Opinion

Michelle Kaszowski v. Department of the Air Force

  • 2023 MSPB 15
Court
Merit Systems Protection Board
Filed
Apr 4, 2023
Status
Published
Cited by
11 cases
Authority
More cited than 82.3%

finding that the appellant’s election to challenge her removal through the negotiated grievance procedures was not binding where the agency did not specifically notify her that electing to file a grievance would result in a waiver of her Board appeal rights

How later courts described this case

  • finding that the appellant’s election to challenge her removal through the negotiated grievance procedures was not binding where the agency did not specifically notify her that electing to file a grievance would result in a waiver of her Board appeal rights
  • discussing the requirements for a notice issued under 5 C.F.R. § 1201.21 (d)(1), informing an employee of her right to contest an adverse action

Written by the judges who cited it.

The opinion

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

MERIT SYSTEMS PROTECTION BOARD

2023 MSPB 15

Docket No. CH-0752-16-0089-I-1

Michelle E. Kaszowski,

Appellant,

v.

Department of the Air Force,

Agency.

April 4, 2023

Keith E. Kendall, Esquire, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, for the appellant.

Justin Strong, Youngstown Air Reserve Station, Ohio, for the agency.

BEFORE

Cathy A. Harris, Vice Chairman

Raymond A. Limon, Member

OPINION AND ORDER

¶1 The appellant has filed a petition for review of the initial decision, which

dismissed her appeal for lack of jurisdiction. For the reasons discussed below, we

GRANT the appellant’s petition for review, VACATE the initial decision, and

REMAND the appeal to the regional office for further adjudication consistent

with this Opinion and Order.

BACKGROUND

¶2 On November 13, 2015, the appellant filed a Board appeal challenging her

removal, effective October 16, 2015, from her position as a Drug Demand

Reduction Program Manager. Initial Appeal File (IAF), Tab 1. The agency

2

moved to dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction on the basis that the appellant

had previously elected to file a grievance concerning her removal. IAF, Tab 5.

The administrative judge issued a show cause order explaining that the Board

may lack jurisdiction if the appellant had elected to challenge her removal

through the negotiated grievance procedure and instructed the appellant to file

evidence and argument establishing Board jurisdiction over h er appeal. IAF,

Tab 8. In response, the appellant contended that the Board has jur isdiction

because although she challenged her removal via a union-filed grievance, the

union unilaterally declined to pursue arbitration on her behalf. IAF, Tab 10 at 5,

21.

¶3 Without holding a hearing, the administrative judge issued an initial

decision dismissing the appeal for lack of jurisdiction. IAF, Tab 25, Initial

Decision (ID). The administrative judge found that there was no dispute that,

prior to filing her Board appeal, the appellant had elected to challenge her

removal via a union-filed grievance. Further, the administrative judge found that

the union’s decision not to pursue arbitration did not render invalid the

appellant’s election. ID at 3. In particular, the administrative judge noted that it

was undisputed that, on October 20, 2015, the union submitted on the appellant’s

behalf an informal grievance concerning the appellant’s removal. ID at 2. After

the informal grievance was denied, on October 30, 2015, the union filed a step 4

grievance, noting that steps 1-3 did not pertain to the grievance because the base

commander was the deciding official. Id. Thus, the administrative judge found

that, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. § 7121(e), the appellant had elected to challenge her

removal through the negotiated grievance procedure, which precluded her Board

appeal. ID at 3. Accordingly, the administrative judge granted the agency’s

motion to dismiss the appeal for lack of jurisdiction.

¶4 The appellant filed a petition for review, which the a gency opposed.

Petition for Review (PFR) File, Tabs 1, 3.

3

ANALYSIS

The appellant’s election to file a grievance was not a binding election and did not

preclude her removal appeal.

