Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
5,308 results
1.88s
Ray v. Department of Social Services
156 Mich. App. 55 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Nov 4, 1986
Whether the trial court’s findings of fact were clearly erroneous. i Do the facts in this case fall within the general rule of governmental immunity or does the building exception provision, MCL 691.1406; MSA 3.996(106), … Underhill to testify as her testimony clearly proved prior notice by her and through her to her superiors of the dangerous and unsafe conditions.
Cited 5 timesPublished163 Mich. App. 25 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Sep 10, 1987
1985), lv den 424 Mich 878 (1986), this Court held that, where a defendant had not been subpoenaed, never refused to testify, and never invoked his privilege against self-incrimination, he was not entitled to transactional immunity … It was not necessary that the actual preparer of the business records be present to lay the foundation for the admission of the documents as the testimony of other "qualified” witnesses was sufficient.
Cited 13 timesPublishedEstate of Ezekiel D Goodwin v. Northwest Michigan Fair Association
325 Mich. App. 129 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 3, 2018
Although the imposition of a brightline rule may seem arbitrary in some cases,19 the age of seven is the long-established “dividing line” in Michigan. … “[R]elevance must be specifically established” before evidence of a violation may be used as evidence of negligence. Id. See also Zalut, 186 Mich App at 235.
Cited 43 timesPublishedSocomet, Inc. v. City of Detroit Socomet, Inc.
33 Mich. App. 626 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 20, 1971
Therefore, it was claimed exempt or immune under Article I, § 10, cl 2, of the Constitution of the United States. … Maryland, supra, it has become well-established that imports lose their constitutional immunity when the importer (1) sells them or (2) ‘breaks up the packages’ or (3) puts them to the use for which they were imported.
Cited 6 timesPublished228 Mich. App. 125 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 17, 1998
Plaintiff has presented evidence to establish that the traffic signals at the intersection of Dixie Highway and Watkins Lake Road may not have been properly positioned or programmed to ameliorate the hazard of an oncoming … Clearly, then, the mdot actually exercised control over the area in question and must be perceived to have jurisdiction over this spot pursuant to the conception of jurisdiction as used in the statute.
Cited 7 timesPublishedAdams v. Department of Transportation
251 Mich. App. 801 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 2, 2002
Recently, our Supreme Court acknowledged that when determining whether a decision should not have retroactive application, the threshold question is “whether the decision clearly established a new principle of law.” … Under these circumstances, we cannot say that the Nawrocki decision “clearly established a new principle of law.” Pohutski, supra at 696 (emphasis supplied).
Cited 1 timesPublished18 Mich. App. 109 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 10, 1970
Garavaglia (1952), 333 Mich 317 , which clearly recognizes three categories of nuisance, the last one based on negligence. At p 331 the Court quoted from Beckwith v. … The rule is contra by the established weight of authority when there is a ‘classic’ or ‘standard’ or ‘absolute’ nuisance involved. See 73 ALR2d 1381.
Cited 25 timesPublished181 Mich. App. 298 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Nov 21, 1989
Clearly, Walls’ determination of the seriousness of Robnett’s condition and his decision to call ems were discretionary functions. … The language used in. subsection (1) clearly provides that the amended MCL 691.1407; MSA 3.996(107) does not apply to causes of action arising prior to July 1, 1986.
Cited 3 timesPublished241 Mich. App. 143 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 26, 2000
The motion should be granted only when the claim is so clearly unenforceable as a matter of law that no factual development could possibly justify a right of recovery. … As noted supra, n 12, we do not suggest that the statute grants absolute immunity in every case.
Cited 5 timesPublished171 Mich. App. 153 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 1, 1988
immunity results in the suppression of testimony favorable to the defendant or where the immunity is necessary to obtain exculpatory testimony. 12 In the within case, the failure to grant immunity to Pomerico did not foreclose … This man, the file indicates, that when his father was contacted initially when he came in, his father said that he has a short temper and clearly he has demonstrated that.
Cited 35 timesPublished122 Mich. App. 482 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 19, 1983
Paragraph 1 merely establishes the reliability of the affiant. … be insufficient to establish the informant’s credibility.
Cited 16 timesPublishedMelissa Mays v. Governor Rick Snyder
323 Mich. App. 1 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 25, 2018
In this case, unlike in Rusha , application of the harsh-and-unreasonable-consequences exception is clearly supported. … The state and its officials also enjoy broad immunity from liability under state law.
Cited 81 timesPublishedJohnson-McIntosh v. City of Detroit
266 Mich. App. 318 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 26, 2005
Clearly, whether the Court's decision in Evens would "shift liability" for signage to municipalities was germane to the Court's holding regarding immunity of the state and county road commissions and displayed the "application … devices are not part of "the improved portion of the highway designed for vehicular travel" as delineated in MCL 691.1402(1). [3] MCR 7.215(J)(1) states that [a] panel of the Court of Appeals must follow the rule of law established
Cited 11 timesPublished73 Mich. App. 378 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 17, 1977
Clearly statements made by a mayor during the exercise of his express power to veto are an essential *389 function of his office. … It is the occasion or circumstance, as well as the office, that calls forth the immunity, not the individual as such.
Cited 20 timesPublishedJaqua v. Canadian National Railroad
274 Mich. App. 540 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 21, 2007
Although the Court did not explain what will qualify as a “compromis[e] [of] a claimed liability” it did say that parties may settle “[w]here controversies exist as to whether there is liability, and if so for how much.” … The court also discussed the Sixth Circuit’s opinion in Babbitt and observed that it “appears to establish a broad, legal rule prohibiting the use of general releases in cases such as this.” Id.
Cited 16 timesPublishedNational Bank v. Department of Social Services
240 Mich. App. 348 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 22, 2000
For purposes of the previous sentence, the term “grantor” means the individual referred to in paragraph (2). (2) For purposes of this subsection, a “medicaid qualifying trust” is a trust, or similar legal device, established … trust is irrevocable or is established for purposes other than to enable a grantor to qualify for medical assistance under this title; or (B) whether or not the discretion described in paragraph (2) is actually exercised
Cited 6 timesPublished97 Mich. App. 797 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 3, 1980
Drescher was granted on the basis of governmental immunity. … Those actions, therefore, are covered by the protective cloak of governmental immunity. Plaintiff failed to plead facts in avoidance of immunity.
Cited 20 timesPublished124 Mich. App. 291 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Mar 21, 1983
The governmental immunity statute, however, applies only to government agencies. A public employee’s immunity, if any, must rest on a different ground. … The history clearly indicates he was violence prone. A disorganized person has no control over their behavior or emotions.
Reversed on other grounds by Canon v. Thumudo, 430 Mich. 326 (1988)Cited 59 timesPublishedRohrabaugh v. Huron-Clinton Metropolitan Authority Corp.
75 Mich. App. 677 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 17, 1977
Plaintiff, in fact, however, indicated in a deposition that this was the first time she patronized this facility, and that normally her skating was done at a private profit-oriented establishment. *683 A review of Michigan … Such operations are incapable of existing absent the park and the operation of such services are clearly inseparable from the operation of the park.
Cited 10 timesPublishedCapital Region Airport Authority v. DeWitt Charter Township
236 Mich. App. 576 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 22, 1999
.; MSA 28.2271, et seq., the Legislature intended to grant the Department of Corrections immunity from local zoning ordinances when establishing state penal institutions. … Clearly, this goal would be thwarted if the agency’s aeronautical activities were subject to local land-use ordinances.
Cited 10 timesPublished
Ask Donna