Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
10,000+ results
8.56s
177 F.3d 1245 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jun 14, 1999
Under the qualified immunity doctrine, government officials performing discretionary functions are immune not just from liability, but from suit, unless the conduct which is the basis for suit violates clearly established … To overcome the defendants’ qualified immunity, plaintiffs must establish that the defendants’ conduct violated a clearly established statutory or constitutional right of which
Cited 21 timesPublishedMason ex rel. Marson v. Vasquez
5 F.3d 1226 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Oct 6, 1993
In so doing, the court placed more weight oh the deficiencies in Attorney Marson’s proof establishing ineompetency than on the government’s proof establishing competency.
Cited 4 timesPublishedDavid Glen Meyers v. Contra Costa County Department of Social Services, Defendants
812 F.2d 1154 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Mar 16, 1987
Under the doctrine of qualified immunity, executive officers are shielded from liability where “their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have … Haaland’s conduct on October 23, which indisputably involved no physical interference with parental custody, cannot be said to have violated clearly established statutory or constitutional rights.
Cited 181 timesPublishedVictor George Bryant v. William R. Muth Gregg Robbins
994 F.2d 1082 · Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit · May 24, 1993
The district court held that Muth and Robbins were not entitled to qualified immunity and that, even though Bryant had no constitutional right to , possess the contraband disks, he did have a clearly established constitutional … Once the defendant raises, a qualified immunity defense, the plaintiff carries the burden of showing that the defendant’s alleged conduct violated the law and that such law was clearly established when the alleged violation
Cited 33 timesPublished455 F.3d 186 · Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · Jul 25, 2006
We are asked to determine whether, for the purposes of qualified immunity, the conduct alleged by Williams constituted a violation of his "clearly established" rights. … Long, 72 F.3d 70, 72-74 (8th Cir.1995) (denying qualified immunity because Muslim inmates had a clearly established right not to be forced to handle pork); Kenner v.
Cited 31 timesPublishedSherelle Thomas v. City of Harrisburg
88 F.4th 275 · Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · Dec 6, 2023
The court rejected the Officers’ claims of qualified immunity because it found that Sherelle Thomas alleged sufficient facts to state her claims and both rights were clearly established at the time of the violations. … Clearly Established Right However, before the Officers can be denied qualified immunity from being sued for deliberate indifference to a serious medical need, the constitutional right violated must be clearly established
Cited 85 timesPublishedBerkley Specialty Insurance Company v. Masterforce Construction Corp.
District Court, M.D. Pennsylvania · Jan 26, 2021
judgment on the pleadings.27 Berkley asserts that it is entitled to judgment in its favor as, for five reasons, it owed no duty to indemnify Masterforce.28 First, Berkley contends that Masterforce’s conduct does not qualify … Galloway, 483 F.3d 258, 271 (4th Cir. 2007) (noting that, under the qualified immunity standard, a constitutional right is not clearly established when there are “conflicting decisions” in that area); Soares v.
Cited 0 timesUnknownManganiello v. City of New York
612 F.3d 149 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Jul 23, 2010
Only the third aspect of the qualified immunity doctrine was genuinely at issue in the present case, for “[fjreedom from malicious prosecution is a constitutional right that has long been clearly established.” Kinzer v. … Although a mere mistake in the performance of an official duty may not deprive the officer of qualified immunity, the doctrine does not shield performance that either (a) was in violation of clearly established law, or (b
Cited 637 timesPublishedAndres M. Martinez v. G.D. Stanford W. Owen M. Atkinson D. Rockholt J. Stovall
323 F.3d 1178 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Mar 26, 2003
Martinez’s attorney declares that she assumed that the officers’ motion would be denied because Saucier did not establish the officers’ qualified immunity as a matter of law. … The district court correctly stated the two-part test for qualified immunity announced in Saucier v.
