Case law

Opinions from 1658 to today.

Filtersca11

9,466 results

1.27s

  • Willingham v. Loughnan

    261 F.3d 1178 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Aug 15, 2001

    The Officer Defendants argue, most substantively, that they are entitled to qualified immunity because their acts violated no clearly established law at the pertinent time. … established preexisting law for qualified immunity purposes.

    Vacated on other grounds by Willingham v. Loughnan, 537 U.S. 801 (2002)Cited 83 timesPublished
  • Cottone v. Jenne

    326 F.3d 1352 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Apr 11, 2003

    [u]nless the plaintiffs allegations state a claim of violation of clearly established law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to dismissal before the commencement of discovery.” Id. … The Supreme Court has established a two-part test to determine the applicability of qualified immunity.

    Abrogated in part, on other grounds by Randall v. Scott, 610 F.3d 701 (2010)Cited 382 timesPublished
  • Gary Mason v. Ricky Stallings, C.L. St. Clair, Jr., Charles Burkhalter, Harold Woodall, Phillip Jordan, All Individually

    82 F.3d 1007 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · May 9, 1996

    Judicially created qualified immunity enables a public official to avoid suit on an alleged constitutional or federal law violation where the law governing the claimed right was not clearly established at the time of the … The relevant question on a motion for summary judgment based on a defense of qualified immunity is whether a reasonable official could have believed his or her actions were lawful in light of clearly established law and the

    Cited 178 timesPublished
  • Wilson v. Strong

    156 F.3d 1131 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Sep 28, 1998

    General Qualified Immunity Principles Qualified immunity shields a § 1983 defendant from liability for harms arising from her discretionary acts, so long as her acts do not violate any clearly established statutory … Second, "[i]n this circuit, the law can be "clearly established' for qualified immunity purposes only by decisions of the U.S.

    Cited 47 timesPublished
  • Dr. Lana Foster v. Shannon King

    Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Mar 18, 2026

    But the second question, whether the law is clearly established, presents a set of doctrinal challenges unique to qualified immunity. … Accordingly, we address only step two of the qualified immunity analysis: whether the alleged conduct violated clearly established law.

    Cited 0 timesPublished
  • Oberist Lee Saunders v. George C. Duke

    766 F.3d 1262 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Sep 8, 2014

    Under this doctrine, “courts may not award damages against a government official in his personal capacity unless the official violated a statutory or constitutional right, and the right was ‘clearly established’ at the … Saunders] to show that qualified immunity is not appropriate.” Lee, 284 F.3d at 1194. With these principles in mind, we turn to the qualified immunity analysis.

    Cited 235 timesPublished
  • Barbara Donald v. Tyler Norris

    131 F.4th 1255 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Mar 13, 2025

    We need address only whether Burrell’s right to some other treatment was clearly established because that answer resolves the qualified-immunity question. … Indeed, the formulation from the Hill dicta would eliminate the “clearly established” part of the qualified-immunity analysis as we know it.

    Cited 16 timesPublished
  • James Ryan Singletary v. Juan Vargas

    804 F.3d 1174 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Oct 29, 2015

    Qualified Immunity Resolution of Defendant’s appeal requires us to decide whether Plaintiff proved that Defendant was not entitled to qualified immunity for his actions.9 Qualified immunity balances two important … Clearly Established Law Even assuming a constitutional violation, Defendant is entitled to qualified immunity unless Plaintiff can show that his Fourth Amendment rights were “clearly established” at the time of

    Cited 88 timesPublished
  • John Eugene Youmans v. M. J. Oschner

    626 F.3d 557 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Nov 16, 2010

    We “review de novo a district court’s denial of a motion for summary judgment on qualified immunity grounds.” … was not already clearly established at the time of the alleged violation.

    Cited 159 timesPublished
  • McMillian v. Johnson

    88 F.3d 1554 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jul 9, 1996

    The issue for qualified immunity purposes, however, is not whether the due process right not to be punished before conviction was clearly established. … Clearly Established Law Prohibited Police' Suppression of Exculpatory and Impeachment Evidence Tate, Ikner, and Benson are protected by qualified immunity unless their actions violated clearly established law.

