In the Matter of DAVID R. FERGUSON
Agency decision
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
February 16, 2011
CBCA 2193-TRAV
In the Matter of DAVID R. FERGUSON
David R. Ferguson, Ellicott City, MD, Claimant.
Jennifer A. Strazza, Office of Associate General Counsel, National Security Agency,
Fort George G. Meade, MD, appearing for Department of Defense.
HYATT, Board Judge.
Claimant, David R. Ferguson, has requested the Board’s review of the decision of the
National Security Agency (NSA) to deny reimbursement for travel expenses he incurred in
connection with a temporary duty (TDY) assignment at the United States Army Command
and General Staff College (CGSC) at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas.
Background
Mr. Ferguson was selected by NSA’s Associate Directorate for Corporate Leadership
to attend the School of Advanced Military Studies (SAMS) at the CGSC, as the NSA
civilian participant. CGSC provides graduate-level education for Army majors as well as
for students from the Air Force, Navy, and Marines, along with civilian government
personnel and foreign military officers. The program in which Mr. Ferguson was enrolled
was for eleven months and his report date was June 14, 2010.
Shortly before he left for training, claimant visited his doctor for a checkup. His
physician referred him to several other doctors, who ordered various tests. At that time,
claimant was told that he would need an additional test, which he was not able to schedule
before departing for the TDY assignment.
CBCA 2193-TRAV
2
Claimant drove from his permanent duty station (PDS) in Maryland to Fort
Leavenworth. Once he arrived, Mr. Ferguson met with his instructors and, after obtaining
more information about the curriculum and class schedule, he realized he would have to
miss some classes to find doctors and undergo laboratory tests. He also began to experience
symptoms of a new physical problem. He decided that it was not a good time to take the
training. He contacted his office at Fort Meade, and personnel at the college, and apprised
them of his concerns about his health status and the need for periodic medical checkups,
which he thought would be incompatible with the rigorous nature of the program. Claimant
then drove back to Maryland.
Mr. Ferguson explained his situation more fully in an email message to NSA. He
offered two reasons for his decision to discontinue the training. First, he had not fully
understood what the program entailed when he accepted the assignment. When he learned
more about it, he concluded that it was not a good fit for him. Second, he believed that his
medical circumstances presented an obstacle to continuing in the program, because of the
need to locate suitable physicians in Kansas City and to schedule follow-up doctor visits and
laboratory work, including the need for blood tests every three months. In addition,
claimant’s insurance plan would not cover medical expenses incurred in the Kansas City
area.
Mr. Ferguson states that since returning to his PDS, he has seen three doctors and a
surgeon and undergone numerous medical tests. He continues to see doctors on a quarterly
basis. Mr. Ferguson considers that the logistics of setting up repeated doctor visits and tests
while taking classes was unworkable and that these circumstances should thus qualify him
for reimbursement of his travel expenses incurred prior to his departure from Kansas City.
Mr. Ferguson submitted a voucher for his travel expenses prior to abandonment of
the mission. His expenses included mileage to Kansas City in the amount of $557.25 and
hotel and per diem in Kansas City for the amount of $1184. NSA disallowed the claim.
Discussion
Agencies have no authority to reimburse the expenses of travel and per diem of an
employee who fails to complete a temporary duty assignment for personal reasons. See
Robert T. Matsui, B-198167 (Feb. 12, 1981); Calvin A. Ehly, B-192718 (Mar. 14, 1979); 47
Comp. Gen. 59 (1967); 41 Comp. Gen. 573 (1962). This rule is reflected in Joint Travel
Regulations (JTR) C4420-C, which states as follows:
The employee is responsible for carrying out the mission for
which travel is undertaken. An employee who does not report
CBCA 2193-TRAV
3
to the TDY location, or who, upon arrival there, refuses to
perform the mission or resigns, is financially liable to the
[Government] for the [Government]-paid TDY travel and
transportation allowances.
The statutory provisions governing reimbursement of employees’ expenses of official
travel provide an exception for circumstances involving an incapacitating illness or injury
of the employee, or personal emergency, involving illness, incapacitation, or death of a
family member, or other emergency situation such as a fire, flood, or other act of God.
5 U.S.C. § 5702(b)(1) (2006). If an exception is applicable, the agency may approve
reimbursement of certain expenses. Id. § 5702(b)(2).
These provisions are implemented in the Federal Travel Regulation (FTR), at 41 CFR
301-30 (2009), and in various JTR provisions. JTR C4470, which is cited by claimant,
provides as follows:
Except as in Ch[apter] 7, Part H, if an employee abandons travel
for acceptable personal reasons (e.g., illness in the family or
similar circumstances) before reporting to or completing a TDY
assignment, only travel and transportation allowances to the
abandonment point are allowable. Costs relating to the
employee’s return to the PDS are the employee’s financial
responsibility unless the employee completed the TDY mission.
NSA points out that JTR C4470 does not apply to claimant’s situation, which is
covered by chapter 7, part H of the JTR. Under JTR C7350, travel and transportation
expenses may be allowed when an employee discontinues or interrupts a TDY travel
assignment before completion as a consequence of an incapacitating illness or injury or a
personal emergency situation. The term “incapacitating illness or injury” is defined in JTR
C7365-C:
For purposes of this Part, an “incapacitating illness or injury” is
one that occurs suddenly for reasons other than the employee’s
own misconduct and renders the employee incapable of
continuing, either temporarily or permanently, the travel
assignment.
It is within the agency’s discretion to determine whether claimant’s reasons for
abandoning his temporary duty assignment fell within the parameters of the pertinent
regulation. When a regulation calls for the exercise of discretion by an agency, the agency’s
CBCA 2193-TRAV
4
determination will not be overturned in the absence of abuse of that discretion. See, e.g.,
Judith A. Sukol, CBCA 2092-RELO, 10-2 BCA ¶ 34,574; Benjamin A. Hanfelder, CBCA
1294-RELO, 08-2 BCA ¶ 33,987. An exercise of discretion is valid if there is a reasonable
basis for the decision made. See, e.g., Donavan L. May, CBCA 2188-TRAV (Jan. 7, 2011)
(citing Arthur Hubbard, CBCA 1932-RELO, 10-2 BCA¶ 34,540 and Jeanne Hehr,
GSBCA16936-RELO, 06-2 BCA ¶ 33,431); Paula A. Shimata, CBCA 1135-RELO, 08-2
BCA ¶ 33,901.
In this case, NSA considered Mr. Ferguson’s statements about his personal health in
conjunction with his acknowledgment that after learning more about it he did not think the
course was a good fit for him. In its response to the claim, NSA points out that the personal
health information provided by claimant does not meet the definition of an incapacitating
illness. The agency evaluated this information and concluded that the need to schedule
periodic medical appointments and tests during out-of-town training may have been
inconvenient for claimant, but did not amount to incapacitation as that term is used in the
regulation. After returning to his permanent duty station, Mr. Ferguson continued to be able
to work. As such, NSA takes the position that the regulation does not apply to claimant’s
circumstances and he is not eligible to be reimbursed for his travel and per diem expenses.
Claimant has produced no evidence to show that the agency’s conclusion that he was not
incapacitated within the meaning of the regulation is an abuse of its discretion.
Decision
The agency’s decision is sustained. The claim is denied.
_________________________________
CATHERINE B. HYATT
Board Judge
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.