Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
4,869 results
0.28s
Western Lithograph Co. v. State Board of Equalization
11 Cal. 2d 156 · California Supreme Court · Apr 19, 1938
The principle of immunity thus has inherent limitations. ’ ’ It was also said in Metcalf & Eddy v. … Clearly the imposition of a privilege tax on the retailer of commodities does not interfere with the power of the government to borrow money; nor does it affect in any substantial manner the efficiency of its agency in the
Cited 69 timesPublished8 Cal. 4th 587 · California Supreme Court · Oct 27, 1994
To hold that a scientific technique could become immune from Kelly scrutiny merely by reason of long-standing and persistent use by law enforcement outside the laboratory or the courtroom, seems unjustified. c. … The foregoing decisions, however, do not explain how police officers are competent to establish general acceptance of HGN testing in the scientific community, or how they are qualified to relate the scientific bases underlying
Cited 175 timesPublishedPayne v. City of San Francisco
3 Cal. 122 · California Supreme Court · Apr 15, 1853
It differs essentially from those provisions of law which are construed by the courts as being merely directory; and it does not come within the rule established by this court in the case of The People, ex relatione Harris … Not only did the plaintiff fail to qualify in time, but it does not appear that he ever qualified before a proper officer.
Cited 7 timesPublished10 Cal. 2d 409 · California Supreme Court · Dec 22, 1937
such proviso; with the result that the principal part of the statute or ordinance thus modified remains intact excepting as it may be thus qualified. … In short, a proviso carves special exceptions only out of the enacting clause; and those who set up any such exception, must establish it as being within the words as well as within the reason thereof. ’ (United States v.
Cited 15 timesPublished49 Cal. 2d 815 · California Supreme Court · Mar 21, 1958
Los Angeles County General Hospital, 123 Cal.App.2d 143, 144 [ 266 P.2d 221 ]), and, where, as here, the Legislature has clearly expressed its intention to maintain immunity, that intention is controlling. [5] Several cases … Once again this court is faced with the question of the scope of governmental immunity and again the majority has seen fit to broaden the scope when an analysis of applicable statutes shows such action to be clearly unwarranted
Cited 29 timesPublishedCalifornia Supreme Court · Aug 25, 2025
The voters could have amended section 1192.7(c) with language that makes gang-related felonies immune from subsequent changes. … Similarly, Anderson explained, “Clearly, the Legislature intended that the qualifying status of a conviction would be fixed upon the date of the prior conviction, so that no subsequent actions, including those listed in [
Cited 0 timesPublished55 Cal. 4th 683 · California Supreme Court · Oct 29, 2012
(c)(8)(B))3 and that the signed drawings qualified as source items under the “Association” category (id., subd. 3 “Tattoos and symbols. … Cabrera, by contrast, does argue that the CDCR‟s proffered interpretation is clearly unreasonable. He relies on In re Andrade (2006) 141 Cal.App.4th 807, but the case is clearly distinguishable.
Cited 26 timesPublished212 Cal. 587 · California Supreme Court · May 1, 1931
in each ease was not inserted by the signer of the petition, but by its sponsors, the work being rendered especially difficult because, just prior to January 1, 1930, the election precinct lines within the city were re-established … is qualified.
Cited 59 timesPublishedNestle v. City of Santa Monica
6 Cal. 3d 920 · California Supreme Court · Apr 28, 1972
I dissent, however, from the reversal of the judgment dismissing the nuisance count for in my view the California Tort Claims Act quite clearly immunizes governmental agencies from, liability for nuisance, except insofar … The commission’s comment regarding proposed section 830 conclusively establishes its intent that a government entity would be immune from liability for nuisance under Civil Code section 3479: “Under the previous law, public
Cited 346 timesPublished32 Cal. 3d 504 · California Supreme Court · Sep 30, 1982
This series of events establishes that during the critical reexamination of appellant, Dr. … The blanket immunity of Tarantino avoids such an anomaly in this state.
Cited 78 timesPublished70 Cal. 544 · California Supreme Court · Aug 31, 1886
Notwithstanding the judgment, the plaintiff insists that the land ought to have been awarded to him, because, as it is alleged, he established his right to purchase it under the laws of the United States by satisfactory proof … Was the plaintiff a qualified pre-emptor ? —and that those issues were found against the plaintiff and in favor of Brown.
