Case law
Opinions from 1658 to today.
4,869 results
1.17s
29 Cal. 480 · California Supreme Court · Jul 1, 1866
It is well settled that every Act deliberately passed by the Legislature must be regarded by the # Courts as valid unless it is clearly and manifestly repugnant to some provision of the Constitution. … time to time, by a two-thirds vote of all the members elected to both Houses, as the public good may require.” * * * * It is claimed on the part of the appellant that the number of the districts is permanently fixed and established
Cited 21 timesPublished216 Cal. Rptr. 3d 75 · California Supreme Court · Mar 20, 2017
But this construction, he concludes, is unconstitutional under well-established precedent. … On this narrower understanding of the required waiver, Penal Code section 1203.067, subdivision (b)(3) does no more than what the law clearly permits: It has long been established that ―a State may validly insist on answers
Cited 54 timesPublished29 Cal. 3d 1 · California Supreme Court · Feb 11, 1981
Moreover, the exemption of section 552.1 is clearly not intended solely to facilitate union-employee communication. … Whether the 1978 amendment to that subdivision codified existing law, as we stated in Sears, or created new law, it would clearly defeat the legislative purpose if union activities immunized from prosecution under that amendment
Cited 33 timesPublished34 Cal. 2d 632 · California Supreme Court · Jan 20, 1950
been granted no tax immunity." ( Alabama v. … In my opinion such holding is in direct violation of the established rule of reciprocal immunity against the taxation by either the state or federal government of property owned by the other. ( McCulloch v.
Cited 7 timesPublished29 Cal. 3d 531 · California Supreme Court · Jun 18, 1981
Rptr. 750 ], a plaintiff, otherwise qualified, was denied relief because plaintiff had failed to "specify a fund or appropriation from which a judgment may be paid. … The right to sue becomes worthless if, once liability of the state is legally established, there is no remedy. The execution exemption is as outmoded as the tort immunity abolished in Muskopf .
Cited 79 timesPublishedTorres v. Parkhouse Tire Service, Inc.
111 Cal. Rptr. 2d 564 · California Supreme Court · Aug 30, 2001
There are, however, statutory exceptions to coemployee immunity. … To that end, they argued that the exception requires only a “hostile intent,” which they did not clearly define, to commit a physical act of aggression. We are unpersuaded.
Cited 150 timesPublished5 Cal. 4th 1218 · California Supreme Court · Oct 14, 1993
Clearly such a result would be contrary to the Legislature’s intent in enacting section 1157.” 9 III. … Code, §§ 43.7 [conditional immunity for actions taken by members of medical staff committees engaged in quality assurance activities], 43.8 [absolute immunity for those who communicate certain information to medical staff
Disapproved on other grounds by Hassan v. Mercy American River Hospital, 3 Cal. Rptr. 3d 623 (2003)Cited 79 timesPublished15 Cal. 3d 508 · California Supreme Court · Nov 12, 1975
We have recently held that an analogous tort immunity for the denial of a building permit (Gov. … Code, § 818.4) constituted specific legislation qualifying the general rule that one may append a damage claim to a mandate action (Code Civ. Proc., § 1095). (State of California v.
Cited 132 timesPublishedState Bar of California v. Superior Court
207 Cal. 323 · California Supreme Court · May 31, 1929
which upon the same terms shall not be granted to all citizens,” we do not deem a discussion of this phase of the State Bar Act to be germane to the issues involved in this special proceeding for reasons which clearly appear … Hardy was, and for some years prior thereof had been, a duly admitted and qualified attorney and counselor at law within the state of California.
Cited 78 timesPublishedPac. Emp. Ins. Co. v. Industrial Acc. Com.
19 Cal. 2d 622 · California Supreme Court · Feb 27, 1942
Petitioner argues, however, that even if it be assumed that the evidence established that Ehrhardt contracted the disease in the course of his employment, the application of the doctrine that an injury to be compensable must … Com., supra.) [5] The opinions of qualified medical witnesses with reference to the origin and cause of the injury are valid evidence which will support an award. (Newton v. Industrial Acc.
