Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
4,219 results
1.98s
Simmons v. St. Clair Memorial Hospital
332 Pa. Super. 444 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 17, 1984
Clair Hospital should be granted immunity for ordinary negligence. We will address appellant’s contentions seriatim. I. … The immunity issue in this case is potentially moot and we decline to consider that issue at this time. Id.
Cited 36 timesPublishedPhiladelphia Life Insurance v. Commonwealth
410 Pa. 571 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 16, 1963
Supp. 809 ) fall within the first class of suits and are clearly with *577 in the rule of the Commonwealth’s immunity; the case at bar falls within the second class and is not within the rule of immunity. … Torquato, 386 Pa. 306, 328 , 125 A. 2d 755 , clearly controls this situation: “. . . it is equally well established that a Court of Equity has jurisdiction and in furtherance of justice will afford relief if the statutory
Cited 80 timesPublished470 Pa. 420 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 28, 1977
Thus, reference to the Corrupt Organizations Act of 1970 to interpret the previously enacted Immunity Act would clearly be improper. … The order to testify shall not be given except upon the order of court after a hearing in which the attorney general has established a need for the grant of immunity, as hereinafter provided.
Cited 7 timesPublishedShaler Area School District v. Salakas
494 Pa. 630 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jul 2, 1981
. 11 In his brief, appellant argues that his property rights have been affected in that the unsatisfactory rating: (1) threatens his right to continued employment in his current tenured position; 12 (2) divests him of a qualifying … The entry of a peremptory judgment in this instance was clearly erroneous, since the ultimate question of whether any of appellant’s personal or property rights were affected involves factual as well as legal issues.
Cited 33 timesPublished526 Pa. 227 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jan 9, 1991
Therefore, plaintiff has failed to establish that he is presently “unable to do or perform a bodily act which he was able to do or perform prior to the injury.” … Plaintiff has established sufficient facts to merit an award for pain and suffering under the statute.
Cited 57 timesPublished507 Pa. 27 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Feb 21, 1985
The evidence in this case established that on July 1, 1980 at approximately 2:30 a.m. a young woman was raped by two men. The rape occurred in a house on North 29th Street in Philadelphia. … The Superior Court concluded that the testimony sought to be immunized was not shown to be clearly exculpatory or essential, thus, the denial of immunity was sustainable.
Disagreed with by In the Interest of Whaley, 350 Pa. Super. 213 (1986)Cited 24 timesPublishedBalentine v. Aplt. v. Chester Water Auth
191 A.3d 799 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 21, 2018
Judge Friedman maintained that the majority erred by distinguishing between voluntary and involuntary movement of a vehicle because "the statute does not qualify the word 'operation.' " Id. at 77 . … Balentine has pled facts sufficient to establish a prima facie cause of action in negligence based on acts that constitute the operation of a vehicle.
Cited 40 timesPublishedOverstreet v. Borough of Yeadon
327 Pa. Super. 291 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Apr 13, 1984
The criminal charges were dismissed after a preliminary hearing on the ground that a prima facie case had not been established, and a petition for rearrest was rejected by the Deputy Administrator for District Justices, the … As the facts alleged clearly would support a determination of willful misconduct on the part of the individual appellees, the preliminary objections of the individual appellees should not have been sustained on the ground
Cited 12 timesPublishedScientific Games International, Inc. v. Commonwealth
620 Pa. 175 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Mar 25, 2013
Summary The Procurement Code establishes administrative processes to address disputes arising in the procurement setting. … The Legislature obviously was entitled to rely on this clearly-expressed understanding when it subsequently devised the Procurement Code and its internal immunity reaffirmation.
Cited 41 timesPublished534 Pa. 581 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 10, 1993
In subsection (b) of § 5725 it clearly states that officers of the Commonwealth will not be protected by the doctrine of sovereign immunity in civil actions brought against them for violations of the provisions of this Act … That defense is defined as follows: “government officials performing discretionary functions generally are shielded from liability for civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory
Cited 30 timesPublishedBendas v. Township of White Deer
531 Pa. 180 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 17, 1992
Thus, in Mindala , three Justices, including this author, clearly were of the opinion that the question of what constitutes a dangerous condition constituted a fact question. … Nothing in this Opinion is intended to preclude a court from entering judgment in those cases where the facts establish as a matter of law that a dangerous condition did not exist. See generally Thompson Coal Co. v.
Cited 62 timesPublished336 Pa. 289 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 25, 1939
In short, the Schmid case ruled that under Article III, section 7, of the Constitution, which forbids the granting of any special or exclusive privilege or immunity, a statute was constitutional if it granted to war vetterans … a preferential right to appointment provided they had qualified for the position under uniform eligibility rules, but was unconstitutional if it permitted veterans to qualify under less rigorous standards than those prescribed
Cited 15 timesPublished502 Pa. 600 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 3, 1983
Evidence of a crime other than the one charged is clearly relevant and admissible for establishing a common plan, scheme or design. See, Commonwealth v. Galloway, supra; Commonwealth v. … The same rationale was clearly applicable here. 7 .
Cited 41 timesPublishedChristy v. Cranberry Volunteer Ambulance Corps, Inc.
579 Pa. 404 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Aug 16, 2004
Id. 9 (citing 42 Pa.C.S. § 8332). *413 The landscape regarding the criteria for establishing local agency immunity changed while the matter sub judice was pending on appeal. … Whether Cranberry Ambulance will qualify for local agency immunity pursuant to Sphere Drake cannot be not known at this stage of the proceedings; however, it is clear that the Commonwealth Court erred by failing to apply
Cited 34 timesPublished434 Pa. 507 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 28, 1969
Appellant counters by arguing that this definition applies only to Article IV of the Act, that the employer’s immunity from liability is established in Article III and that, therefore, the general definition of “employer” … Instead, we are convinced that the legislature intended that the *514 broader definition which clearly applies in §319 should also apply in §303 establishing the employer’s immunity.
Cited 41 timesPublished511 Pa. 112 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Jun 30, 1986
This is prohibited and clearly does not serve as the basis of an acceptable attorney-client relationship. … Polak, 438 Pa. 67 , 263 A.2d 354 (1970), cited by Judge Spaeth, is clearly inapposite.
Cited 43 timesPublished334 Pa. 538 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 8, 1939
Fewer teachers were required in them, and new teachers were needed in the commercial department, but appellant could not qualify. … To avoid this risk, they must forever continue only those *542 courses in which their preseut staff is qualified. What we said in Ehret v.
Cited 14 timesPublished527 Pa. 330 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · May 20, 1991
Not surprisingly, the by-product of eliminating hospital immunity has been the filing of malpractice actions against hospitals. … Initially, suits against hospitals qualifying as charities failed because such hospitals were not liable vicariously or otherwise. Benedict v. Bondi, 384 Pa. 574 , 122 A.2d 209 (1956); and Yorston v.
Cited 186 timesPublished496 Pa. 204 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Nov 5, 1981
Thus, any reliance on the alleged assurances made in 1975 was clearly unreasonable after D.P.W.'s refusal to relicense appellant in 1976. … the six-month limitation on actions is a limited waiver of sovereign immunity.
Cited 3 timesPublishedSiidekum v. Animal Rescue League of Pittsburgh
353 Pa. 408 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · Sep 26, 1945
On the day of the accident there was only one qualified driver on hand, so that three of the four policemen assigned by the City were engaged in operating the trucks. … Its status as such has been established by judicial decision (Ammon’s Estate, 72 P. L. J. 872) and by rulings of governmental agencies.
Cited 74 timesPublished
Ask Donna