SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Agency decision
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
WASHINGTON. D.C. 20549
DIVISION OF
MARKET REGULATION
June 29,2007
W. Thomas Conner, Esq.
Eric C. Freed, Esq.
Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP
1275 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20004-2415
Re:
Request of Ameristock Fixed-Income ETF Trust for Relief from Section
ll(d)(l) of, and Certain Rules under, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
Dear Messrs. Conner and Freed:
In your letter dated June 29,2007, you request, on behalf of Ameristock ETF Trust
("Trust"), the Funds (as defined below), the American Stock Exchange or any other national
securities exchange through which shares of the Funds ("Fund Shares") may trade, the Funds'
principal underwriter (ALPS Distributors, Inc.), and persons or entities engaging in transactions
in Fund Shares and the purchase and redemptions of Creation Units (as defined in your letter),
including Authorized Participants (as defined in your letter), exemptions from, or interpretive
advice or no-action relief regarding, Section 11(d)(l) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
("Exchange Act"), and Rules lob-10, 1ldl-2 and 15cl-6 thereunder, in connection with
secondary market transactions and the creation or redemption of Creation Units.
We understand that the Trust is an open-end management investment company and
currently consists of five separate investment portfolios (each a "Fund" and collectively the
"Funds"). Each Fund will seek investment results, before fees and expenses, that correspond
generally to the price and yield performance of a specified fixed-income securities index (each
an "Underlying Index" and collectively the "Underlying Indices"), as described more fully in
your letter. Each Underlying Index is comprised of only one or two debt securities issued by the
U.S. Treasury ("Treasury Securities"), and the components of each Underlying Index change
whenever there is a new public sale or "auction" by the U.S. Government of an Index's
underlying Treasury Security or Securities.
Response:
As we discussed,' we are treating your request for relief as a request that the staff of the
Division of Market Regulation ("Staff ') confirm that it will not recommend enforcement action
1
Telephone conversation between Matthew A. Daigler and Eric C. Freed on June 28,2007
W. Thomas Conner, Esq.
Eric C. Freed, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 2 of 2
to the Commission if a broker-dealer treats Fund Shares, for purposes of the relief from Section
11(d)(l) and Rules 10b-10, 11d l -2, and 15cl-6 provided in the Letter re: Derivative Products
Committee of the Securities Industry Association (November 21,2005) ("Class Relief Letter"),
as shares of a Qualifying ETF (as defined in the Class ~ e l i e~f e t t e r ) . ~
Based on the facts and representations set forth in your letter, and, in particular, the
representation that the Trust may rely on the Fixed-Income Class Relief Letter, the Staff will not
recommend enforcement action to the Commission if a broker-dealer treats Fund Shares, for
purposes of the relief from Section 11(d)(l) of the Exchange Act and Rules 10b-10, 11d l -2, and
15cl-6 thereunder provided in the Class Relief Letter, as shares of a Qualifying ETF.
Accordingly, with respect to Fund Shares, to the extent that a broker-dealer satisfies the other
conditions in the Class Relief Letter, it could rely on the exemptive and no-action relief
contained therein.
This no-action position is subject to modification or revocation if at any time the Staff
determines that such action is necessary or appropriate in furtherance of the purposes of the
Exchange Act. In addition, this position is based solely upon the representations you have made
and is limited strictly to the facts and circumstances described in your letter. Any different facts
or circumstances may require a different response. Finally, we express no view with respect to
other questions the proposed activities may raise, including the applicability of any other federal
or state laws or the applicability of self-regulatory organization rules.
Finally, we note that we have twice expressed our views on the ability of broker-dealers
to treat shares of fixed-income exchange-traded funds as shares of a Qualifying ETF for purposes
of the relief provided in the Class ~ e l i e~f e t t e r Having
.~
stated our views, we will no longer
respond to requests for relief fiom Section 1l(d)(l) and Rules 10b-10, 1ldl-2, 15x1-5, and 15cl6 relating to new fixed-income exchange-traded funds, unless they present novel or unusual
issues.
Sincerely,
r
Brian A. Bussey
Assistant Chief Counsel
0
2
On April 9, 2007, the Commission granted class relief specifically geared to ETFs investing in
fixed-income securities with respect to Rules 10a-1, 10b-17 and 14e-5 under the Exchange Act,
Letter re: Class
Rules 101 and 102 of Regulation M and Rule 200(g) of Regulation SHO.
Relief for Fixed Income Exchanne-Traded Funds ("Fixed-Income Class Relief Letter").
3
See also Letter re: ishares Trust (Dec. 22,2006).
--
1275 Pennsylvania Avenue. NW
Washington. DC 20004-2415
202.383.0100
fax 202.637.3593
Sutherland
Asbill st
Brennan UP
www.sabtaw.com
ATRIRNEYS AT W
June 29,2007
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
Associate Director and Chief Counsel
Division of Market Regulation
Securities and Exchange Commission
100 F Street, N.E.
Washington, DC 20549
Request of Ameristock ETP Trust for Relief from Section ll(d)(l) of,
and Certain Rules Under, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
Re:
Dear Ms. McGuire:
I.
Background and Summary of Request for Relief
AmeristoclcETF Trust (the "Trust") is an open-end management investment company
which was organized on June 5,2006 as aDelaware business trust. The Trust currently consists
of five separate investment portfolios (each a "Fund" and collectively the "Funds"), and relief is
being requested in this letter as to each such ~und.' The Trust has filed a registration statement
with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the "Commission") to register the Funds and
their shares ("Fund Shares") with the Commission under the Investment Company Act of 1940,
as amended (the "1940 Act") and the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the "1933 ~ct'').' The
Trust intends to list Fund Shares on the American Stock Exchange (the "Amex") in accordance
with AMEX Rule 1 0 0 0 ~ - A E M I . ~
'
Relief is also being requested as to any investment portfolio of the Trust that may be created in the future that
seeks investment results that correspond generally to a U.S.Treasury securities index.
