Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
10,000+ results
2.84s
624 A.2d 479 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · May 11, 1993
On a motion by Levesque, the court dismissed the civil rights claim finding that Levesque did not violate any clearly established statutory or constitutional rights and therefore was en *482 titled to qualified immunity. … Malice or improper motive, alone, is not sufficient to defeat qualified immunity. Myers, 810 F.2d at 1457 . An official’s entitlement to qualified immunity is a legal, not a factual issue. Snell v.
Cited 28 timesPublishedWest Virginia Supreme Court · Jun 15, 2023
Devono now assert the defense of qualified immunity? … Hall, 828 F.3d 298, 303 (4th Cir. 2016) (“Qualified immunity shields government officials from personal liability when their conduct does not violate clearly established rights of which a reasonable person would have known
Cited 0 timesSeparateWV Division of Corrections, Scott Patterson and Jason Walton v. P.R.
West Virginia Supreme Court · Nov 22, 2019
The parties disagree about whether Policy Directive 332.02 constitutes a “clearly established law” for purposes of defeating qualified immunity. … whether or not a right is clearly established, has resulted in the “conver[sion of] qualified immunity to near absolute immunity,” Rebalancing Harlow: A New Approach to Qualified Immunity in the Fourth Amendment, 68 Chase
Cited 0 timesPublished424 Md. 549 · Court of Appeals of Maryland · Jan 31, 2012
qualified immunity. … The test clearly conflates the doctrines of absolute judicial immunity and qualified public official immunity.
Cited 84 timesPublished947 P.2d 816 · Alaska Supreme Court · Aug 15, 1997
Qualified immunity under federal law protects officials except where it is “clearly established” as of the time of the acts complained of that the acts violated the plaintiffs rights. … If the plaintiffs allegations fail to establish a constitutional claim, the defendant is entitled to dismissal on the basis of qualified immunity, or, of course, under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6).
Cited 24 timesPublishedVenegas v. County of Los Angeles
11 Cal. Rptr. 3d 692 · California Supreme Court · Apr 5, 2004
A rule of qualified immunity shields a public officer from an action for damages under section 1983 unless the officer has violated a “clearly established” constitutional right. (Saucier, supra, 533 U.S. at p. 201.) … The high court explained that “[i]f the law did not put the officer on notice that his- conduct would be clearly unlawful, summary judgment based on qualified immunity is appropriate.” (Ibid.)
Cited 164 timesPublishedBaggerly v. CSX Transportation, Inc.
370 S.C. 362 · Supreme Court of South Carolina · Aug 28, 2006
Causation-in-fact is proved by establishing the injury would not have occurred “but for” the defendant’s negligence, and legal cause is proved by establishing foreseeability. Id. … or to determine a fact in issue, a witness qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education, may testify.”
Cited 51 timesPublished403 Mass. 586 · Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · Dec 14, 1988
The defendant asserts that at least qualified immunity is available to him because his conduct did not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known. … One issue is whether on clearly established principles of law, he could have reasonably believed his acts to be lawful. Breault v. Chairman of the Bd. of Fire Comm’rs of Springfield, 401 Mass. 26 , 32 (1987).
Cited 4 timesPublished195 Vt. 308 · Supreme Court of Vermont · Dec 6, 2013
We first address the superior court’s ruling that defendant is entitled to qualified official immunity under, the circumstances of this case. * “Qualified immunity attaches to public officials who are (1) acting during the … An objective person in defendant’s position could not have believed that his conduct violated clearly established law. ¶ 16.
