaintiff must
establish standing ‘with the manner and degree of evidence required at’ the relevant stage of the litigation”)
(quoting Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 561
(1992)). But the court found standing based on petitioners’ separate assertion that sea otters, if not removed
from the management zone, would “significantly reduce[]
shellfish populations along the coastline,” thereby injuring the business interests of petitioners’ members. Id. at
C6-C7 (citation omitted). And the court reasoned that a
favorable judgment on the merits could potentially redress that injury because—although sea otters had been
allowed to migrate into and inhabit the management zone
since 1993—reinstatement of the regulations would in
principle require the Service “to relocate otters” from the
management zone if the Service ever “identified a ‘feasible, nonlethal’ method for doing so,” although that scenario was “unlikely.” Id. at C7.
On the merits, the district court upheld the Service’s
determination that it possessed the statutory authority to
terminate its experimental plan. The court rejected petitioners’ argument that P.L. 99-625 unambiguously required the Service to maintain the relocation-andmanagement plan permanently, explaining that the statutory text “neither requires the [Service] to develop the
13
Plan nor prohibits the [Service] from repealing the Plan
after it is developed.” Pet. App. C14. Concluding that
Congress did not “sp[eak] directly to the question at
hand,” the court found the Service’s determination that it
possessed authority to end the plan was “reasonable” and
consistent with the statute’s text, structure, and legislative history. Id. at C15; see id. at C15-C18.
b. While that litigation was pending, in 2014, petitioners filed an administrative petition requesting that the
Service revoke its 2012 final rule and thereby reinstate
the 1987 regulations. See Pet. App. E7. When that effort
proved unsuccessful, three of the petitioners filed suit in
the Central District of California arguing that the Service
had acted unlawfully in denying their petition, advancing
in substance the same arguments made in the first suit. 5
See id. at E7, E16-E25. The Service moved for summary
judgment. Id. at E2.
The district court in that separate suit granted summary judgment for the Service on both standing and merits grounds. Pet. App. E1-E25. The court found that petitioners had failed to establish standing based on their
“fear of prosecution for take of otter,” id. at E14 (quoting
Compl. ¶ 68), because they failed to offer “any evidence”
demonstrating that they faced a genuine risk of prosecution for incidental taking of sea otters, id. at E15. The
court also found that petitioners could not establish standing based on their assertion that sea otters in the management zone were “consum[ing] * * * large amounts of
shellfish,” explaining that petitioners’ suit would not redress that injury. Id. at E13. As the court observed, petitioners had expressly disclaimed any effort to “require
the Service to resume capturing and removing otters that
Petitioner California Lobster and Trap Fishermen’s Association
did not join as a plaintiff in this second suit. See Pet. ii n.*.
5
14
wander into the management zone”; instead, they sought
only to avoid liability “for accidentally harming[] [or] harassing” sea otters in that zone. Id. at E13-E14 (quoting
14-cv-8499 Docket entry No. 44, at 1, 17 (C.D. Cal. Aug. 5,
2015)). Thus, “[petitioners] conce[ded] that any alleged
injuries that might result from the diminution of the shellfish stocks caused by the sea otters’ consumption * * * will
not be redressed by their lawsuit.” Id. at E14.
“Even assuming that [petitioners] have standing,” the
district court determined, their claims would fail on the
merits. Pet. App. E16. Noting that “P.L. 99-625 uses
purely discretionary language authorizing the program,”
the court concluded that “the plain language of the statute” gave the Service “the discretion to both commence
and cease implementation of the program.” Id. at E16E18. The court also stated that “[e]ven if there was any
ambiguity in the statute,” it would sustain the Service’s
interpretation as a “ permissible construction.” Id. at E18
(citation omitted); see id. at E18-E25 (analyzing statutory
text, context, purpose, and legislative history).
3. Petitioners appealed both judgments, and the court
of appeals unanimously affirmed as to “both district
courts’ conclusions that the Service acted lawfully in terminating the southern sea otter relocation program.” Pet.
