Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
8,699 results
1.17s
184 N.E.3d 925 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Feb 7, 2022
Chapter 2744 establishes a three-tier analysis to determine whether a political subdivision is immune from liability. Greene Cty. Agricultural Soc. v. … {¶56} To establish negligence, a plaintiff must establish a duty, a breach of that duty, proximate cause, and damages.
Cited 2 timesPublished2019 Ohio 4266 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Oct 17, 2019
This privilege is either absolute or qualified. Mettke v. Mouser, 10th Dist. No. 12AP-1083, 2013-Ohio-2781, ¶ 6. … The procedure for determining this immunity is set forth in R.C. 2743.02(F).
Cited 7 timesPublishedHelton v. Kettering Medical Ctr.
2026 Ohio 1476 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Apr 24, 2026
Because Helton had the burden to establish the elements of R.C. 2305.51(B), KHBMC’s amended answer adding an immunity defense was unnecessary and irrelevant. … The trial court permitted the late amendment adding the immunity defense and then sua sponte vacated the trial date, reopened discovery related to the immunity defense, and established a briefing schedule for a second motion
Cited 0 timesPublishedHogan v. Village of South Lebanon
73 Ohio App. 3d 230 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Apr 22, 1991
The district court found the resolution to be unconstitutional, but determined that the trustees were entitled to qualified immunity. … If their conduct is administrative, they are entitled to qualified immunity. If their conduct is neither judicial, legislative nor administrative, they are not entitled to any immunity.
Cited 9 timesPublishedSickles v. Jackson County Highway Department
196 Ohio App. 3d 703 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Nov 17, 2011
The parties agree that the engineer’s and the commissioners’ offices qualify for the general grant of immunity under the Political Subdivision Tort Liability Act. … Id. {¶ 20} The Sickleses do not dispute appellants’ contention that claims against the Jackson County commissioners and Jackson County engineer generally qualify for the broad grant of immunity under R.C. 2744.02
Cited 20 timesPublished5 Ohio App. 2d 57 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Jan 25, 1966
The comments in Standard Fire as to nuisance are also clearly dicta. … Perhaps it was an ‘ ‘ absolute ’ ’ nuisance and not merely a ‘ ‘ qualified ’ ’ one.
Cited 1 timesPublished2023 Ohio 4829 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Dec 29, 2023
Even if the record established that Mr. Jones could be considered a “qualifying adult[,]” the record is also devoid of any evidence indicating that Mr. … Jones’s burden to establish error on appeal, and he has failed to do so. State v. Grether, 9th Dist. Summit No. 28977, 2019-Ohio- 4243, ¶ 16, quoting State v. Patel, 9th Dist.
Cited 1 timesPublished2015 Ohio 3717 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Sep 14, 2015
. {¶16} Here, the Biblers do not dispute that the City is a political subdivision and qualifies for general immunity. … has been established by the political subdivision, the burden lies with the plaintiff to show that one of the recognized exceptions applies.
Cited 4 timesPublished104 Ohio App. 3d 636 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Jun 16, 1995
immunity. … U.S.Code; (8) Davisson was entitled to either absolute or qualified immunity from suit for alleged civil rights violations under Section 1983; and (7) the deputy and the sheriffs department were entitled to sovereign immunity
Cited 52 timesPublishedGundel v. Whalen Lawn & Landscaping, L.L.C.
2022 Ohio 2763 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Aug 10, 2022
. {¶8} Gundel responded by arguing that WLL was the employer and though Whalen was its sole member, he did not qualify as employer on the facts of this case. … ruling and finds Whalen is entitled to immunity under these statutory provisions.
Cited 2 timesPublished2012 Ohio 1605 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Apr 4, 2012
. {¶13} Once immunity is generally established, “the second tier of analysis is whether any of the five exceptions to immunity in subsection (B) apply.” Id. at ¶ 12. … In other words, regardless of whether obstruction-related traffic control devices qualify as public roads, Scioto App.
Cited 6 timesPublished2019 Ohio 1517 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Apr 24, 2019
This broad immunity, however, is not without limits. … Moreover, just because a pipe fails or does not perform optimally does not establish negligence in the immunity context. 2. {¶26} The Bernards also turn exclusively
Cited 3 timesPublished152 N.E.3d 340 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Feb 18, 2020
Chapter 2744 establishes a three-step analysis to determine whether a political subdivision is immune from liability. Greene Cty. Agricultural Soc. v. … Whether the Alcuses also met their burden to establish an exception to the Township’s immunity under R.C. 2744.02(B)(4) is moot.
Cited 5 timesPublishedTransky v. Ohio Civil Rights Commission
193 Ohio App. 3d 354 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Apr 15, 2011
If they were acting in the latter capacity, appellants claim that the officials are entitled only to qualified immunity. … , but merely qualified immunity.
Cited 7 timesPublished2013 Ohio 4479 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Oct 10, 2013
However, before R.C. 2744.02(B)(2) will remove a political subdivision’s immunity, a plaintiff must first establish the elements required to sustain a negligence action and second, that the negligence arose out of a “proprietary … The city concedes that the maintenance of the manhole qualifies as a “proprietary function” under the statute and, therefore, we move on to consider whether Puffenberger has established that the city was negligent in maintaining
Cited 3 timesPublished125 Ohio App. 3d 33 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Jan 7, 1998
It is clear from case law and the Ohio Political Subdivision Tort Liability Act that some form of qualified municipal immunity has existed in Ohio from the mid-nineteenth century until the present day, covering the period … Barring this statutory action by immunity in another part of the Revised Code would be nonsensical and clearly contrary to the intent of the General Assembly.
Cited 17 timesPublished2013 Ohio 4338 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Sep 30, 2013
Appellant's proposed interrogatories asked the jury if Fridd's negligence was a proximate cause of appellant's injury, whether Fridd established that he was entitled to immunity, and what amount the jury should award as damages … Accordingly, the evidence established that Premierfirst consented to or acquiesced in horseplay occurring at the office, rendering Fridd's horseplay within the course of his employment and entitling Fridd to immunity under
Cited 7 timesPublished155 N.E.3d 258 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Jun 18, 2020
R.C. 2744.02(A)(1) establishes the general rule of immunity granted to municipalities and provides in relevant part: Except as provided in division (B) of this section, a political subdivision is not liable … While there are five exceptions to this immunity, appellants have failed to present any evidence establishing a genuine issue of material fact regarding any of those exceptions.
Cited 8 timesPublished113 Ohio App. 3d 14 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Jul 25, 1996
There was no eyewitness testimony at trial establishing the speed at which the ambulance was traveling. … to immunity pursuant to the statute.
Cited 28 timesPublished46 Ohio App. 3d 166 · Ohio Court of Appeals · Mar 25, 1988
may be asserted to establish non-liability: * * “(5) The political subdivision is immune from liability if the injury, death, or loss to persons or property resulted from the exercise of judgment or discretion * * * unless … Accordingly, appellee, a regional transit authority and a political subdivision, qualifies for sovereign immunity within R.C. 2744.03.
Cited 2 timesPublished
Ask Donna