Registration Nos. 811-21941 and 333-136721. The registration statement was filed on August 18,2006, and was
declared effective on June 28,2007.
'The Funds would meet Amex listing standards for fixed income exchangeaaded funds that were recently
approved by the Commission. See Securities Exchange Act Rel. No. 55437 (March 9,2007). In the future, the
T~ustmay determine to list Fund Shares on another national securities exchange registered with the Commission
(each of Amex and any other such national securities exchange, an "Exchange"). If Fund Shares axe listed on an
Exchange other than AMEX in the future, Fund Shares will be listed in accordance with exchange listing standards
that are, or will become, effective Dursuant to Section 19b)
. ,of the Exchanee Act. If the Fund Shares also trade on
an ~ x c l i a n pursuant
~e
t i unlisted iading privileges, such trading will be conducted punuant to self-regulatory
organization rules that have become effective pursuant to Exchange Act Section 19(b).
-
Atlanta
m
Austin
rn
Houston
NewYork
Tallahassee
Wash1ngton.DC
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 2
On October 5,2006, the Trust filed with the Commission an application under Section
6(c) of the 1940 Act, and on May 29,2007 filed with the Commission an amended and restated
application under Section 6(c) of the 1940 Act, for an exemption from Sections 2(a)(32), 5(a)(l),
22(d) and 24(d) of the 1940 Act and Rule 22c-1 under the 1940 Act, and under Sections 6(c) and
17(b) of the 1940 Act for an exemption from Sections 17(a)(l) and (a)(2) of the 1940 Act, File
No. 81 2-13332 (the "Application"). An order granting the relief requested in the Application
was issued by the Commission on June 26,2007. The exemptive order permits the Funds to
operate as open-end investment companies that are traded on an Exchange.
The market prices of exchange-traded Fund Shares are expected to vary from their net
asset values ( ' W s " ) . Each Fund will issue and redeem Fund Shares at their NAVs only in
aggregations of a specified number of Fund Shares, as further discussed below. Given the
opportunities for arbitrage, it is not anticipated that any deviation between market prices and
NAV will be material.
In connection with the secondary market trading of Fund Shares, the Trust, on'behalf of
itself, the Funds, the Amex or any other Exchange through which Fund Shares may trade, the
Funds' principal underwriter (ALPS Distributors, Inc.), and persons or entities engaging in
transactions in Fund Shares and the purchase and redemptions of Creation Units (defined below),
including Authorized Participants (also defined below), hereby requests, as appropriate, kom the
staff of the Division of Market Regulation (the "Staff") of the Commission, or &om the
Commission, exemptions from, or interpretive or no-action advice regarding, Section 1l(d)(l) of
the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the "Exchange Act"), and Rules lob-10,
1ldl-2 and 15cl-6 under the Exchange Act in connection with secondary market transactions
and the creation or redemption of Creation Units.
The relief requested in this letter is substantially similar to the exemptive, interpretive or
no-action relief granted by the Commission or the Staff to other open-end investment
management companies and unit investment trusts (registered as such with the Commission) that
have been listed and traded on an Exchange as exchange-traded funds ("ETFs").~In addition, the
The Commission or the Staff has previously granted exemptive, interpretive or no-action relief from Section
1l(d)(l) of the Exchange Act, and from Rules lob-10, 1ldl-2, 15cl-5 and 15cl-6 to investment companies and unit
investment trusts holding domestic and international secwities similar to the relief requested in this Letter. &%
ishares Trust, letter from James A. Brigagliano, Acting Associate Director, Division of Market Regulation, to
Benjamin J. Haskin of Willkie Fan & Gallagher, LLP, dated December 22,2006; PowerShares Lux NanoTech
Pornolio.letter from lames A. Brigagliano, Assistant Director, Division of Market Regulation, to Stuart Strauss,
Clifford Chance, US LLP, dated October 25,2005; Shares MSCI EAFE Growth Index Fund and ishares MSCI
EAFE Value Index, letter from James A Brigagliano, Assistant Director, Division of Market Regulation, to Jack P.
Drogin of Morgan Lewis & Bockius, LLP, dated August 4,2005; Proshares Trust, letter from Brian B. Bussey,
Assistant Chief Counsel, Division of Market Regulation, to Kathleen H. Moriarty of Carter. Ledyard & Milburn,
dated June 20, 2005: Vaneuard Emerginp: Markets Stock Index Fund. et a]., letter from James A. Brigagliano,
Assistant Director, Division of Market Regulation, to Kathleen H. Moriarty of Carter, Ledyard & Milburn, dated
March 9, 2005; PowerShares WilderHill Clean Energy Portfolio, letter from James A. Brigagliano, Assistant
Director, Divisioil ofMarket Regulation, to Stuart Strauss, Clifford Chance US LLP, dated March 2, 2005; iShares
FTSEIXinhua China 25 Index Fund, letter from James Brigagliano, Assistant Director, Division of Market
Regulation, to Jack P. Drogin of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP, dated October 8,2004; Vaneuard Enersv Index
Fund and Vaneuard Telecommunication Services Index Fund, letter from James A. Brigagliano, Assistant Director,
WO 728598.2
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 3
Commission, in a letter to the Derivatives Products Committee of the Securities Industry
Association (the "Class Relief Letter"), has granted class relief from Section 1 l(d)(l) of the
Exchange Act and Rules 1ldl-2, lob-10, 15cl-5 and 15cl-6 under the Exchange Act to ETFs
meeting certain criteria set forth in such letter.5
The Class Relief Letter includes the condition that an ETF relying on the letter consist of
a basket of twenty or more "component securities," with no component security constituting
more than 25% of the total value of the ETF. Given that the Funds intend, as described in more
detail below, to track the performance of certain securities indices consisting at any given time of
one or two securities issued by the United States Treasury, the Funds would not appear to meet
this requirement of the Class Relief Letter based on a strict reading of such requirement.
