Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
3,447 results
1.11s
988 A.2d 740 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 8, 2010
Although Section 8542 states that there is an exception to immunity for negligence with regard to the care, custody or control of real property in the *746 possession of the local agency, it clearly states that liability … Here, although the contractor was never identified, City and Commission employees established that an unknown independent contractor did construct the alleged defective garden.
Cited 4 timesPublishedV. Balentine, Individually and as Administratrix v. Chester Water Authority
140 A.3d 69 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 3, 2016
This Court held that the allegations were sufficient to establish that the truck was in “operation” at the time of injury under the motor vehicle exception to governmental immunity because it was essentially alleged that … Unlike the majority, the statute does not qualify the word “operation.” If the movement of the vehicle causes the injury, the vehicle is deemed to be in operation.
Cited 1 timesPublished133 Pa. Commw. 327 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 9, 1990
of juris *331 diction was clearly erroneous, Akron Borough v. … Sovereign immunity, established under Art. 1, § 11 of the Pennsylvania Constitution and statutorily instituted by the General Assembly, 1 Pa.C.S. § 2310, has been waived only in those instances enumerated under the provisions
Cited 7 timesPublishedThomas v. City of Philadelphia
133 Pa. Commw. 121 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 11, 1990
WAIVER OF GOVERNMENTAL IMMUNITY Section 21-701. Police Officers. … However, Middleton is clearly distinguishable from the instant case in that the injured party was in police custody. He had collapsed on a sidewalk, was approached by police officers and was accused of being drunk.
Cited 15 timesPublishedDresser Industries, Inc. v. Commonwealth
146 Pa. Commw. 114 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 2, 1992
DER is clearly an “agency of state government” and, under the terms of the act, a “person” who can be sued. 3 *123 DER also makes with some force the argument that immunity must be specifically waived by the legislature. … We certainly recognize this established principle, but such waiver is not confined to the specific words “immunity is waived” and certainly includes words which permit a cause of action against a person, as does Section 601
Cited 4 timesPublishedClark v. Pennsylvania Department of Transportation
962 A.2d 692 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 8, 2008
To hold the Commonwealth party liable, the plaintiff also must establish that the cause of action falls under one of the exceptions to sovereign immunity contained in section 8522(b), 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b). … The Clarks argue that DOT’s negligent actions clearly are encompassed within this exception to sovereign immunity. In support of this position, the Clarks rely on the testimony of Karl Miller. Mr.
Cited 4 timesPublished698 A.2d 1382 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 6, 1997
Clearly, these averments, including the legal conclusion, are sufficient, if proven to be true, to establish that the real property exception to governmental immunity applies under Section 8542(b)(1) of the Act, and thus … In this case, however, the nature of the shower structure is not by any means established by “undisputed evidence of record” and remains a genuine issue of material fact that has yet to be determined.
Cited 22 timesPublished117 Pa. Commw. 371 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 29, 1988
Taylor, 451 U.S. 527, 535 (1981). 9 A local government qualifies as a “person” who may be directly liable under 42 U.S.C. §1983 . Monell v. Department of Social Services, 436 U.S. 658 (1978). … The opinion contains no discussion of governmental immunity and no indication that it had even been asserted. Another prerequisite to all actions claimed to fall under the eight exceptions to immunity in 42 Pa. C.
Cited 19 timesPublishedM.J. Brouillette v. T. Wolf, Governor
213 A.3d 341 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 2, 2019
Respondents also assert that the Senate and House Respondents are protected by legislative immunity and/or sovereign immunity. … to which immunity has been waived.
Cited 31 timesPublishedRousseau v. City of Philadelphia
100 Pa. Commw. 173 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 29, 1986
That no duty was owed by the city is also established by recognizing that the agreement to inspect the work constituted a benefit which runs to the interest of the federal government, and not to appellant. … Appellant has thus not satisfied the strictures of the immunity exception. 2.
Cited 10 timesPublishedOrange Stones Co. v. City of Reading
87 A.3d 1014 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 21, 2014
First, a party may raise the affirmative defense of immunity as a preliminary objection where it is clearly applicable on the face of the complaint; that is, that a cause of action is made against a governmental body and … In and of themselves, these averments are markedly insufficient to establish that Lachat possessed the wrongful intent necessary to overcome the official/governmental immunity conferred to him by the Tort Claims Act.