App. A22; see id. at A1-A22.
At the threshold, the court of appeals found that petitioners had established standing. Pet. App. A11-A15. It
agreed with both district courts that petitioners could not
establish standing based on their unsubstantiated claims
of an “increased risk of liability because of the elimination
of exemptions for incidental takes in the management
zone.” Id. at A12. The court of appeals found, however,
that petitioners were injured by “sea otter predation of
15
shellfish.” Id. at A14. And although the court acknowledged the Service’s argument that a judgment in petitioners’ favor would not redress their injury—inasmuch as
the Service would still be under no immediate obligation
to remove sea otters—the court nonetheless concluded
that “[w]here there are legal impediments to the recovery
sought, it is enough for standing that the relief sought will
remove some of those legal roadblocks, even if others may
remain.” Id. at A14-A15.
Turning to the merits, the court of appeals noted that
“[a]ll parties agree” that the statutory question “should
be assessed under the two-step * * * analysis” set forth
in Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense
Council, Inc., 467 U.S. 837 (1984). Pet. App. A16. Under
that framework, if Congress has “directly spoken to the
precise question at issue,” then the court “must give effect
to the unambiguously expressed intent of Congress.”
Chevron, 467 U.S. at 842-843. If, however, “the statute is
silent or ambiguous with respect to the specific issue,” the
court upholds the agency’s interpretation if it is “based on
a permissible construction of the statute.” Id. at 843.
Applying that framework, the court of appeals rejected
petitioners’ argument that Congress had foreclosed the
Service from ever terminating a translocation plan if it exercised its discretion to implement one. Pet. App. A16A17. The court explained that although petitioners had
identified some “scattered mandatory language in the
statute” that created specifications for any plan that
might be implemented, id. at A16, the statute did not direct the Service to implement a translocation plan in the
first instance, and it neither expressly obligated it to “operate [one] in perpetuity” nor expressly granted the Service authority to terminate the program, id. at A17. Thus
concluding that “the statute is silent or ambiguous with
16
respect to the specific issue” whether the Service had the
authority to terminate the program, the court proceeded
to consider whether the agency’s action was “based on a
permissible construction of the statute.” Ibid. (quoting
Chevron, 467 U.S. at 843).
The court of appeals “h[e]ld that it is reasonable to interpret the statute as implicitly giving the Service authority to terminate the program when it determines that the
purposes of the statute would no longer be served, or
when its continuation would be at odds with the goals of
the ESA or the MMPA.” Pet. App. A18. Noting that P.L.
99-625 repeatedly refers to the ESA and incorporates its
requirements, the court found it “reasonable for the Service to interpret the provisions of [P.L.] 99-625 as authorizing it to act in harmony with the goals of the ESA,” including by “[t]erminating the failed translocation program” once it had been determined to undermine the
ESA’s goals. Ibid. Petitioners’ competing reading of the
statute, by contrast, would “require the [translocation]
program to continue even if the Service determined that
it was counter-productive.” Ibid. The court also noted
that P.L. 99-625 “was not intended to limit expansion of
the northern parent population,” ibid., making it “reasonable for the Service to end the program once it has determined that * * * continuing the program now would pose
a threat to” that population, id. at A19. The court also rejected as “unconvincing” petitioners’ “constitutional avoidance” theory that permitting the Service to discontinue
the failed program would likely result in an impermissible
delegation of legislative authority to the Service. Id. at
A20; see id. at A20-A22.
The court of appeals nonetheless emphasized that it
did not intend to establish a “broad principle that if the
implementation of a regulation is discretionary, then the
17
agency always has discretion to end the regulation at any
time and for any reason.” Pet. App. A19. Instead, the
court explained that it was “hold[ing] only that in the circumstances here, where the agency has discretion to implement an experimental program, [the agency] can reasonably interpret the statute to allow it to terminate that
program if the statute’s purpose is no longer being
served” or, indeed, if “the agency concludes that continuing the program” would actively “undermine the stated
purpose of the statute that authorizes it.” Id. at A19-A20.
