Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
2,129 results
3.81s
152 N.C. App. 347 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Aug 20, 2002
We conclude that the record on appeal supports the trial court’s determination that Teresa Kroh acted with actual malice, thus negating any qualified immunity she otherwise would have enjoyed under G.S. § 7B-309 for her statements … immunity under G.S. § 7B-309.
Cited 12 timesPublishedPetroleum Traders Corp. v. State
190 N.C. App. 542 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · May 20, 2008
Defendants assert that the Declaratory Judgment Act does not waive sovereign immunity, and Plaintiff concedes that it “has not relied on the Declaratory Judgment Act to establish the absence of sovereign immunity.” … We agree, and conclude that the waiver of sovereign immunity established by Corum does not extend to Count I or II of Plaintiff’s complaint.
Cited 11 timesPublishedCourt of Appeals of North Carolina · Oct 18, 2022
However, denial of a motion for summary judgment ‘on the grounds of sovereign and qualified immunity is immediately appealable.’ ” Epps v. Duke Univ., 122 N.C. … FUNDERBURK 2022-NCCOA-676 Opinion of the Court “three-step inquiry” established in Estate of Williams v.
Cited 0 timesPublishedWilkerson v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co.
151 N.C. App. 332 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Jul 16, 2002
It is only when an individual pleads qualified immunity or public officer immunity that the distinction between discretionary and ministerial acts is important. … This testimony clearly supports the finding that the City did not waive its immunity regarding the improvement project.
Cited 8 timesPublished122 N.C. App. 507 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Jun 4, 1996
It is well-established in North Carolina that the common law doctrine of sovereign immunity “prevents a claim for relief against the State except where the State has consented or waived its immunity.” … We recognize that those activities are discretionary in nature and clearly within the scope of defendant’s official duties.
Reversed on other grounds by Meyer v. Walls, 347 N.C. 97 (1997)Cited 15 timesPublishedRay v. B. Keith Forgy, M.D., P.A.
245 N.C. App. 430 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Feb 16, 2016
Lastly, the trial court issued a qualified protective order authorizing the disclosure of log 305 to plaintiffs. … KEITH FORGY, M.D., PA., Opinion of the Court affidavits and the Medical Staff bylaws of Grace to establish that their MRCs qualified as MRCs pursuant to the meaning contemplated
Cited 1 timesPublished121 N.C. App. 273 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Jan 2, 1996
The evidence in the record before us was sufficient to establish defendant’s presence and participation in the various drug transactions. … Immunity Defendant argues that two of the State’s witnesses, Mark Rook and Gary Francis, testified at defendant’s trial under defective grants of immunity.
Cited 7 timesPublishedBarfield v. North Carolina Department of Crime Control & Public Safety
202 N.C. App. 114 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Jan 19, 2010
“It has long been established that an action cannot be maintained against the *119 State of North Carolina or an agency thereof unless it consents to be sued or upon its waiver of immunity, and that this immunity is absolute … “Waiver of sovereign immunity may not be lightly inferred and State statutes waiving this immunity, being in derogation of the sovereign right to immunity, must be strictly construed.”
Cited 2 timesPublishedCourt of Appeals of North Carolina · Feb 6, 2024
Nonetheless, a party claiming the protection of statutory immunity must satisfy “all of the requirements” of the statute granting the claimed immunity in order to establish a substantial right entitling him to an immediate … The protections against civil liability afforded the health care providers who qualify for the immunity under these statutes are, however, not unlimited. N.C. Gen.
Cited 0 timesPublishedMurray v. Univ. of N.C. at Chapel Hill
246 N.C. App. 86 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Mar 1, 2016
Defense counsel clearly argues that plaintiff’s complaint fails to state a claim by “neither alleg[ing] a waiver of immunity nor demonstrat[ing] the basis for such a waiver.” … The record clearly shows defendant raised sovereign immunity at the hearing under Rule 12(b)(6). This issue is properly before this Court.