Accordingly, the Trust, on behalf of itself and the other aforementioned parties, hereby requests
relief from the aforementioned Exchange Act provision and rules.
11.
Parties
A.
The Funds
Each Fund will seek investment results, before fees and expenses, that correspond
generally to the price and yield performance of a specified fixed income securities index
Dtvislon of Market Regulanon, ro Harry A. .Mendelson of Thc Vanguard Croup, Inc., dared Ocroher 8, 2004, iSharcr
Lrhman U S . Treasury lnflanon Protected Srcurlt~esFund and iSharcs Lehman U S AePrcpatc Bond Fund (each a
series of the ishares Trust), lener from James A. Briraaliano, Assisrant Daecror, D~visionof Marker Reaulation, to
LLP, dated September 25,2003; NASDAO Stock ~arket.-~nc.,
Jack P. Drogin of ~ o r ~ a n ; . ~ e &
w Bockius,
is
lekr
from James Brigagliano, Assistant Director, Division of Market Regulation, to Edward S. Knight, Executive Vice
President and General Counsel of NASDAQ Stock Market, Inc., dated November 13,2002, (regarding an extension
to NASDAQ of the application of "generic relief' previously granted to the AMEX with respect to certain exchange
kaded funds); ETF Advisors Trust (with respect to the aading of FITRs), lener from James A. Brigagliano,
Associate Director, Division of Market Regulation, to Mary Joan Hoene of Carter, Ledyard & Milbum, dated
November 1, 2002; & a r c s Tntsl, leners from James A. Driga~liano,Associal? Director, Division of Market
Rceulafion. ro \V. John McCuirc of Morcan. Lewis & Bockius LLP. dated Julv 25.2002, ro .Maw Joan Hoene of
~ G e r~, e d ~ a&
r dMilbum, dated ~ e c e i b e ;I , 2000, and septemb& 5,2000.8nd to ~ a t h l e e nH: Moriarty of
Carter, Ledyard & Milbum, dated May 16,2000; Nasdaa 100 Trust letter from James A. Brigagliano, Assistant
Director, Division of Market Regulation, to James F. Duffy, Executive Vice President and General Counsel, AMEX,
dated March 3, 1999; Select Sector SPDR Trust, letter from Larry E. Bergman, Senior Associate Director, Division
of Market Regulation to Stuart M. Skauss of Gordon Altman Butowsky, dated December 14, 1998; and
DIAMONDS Trust, letter from Larry E. Bergman, Senior Associate Director, Division of Market Regulation, to
James F. Duffy, Executive Vice President and General Counsel, AMEX, dated January 9, 1998.
Letter from Catherine McCuire, Chief Counsel, Division of Market Regulation, to Derivative Products Committee
of the Securities Industry Association, dated November 21,2005. Very recently, the Commission granted class
relief specifically geared to ETFs investing in fixed-income securities with respect to Rules 10a-1, lob-17 and 14ed
under the Exchange Act, Rules 101 and 102 of Regulation M and Rule 200(g) of Regulation SHO to ETFs meeting
similar criteria. Letter from James A. Brigagliano, Associate Director, Division of Market Regulation, to Benjamin
J. Haskin of Willkie F a r & Gallagher, LLP, dated April 9, 2007 (the "Willkie Farr Class Relief Letter"). We
believe that the Trust may rely on the Willkie Farr Class Relief Letter without submitting a separate request for
relief as to the provisions addressed in that letter.
Catherine McGuire, Esq
June 29,2007
Page 4
(individually, an "Underlying Index" and collectively, the "Underlying Indices"), as described
below and in more detail in Appendix A hereto. Each Underlying Index is comprised of only
one or two debt securities issued by the U.S. Treasury ("Treasury Securities"), and the
components of each Underlying Index change whenever there is a new public sale or "auction"
by the U.S. Government of an Index's underlying Treasury Security. This "rolling" aspect of
each Underlying Index is intended so that each Underlying Index serves as a benchmark
reflecting the current yield of U.S. Government securities of a given maturity. The Underlying
Indices are owned and maintained by Ryan Holdings LLC and Ryan ALM, Inc. (collectively, the
"Index ~rovider").~
Each Fund will invest at least 90% of its total assets in Treasury Securities, and up to
10%in futures contracts, options, various money market instruments and other derivative
instruments. Because each Underlying Index is comprised of only one or hvo securities, and
those securities change each time an auction of a security occurs, it is not practicable for the
Funds to invest exclusively in the component securities of the Underlying Indices. Instead, each
Fund invests in a limited number of (fewer than ten) Treasury Securities that are intended to
produce portfolio cash flows similar in duration to those of the security(ies) in its Underlying
Index. These Treasury Securities may include the Treasury Securities that are component
securities of the Underlying Index, Treasury Securities that were such components when
purchased by the Fund but no longer are because of a subsequent auction, and Treasury
Securities that had longer maturities when initially issued but whose remaining maturities make
them appropriate for investment by the Fund. In order to track the performance of its Underlying
Index, Ameristock Corporation (the "Adviser"), the investment adviser of each Fund, seeks to
match the average dollar-weighted duration of the Fund closely to the duration of its Underlying
Index (plus or minus a number of months specified below).