ARGUMENT
Petitioners urge (Pet. 18-37) this Court to grant review
to address whether federal agencies should receive deference for assertions of regulatory power that rest only
upon statutory “silence.” But this case does not present
that question. The Service did not purport to exercise authority to regulate activities about which Congress was silent. Rather, the Service discontinued an experimental
program that Congress had not only expressly authorized
the Service to undertake through the issuance of regulations, but also expressly made discretionary. The court of
appeals’ determination that the Service acted lawfully in
terminating this discretionary program was correct and
does not conflict with any decision of this Court or another
court of appeals. Moreover, threshold justiciability problems would likely preclude this Court’s review of the merits in any event, particularly insofar as petitioners expressly disclaimed the factual predicate upon which their
theory of redressability now rests. Further review is not
warranted.
1. As an initial matter, for the reasons set forth below,
by far the most natural reading of P.L. 99-625—indeed,
the one that the Service views the plain language of the
18
statute to require—is that the Secretary had the discretionary authority to terminate the relocation plan when
it determined that the plan was no longer serving its
species-protective purpose. Deference to the agency’s interpretation therefore is not required.
In any event, “[a]ll parties agree[d]” below, Pet. App.
A16, that petitioners’ claim is properly adjudicated under
the interpretive framework set forth in Chevron U.S.A.
Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., 467 U.S.
837 (1984). Under that framework, “[w]hen a court reviews an agency’s construction of the statute which it administers, it is confronted with two questions.” Id. at 842.
“First, always, is the question whether Congress has directly spoken to the precise question at issue. If the intent
of Congress is clear, * * * the court, as well as the agency,
must give effect to the unambiguously expressed intent of
Congress.” Id. at 842-843. If, however, the statute is “silent or ambiguous with respect to the specific issue,” the
court considers whether the agency interpretation is
“based on a permissible construction of the statute.” Id.
at 843. If the agency’s resolution of the question is reasonable, the court sustains that interpretation.
a. As this Court has recognized, the fact that a statute
is arguably “silent” about a matter in dispute does not categorically have the same import in all cases under Chevron. Instead, as with other interpretive questions, the
court must consider the relevant statutory text and surrounding context. See Chevron, 467 U.S. at 843 n.9
(courts use “traditional tools of statutory construction” in
determining whether statute is silent or ambiguous); cf.
Holloway v. United States, 526 U.S. 1, 7 (1999) (“[T]he
meaning of statutory language, plain or not, depends on
context.”) (citation omitted).
19
In some instances, a statute’s failure to address a particular activity may properly be understood as reflecting
that Congress did not intend the agency to regulate that
activity. Because “an agency literally has no power to act
* * * unless and until Congress confers power upon it,”
Louisiana Pub. Serv. Comm’n v. FCC, 476 U.S. 355, 374
(1986), “sometimes statutory silence, when viewed in context, is best interpreted as limiting agency discretion,”
Entergy Corp. v. Riverkeeper, Inc., 556 U.S. 208, 223
(2009). See, e.g., Food & Drug Admin. v. Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. 120 (2000) (concluding
that absence in Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act of authorization to regulate tobacco precluded FDA from regulating tobacco products).
In other cases, however, a statute’s failure to expressly
resolve a question of agency practice is better understood
as a “refusal to tie the agency’s hands.” Entergy, 556 U.S.
at 222. As this Court has repeatedly stated, “a statute’s
silence * * * as to a particular issue means that Congress
has not ‘directly addressed the precise question at issue’[,]
thus likely delegating gap-filling power to the agency.”
United States v. Home Concrete & Supply, LLC, 566 U.S.
