Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
3,447 results
1.16s
Moles v. Borough of Norristown
780 A.2d 787 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 11, 2001
Summary judgment is only appropriate when, after examining the record, there is no genuine issue of material fact, and the movant clearly established its entitlement to judgment as a matter of law. … Appellants contend that their allegations establish liability on the part of the Borough for Gep-perts damage to the Woolworth Building.
Cited 9 timesPublishedCity of Philadelphia v. Delaware County Board of Assessment Appeals
691 A.2d 992 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 28, 1997
from taxation under the doctrine of intergovernmental immunity. … Clearly, a building which has the purpose of facditating the regional distribution of the mad away from the Airport is not a general service budding that would qualify for taxation under the terms of Paragraph 8 of the Agreement
Cited 2 timesPublishedSalix State Bank v. Commonwealth, Department of Banking
36 Pa. Commw. 120 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 16, 1978
The Department’s assertion of immunity from suit is without merit. Though it has been held that this *123 immunity extends to actions in equity, Boss v. Keitt, 10 Pa. Commonwealth. … officials from performing affirmative acts are not within the rule of immunity.
Cited 1 timesPublishedZauflik v. Pennsbury School District
72 A.3d 773 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 3, 2013
Therefore, this Court cannot sanction a political subdivision by ordering an express waiver of its governmental immunity, consistent with the well-established precedent that governmental immunity is an absolute defense that … lack of support as to be clearly erroneous here.
Cited 20 timesPublishedJohnson v. City of Philadelphia
657 A.2d 87 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 29, 1995
Additionally, Johnson asserts that retroactive application of Gray is inappropriate because the Supreme Court established a new principle by overruling the Commonwealth Court’s decision in the same case. … However, an entire reading of Ludwin clearly demonstrates that, although the City could be held liable to PATCO under the terms of the lease, the City cannot be held directly liable to an injured party.
Cited 2 timesPublished46 Pa. Commw. 67 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 18, 1979
We will consider the objections seriatim. 2 In ruling on preliminary objections, we accept as true all well and clearly pleaded facts as well as inferences fairly deducible therefrom, but not conclusions or averments of law … rule of immunity.”
Cited 12 timesPublished119 Pa. Commw. 324 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 8, 1988
and remain immune from suit except as the General Assembly shall waive the immunity. … the legislature could declare sovereign immunity to be constitutional.
Cited 7 timesPublished10 Pa. Commw. 375 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 7, 1973
“Thus, where the obligations of defendants under a contract are clearly joint, all the obligors must be joined as defendants. Joint owners of property causing an injury to plaintiff must be joined as defendants. … This immunity has been held to extend to actions in equity. Philadelphia Life Insurance Company v. Commonwealth, 410 Pa. 571 , 190 A. 2d 111 (1963).
Cited 25 timesPublishedJackson Township Volunteer Fire Co. v. Workmen's Compensation Appeal Board
140 Pa. Commw. 620 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 28, 1991
The fire compa *624 ny contends that Wallet was not injured and that if he was, he has not established that his injury was causally related to his work. … However, this case is clearly distinguishable from a coal miner’s pneumoconiosis case, and our holding is not nearly so broad.
Cited 20 timesPublishedRieger Ex Rel. Rieger v. Altoona Area School District
768 A.2d 912 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 2, 2001
of the immunity exceptions enumerated in 42 Pa.C.S. § 8542. … Section 8546 of the Act provides in pertinent part: Defense of official immunity.
Disapproved by Brewington, S. v. Phila. Sch. Dist., Aplt., 199 A.3d 348 (2018)Cited 10 timesPublished795 A.2d 497 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 4, 2002
The court emphasized that it is the public’s interest rather than the interest of the official that supports the establishment of an absolute privilege. … Whether a police chief is qualified is a pertinent subject to borough council, because that governmental body is responsible under Section 1121 of The Borough Code for the appointment of the police chief. 53 P.S. § 46121.
Cited 20 timesPublishedMosley v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority
842 A.2d 473 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 3, 2003
The Commonwealth and its agencies enjoy sovereign immunity and remain immune from suit, except where the Legislature specifically waives the immunity. Section 8521 of the Judicial Code, 42 Pa. C.S. § 8521. … Mosley failed to establish that her cause of action falls within the motor vehicle exception to sovereign immunity. Accordingly, the trial court did not err in entering summary judgment in favor of SEPTA.
Cited 1 timesPublishedSpeece v. Borough of North Braddock
145 Pa. Commw. 568 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 19, 1992
The city asserted immunity. The Supreme Court affirmed this court’s finding of immunity. … In the present case, at the time the hose burst, the two fire trucks were stopped, were being used to pump water to the fire, and were clearly not being “operated”, as defined by the Supreme Court in Love .
Cited 4 timesPublished920 A.2d 913 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 9, 2007
Laurelton Center was established in 1918 for the rehabilitation, care and treatment of persons with mental retardation. … Id. *917 Preliminary objections in the nature of a demurrer should be sustained only where the pleadings are clearly insufficient to establish a right to relief; any doubt must be resolved in favor of overruling the demurrer
Cited 9 timesPublishedTaylor v. Northeast Bradford School District
101 A.3d 144 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 9, 2014
The trial court then concluded that [t]he gymnasium partition clearly falls into the third category. … If the latter, the District enjoys immunity.
Cited 8 timesPublishedCherry v. Pennsylvania Higher Education Assistance Agency
153 Pa. Commw. 210 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 1, 1993
PHEAA’s determination of what constitutes a “qualified applicant” is clearly within its scope of responsibility and is, for the reasons discussed above, not clearly erroneous. Accordingly, we affirm. … Definitions The following words and phrases when used in this act shall have the meanings given to them in this section unless the context clearly indicates otherwise: "Qualified applicant.”
Cited 7 timesPublishedM. Renner v. The Court of Common Pleas of Lehigh County
195 A.3d 1070 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 12, 2018
It tests the legal sufficiency of the challenged pleadings and will be sustained only in cases where the pleader has clearly failed to state a claim for which relief can be granted. … Court established waiver of the common pleas court’s sovereign immunity.
Cited 3 timesPublished85 Pa. Commw. 414 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 5, 1984
Although the record does not clearly establish exactly what “suspension” of PAL activities entailed, we gather that the prison officials prohibited inmates from conducting any corporate *416 business, but did not actually … Petitioners must establish that they have a clear legal right, that the respondents have a corresponding legal duty, and that there is no other adequate or appropriate remedy at law. Francis v.
Cited 37 timesPublishedComyn v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority
141 Pa. Commw. 53 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 1, 1991
Further, it is a *56 well established rule that in order to grant a petition to open a default judgment, the following three criteria must be met: (1) the petition to open must be promptly filed; (2) there must be a reasonable … The City argues that governmental immunity under 42 Pa.C.S.A. § 8541 is a meritorious *59 defense to Appellee’s claim.
Cited 16 timesPublished81 A.3d 167 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 9, 2013
The Supreme Court further explained that “the exception to sovereign immunity pertaining to Board-of-Claims jurisdiction defines the extent of the Commonwealth’s statutory exception from sovereign immunity for claims arising … [[Image here]] While more general clarification of the relationship between sovereign immunity and jurisdiction may be appropriate in the arena at large, for present purposes, we regard sovereign immunity as a jurisdictional
Cited 13 timesPublished
Ask Donna