Case law

Opinions from 1658 to today.

Filters2023

10,000+ results

2.37s

  • Outlaw v. Nasworthy

    250 Ga. App. 362 · Court of Appeals of Georgia · Jul 3, 2001

    by reference to clearly established law. … On a motion for summary judgment, if the applicable law was clearly established at the time the defendant acted, the immunity defense ordinarily should fail, since a reasonably competent public official should know the law

    Cited 14 timesPublished
  • Steven Kulkay v. Tom Roy

    847 F.3d 637 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · Feb 2, 2017

    But “[u]nless the plaintiff’s allegations state a claim of violation of clearly established law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to dismissal before the commencement of discovery.” Mitchell v. … The officials are thus entitled to qualified immunity. Moreover, because Kulkay fails to state a claim of violation of clearly established law, he is not entitled to discovery before dismissal.

    Cited 309 timesPublished
  • Tesla Inc. v. Louisiana Automobile Dealers Association

    District Court, E.D. Louisiana · Mar 7, 2025

    The Impact of Asserting Qualified Immunity on Discovery When dismissal is sought on the grounds of qualified immunity, however, a stay of discovery is virtually routine because a defendant pleading qualified … immunity operates to stay discovery only as to the defendants asserting qualified immunity, not to co-defendants or on other claims not subject to qualified immunity.

    Cited 0 timesUnknown
  • Connell v. Signoracci

    153 F.3d 74 · Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit · Aug 21, 1998

    A defendant is entitled to qualified immunity on a motion to dismiss if the allegations of the complaint fail to “state a claim of violation of clearly established law.” Behrens v. … Qualified immunity shields officials “from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.”

    Cited 81 timesPublished
  • Petcu v. State

    86 P.3d 1234 · Court of Appeals of Washington · Mar 30, 2004

    Finally, he argued that Smith was not entitled to qualified immunity because she violated Petcu's clearly established right to family unity. … Once a defendant asserts a defense of qualified immunity, the plaintiff must show that a clearly established constitutional right exists. Robinson, 119 Wash.2d at 65-66 , 830 P.2d 318 .

    Cited 33 timesPublished
  • Carrero v. Farrelly

    310 F. Supp. 3d 581 · District Court, D. Maryland · Apr 19, 2018

    In other words, he is entitled to qualified immunity if the constitutional right at issue was not clearly established. … In determining whether a constitutional right is clearly established or not for purposes of qualified immunity courts must consider whether "any reasonable official in the defendant's shoes would have understood that he was

    Cited 57 timesPublished
  • Heller v. Plave

    743 F. Supp. 1553 · District Court, S.D. Florida · Jul 18, 1990

    Qualified Immunity Qualified immunity insulates government officials from personal liability for actions within their discretionary authority. Harlow v. … Whether an official is entitled to qualified immunity requires two inquiries: (1) whether the law was clearly established at the time of the alleged misconduct; and, (2) whether the alleged misconduct violated that clearly

    Cited 13 timesPublished
  • Estate of Clemente N. Aguirre v. County of Riverside

    29 F.4th 624 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Mar 24, 2022

    The Clearly Established Inquiry Because the Najeras have presented facts sufficient to establish a Fourth Amendment violation, we consider the second prong of qualified immunity: whether the law was clearly established … The posture of this interlocutory appeal coupled with clearly established law supports the district court’s denial of qualified immunity. IV.

    Cited 32 timesPublished
  • Robert Reese, Jr. v. County of Sacramento

    888 F.3d 1030 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Apr 23, 2018

    Rose’s entitlement to qualified immunity therefore turns on whether Reese’s right was clearly established at the time of the incident in 2011. … Ct. at 310 (quotation marks omitted).1 Absent a showing by Reese that the right was clearly established at the time, Rose is entitled to qualified immunity on the Fourth Amendment excessive force claim.

    Cited 387 timesPublished
  • Lombardo v. Saint Louis City

    361 F. Supp. 3d 882 · District Court, E.D. Missouri · Feb 1, 2019

    established right and were entitled to qualified immunity. … Defendants have appealed the portion of the court's order denying them qualified immunity based on whether the law was clearly established law. The same is true for Hopper v.