478, 488 (2012) (citation omitted); see, e.g., EPA v. EME
Homer City Generation, L.P., 134 S. Ct. 1584, 1604 (2014)
(“Under Chevron, we read Congress’ silence as a delegation of authority to EPA to select from among reasonable
options.”); Utility Air Reg. Grp. v. EPA, 134 S. Ct. 2427,
2445 (2014) (noting that “[a]gencies exercise discretion” in
“the interstices created by statutory silence or ambiguity”); Entergy, 556 U.S. at 222 (“It is eminently reasonable
to conclude that § 1326(b)’s silence is meant to convey
nothing more than a refusal to tie the agency’s hands as
to whether cost-benefit analysis should be used, and if so
to what degree.”).
20
b. The court of appeals correctly concluded that P.L.
99-625 did not unambiguously foreclose the Service’s determination that it had the authority to terminate the
failed experimental plan. P.L. 99-625 provided that “[t]he
Secretary may develop and implement” a “plan for the relocation and management of a population of California sea
otters from the existing range of the parent population to
another location.” P.L. 99-625, § 1(b), 100 Stat. 3500 (emphasis added). But the statute nowhere required the Service to exercise that authority. Nor does the statute anywhere state that the Service, if it exercised its discretion
to develop and implement a plan to create an experimental population, was obligated to “operate the translocation program in perpetuity.” Pet. App. A17.
The court of appeals correctly rejected petitioners’ argument that “scattered mandatory language” within the
text of P.L. 99-625 had the effect of foreclosing the Service
from rescinding its regulations. Pet. App. A16. The statute does establish certain specifications for any plan if the
Service, in its discretion, chooses to pursue one. See, e.g.,
id. at A17 (noting that “Section 1(b) of [P.L.] 99-625 says
that the translocation plan ‘shall include’ a specified management zone”). But that language does not purport to
direct what the Service may or must do if the experimental plan ultimately fails to achieve its purposes. Accord id. at C14 (noting that “[t]he language quoted by [petitioners] * * * neither requires the [Service] to develop
the Plan nor prohibits the [Service] from repealing the
Plan after it is developed”); id. at E18 (“There is nothing
in the statute that would suggest * * * that, if the Service
decided to embark on such a program, it would exist indefinitely.”).
21
The court of appeals also was correct to conclude that
the Service’s interpretation of P.L. 99-625 was, at a minimum, a reasonable construction of the statute. In the Service’s view, “the plain language of the statute” itself
“g[i]ve[s] the Service discretion to determine whether a
sea otter translocation program would ever be developed,” and “[b]ecause implementing the program is discretionary, the Service had the discretion to both commence and cease implementation of the program.” Pet.
App. E17-E18; see also id. at C15 (“If the [Service] ‘may
. . . implement’ the Plan, it follows that the agency may
also stop implementing the plan.”); cf. Halo Elecs., Inc. v.
Pulse Elecs., Inc., 136 S. Ct. 1923, 1931 (2016) (“[W]e have
emphasized that the ‘word “may” clearly connotes discretion.’ ”) (citation omitted). That conclusion is also supported by, inter alia, the “well-established general rule of
administrative law * * * that agencies may, with reasoned
explanation, repeal their own regulations.” 15-56672
Gov’t C.A. Br. 34-35 (citing, inter alia, Motor Vehicle
Mfrs. Ass’n of the U.S., Inc. v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins.
Co., 463 U.S. 29, 51-52 (1983)); cf. Pet. App. C15-C16. The
Service’s interpretation of the statute is therefore correct
as a matter of law and without any need to resort to doctrines of deference.
Even assuming arguendo that a more restrictive interpretation of the statute would also be permissible, however, the Service’s view that it had discretion to terminate
the failed experimental plan was clearly reasonable, for all
of the reasons given by the court of appeals and both district courts. See Pet. App. A18-A20, C15-C18, E18-E25.
