Opinion

East Dr. Hous. Dev. Corp. v. Lawrence

  • 2024 NY Slip Op 30470(U)
Court
New York Supreme Court, New York County
Filed
Feb 12, 2024
Status
Unpublished
Cited by
0 cases
Authority
More cited than 15.3%

The opinion

East Dr. Hous. Dev. Corp. v Lawrence

2024 NY Slip Op 30470(U)

February 12, 2024

Supreme Court, New York County

Docket Number: Index No. 161032/2022

Judge: Nancy M. Bannon

Cases posted with a "30000" identifier, i.e., 2013 NY Slip

Op 30001(U), are republished from various New York

State and local government sources, including the New

York State Unified Court System's eCourts Service.

This opinion is uncorrected and not selected for official

publication.

INDEX NO. 161032/2022

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 159 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/13/2024

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK

NEW YORK COUNTY

PRESENT: HON. NANCY M. BANNON PART 42

Justice

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------X INDEX NO. 161032/2022

EAST DRIVE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION,

MOTION DATE 02/01/2024

Plaintiff,

MOTION SEQ. NO. 010 011 012

-v–

DECISION + ORDER ON

STEVEN M LAWRENCE, TIFFANY LAWRENCE and IMANI

MANAGEMENT, INC. MOTION

Defendants.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------X

The following e-filed documents, listed by NYSCEF document number (Motion 010) 129, 130, 131, 132,

133, 134, 135, 151

were read on this motion to/for JUDGMENT - DEFAULT .

The following e-filed documents, listed by NYSCEF document number (Motion 011) 138, 139, 140, 141,

142, 143, 150

were read on this motion to/for JUDGMENT - MONEY .

The following e-filed documents, listed by NYSCEF document number (Motion 012) 121, 144, 145, 146,

147, 148, 149, 152

were read on this motion to/for DISCOVERY .

In this action arising from an alleged breach of a proprietary lease and breach of

fiduciary duty, the plaintiff, East Drive Housing Development Corporation, seeks money

damages for unpaid maintenance charges as well as declaratory and injunctive relief. As

against defendants Steven Lawrence and Tiffany Lawrence, shareholders and proprietary

lessees of Unit 3BC of the subject cooperative building at 205-207 East 124th Street in

Manhattan, the plaintiff seeks a judgment declaring that the plaintiff properly terminated their

lease for, inter alia, misappropriation of funds of the corporation and enjoining the Lawrences

from selling the apartment without board approval, use and occupancy from the Lawrences for

remaining in possession of the apartment without paying maintenance, money damages from

Steven Lawrence for breach of his fiduciary duty as board treasurer, and money damages from

defendant Imani Management, Inc., the property manager, for negligence and breach of

161032/2022 EAST DRIVE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND CORPORATION vs. LAWRENCE, Page 1 of 5

STEVEN M ET AL

Motion No. 010 011 012

1 of 5

[* 1]

INDEX NO. 161032/2022

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 159 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/13/2024

fiduciary duty in failing to monitor the allegedly improper conduct and money transfers by

Steven Lawrence. Defendants Tiffany Lawrence and Imani Management have not answered.

The plaintiff previously moved pursuant to CPLR 3212 for partial summary judgment

against defendant Steven Lawrence, seeking, inter alia, a judgment declaring that the shares of

that defendant and defendant Tiffany Lawrence and their proprietary lease are canceled, a

warrant of ejectment and judgment of possession of their unit and an order dismissing any

affirmative defenses (MOT SEQ 006). The motion was denied for failure of proof.

The plaintiff’s motion for, inter alia, use and occupancy (MOT SEQ 007), was granted in

part by interim order dated August 16, 2023, and was otherwise withdrawn without prejudice.

The obligation of defendant Steven Lawrence to pay use and occupancy of $1,628.00 per

month was set forth therein and continues until a further order of this court. In an order dated

September 6, 2023, the court denied without prejudice the plaintiff’s first motion for leave to

enter a default judgment against Tiffany Lawrence, allowing her additional time to answer as per

the parties’ stipulation (MOT SEQ 008). In the same order, the court deemed withdrawn without

prejudice a motion by the plaintiff to modify the prior use and occupancy order to increase the

amount to be paid by Steven Lawrence (MOT SEQ 009).