Cited 29 timesPublished419 Mont. 1 · Montana Supreme Court · Nov 12, 2024
Qualified Prosecutorial Immunity. … Ct. at 2815 (government officer “entitled to dismissal” of compensatory civil claim due to qualified immunity “[u]nless the [complaint] allegations” are facially sufficient to “state a claim of violation of clearly established
Cited 2 timesPublished436 S.W.3d 141 · Supreme Court of Arkansas · Jun 19, 2014
“Under the standard of qualified immunity articulated in Harlow v. … “The more critical inquiry for qualified-immunity purposes is whether it was ‘objectively legally reasonable’ for the prison officials to believe that [their] conduct did not violate the inmate’s clearly established Eighth
Cited 16 timesPublishedJeremiah Hogan v. Lincoln Medical Partners
2025 ME 22 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Mar 4, 2025
Even construed strictly because it is in derogation of the common law, the immunity statute is clearly broad in scope. See Jamison v. … As to Hogan’s assertion that the immunity provision violates the child’s constitutional right of bodily integrity, “[i]n the context of COVID-19, courts across the country have concluded that Jacobson established that there
Cited 1 timesPublishedDistrict of Columbia v. Jackson
810 A.2d 388 · District of Columbia Court of Appeals · Nov 14, 2002
that the officers acted beyond the reach of qualified immunity protection). … That "general proposition,” the.Supreme Court reiterated in Saucier, "is not enough” to resolve the immunity question; instead "the right the official is alleged to have violated must have been clearly established in a more
Cited 28 timesPublished58 Tex. Sup. Ct. J. 678 · Texas Supreme Court · Apr 24, 2015
Brown & Gay’s reliance on Filar-sky's qualified-immunity analysis is misplaced. … The federal doctrine of qualified immunity “protects government officials ‘from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable
Cited 143 timesPublished119 Wash. 2d 34 · Washington Supreme Court · May 14, 1992
constitutional or statutory rights; such persons are entitled to qualified immunity from a claim under section 1983 if their conduct is objectively reasonable when measured against clearly established law. … Qualified immunity from suit must be granted when the law or right allegedly violated is not clearly established. Conner v. Santa Ana, 897 F.2d 1487 , 1492 (9th Cir. 1990).
Abrogated on other grounds by Chong Yim v. City of Seattle, 451 P.3d 675 (2019)Cited 211 timesPublishedSpenner v. CITY OF SIOUX FALLS, SOUTH DAKOTA
580 N.W.2d 606 · South Dakota Supreme Court · Jun 3, 1998
“To find whether qualified immunity applies, the test is to ask if the officer’s conduct violated clearly established statutory or constitutional rights a reasonable officer would have known at the time.” Id. … ” of the action, assessed in light of the legal rules that were “clearly established” at the time it was taken. ****** [0]ur cases establish that the right the official is alleged to have violated must have been “clearly
Cited 48 timesPublished665 A.2d 1005 · Supreme Judicial Court of Maine · Oct 10, 1995
Haas contends that he is protected from the Webbs’ action by the doctrine of qualified immunity pursuant to 42 U.S.C.A. § 1983 8 because he has not violated a clearly established right of the Webbs’. … Pursuant to the doctrine of qualified immunity, “ ‘government officials performing discretionary functions[] generally are shielded from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established
Cited 15 timesPublishedHarris v. Mississippi Valley State Univ.
873 So. 2d 970 · Mississippi Supreme Court · May 13, 2004
The test for qualified immunity is two fold, with the threshold question being whether the plaintiff has suffered a violation of a clearly established constitutional right. … Whether an official is entitled to qualified immunity depends on the "objective reasonableness of the action" assessed in light of the legal rules that were "clearly established" at the time it was taken.'
Cited 103 timesPublishedDurrant v. BD. OF EDUC. OF CITY OF HARTFORD
284 Conn. 91 · Supreme Court of Connecticut · Oct 2, 2007
pursuant to section 10-16n [which allows the establishment of grant programs to assist local boards of education establishing extended day Head Start programs]”). … “[A] municipal employee . . . has a qualified immunity in the performance of a governmental duty, but he may be liable if he misperforms a ministerial act ... .
Cited 36 timesPublished20 Brief Times Rptr. 952 · Supreme Court of Colorado · Jun 17, 1996
The qualified immunity defense should fail if the law was clearly established because “a reasonably competent public official should know the law governing his [or her] conduct.” … called for the destruction of Garrison’s residence because, in their view, avoiding clearly established procedures would be cheaper.
Cited 14 timesPublished
Ask Donna