The five Funds and their Underlying Indices are as follows:
(1) AmenstockRyan 1-Year Treasury ETF. The Fund seeks performance that
corresponds generally to the performance of the Ryan 1 Year Adjusted Treasury Index.
The Ryan 1 Year Adjusted Treasury Index is based on the return of a portfolio with 213
weighting in the most recent auctioned 6-month U.S. Treasury bill and 113 weighting in
the most recently auctioned 2-year U.S. Treasury note. The Adviser attempts to match
the average dollar-weighted duration of the Fund to within one month of the duration of
such Underlying Index.
(2) Ameristock/Ryan 2-Year Treasury ETF. The Fund seeks performance that
corresponds generally to the performance of the Ryan 2 Year Treasury Index. The Ryan
2 year Treasury Index is based on the return of the most recently auctioned 2-year U.S.
The Adviser (as defmed below) has entered into a Consulting Services and Licensing Agreement ("Licensing
Agreement") ;ith the Index Provider. Under the Licensing ~greement,the Index ~ r & i d e rgrants the ~ d v i s e r a
license to use the Underlying Indices and certain related service names and marks of the Index Provider. Under a
Sublicense Agreement, the Adviser in turn grants sub-license rights to the Trust at no charge.
WO 728598.2
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 5
Treasury note. The Adviser attempts to match the average dollar-weighted duration of the
Fund to within two months of the duration of such Underlying Index.
(3) AmeristocWRyan 5-Year Treasury ETF. The Fund seeks performance that
corresponds generally to the performance of the Ryan 5 Year Treasury Index. The Ryan
5 Year Treasury Index is based on the return of the most recently auctioned 5-year U.S.
Treasury note. The Adviser attempts to match the average dollar-weighted duration of
the Fund to within six months of the duration of such Underlying Index.
(4) AmeristockiRyan 10-Year Treasury ETF. The Fund seeks performance that
corresponds generally to the performance of the Ryan 10 Year Treasury Index. The Ryan
10 Year Treasury Index is based on the return of the most recently auctioned 10-year
U.S. Treasury note. The Adviser attempts to match the average dollar-weighted duration
ofthe Fund to within six months of the duration of such Underlying Index.
(5) AmeristocklRyan 20-Year Treasury ETF. The Fund seeks performance that
corresponds generally to the performance of the Ryan 20 Year Treasury Index. The Ryan
20 Year Treasury Index is based on an equal weighting of the most recently auctioned
10-year U.S. Treasury note and 30-year U.S. Treasury bond. The Adviser attempts to
match the average dollar-weighted duration of the Fund to within nine months of the
duration of such Underlying Index.
B.
Other Parties
Adviser- The Adviser is the investment adviser to each Fund, with overall responsibility
for the management and administration of the Funds, subject to the supervision of the Trust's
Board of Trustees. The Adviser is a California corporation, with its principal office located at
1320 Harbor Bay Parkway, Suite 145, Alameda, California 94502. The Adviser is registered as
an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended. The Adviser has
the authority to engage one or more sub-advisers to manage the investments of each Fund, but
has no current intention of doing so.
Distributor - ALPS Distributors, Inc. ("Distributor") is a Commission-registered brokerdealer and a member of the National Association of Securities Dealers, Inc. The Distributor acts
on an agency basis and is the principal underwriter for the Trust in connection with the issuance
of Creation Units (as defined below) of each Fund. The Distributor is not an affiliated person of
the Trust or the Adviser.
Administrator/CustodianfTransferAgent -Brown Brothers Haniman & Co. ("BBH)
acts as administrator ("Administrator"), custodian ("Custodian"), and a transfer agent ("Transfer
Agent") for each Fund. The identity of the Administrator, Custodian, and the Transfer Agent is
disclosed in the Prospectus and Statement of Additional Information for the Trust. The
performance of the duties and obligations of BBH in these various capacities will be conducted
within the provisions of the 1940 Act and the rules thereunder.
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 6
111.
Fund Shares
A.
Purchase of Creation Units
Shares are issued and sold by the Funds only in "Creation Units," each of which consists
of 100,000 Shares, on a continuous basis through the Distributor at their net asset value ("NAV")
next determined after receipt of an order in proper form.' Creation Units may be purchased only
by or through a DTC Participant that has the ability to clear through the Federal Reserve System
and that has entered into an agreement with the Distributor and the Transfer Agent with respect
to creations and redemptions of Creation Units (each such entity being an "Authorized
Participant"). The Distributor will deliver the Trust's Prospectus (and, upon request, Statement
of Additional Information) to each Authorized Participant purchasing Creation Units.
The consideration for purchase of a Creation Unit generally consists of the deposit of a
designated portfolio of securities that the Adviser believes in the aggregate will cause the Fund
to closely match the duration and price and yield performance of the Fund's Underlying Index
(the "Deposit Securities") and an amount of cash (the "Cash Component"). The Cash
Component represents the difference between the net asset value of a Creation Unit and the
market value of the Deposit Securities. Together, the Deposit Securities and the Cash
Component constitute the "Fund Deposit," which represents the minimum initial and subsequent
investment amount for the purchase of a Creation Unit of any Fund.
