Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
9,602 results
1.79s
District Court, W.D. Washington · May 23, 2024
Section 1983 First Amendment Retaliation Claims & Qualified Immunity 13 Defendants Alspach and Henderson—who, as law enforcement officers, investigated 14 allegations against Plaintiff—say that the doctrine of qualified … Thus, the Court may determine that there is qualified immunity on the 2 “clearly established” prong without deciding whether a constitutional violation occurred. 3 This second prong of the qualified immunity analysis
Cited 0 timesUnknown68 Wash. App. 96 · Court of Appeals of Washington · Dec 21, 1992
The dicta in Forks suggests a farther effort to qualify a government's duty to protect its inhabitants from third party conduct. There are unique policy reasons for limiting liability in these circumstances. … Any error in the giving of this instruction would be harmless because the jury clearly rejected the emergency theory when it found Handorff-Sherman 50 percent negligent. See Thomas v.
Cited 16 timesPublishedDistrict Court, W.D. Washington · Aug 20, 2026
(MJP at 21–22.) 8 The court exercises its discretion to begin with prong two of the qualified 9 immunity framework—whether the asserted substantive due process right was clearly 10 established in August 2023. … Because the court has determined that those claims fail as a matter of law under 1 the clearly established prong of the qualified immunity framework, no additional factual 2 allegations could overcome the individuals’
Cited 0 timesUnknownSilas Mason, Inc. v. State Tax Commission
188 Wash. 98 · Washington Supreme Court · Oct 28, 1936
claim of immunity was upheld because the instrumentalities taxed were all so intimately connected with the necessary functions of government as to fall within the established exemption. … In a dissenting opinion, Justice Bradley, after contending that the rule established in McCulloch v.
Cited 14 timesPublishedDistrict Court, W.D. Washington · Aug 3, 2022
immunity on that claim” (which would imply that the viability of such a claim is clearly 8 established). … A two-part test resolves claims 19 of qualified immunity by determining whether plaintiff has alleged facts that “make out a 20 violation of a constitutional right[,]” and if so, whether the “right at issue was ‘clearly
Cited 0 timesUnknown752 F. Supp. 2d 1185 · District Court, W.D. Washington · Oct 27, 2010
immunity. … Qualified Immunity Defendants contend that they are entitled to qualified immunity as to Mr. Florer’s constitutional claims.
Cited 2 timesPublishedWashington Public Employees Ass'n v. Personnel Resources Board
127 Wash. App. 254 · Court of Appeals of Washington · Apr 26, 2005
The Civil Service Law established a new State Personnel Board and brought most general government employees under the Board’s control. … Moreover, if we are to compare members of the designated class with persons outside the class, it should not matter whether all members of the designated class are treated alike because a class of one qualifies for equal
Cited 5 timesPublished20 Wash. App. 691 · Court of Appeals of Washington · Jul 17, 1978
Counsel has not called to our attention, nor do we find from our own examination of the record, any facts which would tend to establish the illegality of the warrants, or their illegal execution. … If these preliminary questions can be clearly and unequivocally answered in the affirmative, then the challenged act, omission, or decision can, with a reasonable degree of assurance, be classified as a discretionary governmental
Overruled by Bender v. City of Seattle, 99 Wash. 2d 582 (1983)Cited 16 timesPublished104 Wash. 2d 293 · Washington Supreme Court · Aug 22, 1985
The case further holds that whether the sheriff disclosed sufficient material facts to establish probable cause was an issue for the jury. … Accordingly, Bender's discussion of discretionary immunity has no effect on the Turngrens' § 1983 action.
Cited 45 timesPublished78 Wash. App. 5 · Court of Appeals of Washington · May 30, 1995
Manor’s employer as a matter of law and, thus, immune from suit. The Manors contend the question is one of fact, not of law. … In the workers’ compensation claim, Nestle’s position was not adversarial while it is clearly an adversary in the present claim.
