Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
5,177 results
4.79s
Kane ex rel. K.J. v. Chester County Department of Children, Youth & Families
10 F. Supp. 3d 671 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Mar 31, 2014
The CYF Motion to Dismiss next argues that the discretionary conduct of the CYF defendants is protected by the doctrine of qualified immunity because plaintiff has not pleaded a right that was so clearly established that … clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known.’ ” James v.
Cited 30 timesPublishedBasile v. Elizabethtown Area School District
61 F. Supp. 2d 392 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Aug 12, 1999
The Supreme Court established the standard for qualified immunity in Harlow v. … (a) were clearly established.
Cited 10 timesPublished994 F. Supp. 2d 649 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Jan 10, 2014
‘clearly established’ at the time of the challenged conduct.” … was clearly established at the time of the challenged conduct.
Cited 22 timesPublished791 F. Supp. 2d 419 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Mar 28, 2011
Qualified Immunity In his Motion for Summary Judgment, Defendant asserts he is entitled to qualified immunity because he did not violate a clearly established law of which a reasonable officer in his position would have known … The Right Was Clearly Established at the Time of the Violation Under the second prong of the qualified immunity test, the Court must determine whether the right violated was clearly established at the time of the violation
Cited 1 timesPublished148 F. Supp. 3d 395 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Nov 24, 2015
The right in question was clearly established, such that qualified immunity is unwarranted. ‘ Defendants argue that Officer Jones is entitled to qualified immunity because the constitutional right allegedly violated was not … clearly established at the time Officer Jones acted.
Cited 14 timesPublished418 F. Supp. 2d 724 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Mar 9, 2006
The Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has enunciated the qualified immunity inquiry as follows: “First, we must determine whether the defendants violated ‘clearly established’ rights. … Saucier instructs lower courts to examine whether a constitutional right was clearly established in the second-prong of a two-prong qualified immunity inquiry, whereas Harvey examines whether defendants violated a clearly
Cited 2 timesPublished456 F. Supp. 449 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Sep 6, 1978
Under the circumstances, the “clearly established right” aspect of Wood v. Strickland is unavailing to plaintiff here, and defendants’ assertion of qualified immunity must therefore prevail. … With respect to the equal protection claim, however, plaintiff does not even suggest that prior decisions delineate a “clearly established” right that would defeat defendants’ assertion of qualified immunity.
Cited 5 timesPublishedWhitfield v. City of Philadelphia
587 F. Supp. 2d 657 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Nov 19, 2008
Second, if the answer is yes, the court must then determine “ ‘whether the right was clearly established.’ ” Id. … In considering the second prong of the Saucier test, the Third Circuit clarified that “[a] right is clearly established for the purposes of qualified immunity when its contours are ‘sufficiently clear that a reasonable official
Cited 41 timesPublished302 F. Supp. 3d 700 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Mar 28, 2018
Qualified Immunity When a defendant in a § 1983 action claims qualified immunity, a court must first determine if the plaintiff's allegations are sufficient to establish the violation of a federal constitutional or statutory … Regarding the qualified immunity analysis, Defendant only contests whether the injury was sufficiently serious, and whether Plaintiff's rights were clearly established.
Cited 4 timesPublishedFanning v. Montgomery County Children & Youth Services
702 F. Supp. 1184 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Dec 29, 1988
Mason argues that he violated no clearly established right of the plaintiffs, and is therefore free from liability even under the less protective cloak of qualified immunity. … Qualified Immunity The remaining question with respect to Mr. Mason is whether the plaintiffs have alleged a violation of a clearly established right of which Mr. Mason should have been aware.
Cited 14 timesPublishedDistrict Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Mar 29, 2024
purposes of qualified immunity.” … Forsyth, 472 U.S. 511, 526 (1985) (“Unless the plaintiff’s allegations state a claim of violation of clearly established law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to dismissal before the commencement of
Cited 0 timesUnknownClifton v. Borough of Eddystone
824 F. Supp. 2d 617 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Oct 7, 2011
A state official with qualified immunity has no civil liability for discretionary conduct so long as he does “not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known … Furthermore, the right to be free from the use of excessive force in the course of handcuffing is clearly established and is not defeated by qualified immunity. Id. at 778 . Plaintiff was not subject to excessive force.
Cited 13 timesPublishedDistrict Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Oct 6, 2023
As an affirmative defense, the burden of establishing qualified immunity falls on to the official claiming it. , 642 F.3d 163, 176 (3d Cir. 2011). … clearly established when the conduct took place. , 905 F.3d at 716.
Cited 0 timesUnknownSupra Medical Corp. v. McGonigle
955 F. Supp. 374 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Jan 31, 1997
The burden then shifts to the plaintiff to produce evidence establishing that the foreign state is not entitled to immunity under one of the exceptions in § 1605. … The UMDS Defendants have provided no evidence of UMDS’ ownership, relying instead on a claim that the Schools’ qualify for immunity as an “organ of a foreign state.”
Cited 18 timesPublished948 F. Supp. 2d 480 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Jun 11, 2013
Accordingly, using pepper spray under these circumstances did not violate clearly established constitutional or statutory law, and so the Court finds that Baran is entitled to qualified immunity on this issue. 3. … Under these circumstances, Winik’s use of deadly force did not violate clearly established constitutional or statutory law. Accordingly, Winik is entitled to qualified immunity.
Cited 8 timesPublishedLattany v. Four Unknown U.S. Marshals
845 F. Supp. 262 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Feb 10, 1994
I must next decide whether the defendants were entitled to qualified immunity because the constitutional rights violated by the defendants were not “clearly established” at the time of the incidents. … There is no meaningful dispute regarding qualified immunity. The right of both convicted prisoners and pre-trial detainees not to suffer deliberate indifference to serious medical needs is clearly established.
Cited 7 timesPublished608 F. Supp. 2d 629 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Mar 19, 2009
Qualified Immunity Qualified immunity can protect police officers sued in their individual capacities from liability under § 1983, the Fourteenth Amendment, and the Fourth Amendment if their conduct does not violate clearly … “Unless the plaintiffs allegations state a claim of violation of clearly established law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to dismissal before the commencement of discovery.” Mitchell v.
Cited 35 timesPublishedTunnell v. Office of Public Defender
583 F. Supp. 762 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Mar 23, 1984
If the law was not clearly established, the defendant will prevail on summary judgment on the basis of the qualified immunity defense, id. at 818, 102 S.Ct. 2739 , unless the plaintiff claims that the official actually knew … If, on the other hand, the applicable law was clearly established, then, as the Court noted in Harlow , it should have been known to “a reasonably competent public official,” and the qualified immunity defense “should ordinarily
Cited 1 timesPublishedSafeguard Mutual Insurance v. Miller
456 F. Supp. 682 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Jul 13, 1978
On the other hand, conduct falling within the investigative and administrative functions of these defendants is subject to a qualified immunity and they must establish their good faith in order to escape liability. … As such, he is entitled only to the qualified immunity of other executive officials, and he must establish his good faith to avoid liability. Again, this is an issue best resolved at trial.
Cited 7 timesPublishedFields v. City of Philadelphia
166 F. Supp. 3d 528 · District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania · Feb 19, 2016
immunity, “our case law does not clearly establish a right to videotape police officers performing their official duties.” … Affirming the district court and rejecting officers’ claim of qualified immunity, the court of appeals held qualified immunity did not apply to officers because it was clearly established, "gathering information about government
Cited 2 timesPublished
Ask Donna