Discovery is ongoing between the plaintiff and defendant Steven Lawrence.

The plaintiff now moves (1) for a second time for leave to enter a default judgment

against defendant Tiffany Lawrence (MOT SEQ 010), (2) for a money judgment against

defendant Steven Lawrence in the sum of $6,512.00 for unpaid use and occupancy and an

order directing that defendant post a bond for future use and occupancy ,and (3) an order

extending the Note of Issue filing deadline and compel additional discovery in the form of

documents, interrogatories and depositions. No opposition is submitted to any of these motions.

(1) “On a motion for leave to enter a default judgment pursuant to CPLR 3215, the

movant is required to submit proof of service of the summons and complaint, proof of the facts

constituting the claim, and proof of the defaulting party’s default in answering or appearing (see

CPLR 3215[f]; Allstate Ins. Co. v Austin, 48 AD3d 720, 720).” Atlantic Cas. Ins. Co. v RJNJ

Services, Inc., 89 AD3d 649 (2nd Dept. 2011). The proof submitted must establish a prima facie

case. See Silberstein v Presbyterian Hosp., 95 AD2d 773 (2nd Dept. 1983). The plaintiff has

161032/2022 EAST DRIVE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND CORPORATION vs. LAWRENCE, Page 2 of 5

STEVEN M ET AL

Motion No. 010 011 012

2 of 5

[* 2]

INDEX NO. 161032/2022

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 159 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/13/2024

met this burden. The motion is granted, without opposition, as to the causes of action alleged

against defendant Tiffany Lawrence - the first cause of action, seeking declaratory relief that

the Lawrence’s proprietary lease was properly terminated, the fourth cause of action for

injunctive relief enjoining an unauthorized sale of the apartment by the Lawrences, and the fifth

cause of action for use and occupancy. The plaintiff’s proof includes the complaint, verified by

Avraham Chein, plaintiff’s treasurer, and affidavit of Chen, demand letter, and a ledger for the

Lawrence’s unit showing an outstanding balance of $14,843.00 as of December 12, 2023.

Having failed to answer, defendant Tiffany Lawrence is “deemed to have admitted all factual

allegations in the complaint and all reasonable inferences that flow from them.” Woodson v

Mendon Leasing Corp., 100 NY2d 62, 70–71 (2003). However, in light of the nature of the relief

sought against both Lawrence defendants, including termination of a lease held by both

defendants and continuing money damages, the relief to be granted on this motion shall await

disposition of the action as against defendant Steven Lawrence.

(2) In MOT SEQ 011, the plaintiff seeks a money judgment against Steven Lawrence in

the sum of $6,512.00 for the unpaid use and occupancy for October, November and December

2023, and an order directing that defendant post a bond for future use and occupancy. In light

of this court’s order of August 16, 2023, the plaintiff is clearly entitled to recover this sum and

any further unpaid use and occupancy, with interest. However, this motion is denied without

prejudice to seek that sum and any further unpaid sums, with interest, upon any dispositive

motion or at trial. In that regard, defendant Steven Lawrence is cautioned that continued

occupancy of the subject premises is conditioned upon timely compliance with the court-

directed payment of use and occupancy such that her failure to comply will result in ejectment

from the premises. See Marbru Assocs. v White, 206 AD3d 562 (1st Dept. 2022); Park Terrace

Gardens, Inc. v Penkovsky, 100 AD3d 577 (1st Dept. 2012); Rose Assocs. v Johnson, 247 AD2d

222 (1st Dept. 1998). This is because “[a] party claiming a security interest in a lease must, as a

condition for asserting its rights in the litigation, comply with the court’s directions to maintain the

status quo or lose its interest in the property.” 61 West 62nd Owners Corp. v Harkness

Apartment Owners Corp., 202 AD2d 345, 346 (1st Dept. 1994), citing 313 West 57 Rest. Corp. v

313 West 57th Associates, 186 AD2d 466 (1st Dept. 1992).

(3) In MOT SEQ 012, the plaintiff seeks an order extending discovery deadlines,

including the Note of Issue filing deadline, and to compel defendant Steven Lawrence to

produce documents and respond to interrogatories and to compel both Lawrences to appear for

161032/2022 EAST DRIVE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND CORPORATION vs. LAWRENCE, Page 3 of 5