Cited 4 timesPublishedFoley v. Department of Fisheries
119 Wash. 2d 783 · Washington Supreme Court · Oct 1, 1992
landings until after the end of the qualifying period. … First, they argued RCW 75.30.210 violated the federal equal protection clause and the privileges and immunities clause contained in the Washington Constitution.
Cited 17 timesPublishedColombo v. Washington Department of Natural Resources
District Court, W.D. Washington · May 19, 2025
A court “may begin the qualified immunity analysis by 12 considering whether there is a violation of clearly established law without determining whether a 13 constitutional violation occurred.” Krainski v. … “To determine whether a constitutional right 15 has been clearly established for qualified immunity purposes,” the court “must survey the legal 16 landscape and examine those cases that are most like the instant case
Cited 0 timesUnknown196 Wash. 2d 439 · Washington Supreme Court · Oct 22, 2020
Nevertheless, “[t]he power of government to compel persons to testify in court or before grand juries and other governmental agencies is firmly established in Anglo-American jurisprudence.” Id. … For example, the Washington Constitution clearly recognizes an individual’s right to privacy with no express limitation. CONST. art. I, § 7.
Cited 7 timesPublishedWest v. Mount Vernon Sand & Gravel, Inc.
56 Wash. 2d 752 · Washington Supreme Court · Sep 22, 1960
Consequently, under the statute as above quoted, the defendant is clearly immune from civil liability if the plaintiff *754 was in fact’engaged in extrahazardous employment at the time of his injury. Denning v. … The rule establishing the requisite proof to support a conclusion of contributory negligence as a matter of law was set forth by this court in O’Brien v.
Cited 4 timesPublishedAutomotive United Trades Organization v. State
183 Wash. 2d 842 · Washington Supreme Court · Aug 27, 2015
The State agrees with AUTO that to qualify as a refund under article II, section 40, a disbursement must be a refund authorized by law. Br. of Resp’ts at 17. … App. 408 , 110 P.3d 1196 (2005). ¶21 More importantly, AUTO has not established that the tribes were legally obligated to pay the tax outside of their contractual agreement to do so.
Cited 9 timesPublished130 Wash. 2d 368 · Washington Supreme Court · Sep 26, 1996
New York Times, however, established a qualified privilege under the First Amendment for statements concerning public officials. … I, § 5 did not grant absolute immunity. Wilson, 137 Wash. at 133 .
Cited 56 timesPublished273 P.3d 477 · Court of Appeals of Washington · Mar 27, 2012
The court held, "If these preliminary questions can be clearly and unequivocally answered in the affirmative, then the challenged act, omission, or decision can, with a reasonable degree of assurance, be classified as a discretionary … In order for a decision to qualify as discretionary, the State must show that the decision was the outcome of a conscious balancing of risks and advantages. Taggart, 118 Wash.2d at 214-15 , 822 P.2d 243 .
Cited 45 timesPublished38 Wash. App. 831 · Court of Appeals of Washington · Nov 5, 1984
Immunity would have jeopardized his conviction, for if he were successful in obtaining a reversal, he could not be tried again. State v. Runions, 100 Wn.2d 52 , 665 P.2d 1358 (1983). … It is debatable whether Toomey's claim qualifies, but we nevertheless elect to consider it. 6 In Michael M. v.
Cited 41 timesPublishedFMC TECHNOLOGIES, INC. v. Edwards
464 F. Supp. 2d 1063 · District Court, W.D. Washington · Nov 27, 2006
The defamation context clearly qualifies “all liability.” 2 Similarly, while the Dexter decision by the Washington Court of Appeals came after the Washington Supreme Court’s extension of the litigation privilege to contexts … Were we able lo invoke only clearly established state law, litigants seeking to protect their rights in federal courts by availing themselves of our diversity jurisdiction would face an inhospitable forum for claims not identical
Cited 2 timesPublishedDistrict Court, W.D. Washington · Jan 7, 2026
20 immunity because Plaintiffs fail to show that any individual Defendant violated a clearly 21 established right. … A court “may 1 2 begin the qualified immunity analysis by considering whether there is a violation of clearly 3 established law without determining
Cited 0 timesUnknown
Ask Donna