    Cited 4 timesPublished
  • Nathaniel Hicks v. Gerald Ferreyra

    965 F.3d 302 · Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit · Jul 14, 2020

    Nor were the officers entitled to qualified immunity as a matter of law under the “clearly established” prong of the inquiry: “[D]etaining [Hicks] under these circumstances – when the officers had a reasonable suspicion … Nor, again, could Phillips show that the alleged Fourth Amendment violation was not “clearly established” for qualified immunity purposes. Id.

    Cited 108 timesPublished
  • Schlicher v. Board of Fire & Police Commissioners

    363 Ill. App. 3d 869 · Appellate Court of Illinois · Mar 6, 2006

    The Supreme Court has explained the concept of a “clearly established” constitutional right in the context of a qualified immunity claim as follows: “ ‘[Cjlearly established’ for purposes of qualified immunity means that … Because “it is well established that the qualified immunity doctrine does not apply to official capacity claims” (Ruffino v.

    Cited 10 timesPublished
  • Sok Kong v. City of Burnsville

    960 F.3d 985 · Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit · May 29, 2020

    They are entitled to qualified immunity unless (1) the facts show a violation of a constitutional right, and (2) the right was clearly established at the time of the misconduct. See Pearson v. … Because a reasonable jury could decide the officers violated this clearly established right when they shot Kong, I would affirm the district court’s denial of qualified immunity.

    Cited 39 timesPublished
  • Shelly Ioane v. Jean Noll

    903 F.3d 929 · Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit · Sep 10, 2018

    Clearly Established The second part of the qualified immunity test requires us to determine whether, at the time of Agent Noll’s actions in June 2006, the law was clearly established. … But the existence of a constitutional violation alone is insufficient to deny qualified immunity—we must find that the right at issue was “clearly established.”

    Cited 83 timesPublished
  • Root v. Comstock

    Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit · Jan 14, 2026

    Qualified immunity “[Q]ualified immunity shields officials from civil liability so long as their conduct ‘does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would … Root’s out-of-circuit cases do not provide clearly established law. Most of them are district court and unpublished decisions that cannot qualify as clearly established law. See Surat v.

    Cited 0 timesUnpublished
  • Tammy D. Scarbrough, Carol C. Davis v. Bryant Myles, Jr., Chuck Hall

    245 F.3d 1299 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Mar 29, 2001

    Because Hall had arguable probable cause to arrest Scarbrough and Davis, he violated no clearly established law and is entitled to qualified immunity. 9 *1304 The district judge denied immunity to Myles, who was not involved … In addressing discretionary-function immunity and qualified immunity, our court has stated that "[ujnder both Alabama law and federal law, the core issue is whether a defendant violated clearly established law.”

    Cited 117 timesPublished
  • Boggs v. Pearson

    2021 S.D. 44 · South Dakota Supreme Court · Jul 28, 2021

    “Qualified immunity shields a government official from liability and the burdens of litigation in a § 1983 action for damages unless the official’s conduct violated a clearly established constitutional or statutory right … immunity because it was not clearly established that their actions were unlawful.”

    Cited 2 timesPublished
  • King v. State

    242 Cal. App. 4th 245 · California Court of Appeal · Nov 18, 2015

    But Defendants are only entitled to qualified immunity as a matter of law if, taking the facts in the light most favorable to [the Plaintiff], they violated no clearly established constitutional right. … The state and Tawney premise their 26 qualified immunity claim on an extremely narrow, factually detailed view of what the clearly established law would be in this case.

    Cited 31 timesPublished
  • Santiago v. Leik

    179 Wis. 2d 786 · Court of Appeals of Wisconsin · Oct 28, 1993

    Thus, if at the time the challenged act occurred the law identifying the act as a constitutional violation was not clearly established, qualified immunity protects the official from suit. … The Barnhill court noted that confusion regarding qualified immunity "derives from the level of generality that should be afforded to 'clearly established law' at the time of the alleged unlawful act."

    Cited 3 timesPublished
  • Brown v. Scott

    329 F. Supp. 2d 905 · District Court, E.D. Michigan · Jul 26, 2004

    The defendant claims that he is entitled to a dismissal on the basis of qualified immunity because the undisputed facts do not demonstrate a violation of the plaintiffs clearly established Eighth Amendment rights. … further inquiries concerning qualified immunity.”).

    Cited 70 timesPublished

Ask Donna

Ask Donna

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.