Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
5,308 results
0.33s
Hendricks v. Southfield Public Schools
178 Mich. App. 672 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Mar 22, 1989
The court must accept as true all wellpled factual allegations plus any conclusions to be reasonably drawn therefrom and may grant the motion only when the claim is so clearly unenforceable as a matter of law that no factual … To establish a claim of intentional nuisance against a governmental agency, a plaintiff must show that there is a condition which is a nuisance and that the agency intended to create that condition.
Cited 1 timesPublishedPaul v. Wayne County Department of Public Service
271 Mich. App. 617 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 12, 2006
Clearly, the holding in Grimes , if applied to this case, requires summary disposition in favor of defendant. … The threshold question in determining the application of a new decision is whether the decision in fact clearly established a new principle of law.
Cited 11 timesPublished260 Mich. App. 684 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 24, 2004
Defendant moved for summary disposition, relying on the doctrine of governmental immunity. … In response to the dissent, we note that it is interesting that the dissent cites MCR 7.215(J)(1), as this is the same rule that requires us to follow the precedent established by Carr, supra.
Cited 6 timesPublished187 Mich. App. 475 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Feb 19, 1991
Specifically, under the historical analysis method, the only judicially created exceptions to immunity which are recognized are those established in the case law prior to the enactment of the governmental tort liability act … her *490 allegations, then she can establish a claim under public nuisance.
Reversed on other grounds by Li v. Feldt, 439 Mich. 457 (1992)Cited 8 timesPublishedGordin v. William Beaumont Hospital
180 Mich. App. 488 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jul 21, 1989
It was also held that the statute "only seeks to delineate the partial immunity afforded in terms to indicate that *493 immunity does not exist for persons whose actual function is to respond to emergency situations.” … Howard was required to allege facts in his summary disposition motion establishing the absence of gross negligence and wilful and wanton misconduct in order to qualify for immunity under the Good Samaritan statute.
Cited 4 timesPublishedDrewes v. Grand Valley State Colleges
106 Mich. App. 776 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 3, 1981
667 ; 232 NW2d 636 (1975). 9 In the instant case plaintiff asserts that the act unreasonably discriminates between employees of insured contractors, who may still maintain a cause of action against a third party who would qualify … This is clearly a legitimate state interest, and it is well served by holding the principal liable for workers’ compensation payments where the contractor is uninsured.
Cited 6 timesPublishedProgress Michigan v. Attorney General
Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 19, 2018
] -4- It is a clearly established principle that “when the Legislature specifically qualifies the ability to bring a claim against the state or its subdivisions … Even “ ‘post-Court of Claims Act’ legislation waiving suit immunity . . . is limited by the terms and conditions of jurisdiction established in the Court of Claims Act.”
Cited 0 timesPublished116 Mich. App. 745 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 8, 1982
Clearly this was a proprietary function. … To summarize the preceding, we conclude that the following findings by the trial court were not clearly erroneous: (1) the defendants were not entitled to the defense of governmental immunity; (2) the defendants were in complete
Cited 12 timesPublished47 Mich. App. 326 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 23, 1973
"The Michigan Court of Claims is a court of limited jurisdiction and the State of Michigan having clearly retained its defense of sovereign immunity in this particular action asserted against it by the plaintiff this Court … The issue there was whether the Legislature clearly understood the impact of the distinction between "torts” and "negligence”.
Cited 11 timesPublishedEst of Dale Wehner v. Tri-Hospital Emergency Medical Services Corp
Michigan Court of Appeals · Oct 23, 2025
The trial court granted summary disposition to defendants after concluding that the immunity provisions of the emergency medical services act (EMSA), MCL 333.20901 et seq., applied and that plaintiff failed to establish that … Ultimately, the inquiry is quite simple: “to qualify for immunity, a defendant must show, among other things, that the act or omission occurred ‘in the treatment of a patient.’ ” Bartalsky, 337 Mich App at 392.