Cited 81 timesPublishedPoliskiewicz v. East Stroudsburg University
113 Pa. Commw. 13 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 22, 1988
We interpret this section as being evidence of an intent on the part of the General Assembly to *18 exempt the sovereign from immunity only in specific, clearly-stated situations and that it is our duty, therefore, strictly … At one time the view was that this provision substantively operated to establish sovereign immunity, see e.g., Sweigard v.
Cited 13 timesPublishedMcDonald v. Penn Hills Township School Board
7 Pa. Commw. 339 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 29, 1972
However, as well as being a creature of the Legislature, it is also a political subdivision created by the Legislature and clearly within the context of the Local Agency Law.” 219 Pa. … The 1968 Constitution, however, necessitated a change in this situation, Section 9 of Article 5 establishing that there must be a right of appeal from any administrative agency to a court of record.
Cited 14 timesPublished101 Pa. Commw. 258 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 16, 1986
The history and scope of that provision of the constitution are fully and clearly set forth in Com. ex rel. Police Pension Fund Assn. v. … The men could enter burning buildings, but were explicitly ordered not to interfere with firefighters. 7 In Flagiello, the Supreme Court expressly rejected the charitable immunity doctrine as established in Boyd I and Boyd
Cited 21 timesPublished687 A.2d 34 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 24, 1996
In order for a local agency to be held liable under an exception to immunity, a plaintiff must establish that (1) his or her damages would be recoverable under statutory or common law if the injury were caused by a person … The parties stipulated that Chuckles, a South American River Dolphin, is a wild animal. 4 The statutory exception to immunity for injuries caused by animals in the care, custody or control of the local agency clearly does
Cited 4 timesPublishedFrank v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority
96 Pa. Commw. 221 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 2, 1986
. *224 The appellant contends here that the facts alleged place this action within the “real property exception” established by Section 8542(b) (3) of the Judicial Code, which pertinently provides: (b) Acts which may impose … Such language clearly evinces the legislative intent to prevent trespassers from availing themselves of the advantage otherwise created by the real property immunity exception.
Cited 13 timesPublished782 A.2d 1090 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 23, 2001
The trial court denied the defendants’ post trial motion for summary judgment on the issue of sovereign immunity, but granted the defendants’ post trial motion for judgment n.o.v., holding that the inmate failed to establish … While the Wareham court agreed that a prison is similar to a detention center, they noted that the function of the prison infirmary clearly is to deliver medical care to the inmates and is therefore distinguishable from the
Cited 35 timesPublishedDEPT. OF ENVIRON. RESOURCES v. Myers
135 Pa. Commw. 526 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 22, 1990
DER maintains that the trial court erred when it denied DER’s motion for judgment n.o.v. because Myers failed to establish that he satisfied the requirements of the personal property exception to sovereign immunity. … Commonwealth Ct. 86, 91 , 476 A.2d 998, 1000 (1984), we stated: We interpret this section as being evidence of an intent on the part of the General Assembly to exempt the sovereign from immunity only in specific, clearly-stated
Cited 5 timesPublished152 Pa. Commw. 163 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 7, 1992
have violated La Frankie’s constitutional rights. 1 II In an action for malicious prosecution, a plaintiff has the burden to establish thát the defendant initiated the underlying criminal proceeding without probable cause … A review of the record clearly indicates that Trooper Miklich did not raise the affirmative defense of La Frankie’s guilt but, on the contrary, merely denied La Frankie’s allegations that the Trooper acted without probable
Cited 131 timesPublishedGramlich v. Lower Southampton Township
838 A.2d 843 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 17, 2003
One exception to this general immunity, known as the “streets exception,” exists where there is [a] dangerous condition of streets owned by the local agency, except that the claimant to recover must establish that the dangerous … City of Philadelphia, 127 Pa.Cmwlth. 466 , 561 A.2d 1334 (1989), affirmed, 526 Pa. 300 , 585 A.2d 1003 (1991) (concluding that the plaintiff failed to establish an exception to governmental immunity because she offered only
Cited 13 timesPublished
Ask Donna