Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
3,531 results
0.57s
18 A.D.3d 908 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · May 5, 2005
When constructing or reconstructing a highway, the municipality is afforded qualified immunity for “judgmental error in planning highway design” (Gutelle v City of New York, supra at 795; see Weiss v Fote, 7 NY2d 579 [1960 … Indeed, finding an expert who disagrees with the municipality’s reasoned decision in such a project is not enough since a “choice between conflicting experts is insufficient to establish municipal liability” (Evans v Stranger
Cited 9 timesPublishedHeinrichs v. Town of Brookhaven
2025 NY Slip Op 07000 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Dec 17, 2025
a person of rights, privileges or immunities secured by the Constitution or laws of the United States" ( Pressley v City of New York , 233 AD3d 932, 936 [internal quotation marks omitted]). … Contrary to the Town defendants' contention, they failed to establish at this stage of the action that the Town defendants other than Gallino are entitled to qualified immunity ( see Sculti v Finley , 167 AD3d 796, 797-798
Cited 0 timesPublishedCommissioner of the N.Y. State Dept. of Transp. v. Polite
2024 NY Slip Op 06023 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Dec 4, 2024
Actions that "seek to recover funds from tribal coffers or establish vicarious liability of a tribe for damages . . . are barred by tribal sovereign immunity even when nominally styled as against individual officers" ( Jamul … Moreover, we reject the commercial defendants' argument that the Westwoods qualifies as "Indian country" pursuant to 18 USC § 1151 .
Cited 0 timesPublished126 A.D.3d 1203 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Mar 19, 2015
As to the City, it is well settled that "[a] municipality is accorded a qualified immunity from liability arising out of a highway planning decision, but may be held liable when its study of a traffic condition is plainly … Even where a municipality is not entitled to immunity, a plaintiff must still demonstrate that the alleged negligent design of the roadway was a proximate cause of the accident (see Atkinson v County of Oneida, 59 NY2d 840
Cited 6 timesPublishedDann v. Auburn Police Department
138 A.D.3d 1468 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Apr 29, 2016
Although prosecutors are afforded only qualified immunity when acting in an investigative capacity (see Buckley, 509 US at 275-276 ; Kirchner, 107 AD3d at 1623; Claude H. v County of Oneida, 214 AD2d 964, 965 [1995]), we … It is well established that “ ‘information provided by an identified citizen accusing another of a crime is legally sufficient to provide the police with probable cause to arrest’ ” (Lyman, 74 AD3d at 1843 ; see Zetes, 108
Cited 0 timesPublished2026 NY Slip Op 01907 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Mar 27, 2026
A hospital's bylaws are not a contract entitling staff members to sue for relief in the event of failure to comply with the bylaws unless the bylaws clearly delineate such a right ( see Mason v Central Suffolk Hosp ., 3 NY3d … Here, based on the allegations of the complaint, liberally construed, we conclude that Kaleida failed to establish, on this CPLR 3211 motion, that it is entitled to immunity.
Cited 0 timesPublishedMarten v. Eden Park Health Services, Inc.
250 A.D.2d 44 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Nov 19, 1998
If immunity or privilege are raised, the party challenging disclosure “bears the burden of *47 establishing that the information sought is immune from disclosure” (Bloss v Ford Motor Co., supra, at 805; see, Central Natl. … Initially, we conclude that the requested materials are clearly relevant to the defense of this action.
