Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
3,447 results
0.76s
Fagan v. DEPARTMENT OF TRANSP. OF COM.
946 A.2d 1123 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 15, 2008
Its two main arguments invoked immunity and the plaintiffs’ failure to establish causation necessary for a negligence action. Factually, the plaintiffs submitted the expert’s report previously referenced. … In order for a Commonwealth party such as PennDOT to be found liable, a plaintiff must also establish that the cause of action falls under one of the specifically enumerated exceptions to immunity. 42 Pa.C.S. § 8522(b).
Overruled by Cagey, J., Aplt. v. PennDOT, 179 A.3d 458 (2018)Cited 12 timesPublished46 Pa. Commw. 105 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 19, 1979
Pennsylvania, 479 Pa. 384 , 388 A.2d 709 (1978), wherein the judicially developed concept of sovereign immunity in Pennsylvania was abandoned. … Failing to adhere to established procedures and policies for operation of the Center; c. Failing to provide adequate and necessary security and protection for the employees of the Center; d.
Cited 6 timesPublishedCommonwealth, Department of Transportation v. Koons
661 A.2d 490 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 7, 1995
Summary judgment is only appropriate when, after examining the record in the light most favorable to the non-moving party, there is no genuine issue of material fact, and the moving party clearly establishes that he is entitled … Our Supreme Court has stated that, since the General Assembly intended to exempt the Commonwealth from immunity only in specific clearly defined situations, the real estate exception to the Act must be strictly construed
Cited 4 timesPublishedCanon-McMillan School District v. Bioni
127 Pa. Commw. 317 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 13, 1989
the real property exception to immunity. … The record clearly establishes that the lathe is physically connected with the real estate, and that it can be removed without destroying or materially injuring the lathe or the property to which it is annexed.
Cited 25 timesPublishedWURTH BY WURTH v. City of Philadelphia
136 Pa. Commw. 629 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 14, 1990
insufficient on its face to establish the pleader’s right to relief. … This issue would be ripe only if the City’s Recreation Act defense was firmly established. See 68 P.S. § 477-6.
Cited 107 timesPublished20 Pa. Commw. 606 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 1, 1975
First, plaintiff requests this Court to strike down sovereign immunity from the body of Pennsylvania law. … This concept of prior restraint advocated by plaintiff is clearly an anathema in a system structured upon the division and delegation of powers among three independent and coequal branches of government.
Cited 9 timesPublishedMcKeesport Municipal Water Authority v. McCloskey
690 A.2d 766 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 24, 1997
Summary judgment is only appropriate when, after examining the record in the light most favorable to the non-moving party, there is no genuine issue of material fact, and the moving party clearly establishes that he is entitled … Simpson, 523 Pa. 235, 239 , 565 A.2d 1153, 1155 (1989) (“Although the Commonwealth traditionally had sovereign immunity from suit, the establishment of the Board of Claims waived that immunity by providing a tribunal whose
Cited 10 timesPublished894 A.2d 867 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 16, 2006
by sovereign immunity. … The Police moved for a new trial or a judgment n.o.v. and asserted its conduct did not qualify as an exception to the real estate exception to sovereign immunity.
Cited 2 timesPublishedMiller v. Erie Metropolitan Transit Authority
152 Pa. Commw. 64 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 2, 1992
Because the word “operate” was commonly defined as a mode of action or to run or control the function of, the van clearly was not operating at the time of the accident as it had ceased movement. … We stated, “Nothing in Love ... requires that an entire *68 vehicle be in motion to establish ‘operation’ for purposes of the vehicle liability exception to the Code.
Cited 11 timesPublishedJohnson v. Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority
91 Pa. Commw. 587 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 11, 1985
Exceptions to governmental immunity. … Clearly they did.