Cited 245 timesPublished410 Mass. 878 · Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Aug 12, 1991
Qualified immunity. We consider first whether Furtado and Dr. Falkoff are immunized from liability as matter of law. We conclude that they are immunized. … While the plaintiff is correct when she argues that the Aguilar-Spinelli requirements were clearly established at the time Furtado applied for the warrant, that is not sufficient to preclude Furtado from using a qualified
Cited 48 timesPublishedTexas Court of Appeals, 2nd District (Fort Worth) · Sep 16, 2021
It is not clearly established whether Burlington’s “materially adverse” standard applies to retaliation for protected speech. See Gibson . . . , 734 F.3d [at] 401 n.4 . . . … Saunders, 588 F.3d 282, 288 (5th Cir. 2009) (finding that the application of Burlington to First Amendment retaliation is not “clearly established”)[, abrogated on other grounds by Sims v.
Cited 0 timesPublished148 F.3d 692 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Jun 11, 1998
Qualified Immunity The appellants next argue that them actions are protected by qualified immunity. … The doctrine of qualified immunity generally shields officials who perform discretionary functions from liability for civil damages “insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional
Cited 22 timesPublishedGeorge Rakovich v. Gregory Wade and Darryl Drake, George Rakovich v. Chester Kass
850 F.2d 1180 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Jul 14, 1988
The parameters of the argument were clearly set: does a police officer in this situation enjoy a qualified immunity? … Nuclear Regulatory Commissioners, 747 F.2d 139, 148 (3d Cir.1984) (no qualified immunity if the defendant violated “a clearly established and well litigated general proposition in which the case at hand merely presents a
Overruled on other grounds by Spiegla v. Hull, 371 F.3d 928 (2004)Cited 370 timesPublishedRenay Hunter v. The District of Columbia
943 F.2d 69 · Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit · Aug 30, 1991
clearly established at the time of the alleged beating in 1986. … Because Hunter’s complaint alleges conduct coming between Norris and Martin , his claim is subject to the officer’s substantively distinct qualified immunity defense that arises from the change in the “clearly established
Abrogated on other grounds by Richard Atchinson v. District of Columbia, 73 F.3d 418 (1996)Cited 60 timesPublished795 F.2d 1296 · Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit · Jun 30, 1986
The only question is whether they violated any clearly established federal constitutional right. … The words “clearly established ... constitutional rights” may not be used to read the defense of immunity out of federal tort law by the facile expedient of stating constitutional rights in the most general possible terms
Cited 151 timesPublished706 F.3d 1052 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Jan 31, 2013
We hold that both Mandeville and Rosario are entitled to qualified immunity because the law at the time Chappell was on contraband watch did not clearly establish that their actions were unconstitutional. … Whether qualified immunity applies thus “turns on the objective legal reasonableness of the action, assessed in light of the legal rules that were clearly established at the time it was taken.” Messerschmidt v.
Cited 162 timesPublished860 F.2d 321 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Oct 25, 1988
The defendants in that case moved for summary judgment on the basis of qualified immunity. … established rights. 9 Therefore, we hold that, viewing the facts in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, the district court was correct in denying defendants' motion for summary judgment on the basis of qualified immunity
Cited 38 timesPublished841 F.2d 1042 · Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · Mar 15, 1988
The Supreme Court has indicated that when the issue with which we are concerned, i.e., whether constitutional rights allegedly violated were "clearly established" for purposes of qualified immunity under Harlow v. … Because the test for qualified immunity turns on whether a right is clearly established, courts should ordinarily determine the existence and character of the underlying constitutional violation(s) before proceeding to the
Cited 23 timesPublishedRichard Harrold v. Lewis Hagen
Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit · Apr 28, 2026
Officer Hagen invoked qualified immunity. The district court held that Officer Hagen was entitled to qualified immunity—because the relevant right was not clearly established— and dismissed the suit. … We determine whether an officer receives qualified immunity by asking two questions: (1) whether the officer violated a constitutional right, and (2) whether that right was clearly established.
Cited 0 timesPublished850 F.2d 79 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Jun 21, 1988
Finally, the court denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss on grounds of qualified immunity, holding that the First Amendment implications of their conduct were clearly established. … of qualified *81 immunity.
Cited 43 timesPublished
Ask Donna