First, even beyond making discretionary the Service’s authority to “develop and implement” a plan, Congress further signaled its awareness of the provisional nature of
the plan by referring repeatedly to the “experimental”
22
population. P.L. 99-625, § 1(a)(3) and (5)(A), (b)(3)-(5), and
(c), 100 Stat. 3500-3501; see Pet. App. C16, E18. Second,
although Congress mandated that any plan contain, e.g.,
both a translocation zone and a management zone, it otherwise left significant plan details to the agency’s discretion. See Pet. App. C16-C17 (reasoning that Congress “intended the agency to have wide discretion in deciding
what efforts were feasible and consistent with the recovery of the species”). Third, Congress was on notice in enacting P.L. 99-625 that the Service intended to include
“failure conditions” in any plan, see 51 Fed. Reg. at 29,371
(proposed rule), but it did not specify in the statute that a
plan must persist indefinitely if the Service chose to adopt
one. On the contrary, one of the co-sponsors of the original bill that ultimately led to P.L. 99-625 stated that “[i]f
the Service determines that the translocation is not successful, it should, through the informal rulemaking process, repeal the rule authorizing the translocation.”
131 Cong. Rec. 20,992 (1985) (Rep. Breaux).
The Service’s interpretation also plainly furthers Congress’s purposes. Here, the Service found that the plan
had not only failed to aid in sea-otter conservation, but
also that its continued implementation would affirmatively undermine the recovery of the species. Pet. App.
A19. The text of P.L. 99-625, however, makes clear
through its “repeated references to the ESA” that it was
intended as species-protective legislation. Id. at A18; see,
e.g., P.L. 99-625, § 1(d), 100 Stat. 3501 (requiring the Service to consider, before implementing a plan, any determination made as to whether the plan would jeopardize
the continued existence of an ESA-protected species).
And P.L. 99-625 was “not intended to limit expansion of
the northern parent population.” Pet. App. A18; see P.L.
99-625, § 1(b)(4)(B), 100 Stat. 3500 (requiring that the
23
management zone not include the existing range of the
species or adjacent ranges needed for expansion). By contrast, “[o]n [petitioners’] unwise interpretation of the statute, the Service would be required to continue the program even if no otters remained in the transplanted San
Nicolas population,” Pet. App. A19, and even “where, as
here, the range of the parent population has expanded”
into the former management zone, ibid. In other words,
petitioners would “turn[] a statute with an express purpose of protecting otters into one that harmed otter populations.” Ibid.
c. Petitioners fail to identify any error in the court of
appeals’ decision warranting reversal. Petitioners principally assert that, for a court properly to defer to an
agency’s statutory interpretation, the “power claimed by
an agency [must] have at least some mooring in a statute’s
text,” Pet. 5, and they assert that here there is “no statutory text to interpret,” Pet. 17. As explained above, however, Congress not only expressly authorized the Service
to issue regulations governing the activities in question
here (i.e., implementing a relocation-and-management
plan for the southern sea otter), but it also expressly made
that authority discretionary. Petitioners’ suggestion that
there is no “text [here] against which the Court could assess the agency’s interpretation,” Pet. 22, is insubstantial.
Nor did the court of appeals purport to issue any broad
ruling “that, under Chevron, statutory silence requires
courts to defer to agencies’ assertions of power.” Pet. 18.
On the contrary, the court’s reasoning was tied to the text,
context, background, and purposes of the particular,
species-specific statute at issue here. Indeed, the court
emphasized the narrowness of its holding: “we hold only
that in the circumstances here, where the agency has dis-
24
cretion to implement an experimental program, it can reasonably interpret the statute to allow it to terminate that
program if the statute’s purpose is no longer being
served.” Pet. App. A19. Petitioners’ assertion that the
court of appeals’ decision applied Chevron in a manner
that “departs dramatically from this Court’s precedents,”
Pet. 21, thus is without merit. 6
2. The decision below does not conflict with that of any
other court of appeals. Petitioners assert that the Ninth
Circuit’s deference to the Service’s construction of P.L.
