Case law

Opinions from 1658 to today.

Filterspacommwct

3,447 results

2.65s

  • Norbert v. Com., State Police

    148 Pa. Commw. 505 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 12, 1992

    The complaint is, therefore, based upon the rationale in Susko , inadequate to establish a duty on the State Police. … The Court opined: Because the general assembly intended to exempt the Commonwealth from immunity only in specific clearly defined situations, we must strictly construe this real property exception..

    Cited 9 timesPublished
  • Consolidated Rail Corp. v. Shirk

    143 Pa. Commw. 422 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 13, 1991

    Summary judgment is only appropriate when, after examining the record in the light most favorable to the non-moving party, there is no genuine issue of material fact, and the movant clearly establishes entitlement to judgment … Exceptions to governmental immunity (a) Liability imposed.

    Cited 3 timesPublished
  • Buffalini v. Shrader

    112 Pa. Commw. 228 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 30, 1987

    (Emphasis added.) *235 This section is clearly intended to grant municipalities the authority to enforce its ordinances under the conditions set out in the statute but its permissive language does not mandate that enforcement … immunity pursuant to 42 Pa.

    Cited 17 timesPublished
  • Reid v. City of Philadelphia

    904 A.2d 54 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 3, 2006

    Judge Smith-Ribner in White had noted that no court decisions had clearly concluded that municipalities lose their ownership interests in streets and roads merely because a street had been designated a Commonwealth highway … Plaintiffs must establish that the accumulation caused ridges or “other elevation” of such a size and character as to obstruct travel.

    Cited 2 timesPublished
  • Brown v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation

    11 A.3d 1054 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 19, 2011

    Summary judgment is appropriate where the record clearly demonstrates that: (1) there are no genuine issues of material fact, and (2) the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Dean v. … The Commonwealth is immune from suit except where the General Assembly has specifically waived immunity. 1 Pa.C.S. § 2310.

    Cited 14 timesPublished
  • Canizares v. City of Philadelphia

    162 Pa. Commw. 444 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 10, 1994

    To establish liability in light of governmental immunity, Appellants were required to establish each of the following at trial: (1) that the City would have been liable under common law or statute for Mr. … Our review of the record reveals that Appellants have failed to establish the second and third aforementioned requirements, each of which would support a conclusion that the City is immune from suit in the present case.

    Cited 3 timesPublished
  • Frazier v. COM. PA STATE, POLICE

    845 A.2d 253 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 24, 2004

    By its enactment of § 3105, the legislature has established a duty upon drivers of emergency vehicles to drive with due regard for the safety of all persons. … Clearly, the emergency vehicle doctrine reduces the duties of drivers of emergency vehicles to comply with some provisions of the Vehicle Code. However, it does not totally abolish duties of those drivers.

    Cited 8 timesPublished
  • Smith v. Manson

    806 A.2d 518 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 6, 2002

    Those exceptions must be strictly construed because the legislature, when enacting the Tort Claims Act, clearly intended to insulate local agencies from liability save only in the specifically defined situations. … The Sovereign Immunity Act preserves the sovereign immunity of Commonwealth parties except where it is waived by the exceptions set forth in Section 8522.

    Cited 3 timesPublished
  • Scott v. Willis

    116 Pa. Commw. 327 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 25, 1988

    Clearly, then, the real property ex *334 ception is unavailable to Appellants, and their claims against the School District were correctly dismissed. … Further, Appellants have failed to plead the sufficient factual predicates on which they could establish willful misconduct. See Weissman v. City of Philadelphia, 99 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 403 , 513 A.2d 571 (1986).

    Cited 19 timesPublished
  • T. Pysher v. Clinton Twp. Volunteer Fire Co.

    209 A.3d 1116 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 8, 2019

    Notably, in Guinn, the immunity of the fire company had already been conceded and was not in issue. The issue before the Supreme Court was whether that immunity extended outside of the scope of firefighting duties. … To qualify as governmental, the function must be a substantial facet of a government activity.” Id. at 1109.