    Modified by McMillian v. Johnson, 101 F.3d 1363 (1996)Cited 125 timesPublished
  • Darryl Pernell Butler v. Hope Davis

    Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Mar 21, 2019

    immunity because Butler’s right was not clearly established. … See Glasscox, 903 F.3d at 1213 (explaining that, to defeat a defense of qualified immunity, a plaintiff must show that “(1) the defendant violated a constitutional right, and (2) this right was clearly established at the

    Cited 0 timesUnpublished
  • James P. Crocker v. Deputy Sheriff Steven Eric Beatty

    995 F.3d 1232 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Apr 20, 2021

    The district court held that Beatty was entitled to qualified immunity because the law underlying Crocker’s First Amendment claim wasn’t clearly established. We agree. … In my view, Smith clearly establishes that Mr. Crocker had a right to photograph the accident scene and I would therefore reverse the grant of qualified immunity to Deputy Beatty on this claim.

    Cited 173 timesPublished
  • Mildred Robinson v. Daniel Arrugueta

    415 F.3d 1252 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jul 7, 2005

    The court found, however, that under the second step the right violated was not clearly established and thus Arrugueta was entitled to qualified immunity. … established, and thus, Arrugueta is entitled to qualified immunity under this step as well.

    Cited 129 timesPublished
  • Charles Johnson, Jr. v. City of Atlanta

    107 F.4th 1292 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jul 12, 2024

    To show that qualified immunity is not appropriate, “the plaintiff must establish two things: (1) the defendant violated a constitutional right, and (2) that constitutional right was ‘clearly established … immunity, and we do not address the second prong—whether the law was clearly established. 7 C.

    Cited 161 timesPublished
  • John Dee Carruth v. Robert J. Bentley

    942 F.3d 1047 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Nov 7, 2019

    Since there is no clearly established law establishing that Carruth’s alleged differential treatment violated the Equal Protection Clause, Bentley and Byrne are entitled to qualified immunity. … It is Carruth’s burden to establish that Byrne and Bentley are not entitled to qualified immunity and he has not met it.

    Cited 53 timesPublished
  • Corey Airport Services, Inc. v. DeCosta

    587 F.3d 1280 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Nov 16, 2009

    We conclude that these Defendants did not violate a clearly established constitutional right and are therefore entitled to qualified immunity. I. … Because this is not such a case, the Defendants did not violate a clearly established constitutional right and are therefore entitled to qualified immunity.

    Cited 25 timesPublished
  • Thomas Hayden Barnes v. Ronald M. Zaccari

    669 F.3d 1295 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Feb 7, 2012

    We turn now to the second part of the qualified immunity analysis: Was Barnes’s right to this predeprivation process clearly established at the relevant time? 2. … The process due Barnes was also clearly established.

    Cited 88 timesPublished
  • Cottone v. Jenne

    326 F.3d 1352 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Apr 11, 2003

    [u]nless the plaintiff’s allegations state a claim of violation of clearly established law, a defendant pleading qualified immunity is entitled to dismissal before the commencement of discovery.” Id. … The Supreme Court has established a two-part test to determine the applicability of qualified immunity.

    Overruled in part, on other grounds by Pearson v. Callahan, 555 U.S. 223 (2009)Cited 383 timesPublished
  • Ralph Harrison Benning v. Commissioner, Georgia Department of Corrections

    71 F.4th 1324 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jun 23, 2023

    The Supreme Court re- cently summarized this aspect of the qualified immunity inquiry: Qualified immunity attaches when an official’s con- duct does not violate clearly established statutory … Thus, because the law was not clearly established, we affirm the district court’s ruling that Ms. Edgar and Ms. Patterson are en- titled to qualified immunity on Mr.

    Cited 26 timesPublished
  • Athel B. Cooper, Cross-Appellee v. William E. Smith, Individually and in His Official Capacity as Sheriff of Camden County, Georgia

    89 F.3d 761 · Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · Jul 26, 1996

    applicable law was clearly established.” … For Cooper to pierce the qualified immunity protecting Smith, he must show that Smith violated one of Cooper’s “clearly established” rights under federal law. Id.

    Cited 32 timesPublished

Ask Donna

Ask Donna

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.