99-625 cannot be reconciled with other courts of appeals’
treatment of interpretive questions involving “statutory
silence” in other contexts involving distinct statutes. But
the decisions cited by petitioners simply confirm that the
interpretation of statutory “silence,” like statutory ambiguity, is context-dependent and requires resort to the
available tools of statutory construction.
Petitioners cite various decisions of this Court, see Pet. 20-26, but
fail to explain how they conflict in any way with the court of appeals’
decision. See Gonzales v. Oregon, 546 U.S. 243, 268 (2006) (declining
to defer to Attorney General’s arrogation of interpretive authority to
prohibit physician-assisted suicide, which was outside his statutory
role under the Controlled Substances Act to “prevent[] doctors from
engaging in illicit drug trafficking”); National Cable & Telecomms.
Ass’n v. Brand X Internet Servs., 545 U.S. 967 (2005) (deferring to
position of Federal Communications Commission that cable companies providing broadband Internet service were exempt from mandatory regulation, notwithstanding prior judicial construction to the
contrary); Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 529 U.S. at 161 (holding that FDA lacked authority to regulate tobacco products);
MCI Telecomms. Corp. v. AT&T Co., 512 U.S. 218, 220 (1994) (holding
unreasonable the agency’s interpretation of its authority to “modify”
regulatory requirements as permitting wholesale exemptions from
regulation).
6
25
For example, petitioners invoke (Pet. 18, 19, 25, 26, 28)
the D.C. Circuit’s en banc decision in Railway Labor Executives’ Ass’n v. National Mediation Board, 29 F.3d 655
(1994), cert. denied, 514 U.S. 1032 (1995), which remarked
that “[w]ere courts to presume a delegation of power absent an express withholding of such power, agencies
would enjoy virtually limitless hegemony, a result plainly
out of keeping with Chevron.” Id. at 671. But the Ninth
Circuit in this case did not rely on any such presumption
or mere absence of an express withholding of authority to
terminate the program. The D.C. Circuit’s Railway Labor Executives’ Association decision, moreover, involved
the question whether an agency had power to act sua
sponte to initiate an enforcement investigation that the
statute required to be initiated by private complaint, not
the question whether an agency had authority to discontinue a discretionary experimental program that Congress expressly authorized the agency to implement
through the issuance of regulations. See id. at 664 (“[O]ur
analysis leads us to the firm conclusion that Congress left
no ambiguity in Section 2, Ninth: the Board may investigate a representation dispute only upon request of the
employees involved in the dispute.”). Indeed, in other
cases, where the relevant statutory text and context have
suggested the existence of a gap for an agency to fill—
rather than an implicit withholding of authority by negative inference—the D.C. Circuit has upheld an agency’s
interpretation of statutory “silence.” See, e.g., Americans for Clean Energy v. EPA, 864 F.3d 691, 733 (2017);
Anna Jacques Hosp. v. Burwell, 797 F.3d 1155, 1164
(2015); Monroe Energy, LLC v. EPA, 750 F.3d 909, 915919 (2014); Catawba County v. EPA, 571 F.3d 20, 36-37
(2009) (per curiam); Methodist Hosp. of Sacramento v.
Shalala, 38 F.3d 1225, 1230 (1994).
26
The three other cases cited by petitioners fall into the
same pattern. See Marlow v. New Food Guy, Inc., 861
F.3d 1157, 1162-1164 (10th Cir. 2017) (holding that the
Secretary of Labor (DOL) lacked power to ban tip pooling
generally, inasmuch as Congress expressly applied a statutory prohibition against tip pooling only to employers
who take a tip credit);7 Chamber of Commerce of the U.S.