Creation Units of each Fund may be created in advance of receipt by the Trust of all or a
portion of the applicable Deposit Securities. In these circumstances, the initial deposit will have
a value greater than the net asset value of the Shares on the date the order is placed in proper
form since, in addition to available Deposit Securities, cash must be deposited in an amount
equal to the sum of (i) the Cash Component, plus (ii) at least 105% of the market value of the
undelivered Deposit Securities (the "Additional Cash Deposit"). An additional amount of cash
shall be required to be deposited with the Trust, pending delivery of the missing Deposit
Securities to the extent necessary to maintain the Additional Cash Deposit with the Trust in an
amount at least equal to 105% of the daily marked to market value of the missing Deposit
Securities. To the extent that missing Deposit Securities are not received by the Trust, the Trust
may use the cash on deposit to purchase the missing Deposit Securities. Authorized Participants
will be liable to the Trust for the costs incurred by the Trust in connection with any such
purchases. These costs will be deemed to include the amount by which the actual purchase price
of the Deposit Securities exceeds the market value of such Deposit Securities on the day the
purchase order was deemed received by the Distributor, plus the brokerage and related
transaction costs associated with such purchases. The Trust will return any unused portion of the
Additional Cash Deposit once all of the missing Deposit Securities have been properly received
T h e net asset value of each Fund will be computed once each day that (i) the U.S. Government securities markets,
(ii) the Custodian, and (iii) the New York Stock Exchange and the American Stock Exchange are open for business.
The net asset value will be computed as of the close of regular trading of the U.S.Government securities markets
(normally 3:00 p.m. Eastern time).
WO 728598.2
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 7
by the Custodian or purchased by the Trust and deposited into the Trust. In addition, a
transaction fee, as set forth below, will be charged in all cases.
All standard orders to purchase Creation Units must be received by the Distributor no
later than the close of regular trading in the U.S. Government securities markets, ordinarily 3:00
p.m. Eastern time ("Closing Time"), on the date such order is placed in order for the purchase of
Creation Units to be effected based on the net asset value of Fund Shares as next determined on
such date after receipt of the order in proper form. Orders requesting substitution of a "cash-inlieu" amount as described below generally must be received by the Distributor no later than 2:00
p.m. Eastern time to enable the order to be effected at the NAV determined at the Closing Time.
The date on which an order to create Creation Units (or an order to redeem Creation Units, as
discussed below) is placed is referred to as the "Transmittal Date." Any order that is not in
proper form will be rejected. Fund Deposits must be delivered through the Federal Reserve
System by an Authorized Participant.
The transfer of the Fund Deposit must be ordered by the DTC Participant in a timely
fashion so as to ensure the delivery of the requisite number of Deposit Securities through DTC to
the account of the Fund by no later than 1:00 p.m. Eastern time, on the Settlement Date. The
"Settlement Date" for all Funds is generally the first Business Day after the Transmittal Date. At
such time, the Transfer Agent will take the necessary steps to release the Creation Unit(s) and
credit them to the Authorized Participant's account with DTC.
The standard transaction fee for each Fund will be $1,000 for an in-kind creation, charged
per day on which the investor purchases Creation Units of Fund Shares, regardless of the number
of Creation Units being purchased by the investor on that day. Authorized Participants will also
be responsible for the costs of transferring the securities constituting the Deposit Securities to the
account of the Fund. In all cases, such fees will be limited in accordance with the requirements
of the SEC applicable to management investment companies offering redeemable securities.
The Trust may permit, in its discretion, with respect to one or more Funds under certain
circumstances, an Authorized Participant to substitute cash in lieu of depositing some or all of
the requisite Deposit Securities, and the Trust may substitute cash for Redemption Securities, as
defined below, in the case of a redemption. In addition, as described above, Fund Shares may be
issued in advance of receipt of Deposit Securities subject to various conditions including a
requirement to maintain on deposit with the Trust cash at least equal to 105% of the market value
of missing Deposit Securities. In each instance of such cash sales or redemptions, the Trust may
impose transaction fees that will be higher than the transaction fees associated with in-kind
purchases or redemptions. In all cases, such fees will be limited in accordance with the
requirements of the Commission applicable to management investment companies offering
redeemable securities, and will be fully disclosed in the prospectus and Statement of Additional
Information for the Funds.
The Custodian makes available through the National Securities Clearing Corporation
("NSCC") on each Bilsiness Day, prior to the opening of business on the Arnex (currently 9:30
a.m. Eastern time), the list of the names and the required number and maturity of each Deposit
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 8
Security to be included in the current Fund Deposit (based on information at the end of the
previous Business Day) for each Fund. Such Deposit Securities are applicable, subject to any
adjustments as described below, in order to effect creations of Creation Units of a given Fund
until such time as the next-announced composition of the Deposit Securities is made available.
The identity, number and maturity of the Deposit Securities required for a Fund Deposit
for each Fund changes as rebalancing adjustments and interest payments on underlying bonds are
reflected &om time to time by the Adviser, with a view to remaining consistent with the
investment objective of each Fund. The composition of the Deposit Securities will also reflect
changes in the composition of the Fund's Underlying Index known to the Adviser on the date of
announcement to be in effect by the time of delivery of the Fund Deposit.
Due to the value of a Creation Unit in each Fund, it is expected that, generally, only
institutions will purchase Creation Units from the Funds.
B.
Redemption of Creation Units
Fund Shares are redeemable only in Creation Units through BBH in its capacity as the
Transfer Agent. Orders to redeem Creation Units of the Funds may only be effected by or
through an Authorized Participant.