Cited 27 timesPublishedWestern Lithograph Co. v. State Board of Equalization
11 Cal. 2d 156 · California Supreme Court · Apr 19, 1938
The principle of immunity thus has inherent limitations. ’ ’ It was also said in Metcalf & Eddy v. … Clearly the imposition of a privilege tax on the retailer of commodities does not interfere with the power of the government to borrow money; nor does it affect in any substantial manner the efficiency of its agency in the
Cited 69 timesPublishedProvigo Corp. v. Alcoholic Beverage Control Appeals Board
7 Cal. 4th 561 · California Supreme Court · Apr 7, 1994
The use of underage decoys to enforce laws against unlawful sales to minors clearly promotes rather than hinders the foregoing salutary purpose. … In sum, we conclude that petitioners have established neither entrapment nor a due process violation.
Cited 54 timesPublished51 Cal. Rptr. 3d 80 · California Supreme Court · Nov 27, 2006
To achieve the goal of “facilitating] the prompt identification of qualified patients and their designated primary caregivers,” the Legislature established a voluntary program for the issuance of identification cards to such … qualified patients. (§ 11362.71 et seq.)
Cited 131 timesPublished15 Cal. Rptr. 3d 643 · California Supreme Court · Jul 12, 2004
Read together, sections 1119 and 1120 establish that a writing—which qualifies as “ ‘[ejvidence’ ” (§ 140)—is not protected “solely by reason of its introduction or use in a mediation” (§ 1120, subd. … Thus, the Legislature clearly knows how to establish a “good cause” exception to a protection or privilege if it so desires.
Cited 47 timesPublished49 Cal. 2d 815 · California Supreme Court · Mar 21, 1958
Los Angeles County General Hospital, 123 Cal.App.2d 143, 144 [ 266 P.2d 221 ]), and, where, as here, the Legislature has clearly expressed its intention to maintain immunity, that intention is controlling. [5] Several cases … Once again this court is faced with the question of the scope of governmental immunity and again the majority has seen fit to broaden the scope when an analysis of applicable statutes shows such action to be clearly unwarranted
Cited 29 timesPublished16 Cal. 4th 739 · California Supreme Court · Aug 26, 1997
Although we have declared a probationer’s revocation hearing testimony inadmissible during the prosecution’s case in chief, we see no purpose to be served by precluding use of that testimony or its fruits to impeach or rebut clearly … First, the adversarial nature of our judicial system demands that the prosecution provide sufficient evidence to establish guilt without the aid of the minor’s testimony, which would impermissibly lighten the prosecution’
Cited 28 timesPublished141 Cal. 56 · California Supreme Court · Nov 6, 1903
Again, it is said: “If the superior should be allowed immunity under such circumstances, he would be permitted to take advantage of his own wrong” (14 Am. & Eng. … All of these reasons are satisfactory; but it may be observed especially that the case here comes clearly within the last, which is the narrowest, of the grounds assigned for the rule.
Cited 15 timesPublishedNestle v. City of Santa Monica
6 Cal. 3d 920 · California Supreme Court · Apr 28, 1972
I dissent, however, from the reversal of the judgment dismissing the nuisance count for in my view the California Tort Claims Act quite clearly immunizes governmental agencies from, liability for nuisance, except insofar … The commission’s comment regarding proposed section 830 conclusively establishes its intent that a government entity would be immune from liability for nuisance under Civil Code section 3479: “Under the previous law, public
Cited 346 timesPublished8 Cal. 4th 587 · California Supreme Court · Oct 27, 1994
To hold that a scientific technique could become immune from Kelly scrutiny merely by reason of long-standing and persistent use by law enforcement outside the laboratory or the courtroom, seems unjustified. c. … The foregoing decisions, however, do not explain how police officers are competent to establish general acceptance of HGN testing in the scientific community, or how they are qualified to relate the scientific bases underlying
Cited 175 timesPublished152 Cal. 637 · California Supreme Court · Jan 21, 1908
In support of appellant’s position under this section it was established in evidence that under the laws of Hawaii an action for the recovery of any debt founded upon any contract, obligation, or liability,' where the cause … His failure in this regard gave rise to the cause of action, and, clearly therefore, that cause of action arose in the state of New York. In a legal sense the cause of action cannot have two places of origin.
Cited 57 timesPublished
Ask Donna