In the Matter of STEVEN P. LYONS
Agency decision
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
August 20, 2015
CBCA 4375-RELO
In the Matter of STEVEN P. LYONS
Steven P. Lyons, Fishers, IN, Claimant.
Sheila Melton, Director, Travel Functional Area, Enterprise Solutions and Standards,
Defense Finance and Accounting Service, Indianapolis, IN, appearing for Department of
Defense.
HYATT, Board Judge.
Claimant, Steven P. Lyons, a civilian employee of the Department of Defense (DoD),
challenges the denial of an extension of temporary quarters subsistence expenses (TQSE)
benefits incident to his permanent change of station (PCS) move from Dageu, Korea, to
Indianapolis, Indiana, to accept a position with the Defense Finance and Accounting Service
(DFAS).
Background
Mr. Lyons was offered the position in Indiana as a participant in the DoD Priority
Placement Program (PPP). The travel authorization for this relocation was issued on
January 27, 2014, with a reporting date of March 9, 2014. The initial PCS travel orders did
not provide for TQSE, but were subsequently amended by the gaining office, which
authorized sixty days of TQSE on an actual expense basis on February 11, 2014.
Claimant entered into temporary quarters at his new duty station on March 8, 2014.
He has been reimbursed by the agency for the first sixty days of TQSE occupancy, from
March 8 through May 6, 2014. On May 19, 2014, however, Mr. Lyons suffered a serious
illness and was hospitalized for one week, followed by approximately two-and-one-half
weeks of convalescence at the temporary residence. Claimant states that his medical
CBCA 4375-RELO
2
condition hindered his ability to close on and move into the home he had purchased. Closing
on the house was completed on June 6, 2014, and the family moved into the house on
June 8, 2014, but had to wait for delivery of household furniture until June 27, 2014.
When Mr. Lyons asked DFAS to extend his TQSE benefits through June 8, 2014, to
accommodate his medical circumstances, the agency responded that under the Joint Travel
Regulations (JTR) it had no authority to extend TQSE beyond the sixty days initially
approved for employees returning from an overseas assignment under the PPP, even in the
presence of extenuating circumstances.
Discussion
The purpose of TQSE is to reimburse transferred employees reasonably and equitably
for subsistence expenses incurred when it is necessary to occupy temporary quarters. See,
e.g., Stephen J. Collier, CBCA 4395-RELO, 15-1 BCA ¶ 35,979; Zenaida Canaba,
CBCA 3993-RELO, 15-1 BCA ¶ 35,958. By statute, 5 U.S.C. § 5724a(c) (2012), federal
agencies are authorized to pay the subsistence expenses of a transferring employee who is
occupying temporary quarters incident to a transfer in the interest of the Government for a
period of up to sixty days, and may reimburse such expenses for up to an additional sixty
days if the designated agency official determines there are compelling reasons for the
continued occupancy of temporary quarters.
The Federal Travel Regulation (FTR), which governs travel entitlements for civilian
employees of the Federal Government, provides the following with respect to actual expense
TQSE:
Your agency may authorize you to claim actual TQSE in increments of
30-days or less, not to exceed 60 consecutive days. However, if your agency
determines that there is a compelling reason for you to continue occupying
temporary quarters after 60 consecutive days, it may authorize an extension of
up to 60 additional consecutive days. Under no circumstances may you be
authorized reimbursement for actual TQSE for more than a total of 120
consecutive days.
41 CFR 302-6.104 (2014).
This FTR provision is further implemented in the JTR, which contains a similar
provision applicable to most civilian DoD employees. JTR C5364. There is a separate
provision, however, in effect at the time of Mr. Lyons’ transfer, applicable specifically to
employees returning from foreign areas through the PPP program. See JTR C5778-E.1.d.
CBCA 4375-RELO
3
This provision states that participants in the PPP may be authorized a maximum of sixty days
of actual expense TQSE. It is silent with respect to an extension of time in excess of the
initial sixty-day period to accommodate a compelling reason for continued occupancy of
temporary quarters. DFAS interprets this provision to deprive it of authority to extend Mr.
Lyons’ TQSE for any additional time beyond sixty days, regardless of circumstances.
The Board has previously addressed the effect of agency rules that differ from the
FTR:
As we have explained many times, the FTR is a “legislative rule” -- a
regulation issued under express authority from Congress, for the purpose of
affecting individual rights and obligations by filling gaps left by a statute, after
following the Administrative Procedure Act’s notice and comment provisions.
It therefore has controlling weight -- the force of law -- unless the provision
in question is arbitrary, capricious, or manifestly contrary to statute. Any
agency rule which is inconsistent with an FTR provision is consequently
trumped by the FTR and must give way.
Kevin D. Reynolds, CBCA 2201-RELO, 11-1 BCA ¶ 34,756, at 171,061 (citations omitted);
accord Stephen M. England, CBCA 3903-TRAV, 15-1 BCA ¶ 35,870 (citing Robert A.
Cherry, CBCA 3878-TRAV, 14-1 BCA ¶ 35,707).
The Reynolds decision is directly on point. In that case, the agency had a rule
expressly providing that no more than sixty days of actual expense TQSE could be
authorized. The Board explained that this blanket limitation could not stand:
The FTR, implementing the statute, allows an agency to authorize as many as
120 days of eligibility for reimbursement of actually-incurred TQSE, with the
last sixty contingent on a determination that a compelling reason for continued
occupation of temporary quarters exists. The [agency] manual precludes
authorization of those last sixty days. It is therefore inconsistent with the FTR
and may not survive.
11-1 BCA at 171,061.
We note that the provision in question is silent about the availability of an extension
of TQSE for PPP participants. Even if DoD intends through this provision to preclude any
extensions of TQSE for individuals returning from overseas through the PPP, it cannot do
so. This position is at variance with the express purpose of the statute and FTR. The FTR
envisions a case-by-case consideration of the circumstances presented in support of a request
CBCA 4375-RELO
4
for authorization of up to an additional sixty days of TQSE beyond the initial sixty-day
period, and an appropriate exercise of discretion by the agency official charged with the
authority to make the determination.
In this case, the appropriate DFAS official should consider the information provided
by Mr. Lyons in support of his request for additional days of TQSE to determine if the type
of compelling circumstances envisioned by the statute and applicable FTR provision have
been demonstrated in this case and would justify granting some or all of the time he seeks.
Pamela S. Boyd, CBCA 2574-RELO, 12-1 BCA ¶ 35,052. We return the matter to the
agency for this purpose.
Decision
The claim is granted to the extent stated herein.
__________________________________
CATHERINE B. HYATT
Board Judge
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.