Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
5,308 results
0.78s
Harris v. University of Michigan Board of Regents
219 Mich. App. 679 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 24, 1997
Thus, in Hutchins , the federal court clearly considered MSU’s operation of its intercollegiate women’s basketball program to be a governmental, not a proprietary, function. … Plaintiff was unable to establish that profit was the university’s primary motive in operating its athletic program or that intercollegiate athletics was not normally supported by taxes.
Cited 15 timesPublishedWillett v. Waterford Charter Township
271 Mich. App. 38 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 25, 2006
cannot establish the essential element of a ‘defect’ and thus Defendant is entitled to governmental immunity. … Plaintiff, relying on MCL 691.1417(2), specifically argues that defendant is not immune because the required elements to avoid immunity have been established, i.e., that the sewage backup was an event under the statutory
Cited 77 timesPublishedGenesee County Road Commission v. State Highway Commission
86 Mich. App. 294 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 3, 1978
The Court of Claims was established by the Legislature under the authority of Const 1963, art 9, § 22 and art 6, § 26. … Thus, since the maintenance of roadways is clearly a governmental function, Thomas v Dep’t of State Highway, 398 Mich 1, 11 ; 247 NW2d 530 (1976), plaintiffs’ right to bring this action is dependent upon the applicability
Cited 11 timesPublished129 Mich. App. 419 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 10, 1983
The state libel laws enjoy no “talismanic immunity” from consti *425 tutional limitations. 6 Freedom of expression upon public questions is secured by the First Amendment. … Last, the Supreme Court said that actual malice necessary to defeat the conditional qualified privilege, which, of course, existed here, can be established by inference and, if there are genuine issues of material fact, the
Cited 34 timesPublished252 Mich. App. 239 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Sep 26, 2002
Testimony presented at trial established that the rusty light pole, erected in 1970 and last inspected in 1979, was placed eighteen inches from the highway’s curb, which was in accordance with industry standards, and was … Consistent with this basic principle, “[n]o action may be maintained under the highway exception unless it is clearly within the scope and meaning of [MCL 691.1402(1)].” Weakley, supra at 326 .
Cited 13 timesPublishedKeagan Farris v. John H McKaig III
324 Mich. App. 349 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 17, 2018
Based on the duties of an LGAL, it is clearly a guardian; after an LGAL is appointed in child protective proceedings, it has the statutory authority and duty to care for the child by advocating for the child’s best interests … Despite the fact that MCL 712A.13a differentiates between a GAL and an LGAL, MCL 712A.13a(1) begins with the qualifier, “As used in this section and sections 2, 6b, 13b, 17c, 17d, 18f, 19, 19a, 19b, and 19c of this chapter
Cited 29 timesPublished182 Mich. App. 177 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 31, 1989
Clearly, defendant’s employees were not in "actual physical control” of the ambulance when the accident occurred. Rather, codefendant David Boretti was operating the vehicle. … However, plaintiffs have not, in answer to the motion for summary disposition, brought forth specific facts or evidence to establish the existence of a material factual dispute, as required.
Cited 4 timesPublished274 Mich. App. 672 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 10, 2007
Thus, while a defect in the sidewalk itself would be required to avoid governmental immunity if this were a natural accumulation case, Haliw does not establish that rule for this case involving unnatural accumulation. 5 * … Clearly, the gravamen of plaintiffs’ complaint against the city in these cases is the unnatural accumulation of snow and ice that prevented Buckner and Wright from using the sidewalk.
Cited 1 timesPublishedMosqueda v. MacOmb County Youth Home
132 Mich. App. 462 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Mar 5, 1984
The panel concluded: "Since Westlake establishes the validity of a claim for deliberate indifference, this Court concludes that the district court’s dismissal of this complaint as frivolous was clearly erroneous. … The claims were therefore not clearly unenforceable and plaintiff was entitled to offer further factual development of her claims.