Consistent with Section 22(e) of the 1940 Act and Rule 22e-2 thereunder, the right to
redeem Shares directly from a Fund will not be suspended, nor payment upon redemption
delayed, except (i) for any period during which the New York Stock Exchange is closed (other
than customary weekend and holiday closings); (ii) for any period during which trading on the
New York Stock Exchange is suspended or restricted; (iii) for any period during which an
emergency exists as a result of which disposal of the Shares or determination of the Shares' net
asset value is not reasonably practicable; (iv) on days that are not Business Days; or (iv) in such
other circumstance as is permitted by the Commission. Subject to the foregoing, Creation Units
are redeemable on any Business Day, principally in exchange for portfolio securities held by the
Funds ("Portfolio Securities").
BBH, through the NSCC, makes available immediately prior to the opening of business
on the AMEX the list of names and the number of shares of each Fund's Portfolio Securities that
will be applicable (subject to possible amendment or correction) to redemption requests received
in proper form on that day ("Redemption Securities"). Unless cash redemptions are available or
specified for a Fund, the redemption proceeds for a Creation Unit generally consist of
Redemption Securities as announced by the Custodian on the Business Day of the request for
redemption, plus cash in an amount equal to the difference between the net asset value of the
Shares being redeemed, as next determined after a receipt of a request in proper form, and the
value of the Redemption Securities, less the redemption transaction fee. In the event that the
Redemption Securities have a value greater than the net asset value of the Shares, a
compensating cash payment to the Trust equal to the differential will be required to be paid by or
on behalf of the redeeming investor. An Authorized Participant or an investor for which it is
acting that is subject to a legal restriction with respect to a particular stock included in the
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 9
Redemption Securities applicable to the redemption of a Creation Unit may be paid an equivalent
amount of cash.
If redemptions are effected in cash the redemption proceeds will be equal to the net asset
value of the Fund Shares based on the net asset value of the Fund next determined after the
redemption request is received in proper form by the Transfer Agent, minus a redemption
transaction fee specified for cash redemptions in the Trust's Prospectus. As with purchases,
redemptions of Shares will be effected through the Federal Reserve System and DTC, and
settlement will occur no later than the Business Day following the day on which a redemption
order is received in proper form.
C.
The Trading Market
Fund Shares will be freely tradeable on the Amex throughout the trading session. The
price of Fund Shares trading on the Amex will be based on a current bidloffer market. The
trading market on the Amex affords investors the opportunity to assume and liquidate positions
in Fund Shares at their discretion, permitting them to take advantage of prices at any time of the
trading day. This combination of intra-day liquidity with the Creation Unit purchase and
redemption features creates potential arbitrage opportunities that, in turn, should mitigate pricing
inefficiencies. The structural characteristics of Fund Shares are believed to provide investors
with a liquid, price-efficient security that closely tracks its Underlying Index.
By offering investors the ability to buy, in effect, a very small amount of Treasury
Securities and to maintain a relatively constant, specified duration, the Funds allow retail
investors to employ a strategy currently available, for all practical purposes, only to institutional
investors, and allow such investment without the restrictions of a non-exchange traded, open-end
fund.
IV.
Disclosure Documents
The purchase of Fund Shares in Creation Unit aggregations or in secondary market
transactions will be accompanied or preceded by a statutory prospectus or a "Product
~escri~tion."~
The Distributor will coordinate the production and distribution of prospectuses and
Product Descriptions to broker-dealers. It will be the responsibility of the broker-dealers to
ensure that a prospectus or Product Description (if the Application is granted) is provided to each
secondary market purchaser of Fund Shares.
In the Application, the Tmst is seeking an exemption from Section 24(d) of the 1940 Act. The exemption would
be conditioned on an undertaking that investors purchasing Fund Shares from or through dealers in the secondary
market will receive a short "Product Description" in lieu of the lengthier statutory prospectus. The Product
Description will provide a plain English description of the relevant Fund and its Fund Shares.
Catherine McGuire, Esq
June 29,2007
Page 10
V.
Requests for Relief
The relief requested in this letter is identical or substantially similar to the relief
previously granted by the Commission to other ETFs not related to the rust?
A.
Rule lob-10
Rule lob-10 requires a broker or dealer effecting a transaction in a security for a
customer to give or send written notification to such customer disclosing the information
specified in paragraph (a) of Rule lob-10, including the identity, price and number of shares or
units (or principal amount) of the security purchased or sold. The Trust requests that the
Commission grant an exemption from Rule lob-10, as discussed below, with respect to the
purchase and redemption of Creation Units. The Trust is not requesting exemptive or
interpretive relief from Rule lob-10 in connection with purchases and sales o f Fund Shares in the
secondary market.
The Trust proposes that broker-dealers or other persons either purchasing or redeeming
Fund Shares in Creation Unit aggregations for their customers be permitted to provide such
customers with a statement of the number of such Creation Units created or redeemed without
providing a statement of the identity, number, price and maturity of individual Deposit Securities
tendered to the Trust for purposes of purchasing Creation Units, or the identity, number, price
and maturity of individual Redemption Securities to be delivered by the Trust to the redeeming
holder. The composition of the Deposit Securities required for tender or the Redemption
Securities required for delivery will be disseminated by the Custodian through NSCC on each
Business Day and will be applicable to requests for creations or redemption, as the case may be,
on that day. This information will be publicly available at the primary listing Exchange and will
be made available to requesting broker-dealers or other persons through the NSCC. Moreover,
institutions and market professionals will be readily able to calculate independently such
information based on publicly available information. The Trust anticipates that any institution or
broker-dealer engaging in creation or redemption transactions would have done so only with
knowledge of the composition of the applicable securities, so that specific information in the
Rule lob-10 notification wot~ldbe redundant.
