Case law

Opinions from 1658 to today.

FiltersS

10,000+ results

6.99s

  • Lubcke v. Boise City/Ada County Housing Authority

    124 Idaho 450 · Idaho Supreme Court · Sep 9, 1993

    Under Harlow , Worrell is entitled to qualified immunity only if she did not violate clearly established constitutional law. … Thus, Worrell should be immune from suit *465 if: a) it was not clearly established law in 1986 that a public employee may not be terminated for her exercise of her First Amendment rights, and b) it was not clearly established

    Cited 50 timesPublished
  • Shoemaker v. Smith

    353 Md. 143 · Court of Appeals of Maryland · Mar 10, 1999

    'abstract issu[e] of law’ relating to qualified immunity ... … —typically, the issue whether the federal right allegedly infringed was 'clearly established. ..

    Cited 107 timesPublished
  • Jenkins v. Hale

    6 So. 3d 452 · Supreme Court of Alabama · Oct 10, 2008

    Therefore, whether Sheriff Hale is entitled to qualified immunity from Jenkins’s § 1983 claim turns on whether the “complaint ... allege[s] the violation of [that] clearly established constitutional right.” … On a motion to dismiss a § 1983 claim because of qualified immunity, this Court looks to the complaint to determine only whether the “ ‘ “complaint ... allege[s] the violation of a clearly established constitutional right

    Cited 11 timesPublished
  • Johnson v. Morris

    453 N.W.2d 31 · Supreme Court of Minnesota · Mar 23, 1990

    Qualified immunity is available if the officer did “not violate clearly established stat *39 utory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.” Harlow v. … Simply stated, if the law the officer allegedly violated was “clearly established” there would exist no immunity, but, if not, qualified immunity would be available. Harlow, 457 U.S. at 819 , 102 S.Ct. at 2738-39 .

    Cited 113 timesPublished
  • The West Virginia State Police, Department of Military Affairs v. J.H., a Minor, by and through His Parent and Next Friend, L.D.

    West Virginia Supreme Court · Mar 26, 2021

    it violated a clearly established law or right in performing its discretionary functions. … Next, we must move forward in the qualified immunity analysis and determine whether J.H. has alleged that the acts of the Trooper Defendants were in violation of clearly established statutory or constitutional rights or

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Barnthouse v. City of Edmond

    74 O.B.A.J. 1297 · Supreme Court of Oklahoma · Apr 22, 2003

    Material issues of fact for a jury exist as to: (1) whether Cochran violated Appellants' clearly established constitutional rights for purposes of his individual qualified immunity defense to the § 1988 claim; and (@)whether … Whether Cochran is entitled to qualified immunity where his conduct violated Appellants' right to due process (a constitutional right), and that right was violated by Cochran when it was clearly established at the time of

    Cited 14 timesPublished
  • Christopher H. Harris v. Asa Hutchinson, Individually and in His Official Capacity as Governor of the State of Arkansas; And Patrick Fisk, Individually and in His Official Capacity

    591 S.W.3d 778 · Supreme Court of Arkansas · Jan 9, 2020

    The General Assembly clearly intended to subject the State to liability under the AWBA. Ark. Code Ann. § 21-1-602(5); Smith v. … , the legislature has established the Arkansas State Claims Commission so that claims against the State may be addressed while preserving the State’s sovereign immunity.

    Cited 15 timesPublished
  • Arnzen v. State

    123 Idaho 899 · Idaho Supreme Court · May 13, 1993

    Thus, in order to determine whether Richardson, in his individual capacity, was entitled to qualified immunity, we must ask: 1. Was there a clearly established law; 2. … This prong of the qualified immunity analysis is a compound question: (1) did Arnzen have a clearly established right; and (2) did Richardson’s conduct violate it?

    Cited 24 timesPublished
  • Sabir v. District of Columbia

    755 A.2d 449 · District of Columbia Court of Appeals · Jun 22, 2000

    Absent violation of “a clearly established right,”a police officer will not be subject to § 1983 liability. Id. at 1015. As the D.C. Circuit articulated the standard in Wardlaw v. … Generally, the review of a deniál of qualified immunity is a question of law — “whether the legal norms allegedly violated by the defendant were clearly established at the time of the challenged actions.” Mitchell v.

