Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
4,219 results
1.23s
SEPTA v. City of Philadelphia, Aplts.
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 26, 2017
The FPO also establishes criminal penalties for non-compliance with orders of the Commission. Phila. Code § 9-1121(1)-(2). … It is well-established and undisputed that sovereign immunity must be waived specifically by the General Assembly, 1 Pa.C.S. § 2310 (“[T]he Commonwealth . . . shall . . . remain immune from suit except as the General Assembly
Cited 0 timesPublishedLobozzo v. Adam Eidemiller, Inc.
437 Pa. 360 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 20, 1970
Because the governmental unit may be either immune from suit or immune from liability for harm caused by such activity, the full burden of absolute liability would fall squarely upon the individual public servant, absent … Lobozzo on cross-examination that he claimed his building had been permanently damaged, the whole record clearly indicates that he proceeded on the theory that the damage was remediable.
Cited 58 timesPublished384 Pa. Super. 335 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 3, 1989
. § 481(a), immunized SEPTA from any liability to Hackenberg other than workmen’s compensation benefits. … An entity providing benefits and qualified in the manner set forth in section 1787 (relating to self-insurance). 75 Pa.C.S. § 1702.
Cited 5 timesPublished392 Pa. Super. 489 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 18, 1990
We are convinced that the instructions adequately, accurately, and clearly explained the relevant principles of law to the jury. II. … In Mahaney , the qualifications of the person who actually performed the testing were established at trial.
Cited 26 timesPublishedSix L'S Packing Co. v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board
615 Pa. 615 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 29, 2012
In this regard, the WCAB explained that McDonald concerned Section 203 of the WCA, see 77 P.S. § 52, a provision which confirms that certain entities deemed to be statutory employers enjoy the same immunity from liability … See Brief for Claimant at 20 (“Use of the disjunctive clearly means that the work under contract must entail either (1) activities pertaining to soil, rock, minerals or timber, ‘or’ (2) activities involving a regular or recurrent
Cited 37 timesPublished351 Pa. Super. 380 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 31, 1986
manifested, and is not in conflict with established principles of law. … According to appellant’s calculations, the principal amount of the note that would qualify as income in respect of a decedent is in excess of $1,300,000.00.
Cited 1 timesPublished308 Pa. 13 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 20, 1932
The immunity so conceded in the latter case is based on grounds of public policy. … We are clearly of opinion that a fire truck is not a device intended for the transportation of persons or property upon a public highway.
Cited 30 timesPublishedGustafson, M. v. Springfield, Inc., Aplt.
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 31, 2025
[J-22-2024] - 14 In response, Defendants counter that the facts and circumstances of this case clearly satisfy each of the required elements of a “qualified civil liability action.” … In Defendants’ view, the Juvenile’s adjudication “conclusively establishes that Plaintiffs’ claims are based on the criminal misuse of the [Firearm] by a third party[,]” id. at 19, and the action is thus a “qualified civil
Cited 0 timesPublished165 Pa. 267 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 7, 1895
The exception is well established and is thus expressed in the strongest authority in its favor, Penn. Coal Co. v. … Unless that would be the substantial result of forbidding his action, he is not within the immunity of any of the cases.
Cited 36 timesPublishedIn re 1991 Pennsylvania Legislative Reapportionment Commission
530 Pa. 335 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 1, 1992
Thus on its face the Constitution clearly establishes a termination date for the reapportionment plan. … The Commission raises legislative immunity in its response to Appellants’ discovery requests.
Cited 25 timesPublished504 Pa. 304 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 15, 1984
In the instant case, it is clearly established that Appellant’s appointment as chief of police was in compliance with civil service procedures. … The First Class Tpwnship Code clearly prohibits his demotion without charges being filed and proper grounds being *311 established. We further find that the Civil Service Commission’s action was within its jurisdiction.
Cited 20 timesPublished60 Pa. 54 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 7, 1869
They are free only to the qualified electors of the Commonwealth. Clearly they are not free to the unqualified. … The Constitution does not provide these, and therefore the legislature must establish the tribunal, and the means of ascertaining who are and who are not the qualified electors; and must designate the evidence which shall
Cited 27 timesPublishedFreed v. Geisinger Medical Center
601 Pa. 233 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 15, 2009
It is also well established that a witness may be qualified to render an expert opinion based on training and experience. … We have explained that “[w]hen this Court issues a ruling that overrules prior law, expresses a fundamental break from precedent, upon which litigants may have relied, or decides an issue of first impression not clearly foreshadowed
Cited 35 timesPublished463 Pa. 597 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 3, 1975
Appellant further contends that the doctor, while qualified as to medical matters, was not properly qualified to testify regarding ballistics, specifically the distance from which the shot was fired. … The *604 more inflammatory the photograph the greater the need to establish its essential evidentiary value. Commonwealth v. Garrison, supra, 459 Pa. at 667, 331 A.2d at 187 .
Cited 22 timesPublished454 Pa. 557 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 4, 1973
This brief recital of the statutory history clearly illustrates the majority’s error in following Meisel v. Lit *567 tle, 407 Pa. 546 , 180 A.2d 772 (1962). … Chief Justice Jones, there noted that “[a]n examination of our decisions clearly indicates that ‘the personal immunity which protects [the husband or wife] is based simply upon the policy of preserved domestic peace and felicity
Cited 25 timesPublishedGermantown Trust Co. v. Powell
265 Pa. 71 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 21, 1919
“Classification, to be valid, must be based upon a necessity springing from manifest peculiarities clearly distinguishing those members of one class from each of the other classes, and imperatively demanding legislation from … If it be held that imposing a liability of property to be escheated when in the possession of corporations embraced by this act, by indirection grants a “special or exclusive privilege or immunity” to other corporations not
Cited 32 timesPublishedCommonwealth Ex Rel. v. Bitner
294 Pa. 549 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 26, 1928
properly qualified person as tax collector of the borough.” … Clearly the borough council intended his appointment was to continue until his successor should be elected at the next municipal election.
Cited 21 timesPublishedTravaglia v. C.H. Schwertner & Son, Inc.
391 Pa. Super. 61 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 29, 1989
Levinson Steel Co., 302 Pa. 287, 295 , 153 A. 424, 426 (1930), set forth five strict requirements under § 203 of the Act which an employer must meet to establish that he is a statutory employer, and thus avoid liability at … Clearly, confusion abounds as to which legislative enactment represents the Commonwealth's position on *74 statutory employer immunity.
Cited 20 timesPublishedSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 19, 2019
Thus, [323 MAL 2019] - 4 the PRPA’s immunity and confidentiality provisions reflect the legislature’s effort “to foster free and frank discussion by review organizations.” Id. … Thus, to the extent these aspects of the credentialing and recredentialing processes can be isolated, Reginelli established that such credential-related documents and documentation of related activities are not privileged
Cited 0 timesPublished216 Pa. 152 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 7, 1907
his successor was qualified. … Without any feasible or practical provision in any other part of the constitution for providing a successor where the candidate elect refuses to qualify, it is clearly within the proper rules of construction to hold that
Cited 9 timesPublished
Ask Donna