Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
4,219 results
1.55s
Ewalt v. Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission
382 Pa. 529 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 27, 1955
Fitzgerald, 359 Pa. 264, 272 , 59 A. 2d 142 , is apposite here, — “As is not unusual in attempts to establish that a statute is unconstitutional, tbe final assault is made on tbe title of tbe Act, it being claimed that Article … III, section 3 of tbe Constitution is violated because tbe subject-matter of tbe statute is not clearly expressed in tbe title ....
Cited 33 timesPublishedCallsen v. Temple University Hospital
539 Pa. 377 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 18, 1995
The majority today chooses to let stand a decision of the Commonwealth Court which is clearly at odds with the system *379 of pleading established by our rules of civil procedure and which clearly misapprehends the standard … the complaint those facts which he wishes to establish at trial.
Cited 2 timesPublished503 Pa. 251 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 30, 1983
To do so, facets of the society often require new immunities or larger responsibility, as the legislature may determine. … Under section 306(b), this would clearly qualify as a permanent partial disability. Scott v. Powell Coal Co., 402 Pa. 73 , 166 A.2d 31 (1960).
Cited 60 timesPublished355 Pa. Super. 160 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 18, 1986
Thus, the trial court did not err in refusing to grant immunity to Bricker. … Evidence of the prior shooting was clearly relevant to establish specific intent to kill, the mode of operation and that it was part of-the conspirators’ common scheme.
Cited 17 timesPublished385 Pa. 79 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 20, 1956
While it is obvious that an insignificant amendment made to a proposed ordinance after advertisement and a public hearing does not require a re-advertisement and public hearing the case is clearly otherwise if the amendment … Lancaster City, 313 Pa. 158, 162 , 169 A. 557, 559 , all of whom pointed out that municipal corporations are mere creatures of the State, being governmental agencies established for the purpose of carrying.out in detail the
Overruled in part by Mt. Lebanon v. County Board of Elections, 470 Pa. 317 (1977)Cited 36 timesPublishedMindala v. American Motors Corp.
518 Pa. 350 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 31, 1988
Thus, our case law establishes that in those instances the victims must demonstrate a special relationship which warrants protection. See, Chapman v. … State-designated highway except where department regulations provide otherwise. (2) Local authorities shall obtain approval of the department prior to erecting any traffic signal except in a municipality with a traffic engineer qualified
Cited 28 timesPublished539 Pa. 484 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 23, 1995
In Jones , we held: *491 Proximate cause is a term of art, and may be established by evidence that a defendant’s negligent act or failure to act was a substantial factor in bringing about the harm inflicted upon a plaintiff … As an initial matter, it should be noted that Dickens was concerned with immunity under the particular language of our governmental immunity statute, rather than our sovereign immunity statute.
Cited 89 timesPublishedWeisblatt, E., and S. Sear v. Gov. Wolf - No.
632 Pa. 147 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 19, 2015
or Debate Immunity. … According to the Legislative Appellants: Such potential unintended consequences only reinforce the public policies that underlie the Legislative Immunity and Sovereign Immunity
Cited 10 timesPublishedJustice, S., Aplt. v. Trooper Lombardo
208 A.3d 1057 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 31, 2019
And despite the somewhat awkward application of it to establishing the defense of sovereign immunity, our intermediate appellate courts have regularly applied the Restatement in this latter context as well. … Trooper Lombardo argues that "nothing [he] did on the day in question qualifies as legally 'outrageous'," as in Howard . Lombardo's Brief at 41.
Cited 74 timesPublished514 Pa. 351 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 7, 1987
These cases, and cases like them, also establish liability over one charged with the control and custody of property when the custodian knows, or should have known, that the property could be misused by persons who could … We believe the Legislature has clearly precluded the imposition of liability on itself or its local agencies for acts of third parties by its language of § 8541, supra, and that it has not seen fit to waive immunity for these
Questioned by Burgan v. City of Pittsburgh, 115 Pa. Commw. 566 (1988)Cited 335 timesPublished411 Pa. 425 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 2, 1963
immunity and relief from liability. … Absent such proof, the claim of immunity falls. .
Cited 119 timesPublishedConsolidation Coal Co. v. District 5, United Mine Workers
336 Pa. Super. 354 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 30, 1984
Nor was there anything done in the equity action, such as a dismissal with prejudice, which could qualify as a judgment on the merits. … hear cases involving violence intermeshed with picketing is clearly a state court.
Cited 36 timesPublishedShovel Transfer & Storage, Inc. v. Simpson
523 Pa. 235 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 6, 1989
Consequently, Shovel’s true objective is to establish the enforceability of that contract, which is clearly a contract claim. … Although the Commonwealth traditionally had sovereign immunity from suit, the establishment of the Board of Claims waived that immunity by providing a tribunal whose specific duty was to entertain contract actions against
Cited 30 timesPublishedCommonwealth, Aplt. v. Lehman, R.
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 21, 2024
Ultimately, the Superior Court affirmed Lehman’s judgment of sentence, holding that DORIA did not afford him immunity because DORIA “provides immunity for only certain, specifically[ ]enumerated offenses” and a violation … With that being said, the Superior Court properly concluded that Renewal Center qualifies as a “correctional institution” for purposes of Section 5123(a.2), (e).
Cited 0 timesPublished561 Pa. 397 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 11, 2000
In support of the government contractor defense, Quality Coach contends that its affordance under either the criteria established by the Superior Court in the present case or those established by the United States Supreme … The owner, however, failed to establish negligence on the part of the contractor at trial, while the contractor established that it had performed its work in strict accordance with the plans and specifications provided by
Cited 8 timesPublishedFrazier v. Workers' Compensation Appeal Board
616 Pa. 592 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 28, 2012
Thus, the employer/compensation insurer may step into the shoes of the claimant to recover directly against a third party tortfeasor, which here would be the Commonwealth and its subsidiaries, an action clearly prohibited … official immunity.
Cited 55 timesPublished523 Pa. 377 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 21, 1989
Borough of Wilkinsburg, 505 Pa. 249 , 478 A.2d 1279 (1984) (notice and hearing are required if order is to qualify as an adjudication — letter from agency will qualify as adjudication if letter is final order and impacts … upon person’s personal or property rights, privileges, immunities, duties, liabilities, or obligations).
Cited 2 timesPublished481 Pa. 579 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Oct 5, 1978
He further contends that the district attorney's purported grant of immunity from further prosecution was of no significance, since he was entitled to reject immunity for "his own reasons." … Such an allocation of the burden of proof is clearly unsupported by our prior decisions in Lenart and Carrera .
Cited 21 timesPublished487 Pa. 152 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Dec 21, 1979
By its express terms, section 503 is clearly limited to adoption by the spouse of a natural parent. … Appellant’s constitutional challenge must meet the “stringent burden” of establishing that the statute “clearly, palpably and plainly violates the Constitution,” In re William L., 477 Pa. 322, 329 , 383 A.2d 1228, 1231 (1978
Cited 27 timesPublished310 Pa. 362 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 3, 1933
A legislative intention to withdraw it should clearly appear before the courts may declare it withdrawn. In O’Reilly v. … L. 1235 (a supplement to the general Banking Act of 1876, supra) prohibiting branch banking establishments.
Cited 15 timesPublished
Ask Donna