Disagreed with by Ludwin v. Port Authority Transit Corp., 102 Pa. Commw. 36 (1986)Cited 11 timesPublishedTownships of Springdale v. Mowod
23 Pa. Commw. 298 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 13, 1976
The defendants raise the issues of sovereign immunity and laches. … Article III, Section 3 of the Pennsylvania Constitution of 1968 provides that: “No bill shall be passed containing more than one subject, which shall be clearly expressed in its title, except a general appropriation bill
Reversed on other grounds by Townships of Springdale & Wilkins v. Mowod, 474 Pa. 82 (1977)Cited 5 timesPublishedJ. Faucon v. Parkland Area School District
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 21, 2025
The Supreme Court explained that the fire chief’s alleged negligence was in the paint removal, and paint removal clearly fell within the exception’s language of the care of the property. Id. at 197. … “the care of the personalty caused a dangerous condition to occur on the real property,” the actual holding in Grieff clearly stated that there was no immunity due to the negligent
Cited 0 timesPublished714 A.2d 539 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 24, 1998
Although it was not necessary to a determination to apply the immunity provisions of the Federal Act in Allison , we clearly recognized its applicability in this Commonwealth. This is true although Dr. … Therefore, despite the fact that the hospital is immune from Dr.
Cited 6 timesPublished161 Pa. Commw. 158 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 30, 1993
However, neither the plain language of Section 8541 nor well-established precedent supports Appellants’ interpretations of the law. … Section 8541 invokes the bar of immunity in terms which clearly negate any right or interest of Appellants, much less a vested cause of action, prior to their signing the agreements of sale.
Cited 11 timesPublished79 Pa. Commw. 305 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 3, 1984
Pew is barred under the doctrine of judicial immunity. 1 ' In addressing the first of the respondents ’ preliminary objections, we note- that in this Commonwealth it is well established that a court of equity lacks jurisdiction … An .important element which must be established before this immunity can apply, however, is whether or not the actions complained of were performed within the quasi-judicial function.
Cited 14 timesPublishedMazin v. Bureau of Professional & Occupational Affairs
950 A.2d 382 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 10, 2008
sovereign immunity. … Initially, we do not believe that he has established a clear legal right to relief. Dr.
Cited 10 timesPublished712 A.2d 345 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 30, 1998
Neither that provision nor any other that this Court has found clearly provides that such an act of designation and taking over constitutes vesting ownership of the street, including the sidewalk, with the Commonwealth. 3 … In view of the comprehensive scheme established in the immunity and exceptions provisions of the Judicial Code, and in view of the applicable provisions of the State Highway Law, the Court cannot conclude that the legislature
Cited 10 timesPublished40 Pa. Commw. 54 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 19, 1979
Pennsylvania Department of Highways, 479 Pa. 384 , 388 A.2d 709 (1978), that the Commonwealth is no longer immune from suit by virtue of the *58 common law doctrine of sovereign immunity, and (2) since the Board of Arbitration … of Claims was established to provide a forum for obtaining a remedy against the Commonwealth where none existed due to the sovereign’s immunity.
Cited 28 timesPublishedJohnson v. Woodland Hills School District
135 Pa. Commw. 43 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 29, 1990
Miladin, 123 Pa.Commonwealth Ct. 405, 553 A.2d 535 (1989), that the real property exception to immunity 1 did not apply. … Summary judgment is only appropriate when, after examining the record in favor of the nonmoving party, there is no genuine issue of material fact and the movant clearly establishes that he or she is entitled to judgment as
Cited 7 timesPublishedKoppenhaver v. Department of Community & Economic Development
898 A.2d 654 · Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania · May 3, 2006
Bd. of Revision of Taxes, 574 Pa. 707 , 833 A.2d 710 (2003), for the proposition that a Commonwealth agency will lose its tax immune status if it acts outside its authorized purpose or outside the scope of its immunity. 9 … They raise legal issues clearly beyond the Department’s scope of review under 53 Pa.C.S. § 8211(d). Bundy; Mellinger, Property *667 Owners.
Cited 2 timesPublished
Ask Donna