Cited 16 timesPublishedBombard v. Amica Mutual Insurance
11 A.D.3d 647 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Oct 25, 2004
The party asserting the privilege provided by CPLR 3101 (d) bears the burden of demonstrating that the material it seeks to withhold is immune from discovery (see Koump v Smith, 25 NY2d 287, 294 [1969]) by identifying the … The language of that letter, as well as the subsequent disclaimer letter, clearly *649 established that the defendant’s investigation of the incident and the facts related to the plaintiffs notice of the incident was ongoing
Cited 29 timesPublished157 A.D.2d 370 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · May 24, 1990
Clearly, defendant was urging the court to submit the question of a special relationship to the jury. … On appeal, it takes that argument several steps further by urging that the assessment of danger is itself a matter of police judgment and discretion immune from judicial second-guessing, and also that other considerations
Cited 11 timesPublished143 A.D.3d 802 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Oct 12, 2016
immunity (see Brigham City v Stuart, 547 US 398, 403 [2006]; Diederich v Nyack Hosp., 49 AD3d 491, 493 [2008]; Sirlin v Town of New Castle, 35 AD3d 713 [2006]; Kubik v New York State Dept. of Social Servs., 278 AD2d 644 … However, the appellants established their prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law dismissing the malicious prosecution cause of action insofar as asserted against each of them by demonstrating that the underlying
Cited 10 timesPublishedBezar v. New York State Department of Social Services
151 A.D.2d 44 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Oct 12, 1989
As to Giraldo, 7 of the 10 *47 factors set forth in the attachment related to incomplete records of specifically named patients such as, e.g., absent pediatric patient growth and development charts and immunization records … The State clearly has a legitimate interest in insuring that the medically indigent receive high quality medical care at reasonable cost through the review provided in the reenrollment process (see, Matter of Camperlengo
Cited 33 timesPublishedDann v. Auburn Police Department
138 A.D.3d 1468 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Apr 29, 2016
Although prosecutors are afforded only qualified immunity when acting in an investigative capacity (see Buckley, 509 US at 275-276 ; Kirchner, 107 AD3d at 1623; Claude H. v County of Oneida, 214 AD2d 964, 965 [1995]), we … It is well established that “ ‘information provided by an identified citizen accusing another of a crime is legally sufficient to provide the police with probable cause to arrest’ ” (Lyman, 74 AD3d at 1843 ; see Zetes, 108
Cited 0 timesPublished80 A.D.3d 171 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Sep 28, 2010
The Supreme Court granted- the motion with respect to the cause of action asserted by the infant plaintiff Shannon Shipley on the ground that she lacked capacity to sue because she did not qualify as “next of kin” as that … This latter duty is not only ministerial in nature (see Tango v Tulevech, 61 NY2d 34, 40 [1983]), but is clearly for the benefit of, and is owed directly to, the next of kin.
Cited 14 timesPublished96 A.D. 383 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Jul 15, 1904
the board is required to issue to the applicant a certificate showing that he is qualified to practice as a master or journeyman horseshoer. … It thus clearly appears by this amendment that for a violation of section 384m of the Penal Code outside of cities of the first and second class no penalty whatever is provided, while within those cities such act is made
Cited 10 timesPublishedSoviero Bros. Contracting Corp. v. City of New York
286 A.D. 435 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Jun 28, 1955
A total immunity clause is bad; a limitation provision, if reasonable, is not. … It is questionable whether they are sufficient to establish an instance of constructive fraud, which plaintiff must establish, at least if it is to be entitled to damages for fraud.
Cited 36 timesPublished2024 NY Slip Op 03264 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Jun 14, 2024
of qualifying offenses in a state other than New York. … Thus, there is no reason to believe that only a few such offenders committed their qualifying out-of-state offenses in a nonviolent manner.
Cited 3 timesPublished166 A.D.2d 795 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Oct 18, 1990
The presence of such hazards in this case were amply demonstrated in defendant’s motion papers, thereby justifying defendant’s "exercise of reasoned judgment” (Tango v Tulevech, supra, at 41 ) and establishing its immunity … As for the allegedly slanderous statements reportedly made by defendant’s employees to plaintiffs sister, those statements clearly do not constitute slander per se, attack plaintiff’s professional ability or accuse him of
Cited 4 timesPublished2022 NY Slip Op 05833 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Oct 19, 2022
which was for summary judgment dismissing so much of the amended complaint as alleged negligence with respect to the planning and design of the exit ramp insofar as asserted against the City and NYCDOT on the ground of qualified … immunity, for the reasons set forth in Riddell v City of New York (___ AD3d ___).
Cited 1 timesPublishedAmerican Catalog Mailers Assn. v. Department of Taxation & Fin.
2026 NY Slip Op 02908 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · May 7, 2026
The statute [*3] "was designed to define clearly a lower limit for [a state's] exercise of [its taxing] power," and "[c]larity that would remove uncertainty was Congress' primary goal" ( Heublein, Inc. v South Carolina Tax … Consistent with that purpose, the statute establishes a functional standard for immunity — activities that are solely solicitation — that must be applied across a wide range of business practices ( see Wisconsin Dept. of
Cited 0 timesPublished2026 NY Slip Op 02239 · Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · Apr 15, 2026
The Government Defendants Failed to Conclusively Establish that Their Actions Were Shielded from Liability by Governmental Function Immunity or Absolute Immunity Governmental function immunity, sometimes referred to as the … "[A] municipality is not immune from liability based upon the exercise of discretionary authority unless the municipal defendant establishes that the discretion possessed by its employees was in fact exercised in relation
Cited 0 timesPublished
Ask Donna