Cited 7 timesPublishedKai-Ling Fu v. Unc Chapel Hill
188 N.C. App. 610 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Feb 5, 2008
Boudreau testified that the Army Medical Institute Special Immunizations Program clinic received a risk assessment from Dr. … Fu did not present any objective evidence that the immune response she experienced was related to her 9 March 2004 booster shot, as Dr.
Cited 0 timesPublished34 N.C. App. 416 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Nov 16, 1977
When the activity of a governmental entity is clearly governmental in nature, and not proprietary, the rule of sovereign immunity will protect the government from suit. As stated in Moffitt v. … However, this judge-made doctrine is firmly established in our law today, and by legislation has been recognized by the General Assembly as the public policy of the State. See Galligan v.
Cited 6 timesPublishedEEE-ZZZ Lay Drain Co. v. North Carolina Department of Human Resources
108 N.C. App. 24 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Nov 3, 1992
However, recent case law clearly establishes that if immunity is raised as a basis in the motion for summary adjudication, a substantial right is affected and the denial is immediately appealable. Herndon v. … Again, this position does not appear to be established by law, nor does it require an oath of office. His duties appear to us to be more ministerial than discretionary in nature.
Overruled on other grounds by Meyer v. Walls, 347 N.C. 97 (1997)Cited 25 timesPublishedKawai America Corp. v. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
152 N.C. App. 163 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Aug 6, 2002
The Act also establishes that the forum for such suits is the Industrial Commission, rather than the State courts. See id. … Our courts have clearly held that any modification or waiver of the doctrine of sovereign immunity must come from the General Assembly. See Blackwelder v.
Cited 32 timesPublished204 N.C. App. 300 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Jun 1, 2010
The Commission’s unchallenged findings of fact establish that the parties clearly intended for Officer Taylor to work the N.C. State football game pursuant to the Agreement. … Substantial Compliance The Commission’s unchallenged and binding findings of fact establish that the parties clearly intended for Officer Taylor to work as a mounted patrol officer with powers of arrest at N.C.
Cited 1 timesPublished246 N.C. App. 426 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Apr 5, 2016
Law enforcement operations are clearly governmental activities for which a municipality is generally immune. … The unambiguous language in Gaston County’s liability insurance policy clearly preserves the defense of governmental immunity.
Cited 26 timesPublished136 N.C. App. 444 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Feb 1, 2000
While officials are not immune for acts outside the scope of their legislative duties, Scott, 716 F.2d at 1423, and arguably may claim only qualified immunity for “executive” acts (such as enforcement of zoning laws), id. … On the other hand, the action is legislative if the facts involve ‘generalizations concerning a policy or state of affairs’ and the ‘establishment of a general policy’ affecting the larger population”).
Cited 13 timesPublishedWarren v. NEW HANOVER CTY. BD. OF EDUC.
104 N.C. App. 522 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Nov 19, 1991
To establish a cause of action for wrongful discharge or demotion in violation of the employee's First Amendment rights, the employee must show first "that the speech complained of qualified as protected speech or activity … Additionally, we find it unnecessary to address defendants' arguments regarding qualified immunity.
Cited 1 timesPublished190 N.C. App. 803 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · Jun 3, 2008
Plaintiff alleged that she has located a person who is reasonably expected to qualify as an expert witness who will testify that Mr. Bishop was alive when defendant May ran over him. … Stat. § 1A-1, Rule 12(c), “on the grounds of collateral estoppel, sovereign immunity, public official immunity, and other forms of governmental immunity.”
Cited 8 timesPublished265 N.C. App. 216 · Court of Appeals of North Carolina · May 7, 2019
Courts applying this framework have recently held that a defendant seeking to establish public official immunity must demonstrate that all three of the Isenhour factors are present. Leonard v. Bell, ___ N.C. … Exercise of a Portion of the Sovereign Power While the contours of what the sovereign power includes are not clearly defined by our case law, it is evident that a defendant claiming themself a public official for
Cited 18 timesPublished
Ask Donna