The Trust agrees that any exemptive or interpretive relief under Rule lob-10 with respect
to creations and redemptions be subject to the following conditions:
(1) Confirmations to customers engaging in creations or redemptions must state that all
information required by Rule lob-10 will be provided upon request;
(2) Any such request by a customer for information required by Rule lob-10 will be
filled in a timely manner, in accordance with Rule lob-10(c); and
' Se e footnote 3, m.
WO 728598.2
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 11
(3) Except for the identity, number, price and maturity of such Deposit Securities or
Redemption Securities, confirmations to customers must disclose all other information
required by Rule lob-10(a).
B.
Section Il(d)(l) of the Exchange Act and Rule lldl-2
Section 1 l(d)(l) of the Exchange Act generally prohibits a person who is both a broker
and a dealer from effecting any transaction in which the broker-dealer extends credit to a
customer on any security that was part of a new issue in the distribution of which the brokerdealer participated as a member of a selling syndicate within thirty days prior to such transaction
with the c u s t ~ m e r . 'Rule
~ 1ldl-2 provides an exemption from Section 1l(d)(l) for securities
issued by a registered open-end management investment company or unit investment trust with
respect to transactions by a broker-dealer who extends credit on such security, provided the
person to whom credit has been extended has owned the security for more than thirty days.
The Trust hereby requests clarification that Section 1l(d)(l) does not apply to brokerdealers that engage in both proprietary and customer transactions in Fund Shares in the
secondary market. The Trust believes that application of the thirty-day restriction in Rule 1Idl2 to broker-dealers engaging exclusively in secondary market transactions in Fund Shares (i.e.,
broker-dealers that do not participate in the issuance of Creation Units as Authorized
Participants) does not further the purposes of Section 1 l(d)(l) or Rule 1ldl-2. The only
compensation a broker-dealer will receive for representing a customer in purchasing Fund Shares
in secondary market transactions is a customary commission (if acting as agent) or markuplspread (if acting as principal), determined in the same manner as in any sale of stock by the
broker-dealer in a secondary market transaction.
In addition, with regard to broker-dealers who participate in the issuance of Creation
Units ("Broker-Dealer APs"), the Trust believes that Broker-Dealer APs do not have incentives
to use credit to engage in the "share pushing" that Section 1 l(d)(l) was designed to address."
First, Broker-Dealer APs do not have the risk exposures that underwriters face in firmcommitment underwritings of new issues. For example, Broker-Dealer APs do not have capital
at risk or market exposure of the type that an underwriter has with respect to its allotment of a
new offering. Authorized Participants are under no obligation to place orders for any amount of
Creation Units, and therefore they act only on a demand-driven basis - Authorized Participants
purchase creation units of ETF shares only as and when they or their customers need the ETF
shares for trading or investment purposes. As a result, Broker-Dealer APs do not have an
incentive to extend, maintain, or arrange credit to induce purchases of securities in order to
reduce funding and market risk exposures.
Section 1l(d)(l) was intended to address conflicts of interest arising when a person acts as both a broker and a
dealer, one oE which is that a broker-dealer could induce his customers to buy on credit the very same securities he
has undertaken to distribute to the public.
" The Ttust notes that Broker-Dealer APs may in certain instances be covered by the exemptions provided in Rule
11d1-1.
WO 728598.2
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 12
In addition, Broker-Dealer APs do not receive the types of special sales compensation
typically paid to undenvriters or placement agents. They will not be paid an underwriting
commission, concession or sales charge from the Trust or the Distributor in connection with the
purchase of Creation Units from the Trust. As noted above, Broker-Dealer APs will be required
to pay a transaction fee for the purchase of a Creation Unit. In addition, upon sale of the Fund
Shares comprising a Creation Unit to customers or other broker-dealers, a Broker-Dealer AP
(like a broker-dealer engaging in or effecting transactions in Fund Shares that is not an
Authorized Participant) receives only a customary commission or mark-upkpread, determined in
the same manner as in any sale of stock by the ~ r o k e r - ~ e a l AP
e r in a secondary market
transaction. These forms of compensation do not create any special incentives for a BrokerDealer AP to extend, maintain, or arrange for the extension or maintenance of credit to investors
in order to induce a purchase of Fund Shares.
We note that upon the initial formation of the Trust, Broker-Dealer APs may invest in a
substantial amount of Fund Shares (in the form of Creation Units), among other reasons, to
facilitate the launch of the Funds. In order to address any concerns that might arise regarding the
incentives created by any such initial investment in the Funds, we believe it would not be
inappropriate for the Commission to continue to apply Section 1l(d)(l) to Broker-Dealer APs for
a period ofthirty days after the Fund Shares initially commence trading.
The Trust also requests that the Staff not recommend any enforcement action to the
Commission under Section 1l(d)(l) of the Exchange Act if broker-dealers treat Fund Shares, for
purposes of Rule 1ldl-2, as "securities issued by a registered open-end investment company. . .
as defined in the Investment Company Act" and thereby extend credit or maintain or arrange for
the extension or maintenance of credit on Fund Shares that have been owned by the persons to
whom credit is provided for more than thirty days, in reliance on the exemption contained in
Rule 1ldl-2.
C.
