In the Matter of COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA

Agency decision

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

April 19, 2023

CBCA 7651-FEMA

In the Matter of COLLIER COUNTY, FLORIDA

Erin Greten and Ernest Abbott of Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell & Berkowitz,

PC, Washington, DC; and Katelyn Dodd of Baker, Donelson, Bearman, Caldwell &

Berkowitz, PC, Birmingham, AL, counsel for Applicant.

Stephanie Stachowicz (Twomey), General Counsel, Florida Division of Emergency

Management, Tallahassee, FL, counsel for Grantee; and Marija Diceviciute, Appeals Officer,

and Melissa Shirah, Recovery Bureau Chief, Florida Division of Emergency Management,

Tallahassee, FL, appearing for Grantee.

Ramoncito J. deBorja, Office of Chief Counsel, Federal Emergency Management

Agency, Department of Homeland Security, Washington, DC, counsel for Federal

Emergency Management Agency.

Before the Arbitration Panel consisting of Board Judges VERGILIO, GOODMAN, and

SULLIVAN.

SULLIVAN, Board Judge, writing for the panel.

Collier County, Florida, sought to arbitrate the denial by the Federal Emergency

Management Agency (FEMA) of its request for public assistance funds for a beach

renourishment project. FEMA denied Collier County’s request because the county began

work on the project before FEMA finished its environmental and historic preservation (EHP)

review. The panel finds that the primary focus of Collier County’s challenge—whether

further environmental review was necessary—is foreclosed as untimely because FEMA made

that determination in 2021. Regarding Collier County’s contention that it reasonably

believed that the environmental reviews were complete or could have been completed after

construction began, the panel finds that FEMA’s 2021 decision put Collier County on notice

CBCA 7651-FEMA

2

that a full environmental review was necessary and declines to disturb FEMA’s

determination that the review had to be complete before construction began.

Background

Collier County experienced widespread flooding as a result of Hurricane Irma in

September 2017. Following the disaster, Collier County sought public assistance funds to

construct emergency sand berms on its beaches. In February 2020, FEMA denied the

county’s request because the work had not been completed within the regulatory six-month

period for emergency work.

Collier County appealed the determination, and in August 2021, FEMA granted the

appeal and provided a time extension through the end of April 2022. However, FEMA

conditioned the extension, in part, upon the requirement that “[a]ll conditions outlined in

FEMA’s Finding of No Significant Impact (FONSI) for the finalized SEA [supplemental

environmental assessment] must be followed.” Request for Arbitration (RFA), Exhibit 2 at

6. When FEMA notified the applicant of its conditional approval with the need for a full

environmental review, it noted that the county’s delays in performing the project “obviated

the expedited EHP and permitting procedures available for the construction of emergency

beach berms. As a result of the project denial, the full EHP review and permitting process,

already in process, was suspended.” Id. at 5.

Collier County started construction on the project on November 1, 2021, to meet the

new deadline and to avoid interfering with turtle nesting season. On November 3, 2021,

FEMA contacted county officials to discuss the outstanding EHP review items and learned

that construction had begun. FEMA informed Collier County that the project was not in

compliance with the requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) because

the necessary consultation with local tribes, as required by Section 106 of the National

Historic Preservation Act and public comment period for NEPA and Executive Order 11988,

had not been completed. FEMA told Collier County that it could cease work until the

necessary steps were completed, but the county declined because it had a very narrow

window in which to complete construction.

FEMA never issued the supplemental environmental assessment or FONSI. In

February 2022, FEMA again denied Collier County’s request for public assistance funds

because the county “failed to adhere to EHP regulations requiring completion of the SEA

prior to commencing construction.” RFA, Exhibit 1 at 5. Collier County appealed FEMA’s

determination, which FEMA upheld on the first appeal.

CBCA 7651-FEMA

3

Discussion

Collier County challenges FEMA’s determination that further environmental reviews

were necessary, asserting that the project was emergency work and the scope of work fell

within the statutory exemption from the NEPA requirements found in the Stafford Act.

See 42 U.S.C. § 5159 (2018). The panel need not examine any of these challenges because

Collier County’s request to arbitrate this issue is untimely. Pursuant to the Stafford Act, an

applicant has sixty days to challenge a decision from FEMA regarding eligibility for public

assistance funds. Id. § 5189a(a). In August 2021, FEMA granted an extension of the time

to complete the project, conditioned upon the county following the requirements of a SEA

and FONSI that were yet to be completed. This determination was a decision regarding

eligibility which the applicant could have appealed or sought to arbitrate. Having failed to

appeal or to seek arbitration, Collier County is bound to FEMA’s determination that further

environmental reviews were necessary. Because Collier County’s challenge to this

determination is time-barred, the panel does not reach the merits of this issue.

Collier County also asserts that it “reasonably concluded” from FEMA’s August 2021

decision that the environmental reviews were complete and that it could proceed with the

project. RFA Reply Brief at 9; see also RFA Brief at 14. FEMA’s decision required Collier

County to comply with “all conditions outlined” in FEMA’s FONSI and SEA. It would have

been reasonable and prudent for Collier County to ask FEMA for these documents to ensure

compliance with this requirement. If Collier County had done so, it would have learned that

the environmental reviews were not complete. Collier County did not act reasonably in light

of the language of FEMA’s conditional approval.

Finally, Collier County asserts that FEMA could and should have completed any

necessary environmental reviews after the commencement of construction activities. FEMA

disagrees, and we will not disturb that judgment, adopting the rationale expressed in

Startex-Jackson-Wellford-Duncan Water District, CBCA 7416-FEMA, 22-1 BCA ¶ 38,229,

at 185,657.

Decision

The panel confirms FEMA’s denial of Collier County’s request for public assistance

funds.

Marian E. Sullivan

MARIAN E. SULLIVAN

Board Judge

CBCA 7651-FEMA

4

Allan H. Goodman

ALLAN H. GOODMAN

Board Judge

Joseph A. Vergilio

JOSEPH A. VERGILIO

Board Judge

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.