Opinion

Brown v. State ex rel. Brown

  • 44 Ind. 222
Court
Indiana Supreme Court
Filed
Nov 15, 1873
Status
Published
Author
Osborn
On the bench
Osborn
Cited by
16 cases
Authority
More cited than 93.3%

The opinion

Osborn, J.

This was an action upon a guardian’s bond. The complaint avers that a copy of the bond is filed with the complaint. None was filed. A demurrer was filed to the complaint, on the ground that it did not contain facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. It was overruled, and an exception taken.

The complaint was defective, and the demurrer to it should have been sustained. “ When any pleading is founded on a written instrument or on account, the original or a copy thereof must be filed with the pleading.” 2 G. & H. 104. The statute is imperative that the instrument or a copy of it must be filed with the pleading; alleging that it is filed is ■not enough. It must be in fact filed; and if not,the pleading is demurrable. Price v. The Grand Rapids, etc., R. R. Co., 13 Ind. 58 ; Kiser v. The State, 13 Ind. 80 ; Hillis v. Wilson, 13 Ind. 146 ; The Peoria, etc., Insurance Co. v. Walser, 22 Ind. 73 ; Holdridge v. Sweet, 23 Ind. 118 ; Sayres v. Linkhart, 25 Ind. 145 ; Nelson v. Myers, 34 Ind. 431 ; Prince v. The State, ex rel. Sage, 42 Ind. 315 .

In this case, neither the original nor a copy of the bond was filed with the complaint. For the error of the co.urt in overruling the demurrer to the complaint, the judgment must be reversed. Other questions are discussed by the appellant, hut as the decision of the one arising on the demurrer to the complaint disposes of the whole case, and as the appellee has filed no brief, we do not deem it necessary to pass upon any other.

The judgment of the said Monroe Common Pleas is *223 reversed, with costs, cause remanded, with instructions to the court below to sustain the demurrer to the complaint, and for further proceedings.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.