Rule 15cl-6
Rule 15cl-6 requires a broker or dealer to send a customer written notification of its
participation in the primary or secondary distribution of any security in which the broker-dealer
effects any transaction in or for such customer's account or induces the purchase or sale of such
security by such customer. Tne Trust believes that disclosure by a broker-dealer of its
participation in a primary or secondary distribution of any security held by a Fund or component
security in the relevant Underlying Index would impose an unnecessary and unjustifiable burden
on broker-dealers engaging in transactions in Shares for their customers. There is no realistic
potential for manipulating the market price of a security held by any Fund or the market price of
any security in the relevant Underlying Index by transactions in Shares because the Portfolio
Securities will predominately be, and the component securities of the Underlying Indices are
limited to, U.S. Treasury securities, which are exempted securities as defined in Section 3(a)(12)
of the Exchange Act. The inability to manipulate the market in these securities is demonstrated
by their exclusion from Rules 101 and 102 of Regulation M . ' ~The same justification would
''See Rule 101(c)(3) and Rule 102(d)(3) of Regulation M.
WO 728598.2
Catherine McGuire, Esq.
June 29,2007
Page 13
apply to granting relief from providing this disclosure to customers in connection with the
creation or redemption of Creation Unit aggregations of Shares. Furthermore, application of
Rule 15cl-6 could adversely affect the attractiveness of Shares to broker-dealers and thereby
affect the market liquidity and the pricing efficiency of Shares. The Trust, therefore, requests
that the Commission grant no-action relief from the application of Rule 15~1-6with respect to
purchase and redemptions of Creation Units, and secondary market transactions in Shares.
V.
Conclusion
Based on the foregoing, we respectfully request that the Commission and the Staff grant
the relief requested herein. Should you have any questions please call Tom Conner at
202.383.0590 or Eric Freed at 212.389.5055.
Very truly yours,
@,k&%,.UA-
W.Thomas Conner
Z-?6+
Eric C. Freed
cc:
Brian A. Bussey
Matthew A. Daigler
Appendix A
Description of Underlvine Indices
The Underlying Indices were created by Ronald J. Ryan, are owned by Ryan Holdings LLC and Ryan
ALM, Inc., and are compiled and maintained by Ryan ALM, Inc. (collectively the "lndex Provider").
Since 1983, the Index Provider and its predecessors have calculated and published indices based on the
"on-the-run" ("OTR) U.S. Treasury yield curve. The Underlying Indices serve as the accepted
benchmarlts of OTR rates. An OTR Treasury Security is the most recently auctioned Treasury bill, note
or bond of a stated maturity.
-
Ryan 1-Year Adjusted Treasury Index Since May 23,2001, this Index has been based on (a) the
retum of the mosf recently auctioned 6-month Treasury bill, weighted two-thirds, and (b) the retum of the
most recently auctioned 2-year Treasury note, weighted one-third. The Index is calculated once each day.
The original Index was created on December 31, 1988. The 6-month Treasury bill is replaced upon each
weekly auction of new 6-month Treasury bills, and the 2-year Treasury note is replaced upon each new
monthly auction.
Ryan 2-Year Treasury Index - The Index is based on the renun of the most recently auctioned 2-year
Treasury note. The Index is calculated once each day. The Index is available for periods back to August
24, 1973. The 2-year Treasury note is replaced upon each new monthly auction.
Ryan 5-Year Treasury lndex - The Index is based on the retum of the most recently auctioned 5-year
Treasury note. The Index is calculated once each day. The Index is available for periods back to August
28, 1979. The 5-year Treasury note is replaced upon each quarterly auction of new 5-year Treasury notes.
Ryan 10-Year Treasury lndex - The Index is based on theretum of the most recently auctioned 10-year
Treasury note. The Index is calculated once each day. The Index is available for periods back to
November 1, 1977. The 10-year Treasury note is replaced upon each new quarterly auction.
Ryan 20-Year Treasury Index - The Index is based on the retum of the most recently auctioned 10-year
Treasury note and theretum of the most recently auctioned 30-year Treasury bond, weighted equally.
The Index is calculated once each day. The Index is available for periods back to December 31, 1977.
The 10-year Treasurynote is replaced upon each quarterly auction of such notes, and the 30-year
Treasury bond is replaced upon each new auction.
Index Constructian Methods
Single Maturity OTR Indices (Ryan 2-Year Treasury, Ryan 5-Year Treasury, and Ryan IO-Year
Treasury)
1. The old auction issue at a particular stated maturity (e.g. 2-year note) is rolled into the new auction
issue on the appropriate auction date at 3:00 p.m. Eastern time for settlement on the new issue's
issue date
2. The new auction issue (OTR) is purchased at the offer price for settlement on its issue date
3. The old auction issue is sold at the bid price for settlement on the new auction issue date
(simultaneous settlement).
4. From auction date to new issue settlement date, the Indices receive the price return of the new
OTR auction issue and the income retum of the old auction issue.
5. Each Index is priced at the bid side once daily at 3:00 p.m. Eastern time to obtain the daily value
most widely published. Intra-day values will be disseminated every 15 seconds by the AMEX
each business day.
6. The index construction assumes no coupon reinvestment since interest is paid semi-annually and
all note auctions are either monthly or quatterly. A change in the auction schedule may necessitate
a change in the treatment of coupons (i.e., reopenings, longer intervals in the auction process).
Composite Maturity Indices (Ryan l-Year Adjusted Treasury and Ryan 20-Year Treasury)
1. The Single Maturity Index procedure is followed for each of the 6-Month, 2-Year, 10-Year, and
30-Year maturities.
2. The l-Year AdjustedTreasury Index is calculated by combining two-thirds of the 6-Month retum
and one-third of the 2-Year retum. The 20 Year Treasury Index is calculated by combining onehalf of the 10-Yearretum and one-half of the 30-Year return.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.