¶5 An employee subjected to an adverse action, such as a removal, and who is

covered by a negotiated grievance procedure may challenge such an action by

filing either a grievance under the negotiated grievance procedure or a Board

appeal under 5 U.S.C. § 7701, “but not both.” 1 5 U.S.C. § 7121(e)(1). An

employee is deemed to have exercised an option when the employee timely files a

notice of appeal under the applicable appellate procedures or timely file s a

grievance in writing in accordance with the provisions of the negotiated grievance

procedure, whichever event occurs first. Id. However, for an election of an

option to be binding, it must be knowing and informed. Agoranos v. Department

of Justice, 119 M.S.P.R. 498, ¶ 16 (2013). The Board has held that, when an

agency takes an action without informing the appellant of her procedural options

under section 7121 and the preclusive effect of electing one of those options, any

subsequent election by the appellant is not binding. Id., ¶ 17; cf. Johnson v.

Department of Veterans Affairs, 121 M.S.P.R. 695, ¶¶ 6-7 (2014) (finding that the

appellant’s election to grieve his removal was not binding because the agency’s

removal decision did not inform him of his right to file a request for corrective

action with the Office of Special Counsel (OSC), or of the effect that filing a

grievance would have on his right to file an OSC complaint and a subsequent

1

Additional avenues of relief are available when an employee who is subjected to an

action appealable to the Board alleges that she has been affected by a prohibited

personnel practice. When alleging a prohibited personnel practice under 5 U.S.C.

§ 2302(b)(1), the employee may elect one and only one of the following: (1) a statutory

procedure, i.e., a Board appeal or an equal employment opportunity complaint; or (2) a

grievance under the applicable negotiated grievance procedures. 5 U.S.C. § 7121(d).

When alleging a prohibited personnel practice other than under 5 U.S.C. § 2302(b)(1),

the employee may elect one and only one of the following: (1) an appeal to the Board

under 5 U.S.C. § 7701; (2) a grievance under the applicable negotiated grievance

procedures; or (3) a complaint seeking corrective action from the Office of Special

Counsel under 5 U.S.C. chapter 12, subchapters II and III. 5 U.S.C. § 7121(g).

4

individual right of action appeal before the Board), aff’d, 611 F. App’x 496 (10th

Cir. 2015). 2 For this reason, the Board’s regulations require that, when an agency

issues a decision notice to an employee on a matter appealable to the Board, it

must provide the employee with notice of the available avenues of relief and the

preclusive effect any election will have on the employee’s Board appeal rights.

See 5 C.F.R. § 1201.21(d)(1). In particular, when an agency issues a decision

notice to an employee on a matter that is appealable to the Board, the agency

must provide the employee with, among other things, notice of any right the

employee has to file a grievance or seek corrective action under subchapters II

and III of 5 U.S.C. chapter 12, including “[w]hether the election of any applicable

grievance procedure will result in waiver of the employee’s right to file an appeal

with the Board.” Id. In proposing this regulation, the Board emphasized that “it

is especially important that the agency notice of MSPB appeal rights required by

5 CFR 1201.21 fully explain the consequences of choosing th e appeal or

grievance procedure” and that “[g]iven the various laws and [collective

bargaining agreements] that come into play, it is essential that agency notices of

appeal and grievance rights state the situation clearly with respect to the

particular employee against whom the action is being taken.” Practices and

Procedures, 64 Fed. Reg. 58,798 (Nov. 1, 1999).

¶6 The agency’s Notice of Decision to Remove provided, in relevant part:

3. If you consider this action improper, you are entitled to:

(a) Appeal this action to the Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB)

or (b) Seek corrective action before the U.S. Office of Special

Counsel (OSC) or (c) File a grievance under the negotiated grievance

procedure or (d) A discrimination complaint with the Equal

Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)

2

Although Johnson is based on 5 U.S.C. § 7121(g), rather than section 7121(e), in

Agoranos, 119 M.S.P.R. 498, ¶¶ 15-16, the Board made it clear that both of these

statutory subsections require that elections be knowing and informed.