STEVEN M ET AL

Motion No. 010 011 012

3 of 5

[* 3]

INDEX NO. 161032/2022

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 159 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/13/2024

depositions. The motion was filed on December 24, 2023. Since that date, Steven Lawrence

was deposed, and he provided some document discovery and responded to plaintiff’s

interrogatories. The court held a status conference and in the resulting order dated January 18,

2024, directed further document discovery and directed Tiffany Lawrence to appear for a

deposition on April 2, 2024. The court extended the Note of Issue deadline to May 31, 2024,

and scheduled an additional status conference for April 11, 2024. Therefore, this motion is

largely moot. Any further discovery issues may be raised at the next conference.

The parties are reminded that CPLR 3126 authorizes the court to sanction a party who

“refuses to obey an order for disclosure or willfully fails to disclose information which the court

finds ought to have been disclosed” and that “a failure to comply with discovery, particularly

after a court order has been issued, may constitute the “dilatory and obstructive, and thus

contumacious, conduct warranting the striking of the [pleading].” Kutner v Feiden, Dweck &

Sladkus, 223 AD2d 488, 489 (1st Dept. 1998); see CDR Creances S.A. v Cohen, 104 AD3d 17

(1st Dept. 2012); Reidel v Ryder TRS, Inc., 13 AD3d 170 (1st Dept. 2004). The court can infer

willfulness from repeated failures to comply with court orders or discovery demands without a

reasonable excuse. See LaSalle Talman Bank, F.S.B. v Weisblum & Felice, 99 AD3d 543 (1st

Dept. 2012); Perez v City of New York, 95 AD3d 675 (1st Dept. 2012); Figiel v Met Food, 48

AD3d 330 (1st Dept. 2008); Ciao Europa, Inc. v Silver Autumn Hotel Corp., Ltd., 270 AD2d 2 (1st

Dept. 2000). Furthermore, CPLR 3101(a) provides that “there shall be full disclosure of all

matter material and necessary in the prosecution or defense of an action” and this language is

“interpreted liberally to require disclosure, upon request, of any facts bearing on the controversy

which will assist preparation for trial by sharpening the issues and reducing delay and prolixity.”

Osowski v AMEC Constr. Mgt., Inc., 69 AD3d 99, 106 (1st Dept. 2009) quoting Allen v Crowell-

Collier Publ. Co., 21 NY2d 403, 406-407 (1968). Depositions are a method of discovery and the

failure to appear for or cooperate in the scheduling or taking of a deposition may be a basis for

the imposition of sanctions under CPLR 3126. See Rocco v Advantage Securities & Protection

Incorp., 283 AD2d 317 (1st Dept. 2001).

Accordingly, it is

ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for leave to enter a default judgment against

defendant Tiffany Lawrence (MOT SEQ 010) is granted, without opposition, on the issue of

161032/2022 EAST DRIVE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND CORPORATION vs. LAWRENCE, Page 4 of 5

STEVEN M ET AL

Motion No. 010 011 012

4 of 5

[* 4]

INDEX NO. 161032/2022

NYSCEF DOC. NO. 159 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/13/2024

liability, money damages and other relief to be determined at trial or on dispositive motion as

against defendant Steven Lawrence, and it is further

ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for a money judgment as against defendant Steven

Lawrence for unpaid use and occupancy (MOT SEQ 011) is denied without prejudice, and it is

further

ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion to extend the Note of Issue filing deadline and

compel further discovery (MOT SEQ 012) is denied moot, without prejudice to raise any further

discovery issues at the status conference scheduled for April 11, 2024, and it is further

ORDERED that the Clerk shall mark the file accordingly.

2/12/2024

DATE

-~

HON. NANCY M. BANNON

$SIG$

CHECK ONE: CASE DISPOSED X NON-FINAL DISPOSITION

□ □

GRANTED DENIED GRANTED IN PART X OTHER

APPLICATION: SETTLE ORDER SUBMIT ORDER

□

CHECK IF APPROPRIATE: INCLUDES TRANSFER/REASSIGN FIDUCIARY APPOINTMENT REFERENCE

161032/2022 EAST DRIVE HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FUND CORPORATION vs. LAWRENCE, Page 5 of 5

STEVEN M ET AL

Motion No. 010 011 012

5 of 5

[* 5]

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.