v. NLRB, 721 F.3d 152, 160-166 (4th Cir. 2013) (holding
that Board lacked power to require employers to post notices, where statute nowhere granted any notice-posting
power); Bayou Lawn & Landscape Servs. v. Secretary of
Labor, 713 F.3d 1080, 1085 (11th Cir. 2013) (holding that
DOL lacked power to regulate employment of temporary
non-agricultural workers, where DOL had only been
granted power to regulate employment of temporary agricultural workers). Indeed, in Chamber of Commerce,
the Fourth Circuit specifically distinguished situations in
which the interpretive question is whether Congress intended to create exceptions to the scope of an authority
expressly granted to an agency, from situations in which
it is unclear that Congress granted any regulatory authority in the first instance. See 712 F.3d at 159-160; see Marlow, 861 F.3d at 1164 (noting that agency there could not
“point to any statutory language” from which the claimed
power could be derived); Bayou Lawn, 713 F.3d at 1085
Marlow concerned the same agency regulation that was upheld
by the Ninth Circuit in Oregon Restaurant & Lodging Ass’n v. Perez,
816 F.3d 1080 (2016), cert. denied, 138 S. Ct. 2670, and 138 S. Ct. 2697
(2018). See Pet. 25, 29 (citing the Oregon Restaurant decision). In
responding to the petitions for a writ of certiorari in that case, this
Office agreed that the statute at issue, properly read, precluded assertion of the regulatory power claimed by DOL. See, e.g., Gov’t Br.
at 21-23, National Rest. Ass’n v. Department of Labor, No. 16-920
(May 22, 2018). This Court nonetheless denied the petitions on June
25, 2018.
7
27
(finding likelihood of success on claim that “DOL has exercised a rulemaking authority that it does not possess”).
The courts of appeals thus have reached varying results not because those courts disagree about the meaning
of “statutory silence,” Pet. 6, but rather, because they
agree that the appropriate conclusion to be drawn from
silence depends on context, which necessarily differs from
statute to statute and from case to case. See pp. 18-19,
supra.
3. This case would be a poor candidate for this Court’s
review in any event because, on the current record, petitioners have failed to show standing to press their claims.
See Steel Co. v. Citizens for a Better Env’t, 523 U.S. 83,
101-102 (1998) (court must resolve issues of Article III
standing before it may adjudicate the merits of a plaintiff ’s claims). As described above, see pp. 12-14, supra, all
three lower courts rejected petitioners’ claim that the rescission of the regulations would expose petitioners to an
imminent risk of prosecution for incidental taking of sea
otters. The court of appeals did find standing based on
the “alleged harm to shellfish populations,” Pet. App.
A15, 8 and upon its assessment that reinstating the translocation program would eliminate “one substantial legal
roadblock” on the path to removing sea otters from the
management zone, ibid. But petitioners themselves stated
that they did not seek to remove sea otters from the management zone, but instead sought only freedom from liability for incidental takes. See pp. 13-14, supra. Although
petitioners have attempted to dispute the significance of
The court of appeals’ reliance upon what petitioners “alleged” also
overlooks that both appeals arose in a summary-judgment posture, in
which a plaintiff must support its claims to standing with evidence and
not merely “alleg[ations].” Pet. App. A14, A15.
8
28
that concession, see 15-56672 Pet. C.A. Br. 17, they nonetheless do not dispute that the Service is under no obligation to remove sea otters unless “feasible, nonlethal
means” are available for doing so, which no party has
shown to exist and which even the first district court similarly found “unlikely.” Pet. App. C7 (citation omitted).
Under these circumstances, petitioners have failed to
make the necessary showing that it is “ ‘likely,’ as opposed
to merely ‘speculative,’ that the[ir] injury will be ‘redressed by a favorable decision’ ” in this litigation. Lujan
v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555, 561 (1992) (citation
omitted).
CONCLUSION
The petition for a writ of certiorari should be denied.
Respectfully submitted.
NOEL J. FRANCISCO
Solicitor General
JEFFREY H. WOOD
Acting Assistant Attorney
General
ANDREW C. MERGEN
RACHEL HERON
Attorneys
SEPTEMBER 2018
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.