Cited 0 timesPublishedPalomba v. City of East Detroit
112 Mich. App. 209 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jan 5, 1982
The standard is whether the claims are so clearly unenforceable as a matter of law that no factual development can possibly justify a right to recovery. … In order to establish an implied contract to indemnify, there must be a special relationship between the parties or a course of conduct whereby one party undertakes to perform a certain service and impliedly assures indemnification
Cited 20 timesPublishedKewadin Casinos Gaming v. Patterson Earnhart Real Bird & Wilson
Michigan Court of Appeals · Mar 23, 2026
If the real party in interest is indeed the Tribe, then tribal sovereign immunity applies. Id. at 163. But that is clearly not the case. … Significantly, Indian tribes have long been “recognized . . . as distinct, independent political communities qualified to exercise many of the powers and prerogatives of self- government,” Plains Commerce Bank v Long Family
Cited 0 timesPublishedMichigan Court of Appeals · Mar 11, 2025
The established “statutory exceptions to the governmental immunity provided to the state and its agencies are the highway exception, MCL 691.1402; the motor-vehicle exception, MCL 691.1405; the public-building exception, … In other words, a governmental agency continues to enjoy immunity from tort liability unless MCL 460.732 provides otherwise or one of the established exceptions to governmental immunity applies.
Cited 0 timesPublishedApostolos Paul Margaris v. Genesee County
324 Mich. App. 111 · Michigan Court of Appeals · May 3, 2018
High level executive officials “may qualify for absolute immunity because they have broad-based jurisdiction or extensive authority similar to that of a judge or legislator.” … But the actual value of the meat that had been stolen from Popoff and which plaintiff purchased was not definitively established.
Cited 20 timesPublishedWayne-Oakland Bank v. Adam's Rib
48 Mich. App. 144 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Jun 27, 1973
We have already concluded the personal immunity of a parent, if established, is not a shield for the partnership entity. … Thus, the instruction claimed as error related to evidence properly admitted and was not clearly erroneous.
Cited 7 timesPublishedPeople of Michigan v. Michael Dean Dupre
Michigan Court of Appeals · Dec 17, 2020
This section grants qualifying patients broad immunity from prosecution. Kolanek, 491 Mich at 394-396. Section 7 of the MMMA on the other hand, prohibits specific acts that negate immunity. … Therefore, we discern no intent within the MMMA to immunize the visibly impaired driver from prosecution.
Cited 0 timesPublished314 Mich. App. 615 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Mar 22, 2016
While dispositional orders must be “ ‘appropriate for the welfare of the juvenile and society in view of the facts proven and ascertained,’ ” they will not be set aside unless clearly erroneous. … As empowered by the Legislature, the DHHS 5 has the authority to establish procedures for *628 the control of diseases and infections, including the ability to establish vaccination requirements. MCL 333.5111(2)(c).
Cited 18 timesPublishedStege v. Department of Treasury
252 Mich. App. 183 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Sep 24, 2002
Exemptions are never presumed, the burden is on a claimant to establish clearly his right to exemption[.] ... In other words, . . . taxation is the rule, and exemption the exception .... … Id. 2 To the *193 contrary, the stipulated facts here establish quite clearly that, notwithstanding the nonresident designation on the jointly filed income tax filing, Cherrie’s Suttons Bay home is her “principal residence
Cited 20 timesPublishedMichigan Court of Appeals · Mar 22, 2016
Because the trial court has the authority to make medical decisions for children under its jurisdiction over respondent’s objections to immunization and the court did not clearly err by determining that vaccination was appropriate … As empowered by the Legislature, the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services5 (DHHS) has the authority to establish procedures for the control of diseases and infections, including the ability to establish immunization
Cited 0 timesPublishedJohnson v. Detroit Metropolitan Airport
133 Mich. App. 603 · Michigan Court of Appeals · Apr 3, 1984
That panel of this Court believed that the question was controlled by the following statutory section: "The acquisition of any lands for the purpose of establishing airports, landing fields or other aeronautical facilities … Clearly, this statute was designed by the Legislature to give the defendant the power of eminent domain, such as railroads, gas companies, and public utilities enjoy.
Cited 3 timesPublished
Ask Donna