Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
2,605 results
4.12s
788 A.2d 179 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Jan 17, 2002
The Federal Court determined that there was an adequate state law remedy, because the defendant wardens did not appear to be immune from suit pursuant to the Maine Tort Claims Act, 14 M.R.S.A. § 8111 (1997). … The trial court granted the wardens’ motion for summary judgment, determin *182 ing that, although Devlin and Morrison were not entitled to qualified immunity, Trask and Trafton had failed to create a genuine issue of material
Cited 17 timesPublished223 F. Supp. 2d 241 · District Court, D. Maine · Aug 14, 2002
immunity. … This recommended decision also renders moot Briand’s cross-motion for partial summary judgment (Docket No. 7) on the issue of qualified immunity.
Cited 16 timesPublishedRodriguez v. Town of Moose River
922 A.2d 484 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · May 29, 2007
Page Keeton ed., 5th ed.1984) (“specific acts of negligence are often clearly ‘operational,’ so that the government is readily held liable for ... negligent maintenance of property”). [¶ 23] The essential question with respect … officials could be immune from suit for allowing the persistence of hazardous conditions on *491 property that they are required to maintain. 2 [¶24] Here, the undisputed facts establish that although the Town required Bell
Cited 31 timesPublishedRoberts v. State of Maine Department of Public Safety
Superior Court of Maine · Oct 4, 2023
Without particularized binding authority or a robust consensus of persuasive authority to clearly establish the right, Roberts has not overcome Thomas’s invocation of qualified immunity. … ). 26 Roberts has met neither requirement to show “clearly established law” for purposes of overcoming qualified immunity.
Cited 0 timesUnpublishedCamp Emoh Associates v. Inhabitants of Lyman
132 Me. 67 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · May 4, 1933
The evidence clearly shows that the plaintiff is a “benevolent and charitable institution incorporated by the state.” … The burden was on the plaintiff to establish its right to exemption. Bangor v. Masonic Lodge, 73 Me., 428.
Cited 21 timesPublished150 Me. 370 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Feb 11, 1955
Zahn ... an executive officer to wit: the duly appointed and qualified Chairman of the State Liquor Commission of the State of Maine, and the said Bernard T. … Sahagian, in testifying at the trial, believed he had gained immunity.
Cited 5 timesPublishedDistrict Court, D. Maine · Oct 10, 2025
immunity from liability unless (1) they violated a federal right, and (2) the unlawfulness of their conduct was “clearly established.” … at 66, I start with the “clearly established” prong of the qualified immunity analysis. The “clearly established” prong includes two related aspects.
Cited 0 timesUnknownDistrict Court, D. Maine · Aug 26, 2025
Stanley argues qualified immunity shields him from liability. … Qualified immunity protects government officials from liability when “their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.”
Cited 0 timesUnknown411 A.2d 682 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Feb 27, 1980
Garland ultimately admitted his involvement to fire inspectors and was given immunity from prosecution in return for his testimony against defendant. In defense, Small blamed the fire entirely on Garland. … Questioning by the court established that “smudge sale” is “a common slang term” that is “used around the community in which [Strickland] operate[s].”
Cited 7 timesPublishedBowen v. Department of Human Services
606 A.2d 1051 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Apr 17, 1992
In order to establish a prima facie case of retaliatory discharge pursuant to Title VII 1 Bowen must show that (1) she engaged in a protected activity, (2) her employer thereafter subjected her to adverse employment action … Bowen argues that this conduct clearly exceeded the scope of Bartley’s discretionary duties and therefore section 8111 does not protect her.
Cited 61 timesPublished106 Me. 165 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Nov 27, 1909
The evidence tending to prove a mutual mistake does not meet the requirements of that high degree of proof necessary to establish the facts in this class of cases. … They undoubtedly thought they were signing a document that would qualify the defendant, William H.
Cited 2 timesPublishedMcCullough v. Visiting Nurse Service of Southern Maine, Inc.
691 A.2d 1201 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Mar 31, 1997
See also Restatement (Second) of TORTS § 581A cmt. f (1977) (It is not necessary to establish the literal truth of the precise statement made. … law....” [¶ 14] The foregoing statutory language provides VNS with immunity from civil liability for fulfilling its obligation to report McCullough’s termination to the board.
Cited 16 timesPublishedState of Me. v. Department of Navy
702 F. Supp. 322 · District Court, D. Maine · Nov 23, 1988
Clearly, if Congress may effectively waive sovereign immunity to each individual requirement of state law, which it indisputably can, then it can, with equal effectiveness, waive sovereign immunity to a generic or broad category … immunity.
Cited 17 timesPublished989 A.2d 726 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Mar 9, 2010
A finding of fact is clearly erroneous when (1) no competent evidence supporting the finding exists in the record; (2) the fact-finder clearly misapprehends the meaning of the evidence; or (3) the force and effect of the … This evidence supports the court’s conclusion that the father had not found a qualified therapist for Jewel in his area at the time of the hearing.
Cited 12 timesPublishedDistrict Court, D. Maine · Jun 1, 2026
The qualified immunity doctrine shields law enforcement officers “from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable … In effect, unless the law was clearly established at the time, the qualified immunity doctrine holds that it is not fair to infer or presume that the defendants would have understood that their actions or inactions resulted
Cited 0 timesUnknown109 Me. 576 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Dec 20, 1912
It is 'claimed in behalf of the plaintiff that these facts and circumstances are deafly established by the evidence. … It was a question which they were peculiarly qualified to determine, and their decision does not appear to be so manifestly wrong as to require the interposition of the Law Court to set it aside.
Cited 4 timesPublishedForrest Associates v. Passamaquoddy Tribe
760 A.2d 1041 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Nov 3, 2000
Accordingly, Forrest is not entitled to a recovery in quantum meruit because it cannot establish a reasonable expectation of payment. [¶ 13] In addition, Maine law provides that the Tribe enjoys the same privileges and immunities … Competent evidence exists in the record to support these factual determinations, and thus they are not clearly erroneous.
Cited 86 timesPublished405 A.2d 230 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Aug 31, 1979
In view of the qualified nature of welfare rights, cases denying the defense of state immunity where plaintiff’s property has been taken by the state without just compensation cannot be relied on as precedents controlling … Little Hunting Park, Inc., 396 U.S. 229, 239-40 , 90 S.Ct. 400 , 24 L.Ed.2d 386 (1969) where the Court used language which seemed from context to imply that section 1988 (before its amendment in 1976) established a rule of
Cited 51 timesPublished529 A.2d 1357 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Aug 21, 1987
Although the alleged conduct does not appear to fall within any of the exceptions to immunity under section 8104, 3 governmental immunity is an affirm *1361 ative defense, to be pleaded under M.R. Civ. … We therefore conclude that the plaintiff has failed to establish a sufficient claim under section 1983.
Cited 32 timesPublishedFoss v. Maine Turnpike Authority
309 A.2d 339 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Sep 10, 1973
frequently made to distinguish between nuisance and negligence, for example, is based upon an entirely mistaken emphasis upon what the defendant has done rather than the result which has followed, and forgets completely the well established … We believe that the answer to this question is clearly in the negative. In Michaud v.
Cited 40 timesPublished
Ask Donna