Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
5,308 results
0.89s
253 Mich. App. 555 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 23, 2003
The Legislature’s use of the definite article “the” clearly evinces an intent to focus on one cause. … and the . . . governmental *567 immunity act to mean.
Cited 21 timesPublishedPeisner v. Detroit Free Press, Inc.
82 Mich. App. 153 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Mar 21, 1978
The first expression of the qualified privilege doctrine appears in Bacon v Michigan Central R Co, 66 Mich 166, 170 ; 33 NW 181 (1887): "Qualified privilege exists in a much larger number of cases. … -it the other extreme are those occasions wherein the social interest involved in publication is so great as . to immunize even deliberately malicious attacks upon one’s character.
Reversed on other grounds by Peisner v. Detroit Free Press, Inc., 421 Mich. 125 (1985)Cited 40 timesPublishedWilliams v. Primary School District 3
3 Mich. App. 468 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 14, 1966
It clearly distinguishes sovereign immunity, which may be claimed only by the State government: i.e., the State and its agencies. … Further, the Myers Case, supra, establishes the rule that subdivisions of governmental and municipal corporations are not shielded from tort liability by any governmental immunity.
Cited 17 timesPublishedAuto-Owners Insurance v. Biddis
107 Mich. App. 173 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 16, 1981
Finally, the Court noted that a third incentive resulted from the fact that an uninsured motorist who was also established to be a tortfeasor with regard to an accident does not enjoy the same degree of immunity under § 3135 … While an uninsured motorist remains liable to injured parties if fault is established, § 3177 imposes a more limited liability without regard to fault. Section 3177 clearly makes no mention of fault.
Cited 4 timesPublished160 Mich. App. 461 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 1, 1987
immunity in this instance. … The facts pled in the third-party complaint clearly state a claim for negligence.
Cited 4 timesPublishedEst of Henry Henderson v. Bd of Hosp Managers for City of Flint
Michigan Court of Appeals · Aug 22, 2024
The alleged acts, omissions, and injuries were wholly unrelated to the pandemic, so deeming defendant immune would contravene the Legislature’s clearly-communicated intent to limit this immunization to services stemming from … Therefore, there was immunity in Warren but there is no immunity here. III.
Cited 0 timesPublished163 Mich. App. 614 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 25, 1987
If governmental immunity is at issue, as in the instant case, the plaintiff must plead facts in avoidance of the bar of immunity. … In order to establish nuisance in fact, it is necessary to show that the defendant is responsible for a "dangerous, offensive, or hazardous” condition.
Cited 4 timesPublishedTim Edward Brugger II v. Midland County Bd of Road Commissioners
324 Mich. App. 307 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 15, 2018
established a new principle of law. … establish a new principle of law in 2016; the only new principles of law were established by Rowland in 2007, and Streng simply resolved the ensuing conflict between two statutes—MCL 224.21 and the GTLA notice provision—in
Cited 5 timesPublished87 Mich. App. 361 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Dec 5, 1978
, 79 Mich App 239, 246 ; 261 NW2d 273 (1977), an opinion released subsequent to oral argument in the instant case: " * * * [W]e would have little hesitation in finding that the training of police officers, including the establishment … However, the statute clearly required *371 that the injury result from the operation of the vehicle. In the instant case the injury resulted from the discharge of a firearm.
Cited 14 timesPublished265 Mich. App. 673 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 26, 2005
GOVERNMENTAL TORT LIABILITY ACT Defendant argues that it is immune from any liability because no exception applies to the immunity granted *691 to it under the GTLA. … This argument is misplaced inasmuch as plaintiffs brought suit against defendant under the CRA, not under an exception to governmental immunity. Governmental immunity is not a defense to a claim brought under the CRA.
Cited 78 timesPublished90 Mich. App. 408 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 23, 1979
The defendant clearly had no owner’s or lessee’s interest and thus no control of the premises. … GCR 1963, 116.4 requires the affidavits be made on personal knowledge and set forth with particularity such facts as would be admissible as evidence to establish or deny the grounds set forth.
Cited 6 timesPublished231 Mich. App. 341 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Nov 18, 1998
This Court found that the negligence alleged in the plaintiffs complaint was “clearly based on parental maintenance of a home environment, in that defendants allowed the home to be occupied by an ‘unleashed and roaming’ dog … To establish a prima facie case of negligence, a plaintiff must introduce evidence sufficient to establish that (1) the defendant owed a duty to the plaintiff, (2) the defendant breached that duty, (3) the defendant’s breach
Cited 16 timesPublished158 Mich. App. 18 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 18, 1987
malice to overcome the qualified privilege. … "Generally speaking, absolute privilege is confined to cases in which the public service or the administration of justice requires complete immunity from being called to account for language used.
Cited 5 timesPublished294 Mich. App. 419 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 20, 2011
Those cases have concluded that acts such as commenting on an official governmental matter and making personnel or employment decisions clearly fall within the scope of the executive authority of the highest executive officials … Indeed, the essential duties of the police chief as set forth in the job description for the police chief of the village of Port Sanilac are administrative in nature and are clearly distinct from the nature of the duties
Cited 4 timesPublished183 Mich. App. 1 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Apr 2, 1990
However, these two cases are clearly distinguishable from Gallegos in that they involve the overruling of established common-law doctrines rather than the constitutional declaration with respect to the validity of a statute … Therefore, the parties on remand are free to relitigate any question of whether plaintiffs qualify for benefits under § 115, as it now stands in the aftermath of East-way. 8 *17 II.
Cited 3 timesPublishedBrown v. Northville Regional Psychiatric Hospital
153 Mich. App. 300 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Apr 11, 1986
The motion is tested by the pleadings alone and may not be granted unless a claim is so clearly unenforceable as a matter of law that no factual development can possibly justify a right to recover. … Also, if a clearly established rule or standard exists requiring that the discharge of a patient in the circumstances of the decedent Brown be accompanied by medication and if through oversight, inattention or other negligence
Cited 11 timesPublishedEndykiewicz v. State Highway Commission
102 Mich. App. 662 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 6, 1981
While common law governmental immunity has since been abolished, Pittman v City of Taylor, 398 Mich 41 ; 247 NW2d 512 (1976), the general rule of governmental immunity remains established by statute. … In Pagano , it was argued that the statute waived immunity for damages "suffered by him” but did not waive immunity for third party claimants when the injured person died.
Cited 4 timesPublishedHannay v. Department of Transportation
299 Mich. App. 261 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 17, 2013
However, the GTLA provides that governmental agencies are “immune from tort liability” when “engaged in the exercise or discharge of a governmental function” unless a specific exception to governmental immunity is applicable … Thus, the general purpose of the act was to abolish tort liability for governmental entities, even if a plaintiff is able to establish the elements of a tort claim.
Cited 5 timesPublished138 Mich. App. 121 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 10, 1984
Even though plaintiffs rights were violated, the court denied plaintiffs claim for damages: "As prison officials, the defendants are entitled to qualified immunity on the damage claim. … However, 'the immunity defense would be unavailing * * * if the constitutional right allegedly infringed by them was clearly established at the time of their challenged conduct, if they knew or should have known of that right
Vacated by Rushing v. Wayne County, 436 Mich. 247 (1990)Cited 13 timesPublished149 Mich. App. 249 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 18, 1986
If the defendant thought that this allegation in the complaint was insufficient to establish an exception to governmental immunity, the issue should have been raised prior to trial in a motion for summary disposition. … The record clearly reveals that when the plaintiff entered into areas that the trial court felt were inappropriate, plaintiff was prevented from making further inquiry.
Cited 14 timesPublished
Ask Donna