    Cited 39 timesPublished
  • Lamb v. Holmes

    162 S.W.3d 902 · Kentucky Supreme Court · May 19, 2005

    establish searches conducted in either described manner would be unreasonable, and therefore the teachers/administrators are entitled to qualified immunity. … Qualified immunity protects state and local officials who carry out executive and administrative functions from personal liability so long as their actions do not violate “clearly established statutory or constitutional rights

    Cited 6 timesPublished
  • Jackie L. Brown, II v. City of Montgomery

    233 W. Va. 119 · West Virginia Supreme Court · Feb 20, 2014

    Code, 29-12A-1, et seq., is entitled to qualified immunity from personal liability for official acts if the involved conduct did not violate clearly established laws of which a reasonable official would have known. … Code, 29-12A-1, et seq., is entitled to qualified immunity from personal liability for official acts if the involved conduct did not violate clearly established laws of which a reasonable

    Cited 8 timesPublished
  • B.R. v. West Virginia DHHR

    West Virginia Supreme Court · Oct 13, 2020

    In affirming the circuit court’s decision, this Court found that pleading simple negligence, without a violation of a clearly established right, is insufficient to overcome qualified immunity. … I. reveals that this Court reviewed the pleadings and found that “[p]leading simple negligence, without a violation of a clearly established right, is insufficient to overcome qualified immunity.” B.R.I., at *2. In B.

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • McKinsey v. Vernon

    130 Idaho 354 · Idaho Supreme Court · Jun 5, 1997

    The three-part inquiry to determine if a public official asserting qualified immunity is entitled to the defense is: 1. Was there a clearly established law? 2. … Did the conduct of the party asserting qualified immunity violate a clearly established right of the party claiming the violation? 3. Was the conduct of the party asserting qualified immunity reasonable? Farnworth v.

    Cited 3 timesPublished
  • Durso v. Taylor

    624 A.2d 449 · District of Columbia Court of Appeals · Jan 29, 1993

    “A plaintiff who seeks damages for violation of constitutional or statutory rights may overcome the defendant official’s qualified immunity only by showing that those rights were clearly established at the time of the conduct … Qualified immunity: objective legal reasonableness. Even if Durso had violated Taylor’s right to due process, we hold that he had qualified immunity for his actions.

    Cited 8 timesPublished
  • Jim Nahas v. Polk County, Iowa

    Supreme Court of Iowa · Jun 9, 2023

    The “clearly established” standard is thus inherently backward-looking. … Further, whether the law was clearly established is inextricably intertwined with the new qualified immunity defense and only relevant to this case to the extent the new qualified immunity defense is operative in this

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Ex parte B.T. Roberts, in his capacity as a member of the Auburn University Board of Trustees PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS (In re: Patti H. Northcutt and Walter M. Northcutt v. B.T. Roberts, in his capacity as a member of the Auburn University Board of Trustees) (Lee Circuit Court: CV-22-900114).

    Supreme Court of Alabama · Jun 27, 2025

    'To overcome qualified immunity, the plaintiff must satisfy a two-prong test; he must show that: (1) the [public official] violated a constitutional right, and (2) this right was clearly established at the … as follows: "To defeat Lawton's qualified immunity, Echols must also prove that Lawton violated a constitutional right that 'was "clearly established" at the time of the challenged conduct.'

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Newton v. Etoch

    332 Ark. 325 · Supreme Court of Arkansas · Mar 19, 1998

    Clearly, the State has not been named as a party, but our inquiry does not stop there. We established the test for whether a suit is one brought against the State in Page v. … Supreme Court has distinguished qualified immunity and absolute immunity by stating that qualified immunity depends on the circumstances and the prosecutor’s motives, as established by the evidence. Imbler v.

    Cited 29 timesPublished
  • City of Lancaster v. Chambers

    37 Tex. Sup. Ct. J. 980 · Texas Supreme Court · Jun 15, 1994

    judgment on qualified immunity is improper.”). … First, federal immunity may be conferred at the summary judgment stage by the court’s finding that the constitutional right at issue was not clearly established. Elder v.

    Cited 853 timesPublished
  • Carney v. Miller

    Nebraska Supreme Court · Feb 14, 2014

    Qualified immunity provides a shield from liability for public officials sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (2006) in their individual capacity, so long as an official’s conduct does not vio- late clearly established … Whether an official may prevail in his or her qualified immunity defense depends upon the objective reasonableness of his or her conduct as measured by reference to clearly established law. 12.

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Melene James v. City of Boise

    158 Idaho 713 · Idaho Supreme Court · May 21, 2015

    The Court explained why the “clearly established law” could not be so general that it would eliminate the rule of qualified immunity. … With respect to qualified immunity, the court of appeals held that there was no clearly established law that the officer’s “use of a police dog to search and bite was unconstitutional.” Id. at 1092 .

    Cited 1 timesPublished

Ask Donna

Ask Donna

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.