Cited 15 timesPublishedStringwell v. Ann Arbor Public School District
262 Mich. App. 709 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 6, 2004
Our Supreme Court has explained the well-established rules of statutory construction: The foremost rule, and our primary task in construing a statute, is to discern and give effect to the intent of the Legislature. … If the language of the statute is unambiguous, the Legislature must have in *712 tended the meaning clearly expressed, and the statute must be enforced as written.
Cited 14 timesPublished148 Mich. App. 524 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 3, 1986
He established and incorporated Ankersen Resources Systems, Inc. … Clearly, however, the Supreme Court in Disappearing Lakes did not overrule its prior decisions on the issue and this Court remains bound by these earlier decisions.
Cited 48 timesPublishedReardon v. Department of Mental Health
157 Mich. App. 505 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 2, 1987
Thus, plaintiff had established an exception to governmental immunity. … That finding was not clearly erroneous. MCR 2.613(C).
Cited 4 timesPublished316 Mich. App. 671 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Aug 16, 2016
In particular, defendant argues that the affidavit failed to mention that he was a qualifying patient under the MMMA as well as a caregiver. … Accordingly, the trial court did not err in refusing to suppress the evidence merely because the affidavit did not establish that defendant was not entitled to the immunity defense under § 4 of the MMMA.9 8 People
Cited 21 timesPublished115 Mich. App. 286 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Mar 23, 1982
and consequent liability rather than to immunity. … Section 1287(1) of the School Code of 1976, MCL 380.1287(1); MSA 15.41287(1), authorizes school boards to establish vocational education programs: "The board of a school district other than a primary school district may establish
Cited 9 timesPublishedPeople of Michigan v. Callen Trent Latz
Michigan Court of Appeals · Dec 20, 2016
In reverse order, if such an irreconcilable conflict exists, the MMMA clearly and unambiguously does preclude defendant’s conviction. … If persons comply with the MMMA, it grants “broad” “immunity” from prosecution. MCL 333.26424(a); Braska, 307 Mich App at 357-358.
Cited 0 timesPublishedMichael J Bedford v. Derek S Witte
Michigan Court of Appeals · Nov 22, 2016
Moreover, this Court reviews de novo, as a question of law, whether there exists a privilege that immunizes a defendant from liability for defamation. … The Court specifically stated, “The immunity is a qualified one, but defendant has met the qualifications that the report must be fair and true.” Id.
Cited 0 timesPublished291 Mich. App. 125 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Dec 14, 2010
The delineated items in § 8 were clearly not intended to be an all-encompassing expression of the elements of an investigation that are considered confidential. … Because the privilege is qualified rather than absolute, it can be overcome by a sufficient showing of need. Ostoin, 189 Mich App at 338 .
Cited 33 timesPublishedMalcolm v. City of East Detroit
180 Mich. App. 633 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 17, 1989
Since no contrary definition or intent is clearly manifested in §20737, "[a]ll persons” must, by express statutory definition and construction, include governmental units. … The city also argues that, even should the ems statute provide an exception to governmental immunity, the evidence was insufficient to establish wilful or wanton misconduct on the part of the city or that its conduct was
Reversed by Malcolm v. City of East Detroit, 437 Mich. 132 (1991)Cited 7 timesPublished159 Mich. App. 620 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Apr 22, 1987
A governmental agency does not have immunity from actions arising out of contracts to which it is a party: In Ross , the Supreme Court held that "[i]f a plaintiff successfully pleads and establishes a non-tort cause of action … , [MCL 691.1507; MSA 3.996(107)] will not bar recovery simply because the underlying facts could have also established a *628 tort cause of action.”
Criticized by Kerbersky v. Northern Michigan University, 458 Mich. 525 (1998)Cited 9 timesPublished253 Mich. App. 555 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 23, 2003
The Legislature’s use of the definite article “the” clearly evinces an intent to focus on one cause. … and the . . . governmental *567 immunity act to mean.
Cited 21 timesPublished
Ask Donna