Debra Ann Livingston

Citibank, NY, NY Checking and Savings — Interest

Fidelity Contratund — Int/Div

4. Fidelity Convertible Security — Int/Div

Fidelity Growth Co — Int/Div

Fidelity Magellan — Int/Div

NYS Dormitory Authority Bonds — Interest

TIAA Traditional Annuity — Interest

US. Savings Bonds { — None

Vanguard 078 Asset Allocation — Int/Div

Vanguard 081 laternational Growth — Int/Div

Paul J. Kellner Professor of Law, Columba I.aw School

Agreement — 2/1999 — Wolters-Kluwer Law & Busi Comprehensive Criminal Pro

Agreement — 2007 — See Part VIII. Additional Information.

Liability — The Scheol at Columbia University — Agreement to pay grade school tuition

Reimbursement — Notre Dame Law School — 2/18-2120/2009 — South Bend, Indiana — moot court judge — transportation, lodging, meals

Reimbursement — Yale Law School — 2/28/2009-3/172009 — New Haven, CT — Federalist Society National Student Symposium

Reimbursement — Wolters-Kluwer Law & Business Aspen Publishers — 312712009 — Boston, MA — Meeting on Criminal Procedure case book — transportation

Reimbursement — U.Michigan Law School — 3131-47272009 — Ann Arbor, Mi — Moot courl judge — transportation, lodging, meals

Reimbursement — ABA & Northwestern Law School — 5/28-5/30/2009 — Chicago. IL — Speaker, ABA Appellate Practice Institute

Reimbursement — Federal Bar Council — 10/23-10/252009 — nox, MA — Panelist, 2009 Fall Bench and Bar Retreat

Reimbursement — Harvard Law School — 10/29/2009 — Boston. MA — Classroom Speaker fer Professor John Manning — transportation

Income — 1.4.409 — Wolters-Kluwer Law & Business Aspen Publishers (royalties) — $11,151.24

Income — Bi-weekly — Columbia Law School (total 2009 W-2 salary) — $24,613.98

Part II. Agreements.

-I remain a member of the faculty at Columbia Law School, teaching a reduced schedule consistent with my primary obligation to the judiciary. I receive

compensation that is consistent with the outside earned income limitations applicable to judges. I have an agreement with the University that while I remain a

faculty member(and subject to all outside earned income and employment provisions of 5 U.S.C. 501-505 and Judicial Conference regulations thereunder), I am

eligible for the Primary Tuition Scholarship (PTS), which covers 50% of the tuition at my son’s grade school, as well as the college Tuition Exemption Program

(for a child who attends Columbia University) or the College Tuition Scholarship (for a child who attends another college). As a faculty member [I also remain

eligible to live in Columbia University-owned housing (where I live now).

-I continue to have retirement accounts maintained through Columbia University, the individual holdings of which are listed under Part VII. Investments and

Trusts.

-As a result of my former employment with the University of Michgan Law School, [ continue to have a retirement account maintained through the University of

Michigan, the holdings of which are listed under Part VII. Investments and Trusts. Contributions are of course no longer made to those retirement accounts.

Part VI. Liabilities.

Upon re-reading the instructions this year 1 see that our agreement to pay tuition to The School at Columbia University appears to be reportable and thus should

have been noted on prior years' reports as well. This is the same tuition discussed under Part 11. Agreements, above. which has been previously disclosed.

Past VII. [nvesunents and Trusts.

-Dividend or other income for CREF stock, TIAA Real Estate, Vanguard College Mod Age-Based Mod Grwth {a New York 529 college savings account) is not

reported on statements. All eamings in all the funds are automatically reinvested in the respective funds. TIAA Real Estate reinvested dividends reported are based

on calculations of difference in number of shares as reported on quarterly statements.