    Cited 5 timesPublished
  • City of Philadelphia v. Cumberland County Board of Assessment Appeals

    18 A.3d 421 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 4, 2011

    , making all of its Property immune from local taxation. … Without delving too deeply into the Trust’s affairs, it appears that it qualifies as an institution of purely public charity.

    Cited 1 timesPublished
  • State Workmen's Insurance Fund v. Caparo Real Estate Inc.

    160 Pa. Commw. 581 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 21, 1993

    , clearly stated situations, and as previously determined, it is the duty of this court to strictly construe this statute. … In Specter , the Supreme Court established the analysis to be used to determine whether various agencies and authorities created by the General Assembly are to be considered "the Commonwealth”.

    Cited 8 timesPublished
  • R.H.S. v. Allegheny County Department of Human Services

    936 A.2d 1218 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 15, 2007

    Preliminary objections in the nature of a demurrer should be sustained only where the pleadings are clearly insufficient to establish a right to relief; any doubt must be resolved in favor of overruling the demurrer. … Plaintiff fails to allege sufficient facts establishing Tarasi’s actions constituted a crime or willful misconduct. Accordingly, Plaintiffs assertion that Tarasí is not immune from suit fails. D.

    Cited 33 timesPublished
  • Brozovich v. Circle C Group Homes, Inc.

    120 Pa. Commw. 417 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 14, 1988

    . *420 The CYS Appellees raised both governmental immunity under 42 Pa. C. S. §8541 and immunity under Section 11 of the Law, 11 P.S. §2211. … However, while she clearly would be entitled to immunity from suit if her good faith in reporting abuse is established, the lack of a presumption to that effect renders this a factual question, fairly raised by Appellants

    Cited 7 timesPublished
  • Phillips v. Insurance Commissioner of the Commonwealth

    980 A.2d 687 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 11, 2009

    Attorney Land explained that Abington had immunity and didn’t have to pay for the damage because the Phillips had collision coverage. N.T, at 13; R.R. at Rll. … Here, Erie established that there were two accidents in a thirty-six month period which required it to pay out more than the threshold amount.

    Cited 1 timesPublished
  • Meyer v. Community College of Beaver County

    30 A.3d 587 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 27, 2011

    Clearly, no form of government unit or public authority is expressly included in the definition. What is less clear is whether the phrase “any other legal entities” extends to public agencies. … Such a result is indefensible, clearly not in the public interest, and inconsistent with our *595 charge to liberally construe the CPL to achieve its objectives.

    Cited 7 timesPublished
  • City of Philadelphia v. Shapp

    44 Pa. Commw. 303 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 17, 1979

    Since the payment of the funds has been provided by statute, from the standpoint of the state, the “claim” has been established and therefore this is not a situation where waiver of sovereign immunity is an issue. … Although immunity is an affirmative defense which ordinarily should be raised as new matter, we have considered and ruled upon issues of immunity raised in preliminary objections, when to delay ruling thereon would serve

    Cited 16 timesPublished
  • Robson v. Penn Hills School District

    63 Pa. Commw. 250 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 16, 1981

    Exceptions to governmental immunity. … immunity by the holding in Ayala v.

    Cited 76 timesPublished
  • K.A. Pezzano v. Towamencin Twp.

    155 A.3d 96 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 16, 2017

    The trial court found that the defamation and invasion of privacy claims against Mo-sesso were barred by immunity because his position as a second-class township supervisor qualified him as a high public official and the … official immunity.

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Canon-McMillan School District v. Bioni

    110 Pa. Commw. 584 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 30, 1987

    If the verdict is clearly against the weight of the evidence, a new trial is compelled. Id. … These are the criteria established in Pennsylvania. See Justice v. Nesquehoning Valley Railroad Co., 87 Pa. 28 (1878).

    Cited 10 timesPublished

Ask Donna

Ask Donna

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.