5

You shall be deemed to have exercised your option to appeal the

adverse action at such time as you timely initiate action to appeal to

the Board, or the OSC, or timely file a grievance in writing under the

negotiated grievance procedure, or a discrimination complaint. If

your appeal includes an allegation that the facility engaged in a

prohibited personnel action in retaliation of protected whistleblowing

[sic], you may elect to file an appeal to MSPB, OSC, or a negotiated

grievance and your election is based on which election you file first.

IAF, Tab 3 at 3. After setting forth the methods for submitting an appeal with the

Board, seeking corrective action from OSC, filing a grievance, and filing a

complaint of discrimination, the decision notice indicated that “[w]hichever is

filed first, an appeal to the MSPB, an appeal for corrective action to OSC, a

grievance under the negotiated grievance procedure, or a discrimination

complaint, shall be considered an election by you to proceed under that appeal

process.” Id. at 3-4.

¶7 Here, we agree with the administrative judge that the appellant elected to

grieve her removal, notwithstanding the union’s purported decision not to

arbitrate the appellant’s grievance of her removal. ID at 3 -4; see Martinez v.

Department of Justice, 85 M.S.P.R. 290, ¶ 10 (2000). Nevertheless, nothing in

the record demonstrates that the agency fully explained the consequences of

choosing the appeal or grievance procedure. The decision letter did not explicitly

inform the appellant that she could raise the matter at issue with the Board or

under the negotiated grievance procedure, “but not both,” 5 U.S.C. § 7121(e)(1),

nor did it provide her with notice as to “[w]hether the election of any applicable

grievance procedure will result in waiver of the employee’s right to file an appeal

with the Board,” 3 5 C.F.R. § 1201.21(d)(1). Thus, we find that the appellant did

not make a knowing and informed election and did not waive her right to file a

3

Agencies may wish to review and update, if necessary, the notice of appeal rights

language in their decision notices consistent with the applicable statutes and 5 C.F.R.

§ 1201.21.

6

Board appeal. See Johnson, 121 M.S.P.R. 695, ¶ 7; Agoranos, 119 M.S.P.R. 498,

¶ 17; 5 C.F.R. § 1201.21(d)(1). 4 Accordingly, we remand the appeal for

adjudication of the merits of the agency’s removal action. 5

ORDER

¶8 Based on the foregoing, we remand this case to the regional office for

further adjudication in accordance with this Opinion and Order.

FOR THE BOARD:

/s/ for

Jennifer Everling

Acting Clerk of the Board

Washington, D.C.

4

During the pendency of this appeal, Congress enacted the National Defense

Authorization Act of 2018 (2018 NDAA), effective December 12, 2017. Pub. L.

No. 115-91, 131 Stat. 1283 (2017). The 2018 NDAA codified, with respect to an action

taken under 5 U.S.C. §§ 7503(b)(1), 7513(b)(1), or 7543(b)(1), an agency’s obligation

to notify an employee of her right to appeal an action brought under one of the

applicable sections, the forums in which she may file her appeal, and any limitat ions on

her rights that would apply because of her forum selection. 2018 NDAA § 1097(b)(2),

131 Stat. at 1617 (5 U.S.C. § 7503 Note). We need not consider the retroactivity of this

provision and whether the agency also failed to comply with this statutory requirement

given our finding that the agency did not comply with the Board’s regulatory notice

requirements.

5

Section 7121(e)(1) applies to an “aggrieved employee.” Under 5 U.S.C. § 7103(a)(2),

a “supervisor” or “management official” is not such an “employee.” Supervisors or

management officials are, therefore, excepted from the election of remedies provisions

of 5 U.S.C. § 7121. See Requena v. Department of Homeland Security, 2022 MSPB 39,

¶ 11. Although the appellant’s title is Drug Demand Reduction Program Manager, we

need not address whether to apply Requena in this case because the record appears to

indicate that she is not a supervisor or management official, see, e.g., IAF, Tab 7 at 98,

and we have otherwise found that her election was invalid.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.