Cited 11 timesPublished15 Cal. 3d 791 · California Supreme Court · Dec 24, 1975
It is clearly established that “. . . there is but one cause of action for one personal injury [which is incurred] by reason of one wrongful act.” (Busick, supra, at p. 975 ; see Panos, supra, at p. 638 ; 3 Witkin, Cal. … Corning Hospital Dist. (1961) 55 Cal.2d 211 [ 11 Cal.Rptr. 89 , 359 P.2d 457 ], we held that governmental entities were no longer immune from liability for the torts of their agents.
Questioned by Consumer Advocacy Group, Inc. v. ExxonMobil Corp., 168 Cal. App. 4th 675 (2008)Cited 231 timesPublishedSivertsen v. City of Menlo Park
17 Cal. 2d 197 · California Supreme Court · Jan 31, 1941
The question, therefore, is whether such discrimination violates the equal protection clause of the federal Constitution and the privilege and immunities provision of the state Constitution. … The court concluded that such ordinance was valid, even though there clearly was classification. Therefore, it cannot be said that the court in its opinion established or approved of a rule of no discrimination.
Cited 10 timesPublished51 Cal. 4th 830 · California Supreme Court · May 19, 2011
) “ „ “ „The burden is on the party seeking severance to clearly establish that there is a substantial danger of prejudice requiring that the charges be separately tried.‟ [Citation.] [¶] „The determination of prejudice … Hunter did, as defendant observes, distinguish use immunity from transactional immunity in rejecting a requirement of a cautionary instruction. “Under federal law the prosecutor cannot grant transactional immunity.
Overruled on other grounds by People v. Hardy, 233 Cal. Rptr. 3d 378 (2018)Cited 321 timesPublished50 Cal. 3d 728 · California Supreme Court · May 3, 1990
In their first amended complaint, plaintiffs clearly distinguish between the liability of Ybarra, which is based on statements, and that of the medical personnel, which is based on a failure to act: “As a proximate result … We reached that conclusion because the Legislature, in enacting the immunity statute, intended to limit the immunity to cases involving misrepresentations of a financial or commercial character.
Cited 54 timesPublished44 Cal. 2d 359 · California Supreme Court · Apr 22, 1955
Such holding would do violence to the provisions of Penal Code, section 836, prescribing the conditions of a lawful arrest, and would be contrary to the settled rules established by the cases dealing with false arrest and … I am firmly of the opinion that these cases were erroneously decided as clearly pointed out in my dissenting opinions therein.
Cited 20 timesPublishedVolkswagen Pacific, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles
7 Cal. 3d 48 · California Supreme Court · May 10, 1972
Volkswagen of America and VW consult with respect to the establishment of retail dealerships in thé exclusive territory of VW. … Appellants, who claim the immunity from tax and thus bear the burden of establishing the conditions for its existence, have failed to prove that packaging of the automobiles was possible or practicable.
Cited 30 timesPublished82 Cal. Rptr. 2d 85 · California Supreme Court · Feb 8, 1999
Application of established law to undisputed facts must leave no room for doubt regarding the proper result. … The opinion describes the general nature of the recreational use immunity, concludes the record establishes that the immunity applies because Green’s purpose in riding his horse was for recreation, and rejects the argument
Cited 270 timesPublished51 Cal. 3d 202 · California Supreme Court · Jul 12, 1990
Clark, supra, 38 Cal.3d 355 , for the proposition that section 47(2) immunizes them from liability. … To the extent the complaint rests on Farnell's alleged communicative acts of "counseling" and "advising" his clients, the privilege is clearly operative. (See Silberg v. Anderson (1990) 50 Cal.3d 205 [ 266 Cal.
Cited 163 timesPublished35 Cal. 2d 577 · California Supreme Court · Jun 29, 1950
Comprehensive regulations are established for the registration or licensing of persons practicing civil engineering. (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 6700 et seq.) … refraining from adopting such requirement, it is pertinent that, although the licensing act refers to persons engaged in a public or private capacity, it was adopted prior to section 2006 of the Streets and Highways Code which clearly
Cited 3 timesPublished
Ask Donna